Latest / Newcomer Pod / Fighting for Pro-Crypto Legislation in Sam Bankman-Fried's Shadow (with Chris Lehane)
Transcript
- 0:01Hey, it's Eric Newcomer. Welcome to the Newcomer podcast.
- 0:03This week I have Chris Lehane, A longtime Democratic operative,
- 0:08Spin Machine spin master, an SVP at Airbnb in charge of policy
- 0:14and communications, and now the Chief Strategy Officer at Han
- 0:18Ventures atop crypto firm. I had him on the episode to talk
- 0:21about the state of the crypto winter and specifically what's
- 0:23going on in Washington, where the regulatory environment is
- 0:27with crypto. We also had fun and dug into
- 0:31more theoretical stuff about how Democrats should be trying to
- 0:35regulate tech and even speculated a little bit about
- 0:38the Republican primary. Give it a list.
- 0:42Chris Lane, welcome to the podcast.
- 0:43Great to have you on. Thank you man.
- 0:45You know, we're doing this with a couple days left in summer and
- 0:49I'm hoping, at least professionally, this will be the
- 0:51highlight of my suburb. Cool.
- 0:52Well, we got to know each other while you were at Airbnb, and I
- 0:55might touch on that sort of later in the podcast, but you're
- 0:59deep in the crypto world and I haven't really caught up with
- 1:02you since. And I know we're overdue for our
- 1:05coffee. Yeah, exactly.
- 1:06So here we are. Everybody gets to sit in on it
- 1:08and obviously, you know, you have deep experience from Bill
- 1:12Clinton campaigns and White House experience and then sort
- 1:17of deep in tech policy world and deep still in sort of to what
- 1:22the Democrats are doing, though I imagine you're spending more
- 1:24time with Republicans also these days.
- 1:27Do you see yourself as talking to both sides of the aisle?
- 1:30I do at some level, although both it's because of where I
- 1:33have, you know, deep preexisting relationships and also because I
- 1:38think it's ultimately with the space needs if it wants to get
- 1:41regulatory clarity and certainty.
- 1:44You know, I do spend a disproportionate amount of my
- 1:46time on the Democratic side. That's where I come out of and
- 1:49you know, we can get into this a little bit more.
- 1:52But coming from Democratic politics, I was actually
- 1:53attracted to this space because of the small dedemocratizing.
- 1:57To pass the potential of the underlying technology.
- 2:01But the short answer to your question is, you know, when I
- 2:04transition from Airbnb over to the fund, which would have been
- 2:07March of last year, so 2022, you know, sort of felt like crypto
- 2:12as a political issue was what I would call prepartisan.
- 2:17Meaning it had really been yet to be defined one way or the
- 2:21other. Politically, neither D nor R On
- 2:25the natural, I think there was a.
- 2:27Particularly given how crypto had been developed, there's a
- 2:29bit of a libertarian element to it.
- 2:31It was fairly undefined. We just saw what 2 committees in
- 2:37the. House, I'm going to get to that.
- 2:39That's why I was taking this. That's why I was taking this.
- 2:41That's why I was taking this going back to that March, right.
- 2:43Thought the challenge is if you really want to have something
- 2:46passed, right, almost nothing gets passed in this day and age
- 2:50because of just the broader dysfunctionality that exists in
- 2:53our political system, in particular at the federal level.
- 2:56Amongst that the elements of drive that lack of functionality
- 2:59is it's a hyper person that right everything immediately
- 3:01becomes partisanized and that because really difficult you
- 3:04know when you have a Senate in the house they're both pretty
- 3:05closely divided or flip flopping every two years in terms of who
- 3:09controls what for anything to ultimately pass.
- 3:12And so I do think you know for this sector to ultimately get
- 3:15that regulatory clarity that it is seeking, it does need to get
- 3:20this issue at some level. To something that's closer to a
- 3:24bipartisan to be clear on that. Like, let's be really clear, you
- 3:27know, I am not necessarily suggesting, you know, that
- 3:30Elizabeth Warren's going to come out tomorrow and endorse right
- 3:33crypto. She was ringed like the worst by
- 3:35somebody, right? Crypto.
- 3:37But I do think what you saw, you know, from the vote that took
- 3:40place on the House Financial Services Committee and the AG
- 3:43Committee, and this was a vote that took place towards the end
- 3:45of July. For those who aren't following
- 3:47it that closely, there are two votes.
- 3:49There's a vote on stable coins and a vote on sort of an
- 3:51overarching cryptocurrency through legislative framework.
- 3:55And what you saw was, yes, you know, generally Republicans
- 3:59strongly supported it. But you did get a core group of
- 4:02Democrats who did support the legislation coming out of
- 4:07committee that sets up the potential.
- 4:10And I stressed the potential, not the, you know, you have to
- 4:12translate this into an actual real vote for there to be, you
- 4:16know, a decent number of Democrats.
- 4:18They're not going to be the majority of the Democrats and
- 4:20the House caucus, but enough Democrats who supported, you
- 4:24know, in a similar ratio as you saw in the House Financial
- 4:26Services vote. So it emerges from the House as
- 4:29not purely, you know, a Republican versus Democrat
- 4:34issue. And so that's the political
- 4:36reality I think of where you need to get this.
- 4:38There is sort of the Democratic strain of like, you know,
- 4:42Gillibrand I think is clearly pretty procrypto.
- 4:45And, like, you can imagine this sort of like, you know, the
- 4:48Democrats who had to support Wall Street or like, who
- 4:50defended industry or a core American competitiveness and so
- 4:54believe in business in some ways are like, friendlier.
- 4:59I think you have that, you know, and I had a lot more hair when I
- 5:02could say this, but you know, a Clinton Democrat, right, that
- 5:04you know, you would think of. And again, I'm not sure these
- 5:06terms really apply in the day and age that we speak in, but
- 5:10more of a sort of center, you know, business creates growth,
- 5:16business creates opportunities. How we think about our global
- 5:19competitiveness, you know, that type of a Democrat.
- 5:21But I also think more so if you look at the folks in the House
- 5:26and even on the Senate side who are Democrats who support this.
- 5:30It actually I think breaks down less along sort of the Clinton
- 5:34Democrat versus, you know, the current sort of, you know,
- 5:37progressive Democrat line and much more along generational
- 5:41lines. I mean, if you look at that
- 5:44vote. That took place in the House
- 5:46Financial Services Committee and even on the AG Committee,
- 5:48because the bill came through both of those committees, a
- 5:50little detailed here. The Democrats who vote for it,
- 5:54you know, by and large broke down not on ideological grounds
- 5:58within the Democratic Party, but more so on generational lines.
- 6:02And so you had, you know, Democrats who've been more
- 6:05recently elected to Congress, who are younger, who I think
- 6:08intuitively get the issue a little bit differently.
- 6:11We have the second oldest Congress, right?
- 6:14In the history of the Republic right now, right, which is the
- 6:17whole separate issue, we can get extrapolate out what you're
- 6:20saying, You know we have what one of the oldest president of
- 6:23all time and he's been pretty quiet on on these issues right
- 6:28though his SEC chairman has been very active.
- 6:30Yeah, we can certainly get that. You know, you obviously had well
- 6:33not maybe not obviously last March, April.
- 6:36I'm trying to remember the exact time period of 2022.
- 6:40You did have the by the administration issue an
- 6:42executive order. And that executive order both
- 6:45extolled the virtues potential of decentralized computing and
- 6:49the role that crypto currencies could play both in distributing
- 6:52economics but also in U.S. economic competitiveness and
- 6:55national security issues, but also called out the need for
- 6:58consumer protections and regulations to make sure that it
- 7:01was being managed responsibly. So they did put that out.
- 7:05Now I would also agree it has not been exactly an
- 7:08administration out there leading the charge on this, which I
- 7:12think has ceded ground. Where they're basically to be,
- 7:15this fight between the CFTC and the SEC, basically taking two
- 7:20completely contradictory perspectives.
- 7:22I say this as a Democrat who thinks that Joe Biden has by and
- 7:25large and a really good job and really difficult time period for
- 7:28our country. But we are almost 24 years into
- 7:32the 21st century and I think whether you're a Democrat or
- 7:35Republican, I think amongst the challenges our country is
- 7:38facing. Is, you know, we still are
- 7:40effectively operating under what I would call a new deal sort of
- 7:44paradigm or structure for government when, you know,
- 7:47society has changed a lot and in particular our economy has
- 7:50changed pretty dramatically. And how do we begin to sort of
- 7:54reimagine, you know, the role of government, particularly for
- 7:59someone who is a Democrat and does ultimately believe that the
- 8:02Democratic Party is at its best when it is standing for and
- 8:06growing a middle class? And how do we do that?
- 8:09You know, in a totally new type of economic context.
- 8:13And so when you talk about the age that we see, you know and
- 8:17I'll speak to Congress again, the 2nd oldest Congress in the
- 8:19history of the Republic. You know, if you get older and
- 8:22not like I say, this is someone who's in his mid 50s, right, How
- 8:24you reimagine the world and re envision the world.
- 8:27I mean there's all sorts of studies that just show that
- 8:29becomes harder the older that you get.
- 8:31And I think amongst the challenges that we face as a
- 8:33country is beginning to really rethink.
- 8:36What is that relationship between the national government,
- 8:38local government, state governments, you know,
- 8:40individual age? All right, well, to stay on the
- 8:42Democratic point, because I'm very interested in that, I want
- 8:45to sort of outline the crypto part of it here too.
- 8:48But you know, I work for the Obama campaign as.
- 8:52What you say that I'm open about it, I'm independent like that
- 8:55was, you know, I'm very clear, like I'm an opinionated reporter
- 8:58now, you know, I feel like the challenge is sort of like a
- 9:00Democrat and pro government sort of person.
- 9:04Is that the tech policy strategies often to move fast or
- 9:08like especially with Uber. I mean I think Airbnb to some
- 9:11degree and crypto it's like and not even necessarily with policy
- 9:14in mind. You know these businesses just
- 9:16want to grow fast so they establish a reality before
- 9:20there's a regulatory regime. And then Even so, someone like
- 9:24myself who believes in tech but also in regulation, then get
- 9:28sort of frustrated that the government, by the time they're
- 9:30coming, consumer behaviors already set and there's a
- 9:33certain fatalism to it. On the other hand, you don't
- 9:37really want government to act so quickly that people aren't even
- 9:41allowed to innovate, right? I mean, we're sort of seeing
- 9:44this question with a I right now where the Democrats have sort of
- 9:48learned this lesson over and over again and they're like, oh
- 9:50man, we actually need to jump really fast before anything
- 9:54forms because once it does, it's so hard to regulate.
- 9:57On that very broad point, I'm curious what you think, how the
- 10:00Democrats should respond to this problem of how quick to move?
- 10:05You're articulating a version of what I was just sort of alluding
- 10:08to, which is structurally how do we think about how government
- 10:14can appropriately intersect with the economy and specifically
- 10:18technology in post industrial age and in this, you know,
- 10:22digital world that we live in. And you know, I certainly do not
- 10:27believe that the structures that currently exist, and it's really
- 10:29easy to diagnose this. It's a lot harder to come up
- 10:31with the solutions. You know what?
- 10:33We're designed for a different age.
- 10:35I mean, you can take a big step back and I'll do a short version
- 10:37of this. But, you know, when our country
- 10:40was first formed, Alexis de Tocqueville does a great book on
- 10:45democracy in America and, you know, talks about this idea
- 10:47that, you know, at that time people just thought democracy
- 10:50was scary. They didn't think it was going
- 10:52to be able to succeed. In many ways, it's similar to
- 10:55how people talk about some of the technology that's emerging
- 10:57now. And you know his book.
- 11:00At least the first version of it, there are two versions of
- 11:02it. The first one's a little bit
- 11:03more optimistic than the second one.
- 11:04But the 1st edition, you know, talked about the fact that, you
- 11:07know, the US had basically created an entity that existed
- 11:11between sort of government and business, and that was civil
- 11:15society that almost served as like the regulator.
- 11:18If you think about an engine or controller, if you think about
- 11:21an engine for democracy to really work, you get to the
- 11:261930s, that Great Depression. Post World War One.
- 11:31And that begins to break down. Like civil society is not really
- 11:35serving the function in many respects because you've got this
- 11:38new industrial economy that's not the same as an agricultural
- 11:41age economy. And FDR steps in with a vision
- 11:45of a New Deal, which is a large government basically stepping in
- 11:48for what had been civil society. You know, as we stand here
- 11:52today, I mean, I remember I was, you know, as we've touched on
- 11:55working with Bill Clinton, President Clinton, why that was
- 11:58an awesome president. And he gave this famous speech,
- 12:00you know, the era of big government is over, but what
- 12:04comes next? Right.
- 12:06And I still don't think we have answered that question of what
- 12:10is our structure and vision for government that actually allows
- 12:15democracy to flourish and deliver for its people in this
- 12:20current economic age. And my short version, and I'm
- 12:23happy to go deeper on this, of where we need to get is I think
- 12:27for the last you know. 506070 years we've serve been operating
- 12:31under this paradigm of a public sector and a private sector and
- 12:34sometimes you get public private partnerships, right.
- 12:36That was the, you know, concept that you heard about.
- 12:39And I actually think we're going to need to design stuff that is
- 12:41a little bit more fully integrated.
- 12:44You know, something along the lines of you know, a common
- 12:47sector and what that common sector ultimately is able to do
- 12:51if done well. And by the way, this is a little
- 12:53bit of the vision that we had at Airbnb frankly, but what it is
- 12:57able to do well. Is exactly what you were just
- 13:00talking about, which is it allows innovation to happen, it
- 13:03allows it to happen quickly, but it also allows government and
- 13:07really by extension the public to have a much bigger voice and
- 13:11how that technology is evolving, being deployed and assuring that
- 13:14is actually. Optimizing for the broader good.
- 13:17Now that's really utopian, probably at some level.
- 13:20Why say I was worried that you'd been a crypto for a year now and
- 13:22you're going to be like it's defy.
- 13:24We need to like, put everything in the blockchain and we're
- 13:26going to solve it. No, no, no.
- 13:28But you know where I come in on this on on the crypto piece in
- 13:30particular is I think you know, right.
- 13:33We're going through some massive technological shifts.
- 13:36You've got crypto, you've got quantum, you've got enormous
- 13:39stuff happening. Biotech, obviously, AI and.
- 13:44Back to both points, I think both of us have made, like I
- 13:46don't feel particularly good about our government's ability
- 13:49to be able to effectively address us.
- 13:51And I remember back in the spring, I spent the day and 1/2
- 13:56in DC, the White House on the Hill, talking about some of
- 14:00these things with some friends and other folks.
- 14:03And you know, and the government's approach was very
- 14:07much looking through the rearview mirror.
- 14:10Here's what we missed with Quote UN quote Web 2.
- 14:13And so here's how we have to approach these next big
- 14:16technologies. And I came back to San Francisco
- 14:19and I was at a small conference where you had folks like Sam
- 14:23Alton from from Open A I. You had the woman from Berkeley
- 14:27who's in charge of the CRISPR project.
- 14:30You had someone talking about driverless cars.
- 14:32You had someone talking about crypto, and they were looking
- 14:36through the front window 10 years down the road, right?
- 14:39And there was no one sort of thinking about okay, where are
- 14:41we now and how do we? Get there And really no process
- 14:45or structure to do it and was just really struck by that and
- 14:49do think we ultimately are going to need some of these new
- 14:51structures in place. And by the way, like, it's
- 14:54really easy to say, as I said earlier, but really hard to do.
- 14:57I mean, you look at the history, right?
- 14:58Like we got the first version of our democracy only after a
- 15:02revolution, right. The New Deal came in place after
- 15:06a World War and the Great Depression.
- 15:09You know, typically you don't get these massive structural
- 15:11changes. Absent some real existential
- 15:13crisis, what's the phrase using common good?
- 15:16Common sector, Common sector. Is there an example entity or
- 15:20like how would you structure one?
- 15:22Or is this, I mean crypto I can think of like Oh well we should
- 15:26you know, have a crypt. Well, it's not really a company,
- 15:28but you could have a government controlled coin or something
- 15:31like that. Yeah, you could have.
- 15:32I mean you could think about dows and you know.
- 15:35The government's putting certain requirements around whether the
- 15:37house should include in his decision making could be an
- 15:41example of that on the crypto side, right?
- 15:42So it's not government doing it, but government building and
- 15:45sent. You can imagine, if you know, to
- 15:47get approved by, you know, a government, right, a government
- 15:51agency, whether it's a CFTSEC or a whole brand new agency, right,
- 15:55that you could build certain, the government could identify
- 15:57certain incentives, where the jobs take place, where the
- 15:59economics go, who participates in it, right.
- 16:02And those basically get built in to the Dow and even the coding
- 16:06that we go into the Dow as a way to think about the distribution
- 16:09of the economics and decisions. You could even imagine, you
- 16:12know, thinking about that from a sustainability climate
- 16:14perspective in terms of how some of the technology works.
- 16:16I think some early examples that you can maybe point to outside
- 16:21of crypto. By the way, this is amongst the
- 16:22reasons why I was attracted to crypto.
- 16:24Like, I think you know, the structure of crypto lends itself
- 16:26to supporting some version of a common sector.
- 16:30So I think the two examples and the first one I think people
- 16:33roll their eyes when I say, but bear with me a little bit you
- 16:35know was when then Facebook now meta you know, set up it's
- 16:39effectively its court system right now.
- 16:41I think of Facebook had done that proactively and not from a
- 16:45deep dark hole that they had put themselves in.
- 16:48They'd have gotten a lot more credit for it, right.
- 16:50But that was an example. And imagine taking that a step
- 16:53further, where. You know, does the FCC have some
- 16:56participatory role in that or some agents where there are
- 16:59legal standards? That right, that gets built into
- 17:02that right. But the Facebook is paying for
- 17:04it. Facebook is staffing it, but it
- 17:06has legitimacy and credibility and people have real
- 17:08transparency into what it's doing.
- 17:11And you know this is somewhat self-serving, but Airbnb amongst
- 17:14the things we ultimately got to was building in and providing
- 17:20local government cities. A PI's so that the city's pipes
- 17:24were built right into that Airbnb tech and so therefore
- 17:29cities had the ability to regulate and enforce their laws
- 17:33in real time right through the Airbnb platform itself, right.
- 17:38And so as you know from having covered Airbnb, one of the
- 17:41issues was what we have these laws.
- 17:42But. It's really difficult for the
- 17:44cities to enforce them. They can't, and Airbnb certainly
- 17:46use that to advantage. It's like we don't have to be
- 17:48cooperative, but we can be. That's right.
- 17:50And ultimately it served as a really powerful tool that
- 17:54there's no question that Airbnb building those API's made it
- 17:57more effective for cities to be able to enforce against Airbnb.
- 18:00And in almost all these situations, the company took a
- 18:03haircut. But the long term benefit of
- 18:07being in a positive, constructive relationship with
- 18:10the city ultimately, actually. Was a real driver of sustained
- 18:15longterm growth because you took teeth down, people had
- 18:18visibility, hosts were then able to come and sign on in a way
- 18:21that, you know, made it a lot easier, right, All of those
- 18:23things. So again, those are just two, I
- 18:26think, you know, maybe rudimentary or crude or early
- 18:29stage examples of what you could imagine.
- 18:32I mean, think about driverless cars and how this could all
- 18:34work, right? There is always some sort of
- 18:37industry wants to say, oh, we can self regulate and that will
- 18:41replace government and that is not new and can sometimes be a
- 18:43dodge and that's the critique obviously of Facebook.
- 18:48So do you have a quick response to that or I mean in some ways
- 18:51that's what you're proposing? Right, Facebook.
- 18:52An earlier version, Airbnb went a step further and actually
- 18:55allowed governments to be able to use the technology to make
- 18:57their enforcement better, right. I think a Facebook had gone
- 19:00proactively and built in that additional component.
- 19:03I was like feeding data. Yeah, that's definitely beyond
- 19:06that. You're helping the government
- 19:07actually do a better job. Of coming.
- 19:09Yes. And taking direct feedback from
- 19:11the government about how this can work better.
- 19:13OK. So crypto, I mean the broadest
- 19:16level. And you know, I'm not deep in it
- 19:18and I don't think, you know, many of our listeners even sort
- 19:20of in venture world, I feel like it's like, oh, it's sort of down
- 19:23there in a winner. Like we're paying attention to
- 19:24AI right now. So I think part of the goal with
- 19:26this episode is just like make sure those people sort of know
- 19:29what's going on. I mean on the broadest level,
- 19:33there's still this question of whether tokens are securities,
- 19:37right? And part of what's going on is
- 19:40that Gary Gensler at the SEC is going after Coinbase and Finance
- 19:46and as part of those cases sort of regulating through legal
- 19:50action to say that there are securities.
- 19:52And then on the flip side, you've got these, you know,
- 19:56bills coming through the House, the Republican controlled House
- 19:59that want to make. Crypto tokens regulated through
- 20:03the Commodities Futures Trading Board, right?
- 20:06Which is seen as. Is that there?
- 20:09Did I get the acronym? Yes, the FTC Commission, yes.
- 20:13Yeah. Yes, the.
- 20:15All legacies at the New Deal that we've already, I know, but
- 20:18yeah, well, we've already sort of alluded that it's going
- 20:20through the Agriculture committee, which is like as it's
- 20:23like always a good sign. Yeah.
- 20:25And so, you know, the crypto world seems to want to avoid
- 20:28especially this hostile SEC, move over the CFTC, and avoid
- 20:34being a security. You think that's a fair gloss of
- 20:36the situation? And what else would you add to
- 20:38that? Yeah.
- 20:38I mean, I think first of all, I think because of just the nature
- 20:41of the legislative process, it's, you know, effectively
- 20:44become, you know, a binary choice as it go to the CFTC or
- 20:48SECI think, you know, there's versions of this where some of
- 20:52it that goes does go to the SEC and some does go to the CFTC.
- 20:55So it's not like they all go to one or they all go to the other.
- 20:58Depending a little bit on the attributes of what the actual
- 21:00coin looks like, what I would emphasize though, just, you
- 21:04know, because we're trying to have, you know, make this
- 21:07conversation as interesting as possible, that's ultimately very
- 21:10much of A looking through the rearview mirror, right.
- 21:13Which is, I would argue that, you know, these tokens are
- 21:17neither a commodity nor a security, but something that is
- 21:22just really totally different and that, you know, if we really
- 21:25wanted to reimagine or reenvision.
- 21:27You know how the world could work or how this particular
- 21:29sector could work. You could be approaching this in
- 21:32a way that really looks to lever, optimize for the
- 21:35opportunity while really putting strong regulations in to help
- 21:40protect consumers. That's not where the
- 21:42conversation is. That's not reality, right.
- 21:44The reality is that this is going through, you know, a
- 21:47legislative process, and that legislative process is seeking
- 21:50to build on existing structures. For something that is just, you
- 21:56know, very different and very new.
- 21:57And so as a result of that reality, right, it is this whole
- 22:00debate about whether it is a commodity or security and what
- 22:04the current legislation does. Yes, most of it, it pushes into
- 22:07the commodities range, right? There will still be things that
- 22:09could have attributes where it ends up becoming a security.
- 22:12How bad is the current situation for crypto?
- 22:15I mean one name we haven't brought up that obviously is
- 22:18huge, especially in the democratic perception of this.
- 22:21Is Sam Bankman freed? Right.
- 22:23Sam Bankman freed. FTX was doing a lot of the heavy
- 22:27lifting for, you know, crypto with Democrats by sort of
- 22:30cozying up to them and sort of speaking to their values and all
- 22:34that. And then when FTX sort of proved
- 22:37to be what you know, which seems to be a sham, it's really
- 22:40embarrassing for those electives and teaches them sort of a very
- 22:44negative lesson about crypto. Yeah, I mean I was going to say
- 22:47earlier when we're talking about the pre partisan to the
- 22:49bipartisan, I thought the space was actually on a pretty good
- 22:51path as reflected in the Biden executive order.
- 22:55And at the FTXSBF explosion, however you want to describe it,
- 22:58the Baco Royale, you know, has, you know, with a huge impact on
- 23:02that, a huge impact on the ability to get this to a
- 23:05bipartisan place and, you know, a huge impact on momentum for
- 23:10regulations. It unleashed the skeptics and
- 23:13the cynics to be even, you know, more forceful in their
- 23:16skepticism and cynicism. And you know, if you came at the
- 23:19space with questions and skepticism, right?
- 23:21That was certainly a pretty powerful.
- 23:23Proof point for you and so somewhat understandable for
- 23:26those who are genuinely coming at this with integrity and
- 23:29questioning it. I think there are some others
- 23:31who are just you know, trying to jump on the issue.
- 23:33But yeah, no, it had a huge a huge impact both on the timeline
- 23:37and you know and how people perceive it.
- 23:39And that's you know, that's a hole that ultimately the sector
- 23:42needs to be able to dig out. Now you're asking a better
- 23:45question of where things are in crypto right now or Web Three
- 23:48depending how you wanted to find it.
- 23:49I think about it is. Decentralized computing, But I
- 23:52think first of all this is a space that has gone in cycles
- 23:55and you've heard a little bit about this.
- 23:57But for those who haven't, there's crypto winters, crypto
- 24:01summer, sometimes crypto springs and crypto falls and that has
- 24:04really been the history of this sector.
- 24:08And there is a specific reason for that, which I think is
- 24:12different maybe than some other technological errors which is
- 24:16crypto basically emerged. All at once as sort of like a
- 24:20technological sector, whereas in the past for the most part as
- 24:26new technology has evolved and come out, it's typically been
- 24:30much more sequential, right? Like, I go back to the early 90s
- 24:36and you know, network computing, you know, which had been a goal
- 24:41since the end of World War 2, but there had never been the
- 24:45technology to allow for protocols.
- 24:48To allow for, you know a computer in San Francisco to
- 24:51talk to computer in New York and do it in a safe and secure way,
- 24:55right. You got HTTP, you got other
- 24:56protocols that came out and really made that happen.
- 24:59But imagine if like suddenly the Internet had shown up and there
- 25:03was cats, videos and porn stuff and all of that happening and it
- 25:07was available to everyone at the same time.
- 25:09And you know, and that's a little bit you know that the
- 25:11opportunity and challenge on the crypto side and amongst the
- 25:14reasons why. You get a little bit of this of
- 25:17the cycles I would offer that sort of crypto is set up in a
- 25:20way to front load the financial reward and now that sometimes
- 25:25viewed as a feature and. A challenge, right?
- 25:27It's like two sides, no pun intended.
- 25:28Two sides of the Bitcoin, I guess or you know, pick your
- 25:31currency. You also have had it sort of
- 25:34emerge, you know, in a time period where as you know, having
- 25:38covered the tech spacing of money was effectively free right
- 25:42when it's different today than it was, you know.
- 25:45March of 2022. And you know, and so this
- 25:48particular cycle, you know, you get crypto, you saw the whole
- 25:51tech cycle go up and then go down.
- 25:54Crypto is probably the sort of frothiest, the end of that tail,
- 25:57right. So it in particular has been
- 25:59impacted by that swing. The one thing I would, I guess
- 26:02two things I would really just focus on is every time it's had
- 26:05these cycles, the water line gets higher and higher, right.
- 26:09So today, you know, more than one in five Americans hold.
- 26:13Cryptocurrency, you know, there's 400 million, more than
- 26:16400 million people around the world, you know, who hold a
- 26:19digital currency, right? That's a significant.
- 26:22I've never had. I'm an amateur.
- 26:24I like to fashion myself. Eric, as an amateur historian,
- 26:26I'm not sure whether I rise to that level or not.
- 26:28But you've never had in, you know, in human history,
- 26:32currencies created at scale that do not involve A sovereign
- 26:37entity or the government, right. From a societal, historic
- 26:39perspective, it's an amazing thing to think that you've
- 26:41actually created currencies. They're based on mathematical
- 26:46formulas that drive people to people trust over those
- 26:48currencies. The other thing I would just
- 26:51point out is the rest of the world is in a really different
- 26:54place than the US. You basically look at every
- 26:58major financial capital or aspiring financial capital in
- 27:03the world and they're all moving way ahead of the US to embrace
- 27:08the technology, whether it's the UK.
- 27:11You know, having even this week, I think there's some additional
- 27:13activity happening there where they're, you know, putting in
- 27:16place a pretty robust regulatory framework that does address
- 27:20consumer issues, but also is designed because they want
- 27:24London to be a center of this Abu Dhabi, Dubai, Brazil,
- 27:28Singapore, the EUI. Mean these are all places,
- 27:33Australia, Japan that have moved well ahead of the US on putting.
- 27:39The regulations in place with an understanding that you know
- 27:44crypto is going to be a significant part, you know of
- 27:47the financial world as we move forward and wanting to make sure
- 27:52and in many respects they took lessons from the 90s from the US
- 27:56that the US currently hasn't applied to itself right which is
- 28:00US 96 and I was part of this put in the.
- 28:02Telco act like that set the US to become the center of the
- 28:05digital economy, right? The rest of those places missed
- 28:08that are a lot of them missed it and you know, they are seeing
- 28:11that this is going to be a big part of the future and wanting
- 28:13to make sure they have a piece of it.
- 28:15What's the sort of worst case scenario here for crypto?
- 28:18I mean, it's crazy to me that Coinbase is allowed to go public
- 28:23and then the government says actually, even though the SEC
- 28:26approved it, we can now sue you for your core business violating
- 28:31SEC. Rules on the business That
- 28:33hasn't changed all since it was approved, right?
- 28:35Right. I mean there's nothing different
- 28:37today from ploy based and was in there S1.
- 28:39You know the document that they show that needs to be reviewed.
- 28:42The government sort of argument is that they should be allowed
- 28:46to take all the legal time. They have to sort of come to a
- 28:49view, I don't know. Yeah, right.
- 28:51But you look at the mission statement and purpose of the
- 28:54SEC, right? They're supposed to.
- 28:57Be there to help protect consumers, you know, they
- 28:59allowed or they at least reviewed and then you know, as
- 29:02one went forward and you know those shares are offered to the
- 29:06public and nothing has changed, you know, since then.
- 29:09Also amongst the SE C's mission and purpose is to help support
- 29:14an economy where more people are able to participate in the
- 29:18economics of our country, you know and today. 10% of the
- 29:22country owns 90% of the web. Like if I was the SEC and you
- 29:26really want to take some big swings at things like I would
- 29:28focus more on that. Then, you know, a technology
- 29:32that was allowed to go forward and where nothing has changed
- 29:37and the technology that ultimately is actually trying to
- 29:38update the financial system to make it more fair.
- 29:43I find it very hard to believe that like Bitcoin or like
- 29:46Ethereum or that they're going to be like illegal in the United
- 29:49States, right? Well you obviously have a court
- 29:50rule right as a District Court but you know from the Southern
- 29:53District of New York and you know and that well respected
- 29:56Obama appointed judge who has made me a points that were
- 30:00adjacent to what you were just saying.
- 30:02Right. In terms of being particularly
- 30:04on the security commodities issue and just given the scale
- 30:07of people and. That work found it was a
- 30:10commodity. Right, Yeah, right.
- 30:11But you had mentioned something earlier that I think is relevant
- 30:13to this, which is amongst the challenges the government faces,
- 30:17particularly at the federal level is that you get consumer
- 30:19adoption of a new technology and then the government has a
- 30:22challenge of how they keep. I mean, you know this is an
- 30:24example of that, right? You live in a time period where
- 30:2780% of the country does not believe the financial system
- 30:30works for them. You look the folks who own
- 30:34digital assets, you know it over indexes.
- 30:38On cohorts of the population that in particular have been
- 30:42impacted by a financial system that doesn't work for them,
- 30:46right, younger people, people of color, people who make less than
- 30:50$100,000. And one of the things that I
- 30:53thought was really interesting is the fact that over 60% of the
- 30:57folks this is from data from a year ago.
- 30:59So it may have evolved a little bit, but directionally I think
- 31:02it's pretty powerful. Which is, you know, over 60% of
- 31:05the people who own digital assets voted for Joe Biden for
- 31:07president. It tells you a little about who
- 31:09they are and you know what their values and politics are, right?
- 31:14I get the strategy of like do what your constituents want or
- 31:17like they have crypto, so vote for them.
- 31:20I mean, the crypto industry at its core, just like hasn't
- 31:23delivered a great case study for why people should cheer for it
- 31:29yet. I mean, I'm sure you're going to
- 31:30come up with a couple, but there have been so many frauds.
- 31:34There's so much financial speculation.
- 31:36I feel like part of the reason for the delay on the side of the
- 31:41government is just like, oh, well, maybe we should give it
- 31:43time to see if anything really good does come out of it.
- 31:47And then that's why stuff like FTX is so hard for crypto,
- 31:51because it's like, oh man, this was sort of one of the things
- 31:54you were holding up. What's worth saving?
- 31:56Yeah, I think the fact that you have.
- 31:58You know, more than 400 million people around the world, 50 +
- 32:001,000,000 in this country, you know, does speak to the fact, I
- 32:03mean consumers do get the vote with their wallet at some level,
- 32:06right, and with their feet at some level.
- 32:08And you know, even the polling I've done in this country and
- 32:11stuff that we've seen from around the world like amongst
- 32:14the reasons folks are buying it is because they are using things
- 32:18like stable coin as a hedge against inflation.
- 32:21You see that globally, right? You see people wanting to use
- 32:24it. You know, we looked at voters in
- 32:26Ohio and Pennsylvania. And you know, over 40% of the
- 32:30folks who own digital assets said they bought them because
- 32:33they wanted to help them be able to do remittances, right?
- 32:35These are immigrant families who are sending money back to real
- 32:38relatives and family members in different parts of the world
- 32:41where they're able to do a lot quicker for a lot less.
- 32:44Those are still just early versions and, you know, and
- 32:47examples. But I do think when you get
- 32:49people at that scale using it right, they're obviously finding
- 32:52some utility and they're using it despite the fact that it's
- 32:56very janky. Very hard to use, right?
- 32:59It's not easy. It's really complicated.
- 33:02And these are not engineers who are using it, right.
- 33:04They're figuring out how to use it because they're so
- 33:06dissatisfied with what the current option is for them.
- 33:10Now, everything you said, I just want to be clear, like
- 33:11everything that you said about the scams, about the utility,
- 33:15Yeah, that's amongst the challenges.
- 33:16It comes back to a little bit of, I mean, if the Internet had
- 33:19just emerged and all people knew it was that it was being used
- 33:21for cat videos and pornography, like.
- 33:24And I do remember 2001. Afterthe.com bomb Like major
- 33:28articles and major publications like the New York Times.
- 33:31I'm doing this off the top of my head, so don't hold me this
- 33:33exact title, but the Internet is dead, right?
- 33:36Right. You know, a I was, you know,
- 33:38initially really pushed in the late 1960s.
- 33:42And then people said why you can't actually use, you know,
- 33:44great algorithms that can replicate neural networks and
- 33:47then all of a sudden, you know, chat G, PT3 or 3.5, you know
- 33:52emerges and suddenly. You know, the world shifts in a
- 33:55pretty significant way, I think. You know, crypto has created a
- 33:59high challenge for itself. Maybe it's a high class
- 34:01challenge, which is it's all happened at the same time.
- 34:04I will say as someone who's at a fund and you know looking at the
- 34:07projects out there, you know that there's a lot of really
- 34:10interesting stuff going on. And at the early stage that
- 34:13really is looking at that infrastructure for what you call
- 34:16level to the sort of the app, conventional language app level.
- 34:20You know, that then ultimately translates into a lot more
- 34:23utility. But I want to be clear, I do
- 34:25think that you are hitting on something that is a core
- 34:27challenge for the space. How do you demonstrate utility
- 34:31for why this should matter to the world so that policymakers
- 34:35care about it, right. That's I think ultimately what
- 34:37you're getting, why the public, you know, more broadly cares
- 34:39about it. I do think the public is ahead
- 34:41of the policymakers on this, which is typically the case,
- 34:44because you wouldn't have that level of engagement unless
- 34:46people are finding real value for it.
- 34:48And seen it as a solution. Are there pieces of crypto web
- 34:53three that Han ventures won't invest in because of policy
- 34:59concerns? Or how much are you letting sort
- 35:03of your policy expertise influence your investing
- 35:07decisions? It's a great question.
- 35:08So we do both an accelerator fund, right and then that an
- 35:11early stage fund and we have a rubric that we use for you know
- 35:17when we make a decision. To invest and one of the key
- 35:21elements or criteria in that rubric is that the founder does,
- 35:25the company does, the leadership team does a project.
- 35:28Understand that you know policy is going to be a very important
- 35:32issue. They don't necessarily have to
- 35:33have all the answers, right because some of this technology
- 35:36is so forward-looking. It's difficult to sit there.
- 35:39You're with a a founding team of three or four to be able to
- 35:42answer where they're going to be in two years, but they have to
- 35:44understand that they are going to need.
- 35:48To manage for that and build with that in mind and if we do
- 35:52not feel comfortable that they don't have an appreciation for
- 35:57that, then that is certainly a criteria that would block us
- 36:01from making an investment. And without naming names because
- 36:05I know you'll ask me that if I for the following sentence, we
- 36:09have made a number of decisions where we did not invest because
- 36:14we were ultimately concerned about.
- 36:16Sensitivity and understanding that these are issues that need
- 36:18to be navigated and done in appropriate ways.
- 36:20Well yeah, because there's certainly a strain of crypto
- 36:22person who's like anti government regulate.
- 36:25So it's not. As I mean Katie Han, right,
- 36:27Katie is the founder of this fund, right.
- 36:29As you know she was a long time, very high profile prosecutor to
- 36:33the Justice Department and she joined Coinbase, you know as a
- 36:37board member early on. And look, I think you know a
- 36:41very receptive founder and Brian Armstrong an executive team.
- 36:46But certainly was a major voice about the fact that you know,
- 36:49Coinbase should work within the legal system even if that meant
- 36:54it was going to impact, you know, its overall shortterm
- 36:58growth and you know you stand here today.
- 37:00Yes, Coinbase is in litigation with the SEC, but it it
- 37:04certainly is a company that went through the public process,
- 37:06certainly a company that seeks to work within the regulatory
- 37:10framework, you know, particularly when it's
- 37:11understandable. You know just even I think in
- 37:14the last couple weeks has gotten you know approvals for some
- 37:18initiatives you know through that process and I think is
- 37:21positioned for long term growth because it made that decision
- 37:24early on to work within the system and in fact I think is
- 37:27understood to be in that position.
- 37:29What's the state of actual venture funds like risk exposure
- 37:35for the like, you know, particularly I guess token
- 37:38purchases, right. I mean there have been looks at,
- 37:41yeah, firms investing in, I guess I'm going to blur the
- 37:46boundaries here like Icos and tokens and then in some cases
- 37:50sort of selling out, I don't know, Do you think that is sort
- 37:54of safe? Are you still investing those
- 37:56types of things? What's your view on?
- 37:58That so we're not a hedge fund, let's be clear about that and I
- 38:01know you know that, but just in case anyone's out there, you
- 38:03know we are a venture fund and you know our Lps understand.
- 38:08That we're investing for the long term.
- 38:11And I'll get even more specifically to your token
- 38:13question in a second, but just as a little background, you know
- 38:16we raised our fund in March of 2022 in the midst of, you know
- 38:22the market going from that suburb into a winter, right?
- 38:25Right in the roots of that correction, it's like 1.5
- 38:27billion or? Something 1.5, right, But we're
- 38:29raising that in the midst of a volatile market and the team,
- 38:33you know, led by Katie, really called out when we're doing, you
- 38:37know. Those sessions with prospective
- 38:39Lps that we thought we were going to be entering a winter,
- 38:43that this was going to be a longterm process and that you
- 38:47know venture, you know by definition means that there's
- 38:50going to be an element risk. But obviously we built in a
- 38:54bunch of systems to make sure that we were optimizing for that
- 38:58longterm return. But we are very straightforward
- 39:00with folks and also made really clear and I think this is an
- 39:03important point. That we were going to approach
- 39:06our investments knowing the time period that we're about to go
- 39:08into with real prudence. To take some what you're saying,
- 39:12we're a venture fund. I think people take two things.
- 39:15You're saying, OK, we're long term oriented.
- 39:17Some people would say, oh we're a venture fund.
- 39:19We only invest in equity. You know we invest in companies,
- 39:22maybe they do a token offering, maybe they don't.
- 39:25That's part of their business. We invest in the equity.
- 39:27I take from your answer and just actually knowing the firm,
- 39:30obviously do also invest, Oh yeah, in tokens directly often
- 39:35when you see those supporting the company as you were just
- 39:37saying, yeah, but I think there's just trying.
- 39:38To support the ecosystem because tokens, unlike equity you know
- 39:42like the rest of crypto, are not well regulated.
- 39:45It exposes the venture fund itself to some of these same
- 39:48legal risks that the companies face like how do you guys
- 39:51navigate that or what's your. Yeah, I think, you know, we risk
- 39:54at the moment. It helps to have Katie over here
- 39:57as someone who you know has A been involved with the space
- 39:59from the really beginning. B obviously is extremely
- 40:03sophisticated. On how government agencies think
- 40:06about these things and see we're able to take you know that
- 40:09information and be able to you know to the public and private
- 40:12tokens in a way that you know we know is really certainly have
- 40:16the all reason to believe is as responsible as anyone could be.
- 40:19It was part of our value proposition.
- 40:21You know I think frankly for those LP's you know who looked
- 40:24around and you know look as things turned out, we've touched
- 40:26on this with FTX and some others you know has you know people
- 40:30right to be sensitive to some of the folks who are in the space.
- 40:33And you know part of our value proposition is that we're going
- 40:36to take a a very responsible approach in terms of how we
- 40:39deploy our capital and how we think about this regulatory
- 40:42policy issues in that context. I mean how do you think you know
- 40:46Solana, which is you know, a currency was a case where it
- 40:50seemed like a lot of venture funds sort of got early access,
- 40:55the price drives up, you know? They cash out at some point and
- 40:58eventually the price falls like I don't know, like do you, I
- 41:03mean then they're very different examples where like there are
- 41:06companies that have valuable tokens that never produce sort
- 41:10of the underlying thing and at some point firms decide they
- 41:14don't believe in the value anymore.
- 41:15So they sell out like, I mean I'll just say that you know
- 41:20there is a pump and dump type accusation to certain crypto
- 41:23projects. Yeah, I don't know.
- 41:25What's your view on those? Actually, I think it relates
- 41:27back to one of your earlier questions about, you know, how
- 41:31elected officials and governments think about this.
- 41:33I mean, as a Democrat, it strikes me as interesting.
- 41:35The Democrats are not necessarily leading on actual
- 41:38putting it in place like regulations from a legislative
- 41:41perspective to actually build all these consumer protections
- 41:44in. Because I do think the whole
- 41:46space would be better off if we are building in those types of
- 41:50consumer protection. Sure, we have a fund, you know,
- 41:54apply our own, you know, that effectively is seeking to make
- 41:57sure we're protecting and doing it in a responsible, smart way.
- 42:01But the whole space would be better off and you would avoid
- 42:04and mitigate, you know, future FT X's or future pump and dump
- 42:10schemes as you've described it. You know, if they're really
- 42:13clear lines out there about what you know, what you don't know,
- 42:16Like, I actually think that there's incredibly powerful ways
- 42:20for tokens to serve as a much more small deed democratizing
- 42:24distributive economic tool. You know, if you're someone out
- 42:28there who's participating in a chain, you know, and you get
- 42:31tokens in return for being a validator on that, or you get
- 42:35tokens in return for building a really interesting project on
- 42:38that, right, you're getting the direct economics for your IP
- 42:43right for your work. You know, imagine a world where
- 42:47you know people are able to actually really own a piece of
- 42:50what their actual labor produces.
- 42:52That's just a completely different way of thinking about
- 42:55the relationship between management and labor and I think
- 42:58these tokens really. And so this is a long winded and
- 43:01you can see I'm thinking aspirationally, but this amongst
- 43:03the reasons I get excited for this space that like if
- 43:05government starts to think about it that way, right.
- 43:07There's ways for government to build in all the consumer
- 43:10protections, building incentives as we've touched it on, but also
- 43:13begin to reward people. I mean, you know, I think you
- 43:16know this story, but I remember, you know, Airbnb, you're two out
- 43:21from going public. You know, I think it was from me
- 43:23actually. We sent a letter to the SEC and
- 43:25I remember doing meetings there where we asked whether we could
- 43:29make equity available to our host in advance of going public.
- 43:34You know, and we're told, you know, because the rule, I think
- 43:36it's 500, you know, where once you're over a certain number of
- 43:39people who have equity is considered a security that we
- 43:41couldn't do it. And I had countless meetings
- 43:43where I would make the argument that look at, you know, our host
- 43:45particularly a core subset of them, you know, are
- 43:49disproportionately responsible for the generation of the wealth
- 43:52is going to take place here. And you know SEC, you know,
- 43:56refused to even really engage I think in a in a conversation
- 44:00with a seriousness of purpose around it other than just
- 44:03putting into that, you know their their rule and how we test
- 44:06and you know these various things that exist for the 1930s.
- 44:09You know, long before there was any type of an economic model
- 44:11like a sharing economy model, Airbnb goes public.
- 44:15You know it goes up to 100 billion that day.
- 44:17You remember the number, you know that that day you had a
- 44:20bunch of banks that really put, you know relatively very little
- 44:24at risk, you know, who end up making a bunch of money on that
- 44:28right. And why should that be the case?
- 44:30Why can't we come up with a better system?
- 44:33Why couldn't those hosts have been able to participate in the
- 44:36upside that they were responsible for helping to
- 44:39create and generate? And so I just use that as, you
- 44:42know, crypto actually can help that.
- 44:44It's actually an underlying technology that can make that
- 44:46possible, and the tokens play that role.
- 44:49But to really get that you would need government to really begin
- 44:52to think about this and imagine ways that you could distribute
- 44:56economics in a fundamentally different way.
- 44:58And as I say all that, I want to be clear, like I think that
- 45:00there's going to be a spectrum of this activity.
- 45:02I mean look at there are some people and I'm big believers in
- 45:04them, you know, who believe you know, 5-10, fifteen, 20 years
- 45:07from now, like the entire world in the economy is going to be,
- 45:10you know, a crypto based economy.
- 45:12There are others who think it's going to happen in a couple
- 45:14narrow places. I tend to be somewhere in the
- 45:16middle, like there's I think going to be a spectrum of stuff.
- 45:18There'll be some spaces that lend itself to this so that
- 45:21people can participate more and there'll be somewhere, you know,
- 45:24if they will benefit from being a just a little bit less
- 45:26centralized. I mean, one response to what
- 45:33you're saying is that there are laws about like sort of, you
- 45:38know, scams, confidence schemes and stuff and like why do you
- 45:44need a particular 1 to ferret at them out on crypto?
- 45:47You know, it's sort of like crypto creates this level of
- 45:50like, it complexifies everything, You know, it makes
- 45:55it so. It makes it like, I mean.
- 45:57You're talking about sort of validators, right?
- 46:00Getting tokens? You're sort of like lending your
- 46:02brain or someone building a project, right?
- 46:05This idea that a brand validator is, you know, it's just
- 46:09promotion for a token sort of going up in some way by lending
- 46:13your brand to it? Yeah, I mean, look, if there
- 46:16people have different views about brand validators, right?
- 46:18Should you be able to participate in the economics or
- 46:20something that you're lending your name to?
- 46:21Could you change the advertising model out there?
- 46:23I mean, yeah, we could take this any number of ways.
- 46:27To me it's a little bit less like, yeah, if you put really
- 46:30strict, you know, there's strict guidelines around what you can
- 46:32and cannot, you know, as a brand validator, right.
- 46:35And you know, you didn't have that for FDX, right.
- 46:37And so I think building that in. But I also think that's a little
- 46:39bit of sort of and I know this is not really directed at you,
- 46:42but it's missing the broader piece here, which is in the
- 46:44absence of regulations, you are not being able to take advantage
- 46:49of something that could have a pretty significant impact, you
- 46:54know, on our financial system and the economics and how they
- 46:58are distributed. You know, I mean I've written
- 47:00this, but you know, if you look at the underlying technology of
- 47:04blockchain, it's inherently progressive technology, right,
- 47:09Redistributes economics. So it goes to the people whose
- 47:11labor are responsible for it. It's decentralized, meaning
- 47:15there is not one centralized authoritarian entity that is
- 47:19driving it. It requires community engagement
- 47:24to make decisions. I mean if you sort of look at
- 47:27the progress it. Rewards capital values.
- 47:31I will say the other piece of it is like early money in sort of
- 47:35tends to get multiplied when things are going well.
- 47:39I mean World Coin is like a fascinating example where it's
- 47:41like okay, we're gonna sort of assign money to a person.
- 47:45Yeah, I mean, it's all sort of how it's.
- 47:48Yeah. I mean, look, here's a really
- 47:49simple version of it to think about.
- 47:51And I use this one sometimes, you know, with elected
- 47:53officials, just because I think it brings it home and makes it
- 47:55really easy. We've talked about some other
- 47:56examples, you know, remittances. I think it is an obvious one.
- 48:00But just think about how art works, right, which is, you
- 48:04know, an artist does a painting. I'm just going to make up
- 48:07numbers here. You know, they sell it to a
- 48:10gallery for $1000, like a local gallery.
- 48:13That local gallery then sells it to a bear gallery, maybe for
- 48:16$10,000. You know, maybe eventually that
- 48:19art really takes on, you know, significant value.
- 48:22Maybe you actually have an art house that corners the market on
- 48:25this particular artist and creates an artificial supply and
- 48:29demand, you know, dynamic, but that artist doesn't have, you
- 48:32know, a retained interest in that piece of work.
- 48:36And then take that example and apply it to all other, you know,
- 48:39could be writing, right. Could be books.
- 48:41It could be even, you know, and this is pretty farfetched.
- 48:44But since we're having, you know this conversation, imagine if
- 48:47you're someone who's a Carpenter and you're working on a house.
- 48:49You could get paid a salary, but maybe you also get to retain an
- 48:51interest in that house or you make it sold, you get to
- 48:54participate. I got these are fairly
- 48:55farfetched and and there's a lot between now and you know some of
- 48:59those examples for it to happen. But this does create that a way
- 49:03to sort of re envision how you think about this in the same
- 49:06way, right, When you move from an agricultural age into
- 49:09industrial age, how economic, even getting from required a
- 49:12complete re envisioning of how money and currency would work
- 49:16and where the economy would work.
- 49:19Yeah, I mean, I feel like. On the intuition or on sort of
- 49:21the thought experiment level, crypto does great.
- 49:23I mean, I love the idea and this is the challenge, right?
- 49:25You could do the thought experiments, you could do all
- 49:27these great tokens. I think some of the lesson is
- 49:29like. You still need great
- 49:31institutions around them. You know what I mean?
- 49:33It's like I think you need to create trust around, right,
- 49:36exactly right and look at the. Space, you know, it's
- 49:39interesting because there's such an engineering culture to it.
- 49:41Like they end up using lexicon that maybe is not doesn't
- 49:46necessarily work as well for the general public.
- 49:48Like crypto itself is a scary name.
- 49:50Trustless, even though it's actually being used in a
- 49:52positive way where you're not relying on a centralized
- 49:54authority. For a normal person like
- 49:57trustless doesn't sound like a great idea, right?
- 50:00And so you know some of the language and even lexicon around
- 50:02us because it comes from such a deep engineering, you know,
- 50:06mathematical type of background. You know this is a, you know, a
- 50:10tech within crypto that's being developed right now.
- 50:12Zero knowledge proofs, which I actually think is a potentially
- 50:16game changer in terms of that utility cases.
- 50:19But even in the name like 0 knowledge proof, that doesn't
- 50:21sound like a great thing when in fact but it really is actually
- 50:25helping the resolve the age-old conflict that has existed
- 50:28between can you have privacy and can you have security?
- 50:30Can you have privacy? Can you have identity zero
- 50:33Knowledge proofs actually solve for that.
- 50:35But that's not what the name is, right?
- 50:36And some people hear that initially and it causes
- 50:39concerns. Changing gears The Republican.
- 50:41Primary and I guess the Democratic primary such that it
- 50:44exists. I don't know any stakes for
- 50:47crypto specifically. And then just given your
- 50:50experience, any hot takes more broadly?
- 50:54Yeah, I think there is. I mean, stake, no pun intended,
- 50:56obviously. Like I think my belief is
- 50:59someone who spent a lot of time in government, politics and
- 51:01policy is that, you know, in democracies, politics drives
- 51:06legislation. Legislation ultimately impacts
- 51:10regulations. How does regulations are
- 51:12interpreted, you know, becomes, you know, how the legal process
- 51:16works. It all begins foundationally.
- 51:18If you think about that as a pyramid with politics, and I
- 51:24think it's going to be a real challenge, I always am an
- 51:25optimist and believe that cup is 1/4 full or half full.
- 51:30That will get legislation done this year.
- 51:32But it's hard, right? It's hard to get anything
- 51:34passed. It's hard to get anything passed
- 51:35in an election year, hard to get something passed that's as
- 51:38complex as you know as crypto, right?
- 51:40So while optimistic, I am looking beyond the 2024
- 51:45election. And where I'm going with this is
- 51:48in a world where, at least in this country, where there are
- 51:51more people who own crypto than hold a union card, and I'm all
- 51:55for the people having more people having union cards
- 51:57tomorrow than have them today. So.
- 51:59But there are more people who own crypto than on the union
- 52:01card. Who those people are, you know,
- 52:04disproportionately young, disproportionate people of
- 52:07color, the crypto digital asset. How the people hold digital
- 52:11assets in this country could be an incredibly interesting voter
- 52:16cohort if they begin to understand and actually vote at
- 52:21some level or cryptos amongst the issues they care about as
- 52:25they listen to these candidates. And you think of a place like
- 52:28Georgia, you can make the argument of Georgia, maybe
- 52:31Arizona are the two most important states to determine
- 52:34who the next president is going to be.
- 52:36There's a subset of about five of these states.
- 52:38But let's look at Georgia. I mean Georgia is a place where
- 52:41you know that one in five, you know, voters across the country
- 52:43actually over indexes even more in a place like Georgia.
- 52:47And if the presidential candidates from both parties
- 52:50begin to understand that there are voters out there who are in
- 52:52fact crypto voters who will vote one way or the other, or at
- 52:56least their decision making will be impacted one way or the other
- 52:59by where a candidate is on crypto.
- 53:02If the sector space is able to do that in the context of the
- 53:062024 election, I do think that has a huge impact on where the
- 53:12pulse he goes. I got politics drives policy
- 53:14right. If both parties emerge from 2024
- 53:18knowing that there's a crypto voter out there who matters and
- 53:21who will respond to what they're doing on issues, then suddenly I
- 53:25think crypto ends up being in a different place when it comes to
- 53:28how the legislation and regulations will play them.
- 53:31So it's outgoing. It's sort of the classic type of
- 53:33issue where. No politician is like defining
- 53:36their political principles and identity around being anti
- 53:41crypto. Like they didn't.
- 53:42Most of them really care one way or the other right now.
- 53:44So. So if suddenly there's like you.
- 53:45Know a vocal minority that really cares about it.
- 53:49It's a very swayable issue. On the other hand, like.
- 53:54Do I mean I get people want their coins to go up in value
- 53:57but you know are people that emotional about their like
- 54:01crypto holding. It's also and I'm sure you deal
- 54:03with this a lot. Unfortunately for crypto a very
- 54:06anti sort of or at least the origins of it were sort of anti
- 54:09government which means often can mean anti government involvement
- 54:14so that it's like it's a hard crowd to get to go.
- 54:17I think their legislator yeah. So I think let's break.
- 54:19That down a little bit. I think you're right.
- 54:21Like I think where this emerged or and we talked about this at
- 54:23the very beginning like a libertarian you know element to
- 54:25it that said is that we've talked about you know the
- 54:28majority of the people who hold crypto voted for bite.
- 54:31And again younger people of color.
- 54:33And if you think that there's roughly 5760 million people who
- 54:36hold crypto in the US. If 5% of those people engage
- 54:41politically on it, that still represents one of the biggest
- 54:44political constituencies out there.
- 54:47And I mean you're very adroit in terms of your observation that
- 54:52like if it's a vocal minority of 2345 million people on an issue
- 54:56where politicians don't have a strong view one way or the other
- 55:01and all they're being really asked to do with the past
- 55:03regulations to help protect consumers and for a politician
- 55:06that. That's a pretty easy place to go
- 55:08to now. Can the sector, can the
- 55:10industry, do these people get excited?
- 55:12Do they get enthused about this? And I think that's, you know,
- 55:14that's what needs to happen between now and Election Day in
- 55:17November 2024. And if the space can do that,
- 55:20then I think it puts itself in a different position.
- 55:23Do you have a view on Vivek if you I?
- 55:24Mean is tech aligned or have you guys talked?
- 55:27Well, I mean, yeah, yeah, I'm still a hardcore, deep blue
- 55:32Democrat. I do think that, you know, the
- 55:35generational aspect is interesting.
- 55:36I mean, you know, as someone who's been in politics, right,
- 55:39You know, he has an interesting cohort that he can appeal to.
- 55:41I do wonder, you know, how much can you grow, you know, beyond
- 55:46that, even within a Republican field?
- 55:48I thought I want to be clear I disagreed substantively with
- 55:52virtually everything that he said and and you know have very
- 55:55strong views on some of the positions he took in that debate
- 55:58and said he has subsequently taken on a variety of issues as
- 56:02a pure how he handled himself on the debate stage.
- 56:06You know when he had a lot coming at him.
- 56:08I thought the fact that he went in there from the just just pure
- 56:12like analyzing from a political consultant perspective, like he
- 56:15didn't go into that debate thinking I was going to play
- 56:17defense. He went in that debate thinking
- 56:18I was going to play offense. You know and I think some of the
- 56:21others on that stage potentially could have taken some lessons
- 56:23from that. I came into crypto because I'm.
- 56:27I'm ultimately an optimist. I do believe that this is an
- 56:30incredible country. You know, I personally have
- 56:33benefited from the opportunities that exist in this country.
- 56:35I came from a middle class, working class background and to
- 56:38end up where I am today is only possible because of this
- 56:41country. And I think this country has its
- 56:43challenges, but it's still a remarkable place.
- 56:45It is still an amazing place. I sit here in San Francisco,
- 56:48right. We talked about, you know,
- 56:50what's going on in San Francisco.
- 56:51San Francisco still an awesome city.
- 56:53Like you walk a couple blocks in San Francisco, you'll end up in
- 56:56conversations on where the world is going that nothing in the
- 56:58world can compare to. I traveled around the world over
- 57:00the course of summer. Nothing compares to what's going
- 57:02on in San Francisco. So it's along with the way of
- 57:04saying like, I don't think this country is in a dark place.
- 57:07I think like anytime we have challenges and we need to
- 57:09address them and we're better off addressing them collectively
- 57:12and we do need to improve our politics.
- 57:14But I fundamentally and just the ground level just have a
- 57:18completely different view on where we are as a country.
- 57:20I find covering like. Business.
- 57:24Like businesses have an incentive in some ways to treat
- 57:27the parties as like the same or like or just like they're two.
- 57:32Entities like we're trying to win both over, like, whatever.
- 57:36Like. On the other hand, if you
- 57:38actually like, pay attention to politics.
- 57:41It's like. I, you know, feel like they
- 57:44operate totally differently. Like Democrats are legitimately
- 57:47trying to govern and like are a serious party, like don't enable
- 57:51their voters and say the election was stolen and go
- 57:53anyway. I could go on and on.
- 57:55Like, I feel like they're very different.
- 57:57I feel like as somebody, you know, even though I'm like a
- 58:01reporter with opinions, it's still like, you know, I want
- 58:03people to feel represented. I'm always going back and forth
- 58:06from. I'm not.
- 58:09I think you get what? Like I wrote about founders Fund
- 58:11the other day like as part of a sort of clinical description of
- 58:14each fund. And I'm like they're
- 58:16conservative. They are upset about DEI and
- 58:19like and I feel like they were annoyed with me and I'm like,
- 58:22but this is what you guys are saying like I I don't
- 58:24understand, like it's hard for me to understand as a non
- 58:27conservative this is what you're talking about or do you not want
- 58:30to be celebrate? So it's very hard like as sort
- 58:32of a. Real sort of Democrat.
- 58:35I can, I could understand sort of the old school Republicans
- 58:37worrying about tax issues. But like, I don't know, how do
- 58:41you deal with like sort of the maggot type Republicans as
- 58:43somebody who's like job in some ways is to engage with them when
- 58:48you put your Democratic cat on. And it's like they're
- 58:51unconscionable. Yeah.
- 58:53It's a look at this, a question that I think so many of us in
- 58:56this country are struggling with and challenged by.
- 58:59You know, I do think it's important to understand and
- 59:02recognize that there is, you know, a significant population
- 59:07in this country that are profoundly unhappy.
- 59:09And you know, while I think that objectively speaking, this
- 59:13country's and, you know, people are should be blessed to be in
- 59:16this country and feel great about it and feel great about
- 59:18the American experiment generally, you have to
- 59:20understand that people and recognize and appreciate that
- 59:23that people are unhappy and there's reasons why they are
- 59:26unhappy and I think, you know, be willing to accept that at
- 59:31least some of them are unhappy for real reasons.
- 59:35I think there are some. And again, my politics here who
- 59:38are unhappy for reasons I do not think are legitimate and I think
- 59:42there is and this, you know, this is sort of woven in through
- 59:45this entire conversation. I do think that there is an
- 59:48interesting opportunity, particularly for Democrats, if
- 59:52they can really begin to think about how can we actually begin
- 59:56to talk to some of these voters because they do have, if you're
- 1:00:00in parts of this country, right, you do have real profound
- 1:00:02concerns about your economic opportunity, you know, the
- 1:00:05fairness of the system and frankly I think some issues
- 1:00:09around what you've been told for 30-40 fifty years.
- 1:00:13That has not necessarily played out in what was represented to
- 1:00:17you and not feeling that either party is effectively addressing
- 1:00:20it and then that allows you to default.
- 1:00:22You know these some of the positions that people are
- 1:00:24taking. But I do think Democrat, like
- 1:00:26I'll say this, I think my friends and I have this
- 1:00:28conversation a lot of dinner parties in San Francisco.
- 1:00:31I think it's worth it to go spend some time in these parts
- 1:00:33of the country and understand you know what people are going
- 1:00:35through and think about that. I agree with what you're saying
- 1:00:38in the. Sense that it's easier to have
- 1:00:39empathy, you know, with Republicans if you think about,
- 1:00:41sort of. The regular Republican voter who
- 1:00:44like, you know, yeah, in some cases as legitimate reasons,
- 1:00:49even if they're reasons I don't find legitimate, maybe I find
- 1:00:51their situation sympathetic. Yes.
- 1:00:53I feel like the challenge in Silicon Valley, though, is like
- 1:00:56the Republicans, that the elite Republicans we have to deal with
- 1:00:59are sort of often the ones happy with sort of the game of the
- 1:01:03Republican Party, which is fire up populism.
- 1:01:06We want low taxes and low regulation.
- 1:01:09And so you're dealing with like. Sort of a disingenuous sort of
- 1:01:13political ideology, though I they often don't admit that.
- 1:01:16First of all, I think there's there was an element of that was
- 1:01:18part of the Republican compact for a long time, right?
- 1:01:20Like business would work with the more extreme elements of the
- 1:01:24party because that would get you 50 + 1% extreme.
- 1:01:28They'd throw some things, the extreme elements and they would
- 1:01:30get their low taxes right. I think that has now been
- 1:01:32coopted as any number of people have written about and spoken
- 1:01:35to. I thought where you were going,
- 1:01:37but I wouldn't take it. What's that?
- 1:01:40Coopted meaning that, you know, for there was a time period
- 1:01:43really, you know, post World War 2, up until, you know, through
- 1:01:46the Bush administration roughly where the business Republicans
- 1:01:51called the Mike Pence Republicans may be in charge,
- 1:01:54right. Would work with other elements.
- 1:01:56And, you know, of the Republican Party, I mean, Pence is a little
- 1:01:59bit of a combination of both. But, you know, maybe the
- 1:02:01evangelical wing of the Republican Party and they would
- 1:02:04say certain things about cultural issues.
- 1:02:07And, you know, by combining those two forces, again, this
- 1:02:10is, you know, this is a generalization, be able to win
- 1:02:13an election when the presidential campaign, you know,
- 1:02:15national security was also part of that.
- 1:02:16That was a trifecta, right. Lower taxes, cultural issues and
- 1:02:19the military. And they would get their lower
- 1:02:22taxes. And they did.
- 1:02:23That's regulations. And when I made the whole lot,
- 1:02:25it is, Yep. The more extreme element now
- 1:02:28actually has, you know, controlled the whole part.
- 1:02:30Right. And so but where I thought you
- 1:02:32were going and maybe if I could be permitted to take it here a
- 1:02:35little bit is what what gets me is there will be people,
- 1:02:40particularly in San Francisco but really the whole Bay Area
- 1:02:43who have been living credible lives with incredible benefits
- 1:02:50and incredible resources that over human history are like
- 1:02:54historic in terms of what and, you know, amongst the first to,
- 1:03:00you know, complain about what's going on in San Francisco where
- 1:03:03the first complaint about, you know, what's happening in San
- 1:03:05Francisco. And like yeah, there are things
- 1:03:08that legitimate issues to be concerned about San Francisco.
- 1:03:11But like, you know, the people that city have voted these folks
- 1:03:14in the office. And if you want to
- 1:03:15constructively engage, there's a lot of ways you could really
- 1:03:17constructively engage And like I'll share someone who I'm like
- 1:03:20a huge fan of like Chris Larson founder of E*Trade Elon.
- 1:03:25You know, at Ripple. You know he's a tech guy in San
- 1:03:27Francisco. Like, he spends enormous both
- 1:03:30resources and time, like on the ground working to improve the
- 1:03:34city. Like, he's a great example of
- 1:03:36it, right. And I, you know, I, and I'm sure
- 1:03:39I'll get a lot of grief for this.
- 1:03:40But like, like the people who have the least to worry about,
- 1:03:44at least to be concerned about, you know, I mean, look, I'll,
- 1:03:46you know, another person. I think that's amazing.
- 1:03:48I was like a Ron Conway. I mean Ron spends his time, his
- 1:03:51effort, his treasure, You know, I'm trying to improve things and
- 1:03:54commits himself to those things, you know, and it's not on
- 1:03:57podcasts or ex, you know, complaining about things.
- 1:04:00So that that's why I thought you were taking this.
- 1:04:03I mean, I agree with you. Yeah, there there is sort of, if
- 1:04:05you're so mad about San Francisco, have a constructive
- 1:04:08vision for it. I mean we saw, I mean the New
- 1:04:10York Times had that fascinating story about, you know, Mike
- 1:04:14Morris and others, Mark Andreessen supporting sort of an
- 1:04:17$800 million project to build a city, I think South of Solano
- 1:04:22County or something. Yeah, I mean that that sort of
- 1:04:25straddles the boundary of what you're saying.
- 1:04:26It's like it's constructive but it's sort of opt out or like I
- 1:04:30don't know, do you have a strong?
- 1:04:31View on that sort of thing? Yeah.
- 1:04:33Look, I think there's a spectrum of people who are involved in
- 1:04:35that. I think there are some who
- 1:04:36probably more constructive than some others.
- 1:04:38But I do like, I like, I guess where I come down is like San
- 1:04:41Francisco and the Bay Area has contributed to the success.
- 1:04:45All these folks have had included myself.
- 1:04:47Like I would not have had the success to except I've had any
- 1:04:50if I had not been out here. And and I think you can be a
- 1:04:53constructive part of the solution.
- 1:04:55And I think there's ways to do that, and it's a lot more than
- 1:04:57putting out a tweet. Alright, I'll give you the last.
- 1:05:01Thank you so much for coming on. Yeah, this was great.
- 1:05:03I really enjoyed it. I hope we get to do it again.
- 1:05:06Yeah, it's awesome. And let's make sure we actually
- 1:05:08get that coffee in person. Yeah, I loved it.
- 1:05:10Great. OK man, great to.
- 1:05:11See you. Thanks for having me.
- 1:05:12Thanks so much. That's my episode with.
- 1:05:14Chris Lehane Shout out to Tommy Herron, our Audio Editor, Riley
- 1:05:18Consula, my chief of Staff, Annie Wenner producing intern,
- 1:05:21Young Chomsky for the wonderful theme music.
- 1:05:23Please, like comments, subscribe on YouTube.
- 1:05:26Give us review on Apple Podcasts and of course subscribe to the
- 1:05:29sub Stack newcomer.co Thanks so much.
- 1:05:31Goodbye, Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:05:33Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:05:35Goodbye, Goodbye. Goodbye.