Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Jodi Arias - (Chapter 4)
Transcript
- 0:00So Burto. This is chapter four in our Deep Dive on the Psychology of
- 0:03Jodi Arius. Let's get into it. What do you say, Let's do
- 0:07it. This is the Psychology and Seattle podcast. I'm your host, doctor
- 0:09Kurkanda, a therapist and professor. My name is and I am a hug
- 0:14trainer. A hug trainer. Yeah, I help people give better hugs.
- 0:17I don't think you're the most qualified person to give those kinds of people that
- 0:22know do the people that don't teach so Burto. This is chapter four in
- 0:28our Deep Dive on the Psychology of jodi Arius epic. And what we're doing
- 0:34is with each chapter, we're going to have an initial portion that is free
- 0:37for everyone, and then and then the second portion will be for patrons of
- 0:41the podcast. Because I've been spending so much time on this that I feel
- 0:45like I want to reward those people who give me the ability to spend so
- 0:49much time on such a topic some value. Yeah, So let's just start
- 0:54where we left off last time with chapter three, and we just got done
- 0:58talking about style, her stalking of him and just how extensive it was.
- 1:03I think I said something like, if there are twenty different signs of stalking.
- 1:07She had twenty one of them, And we also talked about how to
- 1:11protect yourself from stalking and why people stock. You talked about how you in
- 1:18essence kind of behaved like a stalker with your current wife when you were first
- 1:23dating, or how you different patterns. But he didn't like that there was
- 1:29a guy that she was hanging out with that was just a friend, and
- 1:32so you called him on the phone and acted like you were doing a survey.
- 1:37Yeah, you called him on the phone and acted like you were giving
- 1:40a survey as a way of trying to intimidate him or scare him or something.
- 1:45And you were twenty at the time or something. And we talked about
- 1:48how for you, you're not a psychopath. And the reason why people will
- 1:53stock is because of the deep attachment needs and traumas that doesn't justified. Of
- 2:00course, it's still criminal behavior, but understanding it gives us better understanding.
- 2:05It also gives us a way to curb that kind of behavior or prevent it.
- 2:08So the next part of the story we are now in is they're in
- 2:15a zone of their relationship Jody and Travis where they're officially broken up, but
- 2:20they are occasionally seeing each other, and he is starting to date other people.
- 2:25So at this point she wrote that in her diary that she was seriously
- 2:31thinking about suicide. So with borderline personality disorder, which was eventually applied to
- 2:38her by a psychologist that evaluated her during the trial, it is often considered
- 2:44one of the manipulative tactics is to use suicidal threats, and it certainly can
- 2:51be but it usually is genuine. The reason why with people with borderline are
- 2:55often framed as being manipulative is because if you or the target of that,
- 3:00like I don't know if if Jody did this, but it wouldn't be beyond
- 3:04the realm of possibility that she really wanted Travis back because they fell in love,
- 3:09they had this five month intense relationship, and we hypothesize that maybe she
- 3:15had a lot of abandonment, betrayal trauma's growing up, and so she was
- 3:20having that trauma triggered for her, and so she really wants them back,
- 3:23and you know, she's in love, So there's nothing wrong with wanting someone
- 3:27that you're in love with to be in a relationship with you. So there's
- 3:30some normalcy to that, and she starts to feel very sad and very hurt,
- 3:38very betrayed, very demoralized. So in that situation, it's very common
- 3:43for people to become suicidal, meaning that they don't know any other way out,
- 3:46they don't know any other way to solve the problem. They're in pain,
- 3:51and they try lots of different things. And we also know through research
- 3:53that a major factor in suicidal thoughts and behavior is what we call thwarted belongingness,
- 4:00meaning you want to belong, but you're being thwarted to from getting that.
- 4:04Although I can totally see, especially in her case, but it being
- 4:11both, you know, it's a manipulative tactic and it can be real.
- 4:14Right. In fact, kids do this a lot. I remember being a
- 4:16child and thinking, you know, stuff like like self destructive stuff like fine,
- 4:23and I'll just you know whatever, I'll just burn my book or I'll
- 4:26I'll just destroy this thing just to show them. Right, you probably do
- 4:30feel like you're The feeling of destroying it is probably real, and you're also
- 4:34trying to spite or manipulate or whatever. And so in this extreme case,
- 4:40that thought, I could see it brewing, like fine, I guess I'll
- 4:43just kill myself, and I really do want to, but I'm also trying
- 4:46to manipulate, right, Or I'm trying to emphasize how important this person is
- 4:50to me. Or I'm doing everything I can to prevent myself from killing myself,
- 4:55or I'm trying to do anything I can to get this person back.
- 4:58So from the outside, it looks manipulative, and it feels manipulative, and
- 5:01you could argue it is a manipulative but it's not like the person who wakes
- 5:04up and says, haha, I have borderline person die order. I'm gonna
- 5:09lie and say I'm suicidal as a way of trying to manipulate other people.
- 5:13It's not like she probably called them and said, listen, I know we've
- 5:16been going through some struggles, but I have to tell you something. I
- 5:18actually I really am, honestly feeling a bit suicidal. I need to do
- 5:23something about it. Maybe you can help me. It's not I'm imagining.
- 5:26That wasn't the conversation right exactly. It was probably more like I gotta tell
- 5:29you if you leave me, I'm probably gonna kill myself. Yeah yeah.
- 5:32And the classic is you'll get a text saying I need to talk to you,
- 5:39and you're like, you just ignore it, you just signore it because
- 5:43you've been drawing all these boundaries. You said, we're broken up, I
- 5:46can't talk with you anymore, and it's always at eleven anyways, when contact,
- 5:49it's always an emergency. Yeah, And then at two in the morning
- 5:54you get a text that it's like, I just don't know what to do
- 5:56anymore. And then you don't reply, and then they're like, well,
- 6:00I guess you don't care about my life and you don't reply, and then
- 6:02they say, well, I guess this is goodbye because I'm gonna kill myself
- 6:09unless you call or something. And again, they could be serious, and
- 6:13they could be in a serious emotional state do their due to their traumas and
- 6:17possible ancillary depression to this, And at the same time, like you said,
- 6:21they're also trying to get the person back. So around this time,
- 6:25she moves from Arizona back to California, because I remember she moved they broke
- 6:30up. She moved to be close to them and started cleaning his house and
- 6:34was stalking him, showing up at his in his under his Christmas tree.
- 6:40It's just such a never a good sign where when the person who you broke
- 6:44up with, who lives states away, moves right next to you. Yeah.
- 6:47Now, people listening to this might recall or know that Travis was occasionally
- 6:54still having sex with her, and we don't know what state of mind he
- 6:58was in. He could have been bloiding her desperation, using her so to
- 7:02speak. He could have been terrified and just trying to placate her, because
- 7:08presumably it wasn't just sex, it was also meeting up and talking. He
- 7:13could have been confused at times, like well, maybe this will work.
- 7:15He also could have been thinking, well, if we just meet up one
- 7:19last time and I convinced her to move on, she'll stop stalking me.
- 7:24It's just hard to know, and it's I mean, we have some signals.
- 7:28For example, one of the last times we talked about how the friends
- 7:30caught on way sooner right than him, to the point where they were like,
- 7:34she's not allowed back here, you know, like when your roommates have
- 7:39to set that rule for you. There's definitely a big disconnect, right,
- 7:43So we know that in some ways he was in denial. But then we
- 7:46have the anecdote later where he's like, yeah, if I if I'm dead
- 7:48one day, don't be surprised and then to your point, is there terror
- 7:53inside of him? Is there? Sort of like resignation is there? You
- 7:56know, it's confusion of like but what do I do? If I say
- 7:59no, then you'll kill me or kill herself. Guilt. He could have
- 8:01been feeling guilty that, well, what do I do? And there's not
- 8:05a lot of resources out there, I think, particularly for men in this
- 8:09situation, I mean for anyone. But the idea that men are even stocked
- 8:13by women is for some people just impossible. So he probably just you know,
- 8:18it's just hard to know what was going through a side. And by
- 8:22the way, and the carrot in this case isn't a trivial carrot. It
- 8:24is you know, sexuality is one of the most important things for humans,
- 8:28especially in that age, and he's in a situation where he's denying himself for
- 8:33religious reasons. So there's a big carrot, yeah, so to speak.
- 8:39So they both start dating other people. She appears to be kind of moving
- 8:43on. He starts dating Mimi and Lisa and presumably I guess, trying to
- 8:50find a wife. At this point, he's starting to blog about how he
- 8:54wants to settle down after having his twenties, flirting and having kind relationships.
- 9:01She starts to date Ryan Burns, another Mormon in Salt Lake City, maybe
- 9:05as a way of trying to recreate the past relationship or make him jealous.
- 9:07I don't know. But Travis and Jody keep talking on the phone, and
- 9:11at this point she's recording their conversations, including phone sex. Hard to know.
- 9:16Why Why do you think she might What are the possible theories as to
- 9:20why she would record their conversations and them having sex. Some ideas are at
- 9:24one, she wants to have them for herself because it reminds her of being
- 9:28close to him, or maybe her power over him or something too. She
- 9:33might be looking to not blackmail because well maybe with the church or something.
- 9:37Actually, she might be looking to do that. Third, it might just
- 9:41be a kink, like she likes recording herself. Yeah, it's not a
- 9:46stretch to believe that she would use it for blackmail. Yeah, because she
- 9:48was showing up at this point at the houses of the women that he was
- 9:54dating. Right, there was a woman named Lisa that I don't know if
- 9:58they have direct evidence, but they have strong evidence that she was stalking her
- 10:01as well and following Travis when he would go to their house, and on
- 10:07two occasions, allegedly Jody slashed his tires while his car was parked at her
- 10:13house. Yeah, Jody's like, well, okay, we're done. It's
- 10:16like, okay, well I have a very interesting set of things to show
- 10:18your church, right, someone at someone who And it'd be one thing if
- 10:22Jody just stood outside in her car sobbing watching. It's another thing that she
- 10:28went she would go up to the house and look in the window. She
- 10:30would knock on the window to try's scare and intimidate Lisa. She would knock
- 10:33on the door and run away, slashing the tires on two occasions. Like
- 10:37this is someone who is showing a pattern of aggression and hostility and criminality,
- 10:43and knowing what we know now, it's so those women must have been so
- 10:48frightened to think that they could have been killed. Yeah. In fact,
- 10:52I think some people believe that that's what she was intending on doing. That
- 10:58she was intending on going back not to kill Travis, but to kill whoever
- 11:01Travis was seeing. So at this point they are continuing to fight. There
- 11:07are chat logs of them having these really long, drying out fights. Now
- 11:13we are now at two in two thousand and eight, and Travis told friends
- 11:18that Jody and him were going on a trip to Cancun in June. Right,
- 11:22So this shows that Travis is still thinking he's involved with Jody and is
- 11:31publicly stating as well. That one's also confusing. You would think it'd be
- 11:35like, if he were thinking he was going to do that, he'd be
- 11:39hiding it from his friends. Well, the Cancoun trip was a prepaid legal
- 11:43convention trip, I believe, so it'd be hard to hide that given that
- 11:48I think she worked there him. Yeah. Also, I think it's just
- 11:56hard to know week to week where Travis was. Sometimes he was drawing a
- 12:00boundary. Sometimes they were fighting, sometimes he was having sex. Maybe sometimes
- 12:03he thought the other. Sometimes he was dating Lisa, sometimes he's dating MEMI.
- 12:07You know, I just think he's well. And I've seen it before
- 12:11with friends who have these toxic relationships and it doesn't matter what you tell them.
- 12:15All of a sudden you find out that they're getting married. Right,
- 12:18You're like, oh wait what. Yeah, it's just hard to know where
- 12:22he was. But early two thousand and eight, we see that he's still
- 12:28the pendulum swinging, is still going back and forth April, though, he
- 12:33changed his trip to include a friend instead, Mimi and not Jody. He
- 12:37was really pursuing Mimi. He really wanted to be with me. Mimi reportedly
- 12:43was saying she just wanted to be friends. She didn't want to be with
- 12:45him. And by the way, he never went on this trip. And
- 12:48we'll get into that later. There are texts between the two of them indicating
- 12:52fighting and some sort of sexual relationship. Oh so I oh, okay,
- 12:56I misunderstood. I asked me for some reason, had it in my mind
- 13:00that the trip was supposed to happen but he died before he could go on
- 13:03the trip? Is okay? Yeah, what do you think I meant?
- 13:05No? Just now, it made it sound like the trip came and went
- 13:09and he didn't go on it. Oh no, yeah, yeah, he
- 13:11died just before, you know, just days before, which is I always
- 13:15thought in my mind she was so upset that she was supposed to be going
- 13:18right and she got replaced right. So I'll get to that. And it's
- 13:22like March reportedly there's a shift in her journal from might we say, in
- 13:28the borderline personality lingo, from idealization to devaluation. She might have started at
- 13:37this point her plan to do something drastic devaluation? What does it mean in
- 13:43that context? So with people with borderline for the most part, and there's
- 13:48a lot of different profiles, but and of course there's a lot of different
- 13:50types in that there are some people that have been through treatment. There are
- 13:52some people who have a lot of self awareness, there are some people who
- 13:56don't. They're different degrees, blah blah blah. But generally speaking, people
- 13:58with borderline are really typified by having abandonment and betrayal traumas and also some amount
- 14:05of arrested development regarding black and white thinking in a variety of contexts, including
- 14:11attachments. So for a child, for example, when they're two years old,
- 14:16their parents are just wonderful all the time. But if you cross a
- 14:20two year old, they hate you from the bottom, from the bottom of
- 14:24their soul. They hate you. And then that'll pass and then they love
- 14:30you, and there's it's black and white. You're either idealized in their eyes
- 14:35or or devalued is the word. Yeah, So that is retained into adulthood
- 14:43for people with borderline because of trauma and disposition in all likelihood, and so
- 14:48with attachments, they will do that, and it looks as though she was
- 14:52idealizing him for a long time, fighting to be in the relationship, really
- 14:56trying to get him back, obsessing about him, you know, crossing a
- 15:01lot of boundaries, but determined to get back with him. So if someone
- 15:05is normally treating you nicely and kind of maybe even thinks highly of you,
- 15:11and then all of a sudden they start sending you long winded emails about how
- 15:13terrible everything about you is. Is that have you been devalued? Are you?
- 15:18Are you trying to diagnose someone right now? But it sounds like that
- 15:22in a in a little bit like right like you these swings between like maybe
- 15:26not you're the maybe not the child example, but definitely like you're a totally
- 15:31legit person in my worldview to you're the worst thing in my world. I
- 15:35mean, it depends if we just see that. It could be the result
- 15:37of a lot of things, but it is a red flag for that,
- 15:41particularly if it's a pattern and it's intense. Yeah, you'd also have to
- 15:46see the idealization, you know, if someone's just treating you normally as the
- 15:50way a lot of people would, and then suddenly they'd devalue you doesn't necessarily
- 15:56mean borderline, but it could so. In the journal previous to this shift
- 16:02in March, it was a lot of we're meant for each other, I
- 16:04love him, I want him back, Da da da, And then after
- 16:08this point in time, it's a lot of negativity about him, and I
- 16:15would hypothesize that this is when the seed was planted for something that she wanted
- 16:21to do. Potentially even literally, I'm going to kill him, or I'm
- 16:23going to kill someone in his life, or I'm going to kill someone,
- 16:29So that is possible. I don't know that. And they continue to occasionally
- 16:33talk and occasionally have sex beyond this point, but I think it might have
- 16:38had a different feel to it given her shift from the public. There's lots
- 16:44of victim blaming on him because of it. You know. Once the it
- 16:48all came out, everyone was saying, why did he keep having sex with
- 16:51her? He should have drawn a boundary with her. He's just as crazy
- 16:53as she is, that sort of thing. What do you think about that,
- 16:56Burtle? Oh, it's completely unfair. I mean, don't get me.
- 17:00If we were talking about normal dynamics of a relationship without a murder in
- 17:03the mix, or extreme stocking in the mix, I would say if I
- 17:07were talking to this person, I'd say like, yeah, you know what,
- 17:11I think you're being unfair to yourself and to this other person. This
- 17:14isn't healthy for you in whatever number of ways examples I could give. If
- 17:17I'm a friend specially and it's certainly causing some stress to the other person,
- 17:22I think the you know, the best fairest thing to do is to end
- 17:26it. I know it sucks you're not going to get as much sex or
- 17:27whatever, but I mean, let's balance things out. That would be my
- 17:30advice. So I would definitely say, are you stringing this person along?
- 17:34Yeah? Are you, you know, setting her up for more hurt later?
- 17:38Yes? Are you setting yourself up for bad And that's all without the
- 17:42murder in the mix. Right with the murder in the mix, it'd be
- 17:45a different situation. I would certainly not say like, hey, listen,
- 17:48you're setting yourself up to maybe be killed, and if you do get killed,
- 17:52you deserve it because you were being like this. It's more like,
- 17:55hey, listen, this person's unstable and it's dangerous. Yeah, and you
- 17:59need to keep maybe even file a restriction what a restraining order whatever. So
- 18:03no, it would definitely never be about well, I hate to tell you,
- 18:07you know, I warned, Yes, I guess you had to come
- 18:08in, right. Could could someone legitimately say to him if you were alive,
- 18:15Look all the suffering you're experiencing in terms of the fighting and having to
- 18:19deal with her and your life kind of being in limbo, and it's hard
- 18:26to move on to actually seriously dating other women. Are you partially to blame
- 18:32for that? You could say that, of course, But to say that
- 18:36the fact that she was stalking him, committing crimes, terrifying him and killing
- 18:42him is because of his behavior, No, that's that's completely victim blaming.
- 18:47That's like blaming a woman for being raped because of the way she was dressed.
- 18:52Hey, you didn't need to help that that man with the cast on
- 18:55his arm, with his VW bug at the beach, you know, right
- 18:59at Lakes Damish, just down the hill from both of us. Actually,
- 19:03so May twenty six, two thousand and eight, there is some report of
- 19:07them having a big fight over the phone on May twenty sixth speculation. I'm
- 19:12guessing that she was pleading with him to not go to Mexico with another woman
- 19:18because the trip was in a week or two, and she interpreted him going
- 19:22to Mexico with Mimi, because later she told the police that Travis told her
- 19:30that Mimi might be quote unquote the one. Yeah, right for Travis,
- 19:34he was pretty open about the sort of thing. He might even been telling
- 19:37Jody this to try to push her away. I don't know they had an
- 19:41open relationship in this way. I suppose well, and I could even imagine,
- 19:45based on the compromises that Jody had been making to try to still be
- 19:48with him, that she might have been giving off an air of like,
- 19:52oh, you could tell me everything, you know, I'm your friend,
- 19:53right, and then he's like, oh, well, let me tell you.
- 19:56Actually, this girl's pretty neat. I think she might be the one
- 19:59which, of co underneath it's killing Jody inside. Also one question, do
- 20:04you know was Jody gonna go anyways because of work or was she no longer
- 20:08employed with that? Do you know? I don't know, but she was
- 20:12not she was not able to go, or she wasn't qualified to go,
- 20:15maybe because he was more in the upper management. There might have also been
- 20:22some sort of social well definitely social embarrassment for her of like well, now
- 20:26you know, I'm also not going, and everyone's going to know that I'm
- 20:30not going. I don't know, great and humiliation worries is a pretty major
- 20:36motivator for these kinds of crimes. So yeah, I hadn't thought of that.
- 20:40So she knows that Mimi is the one. Now, what she doesn't
- 20:42know is, I'm guessing is that Mimi didn't want to be with him and
- 20:47had told him many times, but Travis was either still pursuing her or was
- 20:52okay with just being friends with Mimi. Now. Also, on May twenty
- 20:56six, it's possible total speculation that she blackmailed him with the sex tape.
- 21:02That she said something like, you know, you could imagine that she would
- 21:06have pulled out all but before she kills him. You imagine she would have
- 21:08pulled out all the stops although which you're probably right. But it is a
- 21:14little puzzling that he then would have led her film them having sex that last
- 21:18time, because he would have been like, well, no, you just
- 21:21tried to blackmail man. I'm not going to give you more footage. Well
- 21:23it's his camera though, so he knows he has control over it, the
- 21:26pictures that was his camera, so he doesn't always going to get murdered fair
- 21:33enough, so again, seemingly at this point, probably in all likelihood,
- 21:37she definitely decided that she was going to kill him at this point because two
- 21:41days later, May twenty eighth, Jody lived with their grandparents and the house
- 21:47that Jody and her grandparents lived in was burgled. The speculation is that Jody
- 21:52was the one who burglarized the house, and among various missing objects was a
- 22:00twenty five caliber handgun, which apparently is a rare type of handgun. You
- 22:03know, normally you will have a twenty two or a nine millimeter or you
- 22:07know that kind of thing. So a twenty five caliber handgun is kind of
- 22:11an older, concealable weapon that people don't usually buy anymore because it doesn't have
- 22:17very good stopping power from what I understand. So let's take a break here,
- 22:22burto and when we get back from the break, what I want to
- 22:25do is I want to go literally minute by minute or hour by hour of
- 22:30what happens from June second through June fourth, which there's so much data to
- 22:36go over and so many theories. There are some definite things that we can
- 22:40say about what happened here around the murder, but there's just a lot of
- 22:42details because you know, I fully nerd it out on you know, I
- 22:47went down some rabbit holes. I looked at a lot of theories online,
- 22:49and there's just so much to get into. But like we were saying earlier,
- 22:53the rest of this podcast will just be for patrons of the podcast.
- 22:56So if you want to listen to the rest of this and all the other
- 23:00full chapters of the Jodi Arias Deep Die that we're doing, you gotta go
- 23:06to patreon dot com become a patron. Do it now, Do it now.