Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Threats to Legal Independence in British Columbia and House Arrest for Manslaughter
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for a regular segment Legally Speaking, joined as always by barrister and solicitor with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, michael Mulligan with Legally Speaking Morning Michael how we doing.
- 0:10Michael Mulligan: Hey, good morning.
- 0:11Michael Mulligan: I'm doing great.
- 0:12Michael Mulligan: Always good to be here.
- 0:13Adam Stirling: It was an item that you and I discussed before it received royal assent, but in the interim, the BC government has passed the Legal Professions Act using closure.
- 0:22Adam Stirling: What happens next?
- 0:25Michael Mulligan: Nothing good, good answer yes, indeed.
- 0:29Michael Mulligan: That's the short answer.
- 0:31Michael Mulligan: Here's the long one.
- 0:32Michael Mulligan: So this is the act we talked about the government trying to replace the Law Society, which is the entity that regulates lawyers in British Columbia, and ever since it's existed in British Columbia, it's done so independent of government, and, of course, as we talked about, that is incredibly important, because the work of many lawyers is to oppose what government is doing.
- 0:56Michael Mulligan: Right, lawyers, in many cases, are the individual's protection from government, and so it should be obvious why it would be unwise to have a regulatory body with authority over the people whose task it is to often oppose things the government is trying to do.
- 1:14Michael Mulligan: It should be apparent to anyone who thinks about it at all.
- 1:17Michael Mulligan: And so this particular bill Bill 21, would do exactly the opposite of what we should be doing or striving for, and it, for example, replaces the current object of the Law Society, which its number one job is this to protect the public interest in the administration of justice by preserving and protecting the rights and freedoms of all persons.
- 1:42Michael Mulligan: It's a pretty good objective, and instead this bill, this piece of legislation now, would insert current government priorities into what the regulator of lawyers is required to do.
- 1:57Michael Mulligan: And so, for example, rather than what was the goal, the goal would then be to facilitate access to legal services.
- 2:05Michael Mulligan: And then the number two goal is, for example, to implement the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People, for example, and then it goes on with other various government priorities, all of which you might or might not agree with.
- 2:17Michael Mulligan: The point is that you should not have the regulator of lawyers tasked with being required to implement the political priorities of the government of the day.
- 2:28Michael Mulligan: Even if you like that one, you may not like the next one, and the point is that lawyers shouldn't be regulated by some entity that's got as its goal achieve government political objectives, and so that's why, at the heart of it, this proposal is such a poor one.
- 2:46Michael Mulligan: And to make matters worse as this poorly conceived piece of legislation, as the debate started only very short time into it and only having gotten through a few sections of it, the government used closure, and for those not familiar with that, that means using their majority to vote to stop all debate to then pass the legislation without even debating it.
- 3:08Michael Mulligan: And so that's what happened with this just almost unbelievable exercise of authority there passing a piece of legislation which would undermine the independence of lawyers, trying to force them to do things the government wants and then refusing to even debate it, and so a genuinely undemocratic and outrageous way in which this was passed.
- 3:32Michael Mulligan: And the immediate response is probably what you would expect an announcement by the Law Society and others, including the Canadian Bar Association, trial Lawyers Association.
- 3:43Michael Mulligan: I think Lawyers Rights Watch and others are all suing now the government to challenge the constitutionality of this piece of legislation.
- 3:51Michael Mulligan: And it's easy to see why.
- 3:54Michael Mulligan: You know the Supreme Court of Canada previously has talked about the fact that you know, to the extent, if the language is true, to the extent humanly possible, so far as by human ingenuity it can be designed, the law society needs to be free from state interference in a political sense and with the delivery of services to individual citizens in the state, and so the Legal Profession Act, bill 21, is the absolute opposite of that, and we will see a legal challenge proceed unless there is some rationality comes either to the current government or a change of government.
- 4:32Michael Mulligan: Happily, both the BC Conservative Party and the BC United Party have indicated they are opposed to this, the Conservatives clearly indicating if they are elected they will repeal it.
- 4:44Michael Mulligan: So hopefully there will either be a reconsideration by government, current or a change that would result in this being repealed.
- 4:53Michael Mulligan: That would be the sensible thing to do, but otherwise we will have to wait and watch as a legal analysis of this runs out, probably for the next several years.
- 5:04Michael Mulligan: As a legal analysis of this runs out, probably for the next several years.
- 5:05Michael Mulligan: So terrible piece of legislation, undebated and will now be the subject of both political interest and legal challenges.
- 5:17Michael Mulligan: So that's what's happened with the Legal Profession Act, bill 21.
- 5:19Adam Stirling: All right, and this is a previous story up next that we've discussed previously regarding a manslaughter conviction and a university security guard.
- 5:27Adam Stirling: We now have a sentencing decision to discuss.
- 5:29Michael Mulligan: yes, Indeed, we do, and so listeners may recall this discussion from a couple of weeks ago when the judge's decision came out, and it was a security guard for a university, trinity Western University.
- 5:43Michael Mulligan: A security guard for a university, trinity Western University, who was called to deal with a report of a man who was rifling through rooms appeared to be either under the influence of drugs or alcohol.
- 5:52Michael Mulligan: Students were calling in about safety.
- 5:54Michael Mulligan: There was one security guard on duty that day.
- 5:59Michael Mulligan: He eventually found the man, or spotted the man, told him to stop the man, bolted towards some other student and the security guard wound up running over and tackling him.
- 6:13Michael Mulligan: The person who was tackled responded physically by doing things, including hitting the security guard in the head with an open and closed fist, pulling his hair, trying to headbutt him, swearing at him, trying to knee him and spitting on the security guard.
- 6:26Michael Mulligan: The security guard punched the man and then put him in a headlock, all of which so far, so good, according to the judge.
- 6:35Michael Mulligan: The judge found clearly the security guard at this point was acting out of concern for the safety of both himself and students, but the judge found that after the man stopped struggling and spitting and trying to kick and punch the security guard that it was not reasonable for the security guard to keep the man in the headlock and sadly, the man unfortunately became unconscious and by the time the police and ambulance showed up they were unable to get a pulse and the man ultimately passed away.
- 7:06Michael Mulligan: And for a manslaughter charge, which is what the man was charged with, it's not necessary that there be an intention to cause somebody's death.
- 7:15Michael Mulligan: And here the judge found clearly that there was no intention to do that.
- 7:19Michael Mulligan: But the judge did find that there was an unlawful act in the form of an assault by keeping him in a headlock too long, and so on that basis, because that was the cause of death, the man was convicted of manslaughter, and so the judge was then sentenced with well, what do you do to sentence that man and this is something that people should be aware of For murder, of course, in Canada there is only one sentence life in prison.
- 7:42Michael Mulligan: There can be different periods of parole, ineligibility, like when you could ask kindly for parole, but life in prison is the only possible sentence.
- 7:51Michael Mulligan: For manslaughter there is no mandatory minimum sentence and the maximum sentence is life in prison.
- 7:56Michael Mulligan: And the judge pointed out that manslaughter is one of the offenses for which there is a very wide range of possible sentences, based principally on the degree of moral culpability of the person that's convicted.
- 8:12Michael Mulligan: And, as the judge pointed out, there can be manslaughter which are near an accident, which would be sort of like this right there's no intention to kill this man, right.
- 8:22Michael Mulligan: Or cases which are near murders, right when maybe this wasn't quite the mental requirement for a murder, but very close to it.
- 8:30Michael Mulligan: And so the range of sentences for manslaughter ranges from life in prison to probation.
- 8:38Michael Mulligan: And so the judge was tasked with what to be done here with the security guard, and the Crown, in this case, was asking the judge to impose a five-year penitentiary sentence.
- 8:49Michael Mulligan: Well, defense counsel was asking the judge to impose either a probation, a suspended sentence or what's called a conditional sentence order, which is sometimes called house arrest.
- 8:59Michael Mulligan: Right, it's a jail sentence that somebody could serve at home, but if they breached the conditions, they would then presumptively go to jail for the rest of the sentence.
- 9:09Michael Mulligan: And in making this decision, the judge reviewed various things, starting with another concept called a victim impact statement.
- 9:16Michael Mulligan: There's statements by the family members of a deceased or the victim of a crime setting out the impact the crime had on them, and obviously this had a very serious impact on the deceased man's family.
- 9:29Michael Mulligan: Apparently he had serious mental health problems.
- 9:31Michael Mulligan: That was likely the cause of his behavior breaking into the rooms and behaving the way he was with the students.
- 9:38Michael Mulligan: But on the other hand, the judge found that the man who was convicted the security guard.
- 9:44Michael Mulligan: He had no criminal record, he was a contributing member of society, many letters of reference speaking to his character by all accounts a hardworking, supportive family man, described by people as their rock and role model, and he was also somebody who was Indigenous and had trauma as a result of some of that background it's all too common for Indigenous people and found as well that the security guard believed that he was using the headlock in a safe way, trying to make sure the man's airways remained open, but he did not know that he could cause serious harm if blood vessels were constricted.
- 10:26Michael Mulligan: So not only was the man thought he was doing what he was doing safely, but he was not at the end of the day, and so that's the fact pattern the judge had to deal with.
- 10:36Michael Mulligan: The judge also found there was no need for rehabilitation and there was no risk of this person committing further criminal activity.
- 10:43Michael Mulligan: There's just no basis to believe that of this person committing further criminal activity.
- 10:46Michael Mulligan: Right, there's just no basis to believe that.
- 10:46Michael Mulligan: And so when a judge is determining whether a conditional sentence should be imposed, a judge has to first of all determine would a sentence of two years or less than two years be appropriate?
- 10:55Michael Mulligan: Right, because you cannot have a conditional sentence that's longer than that.
- 10:59Michael Mulligan: And then, if so, the principal consideration for a judge is whether the safety of the community would be endangered if you allowed somebody to serve their sentence on house arrest rather than in a prison or penitentiary.
- 11:13Michael Mulligan: And here the judge found that indeed a sentence of less than two years was appropriate.
- 11:18Michael Mulligan: She rejected completely the Crown's suggestion that five years was necessary in jail and then, based on that background that I've just talked about, the judge found that indeed a conditional sentence would be appropriate.
- 11:32Michael Mulligan: One of the other things which I think was insightful by the judge and she's a judge who used to be Crown Counsel here in Victoria for many years one of the things she pointed out is that the family was concerned, that they thought there was a lack of remorse expressed in the court process, and the judge pointed out that, you know, the court process is not the sort of place for where reconciliation and remorse is generally a part of it.
- 11:58Michael Mulligan: It's an adversarial process but nonetheless found that this man was genuinely remorseful.
- 12:04Michael Mulligan: He apologized, he had no intention to cause this harm and he thought he was protecting people.
- 12:08Michael Mulligan: And so the judge did impose an 18-month sentence, but did so on a conditional basis so that the man will be able to serve that sentence at home.
- 12:17Michael Mulligan: So, like many of those sentences, he will have a curfew, have to be at home between midnight and 6 am, not use alcohol or other substances because it's a jail sentence not that he had any issue with those things but also imposed 120 hours of community work service and made a recommendation although this isn't, interestingly, up to a judge to decide, she was simply making a recommendation that some or all of that community work service involved educating others security guards, bouncers, police and those involved in the martial arts about the dangers of neck restraints and how they could lead to the sort of tragedy that occurred in this case, even though that wasn't what was intended.
- 12:59Michael Mulligan: So a very interesting case, both in terms of the outcome finding that there was an assault despite what this man was doing, and how quickly something can turn into a death and result in a manslaughter conviction, and also an interesting case because it demonstrates just how much judgment there can be for a judge to make in terms of well, what do you do about that at the end of the day and here the outcome will be rather than five years in the penitentiary that the judge found would serve no purpose, the man will at least be able to serve the sentence at home and hopefully do some useful work educating others about the danger of these kinds of neck restraints, so that there isn't future tragedy.
- 13:41Michael Mulligan: So that's the case of the security guard and the manslaughter conviction.
- 13:45Adam Stirling: Michael Balligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 13:47Adam Stirling: Legally Speaking will continue right after this.
- 13:49Adam Stirling: All right, legally Speaking continues on CPAC's 1070 with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers Up.
- 13:55Adam Stirling: Next it says when residential tenancy claims can go directly to the Supreme Court, bypassing the residential tenancy branch process I didn't even know they could do that or bypassing the residential tenancy branch process.
- 14:07Michael Mulligan: I didn't even know they could do that.
- 14:07Michael Mulligan: Indeed, it wouldn't have come up a lot in the past.
- 14:09Michael Mulligan: But as a result of both, a inflation and, b the very substantially increased penalty awards under the residential tenancy legislation, that may become more common.
- 14:24Michael Mulligan: And the reason for that is a constitutional one.
- 14:28Michael Mulligan: We have superior court judges in Canada are appointed by the federal government under Section 96 of the Constitution Act for those keeping score at home, and that the Constitution provides special protection for superior court judges.
- 14:49Michael Mulligan: Like they can't be removed except by way of a joint resolution of the Senate and House of Commons.
- 14:53Michael Mulligan: It's sort of a very high degree of autonomy and protection they have, as it should be right.
- 14:59Michael Mulligan: You don't want judges getting fired or demoted for making decisions you don't like.
- 15:04Michael Mulligan: That's all part of the importance of the independence not only of the legal profession but the judiciary.
- 15:09Michael Mulligan: And so, in order to make that meaningful, if provinces or the government could just create other courts or tribunals that didn't have any of those protections at all and then just shuffle all of the responsibility of superior court judges to that inferior tribunal, that independence and protection would be meaningless, right, because those people could be fired or eliminated or punished or whatever for their decisions, and so that's not allowed.
- 15:39Michael Mulligan: And one of the implications of that is that and this also explains why provinces have limits on the small claims jurisdiction of provincial court judges right, provincial court judges are appointed by the provincial government and they don't have well, they do have some constitutional protection, not the same degree of protection as a Section 96 court, superior court judge, and as a consequence of that, for example, provincial Court small claims only has a jurisdiction up to $35,000 in British Columbia, and it would be constitutionally impermissible if the province just said, well, we'll just make the financial authority of a provincially appointed judge unlimited and they can just do everything a Superior Court judge would do, because then you would have people making those decisions that would not be potentially as independent as Section 96 provides for.
- 16:32Michael Mulligan: That's the history of it.
- 16:33Michael Mulligan: Now that has implication not just for things like small claims jurisdiction, it also has implications for things like the jurisdiction of the residential tenancy branch, and the residential tenancy branch only has jurisdiction to deal with disputes where the amount of money involved is a maximum of $35,000, the same as the provincial court jurisdiction.
- 16:55Michael Mulligan: And that is so for exactly the same constitutional reason.
- 17:00Michael Mulligan: Now, in the past that wouldn't have come up a lot, because usually the amount of money involved in a residential tenancy dispute would be less than $35,000.
- 17:11Michael Mulligan: So you could have a residential tenancy process which is designed to be kind of simplified and theoretically faster although apparently that's not been achieved all the time which we have Now.
- 17:24Michael Mulligan: If you have a claim that's for more than $35,000, that's not allowed.
- 17:29Michael Mulligan: You have to go to the BC Supreme Court, and so the case I'm going to talk about is a case involving a particular type of a particular claim by a certain individual, which wouldn't be the most common.
- 17:43Michael Mulligan: But what I just talked about will be an issue.
- 17:45Michael Mulligan: For example, the province has sort of added I call them sort of punitive provisions to try to prevent tenancies from being ended.
- 17:54Michael Mulligan: For example, if a landlord wants to move into a property, they have to move into it and live there, for I think it's going to be a year.
- 18:02Michael Mulligan: If they don't do so, the tenant can go get an award, potentially for 12 months rent.
- 18:08Michael Mulligan: Now think about that.
- 18:09Michael Mulligan: Let's say you rented a single family home and the rent was $3,000 a month.
- 18:14Michael Mulligan: Okay, landlord gives you notice they want to move into it.
- 18:17Michael Mulligan: And let's say the landlord's alleged to have moved out after 11 months.
- 18:20Michael Mulligan: Well, the tenant might be able to get themselves 12 months rent, and guess what?
- 18:24Michael Mulligan: That's over $35,000.
- 18:26Michael Mulligan: So no jurisdiction for the residential tenancy branch.
- 18:29Michael Mulligan: You've got to go off to Supreme Court.
- 18:31Michael Mulligan: That wouldn't have come up a lot in the past, but now it will.
- 18:36Michael Mulligan: This particular case was an interesting one.
- 18:37Michael Mulligan: This was a case involving a claim made by a longtime resident of DC housing, and he was making a claim that his right to quiet enjoyment of his apartment presumably a subsidized accommodation under BC Housing was interfered with by a variety of things.
- 18:59Michael Mulligan: He is alleging traffic, noise, heat, other tenants smoking, and he alleged that a BC Housing employee entered his unit in 2023 and broke a curtain he was using to keep the heat out, and so he was suing, and he was suing for large amounts of damages.
- 19:21Michael Mulligan: He was suing, claiming that he was entitled to $5 million for breach of his quiet enjoyment and $8 million for mental and physical injury.
- 19:32Michael Mulligan: Now the judge, hearing this thing, thought well, there's no likelihood that he's going to get that, those amounts of money, right, but the only thing the issue here was could he get more than $35,000?
- 19:43Michael Mulligan: The only thing the issue here was could he get more than $35,000?
- 19:47Michael Mulligan: And, as the judge pointed out, the man agreed that he was going to amend his claim.
- 19:53Michael Mulligan: He self-represented, to put it in the correct legal language, alleging trespass and defamation and negligence and harassment by BC Housing, and the judge concluded well, it wasn't plain and obvious that those claims wouldn't succeed.
- 20:10Michael Mulligan: Nor was it plain and obvious that the man couldn't get more than $35,000 if he managed to prove those things.
- 20:15Michael Mulligan: And so the result was, despite an application by BC Housing to try to get this claim dismissed on the basis of, hey, this can't succeed or shouldn't this be back as a residential tenancy matter?
- 20:27Michael Mulligan: The judge analyzed those jurisdictional limits which we just talked about and found that no, indeed, this man is claiming more than $35,000.
- 20:37Michael Mulligan: And while he might not get $8 million, he might get more than $35,000 if he proves the things that he's claiming.
- 20:43Michael Mulligan: And so, directly to BCC Supreme Court.
- 20:46Michael Mulligan: And while that might seem like a bit of an outlier, for the reasons we've talked about, it's not going to be in all sorts of other circumstances.
- 20:58Michael Mulligan: I mean, what's the average rent for even a two-bedroom apartment, let alone the average rent for a freestanding single-family home that is going to be, I would imagine.
- 21:09Michael Mulligan: I haven't looked at the market lately it's close to $3,000.
- 21:12Adam Stirling: Yeah.
- 21:14Michael Mulligan: And as soon as you hit that $3,000 figure and you multiply it by the 12-month sort of penalty provision if somebody were to terminate a tenancy and then not live there for 12 months all of those are going to skip right past the residential tenancy branch and go straight into Supreme Court, which has a bunch of knock-on effects.
- 21:34Michael Mulligan: But there's much more procedure to succeed in that.
- 21:39Michael Mulligan: You're much more likely to need a lawyer to help you with that, like in the case we just talked about this man who didn.
- 21:45Michael Mulligan: You know he didn't know what paperwork to use and you know he should have used a petition rather than a notice of claim, and you know the judge was trying to help him out.
- 21:53Michael Mulligan: Okay, you got to go to this different paperwork and file that and change the wording you're using.
- 21:57Michael Mulligan: It's not a self-serve system like small claims court or the residential tenancy branch which is designed to be.
- 22:03Michael Mulligan: You know, download a form, fill the thing in, pass it over, right?
- 22:06Michael Mulligan: It's much more process intensive because you could be dealing with millions of dollars or whatever in Supreme Court.
- 22:12Michael Mulligan: And so it's just one more thing we need to think about when you hear about those proposals Again, whether you think they're good or bad or fair or not or what the big you know the policy implications are.
- 22:24Michael Mulligan: The government has now got themselves to a point, thanks to inflation and big penalties, where things are going to be moving into Supreme Court and the provincial government won't have any authority to stop that.
- 22:35Michael Mulligan: So that's why residential Kempsey cases may be going upstairs to the PC Supreme Court.
- 22:40Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 22:45Adam Stirling: Thank you as always.
- 22:46Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 22:47Adam Stirling: Have a great day.
- 22:48Adam Stirling: All right, you too.
- 22:49Adam Stirling: Quick break.
- 22:49Adam Stirling: The news is next.