Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / From Hashtags to Handshakes: Building Compliant Partnerships in the $500B Creator Economy
Transcript
- 0:06Hi, everyone. My name is April Paredes, and I
- 0:08will be moderating today's program, Building
- 0:10Compliant Partnerships in the 500 Billion Creator
- 0:13Economy. This rapidly growing space blends IP
- 0:16challenges, AI content, and shifting regulations
- 0:19far beyond just influencer marketing. Whether
- 0:22you're an entertainment attorney or simply curious
- 0:24about this legal landscape, we are glad you're
- 0:26here. I'm delighted to introduce our speakers,
- 0:29Tisha Morris, Nyansa Shaw, and Matthew Dysart.
- 0:32Tisha Morris is the founder of Legacy Arts Law
- 0:36PC, dedicated to helping artists and creators
- 0:38build and protect their legacies in entertainment
- 0:41and publishing. Tisha is a best -selling nonfiction
- 0:44author and the host of the Entertainment Business
- 0:47Podcast, where the creative life meets the business
- 0:50of entertainment, turning dreams into reality.
- 0:53As a Nashville and Tennessee native, Tisha began
- 0:56her legal career with two federal judicial clerkships
- 0:59before practicing law for over two decades. Nyantza
- 1:03Shaw is fueled by a passion for the creative
- 1:05industries and has helped numerous high -profile
- 1:07projects, providing strategic advice that transcends
- 1:10conventional legal frameworks. Her keen insight
- 1:13into industry trends and her unwavering commitment
- 1:15to protecting her client's interests have made
- 1:18her a trusted advisor and a respected authority
- 1:21in the legal field. Nianta specializes in helping
- 1:24businesses and brands bridge the gap between
- 1:26the creative ventures and business operations
- 1:28to maximize growth and impact. Matthew Dysart
- 1:32is an experienced entertainment attorney with
- 1:34deep expertise across television, feature films,
- 1:37podcasts, digital media and technology, and the
- 1:39creator economy. He has handled more than $2
- 1:42billion in corporate development, M &A, film
- 1:44and TV, slate finance, and production deals,
- 1:47acting as the outside general counsel and deal
- 1:50advisor to production companies. creators, and
- 1:53tech firms. Matthew's practice includes representing
- 1:55several leading podcasts, digital media, and
- 1:58film and television production companies and
- 2:01talent, many of which leverage their brands into
- 2:03successful consumer products, publishing, and
- 2:06live event ventures. And now let's get started.
- 2:09Next slide, please. So this is our agenda. We'll
- 2:14be touching topics on emergence of the creator
- 2:16economy, monetization strategies, illegal pitfalls,
- 2:20emerging regulations, and then we'll finish our
- 2:23presentation with Q &A. Throughout the presentation,
- 2:25feel free to send us your questions and we'll
- 2:27address them at the end. Next slide, please.
- 2:31Market snapshot. So let's start by understanding
- 2:33the size and structure of the space. The creator
- 2:36economy is no longer a side hustle. It's projected
- 2:40to be worth 500 billion globally, over 200 million
- 2:43people identify as creators, and nearly 40 %
- 2:46do it full time. Platforms like TikTok, YouTube,
- 2:49and Patreon have allowed individual creators
- 2:51to build direct -to -audience businesses. But
- 2:54with rapid growth comes fragmentation, and often
- 2:57confusion about rights, responsibilities, and
- 3:00revenue. I'm going to direct this question to
- 3:02Tisha, but Matthew and Neonza, please feel free
- 3:05to chime in as well. So Tisha, how has the rise
- 3:09of the creator economy changed the kinds of legal
- 3:12issues clients are bringing to you? Thanks, April,
- 3:24and thanks to the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 3:27for hosting us. Well, first off, we are in a
- 3:31time we've never been in. This is a very exciting
- 3:34place where the creator economy has merged with
- 3:39the more traditional entertainment space. There
- 3:46are all kinds of mash -up of issues that are
- 3:49playing out, one being with brand awareness being
- 3:53a strong part of the content creator with FTC
- 3:58compliance issues coming up, ownership being
- 4:03a big hot topic in the content creator space.
- 4:07in all forms of entertainment now because of
- 4:10the content creator space as well. So it's just
- 4:13a really interesting time with new issues coming
- 4:17up, the main one being ownership, which I'm sure
- 4:20we'll expound on throughout today. But in terms
- 4:27of the legal challenges that you've experienced
- 4:30with your own list of clients, what has changed
- 4:34in terms of the Are there novel issues that your
- 4:39clients are bringing to you that you've not necessarily
- 4:41seen, but because of the space that's been created?
- 4:46Well, because of the emergence of the content
- 4:49creator space, there is more leverage they have.
- 4:53And so like I said, the ownership, but approvals
- 4:56specificity on deliverables is always needs to
- 5:01be fine -tuned and also the shift of liability
- 5:04who is going to take the brunt of the liability.
- 5:08And so really negotiating on behalf of my client,
- 5:11my content creator clients is the side that I'm
- 5:14usually on. And so really making sure, number
- 5:19one, they are aware of what they're signing and
- 5:22what needs to be changed so that it is more drafted
- 5:27in favor of them, or at least on a 50 -50 level.
- 5:33But definitely, pretty much every point in the
- 5:37contract, termination clauses, deliverables,
- 5:41exclusivity, ownership, yeah. The creator economy
- 5:48continues to mature. We're seeing more creators
- 5:51function like full -fledged businesses. So they
- 5:54generate revenue, they're signing concerts, they're
- 5:56hiring teams, right, and building brands. But
- 5:59unlike traditional businesses or even entertainers
- 6:02representing by agents or studios, many creators
- 6:05are building this from scratch, often without.
- 6:08legal support early on, what are some unique
- 6:12challenges, legal challenges, you would say content
- 6:14creators face compared to traditional businesses
- 6:17that are just starting out? I'd love to see what
- 6:20if possible, April or Tisha, do you have a specific?
- 6:22No, you go ahead, Danza. As Tisha mentioned,
- 6:27as the content creator economy is growing, they
- 6:29are moving towards more production studio, studio
- 6:33base is different than just a pay to post, right?
- 6:35So the difference is, is that they're going from
- 6:38technically creating content to producing content.
- 6:42And so it's not necessarily that there's you
- 6:44know, there are some new um legal challenges
- 6:48that are coming up but I think that they are
- 6:50in their growing pains realizing that there's
- 6:53different types of deal structures that are now
- 6:55applying to the type of business that they're
- 6:58now operating whether it's by the way from scratch
- 7:01even setting up a company setting up a production
- 7:03company how they're engaging and producing content
- 7:06beyond um you know on their phone specifically
- 7:11for a platform. And so then that goes into the
- 7:14types of deals that they're doing with brands
- 7:16and with corporations to see what platform is
- 7:20this going to be on? What type of content are
- 7:22they creating? Where is it being shared? And
- 7:23then it goes to what Tisha was talking about
- 7:25in terms of all the deal structures that come
- 7:27into play along with that growth. I'll add one
- 7:32comment to that. I think that's a really valuable
- 7:35response. You know, one of the things we see
- 7:39with traditional businesses or entertainers is
- 7:41that when they get ready to form a company and
- 7:45establish a brand adjacent to their primary work
- 7:48as actors or writers or directors, and so maybe
- 7:51now they're venturing out into, you know, consumer
- 7:54products or consumer packaged goods or related
- 7:58ventures. By that point in their career, they've
- 8:02often got a team. They've got a team of professionals
- 8:05and they've got access to a lot of capital. And
- 8:08they may even have a production company established
- 8:10already that they can begin to operate these
- 8:12ventures through. And so they're pretty well
- 8:15professionalized and they have access to a lot
- 8:18of professional assistance to make sure that
- 8:20as they build and launch new businesses, they
- 8:23do it in a smart way, in a risk adjusted way.
- 8:26And so with our traditional talent, we often
- 8:28see that they're surrounded by very highly qualified
- 8:31financiers and operators. For our creator clients,
- 8:36it's often surprising how quickly they mature
- 8:39into becoming platforms. Because the barriers
- 8:44to entry are so low and production and distribution
- 8:47is so easily available to them at scale, they
- 8:51reach that point sooner where they're able to
- 8:53branch out and launch and operate businesses.
- 8:56It might be a studio business or it might be
- 8:57a consumer product. They don't always have access
- 9:03to a strong team, great, well -qualified financiers,
- 9:09top -tier operators, lawyers, and other advisors.
- 9:13And so we do see creators sometimes launching
- 9:16businesses without the infrastructure you need
- 9:18for that new venture to go well, to land well,
- 9:23to avoid product risk. messaging risk, comms
- 9:29and PR problems, and then other kind of execution
- 9:32risks of a new business. And so we see a lot
- 9:36more operational hiccups with creator -backed
- 9:39businesses. And so one of the things that we
- 9:40see kind of emerging to fill the gap in the marketplace
- 9:44that this creates is this joint venture between
- 9:48talent and platforms, businesses that have been
- 9:53established to help creators launch these brands
- 9:56and operate companies without having to hire
- 10:00the full team themselves and build all of the
- 10:02back office and even front office infrastructure
- 10:04you need to run a business. And we'll talk more,
- 10:08I think, about that business model in this conversation.
- 10:11But that model is, I think, one of the more interesting
- 10:17things emerging in the creator space and one
- 10:19of the more successful approaches that we see
- 10:21our clients taking. In regards to your response
- 10:25to the question, Matthew, and you mentioning
- 10:27these creators are having teams, right? So we
- 10:33understand that the creator economy isn't just
- 10:36made up of influencers. It's a web of players,
- 10:39including creators themselves, agencies, or managers
- 10:41who represent them, right? And the platforms
- 10:44that distribute and monetize their content. Each
- 10:47of these players serves a different role, but
- 10:49those roles often blur in practice, especially
- 10:52when it comes to their legal rights and responsibilities.
- 10:55So in this ecosystem of creators, agencies, and
- 10:58platforms, how should we think about the respective
- 11:01legal rights and responsibilities? So I'll jump
- 11:08in, kind of pinging off what Matthew said, depending
- 11:12on what stage of their business they're at, they
- 11:15either have a full team or just themselves, and
- 11:18that's going to determine a lot. But overall,
- 11:21it is an area of entertainment that's kind of
- 11:24disrupting the whole model, the agent model,
- 11:26the studio model. And it kind of is a little
- 11:30bit of a wild west as far as the traditional
- 11:33roles that the players play. But at the end of
- 11:36the day, the legal agreements are still are still
- 11:40about the same as far as what needs to be negotiated
- 11:43or how they need to be protected. But really,
- 11:47to Matthew's point, shifting or not shifting,
- 11:50but the attorney being as much of the business
- 11:52attorney is the entertainment attorney taking
- 11:56on that role of of how they're setting up their
- 11:59business. Do they have the right team players?
- 12:02Do they have their own agreements in place with
- 12:05their own work for hire people that are working
- 12:09for them? Having all those pieces in place. Right.
- 12:15And with that, let's go on to the next slide
- 12:17so that way we can focus more on the legal challenges
- 12:20for creators. I think that's a nice segue for
- 12:23that. So one of the biggest gaps as we've been
- 12:26talking about in our conversation so far that
- 12:30we see in the creator economy is that many...
- 12:33creators start building a brand before they build
- 12:35a legal foundation. They're posting content,
- 12:38signing deals, and monetizing their work, often
- 12:40without clear contracts, IP protection, or even
- 12:43a business entity in place. And when something
- 12:46goes wrong, whether it's a copyright dispute,
- 12:49a brand disagreement, or a platform issue, that's
- 12:53when the lack of legal infrastructure can cause
- 12:56serious damage. So what are the most common copyright
- 12:59or IP disputes that in your experience you've
- 13:03seen that creators face and how can these be
- 13:05avoided early on? I'll jump in here. I know both
- 13:11on actually the talent and the brand side, one
- 13:13of the challenges that come up is even the initial
- 13:15protection of the IP because they're going to
- 13:18do a deal for rights and it's like, well, what
- 13:20have you done to establish your ownership in
- 13:23these rights before you're granting any rights
- 13:25to a third party, right? Whether it's a brand,
- 13:27whether it's a platform, et cetera. And so when
- 13:30they are kind of cart before the horse on creating
- 13:33content and not having their business structure
- 13:34set up, that's a challenge that comes up where
- 13:37it's like, okay, well, you have to be able to
- 13:39show a brand that you own the IP, right? Before
- 13:42you can even monetize it, before you can even
- 13:45exploit it. And so that piece is that first piece.
- 13:48And then I think going to even identifying the
- 13:51scope of rights and how they're being used, who
- 13:53they're being granted to, et cetera. And I will
- 13:56mention quickly here in terms of monetization
- 13:59because this doesn't come up as often, but I've
- 14:02also worked with brands and doing branded content
- 14:05and et cetera. And it's actually a very interesting
- 14:09gap even between their knowledge of how to do
- 14:12these deals. as well as the creator talent size
- 14:16knowledge of how to do these deals. And so I
- 14:19have been in places where we're educating the
- 14:22brand on what is your ROI? What are you trying
- 14:24to get from this content creator or influencer
- 14:26so that we can structure the best deal for your
- 14:29ROI, right? Because it's not just about making
- 14:31a post or it's not just about, you know, they'll
- 14:33say, because they don't know. Yeah, we do want
- 14:36something live for a year, but we know in real
- 14:39time, keeping something on, you know, your feed
- 14:41for a year really isn't any of value. And so
- 14:45those kind of knowledge gaps, so I think it goes
- 14:48from the ownership piece, determining what the
- 14:50rights are, and even the knowledge gaps on both
- 14:52ends of trying to figure out how this deal works
- 14:55for both parties in terms of going to those,
- 14:58you know, the ownership piece of who's going
- 15:01to retain ownership, what's going to be granted,
- 15:03etc. There's two, I think that's a really good,
- 15:06there's maybe three actual real big kind of challenges
- 15:10I see working with brands in these deals. One
- 15:13is ownership. Like you said, we often see brands
- 15:16initially taking the position that they should
- 15:17own the creators content and a brand deal. And
- 15:21I have a pretty hard and fast rule. There's only
- 15:24a few cases where it makes sense for the brand
- 15:27to own that content. And that's when they're
- 15:29really hiding the talent as an actor for your
- 15:32commercial or campaign that the brand has previously
- 15:35produced. But if it's social content, if it's
- 15:38creator -produced content that's being distributed
- 15:40on their channels, we have a pretty firm rule
- 15:44that the creator must own all of their own content.
- 15:47We also see brands often refusing to provide
- 15:52indemnity for content that they create, intellectual
- 15:55property that they contribute to the creator
- 15:57for inclusion in a deal. We get a lot of pushback
- 16:00on that point. and have a pretty hard rule there
- 16:04as well. If the brand is contributing something,
- 16:06they should stand behind whatever that intellectual
- 16:09property represents, whether it includes music,
- 16:12it includes their trademarks, whether it's other
- 16:14just sort of creative format related contributions
- 16:17that they make as part of their review process
- 16:20on the content. And then the third is insurance.
- 16:24It's critically important that the creator is
- 16:27covered by the brand's insurance policy for the
- 16:30campaign that they're engaging in. When you are
- 16:35negotiating these brand deals, right? And there's
- 16:40like a set time of when they can use the creator
- 16:43content or for a period of time. Are you seeing
- 16:47that brands want to use that content indefinitely,
- 16:52or they want to use it on different platforms
- 16:54that wasn't originally negotiated? Or what pushback
- 16:58do you see from brands in terms of when they
- 17:01want to I guess, license the content for a period
- 17:04of time and use it for other purposes. Well,
- 17:11I think all those guardrails need to be put in
- 17:13place in the contract. And I think you've hit
- 17:16on the nail of what those negotiated points are.
- 17:22It's how I see it. And it's a mass point where
- 17:26it isn't necessarily just about the ownership
- 17:30piece of it, but it is really specifically in
- 17:33this creator economy, how it is being used, where
- 17:37it is being used, and how long it's being used.
- 17:43Our brand partners are pretty thoughtful about
- 17:46structuring parameters around those use cases,
- 17:51so when and where, and how much paid promotion
- 17:55they can provide behind a post, that sort of
- 17:57thing. And they're responsive to the lawyer asking
- 18:03to define those things carefully, because that's
- 18:05really half the rate card is how it's being used.
- 18:08And then the other half is what price they're
- 18:09going to pay for those uses. So definitely important
- 18:13to make sure that the brand is not getting unlimited
- 18:16usage rights, perpetual usage rights for all
- 18:18media without paying for them. Yeah, and as I
- 18:21mentioned before we see that some brands realize
- 18:24that when we're saying it's not you're not going
- 18:26to just use it in perpetuity or you're not just
- 18:28going to use it broadly they understand it's
- 18:30like okay if you're paying this price this is
- 18:32a value proposition of what you're paying for
- 18:34but also this is again what is the benefit for
- 18:37what you're paying for that you're trying to
- 18:39achieve from this partnership and that is it
- 18:42usually again use in perpetuity or use on all
- 18:45platforms because they do want to be smart about
- 18:48getting a return on their investment Exactly.
- 18:52What would you say is the most overlooked clause
- 18:55in a typical creator agreement and why is it
- 18:58important? I'd say one. I mean, there's we could
- 19:04really riff on this question a lot, but I think
- 19:07one important one is the termination clause in
- 19:09which is I kind of think of that in terms of
- 19:12almost all contracts is termination clause. But
- 19:16specifically with content creators having a morals
- 19:20or cancel clause. on both sides, not just on
- 19:24the creator, but also to the brand. So I think
- 19:28and just having reasonable outs on both sides.
- 19:33I think the other one that comes up a lot is
- 19:35exclusivity. And when you are defining what an
- 19:40exclusive market or exclusive industry is, and
- 19:43sometimes and again, I think generally brands
- 19:47who want to do business in this space are open
- 19:49to advice from the lawyer, but it is that it's
- 19:53not going to be the entire wellness space or
- 19:55the entire drink industry. And you're trying
- 19:58to umbrella things where it's like, okay, let's
- 20:00figure out how we can work together and not feel
- 20:04like there's any conflict with competing brands
- 20:07in a more reasonable, justifiable way that isn't
- 20:10blanketing. blocking the content creator from
- 20:15also doing other deals that may be in similar
- 20:17industries but are for totally different products
- 20:20that might overlap but are not competing. Right.
- 20:28I know we've talked about this on the beginning
- 20:30that creators are operating more like businesses
- 20:33now. At what stage should a creator formalize
- 20:36a business entity and what risks do they face
- 20:38if they delay? Because they start off like just
- 20:41posting content, right? And then they start getting
- 20:43a large following. And then often the times is
- 20:48that they forget to formalize their business.
- 20:51So can you speak a little bit about that? I would
- 20:56say pretty early again because that might be
- 20:58part of the conversation in regards to the ownership
- 21:00of the rights. Do you want to have your company
- 21:03own certain rights, maybe own your YouTube show,
- 21:07maybe own these other things under a company
- 21:09so that the company is licensing it and I'm not
- 21:11a tax advisor, but obviously having a legal structure
- 21:15and then determining what IP is under the legal
- 21:18structure rather than personally owning it. is
- 21:20going to depend on, you know, how you're getting
- 21:22paid for that use, doing these deals, all of
- 21:25those things and potential tax implications.
- 21:30Yeah, I agree. I mean, I think as soon as they
- 21:32are committed to making this a business, once
- 21:34they and that's, you know, something that all.
- 21:37All creatives or all business people, you know,
- 21:39you get at that point where, OK, I'm going to
- 21:41really go for this and I'm going to, you know,
- 21:43file an LLC. And there are tax considerations
- 21:47and admin costs and all that to consider. But
- 21:50definitely, to Nan's point, as soon as possible,
- 21:54just to kind of start setting up the foundations.
- 21:58The only thing I'll add here is I think the tax
- 22:01advantages of having a loan out company. The
- 22:04sort of like income threshold passed where you
- 22:07need to be to where that becomes important to
- 22:10you. But separate from the idea of a loan out,
- 22:14which is kind of limited in terms of the legal
- 22:18liability shield that it forms for you. It really
- 22:21doesn't give a whole lot of value there. But
- 22:24if you're a creator and you're beginning to hire
- 22:26people, if you're beginning to sign lease agreements
- 22:31for space, You're doing larger commercial partnerships.
- 22:36Now you're operating a business. You've got studio
- 22:40space. You're working with independent contractors
- 22:43who maybe you're hiring performers in your videos.
- 22:47At that point, you really do need to have a proper
- 22:50business and you don't want to be doing that
- 22:52as an individual. That is now going to that space
- 22:56where we now have content creators who have legitimate
- 23:00businesses set up, they're doing joint ventures,
- 23:02they're doing investment deals, they're doing
- 23:04production deals with other large companies.
- 23:06And to Matthew's point, like those are going
- 23:08to be company foreign partnerships. That's right.
- 23:13Exactly. And let's move on to the next slide
- 23:17regarding monetization strategies. So as a creator
- 23:20brand, partnerships are growing more complex,
- 23:23right? We're seeing deals that go beyond one
- 23:25-time payments, now including equity, long -term
- 23:28rights, and even AI usage. So legal advisors
- 23:31are key in helping creators navigate these terms
- 23:34and protect their interests. So with that context,
- 23:37I'd like to ask a few questions about how you
- 23:39approach those evolving agreements. So we're
- 23:42seeing more creators ask for equity and partnerships.
- 23:45What little concerns do you consider when structuring
- 23:47those deals? Yeah, I mean, this really taps into
- 23:53my thesis for the space, which is that creators
- 23:57should be owners. And when they're collaborating
- 24:00with brand partners, It's a unique opportunity
- 24:04for the brand to get access to a certain demographic
- 24:07and to get access to a very efficient form of
- 24:10reach. And so I just believe that creators should
- 24:14always approach everything they do from the perspective
- 24:17of an entrepreneur who wants to own everything
- 24:20that they're promoting and not just be sort of
- 24:24work for hire. That's not going to work for every
- 24:26deal. for an agency -run campaign where they're
- 24:32renting reach across 1 ,000 creators, that's
- 24:35not the approach to take. But for larger partnerships
- 24:39where the creator is being engaged by an earlier
- 24:43-stage company, and they're really at the formative
- 24:46stage, providing meaningful value and helping
- 24:49that new brand to break through to an audience,
- 24:52I just love this model of the creator as owner.
- 24:56There are a bunch of legal considerations there.
- 24:59Some of them are tax driven, and some of them
- 25:02are product driven. If you're a creator who's
- 25:08a joint owner in a business, you do have to be
- 25:11careful about validating the business that you're
- 25:14working with. And so you want to make sure that
- 25:16you're not taking on things like product liability
- 25:19risk or operational risk for the business. You
- 25:21want to make sure you're covered by their insurance
- 25:23policies. And you want to make sure that the
- 25:26form of equity or ownership style ownership and
- 25:31control that you take in that business is tax
- 25:33advantaged for you. And there's many different
- 25:35models that you can use to ensure that, but it's
- 25:39critically important for talent to make sure
- 25:41that they have a good business lawyer working
- 25:44with them as they take equity style arrangements
- 25:48and brand partnerships. I would say along those
- 25:54lines that especially in terms of thinking about
- 25:57when you're taking equity, two things come up.
- 26:00One is that a lot of times people are having
- 26:02conversations and they're saying, you're going
- 26:04to get a share of the company, you're going to
- 26:05get a share of the company. And defining, is
- 26:09that an actual equity share? Is it a revenue
- 26:12share? What are you saying when we're sharing?
- 26:15Let's clarify what that is. And on the equity
- 26:17side, then thinking about how big is this venture
- 26:21going to be? Because are there vesting schedules?
- 26:23Are there dilution risks? What happens when the
- 26:26company ends, right? It's kind of going back
- 26:28to teachable. There has to be some sort of termination
- 26:30clause, some sort of out at some point that has
- 26:32to be considered on the front end. So we want
- 26:35to be smart about those things. But part of it
- 26:37is just structuring. What does that equity piece
- 26:39look like? When again, maybe does it vest? How
- 26:45is it like a true ownership or is it just an
- 26:47equity piece? and leaning into for sure, you
- 26:52want that to be an ownership piece because they
- 26:54are bringing IP, they are bringing a value. And
- 26:58a lot of times they're also bringing their own
- 26:59financial to the partnership. And so making sure
- 27:03all of those considerations are taken into account.
- 27:07I think those are great points. And it so varies
- 27:10in the sophistication of agreements that are
- 27:15produced or presented depending on the company.
- 27:19You can't assume that just because a company
- 27:22says, hey, we'll give you five percent and in
- 27:24a very short agreement, it's missing a lot of
- 27:27the points that Nianza just pointed out. Really
- 27:29being aware that you don't trust necessarily
- 27:34the level of sophistication of who you might
- 27:37be dealing with. Definitely appreciate your insights
- 27:43regarding this space, because as we see more
- 27:45creators having large followings and getting
- 27:48these brand deals, that is something that they
- 27:51should be pushing for. In terms of advising creators
- 27:55on specific brand deals, what are the key and
- 28:00legal business factors that you evaluate before
- 28:02recommending that they sign or renegotiate? Well,
- 28:08I think we talked about the biggest one, which
- 28:10is the ownership piece. We also mentioned the
- 28:13exclusivity. Again, that big line of what is
- 28:17actual usage and then determining what those
- 28:20fees are. And it's very interesting. Again, as
- 28:24the creative economy has grown, the types of
- 28:29fee structures have evolved tremendously because
- 28:32it's not just a paid a post. And then is there
- 28:36some sort of performance? Is there additional
- 28:37content to be created? Is there some sort of
- 28:40hybrid payment model? Is there payment over a
- 28:42period of time? Because there's a long standing
- 28:44engagement of multiple posts, content, et cetera,
- 28:49that's created over a long period of time. Like
- 28:51all of those things go into figuring out the
- 28:54value proposition, but also making sure that
- 28:56the talent or the content creator is protected.
- 29:01As you are drafting these contracts, and also
- 29:05another layer to contract negotiations across
- 29:09different aspects of the entertainment industry
- 29:12is AI and how AI fits into this. Have you noticed
- 29:17any new or evolving clauses in influencer contracts
- 29:20recently, such as AI replication rights or platform
- 29:26usage terms regarding AI in this space? I haven't
- 29:37seen it specifically in deals yet, but we definitely
- 29:41talk about making sure, April, for sure, the
- 29:45replication rights are being able to use. And
- 29:48by the way, this is across the board right now
- 29:50with all talent in terms of protecting their
- 29:53name and likeness, et cetera, and how it's being
- 29:55used. So I think it's just a bigger, broader
- 29:58conversation that happens to overlap in this
- 30:00space. Yeah, very, very much. So we're doing
- 30:04a lot of deal making, helping to build AI models
- 30:08through data licensing. And so we're seeing a
- 30:10lot of the contractual language around how content
- 30:16is licensed into models, how it might be used,
- 30:18the parameters and restrictions around its use.
- 30:22indemnity risk around those kinds of uses. Some
- 30:25of that is informing the way that we're thinking
- 30:27about talent agreements. It's now very common
- 30:30in a traditional talent agreement, an actor or
- 30:32deal, a director or writer deal, to have language
- 30:35specifying how artificial intelligence may be
- 30:39used in that project to protect against the use
- 30:43of a talent's personal attributes through AI
- 30:47to give talent some level of control. over how
- 30:50AI is interacting with their personal attributes
- 30:53or their other work product. And that's really,
- 30:56you know, candidly I think driven by the recent,
- 30:59the newer guild agreements that protect talent
- 31:04from certain types of uses of their work product
- 31:06through AI. Those guild agreements obviously
- 31:09don't really exist yet for creators. And so I
- 31:12haven't yet seen a lot of language in creator
- 31:15deals relating to the use of AI, with the exception
- 31:19maybe of language saying that the results and
- 31:22proceeds of their services can't be subsequently
- 31:24licensed into a third party model without their
- 31:27approval. But I think it's an interesting question.
- 31:30It's something that, especially for the larger
- 31:32creators out there, they should be really thoughtful
- 31:34about is thinking about the fact that if you're
- 31:37doing a deal, with Meta or Amazon or another
- 31:42one of these large global tech platforms that
- 31:44are developing AI products. How should you be
- 31:47thinking about making sure that your name likeness
- 31:50and other performance attributes are not being
- 31:53fed into models and then through the development
- 31:57of synthetic data being turned into sort of an
- 32:01AI driven competition for your own work, which
- 32:05we know is going to emerge quickly. No, definitely.
- 32:09I mean, with AI, I mean, it's not going anywhere,
- 32:11right? And across the board, we've seen it in
- 32:15active deals, right? But in this space, it's
- 32:18very interesting. And so we will touch on it
- 32:22in a later slide, and we'll go in a little deeper
- 32:26into the conversation. But yeah, it's just right
- 32:30to get your insights early on. So that way, we
- 32:33know, like, how should creators even think about
- 32:36AI, right? And so thank you for that insight.
- 32:40So let's move to the next slide. Common legal
- 32:45pitfalls. So with so much content being co -created,
- 32:49remixed, or built in on trending media, questions
- 32:53around ownership and licensing are more important
- 32:56than ever, I would say. Yet many creators still
- 32:59move forward without clear agreements or a full
- 33:01understanding of the risks. So let's talk about
- 33:04how you handle these IP and content rights challenges
- 33:07in your work. So who typically owns the content
- 33:10and creator collaborations? Because there's a
- 33:13lot of co -collaborations going on. And how often
- 33:16is that actually spelled out in writing? Well,
- 33:22it comes to us when it falls, when it's not in
- 33:26writing and we end up getting it because there's
- 33:28a breakdown in communication. That definitely
- 33:34happens right because we do see a lot of collaborations
- 33:36between content creators Which is different than
- 33:39collaborating with brands right and so in that
- 33:41space that creates a different scenario of if
- 33:45I am you know I have so many followers you have
- 33:47so many followers we're working together on creating
- 33:49content what that looks like but it is it's just
- 33:53again as you're growing being smart about when
- 33:55are you going to need advice when are you starting
- 33:57to document and put this language in contracts
- 34:01so for future use when a brand maybe does want
- 34:04to come and license excuse me, the content that
- 34:07has been jointly created, what that looks like,
- 34:10and also making sure that as you're creating
- 34:12content, it does not include potential existing
- 34:16IP that might infringe upon a third party's rights
- 34:19when you're going, again, whether it's collaborating
- 34:21with another content creator, doing a deal with
- 34:24a brand, et cetera. I mean, it all goes back
- 34:26to ownership, but that is a piece of like, you
- 34:29know, there's a lot of repurposed content as
- 34:32we know. on the internet everywhere. And so one
- 34:35of the questions that comes up with AI is even
- 34:38source. But that also happens just with repurpose
- 34:42and reuse content, where it's like, who is the
- 34:43original owner? How is that incorporated? Making
- 34:46sure that that original owner isn't being infringed.
- 34:50I'll give one maybe specific example around this
- 34:53question of creative collaborations and ownership.
- 34:56This is something I've seen happen multiple times
- 34:58now, where a couple of creators who sometimes
- 35:02don't know each other that well, or sometimes
- 35:03they're great friends and they have great chemistry,
- 35:05will start a podcast. It'll be a video podcast
- 35:08and it takes off, it goes well for a while, they
- 35:14start to get into the rhythm of producing weekly,
- 35:18the audience grows, and then one of them gets
- 35:22tired of the work. One of them is doing more
- 35:24work in terms of development or editing. One
- 35:28of them is more responsible for bringing the
- 35:30brand deals than any other. Maybe one of them
- 35:33has sort of a life change, wants to move, relocate,
- 35:36or other creative things come across their plate
- 35:38that are more interesting. Usually, they did
- 35:43not put something in place when they started
- 35:45the podcast to define who owns what. What happens
- 35:49if we want to stop someday? And so I've seen
- 35:53multiple disputes now where talent end up, you
- 35:58know, someone steals the show by rebranding it,
- 36:02bringing on a different host and taking control
- 36:04of the social profiles and stuff like that. And
- 36:07then, you know, one of the others is left hanging
- 36:09and lawyers are then hired to try to unwind it
- 36:11all and figure out how to resolve things. This
- 36:17happens a lot. And it's partially because this
- 36:20media format is a really high growth space right
- 36:22now. And because the barriers to entry are low,
- 36:25and it's one of the most accessible ways for
- 36:28charismatic personalities to test ideas. The
- 36:33problem being, obviously, that you can very quickly
- 36:35create a lot of value through that format. And
- 36:39then you have to go to court to figure out how
- 36:44to dispose of it in a dispute. This is one thing
- 36:48where I just, I try to encourage clients to,
- 36:50if you're gonna even just pilot, if you're gonna
- 36:53do a five episode test, even if it's on socials,
- 36:57not even on YouTube, whatever it might be. Just
- 36:59put, like, scratch some thoughts down. Get something
- 37:02on paper of some kind. And, you know, we have
- 37:05these little templates that we give our clients
- 37:07sometimes, which is just a little one sheet for,
- 37:09like, here's how we're going to address these
- 37:11five issues. It doesn't have to be expensive.
- 37:13It doesn't have to take a lot of time. And it
- 37:15can save an enormous amount of heartache down
- 37:19the road. Definitely. I know we see that a lot.
- 37:25I mean, that's a common trend, right? creators
- 37:27are starting out. They want to collaborate by
- 37:30working with other creators. And then oftentimes,
- 37:34they're not. They don't have anything in place.
- 37:35And that's when issues later arise. As an attorney
- 37:41that's advising content creator who's entered,
- 37:45let's say, on a collaboration with multiple creators,
- 37:48and they've developed this type of content, who
- 37:53has the right to that? piece of content, essentially,
- 37:57because one probably recorded, the other one
- 37:59came up with the idea behind it, right? And so
- 38:03there's different aspects and different types
- 38:05of input. So as an attorney dealing in this space,
- 38:11how do you go advising this type of this creator
- 38:14that would come and seek advice? I think that
- 38:19goes to what Matthew was saying, but I also know
- 38:22of specific deals where there are content creators.
- 38:27I had a client, they were launching a podcast
- 38:29and they basically just hired. the two other
- 38:32folks because they knew they weren't going to
- 38:34be on the production side. They were really there
- 38:36as talent, right? So even though it feels like
- 38:37a collaboration, at least they considered, you
- 38:40all are not going to be contributing as much
- 38:42as I am because it was also they were funding
- 38:45it. And so they were not contributing funds.
- 38:50They were not going to contribute to the production
- 38:51of it, et cetera. And so, but it is, it's just
- 38:54trying to get something basic in writing that
- 38:57at least has those basic parameters of what's
- 39:00what. on the front end just makes a huge difference.
- 39:06In terms of trends, right, especially across
- 39:09TikTok, there's multiple trends going on that
- 39:12just people like mimic, you know, what somebody
- 39:15else is doing. And that's part of like the interactive
- 39:17aspect of a platform like TikTok. So how does
- 39:22what a content creator that I'd say came up with
- 39:25like a dance routine, right, or something and
- 39:27it became highly popular. And then another person
- 39:29comes in. replicates that, and then they're actually
- 39:33using that to monetize it and make a profit.
- 39:37Do they actually have some sort of claim or some
- 39:40sort of, I guess, an issue they can address with
- 39:46respect to that, especially how the platform
- 39:48is that you're used to seeing trends and just
- 39:51copying them or using particular dance routines
- 39:55or things like that? So what are your thoughts
- 39:59or have you had clients that feel like they have
- 40:02a claim regarding that aspect? I think it goes
- 40:08to basic copyright law. I mean, in your example,
- 40:12I think choreography is copyrightable. And how
- 40:18unique or how different it is, whether it is
- 40:21how strong the copyright is, is questionable.
- 40:27You know, this also leads to kind of going back
- 40:32to what we were saying about ownership. And if
- 40:36you have ownership, then do you also comes with
- 40:40liability of what you are owning as far as if
- 40:45you're infringing or others are infringing upon
- 40:48you. So it all kind of starts to tie together
- 40:52with these issues. If you are the owner, then
- 40:56you're the owner of the copyright. Are you a
- 40:59copyright infringer or a copyright infringee?
- 41:04And then the indemnification from if you have
- 41:11a deal with a brand, if that falls on you or
- 41:14the brand. So all the dots start connecting in
- 41:18all of these issues, which kind of makes our
- 41:21job fun. That's the creative part, right? As
- 41:25all of these things change and evolve rather
- 41:28quickly, it is a matter of figuring out best
- 41:31case scenario and best practices for how these
- 41:34relationships work, which is very interesting.
- 41:39Definitely. Let's move on to the next slide.
- 41:43the case study example. So I'd like to invite
- 41:45each of you to share an example if you have one
- 41:47of a brand deal that presented unexpected legal
- 41:50or business challenges for the creator. So this
- 41:54could involve issues like mispayment milestones,
- 41:57lack of approval rights, or even the misuse of
- 42:00the creator's content or likeness. From your
- 42:04perspective as transactional attorneys, what
- 42:06went wrong and what would you advise creators
- 42:08or their representatives to look out for to avoid
- 42:11similar issues in future deals. Whenever I've
- 42:17had an issue especially relative to deliverables
- 42:20even if the contract was very clear on what the
- 42:23expectations were there were always times where
- 42:27either the brand didn't feel like it was fully
- 42:29deliverable and they're trying to figure out
- 42:31well why didn't you do it this way or that way
- 42:34or etc. There's still like interpretation issues
- 42:36that come up with what is actually deliverable
- 42:39especially I do a lot of, again, long -term partnership
- 42:44kind of deals, and so there's the monthly deliverables,
- 42:47there's different performance deliverables, there's
- 42:48things that are over a period of time. And again,
- 42:51in that instance, it's really an interpretation
- 42:54of what is considered delivered, and what does
- 42:58that look like, and making sure that we can say
- 43:01the deliverables are X in the agreement, but
- 43:04then making sure when it's actually happening
- 43:06that it's consistent with the expectations of
- 43:08both parties. I see a lot of inconsistencies
- 43:17in contract. Do you have any like type of and
- 43:23talk a little bit more about you froze for a
- 43:26second. I think Tisha, you're going to make a
- 43:29point anyway, so go ahead. I was going to say,
- 43:33I see a lot of inconsistencies in contracts and
- 43:35not by, not intentional, but just by, you know,
- 43:39carelessness and that, for example, if the ownership,
- 43:43if the creator has ownership, but the brand has
- 43:47approval, has approval controls or the creator
- 43:51has. ownership, but there's still a work for
- 43:54hire clause, like, you know, not hidden, but
- 43:57like, you know, somewhere in the language. And
- 43:59so just being aware of those inconsistencies
- 44:03just by human oversight more than anything. Yeah,
- 44:07I would say, you know, candidly, we work with
- 44:11a lot of talent and it is often the case that
- 44:15the talent are the party that, you know, didn't
- 44:18quite meet their obligations under the agreement.
- 44:21just as often as there might be a problem with
- 44:23the brand side. And usually that's some version
- 44:28of, they lost interest, they lost focus, they
- 44:33were unreachable. Again, one of the kind of fun
- 44:37challenges of the space is that as your talent
- 44:39grow quickly, they're learning to be professionals
- 44:43as they're building their profile and they're
- 44:45learning how to work with brands and agencies.
- 44:50So we do see a fair number of discussions around
- 44:55deliverables and timing and termination and what
- 44:59happens in the event of a termination. Those
- 45:01termination conversations are often a little
- 45:03bit murky. It's usually the case that there's
- 45:07some foot fault on both sides. So one of the
- 45:11things we've learned to make sure, this is often
- 45:13not a part of the standard template. And something
- 45:16that's important to make sure that you negotiate
- 45:18for is to get paid for all the work that was
- 45:21done prior to the point of termination. And you
- 45:25can measure that in different ways. It can be
- 45:27prorated based on time or based on deliverables.
- 45:30I like time, especially for deals where the creator
- 45:33is going to be putting in a lot of effort to
- 45:35develop concepts for the brand before they're
- 45:38delivering content. And then I often like a kill
- 45:43fee on top. And there's a lot of negotiation
- 45:46around how you measure those kill fees and when
- 45:48they're payable and not. But I think it's an
- 45:50appropriate ask. You should always be paid for
- 45:54some version of prorated work done to date and
- 45:57then try to get something on top. Well, thank
- 46:02you so much for your insights. and the deals
- 46:04that you've worked on. Let's move on to the next
- 46:08slide regarding emerging regulations. So we talked
- 46:12a little bit about AI. And now, what would you
- 46:17say generative AI and synthetic content are complicating
- 46:22IP, right, of publicity or ownership law in the
- 46:25creator space? We talked about this already,
- 46:27but anything other thoughts that you have regarding
- 46:30this topic that's evolving? I think that goes
- 46:35also back to what Matthew mentioned about indemnification,
- 46:39right? And because we want to make sure that
- 46:41if there is an FTC issue or there's any kind
- 46:44of infringement issue, whatever, that the proper
- 46:48parties are responsible for that. And that's
- 46:52part of the regulation is making sure the rights
- 46:56aren't being infringed and then also identifying
- 46:59when these are true. ad -based partnerships,
- 47:02et cetera. And so there is a gap in the recognition
- 47:07of that, that those things can be quickly addressed
- 47:11so there's not a bigger fallout from it. And
- 47:15a lot of that is just communication, right? Again,
- 47:17when you're dealing with longer -term partnerships,
- 47:20these are communications that are happening all
- 47:22the time. A lot of these partnerships then extend
- 47:26because both parties are getting great benefit
- 47:29from it. And it's just continuing to discuss
- 47:32what it looks like for both parties so that they
- 47:37are both doing what is needed to avoid any regulatory
- 47:41issues. In terms of like FTC trends, right? Should
- 47:49creators and their legal counsel, what should
- 47:52their creators and legal counsel be watching
- 47:54closely right now? Well, it's very clear that
- 48:01the brand endorsement or sponsorship or paid
- 48:04paid whatever needs to be Clear and conspicuous.
- 48:08That's that's that they've made that clear And
- 48:12a lot of examples have come out as far as what
- 48:15that means and videos it needs to be at the beginning
- 48:17and not Nick hidden at the end Hashtags need
- 48:21to be very clear conspicuous that this is a paid
- 48:25endorsement so I think we're actually clear on
- 48:32that one area of the law, with new technologies,
- 48:38with the platforms of whether it's a real, whether
- 48:40it's a story carousel, it is evolving of where
- 48:47and how the clear and spicuous needs to be addressed.
- 48:56We talked about, Lina, there's different, um,
- 49:00unions, right, for actors, um, and, um, you know,
- 49:06those type of, you know, in a sense, you know,
- 49:09creators. Um, but do you see there being, um,
- 49:13do you see real momentum behind creator unions
- 49:15or collective rights groups? And, um, well, legal
- 49:19structures would support them. I think it would
- 49:23be supported by the existing structures, but
- 49:26I think as creators are evolving, like we're
- 49:29saying, into actually creating productions, creating
- 49:32potentially union productions that are film,
- 49:37TV series, etc. Even if they're platform -based,
- 49:40there is going to be a transition into what is
- 49:43the content that's being created that might be
- 49:46under an existing guild or union. If they're,
- 49:49again, hiring actors to produce a series, whether
- 49:52it's on YouTube or not, it still might come under
- 49:54the guild regulations. Yeah, I think that's right.
- 49:59One small thing I'll add here is there are probably
- 50:03pluses and minuses to being part of a collective
- 50:06art in your organization if you're a talent.
- 50:09And specifically around SAG, of course, if you're
- 50:12a creator and you end up working on a SAG production,
- 50:16a commercial shoot, a certain number of times,
- 50:18you're now... you're now a SAG actor. And that's
- 50:22going to have implications for your future engagements.
- 50:26So some talent really don't want the burden of
- 50:30having the baggage of the minimums and the royalties
- 50:34and the contracts around collective bargaining.
- 50:38So we spend just as much time, I think, helping
- 50:41talent figure out whether or not it makes sense
- 50:43for them to take a SAG engagement. as we do thinking
- 50:49about how can talent collaborate and collectively
- 50:52bargain for protections. Well, thank you for
- 50:59your insight on that. There's been a lot of conversations
- 51:03regarding whether there should be a union that
- 51:07supports creators or not, right? And so it's
- 51:14great to hear your perspective on this. And we
- 51:20can go to the next slide on what lawyers need
- 51:22to know. So as this space continues to mature,
- 51:26continues to evolve, creators are starting to
- 51:28think beyond individual brand deals and towards
- 51:30building long -term value, whether through licensing,
- 51:33equity, or even exit strategies. At the same
- 51:37time, more attorneys are entering this field
- 51:39and looking to understand how to best support
- 51:41clients in a fast, evolving landscape. So to
- 51:44close out, I'd like to ask a few forward -looking
- 51:47questions about where this space is headed and
- 51:49how we can best prepare to serve creators. So
- 51:52how do you help creators think long -term around
- 51:57exit strategies, licensing, or ownership transitions?
- 52:06I'll add one aspect as I deal with legacy rights.
- 52:14So considering naming a digital executor to your
- 52:19will or trust, thinking about who's going to
- 52:21take over for you in the future. So that's not
- 52:26something that's on the top of most people's
- 52:28list, which is why I'm mentioning it, because
- 52:31it usually gets overlooked. I think an important
- 52:36distinction to be made is that a lot of these
- 52:39deals are business deals. They're not entertainment
- 52:43deals, right? And so that's also consideration
- 52:46when you're coming into representation of these
- 52:50types of talent. There's a deal structure differently
- 52:54because it's not that they're getting Cast in
- 52:57a movie or cast in a commercial or they're doing
- 52:59talent deals in the same way these types of collaborations
- 53:01that we're discussing these types of partnerships
- 53:03are business deals Right they're building their
- 53:12own businesses and Yeah difference as opposed
- 53:17to thinking about this as an entertainment Transaction
- 53:23and entertainment law transaction. So in terms
- 53:26of like, because I know we've been exposed to
- 53:30like TikTok being banned, right? And that's like
- 53:34an ongoing issue that's might or might not happen.
- 53:40So when talking to creators, right? And how they're
- 53:42like starting off doing a few posts here and
- 53:45there, they're building their following. And
- 53:49what advice do you... I'd like them early on.
- 53:54So, because in terms of sustainability, right?
- 53:59If TikTok's, let's say, removed or then that's
- 54:02where they have the majority of their following
- 54:03or, you know, if something happens, the creator
- 54:09content that they've developed is no longer sustainable.
- 54:12So, how do you go about advising them early on
- 54:14that to think about ways, exit strategies early
- 54:18on and... thinking ahead beyond what they're
- 54:24working on presently? You know what, we didn't
- 54:27touch on this, but I think it's important to
- 54:29mention that this is not only about the IP being
- 54:34created, it's also about the data and the analytics
- 54:38that the content creator has, right? Because
- 54:40this is about accessing their followers, their
- 54:43impressions, and all of those things. So that's
- 54:46also a consideration. And who owns that? And
- 54:49there are some brands who are saying, hey, not
- 54:51only do we want you to post this or expose this
- 54:53or create this content for us, they also want
- 54:56access to that. But when we think about, you
- 54:59know, again, the TikTok 24 hour band. Some of
- 55:04those creators are not as savvy about and should
- 55:08be advised about how are you protecting your
- 55:10data? How are you protecting your analytics?
- 55:11How are you connecting with your followers? Because
- 55:14if TikTok goes down, how do you get in touch
- 55:17with them, right? So then there's a transition
- 55:18of whether it's email, database, other ways that
- 55:23that value proposition can be contained and used
- 55:26in another way and or on another platform. Exactly.
- 55:33Well, thank you all for sharing your insights
- 55:36about this matter. I really want to open it up
- 55:39to the audience before this program ends and
- 55:43give them an opportunity to ask their questions.
- 55:46I do have a question here that says, Madden team,
- 55:50can you commentate at all on the weight of purported
- 55:53class action suits, naming both brands and influencers
- 55:56this year? for instance, Revol, Celsius, that
- 56:00vodka company in Illinois. They are all using
- 56:03insufficient disclosures, not just non -disclosures,
- 56:06to allege incomplete FTC compliance as a trigger
- 56:09for state consumer protection law claims. They're
- 56:12coming from the same firms, following the same
- 56:14format, and casting plaintiffs with flimsy, actual
- 56:18damages. I would have brought this bottle of
- 56:21vodka, for instance, I would have brought this
- 56:23bottle of vodka, had this attractive woman place
- 56:26the Hashtag ad, disclaimer, further up in the
- 56:30text, et cetera. How can we play proactive defense?
- 56:36I'm not familiar with this litigation. It's interesting.
- 56:42How can we be proactive? I'm not sure from whose
- 56:47perspective, but regardless of who we're representing,
- 56:52I think it's very important to make sure that
- 56:56the disclosures are clear. So when we're working
- 56:58on behalf of talent, that's absolutely on the
- 57:01checklist to make sure that all the disclosures
- 57:04are being provided. One thing I really don't
- 57:06like about the brand deals in this space is that
- 57:09they often try to allocate FTC risk to the talent,
- 57:13even if the brand is responsible for giving us
- 57:16the form of disclosure. So we try to negotiate.
- 57:20a different outcome that we try to negotiate
- 57:23for the brand to take FTC risk and to have them
- 57:26provide us the forms of disclosures that they
- 57:29want us to use. Sometimes you get that, sometimes
- 57:31you don't. But in general, regardless of who's
- 57:34got the contractual indemnity risk, our clients
- 57:38should be making absolutely sure that they don't
- 57:41try to cut corners on those disclosures. I have
- 57:45another question here. Thank you, panelists.
- 57:48Could you speak to the importance of factoring
- 57:50trademark infringement liability when structuring
- 57:52deals, particularly in light of cases like Molly
- 57:56Sims, where an influencer was pulled into a trademark
- 57:59lawsuit despite simply following the brand's
- 58:01direction? I think that goes back to what Matthew
- 58:06just said about making sure that the indemnity
- 58:10language is there and that whatever trademark
- 58:13IP information that is being presented from the
- 58:16brand for the creator to use, that those deliverables
- 58:21are clear and who owns that and who's going to
- 58:23defend any claim that comes up because of the
- 58:25use is set out in the deal. Thank you, Niazza.
- 58:31I have another question here. Also, many influencers
- 58:34and creators operate with minimal support. And
- 58:37even with partnering with major brands, they
- 58:39often don't fully appreciate the need for legal
- 58:41protection. How do you, as advisors, help educate
- 58:45or convince your clients, especially smaller
- 58:47creators, of the importance of having legal safeguards
- 58:50in place? Well, really, I think, again, it goes
- 58:56back to this idea that if you're really growing
- 58:59a business and you're really now committed to
- 59:00doing this and making this your business, that
- 59:03you have to start being smart about it. It just
- 59:05is as basic as that. Yeah, I tell them scary
- 59:11stories. Or that. Somebody's going to take, steal
- 59:16your brand. We've all got enough examples at
- 59:21this point of things that have gone sideways.
- 59:23Creators who have lost exceptionally valuable
- 59:26opportunities because they didn't spend a little
- 59:30bit of time and money up front. Unfortunately,
- 59:33clients a lot of times come to us once they've
- 59:36had something bad go wrong or something wrong
- 59:39go bad. There's another question regarding CapCut.
- 59:44So CapCut recently updated their terms of service
- 59:46to give themselves broad license to use modified
- 59:49published creators content, including unpublished
- 59:52drafts and to grant similar rights to third parties.
- 59:55Is this type of broad IP usage typical of or
- 59:58becoming more typical of platforms like CapCut?
- 1:00:01In your opinion, could this signal a trend of
- 1:00:03platforms claiming greater IP rights over users
- 1:00:06work? You know, it's an interesting question.
- 1:00:10One of my partners deals with this type of question
- 1:00:12often, and those terms of service changes if
- 1:00:18they're not presented carefully and in the right
- 1:00:21way. The FTC has taken a really hard look at
- 1:00:24platforms that are trying to initiate a land
- 1:00:28grab around data by updating their terms of service
- 1:00:32to give them broad rights to take that form of
- 1:00:34data and use it in ways that weren't initially
- 1:00:36intended. for the consumer, including we've talked
- 1:00:39a little bit about AI uses and including an AI
- 1:00:42context. I think it's really risky and advisable
- 1:00:47for a platform to try to make those changes to
- 1:00:51their terms and start commercializing consumer
- 1:00:54data. without being really, really explicit about
- 1:00:58what's happening. And I think they're opening
- 1:01:00themselves up to, I mean, I can't speak to this
- 1:01:02case specifically because I haven't read those
- 1:01:04terms and I'm not super familiar with CapCut,
- 1:01:07but in general, when I'm working with a platform,
- 1:01:10we're extremely careful to make sure that when
- 1:01:15they update their terms or if they're using data
- 1:01:17in ways that aren't very obvious to the typical
- 1:01:21consumer that. We initiate term changes really,
- 1:01:25really loudly and boldly so that there are no
- 1:01:29surprises. I know we're up on time, but I just
- 1:01:32have one last question here. Do any of you ever
- 1:01:37use fixed fees and how? Yes, and it depends.
- 1:01:49Yeah, I mean, more typically for a large transactions
- 1:01:53where it's the type of deal that we do frequently,
- 1:01:58and it's fairly easy to predict the level of
- 1:02:03work involved. But that's atypical for us. We
- 1:02:08usually do things hourly or sometimes on a percentage
- 1:02:11basis for talent. That was good. Well, thank
- 1:02:15you so much, Matthew, Nyanta, and Tisha for coming
- 1:02:18on this panel and sharing your insights with
- 1:02:20all of us. Thank you. Thank you to the Beverly
- 1:02:25Hills Bar Association for having us. Absolutely.
- 1:02:28Thank you. You may be eligible for CLE credit
- 1:02:30in your state. Visit bhba .org slash podcasts
- 1:02:34for more information.