Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: Trump South Pars threats, Cambo FID date, and what's hydrogen good for?
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:04podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:08the UK energy market. War in the Middle East continues
- 0:12to wage on Ithaca's ready to pull the trigger on Cambo and
- 0:16Hydrogen has some questions to answer.
- 0:19That's an awful lot to discuss if you're just me.
- 0:22Aberdeen features lead Ryan Duff.
- 0:23But thankfully, joining me this week is our crack team of
- 0:26experts, starting off with news editor Erica Asklyn.
- 0:30How are you doing this week, Erica?
- 0:33Hi, so it's been really fun pulling, you know, the news
- 0:37shifts on energy voice this week and kind of looking at World War
- 0:42Three, it's kind of cool. Kind of cool is maybe not the
- 0:45word I'd use, but Michael Bear, a renewables reporter, might
- 0:49have a slightly different take. How are?
- 0:51You I'm doing well if I mean I'll agree with Erica.
- 0:54It's been exciting being in the hot seat for I mean I we can't
- 0:58call it the biggest event of our lifetimes.
- 1:00There's been too many of them, but it's it's a decently sized
- 1:03event. Decently sized event right?
- 1:06There we go, that's how we're. Describing it.
- 1:09And our NW correspondent Floyd March is joining us.
- 1:12How are you keeping this week? Yeah, keeping good been been on
- 1:15the road travelling around Teesside seeing what's what,
- 1:17talking all things hydrogen. So yeah, looking forward to
- 1:20share some insights and yeah, bit more relaxed and covering
- 1:23what's happening in around. So yeah, I've been living a
- 1:26blissful life in the in Teesside.
- 1:29Do you know, I, I've been on, on leave up until, up until
- 1:33Wednesday morning, I came back, but I haven't really been able
- 1:37to avoid this, this conflict in the Middle East.
- 1:40You know, I've been waking up in the morning, heading downstairs,
- 1:43turning on the telly, watching BBC Breakfast.
- 1:46And every single morning, the war in the Middle East is the,
- 1:50the top of the pops. It's the the leading story.
- 1:53It is also an It is also an energy voice.
- 1:55If you notice that you went there first, it.
- 1:58Is of. Course.
- 2:00You know, Erica, I was on holiday.
- 2:03I'm allowed to take a break. Very true.
- 2:09I mean, to be fair, you know, the if, if anyone has the energy
- 2:12voice app, they'll know that push notifications go out.
- 2:15So I do, I do see the biggest headlines as and when, when, you
- 2:19know, when I am on leave. But Speaking of the biggest
- 2:22headlines, Michael, you've been doing quite a lot of our Middle
- 2:27Eastern coverage this week. Do you mind catching us up?
- 2:30Because we've spoken about this the past couple of weeks.
- 2:32And if any other story was leading the show 3 weeks
- 2:36running, we'd be going, God, how do we, how do we add something
- 2:40new to this? But it seems like you know it's
- 2:43always ever changing, right? Yeah, well, thank you for giving
- 2:46me the chance to panicly rollback my decently sized
- 2:50comment and provide a little more context.
- 2:53Because I think the big question that has been on on everyone's
- 2:58wine mind, looking at the sort of economic consequences of the
- 3:02Iran war has been the scale of the conflict.
- 3:04I think when it started, I'm not going to make any claims to know
- 3:08what's going on inside Donald Trump's mind, but I think he had
- 3:12a vision of it being like what he did in Venezuela, that it was
- 3:17a single quick strike, take out his leadership and then go from
- 3:21there. I think Vladimir Putin probably
- 3:24had a similar plan for Ukraine back in 2022.
- 3:27And I think we can now see what scenario the Iran war is turning
- 3:31into. The it's not the the quick
- 3:35operation. And for every day that goes on,
- 3:40the economic consequences are getting more severe.
- 3:44The especially when it was just the Strait of Hormuz that I
- 3:48suppose everyone was on a kind of scenario where right, if we
- 3:51get this open, we suffer a few months of disruption as halted
- 3:56oil supplies restart. Now the big news is that gas
- 4:01production facilities across the Middle East, in Iran, in Qatar,
- 4:05in the UE, they've all been targeted and that's kind of been
- 4:08a major escalation. If the damage is severe enough,
- 4:12then we're no longer looking at the kind of the economic
- 4:17consequences going away by the end of this year.
- 4:21We're now potentially looking at scenarios where gas supplies are
- 4:25curtailed even past the end of the year, potentially into into
- 4:292020. 8 And and this is the thing, you know, I think, yeah,
- 4:33the, the conversation has, as you say, evolved because gas,
- 4:36gas supply has been halted in some places or gas air
- 4:40production it's in with oil, it's been halted in some places.
- 4:43Attacks are taking place on terminals.
- 4:46It's a major, you know, it's a major change to, to go from, you
- 4:50know, we speak about this in the North Sea about, you know, Oh,
- 4:53well, we couldn't just turn off the taps.
- 4:55The taps are being turned off here right in some instances.
- 4:59Can we just reflect a second on, you know, the absolute, you
- 5:03know, kind of batshit craziness of, you know, Donald Trump's and
- 5:07a Truth Social on his analysis about what's going on?
- 5:12So, I mean, you know, OK, so, you know, he's kind of talking
- 5:17about the fact he's denying knowledge that of Israel bombing
- 5:23S Pars in Iran, which is, you know, like a major gas field.
- 5:28And he says that this was a bad thing to do.
- 5:30He doesn't, you know, think that Israel should have done it.
- 5:34But as a result of Israel bombing S Pars, Iran has bombed
- 5:40Qatar's LNG gas facility. And of course, they'd already
- 5:44announce force majeure shutting down, you know, their capacity,
- 5:49which of course, you know, has a, a knock on effect on global
- 5:54prices. But then, of course, you know,
- 5:55kind of what he says is that, you know, the he says, well,
- 5:59there will be no more attacks by Israel unless Iran continues to
- 6:03whack Qatar, in which case he's going to bomb them back to the
- 6:07Stone Age, I think, which kind of strikes me as being like some
- 6:11sort of like weird escalation. And I suppose it's a threat.
- 6:14I suppose it's meant to kind of like quell Iran's bombing of
- 6:17Qatar, but it just doesn't seem to be a very good way to do it.
- 6:21Yeah, it's strange. It's strange to hear the the
- 6:24president of the United States say that he's gonna, you know,
- 6:29blow up the entirety of the South Par's gas field, an amount
- 6:33of strength and power that Iran has never seen or witnessed
- 6:37before. That is the exact quote he he's
- 6:39got there. And you know what?
- 6:42I, I, I, you know, Michael mentioned earlier the idea that,
- 6:46you know, he doesn't know what's going on in Donald Trump's head.
- 6:49Sometimes I don't know if Donald Trump knows what's going on in
- 6:51Donald Trump's head, but you know, I, I do, I do often wonder
- 6:57where this attitude comes from. And I do think with Donald
- 7:00Trump, and this is purely my own opinion, I'm, I'm, I'm starting
- 7:03to do the thing that business leaders and panels say so that,
- 7:07you know, there's no implication for their company that that
- 7:11Donald Trump is so used to being in business, right?
- 7:15He's so used to, you know, he came into business already
- 7:19having quite a lot of quite a lot of cash.
- 7:21He was always, he's always been the big guy in the room.
- 7:24He's always been this big swinging deck, if you like.
- 7:27And so he can just kind of, he has been allowed to sort of
- 7:31bully and push, you know, when needed.
- 7:33And, you know, we've, we've heard our very own Jeremy
- 7:36Cresswell Speaker with the trials and tribulations of
- 7:38bringing together the, the Aberdeen Offshore Wind Farm and
- 7:43the, you know, the sort of the pushback that the Trump
- 7:47Organization had on that because Trump didn't like the, the, the
- 7:50view of the turbines from his golf course.
- 7:54And how that was, you know, how Jeremy said that he he felt like
- 7:58that his organization, when they were sort of pulling together
- 8:01this one farm was being bullied. Does it feel like Trump's trying
- 8:05to do the same thing but with international politics?
- 8:10Because I sometimes feel like that's what he's doing. 100%
- 8:14Yep, I completely agree. And look, I don't want to come
- 8:17out and say Donald Trump is bluffing.
- 8:19That feels like the kind of thing that would blow up in my
- 8:22face at some point. But when you look at for quite
- 8:24literally, yes, exactly when you look at what they did with the,
- 8:28the Cargoyle terminal that they they struck that relatively
- 8:31recently that they targeted military installations across it
- 8:36without targeting the oil infrastructure.
- 8:38Now again, no no capacity to make any predictions or share
- 8:45any kind of insight on US foreign policy at the moment.
- 8:48It felt like that was purposeful.
- 8:50The like with Venezuela, the game plan was to try and seize
- 8:55the the terminal, take over the the oil infrastructure and in
- 9:01some sort of brave new world where the the current Iranian
- 9:04regime falls that they can now dictate terms.
- 9:07It feels like blowing up the South Pars field is either not
- 9:12on the agenda, they want the the oil and gas revenues for
- 9:16themselves, or it shows that the American regime has now just
- 9:22turned around and gone right. This, this can't be the plan.
- 9:25We just have to keep forming them.
- 9:26Yeah, it's, it's a scary situation.
- 9:29I think, you know, you touched on the the sort of timeline of
- 9:32things here and how, yeah, Trump seemed to indicate that this was
- 9:35going to be done really quickly. And you know, the same could be
- 9:39said about Putin and Ukraine. And Erica at the top of this
- 9:42segment did describe this as World War Three.
- 9:46Well, if we look back to to the original to World War One,
- 9:49didn't we say we'd be back in time for Christmas?
- 9:53It does. It does feel like maybe
- 9:54history's repeating itself on that instance at least.
- 9:57But maybe that's a little bit hyperbolic.
- 9:59Who knows. Anyway, this this situation will
- 10:02be evolving and changing. As I said, it's been the the
- 10:05lead segment on this podcast for the past two weeks.
- 10:08It will no doubt continue to be for the weeks to come.
- 10:10So if you I'd like to stay up to date, well, we'll have more next
- 10:13week, but that does it for this segment.
- 10:16And next we're going to be looking a little bit closer to
- 10:18home, just off the coast of Shetland.
- 10:22Hello, I'm Ed Reed, the editor of E Ford.
- 10:25E Ford is a membership community that brings together the entire
- 10:28UK energy supply chain, every hub, every sector, every stage.
- 10:33Our aim is to deliver growth to the energy sector, working with
- 10:36industry and policy makers to unlock the UK's opportunities
- 10:39and advantages. This is the movement to secure
- 10:43increased investment, improved policy making and better
- 10:46collaboration by providing our members with visibility,
- 10:49influence and access. Join me forward today.
- 10:55So Ithaca came to market this week and indicated that it's
- 10:58looking to make a decision on Campbell sooner than we may have
- 11:02thought before. But this, this kind of also ties
- 11:07into the conversation we were just having ahead of the break,
- 11:09right? There's been a conversation
- 11:11about should the UK be doubling down on North Sea production now
- 11:15that global supply chains have been disrupted?
- 11:18I'm sure we're going to get into that topic as well, Erica.
- 11:21But you were Johnny on the spot for Ithaca this week.
- 11:25What are they actually saying? What's happening?
- 11:27Yes. So they of course are the joint
- 11:32venture between Israel's Delic and any in the North Sea and
- 11:38they have a 25% stake in the campaigners favorite hate filled
- 11:45Rosebank. And then of course I also have a
- 11:48100% stake in Cambo. Both of these of course are #1
- 11:54and #2 I think largest undeveloped fields in not the
- 12:01North Sea West of Shetland. So the fact that they are kind
- 12:07of just like sailing blissfully through the waters of the fact
- 12:13that, you know, there's a no final in a production decision
- 12:19on Rosebank. Albeit the FPSO sailed slightly
- 12:26through the Strait of Hormuz not too long ago after a 2 1/2 year
- 12:30refurbishment in Dubai and is on its way.
- 12:35But they were talking in this case about Cambo.
- 12:38So we remember Cambo as being the field in which Shell about 3
- 12:46years ago decided to wash its hands of it.
- 12:49Like they just didn't even bother to try to sell it.
- 12:52They just said we're not interested.
- 12:55So now what Ithaca has said is that they are reinvigorating the
- 13:00process to try to find a farming partner and go ahead with it.
- 13:05And they have said they they will make a financial investment
- 13:09decision on it within 12 months. Of course, now that's going to
- 13:12be based on the fact that they're waiting for a buy in
- 13:15partner. They will also be.
- 13:18But they also said, you know, they've got a lot of money.
- 13:20They, you know, they, I was listening to the call with in
- 13:23the Friedman after they made the announcement, and he's saying
- 13:26that they've got about $1.5 billion to spend on
- 13:31acquisitions, refurbishments, investments and all that sort of
- 13:34stuff. So they're kind of saying it's
- 13:35all OK. And then of course, it's all
- 13:37kind of a part of what's going on West of Shetland, including
- 13:42what is looking like a very positive thing for the UK.
- 13:46Only if Rachel Reeves is buying the Northern Gas hub.
- 13:51So Ryan, what what's, what's your thinking on this?
- 13:54Yeah. Do you know what I want to I
- 13:55want to actually backpedal slightly.
- 13:57I said, oh, I said FID finance final investment decision
- 14:01earlier than we might have thought.
- 14:02Now that I'm going to stand by that claim because based on
- 14:06recent headlines, right, yes, they've been floundering trying
- 14:08to find a new buyers and Shell left and Ithaca was landed with
- 14:12the entirety of the stake in Campbell.
- 14:15However, I've just been looking back through coverage.
- 14:18Originally the, the FID for Campbell was earmarked for 2022.
- 14:23So we are four years out of date, potentially 5 if it's
- 14:27within the next 12-12 months. So that I want, I want to
- 14:31quickly address that. But yes, on, on sort of the
- 14:35situation West of Shetland earlier in the year, I, I sort
- 14:39of wrote an analysis piece of sort of field you need to watch
- 14:43anything on, on the, the region. It is, I think, without doubt
- 14:50the, the big frontier, if you want to call it that, within UK
- 14:54waters. I think it's, I think it's
- 14:57important to, to sort of clarify this, right, you know, because
- 15:00yes, it does contain the two largest fields that the UK has,
- 15:04Campbell and Rosebank, as you outlined.
- 15:06However, they're not, they're not brands, they're not, you
- 15:10know, 40s, they're not these fields that you did that we've
- 15:13seen sort of become household names almost there in the UK.
- 15:18They are large comparatively. But the reason why these things
- 15:23haven't been developed is West of Shetland.
- 15:26If you think the North Sea, if you think the the central North
- 15:29Sea is a harsh environment, try the West of Shetland.
- 15:32It's, you know, more expensive to develop in and it's, you
- 15:35know, more a more challenging environment too.
- 15:38So, but yeah, that you touched on the Northern Gas Hub, so
- 15:42let's maybe touch on that. So they are also in addition to
- 15:46looking at, you know, the progress of Rosebank and Cambo,
- 15:50which are oil and gas fields is, you know, a gas strategy and
- 15:55what they've called the tornado area and the greater Tobermory
- 15:58area. And then, of course, you know,
- 16:00let's not forget that, you know, Cerica is consolidating in this,
- 16:05you know, area too, you know, because of course, you know, in
- 16:08addition to owning the Shetland gas plant, they're also taking
- 16:12over the assets, you know, LAG and Tormor assets, which have
- 16:17all sorts of connectivity to Solemnvot there kind of coming
- 16:23into place. And then there's also, let's not
- 16:27forget Shell, you know, just before the transfer to Adura
- 16:31took place, have, you know, kind of got victory up and running,
- 16:36which is now part of Adura, which of course, you know, owns
- 16:39Rosebank as well as, you know, J area.
- 16:43But that's like, you know, looking at West of Shetland, you
- 16:47know, there's a possibility. See, I'm wondering, I'm
- 16:51wondering, you know, if Shell maybe walked away from Cambo,
- 16:54would they want to go into or would a juror want to go into?
- 16:58Cambo is another thing altogether.
- 17:00It's an interesting debate, right, because Shell would have
- 17:02walked away from Campbell when it was justifying against
- 17:07international portfolios and as, as I've sort of highlighted,
- 17:11expensive and difficult to work in the West of Shetland.
- 17:13However, if you're a UK, it's only UK company, you aren't
- 17:18thinking, well, oh, we could spend money, you know, taking a
- 17:22NFID on Cambo or we could go to Brazil or we could go to, you
- 17:27know, West Africa, you know, these more lucrative areas.
- 17:32Ajira doesn't have that luxury. So it can maybe justify this a
- 17:36little bit more. And as you say, you know, last
- 17:40in August last year, Ithaca said it was advancing towards FID on
- 17:45Tornado. Victory came online, which gave
- 17:49us some very easy headlines, victory for Shell and all that.
- 17:53And then you've got the sort of Northern gas hub which is is
- 17:58predominantly from my understanding as sort of and
- 18:02it's are operated by Athena Exploration which you know and
- 18:07triangle and. They'll sell to someone.
- 18:09Yeah. So, yeah, smaller names, but
- 18:11it's very interesting. Isn't the sort of the makeup of
- 18:13the West of Shetland. It does feel like in a time
- 18:16where we're saying, well, you know, all Rachel Reeves and Ed
- 18:20Miliband, they're scrapping, the North Sea West of Shetland is
- 18:23still forging ahead, maybe just slightly more quietly because
- 18:27the big names aren't going. OK.
- 18:29And then, of course, let's not forget BP, you know, like has
- 18:34another major third extension to do West of Shetland, you know,
- 18:39because yet so so. And this is the thing, OK.
- 18:43But you know what, We're all, you know, everyone feels like
- 18:46we're just like on this precipice, you know, because Ed
- 18:50Miliband, you know, is dithering frankly about Rosebank just
- 18:56because, you know, it's going to be impossible for him to make
- 18:58that decision while also, you know, kind of being Mr. Clean
- 19:02Green energy, screw fossil fuels because that's, you know, kind
- 19:05of giving us all this problem, you know, that we're now facing
- 19:08once again with rising oil and gas prices.
- 19:11However, you know, there is this issue that if these arguments
- 19:16are that, you know, we need, you know, to have all are ducks in
- 19:21the row in terms of, you know, energy production, then
- 19:26bringing, you know, licensing or allowing, you know, Rosebank and
- 19:33thus, you know, the Northern gas hub and investment would make a
- 19:37huge investment, you know, kind of decision, you know, which I
- 19:41think would galvanized all of this.
- 19:43And so the question is, is this going to become, you know, like
- 19:47an important part of EU KS energy security strategy is what
- 19:52I'm wondering. Well, I think, I think gas is a
- 19:55totally different debate to oil. Oil, at least in my opinion.
- 19:58I'm sure some of our listeners would disagree.
- 19:59But in terms of oil, yes, we, we've got a limited refinery
- 20:03resource in the UK and you know, things go overseas, yada, yada.
- 20:07With gas, at least, you know, we can pipe that back to shore and
- 20:10you know, we can store it ourselves.
- 20:11I mean, that's if Centrica decides that it wants to
- 20:14actually start pumping gas back into rough, but I guess the.
- 20:18The question there is, yes, we could potentially gas could,
- 20:22could definitely support our energy security.
- 20:24And on the sort of the the gas cluster, we've been speaking
- 20:29about, Matthew Bellshaw from Westwood, Westwood Analytics
- 20:34sort of spoke to me earlier in the year about this exact thing.
- 20:38And he sort of said that for the Northern Gas Hub, what really
- 20:43needs to happen to unlock that area is quote, one sizable
- 20:47discovery. And that is kind of what you're
- 20:49speaking about. However, we've got no questions
- 20:52around, does that require an exploration license, something
- 20:56that isn't going to be handed out anymore?
- 20:58Well, that's. Or a near field license maybe,
- 21:01you know, maybe that's. All.
- 21:02Maybe that's all it needs. Or maybe BEP needs to just go
- 21:05ahead with Claire. Maybe there's anyway, you know,
- 21:07it's, it's it's a very interesting question.
- 21:10And I do think, I mean, you know, and again, another thing
- 21:14that kind of popped up, which I thought was quite interesting on
- 21:16Energy Voice today, Tara Singh, who's the new chief executive of
- 21:21Renewable UK is popping up and, you know, kind of like defending
- 21:24the North Sea and saying, you know, we've got to kind of keep
- 21:27that because particularly we'll need gas.
- 21:31And of course, you know, kind of gas is the transition fuel.
- 21:37I know that some people hate that.
- 21:38But on the other hand, you know, we're definitely going to need
- 21:40it, you know, for the foreseeable.
- 21:42But then of course, you know, and maybe you know, the, you
- 21:47know, what the UK and policy makers need to clarify is, you
- 21:51know, North Sea oil and gas production does not, of course
- 21:56lower prices because that's not how international commodities
- 21:59work. But what you do get is a lot of
- 22:04tax revenue in on your hydrocarbon productions, which
- 22:10of course you can use to, you know, kind of do whatever you
- 22:13want in terms of mitigating oil and gas prices and the effect on
- 22:19consumers in the UK, which is also maybe something to think
- 22:22about. It definitely is.
- 22:23Now, I don't think we've solved the West of Jetland.
- 22:26You know, we haven't solved much of this this episode.
- 22:30But then again, it would have been a tough challenge to solve
- 22:32the Middle East, let alone the West of Jetland.
- 22:34So anyone? Hear about solving everything.
- 22:37We're just going to help everyone in their understanding,
- 22:40I hope. I think I, I, I would use the
- 22:43phrase we waffle about everything.
- 22:44But anyway, that's maybe just me, right.
- 22:48So anyway, that does it for for gas in West of Shetland, but
- 22:53there is a slightly different type of gas that we're going to
- 22:55be touching on just after the break.
- 22:58Be the first to hear breaking energy news through the Energy
- 23:02Voice app, available to download for free.
- 23:05You get features like saving the articles you want to return to
- 23:09access to the Energy Voice supplement.
- 23:12You can read exclusive E Forward content and even listen to the
- 23:16Energy Voice Out Loud podcast. If you work in the UK energy
- 23:21sector. Stay in the loop by saving the
- 23:23Energy Voice app to your home screen.
- 23:25Download the app through the Apple App Store or Google Play
- 23:29for breaking energy news on the go by searching Energy Voice
- 23:34app. So from gas in the West of
- 23:36Shetland to the world's smallest molecule or the universe's
- 23:40smallest molecule, I should say, Floyd, you've been at the rehab
- 23:44event, which isn't some sort of, you know, medical convention for
- 23:49pensioners. You're not you're not doing hip
- 23:51replacements. We're speaking about hydrogen.
- 23:54What's been happening in Teesside?
- 23:55Yeah, so the the Rehab annual conference is Teesside
- 23:59University's a conference where they talk basically a state of
- 24:04play of the hydrogen economy each year focuses on like all
- 24:07the way from like academic innovations all the way through
- 24:11to, you know, your hard hitting lane of the pipes and and
- 24:15getting the network moving. So so yeah, you probably expect
- 24:19these events to be like your wishy washy hydrogen's going to
- 24:23save the world and it's going to be the best thing since slice
- 24:27bread. But it was actually brutally
- 24:31honest at time assessment of the of the hydrogen economy.
- 24:34So yeah, it was, it was a great time to be at a conference where
- 24:36you're not hearing about how amazing projects are.
- 24:39You know, that's quite interesting because, yeah, I
- 24:41think it's important for sectors to reflect and maybe that's
- 24:45something that, you know, we're speaking about energy security
- 24:47before the break. Maybe that's something that oil
- 24:50and gas doesn't do too much of. It always seems to be, you know,
- 24:53ringing his own bells are blowing his own trumpet.
- 24:56It's interesting to hear that about hydrogen because I often
- 24:59associate like that industry with doing the exact same thing.
- 25:03And as we said before the call, I've described hydrogen as
- 25:06always the bridesmaid there for the bride always seems to miss
- 25:09its end use. It goes all while we're wanting
- 25:12to do X or someone else is doing that better or, you know,
- 25:16quicker or whatever it may be. So what what was your major take
- 25:20away? You were speaking about
- 25:21pipelines before the call. Yeah.
- 25:23So, so pipelines got a big green tick and decarbonizing industry
- 25:28also got a big green tick. But I think there was more of a
- 25:32fair assessment on like the role it will play in transport for
- 25:35example or heat in home. So so it seems to be it.
- 25:40It was probably in in the hydrogen economy's nature,
- 25:43right. You know, in the early twenty
- 25:4420s when the government decided to explore the role of hydrogen
- 25:48more and set out the 10 point plan, It was like hydrogen.
- 25:52Let's go and find what it'd be used in every sector so that the
- 25:55people in the industry were singing from the same hymn sheet
- 25:58saying no, it could be used here, it could be used here, it
- 26:00could be used here. So I feel like it's kind of like
- 26:02in, in the nature of the discourse really that the
- 26:06hydrogen economy bubble would burst, but not in terms of well,
- 26:10we won't use hydrogen at all, but just finding its feet on
- 26:12what it will be used for the most.
- 26:14And I feel like, you know, kind of like 5 or 6 years on from the
- 26:1710 point plan, we're probably just at that stage.
- 26:21But, but the pipelines were, was a very big conversation.
- 26:25And obviously being in, in the North East, it's kind of like
- 26:28the home of a lot of the, the talk of Project Union, for
- 26:31example, the new H2 E project and obviously Northern Endurance
- 26:37Partnership. You know, there's a lot of
- 26:39pipeline talk in, in the Humber and, and across Teesside.
- 26:43So that dominated conversations throughout the day.
- 26:45So was national gas actually at Rehib?
- 26:47And then what does Rehib actually stand for?
- 26:49Again? Remind.
- 26:50Me. Oh wow, I'm going to have to
- 26:50Google. Them like, you know.
- 26:52Oh no, bear. With me one second.
- 26:56It's a research Research England hydrogen innovation project
- 27:02rolls off the. Charts, yeah.
- 27:04So, so innovation didn't actually get spoken about that
- 27:06much because I was talking about pipelines.
- 27:08But amongst the positivity, obviously National Gas revealed
- 27:12their plans for Project Union yesterday and more depth of
- 27:14their 300 mile East Coast phase. So, so that was obviously spoken
- 27:22about across the event, but also just the, the wider East Coast
- 27:26cluster, the wider H2 E project and just that how they've like
- 27:31one of the biggest. Well, the, the, the first
- 27:33question I asked that panel was like, how can we build the
- 27:38business case to do this when we've not got like off taker
- 27:41agreements? Production is still really,
- 27:43really slow with the delays in the hard process.
- 27:47And their informal response was like, trust me bro, with the
- 27:53build it, build it and they'll come like, I feel like from
- 27:57their perspective, they, because a lot of the, these pipeline
- 28:01plans are, are repurposing existing infrastructure.
- 28:04So they really feel like their responsibility is to to lay out
- 28:08the benchmark really and the intention for the hydrogen
- 28:12economy to actually deliver. Some.
- 28:14So is it was part of the maybe the yeah, trust me, bro approach
- 28:19that you, you outlined there. Is that, is that just due to or
- 28:23was there talk around the fact that we've still not seen a
- 28:26hydrogen? So that strategy from
- 28:27government, is that part of the issue?
- 28:29Is it? Well, we'd love to be going
- 28:31after projects, but we don't know what's happening.
- 28:34We don't know what we're going to be sanctioned to do, whatever
- 28:37it may be. Is that part of the the debate?
- 28:39Yeah, exactly. That like designs was getting
- 28:41ribbed so hard because it's not just the hydrogen strategy
- 28:45that's delayed like car 2 shortlist is also getting
- 28:49delayed like and that leads into half three delays that haven't
- 28:53been announced but are expected because half three's wrapped up
- 28:56in this hydrogen strategy refresh.
- 28:59So what Emma Guthrie, who's the CEO of the Hydrogen Energy
- 29:03Association, was explaining is like, we need to try and
- 29:06decouple half three from the hydrogen strategies that if
- 29:09you've got the wider strategy issues, that's fine.
- 29:12But maybe we can look at half three, like just give to give
- 29:15the industry something to move towards because you know, the
- 29:19tier ones and the tier twos will be OK.
- 29:22Like the lives of this world. And Geo Pure is when, when
- 29:26they've got all the projects going on in like the likes of
- 29:28France, they they can keep plodding along.
- 29:30And when, when it comes, if hydrogen comes to the UK, it
- 29:33comes to the UK, they can, they can hold on.
- 29:35But it's the wider supply chain, like the tier threes that are
- 29:38like based in the UK in a waiting for the projects in the
- 29:42UK, they're falling off. Like I was speaking to a couple
- 29:45of companies yesterday and all of their most recent funding
- 29:50programs have been to service debt, not to fund innovation or
- 29:53build stuff or create stuff. And that's where these delays
- 29:58really hit the hardest. So the cadence of this world get
- 30:01annoyed by the hydrogen strategy, but it's really is
- 30:03make or break for the SMEs in the UK.
- 30:06And then, you know, once that supply chain's gone, it's gone
- 30:09because it's not even there at the moment.
- 30:10So, so, so yeah, that was a really big theme of the day.
- 30:14So yeah, there was a pessimistic angle, but the the pipeline
- 30:18stuff was definitely, definitely the positives.
- 30:21So we can build pipelines, but we don't know where to is the
- 30:25the positive take away is that is that the is that a fair
- 30:28assessment? Yeah.
- 30:30And and though they lent into CCSA little bit obviously the
- 30:34Northern Endurance Partnership, East Coast cluster then high
- 30:36net, a lot of hydrogen's tied to these CCS projects.
- 30:40And although CCS is moving a lot further and faster than the the
- 30:45hydrogen angle, there was a, there was slight confidence that
- 30:49because they're coupled like the pipeline stuff for the CCS will
- 30:53and a lot of the existing pipeline is already there.
- 30:56So that the business case is it's kind of proved a little bit
- 30:59more. So yeah.
- 31:00So yeah, people went into the bigger high net and CCS projects
- 31:03as like, well, if they're going ahead and, and hydrogen's a big
- 31:07part of these projects, then hydrogen will have to like play
- 31:10it's part at some point. So although there wasn't like a
- 31:13timeline onto that, that's where that small like glimmer of
- 31:18confidence was coming from, from the sector.
- 31:20A few weeks ago at Energy Voice Live in Aberdeen, we had a
- 31:25speaker from National Gas on the panel and he was talking about
- 31:29the three molecule strategy, carbon, hydrogen gas.
- 31:34Because, you know, you can move them about in the same pipes or,
- 31:39you know, you'd think that, you know, if it works in one pipe,
- 31:42it works in another. So and it's about, you know,
- 31:44kind of what you do with those molecules and where you're going
- 31:46to be sending them. That kind of makes a lot of
- 31:48sense. So that's why I think there's a
- 31:49lot of like CCS and hydrogen colocation, you know,
- 31:53particularly in the Northwest and Teesside and Humber, right?
- 31:58Yeah, yeah, sure. And, and these clusters are
- 32:00going to play like a huge part. Like if you there was a big
- 32:02graph at the event of where people think the hydrogen
- 32:05economy is going to grow the most.
- 32:06And it was the NE, the northwest, like a tiny bit of
- 32:10Scotland. But like below the northwest
- 32:12there was like nothing, like no one expects anything.
- 32:14I think like the very nature of the clusters just makes it make
- 32:18sense, right, Because more you can have more emitters, more off
- 32:21takers All in all in similar areas.
- 32:23So, so it's quite hard to not be in the Northwest and northeast
- 32:27events and have these positive conversations even with the
- 32:30pessimism about policies, like people are still more confident
- 32:34that that it will happen. Whereas if like you have a
- 32:37conference in London or like South Wales, they might be a bit
- 32:40like what you're talking about. Hydrogen's like not going to be
- 32:43that great, not going to be used that much.
- 32:44But Oh yeah, maybe, maybe these regional hubs will like prove
- 32:48the wider business case. And obviously National Gas with
- 32:51Project Union, they've got big plans with, with a massive
- 32:54pipeline. They're 1500 miles, right?
- 32:57Or kilometres? I think it's Miles.
- 32:58Yeah, yeah, absolutely. It's not small.
- 33:01Yeah, yeah, yeah, Miles, yeah. Yeah, there's an update on the E
- 33:06300 mile bit. That's Humber and Teesside and
- 33:10connects all the projects around the Humber.
- 33:13It's all these neat little maps and there's one of the entire
- 33:18network that National Gas is working in.
- 33:21They got the green light from Ofgem, I guess like late last
- 33:25year, you know, it's in a one billion, £100 billion project,
- 33:28you know, to repurpose and build new pipelines and that sort of
- 33:32stuff. So it's kind of cool.
- 33:34Like you could go on Energy Voice and have a look at the
- 33:36map, see where it's all going to get built out and where it's all
- 33:38going to be connected. Because at least there's some
- 33:40things working in the plan. Even if like R2 and R3
- 33:44allocation rounds for supply chain projects that are going to
- 33:48build the hydrogen economy aren't quite where they probably
- 33:51should be in Scotland. You know, it's a, it's a tricky
- 33:54one. We've had all sorts of hydrogen
- 33:55projects up here fall over. So it's, you know, it's, it's a,
- 34:01it's a tricky 1. Well, maybe it's a good thing
- 34:03that hydrogen's not happening in Scotland.
- 34:05You know, The Proclaimers said they could walk 500 miles and
- 34:07500 more, but 1500 might be just a bridge too far for the two
- 34:11guys from Edinburgh. Anyway, I feel like that
- 34:15probably rounds out our, our conversation on hydrogen West of
- 34:20Shetland Gas and of course, the war in the Middle East this
- 34:23week. If you were, if you're
- 34:24interested to stay up to date on all of these topics and more,
- 34:27well, you can always head off to energyvoice.com.
- 34:30So thank you, Erica, Floyd and Michael, for joining me this
- 34:33week and thank you very much for listening.
- 34:36I'll see you same time, same place next week.