Latest / No Way Out / Trend Following Warfare: John Boyd's OODA Loop in Trading
Transcript
- 0:21Mark McGrath: So, Ponch, as you know, I had a long career in asset management wholesaling, and it was a fun, exciting life.
- 0:29Mark McGrath: The volatility, uncertainty, complexity, ambiguity of markets was a great place to apply the theories of John Boyd daily.
- 0:36Mark McGrath: And I learned really quick that I can't sell product.
- 0:39Mark McGrath: I had to sell myself, and how I sold myself was by teaching people Boyd and teaching people orientation and Uta and how you reorient and how you get feedback and how you create snowmobiles.
- 0:50Mark McGrath: And it was in that process of being delirious of all the product and everything out there that I knew.
- 0:56Mark McGrath: Something almost felt off to me that a friend of mine said, Have you ever heard of trend following?
- 1:01Mark McGrath: I go, No, what the hell is what the hell is trend falling?
- 1:04Mark McGrath: So he gives me this book, who one of our guests today is uh is is widely featured.
- 1:11Mark McGrath: And he gives me this book, and I start reading it, and it's like literally the polar opposite of everything that they were teaching me and my peers to wholesale funds inside of financial institutions.
- 1:21Mark McGrath: I'm like, can we get shot having this information?
- 1:24Mark McGrath: Does this really work?
- 1:26Mark McGrath: I end up getting this book.
- 1:27Mark McGrath: As you can see, it's taped and copied, and the marginalia is drenched.
- 1:31Mark McGrath: Chapter 28 was a cruise missile against the industry that I was in.
- 1:34Mark McGrath: And here we are today talking to two very well-known trend followers to have a conversation with us about the connection between what we see from where we come from from the theories of Boyd and Flow and other things, to a style of investing that almost nobody talks about, that you're not going to see on the news rarely, that you're not going to see in popular financial media, which I like to call financial porn.
- 1:58Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Moose, I want to I want to add something here.
- 2:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Trading is combat.
- 2:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We know that, man.
- 2:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yes.
- 2:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The market is a flow system.
- 2:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You just brought up flow and the connection to John Boyd Zoodaloop.
- 2:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I cannot think of a better way to you'll never master the market, but you can increase the probability that you're going to have success if you follow John Boyd's real observorient decide act loop.
- 2:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's where we're going.
- 2:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So Luce, I I know you spent a lot of time on Wall Street.
- 2:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I haven't, but I do a lot of work on my own.
- 2:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I find that one of the reasons we trade, maybe two reasons.
- 2:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: One, it allows you to get into a flow state.
- 2:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And two, nobody's going to handle your money better than you are, right?
- 2:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We we hand off, you don't hand your kids off to somebody else to get, well, some people do to go raise them.
- 2:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We buy insurance for our house and our cars, but we never, ever, ever learn individually how to trade and how to master the market or how to learn how to increase the probability in the market.
- 2:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think that's what Doodle Loop teaches you.
- 2:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So back to you, Moose.
- 2:52Mark McGrath: Yeah, Jerry and Mike, thanks for Jerry Parker and Mike Melancinos, thanks for joining the conversation with us today.
- 2:57Mark McGrath: Good.
- 2:58Michael Melissinos: Thanks for having us.
- 2:59Mark McGrath: Thanks for having us.
- 3:00Mark McGrath: So let's start at the biggest, let's start at the biggest picture.
- 3:04Mark McGrath: Like I said, I I I learned of this trend following at age, I don't know, 44, 45.
- 3:09Mark McGrath: I immediately wish I would have read the book when I was 13.
- 3:13Mark McGrath: I gave it to my children, so hopefully, hopefully they could uh they could have a different course.
- 3:20Mark McGrath: What is it about trend following that is so radically different to the point where almost nobody talks about it or nobody thinks about it?
- 3:29Michael Melissinos: I'm gonna let Jerry go because he literally has a lifetime of uh experience more than me.
- 3:34Jerry Parker: Well, I think um it comes across as a pretty straightforward and easy to understand concept and idea.
- 3:41Jerry Parker: And then it starts tapping into sort of things that humans don't really like to do.
- 3:46Jerry Parker: And you sort of you sort of embrace that, you know, like, oh wow, I see how that could work.
- 3:51Jerry Parker: It's it's really counterintuitive.
- 3:53Jerry Parker: It's making me or asking me to do things, take small losses.
- 3:57Jerry Parker: I don't like losing.
- 3:58Jerry Parker: I like one-tick winners.
- 4:00Jerry Parker: Give me a winner of any kind.
- 4:03Jerry Parker: Profits run, uh it sounds good, but then when you get into it, it's really difficult to do because you could all that profit that you've accumulated could go away.
- 4:12Jerry Parker: And I think it's uh objective and not subject to discretion, which we all have this experience and uh that we want to tap into.
- 4:21Jerry Parker: A win percentage of 40%, which is like no fun at all.
- 4:25Jerry Parker: And so you can either embrace all of these sort of negatives and say, well, this may be the reason it works and because it's hard to do, and it really calls me to another level of um what works in the markets.
- 4:38Jerry Parker: I shouldn't expect what works in the markets to make me feel good if I can survive and keep take money out of the markets.
- 4:45Jerry Parker: That might be all I should be expecting.
- 4:47Jerry Parker: But um, or you can reject it.
- 4:49Jerry Parker: And I think that's where that comes in.
- 4:50Jerry Parker: It must be something better.
- 4:51Jerry Parker: It gets rid of the drawdowns.
- 4:53Jerry Parker: It certainly makes the losing uh percentage of 60, at least 60% or so, better than that.
- 4:59Jerry Parker: So, and I think that it's easy to reject uh the the difficult, narrow path.
- 5:04Jerry Parker: We're always asking people to eat more broccoli, and that's just not what's in fashion usually.
- 5:11Mark McGrath: You see why it would appeal to contrarians like us.
- 5:14Mark McGrath: How did well you're you're you're featured in this, in the in the the turtle traders.
- 5:18Mark McGrath: You were one of the original turtle traders.
- 5:21Mark McGrath: What had you been doing before that to share with our listeners, and then what was it that clicked for you to say, like, wow, I need to be, I'm I'm I'm gonna do this, and then I need to stay doing this because you've you've done this your entire career.
- 5:34Jerry Parker: I was in public accounting in Richmond, Virginia in 1983, and I saw the ad in the Wall Street Journal to um come to work for Richard Dennis, and he would teach you how to trade commodities and futures, and uh didn't give you money to trade.
- 5:51Jerry Parker: And so um I thought that was a pretty good idea.
- 5:54Jerry Parker: I thought I knew it was, I thought it was legit because I'd seen an article about Richard Dennis, and I had spent a past year or two studying trend following just randomly it hit my uh radar, and uh I had watched Wall Street Week with, and Marty Zwag was a frequent guest on there, and he was about diversification and trend.
- 6:12Jerry Parker: And so I had spent a lot of time really studying, and then when I got the response back and the truefalse test and started the processing from trying to get an interview, I was just hoping that those guys were talking about trend following.
- 6:27Jerry Parker: I didn't know for sure.
- 6:28Jerry Parker: But uh and so I thought trend following was great.
- 6:31Jerry Parker: You know, when I was 20 some years old, I thought it was great when I first read about it, and then I fell in love with it every day since then, more and more.
- 6:38Jerry Parker: It gets better and better every day.
- 6:40Jerry Parker: And uh it's just I just thought, yeah, it's objective and it's rule-based.
- 6:45Jerry Parker: And that sort of, I guess, maybe clicked with me as an accountant.
- 6:48Jerry Parker: And then I looked at the charts and I was like, yeah, I can understand this.
- 6:52Jerry Parker: If the big winners, the infrequent big winners pay for all the losing trades, then things will work out pretty well.
- 6:59Jerry Parker: And that's sort of naive, but in the same way, it's really the essence of it, too.
- 7:03Jerry Parker: Are they going to pay for it?
- 7:04Jerry Parker: And you need to figure out a way or have someone tell you, like me, how to pursue a strategy and in a way that will hopefully ensure or tilt the probabilities in your in your favor that you will get enough of those big trades to cover the losses.
- 7:19Mark McGrath: Mike, how did you uh how did you come into uh trend following?
- 7:23Michael Melissinos: Well, first, hold on.
- 7:24Michael Melissinos: I want to bring up uh you fall in love with it every day more and more.
- 7:27Michael Melissinos: You know, April was tough to love it then, getting rocked by the the tariff-related whipsaws.
- 7:33Michael Melissinos: That I remember having Jerry uh having coffee with Jerry that week, and we were we were a little, you know, had the thousand-yard stare sort of thing going on because the volatility in the whipsaws were so extreme.
- 7:46Michael Melissinos: But um, I just want to go back for uh another second about what makes you know trend following hard or you know what makes people not maybe attract to it as much.
- 7:56Michael Melissinos: I mean, I think in general, you know, trading, investing, whatever you call it, you know, managing money in general is hard and not comfortable.
- 8:05Michael Melissinos: Like, and I think there's plenty of evidence on this that, you know, for the the everyday investor, even up to the pro level, the the the approach they all know and love, you know, the maybe, maybe when when you were working in the business telling people that, hey, stocks go up, this is the story, just keep investing month after month, hold on no matter what.
- 8:31Michael Melissinos: This is this is what this is what uh we believe and what this is what um we're we're here to capture, this this ever this ever ever going uptrend in stocks.
- 8:41Michael Melissinos: Okay, well, even that's hard.
- 8:43Michael Melissinos: Um, it doesn't mean people do it.
- 8:46Michael Melissinos: Okay, I understand that.
- 8:47Michael Melissinos: That sounds lovely, uh, you know, until you get until you get crushed, and until um, you know, you start taking some pain, and then you're like, well, maybe I don't know if I believe that anymore.
- 8:58Michael Melissinos: And then, you know, maybe well, you know, my situation's changed and my risk tolerance changed.
- 9:02Michael Melissinos: You know, I don't like this.
- 9:03Michael Melissinos: And and then you start medicating your your feelings with what's selling out when you shouldn't be selling out and all those types of things.
- 9:10Michael Melissinos: So I think uh, you know, whatever you choose, whatever approach you go with, even if it has long-term validity, doesn't mean it's gonna be some joy ride.
- 9:20Michael Melissinos: I don't think so.
- 9:21Michael Melissinos: You know, markets are chaotic and dangerous at times and uncomfortable.
- 9:26Michael Melissinos: So uh, you know, whatever you go with, you gotta you just have to make peace with, all right, well, this is what we do here, and this is how it works, and we're always up, you know, aware that something can go wrong.
- 9:38Michael Melissinos: And hey, maybe historically something that has never happened before happens on my watch.
- 9:44Michael Melissinos: Yeah, that's just life.
- 9:45Michael Melissinos: And uh so I think, yeah, but maybe, maybe with, you know, when when it gets tough though, in the tough period, you kind of have that belief.
- 9:54Michael Melissinos: You know, the the equities crowd has that belief of, well, okay, I you know, I believe that the stocks are gonna go back up.
- 10:01Michael Melissinos: So, okay, this is fine.
- 10:02Michael Melissinos: I'll I'll buy into this.
- 10:03Michael Melissinos: It's okay.
- 10:04Michael Melissinos: You know, I can get back in easier or something.
- 10:06Michael Melissinos: I don't know.
- 10:06Michael Melissinos: I don't even know if everyone does that, but but that just could be some of the internal chatter that goes on.
- 10:12Michael Melissinos: And with trend following, it's you have to believe that trends are gonna still continue occurring.
- 10:17Michael Melissinos: And I don't think a lot of people get there.
- 10:20Michael Melissinos: They don't understand why they need to have a story, um, you know, a fundamental driven story on why um, you know, trends are gonna keep occurring, commodities, currencies, and all these other markets that we trade.
- 10:33Michael Melissinos: So yeah, that that it just might not occur to them.
- 10:36Michael Melissinos: So it's just uh, you know, if they try it out, they might they might not stick with it because it doesn't give them that story, that that warm that warm blanket they need when they're when they're taking some pain.
- 10:50Michael Melissinos: I don't know.
- 10:53Mark McGrath: That totally makes sense.
- 10:54Mark McGrath: I mean, what what we would say when we're advising clients about orientation, you know, we all have one.
- 11:01Mark McGrath: We all have one individually.
- 11:02Mark McGrath: It's fractal.
- 11:03Mark McGrath: We can have one collectively to create a podcast or a fund or anything.
- 11:07Mark McGrath: At some level, you share orientation with your with your investors.
- 11:10Mark McGrath: And it's important to note that orientation shapes or implicitly guides and controls how we observe things.
- 11:17Mark McGrath: So it's very clear to us that in a in a trend following mindset or trend following frame of thinking, a trend following orientation implicitly guides and controls or shapes a view and sense making within markets that is remarkably different than just about every other actor out there.
- 11:37Speaker 2: And thus the differentiated results.
- 11:40Michael Melissinos: Yeah, I think with trend following, we always know you know, we're I guess maybe frequently emotional or you know, we have some emotion going on, but it's you know, maybe for you know guys like me and Jerry, we're we're not confused about what to do.
- 11:57Michael Melissinos: We know what to do.
- 11:58Michael Melissinos: We have our rules staring at us right in the face every day.
- 12:02Michael Melissinos: So that's that's nice that we have that.
- 12:04Michael Melissinos: We know exactly what to do.
- 12:06Michael Melissinos: We believe in it because we've done all the work that that you know, okay, these rules have long-term validity, and um, you know, we've tested them many different ways on, you know, in and out of sample, different time frames, yada yada yada.
- 12:20Michael Melissinos: So okay, we're we feel cozy with that.
- 12:22Michael Melissinos: But um, you know, it doesn't mean our emotions go uh you know stay nice and even no matter what the PL does.
- 12:30Michael Melissinos: No, you know, that can happen, but it's not enough to abandon ship and you know what, that looks nice over there.
- 12:37Michael Melissinos: Let's go try something else.
- 12:38Michael Melissinos: No, because then you're you know just in chaos, giving into your feelings all the time.
- 12:42Michael Melissinos: No.
- 12:43Mark McGrath: So uh But at the same time, you'll you you'll let go of something if you believe it to be wrong.
- 12:49Mark McGrath: How do you walk us through the discipline of that?
- 12:51Mark McGrath: Like when something doesn't fan out the way that you want it to or believe it to, you know, talk us through the discipline of being able to cut cut your losers and and move for move on.
- 13:02Michael Melissinos: I think I think for me that's pretty much one of the easiest things for me to do is to cut a loser.
- 13:08Michael Melissinos: I don't I don't feel that this, you know, this is a loser.
- 13:14Michael Melissinos: Uh I don't know what I'm doing because if I knew, I wouldn't have taken taken this trade in the first place because see, if I was smart, I I would have I would have been able to avoid this one.
- 13:26Michael Melissinos: No, you don't like no one knows.
- 13:28Michael Melissinos: That's another belief that we have as trend traders.
- 13:30Michael Melissinos: We just we believe that we cannot know the future at all.
- 13:35Michael Melissinos: So so we take these small calculated low-risk bets and say, okay, let's see.
- 13:41Michael Melissinos: You know, it's like planting a seed in the garden.
- 13:43Michael Melissinos: We don't know if this one's gonna work.
- 13:44Michael Melissinos: We're not putting all of our eggs into this seed to, you know, feed the whole family for generations.
- 13:49Michael Melissinos: Just nah, let's try it out and uh monitor it.
- 13:52Michael Melissinos: And hey, if it doesn't work out, no problem.
- 13:54Michael Melissinos: That that is maybe hard for people to get to.
- 13:58Michael Melissinos: I I I I don't know.
- 13:59Michael Melissinos: I don't want to talk for Jerry, but I suspect it's the same for him.
- 14:02Michael Melissinos: You know?
- 14:03Michael Melissinos: Um it's pretty easy just to cut losses and just say, okay, uh move on.
- 14:09Michael Melissinos: Yeah, because we don't have some hardened belief about you know our ego or something about uh you know, if we knew, if if we were smarter, we would have been able to avoid this or something like that.
- 14:22Michael Melissinos: Or I don't know.
- 14:23Jerry Parker: I was taught um that the most important thing, you know, you is you gotta put the trade on.
- 14:27Jerry Parker: There's nothing more important because you're gonna miss that big trend if you don't.
- 14:31Jerry Parker: And the five to ten percent of the trades each year that are gonna turn into all the profits, you can't miss one of those.
- 14:38Jerry Parker: And so right out of the first week of trading, I was not taking all the trades, right?
- 14:42Jerry Parker: I mean, that's just I don't know why, but it so I guess in in some respect, I was a step ahead of the game.
- 14:47Jerry Parker: I was so afraid of taking the loss that I did want to do the trade.
- 14:51Jerry Parker: But once I was putting the trades on, then I was happy to take the loss.
- 14:55Jerry Parker: I don't know why that wasn't a struggle, but um the struggle for me was just putting that on.
- 15:03Jerry Parker: And but the odds are it's just the asymmetry of it is so crazy because you're gonna have this predefined small loss before you put the trade on.
- 15:12Jerry Parker: You've got your exit and your percentage of your capital that you're going to lose, 50 basis points, 10 basis points, it could be something really small, depending upon how many markets you trade.
- 15:22Jerry Parker: And then uh you'll miss something like Cocoa or the stock market.
- 15:26Jerry Parker: We trade the stock, you know, the stocks or stock features as well, or gold and silver.
- 15:30Jerry Parker: And then you look back on that trade, and let's just say, as a trend follower, for some reason you just didn't take the gold and silver trade, and you look back and you say, I was going to risk 50 basis points for all of this wealth in gold and silver that I and so it's really ridiculous.
- 15:45Jerry Parker: So over time, you just experience that, and you hopefully you haven't had any good experiences by not following the rules to lean on.
- 15:53Jerry Parker: And so you you uh build up this history of regrets that informs your behavior in the future.
- 15:59Mark McGrath: What was it?
- 16:00Mark McGrath: So, you know, with with Ponch's background as a naval aviator and mine as a marine officer, you know, we've gone through very exacting transformational programs that weed out all of the people that that can't hack, you know, or or or shouldn't be there.
- 16:15Mark McGrath: So I'm wondering if you walk us back to that very initial time where you gathered with Richard Dennis and everybody in Chicago, what do you think was the major difference between yourself and your path and others?
- 16:26Mark McGrath: Like what were the things that they weren't able to handle or accept that sort of filtered them out or weeded them out, if you will?
- 16:32Jerry Parker: Yeah, that's a great question.
- 16:33Jerry Parker: I've often used this really bad analogy, which is, you know, you can't really become a Marine just by being given the handbook.
- 16:40Jerry Parker: You got to go through basic training or whatever.
- 16:43Speaker 2: And you gotta go through hell.
- 16:45Jerry Parker: Yeah, yeah, exactly.
- 16:46Jerry Parker: And so the the advantage you have too, when it's all said and done, you're like, yeah, I can't imagine just being given a manual or a set of rules.
- 16:54Jerry Parker: And the same with us, you know, we had a great set of rules from great teachers and genius people, and very nice people, too.
- 17:00Jerry Parker: I mean, these are the nicest, smartest people you've ever wanna meet.
- 17:03Jerry Parker: They had broken new ground on using computers at that in the 80s and doing backtesting and understanding math.
- 17:10Jerry Parker: Bill Eckhart is probably one of the smartest people I've ever listened to that I didn't really understand much of.
- 17:16Jerry Parker: But just being put in that kind of pretend environment where they would say things like, uh, do the hard thing, do the right thing, and you're gonna be fine if you follow the rules.
- 17:27Jerry Parker: Now, these are our rules, but if you follow the rules and lose money, you're fine.
- 17:32Jerry Parker: If you don't follow the rules and you make money, you could be in trouble with us.
- 17:36Jerry Parker: And so, and then after just a few months of trading, everybody had lost a lot of money by following the rules.
- 17:43Jerry Parker: Some better than others, but about the same amount.
- 17:46Jerry Parker: And their response was, you're following the rules, you're doing the right thing.
- 17:49Jerry Parker: Here's more money.
- 17:50Jerry Parker: No one does that in real life.
- 17:52Jerry Parker: No one encourages you like that and says, look, concentrate on one thing, follow these rules and be disciplined, and things will work out in the end.
- 18:00Jerry Parker: When you get into the real world, you know, with clients, they're the exact opposite.
- 18:04Jerry Parker: Look, if you have to cheat, use discretion, don't follow the rules especially specifically to make money for me, fine, go ahead and do it.
- 18:11Jerry Parker: Whatever it takes.
- 18:11Jerry Parker: I don't, you know, sitting through these losing trades and these bad periods, this is horrible.
- 18:16Jerry Parker: And I don't like your system.
- 18:17Jerry Parker: So this was this sort of uh great and way to start your career.
- 18:22Jerry Parker: And then another thing they would, I don't really remember exactly, but I remember leaving there with a huge skepticism of clients.
- 18:29Jerry Parker: Clients and other people are gonna steer you in the wrong direction.
- 18:32Jerry Parker: They're gonna ask you to take these shortcuts, they're gonna criticize you for losing when you're doing the exact right trades that you should be doing.
- 18:40Jerry Parker: So I couldn't have been a better, and I couldn't imagine not having that experience with those guys.
- 18:46Jerry Parker: But look, you know what?
- 18:48Jerry Parker: It's no surprise that the secret of the success of some and the lack of maximizing the possibilities that others experienced was just uh how much did you follow those rules?
- 19:00Jerry Parker: And did you really believe those rules?
- 19:02Jerry Parker: And then when you got out on your own after four years with Rich and Bill, were you still dedicated to the at least the philosophy?
- 19:09Jerry Parker: They taught us an enduring philosophy of how to maximize trading life, not just, and they would just say, look, these specific rules or parameters are not going to last forever.
- 19:19Jerry Parker: You're gonna have to evolve and adapt over time.
- 19:22Jerry Parker: But it was deeper than that.
- 19:23Jerry Parker: It was the philosophical way of looking at markets and looking at life and knowing what to expect and that you should expect pain and suffering when you're doing the right thing.
- 19:32Jerry Parker: Once again, going down this path of this narrow path of excellence.
- 19:37Jerry Parker: Quite an experience.
- 19:39Jerry Parker: And it's really, I think that the one thing that never got written about was how smart they were and how nice they were.
- 19:46Jerry Parker: I had I learned that lesson too about dealing with seeing people for the first time who were just incredibly nice and didn't treat us the way we deserved to be treated.
- 19:55Mark McGrath: Remind us the size of the original cohort of turtles.
- 19:59Jerry Parker: So 1983, the December of eighty three, they hired twelve, and the next year was eight.
- 20:05Jerry Parker: So it was around twenty.
- 20:06Jerry Parker: There were some that were we didn't really know that weren't in our office, and there was one or two in our office that really weren't turtles, but just sort of friends.
- 20:16Jerry Parker: There was a lot of friends hanging around, especially in the turtle class.
- 20:20Jerry Parker: Half the room was just brokers of theirs or friends of theirs.
- 20:25Jerry Parker: Yeah, come on in.
- 20:26Jerry Parker: Sit in.
- 20:27Jerry Parker: See what you can learn.
- 20:30Mark McGrath: So this is the other thing that's always blown my mind about trend followers is their willingness to talk, their willingness to mentor, their willingness to teach, their willingness to explain, not only through books, but replying to emails, groups.
- 20:44Mark McGrath: Jerry, I used to attend your group.
- 20:46Mark McGrath: I can't remember what it was called.
- 20:47Mark McGrath: It wasn't on Twitter Live, but it was spaces.
- 20:52Mark McGrath: Spaces or something like that.
- 20:53Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 20:54Mark McGrath: I mean, like the willingness of people, the accessibility to learn and mentor has always really struck me as a very stark cultural difference in an industry also that's usually guarded by arrogance and secrecy and other things.
- 21:08Mark McGrath: That the trend followers are almost the opposite of that.
- 21:11Jerry Parker: Yeah, that's good.
- 21:12Jerry Parker: It's nice to hear I was in it with a group of uh CTAs recently, and someone brought that very idea up that he had had lots of experience dealing with finance, with other types of strategies and funds and hedge funds, and that trend followers were still able to sit around and have a coffee or a beer and talk about and be cordial and wish everybody the best.
- 21:32Jerry Parker: I do think that uh we disagree a lot in the philosophy on how to handle it and how to do things.
- 21:37Jerry Parker: But uh give us more about that.
- 21:39Mark McGrath: Tell tell us more about that.
- 21:40Jerry Parker: Well, I think Mike and I come from more of a classic background of taking small losses and having to stop losses.
- 21:48Michael Melissinos: I I think I think the new element that's involved with uh maybe some of the changes that um some of the trend followers have made in recent years, especially I think since I think the business model changed then.
- 22:01Michael Melissinos: And I think the business model and influenced the trading models, and that was to gather more assets, appeal to more people, make trend following more palatable for people to handle.
- 23:12Michael Melissinos: And that I think spurred a lot of the the work around changing the the the historical uh you know techniques.
- 23:22Mark McGrath: Like made it too commercial or too commodified or Jerry gets really charged up about this, so I'm gonna let him fire.
- 23:28Michael Melissinos: Yeah, let's hear it.
- 23:29Michael Melissinos: Light it up.
- 23:31Jerry Parker: Well, I think uh it has evolved.
- 23:33Jerry Parker: And um I think uh oh just thinking back to the basics, you know, uh are you gonna have a stop loss?
- 23:41Jerry Parker: This is kind of in question now.
- 23:42Jerry Parker: We'll exit, we'll try to exit try to keep losses to a minimum or not let them get out of control.
- 23:49Jerry Parker: But are you gonna have a predetermined stop loss?
- 23:52Jerry Parker: Maybe, maybe not.
- 23:53Jerry Parker: Are you gonna let profits run?
- 23:55Jerry Parker: No, no, no, no.
- 23:56Jerry Parker: This is not letting profits run, we can't really do that.
- 24:01Jerry Parker: We need to scale back our winning positions due to increased volatility or correlation.
- 24:09Jerry Parker: Um I did a calculation the other day, just a simple calculation, based upon the increase in volatility in silver.
- 24:18Jerry Parker: And I would say that uh it would not be unheard of that uh the that uh sort of the typical managed futures CTA is probably out of 80% of their silver and proud of it, and then selling every time there's a big day up.
- 24:34Jerry Parker: And so Mike and I are like, no, no, we're gonna like let the profits run.
- 24:38Jerry Parker: We've done the research, we've done the back test.
- 24:40Jerry Parker: Risk is this is a big change too.
- 24:43Jerry Parker: Risk is that potential loss we had, the 50 basis points.
- 24:48Jerry Parker: And so silver's got a monster profit.
- 24:50Jerry Parker: We don't have that anymore, and the the industry has sort of changed into no losses, the daily fluctuations, negative or positive.
- 24:58Jerry Parker: This is this is now redefined as risk.
- 25:02Jerry Parker: And that sort of takes away the underpinnings of what how we learn trend following.
- 25:08Michael Melissinos: Yeah, I think what uh Jerry is describing, like the vol management, the the daily fluctuations, you know, we don't like that.
- 25:18Michael Melissinos: People don't like that.
- 25:19Michael Melissinos: They don't like giving back gains.
- 25:22Michael Melissinos: Okay, well, let's not give them back then.
- 25:26Michael Melissinos: Let's every time, you know, we we get some gain, you know, to a certain degree, whenever we r rerun our calculation and we see some gain and now it's getting more volatile.
- 25:35Michael Melissinos: Okay, let's take some off.
- 25:37Michael Melissinos: Let's ring that register, as some would say.
- 25:39Michael Melissinos: All right, well, that's inherently counter trend.
- 25:42Michael Melissinos: Because you're the trend is still in favor, right?
- 25:45Michael Melissinos: You're still long the thing, but you want to have you want to hold less now for what reason?
- 25:52Michael Melissinos: Well, yeah.
- 25:53Michael Melissinos: Well that's not the trend reason.
- 25:55Michael Melissinos: So this is inherently counter trend.
- 25:57Michael Melissinos: You're just calling it something else, you know, vol management, you know.
- 26:02Michael Melissinos: And you're really it's really feelings management.
- 26:04Michael Melissinos: I don't care what they say.
- 26:05Michael Melissinos: That's inherently what it is.
- 26:07Mark McGrath: When did the, you know, when you you're both describing risk, you know, I always thought of risk as the permanent, the chance of the permanent loss of capital.
- 26:15Mark McGrath: And years ago, when I was in the biz, and I would go out to the Berkshire Hathaway meeting, and Buffett and Munger would say essentially that, that the the prevailing theme across uh the financial industry was that risk was volatility, just the mere ups and downs.
- 26:29Mark McGrath: But I rejected that because I followed what Buffett and Munger were saying, that no, risk is the classic definition of risk is the chance of the permanent loss of capital.
- 26:38Mark McGrath: But what I found in 15 years of telling people that they thought I was a heretic.
- 26:41Mark McGrath: They thought I was crazy, but that seems to really align with what Jerry just said and what you just added on to, Mike, is that the very orientational definition of risk that I have, miss if if I believe it just to be volatility, that's completely misshaping how I view and sense make inside of inside.
- 26:57Mark McGrath: Right.
- 26:58Jerry Parker: I think what happens, what was good for Mike and me is that we came to trend following without having a background or like a heavy statistical and math background.
- 27:08Jerry Parker: I think a lot of the managed futures CTAs, they're coming from physics or statistics or heavy math backgrounds, and they need to cram that into their trend following.
- 27:17Jerry Parker: They cannot abandon it.
- 27:19Jerry Parker: This is a rejection and turning my back on everything that I've learned, all my PhDs, and it's just not going to happen.
- 27:26Jerry Parker: And I'm going to embrace everything that I learned and make and change the trend following to uh reflect that.
- 27:33Jerry Parker: And Mike and I did not have that problem.
- 27:35Jerry Parker: We came in not knowing anything, thank God, and being taught by people who knew a lot and were super smart, just as smart as anybody else I've ever met.
- 27:43Jerry Parker: And yet took that more straightforward approach of letting the profits run.
- 27:50Jerry Parker: And it can't, you think it's difficult for people to embrace trend following retail or normal people.
- 27:55Jerry Parker: It's super difficult for people who are well-versed in math and advanced degrees to simply do less and uh let the market and let the trends take care of it for you.
- 28:06Jerry Parker: There's lots to do, I think, putting together the portfolio and devising your approach.
- 28:12Jerry Parker: But um, it is a shame that classic trend following is 1% of managed futures.
- 28:19Mark McGrath: How much so is another way to ask this question is that basically that the less you know about classical finance and and modern finance, maybe the better you would be at trend following.
- 28:30Jerry Parker: I think so.
- 28:30Jerry Parker: And some people and I've seen evidence of that.
- 28:33Jerry Parker: They just don't ask all the questions.
- 28:35Jerry Parker: And I think that, you know, definitely when you when we had success, so much success in the first 10 or 15 years, we were subject to that as well.
- 28:43Jerry Parker: Like, okay, what's next?
- 28:44Jerry Parker: We've already kind of conquered trend following and let's make it better.
- 28:48Jerry Parker: What can we do?
- 28:48Jerry Parker: And we just got away from the principles and we had to backtrack.
- 28:53Jerry Parker: We, you know, we would overoptimize and see performance in our real track record that we'd never seen, we'd never seen such poor performance in the backtest.
- 29:03Jerry Parker: And that our response was, we got to stop this.
- 29:06Jerry Parker: This is crazy.
- 29:07Jerry Parker: But it is tempting because every you read about everyone else is doing it.
- 29:10Jerry Parker: But I've told Mike before, when we do our backtest on these approaches that we have that don't have a lot of moving parts, just one entry, one exit, and a stop loss.
- 29:19Jerry Parker: The track record is so good.
- 29:21Jerry Parker: And I've never seen a track record of any CTA as good as that.
- 29:25Jerry Parker: So they're trying uh to make it better, but it's really difficult.
- 29:30Mark McGrath: You know, another another one of my heresies in my career was learning and teaching mass psychology, particularly around behavioral economics and behavioral finance, and you know uh the my favorite book was The Art of Contrary Thinking by Humphrey B.
- 29:44Mark McGrath: Neal.
- 29:45Mark McGrath: And I found that the more that I read those things and studied those things, the clearer I saw it when I looked around how markets were crashing and people were behaving.
- 29:54Mark McGrath: Some places you were quote unquote allowed to talk about it, but what I've what I've noticed, if anybody has studied mass psychology or behavioral economics, I think that from me, from my vanta point anyway, that trend following actually is a really good discipline for someone that does know something about that, because I think that trend following ends ends up leveraging those things without falling victim to those things, if that makes sense.
- 30:17Michael Melissinos: Yeah, I I agree.
- 30:18Michael Melissinos: Um, you know, I think uh trends occur for all different reasons, you know.
- 30:22Michael Melissinos: Could be changing fundamentals, you know, the the dynamics between the you know ever-changing fundamentals and the ever-present, you know, human condition within the markets.
- 30:32Michael Melissinos: People overreact, underreact.
- 30:34Michael Melissinos: Things go way farther, you know, trends go way farther than you think, they don't go as far as you think, you know, all all the biases that have been well documented over the last 20, 25 years, especially.
- 30:46Michael Melissinos: They get talked about every crisis, you know, they'll get talked about what caused it, what what traps we've fallen into.
- 30:53Michael Melissinos: So yeah, so like when you is you know, when you have a set of rules to do, and you know, it really tests and brings out your character, gives you entry points for, oh, you know, maybe I gotta work on this, uh, you know, in order to do it, to do the thing, to do the trades, as Jerry's mentioned in the free, just doing the trade.
- 31:14Michael Melissinos: That's hard.
- 31:16Michael Melissinos: That's just hard to do.
- 31:17Michael Melissinos: You know, it's you know, I I I've been I I've been grew up in sports my whole life.
- 31:22Michael Melissinos: I've been going and working out and training my whole life.
- 31:25Michael Melissinos: You learn so much about people, the first day it rains.
- 31:29Michael Melissinos: Go to the gym.
- 31:31Michael Melissinos: Ten percent of the people are there.
- 31:33Michael Melissinos: Why is that?
- 31:34Michael Melissinos: When it's cold here in New York, no one wants to go out, no one wants to go do it.
- 31:38Michael Melissinos: They don't want to go and layer up and brace the elements on the walk over to the gym and then have to walk back a little sweaty.
- 31:46Michael Melissinos: It's gonna be cold again.
- 31:48Michael Melissinos: Ah, I'll just stay here, you know.
- 31:50Michael Melissinos: I'll just stay cozy.
- 31:51Michael Melissinos: You know what?
- 31:51Michael Melissinos: I'll I'll make up for it later.
- 31:53Michael Melissinos: You know, I'll I'll do two this weekend, or blah, blah, blah.
- 31:55Michael Melissinos: You know, that those are all great entry points for okay, you see what makes it hard.
- 32:02Michael Melissinos: You see what but that doesn't mean it's a reason to change it.
- 32:06Michael Melissinos: No.
- 32:07Michael Melissinos: This is what works, you know.
- 32:09Michael Melissinos: Hit the gym this time's a week, eat your meals, sleep, blah, the whole system that would make you healthy, hard to do, easy to explain, the premise, everyone gets it, hard to do.
- 32:21Mark McGrath: So Jerry, I've often heard the metaphor a little birdie once told me, but you're you're living proof of that right now that a a little birdie came on your shoulder and told you.
- 32:31Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 32:33Jerry Parker: Um I was out of town yesterday, so she missed me, so she's wanting some love this morning.
- 32:38Mark McGrath: Love it.
- 32:39Mark McGrath: Love that.
- 32:39Mark McGrath: Hey, Ponch, I have a quote for you.
- 32:41Mark McGrath: And you're you're uh there's two options.
- 32:44Mark McGrath: It was either Michael Malicinos that said this quote or John Boyd.
- 32:47Mark McGrath: The trend following philosophy is based on adapting to evolving conditions in the now.
- 32:53Mark McGrath: It's about learning from the past in order to make the right decisions today.
- 32:57Mark McGrath: The goal is not to eliminate losses from investing, but to manage them in a way that doesn't kill us.
- 33:03Mark McGrath: Uh that could come from either.
- 33:04Mark McGrath: It could come from either, right?
- 33:06Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 33:06Mark McGrath: I mean, John Boyd could not have said that better.
- 33:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's break, let's break this down a little bit.
- 33:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So when you think about the Outer Loop, and this is for our listeners, and and implicit guidance control represents those processes, those habits of minds, those things that you need to do.
- 33:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Why do we have those things?
- 33:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, it allows us to get in a state of flow, to see the outside world a little bit better, and it helps us overcome our biases, which are part of our orientation, right?
- 33:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It was alright, brought up in this conversation that uh our our heuristics or biases kind of kind of limit our performance in markets.
- 33:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh there's there's all kinds of biases out there, resulting, loss aversion, things like that.
- 33:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So what we need to do is you need a process, and this goes for teamwork too.
- 33:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Teams need a process of how to plan, which leads to better risk management, by the way, how to mitigate uh cognitive biases, which overcome those biases, which we call red teaming.
- 33:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And of course, you need to take action on the environment to get feedback from the environment.
- 33:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And what you do, you end up looking at your process.
- 33:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's an implicit guidance control pathway at the top.
- 34:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You can see how it bypasses the deliberate approach from the middle, that it goes through decision and hypothesis.
- 34:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What we want to do is develop a process that we can follow.
- 34:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's what trend following does.
- 34:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It gives you the process to help you bypass um, we'll just call it the uh the system two thinking there, the del, you know, and narrative to you want to avoid the narrative from the external world and just follow that.
- 34:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I I think what you're bringing up there, Moose, or you what you just shared on the quote, is uh uh again, could come from either John Boyd or anybody in the in the trend following network.
- 34:35Speaker 2: If if John Boyd was talking about trend following, um Wow.
- 34:43Michael Melissinos: That's what I'm saying.
- 34:45Mark McGrath: We know it was you in this in this book.
- 34:46Mark McGrath: You know, on page 90 of uh Michael Covell's trend following, uh, you're quoted on there, but it's a what what resonates with us, Mike, is that one, you told me when we first met that you were quoted in that book, and of course I had that book and I looked it up and I looked at it and I said, well, Boyd could have said that.
- 35:03Mark McGrath: So it goes back to what I've long been thinking about trend following is that the the knowledge and understanding of what it was that Boyd was teaching.
- 35:13Mark McGrath: You know, it only works where humans make make decisions and act.
- 35:18Mark McGrath: Yet trend following is a really good example because that central part, the orientation, is so uniquely different.
- 35:26Mark McGrath: You know, we you and I had talked about, you know, the cultural at the cultural level, at the philosophical level.
- 35:32Mark McGrath: That that distinction alone, that difference alone, implicitly guides and controls.
- 35:37Mark McGrath: You see there on the top or shapes how we sense and how we and how we act.
- 35:43Mark McGrath: And I also think the other thing that's remarkable with trend following is that, and it's in, it's in a lot of the literature in either the trader, the Turtle Trader book, uh, The Complete Turtle Trader or in Trend Following is that decisions are hypotheses of what you think will happen.
- 35:58Mark McGrath: And you test the actions are tests.
- 36:00Mark McGrath: So I the the the correlation to what Boyd was was was teaching, and that the you know the Marine Corps bought into it and reevaluated its entire warfighting doctrine based off of these concepts.
- 36:13Mark McGrath: The the example of trend following to depict what it was that John Boyd was was teaching and continues to teach, and this that's our professional work with trend following, it's uncanny.
- 36:25Mark McGrath: And when you when you go through it and you you read it, and the deeper that you read it, I also think too, Ponch, I don't know that you thought about this, but trend following is the ultimate generalist that looks at all markets and they can go in any direction, not just a very specific piece of the market or not just any any particular direction.
- 36:43Mark McGrath: They can go long, they can go short, they can go into commodities, equities, bonds, cash, you name it.
- 36:48Mark McGrath: Like they have a they look at the market as an entire system.
- 36:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, it's a go anywhere approach.
- 36:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's a go anywhere approach.
- 36:56Michael Melissinos: I mean, to make a metaphor, it might be bad.
- 36:58Michael Melissinos: You know, I don't I don't feel um you know super qualified to be talking about uh your your backgrounds, uh military things, but say, oh well we you know we can only you know we have a we have a military, we can only fight um on this terrain and in this weather using these weapons.
- 37:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You so you sound like the French, by the way.
- 37:21Michael Melissinos: Good luck, fellas.
- 37:22Michael Melissinos: Yeah.
- 37:22Michael Melissinos: Good luck, fellas.
- 37:24Michael Melissinos: You know, it ain't gonna work out.
- 37:28Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 37:28Mark McGrath: Mike, next time we get together, we'll go through patterns of conflict.
- 37:31Mark McGrath: What you just said is exactly that's yeah, people actually do think that.
- 37:35Mark McGrath: And it it's not just war, it's business, it's investing, it's yeah, it's child rearing, it's it's it's everything.
- 37:41Mark McGrath: They actually completely disregard what it takes to thrive in complex nonlinear environments.
- 37:47Mark McGrath: And the system of trend following, the systematic approaches to trend following, at least inherently seem to me to be accounting for all those things to take advantage of anything and have the agility to go in any which way, given the complex nature of markets.
- 38:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to share a quick story about the French, by the way, just for Jerry and Mike.
- 38:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to make sure this could I clarify something.
- 38:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I spent time working with the air component command of the French Air Force.
- 38:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And one of the hardest things I had to do was teach them that, you know, war goes 24 hours a day.
- 38:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It doesn't just work in a 12-hour window, right?
- 38:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So what we had to do is get them prepped up and learn how we fight wars in the U.S., an air war, an air campaign through the air tasking order and getting into weeds at the scheme of maneuver for uh warfare, for air warfare.
- 38:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And what ended up happening a few months after we taught that, they ended up taking the lead in Libya, right?
- 38:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Which was awesome because uh this is what 10 years ago more or more.
- 38:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I'm just saying they had a propensity to lean towards, well, it's time to eat, and we can't fight a war right now.
- 38:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We gotta go drink wine.
- 38:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, it didn't work out so well for them early on in the in World War II, but uh they've really come around, and I think that's uh a kind of a metaphor analogy to think about when uh when people trade, right?
- 38:57Michael Melissinos: Jeez, yeah.
- 38:58Michael Melissinos: That's surprising.
- 38:59Michael Melissinos: I guess not surprising.
- 39:01Mark McGrath: I don't maybe know my history with the French on I know what happened in World War II to them, and then you know We we could also say that trend following is war fighting, and you could take the book war fighting, and Mike, I can again I can give you a copy of this and show you, just cross out war fighting and put trend following trading.
- 39:18Michael Melissinos: Sure.
- 39:18Michael Melissinos: Throw it into Chat GBT and say, write this as a trend following book, and boom.
- 39:23Michael Melissinos: It correlates perfectly.
- 39:24Mark McGrath: So that's the that's the that's the core Marine doctrinal publication is uh Marine Corps doctrinal publication number one.
- 39:31Mark McGrath: And it's basically creating the cognitive operating system that you have to have as a Marine, whether you're an officer enlisted and you know at every level, it goes back to what you had told me and what you said in that what you said in that quote, that the cognitive operating system of trend following is what differentiates it from all other from all other forms and which which gives it its long run advantage.
- 39:56Mark McGrath: Yes, I agree.
- 39:57Mark McGrath: I believe that.
- 39:58Michael Melissinos: And you know, I think it it uh so I I this podcast is great because you know, we're talking to you guys who, you know, you know, um you mark who have you know some market experience, but you know, we're we're talking about something deeper than the markets here.
- 40:17Michael Melissinos: We're not talking about the markets.
- 40:19Michael Melissinos: We're talking about how to think and behave and you know, design and how to approach life, how to think about life, and like the the metaphors, you know, just using uh translating it into a another language that people are more you know comfortable with or used to, you grew up with, and um to help them get the oh yeah, okay, that I know what you're saying now.
- 40:45Michael Melissinos: Like, yeah, that's it.
- 40:47Michael Melissinos: That's it.
- 40:47Michael Melissinos: Because I, you know, I came, you know, same as um uh same as Jerry, not from the market, so to speak, in a in a career, only for a short while, but then you had to tell a bunch of people when I started my fond at twenty six, had to tell a bunch of people about trend following, and they're all older than me and they hadn't heard of it before, so had to had to use metaphors and everyday language and things that would resonate.
- 41:15Michael Melissinos: And they hopefully some of them would say, Oh yeah, okay, that no.
- 41:18Michael Melissinos: I know what you're saying now.
- 41:19Michael Melissinos: Oh, it's like that.
- 41:20Michael Melissinos: Yeah, it's like that.
- 41:21Michael Melissinos: Boom.
- 41:22Michael Melissinos: No, you know.
- 41:23Michael Melissinos: Okay, we got it.
- 41:24Michael Melissinos: Now we're now we're we're connecting the the dots here.
- 41:26Michael Melissinos: So I think when you you know when you're you talk, you know, to some people, they just they don't they don't have the vocabulary, they don't they don't know exactly what you're saying.
- 41:35Michael Melissinos: So to try not to be too stubborn too with hey, you need to get this, you know, this way, you know, you need to understand what I'm saying.
- 41:43Michael Melissinos: Um, well hold on, let me let me let me just you know make a simple metaphor and that's it.
- 41:48Michael Melissinos: You know, it's like a little ABC's book.
- 41:50Michael Melissinos: I got a a three-year-old at home now, you know, and they teach all these lessons through different silly cartoon stories, and it's that's the it's the same stuff, teaching the same lessons, just in different ways, more more fun ways.
- 42:04Mark McGrath: And Jerry, from your sage viewpoint of, you know, having done this since 1983, I mean, it really does come down to one's cognitive operating system, right?
- 42:12Mark McGrath: It really does come down to the way someone thinks.
- 42:15Jerry Parker: Exactly.
- 42:15Jerry Parker: One of the things that would frustrate me over the years has been this idea, which I mean it's a bad idea, but it has a grain of truth, I suppose, that you should choose an approach to the markets investing that suits you so you can do it.
- 42:30Jerry Parker: Able to, it's just acknowledge that, well, I'm not gonna do it if I don't like it.
- 42:34Jerry Parker: And I thought that was so backwards.
- 42:36Jerry Parker: I didn't like it from the very beginning.
- 42:38Jerry Parker: And I don't really like, you know, I'd like to make 1% a month or 2% a month and a really smooth, but I had to acknowledge that what I liked more was actually surviving and being successful.
- 42:49Jerry Parker: And I think if you're asking the market to reward you for a career with a career of trading and investing, then to do it on your own terms, where at the end of the day you feel really good about it and it really ticked all of your emotional boxes, I think is kind of naive and stupid.
- 43:06Jerry Parker: So I think that those people should not trade.
- 43:09Jerry Parker: That's the that's the alternative.
- 43:10Jerry Parker: You know, if you don't want to do hard things and do the right thing and submit yourself to a set of rules that have worked over the long term, and but you're gonna be overwhelmed by the daily negativity and emotions of losing money or giving back big profits, then don't trade.
- 43:28Jerry Parker: I think now the one thing that I would say is purely up to each individual person is deciding how much risk that you want.
- 43:35Jerry Parker: Are you gonna risk if you trade 100 markets, you're gonna risk 1% per trade, 10 basis points per trade.
- 43:41Jerry Parker: You know, anything in between is is fine, you know, because you have to uh you do have to follow the rules.
- 43:47Jerry Parker: And sometimes I've been in situations where I was definitely over-trading.
- 43:50Jerry Parker: Anyone would say that, and my own emotional makeup said that.
- 43:54Jerry Parker: And so then that led me to not do the trades.
- 43:56Jerry Parker: I had to scramble and get out of a bunch of positions or override the rules because I was losing too much money.
- 44:02Jerry Parker: But I don't think that we should expect.
- 44:05Jerry Parker: I I never really desired that.
- 44:07Jerry Parker: I uh I wanted to be successful and I wanted to do it the right way.
- 44:11Jerry Parker: And I took pride in doing things that other people thought was really hard.
- 44:15Jerry Parker: And I thought it was hard too.
- 44:16Mark McGrath: I mean, I mean, there is a lot of nonconformity that has to, I think to be as a trend follower, I think you'd have to be somewhat of a nonconformist.
- 44:23Mark McGrath: Am I am I following that right?
- 44:25Jerry Parker: I think to be, I think that's what we were taught.
- 44:27Jerry Parker: Don't look for positive feedback.
- 44:30Jerry Parker: Don't look for praise.
- 44:31Jerry Parker: You're gonna be alone.
- 44:33Jerry Parker: It's lonely.
- 44:33Jerry Parker: Don't look for consensus.
- 44:35Jerry Parker: Be be skeptical of consensus.
- 44:36Jerry Parker: A lot of the turtle trading that never got, I don't think, written about very much and never really practiced outside of the four years we were all there, was contrary opinion, where Rich would say, you know, if you um read about it in the New York Times, then you should be a little worried.
- 44:54Jerry Parker: But if it's in like your local hometown newspaper, you know, be very worried.
- 44:59Jerry Parker: And then if you get into a taxi, there was taxis, no Uber back then.
- 45:02Jerry Parker: And the and this and the taxi driver says, What about those soybeans?
- 45:05Jerry Parker: You should just get out of your soybeans right there.
- 45:08Jerry Parker: And so you kind of combine the trend with uh maybe using some um contrary opinion when people agree with you too much.
- 45:14Jerry Parker: And most of Wall Street really likes to see unanimity and agreement.
- 45:18Jerry Parker: We're all in this together.
- 45:19Jerry Parker: And uh Mike and I have, we left one thing out.
- 45:22Jerry Parker: We we don't use uh dynamic position sizing and reducing positions or increasing them based upon volatility, and we trade single stocks.
- 45:31Jerry Parker: This is another heresy amongst managed futures.
- 45:34Jerry Parker: You can't trade single stocks.
- 45:35Jerry Parker: So I've been in so many meetings where it's just a no-go.
- 45:38Jerry Parker: We're not gonna give you money.
- 45:39Jerry Parker: We're not gonna, you're not gonna work for us because you trade single stocks and you don't reduce your positions when volatility kicks up.
- 45:45Jerry Parker: And so we're just like, okay, I've often said, you know, I don't know if classic trend following can really be a successful business.
- 45:52Jerry Parker: You're always feeling the need to make some compromises.
- 45:55Jerry Parker: It's it's difficult.
- 45:56Mark McGrath: Ponch, I feel we've once again found people that we can have a conversation with that know everything about John Boyd without knowing anything about John Boyd because what excited about this.
- 46:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, Jury made a lot of connections.
- 46:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, he made a lot of connections there to to be or to do.
- 46:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Choose doing over to be part of the system, that's clear.
- 46:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then, of course, survive and thrive or survival on a system is uh is the name of the game, right?
- 46:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How do we do that?
- 46:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's really what the ODA loop is, is how do agents survive and thrive with an ever-changing environment?
- 46:25Mark McGrath: I mean, it really does come down to that differentiation at how Boyd would look at war, or we could look at business or Sun Tzu the same way at the moral, mental, and physical and physical levels.
- 46:36Mark McGrath: I know that you all trend following, when done well, I think, understands all of those things.
- 46:43Mark McGrath: They understand at the highest level that you do have to have a very clear belief system and philosophical approach to how you look at the you know, the volatility, uncertainty, complexity, ambiguity of markets, that you have to have the mental fortitude to be able to stay in the game and follow the rules and not give in to the emotional swings or the psychological swings.
- 47:03Mark McGrath: And then at the physical level to structure everything in a way that supports the mental and moral approaches to investing.
- 47:10Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 47:11Jerry Parker: Back when I first started trading, um we would sit in front of a computer and look at the markets and the charts, and you do the trade or you don't do the trade.
- 47:20Jerry Parker: And if you didn't do the trade and you or you did it incorrectly and used discretion, everyone knew that you just made a mistake.
- 47:26Jerry Parker: You know, you're not doing what you should do.
- 47:27Jerry Parker: Nowadays, it's much more subtle.
- 47:29Jerry Parker: We can write bad ideas.
- 47:31Jerry Parker: Jerry used to do these things to make himself feel better.
- 47:35Jerry Parker: We'll just write that into the rules.
- 47:37Jerry Parker: So now the rules are no good.
- 47:38Jerry Parker: And they can claim, we're following the rules, and that's what you said I should do.
- 47:42Jerry Parker: So you have to make sure the rules are what they should be as well, because humans will try to circumvent doing the hard thing, doing the right thing with I'll just make it a rule.
- 47:52Jerry Parker: And nobody can criticize because I'm following the rules.
- 47:55Jerry Parker: So a lot has changed in uh 30-some years.
- 47:59Mark McGrath: Jerry, so just kind of following on that, when when you know you look at the 42 years since 83 and you look at you look at the technological change of everything that's happened, of how we look at markets and how we approach markets.
- 48:10Mark McGrath: What what effect have the technological changes had on what people right or wrong, what they say their philosophy is?
- 48:18Mark McGrath: Like in other words, do the philosophies and beliefs get compromised that the the tech has had such an effect on them that they that they steer in favor of the tech, or are they still able, regardless of the technological changes, they're still able to stick to a philosophy that sort of pursues the truth within markets following a rules-based system like you do?
- 48:40Jerry Parker: I think the managed features has evolved into more complexity, smoothing out the trend following, giving the clients what they're asking for.
- 48:46Jerry Parker: Can you give me the bit of trend following that I like and eliminate the part that I don't like?
- 48:51Jerry Parker: And they're trying to do that.
- 48:52Jerry Parker: I think AI is probably just another bad idea for trend following, but we'll see what happens.
- 48:57Jerry Parker: But I think to some degree, it's been a the uh the addition of the markets and expansion of the number of markets.
- 49:04Jerry Parker: I traded 20 markets in 1983.
- 49:07Jerry Parker: Now we're up to hundreds of markets, stocks and many more um commodities and interest rates and currencies are available, and crypto can be another, maybe a fifth new asset class to put in there.
- 49:21Jerry Parker: So that's been a welcome.
- 49:23Jerry Parker: And then the commissions and the execution of our trades, all of the expenses of managing money and trading has gone down.
- 49:30Jerry Parker: So some of it's good, some of it's not so good.
- 49:33Jerry Parker: But Mike and I are in the in the in the minority here.
- 49:37Jerry Parker: No one would have really, not too many people would agree with us on all of this.
- 49:41Jerry Parker: It's uh it's risk-free.
- 49:44Mark McGrath: Tell us more about that.
- 49:45Mark McGrath: Yeah, tell us more about what you just said.
- 49:47Mark McGrath: Or Mike, add to that, you know, being in the minority when when everybody else is seemingly against you philosophically.
- 49:54Michael Melissinos: Well, I don't think we have this extra layer.
- 49:56Michael Melissinos: You know, I I I I messaged you, I didn't see if you uh replied, but before we before you got going on the podcast here, talking about Boyd and he one of his points that I saw, you know, at the the moral level of the culture and trust, you know, okay, you have a system, great.
- 50:16Michael Melissinos: You have a diet and fitness, you have a um yeah, you have you have a diet in the fitness machine, okay.
- 50:24Michael Melissinos: You he's got one, he's got one, he's got one.
- 50:26Michael Melissinos: You know, there's a lot of things that work, you know, within within um uh you know, the the markets uh as far as trading goes at times, but but I think what's often you know very overlooked is that we have, I think especially me and uh and Jerry's that we have we have a culture where we're we're not being pulled in many different directions on well, we gotta change.
- 50:53Michael Melissinos: Well, we gotta think about these guys.
- 50:54Michael Melissinos: They're they're our biggest clients.
- 50:55Michael Melissinos: These are our newest clients.
- 50:56Michael Melissinos: And uh we want to get these these new clients uh that we haven't got yet.
- 50:59Michael Melissinos: We we've been working on them for years now.
- 51:01Michael Melissinos: You know, like that kind of language and that kind of day-to-day hum and pull, and you don't you don't even know what you're doing anymore.
- 51:09Michael Melissinos: You know, you have to have a this is what we do.
- 51:12Michael Melissinos: Is it is everyone at peace with this?
- 51:14Michael Melissinos: This is what we do.
- 51:16Michael Melissinos: And we can't make a guarantee about what next quarter, next year, and you know, well, they're trend traders and they're you know, they've been beating us the last couple of years.
- 51:26Michael Melissinos: Well, what does that mean?
- 51:27Michael Melissinos: We're doing something wrong.
- 51:28Michael Melissinos: No, no.
- 51:29Michael Melissinos: And at the time, um, you know, just looking back a few years, 21 and 22 were good years for most you know, uh managed futures trend followers.
- 51:43Michael Melissinos: But some had better twins and some had better twos.
- 51:46Michael Melissinos: So if you took you know, if you checked in every year, every quarter, and you say, Oh, what are you guys doing wrong?
- 51:52Michael Melissinos: We're up 40.
- 51:53Michael Melissinos: You guys are up two.
- 51:54Michael Melissinos: See?
- 51:55Michael Melissinos: You guys aren't with it anymore.
- 51:57Michael Melissinos: And then oh, the next year you check in again and they're ahead of you that year.
- 52:01Michael Melissinos: It's like, okay, hold, you know, there's gonna be there's gonna be variation on a short-term time frame.
- 52:06Michael Melissinos: Okay, no big deal, you know.
- 52:08Michael Melissinos: But again, this is what we do here.
- 52:11Michael Melissinos: This is how we do it, and these are the ups and downs.
- 52:13Michael Melissinos: We don't, we're not we're not telling people, we're not telling ourselves that we need to be, we expect to be ahead of everyone all the time.
- 52:21Michael Melissinos: That's just you're gonna make yourself insane.
- 52:23Michael Melissinos: And and you're just it's not statistically correct, it's not even healthy to expect that.
- 52:28Michael Melissinos: So again, you know, a terrible analogy.
- 52:31Michael Melissinos: I can't I I can't.
- 52:32Michael Melissinos: I don't think so.
- 52:33Michael Melissinos: I see.
- 52:34Michael Melissinos: I shouldn't even bring it up.
- 52:35Michael Melissinos: But like imagine going into battle and saying, man, they shot one of our guys.
- 52:40Michael Melissinos: You see, we're doing something wrong.
- 52:42Michael Melissinos: Like, what?
- 52:43Michael Melissinos: No, of course you're gonna have things that go wrong and people are gonna get hit, and like this is just how it is.
- 52:49Michael Melissinos: There's that's that's it, that's expected.
- 52:51Michael Melissinos: You don't like it, they don't like it.
- 52:54Michael Melissinos: Try to minimize it, but you're not gonna avoid it.
- 52:57Michael Melissinos: And I think what we have today is that people are trying to avoid it.
- 53:00Mark McGrath: I see Ponch smiling, and I I don't know if this came to you, Ponch, but as Mike was talking, I started thinking about energy maneuverability theory, about how Boyd would shape and design aircraft.
- 53:12Mark McGrath: And one of the points was to be able to gain and lose energy, and sometimes it looks like you're at a disadvantage and you're actually gaining an advantage unforeseen to your opponent.
- 53:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 53:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, I was also thinking about Kinevan framework where we talk about there are no best practices that are just good practices, good processes, right?
- 53:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it's the same thing here, and I think that's what uh is going on here.
- 53:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The other thing is, you know, we have to separate uh decisions from outcomes.
- 53:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You can have horrible decisions and have great outcomes, or you can have great decisions and horrible outcomes.
- 53:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's called complexity, right?
- 53:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that good process, that that good approach doesn't always guarantee you're gonna have a fantastic outcome, right?
- 53:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let me let me uh point this out.
- 53:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You and I could drive a car down the street, do everything correctly, not on our phones, paying attention, and still get hit by a car, right?
- 53:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Why is that?
- 53:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, the environment gets a vote, right?
- 54:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But we did that, we followed a good process.
- 54:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We don't go back and change and go, well, I drove um and I I didn't text and drive.
- 54:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I didn't do any of that, but so now I'm gonna go text and drive.
- 54:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, I know every day kids text and drive and they have good outcomes, right?
- 54:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Horrible decision making, great outcomes.
- 54:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They don't get in car accidents.
- 54:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, no, no.
- 54:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Moose, what you brought up about EM theory and uh everything else, it all connects.
- 54:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's just how does it resonate with us?
- 54:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's uh that's how it resonated with me on Trend Falling.
- 54:24Mark McGrath: We'll save that for the next convo.
- 54:26Mark McGrath: We want to also remind our listeners that Jerry and Mike have a podcast.
- 54:31Mark McGrath: Tell us about that.
- 54:32Michael Melissinos: We have uh talking trends podcast where we just, you know, we get we get hot about certain topics, and then we just get on there and start yelling and ranting and uh, you know, just kind of venting.
- 54:44Michael Melissinos: Um, you know, it's not like it's not an angry podcast or something, but sometimes we're we're a little miffed and sometimes we're uh we're this and we're that.
- 54:52Michael Melissinos: It's just kind of what's hot at the time.
- 54:54Michael Melissinos: Um yeah, so we we get on there, um I I I want to commit to do it weekly, but you know, I I I feel sometimes that we just don't are not always hot about something.
- 55:07Michael Melissinos: Sometimes we're just you know, I don't know, I don't know, what do you want to talk about?
- 55:10Michael Melissinos: It's kind of like well, if we have no not nothing, we're not we're not feeling something, then then we just uh you know kind of wait, wait for it to bubble and then we'll then we'll get on there when we're when we're charged up.
- 55:22Michael Melissinos: But yeah, we I don't know, we got about 30, 40 episodes on there, different, different topics, and they're usually like relevant for the the recent time, like you know, when um the topics of uh around the the the day we we record.
- 55:38Michael Melissinos: So you know, we talk about the tactic.
- 55:40Jerry Parker: We might be using it before um like psych psychology, psychiatry, you know, we're we're counseling each other.
- 55:45Jerry Parker: We we reach a state where we're so frustrated that we get on and do these podcasts.
- 55:48Jerry Parker: But do we also sometimes talk about fantasy hockey?
- 55:51Jerry Parker: We kind of compete against each other in fantasy hockey.
- 55:54Jerry Parker: An adventure that I have dominated over the recent years, but not this year.
- 55:59Jerry Parker: I'm not dominating, so my spreadsheets are letting me down this year.
- 56:02Jerry Parker: But uh do you use a spreadsheet in doing your hockey draft, Mike?
- 56:06Michael Melissinos: No, I'm all intuition.
- 56:07Michael Melissinos: Uh, you just use my inner inner genius at all.
- 56:10Michael Melissinos: Not me, not me.
- 56:12Michael Melissinos: You see, different system, different, different uh you know, Jerry's won, I think, twice.
- 56:19Michael Melissinos: Uh he beat me last year.
- 56:21Michael Melissinos: I came in second last year.
- 56:23Michael Melissinos: So it is also funny too.
- 56:25Michael Melissinos: My dad is also won twice.
- 56:27Michael Melissinos: So we got the two oldest guys.
- 56:30Michael Melissinos: My dad's uh uh 72, Jerry's mid-60s and what it's 67 now, Jerry?
- 56:37Michael Melissinos: 68.
- 56:38Michael Melissinos: 68, and and then we got some guys like around my age, around 40, you know, 30s, 40s, um, that uh that are uh you know trying to get to the top.
- 56:47Michael Melissinos: But it's been me, Jerry, and my dad have been the only people I think that have ever won it.
- 56:51Michael Melissinos: Maybe there's been another winner, but you know, we've been doing it like five, six, seven years now.
- 56:55Michael Melissinos: So it's it's fun.
- 56:56Michael Melissinos: We got a we got a tough league this year.
- 56:58Michael Melissinos: This year's tough for some reason.
- 56:59Michael Melissinos: We'll have to take a look at that.
- 57:01Michael Melissinos: I got I guess hockey's fun.
- 57:03Mark McGrath: Well, I got kicked out of a fantasy football league.
- 57:05Mark McGrath: Somebody dropped out, I was a replacement, but I only did it quantitatively.
- 57:10Mark McGrath: Like whatever whoever was the best, whatever, I just auto-drafted or whatever, and I won two years in a row and I got booted out.
- 57:16Mark McGrath: Wow.
- 57:16Mark McGrath: And I I didn't know the other guys either.
- 57:18Mark McGrath: They were older than me and I didn't get involved in the the shit talking and stuff because I, you know, they weren't my frat brothers from college.
- 57:24Mark McGrath: They were all like close friends.
- 57:26unknown: Right.
- 57:27Mark McGrath: Hey, congratulations on two years, and then get the hell out of here.
- 57:29Mark McGrath: That's what happened.
- 57:30Mark McGrath: But that's funny.
- 57:31Mark McGrath: Well, hey, for your podcast, you know, I'm gonna talk about how to apply the uh how to understand the theories of John Boyd relative to trend falling.
- 57:38Mark McGrath: We got a guy.
- 57:39Mark McGrath: So Okay.
- 57:40Mark McGrath: Happy to happy to keep the conversations going because I I think that really there's uh there's a lot here.
- 57:45Mark McGrath: And I I know that the the people that we interact with from a from a listener base, from a subscriber base in our Substack, this is gonna resonate with a lot of people.
- 57:53Mark McGrath: And I think trend following and the story of the turtles and the story of Trend Falling, the disciplined approach, I think that we'll have a uh I think it'll sit well with a lot of people.
- 58:02Mark McGrath: What do you what do you think, Punch?
- 58:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Oh 100%.
- 58:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean, it aligns perfectly well with what uh Boyd put out there.
- 58:10Michael Melissinos: I like to uh hit on that.
- 58:12Michael Melissinos: You know, next time we talk, I'm gonna hit on that that culture side because uh you know Jerry talked about it in the turtle program, and he's he's said it many times over the years, even he was in this pretend environment where you do the right thing, you lose money, that's okay.
- 58:28Michael Melissinos: That's great.
- 58:29Michael Melissinos: Good job, fellas.
- 58:30Michael Melissinos: You know, just keep doing that.
- 58:32Michael Melissinos: And you know, here in New York, or here, you know, in the in the big boy investment world, no, no, no, no, no, you need to make money all the time.
- 58:41Michael Melissinos: And like if you're losing, you're doing something wrong.
- 58:43Michael Melissinos: Like it's just a totally different planet.
- 58:46Michael Melissinos: And that is is so is such, I believe, an underrated part of uh you know long-term success, is that okay, we'll just keep doing the right things.
- 58:57Michael Melissinos: I'm not I'm not pleased with the recent results.
- 59:00Michael Melissinos: Uh, I don't like this.
- 59:01Michael Melissinos: I don't like to lose, but we're doing the right things and keep doing this, and uh we'll be on the you know, we'll be on the winning side.
- 59:08Michael Melissinos: And again, like what part, what other part do you not want to do?
- 59:12Michael Melissinos: You want to trade against the trend?
- 59:13Michael Melissinos: You want to cut your losses, you want to let your losers ride, you want to bet it all on a few ideas?
- 59:18Michael Melissinos: Like, that's how you die.
- 59:20Michael Melissinos: That's that's not how it works, not how you're gonna succeed long run.
- 59:24Mark McGrath: One thing, you know, you're sitting here talking with two scholars of uh unconventional guerrilla warfare, insurgent warfare.
- 59:30Mark McGrath: It seems to me that trend following is still very much in an insurgent state.
- 59:34Mark McGrath: It's still very much a guerrilla movement within the broader conventional movement of markets.
- 59:39Mark McGrath: And that goes right back to what you talk about, Mike.
- 59:41Mark McGrath: It's it's it's the culture and the philosophy, the belief system of the cognitive space.
- 59:45Mark McGrath: It wins at the moral level, and then everything else will uh will follow, unlike the people that focus on the physical level, like you were saying.
- 59:52Mark McGrath: Did we make money?
- 59:53Mark McGrath: Did you know what what was our performance?
- 59:55Mark McGrath: The people that focus on that are they're disconnected from the mental and the moral realm.
- 59:58Mark McGrath: And that's that's how gorillas win all the time.
- 1:00:00Mark McGrath: That's how insurgents win all the time.
- 1:00:02Mark McGrath: Yep.
- 1:00:03Michael Melissinos: And uh another metaphor is in uh, you know, the spiritual realm, the religious realm of, you know, you got you got your you know, your golden rule, treat others how you want to be treated.
- 1:00:18Michael Melissinos: Okay.
- 1:00:18Michael Melissinos: Good rule.
- 1:00:20Michael Melissinos: Hard to do.
- 1:00:20Michael Melissinos: You know, it's very simple.
- 1:00:21Michael Melissinos: Hard to do.
- 1:00:22Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 1:00:22Jerry Parker: Go ahead.
- 1:00:23Jerry Parker: Ten commandments, good rules, hard to do.
- 1:00:25Jerry Parker: One of the things that I I think I read a book many years ago.
- 1:00:28Jerry Parker: Twenty years ago, I read this book.
- 1:00:30Jerry Parker: I forgot the name of it, but um I came away from reading that book making a promise that I wasn't gonna follow my performance day to day or minute by minute.
- 1:00:39Jerry Parker: And that really helped me quite a bit.
- 1:00:41Jerry Parker: And so I have to pretend sometimes when people ask me, well, how is your fund doing?
- 1:00:45Jerry Parker: How did it do last month?
- 1:00:46Jerry Parker: I have to make something up.
- 1:00:47Jerry Parker: And inevitably, people throughout the year will mention something about performance.
- 1:00:51Jerry Parker: Oh, yeah, you're making money, good job, or you're up a certain percent for the year.
- 1:00:55Jerry Parker: But I think you got to understand your what you need to do to follow this process and be a process driven person.
- 1:01:01Jerry Parker: And that was one of the things that I I never I seldom look at performance.
- 1:01:05Jerry Parker: You know, wow.
- 1:01:05Jerry Parker: Every now and then I look at the markets and I look at the positions and I get a sense whether it's good or bad.
- 1:01:11Jerry Parker: But uh a proper systematic approach should um have some rules as it relates to what to do when the market.
- 1:01:19Mark McGrath: Trevor Burrus, Jr.: Boyd would call that finger spitzen gefuel, that which basically was a translation of a German term, the German military reform movement after Napoleon when they were trying to figure out how we never let this happen again.
- 1:01:33Mark McGrath: And it uh the apex of it was eventually blitzkrieg over those hundred years of study and reform.
- 1:01:38Mark McGrath: But basically, you needed finger spitzen gefuel, which is a fingertip feeling, you know, uh an intuition that's built around Einheit, which was mutual trust.
- 1:01:47Mark McGrath: So we we trust each other, our our team managing the funds, or our team managing clients and having you know the uh the relationship with clients.
- 1:01:55Mark McGrath: So it was uh Einheit, finger spitzen gefuel, and because of trust, we can develop that intuitive feel.
- 1:02:00Mark McGrath: Alftrog, which was contract, which is another way of saying that we're driving on intent, and we understand what the intent is so that we can operate flexibly inside, pursuing that intent.
- 1:02:11Mark McGrath: And then the last part was schwerpunkt or the focus and direction.
- 1:02:15Mark McGrath: Where are we focused and directed together?
- 1:02:17Mark McGrath: And Boyd studied that because he realized that when when facing formidable foes or facing complexity, you had to have those things or else you wouldn't be successful.
- 1:02:26Mark McGrath: And you guys are really good examples of of exactly what they're talking about.
- 1:02:30Mark McGrath: And Einheit, fingerspits a good fuel off trag and schwerpunkt, which uh we might have to put a pin in that one for another another conversation.
- 1:02:37Mark McGrath: But uh but that's just that's really beautifully what you just described in your own way as it relates to trend following.
- 1:02:43Jerry Parker: This is really fascinating.
- 1:02:44Jerry Parker: I've never been on a podcast where I'm learning so much, and I have so much to look into.
- 1:02:47Jerry Parker: Well, you know, um, I want to hear more about this.
- 1:02:50Jerry Parker: Oh, we just touched the surface, man.
- 1:02:52Jerry Parker: Yeah.
- 1:02:52Jerry Parker: We haven't gone deep at all.
- 1:02:54Jerry Parker: No.
- 1:02:55Jerry Parker: How have you how have you guys uh how did you get in involved with uh Boyd?
- 1:03:00Mark McGrath: I'll go first.
- 1:03:01Mark McGrath: So when uh I actually I just found my original notes from 1995 and he was two years from his death.
- 1:03:07Mark McGrath: He died in 1997 from uh an evolution of the art of warfare class, which I took as a sophomore at Marquette University in the Naval ROTC program.
- 1:03:16Mark McGrath: I had a I had a naval ROTC scholarship for the Marine option to become a Marine officer.
- 1:03:20Mark McGrath: And then when we go through all of the training at officer candidate school and the basic school and then our respective areas, you know, Boyd was always a, because he had such impact on our our sort of cognitive, our our cognitive stance towards war fighting, you were given it from a very much of a how and what, not from a why.
- 1:03:41Mark McGrath: And when I when I stepped out of the military originally in medical sales and then, you know, 15 years in asset management, everything that I had been taught kept helping me reframe what it was that I was seeing.
- 1:03:53Mark McGrath: And I noticed that I was looking at everything different than anybody else, particularly in like 08.
- 1:03:58Mark McGrath: Uh, we were on a podcast recently.
- 1:04:00Mark McGrath: I could send you the link, um, where I was out in LA recording and I was interviewed about why I saw things differently in 08.
- 1:04:06Mark McGrath: And the reason was was because I had been grounded in this type of training, this kind of thinking.
- 1:04:11Mark McGrath: Well, I what I realized was I didn't know the whole story.
- 1:04:14Mark McGrath: So I started digging and digging and digging and digging and digging and trying to get to the bottom of really what was behind it.
- 1:04:20Mark McGrath: When I realized was that we weren't just taught a system of thinking to approach combat.
- 1:04:25Mark McGrath: We were actually taught a frame of thinking to approach anything that we do in life that would involve a decision and an action within within complex nonlinear environments.
- 1:04:33Mark McGrath: And I took it on myself to not only pursue that, to learn more and more, but to try to position myself uh to differentiate as a wholesaler.
- 1:04:43Mark McGrath: Hey, I'm not here to push product.
- 1:04:44Mark McGrath: I'm here to show you a different way of thinking that you could apply to markets, you can apply to your client relationships, you can apply to your marketing, your sales, your advertising, et cetera.
- 1:04:52Mark McGrath: That's going to be broadly differentiated, that's gonna help you see what others don't faster.
- 1:04:57Mark McGrath: And that's the that's the journey that uh led me to run into Ponch uh back in, I don't know, 2018, 19, and then eventually going into joining Ponch as a as a business partner and working on these things collaboratively because Boyd was insistent that this not be ossified, that this not be set in stone, that you constantly develop and teach, develop and teach and figure out.
- 1:05:21Mark McGrath: And as you say, Jerry, learn that we're learning, we're learning new stuff from John Boyd every day.
- 1:05:25Mark McGrath: That's how I I wound up through the Marine Corps because the Marine Corps was the one organization that he actually really did have uh an outsized uh influence on.
- 1:05:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'll give you my fluff answer.
- 1:05:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is three things, right?
- 1:05:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's uh naval aviation plus military, and I'll talk about that briefly.
- 1:05:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Complexity theory, and ready for this, psychedelic assisted therapies.
- 1:05:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's how I came to where we are today with John Boyd.
- 1:05:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So military or naval aviation does a horrible job teaching you John Boyd.
- 1:05:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They give you the four-step observer oriented side act.
- 1:05:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's never what it was meant to be.
- 1:05:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It wasn't until I started looking at uh complexity theory 15 years ago, we came across Kanevin, went back, I ended up talking to Chet Richards about complexity theory, saw it in science, strategy, and warfare from uh Francisinga, and really started pulling it apart and go, wait a minute, Boyd was not talking or ever was talking about the military and and warfare with the Oodaloop.
- 1:06:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He was talking about something else, and that something else is the nature of creativity.
- 1:06:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's called it an enacted system, how an agent interacts with its environment.
- 1:06:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what he was trying to figure out.
- 1:06:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what the Oodaloop gave us.
- 1:06:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that pursuit took me through complexity theory and then psychedelic assistant therapy, opened my eyes up to this thing called the free energy principle, which is just basically John Boyd's Oodaloop formalized through math, right?
- 1:06:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's it's what that is at the moment.
- 1:06:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's led us into ecological dynamics, how we interact within sports, or something known as a constraints-led approach, perceptual control theory.
- 1:06:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's all these other connecting tissues, if you will, to John Boyd's work.
- 1:06:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So John Boyd's work is greater than what you can find on the internet.
- 1:06:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, and what you'll find on the internet is a bunch of morons or um charlatans pushing you first you observe, then you orient, then you decide, and then you act.
- 1:06:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, if you provide that to your competition, they're gonna get their ass kicked.
- 1:07:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If you teach the Udaloop like the way you guys are teaching it, and you are, by the way, through trend following, you're gonna dominate.
- 1:07:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you guys brought that up today.
- 1:07:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So appreciate your time.
- 1:07:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, that's been awesome and happy to have other conversations on this.
- 1:07:14Mark McGrath: Our our stance from a business standpoint is basically that successful organizations or successful trend following traders, successful coaches, et cetera, they're already doing these things inherently.
- 1:07:25Mark McGrath: It's the awareness or showing them the awareness around what it is that they're actually doing, then their results actually become geometric.
- 1:07:32Mark McGrath: They act they become they become outsized from even where they're at because they gain a perspective that that their competition won't have.
- 1:07:41Michael Melissinos: Yeah, no, I think that's that's great.
- 1:07:42Michael Melissinos: Um sports too, you know.
- 1:07:45Michael Melissinos: This is why we do it.
- 1:07:46Michael Melissinos: You know, this is what we do, this is why we do it this way.
- 1:07:48Michael Melissinos: You know, that's it's important to know that, especially have that trust internally, especially when um you know things get emotional.
- 1:07:55Michael Melissinos: You have to have like a foundation to, all right, okay, now I I remember.
- 1:07:59Michael Melissinos: This is what we do, and just keep at it sort of stuff.
- 1:08:02Mark McGrath: Keep at it, never quit, never uh never give up the ship and have a smile on your face going into combat.
- 1:08:08Mark McGrath: You know, and marines have a very sick sense of humor.
- 1:08:11Mark McGrath: Things like market fluctuations or whatever, we can we can handle those with a smile on our face.
- 1:08:17Mark McGrath: That's that's kind of the teaching.
- 1:08:18Mark McGrath: But back to the point.
- 1:08:19Mark McGrath: I mean, only successful people actually gr gravitate towards these things because they want to understand why.
- 1:08:24Mark McGrath: Now some don't don't, but then the ones that don't, they're actually our our argument would be that they're actually vulnerable to sudden unpredictable changes in their environment or a competitor that does grasp these things, because a competitor that does grasp these things becomes that gorilla fighter that can topple a an umpire.
- 1:08:41Mark McGrath: So getting getting there faster first.
- 1:08:45Mark McGrath: So anyway, well, for the purposes of the recording, we'll we'll pause here.
- 1:08:50Mark McGrath: We'll no doubt continue this conversation.
- 1:08:52Mark McGrath: We'll make sure that we link to uh your your various sites, certainly the uh the podcast.
- 1:08:58Mark McGrath: We're both really glad to know you and and and and and get to know you better and uh see if we can develop some of these concepts further and uh and show people how they can be successful.
- 1:09:08Mark McGrath: Definitely.
- 1:09:09Speaker 2: Great.
- 1:09:09Speaker 2: Sounds great.
- 1:09:10Speaker 2: Yeah, it's great talking.
- 1:09:11Speaker 2: All right, thanks.
- 1:09:13Speaker 2: Thanks for having us.