Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Economic Goodwill: Valuing the Invisible Moat
Transcript
- 0:00We've all seen it. You have two companies side by
- 0:02side and they look almost identical on a balance sheet.
- 0:06But one is just a financial rocket ship and the other is,
- 0:08well, it's stuck in the mud. So today we're cutting through
- 0:12all that noise. We are going to do a deep dive
- 0:15into your sources to reveal how you can spot a genuine financial
- 0:19superpower, the sort of invisible engine that just
- 0:22prints money. And crucially, how to put a
- 0:25dollar figure on it. Exactly.
- 0:27So let's start with the core dilemma from the research.
- 0:30Imagine you're presented with a choice.
- 0:32You can invest in company A. Now this one requires constant
- 0:36heavy capital input. You have to keep sinking money
- 0:39into new equipment, new factories, just to stay barely
- 0:42profitable. A total treadmill.
- 0:44Or you can pick Company B. This one needs almost zero
- 0:47investment year after year, yet it's profit seem to magically
- 0:51double. It just spits out cash.
- 0:53It's an easy choice, you'd pick B every time.
- 0:55You'd think so, but here's the challenge.
- 0:58When you actually look at the standard financial statements,
- 1:01they can look deceptively similar.
- 1:03And a lot of investors, I think really struggle to tell the
- 1:06difference between that asset heavy burden and this this
- 1:10invisible printing press. And that invisible printing
- 1:12press is what we call economic goodwill.
- 1:14And it's so important we define this right away because it gets
- 1:17confused with its terrible cousin, accounting goodwill.
- 1:22Right, the one you see on the balance sheet.
- 1:23Exactly. And that's usually a bad sign.
- 1:26You know, accounting goodwill is what you see listed there, and
- 1:29it almost always just means one company overpaid to buy another
- 1:33one. It can signal future write
- 1:34downs, impairment, you name it. A management mistake basically.
- 1:37Pretty much. So we need to forget the balance
- 1:40sheet for a second. We are focusing purely on
- 1:43economic goodwill. This is the intangible soul of a
- 1:47business. It's superpower.
- 1:49The whole goal today is to kind of throw out the textbook
- 1:52definitions and just focus on the core truth.
- 1:55What let's a company be so powerful it doesn't have to
- 1:58fight for every single dollar of return?
- 2:00You know, I thought the analogy and the source material was
- 2:02perfect for this. They compare the ordinary acid
- 2:06heavy companies to pig farming, right?
- 2:09If you want more meat, you got to buy more feed, you got to
- 2:12expand the barn. It's just a relentless demand on
- 2:15your capital. But the company with that strong
- 2:17economic goodwill, that's the golden goose.
- 2:20You don't need to keep feeding it.
- 2:22You don't need to pour more concrete.
- 2:24It just it automatically lays those golden eggs.
- 2:27It generates explosive free cash.
- 2:28Flow without demanding endless capital just to keep the lights
- 2:31on or grow. And this superpower, it really
- 2:33shows up in 2 critical ways that we're looking for in any
- 2:36business. 1st and is non negotiable is absolute pricing
- 2:41power. Meaning they can raise prices
- 2:43and customers just stick around. They remain fiercely loyal.
- 2:47They don't switch. And the second characteristic,
- 2:49which is really the other side of that same coin.
- 2:51And the low capital input exactly.
- 2:54When that golden goose wants to earn one more dollar of profit,
- 2:57it doesn't have to spend one more dollar on a new machine.
- 3:01The marginal cost to scale is basically zero.
- 3:03That's the magic. OK, let's unpack this with some
- 3:07real world examples, because spotting this in the wild is, I
- 3:10mean, it's tough until you really know what to look for.
- 3:13It really is so. Case study #1 The classic
- 3:16pricing power and brand loyalty sees candies When Warren Buffett
- 3:21bought sees back in 72, the source makes it clear he wasn't
- 3:25really buying factories, he was buying unparalleled brand
- 3:29loyalty. And the classic proof is always
- 3:31Valentine's Day sees figured out that no matter how much they
- 3:35jacked up the price on a box of chocolates, the consumer,
- 3:38usually the boyfriend, he has to buy that brand.
- 3:41Right, because if he shows up with some generic box.
- 3:44The girlfriend might be genuinely upset that loyalty
- 3:47completely overrides any rational price sensitivity.
- 3:51Fascinating inside, it's like a psychological toll bridge,
- 3:53especially around events like gifting.
- 3:55It is, and that's the core of their Moat.
- 3:57If Seize wants to double its profits, they don't build a new
- 4:00factory, they just print a new price tag and slap it on the
- 4:03same box. That is the first law of
- 4:05economic goodwill in action. Absolute pricing power, no
- 4:08capital required. Precisely.
- 4:10Now let's look at case study two, which shows that low
- 4:13capital input in its most extreme form, the big credit
- 4:17rating agencies like Moody's and S&P.
- 4:21The legal franchise. Exactly.
- 4:23If a huge corporation wants to issue bonds, you know, borrow
- 4:26money, they basically have to get a rating from one of these
- 4:29two. Wall Street just won't touch the
- 4:31debt. Otherwise it's a mandatory toll
- 4:33bridge. I see the advantage there, but
- 4:36what are the economics, The scaling part?
- 4:38That's where the goodwill is. The cost for Moody's to rate one
- 4:41massive company versus say 10,000 companies, it's almost
- 4:45the same. Their product is information.
- 4:48It's digital. So it's basically a 0 marginal
- 4:50cost business. Fundamentally, yes.
- 4:52Their growth doesn't require buying more stuff.
- 4:55It's almost pure profit once that system is in place.
- 4:57But hold on a second, if their Moat is just based on market
- 5:00rules and sort of regulatory tradition, isn't that flimsier
- 5:04than a brand Moat like sees? I mean, what if the SEC just
- 5:08decided tomorrow that three new agencies are perfectly fine?
- 5:11Couldn't that goodwill just vanish?
- 5:13That is a fantastic question and and it gets to the heart of Moat
- 5:16durability. And while, you know,
- 5:19theoretically A regulator could change the rules, the practical
- 5:22reality is that the entrenched power of the incumbents makes
- 5:25that so unlikely. They're too sticky.
- 5:28They're incredibly sticky. They have decades of history.
- 5:31Trust global infrastructure. A new entrant can't replicate
- 5:36that overnight, even with a government permission slip.
- 5:39OK, that makes sense. Now for our third example, which
- 5:41is probably the most powerful one in the modern economy, high
- 5:45switching costs. The textbook example is Apple's
- 5:48ecosystem. Yeah, and I think a lot of us
- 5:50still see Apple as a hardware company.
- 5:53They make phones. They make laptops.
- 5:55But their real economic goodwill is in that ecosystem.
- 5:58I mean, once you're deep into iOS, you're using iCloud, your
- 6:01watch syncs with your tablet, which syncs with your computer.
- 6:04The pain index of switching to an Android phone just becomes
- 6:07enormous. You're not just losing a device,
- 6:09you're kind of losing your digital life.
- 6:11You are. And how do you quantify that
- 6:13pain index? It feels so abstract, but it's
- 6:16not abstract when you look at the cash flow.
- 6:18That high switching cost allows Apple to just continuously
- 6:22harvest high margin services revenue.
- 6:24Think apps, store fees, iCloud storage, Apple Music.
- 6:29They've captured your mindshare, not just market share.
- 6:31And that is so much more powerful than just selling a
- 6:34piece of aluminum. OK, so those are all, you know,
- 6:36phenomenal businesses. But like you said, stories are
- 6:38easy. The challenge is finding these
- 6:40companies before everyone else does.
- 6:42We need some practical filters. We need numbers.
- 6:44Absolutely. We have to go from the
- 6:45philosophy to the cold hard math, and there are three
- 6:49quantitative markers that really signal strong economic goodwill.
- 6:52OK #1 ROIC or return on invested capital, we want to see this
- 6:57consistently and I mean consistently greater than 15%.
- 7:01And why 15%? Why not 12 or 20?
- 7:04Is that an arbitrary number? It's not arbitrary.
- 7:06It's because 15% consistently and significantly beats the
- 7:10average cost of capital. A company that is always making
- 7:1415% or more on every dollar it puts back into the business has
- 7:18a structural advantage, a Moat. If you're at 8 or 10%, you're
- 7:22just fighting for survival at 15 plus you're earning money almost
- 7:26effortlessly. Got it.
- 7:27That clarifies the ROIC benchmark.
- 7:30What's #2. #2 is the gross margin.
- 7:32We want to see this consistently above 40% and it needs to be
- 7:36stable. And gross margin is the best
- 7:38indicator of pricing power. It's the single best.
- 7:41It shows what a company keeps after the direct cost of making
- 7:44its product. If your gross margin is over
- 7:4640%, it means you have incredible control over your
- 7:49price. If the cost of sugar or aluminum
- 7:52goes up 10%, you can absorb that or pass on.
- 7:55If your margin is only 15%, a cost increase like that could
- 7:58wipe you out. That connection to inflation
- 8:00resilience is crystal clear. OK, so what's the final metric?
- 8:04This has to relate back to the golden deuce, right?
- 8:06It does #3 low capital expenditure or CapEx,
- 8:11specifically maintenance CapEx, the money you have to spend just
- 8:15to keep the lights on. We demand that this be low,
- 8:18typically less than 20% of earnings.
- 8:20So if a company earns $100 in profit, it only needs to spend
- 8:24less than 20 just to maintain its current operations.
- 8:27Correct. And to see why that's so
- 8:28powerful, just think about the opposite.
- 8:31Think about an airline or a steel mill.
- 8:33Their maintenance CapEx can eat up 5070, sometimes even 100% of
- 8:38their earnings just to replace engines or upgrade furnaces.
- 8:41They're. Trapped on that pig farming
- 8:43treadmill? Precisely for our Golden Goose
- 8:45Company, if it earns $100 and only needs 20 for maintenance,
- 8:48that other $80 is pure free cash flow.
- 8:51Management can use that for smart reinvestment, dividends,
- 8:54buybacks. It's not trapped in replacement
- 8:56parts. That makes perfect sense, and
- 8:58since that kind of company generates so much free cash,
- 9:02it's no surprise that stock would probably have a sky high
- 9:04PE ratio. Which brings us to the next big
- 9:07challenge. How do we justify paying that
- 9:10high PE? How do we actually put a dollar
- 9:13value on this invisible asset? This is where it gets really
- 9:16interesting. This is the valuation formula
- 9:18that ties it all together, and we can use a really simple
- 9:21example from the sources. 2 hypothetical noodle shops A&B.
- 9:26OK. First, the setup, they're
- 9:28identical on the surface. Both have $1 million in tangible
- 9:32assets. The kitchen, the equipment, all
- 9:34of. That 1,000,000 in physical stuff
- 9:35got it. No noodle Shop A is a totally
- 9:38normal, well run business. It earns $100,000 in profit a
- 9:41year. If we assume the fair market
- 9:43return for a restaurant is say 10%, then Shop A is doing
- 9:46exactly what it should be. It's earning 10% on its
- 9:49$1,000,000 asset base. It's fairly valued at 1,000,000
- 9:52bucks. Makes sense now Noodle shop B.
- 9:55It also has that same $1,000,000 in physical assets.
- 9:58But it has a secret family recipe, an amazing local brand,
- 10:02and because of that it earns $500,000 in profit a year, a 50%
- 10:07return. Whoa, a 50% return on the exact
- 10:10same kitchen? That's that's more than just a
- 10:14good recipe. It is.
- 10:16So let's do the math. We know the $1 million in
- 10:18physical assets should only generate that fair market return
- 10:21of $100,000. Right, the 10%.
- 10:23The extra $400,000 in profit, that's the 500,000 total minus
- 10:28the 100,000 it should have made. That is cash flow generated
- 10:31purely by the economic goodwill, by the invisible Moat.
- 10:35So we've isolated the profit from the Moat, it's $400,000 a
- 10:38year. So how do we get the total value
- 10:41of that invisible asset? We capitalize that excess profit
- 10:43stream. We use that same 10% market rate
- 10:46we established. Basically, how much capital
- 10:48would you need at a fair 10% return to generate $400,000 in
- 10:52profit? So 400,000 / .10, which is $4
- 10:57million. Exactly.
- 10:58The invisible economic goodwill. The brand.
- 11:01The recipe is valued at $4 million.
- 11:05No. So Noodle Shop B's true value is
- 11:09the 1,000,000 in tangible assets plus that 4 million in economic
- 11:14goodwill, total value $5,000,000.
- 11:17And this completely changes how you look at it.
- 11:20A high PE ratio on this business isn't crazy.
- 11:23It's the market recognizing that $4 million of invisible value
- 11:28that accounting ignores. That is unbelievably practical.
- 11:31It shows you how to see right through a high PE to the real
- 11:34asset value underneath. And this leads right to the
- 11:36killer move, which is how these companies perform during high
- 11:39inflation. This is so crucial for any
- 11:42investor listening today. Right.
- 11:43Inflation hurts everybody, but you're saying it hurts those
- 11:45asset heavy companies way more? Disproportionately more.
- 11:48If inflation is 10% and airline has to replace a jet engine and
- 11:51guess what, the price of that engine also just went up 10%.
- 11:54They have to inject way more capital.
- 11:56Just stay in that same place. The returns collapse.
- 11:58But a company with strong economic goodwill like our
- 12:01noodle shop B or Coca-Cola, they don't have depreciating physical
- 12:06assets to replace. They only have to do one thing.
- 12:08Raise their prices. They just raise their prices.
- 12:11Their brand is their printing press.
- 12:13They maintain those higher returns through inflation
- 12:15because their capital needs are so low.
- 12:17It's the ultimate defense. So the core lesson here is
- 12:20pretty clear. Investing isn't just about what
- 12:23a company owns, but how much excess return those assets can
- 12:27generate. So next time you see a company
- 12:29with a high ROIC or a big gross margin, don't just dismiss the
- 12:33high PE. Try to quantify the modes value
- 12:35first. But.
- 12:36We have to end with a really crucial caveat.
- 12:38Economic goodwill is not immortal, right?
- 12:40We have some painful examples. Think about Kodak.
- 12:43Think about Nokia. Both ones had unbelievably high
- 12:46goodwill. Dominant brands, Powerful
- 12:48ecosystems. And then they just.
- 12:50Vanished. Rapid technological disruption
- 12:53came along and destroyed that intangible asset.
- 12:55The market valued their goodwill at 0 almost overnight because
- 12:59their moats, film chemistry, proprietary operating systems
- 13:02were made obsolete by a better technology.
- 13:04That's the ultimate risk. Isn't it?
- 13:06It is. And therefore the key for any
- 13:08long term investor is to find companies with strong economic
- 13:11goodwill, but in industries that are not easily disrupted by
- 13:15technology. And we'll just leave you with
- 13:17this final thought. What industries today have those
- 13:20strong high margin moats, but are also the most resilient to
- 13:24sudden game changing disruption? Are we talking about consumer
- 13:27brands, logistics, Something else?
- 13:29Something for you to Mull over?