Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / Napoleon Didn't Take Power. France Voted To Give It To Him.
Transcript
- 0:00The French Revolution didn't end in tyranny.
- 0:03It invented a new kind. Most history tells you who wore
- 0:08the crown. This channel asks who designed
- 0:11the ceremony and what it costs to make you applaud.
- 0:14History calls Napoleon a genius, a soldier of destiny, a force
- 0:19that bent the modern world. That story isn't wrong, it's
- 0:23just incomplete. And incomplete stories are how
- 0:26power hides. The real engine wasn't genius.
- 0:31It was architecture. Ballot boxes surrounded by
- 0:34bayonets. Referendums written before the
- 0:38votes were cast. Prefects in every province
- 0:42censored newspapers. Bonds issued to men who owed you
- 0:46everything. Then Louis Napoleon ran the same
- 0:49machine. A December coup of midnight
- 0:52constitution. Osman's demolition cruise,
- 0:56gutting medieval Paris not to build a modern city, but to
- 1:00erase the streets where revolutions are born.
- 1:03They didn't seize power. They built a machine that asked
- 1:06the people to hand it over and engineered only one possible
- 1:11answer. But the end of this, you won't
- 1:14just understand the Bonaparte's. You'll recognize the blueprint,
- 1:19the rallies, the referendums, the managed press, the
- 1:24infrastructure projects. You will never stop seeing it.
- 1:46Welcome back to Hidden Forces in History.
- 1:49I'm your host, Jeremy Ryan Slate, CEO of Commander Brand.
- 1:54You can check us out over at commanderbrand.com.
- 1:58So here's the part they tend to skip when they teach you this in
- 2:01school. The revolution had promised
- 2:03everybody equality, and what it actually delivered, at least in
- 2:07those first years, was chaos. And into that chaos walks a
- 2:12young general who's noticed something pretty simple about
- 2:16people under real stress, which is that most of them aren't
- 2:21actually asking for liberty. They want order.
- 2:24They want to feel that certain about tomorrow, and honestly,
- 2:28they want somebody to look them in the eye and tell them it's
- 2:32going to be OK. Napoleon understood that better
- 2:35than almost anyone, but just understanding it was never going
- 2:39to be enough on its own. What he needed was a way to
- 2:42deliver that sense of order while making it look from the
- 2:46outside like the people had chosen it themselves.
- 2:49And the thing he built to do that is what's called a
- 2:52plebiscitary empire. So let me unpack what that
- 2:56phrase actually means. Because it matters.
- 2:59A plebiscite is just really a referendum, a direct up or down
- 3:04vote where in theory the people get their say.
- 3:07But the trick is sitting underneath all of that.
- 3:10Once you control the ballot box itself and the wording of the
- 3:14question and the entire flood of information people are swimming
- 3:18in for the weeks before they vote, then what they're getting
- 3:22isn't really a say anymore. It's the illusion of 1.
- 3:26And that illusion is doing all the work because Napoleon never
- 3:29took power through raw violence on its own.
- 3:32He took it through ceremony, through votes that quietly
- 3:36confirm decisions he'd already made, through a constitution he
- 3:40wrote himself. He got the people to approve it,
- 3:44and then rewrote anytime it started getting in his way.
- 3:48Right at the end of 1799, he puts his brand new government up
- 3:52for a national vote, and when the totals came back, they read
- 3:553 million in favor and 1000 562 against.
- 4:01Now, people don't just fail to show up in numbers like that by
- 4:04accident. In this case, we actually know
- 4:07why they didn't, because the count wasn't faked.
- 4:10The historian Claude Langlaugh went back through the real
- 4:14returns and showed that Napoleon's brother Lussan, who
- 4:18happened to be running the Interior Ministry.
- 4:21It basically doubled the Yes folk, rounding every department
- 4:24up and quietly folding the whole army into the total.
- 4:28The genuine number was probably closer to 1,000,000 1/2.
- 4:32So at that point the system isn't really counting the vote
- 4:35at all, it's writing the result before anybody's walked up to
- 4:38cast 1. The way it held together came
- 4:41down to about 5 pieces, and each one was feeding the others.
- 4:45The first piece was the military.
- 4:48Napoleon didn't rule with ballots, he ruled with soldiers.
- 4:52But the soldiers weren't there to hold the people down.
- 4:55They were there to enforce a decision the people had
- 4:57supposedly already made. You'd have these prefects
- 5:01appointed administrator sitting in every major city and
- 5:05province. And they weren't just handling
- 5:08local affairs, they were managing outcomes.
- 5:11They decided who could speak and where and when.
- 5:14They censored the newspapers. They organized the crowds for
- 5:18rallies that were supposed to look spontaneous, and the
- 5:22prefects answered to Paris. And Paris, well, that answered
- 5:26to Napoleon, and that chain never once broke.
- 5:30The army wasn't only sitting there as a threat, either.
- 5:33It was doing real work. Soldiers were building roads,
- 5:37running supply lines, putting the visible physical face of
- 5:41order out where everyone could see it.
- 5:43So when an ordinary person saw troops in the street, it didn't
- 5:47read to them as an occupation, it read as protection.
- 5:51The second piece was economic dependency, and the logic there
- 5:55is quite blunt. You can't really control people
- 5:59who are able to feed themselves. So Napoleon made sure that they
- 6:02couldn't. He issued government bonds, a
- 6:05lot of them, funding roads and canals and bridges and ports and
- 6:10public works. And the men with money and
- 6:13status bought those bonds. They profited off the system.
- 6:17And when it came time to vote, they turned around and they
- 6:21mobilized their networks, their employees, the people who owed
- 6:25them money, their whole social circle.
- 6:28So those bonds ended up working less like financial instruments
- 6:32and more like loyalty machines. He controlled the grain, too.
- 6:37In a shortage, the government could feed one city and make
- 6:40another starve. In a shortage, the government
- 6:42could feed one city and make another starve, make peace with
- 6:46the hungry in one place and create a desperate refugee
- 6:50somewhere else. Which meant food itself was a
- 6:53kind of power, and he was the one holding it.
- 6:57The third piece was managed press.
- 7:00Before there was social media, there was the newspaper, and
- 7:03Napoleon never actually banned them because an outright ban
- 7:08would have been too obvious. What he did instead was license
- 7:12them. Only certain papers were allowed
- 7:15to exist, and those papers printed what the government
- 7:18wanted printed, and the newspapers got curated.
- 7:21And the opposition just wasn't there.
- 7:24And that absence was by design, rather than by accident.
- 7:28So when a referendum was coming, the papers would fill up with
- 7:31stories about the stability it would bring and the chaos it
- 7:35would prevent. And by the time people actually
- 7:38voted, they've been living inside a fictional version of
- 7:41reality for weeks. This went past propaganda in the
- 7:45crude sense, and into something quieter and more total, a full
- 7:49capture of the information itself.
- 7:52If you lived in Paris in 1800 and the only papers you read
- 7:56were licensed, and the only things you heard were what the
- 8:00prefects wanted you to hear, then the vote never felt coerced
- 8:04to you. It felt inevitable.
- 8:07The fourth piece was the Cult of Personality.
- 8:09By this time, Napoleon had stopped being just a ruler and
- 8:13turned into something closer to a myth.
- 8:16The paintings had him up at the Alps, calm on his horse while
- 8:20the armies roared behind him. His face was on metals and coins
- 8:25worked into the ceremonies, and in every version of it he's
- 8:30glorious and victorious and never once in the wrong.
- 8:34And that image was engineered. As the Napoleon historian Philip
- 8:38Dwyer points out, that famous painting of him crossing the
- 8:42Alps, serene on a rearing white stallion, was pure stagecraft.
- 8:48The real Napoleon made that crossing on a mule led by a
- 8:51guide. The regime wasn't only winning
- 8:53battles, it was commissioning the painting of the battle, and
- 8:57the painting is the part people actually kept in their heads.
- 9:01His opponents never got framed as ordinary political rivals
- 9:05either. They got framed as enemies of
- 9:07France itself, as enemies of order and of the people, and
- 9:12who's going to vote against their own country?
- 9:15The cult held because it stopped being propaganda and started
- 9:18becoming identity. Voting for Napoleon wasn't a
- 9:21political choice anymore. It had turned into a way of
- 9:24declaring yourself French, of putting yourself on the winning
- 9:28side, on the side of the future. And the people who really
- 9:32believed in the myth didn't need to be coerced at all because
- 9:36they wanted to vote for him. The fifth piece is the one that
- 9:38most people miss, and it's the temporary Constitution.
- 9:42Napoleon didn't get his way by ignoring the law so much as by
- 9:46writing it himself, and writing it in a way that made his power
- 9:49look legal and temporary and completely necessary.
- 9:54The Constitution of 1799 handed him enormous authority, but it
- 9:59never claimed to be permanent. It got presented as an emergency
- 10:03measure, a temporary grant of power just to restore order
- 10:07until the crisis passed. Except, of course, the crisis
- 10:10never actually passed. Every time a new one came along,
- 10:15and he made sure the new ones kept coming along, he could go
- 10:19back to the people with another referendum, another revision to
- 10:23the Constitution, each one stretching his authority just a
- 10:26little further, and each one dressed up as a vote.
- 10:30By 1804, he'd revised the thing so many times that he quietly
- 10:35voted himself into being emperor, and the people signed
- 10:38off on it. Once the power was consolidated,
- 10:41it still had to keep itself alive, and keeping plebiscitary
- 10:45power alive takes constant theater.
- 10:48The military victories were a big part of that, and honestly
- 10:51the territory was almost beside the point, even though it
- 10:55helped. What a victory really did was to
- 10:58justify the whole system, prove the strongman was working, prove
- 11:03that order was being held. Every general who won a battle
- 11:07was basically another vote of confidence, and every peasant
- 11:11who watched the new road go in had one more reason to back the
- 11:15arrangement. But the victories on their own
- 11:18weren't enough, because the opposition still had to be
- 11:21handled. And the clever moves that is
- 11:24that you don't actually need to crush it out in the open, you
- 11:27just make it nearly impossible for any opposition to take shape
- 11:30in the 1st place. If you wanted to criticize
- 11:33Napoleon, you ran into a wall. The newspapers wouldn't print a
- 11:38word of it, the prefects wouldn't let you gather in a
- 11:41crowd, and your whole network of support was being watched,
- 11:46suspected, and could be ruined. But notice they don't arrest
- 11:49you, and they don't throw you into prison because a prisoner
- 11:53turns into a martyr. Instead, they just make you
- 11:56irrelevant. Your voice can't reach anybody,
- 12:00the moment never gets to form, and you're perfectly free to
- 12:03talk while nobody's actually able to hear you.
- 12:07And that turns out to work better than censorship ever
- 12:10could, because it wears the appearance of freedom, at which
- 12:14point the whole thing basically runs itself.
- 12:17The local prefect stayed loyal because loyalty is what got
- 12:21promoted. The people under them fell in
- 12:23line because stepping out of it meant losing everything they
- 12:26had. The bondholders had every reason
- 12:29to keep it running, since it was paying them, and the soldiers
- 12:33kept fighting, mostly because fighting was the only life they
- 12:37really knew. And the unsettling part is that
- 12:40nobody inside it had to be evil. Nobody had to sit down and
- 12:44consciously decide to serve a tyranny.
- 12:47They were all just doing their jobs, looking out for their own
- 12:51advantage, following the shape of a system that had been built
- 12:54up around them. Then Napoleon lost.
- 12:58In 1815. After Waterloo, he abdicated and
- 13:02went into exile, and for a moment it looked like the whole
- 13:06thing he'd built was dying right along with him.
- 13:09Only it didn't. His nephew Louis Napoleon, a man
- 13:12most historians write off as fairly mediocre, understood
- 13:16something the mediocre label misses, which is that the
- 13:19machine had outlived the man who built it.
- 13:22The institutions were all still standing, the prefects, the
- 13:27military setup, the whole web of economic dependency and above
- 13:32all, the myth. As the historian Sudair
- 13:35Huzarising has shown, the Napoleonic legend didn't fade
- 13:39out after Waterloo. It got deliberately kept alive
- 13:42through cheap prints and songs and old soldier stories, until
- 13:48it hardened into something close to a folk religion.
- 13:51And that legend was the road the nephew rode straight back into
- 13:54power. Louis Napoleon had spent years
- 13:57in exile studying his uncle's playbook, so when he came back
- 14:00to France in 1848, the country was tipping into chaos all over
- 14:05again. Revolution in the streets.
- 14:08The Second Republic was wobbling.
- 14:10People were hungry and afraid. He already knew what to do.
- 14:14Alexis de Tocqueville was actually inside that government,
- 14:18serving as a minister of the Second Republic, and in his
- 14:22memoirs he describes a political class frozen by fear and a
- 14:26public so warned out by disorder that it would trade almost
- 14:30anything for a little calm. The exhaustion was the opening,
- 14:35and Louis Napoleon offered exactly what his uncle had
- 14:37offered, which was order. He won the presidency in a
- 14:41landslide because the machinery recognized him as one of its
- 14:45own. And then he simply waited.
- 14:48In 1851, he staged his coup in the middle of the night.
- 14:52Soldiers moving into Paris, government buildings locked
- 14:56down, opposition leaders were arrested.
- 15:00Karl Marx watched the whole thing unfold almost in real
- 15:03time, and wrote it up the next year in the 18th broom air of
- 15:07Louis Bonaparte. His famous line is that history
- 15:11repeats itself, first a tragedy and then as farce.
- 15:15But the sharper point underneath it is the exact one that we're
- 15:19tracing here, that Louis Napoleon never needed to be
- 15:22brilliant. He inherited a state machine his
- 15:25uncle had already built, and all he really had to do was grab the
- 15:29levers. And then three weeks after the
- 15:32coup, he holds a referendum. The question is whether Louis
- 15:36Napoleon should have the power to write a brand new
- 15:39constitution and 92% vote yes. And you can see the entire game
- 15:46in that one small detail, which is that the government only
- 15:49printed the yes ballots. If you wanted to vote no, you
- 15:54had to go find or make your own. Most people didn't understand
- 15:58they were voting for a dictatorship.
- 16:00They thought they were voting for order, for stability, for an
- 16:04end to the chaos. Then he rewrites the
- 16:06constitution, expands his own power, and puts up a second
- 16:10referendum in 1852 asking whether France should have an
- 16:14emperor. By the time anybody voted, the
- 16:18decision was already made and the machine was already running.
- 16:22And in December of 1852, Louis Napoleon became Emperor Napoleon
- 16:27the Third. What he builds next is actually
- 16:30more refined than anything his uncle managed.
- 16:34Baron Osman is made the prefect of the Sen, and his assignment
- 16:39is to rebuild the entire city. Most people remember Osman as
- 16:43the man who modernized Paris, who laid down those beautiful
- 16:46boulevards and pulled order out of a medieval tangle.
- 16:50And he did most of that. But that wasn't the whole reason
- 16:53that he was there. Medieval Paris was a maze of
- 16:56narrow streets and dense blocks, the kind of place where a
- 17:00barricade could go up in an afternoon, the kind of place
- 17:03where revolution had already lived more than once.
- 17:07So Osman went in and demolished it.
- 17:10He tore up entire neighborhoods, relocated hundreds of thousands
- 17:15of people, he straightened the streets into wide open
- 17:18boulevards, widened the avenues until troops and artillery could
- 17:22move straight down them, and opened up a square where a crowd
- 17:26could be watched. Now, historians do argue about
- 17:30how much of this was really about controlling crowds,
- 17:34sanitation and traffic and land speculation we're all pushing in
- 17:37too. And the anti barricade logic was
- 17:401 motive sitting among several. Not some single secret master
- 17:45plan. But it was a motive and people
- 17:48noticed it at the time. The same boulevards that made
- 17:51Paris beautiful also made Paris a lot easier to govern.
- 17:55Around the same time, Louis Napoleon expanded the rail
- 17:59network at a pace no French ruler had ever matched, going
- 18:03from something like 3600 kilometers of track in 1852 to
- 18:07around 17,400 by 1870. Thousands of miles of it wiring
- 18:12Paris to the provinces and to the army bases.
- 18:16And if you have to ask what it was all really for, well, it's
- 18:19because soldiers could now move faster than peasants could
- 18:22organize, food could be redirected before shortage
- 18:26turned into revolt, and information could travel at the
- 18:29speed of steam. The railroads look like
- 18:32progress, and they genuinely were progress.
- 18:36But they were also a control system laid right on top of the
- 18:39country. And the prefects, now armed with
- 18:42the census data that a modern bureaucracy could produce, could
- 18:45track whole populations, know where the dissidents lived, know
- 18:50which towns were loyal and where trouble might come next.
- 18:54So you end up with this strange marriage of very modern
- 18:58technology and very old fashioned tyranny.
- 19:01The press stayed under control, but Louis Napoleon grasped
- 19:04something his uncle never fully did, which is that people don't
- 19:08resist a system they actually believe in.
- 19:11So rather than just censoring the opposition, he went a step
- 19:14further and produced propaganda so smooth it didn't even
- 19:17register as propaganda. Stories about his wisdom, his
- 19:22plans for France, his careful handling of the economy,
- 19:26photographs of him at public events.
- 19:29Always dignified, always in command, the papers ran all of
- 19:33it, partly because they held licenses that they didn't want
- 19:37to lose, and partly because the government advertising was the
- 19:41only advertising that really mattered.
- 19:44And it flowed straight into the compliant papers.
- 19:47And partly because every journalist knew that criticism
- 19:50meant their publication got shut down.
- 19:53But the story still went out, They got distributed and people
- 19:57believe them. The belief itself was the entire
- 19:59point of the exercise. Because once you're convinced
- 20:03the ruler is wise, you vote for him without being told to.
- 20:07Once you're sure the system is basically orderly, you start
- 20:11defending it on your own. And once you've absorbed the
- 20:14idea that criticism itself was dangerous, you quietly begin
- 20:19silencing it inside your own mind before anyone else ever has
- 20:23to. At that point, you're more or
- 20:26less your own prefect. And here's what people tend to
- 20:30miss about the plebiscitary empire, which is that it doesn't
- 20:34run forever, but it does last a good deal longer than it ever
- 20:38should. Lewis Napoleon held power for
- 20:41more than 20 years, from the presidency in 1848 all the way
- 20:46to the fall of the empire in 1870.
- 20:49That's more than two decades of plebiscites and a controlled
- 20:54press, a prefects quietly steering the outcomes of a
- 20:59public consent that was underneath it all manufactured.
- 21:04By 1870, the whole thing finally starts to crack.
- 21:08He took the country into a war with Prussia, and he lost it.
- 21:12And he lost it badly, because the machine that worked so
- 21:15beautifully at home simply couldn't produce a victory
- 21:19abroad. And when that defeat landed, the
- 21:22structure came apart. It didn't come apart because the
- 21:25population was suddenly woken up in the morning.
- 21:29It came apart because the myth itself had broken.
- 21:32The strong man had visibly failed, and the cult that had
- 21:36built around him shattered instantly.
- 21:39Within weeks, the revolution was back.
- 21:42The Emperor got captured on the battlefield at Sudan, and by the
- 21:46time that word reached Paris, the Republic had already been
- 21:49declared and the Empire was finished.
- 21:53But the template underneath it was still sitting right there,
- 21:57completely intact. And that's really the whole
- 22:00reason that this matters, because the plebiscitary
- 22:03government didn't die in 1870. It evolved.
- 22:07It's the same playbook, just running in a different century.
- 22:12The ballot boxes are still standing, the referendum's still
- 22:16happening. The votes still carry real
- 22:18legitimacy. What's changed is everything
- 22:21holding them up. The prefects now are the media
- 22:25executives who quietly decide which stories run, which voices
- 22:29ever get a platform, which version of events become the one
- 22:33everybody ends up hearing. The military is still around,
- 22:37but now it's backed by police, by surveillance, by technology
- 22:42that can track a population in real time.
- 22:45The economic dependency has gotten more refined, too, with
- 22:49the old bondholders replaced by hedge funds, workers managed by
- 22:53algorithms through gig platforms, and food security
- 22:58quietly made conditional, ongoing with the system.
- 23:02The cult of personality runs at a scale the Bonaparte could have
- 23:05never dreamed of, built instantly on social media, the
- 23:10rallies broadcast live, the images reaching millions of
- 23:14people in a matter of minutes. And the Constitution, the legal
- 23:18frame underneath all of it, keeps getting rewritten through
- 23:22emergency powers and temporary measures and revisions that
- 23:26stretch executive authority a little further each time.
- 23:31Every one of them sold as necessary, every one of them
- 23:35sold as temporary. And none of it is happening by
- 23:38accident. The names have changed and the
- 23:41technology has moved on, but the machine still runs in the same
- 23:45handful of principles. You control the information.
- 23:49You manufacture the consent, you build the economic dependency,
- 23:54you neutralize the opposition before it can even form, and you
- 23:57always, always leave people with the feeling that they chose this
- 24:03themselves. So when a leader tells you a
- 24:05referendum is 1 editor, I'm gonna get this again.
- 24:09So when a leader tells you a referendum is on the way, it's
- 24:13worth remembering that the outcome was settled before the
- 24:16voting ever started, and the machine was built to guarantee
- 24:19exactly 1 answer. When you see new measures rolled
- 24:23out as temporarily emergencies, remember that emergencies don't
- 24:28come with expiration dates, they come with extensions.
- 24:33And when the opposition voices have simply gone missing from
- 24:36the mainstream, remember that nobody actually banned them.
- 24:40They were just made irrelevant, pushed off to a somewhere that
- 24:43you're never quite able to hear them.
- 24:45And when the myth finally does break, when the strongman fails,
- 24:50don't expect the whole system to fail over the next day.
- 24:53It fractures and it adapts and it goes looking to rebuild
- 24:58itself under a new name, with a new face, because the template
- 25:02has always outlasted the individual.
- 25:05And that's the real take away from the Bonaparts.
- 25:08The power was never really located in the Tyrant himself.
- 25:12It was living in the structure, in a machine you can build and
- 25:16then build again a repeatable set of moving parts.
- 25:20The power was never really located in the tyrant himself.
- 25:23It was living in the structure, in a machine you can build and
- 25:27then unbuild again, a repeatable set of moving parts that keeps
- 25:32working no matter who happens to be standing at the controls.
- 25:37This has been hidden forces in history.
- 25:40I'm Jeremy Ryan Slate. Please like this video, leave us
- 25:44a comment, and smash that subscribe button if you want
- 25:47more hidden forces in history.