Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP212: How Can Large Businesses Tackle Replatforming: Building The Business Case & Planning For Change
Transcript
- 0:02Thanks for listening to the Re Platform podcast sponsored by
- 0:05Crown Pig and Elastic Path and hosted by me James Go Rogers.
- 0:08We bring interviews of industry thought.
- 0:09Lead is the C-Suite at tech companies.
- 0:11Illegal retailers showcase you what they're up to, how they're
- 0:15using tech, hopefully help you make Better Business decisions.
- 0:17All we ask in return is you tell other people about podcast like
- 0:20and and share our posts on social media.
- 0:23And if this is your first time listening, give us a rating that
- 0:26really helps with our visibility.
- 0:28So today's episode's an interest someone.
- 0:30So Paul, I've been speaking to recently and I've visited the
- 0:32last few years to some large organisations around like
- 0:36technology selection and re platforming.
- 0:38And inevitably at that level of change there is more risk and
- 0:41it's more complex and I think sometimes there can be some
- 0:45reticence to to look at re platforming and and to consider
- 0:49and maybe push it down the line. So we wanted to talk about some
- 0:52of the areas around bridge management, how large businesses
- 0:55can tackle re platforming, how you make better decisions and it
- 1:00also leads leads nicely off the back of a post that was on
- 1:03LinkedIn recently by Rick Watson when I think the title was like
- 1:05most enterprise CE OS rather nor off their arm than RE platform.
- 1:09So we want to look at why sometimes it's more challenging
- 1:13and more risky, but actually how you can make sensible decisions
- 1:16and help the business make good technology decisions at this
- 1:18level. So let's kick off with, I guess
- 1:23the foundational question is what are the unique challenges
- 1:26of risks for large organisations or organisations we're we're not
- 1:29just talking about large on revenue, we're talking about in
- 1:32terms of business size, systems complexity.
- 1:37Yeah, absolutely. Yes.
- 1:39I think, I think that's exactly, I think the first point always
- 1:43comes up is like the definition of enterprise.
- 1:45I personally probably ship more around like size of business and
- 1:51you know, number of people that whole piece and I guess that
- 1:56like particularly the people point is probably one of the
- 1:58biggest variables just where you've got more teams, you know,
- 2:02more major stakeholders, you know and there's like bigger
- 2:06impacts and you need to get more people brought in.
- 2:08And I think in my experience you've got that piece and then
- 2:11you've got the tech side and a lot of the larger, more
- 2:14enterprise businesses we work with will have more kind of,
- 2:17yeah, legacy technology, more technical data, you know, more
- 2:21systems that cannot be touched or cannot be changed.
- 2:24So anything you are putting in place, you know, you have to
- 2:26kind of fit in with those systems or you know, you've got
- 2:30kind of a relatively rigid way of working.
- 2:33But I think they're my big two. I guess like you know, having
- 2:37more stakeholders, potentially having you know, really big in
- 2:40house development teams, like yeah, just more variables around
- 2:43people and then the tech side, but what would you add to that?
- 2:47Yeah, the tech deck definitely. I think and the fact that tech's
- 2:52picked in silos is often the problem is that because then the
- 2:54tech isn't isn't designed to integrate and work well
- 2:57together. So you have a lot of manual
- 2:59workarounds and like hard. I've seen it's things where hard
- 3:03coded has been created to label bits of data to transfer from
- 3:06one system to the other. And obviously that means if you
- 3:09pull out one system that's going to break that connection then
- 3:12it's the process step that I think is a bit that's least
- 3:14talked about that enterprise. So this is where you have teams
- 3:19that have grown over time and different parts of business
- 3:22you've grown out without being integrated from a process point
- 3:24of view. So product, product buy in and
- 3:26orchestration is a great one where you might have the buy in
- 3:29team that's using a particular bit of technology or using range
- 3:33of spreadsheets to to do all of the the the product plan in the
- 3:37range of sorts etcetera. And then you've got a
- 3:40merchandising team whose job it is to take the the products and
- 3:43enrich the data and get it all ready for web.
- 3:45They're using a different system and they've got a different
- 3:48process and different spreadsheets.
- 3:49And then you've got an e-commerce team that's basically
- 3:52running and managing the website in another set of technology.
- 3:55And there's lots of reliance on on emails and manual processes
- 4:00that that in its own the process.
- 4:02But when you start looking at from a true BA point of view of
- 4:04mapping it out is what terrifies most people because they realise
- 4:08how much effort is involved to re engineer a process to be more
- 4:12automated and to be aligned with new tech and the impact that
- 4:15then has on people. Because you have you talk about
- 4:18resistance change, you have some people who will always be
- 4:20resistant to change. This is how I do it.
- 4:23Bringing those people on on online with their project where
- 4:26there's better automation and maybe something they've
- 4:29themselves have created and that have real pride and ownership in
- 4:32is no longer required that that creates friction.
- 4:35So I think the process bit often creates some of the the bigger.
- 4:37Problems. Yeah.
- 4:40So I guess this is that just reminded me of something that
- 4:43I've seen a bit more like coming downstream a bit recently that I
- 4:47think can work really well. So you see these larger
- 4:50businesses like build out kind of large transformation projects
- 4:55I guess or different phases address in different parts of
- 4:58the business. And I guess one of the benefits
- 5:00of doing that is that it's going to make it easier to kind of
- 5:03like join up thinking and like influence change across
- 5:07different teams. But yeah I found that's quite an
- 5:10that I didn't know we had. I think we had Josh on once and
- 5:13Jigsaw but he like that's an example of the business which I
- 5:17put in like the kind of medium sized category but like they
- 5:20have like full time headcount in a in transformation roles and
- 5:24they've made some really positive change in their
- 5:26business. And I think yeah that just
- 5:29reminded me of that. It's a bit of a tangible, but I
- 5:31guess that's one consideration when you are trying to make big
- 5:35change in in the businesses is kind of how you structure the
- 5:38projects and how you actually work cross team.
- 5:42Crown Peak enabling organisations to build
- 5:44meaningful digital experiences for everyone, everywhere.
- 5:48Engage your customers with our content management system, reach
- 5:52your entire audience with our digital accessibility and
- 5:55quality tools, and grow your brand with our product discovery
- 5:59solution. Find out more at crownpeak.com.
- 6:02Definitely. Do you know what's interesting?
- 6:04I work in the House of Fraser a few years back and they were
- 6:06going through a massive RE platform and they what they did
- 6:09smartly is they brought in a change management and experience
- 6:12change manager. So they had their their PMO team
- 6:16with with BAS and project managers doing the so they build
- 6:19out because they realize that they they can do it without
- 6:22proper function because existing team didn't have the resource or
- 6:26they didn't have the skills basically.
- 6:27And I think this is often where big business go wrong is is
- 6:30trying to get existing teams alongside and maybe a technology
- 6:33agency. You need program and project
- 6:36management expertise at this level because it is a specific
- 6:39distance. Change management is different.
- 6:42Not all PMS are good at change management.
- 6:44The change manager has a really strong human element in terms of
- 6:46understanding the impact on people's roles and how you plan
- 6:49for that. But the one skill that I I
- 6:51haven't seen it and maybe it's just because the businesses I've
- 6:53worked with haven't gone down this route is product
- 6:57management. So often what what I find is you
- 7:00can have really good project discipline, but there isn't
- 7:02enough focus from the product ownership of what the the, the
- 7:04technology is and doing and what it and what the priorities are
- 7:08because each part of the business has owned its part of
- 7:10it. So the merchandisers own the
- 7:12merchandising tools, you know the the UX team own front end
- 7:16tool, but there's no strategic vision of the product.
- 7:20And when you're looking at a new piece of technology, you've got
- 7:22to have a clear definition of what what the product purpose
- 7:25is, what what you want to own versus what you want to
- 7:28outsource. And I think that for me is where
- 7:31it where enterprise businesses don't always have the right
- 7:35skill. Then that I've got an example or
- 7:41I can read bad example of that from a client I worked on.
- 7:44I think it would take us nicely on to the exploit.
- 7:46But the worst example I saw was essentially where different
- 7:51teams are making different decisions in isolation and there
- 7:55was quite a high budget for the project and they ended up like a
- 7:57number of teams were looking at you know the Magic Quadrant and
- 8:01there were multiple consultancies in and they ended
- 8:04up selecting SAP Hybris as our ecom platform.
- 8:07Then the another team selected site core content management and
- 8:13then they ended up picking various Adobe products as well
- 8:16alongside it. And I guess that's a good
- 8:17example of on paper dependent on your sources, you know that
- 8:22could be considered best in class.
- 8:23But realistically, you're kind of overpaying for solutions,
- 8:27kind of crossover, and probably don't work amazingly well
- 8:30together. That's a perfect example and
- 8:33I've seen this in other places where where people have picked a
- 8:37a additional experience platform because it's strong on CMS but
- 8:41it has other things around it. Obviously DXP is different, it
- 8:44offers additional elements say like might have to search merge
- 8:47personalization, but then somebody else has picked a high
- 8:50end search and merge personalization toy.
- 8:53So you've got and these are these are modular licensing, not
- 8:56like some of the modern ones where you might be able to pick
- 8:58like the search bit but not personalization bit.
- 9:00So they're paid high end enterprise licenses for two
- 9:03platforms that crossover massively and those are
- 9:06enterprise licences negotiated with specific contract terms.
- 9:09You realise you're now locked in for a minimum of 18 months to
- 9:12two years and you've just burnt 10s of thousands of pounds for
- 9:15no reason. Yeah, it's exactly.
- 9:17And that's why the product management.
- 9:19And I think when when an enterprise organization's trying
- 9:22to think about migration and risk management, somebody has to
- 9:25perform the product management role in this process to align
- 9:29that thinking. So that one person hasn't gone
- 9:31over and signed with a vendor that is not, not aligned with
- 9:35the overall stack. And and I think the biggest
- 9:37question starts with what's driving the stack.
- 9:39Is it, is the CMS driving it or is the Econ platform then
- 9:42deriving all the other Subs Like there's no right or wrong to it,
- 9:45but you've got to make a decision of what the primary
- 9:47system is to then dictate the rest.
- 9:49So but yeah the comment you made links on really nicely about the
- 9:52looking at the Magic Quadrant and I have had there been some
- 9:55really good discussions on LinkedIn about you know it our
- 9:59thing I think it's Tim Richland had a question recently about
- 10:02you know should people be paying attention to like gardeners
- 10:04magic Quarren foresters wave what purpose do they serve.
- 10:08And our viewpoint is always do you know what it's good to see
- 10:10what how other people are rating systems but you have to take a
- 10:13pitch of salt they're not the de facto and sources where your
- 10:17info interesting some businesses that's where they go like you
- 10:20know investors or CC will go well well look Salesforce Adobe
- 10:25these guys at the top that's what we should be looking at.
- 10:27So how do you, what do you think of the the risks in that and how
- 10:31do you avoid just people, always enterprise, always looking at
- 10:34the same 3 or 4 platforms? Yeah.
- 10:38So I think like this, this and the next point end up being
- 10:41quite a broad discussion I think.
- 10:44So this episode was triggered by me speaking to a business that I
- 10:49felt had approached a platform selection piece incorrectly and
- 10:54essentially they were trying to do an apples for apples
- 10:58comparison across a number of platforms that can't really be
- 11:01compared. And I think the way that ecom's
- 11:03gone now where you've got you know platforms that essentially
- 11:07won't cover any of the front end, you've got platforms like
- 11:11Shopify where we're going to have a series of important third
- 11:15parties around it. The, you know, need to be
- 11:18considered as part of an overall solution and then you've got
- 11:21like a sales force that is kind of almost kind of like one
- 11:26solution try cover everything. And I think part like with
- 11:30Gartner, I think some of that is covered, but a lot of it isn't
- 11:34as well. And I think that's where some of
- 11:36those solutions fall down. I also think that, I mean I
- 11:40think it's overall that, you know, I know someone that's a
- 11:43Gartner and he was explaining to me that, you know, the
- 11:45researchers do speak to loads of people.
- 11:48I think it's just really hard to do a comparison like that with
- 11:52the amount of variables there are by vertical, retailer size,
- 11:56platform nuance. I just think it's too hard.
- 11:59So, and I think if we go back to that point on kind of like where
- 12:03we started this episode, I personally feel like nowadays
- 12:08because I think in the mid market typically you see very
- 12:12little. You don't see as many like
- 12:14mistakes when it comes to the tech stack.
- 12:16And I think a lot of that is because people are connected,
- 12:19they're going out and speaking to other brands, they're looking
- 12:21at what their competition have done like and there's less major
- 12:25stakeholders. So like that one person or that
- 12:29small team are going away and doing too diligent.
- 12:31Whereas I feel like that doesn't happen as much in the
- 12:35enterprise. But I think based on that one
- 12:37conversation that I had, which I think I felt like there was risk
- 12:40of, you know, almost like they could go and choose an SAP or
- 12:44you know an Adobe just by looking at you know, features
- 12:48and isolation and stuff like that.
- 12:52I feel like you need. Because I think bringing in
- 12:55consultants is one thing, but I just feel like nowadays you just
- 12:58got to put more time into like speaking to different groups of
- 13:02people and just getting more context around you know where
- 13:07things are going, road map, you know, how an ecosystem is
- 13:11developing, like the speed of change around the platform, you
- 13:16know, net new brands that are coming on board that fall within
- 13:20kind of where you want to be. And then also like how people
- 13:24are using it, how it can feasibly work as part of a stack
- 13:27that's relevant to you. So yeah, I don't know.
- 13:30I mean, it's quite a hard one to answer, but I just think you've
- 13:32got to put more time into getting understanding these
- 13:36days, just because it's not as simple as it used to be where
- 13:38you'd go for a a monolith platform and use it for
- 13:42everything. I don't know if you agree with
- 13:43that. Elastic Path is on a mission to
- 13:46breakthrough the barriers that prevent commerce leaders from
- 13:49delivering extraordinary shopping experiences.
- 13:52Both business and tech teams are able to innovate on their own
- 13:55terms, fully embrace composability, and in turn never
- 13:59compromise on what's possible. Learn more at
- 14:02www.elasticpath.com. We are increasingly, I find the
- 14:07word monolith, the misleading thing that I just think people
- 14:11should forget about because we talked about something like
- 14:15Shopify is application is a monolith, but the ecosystem is
- 14:19very different in how it's architected to something like a
- 14:22Salesforce. And you know Salesforce is is
- 14:24obviously trying to modernize by bringing it to composable
- 14:27storefront and you know new connectors.
- 14:29But fundamentally the difference is though it's it's being
- 14:34bought, built out of a legacy stack with a huge amount of
- 14:37functionality native to the platform.
- 14:39But that takes a lot of modernizing, that takes a lot of
- 14:42effort to maintain and support. So I guess the question, I think
- 14:47the point you made out is the key one is it's a mentality and
- 14:51a mindset shift and and sometimes there are
- 14:53preconceptions that if not everything is native to the
- 14:57platform, there is more risk, it's less secure and enterprise
- 15:01level security is critical. And we, we did a project
- 15:03recently done with a big fashion retailer in the enterprise space
- 15:07and they have to see somebody within the I internal IT team
- 15:10who's focused on security. And that is a massive concern.
- 15:14And obviously it is because at that scale if you screw up your
- 15:17security and you have an issue with penetration, it can lead to
- 15:21a massive not just brand damage but but income loss.
- 15:25So, so it is really important but there I think there's a
- 15:28misconception that that having like a SaaS platform for example
- 15:31where you have lots of apps is less secure and therefore you're
- 15:34open to more residents. Actually the the development
- 15:38standards enforced on app partners in order to have an app
- 15:41released into that ecosystem are incredibly high because the SaaS
- 15:45platform without its high up time and you know Shopify had
- 15:48its recent form 5 minute downtime.
- 15:50So that's always, always gets people excited.
- 15:53But the SaaS platforms uptime is its revenue.
- 15:56If it's not stable and it's not secure, it's not going to win
- 16:00business, it's not going to keep business safe.
- 16:02So ultimately the amount of time and effort that goes into it
- 16:06from the core application point of view is huge.
- 16:08So I I think, I think the, I think it's more about trying to
- 16:11change the narrative in a big business to to to help them
- 16:15understand that what they're trying to achieve is the goal,
- 16:19not the architectural way it's done.
- 16:21Because if you start on, oh, everything's in the platform,
- 16:24that's what I want. You're not looking at business
- 16:26need, you're looking at how come, and I think we've got it
- 16:29flipping the narrative. Sometimes people think about
- 16:31things differently because then if they go down that river, it's
- 16:35all based on business need and where they want to get and
- 16:37what's going to support them operationally.
- 16:39If they then decide having evaluated a different model that
- 16:43it isn't right, they've done it on merit and that's fine.
- 16:46But if you exclude it without I mean then then you are missing a
- 16:49trick. Well, I think that's the thing
- 16:52as well. And I think if I look at how
- 16:54some businesses or I've seen some businesses approach this,
- 16:59it's kind of you know, trying to capture native functionality and
- 17:04leaving it there. Whereas I think you've almost
- 17:06got to like build out you know a set of initial requirements and
- 17:11then work either work with the vendors initially to get a view
- 17:16of like how that functionality is going to be achieved and then
- 17:19which third party is going to be needed.
- 17:21And then start to assess like security side, the TCO side with
- 17:25how those are being billed etcetera.
- 17:30And then start to do your due diligence on the quality of
- 17:33those approaches. They also can the other risk and
- 17:35all of this, particularly enterprise Levellers, it's so
- 17:38easy to demo something or say something and make it look
- 17:42amazing, whereas in actual fact, you know, there could be massive
- 17:45knock on effects or you know, it could be like ridiculously
- 17:48rigid. And I think that's the biggest
- 17:51thing. So thinking back to that
- 17:53project, I guess like there was quite a lot of that where like
- 17:56you see something you think that is absolutely perfect for what
- 17:59we need. But yeah, then the more you look
- 18:02into it, the more like you might restrict you in the future.
- 18:06So I think that's the hard thing is like with these enterprise
- 18:10businesses, it's like, yeah, how do they to get to that point.
- 18:14I think it's probably is just a case of like you need to bring
- 18:17in very specialist consultants and I think that's another whole
- 18:20episode in itself around specialist consultants versus
- 18:23consultancies. But yeah, I think you do just
- 18:26need like people or not even necessarily.
- 18:28It could be contractors, but I think you just need people that
- 18:32have been in and around the area like to Imper and tell you where
- 18:39you need to do the extra due diligence.
- 18:43Yeah. And I the one of the key
- 18:45narratives in in in Rick Watson's post which which
- 18:48definitely resonates is is that the the the risk and the
- 18:53potential costs and effort of change puts a lot of CE OS in in
- 18:57in enterprise space off because it's do you know what it's
- 19:00working, it's not perfect but it's working.
- 19:03Christ, it's going to take us so much time and effort.
- 19:05But I guess a a key question that we should discuss is, is
- 19:10like that business case bit like how do you, what is the business
- 19:13case for going through this effort?
- 19:14Because it does take time when you're talking with big
- 19:16stakeholder sets and you've got complex legacy tech stacks that
- 19:20need serious about it. Because when you're looking at a
- 19:22simple D to C fashion brand, OK, it's much simpler to do the this
- 19:28is how we're going to use a platform Shopify Big Commerce
- 19:30Accenture. When you've got all this legacy
- 19:35stack code issues technical debt process debt, you're right that
- 19:39point about the due diligence takes longer because you start
- 19:42at the high level and then you peel it back and you get to the
- 19:44specialist areas and you have to do more and more due diligence.
- 19:47When you realise things like Omni channel flows, when you've
- 19:50got store store stock in inventory like multi warehouse,
- 19:54you know different rules around all this stuff.
- 19:58Next so let's talk about how how you build the business case.
- 20:02So when when somebody comes to you they're like we just you
- 20:05know we're we're thinking that we're not going to bother it's
- 20:07too much effort. How would you?
- 20:09How would you constructively challenge and say, look, you
- 20:11really should do this and here's why.
- 20:12You should put the time and effort into doing the
- 20:14evaluation. Yeah, I think that's a really
- 20:18good question. And I guess usually when we do
- 20:23that, there'll be someone internally that's, you know, got
- 20:26some level of motivation to do this.
- 20:30But I think, I mean it's a really interesting point, isn't
- 20:32it? Because I can think of so many
- 20:33brands that I have spoke to that have been on a very dated stack
- 20:37and they're just kind of like they've just kind of accepted
- 20:40the cost and the ways of working and that they might not be as
- 20:44agile and they've kind of written half medium term re
- 20:49platforming even though you know they're 5 versions out of date
- 20:54on SAP and you know things are taken ages which is really
- 20:59interesting. But I think in terms of the
- 21:00business case, one I guess would be like long term TCO and two
- 21:06would be like I guess the benefits of specific best in
- 21:09class features and areas because usually with like the really
- 21:15dated or like real like legacy systems, you know, there'll be
- 21:19certain things around CRM that have just been you know pushed
- 21:22back on for years or you know pulling data out of the platform
- 21:27could be really valuable to the business etcetera.
- 21:29So I guess it's like starting to quantify like the value of some
- 21:32of those areas and then you know bundling it all together and
- 21:36putting a number on it. But yeah, I think for me it's
- 21:41it's probably that it's like incremental improvement in
- 21:44functionality that could drive revenue or customer experience.
- 21:49Another one could be if you're looking at doing something like
- 21:51an upgrade and a redesign and suddenly the cost of re
- 21:55platforming ends up being similar or less, which I've
- 21:59that's probably been the biggest driver for us actually with most
- 22:02of the projects we've done. And then the other one would be
- 22:05cost saving which I think is going to be very big for next
- 22:08year. So if you can prove massive
- 22:11reduction in OpEx costs and actually over a five year
- 22:15period, you might save a load of money three to five year period
- 22:18and I can now be the other one. Yeah, yeah, for me the the cost
- 22:24of inaction is always an interesting one.
- 22:26So I I once today a cost model with so the head of e-commerce
- 22:30who was struggling to get traction with the her director
- 22:34because his view was we're just you know we're going to spend
- 22:37loads of money and there's no guarantee it's going to improve
- 22:40things like you say and we just looked at that all the processes
- 22:43that her team had to do on a on a daily and weekly basis that
- 22:46didn't need to be done that could be automated regard
- 22:49regardless of of black. We're just with a better either
- 22:52better version of the current one as in a modern version or a
- 22:55new modern tech stack. And I think we worked out
- 22:58something about 80 KA year could be saved in the current team
- 23:05from a team of four, which is quite a lot because of the
- 23:08amount of even promotion. So to do a promotion, they had
- 23:11to set up a promotion in the admin tool.
- 23:14They then had to contact IT because IT then had to code
- 23:18logic to apply the promotional discounting and then that had to
- 23:24be released in staging. It had to be tested in stage and
- 23:26then it had to be set up in live and and you're like, wow, Jesus
- 23:30to set up a promotion. Are you kidding me.
- 23:32So I I think that cost of inaction is brilliant.
- 23:36The opportunity costs and that that project we worked on
- 23:38recently One of the ones we looked at and and one of the
- 23:41ones when the the E com team were pushing back to the in
- 23:45their life boards back was about the inability to execute parts
- 23:48of the strategy to deliver on the growth plans because of the
- 23:52time cost and F of releasing on on one of those market leaders
- 23:57and it was like to launch a new international store.
- 23:59They just they they couldn't justify it and they couldn't do
- 24:03when they suddenly needed tactically to Lawrence they
- 24:05couldn't do it quick enough because it was like a a four
- 24:07month turn around rather than like a two week turn around.
- 24:10And then the the final one which I think is really important and
- 24:14it's quite hard to put a number on there is team churn.
- 24:18So it's hard to maintain really mated shop people who want to do
- 24:23great things if the tech is limiting them and the tech is
- 24:26old and obviously and the tech doesn't do anything to their CV.
- 24:30You know, notice there are, yeah, there are a lot of good
- 24:33technology found out here during their bears, but they're not
- 24:37alike. They don't have a modern vibrant
- 24:39system where loads of brands are going investment.
- 24:42There are some platforms of people moving away more than
- 24:44they're joining. Front end development's a great
- 24:48example. It's where people kind of want
- 24:49to work on outdated tech. They want they want to be able
- 24:52to showcase on STV that they're using what are you know, like
- 24:55next Nuts view React, you know pick your technology front,
- 25:00developer wants to work. So actually not only do you risk
- 25:04losing good staff if the tech continues to be slow behind the
- 25:08market and they're getting no satisfaction, but attracting the
- 25:12best. If you really want to to grow
- 25:15and scale and be a market leader, you need market leading
- 25:20talent and you can't acquire that talent easily if your tech
- 25:23stack is completely out of sync with their expectations.
- 25:26So I think that's really important.
- 25:28As I say, much harder to put a like financial number on to like
- 25:32a board, but it's definitely something worth thinking about.
- 25:37Yeah, I completely agree with that.
- 25:38And I've actually seen that first hand from with like around
- 25:41hiring you know the optimization people and even head of Ecoms
- 25:45where you know they just don't want to work in a business.
- 25:48It's got you know where they're like restricted by technology
- 25:51and the other one that I was going to put in as well around
- 25:55the business case, often dependent on the platform you're
- 25:59on like a few of the ones we've worked on recently have been
- 26:02driven by security and compliance why they're on an end
- 26:05of life platform and actually that's a big part of the
- 26:09business case as well. But yeah, I think all really
- 26:12good points. And what else have you seen in
- 26:17terms of like common blockers? Because one of the ones that
- 26:19I've often come across and it it's a hard one term pick is in
- 26:24bigger businesses. We all know that us humans with
- 26:26fickle characters in some way that technology is prone to not
- 26:30to break in. But with bigger teams with
- 26:34bigger senior leadership teams in inevitably comes more
- 26:37politics. It become the you get more, more
- 26:41silos and you often get like individuals who have a bias to a
- 26:48particular tech and maybe they put in, maybe they've only ever
- 26:52worked on that or maybe they've got a relationship with a
- 26:55supplier and they want to own that and they don't want that to
- 26:59change. And if you get that, that
- 27:03isolation where people have different viewpoints and people
- 27:05feel like they they they should own and then become a blocker.
- 27:10So that's one of the key ones that I found which is a real
- 27:12challenge in dealing with. And you you, you invariably
- 27:15don't get that SME level. I've not seen it for quite a
- 27:18while actually at that level you might have a few disagrees, but
- 27:20I've never seen that level of block.
- 27:22What have you seen that? How do you how do people
- 27:25overcome that so it doesn't derail a project and stop people
- 27:29evaluating on merit? Yeah.
- 27:33So I think definitely have seen that.
- 27:35I think often that's where you bring consultants in.
- 27:37So I once got bought into a project and was kind of tricked
- 27:41actually. So there was one particular
- 27:43stakeholder. He was very pro a technology
- 27:47which I was not informed of. And then essentially without
- 27:50knowing what was happening, I guess I was brought in to build
- 27:54a case against that platform and for another platform and it
- 27:59ended up being quite hostile and this person had you know, a
- 28:04massive background in this technology, was on one of their
- 28:07advisory boards etcetera. So, but I think you know their
- 28:11actual reasoning for bringing me in was right.
- 28:14It was more the way that it was dealt with that probably could
- 28:17have been a bit better and maybe it could have been managed a bit
- 28:19better. I would have communicated
- 28:20slightly differently for sure. So yeah, I think that's one
- 28:25thing, bringing in consultants, another one would I guess just
- 28:28be putting time into building a case another way and another one
- 28:33that I would say the biggest blocker I see by a long way and
- 28:36I don't know if you agree with this is people seeing
- 28:40replatforming as a risk to BAU. So regardless of you know, how
- 28:45much it's needed, how much people want to senior
- 28:48stakeholders, just seeing it as too big a distraction.
- 28:52And I think that's an interesting one because yeah,
- 28:55I've also put like ended up building quite a lot of cases in
- 28:58the past around how you avoid the abstraction.
- 29:00I know you've done a lot of that as well.
- 29:02And I think nowadays you know, you can outsource such big parts
- 29:06of projects and you can bring in like if you bring in the right
- 29:09team. I personally, I mean you're
- 29:10always going to need key internal team members involved
- 29:14in projects, but I don't think it needs to be as bad as it
- 29:18maybe used to be a few years ago.
- 29:21Yeah, I I agree And and I I think the key thing is when you
- 29:24have a large business with lots of stakeholders and they're for
- 29:27lots of different parts and normally more legacy tech
- 29:30challenges is you need a fund, you need a proper project team
- 29:35and APMO function and that needs they.
- 29:38For big ones, you often need a program manager and and and
- 29:41maybe a couple of project managers and you'll need BAS
- 29:44because the process mapping piece needs to be done properly
- 29:47before. You can't evaluate tech.
- 29:50If you don't understand your process, it's really hard
- 29:52because someone goes, this is how you do it.
- 29:53You go, OK, how does that fit with the wild operation?
- 29:56A little. So that bits really important
- 29:59and I think you can you can bring in externals for a lot of
- 30:02that. But you're right, you
- 30:03fundamentally the decision makers need to be the business
- 30:07because the business has to have ownership.
- 30:10Consultants can guide and advise and help them make better
- 30:13decisions and point out things of hey, you do, you do it like
- 30:16this at the moment, other people do it like that.
- 30:17You sure your process shouldn't be changing here, but
- 30:20fundamentally if a business isn't owning the decision gates
- 30:24as you go through, then they don't really have the the same
- 30:27investment and stake in the project.
- 30:28And it's much harder to get people to buy into change when
- 30:31they don't own and don't feel like they are the ones who have
- 30:35guided that change. But I think that's good.
- 30:37I think the balance of Excel and internal is a real challenge and
- 30:40that means speaking the time up front.
- 30:42And I think the bit that external people need to help
- 30:45enterprise businesses with better is explaining to them the
- 30:50the, the justification for the investment because the PMO
- 30:53function costs, it's a chunk of money.
- 30:55It's seen as a cost not a benefit.
- 30:57So you have to be able to flip that and explain that as a
- 31:00benefit and talk about how that's going to protect BAU
- 31:03because you know if somebody's distracted 25% off of peak
- 31:05trading that you could put money on that and go well you're
- 31:08you're not going to be as efficient in your trading
- 31:10campaigns that could be lost this.
- 31:12So therefore we can protect that amount of it.
- 31:14So revenue protection is 1 bear but also I I think it's the the
- 31:18impact of of making the right technology decision as well
- 31:22because as you said before like if you get the wrong text cost
- 31:25will be chewed you'll end up spending on licence in your own
- 31:28magazine. But yeah it's often a
- 31:30conversation that doesn't happen is is when I see like proposals
- 31:34it's like what's the cost for doing this rather than what's
- 31:36the benefit. And and and I think the more
- 31:39people on your way from costs, right, you've got to pay the
- 31:42money. You can't bring in excellent
- 31:43expertise without cash. But fundamentally somebody's got
- 31:46to be talking to the person who signs all this off about why and
- 31:50what impact it's going to have positively for them and their
- 31:52business. Yeah.
- 31:55No, I completely agree. Yeah.
- 31:57And I think actually, yeah, I guess it's probably slightly
- 32:00different in the enterprise as well where there's obviously
- 32:03bigger gaps to fill. So yeah, I think all that makes
- 32:06sense. So let let's let's pause on this
- 32:11one, because I know that I mean this is such a big topic.
- 32:13We can carry on chatting for ages and it'll probably send
- 32:16everybody to sleep. So for those of you who haven't
- 32:18fallen asleep and have enjoyed that love you to like, reach
- 32:21out. Reach out to us on our LinkedIn
- 32:23post. Tell us like what?
- 32:25What do you think? How do you think enterprise
- 32:27position should approach technology evaluation?
- 32:30You know, if you're working in an enterprise business now, what
- 32:33what are the blockers you see? What are the challenges you've
- 32:35got there? What have you learned about how
- 32:37you engage people in these projects and get stakeholders
- 32:39bought in so that you make better decisions for the
- 32:42business? We'd love to hear because no
- 32:44one's got the right answer on this, right?
- 32:45It is a challenging thing to do. But thank you for listening.
- 32:48We hope you enjoyed it. Keep your ear open for the next
- 32:50episode and remember to give us that rating before you go.
- 32:53Thanks very much everybody. For more information on this
- 33:04topic. Head over to Replatform dot FM
- 33:06for our audio podcasts to discuss a project.
- 33:09Or if you'd like to chat about any of the topics covered in
- 33:11this episode in more detail, please reach out to myself,
- 33:14James Kurd, or my Co host Paul Rogers via LinkedIn and Twitter.
- 33:17Thanks again for listening and keep your ears peeled for the
- 33:19next episode.