Latest / Bloomberg Law / Are Those Migrant Flights Legal?
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is bloombird law with June Brusso from Bloomberg radio.
- 0:09Speaker 1: Florida Governor Ron de Santis is doubling down on the
- 0:12Speaker 1: flights he chartered to send fifty undocumented immigrants from Texas
- 0:17Speaker 1: to Martha's Vineyard, saying they won't be the last. We
- 0:20Speaker 1: have to go and figure out. Okay, who are those
- 0:22Speaker 1: people likely to be? And if you can do it
- 0:25Speaker 1: at the source and divert to sanctuary jurisdictions, the chance
- 0:28Speaker 1: they end up in Florida's much less. But the sheriff
- 0:31Speaker 1: of the Texas County those immigrants were taken from, Javier Salazar,
- 0:36Speaker 1: says he's starting a criminal investigation. What infuriates me the
- 0:40Speaker 1: most about this case is that here we have forty
- 0:43Speaker 1: eight people that are already on on hard times right
- 0:46Speaker 1: they are here legally in our country. At that point,
- 0:50Speaker 1: they have every right to be where they are and
- 0:52Speaker 1: I believe that they were preyed upon. Somebody came from
- 0:55Speaker 1: out of state, preyed upon these people Um lured them
- 0:59Speaker 1: with promises of a better life, which is what they're
- 1:01Speaker 1: absolutely looking for. My Guest Is Immigration Law Expert Jack Chin,
- 1:06Speaker 1: a professor at U C Davis Law School. There have
- 1:09Speaker 1: been a record number of crossings at the southern border.
- 1:12Speaker 1: Apprehensions top two million for the first time ever. Is
- 1:17Speaker 1: this increase the result of Biden's immigration policies? Well, I
- 1:22Speaker 1: think the word has gotten around that it is more
- 1:27Speaker 1: possible to exercise your rights at the border than it
- 1:30Speaker 1: used to be and that some people are going to
- 1:32Speaker 1: be allowed in to have their asylum claims or other
- 1:35Speaker 1: claims for immigration status heard. So I think to some
- 1:40Speaker 1: extent it may be the result of more humane policies
- 1:44Speaker 1: under this administration than the last one. But I think
- 1:48Speaker 1: the main issue is that there's a lot of people
- 1:52Speaker 1: in a lot of trouble who are looking for a
- 1:56Speaker 1: safe place to live and work and to avoid the
- 2:01Speaker 1: economic and political and environmental problems that exist where they live.
- 2:06Speaker 1: The reason that there's a lot of people trying to
- 2:07Speaker 1: get to the United States and other countries is that
- 2:10Speaker 1: there are a lot of people who are in trouble
- 2:12Speaker 1: where they live now. So one million undocumented immigrants have
- 2:17Speaker 1: been allowed into the country legally. Are Most of those
- 2:21Speaker 1: seeking asylum. I believe that's right that if there's no
- 2:28Speaker 1: claim for lawful status, either based on some sort of
- 2:33Speaker 1: temporary or permanent immigration status as citizenship or asylum. They're
- 2:37Speaker 1: not going to let that many people in. Certain people
- 2:40Speaker 1: are paroled in temporarily for medical treatment and the other
- 2:43Speaker 1: small numbers and limited categories of people who get in temporarily.
- 2:47Speaker 1: But basically that's the rational. So asylum itself is a
- 2:53Speaker 1: long shot, isn't it? But it's easy to get past
- 2:56Speaker 1: the first part of the process, which is the credible
- 2:59Speaker 1: fear interview. Certainly there are a number of steps that
- 3:03Speaker 1: an applicant has to pass through and asylum probably is
- 3:07Speaker 1: a long shot for a lot of the people that
- 3:09Speaker 1: we're talking about, because you don't get asylum, you don't
- 3:13Speaker 1: get refugee status simply because your conditions are desperate at home.
- 3:19Speaker 1: has to be based on a fear of persecution for
- 3:22Speaker 1: one of a limited number of reasons, and simply environmental
- 3:28Speaker 1: disaster or economic disaster in and of itself isn't sufficient
- 3:34Speaker 1: to get you asylum. On the other hand, a lot
- 3:38Speaker 1: of people who are living in very difficult conditions at home.
- 3:41Speaker 1: It's not simply the economy or the environment. It also
- 3:46Speaker 1: gives rise to social problems, gangs, violence and other challenges
- 3:55Speaker 1: to living any sort of normal life that could fit
- 3:58Speaker 1: into the recognized asylent categories. So, turning now to current events,
- 4:06Speaker 1: last Wednesday Florida's governor, Rhond Santa's, chartered to planes and
- 4:11Speaker 1: sent about fifty migrants, men, women and children out of Texas,
- 4:16Speaker 1: which is about seven hundred miles from the Florida state line,
- 4:20Speaker 1: to Martha's Vineyard. Is there anything wrong with that legally? Well,
- 4:25Speaker 1: there might be a few things wrong with that legally.
- 4:28Speaker 1: One is you can't trick people into going somewhere, even
- 4:33Speaker 1: if you're the government. You can't say, for example, if
- 4:37Speaker 1: you get on this bus, drive to where it's going,
- 4:40Speaker 1: there'll be a job waiting for you. If there isn't
- 4:42Speaker 1: a job waiting for you. You can't deceive people. You
- 4:46Speaker 1: also can't force people to go where they don't want
- 4:49Speaker 1: to go, and so it's really going to depend on
- 4:51Speaker 1: what the underlying facts are. How and why did these
- 4:54Speaker 1: people get on the plane? What were they told? And
- 4:58Speaker 1: I think they're very well might have been conceivably some
- 5:02Speaker 1: deception involved, because I think a lot of people would
- 5:06Speaker 1: not want to just get on a plane and go
- 5:08Speaker 1: to Martha's vineyard with no place to stay and no
- 5:12Speaker 1: job and no reasonable prospect of any sort of settled situation.
- 5:18Speaker 1: So one wonders what those people were told or if
- 5:21Speaker 1: they voluntarily went on that particular journey. But if they
- 5:25Speaker 1: did voluntarily go and they were told more or less
- 5:29Speaker 1: what was going to happen to them when they got there,
- 5:32Speaker 1: then it's not necessarily a criminal offense or a even
- 5:37Speaker 1: necessarily a civil violation on the part of the people
- 5:40Speaker 1: who organized that particular excursion. That being said, there are
- 5:45Speaker 1: state interests here and it's not clear to me that
- 5:49Speaker 1: states have the right, even voluntarily, to scoop up their undesirable,
- 5:55Speaker 1: and here I'm air quotes, supposedly undesirable residents and ship
- 6:02Speaker 1: them to other states. For example, there's a lot of
- 6:06Speaker 1: history of patient dumping and of poor people dumping, and
- 6:14Speaker 1: we can imagine a situation where in any state there
- 6:19Speaker 1: might be sick people who are poor and use public hospitals.
- 6:25Speaker 1: And would it be legal for the government to say,
- 6:29Speaker 1: you know, we can identify a group of people, each
- 6:32Speaker 1: of whom uses hundreds of thousands of dollars of publicly
- 6:35Speaker 1: funded healthcare every year, and what we're gonna do is
- 6:38Speaker 1: we're going to tell them uh that we will give
- 6:41Speaker 1: each of them five thousand dollars if they get on
- 6:45Speaker 1: an airplane and are willing to be flown to another
- 6:48Speaker 1: state and there will come back. And assuming that those
- 6:51Speaker 1: people were told the truth about what was going to happen,
- 6:53Speaker 1: that wouldn't be a crime, it wouldn't be a civil
- 6:55Speaker 1: violation as to them, but it would be a big
- 6:59Speaker 1: problem state to state. We can't have a system where
- 7:03Speaker 1: states are taking, for example, their high cost medical patients or,
- 7:11Speaker 1: to take another example, people who commit crimes and are dangerous,
- 7:16Speaker 1: and just ship them to other states and say this
- 7:21Speaker 1: can be a situation that some other place can deal with.
- 7:26Speaker 1: That would not be a good policy for the United
- 7:28Speaker 1: States to have where each state was constantly trying to
- 7:32Speaker 1: ship it's supposedly undesirable residents to other places. Uh, and
- 7:39Speaker 1: we don't really do that now for good reason. And
- 7:44Speaker 1: if what's going on here, as it seems to be,
- 7:48Speaker 1: is that one state is trying to impose costs on
- 7:50Speaker 1: another state, I mean a lot of things are going
- 7:53Speaker 1: on here, then the core thing is a political stunt
- 7:56Speaker 1: that involves using people as pawns in a very humane way.
- 8:01Speaker 1: But another thing that seems to be going on is
- 8:04Speaker 1: that some states are trying to shift costs to other
- 8:07Speaker 1: states and that is something that in our federal system
- 8:11Speaker 1: very well might be illegal. That's never been litigated, has it?
- 8:15Speaker 1: There are instances that you mentioned in the past of
- 8:18Speaker 1: states shipping homeless people to other states. Has that ever
- 8:22Speaker 1: been litigated, though? Well, what's what's been litigated is the
- 8:26Speaker 1: flip side of it. Uh, there's a famous case called
- 8:30Speaker 1: Edwards versus California from the U S Supreme Court in
- 8:33Speaker 1: Nineteen one where California refused to allow certain allegedly poor
- 8:40Speaker 1: people to come into California and the Supreme Court said
- 8:45Speaker 1: this isn't acceptable, and part of it was the individual's
- 8:48Speaker 1: right to travel, but part of it was the state
- 8:50Speaker 1: to state relations that one state can't say this is
- 8:54Speaker 1: going to be your problem and not my problem. And
- 8:56Speaker 1: so you know, certain aspects of it have been laid litigated.
- 9:01Speaker 1: Is there a case on all fours that's exactly like this?
- 9:05Speaker 1: Not To my knowledge. Not To my knowledge, and I
- 9:07Speaker 1: think the reason is that every reasonable person knows that
- 9:11Speaker 1: this can only be a stunt because it wouldn't be
- 9:14Speaker 1: workable as a long term, consistent policy. You know, if
- 9:19Speaker 1: states started playing tip for tat, you know that would
- 9:22Speaker 1: be a very unpleasant situation and ultimately the states would
- 9:25Speaker 1: have to say, okay, okay, you know, we're going to
- 9:28Speaker 1: stop doing this because it would be costly and harmful
- 9:32Speaker 1: to the individuals involved and embarrassing. So it's not really
- 9:36Speaker 1: something that could be contemplated as an ongoing policy. So
- 9:40Speaker 1: this is uh, this is a prank and it's working
- 9:43Speaker 1: because it certainly has gotten a publicity that it's architects desired.
- 9:48Speaker 1: There is evidence there were brochures, there's evidence that the
- 9:52Speaker 1: migrants were falsely promised cash, work opportunities, schooling for children.
- 9:57Speaker 1: A lawyer's group for about thirty of them said that
- 10:00Speaker 1: our clients were induced to board planes and cross state
- 10:03Speaker 1: lines under false pretenses. The Sheriff of Bear County is
- 10:08Speaker 1: starting a criminal investigation, but he said he didn't know
- 10:11Speaker 1: exactly what laws were involved, and a Massachusetts State lawmaker
- 10:16Speaker 1: has requested a federal human trafficking investigation. I don't know
- 10:20Speaker 1: if this is another stunt to say that they're going
- 10:23Speaker 1: to criminally investigate. Well, as I say, I don't think
- 10:28Speaker 1: that you can tell people hey, travel from here to there,
- 10:31Speaker 1: spend your time doing that and when you get there
- 10:35Speaker 1: there will be these benefits for you there will be
- 10:38Speaker 1: these economic advantages for you. I don't think that you
- 10:42Speaker 1: can do that legally. I think that's fraud and the
- 10:46Speaker 1: exact crime that would it would be in different states,
- 10:50Speaker 1: you know, would vary from place to place, but I'm
- 10:53Speaker 1: willing to bet that there's no state where it's where
- 10:55Speaker 1: it's legal to induce people to spend their time and
- 11:00Speaker 1: money two do a bunch of things when the person
- 11:05Speaker 1: who induces that conduct has no intention of coming through
- 11:08Speaker 1: or knows that it won't come through, it's fraud in
- 11:12Speaker 1: one flavor or another. If that's the way that it happened,
- 11:15Speaker 1: and I personally don't know that, but if that's the
- 11:18Speaker 1: way that happened, that it happened, then it's fraud and
- 11:22Speaker 1: it very well might subject to the people who carried
- 11:25Speaker 1: that out to criminal liability. You know, there's a lot
- 11:29Speaker 1: of considerations, a lot of steps. Just like there's a
- 11:32Speaker 1: lot of steps between showing up at the border and
- 11:34Speaker 1: getting asylum. There's a lot of steps between an allegation
- 11:38Speaker 1: of criminal wrongdoing and somebody being convicted of a crime.
- 11:41Speaker 1: But if I had been asked, as a lawyer, is
- 11:44Speaker 1: it a good idea to have people travel from state
- 11:48Speaker 1: to state on an airplane that I've paid for based
- 11:52Speaker 1: on false pretenses. I'd say no, that that creates a
- 11:56Speaker 1: legal risk for inducing people to do things based on
- 12:00Speaker 1: false pretenses and you shouldn't do it because you might
- 12:02Speaker 1: be charged with a crime. I should point out that
- 12:06Speaker 1: governor to Santis has said that they knew what they
- 12:09Speaker 1: were doing. They signed waivers. I read that if they
- 12:14Speaker 1: were lured onto the planes that that could that that
- 12:18Speaker 1: would mean that there are crime victim and that would
- 12:20Speaker 1: automatically qualify them for a visa. I don't think it's
- 12:25Speaker 1: quite that simple, but certainly some victims of crime, if
- 12:30Speaker 1: they participate in an investigation as witnesses, there's a possibility
- 12:35Speaker 1: that they can get what's called you visa, but they're,
- 12:38Speaker 1: you know, substantial requirements, including a requirement of having suffered
- 12:43Speaker 1: physical or mental harm, and it only applies to certain
- 12:47Speaker 1: offenses and you know it's going to be a complicated process.
- 12:53Speaker 1: Texas governor has sent something like eleven thousand migrants from
- 12:57Speaker 1: Texas to Chicago, New York and Wash Ington, and the
- 13:00Speaker 1: mayors of those cities have said it's a crisis and
- 13:03Speaker 1: asked for the federal government to step in. Shouldn't the
- 13:06Speaker 1: federal governments step in here. I think the federal government
- 13:10Speaker 1: is being careful here not to fan the flames of
- 13:15Speaker 1: political controversy and I do think that the federal government
- 13:20Speaker 1: should take responsibility for managing people who are here applying
- 13:26Speaker 1: for asylum and refugee status. When we're dealing with overseas refugees,
- 13:30Speaker 1: there's a much more orderly procedure and there are destinations
- 13:35Speaker 1: and support systems. The Office of Refugee Resettlement is involved
- 13:39Speaker 1: and manages this, and it certainly would be helpful to
- 13:43Speaker 1: have something similar for people who show up at the border,
- 13:47Speaker 1: and an orderly process with a support system and a
- 13:50Speaker 1: protocol that would render some of these pranks and some
- 13:54Speaker 1: of these demonstrations unnecessary. But I don't think that it's
- 13:58Speaker 1: going to go on forever, I really don't. I think
- 14:00Speaker 1: there's going to be litigation. I think at some point
- 14:04Speaker 1: a state or the federal government is gonna find some
- 14:08Speaker 1: way to get involved and this is not going to
- 14:13Speaker 1: keep going in the way that it's been. At a minimum,
- 14:16Speaker 1: I would predict. I would bet you know, given the
- 14:19Speaker 1: lawyers are involved now, that there's going to be some
- 14:22Speaker 1: way to make sure that the individuals involved, the people
- 14:26Speaker 1: seeking asylum who are transported across the United States give
- 14:30Speaker 1: informed consent before they go. As I say, it seems
- 14:34Speaker 1: unlikely that they would have given informed consent as the
- 14:38Speaker 1: situation is now, because nobody wants to be driven somewhere
- 14:41Speaker 1: and dumped off with no support. That being said, to
- 14:45Speaker 1: the extent that the governors of Texas and Florida are
- 14:48Speaker 1: going to sanctuary jurisdictions, that does give them some cover
- 14:53Speaker 1: because they can say, look, these places said that they
- 14:57Speaker 1: wanted unauthorized migrants or people seeking a side Lem and
- 15:00Speaker 1: we're just giving them what they asked for. And so
- 15:05Speaker 1: I think that circumstance, to the extent that you have
- 15:07Speaker 1: a state legislature or a city council that's passed a
- 15:10Speaker 1: resolution that says we are a jurisdiction that protects unauthorized migrants, well,
- 15:17Speaker 1: that's going to fit into the argument of these governors.
- 15:21Speaker 1: So what happens? Let's say someone coming from Venezuela is
- 15:25Speaker 1: granted asylum, they're just left to their own devices at
- 15:29Speaker 1: that point. There is a widespread, if limited, network of
- 15:34Speaker 1: private humanitarian services available and there's a lot of people
- 15:38Speaker 1: out there in various communities who who try to help
- 15:41Speaker 1: people resettle. But as I understand it, what you get
- 15:45Speaker 1: when you get asylum is the right to stay in
- 15:47Speaker 1: the United States, but not necessarily a lot of benefits.
- 15:54Speaker 1: I think. What do you think about the possibility of
- 15:58Speaker 1: the human trafficking investigation? Is that going too far? Well,
- 16:03Speaker 1: I have no sympathy for these political stunts. I think
- 16:07Speaker 1: they're very inhumane. It doesn't strike me that it's at
- 16:11Speaker 1: the core of human trafficking or kidnapping if it's the
- 16:16Speaker 1: case that these people are not forced, and you know,
- 16:22Speaker 1: I wouldn't be surprised if some of them were coerced.
- 16:24Speaker 1: When we're talking about eleven th people, it does seem
- 16:28Speaker 1: pretty clear that a lot of them wouldn't have gone
- 16:31Speaker 1: if they had known what was really happening. But it
- 16:35Speaker 1: seems to me that the core of the deception isn't
- 16:39Speaker 1: that you're going to be forced to work or you're
- 16:40Speaker 1: going to be required to work even though you didn't
- 16:43Speaker 1: know what was really going to happen, that the core
- 16:46Speaker 1: of what's going on is that they were promised benefits
- 16:50Speaker 1: that that that they didn't get, but not so that
- 16:53Speaker 1: the people who were engaging in these stunts could obtain
- 16:56Speaker 1: their labor or services or anything like that. It doesn't
- 17:00Speaker 1: seem to me to be kidnapping or false imprisonment in
- 17:04Speaker 1: the sense of that they were held by force, they
- 17:07Speaker 1: were tricked into voluntarily going and that seems more like
- 17:11Speaker 1: fraud to me than kidnapping. And it doesn't seem like
- 17:14Speaker 1: human trafficking, because human trafficking has a connotation of people
- 17:19Speaker 1: who were forced to work, forced into sexual servitude, unlawfully confined,
- 17:26Speaker 1: that sort of thing. What's going on here is not
- 17:29Speaker 1: appetizing in any way, but it doesn't seem to me
- 17:32Speaker 1: that human trafficking is that is at the core of it.
- 17:37Speaker 1: We're dealing with people who were free at the beginning
- 17:39Speaker 1: of the trip and who were let loose at the
- 17:41Speaker 1: end of the trip. That's not exactly human trafficking as
- 17:45Speaker 1: I understand it. Thanks so much for being on the show, Jack.
- 17:48Speaker 1: That's Professor Jack Chin of U C Davis Law School.
- 17:53Speaker 1: After the U S Supreme Court throughout New York Central
- 17:57Speaker 1: Law that limited who could carry a handgun in public,
- 18:00Speaker 1: New York and other states rushed to pass legislation. New
- 18:04Speaker 1: York's band concealed weapons in most public places and increased
- 18:09Speaker 1: the requirements for obtaining concealed carry permit, for example by
- 18:13Speaker 1: requiring the list of social media accounts for the past
- 18:16Speaker 1: three years, four character references, sixteen hours of in person
- 18:21Speaker 1: training and two hours of live fire training. Though, federal
- 18:25Speaker 1: judge Glenn Suttaby denied a request to stop the law
- 18:28Speaker 1: from taking effect. His seventy eight page decision described at
- 18:32Speaker 1: length why he found the law to be unconstitutional. Joining
- 18:37Speaker 1: me as Andrew Willinger, executive director of the Duke's Center
- 18:40Speaker 1: for Firearms Law. So New York's new concealed carry law,
- 18:45Speaker 1: which was enacted pretty quickly after the Supreme Court's opinion,
- 18:49Speaker 1: is it almost as restrictive as the law of the
- 18:52Speaker 1: Supreme Court struck down. So what New York did very
- 18:56Speaker 1: shortly after the ruined decision came down is that it
- 19:00Speaker 1: revised its law to remove the specific aspect that the
- 19:05Speaker 1: supreme court had said was unconstitutional. So it removed this
- 19:08Speaker 1: requirement to show proper cause before one could obtain a
- 19:12Speaker 1: concealed carry license. But at the same time New York
- 19:16Speaker 1: took a number of steps to make its licensing regime
- 19:20Speaker 1: restrictive in other areas right. So it's sort of balanced
- 19:23Speaker 1: that out by adding a definition of good moral character
- 19:27Speaker 1: and then requiring certain submissions of applicants in order to
- 19:30Speaker 1: demonstrate good moral character. One aspect that got a lot
- 19:33Speaker 1: of attention is that the state also expanded its list
- 19:36Speaker 1: of sensitive places where guns are banned, so that list
- 19:39Speaker 1: became much longer. And so, you know, I think I
- 19:42Speaker 1: think you can say in New York, you know, address
- 19:45Speaker 1: the specific issue that was identified in brewing, which is
- 19:48Speaker 1: that a state can't require some kind of exceptional showing
- 19:52Speaker 1: by an applicant in order to obtain a concealed carry license.
- 19:56Speaker 1: But New York took other steps that were sort of
- 20:00Speaker 1: things that the court didn't provide clear guidance on and
- 20:02Speaker 1: brew in one way or the other. So in this
- 20:04Speaker 1: case the judge denied a request to stop the law
- 20:08Speaker 1: from going into effect, but then says the law could
- 20:11Speaker 1: be found unconstitutional. How does that make sense? Right, so
- 20:16Speaker 1: it is a little bit unusual what the judge did
- 20:18Speaker 1: in this case. The judge had sort of on a
- 20:21Speaker 1: on a very expedited schedule, briefing from the parties and
- 20:24Speaker 1: then had a hearing on the motion for a preliminary
- 20:29Speaker 1: injunction of this New New York law. And the reason
- 20:32Speaker 1: for that is that the law was said to go
- 20:34Speaker 1: into effect on September one. So this all happened in
- 20:37Speaker 1: a very short time period. And what the judge did
- 20:40Speaker 1: was he ultimately found that there was no standing to
- 20:44Speaker 1: challenge the law and the case was dismissed on those grounds.
- 20:48Speaker 1: But the judge also included about twenty or twenty five
- 20:51Speaker 1: pages of analysis of the likelihood of success on the
- 20:55Speaker 1: merits if the plaintiffs had standing. And what he said is,
- 20:59Speaker 1: you know, I'm include doing this because it could be
- 21:02Speaker 1: that the decision is appealed to the second circuit and
- 21:06Speaker 1: maybe the second circuit will find that there is standing,
- 21:09Speaker 1: in which case this is how I would have held.
- 21:12Speaker 1: And again, you know, it's worth noting that the judge
- 21:15Speaker 1: did actually have a hearing, an argument from the parties
- 21:18Speaker 1: on everything right, so I'm a standing issue and on
- 21:20Speaker 1: the on the likelihood of success. So this is how
- 21:23Speaker 1: he would have decided the case if he had reached
- 21:25Speaker 1: that part. So let's go over some of the reasons
- 21:29Speaker 1: that he thinks that the law might be unconstitutional. This
- 21:32Speaker 1: is a little technical, but the new law amidst the
- 21:35Speaker 1: phrase other than in self defense. So explain that. So
- 21:40Speaker 1: what New York did after the bruined decision came down
- 21:43Speaker 1: in in June and I think New York law was
- 21:45Speaker 1: passed just at the beginning of July. Is that there
- 21:48Speaker 1: was this requirement in the law already. That said, you know,
- 21:52Speaker 1: no license shall be issued unless the applicant meets a BC.
- 21:57Speaker 1: You know this list of criteria, and one of those
- 22:01Speaker 1: items on the list was that the applicant has to
- 22:03Speaker 1: be of good moral character. Now, the law previously didn't
- 22:06Speaker 1: provide any definition of what good moral character means. So
- 22:11Speaker 1: New York added a definition Um and that definition is
- 22:15Speaker 1: having the essential character, temperament and judgment necessary to be
- 22:19Speaker 1: entrusted with the weapon and to use it only in
- 22:22Speaker 1: a manner that does not endanger oneself or others. And
- 22:25Speaker 1: it's sort of that last phrase that the judge really
- 22:28Speaker 1: focused on and he said if you know, if you
- 22:30Speaker 1: read this literally, it would bar anyone from obtaining a
- 22:35Speaker 1: license who intends to use a weapon in a legitimate
- 22:38Speaker 1: defensive way. Right. So if you're trying to get a
- 22:41Speaker 1: concealed carry license because you want to defend yourself if
- 22:44Speaker 1: you are attacked, you know if you use a gun
- 22:46Speaker 1: in that situation you're almost certainly going to endanger the
- 22:49Speaker 1: attacker right. So any time that you you use a
- 22:52Speaker 1: weapon in self defense, it's going to endanger others. And
- 22:55Speaker 1: the judge says that that by in a literal interpretation,
- 22:58Speaker 1: preventing any de sensitive use of a gun, that this
- 23:02Speaker 1: is unconstitutional. And what about the definition of moral character?
- 23:06Speaker 1: It seems pretty broad and open to interpretation. Sure it's. Again,
- 23:11Speaker 1: so the sort of narrow is the opinion here is
- 23:13Speaker 1: of a judge would have just struck this down because
- 23:17Speaker 1: he says it doesn't allow for a gun to be
- 23:20Speaker 1: used in self defense. But that is the sort of
- 23:23Speaker 1: core Second Amendment right that the Supreme Court has identified.
- 23:25Speaker 1: So that's his main problem and that's sort of an
- 23:28Speaker 1: easy fix in some ways, right. The only thing that
- 23:30Speaker 1: New York really needs to do is add the words
- 23:33Speaker 1: other than in self defense at the end of that definition.
- 23:36Speaker 1: But the judge also says he would have struck down
- 23:40Speaker 1: this good moral character requirement in its entirety because he
- 23:44Speaker 1: would find that it gave too much discretion, subjective discretion,
- 23:48Speaker 1: to the licensing officer, in violation of brewing right. So
- 23:52Speaker 1: this is maybe more consequential because the judge is saying
- 23:55Speaker 1: that he reads Brewin to mean there can't be any
- 23:58Speaker 1: subjective criteria and has to just be sort of checking
- 24:01Speaker 1: the boxes of you meet the age requirement, you don't
- 24:04Speaker 1: have any disqualifying felonies, you know, it just has to
- 24:07Speaker 1: be only objective. Things like training, for example, would would
- 24:10Speaker 1: be okay, but anything that requires a subjective evaluation by
- 24:15Speaker 1: the officer is improper in the judge's view. And I
- 24:18Speaker 1: guess you know, I think that's a little bit of
- 24:20Speaker 1: a of an odd way to read Brewin because the
- 24:24Speaker 1: bruined decision explicitly sort of signs off on the licensing
- 24:30Speaker 1: regimes in a few states, Delaware, Connecticut and Rhode Islands Specifically,
- 24:35Speaker 1: that have essentially identical requirements in their laws. They require
- 24:40Speaker 1: good moral character or suitability, and I mean those are
- 24:43Speaker 1: subjective determinations sort of any way you slice it. The
- 24:46Speaker 1: Supreme Court says those licensing regimes are okay, but nevertheless,
- 24:50Speaker 1: in this opinion the judge would have held that sort
- 24:53Speaker 1: of one iota of subjectivity is a problem. So then
- 24:57Speaker 1: what about the laws requirement that the applicant provides social
- 25:02Speaker 1: media accounts used in the past three years? I mean,
- 25:05Speaker 1: someone would be doing the vetting of that. It seems
- 25:08Speaker 1: very discretionary. So this is, I thought, kind of a
- 25:12Speaker 1: curious section of the of the opinion. If you know,
- 25:15Speaker 1: the judge doesn't really provide detailed analysis of the social
- 25:19Speaker 1: media requirements. First he says that he would he would
- 25:22Speaker 1: find that the requirements to submit character references and go
- 25:25Speaker 1: to an in person interview is okay, that that's constitutional
- 25:28Speaker 1: in his view. But then he says that this social
- 25:31Speaker 1: media submission is problematic and he just sort of gives
- 25:34Speaker 1: a laundry list of reasons. Right, so there might be
- 25:37Speaker 1: a first amendment problem and there might be a fifth
- 25:39Speaker 1: amendment problem. It's too subjective. It implicates the self defense
- 25:44Speaker 1: issue as well, and so it's kind of hard to
- 25:47Speaker 1: tell what the actual basis for the holding would be.
- 25:51Speaker 1: You know that the judge identifies the fifth amendment. So
- 25:54Speaker 1: that's you know that you have a right against self
- 25:57Speaker 1: incrimination and says, you know, maybe if you can applicant
- 26:00Speaker 1: and has to disclose all of his or her social
- 26:03Speaker 1: media postings, that might require the applicant to incriminate themselves.
- 26:06Speaker 1: But that doesn't that doesn't actually seem to be a
- 26:09Speaker 1: theory that the plaintiffs in this case had articulated in
- 26:13Speaker 1: their pleadings. So I think this is something that the
- 26:16Speaker 1: court actually raised at the hearing and it's a little
- 26:19Speaker 1: bit of a head scratcher. I mean, I think the
- 26:20Speaker 1: First Amendment challenge to this provision is probably stronger and
- 26:25Speaker 1: probably something that it might be easier to understand right
- 26:27Speaker 1: that you know, if you if you're making some kind
- 26:29Speaker 1: of political post and then the licensing officer, you know,
- 26:33Speaker 1: takes issue with that and denize license on that basis,
- 26:35Speaker 1: that that would be a first amendment problem. But again,
- 26:38Speaker 1: there's not. There's not a ton of of analysis. Is
- 26:40Speaker 1: this requirement of providing social media accounts? Is that something
- 26:45Speaker 1: new that New York has? Do any other states have that?
- 26:49Speaker 1: That's a great question. Um, you know. So this is new.
- 26:51Speaker 1: This is something that New York just passed in July.
- 26:54Speaker 1: I don't believe any other states have a similar requirement
- 26:58Speaker 1: in their licensing, whereas game right, I don't believe any
- 27:01Speaker 1: other states require concealed carry licensed applicants to make any
- 27:05Speaker 1: kind of social media specific submission. I'm not a hund
- 27:09Speaker 1: percent sure on that, but I think it's a pretty
- 27:11Speaker 1: novel approach that New York is taking and again it's
- 27:14Speaker 1: they're sort of various theories that have been put forward
- 27:16Speaker 1: about why it may or may not be constitutional, and
- 27:20Speaker 1: I think the First Amendment one is probably the most compelling.
- 27:23Speaker 1: But again you also see the discretion element playing out here,
- 27:26Speaker 1: where it's unclear how this provision will work in practice. Right.
- 27:30Speaker 1: So you know, is the licensing officer actually going to
- 27:32Speaker 1: have discretions to deny an application based on a post that,
- 27:37Speaker 1: you know, they themselves find to be objectionable, or is
- 27:40Speaker 1: there some kind of guidance given to them? Right, we
- 27:42Speaker 1: really don't know. It also seems like it's going to
- 27:44Speaker 1: be difficult just to administer that, you know, without additional funding.
- 27:49Speaker 1: Going through three years of social media accounts seems like
- 27:53Speaker 1: a lot now. The judge also said that the states
- 27:57Speaker 1: list of sensitive places is extensive. And it is extensive
- 28:02Speaker 1: and I remember during the Supreme Corporal Arguments when the
- 28:06Speaker 1: justices were talking about some places that might be considered sensitive,
- 28:11Speaker 1: but they said, you know, you can't have all of Manhattan.
- 28:13Speaker 1: Basically you can't have this broad brush. And this looks
- 28:16Speaker 1: like a pretty broad brush. Yes, and the judge's opinion
- 28:20Speaker 1: here goes back to that portion of brew and and
- 28:23Speaker 1: you know, his issue seems to be that. You know
- 28:26Speaker 1: he thinks what New York has done is to designate
- 28:29Speaker 1: any place where people congregate in public and where there
- 28:34Speaker 1: is presumptive access, you know, sort of easy access to
- 28:37Speaker 1: law enforcement has a sensitive place. That's what the Supreme
- 28:41Speaker 1: Court and Bruins said. You cannot do. You know, New
- 28:44Speaker 1: York couldn't designate the entire island of Manhattan as a
- 28:47Speaker 1: sensitive place just because it's very crowded and people congregate
- 28:50Speaker 1: there and and there's a lot of police around. That's
- 28:53Speaker 1: not okay. But I think the judge's view here of
- 28:56Speaker 1: what can be a sensitive place is pretty narrow right.
- 29:00Speaker 1: so He seems to think, and he actually says in
- 29:03Speaker 1: this portion of the opinion that you would agree with
- 29:05Speaker 1: the plaintiffs that brewin limited the list of what can
- 29:12Speaker 1: be a sensitive place to only schools, government buildings, legislative assemblies,
- 29:19Speaker 1: polling places and courthouses. Those are the five places that
- 29:22Speaker 1: are specifically mentioned in the opinion and the judge here says, well,
- 29:26Speaker 1: that's that's it right. I don't think that you know,
- 29:28Speaker 1: anywhere else could be designated as a sensitive place. That's
- 29:31Speaker 1: an odd way to look at Brewin, because Brewin explicitly
- 29:35Speaker 1: says that courts should reason by analogy to historical sensitive
- 29:40Speaker 1: places and that there might be new places that weren't
- 29:43Speaker 1: listed or weren't specifically mentioned in that opinion. So I
- 29:47Speaker 1: think it's a little bit it's a little bit odd
- 29:49Speaker 1: that you would just just sort of cut it off
- 29:51Speaker 1: there and think that there there could be no expansion Um.
- 29:55Speaker 1: And you know, the other thing I'll mention here just
- 29:57Speaker 1: briefly is that the judge seems to say, you know,
- 30:00Speaker 1: if I'm reading this correctly, he seems to say that
- 30:03Speaker 1: New York would need to come forward with the historical
- 30:07Speaker 1: law that prohibited guns in every single place on the list.
- 30:12Speaker 1: And again, I think that's that's a little bit strange, right.
- 30:15Speaker 1: You would think that these places would sort of rise
- 30:17Speaker 1: or fall independently, and so you know that that that
- 30:20Speaker 1: a court would walk through them and say, well, you know,
- 30:23Speaker 1: these places are sort of similar to schools and government buildings,
- 30:26Speaker 1: so it's okay to prohibit guns here, but you know
- 30:28Speaker 1: maybe on the subway it might not be as clear.
- 30:32Speaker 1: But here he seems to just sort of take a
- 30:34Speaker 1: broad brush and say, well, if there isn't a historical
- 30:37Speaker 1: law that covers all these places, then New York's approaches
- 30:41Speaker 1: is unconstitutional. Maybe he's taking a page from the Supreme
- 30:45Speaker 1: Court's historical analysis lately. Thanks, Andrew. That's Andrew Willinger, executive
- 30:51Speaker 1: director of the Duke's Center for Firearms Law. And that's
- 30:54Speaker 1: it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law show. Remember
- 30:56Speaker 1: you can always get the latest legal news on our
- 30:58Speaker 1: Bloomberg Law pod cast. You can find them on apple podcasts,
- 31:02Speaker 1: spotify and at www dot bloomberg dot com, slash podcast,
- 31:07Speaker 1: slash law, and remember to tune to the Bloomberg law
- 31:10Speaker 1: show every week night at ten PM Wall Street time.
- 31:14Speaker 1: I'm June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg