Latest / Stage Talks with Bellingcat / "Synthetic Propaganda - Tracing an AI-Driven Political Operation" with Effie Webb
Transcript
- 0:04You're listening to a stage talk titled Synthetic
- 0:07Propaganda, tracing an AI driven political operation.
- 0:12This week we were joined by the Bureau of Investigative
- 0:14Journalism's Effie Webb. Effie specialises in
- 0:18investigating big tech and AI. In this talk,
- 0:21she shares how she uncovered a far right political
- 0:24party that had paid for an AI influencer. and
- 0:28provides advice on how to investigate AI propaganda
- 0:31without amplifying it further. You can find links
- 0:34to all the resources mentioned in the talk in
- 0:36the podcast description. This talk was hosted
- 0:39by me, Charlotte Mar, on Thursday the 16th of
- 0:42April, 2026, in the Bill and Kat Discord server.
- 0:53So over the past few years, we've seen rapid
- 0:56advances in generative AI reshape everything
- 0:59from media production to political communication.
- 1:02At the same time, concerns about disinformation,
- 1:05influence operations and the integrity of online
- 1:07spaces have only intensified, particularly as
- 1:10new tools make it easier to create persuasive
- 1:12and scalable forms of content. Today's conversation
- 1:16sits at that intersection. Our guest is Effie
- 1:19Webb, an investigative reporter with the Bureau
- 1:21of Investigative Journalism. whose recent work
- 1:24explores how emerging technologies are being
- 1:26used within political campaigning in the UK.
- 1:29Her reporting raises important questions, not
- 1:32just about what's possible with AI, but about
- 1:35transparency, accountability and how we understand
- 1:37influence in an increasingly synthetic media
- 1:40environment. Effie will talk to us about her
- 1:42reporting and what some experts are calling a
- 1:44first -of -its -kind case, where a registered
- 1:47political party paid for content from an AI -generated
- 1:50influencer pushing ideological messaging. Before
- 1:53we begin, a short reminder that you can place
- 1:55your questions in the chat accessible in the
- 1:57right -hand corner of your screen. But please
- 2:00remember that this is being audio recorded for
- 2:02the podcast. So if you don't want me to mention
- 2:04your username, please add that as a note in your
- 2:07question. Okay. Effie, over to you. I will mute
- 2:12my mic. Thanks, Charlie. Yeah, I do shout if
- 2:18my audio goes a bit dodge, but it should be okay.
- 2:23Yeah, great to be here. Yeah, as you said, I'm
- 2:27an AI reporter at the Bureau of Investigative
- 2:28Journalism. For those who don't know the Bureau,
- 2:31we're an impact -driven non -profit newsroom
- 2:34based in London. And yeah, I've been increasingly
- 2:38focused on AI influence operations and political
- 2:42campaigning, which brings me to this Danny Bones
- 2:47So yeah, in a nutshell, the last few months I
- 2:52traced this anonymous influence operation essentially
- 2:56behind an AI rapper, political activist, commentator,
- 3:01et cetera, to a registered political party, Advance
- 3:05UK, and their kind of by -election campaign in
- 3:09Manchester. So I thought it would be maybe interesting
- 3:14if we could just like listen to some Danny Bones
- 3:18content okay so i'm gonna try and play a Danny
- 3:24Bones song this might work so this was his most
- 3:28recent track called UK So yeah, that's Steiny
- 4:03Bones' latest song. How do I come across Steiny
- 4:09Bones? Maybe that's useful to... go through first.
- 4:13So I found him on Spotify. It was in a Discover
- 4:16Weekly playlist. I'd been kind of keeping an
- 4:19eye on AI -generated music. So I think Spotify
- 4:23sort of picked up on that. I've been listening
- 4:26to like a bit of the Crew Con Gazette stuff as
- 4:29well, because that had made some headlines. And
- 4:34yeah, I'd listened to This is England, which
- 4:36is by far Danny Bone's most sort of popular song.
- 4:40Um, and yeah, really good production quality,
- 4:44production value, kind of like mixing and mastering
- 4:46that was professional, like authentic sounding
- 4:50vocals, no kind of trace of an AI slot type song.
- 4:56Um, press on the profile and like notice the
- 5:01artist profile image was an AI generated image.
- 5:04Um, I thought that was interesting given that
- 5:07like Aside from that sign of AI, there were hundreds
- 5:12of thousands of streams across the four songs,
- 5:14I think it was at that point. And he not verified
- 5:19as an artist because Spotify doesn't do verification
- 5:21anymore, but registered as an artist. And Spotify
- 5:25didn't seem to be kind of demoting the artist
- 5:29for being AI type thing. So then I went to social
- 5:33media and saw he... he, it was across sort of
- 5:36all the mainstream platforms and having only
- 5:39started in kind of November time was cultivating
- 5:43a like pretty healthy following by posting kind
- 5:48of mostly I'd say YouTube shorts and TikToks,
- 5:52but also kind of reels and videos on Twitter
- 5:56of kind of anti -migrant, anti -Muslim dog whistle
- 6:04type content, very conspiracy adjacent stuff
- 6:08a lot of the time, all with this kind of patriotic
- 6:11undertone and sort of implicit or explicit calls
- 6:16that we should all kind of take back our country
- 6:20and fight for, yeah, fight for the sort of British
- 6:25or Britain that wants wars type thing. What I
- 6:29found in, again, I'm going to just quickly share
- 6:31my screen because I think the way that Danny
- 6:34Bones is presented, yeah, so he has like kind
- 6:40of a roster of different looks that his creators
- 6:43have kind of given him on purpose. So he's kind
- 6:45of like sometimes a religious figure. Sometimes
- 6:50he's like more of a gritty grime artist. Sometimes
- 6:53he's a bit more of like a skinhead type rioter.
- 6:59And yeah, I think that's not an accident. I think
- 7:02he's not made to be... this isn't a deep fake
- 7:07situation. He is a kind of persona and character
- 7:10that can kind of be repurposed and remixed for
- 7:13whatever audience is the target. And in this
- 7:18case, it is kind of young British men, overwhelmingly,
- 7:22but more on that later. I'll stop sharing now.
- 7:28I was interested in this Danny Bones character,
- 7:31but at this point it was just a curiosity. At
- 7:34the same time, I'd been looking at the use of
- 7:38AI and synthetic media by political groups and
- 7:42particularly right -wing political groups and
- 7:46came across Advanced UK's recent shorts they
- 7:51were posting on on Twitter, sorry, and on TikTok
- 7:55actually, in this kind of attempt to appeal to
- 7:59a younger population and just a bit of context
- 8:04about what Advanced UK are for those who probably
- 8:08understand we've never heard of them. They are
- 8:10a kind of fringe splinter party headed by Ben
- 8:14Habib, who's the former co -deputy leader of
- 8:17Reform UK, Nigel Farage's party. They're sort
- 8:21of Christian nationalist, they would dispute
- 8:25the term far -right, but I would say far -right
- 8:27party whose policies all sort of center on this
- 8:31idea that mass immigration is a national emergency
- 8:36and that sort of mass deportation is the solution,
- 8:40alongside a sort of policy to kind of adopt widespread
- 8:48Christianity and sort of pious other religions.
- 8:55And that's kind of where I think the Diabones
- 8:56character has interesting parallels. But at this
- 8:59point, I was just noticing Advanced UK's use
- 9:02of AI. It wasn't the, I hadn't connected the
- 9:06two, so to speak. And it was in late January
- 9:11when Advanced UK were launching their culture
- 9:13and immigration policies. They posted a two minute
- 9:17video, which was a of AI -generated video. It
- 9:21was a montage of British culture and history,
- 9:25all parts of it at least, with various wars.
- 9:30So second world war soldiers, Anglo -Saxon warriors,
- 9:34et cetera. And there was a gritty voiceover that
- 9:38urged people to, or not urge people to vote advance,
- 9:42but say that an advanced UK government would
- 9:45be able to bring back bringing Britain back to
- 9:49its kind of, um, uh, you know, a time when, when
- 9:54it was better type thing. Um, and this, yeah,
- 9:58this video for whatever reason, sort of resembled
- 10:01the Danny Bones type content that I had been
- 10:05kind of keeping on as well. And the same kind
- 10:08of style and overlay. It also had a similar voiceover
- 10:11and the backing track as well. like was actually
- 10:16the instrumental to the This is England song,
- 10:21which is like his most popular song. But that
- 10:23kind of subtle detail was kind of easy to miss.
- 10:25And I had to re -watch this video a couple of
- 10:27times before, before really clocking on to that.
- 10:31And then right at the end of the video, a logo
- 10:33or, you know, a text overlay for the Node project
- 10:37flashes up for a second. The Node project, I
- 10:42then kind of uh, searched up and found that they
- 10:46were the sort of, they described themselves as
- 10:48a collective. So the influence collective behind,
- 10:51um, this Danny Bones kind of character or persona,
- 10:54if you like, um, very, I mean, they've changed
- 10:57their website now, but the website in there in
- 11:00its original form was this very slick boutique
- 11:03style, um, influence agency type website, one
- 11:07that you might expect a kind of high -end modeling,
- 11:09um, agency to have, um, with yeah, Danny Bones
- 11:13kind of plastered over the front of it and at
- 11:18the same time said, intentionally being very
- 11:20vague, both in its language about what it does
- 11:23and who's behind it and sort of also where it's
- 11:28based. There was nothing in terms of clues there.
- 11:33So yeah, I was really interested in what this
- 11:37node project thing was because now we had a kind
- 11:39of indication that um, at the very least, Advanced
- 11:44UK were using, um, node project content in their,
- 11:49in at least one of their videos. Um, so there
- 11:52were two questions, I suppose. One was who, like,
- 11:56who is the node project? How many people are
- 11:57behind it? Where are they based? And two, is
- 12:00money being exchanged hands here? So is, is this
- 12:04sort of a paid job? Um, or, you know, maybe other
- 12:09hypothesis being is advanced UK kind of someone
- 12:13in the social media team advanced kind of just
- 12:16pirating or copying from the node project. So
- 12:19at that point, it became a bit of traditional
- 12:23journalism, just calling up advanced UK and being
- 12:26like, hi, I'd like to speak to you about your
- 12:32AI generated stuff. They were very open with
- 12:36me about their relationship to the node project.
- 12:39They did tell me that they had paid for that
- 12:43two minute video I mentioned earlier. They didn't
- 12:46tell me how much, although they did say that
- 12:49it was not an insignificant amount of money.
- 12:53I did press them a bit on how much they paid,
- 12:54but they wouldn't go into that. I then spoke
- 12:58to someone else at advance who kind of is more
- 13:00on the social media end of things. And they said
- 13:02that it wasn't just that video, but it was a
- 13:04series of videos. which was significant because
- 13:08the other series of videos they commissioned
- 13:10from the Node Project were sort of their campaigning
- 13:16videos for this by -election, which was the Gortland
- 13:20-Denton by -election where Advance UK were contesting
- 13:24their first ever seat. And the Node Project made
- 13:28at least four videos, sort of one that kind of
- 13:33fronted their candidate, Nick Buckley. another
- 13:36that kind of showed this again, similar to sort
- 13:39of the Danny Bones type content, a very dystopian
- 13:41AI generated Britain, whilst urging people to
- 13:45register to vote in the upcoming by -election.
- 13:50So yeah, at this point it was clear that it was
- 13:55confirmed that by a lease advance that there
- 13:59had been a sort of paid payment here. We didn't
- 14:03know how much. there was a contact email for
- 14:07the Node project and that was kind of all there
- 14:09was in terms of how to get in touch with them.
- 14:12They were also relatively happy to engage in
- 14:16conversation over email, not over video, very
- 14:19keen to keep their anonymity as were advanced.
- 14:23So advanced were also, although they'd claimed
- 14:27they'd met some of the people behind the Node
- 14:30project, they were They refused to sort of give
- 14:35anything away in terms of who they were or where
- 14:38they were based, et cetera. So at that point,
- 14:42it was kind of a judgment call. Like we had enough
- 14:44to publish a story or more than enough to publish
- 14:47a story. We had an AI rapper, Danny Bones, an
- 14:51enormous influence operation and a fringe political
- 14:57party that has had the backing of Elon Musk paying
- 14:59for election campaign content that is AI generated.
- 15:06Almost for my own curiosity, I wanted to get
- 15:11to the bottom of who was behind the Node project
- 15:17and indeed how many people there were. So yeah,
- 15:22as I'd been sort of tracking and monitoring the
- 15:27node project. I'd been tracking and kind of just
- 15:31making a huge kind of spreadsheet of who were
- 15:35the most frequent engagers, who was commenting
- 15:37the most, who was donating. So they had a buy
- 15:40me a coffee donation page set up, who were kind
- 15:43of like the early donators on that. And, you
- 15:46know, just searching as well on Meta's ad library
- 15:51and uh, TikTok's, TikTok's ad library as well.
- 15:55So that was useful in two ways. Meta's ad library
- 15:58showed me who, well, one that there was the node
- 16:01project were paying for ads to like paid for,
- 16:05I think it was five ads for, to yeah, to promote
- 16:07themselves. Um, and they were targeting 18 to
- 16:1135 year old UK men, most of them. Uh, and then
- 16:15TikTok was useful in another way because it showed
- 16:18that the, someone had paid for a like not an
- 16:23ad, hashtag ad type thing, but someone had boosted
- 16:26some node project content and this was a particular
- 16:29person called AJ. And AJ had come up in my like
- 16:34earlier kind of network mapping of kind of particularly
- 16:38enthusiastic and committed followers, I suppose.
- 16:43So it then became a question of, is this person
- 16:48a super fan or is he a member of the node project
- 16:54or, you know, node project themselves. And it
- 16:56was very, um, it was interesting because I think
- 17:01there were some behaviors or things being posted
- 17:04that did, um, that resemble just kind of fan
- 17:07behavior. So resharing, reposting, um, liking,
- 17:12engaging, et cetera. There were others that went
- 17:15a step further. So on their personal accounts,
- 17:20particularly on TikTok, on threads as well, posting.
- 17:24I remember distinctly there was a Node Project
- 17:27t -shirt, or there was a t -shirt with the Node
- 17:30Project logo on it that I hadn't seen and was
- 17:33not apparent at all on any of the Node Project
- 17:37or Danny Bones platforms, but only on AJ's platforms.
- 17:41So that struck me as very strange behavior for
- 17:45someone who was just a fan. Um, I did get in
- 17:49touch with both AJ and the Node project, um,
- 17:53Stokes people, possibly the same people about
- 17:55this and they both denied, um, his involvement
- 17:59and said that he, yeah, he was, he was nothing
- 18:02more than a fan. Um, the story did shift a few
- 18:04times. So, um, there was a lot of back and forth.
- 18:08Um, but yeah, when it came to publishing, it
- 18:11was a judgment call that we didn't quite have
- 18:13a smoking gun to say definitively. this is the
- 18:19node project, here you go. Because again, it
- 18:23seems like there's not a kind of zero chance
- 18:27that there isn't at least more than one person
- 18:29involved in this type thing. And we did mention
- 18:34him in the piece though. So that was kind of...
- 18:40That was worth noting, but we didn't want to
- 18:42kind of just pin it on someone when it could
- 18:44be a larger operation. Maybe I will leave it
- 18:48there for now. And yeah, there's a lot more in
- 18:52terms of what happened after. But yeah, Charlie,
- 18:56if you want to. Yeah, I think people in the comments
- 18:59are just digging into the NOE project right now.
- 19:02I posted their websites and people are very interested
- 19:05in what they've got to say on it. It's really
- 19:09interesting what you were saying about just the
- 19:15volume of this and the role that AI is playing.
- 19:19We'd spoken in the comments, particularly about
- 19:21how it's not just a UK focused issue. We've also
- 19:24got, Bellingcat recently covered, how AI generations
- 19:29were being used to spread hate speech in India
- 19:32around election candidates and how troublesome
- 19:35that is. Today, the Foreign Press Association
- 19:40put out a statement on the IDF using AI to change
- 19:44an image of a journalist. It's kind of terrifying
- 19:48how much this is seeping into politics. In regards
- 19:52to this particular operation, how sophisticated
- 19:56is it? Are we looking at something that could
- 19:59be replicable by other party groups? Or is this
- 20:03only something that you think might? operate
- 20:07within the UK political structure? Yeah, it's
- 20:10a good question and don't think it's unique to
- 20:12the UK at all. I can see a world in which Danny
- 20:15Bones himself, there's nothing particularly British
- 20:18about the Danny Bones character except his British
- 20:23outfits. He could easily be used in a Polish
- 20:25election. He looks quite Eastern European, a
- 20:27lot of people have said. In terms of the AI element,
- 20:33I think AI poses a lot of threats to democracy,
- 20:39et cetera. This isn't a deep fake situation.
- 20:42He does look increasingly hyper real, I think,
- 20:46if I came at it fresh. If I was coming at it
- 20:49fresh now, I would probably have taken a step
- 20:54back and been like, is that real? Is it not?
- 20:57But back in January, there were very clear AI
- 21:01giveaways, especially with the the music videos.
- 21:05I think it is quite a sophisticated operation.
- 21:08I think the music in particular. So I wanted
- 21:13to know kind of, yeah, is this just a case of
- 21:16they're downloading a commercial AI music tool?
- 21:18So like some of the mainstream ones like Suno
- 21:20or UDO. I don't know if you pronounce that right,
- 21:25but yeah, UDO and Suno. I downloaded Suno, pasted
- 21:28in the lyrics to a Danny Bowen song and within
- 21:32like a minute or two had four different tracks
- 21:36in four different genres. So like drill, grime,
- 21:42acoustic, and they were nowhere near as good
- 21:47as Danny Bones sort of stuff. But it did make
- 21:51me think, okay, this isn't something where you
- 21:54need to be a musician or a complete tech whiz
- 21:59to do. Um, and I think, but I do think there's
- 22:02something about the Dunnybone stuff that, um,
- 22:04is not like, that does kind of put him in a category
- 22:08that isn't slot. I also think the character itself
- 22:13and the kind of character storytelling and creation
- 22:16that goes into it, um, that the creators or creator
- 22:19has put quite a lot of thought into in terms
- 22:21of making sure both technically that the character
- 22:25is consistent from video to video in terms of
- 22:28voice and appearance, et cetera, but also the
- 22:34political stuff. They are very reactive to the
- 22:38current affairs and current events of the day.
- 22:41During the Gortons and Denton by -election, there
- 22:43was a lot of far -right hate towards the Green
- 22:48Party and the various tactics. He was very on
- 22:50the money and very quick at putting out those
- 22:54videos. Is it sophisticated? Yes. Is it reputable?
- 23:00Definitely yes. Is it something that I think
- 23:04you could do pretty cheaply? Also, yes. And I
- 23:09think that there's nothing to say that we...
- 23:13I think the music medium is like maybe the most
- 23:16interesting part of this because also I think
- 23:18if you're a kind of rapper or a drill slash grime
- 23:22artist, you do have a bit more license to kind
- 23:24of say the controversial or like push the overton
- 23:27window a bit more with like... what you're saying
- 23:29as opposed to a traditional influencer word.
- 23:34We also saw in Iran with the Lego AI rap propaganda
- 23:40that was coming out a few weeks, maybe even still
- 23:43is coming out. I think there's just an interesting
- 23:47move into the music space because music is so
- 23:51visceral and it is catchy and it is memorable
- 23:56and it does a bit of political work without a
- 24:02listener necessarily approaching it from a political
- 24:08space. Yeah, and we've seen recently artists
- 24:11deny politicians from using their music as well
- 24:15in big political stages. We had a comment earlier
- 24:18that said, this is one of the more worrying things
- 24:20about AI for me. It lets fringe groups access
- 24:23a production quality and even artistry that they
- 24:26either couldn't have afforded or they wouldn't
- 24:28have been able to find artists willing to make
- 24:30things for them, which I think is really relevant.
- 24:33We actually had a question about the AI Lego
- 24:36videos earlier and since you brought it up, I'll
- 24:40mention it. When AI is used by multiple actors
- 24:43in a political conflict or war, what can be done
- 24:46by both the media and the public in order to
- 24:48be able to sift through all the slop? What are
- 24:51your thoughts on that particularly? Yeah, it's
- 24:55a great question. And I think the media has,
- 24:58we have to think carefully about coverage being
- 25:03thoughtful, responsible, and that we're not just
- 25:07echoing and amplifying. you know, back and forth
- 25:09slot between two bad actors or more bad actors.
- 25:14I think for this story and this was like, again,
- 25:18it was a judgment call in how much kind of, you
- 25:21know, there's a balancing act of you want to
- 25:24paint the picture of Danny Bones and you want
- 25:26to show the sort of harmful Islamophobic, xenophobic,
- 25:29racist, far -right, conspiratorial content whilst
- 25:32also not just becoming a like unpaid bit of marketing
- 25:36for him. I think whenever you report on something
- 25:41bad like that, and especially with AI where people
- 25:44are curious and they'll go and press on the Spotify
- 25:47artist or go to the social media, which we did
- 25:50see happen, it's kind of an inevitable balancing
- 25:53act that you have to just make a call on. In
- 26:00a general sense, I think a good rule of thumb
- 26:03is like, think about why you're reporting it.
- 26:05Is it just like, huh, like this is, this is kind
- 26:08of, this is really funny. This is, um, this is,
- 26:13yeah, exactly. This is sort of AI slop being
- 26:16done for AI slop sake. I think, yeah, obviously
- 26:19because this had an actual registered UK political
- 26:22party's funding, it was a story worth telling.
- 26:25If it hadn't had the funding, I think There may
- 26:29have been an argument to publish anyway because
- 26:34it was still being used by the party. But I think
- 26:38going forward and knowing now what happened after
- 26:41we published and the kind of publicity that Danny
- 26:43Bones did end up getting and the Node Project
- 26:45did end up kind of making money essentially from
- 26:49our coverage, I will approach stories with that
- 26:55in mind, I think, going forward. I really want
- 27:00to touch on that. But first, maybe you can give
- 27:02us a little bit more background on the Node project
- 27:05because we have had a few questions about that
- 27:08specifically. So someone asked earlier if there
- 27:14was anything in the UK that kind of protected
- 27:17us from organizations like the Node project.
- 27:21And so Hans just asked, is this Node project
- 27:24registered with Companies House? And perhaps
- 27:27you can just give us a little bit more breakdown
- 27:28on the No Project, what it is specifically, and
- 27:33then maybe we can go into the impact the article
- 27:36had after. Sure. Yeah, that's a good question.
- 27:39No, they're not on Companies House, sadly. They
- 27:43have a website, that is kind of all they have.
- 27:46Well, they've got a website and then they've
- 27:48got all their social media platforms where they
- 27:50kind of... Um, frame themselves as sort of the
- 27:53management of Danny Bones, um, the sort of, yeah,
- 27:56artist manager. Um, the, I have archived the
- 28:00previous website, so if anyone's interested in
- 28:02seeing it in its original form, um, I can, I
- 28:05can send that over, but essentially, um, now
- 28:08what the website is or, you know, what the known
- 28:10project shows is a kind of very stripped back
- 28:13thing saying, Hey, sign up for a paid membership
- 28:16here. You can be a £20. you can pay 20 pounds
- 28:19to be a Node founding member, sorry, a Node early
- 28:22member, or you can pay 100 pounds to be a founding
- 28:25member and have access to a private telegram
- 28:28group and all sorts of perks that are promised
- 28:31like that. And you can see that they've made
- 28:34kind of over two grand just in the last three
- 28:37weeks from that. So clearly there is interest
- 28:43in the Node project and In terms of their website,
- 28:48I did a Whois lookup and it had this kind of
- 28:54domain registration that was shielded by a commercial
- 28:58privacy proxy service, like quite standard. So
- 29:03it was just a case of getting in touch with them.
- 29:08trying to, well, trying to keep the conversation
- 29:11going, not being super confrontational and kind
- 29:13of like accusatory essentially, but actually
- 29:15just like entering a dialogue with them. Um,
- 29:19I will say I, and this is kind of a piece to,
- 29:22to come, so I won't like say too much, but I
- 29:25do have a bit more of a lead now on like who
- 29:28is behind the node project. Um, so yeah. more
- 29:34to come on that, but in terms of the bit about
- 29:36kind of protections we have, there are like,
- 29:40I think the key ones are like the Advertising
- 29:42Standards Authority and the Electoral Commission,
- 29:45both of whom have rules in terms of, you know,
- 29:49they weren't, none of these rules really were
- 29:51obviously designed for kind of AI influences
- 29:53or synthetic influences, but there are rules
- 29:56around, you know, disclosure and transparency
- 29:58when something is a um, paid for ads and when
- 30:01something is, um, particularly when it's a kind
- 30:03of political campaign. So, and there is a lot
- 30:07of scrutiny on that kind of thing at the moment
- 30:08and kind of making sure those rules do kind of
- 30:10match the, the AI age. So, um, I think, yeah,
- 30:15yes and no in terms of, in terms of kind of protection.
- 30:18Thanks for answering that. And you, you've kind
- 30:21of hinted a little bit about what happened. Um,
- 30:24but perhaps it's a good lesson as well for the
- 30:28audience to hear about. what happened after you
- 30:30published, because the No Project and a small
- 30:36group of crypto traders then tried to turn the
- 30:38coverage itself into a source of income, right?
- 30:41I'm sharing your second article in the chat now
- 30:44for those who might want to read it as you talk
- 30:46about this. Yeah, so yeah, I think what I was
- 30:52prepared for after we published the first was
- 30:54like backlash from the far right, which often
- 30:58happens and maybe some personal online attacks
- 31:02at me. That didn't happen at all. That was all
- 31:04very above board and professional and there was
- 31:06no doxing, none of that. What happened instead
- 31:09was the Danny Bones character and the Node Project
- 31:11very much leaned into the criticism and leaned
- 31:16into the controversy. They quickly made a reaction
- 31:20video going bit by bit through our article and
- 31:25calling out which bits were wrong in their mind
- 31:29and then ending this video with a call to support
- 31:33the cause and donate and then they had a new
- 31:36donation link. There was a series of other videos
- 31:40that followed that and you could see they were
- 31:44just trying to stir controversy and classic kind
- 31:46of tropes like mainstream media kind of left
- 31:51state. sponsored kind of stuff were being thrown
- 31:56around and sort of accusations we were trying
- 31:59to silence him or, yeah, silence Danny, so to
- 32:03speak. On a completely separate corner of Twitter
- 32:08or, you know, relatively separate corner of Twitter,
- 32:12two groups were set up called The Node Project,
- 32:15which were sort of, yeah, these crypto speculators
- 32:19who saw this stir that had been created around
- 32:22our coverage and also the Daily Mail's coverage,
- 32:25plus Danny Bones and the Node Project, plus the
- 32:29far -right reaction and the back and forth we
- 32:34were having. The crypto speculators very shrewdly
- 32:41thought this seems like a moment that could be
- 32:44flipped into a meme coin or into a lucrative
- 32:48crypto opportunity. At the time, I had tracked
- 32:53four Danny Bones meme coins that popped up on
- 32:58the Solana blockchain created on Pumpfun. And
- 33:02I actually just checked before this talk and
- 33:04now there are 40. Forty and I think there are
- 33:09about a dozen creators behind them. So some of
- 33:12them are kind of duplicates or, you know, the
- 33:15creator created more than one type thing, but
- 33:17still that's... that's a fair amount of coins.
- 33:20And this all happened within about 48 hours.
- 33:25So like the Danny Bones blackbash happened within
- 33:27three hours, the coins popped up. From what I
- 33:32could tell and from what I could trace, largely
- 33:35from people in the US, there wasn't an indication
- 33:40that the people causing the hype and encouraging
- 33:45people to buy into these coins were in any way
- 33:49kind of connected to advanced UK, anyway kind
- 33:52of interested in British politics necessarily,
- 33:56but were more kind of just opportunistic and
- 34:00rightly seeing like this as a kind of political
- 34:03moment that, you know, sitting with parallels
- 34:07to a very simple, another situation with this
- 34:12Amelia character who also was turned into a Mean
- 34:14Boy and I can go into that a little bit more
- 34:16if we want, but a few months prior to our story,
- 34:20Elon Musk had kind of retweeted about this immediate
- 34:23AI character, which had made the mean coins related
- 34:27to her extremely lucrative. So I think there
- 34:32was a sort of logic that maybe we can make that
- 34:34happen again and get endorsement from Musk himself,
- 34:40which didn't happen and the coin sort of... um,
- 34:42crash and value, um, relatively quickly, but
- 34:44they are still, they're still floating around.
- 34:46So you never know. So you didn't predict this
- 34:51kind of response, um, that it did happen. Has
- 34:55it changed the way that you mentioned earlier
- 34:58that you might change the way that your report
- 35:00going forwards? What kind of concerns or, or
- 35:05considerations are you now putting in for this
- 35:08next report that you're working on? Yeah, it's
- 35:12a good question. I wouldn't dissuade people from
- 35:21covering this type of stuff at all. I just think
- 35:24it's interesting to be prepared for these different
- 35:27types of responses and reactions that aren't
- 35:30necessarily the traditional personal attacks,
- 35:34but actually might be much more of a kind of
- 35:37who's going to try and cash in on the coverage.
- 35:41Again, the reason we did that second piece is
- 35:44it was a story in itself. We then had a look
- 35:51at the whole Node project commercial engine and
- 35:54realized there were six revenue streams, commissions
- 35:59from Advanced UK, ad hoc donations, both crypto
- 36:04and normal. There was the money from Spotify
- 36:11and possibly money from X probably. Not, well,
- 36:15the other platforms didn't claim that he was,
- 36:17they were earning on that. Um, and then obviously
- 36:20the crypto hype. So when the sort of 24, 48 hours
- 36:23of crypto hype was happening, uh, the node project
- 36:25shared their own kind of wallet. So they did
- 36:28kind of cash in it to some extent on that or
- 36:30at least appeared to. So I think, yeah, it, it
- 36:34made the. It almost made the, um, hateful kind
- 36:39of side of all this and the kind of, um, yeah,
- 36:44sort of, um, political side secondary to the,
- 36:48um, economic side, I think. And the, the commercial
- 36:51side almost became the more interesting one because
- 36:54again, we didn't, we don't know how political
- 36:57or how apolitical even, uh, the Node project
- 36:59and its actors are. And again, it's something
- 37:02we've seen before. My colleague Niamh published
- 37:04a story. um, late last year about, uh, individual
- 37:07in Sri Lanka who was making a lot of money, um,
- 37:11making kind of, uh, AI slop kind of videos targeting,
- 37:16um, you know, relatively racist videos targeting,
- 37:20um, UK audiences. And not only kind of, he was
- 37:23making and distributing them and cashing in on
- 37:25that, but he had a kind of, um, program or kind
- 37:29of Academy, you can call it, to teach others
- 37:31to do it and go viral and make money. So it's,
- 37:34yeah, the incentives to do this are very clearly
- 37:37financial and you don't need to be a holistically
- 37:40aligned, ideologically aligned person to do this.
- 37:44So it really could be anyone. So I think that's
- 37:46something I'm thinking about more going forward.
- 37:50It's a money -making machine. Interesting. Hexnaught
- 37:54asked earlier, Really great work from Effie.
- 37:57Is there any indication of this type of usage
- 38:00of AI propaganda in a highly targeted manner?
- 38:03I'm effectively thinking of the combination of
- 38:06voter targeting based on area, interest and specific
- 38:09propaganda. Edie, do we see a different Danny
- 38:11Bones type for users in Belfast versus Cardiff
- 38:14versus London? Ooh, that's a very good, yeah,
- 38:19that's a great question. The only, yeah, as I
- 38:23kind of said earlier, the only indication that
- 38:25there are kind of possibly different, different
- 38:30Danny Bones for different audiences are those,
- 38:32um, kind of different digital skins, if you will,
- 38:35that he, that the creators will give him. And
- 38:37I do think there is a sense that they're doing
- 38:39that on purpose to, so as to not alienate, um,
- 38:43part of his audience who clearly are not into
- 38:46like UK grime and UK drill. but are more on the
- 38:51Christian side of things. And then thirdly, the
- 38:55kind of more riot, like overtly political stuff.
- 39:00So I think there's definitely kind of slices
- 39:04of his audience that he is trying to appeal to
- 39:08maybe all at once. It would be really interesting
- 39:11actually, I think, yeah, to see where those,
- 39:14I mean, the Metta ad data could only really give
- 39:17us so much in terms of like how granular that
- 39:20is. Obviously Metta used to be better and I think
- 39:25other platforms are pretty rubbish in terms of
- 39:28targeting, but yeah, no, I think going forward
- 39:32with other elections coming up, you know, midterms
- 39:35in the US and May elections here, it would be
- 39:38really interesting to to have a look at that
- 39:41kind of data and, you know, maybe set up some
- 39:43kind of profiles based in those places to see
- 39:46if different types fetch different kind of profiles,
- 39:50so to speak. There's been a bit of chatter in
- 39:55the chat about whether you saw any evidence towards
- 39:58or any evidence that dismissed a theory that
- 40:01this could have any foreign influence involvement.
- 40:06Often, you know, you see AI propaganda campaigns
- 40:10are coming from foreign sources. Is this just
- 40:14a UK based operation or have you seen any indication
- 40:19that it could be wider field as well? Yeah, I
- 40:22think it's such a hard thing to attribute and
- 40:26going off the word of the Node project, I wasn't
- 40:30keen to like take their word as final. They said
- 40:34they were based in the UK or he, it, whatever,
- 40:36said they were based in the UK. Fine. AJ, as
- 40:41far as I could tell, is also UK based. Advanced
- 40:45UK, Ben Habib himself said he'd met them or had
- 40:49met people who are involved in the Node project
- 40:52and that they were based up north. So increasingly
- 40:57as I was going through this, my hypothesis went
- 41:01further and further away from this being a foreign
- 41:03interference situation. That's not just it, but
- 41:07again, like the whole kind of node project set
- 41:09up and the way that they allude to themselves
- 41:12is that like, this could be one node of like
- 41:15multiple different, um, different kind of, um,
- 41:20different nodes. And again, it's a very kind
- 41:23of nascent operation only starting November.
- 41:26The Danny Bones character is the only kind of,
- 41:28you know, is that kind of, um, proof of concept
- 41:31potentially. And that could be Danny Bones for,
- 41:35for, for other jurisdictions and other kind of
- 41:39localities. There is no indication directly of
- 41:45it being a foreign thing. I also just think there's
- 41:47a hunch that whoever's behind it is so tapped
- 41:50into the minutiae of UK news and not in a kind
- 41:54of way that anyone outside the UK could just
- 41:58tap into, oh, we've got a kind of we've got a
- 42:03lot of backlash towards like small boats or whatever,
- 42:05but like very, very kind of hyper local news
- 42:08and stuff like that. Again, doesn't mean it couldn't
- 42:10be a very sophisticated and politically aligned,
- 42:13you know, for an actor, but that was another
- 42:15kind of heuristic, I suppose. Yeah, it does really
- 42:20speak to a lot of British signals, especially
- 42:24to do with the far right in the UK. If you are
- 42:28interested in learning a little bit more about
- 42:30foreign influence operations and disinformation
- 42:33campaigns, we did speak to DoubleThink Labs Jasper
- 42:36Hewitt, I think last year or the year before
- 42:40on the stage talks about Chinese influence operations
- 42:43and disinformation campaigns. So I just put the
- 42:46link to that in the chat in case you want to
- 42:48listen back to that. It's interesting that they
- 42:51are based in the UK but aren't on Companies House.
- 42:54That's an interesting question. as to why they're
- 42:58not there. But I'm sure you might explore that
- 43:02in your upcoming piece. We had a simple question,
- 43:08they said it earlier in the chat. Did you see
- 43:11any evidence that people believed Danny Bones
- 43:13was real? Did anyone seem to know it was fake
- 43:17and not care? I'm curious about whether we're
- 43:19moving towards a time where authenticity doesn't
- 43:23matter as much as production value and appeal
- 43:25to people's own biases. No, I love that point.
- 43:30Regardless of how real he appears, there is still
- 43:38a compelling character there. There's catchy
- 43:41songs that get stuck in your head that maybe
- 43:43then filter into your unconscious biases. I remember
- 43:48when he got banned from TikTok because we didn't
- 43:51report him, but we asked TikTok for a right of
- 43:52reply. I kind of felt sorry for him, the weird
- 43:55way, because he did this really... Anyways, I
- 43:59was really anthropomorphizing him, despite knowing
- 44:03how synthetic he was. And in terms of the first
- 44:07part of your question about were there people
- 44:10that genuinely thought he was real? Yes, absolutely.
- 44:15Most people that asked me about this initially
- 44:16is, is this guy real? Who is this guy? Is he
- 44:20real? So that's been something to really reckon
- 44:25with. And again, for reporting as well, to just
- 44:28make that explicit. What's been interesting as
- 44:35well is the way he will stitch together footage
- 44:38that is real. Again, because he's sort of commentating
- 44:43on the day's news, he'll stitch together like
- 44:45a normal politician or activist might, stitch
- 44:48together real footage. very sophisticatedly place
- 44:52himself, the avatar, in that space. So that's
- 44:55like Trafalgar Square or something like that.
- 44:59So yeah, I wouldn't blame anyone who would kind
- 45:01of question whether or not he was real. And I
- 45:04think particularly, yeah, as I've said before,
- 45:07the music side of things, I'm sure there are
- 45:09people who are listening to him on Spotify and
- 45:12have no idea that there's like a sort of AI generated
- 45:16persona behind him. And same with Advanced UK,
- 45:21I don't. I think they were pretty convinced by
- 45:23it when I spoke to them. Oh, you think Advanced
- 45:26UK thinks he's a real artist? No, I think they
- 45:30were just very impressed, as they should be.
- 45:32I think they were just like, this is incredible,
- 45:35incredible air. I was about to say, I think someone
- 45:39needs to chat to them with those. They think
- 45:41they're famous for a real creator. You mentioned
- 45:44that you'd reported it just now to platforms
- 45:46like TikTok and Instagram, right? And they both
- 45:50took action. Do you think current moderation
- 45:53systems are equipped for this type of content?
- 45:56And Spotify, I'm guessing you did report to that
- 45:59they didn't take a step. Why was that? Yeah,
- 46:05we didn't report in a takedown way to any of
- 46:08the platforms. We wouldn't ever do that as journalists.
- 46:12We were just generally interested in what's their
- 46:15policies on both AI -generated influences like
- 46:18this, on disclosure, on AI labeling, and on the
- 46:22political links, plus a lot of the more egregious
- 46:26hateful content. It was interesting seeing the
- 46:30array of or the range of responsiveness from
- 46:34the different platforms. So yeah, TikTok completely
- 46:36banned the account straight away, which was a
- 46:38surprise, I think. You can speculate about why,
- 46:41but I think maybe because all of the social media
- 46:43companies are under a lot of scrutiny now with
- 46:45the kind of litigation in America about addiction
- 46:51and social media harms, possibly. Instagram took
- 46:55down three of the videos that I've flagged. YouTube...
- 46:59didn't take anything down, but they added AI
- 47:02disclosure labels, which was interesting and
- 47:05not quite the point. YouTube have demonetized
- 47:11AI generated videos. Not because of this story,
- 47:16but that was sort of earlier in the year. X didn't
- 47:18get back to us, surprise, surprise. Spotify,
- 47:21and I think this is reasonable from Spotify.
- 47:24Spotify didn't act and What Spotify are dealing
- 47:28with content wise are just the songs, which aren't
- 47:30necessarily like overtly racist or Islamophobic
- 47:34or anything. It's the content, which is kind
- 47:36of the more on the problematic side of things.
- 47:40So Spotify, I had an interesting conversation
- 47:42with them where they said, look, there's a whole
- 47:45spectrum of artists using AI and not using AI.
- 47:52there's no way to tell whether an artist necessarily
- 47:55is using AI, which is quite scary. Um, and that
- 47:57some artists, you know, they are real, but are
- 47:59using AI in their, in their day -to -day kind
- 48:02of production, um, uh, methods just like, you
- 48:06know, we all are at work and things like that.
- 48:08So yeah, I think Spotify quite lacks, um, when
- 48:11it comes to AI, but I think in terms of moderating
- 48:14the content, it is really difficult to moderate,
- 48:16um, music and audio and like more so I would
- 48:21say than video just because a lot of the nuance
- 48:24and yeah a lot of the meaning can kind of get
- 48:28lost in like um kind of rhetoric and you know
- 48:33there's then this plausible deniability about
- 48:36like oh maybe you didn't actually mean that because
- 48:38it's a rap song where you know there's lots of
- 48:40it's quite normal to use a slur or it's quite
- 48:42normal to use like language that incites violence
- 48:45type thing uh whereas it would be much more easy
- 48:48to moderate them all. traditional kind of someone
- 48:51giving a hot take on YouTube or something. Yeah,
- 48:55that's a really interesting point about where
- 48:57the lines are when it comes to music. For example,
- 49:01the Indian AI generated imagery that was created
- 49:05to generate hate around the elections that I
- 49:08talked about earlier that we recently released
- 49:10an investigation on. All of that was still imagery
- 49:13and video imagery that clearly contained very
- 49:18hateful messaging and was rightly in some cases
- 49:24taken down from platforms. But yeah, as you're
- 49:27saying in music, the lines are a little bit more
- 49:31blurred and less clear. Somebody shared earlier
- 49:35actually a case, another case where an AI generated
- 49:38band had released two albums on Spotify before
- 49:43they were kind of, before they admitted that
- 49:45they were completely air -generated and they
- 49:47got over 1 million views, listens. Really interesting
- 49:52that Spotify is kind of finding themselves in
- 49:54this kind of hole. You mentioned that the lyrics
- 49:59to Danny Bones' songs aren't... too explicit.
- 50:02What kind of lines are we, what kind of things
- 50:04is he talking about specifically? And where do
- 50:08you think the lines between kind of creative
- 50:12expression and political manipulation, where
- 50:15can we draw the line when AI is involved with
- 50:18that? Yeah, I'm not sure AI changes the line
- 50:22at all. I think AI just makes the accountability
- 50:26much more murky. I think where Danny Bones' music
- 50:30is, I mean, okay, let's say, it is worth saying,
- 50:34I think it has got, and that clip I showed at
- 50:36the beginning, it has got a little bit more crossing
- 50:38the line, I think. So like, you know, more explicitly
- 50:42mentioning, you know, more explicit criticisms
- 50:45of immigrants and, you know, the fact that we
- 50:49are handing quotes, well, I'm not going to directly
- 50:51quote, but like handing out benefits to migrants
- 50:54who don't benefit the country type thing and
- 51:00getting much more overtly political. I think,
- 51:04again, it's the lyrics, but what Spotify I think
- 51:06would say is the lyrics by themselves and the
- 51:09songs by themselves without the music videos,
- 51:12which is kind of a separate beast to Danny Bones
- 51:16short form content, are relatively harmless.
- 51:21The music videos and the songs together, I would
- 51:24say, is where you can kind of pick up on the
- 51:28implications he's making in his songs. I think
- 51:32he's in his right to be very critical of the
- 51:37government and that's totally fine. There's a
- 51:41lot of things he says which I think we'd all
- 51:43agree with. There's, yeah, there's always, you
- 51:49know, like, this isn't to say, like, he shouldn't
- 51:54have kind of free speech, etc. But I think there
- 51:58is, again, yeah, with an AI musician, there's,
- 52:05yeah, there's two levels, or there's two kind
- 52:07of layers of accountability that are more difficult,
- 52:10both kind of, who do you call out if something
- 52:12does? across the line, especially if a party
- 52:16has paid for it. Like, is the party going to
- 52:19take the responsibility? Is the platform, is
- 52:22the musician, is the creator? It's very unclear.
- 52:27And the second one being, well, it's music. You
- 52:30know, it's a genre that can evoke racial slurs
- 52:36or, you know. homophobic slurs, et cetera, which
- 52:41do appear at times in his music. But again, it
- 52:45hits a minefield and I think Spotify and other
- 52:49distributors will have to think carefully about
- 52:52whether they want to keep allowing this kind
- 52:56of stuff to maybe even take over human artists
- 53:00on the platform. I'm not saying that's happened,
- 53:01I don't know the stats, but I think YouTube made
- 53:04a conscious decision to stop monetizing AI. videos.
- 53:09And again, that might be completely commercial
- 53:11as opposed to anything ethical, but like, you
- 53:13know, you're just, if you just have an onslaught
- 53:15of AI slot, then you're not going to get the
- 53:20views you want to get. So it might be something
- 53:22we, I think it'd be interesting to look out for
- 53:24in the next couple months or year or so. Yeah.
- 53:28I think it's interesting how throughout this
- 53:31talk we've really personified this AI. entity,
- 53:36calling in him, you know, talking about someone's
- 53:39just put in the chat. Does an AI entity have
- 53:41a right to free speech though? All these questions
- 53:44are things that we don't necessarily have the
- 53:46answers to. And we also don't really know, right,
- 53:48how involved Advanced UK were in regards to the
- 53:52content of the videos. They could have commissioned
- 53:55something, but we're not sure how involved they
- 53:58were in the actual creation, just involved in
- 54:01the payment and the use of. It's super interesting
- 54:06the way that these lines are drawn and how we're
- 54:10talking about this kind of entity that has had
- 54:13some political sway. If we fast forward five
- 54:17years or even 10, what does the Danny Bones playbook
- 54:22look like for maturity to you? What are your
- 54:25concerns there? What could this mold into? I
- 54:30think... even in a year like AI moves so quickly
- 54:34as does kind of, well, I think especially the
- 54:37right are very kind of more willing already to
- 54:41adapt to like newer types of political influence
- 54:46and like campaigning and they have been much
- 54:49more successful in engaging and using AI. I think
- 54:53like what's to say that human influences will
- 54:56kind of just be totally totally replaced by these
- 55:01AI avatars who are like compelling, who have
- 55:04a kind of backstory, who have a believable set
- 55:07of political and believable and sort of consistent
- 55:11set of sort of values and, you know, to such
- 55:17way that, yeah, we have ended up literally personifying
- 55:19him it. And, you know, obviously that you know,
- 55:25let's assume AI continues the way it is, we'll
- 55:28continue to get cheaper, faster, even automated.
- 55:33There won't really need to be a human in the
- 55:35loop to, to, to, for that kind of thing. And
- 55:39I would say, yeah, as we mentioned a bit, like
- 55:41I think it will, the next frontier might be like
- 55:45hyper personalizing it and maybe, you know, targeting
- 55:48becoming, you know, sort of so strong that, you
- 55:52know, we're all getting a sort of a different
- 55:56version of an influencer or that we don't even,
- 56:01you know, that there isn't even a kind of one
- 56:03influencer that we're seeing kind of explode,
- 56:06but actually kind of a tailor -made kind of,
- 56:10yeah, influencer that our algorithm picks off
- 56:13on. So I think, yeah, we can obviously like look
- 56:16out for stuff and just keep doing like... keep
- 56:21doing good journalism and flagging these cases,
- 56:25but not platforming them if we don't have to.
- 56:31Absolutely. Somebody just shared that AI generated
- 56:34content is generally afford the same first amendment
- 56:37protections as content created by people, corporations
- 56:40and other legal entities, but it's also subject
- 56:42to the same established limits on speech in the
- 56:44US. So it really depends on the country in question,
- 56:47which is really interesting. And absolutely,
- 56:50you were saying, report it, flag it where you
- 56:52see it. But yeah, try not to amplify it so much.
- 56:56That is an issue that Bellingcat faces every
- 56:58day as we're often finding deep fakes and things
- 57:01like that coming through social media, trying
- 57:04not to amplify the original post. Just as a final
- 57:09point. What would be your advice to someone who
- 57:13may be familiar with a case like the Danny Bones
- 57:16case? What would be your advice for first steps
- 57:20if somebody, a researcher or a journalist listening
- 57:22to this has found something similar? I would
- 57:25say, yeah, do all the forensic digging you can
- 57:31just on the mainstream platforms. I think the
- 57:36Danny Bones case was relatively... interesting
- 57:39in that there was all I kind of needed on those
- 57:43big mainstream platforms, but I think definitely
- 57:47take a look on, yeah, go on the telegrams, go
- 57:50elsewhere, because yeah, what I saw in the investigation
- 57:54is once they were banned from TikTok, there was
- 57:56a very swift, ready move to kind of, well, to
- 58:00X, which again, that's pretty mainstream, but
- 58:03there's now telegrams. So there is that kind
- 58:05of like... predictable trajectory of where these
- 58:09people end up. So I'd say you can maybe get ahead
- 58:13of the curve there. I think Facebook groups as
- 58:16well, see which Facebook groups they're in or
- 58:19maybe if you know the creator behind it, see
- 58:22what groups their content is being shared in.
- 58:26I think that's always interesting to get a sense
- 58:27of both who they're targeting but who is finding
- 58:31this stuff just interesting organically. I would
- 58:36say make sure you keep a record of everything.
- 58:38And if that is, you know, one of these, um, kind
- 58:42of screen capture type useful, um, nifty tools,
- 58:46that's great. But if you just have to go through
- 58:48and manually screen record every single TikTok
- 58:50then so be it, because I was very, I was very
- 58:53glad I did that because when the TikTok account
- 58:55was banned and the story had so much of the TikTok
- 58:58content. in it that we were referring to. It
- 59:01was very, it was a relief to have those kind
- 59:03of there and also then to kind of present the
- 59:06case as evidence to, you know, the Electoral
- 59:09Commission, the Advertising Sounds Authority,
- 59:11the relevant people. It was, we had all the documents,
- 59:14evidence, we weren't just going off kind of,
- 59:16you know, memory. Yeah, sadly when one platform
- 59:21door closes, another platform door opens for
- 59:25these groups. I shared in the chat, you don't
- 59:28have to manually save everything. We do have
- 59:31the Bellingcat auto -archiver, which is a tool
- 59:33that you can use. It works on most social platforms,
- 59:37not all, but most. So do have a look at that
- 59:40and make use of it. There's a really useful guide
- 59:43to it on our website, which I've just linked
- 59:46to. Effie, thank you so much for the fantastic
- 59:49talk today. People have been fascinated by what
- 59:52you've got to say. If anybody wants to get in
- 59:54touch with you, maybe they have a lead for you,
- 59:56maybe they want to just chat to you a little
- 59:59bit more about the investigation. Where can they
- 1:00:01find you? How can they reach out to you? I'm
- 1:00:04on LinkedIn, EffieWeb, so E -F -F -I -E -Web.
- 1:00:08I think that would be the best place. I'm also
- 1:00:11on Blue Sky, although I'm trying to be on memoir.
- 1:00:16I'm also on Signal at EFW .40. So either of those
- 1:00:23three. Brilliant. I've just linked to your LinkedIn
- 1:00:25in the chats. Please do make a point of saving
- 1:00:30that. I'll also include it in the description
- 1:00:32of this podcast if you're fine with that. But
- 1:00:36yeah, make sure that you read Effie's pieces
- 1:00:38and the follow -up piece that we're all eager
- 1:00:41to read now. And I can't thank you enough for
- 1:00:44taking time out to chat today. We'll be back
- 1:00:46in two weeks' time with another stage talk. But
- 1:00:48for now, thank you everybody for listening. Great.
- 1:00:51Thanks, Raleigh. Thank you for listening to the
- 1:00:53stage talk. If you'd like to catch a stage talk
- 1:00:56live where you you can ask the guest questions,
- 1:01:00join the Bellingcat Discord server by visiting
- 1:01:02www .discord .gg slash Bellingcat. The music
- 1:01:08you've heard is titled Dawn by Newer Self and
- 1:01:12is courtesy of Artlist.