Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Language Acquisition: Phonemes, Morphemes, Syntax & How We Learn to Speak
Transcript
- 0:00You've been there. I mean, we all have. It is
- 0:02like three in the morning. You've been studying
- 0:04all night for this massive cognitive psych exam.
- 0:08You finally get to the test, and you are just
- 0:11staring blankly at a question. Oh, it is the
- 0:13worst. Just absolute panic. Right. Like, you
- 0:16know the answer. You can practically see the
- 0:19page it was printed on in your notes. The word
- 0:21is right there hovering on the tip of your tongue,
- 0:24but your brain just, well, just refuses to hand
- 0:27it over. It is so infuriating. It's arguably
- 0:29the most helpless feeling in the academic world,
- 0:32honestly. Your own neurological filing cabinet
- 0:35has just completely locked you out. Exactly.
- 0:38And... Well, welcome to the Psychology undergrad.
- 0:41I'm so excited to get into this today. We take
- 0:43a deep dive into the weird, fascinating, and
- 0:46sometimes in critically frustrating ways our
- 0:48minds actually work. We're basically taking all
- 0:50those dense cognitive psych concepts and studying
- 0:53them right alongside you. Yeah, we're all in
- 0:55this together, navigating the madness of Chapter
- 0:5712 today. We really are. And our mission today
- 1:00is to tackle this massive paradox about the human
- 1:02brain. Because on one hand, we're going to explore
- 1:05the incredibly messy, deeply flawed nature of
- 1:09how we forget things like that 3 a .m. test question.
- 1:12Right. But then we're going to bridge that into
- 1:14the absolute miracle of how, despite being so
- 1:17ridiculously forgetful, we somehow perfectly
- 1:20learn and structure the infinite complexities
- 1:23of human language. Which is a paradox that literally
- 1:26keeps cognitive psych psychologists awake at
- 1:28night. I mean how can a brain that forgets what
- 1:31a cash register button does after a two -day
- 1:33weekend flawlessly parse a 20 -word sentence
- 1:37it has never heard before. It's wild. Let's start
- 1:40with the forgetting part, though, because going
- 1:41back to that tip -of -the -tongue phenomenon
- 1:43we were just talking about, that random glitch
- 1:45isn't just some minor biological hiccup. According
- 1:48to the textbook, it is actually classified as
- 1:50a sin. Yeah, Daniel Schachter's framework. It's
- 1:52so fascinating. It really is. So he wrote this
- 1:54book, The Seven Sins of Memory, where he categorizes
- 1:57all our memory failures into two very distinct
- 2:00camps. You've got the sins of omission and the
- 2:02sins of commission. is such a striking way to
- 2:05frame it too. He deliberately chose that theological
- 2:08terminology to separate the absence of action
- 2:12from a wrongful action. Which is such a helpful
- 2:14way to remember it for the exam. Like if you
- 2:17think about omission and commission in a religious
- 2:19or moral context, it's the difference between
- 2:21failing by what you don't do versus failing by
- 2:24what you actively do wrong. Exactly. It's passive
- 2:27versus active. Right. So if we apply that to
- 2:30the brain, the sins of omission are your brain
- 2:33essentially just leaving the chat, dropping the
- 2:36ball. The data is just missing. Yeah. And Schachter
- 2:39outlines three of these omission sins. First
- 2:41is transience. And this isn't really a glitch.
- 2:44It is just the natural fading of memories over
- 2:47time. Because the brain is lazy. Well, more like
- 2:49it's incredibly metabolically expensive to run.
- 2:52From an evolutionary standpoint, your brain doesn't
- 2:54want to waste precious energy storing the color
- 2:57of the shirt you wore on a random Tuesday three
- 2:59years ago. Yeah. So it actively prunes those
- 3:01synaptic connections. OK, that makes sense. Then
- 3:04you have absent -mindedness, which is the second
- 3:06one. This is just a lapse in attention at the
- 3:09exact moment the memory is supposed to be encoded.
- 3:12Oh, like forgetting where you put your keys.
- 3:13Yes. If you've ever lost your car keys, you didn't
- 3:16actually lose the memory of setting them down.
- 3:18You just never formed the memory in the first
- 3:20place because your attention was focused on,
- 3:22like, scrolling on your phone, not your hand.
- 3:25Right. The file was never saved. And then the
- 3:26third Cinevo mission is what you opened with.
- 3:29Blocking. The classic tip -of -the -tongue phenomenon.
- 3:32This is so annoying. It really is. The information
- 3:35is physically stored in your brain. but the retrieval
- 3:38pathway is temporarily blocked, usually because
- 3:41a highly similar competing memory is getting
- 3:44in the way and hijacking the neural network.
- 3:47Okay, so omission is your brain failing to provide
- 3:50the data, but the sins of commission... This
- 3:53is where it gets slightly terrifying. This is
- 3:55your brain actively trolling the chat. Yeah,
- 3:58it's manufacturing bad data. Exactly. Yeah. It's
- 4:01not leaving a blank space. It is filling the
- 4:03blank space with a total lie. Sins of commission
- 4:06are active distortions. And the first one is
- 4:10suggestibility. This is how easily our brains
- 4:14incorporate misinformation from external sources
- 4:17into our own memories. Oh, like the car crash
- 4:19study, right? Yes. If a lawyer asks a witness,
- 4:22how fast was the car going when it smashed into
- 4:24the other car versus when it bumped into the
- 4:26other car, the word smashed actually alters the
- 4:29witness's memory of the speed. The brain literally
- 4:32updates the video file based on the suggestion.
- 4:35That is so crazy. And then there is bias. This
- 4:38is when your current knowledge, your beliefs,
- 4:41or your current emotional state actively skew
- 4:43your memory of a past event. This one hits close
- 4:46to home for a lot of people. Right. Like, if
- 4:48a relationship comes to a really tragic, bitter
- 4:51end, you might look back and only remember the
- 4:53terrible times. You completely overwrite the
- 4:55fact that you were genuinely happy for, like...
- 4:58the first three years. Because the brain prioritizes
- 5:01cognitive consistency. It doesn't like holding
- 5:03conflicting emotional states. If you hate your
- 5:06ex right now, the brain retroactively adjusts
- 5:08the historical record to match your current reality.
- 5:11It is actively rewriting your personal moral
- 5:13history based on your current feelings. It's
- 5:15wild. And the last two are persistence, which
- 5:18is when unwanted intrusive memories just won't
- 5:21go away. Like PTSD. Right, where the amygdala
- 5:24essentially traps the brain in a fear loop. And
- 5:28then the last one is misattribution. That's when
- 5:30you clearly remember a fact, but you confidently
- 5:33attribute it to the completely wrong source.
- 5:37Oh yeah, like when you think you read something
- 5:38in a scientific journal, but you actually just
- 5:40saw it in a dream or, you know, a random social
- 5:43media post. Guilty as charged. But when you look
- 5:46at all seven together, it totally validates why
- 5:49the sin metaphor works so well. Memory isn't
- 5:52just a neutral passive filing cabinet. It is
- 5:55an active narrator. Exactly. When we experience
- 5:57bias, we aren't just misremembering a dinner
- 6:00date. We're literally rewriting our worldview.
- 6:02So if the sins of omission explain the mechanisms
- 6:04of why information drops out, how do we actually
- 6:07measure the gap between what we learned and what
- 6:09we lost? Like, what does forgetting look like,
- 6:11practically? Well, basically, Forgetting is fundamentally
- 6:15measured as a reduction in how well we perform
- 6:18a learned behavior. So imagine you get a job
- 6:20working, a really complex cash register. Oh man,
- 6:24I've been there. The worst. Right. So on Friday,
- 6:28you complete your training, you know, all the
- 6:30intricate buttons, then you take a two day weekend,
- 6:33you return on Monday and you stare at the screen.
- 6:35Totally clueless on how to avoid a transaction.
- 6:38Yes. That weekend represents the retention interval,
- 6:41right? Exactly. The period where you aren't practicing,
- 6:43which allows the memory trace to decay. And researchers
- 6:46measure what survived that interval in a few
- 6:48ways. There's free recall, which is definitely
- 6:51the hardest. That's just a blank piece of paper.
- 6:54Like, describe the neural impulse from Module
- 6:5510 without help. Go. Complete nightmare. You
- 6:58have to generate the information entirely from
- 7:00scratch. Yeah. Then there's prompted recall,
- 7:03or cued recall, where you get a hint. You ask
- 7:05a kid to solve a math problem, they freeze, so
- 7:08you write down the first number to trigger the
- 7:10associative pathway. And then, the most heavily
- 7:12relied upon metric in modern education, the multiple
- 7:16choice test, which measures recognition. You're
- 7:19given a definition, four options, and your brain
- 7:22just has to recognize the correct answer hiding
- 7:23among the distractors. Okay, I have to push back
- 7:26on this though. Because I think multiple -choice
- 7:28exams are an incredibly flawed metric for actual
- 7:31knowledge. Really? How so? Well, if you're taking
- 7:34an exam, you can completely guess, bubble, and
- 7:37see, and get it right by pure luck. The metric
- 7:40then claims you retained the material. It creates
- 7:43a false positive. You didn't remember it. You
- 7:45just played the odds. OK. I wouldn't call it
- 7:47completely flawed. I mean, while guessing is
- 7:49definitely a factor, from a cognitive standpoint,
- 7:52recognition relies on entirely different neural
- 7:54architecture than free recall. But is it actual
- 7:57knowledge? Well, just because you can't freely
- 8:00recall a concept doesn't mean the anagram, the
- 8:03physical memory trace, is gone. A multiple choice
- 8:05question acts as a highly specific retrieval
- 8:08cue. When you see the right answer, the neural
- 8:10network lights up. It proves the information
- 8:13is in there, even if the pathway to retrieve
- 8:16it independently was just too weak. I see the
- 8:18distinction, I really do, but I still think it
- 8:21overestimates our functional knowledge. But moving
- 8:23on to why we actually lose that functional knowledge.
- 8:27Time fading is one thing, amnesia is another.
- 8:30Right, we see retrograde amnesia where brain
- 8:32trauma wipes out memories from before the injury.
- 8:35And anterograde amnesia where damage to the hippocampus
- 8:38prevents the brain from forming any new memories
- 8:40going forward. But for the average person, the
- 8:43most common reason we forget isn't trauma, or
- 8:46even time. It's interference. Interference is
- 8:49the everyday villain of memory. Our neural networks
- 8:52are so densely packed and similar pieces of information
- 8:55just constantly clash with each other. I was
- 8:57thinking about a good way to remember this for
- 8:59the exam because the textbook definitions of
- 9:01proactive and retroactive interference can so
- 9:04easily get flipped in your head. Oh, 100%. They
- 9:06are notoriously tricky. So proactive interference
- 9:09is when OLD information actively messes up your
- 9:12ability to learn NW information. Retroactive
- 9:15interference is when NW information goes backward
- 9:18and messes up your OLD memories. Right, but those
- 9:20abstract definitions are hard to hold on to.
- 9:22How do you actually anchor that? Okay, so take
- 9:25the word positive. Since we were toddlers, we
- 9:27were taught a moral, effective definition of
- 9:30that word. Positive means good. Negative means
- 9:33bad. That is deeply ingrained OLD information.
- 9:38Now fast forward to a college psychology class,
- 9:41the UNOW information. We are taught about a positive
- 9:44correlation. Which just means two variables moving
- 9:47in the same direction even if they are terrible
- 9:49things like smoking and lung cancer. Or positive
- 9:53reinforcement, which just means adding a stimulus
- 9:55to a situation. And the brain just revolts. Completely
- 9:58revolts. Because when we learned positive means
- 10:00good, that deeply entrenched pathway proactively
- 10:04interfered with our ability to accept the clinical
- 10:06neutral definition. That is such a good way to
- 10:08look at it. And it gets even more jarring when
- 10:11you study abnormal psych. You learn about positive
- 10:14symptoms of schizophrenia. A positive symptom
- 10:17means the presence of a problematic behavior,
- 10:19like hallucinations. But your brain struggles
- 10:22so hard to lock that down because your childhood
- 10:24learning is violently screaming, wait, positive
- 10:28means good, a hallucination isn't good. That
- 10:31is a phenomenal example of how tightly our brains
- 10:34bind data to emotional and moral states. I mean,
- 10:38we don't just learn a definition. We encode the
- 10:40vibe of the word. Yeah, exactly. The vibe. We
- 10:42are fundamentally associative creatures. When
- 10:45prior learning has a heavy effect of weight,
- 10:47it violently fights new definitions. The old
- 10:50neural pathway is essentially just bullying the
- 10:53new one. Which makes this next part almost unbelievable,
- 10:55honestly, because we just spent all this time
- 10:57outlining how fragile and easily bullied our
- 10:59memory is. We suffer from omission, our biases
- 11:02rewrite our past, our old knowledge sabotages
- 11:04our new knowledge. It's a mess. It is. Yet, amidst
- 11:07all that chaos, we somehow manage to perfectly
- 11:10retain and execute the immensely complex, infinitely
- 11:13detailed rulebook of human language. It is the
- 11:16ultimate cognitive paradox. And to even approach
- 11:19how we do it, we have to distinctly separate
- 11:22language from speech. Right, they aren't the
- 11:24same thing. Not at all. Language is the code.
- 11:27It is the socially shared set of rules for what
- 11:30words mean, how to sequence them, and how to
- 11:32invent new ones. Speech is merely the mechanical
- 11:35verbal execution of that code using your vocal
- 11:38cords and tongue. And studying that code is called
- 11:41linguistics. There are four main branches and
- 11:44they are basically the layers of the code. You
- 11:46have phonology, which is the study of sounds,
- 11:50semantics, which is the study of meaning, syntax,
- 11:53which governs structure and grammar, and pragmatics.
- 11:56which is kind of the unsung hero of language.
- 11:59It's how we use context. Pragmatics is fascinating.
- 12:01If I say to you, hey, can you crack the window?
- 12:03Semantics knows what the words mean, and syntax
- 12:05puts them in a grammatical order. But without
- 12:08pragmatics, you might literally smash the glass.
- 12:11Right. Pragmatics is the social understanding
- 12:13that you just want to breeze. Exactly. But if
- 12:16we look at the very foundation of the code, it
- 12:19all comes down to phones and morphemes. Let's
- 12:22make this easy to remember for our study buddy
- 12:24listening. Phones equal phones making sounds.
- 12:28Ooh, I like that. A phoneme is the absolute smallest
- 12:31unit of sound that can change the meaning of
- 12:33a word. Think of the word bad. It has three phonemes.
- 12:37The B sound, the A sound, and the DA sound. Swap
- 12:41the first phone to an S sound, and you get sad.
- 12:43Swap it to an M, you get mad. So phonemes are
- 12:46basically the raw audio files. Morphemes, on
- 12:49the other hand, are the smallest units of meaning.
- 12:51So think of morphemes as morphing sounds into
- 12:54meaning. Morphing sounds into meaning. Perfect.
- 12:56Yeah. A morpheme can be a standalone word or
- 12:59can be a prefix or suffix that modifies a word.
- 13:01Let's look at the word grandmothers. That is
- 13:03one word, but it has three distinct morphemes.
- 13:06You have grand, which signifies a generation
- 13:08removed. You have mother, which means a female
- 13:10parent. And you have the S at the end, which
- 13:12grammatically signifies plural. Three separate
- 13:15units of meaning morphing together to create
- 13:16a highly specific concept. And what should terrify
- 13:19anyone who really stops to think about it is
- 13:22the sheer speed of the unconscious processing
- 13:25required to do this. your brain is decoding foams
- 13:28and morphines in milliseconds. It's mind -blowing.
- 13:31Which brings us to the word frequency effect.
- 13:34We actually possess a measurable neurological
- 13:36bias toward words we encounter more often. If
- 13:39I say the door is open, your brain processes
- 13:42that semantic meaning instantly. Right. But if
- 13:45I say the door is a jar, it takes your brain
- 13:48a fraction of a millisecond longer to process
- 13:50because a jar is less frequent, so the retrieval
- 13:52pathway just isn't as heavily lubricated. And
- 13:55it's not just frequency either, it's lexical
- 13:57ambiguity. Think about the word grade. Are we
- 14:00talking about a letter grade on a psych exam?
- 14:03Are we talking about the steepness of a mountain
- 14:05road? Are we talking about a military pay grade
- 14:07or an industrial machine grading eggs? Wow, yeah.
- 14:11The word sounds exactly the same. Our brains
- 14:13have to yank the correct meaning out of the neural
- 14:16network based entirely on the surrounding context
- 14:18instantly. Which requires us to constantly read
- 14:21between the lines. Individual words are incredibly
- 14:25ambiguous so to string them into a coherent reality
- 14:28the brain relies heavily on inference. We rarely
- 14:31communicate all the necessary information. We
- 14:34basically force the listener to go beyond the
- 14:36stated text to understand what is actually happening.
- 14:39There are three main types of inference that
- 14:41our brains do automatically, right? Instrument
- 14:43inferences occur when we infer the tool being
- 14:45used. If I say, I sent an email to my professor,
- 14:49your brain automatically pictures a phone or
- 14:51a computer. I didn't say the word computer, but
- 14:53you inferred the instrument. Right. Then there
- 14:55are anaphoric inferences, which connect pronouns
- 14:58to subjects across sentences, like... Doug is
- 15:01saving money. He took the bus. You instantly,
- 15:04unconsciously lock the word he to Doug. But the
- 15:06most complex, and honestly arguably the most
- 15:08dangerous, is the causal inference. This is the
- 15:11brain's tendency to infer that an event in one
- 15:14sentence was directly caused by an event in the
- 15:17preceding sentence. Like, John studied all night.
- 15:20He earned an A on the exam. The clear automatic
- 15:23inference is that the studying directly caused
- 15:26the A. Yeah, that makes sense. But this is where
- 15:28I want to challenge the mechanism, because I
- 15:30think this exact cognitive shortcut gets humans
- 15:33into profound trouble. What if I say, John wore
- 15:36his lucky socks. He earned an A. Oh, I see where
- 15:39you're going. Right. Our brains instinctively
- 15:42want to bridge those two statements with causality,
- 15:45because they happened in sequence. But we know
- 15:47from intrasyke, correlation does not equal causation.
- 15:51I really think this specific linguistic memorandism
- 15:54is the exact root of human moral superstition.
- 15:57That is a bold leap. How so? Because we are desperate
- 16:01for the world to make sense. We see two things
- 16:03happen in sequence, and our brain automatically
- 16:06applies a causal inference to build a moral framework.
- 16:08Like, I was selfish yesterday, and today I got
- 16:10a flat tire. Therefore, the universe is punishing
- 16:13me. We use the exact same linguistic inference
- 16:16engine that connects John studied and John got
- 16:18an A to build these completely unscientific superstitious
- 16:21rules about how the universe operates. OK, I
- 16:24see your point. But from an evolutionary psychology
- 16:26perspective, perspective, that quote -unquote
- 16:28flawed causal inference is actually a survival
- 16:31mechanism. Oh, really? A survival mechanism.
- 16:34Yeah. The brain is designed to avoid type two
- 16:37errors, which is failing to see a pattern that
- 16:41actually exists. If early humans heard a rustling
- 16:45bush and then saw a tiger, the ones who made
- 16:47a rapid causal inference rustling bushes cause
- 16:49tigers, they survived. And the others didn't.
- 16:52Right. The ones who stood there and said, well,
- 16:54technically correlation doesn't equal causation.
- 16:57It might just be the wind they got eaten. We're
- 16:59hardwired to over infer causality because historically,
- 17:03missing a connection was far more deadly than
- 17:06inventing a fake one. OK, that makes perfect
- 17:08sense. The brain would rather be safely superstitious
- 17:10than logically dead. But to step back from the
- 17:13evolutionary brink for a second, how do we even
- 17:15build this incredible inference machine in the
- 17:17first place? Because the timeline of childhood
- 17:19language development from the notes is just staggering.
- 17:22It happens at lightning speed. It begins with
- 17:24pre -linguistic communicate, you know, crying
- 17:26gestures. And by around two to three months,
- 17:29you get babbling. And it evolves from simple,
- 17:32repetitive phones like ba -ba to complex, varied
- 17:35strings like ba -da -ma -fa. And then around
- 17:3710 to 14 months, the babbling fades and the first
- 17:39real words hit. But they aren't just words. They
- 17:42are holla phrases. A single word acting as an
- 17:46entire sentence of meaning. Oh, I love holla
- 17:48phrases. Right. A toddler lifts their arms and
- 17:50says, up. They aren't just identifying this guy.
- 17:54Pragmatically, they mean, pick me up right this
- 17:56second. And then by 18 months, they level up
- 17:59to telegraphic speech. They use the absolute
- 18:02bare minimum number of words to convey syntax
- 18:04and meaning, like, I read book. And parents instinctively
- 18:08facilitate this using what linguists call motherese,
- 18:11you know, that high -pitched, incredibly exaggerated,
- 18:14slow, infant -directed speech, like, look at
- 18:17the babe. It sounds so silly when adults do it.
- 18:19It feels slightly ridiculous, yeah. But that
- 18:21exaggerated elongation actively helps the child's
- 18:24brain segment the distinct phonemes out of the
- 18:26auditory. wash of normal speech. But the true
- 18:29miracle is the preschool years. By age six, a
- 18:32child has acquired a vocabulary of roughly 15
- 18:35,000 words. Just think about the math on that.
- 18:38They aren't reading dictionaries. They acquire
- 18:41these words through a mechanism called fast mapping.
- 18:44They can ascertain the highly specific meaning
- 18:46of a brand new word based entirely on its context
- 18:49in a sentence and what it's contrasted against.
- 18:51It is brilliant. Fast mapping isn't just passive
- 18:54absorption. It is active hypothesis testing.
- 18:57When a preschooler hears a new word, they instantly
- 19:00hypothesize its meaning. Then, they test that
- 19:03hypothesis by using the word in a sentence to
- 19:05gauge the reaction. If the parent responds normally,
- 19:09that's positive reinforcement. The hypothesis
- 19:11is confirmed. If the parent lasts or corrects
- 19:13them, they instantly discard the hypothesis and
- 19:15map a new one. A three -year -old is essentially
- 19:18running peer -reviewed double -blind linguistic
- 19:20trials using operant conditioning at the dinner
- 19:22table. It is mind -blowing. It really is just
- 19:24a scientific method stripped down to its purely
- 19:27neurological hardware. All right, let's bring
- 19:29this all home. Today, we have covered some serious
- 19:32cognitive ground. We started with Schachter's
- 19:35seven sins of memory. How our brains fail by
- 19:38omission, simply dropping the ball through transience
- 19:40or blocking, or how they fail by commission,
- 19:43actively deceiving us through bias and suggestibility.
- 19:46And we looked at the sheer frustration of proactive
- 19:49and retroactive interference, where the emotional
- 19:52wake of old knowledge violently rejects our new
- 19:54learning. And then we bridge that fragility into
- 19:56the structural perfection of language. The phonemes
- 19:59and morphemes, the immense speed of unconscious
- 20:02processing required to navigate lexical ambiguity,
- 20:05and the evolutionary survival mechanisms behind
- 20:08our constant need to make causal inferences.
- 20:10And finally, we watch toddlers operate as tiny
- 20:13linguistic scientists, using fast mapping to
- 20:15learn 15 ,000 words before they even hit first
- 20:18grade. Juxtaposing how aggressively flawed our
- 20:20memory is with how flawlessly we construct language
- 20:22is just such a wild paradox. It really is. And
- 20:26as we wrap up this deep dive, I want to leave
- 20:28you with a final philosophical puzzle to mull
- 20:30over. We established earlier that our memories
- 20:33are constantly subject to the sin of bias, actively
- 20:36rewriting our past history to match our current
- 20:39emotions. Right. We also established that our
- 20:42understanding of language and the world relies
- 20:45entirely on our brain making causal inferences,
- 20:48aggressively connecting dots that might just
- 20:50be coincidences. So the question is, how much
- 20:53of your personal moral code and your understanding
- 20:55of your own life story is based on actual objective
- 20:58reality? And how much of it is just a convenient,
- 21:01causally inferred story your brain drafted to
- 21:04fill in the blanks? Oh, wow. That's going to
- 21:07keep me up. Good luck sleeping after that one.
- 21:09Thanks for joining us tonight on The Psychology
- 21:11Undergrad, and we will catch you on the next
- 21:13deep dive.