Latest / Comeback Project: Resilience, recovery & starting over / The Art of Holding Space: How to Listen Without Fixing | Comeback Project
Transcript
- You know that terrifying moment when your friend starts crying, and your brain instantly fires up the emergency repair kit? That urge to hand them a tissue, a solution, or a silver lining is not kindness—it’s fear. I want you to picture a scene from last Tuesday. Or maybe it was yesterday. You’re sitting across from someone you love—maybe it’s your sister, your partner, or a colleague who just shared something heavy. Their voice cracks. The air in the room gets thick. And suddenly, your chest tightens with this urgent, desperate need to make it stop. You feel like if you don’t say something, anything, right now, you are failing them. So you open your mouth. Maybe you offer advice. Maybe you say, 'At least you still have your health,' or 'Have you tried meditation?' We do this because silence feels dangerous. Silence feels like we’ve abandoned them. But here is the truth that took me years to learn, partly because I spent a decade as an investigative journalist chasing answers, thinking every problem had a fixable root cause. It doesn’t. Sometimes, people don’t need a detective. They need a witness. Let’s breathe through this for a second. Just imagine what it would feel like if, in that moment, you chose to stay quiet. Not out of indifference, but out of respect. What did that cost you? It costs you your ego. It costs you the comfort of feeling useful. But it gives them something far more valuable: the space to actually be human with their pain. Why is silence so scary to us? I think it’s because we confuse presence with performance. We think being a good friend means performing acts of service or verbal reassurance. We think our job is to smooth over the rough edges of someone else’s life, to sand down their grief until it’s palatable for dinner conversation. But when we rush to fix, we are actually rushing to relieve our own discomfort. We can’t stand to see someone hurting because it reminds us of our own vulnerabilities, our own unhealed wounds. It triggers a primal alarm bell in our nervous system that says, 'Danger! Make it go away!' But here is the thing about pain—it doesn’t always want to go away immediately. Sometimes it wants to be held. Sometimes it wants to sit in the dark with you while it sorts itself out. When we jump in with solutions, we are inadvertently sending a message that their pain is too much for us to handle. It’s too heavy. It’s too messy. It needs to be cleaned up. And that is the loneliest feeling in the world. To feel that your grief is an inconvenience to the person you love most. So, the first step in learning how to hold space is recognizing that your instinct to fix is often just your own anxiety talking. It’s not about them. It’s about you needing to feel safe. Acknowledge that. Sit with that discomfort. Let it be there. You don’t have to act on it. So, what does holding space actually look like in practice? It’s not as mystical as it sounds. It’s incredibly practical. It looks like putting down your phone. It looks making eye contact even when you want to look at the floor. It looks saying, 'I don’t know what to say, but I am here.' It looks nodding when they speak. It looks resisting the urge to share your own similar story unless they explicitly ask for it. There is a fine line between empathy and comparison. When someone shares their struggle, and you immediately say, 'Oh my god, that happened to me too!' you might be trying to connect, but you are also shifting the focus to yourself. You are making their experience about your history. Holding space means keeping the spotlight firmly on them. It means letting their tears fall without trying to wipe them away with words. It means trusting that they have the resilience to navigate this, even if they don’t feel resilient right now. It’s a quiet, steady presence. Think of it like sitting by a riverbank. You aren’t trying to dam the water. You aren’t trying to divert the current. You are just sitting there, watching the water flow, knowing that eventually, the flood will recede. Your job is not to control the water. Your job is to be the solid ground beside it. This requires a kind of patience that feels unnatural in our fast-paced world. We want quick fixes. We want before-and-after photos. But healing is not linear. It’s messy. It’s circular. And holding space means accepting that messiness without trying to tidy it up. There is a profound dignity in allowing someone to struggle without interference. I learned this the hard way after I burned out from journalism. I came home to this small coastal town, exhausted, hollowed out, and ready to quit everything. My mother called me, worried. She started listing things I could do to get better. Sleep schedule changes. New hobbies. A trip to Paris. I listened to her, polite but distant, until finally, I snapped. I told her I didn’t need a plan. I needed her to just listen. To just hear how tired I was. She was stunned. She thought she was helping. But she wasn’t hearing me. She was trying to manage me. Once I explained that, she sat with me. She didn’t offer a single piece of advice for three hours. She just made tea. She held my hand. And in that silence, I felt seen for the first time in months. I felt like my pain mattered. Not because it was solved, but because it was witnessed. That is the power of non-fixing. It validates the reality of their experience. It says, 'Your feelings are real. They are valid. And you are not alone in carrying them.' When we stop trying to fix, we give permission for the other person to fully feel. And paradoxically, that fullness is what leads to release. You can’t move through grief if you’re constantly interrupted by solutions. You have to walk all the way through it. Holding space is walking beside them, step by step, without pulling ahead to show them the exit. Let’s get practical. Because I know some of you are listening right now, thinking, 'Okay, Tiegan, but what do I actually say?' Here are three simple phrases that can replace the urge to fix. First: 'That sounds really hard.' Simple. True. Validating. Second: 'I’m so sorry you’re going through this.' No explanation needed. Third: 'Do you want to be heard, or do you want help solving this?' This last one is a game-changer. It puts the ball in their court. It respects their agency. Most of the time, people just want to be heard. By asking, you avoid the trap of assuming you know what they need. It’s a small question, but it carries immense weight. It shows that you trust their judgment. It shows that you are there to support them, not to take over. Also, remember that it’s okay to admit when you’re struggling to hold space. If you feel overwhelmed, it’s honest to say, 'I care about you so much, and I feel helpless right now. I just want to sit with you.' Vulnerability is not weakness. It’s connection. It tells the other person that you are human too. That you are affected by their pain. And that shared humanity is often more comforting than any perfect solution. It doesn’t have to be perfect, it just has to be yours. Be present. Be real. Be there. We often talk about resilience as an individual trait. 'She’s so strong.' 'He bounced back quickly.' But resilience is not a solo sport. It is a collective art. It is woven together by the people around us. When we hold space for each other, we build a network of safety. We create a community where it’s okay to fall apart. Where it’s okay to not be okay. This is radical. In a world that prizes productivity and positivity, choosing to sit in the darkness with someone is a revolutionary act. It challenges the toxic idea that we must always be happy, always be moving forward, always be fixing. It says that rest is allowed. That grief is allowed. That being stuck is allowed. And in that allowance, true healing begins. We don’t heal by pushing through. We heal by being held. So, I invite you to try this today. Notice the next time someone shares pain with you. Notice your urge to fix. Feel it rise in your chest. And then, gently, let it go. Choose instead to just be there. To listen. To witness. To hold the space. It might feel awkward at first. You might feel like you’re doing nothing. But you are doing everything. You are giving the gift of your presence. And that is a gift no amount of advice can ever match. Trust that process. Trust that they are stronger than they feel, and you are enough just by being there. Thank you for letting me into your day. Thank you for listening, really listening. I’ll be here next time, ready to explore the messy, beautiful work of coming back. Until then, be gentle with yourselves. And with each other.