Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / Coins Don't Lie—Here's What Killed Rome
Transcript
- 0:00Most people think Rome fell because of invasions or bad
- 0:03emperors, but by the time those things happened, the system was
- 0:07already breaking because Rome's money stopped working.
- 0:11For nearly 300 years, Roman coins held their value.
- 0:15People trusted them, built with them, paid armies with them.
- 0:19Then suddenly they didn't. The silver disappeared.
- 0:22The coins kept coming, but they weren't worth what they claimed
- 0:26to be worth. And once people realized that,
- 0:28they stopped trusting the system itself.
- 0:31What followed wasn't just inflation, it was something much
- 0:35bigger. A complete breakdown of how Rome
- 0:38functioned until 2 emperors tried to fix.
- 0:41Diocletian tried to control the system.
- 0:43Constantine the Great replaced it entirely.
- 0:45And you can see that transformation not in the
- 0:47history books, but in the coins themselves.
- 1:09Welcome back to the Roman pattern.
- 1:11I'm your host, Jeremy Ryan Slate, the CEO and Co founder of
- 1:14Command Your brand could check us out over at
- 1:16commandyourbrand.com. And we have a really interesting
- 1:21conversation that I've, I'm excited to share with you guys
- 1:24today because we're in the midst of talking about when Rome kind
- 1:28of really ceased to be Rome and, and in a lot of ways became
- 1:31something else. You know, we've covered the
- 1:33reforms of Diocletian. We've covered a lot of the
- 1:35bureaucrats that kept the system running when emperors died.
- 1:39We're going to be talking about Constantine very soon.
- 1:42And then we're going to move into the next stage, talk about
- 1:44Julian the apostate and a lot of other things.
- 1:45But we've had today's guest on before to talk about propaganda
- 1:51around coins. But I think when we look at kind
- 1:54of this thread in history, this is a really interesting place to
- 1:56bring him back because when you look at Diocletian and
- 2:00Constantine, it is 2 really important people in the world of
- 2:05coinage. So welcome back to the Roman
- 2:09pattern, Dean Kenser. Thank you so much for having me,
- 2:11Jeremy. It's a pleasure.
- 2:13Love talking about this stuff, particularly with you who know
- 2:16so much about Roman history and love to share the info about
- 2:20coins because that's my passion. And my hope is, is that maybe
- 2:24you can transfer some of this interest into your first ancient
- 2:28very. Cool, and you've actually
- 2:29supplied us with a number and you're actually the guy that
- 2:31gives me all the coins that I give to podcast host when I go
- 2:34go on shows. So definitely have to give you
- 2:36kudos there. I know we gave some that we gave
- 2:39some to Sean Ryan. We gave some to to Julian Dory.
- 2:43We, we had a really good time giving people coins.
- 2:45So definitely appreciate all that as well.
- 2:48So Dean, the thing I wanted to kind of start out with is we're
- 2:52looking, we're looking at the idea when money stopped working.
- 2:56And this is one of the big things we see during the 3rd
- 2:58century crisis is coins had started to change dramatically.
- 3:03And because of that, people actually start to opt out of the
- 3:06system. And even when Aurelian tries to
- 3:08bring bring back a better coin, people still don't believe it
- 3:12because they've been told for 50 years there's something wrong
- 3:14with their coins. So I think the place I want to
- 3:17start is we look at the 3rd century crisis in particular,
- 3:22what was happening to coins in that era?
- 3:25We've talked about a lot of other things around the 3rd
- 3:27century crisis, but what was happening to the coinage?
- 3:32Well, when we we, we think about the Roman Empire, we think about
- 3:35stability, particularly in the early era through the five good
- 3:40Emperors. And then there was some
- 3:41stability, but in large part it was chaos, right?
- 3:45A lot of what was going on was unpredictable.
- 3:48There were invaders, but really in terms of coinage, the
- 3:52stability came from the Daenerys.
- 3:55And the Daenerys was a high quality silver coin from the
- 3:58beginning of the Roman Republic all the way through until Nero.
- 4:02And then they start to depleting it a little bit, a little bit
- 4:06further during the five good emperors.
- 4:08But that standard coinage, the American dollar of the day, you
- 4:11would say was relevant, usable, and people could rely on the
- 4:16silver content. And then when the 3rd century
- 4:20began, the Severn dynasty did begin to kind of, they created
- 4:25the double denarius, which actually was, you know, the
- 4:27silver content of I think what, 1 1/2 denarius points.
- 4:31So they kind of took the trust of the Daenerys away and and
- 4:36changed it into something and Antony.
- 4:39I always have trouble sending. Daenerys that had.
- 4:41By the way, when I, when I'm recording, when I'm recording
- 4:44these these videos from a prompter, I always apologize to
- 4:47my editor because I have to like reread the line that includes
- 4:50the the name Antony. And I can't even say now, like I
- 4:53can never say that word anyway. No, like any time I try to spell
- 5:00out Antoninus Pious, it's always a problem too.
- 5:04I mean, there's something about the extra ends or whatever that
- 5:07that. Anyway, you were saying I
- 5:08apologize, but anyway. So the yes, the the value or the
- 5:15the trust in the currency obviously depleted once you
- 5:19claim to be something you weren't.
- 5:21And then the silver content over time went from a high quality
- 5:25silver or higher quality silver as it started out in to a more
- 5:30mixed coin further down the line.
- 5:34And then it just became basically silver plated with
- 5:37about 5% silver content and really bronze on the back of
- 5:42that. Some of those maintain the
- 5:44silver content, some of them didn't even really get any.
- 5:47So a lot of the coins that were originally supposed to be silver
- 5:51are no longer silver. They're bronze, and they're not
- 5:54worth what denarius is worth. And so people are struggling to
- 5:58figure out how to exchange this value when it doesn't have the
- 6:02same value that it's advertised at.
- 6:05And there is a abundant quantity of those coins on the
- 6:09marketplace. You can see just based on the
- 6:12sheer volume of coins that we have still around today from
- 6:16that time period that there was a large quantity of that being
- 6:20minted, but at lower, lesser value.
- 6:23Kind of like the, I guess the German mark after World War One,
- 6:29right, where where there is a lot of money, but it's not worth
- 6:34what it was. And so like you mentioned, some
- 6:37people alter the system or try to go around it because the
- 6:41currency isn't worth what it was.
- 6:43So I guess the thing I want to talk about, and I, I, I mention
- 6:45it a lot and I have a, a very rudimentary understanding of it.
- 6:51And I think this is where I think you can add a lot of, a
- 6:53lot of value in this as well. I've been trying to fill a lot
- 6:56of my, my knowledge gaps recently.
- 6:58I'm almost done reading Kyle Harper's Fate of Rome, which is
- 7:01covering disease and a lot of other things, which is extremely
- 7:04interesting. But I want to talk about the
- 7:05idea of of currency debates. What does that look like in a
- 7:10process? I know we've covered it a bit
- 7:12on. Here.
- 7:13So yeah, I mean that that is something that is very.
- 7:15Understand in a rudimentary way. Right.
- 7:18So the the debasement is taking the value one once was and
- 7:23taking that precious metal, which at the time was the silver
- 7:25content and removing it slowly in an often times I would say
- 7:31that a lot of that silver was kept beyond where it was
- 7:35supposed to be depleted. So the silver content or the,
- 7:39the, the coins themselves didn't generate as much silver in the
- 7:44marketplace and didn't generate as much market transaction as it
- 7:48had previously. So whereas you may have been
- 7:51able to pay for something with a denarius or two at one point,
- 7:54now you're talking about a handful of or, or quite a bit
- 7:58more in terms of bronze coinage, because the coins are not worth
- 8:02what a silver coin was worth. And so the, you know, obviously
- 8:06the, the, the faith in that being tradable is, is a
- 8:11catastrophic thing for, for people who are in the
- 8:14marketplace, particularly when you, when you think of large
- 8:17scale building. I mean, a lot of the Roman
- 8:19Empire was expensive and a lot of money went to it and a lot of
- 8:23money went to soldiers, right? Particularly in this time period
- 8:26when you were fighting relentlessly defending yourself
- 8:30from these conquerors. So you had to at least hold back
- 8:37and try to protect the government, but at the same time
- 8:40release some types of type of currency that they could
- 8:43exchange with. But obviously if the trust is
- 8:45gone, then taking something that once had 100% silver content or
- 8:5095% silver content and is now 5 or less percent is not going to
- 8:55get the transactional value. And so that's the, that's the
- 8:58kind of deal is to try to take away what was once was the value
- 9:04of something to either store or to generate a new version of.
- 9:10Currency. No, it does.
- 9:11Hopefully that makes sense to. To go back to the the Severus
- 9:14point about the Severin dynasty too, in the in the Harper book
- 9:17I'm reading right now, he talks about if you look at even a lot
- 9:19of what's left of Rome, the Severin dynasty was kind of the
- 9:23last until you kind of get to Justinian, but that's more in
- 9:25the East. It was kind of the last major
- 9:28building projects of Rome and people wouldn't have seen, you
- 9:31know, that scale of something that was always Roman, which is
- 9:34quite interesting. But I guess like looking at it
- 9:36at the minting level, I'm curious, do you kind of know
- 9:40what that process was like at the minting level?
- 9:42And did they have trouble with people maybe, you know, stealing
- 9:46things, stealing things at the mint level or what did that?
- 9:48Look like, yeah, I mean, that's that's a constant thing.
- 9:53I mean, one of the things that you'll see on, you know, a coin
- 9:57that you know is graded, it may say clipped and, and stuff like
- 10:03that is, is fairly common. Clipping is more of AI would say
- 10:08a, a thing that was done with later hammered coins that were
- 10:11flat like like the Byzantine coinage or the medieval coinage
- 10:15from England and stuff like that, where you could clip off.
- 10:18But the same as with shavings, the same as with cutting off a
- 10:21little piece to kind of keep hold back and save for yourself.
- 10:25And I think that was pretty predominant during the course of
- 10:28the Roman Empire or pretty much anywhere where there was some
- 10:31hold back. I, I, I kind of harken it back
- 10:34to you. Remember the scene from Casino
- 10:37where everybody, there's the giant room of money and it's
- 10:40constantly flipping and all this money's moving and then one guy
- 10:44puts one thing in his pocket and another guy.
- 10:46So there's like a a transition of people taking a little bit
- 10:50off the top. By the time it gets to the
- 10:52actual person that's needed, it's only a small portion of
- 10:56what was supposed to be a larger portion.
- 10:59And and I that that ran rampant so.
- 11:02The thing I'm curious about too, and we just did an episode where
- 11:04we talked about how did normal people get through the the
- 11:06crisis of the 3rd century, which is actually one of the hardest
- 11:09things to construct because we actually don't know a ton about
- 11:13it. I'm curious, how did people look
- 11:15at this money in the marketplace?
- 11:17Did we, do we know enough about that or kind of how do people
- 11:20that regular people respond to this, if we even know that?
- 11:23Well, I, you know, I mean, you know, some of it, some of it
- 11:26would be guests. I mean, you know, the, the idea
- 11:29I think would be similar to what happened in the 5th century
- 11:33where Rome started to collapse. And it wasn't like an abrupt
- 11:37deal. It, it started to things
- 11:39services stopped happening right, particularly in England
- 11:43and stuff just cut off of communication or cut off of, of
- 11:47resources that are coming in. And I undoubtedly the resources
- 11:52now are changed to bronze in these, you know, cruder coins
- 11:56that aren't worth as much. And people probably in large
- 12:01part started to look to other methods to trade goods or they
- 12:06had to do, you know, kind of the, the German World War One
- 12:10type deal where they'd have a wheelbarrow full of cash to try
- 12:14and trade. You know, that that's the
- 12:17that's, that's kind of what happens, you know, as currency
- 12:19stops being relevant, people start having stop having faith
- 12:24in it and start looking for other opportunities.
- 12:27And that's not totally unsimilar to what we experienced today,
- 12:31right? I mean, there, there is a lot of
- 12:32look at different kinds of currencies because they want to
- 12:36people want to invest in something.
- 12:37So. One of the things I I wanted to
- 12:39jump into. So we just covered pretty
- 12:42extensively, I think in like 3 episodes for the world of
- 12:44Diocletian. And if you look at what
- 12:47Diocletian does, he, he realizes there's this monetary problem
- 12:51and he does try to do certain things about it, most of which
- 12:56are not very effective. But I'm curious when we look at
- 13:00Diocletian and the currency, what does he attempt to do about
- 13:04it and what are the actual results?
- 13:06So what he does with currency? So he reorganizes and I think
- 13:10that's, that's one of the things that, you know, probably was
- 13:14very difficult, I would think for a emperor who I, I, if I
- 13:18remember correctly about Diocletian, he's not a made man.
- 13:22He's not a person that has kind of risen.
- 13:25Yeah, he's just, he's a Croatian soldier named Diocleus.
- 13:31Yeah, that's right. And then and then to take the
- 13:35authority to try and change the entire coinage from a guy.
- 13:39So that that speaks to kind of what thought process he had
- 13:42around organization. Obviously he was concerned about
- 13:46the silver content, concerned about silver coinage.
- 13:49So he reintroduced the Argentis, which would be kind of a similar
- 13:53according to the denarius did have silver content.
- 13:57He was obviously very excited about that because often times
- 14:02he would on the reverse of those coins have all four of the
- 14:05tetrarchy on the back to show the connection of all sides of
- 14:10the empire. And that's really another
- 14:12portion of structure, right? So he's creating structure, he's
- 14:17recreating the coinage to try and organize, organize.
- 14:22A lot of times when people talk about, let's say tyrants or
- 14:26dictators or or things like that nature, usually people say,
- 14:29well, they organize power. The trains in Italy always ran
- 14:33on. Top, that's a step, right?
- 14:39That's a step is organization reorganization, consolidating
- 14:42power. Money is power.
- 14:45Organizing around that helped I would think take something that
- 14:49was struggling and maintain it. His reforms, you know obviously
- 14:54he went to large bronze coins, Follis coins and some of the
- 14:58smaller types that we call AE2AE3AE4 now that were issued
- 15:05and long lasting that I would say other aspects of what he put
- 15:11together did not last long. We did the Argentis did not last
- 15:15long and obviously a lot of his price floor and ceiling and
- 15:20things of that nature to try to control the amount of spending
- 15:24or how much was paid in the marketplace did not last.
- 15:28But he certainly had a tremendous impact.
- 15:30And I think in large part whether you, you know, obviously
- 15:33his his religious persecutions and things like that had a
- 15:38heavyweight on his leadership. But at the same time, I think he
- 15:42probably helped reorganize the empire enough that Constantine
- 15:46was in a fantastic position to kind of succeed from there.
- 15:50And and I don't think without Diocletians reforms that that
- 15:53would have succeeded as well. Even though Constantine, I would
- 15:56say is it was a great leader and somebody highly capable, kind of
- 16:01like Philip the 2nd and Alexander the Great.
- 16:03Sometimes the guy who sets it up for you doesn't get to, doesn't
- 16:07get the credit. But I think that without
- 16:10Diocletian, Constantine doesn't I.
- 16:13Can't remember the name of the book offhand, but Adrian
- 16:15Goldsworthy has a great book about Philip the 2nd and, and,
- 16:20and some of Alexander where he gets into exactly that.
- 16:22Because if you even look at it, just as you know, this is this
- 16:24is a side point what we're talking about.
- 16:25But there is no Alexander without Philip the second,
- 16:29right? He kind of steps into it like
- 16:30it's like kind of your dad dies and he gives you the perfect
- 16:34race car and you go out and you win, you win 10 titles and it's
- 16:37like, well, you know, you weren't driving this jalopy.
- 16:39So you're in great shape, right? And I think there there can
- 16:42often be, you know, you have somebody that inherits the right
- 16:45position and they're the right guy, right?
- 16:47Like if you look at Constantine, you know, like let's say it's
- 16:51Maxentius or somebody else that inherits this, this empire that
- 16:54Diocletian has has changed and altered.
- 16:56Well, maybe they're not as successful as Constantine,
- 16:58right? So it does have to be the right
- 16:59person with the right opportunity as well.
- 17:01Well, and, and think about what, what difference Constantine
- 17:04made, right? I mean, he changed the center of
- 17:06Rome from Rome to Constantinople.
- 17:09Would Constantinople been as great would have been
- 17:12independent? Would Rome have lasted near as
- 17:15long if the center of wealth, which was Constantinople because
- 17:20it was such a great trading port?
- 17:22Would it have lasted as long with Rome being still the
- 17:25center? I think that's one of the kind
- 17:27of maybe not underappreciated, but things that people don't
- 17:31consider is that Constantinople was Byzantian, which is a, a
- 17:37Greek city and not AI would say a, the commerce center that it
- 17:43became because of Constantine and what he developed there and
- 17:47then how it continued on by beyond, I guess.
- 17:49As we get into Constantine a bit here, there's one of the stories
- 17:53that I've heard and I haven't been able to find a ton of
- 17:54supporting sources for this. So I'm, I'm always curious like
- 17:57how true it is. But it's the idea of Constantine
- 18:01and the way he looked at coinage is he wanted to get the empire
- 18:04on a gold standard. And you know, he does this in
- 18:07terms of minting new gold coins. He does a few every year for
- 18:10about a 20 year period, starts requiring taxes to be paid in
- 18:13gold so it goes in circulation. So we look at the monetary
- 18:16reforms and the coinage reforms of Constantine.
- 18:19What did those look like and how effective were they in
- 18:21comparison to the Diocletian? Well, so the, the, the gold
- 18:25coins, the Solidus coins from that era did last they extended
- 18:30beyond his time and the, the I believe the the formulation of
- 18:37those coins or the quality and let's say well done nature of
- 18:43those coins extended. Well, I had also read somewhere
- 18:46that. Obviously.
- 18:46There's even thoughts that it went as far as 1054 with with
- 18:49with kind of the the gold quality of these coins, which is
- 18:53unheard of in in kind of the ancient world.
- 18:55Yeah. Well, think about how much, how
- 18:59much transpired in that time frame.
- 19:01And and Rome, Rome or Constantinople at that time did
- 19:05have a problem because they weren't really able to mint or
- 19:08to mine silver, right. And we talked about that in
- 19:11later Byzantine time. So gold was obviously their
- 19:14their trading, right. That was their way of doing it
- 19:17because they no longer had access to the, the Spanish
- 19:20silver mines and some of the other places and across the
- 19:22world where silver was affluent. And a lot of that they had to
- 19:26actually trade to let's say the Sasanians or the Islamic
- 19:32caliphates to try and get it. But the strength of the aureus
- 19:36or the, or I should say the solidus is probably as much
- 19:40responsible for helping prolong the consistency the, the, the
- 19:45coinage. Now obviously they did get
- 19:47thinner and they did become subject to clipping and all that
- 19:50kinds of stuff, but they did last for for as long as you
- 19:53mentioned. And then they went to I think a
- 19:55histamon or some kind of thinner kind of plated coinage much
- 20:00later as you described. But it it certainly succeeded.
- 20:03It succeeded beyond Constantine is succeeded beyond 476.
- 20:08So that reform is very effective.
- 20:09So I guess when we look at that then was this gold in existence
- 20:14before could a previous emperor had done it?
- 20:16Like how did how was Constantine in a position to be able to do
- 20:19something so different? Well, that's a good question.
- 20:22I don't know that I have a perfect answer for you other
- 20:25than the fact that a strong leader knows that money is
- 20:29valuable. He was dealt what I would
- 20:31consider probably some real financial problems, you know,
- 20:35some self-imposed by Diocletian, some, you know, just based in
- 20:40the era. But he realized the gold
- 20:43standard or the importance of gold continued on.
- 20:47I mean, you know, the the wondering if he if the gold was
- 20:50available. If you if you're a coin
- 20:53collector now and you're looking at gold Aureus coins, the coins
- 20:56before Constantine and you're searching pricing of certain
- 21:01types, the types of the Julio Claudians, the five good
- 21:05emperors, those have, I would say considerably more on the in
- 21:10the marketplace right now. And as you start to get to like
- 21:13let's say Gordian the third or further down the line, like even
- 21:16the Valerian or something like that.
- 21:20Which I which I will say is one of my favorite coins that you
- 21:22provided me to show people. And it's like, hey, this is the
- 21:24guy that was used as Shapur, the first footstool.
- 21:27But anyway. But but they the scarcity of
- 21:31those gold coins in the 3rd century is a lot higher.
- 21:35And so the value of those gold coins still simple.
- 21:38So still the same kind of aureus coin, but but less available.
- 21:43So a a 3rd century gold aureus will be worth quite a bit more
- 21:47than let's say a Nero aureus because it's scarcer.
- 21:51And I think that lends itself to the idea that there was less
- 21:55gold around or less gold being used.
- 21:58So I guess when we look at it then, and this is a, a
- 22:00discussion I actually had with the guys unsubscribe recently,
- 22:03but we did it on their kind of their, their pre show.
- 22:06We were talking about some of the coins he had provided me.
- 22:09One of those was a, a coin of Constantine.
- 22:11And we look at imagery on coins. I'm curious the the coinage of
- 22:16Constantine. What kind of imagery did he use
- 22:18and how did that change as he changed?
- 22:22Well, that's an interesting question.
- 22:24I did. I did just write an article and
- 22:26I think this is pretty interesting.
- 22:27One of the interesting areas of collecting ancient coins,
- 22:32particularly in the 3rd century or the 4th century is the
- 22:37beards, right? There's a whole series of
- 22:39Constantinian era coins, whether it's him or like like Kineus or
- 22:44any of the other guys where there's certain, you know,
- 22:47where, where the most common coin of Constantine is
- 22:50beardless. But then there's stubble,
- 22:52there's sideburns, there's like almost a, a beard.
- 22:55So he is showing, you know, growth, maturity in his.
- 23:00That's really interesting. That's an important thing.
- 23:02He's always clean shaven. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 23:04So there is there is facial hair and that's an interesting
- 23:07collectible side to the 4th century bronzes that that that
- 23:11some people have interest in putting together.
- 23:14A lot of his coinage on the reverse, you know, either
- 23:19exemplified Saul, right, the sun God, which is, you know,
- 23:22debatable about whether he saw that in the sky or the chiro.
- 23:28And so there was a lot of the sun God coinage that but a lot
- 23:33of, let's say, civic pride, the coins of herbs, Roma, the coins
- 23:40of Constantinopoulos that were issued during his lifetime.
- 23:45So celebratory over the the age and the success of the Roman
- 23:48Empire, but also the building and establishment of
- 23:53Constantinopoulos or Constantinople as a centerpiece
- 23:57to the the Roman Empire. So a lot of his coinage is
- 24:01directed at you know how important the works that are
- 24:04being done and you know what what what is being accomplished
- 24:09and who is faith is in and what. And I'm curious as well because
- 24:12I'm trying to remember offhand there was a a particular coin
- 24:16you and I were talking about and I believe it was like it was
- 24:20praying hands or something like that as well.
- 24:23Do do we start to? There we go, Do we?
- 24:25Start to see. Kind of more like piety in his
- 24:28coinage or is it more just self promotion or what do we see in
- 24:31kind of what he's putting out? Well, so his his coins did not,
- 24:35you know, later coins, but particularly the the Byzantines
- 24:39were heavy focused on Christianity in Christ, not, not
- 24:44an Roman coin type really until much later.
- 24:49But you do bring up a a good coin there.
- 24:52There is a posthumous Constantine showing him being
- 24:56escorted off to the heavens on the reverse in the chariot.
- 25:00And that's the Manestea. So that was dedicated to him
- 25:03after his death, but celebrating that that he was making his way
- 25:07up to the sky. So yeah, there definitely was
- 25:10some pious aspects to not just him, but even yeah.
- 25:17It's funny because one of my favorite books that I used those
- 25:21like 20 years ago now when I was working on my grad thesis was
- 25:25about like kind of the, the symbols of power in the age of
- 25:29Augustus. And one of the biggest things
- 25:30that it talked about was coins. And that's what's always gotten
- 25:33me excited about coins. And I guess when we look at
- 25:35coins, what do they teach us the history misses, You know, what
- 25:39are the things that they can teach us that, you know, we're
- 25:41reading a history book and we don't quite get.
- 25:44So, you know, the the easiest, the easiest way to look at how a
- 25:49civilization can rise and fall is really the the length of the
- 25:52empire's coinage. But you can do much, you know,
- 25:55you can shorten that up if you took a denarius from the time of
- 26:00Marcus Aurelius or Commodus and then compared it to let's say
- 26:06the 5th century bronze of Leo, the first right, which is a
- 26:11totally crude bronze, you know, very vague in terms of what the
- 26:18emperor look like, you know, obviously hurriedly made in
- 26:23desperate times. So you can definitely see, you
- 26:26know, we talked about the debasement, right, where it goes
- 26:28from strong silver and and Roman Rome did have bronze coins
- 26:33throughout their time, right? But it wasn't the primary source
- 26:37of funding. So there were Cistercius, there
- 26:40were AS or Asses, there were Dupedonis.
- 26:43That's another. Word as long as we don't get
- 26:44say. All throughout this time, but so
- 26:51it was a part of the currency, but it wasn't the premier part.
- 26:54Silver was always the premier part.
- 26:56And there there are Aureus coins, the gold obviously for
- 26:58higher end stuff. But as bronze became the primary
- 27:01source and silver content started to decline, you can
- 27:05watch. So the quality of the coin, the
- 27:07the the dye, the manufacturer all at at the time of Commodus
- 27:11or Marcus Aurelius is fantastic. It indicative of what the Giulio
- 27:15Claudians did, indicative of similar to what the Republicans
- 27:18did. But by the time you hit the 5th
- 27:21century, 4th century, there is no real artwork or design that's
- 27:26that's beautiful. They're crudely put together.
- 27:29You can tell that they were struck in almost, you know, like
- 27:32a constantly do this in a hurried fashion.
- 27:36So a lot of them are off centered, they're broken off
- 27:38chips. There's a lot of kind of
- 27:40desperate nature to it. And you can see it.
- 27:42I mean, you can, you can take a coin and and look at 1 and 100
- 27:46years later and you can see the very difference.
- 27:48And that speaks to the health kind of the heartbeat of ancient
- 27:53coinage. You can say that that Rome was
- 27:56dying for a long time and there is plenty of evidence and
- 28:01nowhere else. I mean, you can go to Ravenna
- 28:04and you can see some of the late Roman artwork and where where
- 28:07they move the capital to at that time.
- 28:10You know, some of that stuff still prevails.
- 28:12But a lot of that got painted over.
- 28:15A lot of that got built on. You know, you talk about the the
- 28:17what's the arc, right? Or the the victory arch, right.
- 28:21Didn't September. Yeah, kind of slap his stuff on
- 28:24top of other people's stuff. Yeah.
- 28:26So you in a lot of visual history or the places that you
- 28:29go to, a lot of what happened over time is covered up.
- 28:33But with coins, it's obvious, right?
- 28:35I mean, there's, there's no hiding the the difference.
- 28:38And I'm sure that it was visible at the time, the deconstruction
- 28:41of a lot of these buildings and the maintenance of a lot of the
- 28:44roads and all that kind of stuff was very evident.
- 28:47But over time we don't get to see that visually.
- 28:50But coins express that in a way that I don't think there's
- 28:53anything else that you could, you know, maybe jewelry, maybe
- 28:56you know, some of the glass, you know, the, what's that?
- 29:01The Roman glass lamps and stuff like that.
- 29:03Maybe the quality went down. But there's no better testament
- 29:06to declining empire than ancient coins.
- 29:09You can do the same with Greeks too.
- 29:11I mean, you know, as the Greeks stopped dominating, their
- 29:15coinage went from this giant tetradrachum that was 24 grams
- 29:19and or, or high quality silver. They start to flatten out, they
- 29:23start to weigh less, the quality of the artwork declines.
- 29:26And then as the provincial Romans started, you know, kind
- 29:30of taking over, some of that stuff got dropped all together
- 29:33and it became kind of Roman coinage.
- 29:36But you can see that and that and there's very little else
- 29:38that you can do where you can have that kind of same line
- 29:41drawn. It gets, it gets even more fun
- 29:44when you go to medieval, right? I mean, when you we talk about
- 29:47the, the artwork of the 5th century BC Greeks compared to
- 29:52the hammering styles of, you know, the English in the 10th
- 29:56century, you know, just a, a total world difference in the
- 30:02quality and the artwork and the design.
- 30:05Well, you even look at somebody like like like Henry the 7th.
- 30:08The War of the roses never happened.
- 30:10These are all new coins. None of these other people, no
- 30:12one ever existed. There is only been Henry the
- 30:167th. But I guess that a funny note
- 30:20for our for our listeners and viewers here, because they're
- 30:22always eating me alive in the comments.
- 30:23I get told, especially with words like Antenianus.
- 30:28I I I'm from western New Jersey, but I got get often get told I'm
- 30:31I sound like I'm from the Midwest and and those of us with
- 30:35a Midwestern or pseudo Midwestern accent really
- 30:38struggle with pronunciations. That's that's right.
- 30:42Yeah. I mean Drachem, which, you know,
- 30:45I, I always say drum or drat, yeah, it's like 10 to yeah.
- 30:48It's our American translation of I'm.
- 30:51I'm curious for you as somebody that's been studying coins for a
- 30:54really long time, what have you learned the most from studying
- 30:57coins? And this doesn't just have to be
- 30:59ancient coins. It could be medieval, it could
- 31:00be modern. What have you learned the most
- 31:02from studying coins? I think that I think the thing
- 31:05that I've learned the most is that, you know, that people kind
- 31:09of jokingly say history doesn't, what is it repeat itself, it
- 31:15rhymes or history repeats itself or, or all of those kind of I
- 31:21think what, what ancient coins really teach us is, you know,
- 31:25these are these are people that are communicating over time.
- 31:29I think that they're teaching us lessons about what happens in
- 31:33certain circumstances, what what happened to them.
- 31:37And those messages are poignant, right?
- 31:39I mean, there's, there's times of disease, there's times of
- 31:43famine, there's times of government overthrow or, or
- 31:46capture. And these messages are often
- 31:49times in defiance of that or often times in support of the
- 31:54conquering nation. One of my favorite coins of all
- 31:57time is a hexagram from Heraculous in the in the
- 32:05Byzantine Empire Empire. And there was a point where he
- 32:09was fighting the Sasanians and then the Sasanians became Islam
- 32:14and they're, they got desperate. And as Constantinople was
- 32:19getting encroached upon, they started melting down silver in
- 32:22the church to try and pay for the soldiers to support them.
- 32:27And on the reverse of the coin, it'll, it says God save the
- 32:31Romans, right? Because the desperation was so
- 32:33high. And so these coins that you can
- 32:36buy were melted down silverware and, and all, all kinds of stuff
- 32:42to, to defend themselves, to protect themselves.
- 32:45And that's the level of desperation.
- 32:47But they survived beyond that and they continued on and they
- 32:52learned lessons from it. And I think we can learn those
- 32:55same lessons. We can learn about the, you
- 32:57know, people's resilience, people's ideas, people's
- 33:01creativity, art, how art survives in, in high times and
- 33:05low times, just just all kinds of references.
- 33:09I think you really get a better understanding of life and how
- 33:12it's lived over time through ancient coins because it, it
- 33:17really speaks to what was important, what still is
- 33:20important, what's worth fighting for.
- 33:22And you know, kind of how people managed within crazy
- 33:26circumstances because they certainly lived under much
- 33:29crazier circumstances than we did in a lot of cases and still
- 33:34managed to keep the civilization moving forward.
- 33:37So a lot to be learned, but but valuable.
- 33:39I think it gives you a kind of a level of confidence about what
- 33:43you're seeing in the world today because it's been seen before
- 33:47and it's not new and people have survived it and people have
- 33:51thrived in it and. Well, anybody that's on this
- 33:53channel, that's because we, we've grown substantially in the
- 33:55last couple months from some of the, the appearances we've been,
- 33:57we've been lucky enough to do. And they, they've probably heard
- 34:00me on, on other shows, call you my guy Dean or Dean Kinser from
- 34:04kinsercoins.com or you know, lots of other things.
- 34:08And, and a lot of them have have been interested in, in
- 34:10purchasing coins and, and checking out coins and, and even
- 34:14getting into having more interest in them.
- 34:17And we had somebody recently on, on the unsubscribe episode that
- 34:19said they land on your website or like I see at least five that
- 34:22I need. And I guess when we, when we, we
- 34:25look at someone looking at Roman coins in particular today, what
- 34:29things should they be looking for?
- 34:31What things should they be paying attention to?
- 34:33What should they look at when they're looking at one of these
- 34:36ancient coins as a modern person?
- 34:37So first of all, you know, a fantastic way to connect if
- 34:42you're a person of faith, fantastic way to connect.
- 34:45It's, you know, the interest is, is is pretty to easy to pick up.
- 34:53So to me, like, you know, if you were starting out, I would
- 34:56always start with the area that you're talking about explicitly
- 35:00because they, because we talked about the volume of the coins
- 35:04that were produced at that time. There's still a lot of coins out
- 35:08there with Constantine's image on it, with Diocletian's image
- 35:11on it. And they can be had and they can
- 35:14be had affordably. What a lot of people probably
- 35:18assume is that a 17 year old piece of bronze with, you know,
- 35:21an emperor's image on it is worth hundreds if not thousands
- 35:24of dollars. And I don't want to sound like,
- 35:26you know, some kind of late night infomercial, but they
- 35:30really start at 20, thirty, $40, right?
- 35:36And when you think about the impact for value spending that
- 35:40kind of money, you know when you fill up a a tank of gas for
- 35:44equivalent of a 1700 year old, yeah.
- 35:47My my desk is wild. I have some of them just like
- 35:49hanging out by me like on my desk.
- 35:51OK, I look like a crazy person over here.
- 35:53The the good ones are in the house and the safe.
- 35:55But anyway. But that, but that's the value
- 36:00per so anyway, So what I would say is, is that you can dip your
- 36:03toe in, not get burnt right. So, so guys like me for we we,
- 36:08we stand on trying to bring new collectors in people that have
- 36:12other interests that are similar to this because it's an easy
- 36:16landing spot. We, we offer, I do offer NGC
- 36:20certified coins so that they've had analysts look at those that
- 36:26that have 30-40 fifty years experience in handling ancient
- 36:29coins, so they know what to look for.
- 36:30So there is comfort in buying that in an affordable price.
- 36:35So that gives you the option to start collecting on something
- 36:39that you know, experience without a lot of loss.
- 36:43The reason we, we, we emphasize this because there is
- 36:47opportunity to make mistakes out there and a lot of our focus and
- 36:50a lot of action actually a lot of dealers focus is how do I
- 36:54prevent the new guy from buying something he shouldn't have and
- 36:58how can I give him the education to help find what he should
- 37:01have? So we've been focusing a lot of
- 37:03effort on trying to educate. We we write articles, we create
- 37:09checklists, we have our legend decipher tool, all these designs
- 37:16so that you can find some comfort, particularly on the
- 37:19affordable side and make a move into something without Rick
- 37:23putting yourself at too much risk.
- 37:25So I recommend, you know, bronzes from the 4th century
- 37:29Constantine, probably one of the most important emperors in the
- 37:33history of emperors and he can be had affordably, He can be had
- 37:38in excellent condition. Looks like a brand new penny.
- 37:41Those are still available. You know, I mean, if you can get
- 37:44stuff like that. And then the great thing about
- 37:46that is, you know, say you have interest and you know, you,
- 37:51you're like, hey, I like the 3rd century crisis.
- 37:53That's a neat time. What's something I can get into?
- 37:56Well, like Galleyanus. Galleyanus made a collectible
- 38:00set of zoo animals on the reverse of his coins during his
- 38:05rain. And there is a set of I think
- 38:07it's 10 different animals on the reverse.
- 38:10So if you like animals and you like collecting, you can put
- 38:13together a set of Galianus Zoo for a pretty affordable price.
- 38:17Bronze coins readily available. And if you're into collecting
- 38:22and want to put together sets, those are great ways to do it in
- 38:25an affordable way. You don't have to launch out and
- 38:27go, hey, I want to collect the 12 Caesars in gold, you know,
- 38:32because that that represents a lot of risk.
- 38:34You got to know a lot, lot of stuff.
- 38:35What I want you guys to do is to try to, you know, taste a little
- 38:39bit and then see where you go from there.
- 38:41I mean, there's obvious great expensive coins.
- 38:44You know, the Eidmar Daenerys is one of the but you know, we
- 38:47should build up to that. And that's kind of the point of,
- 38:50you know, the the website and kind of welcome people into the
- 38:54community is to try to give you an easy place to land without
- 38:58risking extra money that you need in collectibles that are
- 39:02fun and worth what you're paying for.
- 39:05You're not. I can't help but laugh with
- 39:07Gallianus doing, you know, animal coins that the empire's
- 39:11crumbling around him. And it make, it makes me, it
- 39:13makes me think of Hunorius. And they're trying to tell him
- 39:15that the Barbarians are at the gates and he's more worried
- 39:17about his chickens. I don't know.
- 39:20But but Dean, I want to kind of tie in the Roman pattern element
- 39:24of things. We look at, you know, how things
- 39:26like jointed specifically really tie into to the civilization a
- 39:30downside or on a collapse. And we really try to make this
- 39:33non political. We really just look at systems
- 39:35and I think that's one of the most important things to do.
- 39:38But we look at the modern person and they're looking at their
- 39:40coinage, you're looking at their currency.
- 39:42What should they be most concerned about or what things
- 39:45should they be watching for a modern person?
- 39:47Well. I mean, there are some, you
- 39:49know, and I think I think this is a very, very interesting tie
- 39:54in. They're they're just from a
- 39:57person that knows American coins who, you know, has held them and
- 40:01use them from the time that I grew up.
- 40:04I was born in the late 70s, so I've been around a little while.
- 40:08The coins that were frequents that were in our circulation at
- 40:12that point were made of copper, silver and in good content.
- 40:20What is it now? It's very different, right?
- 40:23You know, your copper coins are not copper, right?
- 40:25I mean, they're, they're, we're not using the materials.
- 40:29So, you know, that's why people are so interested in like
- 40:31nickels before 1959 or whatever because they're, they high
- 40:35silver content. Well, we're looking at coinage
- 40:37now and the relevance of coinage at this point.
- 40:40I'm not 100% certain, but at the same time we're seeing that the
- 40:45coinage that we use on a day-to-day basis is not as
- 40:48described or not as it was intended because we've gone away
- 40:51from that standard. So that's a step in what you're
- 40:55describing, right? It's similar to what the Romans
- 40:58went through. So you know, there are obvious
- 41:02levers that that government can pull to try and alter that kind
- 41:05of thing. You know it even the even with
- 41:07the decrease in the dollar, same thing, right?
- 41:10Just because the Romans didn't have paper money didn't mean
- 41:13that their money wasn't the American.
- 41:15Well, like I think even now the. The idea?
- 41:17So the value. The penny anymore, That's a
- 41:19little alarming, right? Because it's like the, the, the,
- 41:22the penny is so expensive. We can't produce the penny.
- 41:24That should be a red flag to people.
- 41:26Yeah, that's right. That's right.
- 41:28So what is what? What are the alternatives?
- 41:30And that's what we're talking about.
- 41:31Where else are people putting their money right other than
- 41:35traditional coins, right? Traditional cash and carry,
- 41:39right? They put it in Bitcoin, they put
- 41:40it for a while, they put it in NFTS, They invested in other
- 41:44things, the hard currencies, the the gold, the silver.
- 41:47And that's why you see the prices of those go up because
- 41:51the demand for something of actual value versus a piece of
- 41:54paper goes up, whether it's in coinage form or not.
- 41:58And so those are all very familiar sounding things.
- 42:01And it's not to suggest that, you know, we we will have a
- 42:05period where we're making silver coins out of the silverware in
- 42:09our church. But what it's what it does mean
- 42:12is that there are certain things that echo similarly to kind of
- 42:16the fall of the Roman Empire. And again, fall of the Roman
- 42:19Empire isn't something that happened overnight.
- 42:21It took hundreds of years and certain bad decisions by a lot
- 42:25of different people. But at the same time there
- 42:29isn't, there isn't a big difference between kind of the
- 42:34collapse of the currency or the change of the currency at the
- 42:39same time as the the value of the dollar goes down and they we
- 42:43got you back. Sorry about that.
- 42:44No, that's fine. You were, you were talking about
- 42:46the idea that, you know, it's not just that the dollar goes
- 42:48down or whatever it might be. It's, it's also these other
- 42:50things we're looking at. Right.
- 42:52It's it, Yeah. It, it doesn't mean it's the
- 42:54end. It doesn't mean that it, you
- 42:56know, Diocletian probably thought it was the end too.
- 42:59You know, I, Diocletian probably thought there was no, you know,
- 43:03at at times he probably thought, well, will there, you know, will
- 43:05the currency survive? Will we be able to continue to
- 43:07manufacture money? But sometimes great leaders are
- 43:10able to kind of overcome what scares a lot of us and transform
- 43:15and and reform something that needs to be reforming.
- 43:18And that's why the Roman Empire extended beyond.
- 43:21And then, you know, we'll just throw another thousand years on
- 43:24that on top of what they survived.
- 43:26And in Rome itself, you know, so there, there is some survival.
- 43:31We say that Rome ended at 476 and that's fair.
- 43:34But they did last until I would say 12 O 4.
- 43:37But 1453, yeah, that. That that's crusaders.
- 43:41They really kind of put a hamper on things.
- 43:43The Crusaders are like, so we're going to the Holy Land, but we
- 43:46ran out of money, so let's just go sack Constantinople.
- 43:50Yeah, one of the one of the greatest cities in antiquity of
- 43:55all of its incredible beauty and artwork, all melted down for
- 43:59cheap bronze and garbage. We did a video about that on my
- 44:02my other channel, Hidden Forces in History.
- 44:04And it's like, I don't think people realize the Venetian
- 44:07Empire, what an impact that they actually had on the world
- 44:10because they're kind of like, so we'll pay for your ships, we've
- 44:13built them, but go sack Constantinople first, and then
- 44:16maybe we'll pay for them. Oh, wait, you sack
- 44:18Constantinople. Hold on, there's another place
- 44:20we want you to go. Then we'll pay for your ships
- 44:25anyway. Well, Dean, I've just, I've
- 44:26really enjoyed this conversation.
- 44:28I definitely want people to go check you out cuz, cuz I, I, as
- 44:31I said this, you know, we are working at with you.
- 44:34I command your brand. But you know, even before that,
- 44:36I've just been so passionate about what you do.
- 44:38Like I just find coins to be so exciting.
- 44:40We even use these in home school with the kids because it's kind
- 44:43of like to be able to hold something real that's thousands
- 44:46of years old is just so cool and exciting.
- 44:48But where can people to find out more about you?
- 44:51Or where can they check you out? Well, I've created a landing
- 44:54page for people who watch this podcast.
- 44:58It's start ancients.com and on that page I've created a number
- 45:03of different kind of helpful tools to help you get started.
- 45:06We have some starter packs and stuff like that to help you kind
- 45:09of get familiar to what what's going on.
- 45:12The primary website iskinsercoins.com all kinds of
- 45:15access to, you know, articles, the coins that we have for sale,
- 45:21information on people that are are great within the hobby that
- 45:24are helpful. And really the encouragement is
- 45:27for somebody to find and and and learn and love this hobby as
- 45:32much as you and I do, right? It it's infectious.
- 45:36I would say that it's unbelievable.
- 45:39If you've ever shown, and I know Jeremy has done this a couple of
- 45:42Times Now, you show somebody an ancient coin, it it's a light
- 45:47night, a light goes off in their head that it's hard to believe,
- 45:51right? I mean, it's just hard to
- 45:52believe. So, yeah, all of that's
- 45:54available. We want you to, we want you to
- 45:56try out ancient coins as a collectible, learn a little bit,
- 46:00learn a bit about history, make yourself stronger and just a
- 46:05quality hobby that I think is undervalued at this point and
- 46:08it's a great time to join. Very cool.
- 46:09Well, this has been the Roman pattern.
- 46:11I'm Jeremy Ryan Slate. Be be sure to like this video,
- 46:14leave us a comment, and smash that subscribe button if you
- 46:17want more of the Roman pattern.