Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Safest Electric Vehicles of 2025
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome back to The Deep Dive. We take your research, pile your
- 0:11articles, your data, and basically give you the fastest
- 0:13way to get smart on a topic. And today, yeah, we're going
- 0:16electric, but doing it safely. You sent over this huge stack of
- 0:202025 safety studies. We're talking the latest EVs,
- 0:23hybrids, plugins, the works. So our mission today, cut
- 0:27through all the noise, you know, the marketing, spin the
- 0:29different reports and find the actual safest bets based on
- 0:32data. We're not just looking at like
- 0:34overall winners. We want to zero in on that super
- 0:36popular small SUV segment and crucially, check out what makes
- 0:40sense for families, you know, space, seats, that kind of
- 0:43thing. OK, let's unpack this.
- 0:44So when you talk car safety, right off the bat, you run into
- 0:48the two big names in the US, NHTSA, That's the National
- 0:52Highway Traffic Safety Administration and the IIHS, the
- 0:55Insurance Institute for Hwy. Safety.
- 0:57But for EVs, it's not just about crash dummies and steel cages
- 1:02anymore. The really big difference, the
- 1:03thing that gets special attention with electric vehicles
- 1:06is the battery, its integrity. Think about it.
- 1:09These lithium ion packs are, well, powerful and heavy,
- 1:13usually the heaviest single part.
- 1:15So the IHS specifically, they add checks during the crash
- 1:18test. They need to be sure that HIT
- 1:19doesn't damage the battery pack because a damaged pack could
- 1:22mean, you know, a fire risk, thermal runaway.
- 1:24That's kind of the new baseline we're looking for in these top
- 1:27cars. Right.
- 1:28So that structural piece making sure the battery holds up,
- 1:31that's table stakes now, OK, let's quickly cover the basics
- 1:34of the test, but like get to what it means for you listening.
- 1:36NHTSA has got the five star system, right?
- 1:38Yep. The five star safety ratings
- 1:41pretty straightforward. They test frontal crashes.
- 1:44Think of 35 mile per hour head on collision, then side impacts
- 1:47both hitting a barrier and hitting a pole and they look at
- 1:50rollover risk. Five stars is the top score.
- 1:53Simple enough. But the IIH, they're the really
- 1:56tough ones, aren't they? Oh, definitely.
- 1:58The IIHS is known for being rigorous.
- 2:00Their scale is different, Good, acceptable, marginal or poor.
- 2:05And to get their big awards, the top safety pick or the the even
- 2:09better top safety pick. Plus our cars have to ace some
- 2:12really specific difficult tests. We're talking things like the
- 2:15small overlap front test. Imagine clipping a tree or a
- 2:19utility pole with just like 1/4 of the car's front.
- 2:22Ouch, Yeah, that sounds like you would really test the structure.
- 2:24Exactly. That's where the engineering
- 2:26really shows. And they also look hard at roof
- 2:28strength, head restraints and like we said for EVs that
- 2:31battery check. OK, so here's something that
- 2:33really jumped out from the source is kind of the first big
- 2:35take away for you listening. It seems like basic crash
- 2:38safety. You know the structure and
- 2:40airbags part. It's almost a solved problem for
- 2:42these top EVs. Now the tech is standard.
- 2:45That's a great way to put it. It really is.
- 2:47You look across all the top rated models in the studies you
- 2:49sent, the Maki, the Ion IQ 5, the Subaru Soltera, the Cadillac
- 2:54Lyric, the basic safety tech. It's all there.
- 2:57Standard automatic emergency braking, or AEB.
- 3:01You know the system that hits the brakes if you're about to
- 3:03crash. That's standard lane keep,
- 3:06assist, blind spot monitoring, adaptive cruise control.
- 3:11It's just expected now on these vehicles.
- 3:13And here's where it gets really interesting because the sources
- 3:15are showing this move towards like layers of safety
- 3:19redundancy. Exactly.
- 3:20You're seeing more advanced sensors, radar based systems
- 3:23becoming the norm, plus these a sophisticated driver monitoring
- 3:28system. Some watch the road, some
- 3:30actually watch you, the driver, to make sure you're paying
- 3:32attention. Wow so basically top notch?
- 3:34Safety isn't a luxury add on anymore, it's just the price of
- 3:37admission if you want to play in the top tier of the EV market.
- 3:40Precisely. It's foundational.
- 3:41OK, so let's narrow things down a bit.
- 3:42Small and compact electric SUV's are huge right now.
- 3:45Super popular segment. So we look at the IC cars
- 3:48rankings. They do this cool thing where
- 3:50they crunch, what, five years of data?
- 3:52Yeah, five years of both NHTSA and IIHS data, they boil it all
- 3:56down into a single safety score out of 10, which is honestly a
- 4:00great shortcut for you trying to figure this out.
- 4:02It cuts right through the clutter in a really crowded
- 4:04market segment. So IC Cars looked at 10 electric
- 4:07compact SU VS, and the results are pretty striking.
- 4:10The top three all got a perfect 10 out of 10.
- 4:12Perfect 10 OK, who are they? All right, number one on their
- 4:14list, the Subaru Soltera. It got five stars from NHTSA and
- 4:18the IIHS Top Safety Pick Plus award.
- 4:20Just excellent scores all around.
- 4:22Tied with it, also a perfect 10 is the Hyundai IONI Q5, another
- 4:27IIHS Top Safety Pick Plus winner.
- 4:29And rounding out that top group #3 also a 10 out of 10, the Ford
- 4:33Mustang Mach E Again, 5 NHTSA Stars and the IIHS Top Safety
- 4:38Pick Plus 10. Hold on a SEC, the Soltera, the
- 4:41IO and IQ 5, the Mach E, they're all perfect tense, but they're
- 4:47pretty different vehicles, right?
- 4:48I mean, the Maki is quite distinct from the Solterra in
- 4:51terms of like size and shape. How can they all score
- 4:54identically perfect? Does that just mean they all met
- 4:56the standard, even if they did it differently?
- 4:58That's exactly the question. And yeah, the data shows the
- 5:00standard is high. Once you clear that bar, you've
- 5:02cleared it. They all provide top level
- 5:04protection. But here's the interesting part,
- 5:06and this is about the IC cars method itself.
- 5:09It explains why the Solterra gets the the number one ranking
- 5:13despite the tie. If we connect this to the bigger
- 5:16picture, IC CARS uses an overall quality score to break ties when
- 5:20safety scores are identical. That overall score includes
- 5:23things like reliability and how well the car holds its value.
- 5:27Value retention. OK.
- 5:29So they all aced the safety tests equally.
- 5:31Right. But when they looked at the
- 5:32whole package, the Soltera apparently edged out the others
- 5:35on reliability and resale value. That's what put it first.
- 5:39That's actually a really important insight.
- 5:40It's not about one being safer in a crash than the others at
- 5:43that top level, it's more about the long term picture,
- 5:47reliability, value. Good to know.
- 5:50Definitely, and just below those perfect 10s, you had really
- 5:53strong performers too. The Volkswagen ID .4 and the
- 5:56Nissan area both scored an excellent 9 point O out of 10.
- 6:00It just reinforces that this whole segment, these small
- 6:02electric SU VS. They're generally very, very
- 6:05safe vehicles. OK, makes sense.
- 6:06Small SU VS nailed it on safety test.
- 6:08But safe for one person driving is one thing.
- 6:11What about packing in the kids? Let's shift gears now.
- 6:14Forget just crash tests for a second.
- 6:15Let's talk about family life, space, pace, car seats, budget,
- 6:19the real world stuff. Right.
- 6:20So now we're looking at a different study, one that ranked
- 6:22EV specifically on family practicality.
- 6:25They looked at interior volume, how many seats, crucially, how
- 6:28many child seats you can fit. And yeah, price affordability
- 6:31matters. And this study threw up a really
- 6:34interesting winner for families, a vehicle that got a perfect
- 6:37score, 100 out of 100 on their family index.
- 6:40And it's one that's really shaken up the market, especially
- 6:43for three row SU VS We're talking about the Kia EV9.
- 6:46Yeah, the EV9 really stands out here.
- 6:48It offers six or seven seats, which is great flexibility.
- 6:51It's got a really spacious interior, about 128 cubic feet.
- 6:55And here's the kicker. For families, it can fit up to
- 6:58four child seats. Four.
- 7:00Wow. Yeah. 4 which is pretty rare and
- 7:02the price point starting around $54,900 is actually quite
- 7:06competitive for a big electric three row SUV like that.
- 7:09OK, so compare that to the renter up the Rivian R1 S scored
- 7:1296, so still really high. Right, The R1S, now it actually
- 7:16has more interior space than the EV9137 cubic feet, which is
- 7:19massive. And it also fits four child
- 7:22seats. So capability wise, it's top
- 7:24notch. But the price?
- 7:25But the price, that's the trade off.
- 7:26The RNS starts way up there, around $77,700.
- 7:30It's definitely a premium vehicle.
- 7:31So the EV9 kind of hits that sweet spot, doesn't it?
- 7:33Loads a utility top family score but without that luxury price
- 7:37tag. Yeah, exactly.
- 7:38It shows you don't necessarily have to spend huge money to get
- 7:41a really practical, safe, large electric family hauler.
- 7:44And this study also pointed out some great options if budget is
- 7:48like the main concern, right, but still good for families.
- 7:51Absolutely. If affordability is key, the
- 7:53Mazda CX-90 scored really well, 93 points.
- 7:57It starts under $38,000 which is fantastic, offers good space,
- 8:01121 cubic feet and fits three child seats.
- 8:05It's a plug in hybrid mind you. Not a full EV, but great value.
- 8:09The way the VWID .4 popped up again here too, didn't it?
- 8:12It did the Volkswagen ID .4. It scored 80 on this family
- 8:16index. Now 80 might not sound as
- 8:18impressive as 100 or 96, but you have to look at what you get for
- 8:21the price. It starts just under $40,000 and
- 8:24it offers a huge amount of interior space for that money.
- 8:27130 cubic feet more space than the Mazda, actually almost as
- 8:31much as the Kia EV9. The trade off is it only
- 8:33officially fits two child seats easily.
- 8:35So with the ID .4 you're getting maximum space for the money
- 8:39basically, but maybe slightly less kid carrying capacity than
- 8:42the three row options. That's the gist of it, yeah.
- 8:44Great space per dollar. And just to round out that
- 8:46family study, there were luxury players too, right?
- 8:48Like Cadillac, Lexus. Yep.
- 8:50The Cadillac Lyric, Lexus RZ, Genesis Electrified GV 70, they
- 8:54all did well in the family rankings too.
- 8:56It just confirms that even at the high end, family needs
- 8:59aren't being ignored. You can get luxury and
- 9:01practicality. OK, let's try and tie this all
- 9:03together. We've looked at crash tests,
- 9:06small Icvs, family features. And what's really striking is
- 9:10the consistency, isn't it? Seeing models like the VWID .4,
- 9:14the Nissan Aria, the Ford Mustang Mach E show up as strong
- 9:18performers across different lists is different criteria.
- 9:21Yeah, that's a good point. Whether it's pure crash safety
- 9:24or how they stack up against similar SUV's or even family
- 9:28stuff, some names just keep appearing.
- 9:30It really shows they're just fundamentally well engineered
- 9:32safe vehicles overall. So what does this all mean?
- 9:35What's the big take away for you listening?
- 9:37I think it confirms that switching to electric, you
- 9:40really don't have to sacrifice safety at all.
- 9:43The standard is just incredibly high now, especially for these
- 9:462025 models. Exactly.
- 9:48Safety is almost like a given at this point among the top
- 9:50contenders. It lets you, the buyer, focus
- 9:53more on the other things that matter to you.
- 9:54You know, like range, charging speed, how big it is, the tech
- 9:58features inside, and of course the price.
- 10:01You can weigh those factors knowing the safety baseline is
- 10:03already excellent. There was a quote and one of the
- 10:06sources an analyst said something like families don't
- 10:08need to compromise on safety to go electric regardless of their
- 10:11budget. I thought that summed it up
- 10:13perfectly. That's a great quote, captures
- 10:14it well. So quick recap.
- 10:17We looked at the hardcore crash test readings from NHTSA and
- 10:20IIHS. We saw how IC cars rank small
- 10:24SUV's, where overall quality can actually break a tie even among
- 10:27perfectly safe cars, and we dove into family needs, space, seats,
- 10:32affordability, where cars like the Kia EV9 and VWID .4 really
- 10:36shine in different ways. The evidence is clear.
- 10:39The 2025 EV market is fundamentally safe.
- 10:42You've got great choices. OK, so that brings us to one
- 10:44final thought, something that kind of emerged from looking at
- 10:47all this. A bit provocative maybe?
- 10:50We've established all this great standard safety tech, right?
- 10:53AED, lane keeping. It's all baked in.
- 10:55You need it for the top ratings. Right, it's expected.
- 10:58But then you see things like the Cadillac Lyric was mentioned
- 11:01with its super Cruise system. That's the hands free driving
- 11:04thing. Yeah, the advanced driver assist
- 11:06systems. And, the sources noted, Super
- 11:08Cruise requires a subscription, an ongoing payment.
- 11:12That's becoming more common for those really high level
- 11:15features. So here's the question for you
- 11:16to chew on. Are you comfortable with this
- 11:19split where the core safety stuff is standard included but
- 11:23the absolute cutting edge semi autonomous features might become
- 11:28something you pay for monthly forever?
- 11:30It's definitely a trend to watch.
- 11:32Where does standard safety end and premium subscription based
- 11:35convenience begin? Something to think about next
- 11:38time you're comparing window stickers, maybe?
- 11:40Well, that's our deep dive for today.
- 11:42Huge thanks for sending in your sources and letting us break it
- 11:45all down for you. If you found this useful, this
- 11:48kind of expert shortcut through the noise, please do follow the
- 11:52channel. We do this regularly, turning
- 11:55complex topics into clear takeaways.
- 11:57We'd love to have you back. Until next time, stay safe out
- 12:00there.