Latest / Reformed Thinking / Judges: When Israel Forgot the Lord | Thomas R. Schreiner
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Deep Dive. Today we're digging into a book
- 0:03that's, well, it's pretty difficult.
- 0:05This is part of our Reformed Thinking series.
- 0:07We're tackling the Book of Judges.
- 0:09We are, and you know, a lot of people might know the big
- 0:12stories like Samson or Gideon, but they often skip the rest.
- 0:16Which is a shame because it's so central to the whole biblical
- 0:19story. So our goal for this deep dive
- 0:21is to look at the big picture of judges.
- 0:23We want to see how the book is put together and why it seems,
- 0:27well, almost designed to show the need for a king, a righteous
- 0:30king. That's it.
- 0:31We're going to trace Israel's downward spiral and ask what
- 0:35solution the Bible itself offers for the mess we see.
- 0:38OK, so let's set the scene. We're coming right off the end
- 0:40of the book of Joshua. The conquest is, for the most
- 0:43part, done. Israel is in the land we are.
- 0:46So where does that put them? You know, in relation to that
- 0:49huge promise made to Abraham, the Abrahamic covenant.
- 0:52It's a really good question because the situation is kind of
- 0:54mixed and that's what sets up the whole tragedy of judges.
- 0:57The promise had you could say 3 parts. 1st the promise of a
- 1:02great nation, a seed, Second, the promise of the land of
- 1:05Canaan, and 3rd the promise that through Israel the whole world
- 1:10would be blessed. So by the time we open Judges
- 1:13Chapter 1, what's been checked off the list?
- 1:16Well, the first two parts are physically there.
- 1:19They're big population, a nation and they are living in the land
- 1:22of Canaan. OK.
- 1:23So geographically, demographically, they're about
- 1:262/3 of the way there. You could look at it that way,
- 1:28yeah, They're settled, they're numerous.
- 1:30They've got their inheritance. So you'd think they're perfectly
- 1:32in position for that third part to be a light to the nation's,
- 1:36to be that vehicle for blessing. That's the logical next step,
- 1:39but The Book of Judges just slams the brakes on that hope.
- 1:43It makes it crystal clear that just being in the land isn't
- 1:46enough to bring that blessing to the world.
- 1:48Why not? What goes wrong?
- 1:50The book is just relentless in showing that their failure is
- 1:53entirely spiritual. It's a systemic refusal to live
- 1:58under Yahweh's rule. I can almost hear someone
- 2:00pushing back on that. Though they might say, well hold
- 2:02on, at the start of judges, they still hadn't driven out all the
- 2:05Canaanites. You could argue their problem
- 2:08was an incomplete military conquest, a political failure.
- 2:12Why does the text insist it's something deeper?
- 2:15That's really the heart of the matter.
- 2:17The problem isn't political or military at its root.
- 2:20Some scholars, Gregory Wong, for instance, he calls the theme of
- 2:24the book progressive deterioration.
- 2:26It's. Aggressive deterioration.
- 2:28He sees Israel just spiraling downwards into, you know, worse
- 2:32and worse apostasy, the oppression they face from other
- 2:35nations. That's God's judgment on their
- 2:38spiritual sickness. It's not the cause of it.
- 2:40So things like having no central government or the tribes not
- 2:44getting along, those are just the symptoms.
- 2:46That's it exactly. The actual disease, the root
- 2:49cause was their failure to submit to the lordship of
- 2:52Yahweh. They already had a king.
- 2:54Their covenant God. Yes, he'd given them their
- 2:56entire legal and governmental structure at Sinai, but they
- 3:00just refused to be ruled by him. It was like they were declaring
- 3:03independence from their own divine king.
- 3:05Yeah. And the the book has that one
- 3:07phrase that just hammers this point home over and over again
- 3:11at the. End.
- 3:11Oh, it does that chilling refrain that perfectly captures
- 3:14the spiritual anarchy. Everyone did what was right in
- 3:17his own eyes. It's there in chapter 17, and
- 3:20then again, like the final word on the matter at the very end of
- 3:23chapter 21, it. Is and when every person just
- 3:26decides for themselves what's right and wrong based on what
- 3:28they feel. I mean, any sense of national
- 3:31unity just falls apart. It's a recipe for total
- 3:33collapse. So let's break that down.
- 3:35How did this doing what feels right actually play out?
- 3:39What were the specific things they were doing?
- 3:41Well, the two big ones were just rampant idolatry and maybe even
- 3:46worse, a complete loss of knowledge about God from one
- 3:49generation to the next. The idolatry part, yeah.
- 3:52The text mentions the bales and the ash troth a lot.
- 3:55It does. Israel kept turning away from
- 3:57the Lord to serve these Canaanite gods.
- 4:00Can you give us a sense of what that actually involved?
- 4:02Why was that so tempting for them?
- 4:03Well, Bell was the Canaanite God of storms and fertility.
- 4:08He was supposed to bring the rain, make the crops grow, make
- 4:12the livestock multiply. So for a nation of new farmers,
- 4:16that's a pretty big A. Huge draw.
- 4:18They look over at their Canaanite neighbors who were
- 4:20performing all these rituals, sometimes a pretty chaotic
- 4:24rituals involving things like ritual prostitution, and they
- 4:26thought, hey, that seems to be working for them.
- 4:29It gets them rain. So it wasn't just about a
- 4:31statue, it was trading the covenant relationship with
- 4:35Yahweh for what felt like a more direct transactional system.
- 4:39We do this, we get rain. You've.
- 4:41Got it. They thought they could
- 4:42manipulate the divine. The Bible uses really strong
- 4:45language here. It says they hoard after other
- 4:47gods. It's a metaphor for spiritual
- 4:49adultery. They were breaking the very
- 4:51first, most basic rule of the covenant.
- 4:54And this spiritual decay, it didn't just stay with the
- 4:57adults. No, and this might be the most
- 4:59heartbreaking part of the whole book.
- 5:00The text says a new generation grew up who did not know the
- 5:03Lord or the work that he had done for Israel.
- 5:06That's just devastating. It points to a total failure of
- 5:09the family of the community. It does.
- 5:11The whole structure given in Deuteronomy was that parents
- 5:14were supposed to constantly teach their children about the
- 5:17law, about the Exodus, about the covenant.
- 5:19But they were too busy with Baal and doing what was right in
- 5:22their own eyes. So the teaching stopped and the
- 5:24kids grew up essentially as pagans.
- 5:27They had no story, no memory of being rescued from Egypt, no
- 5:30real reason to obey Yahweh. Which brings us to that summary
- 5:34of their state you mentioned earlier.
- 5:35Yeah, they were in the land, but not in the Lord.
- 5:39They had the geography, but not the devotion.
- 5:41They were supposed to be this agent of blessing for the world,
- 5:44but instead they just look like everyone else.
- 5:46They attracted judgment, not blessing.
- 5:48This really sets the stage for the whole cycle we see in the
- 5:51book. Then the sin, the judgment, the
- 5:53crying out, the deliverance. It's the repeating pattern that
- 5:56gives the book its shape. Israel sins.
- 5:58God allows them to be oppressed. They cry out for help.
- 6:01And then in his mercy, God sends a judge, a deliverer.
- 6:05But it never sticks. It never sticks.
- 6:07As soon as the judge dies, the people go right back to their
- 6:10old ways and the whole cycle starts over again.
- 6:13The source material is really clear, though, that these judges
- 6:16are sent by God. They are saviors.
- 6:19Their victories are a sign of God's grace.
- 6:21Oh, absolutely, they are sign of grace.
- 6:24But the whole point of the narrative is to show that the
- 6:26judges were not a permanent fix for Israel's problem.
- 6:29Because the problem was spiritual, not just military.
- 6:32Right. The judges could deal with the
- 6:34symptom, the foreign oppression, for a while.
- 6:37They could bring peace for a few years, but they couldn't cure
- 6:41the disease in the people's hearts, the stubbornness, the
- 6:44defiance. You're like a temporary patch on
- 6:46a deep wound. A very temporary patch, and the
- 6:49fact that the judges themselves were often deeply flawed people
- 6:52just highlights that the whole system, the whole office of the
- 6:55judge, wasn't enough to bring about real, lasting salvation
- 6:59for the nation. That's a great point.
- 7:01The stories often seem to go out of their way to show us how
- 7:04unlikely these saviors were. It's like the author wants to
- 7:06make sure we know it was God's hand at work, not human
- 7:09greatness. The author uses irony and
- 7:12surprise all the time to make that very point, to show that
- 7:15God's plans were happening in spite of the people he was
- 7:17using. So you have someone like Ehud.
- 7:19Ehud. Yeah, the guy who takes out the
- 7:22Moabite king Eglon. The text makes a point of
- 7:25telling us he was left-handed, which was often seen as a
- 7:27weakness or a defect. But that's how he gets the
- 7:29hidden dagger past the guards. And then there's Deborah.
- 7:33A woman leading Israel, which was highly unusual in that
- 7:36culture. And the final victory doesn't
- 7:38even go to her general Barack. It goes to jail.
- 7:42A non Israelite woman with a tent.
- 7:45It's a way of making sure God gets all the credit.
- 7:47It is, and then you get to Gideon, maybe the best example
- 7:50of an unlikely hero. He's from the weakest clan,
- 7:53calls himself the least in his family.
- 7:54He's hiding in a winepress when the Angel of the Lord finds him.
- 7:57He's scared. He's reluctant.
- 7:59He keeps asking for signs. You know the famous story with
- 8:02the fleece? So when he wins, it's obvious it
- 8:05wasn't him, especially after God shrinks his army down to just
- 8:08300 men. And Jephta, too, the son of a
- 8:12prostitute, an outcast who becomes a warlord, and then he's
- 8:15begged to come back and save everyone.
- 8:18It all shows God's power, but it also prepares us for the fact
- 8:22that these saviors are, well, they're going to have some major
- 8:26problems. Let's get into those problems
- 8:27because they really drive home why a temporary leader was never
- 8:30going to be the answer. Let's start with Gideon again.
- 8:33He has that amazing moment where he refuses to be king.
- 8:36It's such a high point in the book.
- 8:38The people come to him and say rule over us, you and your son
- 8:41and your grandson. And he gives the perfect
- 8:44theological answer. The Lord will rule over you.
- 8:46It sounds like he gets it. It sounds like it, but then in
- 8:50the very next breath he undoes it all.
- 8:53He declines the title of king, but then he immediately starts
- 8:56acting like one. Also, he demands all the gold,
- 8:58earrings and loot from the battle and uses it to make a
- 9:02golden ephod. Which is a priestly garment,
- 9:04something he had no right to make.
- 9:06No right at all. And the text says all of Israel
- 9:09hoard after it. This object made from the spoils
- 9:13of a holy war became an idol in his own hometown.
- 9:17It just goes to show that even a great deliverer could
- 9:20immediately lead the people back into idolatry because of his
- 9:23own, I don't know, his own ego or bad judgement.
- 9:27So he proved he wasn't fit for that kind of permanent,
- 9:30righteous leadership. Not at all.
- 9:31And Jeff, though his flaw is maybe even more horrifying.
- 9:36It's this blend of devotion to God with Pagan ideas.
- 9:40Jeff the story is such a tragedy.
- 9:42It all centers on this rash vow he makes before he goes into
- 9:45battle. He promises God that if he wins,
- 9:48he'll sacrifice the first thing that comes out of his house to
- 9:50greet him when he gets back. Which is just That's not how
- 9:53you're supposed to approach Yahweh.
- 9:54That sounds like a bargain you'd try to make with a Pagan God.
- 9:56Completely rooted in a Canaanite worldview, trying to bribe or
- 10:00coerce God instead of trusting in his covenant promises.
- 10:03And the first thing to greet him is.
- 10:05His daughter, his only child. Now people debate whether he
- 10:09actually killed her or just dedicated her to a life of
- 10:12service, but the plain sense of the texture really suggests he
- 10:15went through with. It a human sacrifice.
- 10:17A human sacrifice. It's a total violation of God's
- 10:20law and it shows how messed up even the Savior's were.
- 10:23A judge chosen by God uses a Pagan practice that ends up
- 10:27destroying his own family. Which brings us to Samson.
- 10:30He feels different from the others.
- 10:33It's like his whole life is a living parable of Israel's
- 10:36story. That's a great way to put it.
- 10:38His life is a symbol of Israel's calling and Israel's failure.
- 10:41He was set apart from birth as a not to right.
- 10:44With very specific rules. No wine or grapes, no haircuts
- 10:47and no touching dead bodies. And the text goes out of its way
- 10:50to repeat those rules three times in chapter 13.
- 10:53It's underlining how special his calling was.
- 10:56He was supposed to be completely dedicated to God.
- 10:58And on top of that, he gets this supernatural strength.
- 11:01The Spirit of the Lord rushes upon him.
- 11:04He has the calling, he has the power, and yet it's all wasted
- 11:07because of his own selfish appetites.
- 11:09His downfall is his attraction to foreign women.
- 11:12First the Philistine woman from Timna, then a prostitute, then
- 11:15Delilah. And the parallel is intentional
- 11:19and obvious. Samson falls for foreign women.
- 11:21Just like Israel falls for foreign gods, his choices are
- 11:25all about him, he tells his parents.
- 11:27Get her for me, for she is right in my eyes.
- 11:30It's that same theme again. And he just systematically
- 11:33breaks every one of his Nazarite vows.
- 11:35All of them. He touches the deadline carcass
- 11:37to get honey. He goes to a wedding feast where
- 11:40there would have been wine and of course the big one.
- 11:43He tells Delilah the secret of his hair and she has it cut.
- 11:46And when the covenant vow is broken, the power is gone.
- 11:50His strength, which was a sign of the Spirit's presence, leaves
- 11:53him. He loses his strength and he
- 11:55loses his sight. He literally becomes a picture
- 11:58of Israel. He really does.
- 11:59Israel was called to be wholly set apart, but they broke their
- 12:03vows, they lusted after idols, and they ended up becoming blind
- 12:05slaves to their enemies, the Philistines.
- 12:08Samson grinding grain in a Philistine prison, Blind and
- 12:12powerless is Israel. It's such a bleak picture, but
- 12:16even there, at the lowest point, the narrator gives us this tiny
- 12:20little sliver of hope. It's one of the most powerful
- 12:23lines in the book, I think. After his hair is cut and he's
- 12:25captured, Judges 16.22 just quietly says, But the hair of
- 12:30his head began to grow again. Even though Samson and Israel
- 12:34had been unfaithful, God's faithfulness hadn't run out.
- 12:38It's this tiny hint that God isn't finished with him and he
- 12:41isn't finished with Israel. Restoration is still possible.
- 12:44And that little bit of hope is what carries us into the final
- 12:47section of the book, chapter 17 to 21, and while things get even
- 12:52darker. They get so much darker.
- 12:53This whole section is not just an appendix.
- 12:55It's the author's final thundering argument for why a
- 12:58king is desperately needed. It's meant to show the shocking
- 13:01extent of the evil in Israel when there's no leadership.
- 13:03It moves from the failure of individuals to the total moral
- 13:06collapse of the society. Right.
- 13:08It starts with the story of a man named Micah and his personal
- 13:11idol. Story that sounds a lot like
- 13:13Gideon's failure, actually. It does.
- 13:15Micah steals a bunch of silver from his mom, then he gives it
- 13:17back and she says she's consecrating it to the Lord to
- 13:21make an idol. It's the same twisted logic as
- 13:23Gideon's Ephod using things for Yahweh to make things that
- 13:27Yahweh hates. And he sets up his own little
- 13:29private religion. He does.
- 13:31He makes one of his sons a priest, which is totally against
- 13:33the law, and then when a traveling Levite wanders by, he
- 13:37hires him for 10 pieces of silver and a new set of clothes.
- 13:41He thinks having a real Levite will be like a good luck charm.
- 13:44Yeah, he says. Now I know the Lord will prosper
- 13:46me. It's just reducing religion to a
- 13:49transaction to a personal convenience.
- 13:51It's the ultimate what is right in my own eyes.
- 13:54And this rot just gets worse. It spreads to an entire tribe,
- 13:57the tribe of Dan. The Denites can't conquer their
- 13:59own territory, so they go looking for an easier target and
- 14:02they find this quiet, peaceful town called Lashish.
- 14:06And instead of following the rules of warfare and
- 14:08Deuteronomy, you know, offering peace first.
- 14:11They just attack. They just wipe them out.
- 14:13It's brutal and vicious and on the way there they stop by
- 14:17Micah's house and steal his idols and kidnap his hired
- 14:19priest to come work for them. So you have an entire tribe now
- 14:22organized around stolen idols and violence.
- 14:25It's a terrifying picture and the author drops this little
- 14:28detail. And that is just, it's
- 14:31devastating. The Levite priest they hire,
- 14:33he's the great grandson of Moses himself, the direct descendant
- 14:38of the man who got the law on Sinai, is now the paid priest
- 14:42for a band of thugs worshipping a stolen idol.
- 14:45It shows that even the most sacred institutions had
- 14:47completely broken. Down.
- 14:48If we think it can't get any worse, it does with the story
- 14:52from Gibia. Gibia is the absolute bottom.
- 14:55The story is deliberately written to remind the reader of
- 14:57the wickedest story in the Bible up to that point, Sodom and
- 15:00Gomorrah. So you have a Levite traveling
- 15:02with his concubine, and they need a place to stay in Gibia, a
- 15:05town in the tribe of Benjamin. And just like in Sodom, no one
- 15:08will take them in except for one old man who is an outsider
- 15:11himself. And then the men of the city
- 15:13surround the house. And they demand the Levite be
- 15:16brought out so they can rape him.
- 15:18It's the exact same pattern as Sodom, but this time it's not a
- 15:21Pagan city, it's a town of Israelites.
- 15:24And the Levites response is just as horrifying.
- 15:27He throws his concubine out to the mob to save himself.
- 15:30An act of unbelievable cruelty and cowardice.
- 15:33She's abused all night and dies on the doorstep and this man who
- 15:37should represent the law carves up her body and sends the pieces
- 15:41to the 12 tribes to call them to.
- 15:43War, the horror of it, is just. It's hard to read.
- 15:47It is, and when the other tribes find out, they demand that
- 15:49Benjamin hand over the guilty men.
- 15:51But they refuse. They choose tribal loyalty over
- 15:53God's justice. They decide to protect their
- 15:56own, even though their own committed this monstrous act.
- 15:59And that leads to a brutal civil war.
- 16:01A war that almost wipes out the entire tribe of Benjamin.
- 16:04Almost completely. It's a terrifying picture of
- 16:06what happens when a nation turns its back on Yahweh entirely.
- 16:10But then, even in their attempt to fix the problem, they make it
- 16:13worse. They realize they can't let a
- 16:15tribe disappear, so they have to find wives for the few 100
- 16:18Benjamite men who survived. But they'd all sworn an oath not
- 16:22to give their own daughters. So they come up with these human
- 16:25devices, these schemes. First they attack another
- 16:29Israelite town that didn't show up for the war, kill everyone
- 16:31except the young virgin women, and give them to the Benjamites.
- 16:34More murder and abduction. And when that's not enough, they
- 16:38tell the rest of the Benjamites to go hide in the vineyards and
- 16:40kidnap girls who come out to dance at a festival in Shiloh.
- 16:43It's just one horrific self-made solution after another.
- 16:47And this whole ugly, violent, chaotic section is designed to
- 16:52scream. One thing the need for
- 16:53leadership, the need for a king. That's it.
- 16:57The political chaos is the final, undeniable symptom of the
- 17:00spiritual disease, and the author makes it impossible to
- 17:04miss by repeating that phrase four times in these last few
- 17:06chapters. In those days, there was no king
- 17:08in Israel. And it's always pure to the
- 17:10chaos. There was no king, so Micah made
- 17:12an idol. There was no king, so the
- 17:14Danites took what they wanted. There was no king, and everyone
- 17:18did what was right in his own eyes.
- 17:20It's not just a historical note, it's the author's diagnosis of
- 17:23the problem. It's a theological argument.
- 17:25The author is looking at this history and concluding that the
- 17:27only way to fix this is for Yahweh's rule to be mediated
- 17:31through a human king who will actually enforce God's law.
- 17:34And the biblical story immediately picks up on that
- 17:36threat. Immediately right after judges
- 17:39comes the book of Ruth which is like the anti judges.
- 17:41It's a story of covenant faithfulness set during the time
- 17:44of the judges. And how does it end with?
- 17:46A genealogy. Royal genealogy.
- 17:48It promises a future king from the line of Boaz, who is the
- 17:51great grandfather of David. Which leads his right into one
- 17:54until he's Samuel and the coming of the monarchy.
- 17:56Exactly. We see the failed kingship of
- 17:59Saul and then the rise of David. And David's reign looks like the
- 18:03answer. He unifies the nation, he brings
- 18:05victory. And in second, in Samuel 7, God
- 18:08promises that David's dynasty, his throne, will last forever.
- 18:13It seems like the problem is solved.
- 18:15The chaos of judges is over. David is the king they needed.
- 18:19He is the immediate historical answer.
- 18:22But the Bible doesn't let us stop there.
- 18:24Why not? Because even David, this man
- 18:27after God's own heart, he has the same basic flaw as the
- 18:30Judges. He does what is right in his own
- 18:32eyes. With Bathsheba and Uriah, he's
- 18:35driven by selfish desire. He commits adultery and murder.
- 18:39He's a great king, but he's a flawed, sinful man.
- 18:43He can't be the final answer to the deep spiritual problem.
- 18:46So the story is still pointing forward.
- 18:49It's looking for a king who is even greater than David.
- 18:52That's right, the ultimate solution has to be a king who is
- 18:55not only righteous himself, but who can actually change the
- 18:58hearts of his people. A king who doesn't just manage
- 19:01the sin, but defeats it. Which is where the story finds
- 19:04its final fulfillment. In the reign of Jesus the
- 19:06Christ, He is the true King that Israel and the whole world
- 19:10needed. And this connects all the way
- 19:11back to the very beginning of the Bible.
- 19:13It does. It's the fulfillment of that
- 19:15promise in Genesis 3 that the offspring of the woman would
- 19:18come and crush the head of the serpent.
- 19:20Jesus is that promised offspring, that perfect king.
- 19:23The judges failed because they were human and couldn't fix the
- 19:26spiritual problem. Christ succeeds because he is
- 19:30God and He can. So the Book of Judges isn't just
- 19:33a collection of old war stories, it's a carefully constructed
- 19:36argument designed to create this, this desperation for a
- 19:40real king, a need that only Christ can fill.
- 19:43That's it. The failures of Gideon,
- 19:44Jephthah, Samson, they all show the uselessness of human
- 19:48solutions for a spiritual disease.
- 19:50They're all signposts pointing away from themselves and toward
- 19:53the one true King who was to come.
- 19:55So if we were to wrap up this deep dive, the main take away is
- 19:58that Judges shows us that temporary human saviors can't
- 20:01fix a deep spiritual problem like apostasy and self rule.
- 20:05Right. Israel didn't just need a better
- 20:06general, they needed a righteous eternal to conquer the chaos in
- 20:10their own hearts. The book is really a warning
- 20:12about what happens when people are left to their own devices,
- 20:15even religious people, without submitting to God's rule.
- 20:18It is once they got comfortable in the land, once life was
- 20:21secure, they immediately traded their devotion to God for the
- 20:25comfort of just doing what everyone else was doing.
- 20:27That pattern feels uncomfortably familiar, the way they slid into
- 20:32spiritual decay as soon as things got easy.
- 20:35And that really raises a question for us to think about,
- 20:37doesn't it? How does Israel's pattern of
- 20:39decline right after being delivered shed light on the
- 20:42temptation we all face today, the temptation to substitute
- 20:46real covenant devotion to God for whatever seems right in our
- 20:49own eyes, especially when life is good and the pressure is off?
- 20:52That's a good place to leave it. Israel's problem then is really
- 20:55the human problem now, the desire for self rule over the
- 20:58revealed rule of Yahweh.