Latest / The Resident Podcast / Was Strike 'general', Government rides rough-shod? & 'humanistic' integration – News Review – Ep.27
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Well, thank you for being here. Much precious.
- 0:03Speaker 2: For the fifth of June twenty twenty six, thirty minutes
- 0:06of news spotlight Here Chris Grahame.
- 0:09Speaker 1: So glad you are, Chris, How are you?
- 0:11Speaker 3: I'm fine. How are you guys?
- 0:12Speaker 1: Yeah, yeah, we're good. We're good. We've got lots to
- 0:15talk about.
- 0:15Speaker 2: When you joined, Natasha and I behind the scenes, we
- 0:17were already ranting this morning. So we've got petrol in
- 0:21the tank and we're ready to go.
- 0:23Speaker 1: We'll start with you because you're our special guest.
- 0:25Speaker 2: Great to have you back from essential business and you
- 0:28take us to the action nearer to the capitol, which
- 0:30is always good.
- 0:31Speaker 1: So it's excellent to talk to you.
- 0:33Speaker 2: And I think you had some sort of dealings with
- 0:35the general strike of this week. It's been a very
- 0:37interesting week in Portragal, isn't it, With a general strike,
- 0:39a public holiday, other public workers bridging between the two weekends.
- 0:43Speaker 1: I'm a notably so they've had nine days off.
- 0:46Speaker 2: By the time it gets to next Monday when they're
- 0:48back at their desk, their workload's going to have piled
- 0:50up in that time.
- 0:52Speaker 1: Chris, how was it look?
- 0:55Speaker 4: I think it from my feeling, it was a bit
- 0:57of a damp squid. The only problem that I noticed
- 0:59was that the Metro was completely shut down. And but
- 1:05you know, I've just been glancing through the figures today
- 1:09from the different sectors and it, you know, it just
- 1:12wasn't that well attended to be honest, right, you know
- 1:15you had.
- 1:18Speaker 3: I can just run you through some.
- 1:20Speaker 1: Statistics, now, great, thank you.
- 1:22Speaker 3: I mean I mean, so.
- 1:24Speaker 4: If we look at transport public transport, yes that was affected,
- 1:27but even so it was forty nine percent. There are
- 1:29a lot of drivers that didn't sign up to it,
- 1:32so to all intentsive purposes, it might have been you
- 1:35might have seen delays, but there was a service. It
- 1:40wasn't completely shut down specifically on the buses, although the
- 1:44Metro was so that that was the main thing there.
- 1:49And interestingly enough people had prepared for this by bringing
- 1:53their cars into Lisbon, so there were more cars than normal.
- 1:56And of course the tolls at the bridges, the two
- 1:59main bridges Lisbon, the Vasco de Gama and the Vincinca
- 2:04Brill they actually saw an increase in transit by one
- 2:09point two percent.
- 2:10Speaker 3: Okay, so the.
- 2:12Speaker 4: EDP, the big energy company you know, that only had
- 2:16an adhesion of three percent, Trades and services was only
- 2:20five percent. All the shopping centers were open, by the way,
- 2:25and of course you know private hospitals zero percent, okay,
- 2:32more negligible, It's difficult.
- 2:34Speaker 3: To say exactly.
- 2:36Speaker 4: Hotels zero percent as well, banks, construction and farmers was
- 2:42close to zero percent, okay. Public sector workers was only
- 2:47twenty three percent, and that really shocked me. Now, I
- 2:49thought it would be a lot more than that. Education
- 2:53unfortunately suffered. The figures aren't out yet, but it's anywhere
- 2:56between thirty five and forty five percent adherent. So obviously
- 3:00a lot of schools we were not operating. They basically
- 3:04closed the schools, or some schools were open, but obviously
- 3:07operating with a reduced staff. So, and also the banking
- 3:13sector was completely normal. There was a very low adhesion there.
- 3:18In m was one point six percent. So the ambulances
- 3:21were running fine. And with regards to operations that were
- 3:28already scheduled and booked, seventy two percent of those went ahead.
- 3:33Speaker 3: And that's quite interesting.
- 3:35Speaker 4: Although there was a forty five reduction overall in the hospitals, okay,
- 3:42and all of this seems to completely countervene or contradict
- 3:48I'm using Portuguese. Now, it's terrible, isn't it.
- 3:50Speaker 3: You've contravene. I don't think.
- 3:55Speaker 4: Yeah, all of the numbers seemed to contravene what the
- 3:59union said. The union reckoned that it was between you know,
- 4:05sixty to seventy percent successful, and I just don't know
- 4:10where they got those figures from. I mean, maybe it
- 4:12was just, you know, it was the number of their
- 4:16members as syndicated members's that adhere to the strike, but
- 4:21that wasn't really made clear in any of the articles
- 4:24that I kind of read. So the question is where
- 4:30do we go now? I mean, oh, coming back to
- 4:33the television screen images which showed a lot of disturbances
- 4:41around the Parliament building and also the Prime Minister's residence
- 4:45in Roussin Bental, I mean I seem to see more
- 4:48police there than I did actually actually demonstrators, which was
- 4:54quite interesting.
- 4:55Speaker 3: And the cameras focused on small groups.
- 4:57Speaker 4: Of demonstrators, but they were mostly peaceful, and of course,
- 5:02obviously the television cameras honed in on some kind of
- 5:06scuffles between the police and some of the protesters, and
- 5:09it turned out that only six people were arrested.
- 5:12Speaker 3: So I mean, it's not a big thing.
- 5:15Speaker 4: And the police said that of those people that they
- 5:17questioned that had been arrested, but obviously they questioned all
- 5:20of them, they were all from far right groups, so
- 5:24that had nothing to do with the strike whatsoever.
- 5:27Speaker 1: They'd just taken advantage of the situation. It just took.
- 5:29Speaker 3: Advantage of the situation exactly.
- 5:32Speaker 4: So I think all in all we can safely say
- 5:36it was a damp squid. And I've got to say
- 5:38that this is a hugely complex problem. Why because we've
- 5:45been hearing from years, not only from the previous socialist
- 5:48government under Antonio Koshna, but also under this government under
- 5:53Luisia Montenegro. We've been hearing from the economists and their advisors,
- 5:58and they all said, they all sink from the same
- 6:01hint tune. They all say Portugal's product of it is
- 6:04extremely low, Portugal's competitiveness is really low. They cannot put
- 6:10the wages up. They just cannot put the wages up
- 6:14anymore than they already are.
- 6:16Speaker 3: Why.
- 6:16Speaker 4: Because ninety five percent of the companies in this country
- 6:20are either small or micro companies, and that is just
- 6:24absolutely shocking when you consider that there aren't that many
- 6:27big companies.
- 6:29Speaker 3: So the government is stuck.
- 6:31Speaker 4: Between a rock and a hard place because it's got
- 6:33a ballooning national debt. It's set to have a budget
- 6:37at zero for the end of this year and probably
- 6:44in the minus next year, but probably not by very
- 6:46much zero point one percent, so the government doesn't really
- 6:51have a lot of room to maneuver, I think to
- 6:54improve things now. Of course, there's this argument about the
- 6:58way the our Bank isn't there this sort of idea
- 7:01is what's that, Well, the our bank is where what
- 7:03they want to make They want to make things more
- 7:05flexible so people can be made to work at you know,
- 7:09over time they will obviously they will get paid on this,
- 7:14but some people say it's an affront of their family life,
- 7:16to their their social lives.
- 7:18Speaker 3: And of course there's a lot of resistance to that.
- 7:23So it's really difficult.
- 7:24Speaker 5: Now.
- 7:24Speaker 4: It goes to parliament next month. I think it's on
- 7:27the sixth of July, when it will be sixteenth Chris, Oh,
- 7:32I'm sorry, Yes, you're absolutely right.
- 7:34Speaker 5: I think it's the eighteenth. It comes to parliament very soon.
- 7:37Speaker 3: Okay, yeah, I'm sorry. I don't know why I said
- 7:39the sixth of July.
- 7:40Speaker 4: Anyway, So it's going to Parliament on the eighteenth of July,
- 7:42when it will be kind of discussed. Now Andre Venturo,
- 7:47who's of course this figure from the far right group Seger,
- 7:52he seems to think that it will be voted, it
- 7:55will be it will be thrown out of parliament, that
- 7:58it won't get through.
- 8:00Speaker 3: But actually, look, do.
- 8:04Speaker 4: You I mean, do you know how many hours have
- 8:06been set spent discussing this issue over the.
- 8:09Speaker 2: Last talking of in efficiency, something like nine hundred.
- 8:14Speaker 4: Yeah, it's it's something, it's absolutely exactly that. It was
- 8:17absolutely ridiculous amount of hours. Yeah, you know, they've just
- 8:22gone round and round in circlest un around in circles,
- 8:25you know, and they're now saying I've been reading some
- 8:29commentators and some of them seem to suggest that we
- 8:31should just scrap the whole thing and go back to
- 8:33the beginning. Don't how that's going to change anything, really. Look,
- 8:39I've got a lot of sympathy in certain sectors. For example,
- 8:41It's quite clear for me, for example, in the hotel sector,
- 8:44which employs nearly ten percent of the population, isn't that
- 8:48yeah it is nine percent, okay, but it's a lot,
- 8:52and you know, they have I know some people that
- 8:56work in hotels and they rarely, they hardly ever get
- 9:02weekends off. They work, you know, and often the people
- 9:07that I do know, they're often called in to work
- 9:11on their days off, you know, and that they're given
- 9:16days off in liu, and sometimes those days off in
- 9:19liu they accumulate and they can never seem to use them.
- 9:22So okay, under the law, they do get recompense financially,
- 9:26because you know, I've got one friend that works in
- 9:28a hotel actually, and he said, my life, my life
- 9:32is just work with my colleagues because I can't have
- 9:35a social life.
- 9:36Speaker 2: And would you include teachers as well in those who I.
- 9:41Speaker 4: Think teachers is a slightly different thing. I know a
- 9:43lot of teachers. Actually, I've got my best friend as
- 9:46a teacher, and he works, he works very hard.
- 9:50Speaker 3: He chooses to do so.
- 9:51Speaker 4: He does a lot of private lessons because he's a
- 9:53maths teacher. And yes he is called in sometimes, particularly
- 9:58when people are off sick. But he says, the problem
- 10:01there is they're not they're spending so much time on
- 10:05office work.
- 10:07Speaker 3: That is the issue there. So you know, rather than.
- 10:12Speaker 4: That they're teaching and doing that, you know, spending all
- 10:14this time on spreadsheets that they've got to produce.
- 10:17Speaker 1: These these we need to move on.
- 10:19Speaker 2: But these these problems are not peculiar to Portugal, of course, but.
- 10:22Speaker 3: No, no, no, no no, we will have our.
- 10:24Speaker 2: Own ways of dealing with this finally, perhaps, but thank
- 10:28you for your research and analysis that was really helpful
- 10:31as a as a kind of post mortem on the
- 10:33on the general strike, the takeaway being it wasn't very general.
- 10:37Speaker 4: Uh well, it depends who you talk to. And it's
- 10:40too late. The numbers won't really officially be out until
- 10:45probably the middle of next week or even later, so
- 10:48it's too it's too soon to say, and we don't
- 10:52know the figures, financial figures. But I can tell you
- 10:55that there was quite a high adherence at BOSH, you know,
- 10:58the German company Boss.
- 11:01Speaker 3: Yeah, so that's a private company, so there was quite.
- 11:04Speaker 4: A high adherence in some industrial sectors.
- 11:09Speaker 1: A headline writer's dream with BOSH being.
- 11:12Speaker 2: Well, yeah, yes, okay, thank you very much. I'm sure
- 11:21you'll have comments on our selections as well. The general
- 11:25strike there and the twelfth such strike I believe since
- 11:28the Carnation Revolution, and you've seen a few of those coming. Go,
- 11:31let's see what happens in the aftermath of this one,
- 11:34and it is of course rolled up in lots of
- 11:36bigger issues, national geopolitical issues as well, of course, which
- 11:40makes it quite a difficult issue to deal with. Natasha
- 11:44is talking of difficult issues and what have you chosen
- 11:48for this week?
- 11:50Speaker 5: Well, I've chosen something that definitely was kept off the radar,
- 11:56but it was very chilling. So you see, I've got
- 11:58this theory that things like Chris has just been talking
- 12:02to us about very you know, they're promoted in such
- 12:06a way that the general strike was made out to
- 12:09be a huge thing, and he thinks it was probably
- 12:12a bit of a damp squib, but that doesn't stop
- 12:14the media from you know, talking it out, talking about
- 12:17the government talking about it, the union's talking about it,
- 12:19and all the while other things are happening that, for
- 12:22some reason rather the authorities don't want us to know about.
- 12:26And I think that's where the real news is. And unfortunately,
- 12:29two things happened on Friday. I think one may have
- 12:32happened on Saturday, but I think they're both on Friday,
- 12:35and this is normally the day when if they're going
- 12:38to say anything a little bit complicated, they say it
- 12:42usually after three o'clock in the afternoon in the hope
- 12:45that people are not listening and by Monday they'll have forgotten.
- 12:49But I do try and work at weekends, not because
- 12:52I kind of want to, but I think that we
- 12:54need to keep looking to check what's going on. And
- 12:57so I found these two things. Now, one of them
- 12:59was a very very interesting article written by a lawyer
- 13:02and she was just very troubled by what's been going
- 13:05on in a coffege deal, where the people are trying
- 13:09so hard to fight a lithium mine that's going to
- 13:13completely and utterly destroy their rural way of life where
- 13:18they do a lot of farming. It's Unesco World Heritage
- 13:23farming land, and where they produce beef that has got
- 13:27a special seal, and where that they're dependent on their
- 13:32water and all kinds of things, and all this will
- 13:35be affected by the mind. And as this lawyer was writing,
- 13:39it was it's a bit chilling to see that in
- 13:43this area everybody is against even the public prosecutors officers
- 13:48said there's something wrong with the way that the permission
- 13:51was given and it needs to be investigated. And yet
- 13:55the government continues to absolutely bulldoze on and say no, no,
- 14:00this project must be allowed. As the lawyer said, it's
- 14:04getting to the point that the government has created a
- 14:07precedent so that people's private property is no longer private
- 14:11and that is very chilling. Then at the same on
- 14:16the same day, probably around the same time, the Minister
- 14:20for Environment and Energy and we this out. We say
- 14:24environment and energy, But if you think about it, environment energy,
- 14:29they're they're not Why are they.
- 14:31Speaker 2: Linked uncomfortable bedfellows, you might say yes anyway.
- 14:36Speaker 5: So the Minister Environment of Energy so came out with
- 14:39the marvelous thing. He said, you know, we have tremendous
- 14:42respect for all our agencies, the ones that advise with
- 14:45technical reports on whether a project is good for you know,
- 14:50the environment, or whether it might harm the environment. We
- 14:54have tremendous respect for these agencies that you know, we
- 14:58want to reserve the possibility to consider that no matter
- 15:04what these agencies think, we'll do what we think. And
- 15:08so this is what's happening. They are now going to
- 15:11they're creating this mechanism so that projects that has deemed
- 15:18to be harmful to the environment will be allowed anyway,
- 15:21because they will panda to Brussels agenda for the energetic
- 15:29transition or whatever, and you know, the collateral effects have
- 15:36just got to be taken on the nose. And this
- 15:39really worried me. And then I found a quote, and
- 15:43I honestly think this quote needs to be read out
- 15:47because obviously most people won't have seen it because very
- 15:50few well I don't think any other reporters wrote about it.
- 15:55But I thought this quote was one one of the
- 15:57mining website on one of the mining Facebook groups, and
- 16:02I just felt this is so true. So it's in
- 16:06the link and people can read it for themselves if
- 16:08they like. I mean I can, I can read it out,
- 16:11but it made me so sad.
- 16:13Speaker 1: Just go ahead, go ahead, read the quote.
- 16:16Speaker 5: So this woman wrote, it's my conviction that if this
- 16:19government completes its term, there'll be nothing left of the
- 16:21country period. I'm talking about the megalomaniac phot photov all
- 16:25take projects. These are in the Baila Aisha that will
- 16:28ruin agricultural reserves and the populations that preserve and depend
- 16:32on them. I'm talking about lithium and tungsten mining that
- 16:34will ruin everything else, including our only natural part, pineda jades.
- 16:39We can safely say goodbye to nature tourism and rural tourism.
- 16:43Goodbye to cattle grazing and sustainable agriculture. Goodbye to the
- 16:46biodiversity that is fundamental to the health of ecosystems. Goodbye
- 16:50to ecosystems. With a reshuffling of those in charge of
- 16:53public environmental services, the only aim is to pave the
- 16:57way for multimillion dollar deals from the European Union. They
- 17:00are creating companies with that sole purpose. Further south, the
- 17:06outlook is not encouraging. Goodbye Iberian Licks, and with the
- 17:09erosion of the Portuguese coast, we can soon say goodbye
- 17:12to agarf tourism. With a massive destruction of our natural
- 17:15heritage from north to south of the country, coupled with
- 17:18the systematic destruction that public services, health, housing, education, justice
- 17:23have been suffering for decades, we will have no country
- 17:26left to tell the tale of the country we once were,
- 17:29with good people, good food, good weather, and beautiful landscapes.
- 17:33Only memories will remain. Now, you could say that is
- 17:37very over dramatic, but there is such a point because
- 17:41if you I mean, you might remember that last week
- 17:44we were talking and I said that when I first
- 17:47came here. I don't know how long you've been here, Chris. Well,
- 17:49when I first came here over forty years ago, I
- 17:52just remember a country where people were poor, but they
- 17:55were so much happier. There was so much less anxiety,
- 18:00there was so much less anger, and there was a
- 18:02great deal less violence in the urban centers. And I
- 18:06think the reason people are not happy is the way
- 18:08things have been going and the way people have been
- 18:10overriding the fundamental values of life in the in the
- 18:16name of obviously big business and progress.
- 18:19Speaker 2: Yes, that quote is very moving, and I'll make sure
- 18:21there's a link to it in the sleeve notes. As
- 18:24it were, it would appear based on what you were saying, Chris,
- 18:28with the response to the general strike action and what
- 18:31you've just shared with us, Natasha, is that we've moved from.
- 18:33Speaker 1: Being poor and happy to being poor and unhappy.
- 18:37Speaker 2: Maybe the next we can move to the next quadrants
- 18:40and that can be addressed. And some of the things
- 18:43that are being said there that we I think we'd
- 18:44all agree we want to preserve about this country, especially
- 18:48that last sentence. You know, the beautiful food, the good food,
- 18:51the good people, and the beautiful landscapes, That's why a
- 18:54lot of people, you know, in this community, the foreigners
- 18:57are drawn here. They can see that, and it's quite
- 19:00right that they should be drawn to their attention that
- 19:01there are agendas working against that.
- 19:03Speaker 1: Chris, what's your view on this?
- 19:05Speaker 4: Well, I understand everything that's being said here, but I think,
- 19:09you know, when you look at Portugal in general, I
- 19:14think it's one of the countries in Europe with the
- 19:15highest percentage of kind of unspot spoiled or agricultural green
- 19:20belt lands, right because we have fairly small centers of population,
- 19:26you know, it's it's it's much higher than the UK,
- 19:28and that has a surprising amount of green belt land
- 19:32per percentage in terms of percentage of built up area.
- 19:36And I think the other problem is is, yes, it's
- 19:39the cost of progress. This the fact that we found
- 19:43one of the largest lithium deposits, you know, in the
- 19:46world and certainly in Europe on our doorstep, means that
- 19:50Portugal actually has a chance to become excellent in a
- 19:53certain area and actually make some money. And you know,
- 19:57if the government is poor. This put, all governments in
- 20:01Portugal are poor, and they need to make money to
- 20:04pay for all the services. The education, the health that
- 20:09we need, and it's going to give a lot. It's
- 20:11going to give ultimately jobs, particularly in the area where
- 20:13these lithium processing plants are. And I think it is
- 20:18it is a difficult one because we can all have
- 20:21this wonderful, idyllic, rural image of what Portugal was like
- 20:25in the nineteen seventies. I've actually been here thirty years
- 20:27and Natasha so not as long as you, you know,
- 20:31And if you look at the newsreels, the state sponsored
- 20:35newsreels from the sat the end of the salas are
- 20:38years when television first kind of came in, it does
- 20:40look like everybody's all really happy, you know, hanging out there,
- 20:45washing and on trees kind of. You know.
- 20:50Speaker 3: But you know, I've.
- 20:51Speaker 4: Spoken to people that lived during those salas are years,
- 20:54elderly people, and they told me that there was just
- 20:57complete poverty.
- 20:58Speaker 3: The whole country was governed.
- 21:00Speaker 4: By just about like a dozen large families. And yes
- 21:05there was order, yes there were not.
- 21:08Speaker 3: There weren't strikes.
- 21:09Speaker 4: Because you had a very extensive secret police network. But
- 21:14was it happier. I don't know whether it really was.
- 21:17I think a lot and I.
- 21:18Speaker 5: Remember Chris, I didn't come during the dictatorship. I came
- 21:21well after, it was eighty six ish, and so by
- 21:27then we'd gone into Europe and people were already benefiting,
- 21:31and that people were free. I mean, there were elections
- 21:34and everything else, and they were a great deal happier.
- 21:38But you know, the thing about the nthean thing, I
- 21:40think in a way you're talking it slightly up. Yes,
- 21:43we've got the largest deposits in Europe, but Europe's deposits
- 21:49are piddling in comparison to the other countries like Chile,
- 21:52and you know what I mean. And therefore, to completely
- 21:57devastate a tiny little country for the sake of what
- 22:01is going to be limited going to it's not something
- 22:05that continues. It's not a you know, self sustaining thing.
- 22:09Once we've got it up, it's gone. And then we
- 22:12just got all these holes in the ground. And as
- 22:16somebody has I remember years ago, I did a storia
- 22:19from one of these engineering people, and he said, there
- 22:23is absolutely no point destroying a mountain for a handful
- 22:26of mi lithium, which is what basically it's going to
- 22:29amount to in the large global scheme of things. And
- 22:34I think that's just the thing. The other thing, of course,
- 22:36is that governments are also I know, they've got to
- 22:39pay for services and everything because they do also have
- 22:41to serve their people. And if that people are all
- 22:45adamant that they don't want something, it doesn't make sense
- 22:48to say no, no, no, but you must have it.
- 22:50Speaker 2: That's a great point that we shouldn't forget that perhaps
- 22:54the governments are there to serve people.
- 22:58Speaker 1: At the moment.
- 23:00Speaker 3: But yeah, they are.
- 23:01Speaker 4: But I think we all know in the reality of
- 23:05things is that that's just for that's just on, that's
- 23:09just serious when it comes down to its Unfortunately, it's
- 23:15money that talk cloud.
- 23:17Speaker 2: Chris No, take your point on that, and I think
- 23:20people would be less aggrieved or upset if they saw
- 23:25the benefit of that money. That's that's the problem is that,
- 23:27you know, we've got a.
- 23:28Speaker 1: Number of comments coming in.
- 23:29Speaker 2: Thank you very much to simply Live to Gemini, who
- 23:33are here this morning with some you know, real, real
- 23:35first personal experience of what we're talking about here and
- 23:39the problem here of course, in my opinion, says simply Live.
- 23:42The government is poor due to corruption and mismanagement, not
- 23:44due to lack of incoming money. And that's the standing
- 23:46view I think generally speaking, isn't it. So, Yeah, the
- 23:49money is going to come in from lithium or tourism
- 23:51or wherever it's coming from, but we're not going to
- 23:52see the benefit of any of it. That's perhaps the
- 23:54perception that needs to change, and the benefit people need
- 23:57to feel such that it's worth the stroke or the
- 24:00compromise or the pain, such that public services and quality
- 24:05of life goes up. And that I think that's people
- 24:08why people were striking last week, right or is it?
- 24:10Is it yeah this week while they were striking this
- 24:12week and not feeling that anything's changing, either from striking
- 24:16or from all these proposed plans chilling as you say, Natasha,
- 24:20you know people's private property is not really their property.
- 24:24That sounds very World Economic forum, does it not. And
- 24:28this whole idea of you know, we'll do what we
- 24:30want to anywhere, we'll listen to you, but ultimately we'll
- 24:32do what we want that doesn't create a very good view,
- 24:34does it of a future where the government's got your
- 24:36back necessarily?
- 24:37Speaker 4: Well, I mean, if you look at the TGV, for example,
- 24:41I mean, or any large major public works project, it's
- 24:45quite normal the new airport will be one. It's quite
- 24:48normal that there are compulsory purchase orders. Yeah, those people
- 24:53are compensated. You know, it is unfortunate. I understand people
- 24:57don't want to move, but I think in the grandest
- 25:00scheme of things, you know, it's a fact of life
- 25:03in any country that people, you know, when governments and
- 25:08companies go in to create a resource that will generate
- 25:15millions and millions, if not billions, over a determined period
- 25:19of time, it's inevitable this is going to happen. I
- 25:24remember the people won over the wasn't it? Wasn't it
- 25:28done in Alsajou? There was the oil thing. Do you remember?
- 25:32Do you remember that story?
- 25:36Speaker 3: Yeah?
- 25:36Speaker 4: I mean, and that was kind of okay. In the end,
- 25:38it didn't go ahead. What doesn't seem to have gone
- 25:40ahead because the costs of it were at far outweighed
- 25:43to benefits in the end. So I don't think there's
- 25:45anything to do with people complaining.
- 25:47Speaker 3: Ultimately, I think it.
- 25:50Speaker 5: Was also because let's face it, they were this idiotic
- 25:54country was trying to jump on the fossil fuel bandwagon,
- 25:57just as Europe was saying, we mascow green. So in
- 26:00the end, you know that all the arguments fell away.
- 26:03Because I do think there are probably enormous gas reserves
- 26:07off the off the coast. It's just that it's just
- 26:10no longer politically correct to be digging for them, is it?
- 26:15And nobody wants yes.
- 26:18Speaker 4: In some countries in Europe, it isn't that in America
- 26:21would be different.
- 26:22Speaker 2: Well might drill baby drill. Might be drill baby drills
- 26:26soon here definitely. Well, I've only got a few minutes
- 26:30for my contribution here.
- 26:31Speaker 1: I'm not complaining.
- 26:32Speaker 6: I'm not complaining or bitter, but I'll put it in
- 26:35here because because it's it's relevant to us foreigners here
- 26:40in Portugal or however you see yourself, and I've got
- 26:44Portugal rejects aggressive policies against immigrants, given what's been going
- 26:49on recently in the sense I think that some foreigners
- 26:51and immigrants are feeling not treated in the best possible
- 26:54way in certain instances and how they how they're being
- 26:59managed bureaucally.
- 27:01Speaker 2: Very interesting here. I think I think you may have
- 27:04a different view Natasha on this, but very good to
- 27:06see the minister at least saying this that those aggressive
- 27:09policies against immigrants will be rejected. This is Antonio let Amaro,
- 27:17who has spoken out ahead of tomorrow's So this will
- 27:21be today's built forum on migration and Development, which I
- 27:26think is very high level and should bring some relief,
- 27:31I hope, at least only if in words to the
- 27:34troubled foreigners here in Portugal a rejection. It would seem
- 27:39of some of the tougher policies around Europe.
- 27:42Speaker 1: What do you make of this, Natasha?
- 27:44Speaker 2: Having written it, is it all sort of hype and
- 27:46spin or is it a genuine write it?
- 27:48Speaker 5: Really? I didn't write it was more of a looser text,
- 27:51to be honest, I don't believe anything that comes out
- 27:53of the mouth of this man anyway. But the reason
- 27:56I wrote it was because it was, you know, put
- 28:00Portugal in a better light, perhaps than other countries in
- 28:04the way that we deal with immigrants. But what they're
- 28:07talking about is not obviously the immigrants that have all
- 28:10been complaining about their nationality. This is just about accepting
- 28:13immigrants generally. And yeah, I think Portugal's decision to close
- 28:18the doors that well, you know, as they say, wide open,
- 28:21it was a very it was a very necessary decision.
- 28:24And now everything's calming down. People are disappearing because they can't,
- 28:28you know, they can't manage to get themselves legalized. And
- 28:31I think that, you know, we've got to show a
- 28:34really open and more humanist approach in order to get
- 28:38some immigrants in the future, because of course we will
- 28:42still need them.
- 28:43Speaker 1: Yes, yes, Chris.
- 28:46Speaker 3: Well, I agree with the Tasha.
- 28:48Speaker 4: I think any country has to have an immigration policy,
- 28:52you know, and you have to try and get those
- 28:54people in that your economy needs.
- 28:57Speaker 3: But what I'm.
- 28:58Speaker 4: Reading and what I've been hearing as their immigration associations,
- 29:03whether they are basically saying that a lot of people
- 29:07are wanting to be repatriated because they are not only
- 29:11the yes today no government statistics on this, which is
- 29:16quite shocking. There's no the government isn't monitoring this, so
- 29:19you have to go to the immigration associations. But it
- 29:22and it at both ends. For example, did you know
- 29:24fifty percent of all Americans that come here, and they're
- 29:27they're quite high net wealth individuals in general, or affluent
- 29:31at least, they go back because they heard yes, yeah,
- 29:34they can't adapt for whatever reason, and they get disappointed
- 29:37with all the red tape bureaucracy.
- 29:39Speaker 3: They find it over complicated here.
- 29:42Speaker 4: And then of course a lot of Bangladeshis are now
- 29:45going back now, I happen to stray looking for a
- 29:50restaurant where I was meeting some friends. Story yeah, and
- 29:56hear Martin Munige, And I ended up in a street
- 29:59and I actually thought I was I was in kind
- 30:03of India or Bangladesh, and the poverty that I saw
- 30:10it was absolutely kind of shocking, and I couldn't believe
- 30:14I was in Portugal and I was in Lisbon, you know,
- 30:17and this is just behind al Mirant Rage, you know,
- 30:19where you have all these smart hotels now, And that
- 30:23was kind of quite shocking, and apparently, well we all
- 30:26know anyway, that people are living like ten to are
- 30:29you know, ten to a a few rooms sleeping on
- 30:33the front.
- 30:35Speaker 1: We certainly heard the kind of far right response to that.
- 30:37Speaker 2: Having in the outrage about it, perhaps the minister here
- 30:42is suggesting how that might be dealt with.
- 30:45Speaker 1: From a different and more human point of view.
- 30:48Speaker 2: We're certainly tightening our rules, he says, because we need
- 30:51to conclude now we have He didn't say that. I'm
- 30:53saying we need to conclude that we have significantly increased controls,
- 30:57but we also seek to do so while preserving fundamental
- 31:00rights and adopting an approach that is also very much
- 31:02focused on the integration of those who arrive a more humanist,
- 31:06humanistic integration, and you could argue, couln't you that those
- 31:08people have been let down in being allowed to live.
- 31:11Speaker 1: In the way that you describe there, Chris.
- 31:14Speaker 2: The ultimate goal is for the path to integration into
- 31:16society to be a holistic one, as you said, Natasha,
- 31:19only then is the immigration cycle truly safe and secure
- 31:22from the perspective of safety for the national community, but
- 31:26also safety for the immigrants themselves. As much as you
- 31:30have your reservations, I like the kind of his jib
- 31:32in terms of what he's saying, and I hope we
- 31:33can follow through on that on those words and see
- 31:36some practical action on that, Natasha of the Portugal Resident
- 31:39Chris Graham of Essential Business, thank you so much for
- 31:42tough issues, but excellent talking to you this morning, and
- 31:45have a great weekend.
- 31:45Speaker 1: Bond fore some mana and thanks everybody for give lovely
- 31:48to see you.
- 31:48Speaker 4: Chris, Lovely to see you Natasha in car. Thank you
- 31:51for the kind invite once and we'll.
- 31:52Speaker 1: See you again.
- 31:53Speaker 2: Chris has agreed to be a regular, so we'll see
- 31:55you again. To Chris, thank you very much.
- 31:57Speaker 3: Look forward to it,