Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Putting Together An Ohio State All-Star Team From 1990-2019
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, everybody, Welcome to the buck Eye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony
- 0:04Gerdaman here as always with Tom Moore. Tom. How's it going? Oh,
- 0:10Tony? Guess what? We're running it back? The fourth and final,
- 0:16final, last one in our series of the over the Decades Ohio State
- 0:21teams, because Isaac backintyre asked us maybe the greatest mail bag question of all
- 0:25time, to put together our nineteen nineties and two thousands and two thousand and
- 0:28tens Ohio State all decade teams. Now he wants us to you know,
- 0:32take our take our action figures and crunch them together and tell them who would
- 0:36win and who would be on a team of you know, the combined all
- 0:40decades teams. So we're going to run it back. We're to do a
- 0:43little more. This is this is where we get a little more theoretical,
- 0:47and I think it's I think I have answers for most of these. You
- 0:51seemed more confident in who would win than I necessarily thought I was. But
- 0:55I feel like I feel like in my head I have a ranking of one,
- 0:58two and three. Yeah. And the final part of that question of
- 1:02from Isaac McIntire's which team do you think would be the best and why and
- 1:07for me, Tom the best of the three. And if you haven't listened
- 1:11to the shows, go back and listen to the last three and then come
- 1:14up with your own conclusion. But when I look at what the two nineteen
- 1:22team has offensively defensively, I think they top the two thousand and ten.
- 1:32I don't think the two thousands beats either the nineties or the two thousand tents
- 1:37team. How do you feel about that? I am exactly in the same
- 1:41I felt like the two thousands team was not quite as good at the top
- 1:47end. You don't have an Orlando Pace, you don't have a Quarry stringer,
- 1:49you don't have you know, you don't have the like Sean Springs,
- 1:55like NFL Hall of Fame type players on that two thousands team quite at you
- 2:00know, at quite the same level you've got. I mean, you've got
- 2:01great players on that team, but just not quite the same level. And
- 2:07but I think you look at just the recruiting over the years, John Cooper
- 2:10revolutionized Ohio state recruiting bringing in national players. You had that, you know,
- 2:15you have the incredible talent of Joe Germain from Arizona and David Boston from
- 2:22Texas and you know, all these guys from all over the place, but
- 2:25you just you can't beat the Urban Meyer recruiting. Just the level of talent
- 2:31on those teams was unprecedented into Ohio State history. You saw a consistency of
- 2:38success in that decade that you really had not seen before. You know,
- 2:40it was in the nineteen nineties, remember people talking about, you know,
- 2:44you've got you have to appreciate this is a golden era of Ohio State football.
- 2:47And then under Jim Trust in the two thousands, you exceeded that and
- 2:52they win the national championship and they're winning the Big Ten ever year in the
- 2:53beating Michigan every year, and people saying, this is a golden ara of
- 2:57Ohio State football. You have to appreciate it. And then urb Meyer shows
- 3:00up and they take it to a whole whole nother level where they're winning the
- 3:04Big Ten. But they're not losing. You know, they're not losing out
- 3:07of conference games very much. You're not losing too. You know, you're
- 3:10not losing bowl games, you're not losing to usc out of conference and stuff
- 3:15like that. You're you're really winning an even higher clip with an even higher
- 3:20level of talent. So yeah, I think you you go, you go,
- 3:24twenty tens beats the other two and nineties beats the two thousands. That's
- 3:30that's what I went with as well. I just think the two thousands didn't
- 3:35have the depth that the other decades do, especially like offensive line, defensive
- 3:39line. The amount of guys that didn't make the two thousand and tens that
- 3:46would be the stars of the two thousands and the nineties teams, it's kind
- 3:53of high. And so yeah, I think it's I'm looking there two thousand
- 3:57and tens, then the nineties, then the odds, and right now the
- 4:01two thousand twenties looking fairly decent um. So we'll see where they rank.
- 4:09Go ahead and market calendars for would you say, last show two thousand and
- 4:13thirty seven is something something in that neighborhood twenty thirty seven ish. We don't
- 4:16want to nail down a specific date, just you know, we'll get there
- 4:20eventually. Uh you've got you've got some time. Well, once college football
- 4:26is uh you know, just like one big conference and uh yeah, well
- 4:30we'll get to that show and then we can we can argue about that we
- 4:33should do a live show for that mark that down. So let's get to
- 4:39this. This this mashup of the all time, last thirty years, last
- 4:46three decades team. Picking from these three teams, and there are some a
- 4:53lot of talent has come through Ohio State. I'm not sure if you're aware
- 4:56of this, if I'm not sure if you've been paying attention, but if
- 4:59we started a quarter back, we already decided last show that Justin Fields was
- 5:05the best quarterback in high state that we've seen. And so this is an
- 5:10easy one. Is this is Justin Fields all day. And if you want
- 5:15to let him lead a squad with the amount of talent that it's going to
- 5:18be behind him coming up. As we talk about this team, I'm going
- 5:23to feel pretty good about it. Yeah, this this feels like a team.
- 5:27Just looking through this team, it just this looks like a team that
- 5:30is going to you want to put them up against the last thirty years Alabama
- 5:33All Stars. You want to put him up against the last thirty years Georgia
- 5:35All Stars. Like I I take my chances with this group and Justin Fields
- 5:42being the quarterback. I yep, that's fine because he had plenty of really
- 5:46talented weapons when he was the Ohio State's quarterback. But he can have some
- 5:49pretty talented weapons on this team as well. Let's let's talk about running back.
- 5:54He played with J. JK. Dobbins, Tony on this team with
- 5:57me, he's playing with Eddie George. You know, you go with the
- 6:04we know what we say about the Heisman Award, the Heisman Trophy, and
- 6:08we know our feelings about it. But you got a big, big guy
- 6:15like that, he can he can catch the ball as he did. We
- 6:17saw it in ninety five's out in ninety four. I think if you want
- 6:20to go with Eddie George, for somebody to argue that it would be some
- 6:26nitpicking. And again, three decades of Ohio State football, there's plenty to
- 6:30nitpick. You could say, well, what about Maurice Clarett, what about
- 6:34Beanie Wells, the two guys from the too, from the from the outs,
- 6:39and you know, the the JK. Dobbins, the Ezekiel Elliott in
- 6:45the twenty tens, certainly have I'm honestly a little surprised that you went with
- 6:51Eddie George, But again I don't have an issue with that because he was
- 6:57the Heisman Trophy winner and he was the standard bear for the for the Buckeyes
- 7:01at that position for you know, for a long time and for some people
- 7:06still is. So I'm okay with that. We can go ahead and punch
- 7:10that in with Eddie George. And you know, the funny thing is,
- 7:13I didn't put Ezekiel Elliott on my twenty ten team out with JAK Dobbins ahead
- 7:17of him. I'm looking at this and going, man, you put Ezekiel
- 7:21Elliott on this team, Like, oh boy, that's a I mean,
- 7:25he got kind of I mean JK Dobbins, Ezekiel Elliott, Eddie George,
- 7:28Like, these are different styles of runners. I would be fascinated to see
- 7:31Eddie George in a modern offense. I think that's maybe that's I'm yes,
- 7:35the Heisman, but also I'm just kind of intrigued to see Eddie George in
- 7:39a modern Ohio State offense. But tied end h Eddie George, Yeah,
- 7:46maybe, I mean he's he definitely does not fit the look of the modern
- 7:48running back necessarily, but you know, I would like to see him spread
- 7:56him out Tony and that it let Eddie George just run run between the tackles
- 8:01and just or hey run off tackle like I mean let's you know, justin
- 8:07Fields running the read option with Eddie George or Ezekiel Elliott. I mean I
- 8:13would be interested. I've already seen him do it with JK. Dobbins and
- 8:16that worked out just fine. So I kind of I kind of just want
- 8:18to see something else now. And but you know, I don't. I
- 8:22don't think there's a wrong answer here. No, No, certainly not a
- 8:26wrong answer. Probably not any wrong answers in any of this as we go
- 8:31along. Just a spoiler alert. So we're going with three receivers here,
- 8:37and I am going to port over the two receivers from the nineties and see
- 8:43how you feel about that. With Terry Glenn and David Boston. I think
- 8:48they would still fit into today's game just fine. They would be productive players.
- 8:54They would be as dominant then as they now as they were then,
- 8:58if not more so. So I went with those are my first two guys.
- 9:03Do you agree? Yes? Agree? I think those were easy picks
- 9:07for me. Where you know you've got the size, you've got the speed,
- 9:09you put them together. They missed playing together by one year, but
- 9:15yeah, you put them together on the same offense. I'm gonna I'm gonna
- 9:18take my chances there my third guy, and I put this and I was
- 9:24not necessarily expecting this to be the third guy I put there, But I
- 9:28kind of want to see Santonio Holmes out there with those guys. I think
- 9:31that's I think that's a really really I mean, that is a fast,
- 9:35fast combination of guys. You've got the size in Boston. You know who
- 9:41who do you want to put your slot corner on there? Tony, I
- 9:43don't feel like there's a great answer with So you have to put your third
- 9:46best cover guy on one of those guys. I don't know that there's a
- 9:48great answer for you there. Yeah, And I think Santonio Holmes would do
- 9:54really, really well in the slot. You know, he's a he's a
- 9:56quick guy, he's a strong guy, got everything you need in that area.
- 10:01So yeah, that's who. I also went with Santonio Holmes. Now
- 10:07you can go with Joey Galloway and that role, Curtis Samuel in that role,
- 10:11like they're there are other guys Paris Campbell, h Chris olav as the
- 10:16Z. But if you're gonna go with the Z, you're gonna go with
- 10:18Terry Glenn. You're gonna go with an X, you're gonna go with David
- 10:22Boston, and you know, Santonio Holmes was was not a slot guy.
- 10:26But I think you would fit just fine, and you move whoever you want,
- 10:31wherever you want, and they're gonna figure it out. So those are
- 10:33the three receivers. I'm we're in agreement there. Then we go back to
- 10:39the standard here. The guy that Ricky Dudley at tight end is that where
- 10:43we are right now. He's the guy that we said in the two shows
- 10:48ago, like Ben Hartsock is the guy that gets compared to when you're talking
- 10:52about guys who have had as many catches at tight end since as Ben hart
- 10:54Socks since then, before Ben Hartsock, it was Ricky Dudley and Ricky the
- 11:01first round er. You know, I went with Ricky Dudley as my tight
- 11:05end. I think he's in this offense with these guys and the size and
- 11:09the speed that he had, I think you could attack down field with them
- 11:13as well. I think there's a lot you could do. Yeah, I
- 11:16think if you're looking for kind of the all around tight end who's maybe a
- 11:20better run blocker, maybe you go with Ben Hartsock. But yeah, if
- 11:22you're just looking stretch the defense out stress, you know, put put guys
- 11:26in uncomfortable one on one spots with three wide receivers and a really athletic downfield
- 11:31threat at tight end, and then you've got to try and deal with justin
- 11:35fields and fill in the blank running back. I yeah, I think Dudley
- 11:39gives you just you know, I don't know honey passes he catches on this
- 11:41team, but man, I kind of want to, you know, let's
- 11:45let's watch. Okay, you've already got your slot guy on Santonio Holmes,
- 11:48now you need to Now you need one of your linebackers running with Ricky Dudley,
- 11:52Like I don't. I don't think that's going to work out great for
- 11:54you. So yeah, I think I went back and forth on this a
- 11:58little bit. I think those are both viable choices depending on what you want
- 12:03to do offensively. I just I kind of want to see Ricky Dudley with
- 12:05all these other guys out there. Yeah, then we go to left tackle
- 12:13and that is course, and then let's just do the other tackle then as
- 12:18well. And there there are more options, but I'm still going with Corey
- 12:22Stringer here. I'm just boarding, these two over control. Paste these two
- 12:26guys onto this team. Corey Stringer has the right tackle. Give me your
- 12:31guards time, because we we've already decided, like there are so many different
- 12:35guys that you could throw in here, because one year there a guard,
- 12:39next year they're a center. Hey, both times they were all Americans,
- 12:41you know, So there are so many different guys to to throw in here.
- 12:45So who did you go with? A guard? I went with Pat
- 12:46Alfline and Michael Jordan. But I you know, this is this is one
- 12:50where you could you could give me two completely different names, and I go,
- 12:54yeah, I mean there are there is not an Orlando pace At guard
- 13:00necessarily, but I mean you mentioned Jonah Jackson on the last show, Like
- 13:03you want to throw Jonah Jackson in there? Yeah, fine, great,
- 13:05no problem. You want to throw Um Andrew Norwell what I don't whatever,
- 13:11Like, I don't care, m pick your guy, throw them in there.
- 13:15I have no I have no objection to pretty much any of them.
- 13:18But I did go with pet Alfline and Michael Jordan just because I'm trying to
- 13:22get as many as many Brimington winners as I can on this team, and
- 13:24as many, you know, as I said the last time with Michael Jordan.
- 13:28If you start from day one as a true freshman and you're not too
- 13:31bad, like okay, yeah, that tells me you probably are a pretty
- 13:33special, unique player. Yeah, and so at center, I went with
- 13:39Nick Mangold. I think he's as solid as they come. Now. They've
- 13:45Ohio State has had plenty of centers, all Americans, first rounders, third
- 13:50rounders, like, plenty of guys who have played in the league and done
- 13:52well at Ohio State as well, So they're there. There are other guys
- 13:56you can mention here as well, but I went with Nick Mangold. That's
- 13:58where I went as well. But yeah, you want to put la Charles
- 14:01Bentley in there, Yeah fine. You want to put Billy Price in there?
- 14:03Yeah fine. You want to put Billy Price at guard and pet oflf
- 14:05Line at center, Yeah fine, whatever. I mean, that's there are
- 14:09there are plenty of good choices, plenty of guys who won you know,
- 14:13one national awards, who've had long NFL careers, really distinguished players. I
- 14:18mean, you could you can kind of swap in any of those guys and
- 14:22I would be kind of fine with it. So yeah, that's I'll just
- 14:26agree and we can move on to defense because gets a lot interesting on defense.
- 14:31Yeah. Interesting. I wonder if it will get contentious. Um,
- 14:35you know, maybe let's start with defensive. And I feel like we had
- 14:39this discussion in the last show, and is there anybody from the nineties and
- 14:46the odds that can break into what we already decided with the two thousand tens
- 14:52as Chase Young and Joey Bosa. No, I think the more interesting conversation
- 14:56is how far down the twenty tens list you have to go before you get
- 15:01to someone who would not make one or both of the other teams, because
- 15:05I you know, Chase Young, Joey Bosat, Nick Bosa, all three
- 15:07of those guys are making either the two thousand team or the nineties nineties team.
- 15:15I think you I mean, you want to talk about Taekwon Lewis,
- 15:16he might make at least one of those teams. You want to talk about
- 15:18Sam Hubbard, he might make at least one of those teams. I mean,
- 15:20it's just there's so John Simon would probably make one of those one or
- 15:24both of those teams. I mean, those are you know, And no
- 15:28disrespect to those to those other teams because those had very good defensive ends.
- 15:31But the level of defensive end place since Larry Johnson has gotten to Ohio State
- 15:35has just been a whole another level above what it was before. And that's
- 15:41you know, that's in terms of recruiting national athletes and also just the development
- 15:45under Larry Johnson. That's you know that that's something they did not have in
- 15:48the nineties and the two thousands in at quite that level. I'm interested to
- 15:56you see what you've got at defensive tackle. I think we both would go
- 16:00ahead and put Big Daddy in here. Yes, if you if you were
- 16:03the number one overall draft pick in the NFL, you make the team.
- 16:04Yes, Dan Wilkinson, congratulations, you're one of them. At the other
- 16:08spot, I have Quinn pipe Pitcock with a question mark. He was an
- 16:12All American, so yeah, but I don't necessarily think of him as an
- 16:18absolutely clear cut choice at the other spot. And we talked the last time
- 16:22there were a lot of good defensive tackles in the twenty tens. So who
- 16:27would you have at that spot? I mean, do you put Jonathan Hankinson,
- 16:30Do you put Adolphus Washington there? Do you put I mean you had
- 16:34a hold, you had a different answer than I did in the twenty tens.
- 16:37Who do you have there at that second spot? I went with Draymond
- 16:41Jones, And I'm just scrolling to see if you was ever listed as a
- 16:47first team All American, and I don't believe he was. But Adolphus Washington
- 16:52was, Michael Bennett was. But for my money, Draymond Jones was just
- 16:56so productive, so disruptive, certainly underrated. So that's where I went.
- 17:03Now, if we have to stick with accolades, then they would have to
- 17:06be. If you want to throw big Hank in there, he was an
- 17:08All American. I don't have a problem with that. But and maybe do
- 17:12you need to just a big guy to plug things up and let Dan Wilkinson
- 17:18go crazy, you know, creating all of the pressure or whatever, or
- 17:22if I'm Larry Johnson, No, I want Draymond Jones. I want that
- 17:26three tech, that quick, free tech to go rush to passer, because
- 17:29again, with Joey Bose and Chase Young, you're not going to get to
- 17:32the quarterback, so you're gonna need to get that interior pass rush. Yeah,
- 17:37that's that's one of those. Yeah, do you need size on the
- 17:38interior to make up for the famously undersized Dan Wilkinson. That's a it's a
- 17:42great question, and we'll have to We'll have to dig into that in a
- 17:45whole separate episode. I guess yeah, I mean Draymond Jones has a compliment
- 17:48to Dan Wilkinson. I mean, Tony, you only have five offensive linemen
- 17:53out there. So you've got Joey Bosa, You've got Chase Young, You've
- 17:56got Dan Wilkinson, You've got Raymond Jones. You can't double everyone. So
- 18:03how many how many tight ends and backs are you keeping into chip guys?
- 18:06And how many of them is Joey Bosa just pushing backwards into Christian Hackenburg all
- 18:11of them? This is difficult for me because now he moved to linebacker.
- 18:15And you look at all of these different guys, and we started back in
- 18:18the nineties, and the first guy I mentioned with Steve Tovar, three time
- 18:22All Big Ten, two time All American, but he kind of gets lost
- 18:26and all of these other guys. You know, James law Ight is three
- 18:30time All American, a j Hawkeye, believe he was a two time All
- 18:33American. The first guy that I'm making sure is on this team, though,
- 18:37my first pick as a linebacker for the Buckeyes is Ryan Jazier. I
- 18:44want him out there, and I'll figure it out with the two other guys
- 18:48and I'll be perfectly fine, because there are plenty of guys out there,
- 18:49but I want Ryan Jazier on my team. So that's that's where I'm going.
- 18:52He is my first pick as a linebacker. Yeah. I had him
- 18:56on there as well. Just just so consistently excellent to Ohio State, always
- 19:00in the right spot, so fast, such a hard hitter, just just
- 19:03had everything you'd want as a linebacker. I had him there as well.
- 19:08You know, I don't have that many rules, but if you're a three
- 19:11time All American, I think you probably have to make this team. So
- 19:14James Laurnias, congratulations, welcome to the squad. Yeah, three time All
- 19:21American, three year starter, famously steps in for Bobby Carpenter who breaks his
- 19:27foot unlike the first play from scrimmage of the Michigan game in two thousand and
- 19:32five, and then a legend you wasn't quite born then, but it would
- 19:36be born later in Austin, Texas and the k R Stadium. So yeah,
- 19:42I'm okay there. And now the third linebacker Tim, I this is
- 19:48do you just go, like, can you put together a team from the
- 19:53last three decades of Ohio state linebackers and leave Andy Katzimer off the list?
- 20:00Knowing who else you could be leaving off the list? Do you leave can
- 20:03you? How can you leave AJ Hawk off the list? How can I?
- 20:11I'm going to leave this up to you, Tom, and then I'll
- 20:12tell you whether or not I disagree. Yeah. I went with Andy Katzimware
- 20:17here just because you know, such an impact player, just a dominant player,
- 20:21an absolute star his whole Ohio State career. You know, if you
- 20:26want to put AJ Hawk ahead of him, Okay, I mean I'm not.
- 20:29I'm not going to fight you. I think you've got a bunch of
- 20:30good choices there. I went with Katzimware. I think a J Hawk had
- 20:36the better overall career. But I also think Andy Katsimware was a victim of
- 20:41his own name and expectations as a sophomore and junior, because he had,
- 20:47as we said a couple shows ago, just a ridiculous freshman season with like
- 20:52twenty three tackles for last twelve sacks, five tackles for lost in the rose
- 20:56Ball and the next year year would was he a two time Buckus winner in
- 21:02ninety six ninety eight, So the awards and the accolades are certainly there.
- 21:07So I have no problem with that with putting him there Andy Katzenmoyer as the
- 21:11third linebacker, because I just feel like he is he has a spot in
- 21:15Ohio State history that it lives beyond stats, and like the impact that he
- 21:23had was fantastic. Now quarterback at Ohio State, Tom is perhaps perhaps the
- 21:33deepest, most argued position that so many names, so many first rounders.
- 21:40Is it controversial that for me this answer is easy and I are we wrong?
- 21:48And if maybe you have the same answer, is it wrong for this
- 21:51to be an easy answer. I know what your easy answer is going to
- 21:55be. I actually didn't go with your easy answer because I know, I
- 22:00know, I know many things about Utony Girderman, but the one thing I
- 22:03know is that you have Antoine Winfield on this team and I do not.
- 22:06And I know that that's going to be a deeply troubling thing to you.
- 22:08But I went with Sean Springs and Jeff Okuda, two guys who were both
- 22:14top with three NFL draft picks, at the corner position just absolutely dominant,
- 22:19both of them. At the college level. Antoine Winfield was absolutely outstanding.
- 22:25I think he I think, I'm sure your guests your I'm sure your team
- 22:30is you're you're taking Springs and Springs and Winfield would be my guest as to
- 22:34who you're going to take. And I don't really have an issue with that.
- 22:38That's just not the direction I went with it. But I mean,
- 22:41Winfield, Winfield was so good, such a short tackler, and you know,
- 22:47boy, you want to you want to let us play nickel here,
- 22:48I'll I'll, I'll put him in the slot, and you know that that'll
- 22:55be that'll be a pretty darn good defense too. Well. And here's the
- 22:57thing, if we're putting this together, there is a modern defense. I
- 23:00think Antoine Winfield is your nickel. He is. He is the guy in
- 23:03your four to five that is covering that slot and also blitzing and also helping
- 23:07out and run support. And he's going to be an All American doing that.
- 23:11But so I don't really have an issue with Shawn Springs and Jeff Okuda.
- 23:15As I've said before, Shawn Springs is the best corner I've ever seen
- 23:18at Ohio State. Antoine Winfield I think is the best defensive player I've ever
- 23:21seen at Ohio State. But again, this would be a of course,
- 23:25if we are going Nickel, who are you taking off the field? And
- 23:29and honestly, Andy Katzimayer at six foot four, two hundred and fifty pounds
- 23:33is probably a defensive end. And he's not going to be on this team
- 23:37as a defensive end probably, so he might be. He's maybe the guy
- 23:42you said about although James lower nitis, he can play in modern day football.
- 23:48Don't you think I would think so. I mean, I don't know
- 23:51that you've got a bad choice here. Katzimayer definitely is a little bit of
- 23:56you know, he's like an Alabama linebacker from ten years ago and not an
- 24:00Alabama linebacker today. Kind of is how I think about him. Yeah,
- 24:03he's he's a he's a rush and if if he's if he is a high
- 24:07school senior today. But yeah, I I think you might actually have a
- 24:14better defense if you put Winfield in the slot and take Kats and Lawyer off
- 24:18the team and go four to five. But you know, I mean again,
- 24:22you want to you want to give it, You want to give me
- 24:25a j Hawk there and in place of Laura IDAs or Cheesier. I'm not
- 24:29gonna fight you too hard on that one either, but yeah, that just
- 24:33the idea of three corners on the field and they're Sean Springs and Jeff Okuda
- 24:37and Antoine Winfield. Best of luck completing a pass against that team. Friends,
- 24:44I'm just looking at these three linebackers. I'm looking at these three linebackers
- 24:48with Chazier and Laura Nias and Katz and Moyer, knowing how often Katz and
- 24:52Moyer and Cheesier get into the backfield and they'd be attacking, attacking, and
- 24:56Laura Nias would just be like leaving me. Hang, I've got to defend
- 25:03the entire middle of the field now because you got these attacking guys. So
- 25:06maybe I'm with you. I think the four to five plus, how are
- 25:11these guys covering? You know, obviously you've got the corners and you've got
- 25:15to get secondary. But who's that Which of those linebackers is going to be
- 25:19covering? Like Parker Washington, Well, you've got I think the thing that
- 25:25you get to remember is with Big Daddy and Draymont Jones and Joey Bosa and
- 25:33Chase Young the quarterback, You're gonna have about zero point six seconds to throw
- 25:37the ball, so you've really only got to cover about three yards downfield.
- 25:40So I'm going to quote quote the late, the great, great Ciano and
- 25:45just say we're a press man team, Tony, and best of luck getting
- 25:49off the line against against these corners. And you know, we'll get to
- 25:55the safeties in a minute. But I got some guys in the back that
- 25:56can clean up anything that happens to slip through. So let's move to the
- 26:00safeties. Because for me, there there's always one answer, and there used
- 26:07to always be one answer. Now I think there's always two answers when this
- 26:11question gets asked, because MALIEK. Cooker for me, as at arguably the
- 26:17greatest individual season of anybody, anybody defensively in twenty sixteen, but he was
- 26:23only a one time All American. There is a three time All American out
- 26:27there. So you're asking me, I've got I'm gonna put Mike Dwess at
- 26:33strong safety and I'm gonna put Millie Cooker at free safety. However, Tom,
- 26:37I think this defense could be better with somebody other than Mike Doss.
- 26:41In two days game, I think I don't think that's a question. I
- 26:45think I think in today's game, if you want to go ahead and have
- 26:48a corner or some Jordan Fuller perhaps you know, I'm I'm putting Mike Doss
- 26:55here because he deserves it. But if I'm fielding a team, I might
- 27:00go in a different direction. Yeah, Jordan Fuller is a really good choice
- 27:06just in terms of who is the guy and the back end of that defense
- 27:08who is just not going to ever let anything get past him. I think
- 27:11he's a great choice. I went with my I had Mike dosson Mouli Cooker
- 27:15too, just because you know those are those are you know, you're a
- 27:21three time All American, You're a three time All American. You're on the
- 27:23team like, sorry, I don't make the rules. I mean we do,
- 27:26but I don't make the rules. So so yeah, I went with
- 27:30Mike Dawson MC cooker because Mike Doss, if you're concerned about you know,
- 27:33hey, some of the defensive line has you know, lost their you know
- 27:38that they've gotten out of their rush lanes and lost contain and the running back
- 27:42has leaked through and somehow my linebackers have not not cleaned up the mess.
- 27:48I'm gonna go. I'm gonna take my chances with Mike Mike Doss coming down
- 27:52and cleaning up the mess down in the box. I think you think,
- 27:56just think about the exotic you know, blitz schemes you could run with.
- 28:00You know, you have Mike Doss down there and you can bring you want
- 28:03to bring Andy Katzimore, You want to bring uh, Brian Shazier blitzing in,
- 28:07you want to bring Mike Doss from the safety spot. I mean,
- 28:10man, it's it is. It just does not feel like this would be
- 28:14a really fun defense to face if you were an offensive coordinator. Is that
- 28:18right? Uh? And Doss, you know, we remember him for some
- 28:22of a couple of the passes that got over his head, but he was
- 28:26a He was a playmaker in the passing game as well, So I don't
- 28:27want to say that he wasn't He was like certainly not a liability as he
- 28:33made plays and he was a fantastic tackler as well, and absolutely deserves beyond
- 28:38this list. Now what everybody's been waiting for, Tom this is Mike Nugent
- 28:42at kicker. Is there any like That's that's the honestly, the other guy
- 28:47that would deserves to mention it would be like Josh Houston, it was very
- 28:49good after Mike Nugent, But this is Mike Nugent all day long. Yep.
- 28:53Yeah, Mike Nugent's an easy choice for me there just you know,
- 28:56the last three years of his career in credible leg, incredible consistency, just
- 29:03you know, they're they're the Ohio state has been fortunate to have a lot
- 29:06of really good kickers. They have not had anyone like Mike Nugent since since
- 29:10Mike Nugent, and they didn't really have anyone like Mike Nugent before Mike Nugent
- 29:14either. So yeah, I think I think you could go back a few
- 29:17decades before this and you'd still be picking Mike Nugent for this one. Punter
- 29:21Tony, you know where I'm going. He punted, he punted, He
- 29:26punted it upside down before he came to Ohio. But then Cam Johnston was
- 29:30really really good and you know, the ball headed adjusted the ball spinning the
- 29:34other way in the Northern hemisphere, but yeah, didn't didn't seem to have
- 29:37a big problem adjusting there. You know, incredible leg, incredible placement,
- 29:42brought the Australian punting thing to Ohio State, which for which we will have
- 29:48forever be grateful. I can't imagine you disagree. No, I do think
- 29:55Andy Groom again in two thousand and two had what was it was clutch,
- 30:00especially that season, giving every every every play mattering as much as a dead
- 30:04and b il position being such a factor. I give him a special mention.
- 30:08But Damon Johnston was you know, from from the day he arrived,
- 30:14he was outstanding. He was twenty sixteen Big Ten Punter of the Year,
- 30:18so um, you know, a great job by him there. So yeah,
- 30:22I would agree with that. That's fine, no problems there. Kick
- 30:26return, punt return, Where are you going, Tom, I've got the
- 30:30same guy for both of these. Uh, he's pretty fast. He is
- 30:33ted Gin and as the dead chin Beckler song once said ted Gin ted Gin,
- 30:41Tedkin did everything, and he really did kickoff returns for touchdowns. You
- 30:45betcha putter returns for touchdowns with almost boring frequency. I it's he would be
- 30:52kind of wasted in the modern game. Like we talked earlier about the fact
- 30:56that he I'm one of the other shows about you know that he would be
- 30:59so on to watching a Ryan Day offense. He kind of would be wasted
- 31:03in the kick return game because it's just kind of not a thing anymore.
- 31:06But man, oh man, when it was a thing, you just everyone
- 31:08just sort of held their breath that you know, you're kicking to Ted Gain,
- 31:11You are you better off just kicking the ball out of bounds and just
- 31:15letting the other team take it at the thirty five or the forty or whatever
- 31:18the rule was at that point. It is I think this was this was
- 31:22among the easier choices. Yeah, and this is boom. Just we don't
- 31:26even need to worry about it. That's Ted Gin whichever however you want to
- 31:30kick to him, and just please continue to kick to him and don't fair
- 31:34catch. Just make something happen with it. So, yes, that is
- 31:37the correct answer, both of those. Ted Gin. Now I'm I'm looking
- 31:41here and I've written down like the decade that each of these guys played in,
- 31:48and so I can tell you this up real quick time, unless you
- 31:49already have I have not. So all right, so we've got what we
- 31:55got here, twenty two, twenty six players total. And I'll just tell
- 31:59you how many of these twenty six were from the nineties, we've got at
- 32:04least as far as I wrote down. I think we had maybe had one
- 32:06or two differences. But from the nineties one two, three, four,
- 32:08five, six, seven eight nine players from the nineties. From the two
- 32:15thousands one two, three, four, five six, and at five six
- 32:22is ted Gin from the odds. And then from the twenty tens we've got
- 32:27one, two, three, four, five, six, seven eight nine.
- 32:31So what at nine from the twenty tens and from the nineties and then
- 32:38six you've got nine plus nine plus six, which is twenty four and there
- 32:43are twenty six spots. So you've done it. There's twenty six spots,
- 32:49and I don't understand, yeah, anyway, So the important thing is that
- 32:54I think this kind of aligns more or less with what we were thinking initially
- 32:58anyway, which was twenty tens and nineties, and then the two thousands would
- 33:05probably be a notch below there. Yeah, Actually ten ten from the twenty
- 33:08twenties and from the twenty ten. So I apologize I missed Cam Johnston,
- 33:13didn't see him down there, and then I probably missed one from the odds.
- 33:19So ten, nine and seven just as we said, and you know,
- 33:22the of the two thousands. Three of them are special teams. It's
- 33:28nugents and it's gain and it's gain. So you know, you along the
- 33:31lines of scrimmage, you know, skill positions, there's just there's not you
- 33:37know, defense, you just it probably isn't quite there. For that decade
- 33:42decade went Ohio State won a lot of football games, including a national championship,
- 33:45but just not quite at the level of the other two because yeah,
- 33:49the odds, here's the first teams from the offense and defense. That's Santonio
- 33:53Holmes, Nick Mangold and James lord Nidis and Mike Down, four players basically
- 34:01for those twenty two spots. And so yeah, I think just as we
- 34:07said, sure, football is a game of field position and it's punting and
- 34:12kicking, but the other decades did okay with that as well. So I
- 34:15think we've done it. We have decided all of this, the best of
- 34:19the nineties, the best of the odds, the best of the twenty tens,
- 34:22the best of those decades together, and then the best players from the
- 34:24last thirty years. We apologize to all of the All Americans and Hall of
- 34:28Famers that were left off the list. That was not our doing. That
- 34:30was the doing of the person who asked the question forced our hand. There's
- 34:35nothing we could do. So I want to thank you all for journey us
- 34:38time. Do you have anything else to add or are we done? No?
- 34:40I think we're done. I think we've Thank you to Isaac for maybe
- 34:44the greatest mail bag question of all time, and thank you for listening.
- 34:47And I hope you guys enjoyed this as much as we did. This is
- 34:50a kind of a kind of a fun series, little trip down memory lane,
- 34:52and a little bit of a fun thought exercise as well. So this
- 34:57is the kind of thing we don't necessarily have time to do during the season,
- 35:00but this is this is the perfect time of year for fun trips down
- 35:04memory lane and you know, theoretical questions like this. Yes, feel free
- 35:08to argue amongst yourselves about all of these different teams with your friends and families.
- 35:12So I want to thank you all for joining us. As always.
- 35:15Please find us at bucket huddle dot com. Become a member of say hellos
- 35:16to hello to us there on the message board. Also, continue to find
- 35:20us at YouTube dot com, slash bucket Huddle, find us on Facebook.
- 35:22Go ahead and continue to download the shows wherever you can, leaving five star
- 35:28ratings interviews, So thank you all for tuning in and we'll talk to you guys later