Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / "Credit Union Friendly" Depends on the Issue: Reading the New Congress with Bacino & Mckechnie
Transcript
- 0:00Mark Treichel: Everyone. This is Mark Trichle with another episode of with flying colors. I am excited to be here today with John Mckechnie and Jeff Bacino, formerly of NCUA, now out in the the world doing different things for credit unions. Guys, how are you doing this morning?
- 0:13John McKechnie: Good. Good morning.
- 0:15Mark Treichel: And if you're watching on YouTube, you can see that Jeff has dusted off his Chicago bears fleece. He's looking pretty sharp as are the bears. We're... Vikings have the best record in football right now, but we're not gonna talk about that because they're gonna be six and four by the time the month is over. And John Lamar's hurt again.
- 0:34But with that, guys, let's let's do an intro, and you could talk about your football team too, and then we'll rock into the the world of politics and what it means for credit unions. Who wants to go first? Mac?
- 0:47John McKechnie: I don't wanna talk about football or politics, so I'm not sure why I'm here this morning.
- 0:52Mark Treichel: Very good. And, Jeff. I opened this call by telling the two
- 0:56Geoff Bacino: of you that my daughter sent me a meeting that said it's a good day and be a Bears fan and a Democrat. So we'll just go with that. Why don't we just jump into it?
- 1:04Mark Treichel: Very good. Alright. So I don't know what they're calling it, the blue wave or what exactly, but the the tide has turned in Washington DC. And I know you've probably had conversations with some of your clients on what it might mean for them, for the industry, but let's just open it up there for a free fall chat about what what lays ahead and what happened.
- 1:26John McKechnie: The industry, as I think you you both know and everybody in our audience knows, the industry has to pay very close attention to Congress and the regulators. And it's a political world we exist in whether we like it or not. These kinda... I will say these kinda sweeping changes are unusual, but not unprecedented. In my credit union career, I've seen two wave elections that reminded me a lot this Tuesday.
- 1:53And when I say a wave, I'm talking about a midterm election where one party that had been out sweeps both chambers and does it at the expense of the other party in the White House. I'm talking about 94 when you had Clinton as president, and you wake up the next day and the Republicans had taken both chambers. And then in in 2006, you had George W. Bush as president, and the Democrats took both chambers. So that's the the analogy that I would draw from with last night is that you've had this happen several times in history, and it's going to require credit unions to readjust their messaging to Congress because Democrats and Republicans like to hear different things and talk different ways.
- 2:38And and that's something we can do. We're good at it. I think credit unions are very adept in making sure we tell lawmakers and regulators the credit union story using maybe different vocabulary. That's that's my starting point.
- 2:52Mark Treichel: And Jeff?
- 2:53Geoff Bacino: I think John's actually right. Okay. Credit unions, and we've always been, for the most part, viewed as the white hat industry. And and I think John's point that they speak different languages is absolutely correct. I think the credit unions have to understand that.
- 3:06The one thing I guess I want to... People to take out of this is because sometimes I feel people don't really fully understand the implications of congress. Obviously, you hike the hill, you come to the GAC, you go to the congressional caucus, all great things. But the the the credit union CEOs and the credit unions that really succeed in this atmosphere are the ones that understand, yes, this has an impact. You're not talking about going on the senate side from Tim Scott to Elizabeth Warren.
- 3:38And on the house side, even though she may get a challenger, think Maxine Waters will most likely probably remain in our position, and she'll be now the chair of the house financial services team. Those things carry with them very big implications In addition to the fact that you now have a democratic senate
- 3:55Mark Treichel: that
- 3:56Geoff Bacino: controls nominations. You're probably not gonna see anything for the next two years. That'd be interesting to hear what Johnson's up on that, but I can't see where this administration of the way they've treated things over the last six years, four years in the first time, and then now two years here. That they're gonna be really up for getting along with the Democrats. I saw the president the other day when he was showing off the ballroom talking about some of the Democrats had called.
- 4:18I mean, very interested in knowing which Democrats had called because I'm not sure that any have.
- 4:24Mark Treichel: One equals some. Right? And, like, according to NCUA, one equals a quorum.
- 4:30John McKechnie: That's an interesting word of segue, Mark, and Jeff teed it up. I don't know. I don't claim to have inside knowledge on this, but the fact you have a democratic senate that now that would be in the position to confirm nominees, it's not out of question that we spend the next two years with a single NCUA board because I don't know that the president... The president seems to have two options here. One is he could just leave it alone, but the board continue to function as a one member board.
- 4:56And the other thing I guess he could do would be to nominate one democrat and one republican, which in in a big picture sense, he said, that's not a bad idea because it gives the president a chance to still maintain a Republican majority in NCUA. Right? You have two... At that point, you'd have two Republicans, one Democrat. I've got no indication he's gonna do that.
- 5:16Plus the court case involving board former board members Harper and hasn't been resolved complete. I don't know when it will be resolved.
- 5:25Mark Treichel: I thought I'd seen a date coming up in November, but maybe that was court There's
- 5:29John McKechnie: a hearing. There's a hearing, but I don't know if there's a a ruling definite. I could be wrong. Do you guys know other than that?
- 5:37Geoff Bacino: I don't either, but I will say this. John's point here is well taken that I mentioned this. I'm gonna talk about this before the Supreme Court came down on the on the FTC case because my point was always people would ask, why can't the president just nominate two people? He said control the senate. They can get through in about an hour and a half if they wanted to.
- 5:55The problem was, as I used to say, is until the Supreme Court case came down, you don't know what the decision is. And so you run the risk. If the Supreme Court has said, no. You can't fire them. Now that they've said you can and now that the two former board members have continued their suit, I think that was really what puts a hold on it more than anything, or at least it gives the White House a pretty handy excuse not to do it.
- 6:18Because if I were, then I'd be saying, hey. I'd I'd love to get you some people, but we gotta clarify this thing first.
- 6:23Mark Treichel: And it certainly... Potentially, there maybe certainly is not the right word, but the Cruz chairmanship takes on a little different flavor to it with the possibility of Warren having some hearings. Right? I can expect that NCUA will be... I know she wrote a letter to the NCUA inspector general saying, explain to me how you operated for eight or ten days without any board members, and I haven't seen publicly where that that the response from the IG has come in, but you could potentially see Cruz doing some hearings.
- 6:53You could see Larry Fazio doing some some hearings. The temperature just kinda went up from NCUA having to maybe answer some of the things they've done or not done.
- 7:04John McKechnie: I... I've been on the hill. This is being recorded on a Friday, so I'm... I was on the hill Wednesday and Thursday after the election. And one of the unmistakable word...
- 7:15I've gotten the word from Democratic and Republican staff that you're gonna expect a lot of oversight coming out of both the senate and the house. Elizabeth Warren is the expected, although not... It's not finalized yet, that she's expected to be the chair of the senate banking committee. And we all know what kind of public persona she has about being very aggressive about oversight, about her ideological agenda. She's she's gonna go into that chairmanship.
- 7:46Come... She's gonna come out of Sweden. And I think Maxine Waters on the house side is poised to be similarly aggressive. I will say there's an undercurrent on the hill because she does have a challenger or maybe more than one challenger for that chair. Her age and her health have been discussed, but it's all quiet kind of hallway discussions.
- 8:09I would say she's likely to be the chair, but we don't know we don't know we don't know, Corey, yet.
- 8:15Mark Treichel: And both of them would correct me if I'm wrong, but they might be viewed as credit union friend... Friendly in the past, and maybe some of that that shine may have worn off because of where we're at.
- 8:27John McKechnie: Jeff, why don't you say something about that? Then I'll add more more thing to add.
- 8:31Geoff Bacino: They probably have been viewed as credit friendly. I know that the the league up in Massachusetts has had obviously conversation... Or California league has had conversations with vaccine. I I would say, though, that I don't think anybody is gonna be spared from what happened over the last couple years. Cruz seems to be doing a good job.
- 8:51The folks at the agency seem to like him. I know the people I talked to that have met him say he's very very qualified. The problem is he's could be... He could be painted with the brush of you're there because we basically kicked out everybody else. Once again, I'm not sure sometimes if it's gonna be friendly or not friendly to credit unions.
- 9:08I think it might be not friendly to the policy and the way that actions have been taken over the last two years.
- 9:16John McKechnie: This may cause a surprise, but Democrats and Republicans are different. They think of the world different. And defining somebody's crediting friend when it comes to senator Warren and chair... Chairwoman w Waters and others, Democrats tend to like Credit Units when it comes to the banks attacking us and trying to stop Credit Units from doing all the good things we do. But when it comes to things like regulatory...
- 9:40The the heavy regulatory hand on the industry, I'm not sure if you can define that... Their attitude about that as Friendly because I think a lot of things they do are much... Go much farther than anything credit unions are comfortable with. Look at CFPB. Look at overdraft.
- 9:55There was an article yesterday about how senator Warren is gonna advocate for a 10% interest rate cap on credit cards, which, by the way, I think the president would side at all his desk. But my point is that when it comes to regulatory balance, I think Republicans are more in in line with the credit union position. And I... Where I think it... When it comes to credit union activities and powers and things like that, democrats are more in line with us.
- 10:25It's been... It's always a balancing act, and you just have to tailor your messages to who you're talking to.
- 10:31Mark Treichel: Yeah. That that makes good sense. And another Chicago bear reference, you don't have to be fast. You just have to be faster than somebody if you're being chased by a bear, and that somebody that you can outrun might be the CFPB when you go to all these hearings. Right?
- 10:45And that's Elizabeth Warren's baby.
- 10:48John McKechnie: And if we get a democratic administration in 2028 with the democratic congress, you're gonna see a very much reinvigorated CFPB like we had prior when the Biden administration was in office. You're gonna have an aggressive, assertive, probably much bigger CFPB. You've had a staff reduction over there. I would expect CFPB to go back over a thousand employees as the second that a a democrat takes office if it happens in 2028. But we don't know if it's gonna happen in 2028.
- 11:19Geoff Bacino: Well But, obviously, the fun thing is always predict. And, John, you pointed out if there's a Democratic administration on 2028, the CFPB would be reinvigorated. The other kind of thing that probably falls is, unfortunately for him, John Cruz is probably gonna get caught up in the undertow. We mentioned this, I think, during our last call and maybe the call before. The unfortunate thing about this Supreme Court decision and the ability that they are saying that the White House has to fire what were previously seen as heads of independent agencies or board members of independent agencies is it's going to severely impact the quality of people that I think will be willing to look or be willing to take that job.
- 11:59And, again, what what will most likely happen I can see is that on 01/21/2029, there's a democratic administration. They're gonna basically just ask for the resignation of all all the Republican board members at the, quote, unquote, independent agencies, and they're gonna... With Democrats. It's gonna be... It was, in a way, the nuclear option.
- 12:21I was just gonna keep pressing the button.
- 12:24Mark Treichel: And you think... I think about it from the exam side. The the exams have gotten shorter. The coding has gotten kinder. They've got the proposed camel's rule out there that looks backwards at that as opposed to looking forward at risk the way it's written and and and NCUA's footprint.
- 12:42Right? If we go if we go democrat in 2028, you see a CFPB get bigger. You probably see NCUA get bigger. And then you see... John, to your point, the the the the r's are a little bit...
- 12:55Have been deregulatory. That pendulum, which we've swing... Seen swing in the past, could come swinging back in 2029. The good news for credit unions is the deregulation from an exam perspective is nice right now as far as seeing NCUA less and NCUA maybe not citing safety and soundness as a concern as much as they may have in the past. So what else do we have that's going on in in in the political world right now?
- 13:20We've got the budget briefing. NCUA came out with their budget document. I did a podcast on that last week. I know the trades will be sitting down with NCUA and explaining what they think NCUA should do relative to the budget. Anything on that or any other topics that are hot right now from what you're hearing with your contacts in the credit union world?
- 13:40John McKechnie: Credit union seem to like the the steady drumbeat of deregulatory proposals that they're coming out of the agency right now. I don't think anybody perceives them as a huge earth shattering sea change, but they're all necessary housecleaning, tidying up the regulatory structure. That's a good... I think Chairman Cruz has gotten off, as you were talking earlier about, he's not off of a good... I think with a good foot.
- 14:07People tend to see him as a thoughtful guy. He's being careful and deliberate, which is what they want right now. And the, again, the deregulatory pendulum, I imagine as long as he is... He constitutes the board, it's gonna continue to swing in that direction.
- 14:22Geoff Bacino: Jeff? Yeah. I agree. And sometimes I... Sometimes in these things, I find myself thinking agree with John.
- 14:28John McKechnie: That's a good thing. That's a good thing.
- 14:30Geoff Bacino: Yeah. I know. I like when you agree with me too. But that point is is very well taken. And, again, I hate to see this.
- 14:38I think even though I know we're taping this on Friday after the election, it still is... A lot of the stuff we're talking about is conjecture. What what I'm seeing out there are... Frankly, the the the thoughtful CEOs, the ones that have been around a while, understand that it is the pendulum we talk about, that it it can come back. You have to be careful, and I just...
- 14:59For the clients I've got, some of the things I talk about are, look, you wanna stay the course. You don't wanna get too excited about it. And I will say this. I will say that that Matt Balloris, who the agency put in charge of cure, Credit Union Resource Expansion, I think, is doing an amazing job. A couple credit unions that are a couple of clients who worked either on either field membership expansion, oragers, some new charters.
- 15:25And it... To be honest, was, like, not dead, which is good. It's the one department at the agency that I always felt didn't quite keep up with some of the other things, and I understand why they do it. It's now being run, I think, in a much
- 15:39Mark Treichel: more
- 15:40Geoff Bacino: pragmatic way where looking to market. John, we were all over there. We know that sometimes people tend to look at things and overemphasize the risk, overemphasize what they think might happen, and then they'll take into account, okay, what probably will happen. Or if it does happen, what's the worst that happens?
- 15:59Mark Treichel: Yeah. Matt's wearing Matt's wearing two or three hats right now.
- 16:03John McKechnie: President of CLF?
- 16:04Mark Treichel: Yeah. Yep. And in charge of the consumer compliance and and post skewing. So, yeah mentioned something.
- 16:13John McKechnie: I'm sorry, Mark.
- 16:13Mark Treichel: No. Go ahead. Go ahead.
- 16:15John McKechnie: He mentioned something about things are still a little bit up in the air, and I wanted to bring that back a little bit to the election. As we speak, there's, like, 28 house races and two senate races that are still not called. You've had a democratic pickup in the house of 41 seats, but that could well grow. They can almost have a 100 seat majority come January.
- 16:38Mark Treichel: Some would... Some might say that the votes are still coming in.
- 16:42John McKechnie: They are.
- 16:43Geoff Bacino: If guy from Chicago, I find that dual offensive.
- 16:46John McKechnie: Yeah. It's like the the pope the pope voted. It's it's... But you have seven you have a seven seat senate pickup, which is substantial from the day of things. That could grow to nine if if the two outstanding races, Mississippi and Alaska, go to the Democrats.
- 17:04And right now, the Democrats are narrowly heading both. So we don't even know how big these majorities are gonna be, and that's gonna dictate, I think, how Congress operates. Because in the last con... Or in the current Congress, Republicans only had a couple seat majority, so they had to tiptoe around. Now the Democrats have a very, very healthy majority.
- 17:21I think they're gonna they're gonna use it.
- 17:23Geoff Bacino: John, you've been... You and I have been around a long time. Okay? And when you got a little bigger majority of Johnson and to placate a lot of peep... And when you've got a two or three vote margin, everybody becomes a kingmaker, or they feel they can become a kingmaker.
- 17:36And you get small caucuses of maybe 20 or 30 members, which normally wouldn't mean anything. And all of a sudden, when you need three or four votes to get things over the finish line, they're huge. And I think what may help the Democrats most... Because, again, you see some of these calls for impeachment and things like that, which, to be honest with you, I think are just crazy. I think if democrat...
- 17:57If democrats wanna use 2027 as a dress rehearsal for 2028, they're gonna have to do something because I think what this election was about was you promised things. It didn't happen. It's not going my way. I'm bringing someone else
- 18:11John McKechnie: There are a couple wings of the Democratic party now, and one of them really doesn't wanna be very aggressive or impatient on investigations, trial You're in a... Yeah.
- 18:23Geoff Bacino: This is I guess my point is the bite... The bigger the margin is, the less you have to kinda copy.
- 18:29John McKechnie: That's a re... That's a very good error.
- 18:31Geoff Bacino: Look. But I mean, you and I start in Washington. I don't even wanna look back and see democrats. I mean, what? An honorable 60, a 170 vote margin?
- 18:39I remember when we were at. I was in some junior, I want say, freshman member at the office, and their banking guys told me, let me see if we can be with you. And inside, I'm thinking, you know what? I got the chairman. I got the ranking member.
- 18:51I'm pretty much... I don't really care if you're with me. I'm here at courtesy. And you could kinda get back to that point internally where Keith Jeffries, who I think probably most likely become speaker, has much more room to operate than Mike Johnson did. Johnson did pretty much a really tough job, a crappy fat ball of basically two or three people come to and say, we're on hold for that.
- 19:14Next thing you know, it's going down to twos.
- 19:17Mark Treichel: Yeah. And so let's kinda think that through. So extreme positions, you don't have to cater to those perhaps that have some extreme positions, but then it also puts pressure on to to do the change that the... That you got voted in to do because it wasn't recently done. So we're...
- 19:36It it gives the d's an opportunity to set the table for 2028 by what they've committed to get done. And then on top of that, you've got Trump who can veto things. So what short of impeachment and trials and tribulations, what... With the d's and substantial control of both, what actually can they get done with the with the presidency threatening the veto?
- 19:58John McKechnie: I'd look at I'd look at something like the Credit Card Competition Act, which Durbin... Both senator Durbin and senator Marshall are not gonna be here next year, but the idea underneath that bill is still very much alive. The retailers continue to push it, and the president has said he would sign it if he ever got it to his desk. So there there is something credit unions need to be careful. I think we need to be careful on that during the lame duck.
- 20:21I'm not sure if that's completely out of the question. They could do it as a parting gift for those two senators. It's not likely, but it's also not impossible. I think a lot of pro consumer legislation may come out. I think you might see overdraft protection attempted to be passed in both chambers, interest rate caps, things that take a more pro consumer flavor to them are gonna be, I think, on the democratic financial agenda next year.
- 20:51And I think you're gonna also see a lot of attempts by them to maybe pare back what crypto is doing. So those are some things to watch.
- 20:59Mark Treichel: And and the fintech, the the the energy data centers and things like that, we could see impacted as well. Jeff?
- 21:06Geoff Bacino: Hey, Ben. Mark, you talked about the veto, and that's the last stand for the White House. I like to tell people, and it's almost too simplistic. We need 218 in the house. You need 51 in the senate.
- 21:18You need the president to sign it. If you don't get one of those three things, you're not gonna get the bill you want. It's as simple as that. And if the president vetoes it, I don't think right now the demo... Obviously, the Democrats don't have enough to override it.
- 21:31But, frankly, even if they did, I think the Democrats are gonna... The the White House may do them some favors and may do others favors by saying, you know what? I'm not siding it. And then it becomes, hey, a campaign issue, and then does also happen if you don't want it. Again, I would just go back.
- 21:48I think it's imperative for Democrats to want to get things done. Denver Bronco coach Sean Payne, necessarily, I think, do your job. And that's what I think everybody on January 3 that comes into this congress, both Republican and Democrat. Love for them to start to pay. You know what?
- 22:05Let's do our job. Okay? Because we've really gotten into a we've really gotten into a pattern over the last couple years. I don't know. Pretty much just drawing a line.
- 22:14If Republican proposed it, the Democrats ain't voting. Democrat wants it. Republicans ain't doing it. And then you've obviously got someone in the White House who loves to, you know, tweet every fifteen minutes or whatever it is, and that impacts things.
- 22:27Mark Treichel: The broncos coach who was the saints coach who put a bounty on Brett Favre in the two thousand nine f... NFL... NFC championship game. That guy?
- 22:35Geoff Bacino: That guy.
- 22:35Mark Treichel: That guy.
- 22:36Geoff Bacino: But since I was never a huge Farr fan, I don't find that too offensive.
- 22:39Mark Treichel: I wasn't except for that one year, but but I digress. John?
- 22:45John McKechnie: It's... Our country... Even though you had an enormous electoral victory this week for Democrats, I think our country is still essentially a fifty fifty country in terms of ideologic divisions. We'll see it. Every every time either party gets a majority, there's always a lot of energy to get their agenda done, and there's also a lot of people whispering their ear that you don't wanna overreach.
- 23:07So we'll see what this coming one hundred and twentieth Congress brings us. You're definitely gonna have some different players, though, in the positions of authority you got as Hakim Jeffries. Schumer appears to be on track to be the majority leader unless he gets challenged from his left. But... And then the house, was Jeffries.
- 23:27You got Maxine as a likely chair. The guy named Richie Neal, who is not a household name, but he used to be the chair of the Ways and Means Committee. A very experienced veteran Democratic lawmaker who knows tax policy in and out. And I think he... If he does any tax bills, it will not look anything like what we saw out of the Republicans.
- 23:47And, of course, you got a Democrat in the Senate Finance Committee, Ron Wyden, who I know over the years in several meetings with him, he's very committed to maintaining the credit union tax redemption, so that's a good thing.
- 24:00Mark Treichel: That's positive.
- 24:01John McKechnie: I don't see it, by the way, as much of a a threat on the horizon from this coming Congress. I think last Congress, as as chairman Jason Smith of the House Ways and Means Committee, the Republican chairman who authored tax reform, he said, you guys had a serious threat in our committee in 2025. He said to me recently, I think you're... You've gotten past the tax issue for a while. Not to say the banks are gonna stop bringing it up because they'll always bring it up.
- 24:31But we just saw an ICBA fire another salvo at Credit Union this week. But I... They just don't have any takers. They keep losing. I'm not sure how much longer they're gonna try to waste their energy on that.
- 24:44Mark Treichel: Forever. Forever.
- 24:45John McKechnie: Yeah. That's true. But I just don't think they're... Trying something and doing something are two different
- 24:49Mark Treichel: things. Yeah.
- 24:50John McKechnie: For sure. For sure.
- 24:52Mark Treichel: Any last thoughts on what we're gonna see here? You wanna tell me what you're... If the Jacoby Bacino era and the Carson Wentz era have begun. And, Jeff, you just keep on keeping on with the best quarterback, young quarterback in football.
- 25:06Geoff Bacino: Like I said, you gotta be careful because if you ever know the story... Backstory about the bears Super Bowl shuffle back in '86, and there's there's actually a documentary on this. They filmed that the day after they got beat, and they... Their butts kicked by the dolphins on Monday night. So they come back and they film that thing.
- 25:24Frankly, the only way I think Galt got them to do it was by telling him it was to help feed the needy. But, yeah, I think we're gone from the NFL where you got dynasties or things like that because of the tower cap, but I'll keep my mouth shut. I'll wait and see. Very happy with where we are.
- 25:40Mark Treichel: Know, that game that you just mentioned, I've... I watched it in a Holiday Inn in Cloquet, Minnesota. I was doing an exam. And
- 25:47Geoff Bacino: Hopefully, the was at Camel 1 or two.
- 25:50Mark Treichel: They're gone now. Okay. But they weren't in Cloquet. So they were in somewhere else. That was the nearest hotel.
- 25:58And you guys were set. What? You guys... You're gonna trade that Lamar Jackson for Justin Jefferson? Should we just do that right now, John?
- 26:06John McKechnie: It's hard to talk about football for me at the moment, but things change. I would say that a month ago, we just... We were riding high four and one, and now we're in in in the dumpster.
- 26:16Mark Treichel: We're heading your way. That's my
- 26:18John McKechnie: my We'll see. I'd hate to see the Ravens trade Lamar, and yet at the same time, it's the... What's it? Somebody said earlier in the call about the best ability being availability. This is a lot of games.
- 26:29Mark Treichel: He he does indeed. Alright, guys. This has been fun. This episode will go out Monday morning before the Bills and the Vikings clash. And so I'm gonna predict Bills 35, Vikings 17, and and the slide starts.
- 26:44But I will have you guys on after the budget briefing, after a few of these. Elizabeth Warren pulling NCUA into chat, and we'll decipher. It's always fun chatting with you guys.
- 26:54John McKechnie: Take care.
- 26:55Mark Treichel: You got it, Pat. Thanks, Dennis. Listeners, watchers, thanks for watching. As always, this is Mark Trichol signing off with Flying Colors.