Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Handle a Bad Reference Before It Costs You the Job
Transcript
- Lucas: You just finished a great round of interviews. You can feel the offer coming. Then the recruiter says the words: 'We'll be checking your references.' And you freeze, because you know your last boss isn't going to say anything nice. Luna: That moment of dread — I've been there. And I think most people's instinct is to just hope the reference doesn't say anything terrible and pray it slides. Lucas: Right. And that instinct is exactly what kills the offer. I want to talk today about why the best move is actually to get in front of it. Preemptively disclose the potential issue to the hiring manager before they hear it from someone else. Luna: Disclose it? That sounds counterintuitive. You're basically telling them there's a problem. Doesn't that make you look risky? Lucas: You'd think so. But the data says the opposite. There's a study from a large HR consulting firm — I think it was from Mercer a few years back — that tracked candidates who proactively addressed a known bad reference. They were hired roughly 30 percent more often than candidates who stayed silent and let the reference call happen blind. Luna: Thirty percent. That's not nothing. What's the psychology behind that? Lucas: It's about control of the narrative and trust. When you disclose the issue yourself, you frame it. You're saying, 'Look, my former manager and I didn't see eye to eye on X, and here's what I learned from that.' The hiring manager hears self-awareness and honesty. When they hear it from the reference first, it feels like a hidden problem they had to uncover. Luna: So it's not just about avoiding the bad reference — it's about building trust by being transparent. But how do you actually do this without sounding like you're making excuses? Lucas: You need a script. And the key is to keep it brief, specific, and forward-looking. Something like: 'I want to be upfront — my former manager and I had a disagreement about project direction that led to some tension. I've since reflected on that, and I learned to communicate my concerns more diplomatically. I'm happy to share more if you'd like.' Luna: That's good. It frames the disagreement as a learning moment, not a character flaw. What if the reference is just plain unfair — like a boss who was toxic or had it out for you? Lucas: Same strategy, but you get one extra move. You can also provide an alternative reference who can speak to your work in that same time period — maybe a peer, a client, or a senior leader who wasn't your direct manager. And you say to the recruiter: 'I'd also encourage you to talk to so-and-so, who worked closely with me on those same projects.' Luna: That way you're not trying to hide the bad reference, but you're offering a more balanced picture. I think a lot of people don't realize that most companies will accept a colleague or a client as a reference — it doesn't have to be a former manager. Lucas: Exactly. In fact, some recruiters prefer it. A manager reference can be canned — they often just confirm dates and titles. A colleague or client can give a much richer sense of your day-to-day impact. Luna: So let's say you do the disclosure, and the hiring manager seems cool with it. Then what? Do you still have to worry about the reference call? Lucas: You do, but you've already neutralized it. The hiring manager now expects the reference to say something negative, so when it comes, it's not a surprise — it's confirmation of what you already told them. And because you framed it, they'll interpret it through your lens. Luna: That's powerful. But there's also the legal side — some states have laws about what former employers can say. But most people don't know how to find out what's being said without getting themselves in trouble. Lucas: Right. You can't ask a friend to call and pretend to be an employer — that's actually illegal in some places. But you can ask a trusted former colleague if they've ever heard anything about what your old boss says in reference checks. That's usually safe ground. Luna: Or you can use a service like a reference-checking firm — some career coaches offer that as part of their package. They'll call and give you a summary of what's being said. Lucas: Also worth noting: many companies now outsource reference checks to third-party vendors who just verify dates and titles. They don't ask about performance at all. So sometimes the fear is overblown. Luna: Okay, so let's say a listener is in the middle of this right now. They've got a great interview coming up, they know the reference will be bad. What's the single most important step they should take this week? Lucas: Write the disclosure email or script before you even get to the reference stage. Have it ready. And if you can, identify one alternative reference — a client or peer — and ask for their permission in advance. That way, when the recruiter asks for references, you're not scrambling. Luna: Preparation is everything. I'd add: practice the disclosure out loud. It needs to sound natural, not rehearsed. You want to come across as someone who's reflected on a past conflict, not someone who's defensive. Lucas: And one more thing — never, ever lie about why you left a job or why the reference might be negative. If you say 'we parted on good terms' and the reference says 'he was fired,' you're done. The truth, framed well, is always safer. Luna: If today's episode was useful to you and you want to keep it ad-free, buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo helps. Lucas: Yeah, that's the place. Even a small contribution means we can keep doing these deep dives without any sponsor pressure. Now — back to the reference question. What if you're the one being asked to give a reference for a former employee you didn't love? Luna: That's a whole other episode. But quick tip: you can be honest without being destructive. Stick to factual, job-related observations. 'They struggled with meeting deadlines' is fair. 'They're lazy' is not. Lucas: Great point. And for the person receiving that reference, the same disclosure strategy applies. If you know a former manager might say something critical, you get to tell your side first. That's the key takeaway today — don't hide. Disclose, frame, and move forward. Luna: It's one of those rare career moves that feels risky but actually reduces risk. Lucas: Exactly. Thanks for listening, and we'll talk next time.