Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 144 - Leon Wankum: The Real Estate Reckoning
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities podcast. My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast
- 0:17of the Free Cities Foundation.
- 0:30Hello and welcome to this episode number 144 of the Free Cities podcast.
- 0:36Brought to you as always by Veritas Villages.
- 0:40Veritas Villages are off-grid, energy-self-sufficient, luxury communities in Latin America
- 0:45designed especially for freedom lovers just like you.
- 0:50Bitcoin is accepted at all villages, including for the purchase of property.
- 0:56But you already know that, don't you?
- 0:58Because I say that every week.
- 0:59you probably know where to find more info as well www.ecovillages.life forward slash free cities
- 1:07patrick hebert the creator of veritas villages will be speaking this year at the wonderful free
- 1:15cities conference yes only about two months away now for our conference and to be honest
- 1:22how can i put this if you are listening to this podcast which you obviously are
- 1:28and you're someone who's mobile, then according to me at least, you owe it to yourself to come
- 1:34to this conference. It is the year's best gathering of Free Cities people. If you're involved
- 1:42in the scene or just curious or if you're pitching an idea, whatever, you should come
- 1:49to Prague for this. This is the meat space epicenter for all this stuff that we talk about
- 1:56on the pod and the great news is that in my experience at least the community is still small
- 2:03enough that you can mix with everyone at the conference you can talk to whoever you want
- 2:09i've never had anyone that didn't have the time of day to speak and you get to interact with the
- 2:15people who are actually working on all these projects i'll be there of course i look forward
- 2:22to this one every year not least because it's the time that I get to see all the great friends
- 2:27and colleagues that I have acquired so fortunately since becoming involved in this movement and of
- 2:34course I normally record 21 interviews in seven days three a day for seven days it's amazing
- 2:42my brain is exploding by the end of it obviously and in the event the hope and the positivity
- 2:49is palpable see you there anyway there's a web address if you want tickets freecitiesconference.com
- 2:56or one word freecitiesconference.com right today's guest leon vancom is a veteran real estate
- 3:05developer who has somewhat seen the light on property and the state of the world in particular
- 3:13its financial system and he's very candid with his beliefs about the future of the real estate
- 3:20markets. Now I know many of you own real estate. If you own property or your business is in property
- 3:30I would say that this could be an important episode for you to ponder over. Here's what AI
- 3:38I made of it. Leon shares his journey from growing up in his family's real estate and construction
- 3:44business to discovering Austrian economics and Bitcoin, framing his disillusionment with property
- 3:51management and the distortions caused by monetary expansion. He critiques the widespread belief that
- 3:59real estate is a safe investment, arguing that its monetary premium is misplaced in a digital economy.
- 4:06he warns that a shift towards utility-based pricing threatens the global financial system
- 4:13and insists property developers must adapt now he outlines how the real estate industry will be
- 4:21turned into a service-oriented industry while enabling innovations like bitcoin-based reserves
- 4:28and proof-of-work architecture i'm a big fan of that the conversation concludes with optimism
- 4:35about Bitcoin's role in strengthening resilience, transforming property markets,
- 4:40and even enabling competitive governance models through free cities. And Leon's a veteran of the
- 4:51property business. So he's someone to listen to. I certainly did. Coincidentally, he also studied
- 4:58and still studies, sometimes Austrian economics, under Rahim Tarzadegan, who was the former CEO
- 5:06of the Free Cities Foundation before Peter Young joined. I only actually discovered that when
- 5:12he arrived at the studio. Anyway, he's got a phenomenal take on the property industry and
- 5:20one that should be listened to as far as I'm concerned. Quick addendum to the conversation,
- 5:25something i need to clarify i was slightly wrong in our discussion it's not actually the law
- 5:31in japan that houses must be rebuilt every 30 years but it kind of looks that way because of
- 5:38how the system works so i was wrong about the law but i was right about the way it plays out
- 5:43basically for tax and mortgage purposes japanese homes especially the wooden ones are assumed
- 5:50to lose almost all their value in about 30 years after which the land still has value but the
- 5:56building is considered worthless now the reasons are strict building codes earthquake safety energy
- 6:05efficiency etc buyers prefer new builds rather than refitting old ones and social preference to
- 6:13newness is valued more highly than preservation the result is as i said many houses are demolished
- 6:21and rebuilt after 20 to 30 years even if structurally sound so it's not mandated by law
- 6:27but it's driven by tax policy market preference and safety codes there you go look into that one
- 6:34if you want to know more right thanks to all our wonderful subscribers and please if you are a value
- 6:41for value listener you can pledge just six bucks a month for the subscriber benefits that we offer
- 6:49speaking of which a new bonus episode will be out next week so look out for that one and many thanks
- 6:56to everyone that supports this show i fully appreciate you right time to challenge your
- 7:03attitude towards your property portfolio or lack of in my case make sure you're comfortable this
- 7:11one might sting a little but as always just sit back relax and enjoy my conversation with
- 7:18Leon Vancombe
- 7:21and it turns out you you actually studied under Raheem is that right yes right that's that's
- 7:32an incredible start because he used to be the CEO of the Free Cities Foundation. You know that,
- 7:39don't you? Wow. So did he introduce you to any of that stuff or was it more Austrian economics?
- 7:46Because that's what he's originally best known for, right?
- 7:48Both. So I learned about Rahim through a friend and then I started studying with him at the point,
- 7:55which is I think a year and a half ago or so. So I've been studying with him for a year and a half.
- 8:00I've already been familiar with the concept of free cities but obviously through his teaching
- 8:07I've been able to grasp the concept of of freedom generally speaking also also the Austrian school
- 8:12of thought and the effect that the Bitcoin will most likely have on the way that we we live and
- 8:20and build and work so that helped me okay right this is this is good it's probably the best thing
- 8:26might be then to just set the scene a little bit with who you are and what what i know you through
- 8:31the bitcoin scene because you've been talking a lot about real estate and bitcoin you're a real
- 8:36estate guy yes yes right through and through like maybe you could introduce yourself then for
- 8:40everyone else yeah sure sure sure so i got introduced into real estate because that's
- 8:45the family business so i grew up on construction sites we've been in the business of of construction
- 8:50and then with 19 I went to the UK and I studied philosophy and business management
- 8:56and that's where I learned about Austrian economics, the Austrian school of thought
- 9:01and Bitcoin as well.
- 9:02In London?
- 9:03In Bau.
- 9:05It's not a hotbed of Austrian economics.
- 9:08I'm always surprised when anyone learns about Austrian economics at university or college
- 9:12because...
- 9:13Yeah, it wasn't at university, sorry.
- 9:14It was while being at university.
- 9:16So you met someone cool who said hey look have you heard about this And you like wow yeah mind blown right okay reddit oh reddit yeah yeah they were not even in person oh shoot well it is and it
- 9:29very rare like often sometimes you hear of people that grew up in eastern europe sometimes you hear
- 9:34that they knew about austrian economics but it's one of those things that's um it's like hidden
- 9:40from people almost really yeah so you were lucky then but that well it was reddit reddit was the
- 9:46reason but yeah the internet to be honest with you i'm very thankful for the internet for sure i
- 9:51learned about bitcoin because people were using it it was a topic at university at the time i mean
- 9:56also wikileaks was a big topic at the time so people were talking about it not just at university
- 10:01but also in the media and i just tried to pay attention to what's going on around me and i
- 10:07picked up on bitcoin and at the same time i picked on up on ludwig von mises and then i just started
- 10:13going down the rabbit hole.
- 10:15And what about the property side of your life then?
- 10:19You're still a property developer?
- 10:22I mean by trade, yes.
- 10:25Right now, if you'd ask me what do I do day to day, Bitcoin has become, I think, 50% of
- 10:32my focus.
- 10:33I'm still active in property development and once you start the development, as you know,
- 10:38it takes a lot of time.
- 10:40So some of the developments have been ongoing for three to five years.
- 10:44And sometimes it can take up to 10 years to complete a project from the idea to fully letting it out and then potentially also selling it.
- 10:52We usually manage the property.
- 10:53So I'm also in property management, which is a headache and which makes me appreciate Bitcoin even more.
- 10:59Because on a day-to-day basis, I am very much aware of what you have to deal with, with being in property development and property management.
- 11:07and the negative effects of the monetary expansion on the property sector is it's wild i mean you're
- 11:15you're very aware of it i know and it's not just a tenant that's negatively affected it's also the
- 11:21property developer well let's let's go there then let's give i know that property is one of those
- 11:28investments that people really trust. At a certain age, let's say, probably around my age especially,
- 11:39still to date, if you asked one of my friends, the non-Bitcoiners, if you asked one of them,
- 11:45you've just inherited some money from somebody, what do you do with it? They were like, I'll buy
- 11:49a property. For me, that's complete nonsense. I wouldn't. You're a property developer,
- 11:56a that's that's a separate thing but for me i would never do that now not not not understanding
- 12:03that you could park it in bitcoin very simply and easily with a good rate of return i suppose you
- 12:10would call it a rate of return but also with no hassle and that's one of the things i see about
- 12:17property that i'll tell you an interesting story this is a slightly different angle on this whole
- 12:21thing but i've um i don't i only own one property which is our our house and i've done the classic
- 12:28thing of i bought i borrowed money once after the first time i never borrowed again i managed to pay
- 12:35off my mortgage and then we renovated properties it got bigger and bigger and bigger and we've ended
- 12:40up now we two years ago we bought what i considered to be the last one you know but it does need
- 12:47doing up but an interesting things happen to me um since i've been in this house for the first time
- 12:54i've started noticing it's a liability not to me and and i'm not saying necessarily from a financial
- 13:02standpoint i think about some kind of uh wealth tax that might appear soon are they going to wealth
- 13:11tax my property? Am I going to suddenly have to start paying a few 10,000 pounds to the government
- 13:17each year because the value of my property is going up even though I'm living in it? Something
- 13:21like that. And I've noticed I've changed. My mindset has changed. I no longer trust property.
- 13:29And obviously there's a much better place for me to part my capital. If I did, it would be Bitcoin,
- 13:35for example. But it's a slightly different take on yours, I think. I think yours is more,
- 13:39you're not you're not worried when you when you analyze the property market and
- 13:44and compare it to bitcoin you're not thinking about the state
- 13:47taxing properties are you're more thinking about just the simple fact
- 13:51that if you look on paper um putting your money into bitcoin is just a
- 13:57better bet than buying a property is that right
- 14:00no i mean i share the same thought process i think the same i mean i go
- 14:03through the same thoughts i've i mean i'll go to various stages
- 14:06But I have the same line of thinking.
- 14:08So I don't believe that putting money into real estate is a good investment.
- 14:12I do not think that there's any societal benefit of us investing into property.
- 14:19And that's something I did not understand 10 years ago, of course.
- 14:2210 years ago, being in my early 20s, I was just aware of the fact that real estate is a way to hedge against inflation.
- 14:31and I was of the opinion that inflation is the natural state of the economy, right?
- 14:40But learning about Bitcoin, experiencing Bitcoin, holding Bitcoin over time,
- 14:47learning about the Austrian School of Economics,
- 14:49I started to understand what land really is valued on, which is the utility value.
- 14:57There's a difference, of course, when we talk about land,
- 15:00because there's agricultural capacity, so farmland, and then there's property.
- 15:05And property serves both as shelter, as a place of, you know, you can use it to produce,
- 15:13you can use it as an event space, for concerts or whatever,
- 15:17but there's very little use for real estate as money.
- 15:22So the monetary premium that sits in real estate is completely senseless.
- 15:26And if you would take a bird's eye view and you would look at the world and the stage we are in, we are a species that is living in a digital economy, but we have a physical good that's used as a monetary substitute by default, not by design.
- 15:44and that creates a lot of problems.
- 15:46So our line of thinking is very, very similar.
- 15:49But what I'm sharing mostly with the public is,
- 15:52number one, it's my thought process
- 15:54because I think it can help other property developers
- 15:56understand why Bitcoin is the better store of value.
- 16:00And then I also think that,
- 16:01let's assume 100 years from now,
- 16:05the monetary premium that sits in real estate
- 16:07has flown into Bitcoin.
- 16:09There are two questions that arise.
- 16:12How are we going to manage that change?
- 16:14because I do not think the state should be in charge of providing living spaces.
- 16:22I think that should be done from the private sector.
- 16:25So incorporating Bitcoin into property development, property management,
- 16:29knowing that it is a superior store value,
- 16:33I think gives the ability to continuously be productive
- 16:37and produce adequate living spaces
- 16:42and also provide businesses with office spaces, so to say.
- 16:45So that's kind of how I'm thinking about it.
- 16:48And then secondly, sorry, just the last thought is,
- 16:52if that happens, what is going to happen afterwards?
- 16:56Let's say real estate is based and priced on its utility value
- 17:00on a Bitcoin standard.
- 17:03How do you then deal with property?
- 17:05That's just like an interesting thought to have, right?
- 17:08Yeah, that was just about to ask you, actually.
- 17:10But before I do, I just recount another experience of mine, because I know people who still remember the time when property was utility value.
- 17:21I'll give you an example.
- 17:22I bought an old derelict farm in the middle of Wales once, many years ago, and I paid £70,000 for it.
- 17:33And the local farmers were laughing at me because a few years before it was worth £3,000 because it was the value of the acre of land.
- 17:42It came with a number of acres, but I could have bought that house for the price of the land.
- 17:48The house had absolutely no value.
- 17:52I think now it's probably worth about £750,000.
- 17:56So from £3,000 to £750,000 is ridiculous.
- 18:01I don't own it anymore.
- 18:02I sold it many years ago.
- 18:04I think it more than trebled in price after I sold it.
- 18:07And I didn't do anything to it.
- 18:08I didn't even do it up.
- 18:09It was still derelict.
- 18:10I never got around to fixing it up.
- 18:13But that's a really astonishingly ridiculous increase in value, $3,000 to $750.
- 18:20Almost like Bitcoin.
- 18:22Well, yeah, of course.
- 18:23So my question anyway about if this is true, and I think it is, that the price of real estate
- 18:33that we see around us is because people are using it as money when people stop using it as money so if the thesis plays out which I think it already is and will continue which is people are realizing okay using houses as money is a bad idea because here is real digital money that I can use and it much better for storing my value
- 18:57What happens to property developers?
- 18:59What happens to the state of the market?
- 19:01Obviously, everything would trend back to utility value.
- 19:05But what about people like yourself?
- 19:07Would people pursue property developments anymore if it didn't make them enough money?
- 19:14I mean, I hope not.
- 19:16Because to be very honest with you, at the moment, the market is oversaturated.
- 19:21And to be very honest with you, it's not just...
- 19:26I'll explain my line of thinking in a second, but I just want to also raise the point that real estate as a monetary substitute, it's not just a store of value.
- 19:36people also use it as collateral, right?
- 19:38People lend against their real estate.
- 19:40This is true for households, wealthy individuals,
- 19:43even nation states, insurance companies, and so forth.
- 19:45So the existing system has no interest
- 19:48in real estate being priced on its utility value
- 19:52because that would mean that the bedrock
- 19:55of the global financial system,
- 19:56because next to the 10-year US treasury
- 19:58and other treasuries,
- 20:00real estate really is the bedrock
- 20:01of the global financial system.
- 20:03If it would go down in value,
- 20:04the system would collapse. So I think that what we're talking about is going to happen in parallel.
- 20:11So the rise of Bitcoin is going to happen in parallel with chaos in the existing system,
- 20:16right? This makes Bitcoin thrive. Bitcoin was built for chaos. Real estate was not.
- 20:21So I can't really say what is going to happen in real estate. But if you are in property
- 20:25development and you do not understand what is happening, you're going out of business.
- 20:28that's that's that's what it is it's the same uh as operating a retail store let's say on a
- 20:35on a london high street in the 90s not being aware of the internet or operating shopping centers not
- 20:42being aware of e-commerce right we're living in a digitalized world and people want to store their
- 20:47their productivity digitally and not in a house and you and that's a good thing because at the
- 20:53moment, yes, working in property development means you are benefiting from what we just described.
- 21:00But if you really think about humanity as a whole, there's nothing positive in houses going up in
- 21:06value constantly because it increases the cost of living. That's just if we talk about the
- 21:11socio-economical effects of what we are talking about, right? But also from a business aspect,
- 21:16If you ask me as a Bitcoiner, as an investor as well, Bitcoin is saving, real estate is investing.
- 21:27And now that Bitcoin exists, you don't need to invest anymore.
- 21:30You can just save in Bitcoin.
- 21:32But if you do want to invest for whatever reason, you need to do it based on using Bitcoin as a unit of account.
- 21:39because if you work in property development and your property rises in nominal value,
- 21:44meaning it rises in the value that the fiat currency that you operate in, it's based on.
- 21:52So let's say you work in the UK and you own land or you own a property and over time it goes up in pound.
- 21:58You live in Germany, the property you own over time goes up in euro with monetary debasement, right?
- 22:03It's not actually the property goes up in value, it's that the currency it is measured in is being debased.
- 22:09But once you switch your line of thinking, you understand that Bitcoin is not just relatively scarce, it's absolutely scarce and relatively scarce because the demand for Bitcoin exists because it's near perfect money.
- 22:21You do understand that you need to expose yourself to Bitcoin if you want to be a successful investor.
- 22:26If you do not engage with Bitcoin as an entrepreneur, you're almost failing, in my opinion.
- 22:30What about people that do offer a legitimate service in property development?
- 22:40You know, I'm thinking people that do, let's say, take an old building, renovate it, turn it into something that's usable again.
- 22:47This is a good thing.
- 22:48Yeah, it's a great service.
- 22:49Same with, you could say, commercial real estate in many senses.
- 22:54I know the price of commercial real estate is all over.
- 22:58Well, I had a conversation with someone recently about what was happening to commercial real estate in the US.
- 23:05It's ridiculous.
- 23:06He said exactly the same thing as you.
- 23:07He said, no one's going to let it crash.
- 23:09Because when it crashes, that's the end of this paradigm as we know it.
- 23:14But what happens to those people that do want to renovate property?
- 23:19If they're not making as good a return as parking their money in Bitcoin, would they still choose to do the renovation?
- 23:27do you think i suppose because they're they're imagining they're going to be generating income
- 23:31continuously i mean would you as a property developer would will you carry on in the future
- 23:37yes and no so you i obviously understand that it's better if you own real estate in germany
- 23:45holding it for 10 years means you can sell it tax-free if you live in a property you can sell
- 23:50it tax-free after two years and if you don't live in a property but you operate it as a as a manager
- 23:56or as a developer, you can sell the property tax-free after 10 years.
- 24:00So if you have a portfolio, there's two options for you now.
- 24:05First option is you sell the properties after 10 years.
- 24:09You put the money into Bitcoin because holding Bitcoin after 12 months
- 24:14also then becomes tax-free in Germany.
- 24:17So if you hold Bitcoin after 12 months, you do want to sell it,
- 24:20it would be tax-free, right?
- 24:23So you could sell the properties that you own for over 10 years, buy Bitcoin, wait 12
- 24:28months, you'll never have to pay taxes, you don't even feed the bees.
- 24:33The second option is, and that's what some companies are doing now, if you want to stay
- 24:36active in real estate development because you like it, because you think you have a competitive
- 24:40edge or knowledge that allows you to outperform other market actors, you could obviously group
- 24:46the properties that you own, take the company public, that's what MetaPlanet has done in
- 24:51Japan become a so-called Bitcoin Treasury company, right?
- 24:55But my root, because I come from, let's say, my roots are within the cypherpunk ethos,
- 25:03I do very much find interest in what the Bitcoin Treasury companies are doing.
- 25:08I recently wrote a long report on MetaPlanet.
- 25:10I also wrote a long report on strategy, because what they're doing is they're leveraging their
- 25:15balance sheet.
- 25:16That is the play that I personally know being a real estate developer.
- 25:20insurance companies and real estate developers are actually leveraging their balance sheet.
- 25:25That's what they're doing. So that's the same thing that strategy is doing now and meta planet
- 25:29is doing. But saying you want to take a private road, right? Let's say you want to stay true to
- 25:34the cypherpunk ethos because you choose to. You can just sell off the properties, buy Bitcoin with
- 25:39it. And if you do want to stay in real estate development and the real estate business,
- 25:45offer a service to the market.
- 25:48You can consult people.
- 25:51And if you are good at constructing buildings
- 25:53and somebody gives you capital,
- 25:55you could become the partner
- 25:57that brings in zero money.
- 26:00But maybe you have contacts to a bank.
- 26:02You organize the loan.
- 26:05You have a capital partner
- 26:06that provides the equity.
- 26:08And then you start with the project.
- 26:10So now you're being paid for your knowledge.
- 26:12You're being paid for your service.
- 26:13and I think that structure overall is the structure that I could very much also imagine on a Bitcoin
- 26:19standard because what is a Bitcoin standard right it means different things for different people
- 26:24today there are people that don't use the internet there are people that don't use mobile phones
- 26:29so we can assume that also in the future people maybe some people won't use Bitcoin so not
- 26:36everybody will use Bitcoin but Bitcoin will be I think what treasuries and real estate are today
- 26:43the bedrock of the global financial system, collateral people lend against,
- 26:48and potentially it's used as currency itself, or there are other currencies and other types of money,
- 26:55e-cash tokens, for example, like Cashew or Feddy that are being issued with Bitcoin as the base, right?
- 27:02And then society operates on that.
- 27:05And real estate then becomes a service because the service that you provide to the market is housing,
- 27:11shelter or a place to produce a place to think a place to record a podcast things like that
- 27:17so the service of uh of providing uh housing to the market i think that's what ludwig von mises
- 27:25called originary interest as an entrepreneur you take risk you build something then you rent it out
- 27:33and the surplus that's the originary interest that's what you receive for for doing that right
- 27:38That would be the same on a Bitcoin standard.
- 27:41But the business model of buying as much real estate as you can,
- 27:45leveraging that with a low interest,
- 27:47because that also is dependent on the interest rate.
- 27:49With interest rates above 3%,
- 27:51the real estate business model that existed since 2008 fails.
- 27:57Is that right?
- 27:58Yeah.
- 27:58Above 3%?
- 27:59Yes.
- 27:59So at the moment both in the States and in Europe And these are the dominant markets I mean China is different because China and Japan have been operating under 1 interest rates for a long time
- 28:15The Japanese central bank raised interest rates now.
- 28:18But in China and Japan, the housing market has been inflated to levels that we haven't seen in Europe yet.
- 28:27The Japanese housing market was inflated in the 80s to an extent it was not able to recover.
- 28:32till today and the Chinese real estate market is going through a similar phase
- 28:37right now because they have been pushing interest rates down whereas in Europe
- 28:43and in the US even though historically speaking interest rates as you know are
- 28:47actually still very low because historically interest rates around 10 to
- 28:5015 percent were actually the average so right now we have interest rates for
- 28:55construction loans sitting between three to five percent and that margin does not
- 29:01allowed to make money because the think about it like that if you build a
- 29:05property let's say you have a 5% yield on an annual basis but the cost of
- 29:12capital is also 5% what's the point of doing it right so it needs to be
- 29:17worthwhile taken on that and then building a property because if I take on
- 29:25money for 5% so the cost of capital is 5% I build a property and it has a 5%
- 29:31Now excluding leverage, right?
- 29:33We can also talk about the leverage effect, but there's no money to be made.
- 29:36Whereas Strategy, for example, or MetaPlanet, they are also operating on a balance sheet,
- 29:42right?
- 29:43But they can take money for 10% interest and buy Bitcoin, which grows in purchasing power
- 29:50on average 50% a year.
- 29:52So that arbitrage effect is huge, it's 40%.
- 29:56But in the real estate market, if interest rates don't go below 3% and you make, let's
- 30:03say, 3% annualized in growth, there's no arbitrage to be made.
- 30:10You could argue though that the Bitcoin arbitrage that MetaPlanet are doing, for example,
- 30:17won't last.
- 30:18And that's a huge amount at the moment.
- 30:20But I would say that's because we're at a certain point in the adoption curve of Bitcoin
- 30:25that means that you can do that.
- 30:27Yeah, yeah, so so.
- 30:28I don't know what it'll settle out at eventually.
- 30:31It might be interesting to see
- 30:33because it would hopefully be the free market rate.
- 30:37One would expect it
- 30:39because Bitcoin really is a free market at the moment.
- 30:41Yeah, yeah.
- 30:42And it would be a good,
- 30:43we'll be able to use it as a lesson
- 30:46for what really happens
- 30:48when a large group of people all decide
- 30:51on how much it should cost to borrow money
- 30:53or how much they should get to lend it.
- 30:56But I've never heard that before.
- 30:58So the play you're talking about is,
- 31:01what about when people use their property as collateral
- 31:07to then buy more property?
- 31:08Is that 3% borrowing rates?
- 31:13That applies there as well.
- 31:14Yeah, it would still count
- 31:15because what MetaPlanet and Strategy are doing right now,
- 31:19that's what real estate investors have been doing since 1971.
- 31:22won. And the positive effect of these companies doing it on Bitcoin is you can think of it whatever
- 31:30you want. You can think it's gambling. You can think it's degenerate, but it doesn't drive up
- 31:34the cost of housing. That's good, right? So Bitcoin is the most speculative asset. It's
- 31:38more speculative than the housing market, but that's fine because there's no negative effects
- 31:43on the housing market. For example, because people can save and speculate on Bitcoin. They
- 31:47don't have to invest into housing to outperform inflation no negative secondary order effects for
- 31:52the housing market but this can go on i think the treasury play if it's done well i mean can go on
- 31:59for the next 50 to 60 years if the if the collateral basis managed properly but then the question is
- 32:05what does this mean for housing what does this mean for property development because it's in my
- 32:10blood it's in my soul i grew up on construction site so yes the asset class has gone through a
- 32:15process of financialization and right now we're seeing it being drained of its monetary premium
- 32:22right and actually it's happening in real time and the bitcoin treasury companies are actually
- 32:26accelerating it because people now can think okay right so for the past 15 years people had the
- 32:33option to invest into bitcoin instead of putting their money into real estate but some people do
- 32:38not understand that an asset that does not generate cash flow by itself will outperform
- 32:46an investment they can make that has cash flow because people have been drilled into thinking
- 32:51they need to outperform the rate of monetary inflation by with cash flow. But if there's an
- 32:55asset class like Bitcoin where the rate of inflation is decreasing over time, it's inflationary,
- 33:00you don't have to generate cash flow, you just have to hodl it because the money that's being
- 33:06produced in the fiat system and the productivity of humanity will cause it to go up in value more
- 33:11than any cash flow based business can generate cash flow right but people want cash flow it's
- 33:16just a line of thinking so now you have these companies that provide cash flow which is
- 33:21apparently a good thing for people that have a fiat type of of mindset so i've talked with many
- 33:29of my friends that work in real estate and they did not buy bitcoin but now they are they want to
- 33:35buy MicroStrategy stock, they're buying MetaPlanet stock, they're buying their fixed income products.
- 33:41And I'm thinking to myself, guys, are you crazy? I've been telling you for Bitcoin for 10 years.
- 33:45But I came to understand this, that it very much is an arbitrage because there's an information
- 33:51asymmetry existing between you and me and the rest of the world. And the rest of the world is
- 33:56willing to receive 10% distribution on a year-by-year basis and giving their money to someone
- 34:03who can buy an asset that appreciates in value 50% of time.
- 34:06It's crazy, right?
- 34:07But that's the way it is.
- 34:09And then, so this also means that the demonetization of real estate and land, that includes farmland,
- 34:16is happening right now with these treasury companies absorbing the speculative, I think,
- 34:26capital that would otherwise be directed towards fixed income, yes, but also real estate.
- 34:32because a large portion of the capital that's being allocated to real estate is being allocated
- 34:38to real estate to generate cash flow.
- 34:40I'd say maybe from my personal experience, maybe 20, 30 percent, even more of the people
- 34:45that I talk to that buy real estate, they do it to generate cash flow.
- 34:50And now they can do it without that.
- 34:52And all of these things have positive effects on the housing market because it eases the
- 34:57pressure, less people have to invest into real estate, but it increases the pressure
- 35:01if you work in property development.
- 35:04And if you don't want to take your company public,
- 35:06if you don't want to become a Bitcoin treasury company,
- 35:08if you don't want to sell all the assets off that you hold,
- 35:11you need to incorporate Bitcoin.
- 35:13And that's what I'm sharing right now with a lot of people
- 35:15because for me, it's very easy to say,
- 35:17sell the property by Bitcoin.
- 35:18If you'll ask me, I happily own Bitcoin, nothing else, right?
- 35:23But I have to deal with other people
- 35:26that I run a business with.
- 35:28And I'm also aware of the fact that other people
- 35:31understand things at different times whenever they need to understand it, right?
- 35:36So it's a process.
- 35:38And Bitcoin can be integrated into real estate gradually over time
- 35:42in order to help everybody that is involved in the capital structure
- 35:47that is real estate, from the bank to the tenant to the landlord
- 35:49to the capital partner to understand what is happening and benefit from it.
- 35:55Isn't it true, though, that people who want to buy a treasury,
- 36:00like MicroStrategy for example, they're paying for the peace of mind. They're paying 30% for the peace of mind or 20 whatever, it is about 30%. What's the return on Bitcoin currently? You're saying they're getting a 10% return from MicroStrategy and MicroStrategy are making 40%.
- 36:22So yeah, they're paying a very large premium for the peace of mind of not understanding Bitcoin, really.
- 36:30Like you say, it's an asymmetry of understanding.
- 36:33That's worth, that asymmetry is worth, it just shows how much it's worth.
- 36:38It just shows that you should go out and learn about Bitcoin.
- 36:40Really, you should.
- 36:42It's worth a huge amount of money for you, even if you're in a financial brain and you're used to investing and parking your money here and making it work for you.
- 36:51You really do need to study it because it's worth a lot of money to you.
- 36:55It is worth a lot of money.
- 36:57And the opportunity cost is increasing over time because Bitcoin kind of changed the time value of money.
- 37:03And I'll tell you what I mean by that.
- 37:04Because I'm very well aware of the negative effects of leverage in real estate.
- 37:07I've seen projects go bust.
- 37:09I've seen companies go from zero to 100 back to zero in a very short time frame, right?
- 37:15And so in the fiat world, money loses value over time.
- 37:23There's a negative time value of money.
- 37:26With Bitcoin, it's the opposite.
- 37:27There's a positive time value of money because over time,
- 37:30time Bitcoin increases in purchasing power.
- 37:33And once you understand that money has a lot of functions and people talk about money being
- 37:39a medium of exchange and a store of value in a unit of account a lot.
- 37:43But I think it's also important to understand that money is collateral and it always has
- 37:48been.
- 37:48So let's say we're living on a gold standard 1871 in Germany, let's say.
- 37:56Prussia just won the war against France.
- 37:58Bismarck unified the Holy German Empire
- 38:02he created a central bank
- 38:03highly centralized Prussian government
- 38:06but they did have a gold standard at the time
- 38:09and
- 38:10so even at that time
- 38:14if you would own gold
- 38:16and you're a young family father
- 38:19you want to start a business
- 38:20you wouldn't spend all your savings
- 38:22because the savings that you have
- 38:23also guarantee that you can deal with
- 38:26the uncertainty of the future
- 38:27you can take care of your children and so forth so you would most likely go to an investor
- 38:32you'll ask for money and for that money maybe he receives equity in your business right so the
- 38:39dynamic of using money as collateral is a dynamic that exists always on a fiat standard and on a
- 38:46bitcoin standard on a fiat standard though the money that you receive loses value over time so
- 38:53there's an urge to consistently outperform the rate of monetary inflation. Whereas on a Bitcoin
- 38:58standard, if you start a business and then with the money that you receive, let's assume you buy
- 39:04Bitcoin immediately, you start the business, you, I must take out a random number here, $10,000,
- 39:11right? So you have $10,000, you start a business and you immediately buy Bitcoin worth $2,000 in
- 39:17your business. So in theory, you could do nothing for five years. And just because Bitcoin year on
- 39:23year grows in purchasing power, you would already outperform all your competition. And then you
- 39:29could start thinking properly and strategize of how to run your business. And that's why Bitcoin
- 39:35as collateral, Bitcoin as capital, Bitcoin as an anchor in a business, generally speaking,
- 39:41is how you should, in my opinion, run any business.
- 39:46And the Bitcoin treasury companies now just arbitrage the information asymmetry
- 39:50because they're publicly listed, but also on a personal level
- 39:54and in the private sector, any business should operate like that.
- 39:59So when I'm saying like that, I'm not saying any business should take on excessive leverage.
- 40:03I'm saying any business should anchor its decision-making around Bitcoin.
- 40:09I think detractors would say that's all very well, but on year two, you may be in the red.
- 40:16Yeah, sure.
- 40:16Year three, maybe year five, sure.
- 40:19And it's difficult to make business decisions if you're a forced seller of Bitcoin at a loss, say, for example.
- 40:28But why would you need to sell?
- 40:29That's why I'm saying don't over excessively engage in leverage.
- 40:33Don't put all your money to Bitcoin.
- 40:35Just anchor your doing.
- 40:37whatever you do anchored in Bitcoin in a way where you never have to sell the Bitcoin that you anchor your idea in.
- 40:45And then you provide a service at the same time.
- 40:47So with real estate, that's how-
- 40:49I see what you mean.
- 40:49I see what you mean.
- 40:50It's like literally buying an apartment block or something.
- 40:52It would be the equivalent.
- 40:54Not for $2,000, obviously.
- 40:56But if you scaled it up, it would be like buying an apartment block and then continuously using it as collateral.
- 41:03You can use it as collateral.
- 41:04You don't even need to.
- 41:05You can just have it in the back of your mind that I'm not stressed.
- 41:08I don't need to do anything.
- 41:09I could just do nothing and sit here and I'd still outperform my competition.
- 41:13With that 20% though?
- 41:15Yeah, with that 20% on average.
- 41:16But then now the next question comes, how do you generate income?
- 41:20So you offer a service to the market.
- 41:21So we are still productive individuals.
- 41:23We're still productive members of society.
- 41:25I'm not saying just buy Bitcoin and sit on it.
- 41:28But if you'll ask me how should a real estate company operate
- 41:32or how should anybody operate that wants to an entrepreneur that has an idea within the real
- 41:38estate sector now that bitcoin exists and you need to start by buying bitcoin like don't start by
- 41:44doing your project and then thinking in the future you'll buy bitcoin that's like the the wrong type
- 41:49of thinking because bitcoin changed the time value of money you have to accept it you have to buy
- 41:54bitcoin first and then act don't act and then i buy bitcoin that that's how you how you acted in
- 42:00the fiat world but in bitcoin you'll you act the other way something that's just occurred to me
- 42:05as you were saying that i'm thinking about how real estate not even commercial real estate
- 42:11private real estate people will add value in the future and i'm thinking about architecture and the
- 42:19the way houses are built the the the quality of the house is that is that what's going to happen
- 42:27Are we going to trend back to a time where, because if you look at houses now, they're not only too expensive, but they're also very inferior quality, I think.
- 42:37Certainly houses that you see getting built, you know, where I live, they go up in a month.
- 42:44It's amazing.
- 42:44And the walls are often just like they've made a paper.
- 42:48They're literally, you know, my house was built in originally in 15 something, where I live now.
- 42:55And the walls are solid stone.
- 42:57Well, there's a little gap in the middle, but they're at least a meter thick.
- 43:01Yeah.
- 43:01You know, and back then also, that house wasn't an expensive house.
- 43:06It was a rural farmhouse.
- 43:08It was probably one of the cheaper houses, which is something else I find very strange about the housing market now.
- 43:15You see this in London.
- 43:16People buy houses.
- 43:19Rich people buy houses that poor people used to live in for exorbitant amounts of money.
- 43:24It's a bizarre concept. You know, a three bedroom terraced house would have been sort of nice, you know, wouldn't be an expensive house. It would be and they are one and a half million in certain parts of London, two million more for these really, you know, bizarre, bizarre things.
- 43:43But are you saying then that that's going to be one of the ways in the future, if people follow this trajectory and the system goes the way we think it's going, is that how you add value?
- 43:55You have to increase the quality of what you're building.
- 43:59So you're competing against badly built houses, essentially.
- 44:03Yes, exactly.
- 44:03Now you almost compete on interest rates.
- 44:06It's like if I can get a cheaper loan, I'll make more money.
- 44:11or if I save money on construction, I make more profit.
- 44:14So people almost compete on providing the worst service possible
- 44:19with the cheapest money they can find.
- 44:22It's actually very perverse if you do think about it.
- 44:25And maybe we can say the following.
- 44:27Real estate investing doesn't make sense anymore.
- 44:29Real estate development, though, is a business line.
- 44:31It will always make sense.
- 44:33And then you have to just adopt to the circumstances,
- 44:35integrate Bitcoin, anchor your business around Bitcoin,
- 44:39I use Bitcoin to build maintenance reserves, use Bitcoin mining to save costs on heating.
- 44:45So not just the capital structure real estate.
- 44:48When I talk about capital structure, I maybe explain what I mean and then I go into architecture
- 44:53because that's something that interests me a lot as well.
- 44:55And it kind of frustrates me at the same time.
- 44:59When I say real estate is a capital structure, I say, of course, real estate should be priced
- 45:05on its utility value, but it's been priced away from its utility value.
- 45:08Now it's a capital structure with different players like the developer, potentially an investor, the bank that gives the loan, the architect and the tenant.
- 45:19And everybody is worse off on a fiat standard over time.
- 45:23Everybody, even the developers, worse off over time because eventually the system collapses.
- 45:27And what's the point in building a system that will eventually collapse?
- 45:31There's no point, right?
- 45:31So within that capital structure, the architect, I think, and also from my personal experience, loses out the most next to the tenant.
- 45:42The tenant loses out because as the landlord with inflation, meaning the maintenance costs go up, construction costs go up, you have to raise rents.
- 45:52It's a very, I'd say, negative dynamic, but that's the way it goes because you have to look at profits.
- 45:59And then the architect has no time.
- 46:01I'm sometimes sitting in meetings.
- 46:04I'm not taking part in S meetings as I used to because I'm really focused right now on the Bitcoin strategies within our existing business, also on restructuring the business and making Bitcoin a focus.
- 46:16So I'm spending a lot of my time at home in front of my computer as we do.
- 46:20But I used to attend a lot of construction meetings.
- 46:24And you have phase one to four, which is planning, and then you have phase four to nine.
- 46:29within a construction phase and 4 to 9 is the building phase.
- 46:33If you are an architect that's in charge of the construction phase,
- 46:37I feel very sorry for you because I've never seen
- 46:40that architects were able to really bring their vision into reality.
- 46:45Because after year 2 or 3 of the construction process every meeting is about saving cost Because after three years usually because of a shortage and a certain commodity because of a geopolitical
- 46:58conflict or because of monetary debasement, construction costs have gone up and whatever
- 47:03was planned two or three years ago is not possible anymore.
- 47:06So maybe the architect wanted to build beautiful doors.
- 47:11He's like, no, we need simple doors.
- 47:13It's too expensive.
- 47:14Maybe the architect wanted to incorporate certain elements in the windows.
- 47:17Now we need to take these elements off.
- 47:19It's too expensive.
- 47:20That's literally the dynamic on the construction side between the investor and the architect.
- 47:24And they start to fight always.
- 47:26The investor and the architect, from my personal experience, being in real estate for almost 30 years, they always fight.
- 47:33They always end up fighting.
- 47:35And it doesn't need to be like that.
- 47:36It doesn't need to be like that.
- 47:38Because if we would live in the natural state of the market, like Jeff Booth so well explains,
- 47:44things over time would fall to the marginal cost of production because we are becoming better at producing things.
- 47:52And we are also, due to the technological process, actually we experience deflation.
- 47:58The problem is our monetary system is inflationary.
- 48:01So if we would live on a Bitcoin standard or if we would live in a world where money would be scarce,
- 48:06it would actually become cheaper to maintain buildings over time. And you would benefit
- 48:11largely from building maintenance reserves in Bitcoin. So the rental income would allow you
- 48:18to accumulate Bitcoin. That would allow you to then grow your business by just hoarding Bitcoin,
- 48:24and you wouldn't have to raise rents as well. So when this would go down over time, it would become
- 48:28cheaper to maintain buildings. And the whole dynamic in the real estate market will be flipped
- 48:32on his head and buildings will become more beautiful buildings will become a beautiful
- 48:37sorry exactly i took a photo yesterday i i you know i i like the architecture around here it's
- 48:46not too bad i've got to show you this because it's just ridiculous i walked down the street here
- 48:50there's a there's a supermarket down there and i was walking down there and there was a corner
- 48:55that was empty and they they were you know they were going to build something there so there was
- 48:59a placard there with what they're going to do and it just i just looked at it and i thought jesus
- 49:06christ look at this yeah exactly i mean look what the hell is that i mean this is the state of fear
- 49:16this is the state of the world i don't know whether i'll put i'll pop it on the thing but
- 49:21it's basically here's this corner and you think great they're going to develop it yeah and they're
- 49:26putting what looks like i don't know what it even looks like a box it looks like a cheap knockoff
- 49:32bauhaus yeah with windows like that many windows down the middle it's just so ridiculous number
- 49:41one that people even think like that i i don't mind people having strange ideas about architecture
- 49:46that's their prerogative right but that is a sociopathic building that building makes you feel
- 49:52bad feelings no i don't know who looks at that compared to looking at if you go in you know even
- 50:00this building here from the outside it's pretty beautiful and you look at it and you you see this
- 50:05avenue of of beautiful buildings and all right they're they're pretty derelict this is a
- 50:11former sort of communist air you know place so a lot of it's in bad repair but it will get better
- 50:17I used to live in Berlin, you know, in Potsdamburg.
- 50:21When I first went there, some of the buildings were still covered in bullet holes.
- 50:25Now it's like walking down the poshest streets in Germany.
- 50:30It's beautiful, you know.
- 50:32But the fact that that kind of building gets built is all down to everything you're talking about,
- 50:40which is build it as cheaply as you can with as little interest.
- 50:45because I think what was fall and foul of the fiat system is beauty. Very much so. Beauty costs,
- 50:53we know that. There's a cost to beauty. And in buildings, it's considered an excessive cost
- 50:59over utility, right? But I don't see that at all. I've renovated houses. I've built a house
- 51:06in my own house, the past one. And building a beautiful house was an important utility to me.
- 51:14It actually gives me utility. I used to come home to my own house and go, nice one, good. And for years and years and years, I got that same feeling until I sold it to someone else. And then I was happy for them.
- 51:26you know so but but the average sort of the way the system works now utility the beauty is not
- 51:34included as a utility in any shape or form and that style of that kind of brutalist minimalist
- 51:42anti beauty style is just used because it fits into the system quite well it's cheap basically
- 51:51And I hate that. I really dislike that. I think a lot of people, a lot of architects, have been convinced that it's a good thing. You know, the kind of the post-modernist idea that let's reject everything after the war. We should reject everything. All ideas, all beauty, all everything. And people go, yeah, cool, man, let's do that.
- 52:12and then you end up with like ridiculous looking buildings but people are still looking at them
- 52:19as things of beauty and i will never i will never see that building as a thing of beauty i see it as a
- 52:26as a an infringement on on on on you know you walk past this thing and you're like jesus what
- 52:34the hell is that and why is it doing that to me it feels it feels alienated right yeah i do think
- 52:41that and a friend of mine, Kelly Lane, and who also talks about Bitcoin urbanism a lot.
- 52:47So he talks about how cities will maybe change because right now cities are mostly car centric.
- 52:52They should be pedestrian centric.
- 52:54And that also has to do with the age of standardization, I think.
- 52:58And if we look at the 1920s in Vienna, when, you know, Eugen Böhm von Barmwerk and Friedrich
- 53:06von Wieser, Karl Menger, and then Ludwig von Mises and all the other Austrian economists
- 53:11were strolling around Vienna, sitting in cafes.
- 53:14There was an architect also called Alfred Loos.
- 53:17And he came up with the idea of, you know, modernity has to do with standardizing everything
- 53:22and take everything away from the past.
- 53:26And you had art deco, art niveau before.
- 53:28So you had a development.
- 53:29So architecture was going through this development in the early 1900s of going through a standard
- 53:34of standardization.
- 53:35and similar to money and to production facilities.
- 53:39And I think people underestimate the effect the war had on architects.
- 53:44And some of the architecture that we are talking about right now,
- 53:47I think it feels so alienated because the people back then felt alienated
- 53:51due to the war, the First World War and the Second World War as well.
- 53:57So I can definitely say that some of the early Bauhaus architecture
- 54:01has something to it that, like you said, I can enjoy because it's interesting and you see somebody
- 54:08deeply thought about whatever they were doing. But it has reached a point where standardizing
- 54:15architecture, standardizing money, standardizing this has taken away the soul from buildings.
- 54:20And it's been a process that has been working and moving in parallel with the fiat system.
- 54:28and at this point it's being sold as culture because the state has a monopoly on culture
- 54:35and if you look at also most of the totalitarian authoritarian socialist dictatorships the
- 54:43intellectuals were mostly working with the state they were actually not working against the state
- 54:49so there is an intellectual class today that would argue against what you just said and they
- 54:56would argue why this building for example carries beauty and beauty is subjective as well but we do
- 55:03understand that there are some things that when you show them to children 90 of the children say
- 55:09that's beautiful 90 of the children say that's not beautiful so there is some some some objectivism
- 55:16in form and the human experience and i think why we like this building is because it's built with
- 55:22clay with wood and there are round forms this is more like nature whereas the building that you
- 55:28showed me maybe you show a picture so people see it's literally straight lines and there are no
- 55:34straight lines in nature so if you build with like something with straight lines and if also people
- 55:39spend too much time inside and don't absorb sunlight they'll get depressed over time and so
- 55:46So socialist architecture is also, by the way, a way to capture people's minds.
- 55:52If you force people to stay indoors all the time and they are not exposed to sunlight,
- 56:00it also has a negative effect on their conscious and spiritual development.
- 56:04So architecture, money, spirituality, all these things, they are also intertwined.
- 56:10I agree with you on that socialist kind of The socialist world was anti in many ways certainly in its latter stages
- 56:20And as a reflection of seeing the individual as a cog in a mechanism.
- 56:26It's the same thing.
- 56:28I'm slightly different to you.
- 56:30I think what gives architecture value is actually a proof of work, just like with Bitcoin.
- 56:34so i would value a hand created facade like walk around prague and you look at the buildings you're
- 56:44like oh my god in fact there's a building just there outside of here with intricate wooden
- 56:49carvings all over the building i mean it's totally unnecessary if you're a utilitarian it's really
- 56:56really and it's not even this isn't a posh building in any shape or form this is a sort of
- 57:01simple building but it's covered in this stuff and for me i look at that and i think yeah that's
- 57:06worth something because of the proof of work the building that i showed you earlier is the proof of
- 57:12work is is trending to nothing it's a computer and in fact it will absolutely trend to nothing
- 57:19in the end because a robot will build that kind of building and the robot won't cost much the robot
- 57:25will build other robots that won't cost much and the raw material will be the main cost of it
- 57:31I mean, on the other hand, though, they will also, those same robots will probably create beautiful facades as well, if you require them, at also a very small cost, really.
- 57:43So, I mean, I'm hopeful for the future.
- 57:45I think everyone, what I don't like about the intellectual class that enjoys brutalist architecture or whatever, that's not even brutalist, that's just, I don't know what you call that, utilitarian architecture or something.
- 57:59Yeah.
- 57:59is they always say, look, everyone in the past, during this period, people said the same thing
- 58:08about buildings. The most modern buildings, a lot of people think are uglier because they're used to
- 58:14the previous iteration of architecture. Except when I look back at the past, I think I like every
- 58:22single other type of architecture, everything. And if you go back far enough, think about
- 58:28period properties in London, for example, which have pillars. Pillars were in Greece
- 58:36a very long time ago, and they looked beautiful then. They looked beautiful in the 1800s as well.
- 58:43So I think this whole period we're going through is an absolute blip in the history of humans.
- 58:54We've rejected beauty in so many ways.
- 58:59And I think fiat is rejecting beauty.
- 59:01Fiat is rejecting value.
- 59:04It's taking away value from things.
- 59:07And meaning.
- 59:08Yes, which is the same thing as what beautiful buildings are.
- 59:12There's value and meaning in them, which it's hard to put a price on.
- 59:17I mean, you can see it in the real estate market, certainly in the UK,
- 59:20because an old building sells for more than a new building.
- 59:23I don't know whether that's the same in Germany.
- 59:25It depends how old.
- 59:26It depends how old.
- 59:27So if it's a real old building, there might be a premium on it.
- 59:32But if it's something built in the 60s or 70s…
- 59:34Sorry, I meant old as in European old, not US old.
- 59:39No, anything with what we call period features.
- 59:43Like from the Victorian age.
- 59:44Or even 1920s.
- 59:47Arts and crafts, we call those kind of buildings you get in London
- 59:52are at an absolute premium.
- 59:54Do you know what arts and crafts?
- 59:55Yes.
- 59:561930s looking buildings, whatever.
- 59:59What distinguishes them in my mind
- 1:00:01is that they were built well.
- 1:00:03You know, the walls were thick
- 1:00:05and made with, you know, bricks.
- 1:00:07They were built to last.
- 1:00:08Exactly.
- 1:00:09But that wasn't even probably...
- 1:00:12The thought that a building wasn't built to last
- 1:00:14probably didn't even exist, did it?
- 1:00:16I mean, who thought that I should build a building
- 1:00:19with the idea that in 30 years
- 1:00:21I'll tear it down and build another one. Actually, they do in Japan, right?
- 1:00:24I was just thinking that.
- 1:00:25But that's very specific.
- 1:00:27That's very specific.
- 1:00:28Maybe you could explain it.
- 1:00:29Yeah, I mean, I can try to explain it. But I also want to say one thing that's important.
- 1:00:35Back then, they had slaves. Let's talk about the Greeks, for example, right?
- 1:00:41Culture, generally speaking, develops in times of high leisure. So when we are stressed,
- 1:00:47we don't have time to think about poetry, maths, art. So you can generally say that societies like
- 1:00:53the Sumerians, the Greeks, societies that came up with things that we still value today, they had a
- 1:01:00lot of time. Back in the day, people were also making use of slaves. I just have to say that
- 1:01:06because it's true. But today we have a technology where we can actually build cheap due to the 3D
- 1:01:14printing and we have a disinflationary money like Bitcoin.
- 1:01:17So labor over time can become cheaper, not because we force people to work for nothing,
- 1:01:25but because we have a money that grows in value and we have technology that we can use
- 1:01:31to construct and we need less human labor.
- 1:01:34But I have to say that it's an important point that sometimes people don't mention that also
- 1:01:38So labor was so cheap back in the day because people were sometimes forced to do things, right?
- 1:01:44But just before you go on, but even in the 1960s and 70s, though, labor was much cheaper.
- 1:01:51Yes, yes, yes, yes, for sure.
- 1:01:53But what's that then?
- 1:01:54Why is labor, like the price of a builder now has trended up to, you know, like I've talked about this before on this pod.
- 1:02:04If you look back to the past, what you would have called white collar and blue collar jobs, you know, blue collar jobs, as in the kind of working with your hands, building this plumber, you know, electrician, they were quite, the wages weren't great.
- 1:02:23But white collar jobs were.
- 1:02:26Now, as a blue collar worker, if you're working on an app, if you talk about working for a wage, you can command a very good premium on your hands that you didn't used to before.
- 1:02:36If you compare it to your contemporaries who work in something else that isn't working with your hands.
- 1:02:45So why has that happened?
- 1:02:46I think we value human labor again because there's so much automation that human labor becomes valuable again.
- 1:02:51If I understand your question correctly, that's how I think about it.
- 1:02:56Yeah.
- 1:02:57I would quite happily use a robot to build my house.
- 1:03:01You would, but it's not possible yet.
- 1:03:02It doesn't exist.
- 1:03:03It's not possible yet.
- 1:03:04So maybe in 20 years' time, that's the status quo.
- 1:03:08But due to regulation in Europe, it will take a long time.
- 1:03:11So there's already self-driving cars in some states in the US,
- 1:03:16but it will take time for that to happen in Europe due to regulation.
- 1:03:18But if you think about it, this is almost certainly going to happen. This gives me hope. The cost of chipping a stone facade by hand is quite a lot. The cost of an AI robot doing it will trend to almost nothing. So why wouldn't we have beautiful looking buildings in the future?
- 1:03:39I think I would agree with you. If we'll take a step back, like things can seem quite challenging because they are because the existing systems are failing. And the elites that are in power are trying to cling on to existing power structures. Of course, that's always what happened. That's been happening for five to six thousand years. But the difference now is number one, Bitcoin, number two, technological progress.
- 1:04:04and I agree with you
- 1:04:06this conversation so far has been
- 1:04:08I think a lot about criticizing
- 1:04:10the state of the world
- 1:04:12which is important in order to understand
- 1:04:14what problems we have and what the solution will be
- 1:04:16which is Bitcoin but once you understand
- 1:04:19there's Bitcoin, there's 3D
- 1:04:21printing, robotics, AI
- 1:04:23things will
- 1:04:24get better from here
- 1:04:27so I generally am very
- 1:04:29optimistic about the future
- 1:04:30and that's also why I think if you work
- 1:04:33in real estate
- 1:04:33development. If you work in real estate investment, put your money into Bitcoin.
- 1:04:40But if you work in real estate development, maybe take the pressure off a little bit.
- 1:04:47Try to give yourself a bit more time. Don't grow by growing your business. Grow your business,
- 1:04:53growing your Bitcoin stack. I think that's important. And you don't have to leverage
- 1:04:59every property that you own, you even can take out leverage, selling some of the properties,
- 1:05:05putting some of that money into Bitcoin, because Bitcoin will outperform any dollar or any euro
- 1:05:11or pound invested into real estate, including leverage, over five years.
- 1:05:18Currently.
- 1:05:19Currently.
- 1:05:19And I think for the next decade, for sure, that because if you think about the
- 1:05:23the compound annual growth rate of Bitcoin,
- 1:05:27it's around 70% for the past four years.
- 1:05:30If you asked me two years ago it was 50 Now it 70 If we take the last four years I thought it was going down over time i thought it was trending down it is going down over time it used to be 250 percent
- 1:05:42but you but i'm saying it's still around 50 to 70 percent depending on the year we're talking about
- 1:05:47so if we talk about so today it's uh right and we talk about uh december or november october
- 1:05:58of 2025 and you'll go back four years,
- 1:06:03you'll have a different pricing
- 1:06:05than if you take December, October, November,
- 1:06:07September of 2024
- 1:06:08because there's different phases in Bitcoin.
- 1:06:11But obviously right now looking back
- 1:06:13is a good time
- 1:06:14because we've just come from a bear mark.
- 1:06:16I'm very much aware of that,
- 1:06:18but we could even say
- 1:06:18if it comes down to 20, 30%.
- 1:06:20Let's say the compound annual growth rate
- 1:06:22of Bitcoin comes down to 20, 30%.
- 1:06:24That's a modest compound annual growth rate
- 1:06:26giving what it has done over the past decade that will still outperform the money you put into real
- 1:06:34estate including leverage including the tax advantages so just i think that that fact by
- 1:06:41itself also helps to just because i don't know how you feel about it i'd like to know actually
- 1:06:46how you feel about it also with the free cities movement the regulation right now makes it very
- 1:06:51very difficult to really put concepts into reality and real estate, right? How do you feel about it?
- 1:06:58Oh, yeah, 100%. I mean, I spoke last year to Patrick Schumacher. He works for Zaha Hadid
- 1:07:05Architects. He's their chief architect. And pretty much they work out in the Middle East now,
- 1:07:11for all intents and purposes. He said it can take... In the time that you could build design,
- 1:07:18get it passed and build a building in London you could have built a whole city out in the Middle
- 1:07:24East literally and for a fraction of the cost because that the amount of money you now have to
- 1:07:30park for legislation and lawyers fees and passing all the rules is astonishing it's something like
- 1:07:4040% or something you probably know this better than me but the amount of money that you have to
- 1:07:44basically spend, before you've even started constructing your house, just to pass all
- 1:07:48the rules and regulations is astronomical. Well, that puts a lot of people off. But then
- 1:07:55the actual regulations themselves, and some of them are completely idiotic, you can't
- 1:08:00service a whole country with one rule about the size, you know, like, I don't know, in
- 1:08:07In England, it's like windows have to be XYZ to do with climate change.
- 1:08:14Windows have to be a certain size now.
- 1:08:17Or even they have to be smaller, I think, because they let too much heat out if they're too big.
- 1:08:24Or ridiculous things like this.
- 1:08:26This happens a lot where I live.
- 1:08:29Because all the houses where I live, they're all old, very old.
- 1:08:31I live in an old valley full of ancient farms, basically.
- 1:08:35and um one of my neighbors decided she wanted to extend her house but it's it's um because they're
- 1:08:43so old a lot of the houses are protected so you can do things to them but you have to go through
- 1:08:49a lot of regulation to do so and um in the end this is just how ridiculous it is in order to
- 1:08:56build an extension on her house which basically looks like a almost looks like a small castle
- 1:09:02It's beautiful. It's like the only thing that they could agree upon was a glass cube attached to the side of the house because the regulations said that any new construction had to, because it was such a beautiful building, had to be in isolation.
- 1:09:20It had to exist separate to the building so that you knew it was an addition.
- 1:09:26Imagine that, a glass cube on the side of a beautiful old house.
- 1:09:30People do it. People do it all around the country now because there is ridiculous planning rules say you can't fake a 15th century facade. That's not cool. No, no, no. You have to create something that is distinctly different from the thing so that everyone knows it's not the real building. I mean, how ridiculous. And you've got to pay someone a lot of money for the privilege of that.
- 1:09:55you know really and i've had this in building my own houses i i i previously i renovated house and
- 1:10:03i built a sort of office next to it and out in the countryside and stupid things like you have
- 1:10:10to get so many things side are signed off by building regulations you must know this you've
- 1:10:14hundreds of hours talking to these guys and if you accidentally lose a piece of paper or
- 1:10:20you can't prove that this has been signed off oh god help you yeah they'll literally say take it
- 1:10:26down and do it again almost like oh no you have to you have to really take care of of being in line
- 1:10:31with with the regulators well check this one out so for example i was told to put up a banister on
- 1:10:38a staircase because but then i could just take it straight down again so i could take it away but
- 1:10:43when they did the thing i should put this banister up because i didn't you know um i was told that
- 1:10:48my electricity needed my electricity wires needed to be checked because i'd forgotten and i said
- 1:10:55don't worry the electrician's here at the moment and he said oh no no we have to commission our own
- 1:11:00electrician sorry it's it's it's rules and he commissioned the same guy for about five times
- 1:11:07the price you know it was just like every time i had dealings with the people i was just enraged
- 1:11:13and now we have a rule in this was in wales at the time i was living just over the border in wales
- 1:11:19if you build a building now you have to put a sprinkler system in it you know like uh you know
- 1:11:24just to stop a fire any any building any new build any anything like imagine putting a sprinkler
- 1:11:32system in your house i mean number one how many houses burned down like not many right not many
- 1:11:37if you think about it but but how many people are going to accidentally trigger that that system
- 1:11:43now that every single new house has to have a complete sprinkler system in it
- 1:11:47to rain water down if there's a naked flame there.
- 1:11:52It's going to cause so much damage because people are accidentally going to do it.
- 1:11:57It might not even save any lives.
- 1:12:01I think if you also, what you've been telling me,
- 1:12:06if you do work in real estate, I think it really helps to understand
- 1:12:09most of the issues that we have in the existing monetary, financial, and political system.
- 1:12:15Because everything that you've been describing actually shows that it's a politically protected
- 1:12:22asset class because of its use as collateral in an inflationary system.
- 1:12:28And people can exert their power and their will onto it.
- 1:12:31and whether it's about the climate, immigration, monetary policy,
- 1:12:38all of these different aspects somehow intertwine with the real estate.
- 1:12:43That's why I think it's such an interesting asset class to talk about,
- 1:12:46to also understand the way that our monetary system works
- 1:12:49and also the way our political system works.
- 1:12:51I think that's quite interesting.
- 1:12:52Do you think that's by design?
- 1:12:56Is that an age-old thing?
- 1:12:58like can you go back deep into history and realize that real estate was at the heart of a lot of this
- 1:13:05stuff or not i mean in a way yes if you think about it the senators in rome had to own land
- 1:13:10so if and also in in greece most of the citizens i think people please check this i think owned land
- 1:13:17i don't know but i know in rome for sure if you were a senator you had to own land and the more
- 1:13:23land you own the more agricultural capacity the the welfare you wear so land and political power
- 1:13:29was always tied to each other but that is actually now dwindling because now you can own bitcoin so
- 1:13:35you don't need to own land to um and and also what we understand as power is changing so
- 1:13:45what power is for me is the ability to live a self-sovereign life and in case i need to change
- 1:13:52jurisdiction i can do that without being maybe negatively affected by a totalitarian government
- 1:14:00that's power i don't want to exert power over other people i just want to be able to live my
- 1:14:06life as i want to which bitcoin allows me to do because land and real estate always means you also
- 1:14:11need to somehow get involved into the political process because it's a political politicized
- 1:14:16asset class and i think this is something that has been the case for thousands of years also
- 1:14:20So in Japan, the shugunat system was based on people owning land.
- 1:14:26And also, you could go through different, also in the Inca Empire, as far as I know,
- 1:14:33it was also political power was also tied to owning land.
- 1:14:36So owning land itself, due to the ability of land to generate income, has been tied to politics.
- 1:14:42But what is an abnormality is that land by itself has become a commodity,
- 1:14:48not because of the soil that maybe is able to produce,
- 1:14:52but because it is scarce
- 1:14:55and we live in an inflationary fiat-based system.
- 1:14:58And that is...
- 1:15:00is a historical abnormality.
- 1:15:01So what we've seen since 1971,
- 1:15:04where real estate has become this monetary substitute,
- 1:15:07that is definitely historical abnormality.
- 1:15:10And I looked into, as we Bitcoiners like to do,
- 1:15:15obviously I'm very much interested in Rome.
- 1:15:17I also had Latin in school.
- 1:15:18So I've always been interested in Latin,
- 1:15:20in Latin, the language, and also in Roman culture.
- 1:15:23And then also, you know, that until 1871,
- 1:15:26Germany was called Holy Roman Empire of German Nations.
- 1:15:30So there's a direct lineage between Rome, Karl the Great and then Germany and then also Prussia.
- 1:15:37So that part of history has always really interested me.
- 1:15:40And the Romans used a currency called the Aureus, which was a gold-backed currency.
- 1:15:45And towards the 2nd and 3rd century Antedius, so in the year 200 to 300,
- 1:15:52they started to merge other metals into the currency like silver and copper and so forth.
- 1:15:57they were basically debasing the currency and as a result of that land rose in value.
- 1:16:03So that dynamic of land going up in value as currency debasement occurs has been happening
- 1:16:08also for thousands of years but we reached a tipping point where it hasn't come down
- 1:16:12back to its utility value and there's something called maybe you are aware of it.
- 1:16:17A friend of mine last year actually here at the Honey Badger conference told me about
- 1:16:21the 18 year property cycle.
- 1:16:22So within Lend, like in Bitcoin, we have four-year cycles because Bitcoin is scarce, meaning if more people want Bitcoin, yes, we'll go to speculative frenzies, we'll go through bubbles, but at some point we find a higher low and then the price starts moving up from there again, which is a four-year cycle.
- 1:16:42In land, you have a similar cycle, but it's 18 years.
- 1:16:46And that cycle has also existed before the advent of fiat money.
- 1:16:50So because land is scarce, it goes up in value, and then it goes through a speculative frenzy,
- 1:16:55and it goes back in value.
- 1:16:56And you can go throughout history, throughout different jurisdictions.
- 1:16:59The book that I was reading went through the United States in particular, and it showed
- 1:17:05how the 18-year property cycle pretty much fits in into the last 400 years of the American
- 1:17:09real estate market, both in the East and in the West.
- 1:17:12But now Bitcoin breaks through that 18-year property cycle because the monetary premium that's locked in land can go away now because it can flow into Bitcoin.
- 1:17:20That's fascinating.
- 1:17:21I wonder what drove the 18 years.
- 1:17:25It's obviously something to do with how long people lived and how long it took to have almost a generation.
- 1:17:32It's true.
- 1:17:32That is like a generation.
- 1:17:33Yeah, that's like a generation, actually.
- 1:17:34And it must be that something to do with I'm passing my land onto my, or now my son or daughter is old enough to be a business person.
- 1:17:43So they're going to buy land at this point.
- 1:17:45It's going to pump, you know, it's going to pump from that point.
- 1:17:48I don't know.
- 1:17:49That's absolutely fascinating.
- 1:17:51Just a couple of things.
- 1:17:53We didn't mention why Japan has an interesting.
- 1:17:55Oh, sorry.
- 1:17:55I mean, you can do it real quick because it is a quick answer.
- 1:17:59But you please step in as well.
- 1:18:03Well, no, I just think because of the nature of the land and earthquakes, by law, you have to rebuild houses in Japan every certain number of years.
- 1:18:17Is it 35 or 60 or something like that?
- 1:18:19I'm not aware how fast you have to do it.
- 1:18:21what I'm aware of and maybe that also works in the the fact that there you have earthquakes is
- 1:18:29that basically real estate does not serve as a store of value in Japan and because of that
- 1:18:35there's little value in the buildings and people must see it as as it being
- 1:18:40good with utility values so that's what I've been told when somebody moves in
- 1:18:45they usually deconstruct the building because it's pretty cheap to build
- 1:18:49and that that's like the dynamic that i was told causes that but i don't know if i learned this
- 1:18:54because there's been a number of people on social media buying properties in japan recently and
- 1:19:01they're like a hundred like it was a four thousand dollars five thousand dollars for a very beautiful
- 1:19:07looking three-bedroom house and when i then i looked into it because i and i'm pretty sure
- 1:19:12that by law you have to rebuild a house every certain amount of time so they're literally built
- 1:19:17to take down okay which is obviously part of the reason why they have very little you know asset
- 1:19:23value as well because they're a liability they are liable and you have the demographic change
- 1:19:28in japan like in any western or industrialized nation over time as automation increases people
- 1:19:35have less children and if there's also wealth increases people are less inclined to have to
- 1:19:41have children right so in japan you have a decreasing population meaning you have an
- 1:19:45over surplus of housing. That's why I was in, I think it was in November, 2023. I went to Japan
- 1:19:53for the Nostra conference and I met the Bitcoiner down there as well. And he told me the same thing.
- 1:19:57So he bought a property in Japan with his family. He moved from the, from the U S I think. And the
- 1:20:03Japanese government basically sells you the property for very little with the obligation of
- 1:20:09you may having to maintain a building because there's no one else that would take it because
- 1:20:13of a declining population.
- 1:20:14In the Japanese, they're very,
- 1:20:18they want to protect their culture.
- 1:20:19They don't like immigration.
- 1:20:20So in the UK and in Germany,
- 1:20:22we have the same issue,
- 1:20:23but people say, okay,
- 1:20:24instead of housing coming back down
- 1:20:25to its utility value,
- 1:20:27we let people from somewhere else
- 1:20:29move into the buildings.
- 1:20:30Then we produce the money.
- 1:20:32We say it's social housing
- 1:20:34and we pay the rent
- 1:20:35and that's a way to drive up
- 1:20:37the cost of housing.
- 1:20:38It's actually kind of a scheme
- 1:20:39to drive up the cost of housing.
- 1:20:41In the Japanese, they don't do that.
- 1:20:43because they are very...
- 1:20:45The Japanese like their culture.
- 1:20:47I'm not an expert on Japanese.
- 1:20:49It's a very unique culture as well.
- 1:20:51Assimilating into Japanese culture is relatively difficult,
- 1:20:54I think, compared to a lot of Western cultures anyway.
- 1:20:58It's very specific and very, very, very specific.
- 1:21:02Yeah, it's almost like German used to be
- 1:21:03until, let's say, the First World War under the Prussians, right?
- 1:21:06Because the Prussians, who were until 1871,
- 1:21:11the Austrians and the Prussians were always fighting who is the strongest German nation
- 1:21:18state, right? Because there were various German nation states at the time. By winning the war
- 1:21:24against France in 1871 under Bismarck, the Russians, sorry, the Russians, the Prussians
- 1:21:28took control of Germany. And in Japan, the emperor, even when they lost the Second World War,
- 1:21:35the emperor was still respected by the people. Whereas Wilhelm, for example, was not respected
- 1:21:40by the Germans anymore until today.
- 1:21:43Germans have very little respect for their heritage,
- 1:21:45but the Japanese have always stayed within their heritage,
- 1:21:50and they've done mistakes culturally as well,
- 1:21:52just like the Germans,
- 1:21:53because being proud of your heritage
- 1:21:55sometimes can lead to thinking of being,
- 1:21:59like a supremacy type of thinking,
- 1:22:01which both of these nation states,
- 1:22:03both of these cultures went through.
- 1:22:04But the Japanese, they still respect their ways.
- 1:22:08The Germans do not,
- 1:22:09so they don't care about preserving their culture.
- 1:22:11So then immigration is used as a way to drive up property prices.
- 1:22:16And in Japan, that doesn't work.
- 1:22:17So property prices are declining,
- 1:22:19except in areas like Tokyo and other metropolitan areas
- 1:22:23where you have demand.
- 1:22:25But generally speaking, in Japan,
- 1:22:27housing is not used as a store of value since the late 80s.
- 1:22:31When Japan went to this real estate bubble,
- 1:22:33they went to rampant rates of inflation.
- 1:22:37but housing collapsed and it never came back up and that's something that we can also expect in
- 1:22:43the western world now because the western world has been able to elevate property prices until now
- 1:22:50but now the western societies have reached a tipping point where the local population
- 1:22:56is so negatively affected by the rising cost of housing because of that that i think the political
- 1:23:02class will not be able to maintain that system there will be change in politics
- 1:23:07and that change in politics also if you're a property investor will lead to properties losing
- 1:23:13value which is but that's not a good political look either i think excuse me most political parties
- 1:23:21um are trying their hardest not to let property prices go down because we've built a whole culture
- 1:23:28around property being a store of value. And I think there's still a lot more they can do
- 1:23:36to print money and fund housing. I don't know. I mean, we should probably talk about that,
- 1:23:43but just about the future and whether or not you envisage some kind of a collapse or whatever.
- 1:23:48But I just want to ask another couple of questions. The way you've described it,
- 1:23:54and it's really helped me actually, is you've basically described Bitcoin as digital real estate.
- 1:24:01Okay. And as a result, I know many people who are doing the real estate play with Bitcoin,
- 1:24:10which is you own some collateral. Previously, it would have been a big building,
- 1:24:15and you borrow against it and the price of the building rises through inflation So you just keep refinancing it And you keep generating an income from it over time And people are now doing that with Bitcoin
- 1:24:29And even now, companies are rising to service individuals rather than industries and corporations.
- 1:24:38We see that now. Let's say you're a Bitcoiner from 2015 or something. You might well be sitting
- 1:24:44on a big enough stack to actually make that play and live off it. Are you into that idea
- 1:24:51or do you think that has a future or is that the way to go? It's not a very cypherpunk
- 1:24:57way of living if you think about it. It's leveraging your pristine asset to just get
- 1:25:02the shitcoin and spend it. But what do you think about that as a method to use Bitcoin,
- 1:25:10as a utility of it?
- 1:25:13First of all, it's a rational, economically sound decision.
- 1:25:18If you want to do it or not, that's your subjective decision.
- 1:25:21If you'll ask me, coming from the real estate sector,
- 1:25:26of course, understanding Bitcoin has come from a place of what I've known.
- 1:25:33What I personally have known is outperform the rate of monetary inflation,
- 1:25:37hedge against it, build a collateral base, and then leverage the balance sheet.
- 1:25:42That's how I was taught.
- 1:25:44And so within that mindset, Bitcoin as digital real estate, meaning being near perfect money,
- 1:25:53which means you can spend it because people will accept it because they know it keeps its purchasing power
- 1:25:59and it grows in purchasing power.
- 1:26:00So it's a great store of value, which makes it good collateral.
- 1:26:04How you want to deal with it is up to you.
- 1:26:07But I believe that, and I very much agree with the fact that somebody's saying that if you start using Bitcoin as real estate within the existing parameters of both the fiat system and Bitcoin, you do kind of feed the fiat beast because you are participating in the Cantillon effect, which means whoever's closest to the money printer benefits and whoever's the furthest away loses because the savings are being devalued.
- 1:26:35But then the question is, and I've been thought about this a lot, and I respect everybody's opinion.
- 1:26:40I really do.
- 1:26:41I respect people who say, no, that's not for me.
- 1:26:44I respect people that say, I'm going to build a treasury company and I'm going to do it the right way.
- 1:26:48Because I've been thinking, you said it's not within the cypherpunk ethos.
- 1:26:53And then the question is, what is the cypherpunk ethos?
- 1:26:56It's not me to tell anybody what the cypherpunk ethos is.
- 1:27:01so um i think as an entrepreneur the question becomes if you if you spend a dollar what are
- 1:27:10you spending that right because every dollar is that our whole system is based on that and then
- 1:27:18you just have have to ask yourself how much do i want to go into debt how much is the system into
- 1:27:25debt and how much is me going into debt going to affect the overall system probably very little
- 1:27:31and if we all do it at the same time what what is that going to to to bring well i don't know
- 1:27:39that's a speculative attack that pure shard described in 2014 it took the world 11 years
- 1:27:45to figure it out but i've been sitting for quite some time and also before sharing my thoughts
- 1:27:51publicly and i've been thinking like that all the time because obviously in 2020 i think michael
- 1:27:57say like a burst onto the stage and he was started talking about bitcoin as collateral and no no
- 1:28:01and i thought wow he's talking about bitcoin like i've been talking about real estate uh
- 1:28:06right he did even call it digital real estate at one point i think i he sure he calls it digital
- 1:28:11property i think but it's the same thing i think he also surely called it digital real estate i
- 1:28:15know that surfer jim for example wrote a great article called bitcoin is digital real estate
- 1:28:20that helped me because i read that article i started uh to listen to sailor and then i was
- 1:28:24sitting there and I was sitting in my office. I was like, wow, this is like a digital real estate
- 1:28:28place. So I started to move like that immediately. I started to incorporate Bitcoin with our company
- 1:28:33structure. We had actually like some financial difficulties over the past two to three years,
- 1:28:37not like extensively, but any real estate business have. If somebody tells you that didn't,
- 1:28:40they rely on my opinion, right? So what we did and the way I was able to maneuver is that I used
- 1:28:45Bitcoin as a capital base to lend against because interest rates went up. So then the question is,
- 1:28:50are you able to refinance a building that you finance at 1% at 5%?
- 1:28:56No, because you're going to go bust.
- 1:28:57But you want to keep the business alive because you're feeding yourself,
- 1:29:00you're feeding your family, you're feeding other people.
- 1:29:02So I started using Bitcoin as collateral to lend against
- 1:29:06and keep the business alive and survive and feed my family.
- 1:29:11So then I actually kind of think, you know, I want to feed my family.
- 1:29:14So I do it in a way where it's most beneficial for the world.
- 1:29:17that's why I also think okay if you use bitcoin as collateral you might as well share that idea
- 1:29:23with other people by also alluding to the risks because right now we're sitting here bitcoin is
- 1:29:29above it's 15 to 20 000 bottom it had in the bear market so at that point of time
- 1:29:35I would have maybe suggested to think about the opportunity of using bitcoin as collateral
- 1:29:41at this point of time I'd be way more cautious because bitcoin will drop again and then you have
- 1:29:46to be able to sustain that job and i also want to say that if you are someone who does not believe
- 1:29:53in paying taxes because this is i think also a fundamental question if you run a business that
- 1:30:00pays taxes you are feeding the fiat beast you are if you have to do it because you have been
- 1:30:07building a business while building the business you have become consciously aware of the negative
- 1:30:12effects of the fiat system you can't just stop doing the business so you still have to work with
- 1:30:17that and if you work in real estate and you've reached a certain scale so we have built around
- 1:30:21100 000 square meters over the past 10 years and if you operate on that scale it's basically a debt
- 1:30:28balance sheet play and i i wasn't aware of that so in order for this business to survive you must
- 1:30:36incorporate bitcoin as collateral and if you don't you basically you basically die so for me
- 1:30:42if you ask me it has become a question of survival and then the ethical question is something that i
- 1:30:48think about in the back of my mind and i'm very careful about what i share because i agree with
- 1:30:54what you're saying in an ideal world you can just save in bitcoin and focus on your craft
- 1:31:00especially as an individual you can imagine as a as a company or as a corporation
- 1:31:05and with a lot of other people at stake um it's a difficult decision to make yeah and
- 1:31:12like you say what else are you going to do you you you let your business go bust or you leverage
- 1:31:18what you've got in the form of that yeah i mean it was just a thought because i've just noticed
- 1:31:24I think the reason why all these companies that are allowing you to borrow against your Bitcoin are kind of starting to appear, there's lots of them, is because of where we are.
- 1:31:36If you look back, if you think about it, the average person who's, if you've been DCAing into Bitcoin, just the average person, if you can track back and say you go back to 2016, you've probably got quite a lot of money by now.
- 1:31:50you're probably at that point where you could potentially leverage some of it to give yourself
- 1:31:57an income but if you go back yeah if you go back to 2020 that's not true someone like sailor sure
- 1:32:02if you're bunging in 10 million dollars at a time fine but if you're a normal person and you were
- 1:32:08stacking you know a few thousand you know a few thousand every now and then or 10 000 a year or
- 1:32:13something if you go back far enough you can see that right now when there was quite an influx of
- 1:32:19people in 2016 2017 those people are probably in the point where they may have more than a million
- 1:32:26quite realistically even 10 million and that's at 10 million dollars worth of bitcoin that play
- 1:32:34makes a lot more sense because you can you can you can just use a very small amount of it basically
- 1:32:40you don't whereas if you own a hundred thousand dollars worth of bitcoin it's probably not a good
- 1:32:44idea to to borrow 50 grand yeah you're not going to last very long and you're not going to be able
- 1:32:49do it for very many years but but but i see that that's kind of that's why now all that stuff is
- 1:32:55becoming much more popular because there's more demand for it basically one i mean 100 percent
- 1:32:59three years ago i did it was a german uh podcast but i did the german podcast called a bitcoin
- 1:33:05digital real estate 2.0 and i laid out a whole plan but bitcoin at the point was at 20 000 so
- 1:33:12i'm not going to repeat what i said there but i laid out a whole plan of how to buy bitcoin
- 1:33:16lent against it tax-free never having to work again and you use bitcoin as digital real estate
- 1:33:23to create a place for yourself where you can become independent of the the fiat system and i do
- 1:33:31find it very interesting that all these companies are now coming into existence and they're following
- 1:33:36um sailors playbook right but at the moment i a bit cautious because we at a different point in the cycle I know a lot of new people usually comment at this point in the cycle and i would suggest to stack wait till the next bear market
- 1:33:52and then start to operate strategies like that if you want if you don't want to don't do it right but
- 1:33:57it's the natural progression of bitcoin as near perfect money or this is the last cycle
- 1:34:05I was thinking about it.
- 1:34:08You might find yourself in a dodgy situation as you, it gets to a million dollars and you're
- 1:34:13still waiting for a bear market.
- 1:34:14I mean, I know every, every four years people say, this is the super cycle or this is it
- 1:34:20now.
- 1:34:20It's just going to go up.
- 1:34:22But I, I have limited understanding, let's say of markets, but I have been watching the
- 1:34:28Bitcoin market for a very long time.
- 1:34:30And I can say that according to me, there's been a change in attitude to the price. And you can see that now. And it obviously corresponds to larger chunks of capital coming in.
- 1:34:44the last sort of year or so, the price, the way the price has been rising has been different
- 1:34:50to the previous cycles. It's more of a, I think I heard someone describe it. It's very similar to
- 1:34:57the way ETFs go up in price. Obviously, we have an ETF now, a very large one indeed, you know.
- 1:35:04So there is a little bit more credence to the idea that maybe the traditional structure of the
- 1:35:11Bitcoin market and its cycles might have changed this time. And it might be that it just stair steps
- 1:35:18up forever now because there's so much capital coming in. I don't know. You could argue it.
- 1:35:23Yeah, I think actually it's very, I mean, a lot of people that I really respect and that are much
- 1:35:27much smarter than me and much more successful argue that as well.
- 1:35:31Do they?
- 1:35:32Yeah, a lot of people.
- 1:35:33Oh, right. I didn't know that.
- 1:35:34But I, to be honest with you, you know, two things.
- 1:35:38First of all, I try to operate my life and my business in a way where I never have to sell anything to be able to withstand an 80% drawdown.
- 1:35:51So that's because I've been thinking about this a lot over the past couple of days.
- 1:35:55And I came to the conclusion, Leon, you are wasting your thoughts.
- 1:35:59You have 24 hours a day.
- 1:36:01Think about your business.
- 1:36:03Think about your family.
- 1:36:03thinking about buying more Bitcoin rather than what is the market going to do? Because if you
- 1:36:08understand Bitcoin and you understand that, yes, it can go down 80%, but over time it goes up,
- 1:36:15it actually doesn't matter what the price is doing as long as you just keep accumulating,
- 1:36:19keep accumulating, keep accumulating and protect yourself from an 80% drawdown.
- 1:36:23And then I was talking with a friend of mine yesterday, Scala, who was also very much within
- 1:36:27the, I'd say, Austrian scene.
- 1:36:32I mean, with Austrian, I mean the Austrian School of Economics.
- 1:36:34And he was also saying, and I agree that from a praxeological viewpoint, so if you start
- 1:36:40to analyze human behavior and human action, the only reason why Bitcoin can go up is because
- 1:36:46it goes down.
- 1:36:47Any system that does not wash out leverage has to collapse.
- 1:36:53And the Bitcoin price is not objective.
- 1:36:55It's subjective and it's based on different subjective preferences and perception.
- 1:37:02And somebody might think Bitcoin will go to 500,000 and somebody is shorting Bitcoin.
- 1:37:06And the truth is somewhere in the middle.
- 1:37:08And that is the reason why Bitcoin has to come down a priori based on the experience
- 1:37:16that people always misprice and misjudge both the past, the present and the future.
- 1:37:21And they'll always do that.
- 1:37:22And because of that, there will be a point, an infliction point, where enough people within the market will have misjudged both the price and their personal position, either in the market or within the company they operate in.
- 1:37:38And that misjudgment will then be penalized by the market by a drawdown.
- 1:37:43And only the people that value Bitcoin for more than it is worth will stay.
- 1:37:50And then they will drive up the price higher.
- 1:37:51So for this asset to go up in price, it needs to go down.
- 1:37:59Yeah, unless everyone understands it.
- 1:38:03Yeah, but they don't.
- 1:38:04Yeah, but it is something that you understand to a degree in the end.
- 1:38:10No matter who you are, you understand that it's a way –
- 1:38:16the more you get in contact with the effects of the fiat system,
- 1:38:19like particularly inflation, the more you notice what things are good to have and what things aren't
- 1:38:26good to have. No matter whether you don't have to be an economist to know that, you know, if you
- 1:38:32own a painting or a bit of antique furniture in your house, it's going up in price. The price of
- 1:38:39it's going up. You think, great, you know. So you're more likely when you're out shopping,
- 1:38:44you're more likely if you've got, oh yeah, let's get that, because there's this added advantage that
- 1:38:48not only can i sit on this chair but i know that it's actually when i come to sell it when my
- 1:38:53children don't want it anymore it's actually worth some money so there's there will be this
- 1:38:57general understanding i think because there already is the general understanding that
- 1:39:02inflation is an increase in the money supply for example that general understanding is seeping into
- 1:39:08into common conversations i don't know if you've noticed this it's it's talked about in those terms
- 1:39:15more. It used to be people said, oh, prices are going up, therefore we've got inflation.
- 1:39:20You know, it's like no one understood anything about this. But now youngsters get it. You know,
- 1:39:26your average 18 year old has heard that on Robin Hood doing a bit of trading or whatever, they kind
- 1:39:32of started to understand a few economic principles that really were hidden from the world for a very
- 1:39:39long time. Even like the, you know, the leverage, the asset play that real estate people have done,
- 1:39:47it's been like a hidden secret, hasn't it, really, for many, many years. And now, thanks to the
- 1:39:52internet and TikTok and all kinds of stuff, people understand, wow, that's how a lot of rich people
- 1:39:58stayed rich. And I was the idiot putting my money in the bank or buying something we have in the UK
- 1:40:06called premium bonds or buying you know buying you know what i mean or buying shares in british
- 1:40:12telecom that go up hardly anything and you know that what the public were told about investing and
- 1:40:19doing things with your money and what people who were who knew what they were doing who all sort of
- 1:40:25like kept it a little secret in a way between them because there wasn't so much of a free
- 1:40:29transfer of information around you know but i so first of all i don't know i have no idea right i
- 1:40:35we don't know about the future but i think it's an interesting conversation because i was sitting
- 1:40:39with a few youngsters so to say who are studying right now in their early 20s i think they were
- 1:40:43from 19 till 21 and what you said was true because none of them started to argue with me about bitcoin
- 1:40:50everyone's like oh yeah bitcoin is the stove value 100 but they were all leveraging their
- 1:40:54bitcoin to trade solana meme coins so that's a fiat thought though yeah that's a short but that's
- 1:41:01that's how they all think that's how they think okay so so so so like it's like very few people
- 1:41:05think like you and me but but over time presumably as the culture change the culture will change
- 1:41:12what you only if they are penalized like if these boys for they will be won't they yeah
- 1:41:16through the bear market right okay so okay but in the end i suppose yeah i i i agree with you i think
- 1:41:23that the the bitcoin's a really fascinating thing in its entirety because it's a forcing function
- 1:41:31in cultural change which is bizarre when you think about it because when most people enter
- 1:41:38first hear about bitcoin well if you were lucky it was because of cypherpunks if you weren't as
- 1:41:43lucky it was because the price was going up um but very few people really probably started
- 1:41:50adopting Bitcoin because they thought it was going to change the cultural fabric of the whole world,
- 1:41:55which is basically it, I think. That's what it is. It's going to, you could argue, I mean,
- 1:42:00it sounds a bit stupid when I say it, but it's going to usher in a new, a kind of like new
- 1:42:05Renaissance architecture buildings by taking away the sort of the premium on things being used as
- 1:42:15money. That's all it is. It's like taking this one thing and saying, right, now this is money,
- 1:42:21everything else, let's see what the value of that is. Let's see how humans value that,
- 1:42:25as the Austrians would say. How much do we really value these things now that
- 1:42:30they're being used in a real way? They're not being used in this distorted way, which is like
- 1:42:36buying it because I think it's going to store my value. But you could easily argue that that's the
- 1:42:42place we're going.
- 1:42:43You know, I mean, it does sound a bit like, oh yeah, listen to this guy, there's a new
- 1:42:49renaissance coming or whatever, but I don't know, prove me wrong.
- 1:42:52Yes.
- 1:42:53No, I agree with you.
- 1:42:54Maybe we could say two things.
- 1:42:56Maybe we've been in a bull market for 15 years.
- 1:42:58True.
- 1:42:59And we be in a bull market for the next 15 years but we just have to manage the way we operate within that market And we just have to expect drawdowns that are important to build resilience Because the difference between Bitcoin and the fiat system is nobody controls arbitrarily speaking nobody controls the supply of Bitcoin
- 1:43:24So if Bitcoin goes down, it goes down and then has the positive effect of penalizing, for example, the boys that I really like that I just talked about.
- 1:43:32that were margining their Bitcoin to trade Zolana meme coins.
- 1:43:35Yes, they do understand Bitcoin is a better store of value
- 1:43:38than anything that exists in the physical world,
- 1:43:40but there are still young kids that just want to speculate,
- 1:43:43and they do it on Zolana, and almost every 20-year-old that I talk to
- 1:43:48that is into Bitcoin is also into Zolana meme coins,
- 1:43:50except the hardcore Bitcoinos, of course.
- 1:43:52Are they all losing money?
- 1:43:54Most of them are losing money, but it's an addiction, right?
- 1:43:58It's a very small percentage of people that can make money trading, right?
- 1:44:01Yes, yes.
- 1:44:02Especially on meme coins.
- 1:44:03I mean, it's basically like a gamble, really.
- 1:44:07It's not, I mean, you're either inside a trade or you're just 100% gambling, you know, which is a bit of a buzz, I'm sure.
- 1:44:15It's like releasing a shoe.
- 1:44:16If you are Nike and you're releasing a shoe, you're making a lot of money.
- 1:44:19If you're a reseller of the shoe and you're getting it for a cheap price, you're also making a lot of money.
- 1:44:23If you're the collector who buys the shoe, you're not making any money.
- 1:44:27A meme coin is almost like that, just in a digital form, right?
- 1:44:29So if you create it and if you are part of the early crowd, you'll make money with it similar to a shoe.
- 1:44:35But there's no monetary use case within it.
- 1:44:38But what I do want to say is, and I think you describe it like beautifully because Bitcoin pushes us to the next level by penalizing bad behavior.
- 1:44:49And also talking about myself, if Bitcoin would have gone from zero to 100 from the moment I got in, I probably would be like a very bad person.
- 1:44:58because the bear markets really taught me a lot of lessons.
- 1:45:04Don't go into, like in the early days,
- 1:45:07don't go into other coins,
- 1:45:09don't leave your coins on exchanges,
- 1:45:11don't over leverage.
- 1:45:12Like all these lessons I learned through bear markets.
- 1:45:15Oh, and then that's what the cycle is.
- 1:45:17It's people learning those lessons.
- 1:45:19Part of the cycle, yeah.
- 1:45:20But it is the cycle.
- 1:45:21It is the cycle, yeah.
- 1:45:22Because you losing on leverage
- 1:45:26is what's causing the stair-stepping price.
- 1:45:31Yes.
- 1:45:32Yeah.
- 1:45:33So it's almost like Bitcoin doesn't,
- 1:45:35a bull market does not exist without a bear market.
- 1:45:37There is no bull market without a bear market.
- 1:45:39It's a very, that's fiat.
- 1:45:41Because in fiat, as soon as that happens,
- 1:45:46and people should learn,
- 1:45:48the government, because they want to protect their interests,
- 1:45:51create money to protect certain institutions,
- 1:45:54individuals, SF classes, so forth.
- 1:45:56So the market never learns.
- 1:45:58So it's not resilient.
- 1:45:59That's why we have the boom and bust cycles.
- 1:46:01Right.
- 1:46:01So if taking that into the future then, in the distant future, that is a renaissance.
- 1:46:07Yes.
- 1:46:08Because people no longer leverage at that point.
- 1:46:10Everyone in the market has learned the lesson through pain, basically.
- 1:46:15Because no one, and even the government has learned the lesson, because they're now defunded themselves.
- 1:46:22Pretty much, when you think about it.
- 1:46:24That's what they're doing right now, actually.
- 1:46:25kind of funny to watch well they are but but it's i mean i've i thought i think about this a lot
- 1:46:32and i'm not sure how the government ever lets go of it's this power that it has to to basically
- 1:46:39well create money ask someone to buy its debt you know here's a bond and if you won't buy it
- 1:46:47and your company won't buy it well the central bank will so let's you know that's that's the
- 1:46:53biggest power on the planet really, especially if you're the US or some, you know, you can do
- 1:46:58anything. You can literally do anything. You can invade Iraq for 10 years and it costs trillions
- 1:47:04of dollars. And actually you don't even really notice, well, you don't notice anything. People
- 1:47:10that use dollars obviously notice an inflationary pressure and all this kind of stuff. But really
- 1:47:16it's the final boss. I mean, who's going to give that power up? I know theoretically,
- 1:47:24they don't even give it up. There's a forcing function. The forcing function of Bitcoin,
- 1:47:29one of them, is to join the network. You either join it or you don't. There's no alternative.
- 1:47:35And if you join it, you follow the rules. So you either join it or you don't. When you're in the
- 1:47:40network, you either follow the rules or you don't. If you don't follow the rules,
- 1:47:44you're not using bitcoin follow the rules you're not using bitcoin so it's very primordial you know
- 1:47:51and and once you're following the rules you can't print your own money you have to add value and
- 1:47:57everybody knows governments don't create their own don't don't create value i mean other i mean they
- 1:48:05they they create money but they don't actually create a value like they have to demand it from
- 1:48:11you in the form of tax, or they have to persuade you to lend them money, which is obviously what
- 1:48:18they'll have to do under a Bitcoin standard. And who's going to lend the government Bitcoin? I
- 1:48:23don't know. That's a really interesting conversation as well, how that dynamic is
- 1:48:29going to change. Yeah. Anyway, look, we've been talking for a long time. Can I ask you one more
- 1:48:33question? Because we didn't even talk about free cities. And I know you actually know something
- 1:48:37about free cities but i think talking about i mean i talk a lot about free cities on this podcast
- 1:48:42obviously but real estate's a great um topic of conversation because so many people are involved
- 1:48:47in it especially people who you know like and i don't even mean people who use it as a business
- 1:48:53just everyone owning your own house is a big deal so we've done that but tell me what you know about
- 1:48:59free cities and and and see if you can link it to the real estate play yes sure i mean what do i
- 1:49:05know about free cities i know about i mean i like say private cities yeah that's a better one free
- 1:49:10cities is a bit more of an umbrella term now for a lot of things but you you've basically studied
- 1:49:16with somebody who was the former um ceo of the free cities foundation which i didn't know until
- 1:49:22now yes so you but that back then it was more the private city model that a free private city which
- 1:49:28is titus gable's idea of um i mean everyone should know this but i better quickly say it
- 1:49:34you create a place which has independence.
- 1:49:40If you want to join it, you have to sign a contract to be there.
- 1:49:43So you don't have a political system.
- 1:49:45You don't have voting.
- 1:49:46You have a contract.
- 1:49:48And that contract says this is what you can and can't do.
- 1:49:50If you follow it, you stay.
- 1:49:51If you don't, you might be reprimanded or even asked to leave.
- 1:49:56And if you don't like it, you go to another free city, which is –
- 1:50:00But the world should be, kind of.
- 1:50:01Well, I mean, and you're German.
- 1:50:03you know there was a the hansiatic league i'm from hamburg by the way right okay so you know the
- 1:50:08the history of those kind of ideas yeah no i really like it i also growing up uh i am very
- 1:50:14much aware of the hansiatic um league hansiatic league and and the idea of free cities and uh
- 1:50:22i mean if you'll ask me what's the ideal model like that's the ideal model basically it's the it's
- 1:50:28the city, the government, the municipality, or the jurisdiction, whatever it is, will be,
- 1:50:35being a service provider and providing a service to you. And I think that if they can't extort money
- 1:50:41from you, that's what they have to do. And I do like the idea and I do follow people, Rahim especially.
- 1:50:48I mean, I have a lot of respect for Rahim. He's very knowledgeable. I personally, if you ask me,
- 1:50:58Maybe at this point in time, what is more important to me, living in a private city or accumulating Bitcoin, I'd rather accumulate Bitcoin now and then decide where I want to move.
- 1:51:14So the mobility that Bitcoin gives, I think, is good for the individual to then decide where to live, because that's actually one of the main questions that I'm asking myself.
- 1:51:23I think that a lot of my friends are asking themselves, where do I want to live?
- 1:51:26this question was not as important before the internet and before bitcoin with the internet
- 1:51:33we've been able to travel more and with bitcoin we've been able to also have our wealth mobile
- 1:51:39and if we go back into the sovereign individual thesis just the fact that we can say like f you
- 1:51:46i don't agree with your rules and regulations i'm moving on should create competition amongst
- 1:51:53nation states but also cities to provide the best service possible to their citizens so if you ask me
- 1:52:00like what is the free city movement like i would expect them to like kind of bring that into reality
- 1:52:05to create um habitus and places for individuals and families to live to prosper to thrive
- 1:52:13to freely live out their their dreams and create their own sort of reality like that's kind of like
- 1:52:20the take I'm having on it.
- 1:52:21You're making me really bullish on Free Cities actually, just talking about it.
- 1:52:25Because when you add it to what we've all just been talking about,
- 1:52:29It does work. I mean, everything we've just spoken about and even the fact that
- 1:52:35the current age is the age in which we're most mobile. I mean, when you think about
- 1:52:41the competitive nature of governance, it works with that. It works with mobility. Without mobility,
- 1:52:49it doesn't work at all. And that's kind of the system we've come from, you know,
- 1:52:53traveling to moving from one country to another, even say a hundred years ago,
- 1:52:57hardly anyone did it yeah no and and in fact in 100 years ago moving from where i live to london
- 1:53:03which is i can drive it in four hours that was a big deal that was like but now people commute that
- 1:53:09and people go to dubai for the weekend so so we we really do live in that time the the the signals
- 1:53:16are there that we live in this time where we can move around so yeah of course we
- 1:53:22competitive governance should now rise because the market being created for it You know I mean and when you add that to Bitcoin and everything you just said about it demonetizing you know I known the theory that
- 1:53:38Bitcoin demonetizes various assets for a long time, but you're describing it actually in reality,
- 1:53:46and you are the guy who works in an industry in which it's happening. Right. So it's really
- 1:53:52happening and when you piece all these pieces the jigsaw together it's very bullish for the whole
- 1:53:59free cities movement it's bullish for individuals it's bullish for everyone who's who's thinking
- 1:54:04about these kind of things and i agree with you that in the last say four or five years i know so
- 1:54:11many people i mean since covid probably so many people thinking about where do i want to live
- 1:54:16And there no doubt that the states around the world are now trying they going to try and squash this exit taxes movement licenses you name it You can see that that all going to come because they never want to compete The state never instinctively competes It tries to legislate
- 1:54:42That's the system. It needs you so much now to fund it or lend it money, give it taxes or lend
- 1:54:51it money it needs you it's going to put a wall up to stop you going not stop you coming in
- 1:54:56and um yeah i mean it's true we're in that age it's great yeah i mean it's going to be it's going
- 1:55:02to be pretty crazy though um because it's all very well i mean i've got uh i'm going to talk
- 1:55:08about this later with i've got another three guests today but i want to talk about property
- 1:55:13rights um because that's the final boss property rights in the digital world now we understand it's
- 1:55:20It's very simple.
- 1:55:22Property rights in the real world,
- 1:55:24that's a whole different thing.
- 1:55:26Yeah you need a legal system to enforce it Even that you know who got the biggest gun You know I don know that for another conversation yeah leon it been a great conversation i i really appreciate you speaking
- 1:55:38and i love hearing i love a good expert i think you're an expert on property because you've
- 1:55:43actually been living it for how long 30 years consciously i mean like 28 years yeah but that's
- 1:55:50that's that's you've done you've put the 10 000 hours in and it's interesting to hear you say that
- 1:55:54your see your choices at this particular point in history because um and you say a lot of other
- 1:56:01people have started to make these same choices because the thesis is another the thesis is being
- 1:56:05proven again the bitcoin thesis is being proven in another realm so thanks for coming in and
- 1:56:10thanks for sharing all your wisdom mate thanks for having me really i enjoyed the conversation as well
- 1:56:24.