Latest / Becker’s Payer Issues Podcast / Dr. Sachin Jain, President and CEO of SCAN Group
Transcript
- 0:02This is where health insurance leadership comes together.
- 0:05Becker's fourth annual spring payer issues roundtable brings
- 0:08together over 400
- 0:10payer and health plan executives and more than
- 0:13100 speakers to Chicago April.
- 0:16This year's event includes keynote conversations with the
- 0:19industry's top leaders and former president George W.
- 0:23Bush. For the full agenda and event details,
- 0:25visit beckershospitalreview.com
- 0:27and click on the events tab in the
- 0:29upper right. We're looking forward to hosting you
- 0:31here in Chicago.
- 0:33Hello, everyone. This is Jacob Emerson with the
- 0:36Becker's Pay Your Issues podcast. Thrilled today to
- 0:38be joined by SCAN Group president and CEO,
- 0:41doctor Sachin Jain. Doctor Jain, thanks so much
- 0:44for taking the time to chat with me
- 0:45on the podcast once again. Thanks so much
- 0:47for having me, Jacob. It's always an honor
- 0:49and a pleasure. Absolutely. Likewise. And, we've got
- 0:52a lot we wanna, talk with you about
- 0:54today, Sachin,
- 0:55about a piece you wrote for Forbes.
- 0:58But, obviously, as you know, there there's been
- 0:59a lot happening
- 1:01across the health care industry this year already
- 1:03in the first few weeks of the year.
- 1:05A lot of federal policy debate and proposals,
- 1:08in Washington.
- 1:09Got the CEOs of the largest insurers testifying
- 1:11before Congress last week over rising premiums.
- 1:14And then you wrote in your piece that,
- 1:16of course, that all of this is happening
- 1:17as trust in the industry overall remains fragile,
- 1:20given the events of the last couple of
- 1:22years. So
- 1:24against that backdrop,
- 1:25you published an op ed in Forbes this
- 1:27month outlining 10 health care leadership resolutions for
- 1:30the year ahead.
- 1:32You you noted it's it's not a trend
- 1:33forecast. It's not a strategy framework. It's a
- 1:36candid call for
- 1:38accountability.
- 1:39And you're arguing that health care's core challenge
- 1:40is not innovation fatigue or talent talent shortages,
- 1:44but a growing deficit of leadership resolve.
- 1:47So so, correct me if I if I
- 1:48frame that incorrectly at all, Sachin. But but
- 1:51how I wanna discuss I think you framed
- 1:52it I think you framed it better than,
- 1:54I framed it, Jacob. So thank you. Yeah.
- 1:55I appreciate it. Hear that. I mean, tell
- 1:57us, why'd you wanna write this piece? Why'd
- 1:59you wanna start up this year writing this
- 2:01in in such a public manner? Well, on
- 2:03a on a personal note, I'm a big
- 2:05New Year's resolutions guy, so I like to
- 2:08spend the last couple of weeks of the
- 2:09year thinking about the next year. And
- 2:12as I was doing that for myself on
- 2:14a personal level, I started to think about
- 2:18my resolutions from a professional perspective.
- 2:21And
- 2:22I started to think about the behaviors that
- 2:24I wanted to see more in myself and
- 2:26then also behaviors
- 2:27that I think we need to see, you
- 2:29know, more broadly. And,
- 2:32you know, number one is something I believe
- 2:34in, you know, to my core, which is
- 2:36that we all need to say the hard
- 2:38things and do the hard things more.
- 2:40I think health care is an industry that
- 2:42is just bereft with happy talk,
- 2:45and we need to kinda move beyond the
- 2:47happy talk in part because
- 2:49I think the happy talk actually gets in
- 2:52the way
- 2:53of actually addressing
- 2:55the real problems, the real elephants in the
- 2:57room. If we're constantly kinda talking about what's
- 2:59working,
- 3:00we're not talking about what's not working.
- 3:02And, you know, to connect it back to
- 3:04the trust point that you made earlier,
- 3:06we may not be talking about it as
- 3:08health care leaders,
- 3:09but all of our patients
- 3:11and health care workers are all talking about
- 3:13it everywhere.
- 3:15And so the trust gap builds when there's
- 3:18one talk track that's happening at a leadership
- 3:20level, and then there's another talk track that's
- 3:23happening at the patient
- 3:25and clinician level.
- 3:26And when those two things are, you know,
- 3:29increasingly misaligned,
- 3:31it actually
- 3:33widens the trust gap because it's it gives
- 3:35people the feeling
- 3:36that, you know, some people are living on
- 3:39Mars while other people are living on Venus.
- 3:41And
- 3:42we all need to be on planet Earth.
- 3:44And I think part of that begins with
- 3:46actually
- 3:47just naming the problem so that we can
- 3:49actually start to fix the problem.
- 3:52Sure. And I and I hear you loud
- 3:53and clear. I would, share
- 3:56in being,
- 3:57and getting sick of of the happy talk
- 3:59from leaders within the industry. I certainly hear
- 4:02hear it,
- 4:03daily. Nick, if you're only now getting sick
- 4:05of it, I mean, you just you listen
- 4:06to it all the time. So I'm just,
- 4:07you know, you listen to it more than
- 4:09I do. But let me ask you because
- 4:10I think where this is coming from is
- 4:12it's, from, you know, you wrote this isn't
- 4:14coming from lack of intelligence. It's it's not
- 4:16coming from people who don't know what they're
- 4:18doing. But at least from, you know, when
- 4:20I'm having interviews with very senior executives in
- 4:23this industry,
- 4:24they are scared to say what they really
- 4:26feel either because, you know, they they have
- 4:29their PR department that has written them very
- 4:31strict things to communicate.
- 4:33They don't wanna get into legal trouble. They
- 4:35don't wanna, you know, get into trouble with
- 4:37their board. Whatever it is, executives are often
- 4:39very afraid to step in it, and they
- 4:41don't wanna go in in the way that,
- 4:43you know, is, I think, framed as the
- 4:45correct way of communicating
- 4:47whatever we're talking about in the given moment.
- 4:49So
- 4:50how do you how do you counter something
- 4:52like that? Something that, I think innately is
- 4:55a fear, from a lot of leadership in
- 4:57the industry. Well, I'm glad you mentioned the
- 4:59PR people because I think we have a
- 5:01broken PR playbook for health care.
- 5:04And I liken it a lot to the
- 5:06Ivy League presidents that were
- 5:08in congress
- 5:10testifying
- 5:11and not answering questions that were asked very
- 5:13directly directly.
- 5:15And you see that that playbook
- 5:17of obfuscation,
- 5:19of
- 5:21being excessively careful in the face of hard
- 5:23questions,
- 5:25plays exactly the way that it played, you
- 5:27know, when the those Ivy League presidents were
- 5:29actually testifying
- 5:30before congress, which is actually plays very badly.
- 5:33If you're asked direct questions and you don't
- 5:35answer them directly, and if you're not speaking
- 5:37truth
- 5:38in situations where you're
- 5:39asked to speak truth,
- 5:41it leaves a certain taste in your mouth.
- 5:43And I think that,
- 5:44you know, the instructions that we're getting from
- 5:47PR people
- 5:48are outdated. Now we have a great PR
- 5:51department, small and mighty at SCAN.
- 5:53But, you know, the truth is is that
- 5:55we are,
- 5:57you know, getting out of the world of
- 5:59talking points and getting into the world of
- 6:01just speaking the truth plainly and simply and
- 6:04honestly.
- 6:05I think, you know, you know, we had
- 6:06this big national campaign last year with which
- 6:09was health insurance is broken,
- 6:11was our our tagline.
- 6:13You know, SCAN sees it and, is doing
- 6:16something to fix it.
- 6:18That's a very different message than you hear
- 6:19from almost all of our competitors,
- 6:22both on the payer side and the provider
- 6:24side, where most folks are touting their US
- 6:26News and World Report rankings.
- 6:28They're touting their,
- 6:30you know, VISIANT ratings. Whatever it is, the
- 6:33truth is is that
- 6:34if you actually
- 6:35look at what's really happening to patients and
- 6:38clinicians, health care is getting worse and not
- 6:40better.
- 6:41And if you actually say that out loud,
- 6:44it gives you the best chance possible to
- 6:46actually fix it.
- 6:48But I think we're robbing ourselves of that
- 6:50when we hide behind
- 6:52the p the simple PR talk. And, again,
- 6:55I'll just say that old playbooks are really,
- 6:57really outdated. Saying nothing is not a strategy.
- 7:01And so I would I think that one
- 7:02of the biggest opportunities we have as an
- 7:04industry to move forward the quality of leadership
- 7:07and the impact of leadership
- 7:09is to actually
- 7:11commit to speaking more plainly and more truthfully
- 7:14and more honestly
- 7:15about what's really going on.
- 7:17Absolutely. And I and I definitely would give
- 7:19kudos to SCAN for a very unique Medicare
- 7:22Advantage campaign last year, such and definitely one
- 7:25of the more candid moments we've seen in
- 7:26the industry over the last few years in
- 7:28terms of just openly talking about the frustrations
- 7:31that members all across the country, not not
- 7:33SCAN,
- 7:34have with their health plans.
- 7:36But I also wonder, you know, there's a
- 7:37lot of leaders that don't necessarily see themselves
- 7:40as wanting to be or needing to be
- 7:43mouthpieces
- 7:44for,
- 7:45industry wide change. They just wanna focus on,
- 7:48quiet
- 7:49operational discipline within their their specific organizations.
- 7:53Do you think that there's a risk here
- 7:55of them getting drowned out by people who
- 7:58are louder,
- 7:59even if those people are less,
- 8:02substantive in what they're saying? Yeah. Again, I'm
- 8:04gonna sound like a broken record, but I
- 8:06think it's an outdated playbook.
- 8:08I think, you know, one of the reasons
- 8:10we haven't had more policy change is that
- 8:12we are quietly going about our business, not
- 8:15really asking the hard questions and saying the
- 8:17hard things and and leading the kind of
- 8:19policy advocacy that we need. And what I'll
- 8:22say is if you're not part of driving
- 8:23change, change will happen to you.
- 8:26That happens over and over again. History proves
- 8:28that, you know, change will happen to those
- 8:30who don't actually
- 8:31participate in creating it themselves.
- 8:33And so I think we, as leaders, have
- 8:36an opportunity and almost an obligation
- 8:38to take our knowledge of what's not working
- 8:41and actually work proactively
- 8:43to address it,
- 8:45whether it's through operations, but also through advocacy,
- 8:48through policy, through public proclamations. I I think
- 8:51when you don't speak in 2026,
- 8:54you're seen as, frankly, complicit in the status
- 8:57quo. And I don't think that that's unfair.
- 9:00I think if you are not part of
- 9:02the voices
- 9:04advocating for change, you are indeed part of
- 9:06the broken status quo. And that is not
- 9:09a position that I think history will look
- 9:11favorably upon,
- 9:13in the in the future. So I think
- 9:15we all have to,
- 9:17you know, really think hard about how we
- 9:19show up and what we really stand for
- 9:21and move beyond the platitudes. And one of
- 9:23the my least favorite industry platitudes is the
- 9:26no margin, no mission platitude because it avoids
- 9:29the kind of reflection that's actually
- 9:32necessary about what the actual mission is. And
- 9:35I don't think the mission is to just
- 9:37keep your organization alive no matter what. I
- 9:39think the mission is to heal people, to
- 9:42serve the community, to improve population health. That's
- 9:45the work that we really need to do.
- 9:47Yeah. No. It's a it's a good call
- 9:49out. I I like that you're calling out
- 9:51your least favorite platitude such, and I I
- 9:53think maybe mine I would add is, meeting
- 9:56the member where they are. I hear that
- 9:58consistently,
- 9:59probably on a weekly basis. And at least
- 10:01from my perspective, that seems like something that
- 10:03should have been What about what about right?
- 10:05Right care, right time, right place. That's another
- 10:07one I'm sure you hear a lot on
- 10:08this, podcast, Jacob. Yeah. Definitely. And, hey, it's
- 10:11it's it's also something I wanted to ask
- 10:12about in in terms of just what we
- 10:15hear so much of right now, but it's
- 10:17it's almost saying everything and yet nothing, and
- 10:19it's it's the AI conversation
- 10:22section. And I and I say that because
- 10:23it's almost like every press release,
- 10:25every product raw, every initiative, every project has
- 10:28to have some kind of AI powered, AI
- 10:30driven
- 10:31explainer on on attached to the front of
- 10:33it. And, you know, I know this technology
- 10:35is is has been transformative for the industry
- 10:38right now, but I wanted to connect it
- 10:40back to what something you said in your
- 10:41piece. Well, actually actually, Jacob, I've pushed. I
- 10:43don't think it has been transformative. Right? That's
- 10:45the point is that, you know, you know,
- 10:47are you or I getting in to see
- 10:49our primary care doctors any sooner? Yeah. Are
- 10:52you or I, you know, actually
- 10:54getting the kind of care that we need
- 10:56when we need it because of it, you
- 10:57know, something that some health system is enabled
- 10:59by AI? I don't think so. Sure. And
- 11:02so until the benefit really accrues to the
- 11:04end customer,
- 11:06I you know, which is the patient,
- 11:08I don't think we can actually say that
- 11:09AI has led to any real change. And
- 11:11I think a lot of what's happening right
- 11:12now is we're we're getting a lot of,
- 11:14quote, unquote, back office innovation, which is really
- 11:16about revenue cycle management and coding,
- 11:19and we're not necessarily getting patient facing innovation.
- 11:22I I had this, you know, my my
- 11:25team a couple weeks ago was presenting to
- 11:27us the chatbot
- 11:28that feed a chatbot feature, which is, you
- 11:30know, kind of table stakes that, you know,
- 11:32every company has. And I just kept thinking
- 11:34to myself, has anyone ever met a chatbot
- 11:36that they actually like?
- 11:38And I couldn't couldn't think of anyone who's
- 11:40there like, oh, man. I use the United
- 11:42Airlines chatbot, and it was really awesome.
- 11:45I really prefer that to actually interacting with
- 11:47a person. Now certainly, like, if I had
- 11:49a simple request, like, you know, you know,
- 11:51send me my membership card or something like
- 11:53that,
- 11:54Those those types of, you know, features are
- 11:57are helpful and reduce friction.
- 11:59But what most people's health care problems aren't
- 12:01as simple as needing a membership card or
- 12:03needing a, you know, a a a, you
- 12:06know, a referral to a specialist. I think
- 12:07it gets much more complicated than that.
- 12:10It you know? And and that's the work,
- 12:12you know, that we need to do is
- 12:13make those complicated things better and simpler.
- 12:16So until AI is actually influencing
- 12:20the the complicated things and truly making the
- 12:23system work better,
- 12:24You know, I think we're we haven't the
- 12:25game hasn't even started yet.
- 12:27No. And I I appreciate the pushback. I
- 12:29certainly am guilty of falling for the rhetoric,
- 12:32I think, just as much as anybody. And
- 12:33I I I think the question there, Sachin,
- 12:36is how should the leaders listening in, who
- 12:38can also be just as guilty of this,
- 12:39how can they distinguish themselves between genuine transformation,
- 12:43whether that be at the company or industry
- 12:45wide, and some of the organizational
- 12:47noise that you described in your piece? I
- 12:50would say skepticism is in and toxic positivity
- 12:52is out.
- 12:54And I think, you you know, the way
- 12:55we can actually you you know, another another
- 12:58truism that my friend, Aman Bandari,
- 13:01who is,
- 13:02you know,
- 13:03the head of AI and and data science
- 13:05at Vertex Pharmaceuticals
- 13:07is, you know, show me a startup that's
- 13:08actually moved the needle on care delivery.
- 13:11And it you know, the truth is there's
- 13:12a few. But for the most part,
- 13:15most of what, you know, the startup ecosystem,
- 13:18the venture ecosystem is doing is adding a
- 13:20lot of noise. Now they're getting a lot
- 13:21of attention right now.
- 13:23But the truth is is that, you know,
- 13:25there's a lot of noise,
- 13:26and the noise
- 13:27the noise to actual impact ratio is off
- 13:30the charts right now. And I'd like to
- 13:33see us really push the impact
- 13:35numbers up and reduce the noise. And, you
- 13:38know, maybe part of part of, you know,
- 13:41what a Beckers can do is is start
- 13:43to be a more skeptical voice. And I
- 13:44think health care journalism could play an important
- 13:47role in this too.
- 13:49It's yeah. It's I really appreciate that call
- 13:51out as well. I would agree.
- 13:53We definitely have a responsibility to be more
- 13:56skeptical in all of the communications that are
- 13:58coming our way and what the authorities on
- 14:01these topics are telling us. So, yeah, I
- 14:03would agree with you. A simple a simple
- 14:04fix here. I mean, again, I don't think
- 14:06Becker's does this that much, but I think
- 14:07a lot
- 14:08of venues just get really focused on the
- 14:10fundraising.
- 14:11Mhmm. Right? It's like, oh, Joe's startup has,
- 14:14you know, raised a series b that has
- 14:17x, y, and z investors, and it's, you
- 14:18know, $30,000,000 round.
- 14:20And, you know, we're not actually talking about,
- 14:24hey. Joe startup,
- 14:26move the needle
- 14:27on the care of diabetics in x health
- 14:30system. Right? That's the kind of conversation that
- 14:32we need to be having more of, and
- 14:34that's the kind of stuff that we should
- 14:36be elevating more, not, you know, whether someone
- 14:38was clever enough to, you know, raise money
- 14:41from a syndicate of investors. Yeah. Absolutely. And
- 14:44I think, unfortunately, that's also a symptom of
- 14:46our media
- 14:47media ecosystem,
- 14:49going towards what are the audiences clicking on.
- 14:52And I know that's an entire other conversation,
- 14:54so I won't, you know, go down that
- 14:55path session. Sure. Sure. Yeah. I'm sorry I
- 14:57took us there. Sorry. No no worries at
- 14:58all. But I I wanted to ask about
- 15:00a few of your resolutions.
- 15:02One is elevating frontline workers, the people who
- 15:04are actually doing the work of health care
- 15:07in these organizations,
- 15:08rooting out toxic positivity, ending performative initiatives.
- 15:13I think all of these things really require,
- 15:15these leaders at these companies to seed some
- 15:18of their power or or at least confront
- 15:21entrenched interests, within their own organizations, which, as
- 15:24you know, across the industry, these companies can
- 15:27be massive.
- 15:28So what makes you confident that
- 15:30executives
- 15:32will actually do this, can actually do this
- 15:34kind of thing, rather than simply agreeing with
- 15:36you having the good intentions,
- 15:38but then moving on same as usual?
- 15:41Well, I think we need to change. I
- 15:42think everyone knows we need to change. I
- 15:44think most people in the middle ranks of
- 15:46most health care organizations
- 15:48are miserable.
- 15:49And I'll tell you why they're miserable. They're
- 15:50miserable because there's the happy talk that's coming
- 15:53from the top, and then there's the frontline
- 15:55reality that they're trying to manage and buffer.
- 15:58And they are struggling with the cognitive dissonance
- 16:02of the words they hear from their bosses
- 16:04and the cries that they hear from the
- 16:07front lines
- 16:08and,
- 16:09you know, the impact that they may not
- 16:11be having on patients.
- 16:14And so I think, you know, most people
- 16:16live with a certain
- 16:18amount of cognitive dissonance and moral discomfort.
- 16:21And I think, you know, part of what
- 16:23I wanted to do with these resolutions is
- 16:25give them a language, give these folks a
- 16:27language,
- 16:28and maybe even point to me or point
- 16:30to this article and say, look at what
- 16:32this guy's saying. How does this apply to
- 16:33our organization?
- 16:35It's not easy for someone to say these
- 16:36things out loud themselves. They are the things
- 16:38that they grumble about when they're talking to
- 16:40their friends and their families.
- 16:42But, you know, if it's an article form,
- 16:44maybe it's the kind of thing that can
- 16:46circulate
- 16:47and start a productive conversation
- 16:49about how these behaviors are happening in one's
- 16:52organizations and how they can move beyond them.
- 16:55So you're laying the groundwork for other leaders,
- 16:58to
- 16:59to use themselves, Sachin. I wonder, you know,
- 17:02jumping off of what we what we talked
- 17:04about, and what we saw last week in
- 17:06congress with some of the CEOs of the
- 17:07largest insurers,
- 17:09and and what was said or or what
- 17:11was not said, I think.
- 17:13Do you see examples of what you're talking
- 17:15about today already happening in the industry? Is
- 17:18there something you would point to that gives
- 17:19you hope that the industry is on the
- 17:21right path,
- 17:23or or am I framing that correctly? How
- 17:24would you describe where we're at in this
- 17:26process? You know, I give the folks at
- 17:27AHIP,
- 17:29a a a lot of credit for some
- 17:31of the work that came out of the
- 17:33post Brian Thompson murder. Right? The reform
- 17:37that they put in place, I think, was
- 17:39was meaningful, and it was potentially transformative. Certainly
- 17:42steps in the right direction and something that
- 17:44we at Scan
- 17:45have participated in as well.
- 17:47That said, I don't think we're going far
- 17:49enough because I think
- 17:51what the dominant culture is is to
- 17:54treat answering phones,
- 17:56and and contracting networks like we're saving lives.
- 17:59And
- 18:00I have a message to everyone in the
- 18:02pair industry who,
- 18:04you know, believes that we're saving lives we're
- 18:06not. I think the people on the front
- 18:08lines of care delivery
- 18:09are. Our work is to enable those people.
- 18:12But in many cases, we're putting barriers up
- 18:14to people actually accessing care, and we have
- 18:17to make things
- 18:18as easy as possible. We have to treat
- 18:19people like they're human beings,
- 18:21and we have to rehumanize our industry. I
- 18:23think that that term, rehumanization,
- 18:27is something that
- 18:28really needs to start to resonate and percolate
- 18:31in boardrooms and management teams
- 18:34because,
- 18:36unfortunately, a lot of what people have experienced
- 18:38is actually dehumanization,
- 18:39not not humanization.
- 18:42Wonderful. I I think that's a really good
- 18:44place to leave things, doctor Jain. So I
- 18:46wanna thank you for taking the time to
- 18:48chat with me on the podcast, and as
- 18:50always for for being candid with us and
- 18:52with our listeners,
- 18:54in what you said can often be,
- 18:56an industry and and periods where it's difficult
- 18:59to to hear those kinds of perspectives. So
- 19:02thank you for doing so. I really appreciate
- 19:04it. Always a pleasure, Jacob. Thank you so
- 19:06much, and, really appreciate the time. Yeah. Likewise.
- 19:09And and to our listeners, if you'd like
- 19:10to listen to more podcasts from Becker's, you
- 19:12can visit beckershospitalreview.com.