Latest / Film And Whiskey / City Lights / Town Branch Rye feat. Marya Gates
Transcript
- 0:00As we get into today's episode, I just want to take a second,
- 0:03remind you that there's a ton of extra content, available to the
- 0:06members of film and whiskey Nation who support us through
- 0:09our patreon. Check us out on patreon.com
- 0:14film. Whiskey in 1931 director and
- 0:18star Charlie Chaplin, gave the world.
- 0:20A dynamic comedy, that pulls not a single punch in 2023.
- 0:26We hang out in Kentucky, to try a different kind of whiskey.
- 0:30The film is City Lights. The whiskey is Town Branch rye
- 0:34and we'll review them both. This is the film that whiskey
- 0:38podcast. Welcome to the film and whiskey.
- 1:00Cast were each week, we review a classic movie and a glass of
- 1:03whiskey. I'm Bob book, I'm Brad G.
- 1:06And this week we are looking at our first silent film in the
- 1:10history of the filmin. Whiskey podcast bought a bomb.
- 1:13I am so excited brat, like I've been waiting for this moment for
- 1:17many seasons. See and that's the thing, man.
- 1:20When you get your, your excitement up, your hopes up, I
- 1:25everything in my soul Just wants to crush it.
- 1:30I can tell, ya. I already know that you're
- 1:32coming in here. Just ready to test.
- 1:35All of my patients today, Brad, because we're looking at our
- 1:38first silent film and it is perhaps the the highest regarded
- 1:41American silent film from that entire era.
- 1:44We're talking about Charlie, Chaplin's 1931, film City Lights
- 1:49Brad. This is a movie that is ranked,
- 1:50I believe. Now, inside the top ten on the
- 1:53American Film institute's updated top 100 list.
- 1:57It's a movie that It appears on the BFI Sight and Sound pull
- 2:01Brad. This is, this is a juggernaut of
- 2:03Silent Cinema from a guy that I think most people know, if you
- 2:07haven't actually watched Charlie Chaplin, they know him from just
- 2:10being, like, the silly guy with the funny mustache.
- 2:13And here he is being a silly guy with a funny mustache.
- 2:16And people are saying it's one of the greatest films of all
- 2:18time. Yeah, I mean I was going to say
- 2:20the other day you sent me. His Oscar.
- 2:23What was it? Kind of like an honorary
- 2:25lifetime Oscar that they gave. Yep.
- 2:27And I don't That to disqualify it.
- 2:29I don't. He is one of the greatest
- 2:31filmmakers of all time and his speech if you could call it that
- 2:36was utterly heartwarming and touching.
- 2:39Hmm. But the movie itself Brad, where
- 2:43are we standing on that? That's the question.
- 2:46That's what we're here to answer and I think that you were
- 2:50hedging your bets, you knew my darker impulses and so you
- 2:55brought like, you know, Bob you you consider yourself the Expert
- 2:58here. But if you know about 5% of film
- 3:02you brought in somebody who probably knows 99% of silent
- 3:06film. Honestly, you know, and I don't
- 3:09mean this like to make anybody blush here, but we're going to
- 3:12introduce Our Guest. It is the film critic Mariah
- 3:15Gates and she is maybe. I mean, she's got to be among
- 3:19the world's pre-eminent silent film Scholars.
- 3:22We literally were just talking to her before we press record
- 3:24about her the movies that she watched last year and logged on.
- 3:28And she said that on average she logs about 800 movies a year on
- 3:32letterbox. So she's seen quite a few more
- 3:35movies than I am. And Brad, if anyone is going to
- 3:38be able to stand in my corner, like, Charlie Chaplin in this
- 3:41boxing scene, in this movie, it's Mariah.
- 3:44So Mariah, thank you for being here today.
- 3:46How are you is Mariah? Going to be the referee standing
- 3:49between us would be that I could be that.
- 3:54It's great to be here. Yeah it's great to be here.
- 3:56I love talking about silent. Movies.
- 3:58Anytime someone's interested. I'm like, I'm things to say,
- 4:03maybe too many things to say, well, let me ask this, I think
- 4:06this is like a good introductory question because, you know, our
- 4:10podcast is built around. The premise that a lot of the
- 4:12movies that were watching are being introduced to Brad for the
- 4:15first time as someone who has seen as many silence as you
- 4:19have. We talk all the time about the
- 4:22fact that, like, 90% of silent films have been lost to time and
- 4:25deterioration but even The 10% that survived.
- 4:29I feel like we really only talk about a small handful of them
- 4:33and you know, it's for good reason.
- 4:35These are great, great movies that are still mimicked and and
- 4:39parodied and lifted from today. Does it ever get old to you to
- 4:44talk about the same? Like, five silent films all the
- 4:47time? No, I do like it when I am with
- 4:52my my people. And I can talk about a deeper
- 4:55cut, they'll I could talk about John each car.
- 4:58Islands or you know. So they use directors that he
- 5:01died in the 1919 Spanish influenza.
- 5:03So treating a lot of people have seen his self but the fact that
- 5:08there are some silent films that normal people will watch is and
- 5:15I'd not to put all silent film fans under the category of
- 5:18abnormal, but I think if you have to be a little abnormal,
- 5:21its watches many, if some of us do, he's a testament to what you
- 5:25said that some of these films truly are And I love all of the
- 5:31silent era. It's about 40 years worth of
- 5:33Cinema. And it's as I was I think I was
- 5:36saying earlier before everyone was listening that it's a
- 5:40specific mode of of art, it's a different type of art.
- 5:44It's a different any, within those 40 years.
- 5:47There's different modes of Storytelling.
- 5:50And that's why Each decade practically.
- 5:52And sometimes every five years, you have different ways of
- 5:55making a film. The fact that some of Those
- 5:58films are still watch today and and you can put chaplain in
- 6:03front of children and, and they see the magic, or you can put
- 6:08one of my favorite screenings. Ever was the mark of Zorro with
- 6:12Douglas Fairbanks. I watched that with a bunch of
- 6:15eight year olds. I think in terms of Cisco, maybe
- 6:1810 years ago and they were cheering just as if he was that
- 6:22man or something. Yeah so the fact that some of
- 6:24these movies are so timeless The children can watch them or you
- 6:31know whatever age you are, you can come to it, it's 100 years
- 6:35old. This one's not quite a hundred
- 6:36years old, but getting there and people love it.
- 6:39The same exact way. I think is a testament to the
- 6:44height of this artistry for some of these films.
- 6:47Yeah, it honestly is an interesting illustration of a
- 6:51question. I've always had which is like
- 6:54you know, music has been around for forever but we from a
- 6:57certain era We only really remember Beethoven Bach like
- 7:01these big names and I'm always curious like when you think
- 7:04about music from the 1960s like how long will the Beatles last?
- 7:10And like these are young people who don't like Mia, right.
- 7:15Yeah. But like 150 years from now,
- 7:17like how many of their songs will people remembers?
- 7:21Is it just going to be one or two?
- 7:24And it's interesting to look back on film because I think you
- 7:27have that question, kind of being Because we're getting to
- 7:30the point where these films are 100 years old and what what
- 7:34lasts. And like you said, you know, I'm
- 7:36looking at City Lights here, there's 188,000 rankings on IMDb
- 7:42for this movie, so it's not like, it's a not well seen film.
- 7:46Yeah, exactly. Brad, you know, I, if I can wax
- 7:49poetic here for a minute, one of the things I love about silent
- 7:52film and I have obviously not seen nearly as many as our guest
- 7:55today, but it is timeless, and it is so accessible.
- 7:58Able to everybody from young to old, you know.
- 8:01And this was the thing about Chaplin was it spanned ages, it
- 8:04spanned classes. It was an iconic character, that
- 8:08transcended all of the societal divisions in America and the
- 8:13movies themselves. Even today, you know, I like to
- 8:17put my children down in front of the TV and have them watch quiet
- 8:20TV, because there's a lot of loud children's programming now.
- 8:24And so like we ought, I try to do mr.
- 8:26Rogers with them and that worked like gangbusters.
- 8:28For a couple of years until they figured out what I was doing
- 8:30when I put mr. Rogers on, and then I was like,
- 8:33you know what, I'm going to try some chaplain, I'm going to try
- 8:35some Buster Keaton, my son, my six-year-old has watched the
- 8:40clip. There's a specific clip from
- 8:42Modern Times which we're going to watch in a couple weeks here.
- 8:44Brad of chaplain being strapped into this newfangled feeding
- 8:48machine and it is, I mean, it's hilarious.
- 8:51I laugh out loud. Every time I have never seen my
- 8:54son laugh as hard as he laughs at that clip every single time
- 8:56we play it you know we just started watching.
- 8:58Chewing Buster Keaton. He has a short called one week
- 9:01that is just absolutely hilarious.
- 9:04And it's so cool to see that without words and just with a
- 9:08little bit of reading comprehension, this kid is
- 9:10locked into these movies in a way that he's not with super
- 9:13bombastic. You know, sensory overload, kind
- 9:17of children's programming that you get elsewhere today.
- 9:20Anyway, that's my plug for taking your kids in front of
- 9:23silent films. Yeah, no.
- 9:25I mean, that's the reality. I mean, why?
- 9:28I didn't grow up with silent films.
- 9:30I did grow up with, like, things like The Three Stooges and so,
- 9:34there's something about the physicality that children are
- 9:39drawn to. I don't think there's anything
- 9:41wrong with saying, hey, like put your kids down, have them watch
- 9:44Three Stooges. Have them watch Charlie Chaplin
- 9:46because they have such an engaging manner of visualization
- 9:52that I had entertained me for hours and hours and hours.
- 9:55And I know it would any other kid listen.
- 9:58Like people falling over and poop jokes are Universal.
- 10:02And they last forever. And this movie has both of those
- 10:04things. So we're going to get into
- 10:06talking about them. Brad.
- 10:07We will set the stage for this movie and the the context into
- 10:10which it was released in just a minute.
- 10:12But before we get there, it is time for America's favorite
- 10:15segment, which we call Brad explains.
- 10:18That's gonna give us the movie plots with only 60 seconds
- 10:21ticking on the clock. So let's go ahead and do your
- 10:24take with this little segment that we call Brad explain.
- 10:27Brad explains his Part of the podcast, where Brad breaks down
- 10:30the plot of the movie that he has just seen often for the
- 10:33first time Brad. I assumed this was your first
- 10:36time seeing City Lights. Absolutely.
- 10:38It was, this is your first silent movie ever, right?
- 10:42Yes. Okay, I think I've said before
- 10:44I've seen Clips here and there, I know I've seen the clip you
- 10:47were referring to, from Modern Times.
- 10:49Okay. So it's, you know, but this is
- 10:51the first time I sat down and just watched it start to finish.
- 10:54I was thinking that it would be difficult to do an episode on
- 10:57silent film. Um, and so seasons and seasons
- 11:00ago, I started planning ahead for this.
- 11:02We used to splice in Clips audio clips of the movies into our
- 11:05episodes, and I was like, one day, we will do Chaplin and I
- 11:08will have nothing to splice. And so we kind of stopped doing
- 11:11that. But the more I think about it.
- 11:13There really is no difference in, describing the plot of the
- 11:16movie, the mechanics of the movie here.
- 11:18So you've had seven years of practice leading up to this
- 11:21point. Brad, I'm going to give you 60
- 11:23seconds on the clock to break down the plot of this movie and
- 11:27go sit. Lights is a film, about a tramp.
- 11:30In what I would assume to be New York City, New York City look
- 11:34alike at the very least Who falls in love with a blind.
- 11:39Flower girl and is trying to do his best to win her love.
- 11:44He runs into a well. His title is the erratic
- 11:50millionaire who tries to kill himself because his wife has
- 11:54left him, chaplain saves his life, and they become best.
- 11:57Drunken Ends until he's not drunk anymore and then he
- 12:00doesn't like him and doesn't remember him, but then he gets
- 12:03drunk again and they hang out, but then he's not drunk and they
- 12:07stopped hanging out. But Chaplin the Tramp finds a
- 12:10way to get into a boxing match in order to win money and he is
- 12:16given money from the millionaire to be able to help heal his his
- 12:21blind five-second friend, and it is he successful.
- 12:27You'll have to watch the movie. The find that bomb.
- 12:29We're going to spoil everything until the last five minutes and
- 12:32then you have to watch that for yourself.
- 12:33I mean it's only been out for like what 89 90 years.
- 12:37So yeah. You know, Mariah you have been
- 12:40waiting so patiently in the background here and I appreciate
- 12:43you letting us ramble as we set the stage for this movie.
- 12:47Can you give us like just a brief overview of the history of
- 12:52the character of the Tramp? This was Chaplin's, you know,
- 12:55like honestly it was the only character He played for decades.
- 12:58I don't know if I can adequately explain the hold that this
- 13:02character had on the American culture leading, up to City
- 13:05Lights. Yeah, and what's interesting is
- 13:09that Chaplin started out sort of like Keaton as a physical
- 13:13performer for the British version of Vaudeville and was a
- 13:19physical comedian. His whole life, the Tramp was
- 13:23created on this 18:14 short films that were over 100 years
- 13:29called Mabel's strange. Predicament starring Mabel
- 13:33Normand. Who is one of those stars?
- 13:35Who was so famous and now, no one knows who she is.
- 13:38Except a handful of people but Mabel Normand everything Chaplin
- 13:43knew about working on screen he learned from Mabel Normand.
- 13:46So but essentially he accidentally created this sort
- 13:50of trampy character. He showed up in a few other
- 13:55Schwartz, he was in In this other Keystone film, called kid
- 13:59auto races at Venice, which sounds exactly what it is.
- 14:02It's a bunch of kids doing Auto races in Venice and slowly his
- 14:11Tramp clown character, became this National and then later
- 14:16International phenomenon, but also aspects of the visual
- 14:24Styling of the little Tramp with the hat and the mustache came
- 14:27from a very famous French comedian called Max Linder who
- 14:32had just come to America and sort of was starting to
- 14:38influence, American Comedy, was actually film comedy really came
- 14:43out of Frank's, like a lot of things in cinema France was
- 14:47really the first International Superstar.
- 14:50International comedians Superstar comedian.
- 14:53Mostly we're Out of France. So we have Max Linder.
- 14:56You have Mabel Normand. Now, you have the Tramp Charlie,
- 14:58Chaplin, usurps them all Chaplet, obviously is more
- 15:01remembered. You can get, like, Blu-rays of
- 15:04Chaplin's movies. You cannot get, Blu-rays of Max
- 15:07Linder. Although I think some of Mabel
- 15:09arm is homes are now on like Blu-ray set.
- 15:11So there's at least that but obviously he was this, this
- 15:17probably I think still the most famous feasts of the silent era
- 15:23you You come kind of close with Buster Keaton and then you have
- 15:27the three American comedians, everyone remembers which saw
- 15:31Harold Lloyd those three guys are sort of who you remember,
- 15:35now, but they all sort of came out of this earlier history of
- 15:40Silent comedy. That's also came out of
- 15:43Vaudeville like almost everyone came out of Vaudeville.
- 15:46So by the time this film came out 1931, Chaplin had been the
- 15:50Superstar for 15 years or more and but also silent Cinema had
- 15:57gone away. It was the jazz singers. 1927 by
- 16:01making 28 you started to have more and more very primitive.
- 16:07I would say sound films, there are little creaky, they're
- 16:11trying things and some of the greatest silent films, truly it
- 16:16was an art that was like ascendant and then sound came in
- 16:20and it went like in the gutter again.
- 16:23And I don't know if it'll ever get Vaccination 28 frankly, but
- 16:26that's that's another podcast. So chaplain was in the middle of
- 16:29developing this when sound came in and he was like I don't care
- 16:33and I'm very popular. So I'm going to do this movie
- 16:36and people are still going to watch it and people did watch
- 16:39it. And some 1931 you were seeing
- 16:41like pre-code, you know, gangster films, you had pretty
- 16:47much would be like the equivalent of, you know, we're
- 16:51in the Marvel films now, right? If you the equivalent Has like a
- 16:54Terrence Malick like spiritual movie in the forest being the
- 16:59number one box office. Well, you can you you, can you
- 17:02imagine that? But he was, he was so popular
- 17:05that people were like, you know, Cagney can wait, I'm gonna gotta
- 17:09see chaplain. And he five years later made
- 17:12Modern Times, which I think you said, you're going to be
- 17:14watching also a silent film, but I do think his greatest work is
- 17:20the silent films and that's partially because his face is so
- 17:23expressive. It's I said, which I'm sure you
- 17:25noticed while watching the cell, not something we can put on a
- 17:27podcast like something, we can put the essence of his eyes.
- 17:33Like, you know, sound which is sort of, the hard thing about
- 17:37writing and talking about silent film.
- 17:39And I what I always find the most difficult is that there's
- 17:42something ineffable about the magic that comes off in the
- 17:46silent film. And, you know, there's that
- 17:48quote in Sunset Boulevard, we had faces then and I do think it
- 17:53fear is Is something about her secret to that.
- 17:56Yeah, it really is something about the faces that made it
- 17:58into Hollywood and the expressive eyes and the kind of
- 18:01talent that directors, and, and Camera people found.
- 18:06And we're looking for that brought something that isn't
- 18:12necessarily there. For once you have sound there,
- 18:16you know, there's some actors who I think are still a little
- 18:19ineffable, but it's never been the same.
- 18:22Well, I mean by I were talking about it before we got on here,
- 18:26the final scene of the film. Yeah.
- 18:28Like, Charlie is acting his heart out and it's incredible
- 18:33and like the close up on his face.
- 18:35He said, the reason it's so good.
- 18:36As he's a, not acting and beaky underplayed it and you watch
- 18:41that in your like, what? I think this is a minor playing.
- 18:44Yeah, like, we will get into talking about, Chaplin the actor
- 18:48to, but I think that scene is a really great key into talking
- 18:51about Chaplin, the filmmaker here, Brad because this movie
- 18:53Has close-ups very sparingly. Like most of this movie is done
- 18:57either in wide shot. So you can see his whole body or
- 19:00in like a two shot. You know, I'm thinking
- 19:02specifically of like the scene where he's getting ready to go
- 19:04box and he's sitting across the table from the guy that he's
- 19:07going to box with and they have them both framed in the shot.
- 19:10But the reason that ending works so well is you don't see that
- 19:14face in close-up, you know, in that extreme of a close up until
- 19:18the very end of the movie and and it's so effective because
- 19:21Chaplin knows how to play a Shot where the camera is 15 feet away
- 19:26versus how to play a shot where the camera is 6 inches from his
- 19:29face, you know? And honestly, Brad like, I, I'm
- 19:32so excited to dive into talking about the filmmaking behind this
- 19:36movie. So chaplain transitions for
- 19:39making shorts to making feature-length films in 1921
- 19:42when the movie, The kid comes out, so he's been doing it for a
- 19:45decade now, and audiences have come to expect that a Chaplin
- 19:48film is going to be a big event. They're really expensive movies
- 19:52and they make a killing at the box office.
- 19:53Yes, he comes out with a movie in the late 20s called the
- 19:56circus, and the circus is a great movie that has kind of,
- 20:00like, I don't want to say it's like Fallen by the wayside
- 20:03because it's really, really revered.
- 20:06But it's kind of like when we talk about Hitchcock, Brad and
- 20:08how you, and I have reviewed now, like the four biggest
- 20:11Hitchcock movies, and then everybody kind of has like their
- 20:14fifth favorite, Hitchcock movie. It's kind of like that with with
- 20:17the circus. It was a movie that Chaplin had
- 20:20a ton of personal outside. Affecting.
- 20:24And it was really, really a hard period of his life.
- 20:28The movie was successful, but it wasn't as successful as he
- 20:30wanted it to be. He doesn't win any Oscars for
- 20:33it, except they give him an honorary Oscar, which made him
- 20:36feel like even more embarrassed and insulted by it, because the
- 20:39movie wasn't really good enough in their eyes to win competitive
- 20:42Oscars. And so, that's when The Jazz
- 20:45Singer gets released, and the world is going crazy for talkies
- 20:49and perhaps stubbornly, perhaps, because he really did think
- 20:53this, he would work better as a silent.
- 20:55He decided to plow ahead with this movie as a silent, but he
- 20:59figured out that there were elements of the new sound that
- 21:03you could have basically imprinted onto the film, that
- 21:07really worked in his favor for the first time, he could put a
- 21:10score to the movie and it would be the same score in the exact
- 21:13same spot at the exact same tempo as he's always wanted it
- 21:16to be. And so the, you know, the music
- 21:18is part of the movie. And then he also does this thing
- 21:22where he's really Ragging on the crappy, sound quality of early
- 21:27talkies? Because it, you know, I just
- 21:29imagine a crowded theater, the lights go down this movie starts
- 21:33and this is an audience that's been used to like craning their
- 21:36necks to try to figure out what people are saying on this
- 21:39horribly recorded. You know, Contraption for the
- 21:41last three years that we've had talkies.
- 21:44And the first thing you hear is Chaplin, making fun of that
- 21:47because it fades up on this scene of a mayor, dedicating a
- 21:53statue. Ooh and instead of a voice
- 21:55coming out of his mouth, it's Chaplin playing a kazoo and just
- 21:59going to another and it is like it's it's such a mean joke, but
- 22:05it is so silly and it's so funny and it perfectly sets the stage
- 22:09for what's going to happen in the movie.
- 22:11Yeah, I when re-watching, it this this week, I forgot how
- 22:17funny that sounds you is, because it is sort of like, the
- 22:20peanuts. Yes.
- 22:22You know, when the adults speak it?
- 22:24Yep. The and it's so that eats it's
- 22:27funny because it's this in joke about sound, but it's also sort
- 22:31of similar to all of his. He's running.
- 22:36Not hatred, but running ragging of organized.
- 22:40Yeah. Like 40 figures it already.
- 22:42Yeah, he's always. He's always trying to find ways
- 22:44to cause chaos and he just starts his movie, straight up
- 22:48being like his mares full of full of crap.
- 22:51So, why we don't even need to listen.
- 22:53And I I love that. Hehe doesn't give him an
- 22:56intertidal either. So you don't know.
- 22:59You don't know what he's supposed to be saying it's time
- 23:01we don't need the speech. And and the best thing is as
- 23:05with any great comedian, the inside joke, works like
- 23:09everybody who was there in the time understood what he was
- 23:12trying to say, but it still is funny.
- 23:14If you have no idea, the joke he's trying to make about, you
- 23:18know, Takis at the time like here, here we are.
- 23:21You know, 90 years later. It's still just funny to hear
- 23:26like it still is something that's amusing.
- 23:28I think it's, it's stuff like that.
- 23:30That makes him stand out to me, that it doesn't just work as an
- 23:34inside joke. It also works as just a funny
- 23:38gag. You Know, audio gag in the film
- 23:41Brad, you know, it's hard to talk about performances when we
- 23:45think about this movie, because it's like so dominated by
- 23:47chaplains character, and we will obviously be talking about
- 23:51chaplains performance throughout this episode.
- 23:52But Where would you like to start in terms of like other
- 23:56players in the cast that you really like their performance?
- 24:00Honestly, I really like the butler.
- 24:02Mmm. And I really liked the other
- 24:06fighter who he was fighting against.
- 24:08Yeah. Like I think we'll get to
- 24:10Virginia Cheryl and Harry Myers who played the millionaire in
- 24:14the blind girl. But if we're just going to give
- 24:17a quick shout out to anybody else.
- 24:19I really enjoyed the butler who, you know, engages in some of the
- 24:23physical comedy. Midi with Chaplin as well as the
- 24:27he seems to be titled A Prizefighter.
- 24:31So both of those actors are actually people to Chaplin had
- 24:34worked with a ton in the past and they were kind of like part
- 24:36of his company and the guy that plays the butler will actually
- 24:39see him again in Modern Times And like a really small role
- 24:43when we watch that movie. But yeah, man, I'm totally with
- 24:45you. They're both just like the great
- 24:48thing about a Chaplin movie is and this is kind of like the
- 24:51terror of working with chaplain from all those stories that Said
- 24:54he was such a micromanager. The little boy that is blowing,
- 24:58like spit wads at him at the end of the movie, he gave an
- 25:01interview years and years later where he talked about how onset
- 25:04chaplain would would basically be saying, okay, here's how you
- 25:08blow like, a spit wad at me, and then he would go mimic that and
- 25:13then, run over here and mimic him reacting to it.
- 25:16And then he would mimic what the other little boys supposed to be
- 25:18doing and then he would tell every extra in the background.
- 25:20Exactly what they're supposed to be doing.
- 25:22And It's such a choreographed, you know, I don't know, Symphony
- 25:28kind of a thing, but it also makes for every tiny performance
- 25:33in the movie being pitch-perfect.
- 25:35Like I was laughing my ass off. At the moment.
- 25:39We're Chaplin driving a Rolls-Royce dressed to the
- 25:43nines. You know.
- 25:44Pretending he's rich but needing a cigar sees one sitting up
- 25:49sitting on the ground. Pulls his Rolls-Royce over and
- 25:52just knocks a Over so that he could pick up the cigar for
- 25:55itself and then the reaction shot of the homeless guy is like
- 26:00it's Pitch. Perfect, dude.
- 26:02Yeah, dude, there's just so many little gags throughout the film
- 26:07that I like, I don't even think that directors would understand
- 26:13how to keep things moving the way Chaplin does here.
- 26:16Like the he just keeps things moving and there's so many
- 26:19little things kind of happening on the side that honestly, I
- 26:23want to go back. Back and watch this again
- 26:25because I know for a fact that I missed a lot and I'm like, I
- 26:28need to come back to this. And here's the beautiful thing.
- 26:31Bob under 90 minutes and 82 minute movie as God intended, am
- 26:38I right? The best things about chaplain
- 26:41is that he's such a visual Storyteller.
- 26:45But there are always like multiple gags going at once even
- 26:50in some of the scenes that are really heartfelt.
- 26:53There's Often something else if you if you're notif you, if
- 26:57it's, if you're looking there, I'm like he understood that.
- 27:00Every part of the frame should have some sort of information
- 27:05should make you think of something.
- 27:08One of the things I love is how intuitively he uses the camera.
- 27:13And so, there's a very famous story, Brad that I will.
- 27:16Now introduce you to about how he and the co-star of this
- 27:20movie. Virginia cherrylle did not like
- 27:22each other. At all, they did not.
- 27:23Get along. She actually got fired for a
- 27:25period of time and then rehired by chaplain, when he basically
- 27:28figured out he had shot too much to replace her so he just had to
- 27:31bring her back but the scene that he could not crack for
- 27:35months and months and months of the shooting schedule was their
- 27:38introduction to each other. How is, how are we going to
- 27:41convey that? She mistakes him for being a
- 27:46rich man visually because obviously you can't do it.
- 27:48You know, through dialogue and she's blind.
- 27:50So there has to be something that she encountered.
- 27:53Doctors that she hears that would Q into her.
- 27:56That he was a rich person and start this whole kind of comedy
- 27:59of errors and it didn't occur to him until way later in the
- 28:03schedule. The idea of a slamming car door
- 28:06that a rich guy is getting into and she thinks that it's him but
- 28:10leading up to that moment. Brad Chaplin had done 342 takes
- 28:17of this scene and it was trying to work it out as they were
- 28:21acting it out and that's kind of what drove Virginia cherrylle
- 28:24crazy about it was because she could tell that he didn't really
- 28:27have it figured out and he just was waiting for the inspiration
- 28:29to come by making them. Continue to perform it until
- 28:33something happened. He did more takes on that than
- 28:37we have done episodes of this podcast but like Far and Away.
- 28:41More like, 150 more take. Yeah, I was gonna say when they
- 28:45talk about filmmakers like Fincher Kubrick who did life,
- 28:49lots of cakes Chaplin is absolutely on that list.
- 28:53I think this is the record on a, for his, in terms of how much.
- 28:58But is she shot me? Because he made the film over
- 29:00two years and not normally. When you hear like, oh, it took
- 29:04two years to make this movie like normally that's because,
- 29:07you know, like Claudia Wheels girlfriends or something where
- 29:09she was shooting it on a Saturday once a week.
- 29:13You know, when she had the money - thing, like it was not common
- 29:18for a movie, unless it was like Von stroheim's greed.
- 29:22It was not common for a movie. To take that long to make and
- 29:26you know in the teens when he was starting out those
- 29:29filmmakers are making the to reelers wanted to realize they
- 29:31were making one of those a week. It was a new TV episode he shot
- 29:36over three hundred thousand feet of film for this movie.
- 29:43This is the equivalent of like went not to bring my leg up
- 29:46again, with Malik made The Thin Red Line.
- 29:48And he shot so much footage. There was supposedly an eight
- 29:53hour Our assembly cut of that film before, you know, before
- 29:58they whittled it down to what we ended up seeing.
- 29:59That's why I like half the cast for The Thin Red Line is not in
- 30:03the movie but eventually from the three hundred thousand feet
- 30:08of film, The the 89 minute film is yeah 8,000 just 80 100 feet
- 30:14so like that's It's a lot of filled that didn't end up on The
- 30:19Cutting Room floor and, you know, it's a good digital you
- 30:22can you can just keep shooting with film.
- 30:24You have to keep buying more film you have to, um, you know.
- 30:29Oh, so I was going to say one of the things I love about him as
- 30:31the as a director though is that, he's so clearly
- 30:35understands how to move the camera and that scene in
- 30:37particular is such a very simple pan.
- 30:40Like it is, it is like the two of them standing against this
- 30:43gate and then when she hears the car door, slamming the A very
- 30:47quickly it's like almost like a whip pan at pans right over to
- 30:49what she's hearing and then very slowly, pans back over again as
- 30:54chaplain sneaks away. And one of the things that the
- 30:58silent the great silent directors did so well, was to
- 31:01know how to choreograph the action and how to consider the
- 31:06camera as like another member of that kind of dance.
- 31:09I guess, you know, I remember talking to you about the movie
- 31:11are our last year and how everybody freaked out about the
- 31:15the choreography to that song. Now, You not to and the very
- 31:17famous clip that's been gift to death.
- 31:19Now of just them like fixed in the center of the frame as it
- 31:24kind of tracks to the right and they just follow it as they're
- 31:26dancing. Like as hard as they can and I
- 31:29remember, you know, making a post about this and saying like
- 31:31this is what American directors of modern musicals are not
- 31:35remembering anymore. Is that the most compelling
- 31:37camera move in the musical is just to put your subject in the
- 31:41dead center of the screen and then either track or pan along
- 31:45with them because bodies, And motion are compelling in
- 31:48themselves. Like you don't have to make the
- 31:50most complex camera move to go along with it.
- 31:53And I think, Chaplin understood that better than almost any
- 31:56director because he knew what he was capable of and he knew what
- 31:59he could choreograph in front of the camera.
- 32:02And so the camera moves are never Superfluous.
- 32:05You know what I mean? It's just exactly what needs to
- 32:07be done, and if it tracks a little bit, if it Wheels around
- 32:10the boxing ring a little bit, it's just because that's what's
- 32:13needed for that shot and then everything you see is creating
- 32:16Enough movement to accentuate that and he said that he thought
- 32:20of himself as a dancer always. And I think you see that in a
- 32:25way he performs as the Tramp but also you see it like you said in
- 32:30the fluid camera movements. And I think some of the reasons
- 32:32he had issues with some of his leading ladies, he did not
- 32:37repeat leading ladies that often was he didn't always cast.
- 32:42Somebody who thought of themselves as a dancer who
- 32:44thought like a dancer who understood the that I, that way
- 32:49of making a film. Whereas, like, some of the
- 32:53actors, like, you mentioned the boxer.
- 32:57He was a keystone cop. They had no, they'd known each
- 32:59other, you know, going back to the beginning of each in their
- 33:03careers and the Keystone Cops while you know, very funny were
- 33:07sort of It's more similar to dancers than any other kind of
- 33:12Comedy because that that running chasing athleticism that they
- 33:16did and the tumbling. And the following is sort of a
- 33:18mixture of dance, and acrobatics, really.
- 33:23And I think you see the more successful Co-stars for chaplain
- 33:29are ones who came out of that earlier era of filmmaking
- 33:32because they understood that way of filmmaking.
- 33:34As opposed to the sort of matinee Idol drama style
- 33:39actresses who are quite as used to thinking about their bodies
- 33:44that way. Yeah, exactly.
- 33:46And what's interesting about this coming in 1931, is that you
- 33:51stopped seeing that kind of fluid camera movement, but in
- 33:53the 19 late 1900's like from 1925, to 1928 those.
- 33:58Montero films, tend to be the ones people watch the most.
- 34:01I think because they have that beautiful camera movement and
- 34:05they've gotten to a point where they've been doing it for 30
- 34:07years, and they understand how to choreograph big Scopes, or to
- 34:11move the camera in such a way that you feel like you're
- 34:14immersed in the film. When 1831 most films weren't
- 34:18doing that. They had the creaky sounds, they
- 34:20had more stationary camera shots again because you had to worry
- 34:24about where's the microphone, right?
- 34:27And You do see some filmmakers making pre codes that have a
- 34:33little more finesse to them and they tend to be again, the
- 34:36filmmakers who started out as silent film directors in the
- 34:39teens. And so they've been doing it for
- 34:41so long that just adding, adding a microphone didn't, you know,
- 34:46salt their game too much but you but the bulk of what you saw.
- 34:50And then I early, 1930s is the camera movements just gets gets
- 34:53really stationary and so you have a movie like this.
- 34:58Come out and people are so used to, you know, not this anymore,
- 35:04like they've gotten. They've gotten used to the new
- 35:08normal and suddenly they reminded of what film could be
- 35:12and I think that's part of why this has a legacy to it in a way
- 35:15that few films from this year do.
- 35:18That's a good point, I didn't think about that.
- 35:19I mean, it's kind of the opposite of what I was saying
- 35:21because I'm like, you know, chaplains, not moving the camera
- 35:25in these really intricate wonders like Spielberg would you
- 35:28know? And that's because the camera is
- 35:29huge and bulky at that point. But also what you're saying is
- 35:33because of the the kind of restrictions that a lot of these
- 35:37directors were facing with the implementation of sound.
- 35:39They just didn't move the camera at all.
- 35:41Yeah. And so this probably looks 10
- 35:43times as fluid to the normal person who is used to just
- 35:47seeing a Asian every camera, I love that.
- 35:49Yeah, you, it really like pre codes and interesting era
- 35:52because the stories get really racy a costume to get really,
- 35:57really beautiful, but scandalous.
- 36:00But the camera work is leaves a lot to be.
- 36:06Except for the busy, obviously, the Busby Berkeley ones because
- 36:08he again, he was a choreographer and he figured out ways.
- 36:11You don't need the sound to really work.
- 36:13When you're, like, going underneath someone legs right
- 36:16around them to use able Do a lot of what's beautiful and known in
- 36:19his craw, graffiti because the sound was added later for all
- 36:22those dance numbers that Busby Berkeley shot when when you're
- 36:28doing like a costume drama or like a Joan Crawford film or
- 36:31something. Where it's dialogue, heavy, you
- 36:34end up having less interesting camera moves for quite a while
- 36:38because you would hear everything with the boom mic and
- 36:42and I think those films tend to be sometimes a little creepy and
- 36:47I love them. I love the pre-code era.
- 36:49I pretty much love every era. It's hard hard for me to find an
- 36:51arrow that I don't like, but you have to kind of have more
- 36:54context in a way and so it's another are that's not well
- 37:00remembered. I think prequels are starting to
- 37:01have a little more of a Resurgence of think Criterion
- 37:04channel has done a great job of trying to get people to watch
- 37:07them but begin you just you have a film like this and you look at
- 37:12this film and you look at most of the other fellows from 1931.
- 37:14You're like but be we did Like maybe we should just stop having
- 37:19sounds reliable again. Yeah.
- 37:22Brad real quick. Before we go to break because we
- 37:24do need a break. I want to say up front, like,
- 37:27we've been talking about all of the incredible technical
- 37:29achievements of this movie and all of the historical context
- 37:33that it was released in two. I just want to say very plainly.
- 37:36This is a very silly, very funny movie for most of its run time.
- 37:39It's, I mean, it's super profound and yet wrenching at
- 37:42the end, but like, this is a hilarious comedy and I was I was
- 37:46going to say, The boxing scene the physicality of that scene
- 37:51reminded me of watching Looney Tunes growing.
- 37:55Yeah, you know I mean like it feels like something where you
- 37:59have Bugs Bunny being chased by the hunter, whatever his name is
- 38:05Elmer farmer. Fuck.
- 38:06Yeah. Like it feels like that but it's
- 38:10live action and it's hilarious. And that there's so many visual
- 38:15gags in that scene that Yeah, but I have with you.
- 38:18This is just a fun movie that just so happens to be
- 38:22technically. Brilliant, yeah, well and that's
- 38:25that's another thing like talking about that boxing scene.
- 38:28You know, I think the people who have never seen a Chaplin movie,
- 38:31they have an idea of chaplain as like this.
- 38:33Funny pratfall guy. He's a guy that's gonna get
- 38:35knocked over or do something silly with his body but what I
- 38:38love is like when you actually watch the gags, not only are the
- 38:41gags incredibly intricate with their physicality, but they also
- 38:45have so much like character. And behind them and he does a
- 38:49great job of setting up the gag. There's like ten minutes of
- 38:52build-up to the actual fight and chaplain gets roped into
- 38:57fighting so he can win money for this blind girl.
- 38:59And the guy that he's going to fight is going to split the
- 39:01money with him 50/50, because he just wants a quick Buck.
- 39:04But then that guy gets a telegram, it says, get out of
- 39:06town, the cops are after you. So they pull another guy off the
- 39:09street and he's big and lumbering and he's just going to
- 39:11beat the hell out of Charlie Chaplin.
- 39:13And so, then you get this great sequence, were chaplains trying
- 39:16to like flatter him. And like be real chummy with him
- 39:19so he won't get beat up and then when they finally get into the
- 39:22ring chaplains, taking every opportunity to take cheap shots
- 39:25at this guy so that he can knock him out because he's scared.
- 39:28And when the guy finally starts to get woozy, you get that great
- 39:31little beat of Chaplin, like, pushing down on his shoulders,
- 39:34to try to get him the ball quicker.
- 39:37It's just like, I think the thing that people don't realize
- 39:40if you've never watched one of these movies, is that it's not
- 39:43just a guy falling over for a gag.
- 39:46It is like, it's Really well thought out and we'll get around
- 39:49to this. When we do our let's make it a
- 39:50double. But I think that the influence
- 39:53of Chaplin's comic timing and the way these gags are set up
- 39:56are still being mimicked to this day and Cinema Brad.
- 40:01Yeah, no, I'm with you man. I think that it's almost like
- 40:05when you see a brilliant stand-up comedian the way that
- 40:09they intro with the joke and then three or four times
- 40:14throughout the set, they refer back to that joke.
- 40:17They just weave it into their other jokes and then there's a
- 40:20Brilliance to it and you see that with chaplain here that he
- 40:24sets the stage. And then he uses that stage
- 40:27throughout the rest of the film building on itself to to build
- 40:31better and better jokes. Well, Brad, I like to think that
- 40:36our podcast builds to better and better moments.
- 40:38So like when we invite people like Mariah on.
- 40:42Exactly. Let's hit pause here.
- 40:44Let's go. Try this Town, Branch rye, and
- 40:46then we'll come back and finish. Talking about City Lights.
- 40:48What do you say? Let's get to it.
- 40:56Alright, so today we are checking out Town Branch.
- 41:00Why Brad Town Branch is a distillery in Lexington Kentucky
- 41:04that is near and dear to my heart because it is the first
- 41:09Distillery I ever took a tour of on the Kentucky Bourbon Trail.
- 41:13Hey, when I first moved to Lexington, the Lexington area,
- 41:16my wife and I went to All Tech which is the giant conglomerate
- 41:19that owns Lexington Distilling Company.
- 41:22They also, in fact, so how'd they make Kentucky bourbon?
- 41:25That's right, which is incredible.
- 41:27They also have a brewery on site and so when you go on the tour
- 41:31you check in you pay your $10 or whatever it is and they give you
- 41:34a little cup full of tokens. And the cool thing about this
- 41:38Distillery tour is that you can cash in the tokens to try
- 41:41samples of whatever you want, along the way.
- 41:44So you could spend your four or five tokens on four or five
- 41:47beers to try, you could spend them on all the spirits they
- 41:50make, or you could mix and match.
- 41:52So it's a really, really fun and super customizable.
- 41:54Abel tour. That was actually the first two
- 41:57are. I took my parents onto and they
- 41:58came to visit when we lived in Kentucky.
- 42:00I just think it's a really fun entry point.
- 42:03Like if you're not all consumed by being a bourbon bro, then you
- 42:07just want to kind of dabble in the world of bourbon.
- 42:09It's a really good starter level.
- 42:12Distillery tour. So Town, Branch Rye, here's the
- 42:17thing. Brad, I don't know what to do
- 42:19with this because the bottle that I have sitting in front of
- 42:22me right now has been discontinued.
- 42:25No, of you will remember I'll send you a picture of what the
- 42:27bottle used to look like they. Have since rebranded, and
- 42:30they've kind of relaunched Town Branch as a brand.
- 42:34In these Nifty looking Square bottles.
- 42:36The thing about the Old Town Branch, why is that?
- 42:39I can't actually tell if everything in this bottle was
- 42:43distilled on all Tech's campus in Lexington and this is just a
- 42:47little insight into the jargon that they put on labels when
- 42:51when you flip a bottle over and on the back of it it says
- 42:54something like Like this whiskey was made in Indiana or something
- 42:59but bottled by Jack and Jill's distillery in Bardstown
- 43:03Kentucky, like they didn't make it.
- 43:05They got it from Indiana. One really confusing word that
- 43:10they use sometimes is produced by.
- 43:12Because what does that even mean?
- 43:14Like, there's no regulation behind produced by it's not, it
- 43:18doesn't say distilled by. So I have no idea because it
- 43:21says, produced by all text Lexington Distilling Company.
- 43:24In Lexington, Kentucky, I don't know that if they distilled all
- 43:28this or not by produced you mean like pulled it out of a hat like
- 43:32a magician. Yeah, I think I know that
- 43:37they're more. Recent label says that it was
- 43:40all distilled on-site. So this may be a combination of
- 43:43stuff, they distilled. And then they blended with older
- 43:46stock that they sourced from somewhere else.
- 43:49Here's the other thing about it, when I tried to look this up
- 43:52online even though they make a lot of Of whiskey and they're a
- 43:55fairly, you know, a fairly sizable player in the industry.
- 43:59Now there's not a lot of information about this whiskey
- 44:02online. I know that some of our more
- 44:04learned friends, probably know the ins and outs of All Tech so
- 44:08like Zach Johnston yeah. Hit me up after this episode and
- 44:12let me know what was going on with the old label Town Branch.
- 44:15But for now Brad, I'm just going to assume this was all made at
- 44:20The Distillery in Lexington. All I hear you saying is welcome
- 44:24to film and Where everything is made up and the points don't
- 44:26matter. This is why whiskey scares
- 44:29people off Brad, like people who aren't in the world of whiskey.
- 44:33All this jargon, all this like does any of this matter at the
- 44:37end of the day, does the whiskey taste good or not?
- 44:39And that's what we're here to figure out.
- 44:41This is a 100 Proof rye whiskey. It does not say that.
- 44:44It is straight rye whiskey. Which is what the new label
- 44:46says. So I have no idea how freaking
- 44:48old this is either. So I'm gonna assume it's at
- 44:52least four years old because there's no age statement on the
- 44:54bottle. Let's give it a try Brad.
- 44:56What do you picking up on the nose?
- 44:58The nose here has some Vanilla, some, some clove, some some rye
- 45:03coming through, and then almost like a, like, a spiced cherry,
- 45:08and it's kind of unique and interesting.
- 45:11I'm intrigued by it. I will give it a seven and a
- 45:13half out of ten. I am not ashamed to admit.
- 45:16That drinking Rye is always a humbling experience for me,
- 45:20Brad, because I like to think that with as many Whiskey's as
- 45:23we try to have a fairly discernible.
- 45:24In palette now. But there's something about the
- 45:27Rye grain that I could never pick up as many things on the
- 45:31nose, as you can with Rye. Like I just can't, I smell ride.
- 45:34It smells like a ride. It doesn't smell like a minty
- 45:37Rye. I think in my mind I have two
- 45:39categories of Ryan. It's like minty rye and Dill rye
- 45:44and this is more Dill Rye for me, which I'm people with
- 45:47peated, scotch and non peated. Exactly.
- 45:50I like it a lot. I actually, if I'm gonna drink
- 45:53Rye, I want it to taste like rice.
- 45:54Why? Like, I wanted to go all the way
- 45:56and this one really has a strong Rye grain with that almost kind
- 46:01of soured ill presence to it. A little bit of sweetness, kind
- 46:04of undergirding it. I like it a lot.
- 46:06I'm going to give it a seven and a half on the nose.
- 46:09Yeah. And when I got into the palette,
- 46:11there's some really nice complexity here that that isn't
- 46:15overwhelming. I think that there's a little
- 46:17bit of a citrus flavor in the middle of my palate.
- 46:21There was some honey on the tip of my tongue and then they're
- 46:24there. There is just this really nice
- 46:26feeling of like a fresh spongy spice cake that had that, you
- 46:33know, wasn't as sweet as it was kind of savory.
- 46:37And then at the at the back end I finished after drinking a
- 46:40little bit and felt like, you know, there's just some really
- 46:43nice vanilla here. So 8 out of 10 on the pallet for
- 46:46me, I do not like this, this who, you know, sometimes like
- 46:56you can just kind of tell that something's not working for you.
- 46:59It doesn't mean it's not good but like it just doesn't work
- 47:02for you. For me, the way this manifested
- 47:04was like really young Rider grain and then it tipped into
- 47:09like super bitter. Grapefruit like not sour but
- 47:15really, really bitter. And then the bitterness kind of
- 47:19fed back into the youthfulness of it and it's like this /,
- 47:22self-perpetuating cycle and by the Time I swallowed.
- 47:26I was like, oh man. I don't like this at all.
- 47:28It started off, okay. It's like one of those
- 47:31experiences really like, hmm. Oh, it's just it kept getting
- 47:39worse and worse for me. This is a 4.5 out of 10 on the
- 47:43pain. The power 0.5.
- 47:45I mean, I'm not, this is wow. And like the longer I sit here
- 47:50with this aftertaste, it is not not doing it for me, man.
- 47:54Man. Well I'm just gonna I'm just
- 47:56going to finish out my finish and balance scores, seven and a
- 47:59half on the Finish. There's some Oak, some Vanilla,
- 48:02some ride, nothing too crazy, but nothing, nothing bad,
- 48:05nothing, sour, bitter, gross or anything, anybody who tells you
- 48:10otherwise is crazy seven out of ten on the balance decently
- 48:14complex has some good flavors but nothing that makes it stand
- 48:18out. I'm on step number three and it
- 48:23is approaching palatability at this point.
- 48:29But yeah, man, this is like the closest thing that I like.
- 48:31I don't know what I could compare it to.
- 48:33It's like, if a whiskey could get skunked this is like what
- 48:37what it's doing in my mouth. Does that make sense?
- 48:39Like I know you're not having the same experience but I'm
- 48:41trying to parse out what part of it of this is just like a really
- 48:47herbal experience versus youthfulness on the Grain versus
- 48:51something really off in how bitter it is and it's just not
- 48:57working for me, man, I'm going to give it, I don't know a 5 out
- 49:01of 10 on the Finish. It's a little bit better than
- 49:03the palette was for me, but I'm like slightly worried that
- 49:07something is off with my bottle. And therefore, the balance is
- 49:15way out of whack on this bad boy.
- 49:18It started off okay. And it's Early tipped into
- 49:21fearing for my safety. So I am going to give it a five
- 49:24point five on the balance, the Han.
- 49:28Yeah, so the value here, Bob, I'm seeing this bottle at $49.
- 49:33Is that what you're having at? Yeah, Brad, that looks about
- 49:36right now. Again, this bottle that we're
- 49:38drinking out, it has been discontinued which is really
- 49:41hard. It's hard to review a product
- 49:43that they may or may not have completely overhauled at this
- 49:45point. And I would be more than happy
- 49:47to come back around to this someday.
- 49:49And try the New Town Branch Rye. If in fact, it is new and not
- 49:53just the same whiskey with a new label on it.
- 49:55So, let's be very clear here Old Town, Branch Rye.
- 50:01I don't know how much it would cost you to find a bottle of it.
- 50:03I would not advise you seeking this out by any means, but we're
- 50:07going to score it as if it is priced at the New Town, Branch
- 50:11Rye price. And at that price, Brad, I
- 50:14cannot advise against this strongly enough.
- 50:18This is this Is the most visceral reaction to a whiskey
- 50:23on a regular episode that we've done in a long, long time for
- 50:27me. Yeah, what's your score for a
- 50:30$50 bottle then? I trust your palate enough to
- 50:36think that maybe I'm just reacting weird to this and that
- 50:38it's not just like a horrible product but I trust my palate
- 50:43enough to know that I would never spend money on this so I'm
- 50:45going to give it a 3 out of 10 on value.
- 50:49Yeah I actually gave it a 5 out of 10.
- 50:51I don't think this is a great value.
- 50:54I think that overall it's a decent product that should be
- 50:58about 10 to 15 dollars cheaper. Like If this was a thirty to
- 51:02thirty five dollar bottle and say Yep this is really solid
- 51:06value, but at $50, I don't know. It's just, it's just not quite
- 51:12as worth it for me. I'm coming to a 35.5 out of 50.
- 51:16Bob, where are you at? In the teens, I am coming out to
- 51:20a 25.5 out of 50. So let's bring us to an average
- 51:24of a 30.5 or a 61 out of 100. I absolutely.
- 51:30And unequivocally do Recommend trying or buying this.
- 51:33However, I will say, I absolutely recommend going on
- 51:38the alltech tour. Like I'm I'm shocked at how?
- 51:42I don't remember this being this bad, which is making me wonder
- 51:45if like, if they did. In fact, just overhaul the
- 51:48entire, you know, product itself.
- 51:51Yeah. Yeah.
- 51:52And maybe they did and like you said, we are both big fans at
- 51:56alltech. They make great beer.
- 51:58They make good whiskey. So go check them out.
- 52:01Out. If you are in Lexington, I think
- 52:04I would man out of it. It doesn't matter if I recommend
- 52:07this Bob, you can't get it anymore.
- 52:10So go drink, go drink, Kentucky Bourbon Barrel Ale, it's
- 52:13delicious, it's real good. My wife's favorite beer.
- 52:15That's, that's my, that's my recommendation for the day, get
- 52:19it on tap, if you can that I will say, like, in the bottle
- 52:23it's like a solid seven and a half beer, but getting it on tap
- 52:27as like a nine and a half out of ten experience.
- 52:31All right, man, that was a letdown.
- 52:33But, you know, what's not a letdown is talking to our new
- 52:35friend Mariah Gates about silent movies.
- 52:38So what do you say? We get back into talking about
- 52:40City Lights. Let's get to it.
- 52:46All right, everybody that was Town Branch Rye, a whiskey that
- 52:51is might be one of the most simply named Whiskey's.
- 52:54We've drank in a long time. Bob they really have been a
- 52:57mouthful lately. It's nice to just stay in town
- 52:59Branch. Right.
- 52:59And be done with it. That's it.
- 53:03Well, Brad. It is time for us to get into
- 53:05our next segment of the day Canada's favorite segment, which
- 53:08we call to fax in a falsehood is gonna try to stop you.
- 53:13Bob All right. And what is wrong to fax in a
- 53:20falsehood to fax in? A falsehood, is the part of the
- 53:23podcast where Brad presents three items to me, as fact about
- 53:27the making of this movie, one of which is a complete fabrication
- 53:31that Brad has made up. And it's my job to figure out
- 53:34which one is the LIE Brad. I believe I am sitting at 500 on
- 53:38the year right now at a comeback.
- 53:40Victory last week. Oh no I didn't.
- 53:42I had to defeat last week. You definitely had VI had to.
- 53:46Thank you very much. Thanks Vince for that one.
- 53:49Vince, Mancini did not help me out on that one at all.
- 53:52So, I think you're right, I am, I might be one under 500, which
- 53:56puts the pressure on Mariah, to help me with this to facts in a
- 53:59falsehood Brad. I am a little comforted by the
- 54:01fact that you don't know anything about silent movies.
- 54:04Yeah, I feel is Eero confidence. I almost wanted to, like, call a
- 54:08truce for the next four or five weeks, however, long, we're
- 54:12doing chaplain, but I'm going to Soldier on.
- 54:15On ahead and see if I can catch you.
- 54:18I'll be honest. If I can catch you this week.
- 54:21I think I should just win for the season, all right.
- 54:25With Mariah helping you and I don't doubt that you will get
- 54:28this one. Well, I am not sweating over
- 54:31here. So hit me with your two facts
- 54:33and falsehood. Alright fact.
- 54:36Number one, one of Sir, Charles Chaplin's friends, the famous
- 54:39illustrator Ralph Barton was on set one day during the filming
- 54:43of the scene where Charlie in the blind, girl.
- 54:45Me Meet his home movies, which appear in unknown Chaplin from
- 54:491983? Are the only known behind the
- 54:51scenes footage of chaplain at work in costume as the Tramp.
- 54:57Fax number to the scene where chaplain first, meets The
- 55:00Eccentric eccentric millionaire had to be reshot many, many
- 55:05times over due to chaplains insistence that Harry Myers was
- 55:08not, quote falling properly and quotes into the river.
- 55:14Fax number three, Sir Charles Chaplin had invited Albert
- 55:17Einstein and his wife Elsa to join him at the Los Angeles
- 55:20premiere on January 30th 1931 when the house lights came up,
- 55:24Chaplin was surprised to see Einstein's eyes.
- 55:26Were tearing over at the final scene.
- 55:31I believe number three is a fact because I do well.
- 55:34I know the first part of that statement is a fact.
- 55:36I know he took Albert Einstein and his wife to the premier, and
- 55:39I like to think that mr. Einstein dr.
- 55:41Einstein had a heart and was affected by the end of this
- 55:44movie. So, I'm going to say three is
- 55:46true. One and two both sound
- 55:50plausible, but I might have to phone a friend here Mariah.
- 55:54Are you gravitating towards either of these as the
- 55:56falsehood? I feel like there's more behind
- 56:00the scenes. That's what to catching me up
- 56:02there because I know, I know that that documentary but I feel
- 56:05like there's more behind the scenes than just the one movie.
- 56:09Yeah, the in costume is what's throwing me off here?
- 56:12Yeah, he wasn't it. And, you know, I actually was
- 56:14just watching the Criterion Blu-ray for city lights before
- 56:17we started recording. And I had just started watching
- 56:20that behind-the-scenes footage, so I know that that's a thing, I
- 56:23know it exists. But yeah, is it the only?
- 56:26I don't know, definitely one of those.
- 56:27Like is this, is this too much information?
- 56:30And therefore, it's wrong. Or is it too much information?
- 56:33Because that's exactly the truth.
- 56:35I'm, I'm a terrible phone a friend here because I don't
- 56:38actually know let's. All right, I will, I will bite
- 56:42the bullet. On this one.
- 56:44I'm gonna say number two is the falsehood even though it sounds
- 56:49very plausible. I just think that it sounds a
- 56:54little too simplistic and so I'm going to say Brad wrote that.
- 56:58That sounds insulting our I'm sorry what?
- 57:00I didn't mean it like that, that 100% sounded insulting I will
- 57:06say this. This is the disclaimer.
- 57:09We always let our guests know. These are true as IMDb says
- 57:15they're true. These says, I lifted from the
- 57:17IMDb trivia section. However, Bob you are correct.
- 57:22Number two was the falsehood written by simpleton brows just
- 57:26gonna say thank you. Mr. Simms Plastic.
- 57:30I feel terrible. I didn't mean it like that at
- 57:32all but it worked in my favor. So I do you feel tearing do not
- 57:35retract that statement. At all Mariah has helped me pull
- 57:39ahead on the season and I can Lord it over you now for at
- 57:42least a couple more weeks. Brad.
- 57:44Hmm. Yeah, you're welcome.
- 57:46You're welcome, Baba, suppose. All right, let's get back into
- 57:49talking about this movie. We have left out one, huge
- 57:52component of the movie. When it comes to actress,
- 57:54Virginia cherrylle. We haven't talked about her
- 57:57performance. This is by far the performance
- 57:59that she is best remembered for. I think I said in the first half
- 58:03that they did not really get along at all.
- 58:05I don't think you can really tell this is a pretty
- 58:08exceptional pairing on screen. And, you know, there I don't say
- 58:12their chemistry is palpable, but it kind of is, but I think their
- 58:18commitment to their characters and the way that they
- 58:20dramatically portray each of their respective States, you
- 58:25know what I mean? Him being down on his luck.
- 58:27Her Having a disability Brad. There's a great story of
- 58:30chaplain hiring her because he noticed that she was very near
- 58:35sighted. And so her way of kind of
- 58:37looking like, physically looking at her surroundings made her,
- 58:41the only actress that church, that chaplain screen tested,
- 58:44that could play Blind without being offensive.
- 58:47That's what's that was his, his quote about it.
- 58:50So, that's impressive. I think she's great in this
- 58:53movie, man. Yeah, I think that she has an
- 58:57Credible softness to her, hmm. That counteracts the physicality
- 59:04of Chaplin's, you know, just sticky elating.
- 59:08And just the way he commands the screen, there's there's a
- 59:11gentleness to her that draws you in, and makes sense to why the
- 59:16Tramp would fall in love with her.
- 59:18Is it does that make sense? Oh, 100% Mariah.
- 59:21Like when you think about all of you were mentioning this in the
- 59:25first half, like all of the partners.
- 59:27Has that he shared the screen with over the years?
- 59:29Where would you rank her? And this pairing, I think they
- 59:33are really wonderful together. I think my favorite is, is poly
- 59:37Godard from me to Modern Times names because she's also a
- 59:40clown. But in terms of what I think he
- 59:44wanted to achieve with, with this movie, I think it was
- 59:47perfect casting, even if she was very difficult and she wasn't
- 59:51ever really intending to be an actress.
- 59:53She was just one of those, you know, modern women who got a
- 59:56divorce and move. Moved to LA and made a go of it,
- 59:59kind of thing was a very twenties thing to do.
- 1:00:04She's like, of the first generation of women who really
- 1:00:06had the freedom to try to do something like that ended up in
- 1:00:10this movie. It's almost got fired for this
- 1:00:13movie, made a few other movies, they're not, not very many of
- 1:00:16them, are very good. I like Fast workers.
- 1:00:19It's got John Gilbert in it and make Clark but Virginia tyrol is
- 1:00:23like fifth cast in it. And then really What's
- 1:00:28interesting is that she may have been a great actress in The
- 1:00:32Silent era, right? Because you mention, she has
- 1:00:35that softness and she has that sort of magical quality it, to
- 1:00:41her eyes that were valued in the silent era.
- 1:00:47But if you watch some of her later films, I think fast worker
- 1:00:49is the only one I've seen. She's not great, she's not a
- 1:00:53great actress in terms of speaking.
- 1:00:57So the drachma tiered. Yeah, so the fact that she has
- 1:01:01acted she ended up in basically the last great silent film other
- 1:01:05than modern times last great American silent film is, is kind
- 1:01:09of almost appropriate. Like this was the end of this
- 1:01:12kind of art and she, she came to this Hollywood, write it as this
- 1:01:17part of the art was dying and gave one of the last great
- 1:01:20silent film performances in a film that became Timeless, but
- 1:01:25she's at Timeless Beyond. And I think that's because her
- 1:01:30what the talent she had and maybe it was like, Chad Chaplin,
- 1:01:33maybe the 3,000 or 300,000 feet is just bad footage of her, I
- 1:01:39don't know, but he was able. He was able to find that magic
- 1:01:43in her and put it in this movie and I think it's both a
- 1:01:47testament to him as a director editor and her at least having
- 1:01:51that somewhere in her, you know, right.
- 1:01:53Even if even if that's only 1% of what was on the film, right?
- 1:01:57Right. Mariah normally Bob is the
- 1:02:00expert at giving underhand in childhood but man.
- 1:02:05Oh man, you are gunning for the crown.
- 1:02:07My friend I was gonna save it is it's it's fascinating that she
- 1:02:12is so well known for this one roll, and that's it.
- 1:02:18And I probably more people, I would, I would venture to say
- 1:02:22more people have seen her one, great performance, then probably
- 1:02:26everything that like, Louise Brooks ever did right?
- 1:02:30And you know one is the only looking at Virginia Terrell
- 1:02:32Louise Brooks and saying like they're on the on par or like
- 1:02:35Mabel Normand, same part of its Mabel Normand spells are a lot
- 1:02:39of them are lost but it's interesting and shows sort of
- 1:02:44the the irony of this business that it is, you know, they
- 1:02:49always say like it's not just the talent you have, it's who
- 1:02:51you know. And in this case, you know she
- 1:02:54met Chaplin, she got in this last great Chaplin movie.
- 1:02:57See this last great. Silent era, Chaplin movie.
- 1:02:59And she was nearsighted. There it is, right?
- 1:03:07You can't plan that. So before we wrap up today,
- 1:03:11guys, I want to say that, you know, Brad, we could go on and
- 1:03:15on about our favorite gags in the movie.
- 1:03:16I talked about just that little throwaway moment of him shoving
- 1:03:19over a hobo. I don't know why I laughed so
- 1:03:20hard at that moment, but it really got me.
- 1:03:23There are so many, like, little throwaway gags in this movie,
- 1:03:26but I think On a deeper level than that.
- 1:03:29The reason that chaplains movies are remembered even more than
- 1:03:33his contemporaries like Keaton or Harold Lloyd is that they are
- 1:03:37unashamedly sentimental. I mean they just are like they
- 1:03:41and they so perfectly pair The Melancholy with the comedy and I
- 1:03:46think that that is like the key to understanding chaplain as a
- 1:03:51director, he had like a very keen sense of what the average
- 1:03:55person who was going to his movies.
- 1:03:57Was going through like that. This movie comes out as America
- 1:04:01is recovering not recovering from is like plunging headfirst
- 1:04:05into the Great Depression and it's a movie about insane,
- 1:04:09wealth versus insane, poverty and the Tramp as kind of
- 1:04:13navigating this crazy world around him, and it's
- 1:04:16appropriate. Brad that we just did another
- 1:04:18little mini series on Billy Wilder, because I think that we
- 1:04:22had a really great discussion about how Wilder uses suicide.
- 1:04:27As like a pointing device, in a ton of his movies.
- 1:04:30I've been thinking about that this whole time where I'm like,
- 1:04:34I was completely wrong like, like Brian for reference.
- 1:04:38I kept saying I was like I feel like there's nobody in Hollywood
- 1:04:42that's willing to go in the like hey let's talk about suicide,
- 1:04:46you know there will be a fun time for everyone and yet Billy
- 1:04:50Wilder does it and then I come here and I watched our own you
- 1:04:52know mr. Chaplin sir Chaplin and he it's
- 1:04:57like Like 15-20 minutes into the movie and you got the
- 1:05:00millionaire trying to kill himself.
- 1:05:01Mmm, I mean like and it's not just done for last.
- 1:05:05Like, that is one of the funnier gags in the movie.
- 1:05:07It's also like the darkest gag in the whole movie, but I think
- 1:05:10it's really indicative of the fact that chaplain is always
- 1:05:13willing to go. There Chaplin is willing to show
- 1:05:15P, you know, in the movie, The Circus, I started watching it
- 1:05:18with my six-year-old and there's a very funny gags and then like
- 1:05:22the, the main female protagonist in that movie is getting like
- 1:05:26horrifically. To buy her dad and that movie
- 1:05:28just like getting the crap kicked out of her in more a
- 1:05:31six-year-old kid, I was like, all right, we're gonna press
- 1:05:34pause on the circus and let's go to something else now.
- 1:05:37But I think, again, the reason that it's so successful is that
- 1:05:42chaplain knows when to use the dark moments of humanity to
- 1:05:46alike to find the humor in it. But then to also like Leverage
- 1:05:50those moments into something like the ending of this movie
- 1:05:53which we still haven't really talked about.
- 1:05:55I really wouldn't discuss the ending of this movie.
- 1:05:58Definitely one of those greatest endings of all time.
- 1:06:02Endings. You see the SRU, just you see
- 1:06:04that ending? And you're like, why can't
- 1:06:07people why do people not know how to end movies anymore?
- 1:06:10Like, I that's what I and literally said that out loud.
- 1:06:12When I watch this couple days ago, it's like you don't know
- 1:06:15how to end movies anymore is like, this is a perfect ending,
- 1:06:20yeah, right? No 100%.
- 1:06:22The the beauty of the unspoken like Ride off into the sunset.
- 1:06:29You don't, you don't know if they get together, you don't
- 1:06:32know if all these things happen but the, the sentimentality of
- 1:06:36his smile and he's still a little bit like bashful and and
- 1:06:42it's just slowly Fades to Black and the end and it's, it's
- 1:06:47beautiful and it's heartwarming and you don't expect it after
- 1:06:52all the gags that have come through out like, like, you're
- 1:06:54expecting him to fall, you know, pratfall The end and yet it's
- 1:06:59utterly and I'm going to use my favorite word.
- 1:07:02It's utterly sincere Bob. Hmm.
- 1:07:05You know, Brad like we don't often make comparisons to like
- 1:07:08great works of philosophy or religion on this podcast.
- 1:07:12But listen is about to quote gorgeus, listeners of this
- 1:07:17podcast. Know, you know, Brad and I both
- 1:07:19went to Seminary. And so, once in a while,
- 1:07:21something Sparks are interest on the theological front and I was
- 1:07:24watching this movie and I kept thinking of this, this Story in
- 1:07:27the New Testament where Jesus is talking about.
- 1:07:32He encounters a woman at the temple that puts her last two
- 1:07:35mites into the offering and talks about how she ain't more
- 1:07:37than anybody else. And I think, honestly, you know,
- 1:07:40Chaplin not known for his religious allegories.
- 1:07:44But this is, this is his most like nakedly religious symbolism
- 1:07:50iconography kind of movie for me because it is, it is such a, an
- 1:07:56obvious like self. A pouring out kind of thing.
- 1:07:59And it's so obviously connected to the poor and to the
- 1:08:03impoverished. And like, I just love the ending
- 1:08:07of this movie where you don't know, if this person who is at
- 1:08:11his most destitute. He's been destitute the whole
- 1:08:14movie, but when you see him come out of jail, at the end of the
- 1:08:17movie and he is just literally wearing Rags that are tattered
- 1:08:21and he has no shirt on underneath his iconic Jacket
- 1:08:24anymore. It's like a pitiable state.
- 1:08:27And for him to leave the character of the Tramp in an
- 1:08:31even more. Pitiable State and asking the
- 1:08:34question of like, will he be accepted like this and the the
- 1:08:38last line of the movie to be her saying?
- 1:08:41Yes, I can see. Now it gives you the hope but it
- 1:08:45never actually shows you the payoff and I think that is
- 1:08:48exactly why it's the perfect ending for this movie.
- 1:08:50It's ambiguous, but he still won't let you leave without
- 1:08:54holding out hope that the rest of the world will.
- 1:08:57I'll be as sacrifice self-sacrificial as the Tramp
- 1:09:01is, dude. And even like that line of,
- 1:09:05like, yes, I can see. Now, like that, that for me,
- 1:09:08just sounds like Jesus calling out, like, he who has ears.
- 1:09:11Let him hear. Well, I think like there's,
- 1:09:12there's a very like again, like the way that I was reading in a
- 1:09:17book about city lights today and the the author was commenting on
- 1:09:21how there is a supernatural kind of element to this miracle cure
- 1:09:26for for blindness. That this doctor is healing, you
- 1:09:30know, the poor for free and it's a miracle.
- 1:09:33And all you have to do is come to him.
- 1:09:34Like, it is a very obvious, kind of symbolism in this movie, and
- 1:09:38I don't know to what end like. I don't really know why chaplain
- 1:09:41is being so overt with it, but I really just, I just do love the
- 1:09:47idea of this movie coming out in the middle of the Great
- 1:09:49Depression about Sympathy with and I don't know, solidarity
- 1:09:56with the poorest of the poor and using the Tramp to exemplify
- 1:10:00that and also kind of bashing on the millionaire.
- 1:10:04Little bit like he loses his wife.
- 1:10:08He has thousands of dollars stolen from him.
- 1:10:11They'll not stolen. He gives it away and forgets
- 1:10:14that he gave it away. Robin Hood thing, you know?
- 1:10:16Yeah, totally. Totally Mariah.
- 1:10:17When you think about this movie, you know, obviously, we're over
- 1:10:20here talking about Theology and everything like, What is your
- 1:10:22big takeaway in terms of like the overarching sentiment of the
- 1:10:27movie and what? It's trying to communicate at
- 1:10:29the end, I likes your point about it, having a little
- 1:10:33glimmer of hope at the end. I think a lot of Chaplin's films
- 1:10:39wrestle with Melancholy and wrestle with systems that are
- 1:10:47not for lack of a better word Fair.
- 1:10:50Even even though the American, Remus that everyone with a
- 1:10:53little gumption can make it right.
- 1:10:57But that's not this, that's not how the systems are actually set
- 1:10:59up. And a lot of his movies,
- 1:11:01especially his his teachers sort of investigate that idea like
- 1:11:05the kid is all about, not to spoil the kid but it's about
- 1:11:12poverty and about living on the street and as a child and
- 1:11:17wanting to adopt a child and the issues of like Who's allowed to
- 1:11:22be a parent and who's actually got the best intention for what
- 1:11:28is a family, right? And it's a beautiful film.
- 1:11:31Jackie Coogan is fantastic in it, but it's a lot of his films.
- 1:11:35Look at these systems. And look at how someone like a
- 1:11:38tramp will come in and he doesn't care about the systems.
- 1:11:42And he just kind of fumbling through in between, he sort of
- 1:11:46a, like, a trickster kind of, he's got the coyote God, right?
- 1:11:52And he just sort of in between the lines liminal space kind of
- 1:11:55person and shows you the Folly of, of systems and the Folly of
- 1:11:59the idea that things are fair things.
- 1:12:01Wherever fair not just in America, but like anywhere.
- 1:12:05But, but even though, that's, that Bleak line is always there,
- 1:12:09he always ends on a place of, but maybe right.
- 1:12:13But maybe, maybe with love Things that even as the bad
- 1:12:17system is still in place, will we can find a little Paradise
- 1:12:21for ourselves. And I think that's, that's part
- 1:12:23of why his films are even more Timeless than even Buster.
- 1:12:27Keaton, whose films are may be funnier.
- 1:12:29I think they're funnier, but they're definitely not as deep
- 1:12:34in terms of the emotions. They try to evoke.
- 1:12:36Yeah, in its viewers. Well, you know, if this all
- 1:12:40isn't your cup of tea, dear listener, there is a joke about
- 1:12:44an elephant pooping in this movie.
- 1:12:46So, Oh, like you get. You get the best of both words.
- 1:12:50I have to say, I don't know if you saw Babylon.
- 1:12:53Oh yeah. Babylon, the fact that people
- 1:12:56were upset about that and I was like, okay.
- 1:12:58But do you love City? Only, it's like all of this.
- 1:13:02I like, it's there. So everyone has re-watching,
- 1:13:05this. That was like, ah, it's a
- 1:13:07reference Aeneas that I love that movie memories really
- 1:13:13smart. And I feel like a lot of people
- 1:13:15who knows, Enough to not know everything.
- 1:13:18He's doing thinks that it's not as smart as it is.
- 1:13:20But it's a very smart movie. And, and the main thing that
- 1:13:24every silent comedian knows is here.
- 1:13:28Boy, people falling down and poop jokes are funny and barf
- 1:13:33jokes like Harley times funny. It's funny and Babylon, it's
- 1:13:37funny in the sound joke in Babylon, where it's like, who's
- 1:13:40gonna want sound. And then the guy likes in that
- 1:13:44in the stall, that's so funny. Me, I like that movie.
- 1:13:47Three times, I laughed every time.
- 1:13:49That's a great. That's a great Timeless,
- 1:13:51Timeless joke. And so he the thing that's great
- 1:13:55about chaplain as he does both those things.
- 1:13:56He has this very big bra heart and then he just does the it's
- 1:14:02slapstick for a reason and you know, it's so you get both, you
- 1:14:05get everything. Well, on that note, if we can
- 1:14:08have both Brad, I think this is a good segue into our final
- 1:14:11segment of the day which we call.
- 1:14:13Let's make it a double we near the end of the episode.
- 1:14:16So thanks for listening to the film and whiskey show, but spare
- 1:14:20another film with this one. Even if it's struggling, it's a
- 1:14:22final segment of the day. Now let's make it a double.
- 1:14:25Let's make it. A double is the part of the
- 1:14:26show, where we pair this movie up with another film to make the
- 1:14:30perfect double feature. We were kind of walking Mariah
- 1:14:34through the outline of our show before we hit record.
- 1:14:37And she said, oh, I've already got something for that segment,
- 1:14:40so I want to turn the floor over to you Mariah.
- 1:14:43What is your? Let's make it a double film.
- 1:14:46So I'm actually targets we used to films, so I want a
- 1:14:50proposition to separate double features.
- 1:14:54Now, let's have a feature. Number one, if you want to stay
- 1:14:56in the silent era, double feature.
- 1:15:00Number one is 1928 Lonesome, which is also Criterion film.
- 1:15:04Suzy, did it to get on Blu-ray and it's about this couple
- 1:15:08played by Barbara, Kent and Glenn tie rod who meet at Coney
- 1:15:12Island and they fall in love, fall in a whirlwind 24.
- 1:15:16Ours. And it's all about Modern Life
- 1:15:18and isolation of City, living. And what it is to connect with
- 1:15:22somebody and the magic that it to be in a city of millions of
- 1:15:26people and find your person, and it's another short one.
- 1:15:30I feel like it's like 70 something and it's 75 minutes
- 1:15:331769 minutes. I don't know.
- 1:15:35There's two different things. It has some sync sound in it as
- 1:15:38well. It's just beautiful and I think
- 1:15:41pairs nicely with the the romantic comedy side of city
- 1:15:45lights. But on double feature.
- 1:15:48Number two, if you want Melancholy nights of cabiria,
- 1:15:52the Fellini film, mmm, sorry. His wife, do we had a mussina
- 1:15:55who was often referred to, as the female chaplain for her
- 1:15:59expressive face and specifically the how can it ever?
- 1:16:05Yeah. How it keeps getting worse and
- 1:16:07worse and worse for the Tramp and see lights cabiria.
- 1:16:12Goes through a lot of trials and tribulations and things, get
- 1:16:14really bad and she's Too trusting and they'll be trusting
- 1:16:19in this world. It is not a world for anything,
- 1:16:22but by me end, again, it leaves you with some hope and it leaves
- 1:16:26you. She's at her lowest point.
- 1:16:29I don't want to spoil why, but she's in is literally the worst
- 1:16:31possible place you could possibly be as a like a single
- 1:16:35woman alone in the world and it ends with his beautiful smile,
- 1:16:39very similar to the way City Lights ends.
- 1:16:42And you realize the like is she still got her?
- 1:16:45You know her Coat on her back and she's got her smile and
- 1:16:48she's got her feet. Things can be a things will look
- 1:16:52it up. And and so there these two
- 1:16:54movies that are for people who are like everything's terrible
- 1:16:58but at least I'm alive. Yeah, so that's a double
- 1:17:01feature. I love that.
- 1:17:03All right. Brad.
- 1:17:04You have just seen your first silent movie, ever.
- 1:17:08What would you pair it up with? All right, this is going to be
- 1:17:13nowhere near what has just been offered II think I might give
- 1:17:19two double features as well. The first one is going to be
- 1:17:22Some Like It Hot. I just think that Wilder has so
- 1:17:27much philosophically in common with with chaplain and I think
- 1:17:34that there's so much going on there that just feels like it
- 1:17:37would vibe together that. I think those two movies
- 1:17:39together would be a great great double feature if I may I think
- 1:17:45it was Joshua Logan In the director Joshua Logan said of
- 1:17:48Marilyn Monroe that she was the only other film actor who could
- 1:17:52simultaneously hold Melancholy and comedy with just her face.
- 1:17:57Hmm. In the exact same way as
- 1:17:59chocolate he referenced chaplain when talking about her her, as
- 1:18:05an actor. So I think that's actually a
- 1:18:07brilliant double man. Well, I admit I should probably
- 1:18:12do there but I want to shout The movie that I loved to watch as a
- 1:18:19child. And I think that there's this,
- 1:18:24this movie might be the cheaper form of Chaplin comedy, and I'm
- 1:18:28okay with that. I'm going to recommend the time
- 1:18:32of their lives with Bud Abbott and Lou Costello, because I
- 1:18:38loved that movie growing up. And I think that, at the very
- 1:18:43least, some of the physical comedy that you, Get from Abbott
- 1:18:47and Costello can kind of mimic the older style.
- 1:18:51And I just, I love that film. So I'm going to put that one up
- 1:18:55there as well, Brad. I'm gonna, I'm gonna bring this
- 1:18:59into the modern era and when I was watching City Lights this
- 1:19:03time, one thing that I really want to call attention to, and I
- 1:19:05hope people go watch this like as their first silent movie
- 1:19:08because like I said, the influence of this movie is felt
- 1:19:13even today. And I'm most, especially noticed
- 1:19:15it in this All scene, where the eccentric millionaire is hosting
- 1:19:19a party for Charlie Chaplin After, he finds him out on the
- 1:19:22street. A second time, he gets drunk and
- 1:19:24he has all these, all his friends over, and somebody puts
- 1:19:26a whistle in Charlie, Chaplin's mouth.
- 1:19:28And Charlie, Chaplin is slap on the back, and then swallows the
- 1:19:30whistle. And there is this extended gag
- 1:19:34where there's like an opera singer.
- 1:19:36That's going to perform a little song.
- 1:19:38You know, an aria or something in the room and chaplain starts
- 1:19:42coughing and every time he coughs, it makes a whistle
- 1:19:44sound. And he interrupts it and they
- 1:19:48all look at him and then he stops and then they get ready to
- 1:19:51start again. And then the whistle starts
- 1:19:53again, and it happens like three or four times and the sheer
- 1:19:56comic timing of that moment. I was like, oh my gosh, I have
- 1:20:00seen this kind of moment replicated for decades and
- 1:20:05decades and decades and in the spirit of bodily fluids on
- 1:20:09screen, it reminded me of this moment in the first Austin
- 1:20:13Powers international Man of Mystery.
- 1:20:16Yes, when right, after Austin Powers gets be thawed, he has to
- 1:20:21p. And this p goes on for like 45
- 1:20:24seconds and then every single time you think the scene is
- 1:20:29gonna go on. There's just a slight, little
- 1:20:31dribble more of p. And it is truly Chaplin himself
- 1:20:35would be proud and like, honestly, the more I thought
- 1:20:38about it, the more I realized Mike Myers really, really leaned
- 1:20:42heavily on chaplain in those movies and the weather way that,
- 1:20:46you know, No, the physicality of it but also just the comic
- 1:20:48timing of those scenes. I just, you know I can never
- 1:20:52recommend Austin Powers highly enough so that's my let's make
- 1:20:56it a double that's he's having never seen in Austin Powers.
- 1:21:00What what? But Brad you've seen a Chaplin
- 1:21:04film. How have you never seen?
- 1:21:05Austin Powers. Come on.
- 1:21:06Hey I'm a man of culture. What can I say?
- 1:21:10All right guys, it is time for us to give final scores on this
- 1:21:13movie. I will get mine out of the way
- 1:21:15right now Brad. This is Only one of my top 20 or
- 1:21:1825. Movies of all time is a 10 out
- 1:21:21of 10. The end Bob, I am going to let
- 1:21:27Mariah go first. Oh yeah, I mean I think it's
- 1:21:32also a 10/10. I feel like I think it's a
- 1:21:36perfectly weighted, I don't know.
- 1:21:40So here's here's my caveat. I will come back and score this.
- 1:21:46Us another day. I'll score it today, but I'm
- 1:21:48gonna come back, watch the movie again at some point once I've
- 1:21:51watched more silent film, like I trust your guy's opinion having
- 1:21:56seen, I don't know, a billion silent films at this point
- 1:22:00between the two of you. I just haven't seen another
- 1:22:03silent films. And I don't know how to gauge
- 1:22:06this against other movies that I've watched because every
- 1:22:11single other film I've watched, has had sound attached to it.
- 1:22:16I'm going to go ahead and give this an eight and a half out of
- 1:22:19ten and that's just based purely on your level funny.
- 1:22:24Now, say it again, your love of Fellini my deep and adoring love
- 1:22:29of Federico Fellini. Yes, obviously, that's just
- 1:22:34based on my enjoyment. I like, it was hilariously
- 1:22:37funny. I really enjoyed it.
- 1:22:39One of the one of the better comedies I've watched I think
- 1:22:42that I could probably come back and give this a nine, nine and a
- 1:22:45half. Its Some point.
- 1:22:46But for today I'm going to sit and at an eight and a half.
- 1:22:50All right. There you have it between Brad
- 1:22:52and I we are at a nine point, two five out of ten.
- 1:22:56Now, I do not expect that a lot of film, and whiskey nation has
- 1:22:58seen this movie, but if you have, I would like to know what
- 1:23:01you think. If we have inspired you to go
- 1:23:03watch your first silent movie. Once again, a plug for the fact
- 1:23:07that it is 82 minutes long and it is currently streaming on HBO
- 1:23:11Max or Max, as it has rebranded to now, and you can watch it
- 1:23:15with your age. Nine and ten-year-old like yeah
- 1:23:17totally fine. You know as long as she can get
- 1:23:19over a couple suicide jokes, you should be good, but we're at a
- 1:23:249.25. Let us know what you think you
- 1:23:27can find us on our social medias Facebook, Twitter, Instagram,
- 1:23:31and Tick-Tock at film whiskey. Or you can jump onto our
- 1:23:34Discord. We are on there every single day
- 1:23:37talking to you guys, the fans of the film and whiskey podcast.
- 1:23:41So please join the conversation. You can find a link to our
- 1:23:44Discord at the end of every Engel one of our show notes.
- 1:23:47We want to thank our guests again today, Mariah Gates
- 1:23:50Mariah. I'm going to turn the floor over
- 1:23:51to you. Is there anything you'd like to
- 1:23:53plug and where can we find you? Sure, I think I said, would plug
- 1:23:57my sub stag. It's is where like, in the
- 1:24:002010's again, where newsletters are the new blog, which are the
- 1:24:04new Twitter, but it's old films flicker that sub stack.com.
- 1:24:09I write a every Friday. I write a feature called strike.
- 1:24:16Women viewing guide where I recommend seven films directed
- 1:24:19by women to watch every sea of a film a day for the whole next
- 1:24:23week. Usually, it's one or two new
- 1:24:25releases and then five to six streaming pics.
- 1:24:29I just recently hit over 500 films recommended.
- 1:24:33Well, there are lots of films directed by women and
- 1:24:37occasionally, I will talk about silent films on that as well.
- 1:24:39But on the sub stack itself, I also that's where I tend to do
- 1:24:44my writing about silent film. Because believe it or not,
- 1:24:47people did not pay that much. Although coming out of Babylon,
- 1:24:50I did get several pieces and that and then strangely Harold
- 1:24:55Lloyd's safety last hit 100 years last month and I said,
- 1:24:59okay me to write about that and I was like everything's coming
- 1:25:02up Mariah. So if you are a listener who
- 1:25:05does have money, and once writing about silent film,
- 1:25:08please contact me, but otherwise, I write on the
- 1:25:11subject, I just launched a feature called called you are
- 1:25:15silent. Ace where which is a new orders
- 1:25:18on that. I love, but we're right about.
- 1:25:22I've only done one so far. I did it was Mary Astor but
- 1:25:25mostly I write about our plan to write about silent film.
- 1:25:29Actors, who transitioned successfully at are, maybe more
- 1:25:34known for their acting in talkies.
- 1:25:37So, for example, Mary Astor is probably best known for Maltese
- 1:25:41Falcon among the other 1940s films but she was One of the
- 1:25:46actresses to sort of come out of the late era of the silent film.
- 1:25:50And that's, that's how she started.
- 1:25:52And she's got the most expressive eyes.
- 1:25:54And there's a lot of actresses, like that, like Norma Shearer,
- 1:25:58who was the queen of MTM. I'm going to write one about her
- 1:26:00at some point, just to get people sort of thinking about
- 1:26:04these stars that maybe they think, in other than one mode
- 1:26:10And are afraid to go back and look at the silence and and try
- 1:26:14to get people interested, Joan Crawford's another one.
- 1:26:16I'm going to write about it at some point.
- 1:26:19So I want to sort of highlight some of those actors that got,
- 1:26:23you know, the we're able to transition.
- 1:26:25But now they're silent films are sort of the ones that people
- 1:26:28take for granted. I just keep hearing like
- 1:26:31Crossover with film and whiskey episodes were like, I will talk
- 1:26:34about Mary Astor all day because nestor's amazing, she's got an
- 1:26:37iv personal life to that. Sad, Brad down and just told,
- 1:26:41like I made Brad, watch Meet Me in st.
- 1:26:43Louis, because it's may be my favorite movie of all time.
- 1:26:45And I was like, Mary Astor in the scene where they sing the
- 1:26:48song You and I is like one of the best pieces of acting I've
- 1:26:51ever seen in my life. You know, you know why, she's so
- 1:26:53good. Why is he started what acting?
- 1:26:57She said they had faces. That's why she's so good Brad
- 1:27:02before we get out of here. I want to do one thing.
- 1:27:03We've never done. On the history of filming
- 1:27:05whiskey podcast. Oh my goodness.
- 1:27:07My favorite Charlie. Chaplin movie is on the docket
- 1:27:11for next week and that is modern times is a film that like goes
- 1:27:15back and forth with City Lights as you know chaplains greatest,
- 1:27:18do you want to do it next week or do you want to do the two
- 1:27:22other Chaplin films? First, and do that?
- 1:27:24One last, would it be better for you to do them head-to-head or
- 1:27:29to get more chaplain context and then do that one?
- 1:27:32At the end of the series, man. Look at, I just want to savor
- 1:27:36this moment of Bob, giving me a choice like that light has
- 1:27:42happened for 15 of our, what 202 movies, where I actually had a
- 1:27:47say in what was happening. Bob, I think that we should just
- 1:27:53forget chaplain for a few movies.
- 1:27:55And go into some I don't know. Mariah can guide us who's to say
- 1:28:01no, Max Linder. Yeah, Max Linder.
- 1:28:06Let's throw them in there. No, I think we should do the
- 1:28:10other two films first. Okay.
- 1:28:12I'd like a little more time before to, you know, get my feet
- 1:28:16wet before I jump into modern times.
- 1:28:18Well then, what we're going to do is we're going to throw it
- 1:28:20back a few years from this, and we're going to look at 1925 s
- 1:28:24the gold. Rush next week so we'll be
- 1:28:26watching the Gold Rush week. What we're calling an audible on
- 1:28:30film and whiskey for the first time in history.
- 1:28:32Thank you for that Brad. And thank you once again to our
- 1:28:34guests, Mariah Gates, we will see you next week for the gold
- 1:28:38rush, but until then I'm Bob book, I'm Brad G and we'll see
- 1:28:42you next time.