Latest / Seasons of Joy / Let Freedom Ring: Observation vs. Evaluation
Transcript
- 0:00What if I told you that most of the pain in your hardest conversations isn't
- 0:04actually coming from what happened?
- 0:06It's coming from what you make it mean.
- 0:09And what if there was a way to tell the difference in real time,
- 0:14right in the middle of the moment that's pushing all your buttons?
- 0:18That's what we're talking about today. It's this distinction that I learned
- 0:23years ago and was recently reinforced in a nonviolent communication course by Marshall Rosenberg.
- 0:31And I promise, once you see it, your relationships will begin to change for the better.
- 0:37It has quietly untangled more hard moments in my marriage, with my adult kids,
- 0:42and honestly with myself than almost any other tool I know.
- 0:48Are you a woman of faith who is struggling to navigate your current season of
- 0:52life? Do you feel like life is just happening to you instead of for you?
- 0:56My name is Jill Pack, and I'm a certified faith-based life coach and a member
- 1:01of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
- 1:04I want you to know that no matter your season or your circumstance,
- 1:09it is possible to create a more
- 1:11joyful life, and I would love to show you how. Are you ready? Let's go.
- 1:22Hello, my friends, and welcome back to the Seasons of Joy podcast.
- 1:26I'm Jill Pack, and today's episode is number 110, and it is called Let Freedom
- 1:32Ring, Observation vs. Evaluation.
- 1:37Here's what I hope you will take away from this episode today.
- 1:41There is a difference between what happened and what you made it mean,
- 1:45and most of us, I'll include myself here, go through our whole lives blurring
- 1:51those two together and calling the blur reality.
- 1:55So let me show you what I mean. First, I want you to picture a camera in a room, just a camera.
- 2:01It has no feelings, no history with anyone, no opinions. It only records what it sees and hears.
- 2:09So if your husband walked into the kitchen and set his keys on the counter and
- 2:13said, I'm going to bed, the camera would record exactly that.
- 2:18Words, tone, and action. That's it.
- 2:22That's an observation. It's what happened. It's provable.
- 2:26Anyone who watched the footage would agree on it.
- 2:30Now, what did you hear when he said, I'm going to bed?
- 2:34Maybe you heard something like, he's shutting me out again, or he's upset with
- 2:39me and won't say it, or he doesn't care that we didn't even finish talking.
- 2:44None of that is on the camera footage. None of it. That's the meaning that you
- 2:49have added. That's the evaluation.
- 2:52And I want you to notice that the camera footage doesn't hurt you.
- 2:56What hurts is the meaning that you are giving it. So let that settle in for a second.
- 3:03And now I want to give you a few more examples because this is such an important concept to understand.
- 3:09Let's say your daughter calls you on a Sunday afternoon. You see her name on
- 3:13the screen and you pick up. And the first thing she said is,
- 3:16Mom, can I ask you something?
- 3:19The camera hears, Mom, can I ask you something? Six words, a tone that maybe
- 3:25sounds a little tired. that's it.
- 3:27But what did you hear? Maybe you heard, she's only calling because she needs
- 3:32something, or here we go, she's upset with me about last week,
- 3:37or something's wrong, I can feel it.
- 3:40You've had a whole conversation with yourself before she's even asked the question.
- 3:46Here's another one. You send a text to your friend on Tuesday morning.
- 3:50Something simple. Hey, are we still on for Thursday?
- 3:54And you watch those three little dots appear, and then they disappear.
- 3:58And then nothing. No response for hours.
- 4:03The camera records.
- 4:05The dots appeared. Dots disappeared.
- 4:08No reply for six hours. That's it. That's the footage.
- 4:12But what did you make it mean? She's mad at me. She's flanking.
- 4:18I said something wrong at lunch last week. She doesn't actually want to be friends with me.
- 4:23And none of that is on the camera. Not one word of it. But your body is already
- 4:28reacting like it's all true.
- 4:31Or how about this one? And this one I used to catch myself in all the time.
- 4:36Let's say you walk past a mirror. The camera sees a woman walking past a mirror. That's it.
- 4:43But what do you say to yourself in that half second glance? I look so tired.
- 4:49Man, I've let myself go. Look at what midlife has done to me.
- 4:53You've had a judgment handed down before you ever even finished walking through the room.
- 4:59Now, I want you to notice this. You didn't observe yourself in the mirror.
- 5:04You evaluated yourself. And then you took that evaluation and you treated it like it was reality.
- 5:11Here's one more. You're sitting in church, and someone gives a talk or a lesson,
- 5:15and afterward, you can't stop thinking about a look that someone gave you from across the room.
- 5:22The camera saw her eyes met yours for about two seconds, and then she looked away.
- 5:28That's the footage. But what did you make it mean? She's judging me.
- 5:32She heard about what happened. She doesn't approve of the choices I've been
- 5:36making or my kids have been making.
- 5:39And you could carry all that meaning home with you.
- 5:43You could carry that for a week. You could build a whole story about you and
- 5:48how you are viewed in your church congregation based on two seconds of eye contact
- 5:54that the camera would tell you was just
- 5:57two seconds of eye contact.
- 5:59Now, I'm not sharing these examples with you to make you feel silly.
- 6:03I'm sharing them with you because we all do this. You do this.
- 6:08I do this. Every woman I've ever coached does this.
- 6:11There is nothing wrong with you, though. It's just how we're wired.
- 6:15But once you can see it, you can start to work with it.
- 6:19Now, the second thing that I want you to take away from today is why this matters so much.
- 6:25When we can't tell the difference between observation and evaluation,
- 6:30we react to our interpretation as if it were the event itself.
- 6:36We get defensive about a story we wrote. We grieve over a meaning we assigned.
- 6:42We argue with our husband about what he really meant and he's standing there
- 6:47completely bewildered because from his side, he just told you he was going to bed.
- 6:53Now think about how much of your mental energy this week has gone into meanings and not actual events.
- 7:02The tone you thought you heard, the look you thought you saw,
- 7:05the pause you thought was too long, the comment someone made that you've replayed
- 7:11over and over in your head,
- 7:13and with every replay, you're adding another layer of intent that they may or may not have even had.
- 7:20That's not the event costing you. That's the evaluation costing you.
- 7:27This is where so much of the pain in our closest relationships exist.
- 7:31Not in what actually happened, but in visible layer we've laid on top of it.
- 7:36And because we can't see that layer, we can't question it. We just live inside
- 7:41of it and we call it the truth.
- 7:44Two people can be in the exact same conversation and walk away with completely
- 7:49different accounts of what was said.
- 7:52He may say, I just told you I was tired. And you may say, but you were being dismissive.
- 7:59And you're both convinced that you're right. Both of you are convinced that
- 8:03you're describing what happened.
- 8:06But one of you is describing the footage, and maybe the other one is describing the meaning.
- 8:12And neither of you knows it. This is why couples can argue for 30 years about
- 8:17the same three things and actually never get anywhere.
- 8:21They're not actually arguing about what happened. They're arguing about the
- 8:25interpretations they've each mistaken for reality.
- 8:29Marshall Rosenberg had a strong way of saying this. He called mixing observation
- 8:35and evaluation one of the most violent things we do to each other.
- 8:40And I know that sounds a little intense, but think about it for a minute.
- 8:43When you've already decided what he meant, what she was thinking.
- 8:48Why they did what they did, you've closed the door on them.
- 8:51They don't get to be anything other than what you've already made them in your mind.
- 8:56That's the violence he's talking about. Not shouting, not slamming doors.
- 9:01It's just quietly deciding who someone is before they've had a chance to even show you.
- 9:07We do this to ourselves too, constantly, believing things like,
- 9:11I'm behind, I'm failing, I'm not enough.
- 9:14I'm too much. I should be further along by now.
- 9:17None of that is footage. All of it is meaning.
- 9:22Those judgments become the ground we are walking on.
- 9:26And finally, here's a practice I want to leave you with.
- 9:30The next time something pushes your buttons, a look, a text,
- 9:34a silence, a comment from one of your adult children, a glance in the mirror,
- 9:39a pause in a conversation, I want you to do one small thing.
- 9:43Get out a piece of paper and draw a line down the middle.
- 9:47On the left side, you're only going to write what the camera saw. Camera language only.
- 9:54No adjectives about tone, no guesses about motive. No, he was being dismissive.
- 10:00Just he said these words. He did this action.
- 10:05And if you can't prove it in court, it doesn't belong on the left.
- 10:10Let me give you an example so you can hear the difference. Instead of he shut
- 10:14me down at dinner, the camera version is at dinner when I said I was thinking
- 10:18about signing up for the retreat.
- 10:20He said, we'll see. And then he kept eating.
- 10:24That's it. That's what happened. Read those two sentences back to back and feel
- 10:29how different they are in your body.
- 10:31Or instead of my daughter is pulling away from me, the camera version is over
- 10:36the last three weeks, my daughter has called me twice instead of her usual four or five times.
- 10:42And our last two calls were under 10 minutes.
- 10:45Just the footage, just what a camera would capture.
- 10:49On the right side, write everything you made it mean.
- 10:52My daughter is done with me. I did something wrong. She's closer to our mother-in-law
- 10:57than I am. I'm losing her.
- 11:01Get it all out, not because it's even true, but because until you see it on
- 11:06paper, you cannot tell that it's a story.
- 11:10Now read the left side out loud and notice what happens in your body.
- 11:15Then read the right side out loud and notice what happens in your body.
- 11:20Can you feel the difference?
- 11:22The left side is usually pretty quiet in the body, almost boring.
- 11:27You can breathe through it, but the right side, that's when the tight chest comes.
- 11:33That's when the tears start to come.
- 11:36That's where the I knew it feeling comes from.
- 11:40And that difference in your body is the whole point. Your body is telling you
- 11:45which side is doing the hurting.
- 11:48And the gap between what happened and what you made it mean,
- 11:51that's where all your freedom lies. That's the doorway.
- 11:55Every time you catch yourself standing in that gap, you get a choice that you
- 12:00didn't have five seconds ago.
- 12:02You get to ask, is my meaning true?
- 12:05Is it the only meaning? Is it the meaning I want to keep?
- 12:09What else could this mean? What would I see if I were being generous instead of scared?
- 12:15That's the whole practice. Camera on the left, meaning on the right, and a breath in between.
- 12:22I hope you understand that you're not wrong for adding meaning.
- 12:25We all do it. Our brains are designed that way.
- 12:28They are meaning-making machines. It's how we were built.
- 12:33God designed us to be creatures who make sense of the world by giving it shape and story.
- 12:39The work is not to stop making meaning. The work is to know that's what you're doing.
- 12:45Because the moment you know, you're free. The moment you can see that layer,
- 12:50you can question the layer.
- 12:52And once you can question it, you can choose something different.
- 12:56That's the freedom that I want for you.
- 13:00So today, if this episode hits home for you, if you felt a little flicker of,
- 13:04oh, I do that, I want to invite you to go one step further.
- 13:09Everything we talked about today is the very first step on my Clarity Map.
- 13:13It's a six-step coaching tool that I use with every one of my clients to help
- 13:17them move from a hard, tangled moment into clarity, connection, and choice.
- 13:23Observation is where it begins, but there are five more steps after it,
- 13:27and each one gives you back a little more of yourself.
- 13:31You can grab the Clarity Map for free over at seasons-coaching.com,
- 13:36print it out, keep it in your journal, tuck it in your scriptures,
- 13:38or hang it on your mirror.
- 13:40Wherever you will see it and where
- 13:42it will meet you the next time a hard conversation catches you off guard.
- 13:47And if this episode resonated with you, would you do me a favor and share it
- 13:52with a friend who needs it?
- 13:54That's how this little corner of the world keeps growing. Until next week,
- 13:58remember, you've got this.
- 14:00Let freedom ring, friend, and I'll see you soon.