Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️117|Public Inquiry Week Beginning 10th Nov Carbon Calculations Day 2 |
Transcript
- 0:10Unknown: Welcome back. I'm Marella, your host, and I'm part of the Save Our Sperrins campaign. And this podcast is following the Curranalt public inquiry and the proposal for a gold mine in The Sperrins. If you're new to the podcast and wondering how we got here, I'd suggest going back to podcast
- 0:28number 43, the first in this public inquiry series. That will give you some of the background before joining us here. As the inquiry continues, I'll be following the evidence and the arguments, and trying to make sense of what they could ultimately mean for the people, the water, and the landscapes of
- 0:50The Sperrins. In the next day or two, I'm going to walk out of the public inquiry for the last time, and I'm not entirely sure how I feel about it. Relief, certainly. Exhaustion, without a doubt. Possibly an overwhelming desire never to hear the words "public inquiry" ever again. But I suspect there will be a
- 1:15sadness too, because this inquiry has become part of our lives, and the people who have travelled this road together have shared something that very few others will ever fully understand. For a long time now, people from across The Sperrins and beyond have given an extraordinary amount of
- 1:34themselves to protecting this place. They have worked their way through mountains of documents, learned things about mining and environmental legislation that they had never wanted to know. Challenged government departments, raised money, organised meetings, supported one another through
- 1:54difficult times, and somehow kept finding the energy to carry on. There have been sacrifices along the way, friendships have been tested, patience has been stretched beyond anything that could reasonably be expected, and there have been days when I'm sure some of us would have happily thrown the entire
- 2:15contents of the inquiry into the near skip. But we kept coming back, even though there was more than one occasion when we were sorely tempted to give up and walk away, but we didn't, because we understood what was at stake. And all of this has gone on against the backdrop of ordinary life, with its own
- 2:36demands and worries and responsibilities. And I want to say something tonight about the people who have made that possible. I've met some remarkable human beings through this campaign, people whose knowledge, generosity, courage, and sheer bloody-minded determination, doggedness, have
- 2:56been an inspiration to me. People who could have spent their day doing any number of more enjoyable things, but chose instead to defend the mountains, the rivers, wildlife, and the communities they love. I am immensely proud to know them, and I am proud to stand alongside them. There is
- 3:18something deeply hopeful about people coming together in this way. Nobody has been paid to care for The Sperrins. Nobody has been offered a bonus for protecting a river, or speaking up for a species that cannot defend itself. There was nothing in this for any of them. They have done it because they
- 3:40believe that the living world deserves better than to be treated as an obstacle to somebody else's commercial ambitions. We don't know what the commissioners will recommend, and we certainly don't know what the final planning decision will be. But we have already achieved
- 3:58something important. We have brought the concerns of this community into a formal examination of one of the most consequential industrial proposals ever put forward for The Sperrins, and indeed on the island of Ireland, and we have made sure those concerns are on the record, because
- 4:18astonishingly there is no official government transcript of this inquiry, so we've made our own, with detailed daily accounts on our website and an audio archive of the proceedings. The government may not have preserved a public record of what was said at this inquiry, but we have made damn
- 4:39sure there is one, and perhaps that is how we will help shape the future ourselves through the work we have done and the evidence we have preserved. Dalradian has spent much of today placing its faith in what it promises to do in the future. We have spent years doing the work so that when the future
- 4:59generations. Generations look back; they will know what was proposed for these mountains, what questions were asked, who stood up to protect them, and, just as importantly, what government departments such as DFI, DERA, and NIEA did or failed to do when it mattered most.
- 5:21So, coming back to today, ladies and gentlemen, we entered the fascinating world of carbon neutrality, where a proposed gold mine can produce an enormous quantity of greenhouse gases and still aspire to become carbon neutral, provided a sufficiently impressive collection of things happen in
- 5:39the future. And what a busy future Delradian has planned! The commissioner spent much of the day trying to establish the basis for the carbon, the company's carbon calculations, and witnessing them pursue the answers was deeply satisfying. Especially when the carefully constructed explanations by the
- 5:59applicant began to come apart at the seams. It was a refreshing change from watching difficult questions disappear beneath an avalanche of technical explanations. There was a reoccurring pattern to the evidence. The commissioners would ask about a particular assumption. Dalradian's
- 6:19witnesses would explain the proposed approach, a difficulty would emerge, or a detail would remain unresolved, and before long, we would find ourselves discussing something that could be arranged, assessed, verified, or managed. And you have guessed it, yes, at a later date in the future. We began with
- 6:40electricity. The proposed mine is expected to consume 48 million kilowatt hours of electricity every year, and Dalradian's carbon assessment assumes that the electricity it purchases will be 100% renewable. That assumption allows the company to record zero emissions from purchased
- 7:00electricity under the market-based accounting method. The mine would still draw electricity from the grid, which carries power generated from a mixture of sources. Dalridium proposes to purchase electricity through arrangements that would allow it to reclaim the renewable attributes associated
- 7:23with the power it uses. There is one snag, though: the company has not yet secured the relevant power purchase agreement. So the commissioners began exploring where this renewable electricity might come from, how it would be purchased, and whether it would result in any additional renewable generation. Northern
- 7:47Ireland was mentioned. Scotland entered the conversation. The wider electricity market was discussed. Commissioner MacParlin brought the decision back to the practical consequences. If Dalredian buys renewable electricity that would otherwise have been available to another consumer, somebody else
- 8:09may end up relying on electricity generated from fossil fuels. She described it as robbing Peter to pay Paul, and that was the difficulty the commissioners were trying to untangle. The carbon accounting rules recognise particular forms of renewable electricity purchasing, but the
- 8:31environmental benefit depends on what those arrangements actually achieve. The Alredian maintained that its approach was legitimate, and that the necessary agreements could be secured in due course. There was that future again, making its first substantial appearance of the day. From electricity, we
- 8:54moved to peat. Peat is one of the great natural carbon stores of The Sperrins. It has accumulated over 1000s of years, locking away carbon in water-locked ground, where decomposition is slow. Disturbing it can release that carbon, although the amount released depends on the
- 9:15condition of the peat, the way it is handled, and what happens to it afterwards. Formanana district. and the applicant Dalraadian have entirely different approaches to estimating those emissions. The council's evidence examined the carbon stored in the volume of peat at risk. Dalradian's
- 9:38expert, Dr. Marshall, relied on emission factors associated with different peatland conditions, and the changes expected during the development. Dr. Marshall defended his mythology and explained that excavating peat does not mean all its stored carbon is immediately released. That's an. Important scientific
- 10:01distinction, but it also places a great deal of weight on the assumptions about how peat will behave after disturbances. And the commissioners were determined to understand those assumptions. We heard about peat being excavated, moved into storage areas, mixed with mineral material, kept for
- 10:23periods of time, and eventually used in restoration, some of it would be moved more than once. The discussion became increasingly detailed as the commissioners examined the store arrangements, drainage conditions, and the route by which Peat would eventually reach areas proposed for
- 10:43rehabilitation. At one point, Commissioner MacParland was trying to establish exactly where the transport of peat had been accounted for in the emissions calculations. The answer was that it had been included, although the precise location of the relevant figure was not immediately clear from
- 11:04the exchange, it was one of those moments when I was imagining the commissioners wanting to spread the entire assessment across the hearing room floor and start following the numbers with a piece of string.
- 11:18There was also questions about Pete remaining in a place while development progressed around it. Dr. Marshall argued that the proposed arrangements would maintain suitable conditions. Others disputed whether this was realistic, given the scale of the works and the existing hydrology. Changes to drainage
- 11:38can affect the moisture content of peat and moisture is fundamental to whether it continues storing carbon or begins releasing more of it. The commissioners also explored the emissions factors used for excavated peat, and whether they adequately represent the effects of handling, mixing, and
- 11:57storage. A 20% allowance for disturbance was discussed, with the council questioning whether that could compensate for any weakness in the underlying assumptions. It's a comforting thought that uncertainty can be dealt with by adding 20% to a figure whose accuracy is itself in dispute, and just by the by,
- 12:26my reckoning today was that there were 62 references to assumptions and their close relatives in today's notes. If assumptions could generate electricity, Dalradian might have solved its renewable energy problem by lunchtime. Anyways, moving on to restoration, Dalradi's calculations include
- 12:49carbon benefits from proposed peatland restoration, particularly the blocking of drains to raise water levels. Dr. Marshall explained that reducing drainage can lower greenhouse gas emissions from degraded peatland. He referred to a reduction in the relevant emission factor from around 3.32
- 13:11to 0.32 tonnes of carbon dioxide, equivalent per hectare per year. That's a meaningful potential benefit, provided the restoration succeeds and the improved conditions are maintained, the commissioners pressed him on how quickly those benefits would arise and what monitoring would establish that
- 13:33the work had succeeded. I found this interesting because anyone who knows The Sperrins understands that restoring damaged peatland is not the same thing as repairing a garden fence. Water levels, vegetation, peat condition, and the wider hydrology all matter, and the outcome has to be sustained. The
- 13:54calculations may project a particular result, but at the end of the day, the land has its own final say. Next up was cement, and Dalradian's updated carbon assessment claims a saving of more than 91,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide, equivalent through the use of lower carbon cement. 91,000
- 14:17tonnes of projected carbon savings, while the commissioners were still trying to establish whether the earlier testing adequately supported the cement specifications now being relied upon, and this is important because this cement would be used in the paste design to backfill the underground mine
- 14:38workings, its chemical properties, strength, and suitability for those conditions are critical. So the commissioner began digging into the into the chemistry, the proposed alternatives, and the testing carried out to support a carbon saving that, on paper at least, had already been
- 14:59accounted for. Mr. Morrison explained that the lower carbon cement technology was developing, and that alternatives were available. When the discussion turned to the properties of the material, he acknowledged that he was not a concrete expert. mr. Murray was brought into the
- 15:17conversation, and explained aspects of the proposed backfill, but when Commissioner Donohue asked about the testing associated with the change to lower carbon cement, mr. Murray said he would need to check with the geochemist and provide an answer tomorrow. I could almost hear another page being added to
- 15:37tomorrow's homework, and it wasn't only cement. Dalradian is also proposing to use hydro-treated vegetable oil, known as HVO, in place of conventional diesel. The updated assessment attributes a saving of more than 144,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide, equivalent to that change. The commissioner
- 15:59and other participants examining the assumptions about fuel use, the duration of operations, and the basis for calculations. mr. Morrison confirmed that the mine was assessed over a long operational period, with construction and closure also included. The scale of the project fuel consumption is
- 16:22enormous, and the proposed reduction depends on using the alternative fuel as envisaged. There was something almost artistic about the precision of these calculations, given the uncertainties surrounding them: 10s of 1000s of tonnes of emissions apparently saved from future purchasing decisions,
- 16:41calculated with impressive confidence, while some of the arrangements needed to deliver those savings have yet to be made. It reminded me of somebody producing a beautifully detailed household budget on the assumption that the electricity bill will disappear, the car will run on a different fuel,
- 16:59and the builder will invent a cheap form of cement before the extension is finished. Everything adds up splendidly, though, provided everything happens.
- 17:09And then we reach the great refuge of the afternoon, ISO 14068. If you listen to the day's evidence, you could be forgiven for thinking that ISO 14068 was particularly capable individual who would arrive at the mine after planning permission had been granted and sort out whatever remained
- 17:29unresolved. Rather, ISO 14068 is an international standard. The standard sets out a framework for carbon neutrality claims. It requires the organisation to account for its greenhouse gas emissions, establish a plan for reducing them, address remaining emissions, and have its claims independently verified. It
- 17:52places emphasis on reducing emissions before using carbon credits to deal with the remainder. It's a serious process and one that can provide useful scrutiny, but it does not automatically make an organisation carbon neutral simply because it has committed to following it. Actual
- 18:13performance has to be measured, the reductions must be demonstrated, and the claim has to withstand verification. Throughout the afternoon, the ISO process was repeatedly mentioned as the mechanism through which emissions and future changes would be picked up. Eventually, the council's
- 18:32barrister Connor Fagan had heard enough. He challenged the repeat reliance on ISO as the answer to matters that had not been fully assessed. His point was that the commissioners were being asked to examine the climate implications of the development now, while the company was proposing to resolve a
- 18:51succession of uncertainties through a process that would operate later. It was one of the sharper, more articulate interventions of the day, the commissioners cannot assess a promise with the same confidence as an arrangement that has been demonstrated. mr. Morrison explained that Dalridian would
- 19:11prepare carbon inventories and pursue independent verification as the project progressed. He also made clear that the company was not claiming the proposed mine was already carbon neutral, going on to say that the carbon neutrality claim would have to be supported by actual emission data, which is kind of odd, as
- 19:33on their website this evening in black and white is Dalradian's Coronal project has achieved carbon neutral certification every year since 2019, peculiar and damned odd. Which is it, mr. Morrison? mr. Beattie then argued that it would be unreasonable to expect Delraydian to have every
- 19:53commercial agreement in place before planning permission had been granted. Electricity contracts and carbon. Credit arrangements would have to be negotiated at the appropriate time. There is a practical argument there, and it deserves to be acknowledged. But it also leaves the commissioners facing
- 20:10a very difficult task. Delrayan has placed carbon neutrality at the centre of its environmental case, while some of the means of achieving it remain dependent on decisions that would be taken after permission is granted. mr. Beattie argued that the proposed carbon neutrality management plan and the planning conditions
- 20:31would provide the necessary controls. He said the department would have to approve the plan before development could begin. Once again, Conor Fagan challenged whether those arrangements would guarantee the promised outcome, as opposed to requiring the company to follow a process. The differences will
- 20:50prove important when the commissioners come to consider their recommendations. A management plan can be reviewed and updated, reports can be submitted, independent auditors can examine the figures, but the question of what happens if the promised carbon neutrality is not achieved remains central to
- 21:09the argument. And after a full day of listening to these exchanges, I was left with the impression that the commissioners were trying to pin down a moving target. Every time they reached for something solid, another element of the strategy seemed to be waiting somewhere in the future. Then,
- 21:26later in the proceedings, mr. Beattie mentioned that Dalradian was continuing to acquire land for the proposed development, including last week. I nearly fell off my chair. Here we were approaching the end of an inquiry that has occupied so much of our lives, with the commissioner still examining the
- 21:44evidence and the company apparently carrying on with its preparations. Of course, purchasing land is not the same thing as obtaining planning permission, and it tells us nothing about what the decisions will be. But I found the timing extraordinary, for those of us who have spent years trying to
- 22:00protect The Sperrins, every day of this inquiry has mattered enormously, and Dalradin, it seems, has been happily getting on with the shopping. Saying that, I came away today with a renewed appreciation of the work the commissioners have been doing.
- 22:17They have sat through weeks of highly technical evidence, much of it complex, occasionally contradictory, and sometimes delivered in language that would challenge the patient of a saint. Today they followed the figures, questioned the assumptions, and kept returning to the details. There were
- 22:34moments when mr. Beattie seemed to be holding Dalradian's case together with little more than legal ingenuity and sheer force of will to keep the whole contraption upright, and couldn't have feeling that if the company's future carbon management arrangements turn out to be half as energetic as its
- 22:50legal team, the auditors will have their hands full. But the humour of the day should not obscure the importance of what has been examined. We are talking about emissions associated with a major industrial development in a landscape containing ancient peatlands, rivers, farms, homes,
- 23:07and wildlife habitats, those emissions have consequences, and the assumptions used to calculate them deserve this closest scrutiny. I found myself thinking too about the distance between the hearing room and the mountains, in the hearing room, peat is discussed in tonnes and cubic metres, electricity in
- 23:27kilowatt hours, and emissions in carbon dioxide equivalents. Out on The Sperrins, the peat is holding water beneath the heather. The rivers are moving through the valleys, and the land is carrying on with the quiet business of being alive, it has no idea that its future has been debated in a room full
- 23:45of lawyers, experts, and spreadsheets. And that brings me back to the people I spoke about at the beginning. We have reached this point because people cared enough to become involved, even when the work was difficult, exhausting, and often deeply discouraging. They have done something that deserves to
- 24:03be remembered. They have refused to accept that decisions affecting their home should be made without their voices being heard. They have brought knowledge, experience, persistence, and an extraordinary sense of responsibility to this inquiry. And I hope, as we approach its
- 24:20conclusion. We can allow ourselves to feel proud of that. And my request, my special request to you all, who have been following this podcast, is: we would love to see as many of you as possible in the hearing room when the final day arrives. Come along and witness for yourself what your support,
- 24:39determination, and belief in the value of this place have helped us to achieve. We may be finished tomorrow, but we would still be there on Thursday. But whenever it comes, I hope we will be there together. Come for The Sperrins, for the communities call them home, and for all the people who have
- 24:57given so much of themselves to. To protecting a place they love, and after everything we've been through, I think we've earned the right to stand together and feel proud. We'll see you all tomorrow. You've been listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from the Front Line. Thank you for joining us
- 25:19today. All the links you'll need, from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared by today's guests and resources mentioned in the conversation, are available in the show notes. Please take a moment to share this podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares
- 25:38about protecting our land and communities, and don't forget to hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these voices further. Together, our voices are stronger. Thanks for listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people
- 25:58who protect them.