Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Why Intuit Stock Plummeted Despite Record Profits
Transcript
- 0:00You know, there is like a basic rule of gravity on Wall Street.
- 0:04Right, the whole good news equals stock goes up thing.
- 0:07Exactly. Usually when you see a company
- 0:09report its most profitable quarter ever, there's this
- 0:12expectation of a celebration. You expect the financials to
- 0:15look great, the analysts to applaud and you know the stock
- 0:19to just go up. Yeah, it's a clean, almost
- 0:21binary reaction. Right, But then you step into
- 0:24the world of Intuit. Yes, the giant behind TurboTax
- 0:29and QuickBooks. Yep.
- 0:30You look at their latest earnings and suddenly that basic
- 0:32physics just completely breaks down.
- 0:35I mean, they posted an absolute blowout quarter and the market
- 0:38responded by basically throwing their stock off a Cliff.
- 0:41Yeah, a 13% drop practically overnight.
- 0:44It is the absolute definition of a financial paradox.
- 0:47It really is. Because when the market behaves
- 0:49this irrationally, it usually means someone is fundamentally
- 0:52misunderstanding the data. And that is exactly what we are
- 0:55going to untangle today. Welcome to the deep dive
- 0:59everyone. Our mission today is to analyze
- 1:01a massive stack of financial research and SEC filings
- 1:04regarding Intuit Inc trading under the ticker INTU.
- 1:08It's. A wild ride.
- 1:09It really is. We are going to figure out why a
- 1:12company with seemingly stellar financials just saw its
- 1:15valuation contracts so violently.
- 1:17Like is it a dying dinosaur or is it the completely
- 1:20misunderstood deep value opportunity?
- 1:23That's the billion dollar question.
- 1:24Literally. But before we unpack all this
- 1:26data, we have a quick community note for you to access more
- 1:29advanced researches, applications and our latest
- 1:31published personal intelligence Multi Agent Deep value
- 1:34Intelligence. Welcome to explore and join deep
- 1:37values dot AI community track total market temperature.
- 1:40Welcome to Search and download iOS App Buffet indicator from
- 1:43Apple App Store. Disclaimer All analysis is based
- 1:47on publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions
- 1:50or differing interpretations. All contents from this channel
- 1:54is for information and research purposes only and does not
- 1:57constitute investment advice. Conduct your own due diligence
- 2:00before making investment decisions.
- 2:02If you like to access wider topics, including life and
- 2:05investing philosophy, please subscribe to our sister channel
- 2:08Deep Values. Don't forget to like this video.
- 2:11Much appreciated all. Right.
- 2:12So let's get into the actual filings, because when you start
- 2:15peeling back the layers of these research notes, this isn't just
- 2:19some dry accounting story. Oh, not at all.
- 2:21No, this is a full blown corporate drama.
- 2:24You've got AI disruption, mass layoffs, and billionaires
- 2:28betting their own personal wealth.
- 2:29Yeah, it's got all the makings of a thriller, really.
- 2:31Right. So we have to start with the
- 2:32immediate paradox that triggered this whole investigation, that
- 2:36bizarre market reaction to their Q32026 earnings.
- 2:40Right, the quarter ending April 30th.
- 2:42Exactly. Looking at the notes on their
- 2:44performance leading up to April, you'd think they'd be popping
- 2:47champagne. Let me just read these stats.
- 2:50Revenue hit 8.5, then $8 billion.
- 2:54Which is a 10.4% jump year over year.
- 2:57Right, a massive jump. And their adjusted EPS earnings
- 3:00per share was $12.80. That beat consensus by $0.23.
- 3:06By every traditional metric, they completely knocked it out
- 3:08of the park. But instead of a rally, the
- 3:10stock contracts 13%, sliding all the way down to that 300 and
- 3:1583384 range. OK, let's unpack this.
- 3:18Please do. So imagine a packed restaurant.
- 3:21The owner is looking around and realizes the people taking up
- 3:24the most tables are only ordering tap water and like the
- 3:28cheapest side salads. Yeah, the low margin crowd.
- 3:30Right, so overnight the owner decides to completely remodel.
- 3:34They tear out the cheap booths, fire the wait staff dedicated to
- 3:37that section, and start building this VIP lounge for high paying
- 3:41state customers. Right.
- 3:42Makes business sense. It does, but the market walks by
- 3:45the very next morning, sees the construction debris in the fired
- 3:48waiters, and immediately panics, assuming the restaurant is going
- 3:51bankrupt. That is a perfect analogy and
- 3:54what's fascinating here is that the markets panic wasn't about
- 3:56the revenue into it made, it was exclusively about the specific
- 4:00customers they are actively losing.
- 4:02The tap water customers. Exactly.
- 4:05During the earnings call, their CEO Sasonga Darzi made this
- 4:09really brutal admission. He flat out said that Intuit
- 4:13lost on price. Lost on price?
- 4:15Wow, you don't hear tech monopolies admit that very
- 4:17often. You really don't.
- 4:18They saw a massive wave of churn among highly price sensitive do
- 4:22it We are talking about the DIY cried making under $50,000 a
- 4:27year. And I mean, in a tough
- 4:28macroeconomic environment, that demographic is feeling the
- 4:32squeeze more than anyone. Oh, absolutely.
- 4:34They aren't going to pay a premium software fee when they
- 4:36can go find a free alternative online.
- 4:39So Intuit basically admitted they're getting undercut in the
- 4:42cheap seats. And Wall Street hates to hear a
- 4:44tech giant admit they are losing ground anywhere.
- 4:47Yeah, the market hates weakness. But management didn't just, you
- 4:52know, shrug this off. They reacted with an absolute
- 4:55sledgehammer. They really did.
- 4:56They announced a massive 17% workforce reduction.
- 5:00Over 3000 employees cut just like that.
- 5:03Yeah, that is not a small pivot. Yeah, that triggers A
- 5:06restructuring charge of over $300 million, maybe up to 340
- 5:10million just to execute the layoffs.
- 5:12Which is a massive hit to take voluntarily.
- 5:15Right, They are entirely shutting down offices in Reno
- 5:19and Woodland Hills. They are pulling back on
- 5:22marketing initiatives for MailChimp, and they're
- 5:25aggressively eliminating duplicate roles.
- 5:27Roles that have probably been sitting around since they merged
- 5:30TurboTax and Credit Karma, right?
- 5:31Exactly. So when you see a a company
- 5:34slash 17% of its staff, the immediate assumption is, well,
- 5:38the ship is sinking. Yeah, they're throwing cargo
- 5:39overboard just to keep the lights on.
- 5:41Right, but when you dig into their forward-looking
- 5:43statements, that thesis falls apart completely.
- 5:47It falls apart because management actually raised their
- 5:50full year fiscal 2026 guidance at the exact same time they
- 5:56announced those layoffs. Wait, really?
- 5:57They raised guidance while firing 3000 people.
- 6:00Yes, they are projecting a 13 to 14% growth rate for the year.
- 6:05A dying company doesn't raise its profit guidance.
- 6:08No, definitely not. What we are witnessing is
- 6:10ruthless, deliberate pruning. They are actively shedding those
- 6:15low margin, high churn customers so they can redirect all their
- 6:19capital and engineering talent to focus on high margin growth.
- 6:22So if they are deliberately walking away from the budget
- 6:25filers, what's actually keeping the lights on?
- 6:28Right. What's the core engine?
- 6:30Yeah. What is the core engine they are
- 6:31trying to protect? Because when I look at the
- 6:33broader landscape into it is facing some terrifying
- 6:36existential threats. They absolutely are.
- 6:38Let's look at their revenue mix first, because according to
- 6:41their fiscal year 2510 K, 59% of their revenue comes from Global
- 6:46Business Solutions. Which is the QuickBooks
- 6:47ecosystem? Right.
- 6:49And the remaining 41% comes from the consumer group, which is
- 6:52mostly TurboTax and Credit Karma.
- 6:54And that mix surprises a lot of people.
- 6:57The majority of their lifeblood isn't actually individual
- 7:00consumer taxes. It's small to mid market
- 7:02businesses running their day-to-day operations on
- 7:04QuickBooks. Precisely.
- 7:06OK, but I have to push back here because those two segments are
- 7:09under absolute siege right now. You mean the twin threats?
- 7:12Yes, first you have the AI disruption.
- 7:15We are seeing the rise of incredibly powerful open source
- 7:19large language models and autonomous AI agents that can do
- 7:23complex reasoning. Right, the AI threat.
- 7:26Yeah, so won't software like bookkeeping and basic tax prep
- 7:29just become completely free? And 2nd, the government is
- 7:33actively encroaching on their territory.
- 7:35The IRS Direct file system. Exactly, the IRS is rapidly
- 7:38expanding that free federal alternative.
- 7:41So why would any rational person or business pay into it a
- 7:44massive premium when the government and open source AI
- 7:48will do it for $0.00? Those are the exact twin threats
- 7:51that spooked Wall Street into that 13% sell off.
- 7:54Yeah, it makes sense why they panicked.
- 7:56But if we connect this to the bigger picture, you start to see
- 8:00the incredibly wide structural Moat into it has built to defend
- 8:04against both of those things. OK, let's break that down.
- 8:06Let's take the threat to that 59% of their business,
- 8:09QuickBooks. Wall Street assumes software is
- 8:12easily replaceable, but QuickBooks has massive, almost
- 8:16insurmountable switching costs. Let's ground that for a second.
- 8:20Yeah. How does a switching cost
- 8:21actually play out for a real small business?
- 8:24Imagine you run a 50 person logistics company.
- 8:27OK, logistics company. Your entire operational history
- 8:30is in QuickBooks. Your biweekly payroll systems,
- 8:33your contractor tax ledgers, your complex cash flow
- 8:37projections is all deeply integrated into this one
- 8:40platform. So it's basically the nervous
- 8:42system of the company. Exactly.
- 8:43Yeah, Now if a cheaper AI driven bookkeeping startup pitches you,
- 8:48migrating those complex financial ledgers isn't just a
- 8:51weekend IT project. Right, it's a huge headache.
- 8:53It is a massive operational hazard.
- 8:56You risk data corruption. You risk missing payroll.
- 9:00You have to retrain your entire accounting department on a
- 9:03completely new interface. Oh wow, yeah, that sounds awful.
- 9:07No rational business owner is going to risk an employee mutiny
- 9:11over missed paychecks just to save, you know, 40 bucks a month
- 9:15on a software subscription. Right, the friction of leaving
- 9:17is simply too high. And that creates incredibly low
- 9:21customer churn, which gives Intuit massive pricing power.
- 9:25OK. The business side makes sense.
- 9:27The pain of switching is worse than the price of staying.
- 9:29But what about the consumer side?
- 9:31What about TurboTax? Right, the 41%.
- 9:33Yeah, if a free AI agent can just instantly read my W2 and
- 9:37file it, that whole segment of their business is dead in the
- 9:40water. That assumes into it is trying
- 9:42to build walls to fight AI. Are they not?
- 9:45They aren't fighting it at all, they are absorbing it.
- 9:47The research details their massive transition toward a
- 9:50proprietary generative AI operating system, which they
- 9:53call Genous. Oh, genous, I saw that in the
- 9:56filing. Yeah, to train an AI to do
- 9:59complex financial workflows, you need an ocean of highly
- 10:02structured, flawless data. Intuit has the private financial
- 10:07data of 100 million customers. 100 million.
- 10:10That is an insane data advantage A.
- 10:12New open source AI startup simply cannot replicate that
- 10:16scale of proprietary data. But having the data is one
- 10:18thing, right? How you sell it is another, and
- 10:21what stood out to me in these notes is the specific way
- 10:24they're deploying this AI. The hybrid model.
- 10:27Exactly. They aren't just slapping a
- 10:29chatbot on their homepage. They are using a hybrid model.
- 10:32TurboTax Live and QuickBooks Live.
- 10:35And this brings us to the single most critical data point in
- 10:38their entire earnings report. While the cheap DIY sector was
- 10:41churning, TurboTax live volume grew by 36%.
- 10:45That is a staggering #36% growth in their premium tier.
- 10:49It really is. And the psychology behind why
- 10:51that is happening is fascinating.
- 10:52It turns out people don't actually want an autonomous AI
- 10:55to blindly file their taxes in the background.
- 10:57No, the stakes are simply too high.
- 10:59Exactly. Consumers are inherently
- 11:01terrified of the IRS. Right, because if a free open
- 11:04source AI hallucinates A deduction or makes a
- 11:08mathematical error, the AI doesn't go to jail.
- 11:11You do. Exactly, you are the one who
- 11:13gets audited. So what Intuit realized is that
- 11:16people want the speed and the magic of AI doing the heavy
- 11:19lifting, gathering all the documents, doing the math.
- 11:21Right, doing the boring stuff. Yeah, but they desperately want
- 11:25a human expert to look them in the eye, verify the AI's work,
- 11:29and sign off on it so they can sleep at night.
- 11:32And that hybrid model, connecting automated AI
- 11:34workflows with a proprietary network of thousands of virtual
- 11:39AI enabled human experts creates a premium service category.
- 11:42A purely free digital alternative just can't offer
- 11:45that human liability shield. It's the difference between self
- 11:48diagnosing on web MD and having a doctor actually confirm the
- 11:51diagnosis. You will always pay a premium
- 11:53for the doctor's signature. OK, so the narrative is shifting
- 11:56here. We know the threats and we know
- 11:58into its defense strategy, high switching cost on the business
- 12:01side and human verified AI on the consumer side.
- 12:04But how do we actually quantify who is winning this tug of war?
- 12:09We have to look at the raw value metrics and more importantly, we
- 12:12need to look at what the people inside the company are doing
- 12:14with their own personal money. Let's run the devalue audit.
- 12:18If you are a strict traditional value investor, Intuit's surface
- 12:22numbers look like an absolute disaster.
- 12:26Let's slow down and look at these metrics because on AER it
- 12:29screams value trap. The trailing 12 month price to
- 12:33earnings. the PE ratio is sitting at 23.28 right now.
- 12:38The strict baseline limit for a deep value play is usually APE
- 12:42of 15, so it's already looking expensive there.
- 12:44Very expensive. Then you look at the Peter Lynch
- 12:46PEG ratio which is at 1.25. Remind me how the PEG ratio
- 12:50changes the story from a standard PE?
- 12:52So the standard PE ratio just tells you how much you were
- 12:55paying for $1.00 of the company's current earnings.
- 12:59But Peter Lynch championed the PEG ratio price to earnings to
- 13:02growth because it factors in how fast the company is actually
- 13:05growing. Got it?
- 13:06A PEG ratio under 1 means the stock is cheap relative to its
- 13:10growth rate. Since Intuit is at 1.25, it
- 13:14technically fails that test too. And then there is the price to
- 13:17book ratio, the PB sitting way up at 5.21.
- 13:21This is where you really need context on why it fails these
- 13:24old school tests yet remains A dominant company.
- 13:27Right, because PB is tricky for for software.
- 13:29Exactly. Traditional price to book ratios
- 13:32were designed a century ago for industrial companies.
- 13:35They were meant for businesses, where the intrinsic value sits
- 13:38in physical factories, heavy machinery and warehouses full of
- 13:42inventory. Assets you can literally touch
- 13:44appraise and sell for scrap if the company goes under.
- 13:47Precisely. But Intuit is an asset light
- 13:50software company, right? Their true assets are
- 13:52intellectual property, millions of lines of proprietary code,
- 13:56and those 100 million customer data points.
- 13:58And none of that not immense value sits neatly on a
- 14:01traditional balance sheet. So naturally their price to book
- 14:03ratio looks artificially inflated.
- 14:05OK, that makes sense. But if you want to see where
- 14:08Intuit passes the deep value tests with flying colors, you
- 14:12have to look at their sheer operational efficiency.
- 14:15The efficiency numbers are actually wild.
- 14:18Their gross margin is hovering around 80%. 80%, that is huge.
- 14:22Huge. Their Net margin is nearly 22%
- 14:26and then you look at their ten year average return on invested
- 14:28capital, their ROIC, it is an incredible 25.4%.
- 14:34Which is staggering over a 10 year period.
- 14:36Basically, for every dollar management puts back into the
- 14:39business, they generate a massive reliable return of over
- 14:43$0.25 on that dollar year after year.
- 14:46That kind of compound efficiency is rare, but if you really want
- 14:50to know what a company is truly worth, ignore the public metrics
- 14:53and watch what the executives do with their own wallets.
- 14:55Yes. Here's where it gets really
- 14:57interesting. Let's rewind to March 16th,
- 14:592026. The insider signal.
- 15:02Yes, the entire executive leadership team made a highly
- 15:06unusual synchronized move. And it wasn't just the mid level
- 15:10executives. The founder, Scott Cook, who
- 15:13personally holds over $2.3 billion in company equity, got
- 15:17involved. He's a major.
- 15:19Player they all suddenly terminated their pre scheduled
- 15:21rule 10B51 automatic stock sales.
- 15:24We need to explain how significant that is.
- 15:26Executives use these 10B51 plans to slowly and automatically sell
- 15:32off portions of their stock over a scheduled period.
- 15:35It's completely blind to the current stock price, right?
- 15:37Right, It's how they get liquid cash to buy houses or pay taxes
- 15:40without getting hit by insider trading accusations.
- 15:43So stopping that is a big deal. Terminating those automated
- 15:46plans is a massive logistical headache.
- 15:49It means they looked at the crashing stock price and made a
- 15:51conscious collective decision. They essentially said this
- 15:54market reaction is completely wrong.
- 15:56The stock is way too cheap and I'm not selling a single share
- 16:00at these. Levels exactly.
- 16:01Not only did they stop selling, but the company itself started
- 16:04buying aggressively. They accelerated their corporate
- 16:07stock buybacks, deploying $1.6 billion in the third quarter
- 16:11alone. They essentially doubled what
- 16:13they were spending on a buybacks in previous quarters.
- 16:15Which forces us to look at the actual evaluation gap.
- 16:18Why are the insiders so utterly confident?
- 16:21To figure that out, we look at the discounted cash flow models
- 16:24from the research, the DCF analysis.
- 16:28Let's run the numbers. ADCF model is basically a
- 16:31financial time machine. IT projects how much free cash
- 16:35the company will generate over the next decade and
- 16:38mathematically discounts all that future money back to what
- 16:41it is worth in today's dollars. OK, so let's look at how the
- 16:43math plays out. The research ran a few different
- 16:46scenarios. First, the worst case, highly
- 16:50conservative scenario. The doomsday model.
- 16:52Right. They modeled a world where
- 16:54intuits cash flow actually shrinks by over 3% a year for a
- 16:57decade. Under that pessimistic model,
- 17:00the intrinsic value of the stock comes out to $242.72.
- 17:04But that assumes a total structural collapse.
- 17:07Now look at the nominal more realistic scenario.
- 17:10If we assume they grow their cash flow at a modest 12% a
- 17:14year, which by the way is actually well below their
- 17:16historical average growth rate, the compounding effect is
- 17:20massive. Wait.
- 17:21What is the intrinsic value hit under that model?
- 17:24Under that 12% model, the intrinsic value skyrockets to
- 17:28800 and $31.06 per share. Wow, let that number sink in.
- 17:34The intrinsic value is $831.00, and after that post earnings
- 17:38panic, the market has the stock trading around 383.
- 17:43Based on that nominal DCF model, the company is offering a
- 17:46staggering 53.9% margin of safety.
- 17:49It is a massive discount for a company operating with 80% gross
- 17:52margins. It explains exactly why the
- 17:54founder and the executives halted their stock sales and
- 17:57fired up the buyback machine. They aren't betting the house on
- 18:01a dying dinosaur. No, they're betting the house
- 18:03because they see a structurally undervalued cash machine that
- 18:07the broader market has temporarily mispriced due to a
- 18:11complete misunderstanding of their strategic pivot.
- 18:14So what does this all mean? When you stack all this research
- 18:16together, a very clear picture emerges.
- 18:19It does. Into It isn't a company being
- 18:22quietly destroyed by free open source AI or a new government
- 18:27filing website. It is a company making a very
- 18:30loud, very aggressive choice to shed its low margin, high turn
- 18:35customers. Yeah, they are perfectly willing
- 18:37to take the short term hit to their stock and their workforce
- 18:40to double down entirely on an extremely profitable high
- 18:44switching cost hybrid AI platform.
- 18:47They are trading in the cheap appetizers to build a
- 18:50steakhouse. This raises an important
- 18:52question, and it's something I hope you ponder long after this
- 18:55deep dive is over an. Intrigued.
- 18:57We've spent the last few years completely terrified that AI is
- 19:00going to replace human workers entirely.
- 19:01Oh yeah, the AI doomsday narrative.
- 19:04Right, but look at into it's 36% growth in their live Human
- 19:08Services. If consumers will happily pay a
- 19:10premium just to have a human verify and validate the complex
- 19:13work and AI is already done, well, does that mean the future
- 19:16of white collar work isn't about humans competing with AI at.
- 19:19All Oh wow, think about that. The future economy might belong
- 19:23entirely to the humans who act as premium validators for AI
- 19:27output. Exactly.
- 19:29The AI does all the heavy lifting and data gathering, but
- 19:32the human holds the liability, the trust and ultimately the
- 19:36premium price tag. That completely flips the script
- 19:39on everything we've been told about AI.
- 19:41The value of the future isn't in generating the numbers, the real
- 19:44value is in providing the Peace of Mind.
- 19:47That is an incredible thought to leave on.
- 19:49Thank you so much for joining us on this deep dive.
- 19:52And a quick reminder, if you enjoyed this and want to explore
- 19:54wider topics including life and investing philosophy, be sure to
- 19:58check out our sister channel, Deep Values.
- 20:00Always a pleasure. So the next time you see a
- 20:02dominant company post record profits but the stock plummets
- 20:05like a fired waiter dropping a tray, well, don't just look at
- 20:08the mess on the floor. Pay very close attention to who
- 20:11they are clearing the tables for.
- 20:13We'll catch you on the next one.