Latest / I Woke Up This Gay / 44. The AIDS Guy, Part Two
Transcript
- 0:03[SPEAKER_00]: My name is Stuart Merrill, and I woke up this gay.
- 0:08[SPEAKER_00]: Episode 44, The AIDS Guy Part II.
- 0:14[SPEAKER_00]: In the AIDS Guy Part I, I really enjoyed remembering the mini hilarious moments of my time as a lobbyist that you have to say legislator.
- 0:23[SPEAKER_00]: If you haven't heard the AIDS Guy Part I, you should definitely go back and listen to that first.
- 0:27[SPEAKER_00]: I think it's the funniest episode I've ever written, and I had a blast writing it.
- 0:33[SPEAKER_00]: It's a strange thing to say, but for me, it was a lot of fun, convincing Utah's predominantly Mormon legislators to pay for HIV medication, and I'd be lying if I didn't admit black mailing the ones I couldn't convince was even more enjoyable.
- 0:49[SPEAKER_00]: That was all covered in the first episode, so check it out.
- 0:52[SPEAKER_00]: Part 2 will make a lot more sense if you do.
- 0:56[SPEAKER_00]: Though selected memories of my life in Utah can be enjoyable, mostly, like time there, felt more like a sentence, a punishment, a judgment.
- 1:07[SPEAKER_00]: Not for a crime, though, I committed no crime.
- 1:11[SPEAKER_00]: No, I had to be punished for my birth, and that nested disparity that existed between their expectations and the reality of who I truly am.
- 1:23[SPEAKER_00]: because I was born a Mormon male in the narrow family.
- 1:27[SPEAKER_00]: I was expected to live up to certain things and to be proud of who I am.
- 1:33[SPEAKER_00]: Well, at least they got the second part right.
- 1:35[SPEAKER_00]: I'm very proud to be gay.
- 1:37[SPEAKER_00]: Out loud and proud.
- 1:39[SPEAKER_00]: Hell, I'll even admit to being a bit eccentric.
- 1:42[SPEAKER_00]: But that pretending to be something I'm not bit.
- 1:45[SPEAKER_00]: That has always been a problem for me.
- 1:48[SPEAKER_00]: I can't change who I am.
- 1:50[SPEAKER_00]: I've never been good at pretending to be something I'm not, and I always regret it when I try.
- 1:56[SPEAKER_00]: My life in Utah felt like a never-ending punishment for the crime of being proud to be me.
- 2:04[SPEAKER_00]: My me, not theirs.
- 2:06[SPEAKER_00]: Returning to Utah's an adult was one of the most difficult periods of my life.
- 2:11[SPEAKER_00]: Those are memories I don't enjoy.
- 2:18[SPEAKER_00]: I am very proud of my accomplishments as an HIV-AIDS and LGBTQ rights lobbyist in Utah.
- 2:25[SPEAKER_00]: I achieved what everyone told me was impossible, but I had few friends with whom I could share these proud victories.
- 2:33[SPEAKER_00]: Many of the people I had helped despise me, some even tried to stop me.
- 2:37[SPEAKER_00]: The rest mostly remained silent.
- 2:42[SPEAKER_00]: Returning to Utah's an adult was every bit as lonely and painful as my Utah childhood had
- 2:50[SPEAKER_00]: I was raised in a family with a strong tradition of service and volunteering.
- 2:55[SPEAKER_00]: When I returned to Utah, my health was in shambles as was my life as a result.
- 3:00[SPEAKER_00]: There was little I could do to improve my own situation.
- 3:03[SPEAKER_00]: However, I could take advantage of my prominent family name, to help others struggling with HIV-AIDS.
- 3:10[SPEAKER_00]: For a couple of years, I'd served on the board that oversaw the distribution of federal funds for HIV and AIDS treatment in Utah.
- 3:17[SPEAKER_00]: The George S. of the U.S. Administration had flat-funded the federal HIV AIDS budget.
- 3:22[SPEAKER_00]: As a result in Utah and many other states, we could barely afford medication for our existing clients.
- 3:29[SPEAKER_00]: any newly diagnosed HIV age patients had to be turned away and literally left to die.
- 3:35[SPEAKER_00]: In 2005, nine years after the release of life-saving medication, that was simply unacceptable.
- 3:44[SPEAKER_00]: There was no federal legislation on the horizon that would eventually alleviate our budget problem.
- 3:49[SPEAKER_00]: But by the time it passed, both houses of Congress, a lot of people were already be dead.
- 3:54[SPEAKER_00]: The reauthorization of this legislation, the Ryan White Care Act, was co-sponsored by the two most powerful senators in America at the time.
- 4:03[SPEAKER_00]: Democratic Senator Ted Kennedy of Massachusetts, the Lion of the Senate, and the longest serving Republican Senator in American history, Senator Orin Hatch of Utah, and all
- 4:14[SPEAKER_00]: I had no Senator Hatch since I was a little boy, and as an adult, I'm proud of the wonderful working relationship he and I developed during my mini trips to Washington lobbying for his bill.
- 4:25[SPEAKER_00]: With America's two most powerful senators co-sponsoring this legislation, it's passage was almost a certainty, but it would take time, two or three years.
- 4:35[SPEAKER_00]: I decided to lobby the Utah State Legislature and ask them to make up the difference at our budget shortfall for those three years.
- 4:42[SPEAKER_00]: Simultaneously we promised to work on the new federal legislation that would eventually fully fund our needs.
- 4:48[SPEAKER_00]: After which, at promised Utah's legislators, we wouldn't ask for any more money.
- 4:54[SPEAKER_00]: Famously, my prominent Mormon grandfather had run a charity in Utah that paid for healthcare for anyone who needed it for over 40 years.
- 5:02[SPEAKER_00]: I simply told Republicans, I was a healthcare lobbyist carrying on my family's tradition.
- 5:08[SPEAKER_00]: Since most of the senior legislators knew who my grandfather was, it was a very effective way to get my foot in the door, at least with the Republicans.
- 5:16[SPEAKER_00]: The Democrats mostly disapproved of nepotism.
- 5:20[SPEAKER_00]: My mother had also been a women's and children's rights lobbyist in Utah, though, in all honesty, the misogynistic 75% Republican Supermajority in Utah remembered her a little less fondly.
- 5:33[SPEAKER_00]: I agreed with my mother's philosophy, though.
- 5:36[SPEAKER_00]: As long as you're using it for good, any tools you have at your disposal should be utilized, I had nepotism, so I used it.
- 5:44[SPEAKER_00]: With my massive polygamous family, I was related to damn near half the Utah State legislature.
- 5:51[SPEAKER_00]: All my life my grandpa had been the head of the Massive Merrill clan, and I knew he was support my deal, and my tactics.
- 5:58[SPEAKER_00]: I received health care from the veterans who had been in the situation, so I didn't have to worry for myself.
- 6:03[SPEAKER_00]: However, I was in a unique position where I could help others in Utah as my wonderful grandfather had done before me.
- 6:10[SPEAKER_00]: HIV medication had saved my life, however the dreadful side effects had completely destroyed my health.
- 6:18[SPEAKER_00]: On the years later what I learned that I'm in the unfortunate 2.5% of people who suffered from the side effects of extreme chronic fatigue, I was constantly tired.
- 6:31[SPEAKER_00]: It would be another 20 years before my doctors were finally able to explain much less correct the destructive impact this medication had on every aspect of my life.
- 6:42[SPEAKER_00]: The career I had been so proud of and had worked so very hard to obtain was gone.
- 6:47[SPEAKER_00]: My income had dropped from $140,000 a year, which is the equivalent of over a quarter of a million dollars today, to not that far above minimum wage.
- 6:57[SPEAKER_00]: I was working a dead end job at American Express as a Russian German and English-speaking customer service agent for their centurion card.
- 7:05[SPEAKER_00]: It was abundantly clear to me that as allowed proud out gay men, my chances for advancement there were nil.
- 7:14[SPEAKER_00]: My own community, the LGBT community, especially its leadership, tell my loud and proud sex positive approach to life, offensive to their prudish attitude of conformity.
- 7:25[SPEAKER_00]: They weren't upset because they had an active sex life, they were offended because they didn't hide it and lie about it like they did.
- 7:33[SPEAKER_00]: I guess unknowingly, I was among Utah's first advocates for a sex positive approach to gay life.
- 7:38[SPEAKER_00]: It would be another decade or two before the gaze in Utah would grasp this healthy and enlightened concept.
- 7:45[SPEAKER_00]: Also, since the doctors were unable to address McCronick fatigue, I struggled with the only solutions that had ever helped.
- 7:53[SPEAKER_00]: I self-medicated with tons of caffeine in every form I could find, and I occasionally used crystal meth to varying degrees.
- 8:01[SPEAKER_00]: I soon discovered, gay men were extremely eager to hook up with me, but they wouldn't acknowledge me if they saw me in the street.
- 8:09[SPEAKER_00]: I started to feel like a mixed race courtesend in the antebellum south.
- 8:13[SPEAKER_00]: At a Christmas party hosted by a prominent gay political, a very sexy man I knew, took me aside when no one was looking, and explained that he had lied to his boyfriend about a fake business trip in the coming week.
- 8:26[SPEAKER_00]: Instead he wanted me to meet him in a hotel to party in half-sex.
- 8:31[SPEAKER_00]: A few minutes later, his boyfriend came up to me and said, hey, my boyfriend's going to be out of town next week.
- 8:37[SPEAKER_00]: Do you want to come over to party and play?
- 8:40[SPEAKER_00]: in all five different men from three couples approached me that night.
- 8:44[SPEAKER_00]: I turned them all down and went home, rather disgusted.
- 8:48[SPEAKER_00]: My family and most religious Mormons treated me with that condescending tolerance they reserved for people of lesser human value.
- 8:57[SPEAKER_00]: They behaved as if I was a Dickinsonian cherry case that they were obliged to acknowledge, but didn't really like very much.
- 9:04[SPEAKER_00]: Spending time with my family increasingly started to feel like I was pathetically groping to be a part of a club that didn't really want me as a member.
- 9:12[SPEAKER_00]: My favorite example of this was spending Christmas at my brother's house in 2008, a couple of weeks after the economic crash.
- 9:20[SPEAKER_00]: Charles Schwab had special order to private jet, but he could no longer afford it.
- 9:25[SPEAKER_00]: So one of my nephews bought it with the money he had gained by basically legally stealing the snuggie patent.
- 9:32[SPEAKER_00]: Such a typically Mormon thing to do.
- 9:35[SPEAKER_00]: They have the habit of convincing themselves that if it's not illegal, then it's also
- 9:41[SPEAKER_00]: Christmas morning I spent two hours watching every member of my family open their numerous Christmas presents, a landover, a lexas, thousands upon thousands of dollars worth of electronics for the kids.
- 9:54[SPEAKER_00]: I got one gift, a dollar store mug that said, live simply.
- 9:59[SPEAKER_00]: Hey, at least it was grammatically correct, unlike their conversations I was never a part of.
- 10:05[SPEAKER_00]: My sister-in-law then took me aside and said, listen, we are going to take the jet to Vegas for lunch.
- 10:11[SPEAKER_00]: We want to bring the new puppy so there's no room for you, but we need you to stay here for a delivery anyway.
- 10:16[SPEAKER_00]: Merry Christmas.
- 10:18[SPEAKER_00]: That was my life in Utah.
- 10:20[SPEAKER_00]: I had hoped that if I returned to my childhood home, my friends and family would support me while I tried to get my life back on track.
- 10:27[SPEAKER_00]: Instead, my family barely tolerated my presence, my community shunned me by day and secretly visited me by night, LDBTQ plus leadership tried to prevent my success as a little lobbyist, even though it meant HIV positive Utahns would die if I failed.
- 10:44[SPEAKER_00]: So as I'm sure you can imagine, this has been an extremely difficult episode for me to write.
- 10:49[SPEAKER_00]: I should have written it years ago, but it was just too painful to remember.
- 10:54[SPEAKER_00]: Maybe writing this will help me let go of the pain I always associate with Utah, Mormons, my violently homophobic childhood, my family and my friends who betrayed me there.
- 11:05[SPEAKER_00]: Perhaps this will nudge me one step closer to finally forgiving them and myself.
- 11:11[SPEAKER_00]: In all honesty, I'm not sure they deserve forgiveness though, but I know I do, and I can
- 11:22[SPEAKER_00]: I never chose any of this, you know?
- 11:24[SPEAKER_00]: I never asked for it.
- 11:27[SPEAKER_00]: I just happened to be born into a family and a society where I always had to fight for respect and the right to be who I am.
- 11:34[SPEAKER_00]: It was a very lonely reality for a child, but I knew no other until I left Utah behind.
- 11:41[SPEAKER_00]: When I returned to Utah as an adult and my best friend betrayed me, I realized it was the painful solitude I had feared the most.
- 11:49[SPEAKER_00]: In Utah, the solitude quickly took over my life again, just as I had feared it would.
- 11:54[SPEAKER_00]: once again I realized that all encompassing loneliness would always be my only loyal companion in Utah.
- 12:02[SPEAKER_00]: That's just the way it had always been for me there, and I was a fool to have thought this time would be different.
- 12:08[SPEAKER_00]: The worst part about being thrust into the role of a trailblazer fighting against social injustice and bigotry in a place like Utah was for me the loneliness and
- 12:23[SPEAKER_00]: Looking back now, I understand it had always been that way though, and not just for me, but also for my mother, I have century earlier when she fought for women's rights in Utah.
- 12:33[SPEAKER_00]: Even many of history's greatest heroes encountered opposition from the very people who should have been supporting them.
- 12:40[SPEAKER_00]: In her time, women considered Joan of Arc, a witch, and called for her to be burned at the stake, which of course she ultimately was.
- 12:48[SPEAKER_00]: were it not through my favorite civil rights hero, Byard Ruston, none of us white folk would have ever even heard of Martin Luther King.
- 12:55[SPEAKER_00]: It was Byard Ruston's stunning organizational skills that made the march on Washington, the Montgomery Bus boycott, and the Southern Christian leadership conference possible.
- 13:05[SPEAKER_00]: The main reason Americans proudly remember these stunning moments in our history is because of Byard Ruston's communication and media brilliance.
- 13:15[SPEAKER_00]: Yet many of his contemporaries were ashamed of him, and made him take a backseat in history because he was unapologetically gay.
- 13:25[SPEAKER_00]: Now I'm in no way comparing myself to such great heroes.
- 13:28[SPEAKER_00]: My contributions were miniscule by comparison.
- 13:32[SPEAKER_00]: But they were my idols and my role models.
- 13:35[SPEAKER_00]: I often wondered what kept them going in the face of such vicious cruel and at times downright evil opposition from the very people who ultimately benefit it from their activism.
- 13:46[SPEAKER_00]: How did they do it?
- 13:47[SPEAKER_00]: How did they stay motivated in the face of such cruelty from the very people they were trying to help?
- 13:53[SPEAKER_00]: If I was going to survive my solitary existence in Utah, I needed to tap into that drive that bottomless well of inspiration that somehow kept them going.
- 14:04[SPEAKER_00]: In Utah, many in the LGBTQ plus community, my community, and the vast majority of its leadership, refused to help me in my endeavor to save the lives of people with HIV.
- 14:15[SPEAKER_00]: Some of them actively campaigned against me.
- 14:18[SPEAKER_00]: My allies consisted mostly of Utah's liberal straight community.
- 14:22[SPEAKER_00]: and as grateful as I am for their support, being shunned by my own community, left me feeling profoundly alone.
- 14:30[SPEAKER_00]: I had to constantly remind myself that by the time I was 30, the vast majority of my friends were dead.
- 14:36[SPEAKER_00]: I'm one of the lucky ones.
- 14:37[SPEAKER_00]: I'm still here, and I owed it to my dead friends to keep on fighting.
- 14:43[SPEAKER_00]: My support system and my motivation became the memory of my friends I had lost to AIDS and the promise I had made to them to never stop fighting for equality.
- 14:52[SPEAKER_00]: Much as my heroes and role models had done, I fought out of the sense of duty to future generations and to my friends I had loved and lost.
- 15:01[SPEAKER_00]: When my mother was fighting against misogyny, fighting four women's rights in Mormon society, her most vicious opponents weren't the Mormon men.
- 15:10[SPEAKER_00]: She took their opposition and stride.
- 15:12[SPEAKER_00]: She expected that and she knew how to deal with it.
- 15:14[SPEAKER_00]: And I'm proud to say she dealt with it extremely well.
- 15:17[SPEAKER_00]: It was the relentlessly vicious Mormon women and her own family, my family, the very people who stood at them by her side.
- 15:26[SPEAKER_00]: They were the ones that sent her into fits of rage and despair.
- 15:29[SPEAKER_00]: As a child, they didn't understand that.
- 15:32[SPEAKER_00]: I couldn't comprehend why my mother was so unhappy and so lonely.
- 15:37[SPEAKER_00]: But I understand it now.
- 15:39[SPEAKER_00]: Like so many others before us, my mother and I were trying to prove to an entire society that the way they thought and behaved was unjust, immoral and needed to change.
- 15:51[SPEAKER_00]: In my case, it was the LGBTQ plus leadership, even the leadership of Utah's HIV positive community who actively campaigned against me.
- 15:59[SPEAKER_00]: I was trying to save their lives by getting our government to pay for their HIV medication.
- 16:05[SPEAKER_00]: My medication was paid for, yet some of the very people whose lives I ultimately did save tried to stop me, and they still despise me.
- 16:14[SPEAKER_00]: It breaks my heart to remember that, and I may never fully understand it.
- 16:20[SPEAKER_00]: I did have two wonderfully dependable allies in the Utah State Legislature on whom I could always count.
- 16:26[SPEAKER_00]: Two amazing members of Utah's LGBTQ Plus community, whom I'll always respect and admire.
- 16:33[SPEAKER_00]: Senator Scott McCoy, Utah's first and only openly gay state senator at the time, and of course the spectacular Jackie Biscoupsky, who served in Utah State House of Representatives, Jackie would also go on to become mayor of Salt Lake City.
- 16:50[SPEAKER_00]: My first week lobbying useless legislators had gone brilliantly well, and it was a hell of a lot of fun.
- 16:56[SPEAKER_00]: As I said, I already covered that in episode 1.
- 16:59[SPEAKER_00]: I had already managed to get most of the Republican leadership to support my bill.
- 17:03[SPEAKER_00]: My second week at the legislature began with Jackie and Scott taking me aside to tell me I had a problem.
- 17:10[SPEAKER_00]: Stan Penfold, the director of the Utah Ace Foundation, had spent the weekend calling his contacts at the legislature to tell them I was lying and we did not need more money for HIV medication in Utah.
- 17:23[SPEAKER_00]: He called both Jackie and Scott and told them not to support me.
- 17:28[SPEAKER_00]: I was outraged, but not terribly surprised.
- 17:32[SPEAKER_00]: Many of us got the impression that Stan was in it for the paycheck.
- 17:37[SPEAKER_00]: He wasn't very hands-on, and I was not surprised to discover he was unaware of the fact that his clients were about to start dying, and thus we found more money.
- 17:47[SPEAKER_00]: I genuinely think Stan had no idea this was happening.
- 17:51[SPEAKER_00]: That being said, the fact that the head of Utah's preeminent age charity would rather let his own patients die than see me succeed?
- 18:00[SPEAKER_00]: Tells you the kind of sick freaks I have to deal with in my own community.
- 18:05[SPEAKER_00]: It boggers belief that anyone could let themselves become so irrational and twisted by petty hatred.
- 18:13[SPEAKER_00]: But that was my Utah reality, and the reason I would ultimately have to leave.
- 18:17[SPEAKER_00]: First thing I did was have my contact at the Utah Department of Health in charge of HIV&AIDS, write an email or just to all of Utah's legislators, stating we indeed did urgently need more money for HIV medication or people in Utah were going to die.
- 18:33[SPEAKER_00]: Then, in a thick of rage, I went to the Utah AIDS Foundation to confront Stan.
- 18:38[SPEAKER_00]: Apparently, he got wind I was coming, and being the coward he repeatedly proved himself to be, stands suddenly felt unwell and went home before I got there.
- 18:48[SPEAKER_00]: Stan would spend the next years actively avoiding any contact with me whatsoever.
- 18:54[SPEAKER_00]: He never apologized or even explained his irrational and life-threatening behavior.
- 19:00[SPEAKER_00]: A couple of years later, a group of his clients tried to oust Stan from the Utah AIDS Foundation.
- 19:06[SPEAKER_00]: This was after I left Utah, but I happened to be there for a family thing when it went down.
- 19:12[SPEAKER_00]: So when some community leaders got together to discuss possibly removing Stan, I was asked to explain how Stan had risked the lives of some of the people he was paid to take care up.
- 19:24[SPEAKER_00]: One of the members of this board accused me of making it up so I could take his job.
- 19:30[SPEAKER_00]: I told her I would rather slash my wrists with a rusty tuna cam than return to this community.
- 19:36[SPEAKER_00]: You could offer me the Governor ship and I'd say no.
- 19:39[SPEAKER_00]: There is absolutely nothing you could possibly say or do though it ever induced me to return to a place where my own community treats me the way you were treating me right now.
- 19:54[SPEAKER_00]: I spoke up to improve their lives.
- 19:58[SPEAKER_00]: This was all covered in the local gay press, and even though Scott and Jackie both confirmed it was true, stand a night it ever happened, while minimizing my success and the fact that I had saved the lives of some of these clients.
- 20:12[SPEAKER_00]: Of course, Stan retained his position.
- 20:15[SPEAKER_00]: I will never understand how Seeking Me Fail could have been more important to Stan than saving the lives of the people he was paid to help.
- 20:24[SPEAKER_00]: I can only guess why Stan hated me so much.
- 20:27[SPEAKER_00]: For reasons I've never really understood, many Americans of that generation tended to have rather extreme reactions to me.
- 20:35[SPEAKER_00]: I guess I have a rather conspicuous presence.
- 20:38[SPEAKER_00]: As my mother always said, some people simply can't live life unnoticed.
- 20:44[SPEAKER_00]: That generation of Americans have either a very positive reaction to me or they aggressively despise me.
- 20:52[SPEAKER_00]: This was particularly true for me and you trust community of gay men, just like all those woman women my mother tried to help, who's so passionately aged at her.
- 21:01[SPEAKER_00]: With Stan, it may have gotten a little deeper than just my outside eccentric personality.
- 21:06[SPEAKER_00]: He had a vested interest in seeing me fail because his best friend at the time Michael Mitchell despised me.
- 21:13[SPEAKER_00]: Michael Mitchell was the first executive director of Requality Utah,
- 21:20[SPEAKER_00]: Michael had also been one of my best and oldest friends for over 20 years.
- 21:25[SPEAKER_00]: He grew up across the street from my grandparents in Preston, Idaho.
- 21:28[SPEAKER_00]: We became close friends in Chicago years before, then roommates in New York, I even rented a vacation home on Fire Island for the two of us.
- 21:37[SPEAKER_00]: When I first started getting sick from HIV medication in Miami Beach, Michael was the one who convinced me to move back to Utah.
- 21:44[SPEAKER_00]: I warned him, I tried to make him understand that the gay community there has always had an incomprehensible but intense dislike of me.
- 21:52[SPEAKER_00]: I was and still am terrified of Utah and the way my own community has always treated me there.
- 21:58[SPEAKER_00]: However, Michael was persistent.
- 22:00[SPEAKER_00]: He spent his weak leg vacation in my Miami Beach apartment begging me to return to Utah with him.
- 22:06[SPEAKER_00]: He swore to me that he would stand by my side no matter what.
- 22:10[SPEAKER_00]: Worst comes to worst you will always have me, he promised.
- 22:14[SPEAKER_00]: So hoping to regain my health, I made possibly the greatest mistake of my life, and I returned to Utah.
- 22:21[SPEAKER_00]: Like many of us who grew up gay in the Mormon culture, Michael craved acceptance.
- 22:27[SPEAKER_00]: While at a very early age, I had grown accustomed to the fact that some societies would just never like me.
- 22:33[SPEAKER_00]: Michael's need to be popular was unquenchable.
- 22:37[SPEAKER_00]: It was downright pathological.
- 22:40[SPEAKER_00]: There was nothing he would not do, and as I learned, no one he would not betray to finally be popular.
- 22:47[SPEAKER_00]: As I knew they would, the in crowd of Salt Lake City's gay community, strongly disliked me.
- 22:53[SPEAKER_00]: I was not capable of conforming to their massively oppressed so-called normal behavior.
- 22:59[SPEAKER_00]: I am proud of my outsized personality, and my active sex life, I think it's healthy.
- 23:10[SPEAKER_00]: The sex positive movement didn't exist yet at a Utah, but I guess I was eternally as Dadbic at there.
- 23:16[SPEAKER_00]: The extremely conformist and oppressed gay community in Utah tell my personality and my behavior offensive, so they shunned me.
- 23:25[SPEAKER_00]: When Michael realized I had been correct and Utah's gay community strongly disliked me, he forgot his promise to me and basically threw me under the bus like everyone else.
- 23:34[SPEAKER_00]: He could not risk his first ever popularity by honoring his word and standing by one of his oldest friends.
- 23:40[SPEAKER_00]: My worst fears about Utah had come true, and I was left basically friendless.
- 23:47[SPEAKER_00]: When I started lobbying for more money to help people with HIV-AIDS, I, of course, assumed as the executive director of Equality Utah, Michael would set aside his petty prejudice and be a professional.
- 24:03[SPEAKER_00]: Michael did not answer a single one of the multiple communications to him, requesting equality Utah support, nor did his board of directors, they all blackballed me entirely.
- 24:16[SPEAKER_00]: The equality Utah board at that time consisted mostly of successful lesbian lawyers and business women.
- 24:22[SPEAKER_00]: They were far more interested in raising their national profile than serving the urgent needs of Utah's LGBTQ plus community.
- 24:30[SPEAKER_00]: They turned a blind eye to the AIDS problem and completely ignored the very pressing issue of drug addiction in our community.
- 24:37[SPEAKER_00]: These ladies wanted national prominence and prestige.
- 24:41[SPEAKER_00]: Ugly issues like AIDS and drugs had no place in their pretty little portfolio.
- 24:47[SPEAKER_00]: Within much of the LGBTQ plus community, these ladies were rather derisively referred to as the hersbola.
- 24:57[SPEAKER_00]: I had to accept these realities and figure out how to turn them to my advantage.
- 25:01[SPEAKER_00]: Ironically, the rift that existed between me and LGBTQ plus leadership, especially Stan Penfold, Michael Mitchell and the Herzbollah, turned out to work very much in my favor.
- 25:13[SPEAKER_00]: Even though I most certainly considered myself to be an LGBTQ plus rights lobbyist, it was very helpful if Republicans did not think of me that way.
- 25:22[SPEAKER_00]: I wanted them to define me as a healthcare lobbyist, carrying on my storied morning-town naturedition of helping people access healthcare.
- 25:30[SPEAKER_00]: That made them far more receptive to my message.
- 25:33[SPEAKER_00]: I was left with no choice, but to make sure Utah's Republican caucus was well aware of the animosity that existed between myself and Utah's LGBTQ-plus leadership, especially the hersbola.
- 25:47[SPEAKER_00]: Frankly, the majority of Republicans despised them.
- 25:50[SPEAKER_00]: I turned their hatred of me into a major asset and put it on display for all of the Republicans to see.
- 25:57[SPEAKER_00]: Ironically, in the end, their irrational behavior towards me opened quite a few doors, and won me more than just a few votes from their Republicans who otherwise may not have supported my bill.
- 26:09[SPEAKER_00]: I forced myself to start watching Fox News and the ultra-conservative Mormon television channel from Brigham Young University, the Mormon University.
- 26:17[SPEAKER_00]: I made a study of conservative Mormon vocabulary in vernacular.
- 26:21[SPEAKER_00]: I studied their political points of view and priorities.
- 26:24[SPEAKER_00]: I explored ways to fold my needs into theirs.
- 26:28[SPEAKER_00]: I learned which democratic arguments didn't work with Republicans and why, so I could avoid using them.
- 26:33[SPEAKER_00]: I came up with ways to phrase my arguments so conservatives were more receptive.
- 26:38[SPEAKER_00]: I explored tailored my message to sound like theirs.
- 26:41[SPEAKER_00]: I translated my arguments into Mormon talk, Republican talk, and practiced them out loud in my apartment or went out walking my dog.
- 26:48[SPEAKER_00]: Everybody already thought I was crazy, so I had nothing to lose.
- 26:51[SPEAKER_00]: I intentionally engage random Republicans in political debates to test these arguments.
- 26:57[SPEAKER_00]: I studied their reactions and explored ways to counter the responses and or tailored my words so they were more receptive.
- 27:04[SPEAKER_00]: I discovered the argument of doing what's right in saving lives, held very little sway with the Republican Party.
- 27:10[SPEAKER_00]: Charts and graphs proving it was cheaper to pay for the medication that kept people working and paying taxes, rather than letting them get sick and go unwell for the rest of their lives, was a far more effective argument.
- 27:24[SPEAKER_00]: Once the problem with Stan was neutralized, I still had to go to the capital every day, as long as the legislature was in session.
- 27:31[SPEAKER_00]: I had to be there in case there were any more fires that had to be put out and to pick up any stragglers along the way.
- 27:37[SPEAKER_00]: In spite of my success with Republican legislators as a whole, there was one man, Senator Chris Budders, who actively campaigned against me throughout that first session.
- 27:47[SPEAKER_00]: Actually, Senator Butters kind of made me laugh.
- 27:51[SPEAKER_00]: I saw him as an almost stereotyped cartoon character, a caricature of the perfect anti-gay villain.
- 27:58[SPEAKER_00]: Abraham Lincoln is frequently credited with their quote.
- 28:01[SPEAKER_00]: Every man over 40 deserves the face he has, or is responsible for his face.
- 28:06[SPEAKER_00]: Implying that one's character, choices, and life experience mold a man's appearance over time.
- 28:12[SPEAKER_00]: never have I met a man, for whom that was more true than Senator Chris Butters.
- 28:18[SPEAKER_00]: That poor man's face was so twisted with bitterness, bile, and hatred.
- 28:23[SPEAKER_00]: It was painful to even look at him.
- 28:26[SPEAKER_00]: He was violently homophobic in that way only a closeted gay man can be.
- 28:31[SPEAKER_00]: History has repeatedly taught us that such high intensity homophobia is inevitably fueled by the self-loathing of a closeted gay man.
- 28:42[SPEAKER_00]: Even when it was totally out of the blue and off topic, he would start spewing vial anti-gay rhetoric.
- 28:49[SPEAKER_00]: All they took was seeing me or a pro-gay lobbyist walk by and he'd lunch into another
- 28:56[SPEAKER_00]: I had long since learned there is absolutely no point in trying to reason with such a man.
- 29:01[SPEAKER_00]: I had also learned, with hateful men like Senator Chris Budders, the best strategy is just to wait.
- 29:07[SPEAKER_00]: Such hatred and hypocrisy eventually inevitably catches up to you.
- 29:13[SPEAKER_00]: Sure enough, one day out of the blue, a bunch of gay activists stormed the capital and passed out flyers, claiming Senator Budders was a closet or homosexual that frequently hired gay sex workers.
- 29:26[SPEAKER_00]: in perhaps the best acting performance of my life.
- 29:29[SPEAKER_00]: I went up to Senate about it with one of the flyers in hand and tore it up, told him how shocked and horrified it was.
- 29:36[SPEAKER_00]: How could these disgusting men slander his honorable name in such an unspeakable fashion I asked?
- 29:42[SPEAKER_00]: I told them how profoundly sorry I was and assured them that these horrible people passing out these vile flyers most certainly did not represent the gay community as a whole.
- 29:53[SPEAKER_00]: They were nothing but crazy extremists and I had nothing to do with them.
- 29:56[SPEAKER_00]: I was totally ashamed of them.
- 29:59[SPEAKER_00]: I went on and on with the most flowery apology I could possibly master to disassociate myself from these guys.
- 30:06[SPEAKER_00]: The truth was, I thought the whole thing was hilarious, and Senator Butters got exactly what he deserved.
- 30:16[SPEAKER_00]: Then I found the guy who organized the whole thing, took him out around to the side of the Capitol and thanked him profusely.
- 30:22[SPEAKER_00]: I started to explain how he'd helped me gain the favor of my last holdout in the Republican Party, to which he responded, well, duh, why do you think I did it?
- 30:32[SPEAKER_00]: I'd never had any troubles with Senator Butters after that.
- 30:35[SPEAKER_00]: I slowly started to discover, I had a lot more allies in the gay community than I had originally thought, and time came to believe even a silent majority of my community eventually came to support me.
- 30:49[SPEAKER_00]: In between sessions, I wrote a monthly political column for both Utah's gay publications.
- 30:54[SPEAKER_00]: Every month, Laura Jones, a dear friend and reliable ally, hosted a call-in-talk radio show in KCPW, one of our local NPR stations.
- 31:02[SPEAKER_00]: We discussed the situation of HIV-AIDS in Utah and at the Utah State Legislature.
- 31:07[SPEAKER_00]: I organized an AIDS Memorial event to keep the issue in front of everyone's minds.
- 31:12[SPEAKER_00]: We lined up 8,500 pairs of shoes in library square to illustrate the number of people still dying daily from AIDS worldwide.
- 31:21[SPEAKER_00]: The summer before my second session, Gil Rizica lost a son.
- 31:27[SPEAKER_00]: Gael was Utah's most influential lobbyists.
- 31:30[SPEAKER_00]: She famously and very successfully blocked any and all pro LGBTQ plus rights legislation in Utah for decades.
- 31:38[SPEAKER_00]: However, she had actively supported my bill to pay for HIV medication.
- 31:43[SPEAKER_00]: There was a great deal of speculation in the local press regarding a rumor that the death of her son had been drug related.
- 31:50[SPEAKER_00]: A couple of years earlier, my brother had lost his lovely daughter to a drug overdose.
- 31:55[SPEAKER_00]: My brother started a non-profit called Dad, Dad's against drug dealers.
- 32:01[SPEAKER_00]: It got a great deal of local and national press.
- 32:04[SPEAKER_00]: He was even on good morning America and an equivalent TV show in London.
- 32:09[SPEAKER_00]: Someone wrote a letter to the editor that claimed my family thought Gael should have gone public and used the death of her son for good.
- 32:17[SPEAKER_00]: I wrote a letter to the editor that was published the next day.
- 32:21[SPEAKER_00]: I stated while we were proud of our brother for having turned our family tragedy into a force for good.
- 32:28[SPEAKER_00]: We in the narrow family believe everyone has the right to grieve in their own way, and whatever way they choose must be respected.
- 32:36[SPEAKER_00]: Besides, we don't know the cause of his death, and it doesn't matter.
- 32:41[SPEAKER_00]: The only thing I do know is that the son of a friend had died.
- 32:46[SPEAKER_00]: We weren't gay and her family to know that our thoughts and prayers are with her and her family.
- 32:52[SPEAKER_00]: Beyond that, nothing else matters.
- 32:56[SPEAKER_00]: My second year at the Utah State Legislature was also successful and much easier than the first.
- 33:02[SPEAKER_00]: I was able to use the relationships that I built with a Republican leadership to advance quite a bit of legislation more favorable to the LGBTQ plus community, adoption, discrimination, and our biggest victory was getting the LGBTQ plus community included in Utah's new hate crimes legislation.
- 33:27[SPEAKER_00]: The nighted past, Gail very graciously came up to me and congratulated me on our success.
- 33:33[SPEAKER_00]: The rest of our community may have despised her, but Gail is a class act, and I will always respect her.
- 33:40[SPEAKER_00]: Shortly after the end of the second session, Oren hatches version of the Ryan White Care Act finally passed both houses of Congress and President Bush quietly sided into law.
- 33:51[SPEAKER_00]: I had asked to be at the signing ceremony, but there was none.
- 33:55[SPEAKER_00]: Bush didn't want people to know he was helping our community, so late one night he signed it alone in the Oval Office.
- 34:02[SPEAKER_00]: My work in Utah was done.
- 34:05[SPEAKER_00]: At the beginning of what would have been my third session at the Utah legislature, I strongwarm some connections into allowing me to be the first lobbyist to address the legislature that year.
- 34:17[SPEAKER_00]: Three years ago, mid-Session, I showed up out of nowhere and asked you to fund an emergency bill to pay for medication for people with HIV-AIDS in Utah.
- 34:28[SPEAKER_00]: At that time, I made you a promise, I'd promised that if you would fund this medication for three years, we would get a bill passed in Washington, D.C. that would pay for this life-saving medication after that.
- 34:40[SPEAKER_00]: Well, I am proud to report that we kept that promise, and we did it it only two years.
- 34:46[SPEAKER_00]: President Bush recently signed Senator Hatch's version of the reauthorization of the Ryan White Care Act into law.
- 34:54[SPEAKER_00]: This version of the bill is financially dramatically more favorable to the state of Utah.
- 35:00[SPEAKER_00]: Going forward, we no longer need money from you.
- 35:04[SPEAKER_00]: today, I stand for you to simply say thank you.
- 35:08[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you for your wisdom.
- 35:10[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you for your courage to do what was right.
- 35:13[SPEAKER_00]: You saved countless lives and you saved the Utah State Taxpayers a great deal of money.
- 35:19[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you.
- 35:21[SPEAKER_00]: That little speech made it in the local papers the next day.
- 35:24[SPEAKER_00]: Apparently, nobody had ever done that before.
- 35:27[SPEAKER_00]: It seemed to me to be a perfectly obvious political move that would leave the door open for my community in the future.
- 35:34[SPEAKER_00]: That's why I did it.
- 35:37[SPEAKER_00]: After that, I got a wonderful new job and was finally able to leave American Express.
- 35:43[SPEAKER_00]: My friend Wayne Holland, the chair of the Utah Democratic Party,
- 35:50[SPEAKER_00]: Katie had a law, she was stunning brilliant, very successful, and I absolutely adored her.
- 35:56[SPEAKER_00]: She was second in command, running a sort of telemarketing team at a medical staffing company called Comp Health on by CHG. She offered me a job where I basically booked traveling fiscal therapists and occupational therapists for various medical facilities around the country.
- 36:13[SPEAKER_00]: I loved working for Katie and I loved my new job.
- 36:16[SPEAKER_00]: I was named employee of the month on my ninth day of employment.
- 36:22[SPEAKER_00]: I was thrilled and thought I had finally found my place in Utah.
- 36:26[SPEAKER_00]: However, I had one intensely homophobic coworker.
- 36:30[SPEAKER_00]: I weren't Katie, this was going to be a problem.
- 36:33[SPEAKER_00]: On my tenth day of employment, I went into the office early and she worked in a few minutes later.
- 36:37[SPEAKER_00]: It was only the two of us in the office and she immediately started accusing me of trying to give her AIDS because I had touched one of her pencils the day before.
- 36:48[SPEAKER_00]: I was flabbergasted, but I knew I had to handle this delicate situation very carefully.
- 36:54[SPEAKER_00]: Rather quickly it escalated and she started pounding me on the chest with her fingers, accusing me of attempted murder.
- 37:02[SPEAKER_00]: I immediately put my hands behind my back to make it clear I had no intention of returning her physical aggression.
- 37:08[SPEAKER_00]: In all fairness, I did lose my temper verbally, but who wouldn't.
- 37:12[SPEAKER_00]: I tried to explain you can't get AIDS from touching a pencil.
- 37:16[SPEAKER_00]: At that time, I had zero viral load for over five years.
- 37:20[SPEAKER_00]: It was a medically proven fact that nobody could get HIV from me period, much less from touching a pencil.
- 37:27[SPEAKER_00]: She heard none of it.
- 37:29[SPEAKER_00]: She just kept hitting me in the chest and telling me I was trying to kill her.
- 37:32[SPEAKER_00]: By this time I was yelling and kept repeating, please stop hitting me, please stop hitting me, which was overheard by a coworker in another room.
- 37:41[SPEAKER_00]: In spite of the fact that the only witness had told HR, he had heard me say I was being hit by her.
- 37:48[SPEAKER_00]: What he apparently emphasized at his statement was that I yelled at her.
- 37:52[SPEAKER_00]: Once again, in that situation, who wouldn't?
- 37:55[SPEAKER_00]: I was being physically attacked by a completely irrational woman for a totally non-sensical reason.
- 38:01[SPEAKER_00]: She just kept hitting me and accusing me of attempted murder because I touched a pencil.
- 38:08[SPEAKER_00]: H.R.
- 38:09[SPEAKER_00]: never spoke with me.
- 38:10[SPEAKER_00]: My side of the story was never heard.
- 38:13[SPEAKER_00]: They hold me into the office to tell me I was being fired for aggressive behavior.
- 38:19[SPEAKER_00]: She hit me repeatedly, I said, I never touched her, not once.
- 38:24[SPEAKER_00]: The whole time she was hitting me, all I did was put my hands behind my back to prove to her, I had no intention of returning her violence, and then I begged her to stop hitting me.
- 38:33[SPEAKER_00]: I stood up and tried to demonstrate when I had done, and the two security guards grabbed me and forced me back into my seat.
- 38:40[SPEAKER_00]: According to her, I had puffed out my chest, and for that, they fired me.
- 38:46[SPEAKER_00]: The fact that she repeatedly hit me, what literally accusing me of attempted murder because I touched a pencil, was apparently not a fireable offense.
- 38:54[SPEAKER_00]: In an attempt to be fair to Katie, she and her boss both told HR that they didn't believe this young lady story.
- 39:03[SPEAKER_00]: What she claimed I did was totally out of character for me.
- 39:06[SPEAKER_00]: I pride myself in being an extremely gentle man.
- 39:10[SPEAKER_00]: They explained she had already been written up for causing exactly this kind of trouble in the past.
- 39:16[SPEAKER_00]: They suggested my story would be far more believable, but it didn't matter.
- 39:22[SPEAKER_00]: HR never made the slightest attempt to even discover if there was another side to the story.
- 39:28[SPEAKER_00]: They never spoke with me except to fire me.
- 39:32[SPEAKER_00]: They had all the information they needed, a bag with AIDS had first endangered and then yelled at a pretty straight white woman, so they fired me, and their security guards manhandled me, and that was that period, end of story.
- 39:47[SPEAKER_00]: This is possibly the best example I have, of how deeply ingrained latent homophobia is in a place like Utah.
- 39:56[SPEAKER_00]: That day, I just hit rock bottom.
- 39:59[SPEAKER_00]: It was one of the most hopelessly depressing moments of my life.
- 40:03[SPEAKER_00]: I lost all hope of ever getting a fair shot in Utah.
- 40:08[SPEAKER_00]: The inherent bigotry and blatant homophobia simply ran far too deep to ever be overcome.
- 40:16[SPEAKER_00]: Because I had quit MX and only worked for CHG for two weeks, I didn't qualify for unemployment, so I needed a job fast.
- 40:26[SPEAKER_00]: In total despair, I wrote a letter to the owner of CHG who had taken quite a sign to me, but it did no good he never responded.
- 40:35[SPEAKER_00]: However, I fear it was not my best letter, I was too outraged and depressed to be fully coherent and rational.
- 40:44[SPEAKER_00]: I'm afraid I unintentionally threw Katie under the bus by stating I had warned her this woman is going to be a problem.
- 40:51[SPEAKER_00]: It was immediately clear to me that I had no hope of ever getting my job back, so I wrote a second letter to try to repair the damage I had done to Katie.
- 41:01[SPEAKER_00]: I will always deeply regret that in my pain and outrage, I may have unintentionally hurt a lady that I so admire in a door.
- 41:10[SPEAKER_00]: Two weeks before that, another straight ally, Ralph Becker, the Utah State House Minority Leader, had offered me a job as his campaign manager for his run to be mayor of Salt Lake City.
- 41:22[SPEAKER_00]: I turned it down to take what I thought would be a more permanent position working for Katie at CHG.
- 41:28[SPEAKER_00]: I had already spent that summer campaigning for wealth.
- 41:31[SPEAKER_00]: I even marched with him in the gay pride parade with my shirt off.
- 41:34[SPEAKER_00]: With the newly acquired respect, I had slowly earned from hopefully a silent majority of the LGBTQ Plus community.
- 41:42[SPEAKER_00]: I think I helped bring a very large block of votes to Ralph.
- 41:46[SPEAKER_00]: However, by the time I lost my job at CHG, Roth had found a far more suitable young man to run his campaign.
- 41:54[SPEAKER_00]: This kid was brilliant, a political savant.
- 41:58[SPEAKER_00]: He was simply born a great political strategist, Roth very kindly offered me a job to manage his media, and of course I was subordinate to this brilliant young man who was running his campaign.
- 42:09[SPEAKER_00]: It was very kind of rough, but I instantly recognized it wasn't going to work.
- 42:14[SPEAKER_00]: This young man was convinced I was out to get his job.
- 42:17[SPEAKER_00]: He either didn't believe me or was just incapable of hearing me when I sincerely explained him that he was quite obviously a much better campaign manager than I could ever be.
- 42:29[SPEAKER_00]: Once again, I was faced with someone who was incapable of recognizing their blatant bias against me.
- 42:36[SPEAKER_00]: everything I wrote, did or said was wrong, corrected and criticized.
- 42:41[SPEAKER_00]: It was clear after a couple of days that I wasn't going to last the week with Ralph's campaign manager doing everything he could to get rid of me.
- 42:49[SPEAKER_00]: So in the last ditch attempt to save my job and prove his bias, I tried a rather unethical trick.
- 42:58[SPEAKER_00]: I wrote a press release, quoting something Ralph had said years before, and I put my name on it.
- 43:04[SPEAKER_00]: Then I wrote an additional quote, and I put Ralph's name on it.
- 43:08[SPEAKER_00]: I had nothing to lose, I knew I was going to be fired that day anyway.
- 43:12[SPEAKER_00]: I certainly had no intention of ever letting that press release be seen by anyone other than the three of us.
- 43:18[SPEAKER_00]: I just wanted to prove to this young man and to Ralph that I wasn't being given a fair shot.
- 43:23[SPEAKER_00]: Well, the young men did exactly what I knew he would.
- 43:27[SPEAKER_00]: He fell through my trap, hook, wine, and sinker.
- 43:30[SPEAKER_00]: He praised my work endlessly, thinking it was Ralphs, and totally paned Ralph's quote, thinking it was mine.
- 43:39[SPEAKER_00]: Before I had an opportunity to explain this to Ralph, this kid fired me on Ralph's behalf.
- 43:45[SPEAKER_00]: Though I repeatedly tried, Ralph has never spoken with me again, and I assume he still has no idea what really happened.
- 43:52[SPEAKER_00]: When he fired me and I started to leave, he asked, well don't you know when to know why you're being fired?
- 43:58[SPEAKER_00]: I responded, oh I already know, but you don't, and I have no desire to hear what self-deceptive lies you've come up with to tell yourself or me, and I walked out.
- 44:10[SPEAKER_00]: On my way home, after being fired by yet another friend from the Democratic Party, I thought to myself,
- 44:17[SPEAKER_00]: There is only one political ally in Utah, who has never let me down.
- 44:22[SPEAKER_00]: The only politician whose loyalty I could always count on was Gale Rizica.
- 44:30[SPEAKER_00]: How ironic and twisted is that?
- 44:33[SPEAKER_00]: Gail Risica, the despise arch enemy of the LGBTQ Plus community, was the only reliable friend I had in Utah politics.
- 44:41[SPEAKER_00]: She had always been scrupulously honest and forthright, when she opposed me she did so with integrity and without malice, when she gave me her word, I always knew I could count on her.
- 44:53[SPEAKER_00]: More than anyone else, I have Dail to think that Utah never lost funding for HIV medication
- 45:01[SPEAKER_00]: In Utah, my oldest friend betrayed me, L.D.B.T.K.
- 45:05[SPEAKER_00]: plus leadership blackballed me.
- 45:07[SPEAKER_00]: The head of the Utah AIDS Foundation would have rather seen his own clients die than see me succeed.
- 45:13[SPEAKER_00]: My family stunned me, woman society consistently haze me, even my friends in the Democratic Party, ultimately if inadvertently, slurmy under the bus.
- 45:23[SPEAKER_00]: But Gail Risica, my main political opponent, Doyle supported me to the end when no one
- 45:32[SPEAKER_00]: It was that realization that made me understand I had to leave Utah for good and as soon as possible.
- 45:40[SPEAKER_00]: Later, when I told Gail about this moment, her response was, well, endearing.
- 45:46[SPEAKER_00]: She was worried about me.
- 45:48[SPEAKER_00]: She wanted to make sure I was okay.
- 45:49[SPEAKER_00]: She even offered to let me come hide out at her place for a few days and look my wounds.
- 45:55[SPEAKER_00]: A few days later, while watching Ralph win his election on TV, I packed up my apartment and got ready to move to Niniapolis.
- 46:04[SPEAKER_00]: Ninizona had and still has, the longest running record of voting for Democrats and presidential elections.
- 46:10[SPEAKER_00]: That's why I chose it.
- 46:12[SPEAKER_00]: Maybe dear, I would finally get a fair shot.
- 46:16[SPEAKER_00]: The evening before I moved to Niniapolis, I took my dart for one last walk in her favorite place City Creek Park.
- 46:24[SPEAKER_00]: of all people.
- 46:26[SPEAKER_00]: I ran into Senator Orin Hatch, at Walking with Utah's Attorney General Mark Schertlev, who also had been a reliable ally to me.
- 46:35[SPEAKER_00]: I was a little embarrassed when Senator Hatch literally gave Mark the hand and called me over to chat.
- 46:41[SPEAKER_00]: As he put his arm over my shoulder, he said, Oh, Stuart, I'm so glad I read into you.
- 46:45[SPEAKER_00]: I've been so worried about you since our last meeting in Washington.
- 46:50[SPEAKER_00]: Um, you looked exhausted and unwell.
- 46:53[SPEAKER_00]: I was honestly afraid that maybe you had sub-responding to HIV medication, but I can see now that you look great and healthy again, I'm so relieved.
- 47:03[SPEAKER_00]: And how is your dear mother?
- 47:04[SPEAKER_00]: Please tell her high for me.
- 47:07[SPEAKER_00]: Then he congratulated me on the passage of the Ryan White Caract, his bill.
- 47:13[SPEAKER_00]: I just laughed and said, Senator, I think the phrase should be going in the other direction don't you?
- 47:17[SPEAKER_00]: It was your bill and you guys did all the work.
- 47:21[SPEAKER_00]: You saved countless lives, especially here in Utah, and I'll be forever grateful.
- 47:26[SPEAKER_00]: He laughing they responded, don't sell yourself short young men, you were brilliant.
- 47:32[SPEAKER_00]: I laughed so hard when I heard what you did to Secretary Levitt, that was a master stroke.
- 47:39[SPEAKER_00]: Your mother taught you very well.
- 47:42[SPEAKER_00]: Mike Lebett was a former governor of Utah who had been appointed as President George W. Bush's secretary of Health and Human Services.
- 47:50[SPEAKER_00]: I had basically blackmailed him into arranging a very important meeting with his under-secretary in charge of HIV and AIDS during one of the mini trips to Washington while I was lobbying for Senator Hatch's bill.
- 48:03[SPEAKER_00]: Then Senator Hatch just honestly said, yeah, Ted and I were just doing what was best for you in the country.
- 48:10[SPEAKER_00]: maybe on some level, both Senator Hatch and I sense that this would be the last time we ever saw each other.
- 48:17[SPEAKER_00]: I remember the first time I had met him when I was on the 8 or 9 years old, and I was a little embarrassed, but I started to tear up.
- 48:26[SPEAKER_00]: When he saw this, he gave me a bit of an awkward one arm hug, and I thought to myself, what a wonderful book end for my last day in Utah.
- 48:37[SPEAKER_00]: Senator Hat famously despised Donald Trump.
- 48:42[SPEAKER_00]: A few years later after Trump was elected president, I watched on TV a Senator Hat announced that a press conference that he was going to retire.
- 48:50[SPEAKER_00]: Then he explained to the press that he had to return to the Senate floor to vote his conscience and vote for transgender rights.
- 49:07[SPEAKER_00]: When I think back, on those dreadful ages, on the incalcable loss, the unimaginable grief and seemingly endless pain we all suffered and are still suffering.
- 49:19[SPEAKER_00]: I tried to live up to the words of one of my favorite writers, Dalton Trumbo.
- 49:25[SPEAKER_00]: Dalton Trumbo was a novelist and Hollywood's best-paid screenwriter.
- 49:30[SPEAKER_00]: He was also one of the famed Hollywood 10 who refused to name names when called before
- 49:38[SPEAKER_00]: Trumbo was a man who was treated as principles and willing to stand up for where he believed in no matter the consequences.
- 49:45[SPEAKER_00]: For this brave act of heroism refusing to ruin the lives of his friends, he was imprisoned and blacklisted for over 13 years.
- 49:56[SPEAKER_00]: Trumbo managed to survive and kept working in the industry he loved by writing under pseudonyms.
- 50:02[SPEAKER_00]: He won the Academy Award for Best Screenplay twice, including one of my favorite movies, Roman Holiday.
- 50:14[SPEAKER_00]: He saw his friends bankrupted, their families destroyed, their innocent children bullied and persecuted, a great many of them died in prison or from suicide.
- 50:25[SPEAKER_00]: Finally Otto Premendor and Kirk Douglas had the courage to publish his name as the writer of Exodus and Spartacus, two of the greatest movies in Hollywood history.
- 50:35[SPEAKER_00]: That signal the end of the blacklist that ravaged the lives of so many people for so long.
- 50:42[SPEAKER_00]: At an award ceremony honoring his achievements, Dalton Trumbo said, when you look back upon that dark time as I think you should every now and then, it will do you no good to search for heroes or villains.
- 50:58[SPEAKER_00]: There weren't any.
- 51:00[SPEAKER_00]: There were only victims.
- 51:02[SPEAKER_00]: Because each of us felt compelled to think or do things, we otherwise would not.
- 51:07[SPEAKER_00]: to deliver or receive wounds which we truly did not wish to exchange.
- 51:14[SPEAKER_00]: So what I say here tonight is not intended to be hurtful to anyone.
- 51:19[SPEAKER_00]: It is intended to heal the hurt, to repair the wounds, which for years have been inflicted on each other and most egregiously upon ourselves.
- 51:32[SPEAKER_00]: I strive to live up to those fine words, and I pray some of my perceived former Utah enemies will do the same.
- 51:41[SPEAKER_00]: Malcolm X's widow Betty Sabaz and Martin Luther King's widow, Coretta Scott King.
- 51:47[SPEAKER_00]: I think they understood this.
- 51:48[SPEAKER_00]: Even though their husbands may have at times appeared to oppose each other, in the long life of the civil rights struggle.
- 51:55[SPEAKER_00]: Each of these great American heroes did their part to advance that noble struggle, and both of them were essential.
- 52:03[SPEAKER_00]: In the last decades of their lives, Betty Shabbaz and Coretta Scott King worked together.
- 52:11[SPEAKER_00]: Even when it may have appeared, we in Utah's LGBTQ plus community were working against each other.
- 52:18[SPEAKER_00]: we were not.
- 52:20[SPEAKER_00]: We were all fighting homophobia, that horrible disease and American shameful response in the best way we knew how.
- 52:30[SPEAKER_00]: Even those we may have at the time perceived to be working against us, were only doing their best under monstrously difficult and heartbreaking circumstances.
- 52:48[SPEAKER_00]: very proud indeed.
- 52:54[SPEAKER_00]: My name is Stuart Merrill and I walk up this gay.