Latest / Becker’s Healthcare Podcast / Building a Physician Retention Roadmap with Scott Polenz of CHG Healthcare
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, everyone. This is Erica Spicer Mason with
- 0:02Becker's Healthcare. Thank you so much for tuning
- 0:04into the Becker's Healthcare podcast series today.
- 0:08So today we're going to talk about a
- 0:10roadmap for healthcare administrators
- 0:12that touches on physician alignment, engagement,
- 0:14and retention.
- 0:16And joining me for today's discussion on this
- 0:18roadmap is Scott Pollens,
- 0:20a principal consultant at CHG Healthcare Advisory Services.
- 0:25Scott, great to have you on the podcast.
- 0:26Thank you so much for being here today.
- 0:29Yeah. Thank you, Erica. I'm I'm I'm excited
- 0:30to to talk about a topic I'm quite
- 0:32passionate about. Yeah. I'm excited to learn more
- 0:35about this road map and and the role
- 0:37that you've played in developing it. And before
- 0:39we get to that, I wanted to talk
- 0:41a little bit about your background just to
- 0:43give our listeners a little bit of context
- 0:44here.
- 0:45I know you've held both rural CEO roles
- 0:48and system leadership positions, and now you consult
- 0:51nationally for health care. So how has your
- 0:53own journey shaped the way that you think
- 0:56about physician alignment, engagement, and retention, and why
- 0:59are these areas so important to organizational success
- 1:02right now? Yeah. Thank you. Yeah. I I've
- 1:05had a really cool career and,
- 1:07have been a CEO and a CEO of
- 1:10hospitals in Central North and Western Wisconsin and
- 1:12rural areas and then,
- 1:14or saw physician in APP recruitment
- 1:17and really retention, and that's really got focus.
- 1:19So back to your question, I, I think
- 1:22about it all the time as my career
- 1:23has evolved because I just feel very strongly
- 1:26that physician relations and how we treat our
- 1:28physicians
- 1:29is mission critical for all health care organizations.
- 1:32And, you know, if you think about
- 1:34take care of your physicians, it improves patient
- 1:37care, it enhances innovation, it reduces burnout and
- 1:40a turnover across your organization,
- 1:43it enhances efficiency and standardization of care, it
- 1:46improves your eight your health care organization
- 1:48performance,
- 1:49focuses on the quadruple aim, improves continuity of
- 1:53care, and reduces recruitment costs, and just really
- 1:55improves your overall culture. And if you think
- 1:57about physicians,
- 1:59many of them are in leadership roles, but
- 2:00most of them are not in leadership roles
- 2:02and but they're still the captain of the
- 2:04ship or the captain of the team in
- 2:06the OR,
- 2:07in the clinic if they're in a a
- 2:09primary care type of setting in the hospital.
- 2:11So they're the ones that are really running
- 2:13the show, and they're the cornerstone and they
- 2:15really lead. If you think about pillars of
- 2:17excellence,
- 2:18from quality and safety, service, patient experience, growth,
- 2:21finance, people. If you take care of your
- 2:23docs, you take care of all your pillars
- 2:25of of excellence. And and what I worry
- 2:28about in the industry and what I've seen
- 2:30the last few years is it seems like
- 2:32we're moving to,
- 2:33and have been moving to treating physicians more
- 2:36like a commodity.
- 2:37And they're not commodities. We're all you know,
- 2:40we seek health care. We're not commodities.
- 2:42These aren't widgets we're making. And,
- 2:45so I'm just very passionate about committing to
- 2:47align and engage our physicians then we can
- 2:49retain them. And from a financial standpoint, Erica,
- 2:53an engaged physician is 26%
- 2:55more productive than a disengaged physician. So the
- 2:58numbers will will demonstrate that
- 3:01physician alignment, engagement, and and, retention are really,
- 3:04really important. That's about that 26% more productive
- 3:07is about a half million dollars more in
- 3:09additional revenue annual for an organization.
- 3:13Yeah. Scott, I appreciate you tying some of
- 3:15these,
- 3:16you know,
- 3:17the the benefits of
- 3:19effective physician alignment, engagement, and retention, tying those
- 3:22to some of the key measures and
- 3:24areas that we know health care leaders are
- 3:26worried about right now. You know, you're talking
- 3:27about productivity,
- 3:29efficiency,
- 3:29cost savings,
- 3:31and then of course, you know, the mission
- 3:33critical piece about
- 3:35streamlining and optimizing patient care too. I know
- 3:37that's really at the heart of why we
- 3:39want physicians to be happy and why we
- 3:41want them to be operating well in their
- 3:43roles so they can better serve patients.
- 3:45So again, I really appreciate that overview.
- 3:48And I wanna take a step back too
- 3:50and and talk a little bit about these
- 3:52words, alignment,
- 3:53engagement, and retention.
- 3:55I rattled them off very quickly in the
- 3:57beginning, but I know it's important to distinguish,
- 4:00between each of them. And
- 4:02oftentimes, they're referred to as interchangeable terms, but
- 4:05I have a feeling that's probably not the
- 4:07case. So I I'd like to know how
- 4:08you distinguish those three terms
- 4:10and how you address those,
- 4:12in your physician retention road map. Would love
- 4:14to learn more there. Yeah. Thank you, Erica.
- 4:16It it,
- 4:18was very intentional in in thinking about this,
- 4:20and it it really started a few years
- 4:21ago in a a larger health care system
- 4:24I was working at.
- 4:25And we took an engagement survey, and the
- 4:27results weren't very good at all. And, my
- 4:30diet partner and I had had just kinda
- 4:33stepped back and said, you know, our engagement
- 4:36is low. Okay. We gotta figure out how
- 4:38to to better engage our physicians. But what
- 4:40we realized is that our physicians were engaged.
- 4:42They just weren't aligned
- 4:44with our mission and our vision and and
- 4:47our executive leadership. And until we solve their
- 4:50alignment
- 4:50and focus on their alignment, we will not
- 4:53be able to get them engaged and ultimately
- 4:54retain them. So that's why we we broke
- 4:57it out. And,
- 4:58if you think about the road map that
- 5:00we've put together,
- 5:01it has, four areas under alignment. So in
- 5:04the road map, we talk about culture, executive
- 5:06leadership, communications,
- 5:08and physician voice and leadership. And then under
- 5:11in the road map under engagement, which is
- 5:13really kind of that emotional connection and and
- 5:16and and doctors feeling valued and office feeling
- 5:19valued,
- 5:20we talk about onboarding,
- 5:21you know, how they're introduced to the organization,
- 5:23their work life balance and flexibility, their operational
- 5:26efficiency, and and just the whole social side
- 5:29and the socialization
- 5:30of with their colleagues and collegiality and also
- 5:33their families. And then we we end with,
- 5:36or then we focus on retention,
- 5:38which is really that long term commitment supported
- 5:40by structure and our experience and and we
- 5:42focus in four different areas of professional their
- 5:45professional growth and development,
- 5:47their well-being,
- 5:48their compensation and incentives obviously is important, and
- 5:51then just how do we recognize our physicians
- 5:53for doing the the wonderful things that they
- 5:55do for our communities. And so it's just
- 5:58been really cool to have my have my
- 6:00career with us experience and passion about physician
- 6:03relations and CHG allowing me to kinda put
- 6:06a road map together to, to help our
- 6:08partner HCOs that CHD Health Care works with
- 6:11across the country. And within the road map,
- 6:14we have, like, you know, obviously, definitions and
- 6:16background.
- 6:17We we kinda I try to challenge, health
- 6:20care leaders across the country with strategic reflections
- 6:23and checkup questions. One question would be, like,
- 6:26on a scale of one to ten, ten
- 6:27being the highest, what would your physicians rank
- 6:30their trust in executive leadership?
- 6:32And then we do, for quite a bit
- 6:34some of the client work that we've done
- 6:36and some past experience, we go into a
- 6:37deeper dive,
- 6:39within within the road map. So it's really
- 6:41it's been a really cool project.
- 6:43Yeah. It sounds like it, Scott. Thank you.
- 6:46And I know when you just touched on
- 6:48the area of retention, you named a few
- 6:50important pillars underneath that term. You talked about
- 6:53professional growth, well-being, compensation,
- 6:57recognizing success.
- 6:58So it sounds like there's a lot that
- 7:00goes into the retention piece. So I'd love
- 7:02if you could share a little bit more
- 7:03with our listeners about the common struggles, barriers,
- 7:06or challenges that you see organizations face when
- 7:09they're trying to develop a formal retention plan
- 7:12for physicians and APPs.
- 7:14Yeah. It's because it's really hard work, and
- 7:16it's very complex. And it really takes
- 7:19to put a formal retention plan in place,
- 7:21it really takes a a group of team
- 7:23a professional team that puts it together, puts
- 7:25it to paper, and then operationalize
- 7:28it and lives it daily across the whole
- 7:30organization.
- 7:31And, what I found fascinating is AAPPR, which
- 7:34is our, you know, our industry
- 7:36standard for the recruitment area. They actually,
- 7:40said that less than 25 or right around
- 7:4225% of health care organizations have a formal
- 7:44retention
- 7:46plan in place for their physicians, which is,
- 7:48you know, that's quite low when you think
- 7:50about that. And,
- 7:52many will say health care organizations back to
- 7:54talk I gave yesterday at a national conference,
- 7:56people would say, yeah. We're doing a little
- 7:57bit of this. We're doing a little bit
- 7:58of that.
- 7:59From what I tell people, recommend, and consult
- 8:02with is the great organizations have a retention
- 8:04plan in place that will help them thrive
- 8:07in the future, but it's, it's not easy
- 8:09work to do.
- 8:10Yeah. Absolutely. It sounds like,
- 8:13a lot of
- 8:14different areas that organizations have to pull from,
- 8:17whether it's finance, whether it's, HR and, you
- 8:20know, mental health and well-being.
- 8:22There's a lot that goes into that, so
- 8:23I'm sure it's no easy task.
- 8:26So again, appreciate you highlighting that and also,
- 8:28you know, tying that back to the roadmap
- 8:29that you've developed.
- 8:31And so based on what you're you're seeing
- 8:34across hospitals and health systems, what would you
- 8:37say are the most significant forces that are
- 8:39reshaping the physician experience right now? And how
- 8:42do you think leaders should rethink their approach
- 8:45in response to some of those factors?
- 8:48Yeah. Great question. You know, the biggest forces
- 8:50is we all we all know there's a
- 8:51physician shortage,
- 8:5386,000
- 8:54by the year 2034.
- 8:56You know, you have you have, increased competition
- 8:59for physician time. You have nontraditional employers now
- 9:02getting into this market and wanting to hire
- 9:04your physicians away from you. Engagement levels are
- 9:07a little bit better, but still struggle,
- 9:09and just changing expectations, flexibility, and
- 9:13and the need for flexibility. And what what
- 9:15I wanted to just chat about briefly is
- 9:17a couple areas is, what what we did
- 9:19the study with our physicians because CHD employs
- 9:22thousands of physicians, and we asked them,
- 9:25you know, what's important to you and and,
- 9:28and in in your in your your physician
- 9:30career. And
- 9:32the top five you'd be surprised by this.
- 9:34The top five areas that they focused on
- 9:36or that they said were most important were
- 9:38better work life balance,
- 9:40better workplace culture,
- 9:41more support from administration, executive leadership,
- 9:45opportunity for them to professionally grow and advance.
- 9:48Sometimes I think we think physicians just go
- 9:50and they just wanna practice, but they wanna
- 9:52do different things and and grow and be
- 9:54in leadership or do research or do education,
- 9:57and then increased autonomy. And then the next
- 10:00one is is compensation. So compensation, even though
- 10:03people may say this, it's not the most
- 10:05important,
- 10:07area that physicians are focused on.
- 10:09And in fact, on the autonomy side,
- 10:12advisory board has this this great kind of
- 10:15slide and and discussion that they talk about,
- 10:17and they really talk about three areas for
- 10:19autonomy for physicians. Physicians wanna have clinical autonomy.
- 10:22They wanna be able to make the decisions
- 10:24for their for that are best for their
- 10:26for their patients. They don't want administrators like
- 10:28myself and and others to tell them how
- 10:30to take care of their patients. They wanna
- 10:32have schedule autonomy.
- 10:34They wanna spend their days in a way
- 10:35that works for their patients and the family
- 10:37and and and also themselves. So, again, that's
- 10:39kind of that work life balance, that flexibility,
- 10:42allow them to grow their practice. And then
- 10:44the last one is strategic autonomy,
- 10:46where they wanna help they want help and
- 10:48they wanna be able to shape their their
- 10:50future and and their, you know, their practice
- 10:52wherever that would be. And I actually have
- 10:54a a quite a few doctor friends, and
- 10:57we get together and and and talk we
- 10:58get together monthly and talk coffee and have
- 11:01coffee.
- 11:01And this is what they talk about. They
- 11:03talk about their autonomy in their their clinic
- 11:06and people telling them what they can and
- 11:08can't do,
- 11:09and they wanna take care of their patients.
- 11:11They wanna work hard. They wanna get back
- 11:13to the communities. And, so we, you know,
- 11:15we as organizations,
- 11:17we need to realize that physicians are humans
- 11:19like all of us. They want that balance,
- 11:21that connection, that culture, that clarity. They want
- 11:24they wanna be recognized, obviously,
- 11:26autonomy. So we really need, as health care
- 11:29organizations, oftentimes are kinda conservative.
- 11:31It's obviously changing now, but, you know, eight
- 11:33to five, Monday through Friday, that's not what
- 11:35physicians are looking for. So we need to
- 11:38be more relationship based and and, and really
- 11:41support the physician experience.
- 11:43Yeah. Absolutely.
- 11:45Scott, so much of what you've touched on,
- 11:47those high priority areas for physicians,
- 11:50so many of them tie back to culture,
- 11:52you know, whether we're talking about work life
- 11:54balance,
- 11:55actual workplace culture, support from leadership. And so
- 11:58I know leadership plays such a key role
- 12:00in the culture piece. And in your roadmap,
- 12:03you even talk about the importance
- 12:05of trust, transparency,
- 12:07and also authentic communication.
- 12:09So I'm curious to know what do physicians
- 12:12actually respond to, and what leadership behaviors or
- 12:15structures
- 12:16most reliably
- 12:17can build trust? And I guess on the
- 12:19other side of the coin too, what behaviors
- 12:21erode it quickly?
- 12:22Yeah. No. This
- 12:24is such an important area. And
- 12:26and, I used to have a lot in
- 12:28my role, my past role as
- 12:31of of overseeing physician relations and recruitment and
- 12:33onboarding. I would have docs. I would get
- 12:34to know them really well, and and they
- 12:36would say, I don't trust it, but, Scott,
- 12:37I don't trust administration.
- 12:39And I kinda challenged them and say, well,
- 12:41what do you mean by that? It's you
- 12:42you can't just say that and not give
- 12:45some definition or give some feedback as to
- 12:47what you actually mean by that. And then
- 12:49I also studied
- 12:51Frances Fry does what she calls a trust
- 12:53triangle, and she says there are a triangle
- 12:56of three areas that are important to trust.
- 12:57And and you can do this in your
- 12:59relationship with your family, with your boss, with,
- 13:02your coworkers, or the people that report to
- 13:04you. And she talks about how you have
- 13:06to be as a leader, you have to
- 13:07be authentic.
- 13:08People need to know the real you. You
- 13:10have to be empathetic to what's going on
- 13:12in their world and how how their days
- 13:14are. And then you have to be logical
- 13:16in kinda your communications and your decision making.
- 13:19And if you're often one of those, you're
- 13:21not gonna have the trust that you need.
- 13:23So, like, I can be a very authentic
- 13:24and very empathetic person, but if I just
- 13:26make these irrational decisions on a Monday morning
- 13:29and I don't talk about the why, there's
- 13:31not gonna be trust. And so quite a
- 13:34few physicians, when I would ask them, they
- 13:35would just say, well, when somebody rounds, an
- 13:38administrator rounds or executive leadership rounds, and I
- 13:40say, hey. X, y, or z is not
- 13:42working well in my clinic, and they say,
- 13:43okay. I'll check into that. Then they never
- 13:45get back to me, and there's no follow
- 13:46through. And the physician doesn't mind if the
- 13:49answer is no. They just want somebody to
- 13:51follow through and say, hey. I checked into
- 13:52this, and we can do one, two, and
- 13:54three, but we can't do four, five, and
- 13:56six, and seven.
- 13:57So that's really important. And then I think
- 13:59the other side is, as I talked about,
- 14:00is just being authentic.
- 14:02And when we're communicating, it's not about a
- 14:05really good PowerPoint slide or a really well
- 14:07written memo. It's about telling patient stories. It's
- 14:10about the why. It's about how physicians were
- 14:12involved in the decision making and the communication
- 14:15because physicians still want to be,
- 14:18communicated by their colleagues, their physician colleagues, not
- 14:20necessarily administration.
- 14:22So great question.
- 14:24Yeah. Thank you so much, Scott, for elaborating
- 14:26on that.
- 14:28And as we're winding down here, I wanna
- 14:29make sure we also touch on
- 14:31infrastructure related to supporting all of these areas
- 14:34and recommendations in the road map. I know
- 14:37that in your road map, you close it
- 14:39by,
- 14:40sharing this concept of essentially an office of
- 14:42physician and APP relations.
- 14:45So why is a structure like this gaining
- 14:48traction in health care right now, and what
- 14:50does it solve that traditional organizational models might
- 14:53miss most often?
- 14:55Yeah. It's it's real you know? So, yeah,
- 14:57it's I mean, it's easy to talk about
- 14:58all the thing, you know, that we just
- 15:00talked about, but but but how do you
- 15:01how do you operationalize them? How do you
- 15:03implement things? And I don't know how else
- 15:05to do it besides
- 15:06creating a a structure
- 15:09that really what I would recommend and what
- 15:11I was trying to do in my past
- 15:12career was almost like a one stop shop
- 15:15for physicians and APPs.
- 15:17And if you think about it from an
- 15:19employee standpoint, I can go to human resources
- 15:21for
- 15:22my salary, for my evaluation,
- 15:24for my benefits,
- 15:26you know, PTO, etcetera. But if you're a
- 15:28physician,
- 15:29you often because the structure is kinda all
- 15:30over the place, you have to go to
- 15:32this leader first for privileging, this leader for
- 15:35compensation, this leader for PTO. And and by
- 15:38the time you're you you don't know who
- 15:39to go to, so you just kinda, you
- 15:41know, you just kinda give up to a
- 15:42certain extent.
- 15:44So what we recommend is that you create
- 15:46an office of a physician and APP relations
- 15:49that you have many of these areas, credentialing
- 15:51compensation report directly reporting up to that area.
- 15:54Obviously, recruitment and onboarding.
- 15:56Then you have very strong,
- 15:58you know, dotted line type of relationships.
- 16:00But at the end of the day, this
- 16:01is the group of people and the and
- 16:03the structure and a diet. We would recommend
- 16:05a diet where a physician and administrator
- 16:07where docs can go to when they have
- 16:09questions about burnout, about work like balance, about
- 16:12compensation, about privileging, etcetera.
- 16:15And then, you know, just to think about,
- 16:17think about this. If you're recruiting a physician
- 16:19and
- 16:20and the physician says to you to the
- 16:22recruiter, to whomever, you know, what what sets
- 16:24you apart or what's what makes your organization
- 16:26different than the competition? And you say, we
- 16:29actually have a formal retention program in place,
- 16:31doctor Smith or doctor Jones, and we're gonna
- 16:33take care of you not only on day
- 16:34one in the first ninety days, but throughout
- 16:36your whole career, and here's how we're gonna
- 16:38do that.
- 16:39And I just I were passionate about this
- 16:41because I one time I had a doc
- 16:42I really respected. We recruited him for a
- 16:45long time and his family. And after about
- 16:48three years, he came up and saw him
- 16:49in the hall, and he goes, you know,
- 16:50Scott, you guys did a great job at
- 16:51recruiting and onboarding me, but you forgot about
- 16:53me. And and I don't hear from anybody
- 16:56anymore. And that's not how I want my
- 16:57crew to evolve. And that was just kind
- 16:59of a gut check and kind of the
- 17:01the passion about bringing this all together.
- 17:04Oh, absolutely.
- 17:05A great example, Scott. And it sounds to
- 17:08me like
- 17:09this office of physician and APP relations, it
- 17:12might look different at one organization compared to
- 17:14another, but it sounds like the most important
- 17:16piece is that there are those
- 17:18those resources dedicated
- 17:19to these efforts. Do I have that right?
- 17:22Yes. Exactly. The, you know, the the physician
- 17:24experience.
- 17:25When you're a physician, this is the group
- 17:27of people that are gonna take care of
- 17:29you and and make sure you have a
- 17:31great career.
- 17:32Yeah. Fantastic.
- 17:33And, Scott, I know we've covered a lot
- 17:35of ground in this conversation, and,
- 17:37I I'm sure that once listeners are able
- 17:39to see the roadmap, they'll they'll have even
- 17:41more questions that will come up. But I
- 17:43thought it might be helpful to end our
- 17:45conversation,
- 17:46talking about next steps. So considering everything that
- 17:49we've talked about, if a health system wants
- 17:51to really improve retention in the next twelve
- 17:54to twenty four months, is there a best
- 17:56place they can start or a next step
- 17:58that you'd advise?
- 17:59Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I think a couple areas,
- 18:02like, three or four areas is is, first
- 18:04of all, have a very standardized and structured
- 18:07and consistent onboarding program when you bring them
- 18:09into the organization and their family.
- 18:11Put a formal retention plan in place. Don't
- 18:14just say that, well, we do a few
- 18:15of these things, and and we're doing pretty
- 18:17well right now. Put the actual plan in
- 18:19place.
- 18:20Get executive leadership visible and authentic. We talked
- 18:23about this quite a bit. Executive leadership, our
- 18:26doc docs wanna know them. They wanna touch
- 18:28them, and they wanna shake their hands. They
- 18:30wanna know who they are and how they
- 18:31make their decisions,
- 18:33and then create the like, we just talked
- 18:35about, create the office of physician and AP
- 18:37relations and and start down that don't start
- 18:40down that journey.
- 18:41Fantastic.
- 18:42Scott, I I wanna thank you so much
- 18:44for making time for Becker's today and sharing
- 18:46everything that you've shared about the road map
- 18:48and and what's ahead.
- 18:49Is there anything that we didn't touch on
- 18:51or any final thoughts that you wanted to
- 18:53leave listeners with?
- 18:54I don't no. I don't think so. I
- 18:56think I've kinda talked a lot, and obviously
- 18:58very passionate about that. More than willing to
- 19:00you know, if people wanna reach out and
- 19:02have a further conversation about anything we talked
- 19:04about or the road map or or the
- 19:06office of physician APP relations, more than happy
- 19:09more more than happy to do that. I
- 19:10would just emphasize
- 19:12strongly that
- 19:14physician relations and recruitment and retention and onboarding
- 19:17and alignment
- 19:18should be in your strategic plan as a
- 19:20as a significant
- 19:22initiative each and every year because they are
- 19:24the cornerstone of all health care organizations.
- 19:28Great note to end on, Scott. Thank you
- 19:30again for your time and your insights today.
- 19:33And as Scott mentioned,
- 19:35we will be sure to include his information
- 19:36in this description for the episode so that
- 19:38if you'd like to reach out or,
- 19:41see a copy of the roadmap, that will
- 19:43be available to you. And of course, we
- 19:45also wanna thank our podcast sponsor, CHG Healthcare.
- 19:49Listeners, be sure to tune into more podcasts
- 19:51from Becker's Healthcare by visiting our podcast page
- 19:53at beckershospitalreview.com.