Latest / SHSMD Podcast Rapid Insights for Health Care Marketers, Planners, and Communicators / You Can’t Market What You Haven’t Built
Transcript
- 0:00Intro: The following SHSMD Podcast is a production of DoctorPodcasting.com.
- 0:05Bill Klaproth (Host): This is the SHSMD Podcast: Rapid Insights for healthcare
- 0:09strategy professionals and planning, business development, marketing,
- 0:13communications, and public relations.
- 0:16I'm your host, Bill Klaproth.
- 0:18With me is Rob Whitehouse, Vice President of Marketing Communications
- 0:22at TriHealth, to discuss the gap between brand promises and patient experiences.
- 0:28We're also going to touch on population health, when to know when you're ready
- 0:32to market a promise, and we're going to touch on service lines versus brand.
- 0:38Rob, welcome to the SHSMD podcast.
- 0:40Rob Whitehouse: Bill, thanks for having me.
- 0:41Host: Great to talk with you, Rob.
- 0:43Thank you so much for your time.
- 0:44I appreciate it.
- 0:44I love this subject.
- 0:45So, let's jump into this: you can't market what you can't build.
- 0:49What are some of the biggest disconnects you see between healthcare brand promises,
- 0:56what we're selling, and the actual patient experience, what they're actually getting?
- 1:01Rob Whitehouse: I think the bottom line tends to be looking at an individual
- 1:04health system is too often we're guided by what the competitor's doing.
- 1:09There's someone we want to be like.
- 1:12And as opposed to finding out who we are, what we're doing that
- 1:15consumers like that makes us unique and special, and focusing on that.
- 1:19And then, you can find yourself marketing a more unique space, which is going
- 1:23to help amplify your brand, as opposed to be trying to compete with others
- 1:28who are all clustered in one space.
- 1:30And we experienced that very recently in some brand work we did, if you want
- 1:34me to go a little deeper into that.
- 1:36Host: Yeah, please do.
- 1:36I'd love to hear that.
- 1:37Rob Whitehouse: So, a couple years ago, we decided to not do
- 1:40a full rebrand, like changing our name, but changing our position.
- 1:44Cincinnati's an extremely crowded market.
- 1:46Between Cincinnati and Dayton, there are seven adult health systems in a
- 1:49market that probably should have three.
- 1:51We have a traditional academic medical center.
- 1:53We have another health system that sort of plays in that space as well, and
- 1:56likes to present itself in that space.
- 1:58And so, it results in a lot of desire, particularly from caregivers, to
- 2:02be playing in that high-end, high acuity, we've got the best doctors and
- 2:06coolest equipment kind of marketing.
- 2:09And what we started to do with the brand research was really look into
- 2:14starting with our own people, talking about what do we do that's different.
- 2:17What do you do that our patients really react to positively?
- 2:22And what we found out is that we were very good in the accessibility and
- 2:26the high touch in the explaining what we're doing, just a lot of the warmth.
- 2:31People felt welcome.
- 2:32They felt heard and seen.
- 2:34So then, we went out and we looked at the consumers and what the consumers had
- 2:37to say about us and then, also, people that weren't coming to us in terms of
- 2:40what they're looking for in healthcare.
- 2:42And we found that we were actually offering a kind of care that was being
- 2:46desired in this marketplace, and we were delivering it fairly consistently.
- 2:50And then, we'll get to that in a moment.
- 2:51But by coming up with a brand that met those areas, we came up with a brand that
- 2:55essentially the tagline is, "Be seen.
- 2:57Be heard.
- 2:57Be healed."
- 2:58And behind that, of course, is a whole bunch of expressions of what
- 3:01that means and how we bring it out into the different marketing tools.
- 3:04But it's very different, very more high touch than what you typically see.
- 3:08But as soon as we put it out there, it resonated with our own team members.
- 3:12When we put it out internally at first, which we do inside-out marketing with
- 3:15this, I actually had people approaching me in tears with our launch saying,
- 3:19"You describe what I do every day."
- 3:22And I'm like, "Okay.
- 3:22I mean, we've hit that.
- 3:23Let's see if we hit the consumer."
- 3:25And the consumer response was extremely good.
- 3:28We've seen our brand scores going up significantly, our brand intent in
- 3:31particular through the roof in terms of people wanting this, because that's not
- 3:34what they were seeking and that's not what they were seeing from our competitors.
- 3:37And so, what's cool is, again, we were just being true to ourselves and
- 3:40trying to find out how do we express that to consumers and having something
- 3:44that was real that I would say about 85% of the time, it's been real.
- 3:50What it's done is create a brand that people get excited about, but
- 3:52also then create some aspiration that we can continue to build
- 3:55on and get to that 100% part.
- 3:57So, it's been not only a brand to excite consumers, but it's been a brand that our
- 4:00leadership has used to really motivate those who aren't hitting the targets the
- 4:05way that we want to see them in terms of patient satisfaction, because that's
- 4:08what's moving the needle everywhere else.
- 4:10Host: Yeah, that really makes sense.
- 4:12And I love how you said that, Rob.
- 4:13So, a lot of healthcare systems are guided by the competition, "Oh, we want
- 4:17to be like that," or, "We should be doing that too," kind of an attitude.
- 4:21Rob Whitehouse: I've been in very other competitive
- 4:22marketplaces and it was just that.
- 4:24And I keep saying that if you let the competitor determine what your marketing
- 4:28strategy is, you've already lost.
- 4:30You've already lost.
- 4:31It's over.
- 4:32Host: That is so true, because you do have to find out what you do.
- 4:35And I like how you said, "We asked, 'What do we do that our patients react to?'"
- 4:40So, that is being truthful then.
- 4:42So if you do market on that, that is what you do.
- 4:45You're not trying to sell this aspirational vision where inside the
- 4:49hospital, there's nowhere near that level that you're trying to reach.
- 4:53So, that's where that disconnect happens.
- 4:55Is that right?
- 4:56Rob Whitehouse: That's true.
- 4:56And I think it's because, within healthcare, you know, we are appropriately
- 5:01focused on quality and high acuity and making sure we're providing the best care.
- 5:05But the reality is a lot of people feel that doctors and hospitals are on par
- 5:10with each other with a few exceptions.
- 5:11There's always the Mayo Clinics and the Cleveland Clinics out there.
- 5:13But generally speaking, they're going to feel quality is at a comparable level.
- 5:17It's what do you do that's different.
- 5:19Now, there are those people who are going to want to go to an academic medical
- 5:21center because of what that means.
- 5:23That's fine.
- 5:24You're not going to compete with that if you're not an academic medical center.
- 5:27But what we're finding when the research is showing that there are
- 5:30a lot of other things people want.
- 5:31Access has always been an issue.
- 5:33But again, this whole thing of being understood and seen and
- 5:35heard has become a real big issue.
- 5:37It's a larger societal issue that is now manifesting itself in healthcare.
- 5:43And so, if we actually have that ability to convey that,
- 5:46that's a huge advantage for us.
- 5:47And we were downplaying it before.
- 5:49Now, we're playing it up.
- 5:50Host: Well, you kind of pinpointed your culture.
- 5:52And then, you used that as well.
- 5:55So basically, brand follows the culture, right?
- 5:58So, that's kind of what you did.
- 6:00Rob Whitehouse: Yeah, you're absolutely right.
- 6:01The culture is the brand, and your job is to express that, as a marketing
- 6:06person, not to try to change the culture because that's not your role.
- 6:09That's the role of senior leadership.
- 6:11And so, the fact that we were able to tie into it.
- 6:14And by the way, since we did this, I'd like to point out, since we did tie
- 6:16into the culture, it became something that my CEO was extremely proud of,
- 6:22and he touted it all over the place what we had done, because he saw what
- 6:25we did is not just marketing stuff.
- 6:27What he saw was, you're taking what I value, which is a culture
- 6:31that I've helped create, and you've turned it out to the public, and
- 6:34the public's responded to that.
- 6:36And so, think how that made him feel.
- 6:38This wasn't just marketing mumbo jumbo.
- 6:39It was actually tying into what makes us special and something
- 6:43that made the CEO very proud.
- 6:45Host: Well, when you feel we do things differently here and you're able
- 6:48to pinpoint that, and then you're able to market that and you see
- 6:51how people react to it positively, that's got to make you feel good.
- 6:55It's like we work to build this culture.
- 6:58And now, at least we're getting it out there and people are recognizing
- 7:01that and reflecting that as well.
- 7:03So Rob, I do want to touch on population health a little bit as well.
- 7:06We hear this term bandied about all the time.
- 7:10Population health is more healthcare language than consumer language,
- 7:14yet we still use population health.
- 7:17Consumers don't really don't connect with that language.
- 7:19Why do you think that is?
- 7:20And what kinds of messaging resonate more effectively with patients?
- 7:24Rob Whitehouse: I've been struggling with this for over a decade in two different
- 7:27health systems I've worked with that have been in the population health model.
- 7:30And we talk about it in such an academic way that the general
- 7:33consumer just doesn't care.
- 7:35And I don't think we're ever going to come up with a great shorthand
- 7:37way of describing it, other than to continue to highlight the things
- 7:41that we're doing differently that all add up to population health, such
- 7:46as being proactive with screenings.
- 7:49Our patients understand that we do that more.
- 7:51They feel that's part of our high touch of being caring.
- 7:53But that's really population health, for us getting out there.
- 7:56And our patients are more likely to be screened for breast cancer, more
- 7:59likely to be screened for colon cancer.
- 8:01Our numbers are fantastic in that regard, and we're catching
- 8:03things earlier because of it.
- 8:05And so, it's working for us.
- 8:07And I think that really is the lesson, is continue to talk about the
- 8:11experience, I guess, from the lens of population health without trying to do
- 8:15a lecture to the consumer on population health because they don't care.
- 8:19They want to know they're having an experience they want.
- 8:21They want to know that they have a doctor that cares about their health
- 8:23and is keeping them healthier without getting into the nuts and bolts
- 8:26of what pop health actually means.
- 8:28And it seems to be moving the needle for us.
- 8:30Because when people talk about us online and they make those references
- 8:34to the care they had, they're describing population health without even knowing
- 8:38it, and that's just fine by me.
- 8:39They don't need to be able to write a dissertation on population health.
- 8:43Just know that we're doing something different to make their lives healthier.
- 8:46Host: So for a health system trying to mature their population health
- 8:50strategy, in your opinion, what are some signs that they're truly
- 8:54ready to market that promise?
- 8:57And maybe what are some signs that they might not be there yet?
- 9:01Rob Whitehouse: I think that you've got to make sure you have
- 9:03the infrastructure in place.
- 9:05And I mean operationally have the infrastructure in place, that you're
- 9:09going to be able to give those high-touch experiences where you have the navigators
- 9:13or the technology that's reaching out to make sure that, "Hey, you're due for this
- 9:16screening," or, "You're at risk for this.
- 9:18Did you know, like, this lung cancer screening's available to you
- 9:21because you used to be a smoker?"
- 9:22And having all that data in there that can be acted upon, whether you're using
- 9:27AI or whether you're using humans to do it, if you do not have the ability to be
- 9:31proactive with it, then you shouldn't be out there marketing population health.
- 9:35I mean, that's just a baseline in my opinion to be able to do that.
- 9:39And also, have the services, the additional services that are necessary
- 9:43to make population health work in the way that you're getting to root causes.
- 9:46So, you need to make sure you have a good dietary staff that's a lot to deal
- 9:51with your hypertension and your diabetes.
- 9:53If you're not able to provide those services to manage it, then you're
- 9:55not a population health organization.
- 9:58Host: Well, that makes sense, Rob.
- 9:59Like you said, operationally, you have to be ready to fulfill that brand
- 10:04promise before you go to market with it.
- 10:07That just makes sense.
- 10:09And then, let's flip the tables a little bit.
- 10:12What if you're in the situation where you're a healthcare marketer and you're
- 10:17being asked by people above you to promote your population health initiatives or
- 10:23your transformative initiatives before the organization has operationalized them?
- 10:30What if you're being asked to promote this and you know we're not ready for this yet?
- 10:34What's your advice to marketers in that situation?
- 10:36Rob Whitehouse: Well, the only way you're going to win in marketing is
- 10:38making sure you have the research.
- 10:40And that's one of the reasons we do such detailed internal research
- 10:43along with consumer research.
- 10:46And the internal probably was the key here because, if externally they're telling
- 10:50you no one believes you're doing this, including our existing patients, there
- 10:53might be some hesitancy like, "Well, then marketing's not telling the story."
- 10:57But if the internal research comes back and it's like our own people don't believe
- 11:00we're doing this, that's really bad.
- 11:02And so, the internal research is not something to be overlooked when you're
- 11:06doing the brand research, because they're the ones who will tell you
- 11:09it's like, "We're not doing that.
- 11:10We're not there yet."
- 11:11And then, you just push back with the data on them.
- 11:13Host: Yeah, that makes sense.
- 11:15You can certainly prepare and win that argument more if you have that
- 11:19data as well to go along with it.
- 11:22Rob Whitehouse: I was going to add one more thought, if you don't mind here.
- 11:25And that is, you know, when we say you're ready, I usually say
- 11:2880/20 rule very much that feel like you're most of the way there.
- 11:33You don't have to be 100% there.
- 11:35And I alluded to earlier, the fact that it inspires them to get the rest of the way.
- 11:39So once again, you don't need to be so hardcore that it has to be
- 11:42100% when you have this survey back from your team members.
- 11:46It could be when you get to a certain directional point that it feels like three
- 11:49quarters of the organization is doing it, then I think you're at a good spot to go.
- 11:53And then, you can move the rest through the marketing efforts.
- 11:55But earlier than that, you probably would be not in a good position in the market.
- 12:00Host: So, I love that 80/20 rule or even three-quarters of the way.
- 12:03So, that really makes sense.
- 12:05So Rob, let's talk about service lines versus brand a little bit.
- 12:08So, healthcare organizations often market individual service
- 12:12lines very aggressively.
- 12:14As we know, service line marketing drives volume, brand marketing builds trust.
- 12:20How can systems balance service line growth goals while still building
- 12:25a cohesive brand experience?
- 12:29Rob Whitehouse: Yeah.
- 12:29That's where you've really touched on it.
- 12:31It is an interesting struggle that goes on in that.
- 12:34One of the things that we do is we look at primary care or the
- 12:37entry points for population health, which are PCPs, but also GYNs.
- 12:41And in some cases, even cardiology to a certain extent can be an
- 12:44entry point for a lot of folks.
- 12:46We promote those more heavily than the other things.
- 12:49So if you look at, I guess, a traditional model, you probably have a slight
- 12:53undercurrent of things that are always going on with brand, but then you have
- 12:56these big spikes of the service lines that, maybe for this period, we'll be
- 12:59doing ortho, and then we'll be doing heart, and then we'll be doing neuro.
- 13:02That kind of model is pretty typical.
- 13:04We kind of flip it in that putting a lot more in the entry points
- 13:09going across the entire year.
- 13:11But then, we will have these smaller spikes of our service lines throughout
- 13:15using the same language, using the same themes, the whole look and feel,
- 13:20with something that would be more focused towards cardiology or for
- 13:24cancer or for one of the service lines.
- 13:26So, we do spike like the traditional model of service line marketing looks, but
- 13:33it is concurrent with what's constantly going on in the entry point marketing.
- 13:38And then, what we're doing is putting more effort into educating our primary care
- 13:42physicians, to make sure that the referral patterns are going right, that they're
- 13:46armed with what they need in order to get a patient, convinced that they should go
- 13:50see one of our oncologists or one of our cardiologists or whatever, because that's
- 13:56the way the population health model works.
- 13:58You're trying to get them in.
- 13:59You're trying to put together a care plan for them and for a lifelong experience
- 14:03and trying to keep them within the network so you can manage that care better.
- 14:07So, really educating the referring physicians have been a big role for us
- 14:12in doing that, but then also keeping a certain amount of air cover of marketing.
- 14:17So, they're not having to carry it all themselves, but we do make
- 14:20sure we have those spikes up there.
- 14:21So, people see our cardiology advertising.
- 14:24They do see all of the different service lines.
- 14:27But it really is then up to the doctors, the referring physicians
- 14:30to carry them the rest of the way.
- 14:32Host: So, do you then connect both the individual service lines into
- 14:37the broader promise of the brand that you were talking about before?
- 14:41Is that what you do?
- 14:42Rob Whitehouse: Very much so.
- 14:43I'll give you an example.
- 14:44We did a cancer campaign that was after our brand launch.
- 14:47And it was Ask Fearlessly.
- 14:49And,so , if our overarching brand easily summarizes be seen, be
- 14:52heard, be healed, here you are in cancer saying, "Ask fearlessly.
- 14:56Don't be afraid to ask the questions.
- 14:57We're listening."
- 14:58So, all the service line campaigns, they have their unique spin that are meant
- 15:02for the service line, but you can easily connect them back to the master brand.
- 15:07Host: Absolutely.
- 15:08You can certainly fulfill that brand promise within
- 15:11each individual service line.
- 15:14Rob, you've been around, for sure, and doing a great job right now at TriHealth.
- 15:19When we talk about you can't market what you can't build?
- 15:22How often do you see this problem in our industry?
- 15:25Rob Whitehouse: I think it's very common.
- 15:27One of the things that we make a mistake as marketing folks, if something works
- 15:31for us in one market, and then we move to another health system, then we're going to
- 15:35try to replicate that in the new market.
- 15:37and maybe that's not what this system needs, it's not what this market needs.
- 15:40And I see that quite a bit that there are individuals saying, "This worked here.
- 15:44So, let's just plant it over here and it'll work."
- 15:46And that's not how to do it.
- 15:48You've got to get in, sit down, listen, learn the culture, find out what
- 15:52they're all about, find out what the market's all about and the dynamic.
- 15:56This is my fourth health system now, and I was even a consultant for
- 15:59some other health systems at times.
- 16:01And every one of them was different of how we played it out because of the uniqueness
- 16:05of each system and each marketplace.
- 16:08Host: Yeah, that's kind of a classic leadership fail, trying to come in with
- 16:11a completely different team and market makeup, trying to reproduce what you
- 16:15did and what worked somewhere else.
- 16:17Facets of it can work.
- 16:20But by and large, like you said, if you don't come in, listen and learn and adapt
- 16:25and adjust, usually, it doesn't work.
- 16:27Rob Whitehouse: Right.
- 16:27The only thing that you should be able to repeat is the process and how you
- 16:30got to the answer, not the answer.
- 16:32Host: Rob, this has been fascinating.
- 16:34I love this conversation.
- 16:35Thank you so much for your time today.
- 16:37I really appreciate it.
- 16:38Rob Whitehouse: Well, thanks for having me.
- 16:39Host: You bet.
- 16:40Love to have you back on again.
- 16:41Really good stuff.
- 16:42Once again, that is Rob Whitehouse.
- 16:44And don't forget, SHSMD Connections is approaching.
- 16:47Remember to register at shsmd.org/education/annualconference.
- 16:53And if you found this podcast helpful, please share it on your social channels,
- 16:56and please hit the subscribe or follow button so you get every episode.
- 17:00And to access our full podcast library for other topics of interest
- 17:03to you, visit shshmd.org/podcast.
- 17:07Once again, thanks to Rob for a great interview.
- 17:10This has been a production of Doctor Podcasting.
- 17:13I'm Bill Klaproth.
- 17:14See ya!