Latest / The Sticky From The Inside Podcast / Collective Wisdom: Scaling Human Stories Without Losing Humanity
Transcript
- 0:10Hello and welcome to Sticky from the Inside, the employee engagement podcast that looks at how to build stickier, competition smashing, consistently successful organisations from the inside out.
- 0:22I'm your host Andy Goram and I'm on a mission to help more businesses turn the lights on behind the eyes of their employees, light the fires within them and create tons more success for everyone.
- 0:39This podcast is for all those who believe that's something worth going after and would like a little help and guidance in achieving that.
- 0:46Each episode we dive into the topics that can help create what I call stickier businesses, the sort of businesses where people thrive and love to work and where more customers stay with you and recommend you to others because they love what you do and why you do it.
- 1:03So, if you want to take the tricky out of being sticky, listen on.
- 1:10Okay then, we're living in a world where stories are everywhere from the ones we tell our children, the ones we tell each other and nowadays the ones algorithms create for us and even about us.
- 1:26Now we live in a time where AI can now write, speak and even imagine on our behalf and I think it raises a fascinating question for us, especially with our focus in this podcast on successful modern business and leadership.
- 1:44So, can storytelling still be authentic when machines are involved?
- 1:50Now, my guest today is James Warren who has spent years exploring exactly that space.
- 1:56He's the founder and CEO of Share More Stories, a research and communication business that's built a storytelling and insights platform called SEEQ that seeks to blend human emotion with artificial intelligence to help organizations understand and improve both the employee and customer experiences.
- 2:18Now, James believes that storytelling isn't just a way of communicating, but it's a way to connect, to adapt and to change.
- 2:26It helps us understand ourselves, each other and even what we might become.
- 2:32But as technology gets smarter at telling stories, where does that leave the human element?
- 2:39And what role do belonging, trust and imperfection play in helping us tell stories that still feel real and resonate with us?
- 2:50So, today I think we're going to dive into all of that and ask how storytelling can still build trust and belonging when AI is shaping more and more of what we see and believe.
- 3:04Because as machines get better at imitating us, I think the real challenge is holding onto our faith in what's genuinely human about the stories we tell and those we read.
- 3:16James, welcome to the show.
- 3:18Thank you so much, Andy.
- 3:19I'm really excited to be here and top up this conversation with you because it's so timely and so relevant.
- 3:26I'm just really excited to see what we explore together.
- 3:28Yeah, me too, mate.
- 3:29I have an idea in my head about where this conversation goes, but then I say that every time I sit down with a guest and then stuff happens.
- 3:36So, I'm really looking forward to it.
- 3:38Before we get going, tell us a little bit about you, your background and the stuff you're focused on today.
- 3:44Yeah, well, let's see.
- 3:46I think some of the most important things to describe is I have a family.
- 3:49I'm married and got four amazing kids, two are young adults and two are still school age.
- 3:55I live in Richmond, Virginia and I'm originally from New York.
- 3:58So, I grew up in New York and a lot of my childhood, young adulthood place in the city, which definitely shaped my view of life.
- 4:07But I've also moved around a lot when I was a kid.
- 4:08So, I started to see people in different environments and see things differently.
- 4:12And I think that gave me sort of a very personal connection to this notion of observing, interacting and engaging people and sort of seeing them and meeting them where they are.
- 4:22That's something that I just can't help but get away from.
- 4:24It's the way I'm wired.
- 4:25And I'm grateful for that because it definitely shows up in the work.
- 4:28I wound up meandering through college in terms of starting with economics, then switching to English Lit and then switching to creative writing.
- 4:38So, I think that also has a little bit of a background and seeded some of the things that show up for me in the professional journey.
- 4:46What we do today is we're really focused on helping, as you put it, companies and organizations.
- 4:51I mean, both the staff organization, but also non-profit organizations or public sector entities from brands really dive deep into the experiences people are having.
- 5:03And what we mean by that is so much of the data that's collected today, all over the place, touches on the who, the what, the where, the when.
- 5:13It doesn't really get into much of the how or the why.
- 5:16We really want to help people understand the why, the W-H-Y behind their experiences, because we think that's really where you can understand people more deeply.
- 5:25And I'm not huge on predicting the future, but I think you can be better prepared for that future if you really understand where people are coming from today.
- 5:33Yeah, I love that.
- 5:33I think that sort of sets up the conversation for today really nicely, actually, because I've heard you talk about storytelling being something more than communication, being a way that we, I guess, make sense of the world, right?
- 5:48And so tell us a little bit about that and why, perhaps, integrated with all of that, stories play such a powerful role in creating that sense of understanding, that sense of connection, and maybe point the way to change, because I'm really interested in that.
- 6:05You know, there's something about when we listen to a story or read a story from another human, it starts to activate stuff in us right away, because this is hard-coded into our DNA.
- 6:15And if you go back to the earliest versions of the human experience, even if it were just gathered around the campfire, even if it was just about saying, hey, don't go over there.
- 6:23There's danger.
- 6:25Let's migrate at this time of the year to a safer, better place.
- 6:29Those things were fundamental to survival.
- 6:33But as we started to advance as a storytelling, we added to it, we deepened it.
- 6:40We started to realize that those sort of primal needs, but staying connected to each other for safety, still delivered other benefits.
- 6:47They gave us the ability to create relationships, to form community, even in the most basic sense of five people living in five, you know, pre-industrial huts together.
- 7:01Those ideas of sort of beginning to say, hey, there's something different about us and these other living forms around us.
- 7:10We have this ability to connect, to listen, to share things.
- 7:13And so that basis of connection and community really sets the stage for learning, understanding, or saying, hey, you know, there might be something in your experience that I can relate to.
- 7:24And if I listen to you and I seek out what is common, I'm learning.
- 7:29I may not have to go experience danger to know that danger is there, because I'm listening to your story.
- 7:35But I also may be able to understand in a very real sense, what do we have in common?
- 7:40Not just how are we different, but what do we have in common?
- 7:43And so when you start talking about how do we navigate change as societies, as communities, as organizations, I think it requires two things.
- 7:52It requires our ability to empathize with one another, to sort of see ourselves in the other person, or the other group, or the other identity.
- 8:00But it also requires a new commitment, especially among leaders, to be vulnerable and to listen to stories of other people and groups, because that's how we will learn our way through these next several transformations that I think are ahead of us.
- 8:14I think that's fascinating, because I think this thing around stories in particular, and we've had various people either reference storytelling before within the episodes that we've done, or specifically wanting to talk about the power of storytelling.
- 8:31And connecting what they've talked about, and what I pick up from you, James, is that we're giving a bit of our humanity in a story.
- 8:42Outside of just communicating through bullet points or whatever else it might be, helping us connect the dots, taking a piece of the delivery, taking a piece of the human that's communicating with us at that time, that's what stories, more than anything, allow us to do.
- 9:00Is that the right?
- 9:01Yeah.
- 9:02You know, it is keeping the human, in the most literal sense, keeping our humanity in the forefront, in the center of our engagements and our interactions.
- 9:11And I think this is huge for brands and organizations today.
- 9:14It's been true for a very long time, by the way.
- 9:16I think, to your point, stories are beautiful in that we can constantly rediscover their value and their purpose.
- 9:22They really don't go stale, because it's stood the test of time in terms of 100,000 years, if you will.
- 9:30And so I think this idea that we live our lives through stories, we interact through stories, even at a subconscious level, that's what's happening.
- 9:38But the other part that's really interesting when you get intentional about the stories, is you start to realize that they are code and shortcut for how do people feel about this?
- 9:48What's important to them?
- 9:49What are they valuing?
- 9:51The literal telling of the story and what they choose to tell about their experience reveals those things, but it also gives us things to hook onto.
- 9:59And so that moves us into that space of turning what people are experiencing and sharing in their stories into nuggets of individual truth.
- 10:09We start to say, hey, there's a selective picture emerging here, kind of a collective wisdom that's emerging from this group that we should pay attention to.
- 10:18And I think that's the biggest challenge I've experienced in the work we do, is getting leaders to see and value that.
- 10:25Some are more and more doing that every day.
- 10:28But the last 25, 30, 40, 50 years of business has convinced leaders that they already should know the answers to questions.
- 10:36There shouldn't be any questions that they're asking that they don't know the answer to, which means that they're not learning very much in a rapidly changing environment.
- 10:46So I think this is also pushing almost philosophically on a different way to see organizations, customers, communities in ways that, while it's growing, there's still a lot of people out there who espouse that very predominant view of the last quarter century.
- 11:05I like this idea of collective wisdom through personal experience.
- 11:09I think that's a lovely juxtaposition of, hey, we're all feeling this, but it's expressed individually, but we can still pull out those nuggets.
- 11:16I love that.
- 11:16And if we relate that back to what you've just started
- 11:19to talk about here with a leadership focus, maybe, I know that you're very keen to think about
- 11:26the catalysts for change and adaptability and how storytelling particularly can be a real driver of
- 11:34those and maybe a multiplier of the effect of those things, or at least give us a real sense of
- 11:40understanding, helping people and organizations connect to missions or respond to uncertainty.
- 11:48How are you seeing that stuff evolve in practice and really solidifying or maybe accentuating the role that storytelling's playing in that context?
- 11:59I think when you're navigating a significant change, if that's a human, we always say, whenever the concept gets a little too fuzzy, reduce it to one human.
- 12:07If it were you, how would you feel about this?
- 12:09And then start to zoom out, right?
- 12:11Because you can almost always get an individual to empathize, to reconnect with the human aspect of this if you prompt them that way.
- 12:19And so when you think about what do people need to navigate change, especially big change, they want to feel secure, literally physically secure in the process.
- 12:28They'd love to feel emotionally secure in the process.
- 12:32And then they want to feel like there's a clear path to get where they need to go.
- 12:36So all of those things are things that leaders can provide.
- 12:39Their path is the vision, the strategy, right?
- 12:42You need to communicate it a lot.
- 12:43I think leaders get very bored of their messages after two or three times, like, what's the big deal?
- 12:48I've already said it.
- 12:48I don't want to keep saying this.
- 12:49I'm like, they haven't heard a second of what you've had to say because they're consumed by their fear of the unknown.
- 12:56They're consumed by the fear of uncertainty.
- 12:59So you will need to continue to message that, but you also will need to start showing them the pathway that you're about to lead them on into the great unknown is actually safe.
- 13:08And how do you do that?
- 13:09The physical safety is literally explaining how, you know, if we're going through a big organizational transformation that involves people in new roles, that these create things like opportunities for you to grow and thrive.
- 13:20If earning more and growing in your career is your desire, we'll be able to help you do that.
- 13:26If you can't, because you're downsizing, you need to explain to them how we've fought long and hard about the lead time that you're going to need to find your next career opportunity.
- 13:35And here are the resources we're going to support you.
- 13:36It's not a great message.
- 13:37It's not going to make everybody happy, but it's better than nothing.
- 13:40The emotional safety is where you actually have the most ability influence and impact this change journey for staff and even for your customers.
- 13:49The first step is to empathize with them.
- 13:52And you can't empathize if I don't know what you're going through.
- 13:55How do I know what you're going through?
- 13:56I invite you to tell me your story.
- 13:58What's your experience?
- 14:00How are you feeling about this?
- 14:01What's a time like this that you've actually done navigating that well?
- 14:05Could you and we learn together about how to do this well by examining changed experiences that you've navigated were really challenging, but that you got through.
- 14:15And, you know, we did this with one of our, one of our customers is a health and wellness brand that was navigating a tremendous amount transformation and change.
- 14:25And there was a point back to this sort of leader communication.
- 14:28There was a point at which there was rising frustration about staff feeling like, we don't know where we're going.
- 14:34We haven't heard these things and nobody's communicated.
- 14:36So my initial reaction was, Hey, you know, CC, you've got to communicate more.
- 14:42What I started asking is the communication, the problem, or is it there's stuff blocking in their reception of the messengers?
- 14:49We went back to the stories.
- 14:51We'd already collected a lot of stories from their staff.
- 14:54And basically the question that I asked our data was how are people navigating this change?
- 15:01And when you looked at the stories that were specifically related to the change journey that they were on, we found that people were in one of three stages.
- 15:10They were either in anxiety or anticipation or achievement.
- 15:16Anxiety meant I can't handle this.
- 15:18I don't understand what's going on.
- 15:20I feel aimless, directionless, rudderless, and that's fear, right?
- 15:24But the anticipation means, Hey, I've now seen enough sort of early signals that this is going to be okay.
- 15:31Um, early wins that this is not, we're not blowing ourselves up.
- 15:34I'm anticipating a better future.
- 15:36And then achievement was done something in this process that makes me feel very confident that we are going to be okay.
- 15:42And so now what you realize is it's not that you just need more messaging.
- 15:45You as leaders need to emotionally steward your team through each journey.
- 15:50You have to show them your vulnerability, that you know what it means to feel anxious.
- 15:55You know what it means to anticipate and you know what it means to achieve.
- 15:58And you're here to help them get there.
- 15:59Once they heard that and switched, it was a game changer in terms of how they were able to show the organization where they were and where they were going with more alignment and resistance.
- 16:10And did that, I mean, I love your point about leaders getting bored with their own story.
- 16:16You know, I've done lots of work in hospitality and I swear to God restaurants and businesses create new menus far too frequently for customers.
- 16:25Customers do not see the menu as often as you do.
- 16:28It's not that tired guys.
- 16:31Um, leaders, the leadership point you make about telling stories or giving that message I think is so well-made because they've probably spent goodness knows how long fashioning that story or that, or, or let's hope they have.
- 16:43Um, and then they've told it a few times.
- 16:46It feels like a few times, or, you know, I've told this story 10 times.
- 16:50Most people may have seen you talk about it 10 times.
- 16:53They have not taken in the message 10 times in its totality at all.
- 16:58And I, I love this notion, uh, whether it's chief evangelist offer officer, or like you've just maybe there's, I mean, there's no, I can't think of many CEOs that would take the title of chief emotion officer, but I do like this note notion of look, this is about the connection.
- 17:14I'm a massive believer that businesses who really get this stuff and who supercharged their performance on a sustainable basis have somehow found that connection between where the business is going, what drives the business to get there and what drives the individuals who are working within that business.
- 17:30If we can find that sort of connection, that's the pixie dust, uh, for, you know, sustainable, amazing performance.
- 17:37And I just love the notion of this ongoing job of the leader in that business or leadership in that business of just constantly telling and refining and making sure people connect to that story.
- 17:50It's about connection.
- 17:52I mean, and I really believe that, you know, people sometimes think that that's a squishy thing.
- 17:56I'm like, well, let's play out the opposite, do a quick thought experiment.
- 17:59How much progress have you made with people who have not connected?
- 18:03And the answer is like, pretty little, you know, not much, or it's been, you know, sort of raiding against the grain, trying really, really hard to convince people to do things that they don't intuitively want to do, feel that they should do.
- 18:14So connection becomes that place where we go from us versus them to we, we're navigating this.
- 18:20It's not leadership versus staff or brand versus customers.
- 18:24It's we, you know, when you, when you have a, we a lot, you can get done.
- 18:28So connection to me is, is a precursor to forming bigger.
- 18:31We is bigger.
- 18:32Uses that allow the brand or the organization to, to say, this is a journey we're taking together.
- 18:37This is not a journey we're doing to you.
- 18:40You know, when, as, as customers, we experience this all the time, you know, you sometimes we wonder, we scratch our heads on the center of the experience.
- 18:48How long did they decide this was good for us or ready to be rolled out?
- 18:54Because the experience sucks from your point of view.
- 18:56And so you wonder, you know what, maybe I'm an outlier to them, or maybe they just aren't processing as well.
- 19:02Collective wisdom has to reveal to them.
- 19:05How does your product make people feel?
- 19:06What does your culture make people feel?
- 19:08Why does that matter to the experience and what can you do about it?
- 19:11I think those are fundamental questions that more and more leaders need to ask themselves if they want to grow their businesses and organizations.
- 19:18Yeah.
- 19:19I absolutely agree with that.
- 19:22I think this is what it's going to be so easy for me to kind of just continue to talk to you about all the emotional connection and belonging.
- 19:30And I don't want to ignore that at all.
- 19:32And I think we've come back to that, but I want to bring in the other side of this kind of conversation.
- 19:37And then maybe we'll meet at the, at the result of these things, because I want us to think about the AI piece here, the machine piece in storytelling.
- 19:49So we've broadly talked about the importance of storytelling, the role it plays for all of those key things around connection and change and adaptability and performance.
- 19:58And your work specifically is looking to gather more stories, understand more stories, analyze more stories, tell more stories.
- 20:09And to do that, you are really digging into the use of AI in that space and your platform Seek, which I'd love you to tell us a bit about tries to do that at some sort of scale.
- 20:21We've just talked about the deep emotion element of storytelling.
- 20:25And now we're going to kind of broadly bridge into this topic of AI and storytelling.
- 20:30And I don't know, we're looking at one deeply human thing and one deeply machine-based thing.
- 20:38And can AI really understand, enhance that human emotion stuff, or is it still struggling with that sort of stuff?
- 20:49And based on my own work with AI, trying to sort of talk emotionally or understand things emotionally, most of the time it needs a lot of help.
- 20:58And something is generally lost in translation because it's aggregating or averaging a load of stuff.
- 21:04So I don't know, I've asked about 60 questions in that piece there, James.
- 21:08I'm sorry.
- 21:09Take me for it, my friend.
- 21:10This is the mega question.
- 21:13I love it.
- 21:13So we'll ping on this for a minute.
- 21:17Here's the transition point I see.
- 21:19The leaders who understand the value of connection, understand the value of human centered culture, brand, and impact, they get this intuitively, but they still don't know how to do it.
- 21:29So that's definitely where we come in.
- 21:31So the leaders that don't value those things, it's a really hard sell.
- 21:34And there may be functional reasons why they're not ready to embrace this kind of leadership or thinking.
- 21:40And some of that is just, how's their business performing?
- 21:42We tend to seek out large, mature industries where organic growth is hard to come by, past the low, mid-single digits, because those leaders are generally like, hey, we've got to find pathways to growth, whether it's innovation, new brand, new product.
- 21:58And that sets up the change sort of precipice.
- 22:01How are you going to get from here to there?
- 22:03We're more receptive to ideas about how to get from here to there.
- 22:06There's still a part of their leadership brain that is used to quantifying things, used to earning things that feel intuitively true into things that they can measure and observe.
- 22:15And that's where SEEQ comes in, because we are quantifying the emotion in people's experiences.
- 22:20We are quantifying prevalence of certain themes that show up in their stories and experiences.
- 22:26Before we talk about how we do that, I got to just tell you, this is always on our brain.
- 22:30And my partner, our CTO, his name is Andy Citizen.
- 22:34He's a deeply human-centered developer, programmer, strategist.
- 22:39And he was actually checking out a podcast recently.
- 22:44Podcast was entirely made in Manhattan.
- 22:47And I was like, well, whole thing?
- 22:49And he's like, uh-huh.
- 22:50And he goes, I'm a little broken today, because the banter, the human banter between these two thoughts in a recorded session, even the way you and I jump on each other and cut each other off in a polite, respectful way, they were doing that.
- 23:08They kept saying you, but I noticed by the end, they had not named each other, which was wild.
- 23:14And the topic of the episode he sent me was the mind-bending one.
- 23:20They were talking about how AI can enhance human reproduction and what the ethical dilemmas in that might be.
- 23:27And I'm like, what?
- 23:32I mean, it was painful.
- 23:33My brain froze for a minute.
- 23:35And he was like, this is not a good morning, because I'm processing this, and I'm thinking about it.
- 23:40He's constantly thinking about how we bring ethics to our work, how we center it in the human experience.
- 23:45So I know that for our product and our company, we're in good shape.
- 23:49Well, we started this work in 2015, where we were using initially some of IBM Watson's technology to basically code stories for certain emotions.
- 24:00As that grew in usefulness and in application for our customers, two things happened that sort of changed our trajectory.
- 24:09One was IBM intended those things to be used at a massive scale of coding social media.
- 24:16They didn't sell it.
- 24:18Companies didn't want it that way.
- 24:19We were using it in this very micro scale to go super deep.
- 24:23And if we were their customer, they were like, this is not a workable business for us.
- 24:27So they shut it down.
- 24:28They gave us notice.
- 24:29They shut down the models that they were going to use, that we were using.
- 24:33And so that created an existential crisis for our company.
- 24:37Well, I mean, yeah, we gathered stories, but that's the engagement side of it.
- 24:41What we really do is deliver insights.
- 24:43And we deliver insights in a way that's perhaps more quantifiable, scalable, applicable.
- 24:49We might not have the technology to do that.
- 24:51So Andy, our CTO, says, normally this would take a team and quite a few months to figure out.
- 24:59Let's see if I can do it.
- 25:01And we stumbled across, in the most literal sense, early on, the sort of growing prevalence of large language models and what they could be used for.
- 25:10And initially, we used them just to classify stories and specific pieces of stories that related to different emotions.
- 25:18So in a more practical sense, we take a story, we break it up into smaller pieces, and then we'd score that story for 55 different emotions.
- 25:26And we use those emotional data to start to quantify how people are experiencing their time at your company or with your brand.
- 25:35But that was still very much on the emotional side.
- 25:38And while it was interesting to a lot of people, they couldn't quite figure out, what do I do with it?
- 25:42Well, then, as large language models became even more popular and
- 25:47prevalent over the last two years, you know, hearkened by that GPT and the conversational AI,
- 25:52generative AI, we found we were in the perfect place at kind of the perfect time, where we could
- 25:56use those tools to accelerate the analysis process, to make sure that we designed this really,
- 26:05really deep context of the project, that it would not let outside nonsense seep in,
- 26:10or forget what we just told it, you know, an hour ago.
- 26:14And you don't need to keep reprompting and retelling your chat GPT.
- 26:18No, no, that's not it.
- 26:19You know, you sometimes want to throw the screen, you know, throw the computer across the room.
- 26:23Been designing to minimize and eventually, I don't know if we'll ever fully eliminate it, but take that down a significant amount.
- 26:32And so today, if a person's in the platform, collecting stories from their employees or their customers, can immediately see, how do those stories look emotionally?
- 26:43What's the emotional map of those experiences?
- 26:45And then they can use the tool to start analyzing in real time, what are we learning about people's experiences?
- 26:52So we've built some sort of predetermined reporting styles and templates.
- 26:57And I think that's part of how we go to your original question.
- 26:59How are we keeping AI human centered?
- 27:03It's for us, AI is the enabler.
- 27:05It's not the answer.
- 27:07It's the enabler to understand at scale.
- 27:09If I've collected a thousand stories, I can't read a thousand stories.
- 27:13You know, and that's why people say, we'll do a survey instead.
- 27:16Well, the survey is not rich.
- 27:17The survey doesn't tell me why.
- 27:19So the sweet spot is going to look at how you think about qualitative research, which generally goes deeper and say, how do you scale that?
- 27:26You know, it's hard to do a hundred in-depth interviews and very expensive, but I could collect a hundred stories.
- 27:32I could collect a thousand stories.
- 27:34So that's kind of the rationale in terms of why we're using AI.
- 27:38The question remains for us, how does this help a leader better understand the human experiences in their charge?
- 27:45That's what we're deeply focused on.
- 27:46I guess that was my question here, listening to you.
- 27:50And by the way, I'm in, I want it.
- 27:53But why do you feel it is important to measure the emotion or the emotional quotient or content of these stories?
- 28:05What does it give us?
- 28:06Is it as simple and binary as, hey, they like this thing, it makes them happy.
- 28:12This makes them sad and unproductive.
- 28:14What sort of things are we, are we tracking here?
- 28:17How is it helping these leaders, you know, move their business, move their experiences on question.
- 28:23And in the most, so some of it is as basic and fundamental as you say, look, this is how your product makes them feel.
- 28:30This is how working there makes them feel.
- 28:31And this is why you should care about that.
- 28:33Cause if they don't enjoy it, but they're not experiencing the emotions that you hope they would like at a brand level, you know, you have your brand values, you have your brand personality.
- 28:41You generally want people to like your brain.
- 28:43And if your brain has specific things associated with it, like it's a mission driven brain.
- 28:48So the sense of, of achievement and self transcendence and these other things that sort of show up as values and needs, you might want people to feel that when they're interacting with your brain.
- 28:57And if they're not now, you know, well, this might be some of the lack of brand love, brand loyalty, brand relevance that we're experiencing.
- 29:07But the same thing happens inside the company, in the culture.
- 29:09If you're a company built on a high level of achievement and, and, you know, a highly intellectual, curious culture, we can measure those things.
- 29:17We can measure the curiosity of showing up in their experiences.
- 29:20We can measure the achievement that showing up when those might be things that are really, really crucial for you to have that sense of belonging in your culture.
- 29:27So I think measuring the emotions is both fundamental.
- 29:30How literally, how does this make people feel?
- 29:32And if you're a emotionally intelligent leader, I would argue, you always want to know how it makes people feel because that's like the essence of relationship.
- 29:41Now, if you lack empathy, you probably don't care.
- 29:44And that's also true in a one-on-one relationship.
- 29:47If I don't have any empathy, I probably don't care how I make you feel.
- 29:51But if I have empathy and I want us to grow together and I want you to be successful, then I should care how my actions impact you.
- 29:58The second piece though, to really the practical application of measuring emotions and experiences is it's brilliant for branch strategy, marketing communications, sort of specific leadership or organizational development questions.
- 30:13And, and, you know, what I would say is the biggest piece of it is it helps you understand how to talk to them about their own experiences.
- 30:20You make more sense to them when you understand where they're coming from.
- 30:25And so that to us is really the rationale.
- 30:26We've seen leaders who adopt that, but putting it not just in that higher level, um, feeling state, they're applying it practically to better messaging, better product design, better experience design, better leadership development.
- 30:40Um, they're using it as a compliment to their existing CSAT, you know, their customer satisfaction scores or their NPs.
- 30:47They're using it to say, why is that?
- 30:50Why is that what it is?
- 30:51We see the dip.
- 30:52We don't understand the dip.
- 30:53Let's you seek to better understand why people are feeling this way or why they're, why their sort of relationship to the brain is getting softer.
- 31:00I get it.
- 31:01And, and, you know, the repeated thing in there is, is, is why?
- 31:05And always when I was, if I think back to my marketing end of my, of my career data was telling me one thing, my questions always were, well, why is that?
- 31:16Why is that?
- 31:16Where's that coming from?
- 31:18Because there's a, there's a layer behind all of our decision-making, right?
- 31:21That some of it is in the subconscious, but even some of it's in the conscious.
- 31:25And what is that layer of our thoughts and feelings and values and needs?
- 31:29Yep.
- 31:29Well, measuring my behavior, knowing my demographics really doesn't tell us much anymore because we're becoming an extraordinarily diverse society globally and societies in our different countries are becoming more and more diverse.
- 31:42So demographics that used to be really, really predictive 20, 30, 40, 50 years ago, that's changing.
- 31:47So people started shifting to behaviors.
- 31:49Well, if I understand their behaviors, if I measure their behaviors and their actions, you know, the premise that the best predictor of the future is the past has been true, but that is also becoming a little frayed because people are becoming much more diverse in their motivators, their purchase decisions, their employment decisions.
- 32:09You know, new generations are saying, this is what I value at work.
- 32:12That's different than what even people in my generation valued when I was looking for my career.
- 32:16My relationship to money is different.
- 32:19And so the emotional layer broadly captured as sort of feelings, thoughts, values, needs is increasingly playing a bigger role in their even kinds of decision-making.
- 32:30And so if you want to understand where this consumer or organization or culture is either likely to go or better diagnose the challenges you see already, demos probably aren't going to tell you a ton, but behaviors are becoming still relevant, but maybe less relevant in those places where you don't have a lot of history or you were seeing new behaviors and you're like, why are they doing this?
- 32:51Back to that why question.
- 32:53Well, if we understand their emotional drivers, we have a better chance at understanding their behaviors.
- 32:59And so this is that we call it the meaning layer.
- 33:01It's giving meaning to all of that behavioral analysis, which again, I'm not saying it doesn't provide a value, especially, you know, brands and companies that really want to understand the impact of their, their experiences.
- 33:13You need them to also need the emotional layer.
- 33:15And if there's anything I want to base a prediction on, especially in this rapidly changing world, I'd rather base my predictions on that previous experience that you had, which I measured.
- 33:27Would it make you feel tremendous amounts of love and closeness and stability, or did it make you feel depressed?
- 33:35Because two people might exhibit the same behavior and one might be loving it and one might be hating it.
- 33:40If I don't know why you love it and why you hate it, I might assume that you're both going to ride with me for the next 20 years.
- 33:47And one of them is just waiting for a better opportunity to jump.
- 33:50They just don't see it.
- 33:51Yeah.
- 33:51I think that's really interesting that that color that this stuff adds to really fascinating.
- 33:57Maybe I'm going to try and link and circle.
- 33:59So be prepared for another flipping long question or whatever it will be that comes out of it.
- 34:03But obviously you've learned a lot of around ethics and how to use and what to do and what not to do in that experience.
- 34:11And then you've talked about trying to keep things in line or get the tech rather aligned with values and what have you, which I guess behind the scenes in the engine, there's a lot of tweaking and everything going on there.
- 34:23But if I come back to where I originally cut you off and moved us on, you talked about belonging and trust, two massively core constituent parts of our communication needs and wants and actually the effect of those things.
- 34:41And you also mentioned the primal stuff about connecting to rhythms and archetypes and all that when it comes to storytelling.
- 34:50And I know predominantly what you're doing is extracting stuff from stories, not necessarily creating stories, but there was something you said to me when we first met about the role that imperfection played in all of that stuff that linked directly back to realism, trust, belonging, and was something that maybe AI had to work on or you're really having to focus on.
- 35:16Can you explain how that all comes together?
- 35:18That almost, I'm going to say need for imperfection, but the effect of imperfection in this space.
- 35:26It's a great question.
- 35:27And I think we're all wrestling with this in real time.
- 35:30You look at LinkedIn, there's been a raging debate for the last number of months on whether or not you can use an MDAS in a year and whether or not, it's not this, but that, which was a perfectly acceptable idiom in human conversation till eight months ago.
- 35:45And all of a sudden, AI is like, oh, I love that formula.
- 35:49I'm going to use that in every piece of content I recommend to you.
- 35:52It's not this, but that MDAS one through three.
- 35:54And it's like, oh, and so the, it's become very flunked, very, very flat.
- 35:59There's no peaks and valleys.
- 36:00There's no room for real meaningful difference in what people, so a lot of people think about difference as a divider.
- 36:06It's just a measure of understanding who you are and what brings you here.
- 36:10Difference is not division.
- 36:12Difference is uniqueness and wanting to understand the uniquenesses and the similarities in each other, I think should be something we do as humans.
- 36:21We've done it for a long period of time and we can, we should keep doing it.
- 36:24Imperfection honestly plays an interesting role, both in the diagnostic of that, but I think it also plays a role in response to this tech.
- 36:31I think it plays a role in our desire to grasp onto something that feels essentially human because humans are beautifully, perfectly imperfect on every scale, whether it's, you know, um, justice and crime to love and connection, no human gets anything right all the time.
- 36:50And so that might be the thing that helps us best spot the human in the sea of, of tech is, you know, for the first few versions of AI generated videos, you know, people had eight fingers and it was like, ha, ha, ha.
- 37:03And it's like, now it's like, oh, I don't want to give anything because that's not perfect.
- 37:07So now you have these videos that are circulating that are made, um, that are just so realistic.
- 37:14And so when you listen to them, you can still spot the small imperfections in the dialogue or the, the desire to jump to a conclusion.
- 37:24You know, when I would only work in chat, GPT, I would get very frustrated by it's, it assumed everything needed to be brief.
- 37:31It assumed that being concise was automatically the best way to communicate a thing.
- 37:35I was like, well, it depends on what I'm trying to communicate because brevity does not mean clarity.
- 37:40Brevity just means brevity.
- 37:41And so the goal is clear communication, not necessarily shorter.
- 37:46Sometimes it'll be short, but sometimes you need to give people more.
- 37:49Those models don't like doing that.
- 37:50So sometimes you can see you push it like you're condensing way too much.
- 37:54You're skipping way too much.
- 37:55You're glomming way too much together.
- 37:57So that frustration led us to build our models very differently.
- 38:01Like I said, this need for deep context who really focus on these human stories.
- 38:07What are they telling us?
- 38:08But I'll tell you maybe two years ago, right as chat GPT started to explode and the other tools did too.
- 38:14We had our own firsthand experience with this because in one project we had just started doing data collection on, you know, if you see these things one story at a time as they're coming through, they look and feel normal.
- 38:24And you start realizing there's a pattern to these stories that does not feel normal.
- 38:28And you start realizing that some of these stories look like they're being, you know, somebody sitting behind a computer with their own, you know, script, just changing names, dates and places.
- 38:37And we're like, timeout, you know, we, we don't want to do AI processing of AI generally.
- 38:44Number one, that's a, that would be a tremendous flaw in our business model and really weakened the trust that both our customers and our participants have given us.
- 38:54So we had to pause projects and fix that and say, why, how did that get in?
- 38:58What do we need to do on the security side?
- 38:59The trust side, how do we validate and verify that people are sharing real stories?
- 39:04And it changed a little bit of business process, but also changed, you know, in like traditional paid research, it changed how and when we validate before people get paid.
- 39:13But even if it's not paid research, even if it's just employee experience research, I don't want people making their decisions through AI's replacement of the human in the conversation.
- 39:24I want them making their decisions in a way that AI's enabled them to put their arms around as many participants people as possible, and then make a human decision about a human experience.
- 39:35And so that will be a challenge.
- 39:37You know, the more AI gets better at these things, more people want, you know, faster, faster, faster, not necessarily better.
- 39:44And, you know, we're saying, hey, fast is good.
- 39:47Believe me, when I can run a top line report in 10 minutes, instead of creating one in five hours, it's great.
- 39:54That's going to help our customers learn faster.
- 39:57The sacrifice we have to make to do that is, it's human centricity, is quality and accuracy, then we're not going to do it.
- 40:03And so it's been our journey over the past couple of years, as we've not only had our own AI tools improve, we've now find ourselves in a sea of people who are rapidly, maybe faster than we've ever done before, trying, testing and launching new things without the same level of human trial.
- 40:21How does this show up?
- 40:23And how do we get there?
- 40:24And how does this make us?
- 40:25How does this change us?
- 40:26I think those are things that we haven't answered the questions yet, even though people are, you know, betting trillions on this.
- 40:32So that's one of the things that we just feel like at worst, we're a light in that darkness.
- 40:36I don't mean to sound sort of, you know, evangelistic about it, but that's the worst case scenario.
- 40:40And the better case scenario is, we show people that there's an alternative.
- 40:44Listen, we love an evangelist on this show.
- 40:45Don't you be shying away from that, my friend, not at all.
- 40:48The right Reverend James coming into your life.
- 40:51I love it.
- 40:52Amen, brother.
- 40:53I'm all, I'm all for it.
- 40:55I think before I attempt to get you to sum up this conversation, I I'm interested in your view of the future.
- 41:02And, and again, I'm not saying, Oh, is AI going to tell stories?
- 41:06Cause that's, that's not the end of the chain that you're working on.
- 41:08Right.
- 41:09But I'm really interested in where do you think the understanding of nuance in human emotion is going to, is going to get to with AI?
- 41:21Because I think this thing about imperfection, there's one element there about AI tracking AI and filtering that stuff out, but there's so much nuance to the expression of emotion verbally through written stories.
- 41:37And for, I guess, AI to really help and understand this stuff, it feels like that's still quite a way away.
- 41:45Where do you see it going?
- 41:47How quickly do you think we'll get there?
- 41:49And why do you come to those conclusions?
- 41:51You know, there may be a point in the, in the near future where those humans use AI assistance and agents to do lots of tasks.
- 41:57One of them might be like people use it to help me write this letter, help me write this social posts, help me write this blog.
- 42:02So we will be facing the, help me write this, help me answer this researcher's question.
- 42:08And we're gonna have to figure out like, what are the guardrails on that?
- 42:11How do we want to, you know, what, what becomes normalized in terms of AI-assisted communication and thought?
- 42:18And I don't just mean normalized in the, in the apps.
- 42:20I mean, normalized societally and culturally.
- 42:22Where do we decide this amount of AI assistance is useful?
- 42:26Too much means you're not functioning as you, you're functioning as an agent of you.
- 42:30And, and I think if a, if a company wants to understand how to make a better product or brand or culture, they still need to go to the source.
- 42:38The source is the person.
- 42:39So I think what's happening quickly is navigating that change of the right ratio of AI-assisted human expression, where we draw the line on that.
- 42:49I also think that the nuance is going to matter even more and more as a way of differentiating products and experiences.
- 42:55It will become almost modified very soon, that anything can be made with AI and anything can be said with AI.
- 43:01So at some point, simple differentiator might be, this isn't.
- 43:06And that may or may not capture five points of share, 10 points of share, who knows?
- 43:10But in a sea of sameness, you're going to want to find like, everybody's going right.
- 43:14I need to go left.
- 43:15What is left to look like?
- 43:16And I think that's really where it's going to come down to because I don't necessarily think I want everything that I consume to be replaced by the machine.
- 43:26I would like to have some things be closest version to a human to human interaction possible.
- 43:30And I think that's going to be true for a lot of people for at least a little longer.
- 43:33Yeah, I agree with that.
- 43:35I think this whole space is fascinating and I genuinely don't know where it's going to go.
- 43:40There are times when I'm using it, I think like, my God, I've spent ages feeding this information about me.
- 43:45It really does understand me.
- 43:46And then in the next breath, it hasn't got a clue.
- 43:49And clearly a lot of the large language model, the aggregation and the averaging is the thing that it kind of catches up with itself and maybe waters down some of those things.
- 43:59I don't know.
- 44:00That's it.
- 44:01And the other piece that's happening, which is if you go deep into the research industry, more so than the experience management, as you write experience management is tracking all the things that we're doing.
- 44:11We've had this onset of issues.
- 44:12Research is still asking people a question.
- 44:14And one of the emerging friends in research is, Hey, you need to, you need to get an answer to this really quickly.
- 44:21You don't have to recruit humans anymore.
- 44:22Use synthetic data.
- 44:24So synthetic data is becoming and growing a conversation, but also use case of AI in market research.
- 44:32And, you know, there's, there's definitely more of a clear line in that space between companies and researchers who fundamentally believe like, no, like that's the limit for me is asking AI and ask AI what people would do.
- 44:46That's a prediction engine.
- 44:47That would be interesting to actually replace human response with synthetic response and say, modeling is really, really accurate.
- 44:55I don't care how accurate it is.
- 44:57Why?
- 44:58Why would you want to replace a human response with an AI generated response?
- 45:02And if the answer is, cause I can get like you make a decision quicker, you now understand something about the values of that organization or that brand.
- 45:09Wow.
- 45:09I don't want to get into that too much today.
- 45:11I can only think of the dark manipulation that can go on with someone doing like an employee survey.
- 45:15Yeah.
- 45:16Let's not talk to my employees.
- 45:17Let's talk to my ideal set of crafted AI employees.
- 45:20And we'll put that out to the city.
- 45:23That's not, that's not a great place to be.
- 45:25That's a fascinating thought though, James.
- 45:27Wow.
- 45:28Between that and the AI podcast, you know, you live in a small window, like I'm in a bubble, we've got five years.
- 45:34And then you see things like that and you're like, holy crap, this is happening much, much, much faster than we think.
- 45:39And when you interview the folks out there who are building these things, they will tell you, yeah, this is going faster than we thought.
- 45:47Look deadpan into the camera.
- 45:48I'm like, and when, what do you think about that?
- 45:49Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 45:50Are you okay with that?
- 45:51Cause they're just like, yeah, this is, this is going really fast.
- 45:53Mm hmm.
- 45:54Well, thank you.
- 45:55Hang tight on those reins, my friend.
- 45:57That's, that's cool.
- 45:58I think, my goodness me, we could have gone all over in different places with this conversation.
- 46:03I think the work you're doing is really, really interesting.
- 46:06Uh, I definitely want to keep track of, of what you're doing and how it's evolving in an attempt to kind of summarize, uh, well, my rambling questions, your excellent answers.
- 46:17Can you do me a favor?
- 46:18James, we've got to this part in the show, called sticky notes.
- 46:20I'm basically looking for, I guess your three key takeouts, your three pearls of wisdom, however you want to sort of phrase it.
- 46:27That when we're thinking about really understanding the value of stories, not just in their connection thing, but in the, I guess, in the analysis element of that, what three pieces of advice could you fit on three little sticky notes, my friend?
- 46:42First thing I would say is start talking to the leader, whether it's a brand leader, organizational leader, company leader, your vulnerability starts the process.
- 46:51If you're willing to explore and share your own stories, that changes and shifts responsiveness in your organization.
- 46:59The second thing is, is deep, deep listening.
- 47:03It's again, is still focused on the leadership expectation and experience leaders who listen, better understand the experiences of their customers, employees, and stakeholders.
- 47:12And if they, if they listen, they're generally more inclined to do something with what they've heard.
- 47:17So listening is the second big sticky note.
- 47:20And then the third is really now switching it to the participant side of things, openness, trust.
- 47:27Those are things that I think we as people and consumers and employees want and need from the companies we do business with and looking there is doing business with them, especially now more than ever.
- 47:37So I want a sense of belonging and I want to, I want to be able to trust you.
- 47:42I also, as a person, I'm part of that equation.
- 47:45It's not something that's done through me.
- 47:47It's something I participate in.
- 47:48So, you know, sharing your own stories, being open, being trusting, being willing has benefits for you too, because it gets you the chance to see yourself more clearly and to see others around you.
- 47:59I love those.
- 48:00That's great.
- 48:00What a lovely way to finish before I do let you finally go, James, where can people find out a bit more about you a bit more about seek the platform and everything else?
- 48:12Where should they head for my friend?
- 48:13Well, if you want to find out a little bit more about me, I love spending time on LinkedIn.
- 48:18So you can find me on there.
- 48:19My profile is james-warren-seek online.
- 48:25You can find us at sharemorestories.com.
- 48:28You'll find everything you need to know about our company that are right at the home page.
- 48:31You could click in to learn more about the seek platform and who we're helping them.
- 48:37Between those two, our website and LinkedIn, you'll find me and you'll find us.
- 48:42Brilliant.
- 48:42Well, I've loved talking to you, James.
- 48:44Fascinating topic.
- 48:45I really sincerely hope this isn't our last conversation and I look forward to seeing what you're up to.
- 48:50Likewise.
- 48:51Thank you.
- 48:52Okay, my friend, you take care.
- 48:54Okay, everyone, that was James Warren.
- 48:56And if you'd like to find out a bit more about him or any of the topics that we've talked about today, please check out the show notes.
- 49:04So that concludes today's episode.
- 49:07I hope you've enjoyed it, found it interesting, and heard something maybe that will help you become a stickier, more successful business from the inside going forward.
- 49:18If you have, please like, comment and subscribe.
- 49:22It really helps.
- 49:24I'm Andy Goram, and you've been listening to the Sticky from the Inside podcast.
- 49:28Until next time, thanks for listening.