Latest / The Vegan Report / Thank You, Trump?! With Liam Gray | Ep. 78
Transcript
- 0:00My name is Ryan and you are listening to The
- 0:03Vegan Report. In light of recent news that the
- 0:06Trump administration is scaling back animal experimentation
- 0:10across various levels of government, such as
- 0:13the National Institute of Health, the Environmental
- 0:16Protection Agency, and even the military, it
- 0:20is time to put to rest this idea that conservatives
- 0:24do not care about animals or have no place in
- 0:29the animal protection movement. I believe that
- 0:33anyone willing to advance this cause and put
- 0:36an end to the bloody business of animal exploitation,
- 0:40indiscriminately of religion, culture, race,
- 0:43ethnicity, or something as trivial as political
- 0:47inclinations, should be welcomed and supported
- 0:51by this movement. To discuss this topic and more,
- 0:55we are lucky to have Liam Gray, someone who is
- 0:59immersed in the world of politics. He is the
- 1:02founder of the Wilberforce Institute, which is
- 1:06a public policy think tank, dedicated to advancing
- 1:10the recognition of the inherent value and dignity
- 1:13of life, a market. free from corrupt and coercive
- 1:18government intrusion and intellectually diverse
- 1:21policies that benefit human and animal interests.
- 1:27Visit the link in the episode notes to learn
- 1:30more about their great work and how to support
- 1:33them. one of the biggest scandal of the animal
- 1:44rights movement which is the fact that the biggest
- 1:48progress that we have seen in the animal pro
- 1:52-animal cause came from a conservative government
- 1:57and I'm talking about the ban on animal testing.
- 2:03So the National Institute of Health recently
- 2:05announced an initiative to phase out animal testing.
- 2:09So they will now prioritize human -based research
- 2:13methods, such as data science, artificial intelligence,
- 2:18and tests on lab -grown organ -like structures
- 2:21called organoids. I don't know if you ever heard
- 2:24of that term before. The EPA has the ambition
- 2:29of completely banning animal testing and following
- 2:33this is the Navy, the US Navy that has decided
- 2:39to end all research testing on cats and dogs.
- 2:44Now it is a scandal because if you ask your average
- 2:49animal rights activists what is their opinion
- 2:52of conservatives and of the Trump administration
- 2:56or any right -leaning person, they will have
- 3:01a very hostile reaction. And they believe, and
- 3:06I'm talking from, you know, experience of conversations
- 3:10with them, that there is no progress to be, no
- 3:15accomplishment from, you know, collaborating
- 3:18with conservatives. And obviously this is wrong.
- 3:24So, okay, can you explain what is happening here?
- 3:28How come, you know, one of the if not the biggest
- 3:32progress for the animal cause in recent memory
- 3:36came from a conservative government, from the
- 3:41Trump administration, and without, you know,
- 3:45your the traditional animal rights, you know,
- 3:50ways of putting pressure and, you know, this
- 3:53was not the result of a nationwide campaign from
- 3:58PETA or of protests organized by, you know, name
- 4:04your favorite animal rights organization. So
- 4:06what is happening here? Sure. So and I think
- 4:10you're right. The the impact this is having and
- 4:14the trajectory it's on. I mean, I I don't think
- 4:17it's overly optimistic to say that, you know,
- 4:19the end of animal experimentation uh... writ
- 4:22large could be right on the horizon now uh...
- 4:25obviously is still a lot more to go but but there
- 4:27that the progress has been incredible i think
- 4:30uh... it's really important when we when we look
- 4:34at what happened here to look at the work of
- 4:36uh... white coat waste which is uh... organization
- 4:38there uh... in uh... nonpartisan but they've
- 4:42worked uh... extensively with uh... conservatives
- 4:45and libertarians especially republican uh...
- 4:48republicans in congress a lot of the ones that
- 4:50i think uh... A lot of the much of the animal
- 4:54rights movement would be the least willing or
- 4:57least interested to work with, or they would
- 5:01at least think of them as maybe people that they
- 5:04wouldn't be worth their time to reach out to,
- 5:06like Marjorie Taylor Greene, who had went after
- 5:11Fauci on the NIH's Beagle experiments in front
- 5:13of Congress, or Nancy Mase, who's worked on a
- 5:17ton of these issues with white coat waste. I
- 5:21what white coat did with these with uh with this
- 5:24so i'll back up white coat is um entirely focused
- 5:29on um government funded animal experimentation
- 5:32that that is the whole the the the entire scope
- 5:35of what they work on and uh and they talked about
- 5:38this not only from the cruelty aspect which they
- 5:40they never shy away from talking about uh the
- 5:44cruelty in these experiments, but they also talk
- 5:46about the taxpayer waste, the excessive spending
- 5:51that we're doing on these programs, the absurdity
- 5:53of most of these experiments. My inclination,
- 5:56this is a sort of anecdotal thing, but I don't
- 5:59necessarily have some stats behind this, but
- 6:01I think what you have a lot of with a lot of
- 6:02these... That these kinds of experimentation
- 6:05programs is you know if you've worked in any
- 6:08kind of especially government organization but
- 6:10also big corporations do the same thing and you're
- 6:12coming to the end of the fiscal quarter and you
- 6:14and You you know realize that you're not gonna
- 6:17get the budget you got last year unless you spend
- 6:19some more money So they go and then that's that's
- 6:20how you know when I was in the army we ended
- 6:22up spending Yeah, excessive amounts of money
- 6:24on things like staplers just to make sure that
- 6:26we don't we get the same money We did last year,
- 6:28right? Think you have the same thing going on
- 6:30with these experimentations or experiments in
- 6:32a lot of times where it's they they have these
- 6:34research projects that you know routinely make
- 6:39Senator rent Rand Paul's Festus Festivus report
- 6:42where it just highlights You know absurd spending
- 6:45that the government's doing every year The lion's
- 6:48share that comes from what white coat research
- 6:50and it's always these ridiculous experiments
- 6:52like the yeah Again, the left tried to say this
- 6:56one wasn't real, but it's been proven real, the
- 6:58transgender mice experiments where they were
- 7:01doing transgender operations on mice. Not only
- 7:04is it excessively cruel, it's ridiculous. Why
- 7:08are we doing this? If you take that success and
- 7:14you look at what they've done there and you extrapolate
- 7:17that, to the other areas where animals are being
- 7:22harmed, especially at the hands of the government
- 7:24or with our tax dollars. The most obvious of
- 7:27those being factory farming. I think it gives
- 7:30you a good roadmap on how we can actually make
- 7:32some progress here. And that's what with Wilberforce
- 7:34Institute, what we're trying to do. I want to
- 7:36get back to this perception of conservatives
- 7:40as being the enemy. And I want to give a concrete
- 7:45example of that. So after the election, I made
- 7:50an episode called make animal rights bipartisan
- 7:54again. And I shared that on the vegan subreddit
- 7:59and I got demolished. So let me read some of
- 8:04the comments I got from that podcast. We can't
- 8:09get the conservatives to care about starving
- 8:12humans. So I don't know why they'd care about
- 8:15non -humans. conservatives don't give a shit
- 8:18about animal rights conservatives don't give
- 8:21a shit about human rights then there was someone
- 8:24who commented vegan conservatives here and Someone
- 8:29responded trying to phrase this in a way that
- 8:32isn't a loaded question, but do you feel like
- 8:35there isn't there? There's any inconsistencies
- 8:38between veganism and any of your political views
- 8:42And then following that you mean you're a plant
- 8:45-based conservative Explain yourself. I want
- 8:49to see fewer chickens and more Mexican children
- 8:51in cages and I could go on and on and on Why
- 8:58is there this antagonism towards conservatives?
- 9:04Yeah, you know, I think I think it has to do
- 9:07with the general the general sort of Yeah tribalism
- 9:11and teams thing that we've got and especially
- 9:13in the states I don't know. I don't know what
- 9:16it looks like elsewhere in the world exactly
- 9:17but you know, we've because we have the Two -party
- 9:21system and it's very entrenched in these two
- 9:23teams you anything that gets Coated as one side
- 9:27or the other gets bashed if you have any kind
- 9:29of car crossover, which is obviously a really
- 9:32Unproductive thing for your your normal non deep
- 9:35state citizen, right? Um, but it's it's interesting
- 9:38because it's it's something you know when you
- 9:40look at um Yeah, depending on what what stats
- 9:43you want to you want to use I think in that in
- 9:45that episode you're talking about I believe you
- 9:47referenced the uh, the phonolytic study But there's
- 9:49a number of these where I mean any any study
- 9:51you point to is going to show most people Yes,
- 9:54sincerely and have have sincere heartfelt Care
- 9:57for animals most people love animals. Most people
- 9:59hate factory farming. I would argue I don't think
- 10:02anybody There's anybody out there really who
- 10:05that isn't paid to like factory farming that
- 10:07actually likes factory farming, you know, I but
- 10:11But what even though we have that it's still
- 10:15even though those are the general perceptions
- 10:17everyone has The factory farming is growing every
- 10:20single year, you know, and I think a lot of that
- 10:23has to do with exactly what you're talking about
- 10:24here where it's We're so entrenched and they've
- 10:28this this, you know It keeps conservatives away
- 10:30from the animal issue to to have that kind of
- 10:33response when they try to go into animal issues,
- 10:35right? and it's sort of the reciprocal thing
- 10:37there's there's it's on, you know both ends of
- 10:39it, but But yeah, I think It's it's certainly
- 10:44hurting the the progress and what you know what
- 10:47we can actually hope to attain for animals when
- 10:50we're when you know You have this artificial
- 10:54political divide that doesn't really you know
- 10:56actually make any sense when it comes down to
- 10:57it What does my my view? What are my views on
- 11:00tax policy really have to do with my views on
- 11:02animals, right? And also that that sort of you
- 11:07know, the those kinds of pejorative understandings
- 11:11of what your opposition believes like Yeah, because
- 11:13I voted for Trump doesn't mean I want to see
- 11:16What was the yeah Hispanic kids in cages or whatever
- 11:19that that one quote was, you know that kind of
- 11:21thing. It's like that's that's not that's not
- 11:23actually what I voted for anymore than you know,
- 11:25I mean look it was Biden that went to the to
- 11:29the Supreme Court with you know alongside Smithfield
- 11:32and and Vilsack is his big dairy lobbyist head
- 11:36of the USDA and and you know tried to push the
- 11:38eats act through the Supreme Court and it was
- 11:40Trump's appointees that that ruled against it,
- 11:43right? So, you know, that doesn't mean I'm going
- 11:45to, you know, I'm not now going to say every
- 11:47single Democrat out there, everyone who voted
- 11:50for Biden is a proponent of factory farming or,
- 11:53you know, is anti Prop 12 or wants to federalize,
- 11:58you know, like wants to stop Prop 12 from a federal
- 12:00level. You know, that's obviously not a, yeah,
- 12:03that would be a leap for me to say that, right?
- 12:06But I don't think people are necessarily, you
- 12:09know, accepting that kind of nuance. Let me add
- 12:12a layer of complication to this whole story.
- 12:16I learned from preparing for this conversation
- 12:19that during the first Trump administration, they
- 12:25wanted to ban up to 30 % of animal experimentations
- 12:30with the EPA. And they wanted to accomplish that
- 12:35goal for the year 2025. But when the Biden administration
- 12:40came into power, they stopped that. Now, there
- 12:46is also the fact that during the electoral campaign,
- 12:50when Tim Walz, I think, the VP with Kamala was
- 12:59presented as a candidate, the first promotional
- 13:04video that announced his name and his you know
- 13:08presence on the political scene we saw him in
- 13:11that video in a dairy farm and you know he he
- 13:16worked hard to build that character of hey I'm
- 13:21the hunting guy I'm the guy who cares about dairy
- 13:24farmers and and this felt like the candidate
- 13:32you would not want to vote for as a vegan or
- 13:36someone who cares about animals. So why do most
- 13:41vegans and animal rights activists think of the
- 13:45liberal platform and liberal party as the most
- 13:50pro -animal party when there is evidence that
- 13:55they don't care about animals? Yeah, and that's
- 13:58that's what I can't answer exactly why why they
- 14:00would think it right, but but you're right I
- 14:03then that that whole campaign it makes me think
- 14:05of the the Tim Walls is the big I think that
- 14:09there's something like a overcorrection on This
- 14:12perception of like the the masculinity idea right
- 14:14there. There's like this idea that oh, they're
- 14:17voting for Trump because I don't know because
- 14:19they think he can beat him in a in a an arm wrestling
- 14:22match or something, but It was it's it's a very
- 14:26it's a very silly idea to begin with But I think
- 14:29you you know, you can see that elsewhere where
- 14:32there's that I haven't followed this guy at all
- 14:35I really honestly don't know too much about him
- 14:37but the Hassan piker who they're kind of marketing
- 14:40is like the Joe Rogan of the left, right? Which
- 14:42is it's funny in and of itself because it's he's
- 14:45that's a guy. Yes You can make a case that the
- 14:48Joe Rogan of the left is Joe Rogan, but that's
- 14:50a whole other thing. But it's funny, my understanding
- 14:54is this guy is a big, he's always eating chickens.
- 14:58It's a thing for him where he's like, and I guess
- 15:00it's kind of pitched this manly, masculine kind
- 15:03of thing. But when you compare that to the person
- 15:07they're talking about, Joe Rogan, Joe Rogan's
- 15:09a mediator for sure, and he's a hunter, but he
- 15:11also, he's talked extensively on his show about
- 15:16About yeah, how horrible factory farming is how
- 15:19he's only going to eat the yeah Eat from animals
- 15:23that he kills himself and like he won't eat the
- 15:26factory farming because of the cruelty and you
- 15:27know Is that a is that from a vegan perspective
- 15:31ideal? No, but it's you know directionally exactly
- 15:34where you know way better than the southern guy
- 15:36who's eating mass -produced chicken every day
- 15:37and Advertising and making it into this manly
- 15:40thing and that's coming from the left. So it's
- 15:42interesting I don't know where that perception
- 15:45Where it comes from? You know the namesake of
- 15:48our organization William Wilberforce was it was
- 15:50a Christian conservative performer who you know
- 15:53helped was largely credited with ending the slave
- 15:56trade and in the in England, but he also founded
- 16:01the The RSPCA it was the the first the edibles
- 16:04the first animal welfare organization in the
- 16:06world that came from you know a conservative
- 16:09so it's not like a You know, like there's no
- 16:12history of this. I mean you've talked about Matthew
- 16:14Scully on my on your in other episodes and Matthew
- 16:17Scully is a Who you know for any listen to you
- 16:21haven't caught that he's a You know, it was a
- 16:23presidential speechwriter Republican speechwriter
- 16:26Who wrote a book called Dominion, which is really?
- 16:30I think I think has brought a lot of conservatives
- 16:32Yeah, a lot of the conservatives who? Stopped
- 16:36eating animals. I think points to that book but
- 16:38the interesting interesting thing about that
- 16:39book is it's not really a it's not a conservative
- 16:41case It's for for not eating animals. It's it's
- 16:43a human case for not eating. You know, it's uh
- 16:46So we're coming to these things from the same
- 16:48reasons. We have the same concerns for animals
- 16:50I think that the disparity is almost a Sort of
- 16:56just I think more than anything else is kind
- 16:57of goes back to the sort of the sort of tribal
- 16:59thing and the The team's thing that we have going
- 17:02on But that makes sense. There's a perception
- 17:04where you're not, you know, where you're not
- 17:07if you're if you're of the right, you're not
- 17:09supposed to be a part of these movements of the
- 17:11animal movement and the animal movement, you
- 17:12know, does everything they can to fulfill that
- 17:14and kind of, you know, make make it seem like
- 17:17unfriendly territory, you know, as you pointed
- 17:19out with those those comments and things like
- 17:21that. Yes, definitely. And there's this also
- 17:25this whole thing of tying the pro animal movement
- 17:30with. a more left -wing ideology. So, for instance,
- 17:37talking about veganism as an anti -capitalism
- 17:41movement. Like here. I mean, the first time I
- 17:45heard that, I was thinking, what? I mean, I'm
- 17:48here for, you know, liberating animals and stopping
- 17:50animal expectation. Why are we talking about,
- 17:53you know, capitalism and, and your socialism
- 17:57and no, this is not what I subscribe for. And
- 18:01there's also this aversion towards religion.
- 18:05I believe that, you know, betting on the religious
- 18:10argument for veganism or for animals is how you
- 18:16connect with people, how you make real lasting
- 18:18change, how you establish this doctrine in the
- 18:25life of people. But there is this aversion, you
- 18:29know, and this perception that you cannot collaborate
- 18:35with religious people to make change. um and
- 18:39religion is somewhat responsible for um animal
- 18:43exploitation which you know yeah historically
- 18:47you could make that point you know but this this
- 18:52is not like sacrifices things like that is that
- 18:54the argument there or what's what's the Well,
- 18:57for instance, you know, anthropocentrism, the
- 19:00fact that, you know, everything is for humans,
- 19:04that we are, we have dominion over everything.
- 19:07And so we can do whatever we want. But I feel
- 19:10like, you know, it doesn't reflect the current
- 19:13reality of, you know, religious discourse. So
- 19:18what do you make of that? So, well, I'll start
- 19:22with the religion one, because that's, that's
- 19:23interesting. And I would, I find that The dominion
- 19:27argument and that characterization of it really
- 19:29funny because it's not That doesn't make any
- 19:31sense to me. I mean if you think about it in
- 19:33a very uh, Just yeah simplistic sense like like
- 19:36let's let's say we're you know If i'm if I have
- 19:38dominion over a people right if I have dominion
- 19:41over some yeah Some group of people does that
- 19:43mean that I can then eat my subjects or I can
- 19:45treat them however I you know, whatever whatever
- 19:48cruel in any name ways. I mean that's pretty
- 19:50counter to any any uh any doctrinal understanding
- 19:53of leadership or uh rulers rulership or anything
- 19:57to this line, so I I've always found that kind
- 20:00of I actually think by and large and To you to
- 20:04your point. I think you're making the beginning
- 20:05of that too You know, I think it's really working
- 20:08with the faith communities. I think a lot of
- 20:10the I Think when you apply religious values from
- 20:14really any faith to the animal idea I think that's
- 20:17really where you're gonna see a lot of this movement.
- 20:18I think there's I mean It's it's really it's
- 20:23really hard. I think to make a a strong religious
- 20:27case for treating animals the way that we do
- 20:30on the political part of it and that and that
- 20:32sort of the anti -capitalist thing and that that
- 20:35whole sense that you alluded to at the beginning
- 20:37of that That's another interesting one because
- 20:39I think I think it's part of the problem to what
- 20:41part of why we're not making Why why the animal
- 20:44movement isn't making the progress that we'd
- 20:45like to see it make is that you know, there there's
- 20:48been a My opinion is there's the shift on the
- 20:52left where you've had this I mean, it's always
- 20:54been you know, traditionally the the big the
- 20:58big government party the big government idea
- 21:00but but there used to be a Almost more anti -establishment
- 21:03sense. I think it's kind of gone away and you
- 21:05sort of leaned into this To you know this trust
- 21:08of the government idea, which I think would have
- 21:10been really foreign to a lot of people of the
- 21:12left You know a few decades ago or even less
- 21:15and that's coupled with also I you know like
- 21:18a It's a more there's been more corporate distrust
- 21:22on the right Then maybe even on the left lately
- 21:25with where you have, you know Republicans especially
- 21:29mega Republicans and getting very distrustful
- 21:32of things like big pharma and big, you know,
- 21:33that's kind of the maha movement And big big
- 21:38tech in those areas where I think that's that's
- 21:43something Yeah, if the the complaints the critiques
- 21:47they're making there Really apply to the sort
- 21:50of big ag infrastructure and the and these the
- 21:53ways in which government is really becoming becoming
- 21:56or is one of the or I would say government is
- 21:59or At least one of the biggest perpetrators again
- 22:02animal suffering animal suffering in the world.
- 22:05I mean when you look at You know the USDA and
- 22:10the way the ways in which it bolsters Yeah, big
- 22:13ag way bolsters industrial farm industrial meat
- 22:17production uh... things like you have a beer
- 22:20of land management and the worst roundups in
- 22:22the uh... or wildlife services the kind of rampant
- 22:25killing of animals out there and i'm kind of
- 22:26rattling through things we can talk about an
- 22:27even more depth you'd like but but i uh... it's
- 22:30interesting i think because your because we're
- 22:34uh... are in these political uh... paradigms
- 22:37to it because that the leftist is when when you
- 22:41have those things like that making this an anti
- 22:42-capitalist movement or that kind of deal i think
- 22:44you're kind of allowing for the government to
- 22:47continue to grow and inflict this harm on animals
- 22:50and you're sort of giving them a free pass to
- 22:52do it. Let me get back quickly to that outstanding
- 22:57news of this ban on animal experimentation. I
- 23:04want to just highlight how incredible and impactful
- 23:08this decision from the Trump administration is.
- 23:14he has, you know, liberated millions of sentient
- 23:19creatures from the worst kind of suffering out
- 23:24there, from the worst kind of animal exploitation.
- 23:27And I feel like if this was coming from a left
- 23:34-wing government, if this was the result of some,
- 23:39you know, PETA campaign or your traditional animal
- 23:42rights strain, um, uh, or organization, um, we
- 23:49would have, uh, been witnessing, you know, uh,
- 23:53week after week of celebration, you know, on
- 23:57social media awards, speeches, um, like the,
- 24:03the, that accomplishment would have been, you
- 24:08know, celebrated for months yet. This has been
- 24:15under the radar of most vegans. This went under
- 24:20the radar of most people who care about animals,
- 24:24as if it was something minor. And the few animal
- 24:28rights activists I've seen celebrating this accomplishment
- 24:33from the Trump administration always do it with
- 24:39a few comments on, hey, this is great and they're
- 24:44doing a good job, but I'm against their immigration
- 24:49policy and I'm against this and that. And I think
- 24:51Trump is really, you know, an evil and which,
- 24:55which makes everything confusing. Like how is
- 24:58he responsible of this great accomplishment when
- 25:02he's so evil? Like, um, what are you talking
- 25:05about exactly, but it's a way to protect themselves
- 25:08against, you know, any perception of, uh, being
- 25:12right leaning for celebrating this progress.
- 25:17Uh, what do you make of that? Yeah. Well, um,
- 25:21and again, I think you're, you're, I think there's,
- 25:24it's definitely a symptom of sort of the, the
- 25:27situation we found ourselves in with the kind
- 25:29of the two party system in this whole, this whole
- 25:31deal where you're sort of afraid to step out
- 25:33of the, uh, Yeah, the demagoguery that you're
- 25:37attached to right? But I but yeah, no, you're
- 25:41absolutely right If this was a if this was the
- 25:43Biden administration and they were yeah ending
- 25:45animal experimentation in you know, multiple
- 25:48You know very extremely large departments within
- 25:52the executive branch if they were you know If
- 25:54Biden was taking that kind of action, it would
- 25:56have been lauded you'd be hearing about it all
- 25:57over the you know across Yeah, and all the all
- 26:01the you know through all the vegan Organizations
- 26:04and all the animal movement, uh, you know podcasts
- 26:06and everything else And I don't think you really
- 26:08are where you are hearing about it. Interestingly
- 26:10enough is on is through uh, the right wing, you
- 26:13know, uh media outlets, right like uh, you know,
- 26:16there's the the your your fox news is your uh
- 26:19daily callers your you know, um, Uh washington
- 26:22examiners washington all those kinds of outlets
- 26:24are talking about these issues because of the
- 26:26framing and because of the people attached to
- 26:28it now there's some of of course, they have their
- 26:31biases and that's part of why they're able to
- 26:33talk about these things in such a complimentary
- 26:38way. And who knows how they would be responding
- 26:41to it if the inverse was true, right? If it was
- 26:43Biden who'd done this. But I think you're right
- 26:47to point that out and I appreciate that you do.
- 26:50It's interesting. I really don't think you can
- 26:54point to And this gets to what you're saying
- 26:57about how big it really is. I don't think you
- 26:59can point to another success in the animal movement
- 27:01right now that is really comparable to what's
- 27:04going on there. I think it's really the biggest
- 27:08strides we've made in any area has probably been
- 27:10there. And you're only really hearing about it
- 27:14in conservative circles. So what does that tell
- 27:15you? Yeah, I feel like I'm in a parallel universe.
- 27:22I mean, this is crazy. But I mean, I think it
- 27:26makes the case right that again. We're you know
- 27:29Just because people voted for trump doesn't mean
- 27:31we're you know, we're Some kind of you know of
- 27:35horned monsters that are or you know are out
- 27:37for evil. It's just a different You know, we
- 27:39have different It's this novel concept that we
- 27:41have different views and that's okay But yeah,
- 27:47I think it's it's it's very interesting and and
- 27:50i'm interested to see Yeah, so really the work
- 27:53that we're doing with the over force institute
- 27:55is really trying to Make that movement make yeah
- 27:59that show that that concern from the animals
- 28:02exists on the right because I believe really
- 28:04believe it does already And coalesce that into
- 28:06a movement that is tangible and that we can really
- 28:08you know You can point to so that so that this
- 28:10is not uh You know a couple years down the road
- 28:13when this is when we're talking about these kinds
- 28:14of things again It's uh, it's not so unfathomable
- 28:18to anybody that that or is that uh that Yeah,
- 28:21that the right is spearheading. Yeah. X animal
- 28:26issue. Yeah. When I learned about your organization,
- 28:31I was so happy. You don't even know. I mean,
- 28:35I felt like being alone, like commenting on this
- 28:41issue, this perceived issue. And I kept thinking,
- 28:45you know, if only there was a more right leading
- 28:49or at least non -partisan organization that is
- 28:53interested and has the ambition of mobilizing
- 28:57everyone on the political spectrum to make changes,
- 29:01lasting changes, and who are not scared to talk
- 29:04to conservatives. And to learn that you have
- 29:09created that organization, you know, just made
- 29:12me so happy. So yeah, thank you for that. and
- 29:20you know it's is this should we perceive it you
- 29:26know the you talked about this being the the
- 29:29greatest success of the pro -animal movement
- 29:31i agree with that but does it mean that this
- 29:37animal rights movement right now in this uh incarnation
- 29:42is dysfunctional really is this you know is this
- 29:47success a sign that it has failed at the task
- 29:52of advancing the animal interests. And I look
- 30:01at, before this conversation, I looked at some
- 30:06coverage of political situation regarding animal
- 30:11rights. And what was highlighted was bans. from
- 30:18different US states on lab -grown meat, or as
- 30:23they like to call it, cultivated meat or clean
- 30:26meat. And they were picking on that, talking
- 30:31about how conservative states are so evil for
- 30:34banning this industry. And I feel like you're
- 30:40missing the point. What are you doing, like trying
- 30:45to advance the interest of Corporations that
- 30:49want to play dr. Frankenstein So I don't think
- 30:53that the the movement has failed but I think
- 30:55it needs to evolve and I think it needs to start
- 30:58shifting its perspective and I think one of the
- 31:02major ways for one of the main things for that
- 31:04is You know, it's not that every organization
- 31:08needs to start adopting conservative messaging
- 31:11or become you know conservative organizations
- 31:13or appeal to conservatives, but They what they
- 31:17should do is as groups like yeah, like the Wilberforce
- 31:19Institute come up and groups like white coat
- 31:21waste that already exist and these other organizations
- 31:23that that are are good at talking to the right
- 31:25and and Are involved with the political, right?
- 31:28Yeah, I think they need to understand that You
- 31:32know when we're mission and aligned on the cause
- 31:33for ending animal suffering We are allies. We're
- 31:37not you know opponents. We're not yeah, and we
- 31:40you shouldn't be couching You know your your
- 31:44partnerships with us and that kind of thing.
- 31:46I think when you look at You know if you look
- 31:50at the left This actually kind of goes to some
- 31:53of those comments you read off, right? You can
- 31:55tell in the tone of some of them there. There's
- 31:58this I think there's this idea where maybe maybe
- 32:00the left maybe the Democratic Party Maybe maybe
- 32:02your average Democrat voter is more Generally
- 32:05sympathetic to the animal movement, right? Because
- 32:07they understand that the animal movement is generally
- 32:10speaking associated with the left But they're
- 32:12always going, they always look at it. I think
- 32:14there's a perception at least that they always
- 32:16look at it as secondary issues or like, yeah,
- 32:20yeah, yeah, we'll deal with your issues when
- 32:22we get to it. And yeah, these whatever social
- 32:24justice warrior issues are the front, are the
- 32:28primary issues. And these are the ones we need
- 32:29to focus on. Whereas we're over here working
- 32:32on animal issues and we're directly involved
- 32:36in actually trying to move the ball forward for
- 32:38animals. Those are your allies on these it's
- 32:41not it's not these other groups that are dismissive
- 32:43of the issues that you care about um I you know,
- 32:47and and we're able to talk about these things
- 32:49in ways that I think that uh Would be disingenuous
- 32:53coming from a lot of the groups on the left You
- 32:56brought up the the the cultivated meat bands,
- 32:58which i'm actually um, I wasn't I wasn't sure
- 33:01if you yeah, you got the uh The the frankenstein
- 33:04comments there and I you know, i'm actually i'm
- 33:07i'm Uh, you know, and I think everybody at Wilberforce
- 33:10is for, for, uh, cultivated meat and then, and
- 33:13moving that technology forward. And we're, um,
- 33:15but, you know, when we talk about, uh, when we
- 33:18talk about these bands, I mean, we're able to
- 33:20talk about this from a free market perspective,
- 33:22which is where we've always existed, where we've
- 33:24always, yeah, how we talk about just about every
- 33:25issue, you know, it's, it is, and it is kind
- 33:28of to your point, it's kind of, uh, it's disingenuous
- 33:31for the, you know, these groups to come around
- 33:33and say, uh, they oppose these bands. And then
- 33:38they're also anti -capitalist organizations,
- 33:39right? Like the biggest argument to oppose these
- 33:45bans is that if you allow for the free market,
- 33:49if you allow for people to get consumers to make
- 33:51their choices, then you're not banning these
- 33:54choices. You're not banning my option as a consumer
- 33:56to try a new product that is a cruelty -free
- 34:04version of me, right? That's simply just a free
- 34:11market argument. And so I think it's actually
- 34:13a good argument for why it's important to have
- 34:17our kinds of voices here, because we're the ones
- 34:19that can make that case. Yeah, I'm not against
- 34:23cultivating meat in the sense that if it was
- 34:26available, I would definitely try it and purchase
- 34:31and add it to my consumption. But what I don't
- 34:37like is to see this movement, this social movement
- 34:41sending all of its money, resources to this industry.
- 34:49It's like, okay, you're a corporation, you want
- 34:52to offer cultivated meat. Well, do it. I mean,
- 34:57why put the clothes of a social movement or...
- 35:03just you want to make profits and you want to
- 35:06offer a new product. Like, uh, of course it's
- 35:09ethical and it's good to think about, you know,
- 35:11the ethics of, um, you know, doing business,
- 35:14but you're not like a social movement. You're
- 35:19not an activist movement. You're not part of
- 35:21that. Um, I think that if you look at most successful
- 35:26social movements, they were movements that were
- 35:29driven by religious convictions. That's one point
- 35:34that were popular movements, non -partisan movements.
- 35:40I think those are traits that, you know, they
- 35:43all share. They were not weird movements that,
- 35:46you know, defended an industry or, yeah, shield
- 35:51for corporations or... you know, investors, like
- 35:56it's, it's weird. Like I don't have any, I don't
- 35:59have money invested in this venture. So why,
- 36:02why should I be, you know, promoting it? Yeah.
- 36:07So that's interesting. That's an interesting
- 36:09perspective. I think of it, um, it's similar
- 36:13to, well, in some ways it's the, the, uh, the
- 36:18whole opposition to it is like that where, where
- 36:20you have, uh, in the industry that people will,
- 36:22you know, I'll say the big meat industry has
- 36:26done a really good job of painting themselves
- 36:27as like farmers right as this is that this is
- 36:30the pro farming thing and And so they've made
- 36:33it almost a moral stance to support them when
- 36:35what you're talking about is not farmers even
- 36:37even small meat farmers as the as You know as
- 36:41traditionally understood, right? It's not yeah,
- 36:43you're talking about something entirely different
- 36:46And I do think you see more of that but it is
- 36:50interesting an interesting thing to see on the
- 36:52on the left in general this sort of Movement
- 36:57towards you know corporations and the kind of
- 37:00the sort of pro -corporate stuff that's coming
- 37:01out. I don't know if you heard your From one
- 37:08of your your countrymen Neil Young's new song
- 37:11with the did you hear any of this? He has this
- 37:13song where it's it's uh singing to uh Bored and
- 37:17gm, you know, and it's it's a it's a really corny
- 37:20song It has some kind of dig in there about if
- 37:22you're a fascist by a tesla like it's it's you
- 37:25know But I was thinking it's it's the who would
- 37:27have thought Yeah, so like think it comparing
- 37:30them to neil young of the 60s and 70s. It's it's
- 37:33uh It's a wild thing to see that um I I think
- 37:38sometimes that's uh That's a lot of again where
- 37:42I think the the importance of getting Sort of
- 37:45the you know, the perspective we're bringing
- 37:47to this Involved is that we're really there's
- 37:51this been this kind of corporate movement that
- 37:53I think is actually Hurts the animal movement
- 37:55for that for the left to have kind of bought
- 37:57into that, you know and I think being you know
- 38:03giving an alternative to that is something that's
- 38:04gonna help move things forward as well, too We're
- 38:07not you know Um, it's all ultimately special
- 38:09interests that drive a lot of these conversations
- 38:11and that's that's the kind of thing we need to
- 38:13get away from for sure Yeah, and I I value consistency,
- 38:17you know if you are anti -capitalist and you
- 38:20oppose cultivated meat like I value that Your
- 38:24consistency at the very least you're not a hypocrite,
- 38:27you know in your thinking so Uh, yeah, there
- 38:30is that um, okay moving forward Do you know of
- 38:36any? new progress, new policies that the Trump
- 38:41administration will put in place that would benefit
- 38:46animals. The latest one was about the Navy. So
- 38:52now we're talking about the military renouncing
- 38:56animal experimentations. So are you aware of
- 39:02any more progress? So interesting you brought
- 39:06the military one. I have an article. I'm pushing
- 39:09out right now to try to get to get published
- 39:11that's on on on moving to the To the army and
- 39:15getting the army to do the same thing the Navy
- 39:17did and kind of taking this Go army beat Navy
- 39:19type stance, which I was I was in the army myself
- 39:22So it's hey, you know It's a it's a sort of point
- 39:24of pride to me that I want them to be the the
- 39:26last ones through the door on that but You know,
- 39:30I I don't know where there's a there's a number
- 39:32of bills that were We're hoping that move forward
- 39:36a lot of them deal with with animal experimentation.
- 39:42Yeah, hopefully that that continues throughout
- 39:44the. Throughout the the administration throughout
- 39:48the executive branch, we start seeing more and
- 39:50more of these departments that are because there
- 39:52still are departments that are conducting research
- 39:53or some of the ones that are still better. Yeah,
- 39:56that have kind of signed up to stop it that are
- 39:58still doing it in other ways or or their. Yeah,
- 40:01so there's a lot more work to do there and I
- 40:03think that obviously there's an appetite to do
- 40:05it There's You know, I'd like to see that expand
- 40:10into some things like You know, the USDA has
- 40:14the agricultural research services, which is
- 40:16sort of the research arm for It is effectively.
- 40:20It's the de facto research department of the
- 40:23big industrial farmers, right? And so they're
- 40:25conducting cool cool experiments and they're
- 40:26doing so Solely to to make these the big factory
- 40:30farms Produce more right and it's not produce
- 40:34better. It's not improve animal welfare conditions.
- 40:37It's not improve the food quality It's solely
- 40:40to just crank out more and I and you know, there's
- 40:45the level of the You can you can say there's
- 40:48a free market argument where it's you know, we'll
- 40:51let them do it Fine, let's say we're doing that.
- 40:53But why are we paying for it? Why would our tax
- 40:56dollars go to funding this department? Why can't
- 41:00the biggest of these companies handle their own
- 41:02research? Why would we be doing it? So it doesn't
- 41:04really make sense from a free market level. So
- 41:09from just a taxpayer perspective at all, it's
- 41:12just rampant cronyism. So I'd like to see them
- 41:13kind of get there. I'd like to kind of hope that
- 41:16Brooke Rollins, who is the ag secretary, can
- 41:20kind of pick up on these wins and maybe move
- 41:22that direction as well. But yeah, outside of
- 41:25that, you know, there's, I know there's a lot
- 41:28that would like to see happen. I'm not sure where
- 41:29it's gonna go. What about the subsidies? You
- 41:33know, the big ag subsidies? Do you think we'll
- 41:36see some of them being reduced or abolished?
- 41:42Hope so and that would be you mentioned before
- 41:44value and consistency and that would be the consistent
- 41:46approach I actually I don't know if you followed
- 41:49at all the the one big beautiful bill Act and
- 41:53the whole debate since doing there. It's another
- 41:55article I have out for placement right now on
- 41:59on that and how you know, there's the debate
- 42:02to be had for sure even within conservative libertarian
- 42:04circles about the wisdom of of putting a bunch
- 42:08of money You know a lot of raising the allotments
- 42:11and spending for the border and military and
- 42:13that kind of thing. I mean, there's different
- 42:15approaches But you know that in that thousand
- 42:19plus page bill There's you know, plenty of those
- 42:21pages that are just filled up with what I would
- 42:23call factory farm welfare And it's I mean, it's
- 42:26really it's it's big ag subsidies. It's uh, you
- 42:29know these Insurance kind of bailout policies
- 42:33that they've created too. So it's like there's
- 42:36one in there one provision that's uh for You
- 42:40know theoretical unborn Cows that that aren't
- 42:44born that they pay that yeah make them identity
- 42:46identity payments for that and it's it's you
- 42:48know All kinds of crazy stuff and it represents
- 42:51billions of dollars I think that you know when
- 42:54we if we're talking about this we're taking kind
- 42:56of the You know the Rand Paul approach of this
- 42:59where he said hey look I'm for these cuts, but
- 43:01the spending is just unacceptable You know, um
- 43:04and raising the you know, the the ceiling to
- 43:06five trillion is is crazy, right? Um, well one
- 43:09way where we you know the case I make in the
- 43:11article and what I would say in general is uh
- 43:13Is you know, why don't we look at this area as
- 43:16one of the places where we can start reducing
- 43:17that gigantic price tag? That's associated with
- 43:19this bill so I um You know haven't heard much
- 43:23about it hasn't seemed to be a top line issue
- 43:26which is another one of those uh, the magic tricks
- 43:28of the of the uh, the big ag special interest
- 43:31but uh But I would like to see, I think draining
- 43:34the big ag swamp is something that is very congruent
- 43:37with libertarian thought, with MAGA thought.
- 43:39And it's something that I hope that we can kind
- 43:41of, we can move that direction and start making
- 43:43some real strides there because it's just crazy.
- 43:46And it's the way it's a lot of what I'm talking
- 43:47about when I say, you know, it's really our government
- 43:50that is bolstering the factory farming world.
- 43:53It's strange because I think One year ago, I
- 43:59was having a conversation with Robert Griot.
- 44:04And he's big into protesting big ag lobby and,
- 44:10you know, infiltrating their meetings and all
- 44:13of that. And he was talking about how, you know,
- 44:18animal rights organizations or, you know, vegan
- 44:21supporting animal welfare laws. was not that
- 44:26impactful and that the real impact would be to
- 44:32get rid of those subsidies, get rid of that money.
- 44:37And I'm so happy to see that this is now part
- 44:43of the conversation. At the time when I was discussing
- 44:47this with Robert, I think There wasn't any mention
- 44:53of that on the news or in political debates and
- 44:57all of that, but I feel like trump has Brought
- 45:00this on on the table Yeah, and I think trump,
- 45:04uh, yeah, so One of the things trump talked about
- 45:08when he was running for office was uh this the
- 45:12um revolving door, uh from the from the lobby
- 45:16is to to uh bureaucrats back to lobby is back
- 45:19to bureaucrat And and that's you know, that that's
- 45:23really kind of what he's defined as that that
- 45:25swamp, right? um, and I think when you You know
- 45:28and you look at people like like rfk, um who?
- 45:32you know when he was before he uh Jumped on board
- 45:35the uh, the trump campaign. He was in his own
- 45:38campaign He was talking a lot about that kind
- 45:40of thing and the cronyism, you know, that was
- 45:41a big focus for him. Um Same with like a tulsi
- 45:45gabbard who uh, you know, who will talk about
- 45:48the deep state all the time I think that that
- 45:52right there, because I get into this a good amount
- 45:55with people in the animal movement when they're
- 45:57trying to understand what we're working on with
- 45:59Wilberforce, people always want to talk about
- 46:04regulations and bans and that kind of thing.
- 46:07It's not that I'm against regulations altogether,
- 46:12but when you create this structure where you
- 46:14have this entrenched executive branch that's
- 46:18filled with people who are industry lobbyists.
- 46:19I brought up Tom Vilsack earlier, but I think
- 46:22Vilsack for the last, you know, he's a great
- 46:24example because for the last decade, he's had
- 46:25two jobs. One of them is head of ag and he did
- 46:29that for Biden and for Obama. And when he's not
- 46:32doing that, he's a big dairy lobbyist. I mean,
- 46:34who's interest do we think he's working for when
- 46:37he's in that position? You know, when that's
- 46:41his other job, that's the job he's got to go
- 46:43back to and that's where he makes his real money,
- 46:44right? um And I mean you have that that's a that's
- 46:48a big example, but you have that all throughout
- 46:50these branches So when you're talking about these
- 46:52regulations and the ways in which you know There
- 46:54there's a there's a problem. I think congress
- 46:56has where they they write very they'll write
- 46:59uh These thousand page bills and these bills
- 47:02are uh, you know um It counts out to a number
- 47:07of special interests, but they do they they also
- 47:09defer a whole lot of uh Their legislative power
- 47:12over to these executive branches and so you basically
- 47:15you take these send it over to these unelected
- 47:17bureaucrats who come from the industries that
- 47:19they're supposed to regulate and they write regulations
- 47:21and when i say i'm against those regulations
- 47:23i'm the person who's yeah i i i'll get criticized
- 47:26for that saying i'm not for the animals well
- 47:29the people who are hurting the animals are writing
- 47:30those regulations effectively right and so i
- 47:33i i think yeah a lot of it when you i think that's
- 47:36that's right to say that the subsidies are a
- 47:38big part of this um Because here a lot of what
- 47:41we're doing is just kind of is putting the people
- 47:43who are already, you know, these these massive
- 47:46Industrial meat producers these master massive
- 47:51factory farms, you know gigantic corporations
- 47:53they have you know a ton of unaccountable Unaccountable
- 47:58interests in the government and can guide the
- 48:01way these regulations are made So I think a bigger
- 48:04thing is like let's stop funding them. Let's
- 48:05stop bolstering it. Let's stop, you know creating
- 48:08an environment where we're not just not regulating,
- 48:13we're actually enhancing the cruelty and the
- 48:17waste and everything else. Do you feel like you're
- 48:21having a fight on both fronts with the animal
- 48:26rights movement trying to gain acceptance and
- 48:30support and tolerance and also against, you know,
- 48:38those lobbyists, this industry and the corruption
- 48:42and the animal exploitation. Yeah, yes and no.
- 48:47I'll say, you know, on the one side, yes. I mean,
- 48:49we have these these big powerful interests that
- 48:51I think are on both sides. And, you know, we
- 48:54had I mean, the first day we launched. I think
- 48:57it's just because some of the conservative names
- 48:58attached to us have been in the space and have
- 49:01already drawn that ire from these guys. The first
- 49:04day we launched, we had an attack ad that was
- 49:07pretty clearly coming from, not an ad, but a
- 49:10blog that was guessing at what we were and attacking
- 49:14us from the start. So that stuff's there. We
- 49:18talked about some of the hostility and the...
- 49:21That comes from from the from within the animal
- 49:24movement, but but I'll say also, you know on
- 49:26the other end of it So we've done now, you know
- 49:30the beginning of the year we did a Students for
- 49:32Liberty event called Liberty Con. It's a big
- 49:34libertarian event very student driven And you
- 49:37know some of that was temperature -shaking right?
- 49:38It was our first time, you know We've done a
- 49:40whole bunch of articles and things but we hadn't
- 49:42really been out on the ground yet I mean we only
- 49:44launched back in September, you know, so and
- 49:47when we when we did it, you know we had No, no
- 49:52push back. No, you know real like yeah, there's
- 49:56no one angrily yelling at us or yeah Making yeah
- 49:59any of the kinds of things you'd worry there
- 50:01would be There's you know, I can't say everybody
- 50:04everybody in the yeah at the conference all signed
- 50:07up But a ton did you know, we had a bunch of
- 50:09people come talk to us They're very enthusiastic
- 50:12about a lot of them said what you said, which
- 50:13is something I've heard Even before launching
- 50:15this is something I thought myself as kind of
- 50:17impetus for starting it which is you know, man
- 50:19I wish something like this had existed for years.
- 50:21There's always kind of needed something like
- 50:22this to exist and So, you know, it was super
- 50:25positive and then the on the flip side of it,
- 50:29too I went and did you know, this is where we
- 50:32you and I met you know a panel at Ava the and
- 50:38What is it? Animal Vegan Advocacy Summit, is
- 50:44that right? It's always easier to say, Ava. But
- 50:48I went and did the panel there and honestly,
- 50:52it was the same kind of thing. It was temperature
- 50:54taking the other way, right? Like how are we
- 50:56going to be perceived as we're this conservative
- 50:57libertarian organization where we have the opinions
- 51:02that we do and I was worried there was going
- 51:03to be a ton of blowback. Got none. It was actually
- 51:06I think there's a whole lot of interest in people
- 51:09who are From people who are thinking like man,
- 51:12you know what? It's probably a bad idea that
- 51:14we've been in a silo that we've been cutting
- 51:16off the side because now the side is taking over
- 51:18the you know the whole of American government
- 51:20if we want to move the needle we need to figure
- 51:22out how and So there's a ton of people who wanted
- 51:25to talk to us and we're interested in talking
- 51:26to us from that perspective. So Honestly, I think
- 51:29It's been you know I think part of why I get
- 51:33the privilege of doing this is that I wasn't
- 51:36really too worried about making enemies. I like
- 51:40making friends, but I ultimately have enough
- 51:41of them. I don't need to change what I think
- 51:46to appease anybody, and I'm not worried about
- 51:49that kind of thing. But on the other hand, honestly,
- 51:54it's been a really positive experience. I think
- 51:57a lot of people get what we're doing and really
- 51:59They support the idea. I think there's a lot
- 52:01of conservatives and libertarians out there who
- 52:03have just, you know, who really have wanted a
- 52:06kind of ideological home, a place to kind of
- 52:09point to to say like, no, no, no, I'm this kind
- 52:11of person. This is this is what I think about
- 52:12animals. And here's how it here's how it coalesces
- 52:15with what I think and and my values. And, you
- 52:19know, it's a really cool thing to be able to
- 52:20to kind of represent that and to to build that.
- 52:24Yes, the the event. This is where we meant and
- 52:29I wish I attended your panel, but I could not.
- 52:35But I did attend a meetup you organized. It was
- 52:41called something like a conservative libertarian
- 52:45classical liberal meetup, something like that.
- 52:48And it was so funny because there was just a
- 52:53handful of people and everyone, you know, when
- 52:56we introduced ourselves, no one was conservative.
- 53:04I made a joke about that in my panel. I said,
- 53:07uh, you know, I was like, we had a, we had a
- 53:09tremendous response, a big, you know, way more
- 53:11than I anticipated. It was five strong and of
- 53:14that group, I was, you know, I think there was
- 53:17like three people who were, uh, you know curious
- 53:21um Independence you had like it was like there
- 53:24wasn't no one that showed up was like a card
- 53:27-carrying uh, mega republican, you know There's
- 53:29one like kind of quasi libertarian. Yeah, but
- 53:31but I uh that I mean that was sort of the point
- 53:34in and of itself, right? Um But I I do think
- 53:39um Well, yeah, go ahead. But that was yeah, I
- 53:42was glad you came there. I'm glad that's where
- 53:43we met and it was uh It's funny. I mean what
- 53:47I what I what I talked about in the panel with
- 53:49that was You know that you had over, you know
- 53:54over a thousand people probably at Ava And of
- 53:57them there's what you know, maybe three Trump
- 54:01voters, you know, I mean You know that that's
- 54:06probably not surprising to people but I what
- 54:08yeah the case I meant to that was I think it
- 54:09should be surprising and it's something that
- 54:11you know Like look, there's there's part of this
- 54:13where yeah Conservatives and Libertarians we
- 54:16need to take some ownership and get it. Yeah,
- 54:18take some active You know, they kind of force
- 54:20our way into the movement a little bit, right?
- 54:22Like we need to take some ownership of the causes
- 54:23that we care about But on the other hand, it's
- 54:26it's you know, the challenge I threw to the to
- 54:28the people at the panel was You know, are you
- 54:30doing what you can? Are you being intentional
- 54:33about expanding this movement expanding the intellectual
- 54:36diversity here? Because you know, there really
- 54:38should be a larger representation than that,
- 54:40you know Yeah, that's the thing there's a real
- 54:45bias, you know, a real, first of all, there's
- 54:47gatekeeping. If you're announced that you're
- 54:50a conservative, you won't get support like community
- 54:52support from fellow vegans. And then there's
- 54:57an intentional, you know, desire not to reach
- 55:01out to conservatives, like this defeatist attitude
- 55:05of thinking, oh, but they're conservatives, they
- 55:08won't care about animals. And then they complain
- 55:11that conservatives are not more caring about
- 55:16animals. In the last decades, what kind of actions
- 55:22have you done? done targeted to conservatives.
- 55:27Zero. The answer is zero. So if you look at the
- 55:31landscape of who is vegan and who isn't, and
- 55:36you see that most conservatives are not vegan,
- 55:39maybe you have a responsibility in that. Maybe
- 55:42you're to blame for it. I would point out most
- 55:48liberals aren't vegan either. but it's uh and
- 55:52the numbers are different but still but but you
- 55:54know you you had so you had two conservative
- 55:55vegans on uh at one point i listened to that
- 55:58show it was a very good episode and uh the one
- 56:02of the guests had mentioned that she was in a
- 56:04um a facebook group of conservative vegans that
- 56:07was like 1500 people you know and i and this
- 56:10is another thing i talked about in the um in
- 56:13my uh In my panel was it was uh, i'm gonna, you
- 56:17know will before us. We're in a um in a an x
- 56:19group right a direct message group on x that's
- 56:22I mean Yeah, pretty substantial. It's pretty
- 56:24large and it's uh, you know It's called the patriot
- 56:27animal network and it's a bunch of people who
- 56:28are probably mostly very You know pro trump mega
- 56:33republicans. Um, some libertarians in there,
- 56:36but very very conservative crowd, right? um and
- 56:40most of them have some kind of involvement in
- 56:42and uh Yeah, animal welfare. Yeah, a lot of them
- 56:46do it professionally. Some of them are just like
- 56:48social media influencers who do, who do a lot
- 56:52of animal oriented posts. And, you know, we have
- 56:55this group going on this network and it's, but,
- 57:00you know, the other thing with that, which surprised
- 57:01me with that group too, because I did a kind
- 57:03of an ad hoc poll because I was curious, because
- 57:05it's not something that's very talked about very
- 57:07much in that group, but as it turns out, probably
- 57:10most of them are vegan. Or if not, if not most,
- 57:12if not, you know, If not most of them, it's close
- 57:14to the majority of them. Most of the people that
- 57:16responded certainly were. My question is, why
- 57:22aren't they going to things like ABA? Why aren't
- 57:23they involved in these kinds of movements? Like
- 57:26I said, part of that's on us, on the conservatives
- 57:29and libertarians. I'm going to do my part to
- 57:31try to push them out to these events and get
- 57:32them to take that ownership. These people, they
- 57:38exist. They are there. They're real. it only
- 57:42helps the movement for us to get to kind of coalesce
- 57:44and start working on these animal causes together
- 57:46for sure. I was scared at the election because
- 57:49I was thinking now that conservatives have taken
- 57:56over, there won't be any pro -animal vegan voice
- 58:02at the table. And so we have stopped ourselves
- 58:07from making any progress because we have uninvited
- 58:11ourselves from, you know, the conservative center
- 58:16of powers. But I was wrong. In fact, I was very
- 58:21wrong. Because the biggest. I was waiting to
- 58:25tell you, but you already know. Go ahead. My
- 58:34other fear around that was that I look at the
- 58:38Democratic Party and I look at what constitutes
- 58:43the liberal block, voter block, and I'm thinking
- 58:51those people will not gain back power for years
- 58:58to come. They're so disconnected from reality.
- 59:02and from, you know, the mainstream normal person
- 59:07in the streets, that, you know, I don't, I'm
- 59:12not very optimistic about their political prospects.
- 59:15And I guess, you know, I'm looking at the midterm
- 59:19election to see if the Republicans will keep
- 59:24the House because I guess that would be a great
- 59:27indicator of the political future of the Democratic
- 59:32Party. So if we invited ourselves from the center
- 59:40of power, the conservative center of powers,
- 59:43and we're not there to advocate for animals,
- 59:46and conservatives will have power for years and
- 59:49years to come, then we virtually shoot ourselves
- 59:55in the foot. in terms of progress and advancing
- 1:00:00the animal cause. Now, I was wrong. But, you
- 1:00:04know, what do you make of this analysis? That's
- 1:00:08interesting. I don't know if I'm the best, you
- 1:00:10know, political forecaster. I'm as interested
- 1:00:16as you are to see kind of what them in terms,
- 1:00:18you know, hold and what that what that ends up
- 1:00:20looking like. I do I do agree. I think that there's
- 1:00:24a that that's, you know, The the Democratic Party
- 1:00:28definitely has a problem with being Massively
- 1:00:31out of touch. I think man. I don't want to upset
- 1:00:34so upset the listeners too much, but I Would
- 1:00:37I would recommend to them what you know? Letting
- 1:00:41letting their their voters pick their own candidates
- 1:00:43would be it would be a good start I don't know
- 1:00:46if they've had a real if they've if they've actually
- 1:00:49really had a primary election for president in
- 1:00:52like 12 years, but No, I Think it's interesting.
- 1:00:58I think that Now because of the work of groups
- 1:01:03like white coat waste and Because of the willingness
- 1:01:08of a lot of the cuz that you know, we've done
- 1:01:09a lot of joking and teasing of the the the animal
- 1:01:13we've been on this Discussion and also some yeah,
- 1:01:16so I think realistic and worthwhile criticisms,
- 1:01:19right? But I mean there's there I think there
- 1:01:21are a lot of very smart and very intentional
- 1:01:23very good people We're in the animal movement
- 1:01:27that are also very pragmatic and are seeing this
- 1:01:29issue and understanding that you know the left
- 1:01:32has this problem and they're they're working
- 1:01:33on You know in very sincere and genuine ways
- 1:01:36like okay. How do we fix this? How do we extend
- 1:01:38these olive branches? How do we how we make how
- 1:01:40we improve the situation? And I think that that
- 1:01:42work is going to matter and I you know I think
- 1:01:46this you know, if you're right if your assessments,
- 1:01:49right and and the the the Democrats aren't going
- 1:01:55to get anything together anytime soon, and we're
- 1:01:58looking at them dealing with a lot of electoral
- 1:02:00losses for a while, which I think is a reasonable
- 1:02:04assessment for sure, then I think that we should
- 1:02:09look at that as an opportunity to build up the
- 1:02:12Adam and Lupin in the political right. Happy
- 1:02:16to talk to anyone who wants to talk about how
- 1:02:18we do that. Yeah, you're very optimistic. Do
- 1:02:22you believe that there is a way forward in terms
- 1:02:28of bipartisanship in the animal rights movement,
- 1:02:31or do you see divisions in the future, you know,
- 1:02:37those pragmatic and smart people, and I hope
- 1:02:40I'm one of them. You are. Thank you. Separating
- 1:02:45themselves from the mainstream animal rights
- 1:02:48movement and, you know, just following others,
- 1:02:53because I asked the same question to Rabbi Akiva
- 1:02:57in a previous episode, and I mentioned, do you
- 1:03:03see a future where Jews, vegan Jews, would come
- 1:03:09back to the animal rights movement fold? And
- 1:03:14he said, no, no, I don't see that. I think we're
- 1:03:17going to do our own thing. Makes me feel a bit
- 1:03:19sad, but at the same time, I think there is place,
- 1:03:24more place for diversity than of opinion and
- 1:03:27thoughts for this movement. And maybe, you know,
- 1:03:32this united approach is less impactful than maybe
- 1:03:37a more divisive one and everyone doing their
- 1:03:39own thing. So what do you make of that? Yeah,
- 1:03:43I think It's interesting. It's an interesting
- 1:03:46question. I think that there's a lot of So I
- 1:03:52guess part of this is informed by you know, I
- 1:03:55you've probably noticed I always refer to real
- 1:03:57forces as conservative and libertarian right
- 1:03:59and we have conservatives and libertarians and
- 1:04:01that is as close to a Catch -all for the big
- 1:04:07tank tent that we're trying who are operating
- 1:04:09under here That I that I can get right it was
- 1:04:13used you mentioned that the meetup that we did
- 1:04:15and I had it Literally called a conservative
- 1:04:17libertarian meetup, but then I had it was like
- 1:04:19I don't care Yeah, it's like you call yourself
- 1:04:21a classical liberal a yeah and cap like every
- 1:04:24single designator that I could think of you know
- 1:04:27because I wanted to say like is as Widely defined
- 1:04:30as we can, you know, yeah, that's who we're looking
- 1:04:33for here, right? And and so I think there's something
- 1:04:36similar to that Within the animal of it. I kind
- 1:04:39of see it the same way where it's like there's
- 1:04:41that there's a general caught There's a general
- 1:04:42purpose general mission and then a bunch of different
- 1:04:45approaches to it a bunch of different ways and
- 1:04:47I think You know, I think that can coalesce very
- 1:04:50broadly and then work, you know intentionally
- 1:04:54very In you know in different channels, right
- 1:04:58and sometimes they and collaborating where they
- 1:05:00were that where that makes sense, too I think
- 1:05:04for you know for Okay, so this is a there's a
- 1:05:09magazine called the American conservative right
- 1:05:12and That magazine came out during the Bush years
- 1:05:16and it was It was actually a reaction to the
- 1:05:21Bush presidency, right? It was it was very Anti
- 1:05:26-immigration it was very, you know border security.
- 1:05:28It was very anti -war and You know the number
- 1:05:33the number of these issues that at the time Yeah,
- 1:05:36they did it again to kind of protest Bush and
- 1:05:38call themselves the American server, right? And
- 1:05:40it was very different than what the Republican
- 1:05:44Party looked like at the time. But you look at
- 1:05:47the Republican Party now, and what they started
- 1:05:50writing about then is basically the Republican
- 1:05:53Party now, right? It is the Trump era Republican.
- 1:05:57It looks exactly like what they were talking
- 1:05:59about. And these are actually the guys, incidentally,
- 1:06:01who put JD Vance on the map. they reviewed his
- 1:06:04book hillbilly elegy and that that's what uh
- 1:06:07started the rise of that book and made it a bestseller
- 1:06:09and all that all of that so i'm not saying that
- 1:06:12the american conservative magazine is the reason
- 1:06:14that um that we have now uh yeah the republican
- 1:06:19party that we do but definitely they were put
- 1:06:22they were they were early in in shaping that
- 1:06:24thought and they were working in those channels
- 1:06:25to shape that thought um i think i think about
- 1:06:29them when i feel like this is like a very uphill
- 1:06:31battle and i and i Because I realize that what
- 1:06:34we're trying to do really is create a meaningful
- 1:06:38segment of the American political right that
- 1:06:41cares about animals and that is working intentionally
- 1:06:43for animals. We'd love to see it be a real serious
- 1:06:47plank of the Republican Party and that kind of
- 1:06:49thing. That seems a lot more attainable when
- 1:06:51I start thinking about the way in which that
- 1:06:54party shifted. So I think that you can use that
- 1:06:58example and if you think about the way this movement
- 1:07:02is going to grow in shape and the way these paradigms
- 1:07:04can shift in not that long of a time. I guess
- 1:07:09that's where my optimism comes from on it. Wonderful.
- 1:07:12I think those are great words to close the conversation.
- 1:07:19Liam, did you want to add something before I
- 1:07:21stop the recording? No, I think I covered just
- 1:07:27about everything. It was a great conversation.
- 1:07:28I appreciate you taking the time to do it. I
- 1:07:31would love anyone who wants to find out more
- 1:07:33about what we're doing. Check us out at willbeforest
- 1:07:36.institute or go to see us on X. It's at willbeforest
- 1:07:42.institute. And yeah, also happy to continue
- 1:07:48the conversation with anybody if they want to
- 1:07:49try to send us an email. I will mention all of
- 1:07:55that in the introduction and of course there
- 1:07:56will be links in the episode notes for easy access
- 1:08:00to all of that. Wonderful. Cut that part out,
- 1:08:05that's fine. I'm just editing, just to have a
- 1:08:11better flow. Mostly editing my questions. I thought
- 1:08:16your questions were great. Yes, yes, but you
- 1:08:19know, the execution. Perfect. I think you did
- 1:08:24better. You executed better than I did, for sure.
- 1:08:27No, no, no. Your answers were great. Thank you.
- 1:08:31Thank you so much, Liam, for having accepted
- 1:08:33my invitation and answered my questions. And
- 1:08:37thank you so much for your precious work. I'm,
- 1:08:39again, so happy that you exist. Thank you. Thank
- 1:08:42you for yours. I'm excited. Glad to call you
- 1:08:47a friend. I'm excited to talk more to you and
- 1:08:48yeah, let's keep our conversations going. Definitely
- 1:08:51I consider you as a friend too. Thank you everyone
- 1:08:54for listening. I kindly invite you to share this
- 1:08:57podcast with the vegans you know. Let's encourage
- 1:09:00more people to take action. Again, thank you
- 1:09:04so much for caring and I will see you next Tuesday
- 1:09:07for a new episode.