Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 319. Open the Portal: The Simple Science Behind Impactful Storytelling
Transcript
- 0:00Portals provide a powerful way for you to begin your communication
- 0:04and engage your audience.
- 0:06My name's Matt Abrahams, and I teach Strategic Communication at
- 0:09Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:11Welcome to Think Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:19Today I'm excited to speak with Troy Campbell.
- 0:21Troy is the chief scientist at the firm On Your Feet, and a former behavioral science
- 0:26professor at the University of Oregon.
- 0:28Previously, he was a Disney Imagineer and a researcher at Netflix Insights.
- 0:32Troy specializes in blending a scientific mind with an artistic heart to understand
- 0:37consumer behavior, storytelling, and the psychology of human connection.
- 0:42Well, welcome, Troy.
- 0:43We have chatted on and off for a long time, and I am thrilled to
- 0:46actually have you in studio and the opportunity to chat with you.
- 0:49Thanks for being here.
- 0:50Long-time listener first-time guest.
- 0:53Very excited to be here.
- 0:54All right.
- 0:54Shall we get started?
- 0:55Let's do it.
- 0:56Uh, I love so many ways you frame things.
- 0:59Uh, you describe story theory as essentially the word because.
- 1:04How does understanding causality improve our storytelling?
- 1:08Yeah, so, um, pretty much if you ask any theoretician of story, about one out of
- 1:15two of them will give you a definition that is more or less the word because.
- 1:19They'll talk about causality.
- 1:21So if you read the book Narrative by Abbott Porter,
- 1:24he's gonna talk about causality.
- 1:26If you talk to the comics professor, Kate Kelp-Stebbins,
- 1:29she's gonna tell you it's causality.
- 1:30If you listen to the South Park creators, they'll talk about how in between every
- 1:35scene, what happens in one scene better cause the next thing to happen, right?
- 1:40And causality is just this foundation that really allows us to anchor what
- 1:47we're trying to do when we're telling stories, which is that characters
- 1:50are changing, and there's something that's causing them to change.
- 1:53And that cause is what's gonna make it a story rather than a bullet point list.
- 1:58I just love the idea of thinking about the change, and that
- 2:02change is because of something.
- 2:05So not all of us are in situations where we have to tell grandiose stories.
- 2:09We're trying to pitch our business, we're trying to get people
- 2:11aligned to what we're saying.
- 2:13Help us understand how we can tell stories in our everyday jobs.
- 2:18Yeah.
- 2:18What we can do is we can say, "You're gonna come into the workplace, and you're
- 2:22gonna share a piece of information." Like, "Here's an action that we want
- 2:26to do," or, "Here's a data point that's really important," and you're
- 2:29gonna explain the because behind it.
- 2:32And once you start saying because, and you say because a couple times, it's
- 2:35gonna transform something into a story.
- 2:39The current sales of this product are down and it's because this thing is happening.
- 2:45And a deeper reason is because the consumer cares about this.
- 2:48And it becomes this real simplified way to tell, in my opinion, what
- 2:53is a story, which is explaining why something has happened, what has caused
- 2:58a character, a set of characters, they could be your consumers, to change.
- 3:03It, it all boils down to that causality.
- 3:06And when you frame it that way, it makes it so much easier to
- 3:09think about how do I, as somebody telling the story, structure it?
- 3:13I first have to introduce the players, the issue, the cause, and then explain
- 3:17the cause that comes from that.
- 3:19So you start by explaining who the characters are and the components,
- 3:23and then the cause that's involved.
- 3:25One of the things that you and I connected on right away is you,
- 3:28like, like I, believe very strongly in frameworks and structure.
- 3:31And you have a great structure that I really like, GIA.
- 3:36Goal, insight, action.
- 3:37Can you tell us a little bit about that structure and how can we use it?
- 3:40Yeah.
- 3:41Um, so goal, insight, action is goal, what your audience cares about.
- 3:44We wanna always start with relevance.
- 3:46That insight is the data, the expertise, the ingenuity, the causality, the,
- 3:54the reasons that you're gonna bring.
- 3:56And action is what your audience can do with it.
- 3:59And if you think about this, you'll actually see it so
- 4:04many times in things, right?
- 4:05It's how Steve Jobs always communicated.
- 4:07He would come up to audiences and, right, of all, all the people in
- 4:10the world, Steve Jobs could just be like, "Hey, Apple, we should do this.
- 4:13We should have this think different campaign." But instead he comes up and
- 4:16he says, "The goal we have in the 1990s at Apple is that we need to stand out
- 4:21again, that we aren't resonating." And the insight, and he says this with his hands,
- 4:26like that's always how he would talk.
- 4:28You, you're dressed in black.
- 4:29I'm having a moment here.
- 4:29Yeah, I know.
- 4:30I know.
- 4:31Uh, my lady said I looked a little Steve Jobs when I came over here.
- 4:34Um, and he would be like, "My insight is that marketing is about values. And
- 4:39in a world that's really busy, how you stand out is focusing on values," right?
- 4:44And then he says, "So the action, what we're gonna take, is we are gonna have the
- 4:48Think Different campaign, which is gonna focus on our core value that we believe
- 4:52in misfits. We believe in people who believe that they can change the world."
- 4:56And that structure is just so simple.
- 4:57It, it works, whenever you're talking about data, don't jump to your data.
- 5:01Say, the goal we have at this organization is to reach this consumer
- 5:04or address this fire problem right now.
- 5:08Some insight we have about the consumer, about this moment is this, and the action
- 5:12that we can take to deal with it is this.
- 5:14And we teach organizations this structure, and they love not only the
- 5:18structure, but they love using the words because it creates sort of this
- 5:22collective also culture where they can signpost to their audience 'cause
- 5:26they've both been trained to receive and deliver in goal, insight, action.
- 5:29And it can just be a wonderful personal habit, but also group habit.
- 5:33Goal, insight, action, I think, is a fantastic structure.
- 5:36And what it allows you to do, the goal is often something that's commonly
- 5:40shared or based on a value or your mission that's already shared.
- 5:43So you're already halfway there because you're tapping into something
- 5:47that people already believe in and then you're further focusing it.
- 5:50And, and like any structure, I think with a little practice and ingenuity,
- 5:54this can be a really useful tool.
- 5:56Yeah.
- 5:56And the one thing I would say is, like, the goal may be the most important
- 6:01part of goal, insight, action, and it's that even if people have that goal,
- 6:06it's not always active in their brain.
- 6:08And so you need to remind people that that is what's important, right?
- 6:14Um, they might even tell you, "I know that already," but they're, it wasn't, they
- 6:18really didn't know that in the moment, and those motives were not activated.
- 6:22So make sure you always, before you're communicating, if you can,
- 6:26even if it's just one sentence, repeat the goal that they have
- 6:30that you are gonna help them with.
- 6:32A, a goal, I like to say, is a focusing, has a focusing function.
- 6:35It helps you focus.
- 6:36It helps you frame the discussion and highlighting that.
- 6:39And assuming people understand it, and maybe some people say,
- 6:41"I already got the goals," still state it, and very good advice.
- 6:45You've developed research on identity persuasion and solution aversion.
- 6:50I had to practice saying that several times 'cause I, I slur the words together.
- 6:54When an audience is highly resistant to the truth due to solution
- 6:59aversion or flight from the facts, uh, as you like to say, how does
- 7:04a, how do we as a communicator restructure our message to avoid this?
- 7:08Yeah.
- 7:09So Solutions can be very aversive.
- 7:13And because of these solutions, we will often deny that there's even a problem or
- 7:20that we need to engage in that solution.
- 7:22And I often like to think of solutions aversions as coming from two areas.
- 7:27So one is our tangible things and one are more identity based things.
- 7:32So a tangible thing could be just like, "I don't wanna stop drinking
- 7:36caramel frappuccinos." Right?
- 7:38And when a doctor diagnosed me with these blood sugar problems when I
- 7:41was younger, it was like I had a big Frappuccino on my forehead and like,
- 7:45"Deal with this issue or I'm not gonna believe any of the science you're
- 7:48telling me about my health issue."
- 7:50And one of the things that he did, Dr. Manuel Fernandez, is the very
- 7:53first thing he did is he told, is he's like, "Here's how your diet is
- 7:57not going to be as bad as you think it was." So before all the science
- 8:02and all the stuff, he was managing my solution aversion that I'd have to that.
- 8:07Now the second thing, and, um, this is the one that's gonna get into one
- 8:10of my favorite kind of storytelling principles, is identity, right?
- 8:15And oftentimes really what we wanna be as people is we don't wanna have
- 8:19our identity threatened and we wanna do things that feel authentic, right?
- 8:24And so if somebody is telling you to change your behavior to be more
- 8:32healthy in your behaviors, or you want to, or they're telling you to be more
- 8:36creative, or they're trying to tell you to tell storytelling, they might even
- 8:40think, "You know, that does sound like a good idea, but that's not who I am.
- 8:45That's not me." And so one of the things I really like bringing into
- 8:49this situation is something I worked on in my dissertation and that I
- 8:52now call the destiny narrative.
- 8:54And so the idea behind this is that in all great stories, characters change, but they
- 8:59go through a very specific type of change.
- 9:01They change into who they were always meant to be.
- 9:04The princess was secretly always the princess.
- 9:07The boy on Tatooine looking up at the twin sons longing for more always had
- 9:11the force inside of him, and Moana was always meant to sail across the seas.
- 9:15And we really, really like this thing not only in these stories,
- 9:19but it works in marketing, right?
- 9:20Unleash your inner goddess.
- 9:22There's a warrior inside of you.
- 9:24So the idea is that we are changing, but we're changing more into who we
- 9:29always were meant to be or who we already are, and it resolves these
- 9:33two psychological motives that are so in conflict all the time, right?
- 9:37I want to improve.
- 9:41I wanna have goal progress.
- 9:43I do kinda wanna change.
- 9:47But at the same time, I wanna be authentic.
- 9:49I wanna be me.
- 9:50I wanna have some sense of identity consistency.
- 9:53And what the destiny narrative does, it is allows for you to stay true and
- 9:59have narrative change at the same time.
- 10:01So whenever I'm trying to persuade people to change, I don't tell
- 10:05them storytelling is good.
- 10:06The very first thing I do is prove to them that they're already a storyteller.
- 10:10And so now all you wanna do is you wanna do more of that because
- 10:13you wanna do more of who you are.
- 10:15You might not be eating healthy, but there are some habits that
- 10:17you have that are already healthy, and that's important to you.
- 10:20So eating healthy now is more consistent with who you are.
- 10:24So much richness in that response.
- 10:26So let me break it down from what I'm taking away.
- 10:28Uh, solution aversion, resistance, hesitation, concern that people bring can
- 10:33be focused on something very tangible.
- 10:36There's something I like doing or don't like doing and you're
- 10:39threatening me because you're saying I should or shouldn't do that.
- 10:42And a great way to address that is to immediately address that resistance.
- 10:46This it's not as bad as you think or they're, you're, you're
- 10:49well-equipped to deal with this.
- 10:51So address the emotion, the concern before you layer on all
- 10:54the things that need to be done.
- 10:55And, uh, as you were saying that, I was reflecting on my parenting and how poorly
- 10:59I did because I would always lead with, "Here are all the things you have to do.
- 11:01And oh, by the way, you can do it." Uh, vice versa would be helpful.
- 11:06And then the other part with the identity piece and part of what I
- 11:09heard you say there, what's, what's so important is this notion of consistency.
- 11:13You're showing that you're already there or you have that ability,
- 11:16and having people reflect on that.
- 11:17So as we go to persuade, motivate, inspire, thinking about those areas of
- 11:22resistance that, that, uh, challenge or solution aversion, and then thinking
- 11:26about the tangible and identity issues that play out can help us restructure
- 11:30the narrative to motivate people more.
- 11:33That's fantastic.
- 11:34One of the things that you teach and talk about that has fundamentally
- 11:38changed the way I teach and think about my communication
- 11:41is through the lens of portals.
- 11:43When you talked about portals, and I'd like you to define for all of us
- 11:46what they mean, uh, it really changed the way I think about how I start and
- 11:50how I move through my communication.
- 11:53Can you educate us all on what you mean by portals and how we can apply that?
- 11:56Yeah.
- 11:56So my definition of portal is about how to begin an experience.
- 12:02And the idea is, is that a portal is a way to transition people into an
- 12:07experience where the point of it is, is that you are getting them ready for the
- 12:13most important parts of the experience.
- 12:16So you might start with a bang, but you really don't.
- 12:19You just need to slowly transition people into it.
- 12:23And a lot of this is based upon Walt Disney Imagineering, and they
- 12:27actually use the word portal to describe how to begin experiences.
- 12:32So when you are walking into the Disney park, you go through a tunnel, and that
- 12:37tunnel even says, like, you're leaving the current space you're in, and you're
- 12:41going into fantasy tomorrow and the past.
- 12:44And that transition time inside of that tunnel and knowing the direction
- 12:50in which you're heading allows you to sort of start transitioning.
- 12:54And then when you go on each of the rides, they have these ways in
- 12:58which they ease you into the story that is different for each ride.
- 13:03So in Buzz Lightyear, that is a ride where you're gonna be on the ride and you're
- 13:07gonna be shooting this little laser gun.
- 13:09So the portal into that is a cartoony intro in which Buzz Lightyear gives you
- 13:13a pep talk and they show you the targets.
- 13:16It's silly, high energy, very focused, right?
- 13:20And you can think of, like, a creativity warm-up.
- 13:22They're like, "We're gonna be really active later in
- 13:24this meeting," so we do that.
- 13:26But the portal into Haunted Mansion is very different because Haunted Mansion
- 13:31is a passive ride in which you're gonna go through a haunted mansion
- 13:35and you're gonna look around and you're supposed to look for details.
- 13:38And so the way that introduces you is you walk through a graveyard noticing
- 13:42silly little jokes on the tombstones, and then you get in the stretching elevator
- 13:47where your ghost host literally tells you to look in different directions.
- 13:51And so it's facilitating you into those things.
- 13:54And what they're doing in these portals is they're doing three general psychological
- 14:00things that are overlapping but distinct.
- 14:02One, it's creating anticipation for what's to come.
- 14:06Second, it's getting you in the mindset shift, in the specific
- 14:10mindset you're supposed to be in that.
- 14:12And the third is it's previewing the narrative for that experience.
- 14:18So it's not telling you the whole story, but it's giving you enough
- 14:22into the narrative that you're ready to be going, what Melanie Green
- 14:25would call narrative transportation.
- 14:28I think this is such a powerful idea.
- 14:30Many of us in our communication, especially high-stakes communication,
- 14:33we focus on what's the message we want.
- 14:35We don't think about how do we bring people to that message.
- 14:38And there are lots of ways to do it.
- 14:40You can think about the calendar invite you send out.
- 14:43That can be a beginning.
- 14:44As you mentioned, in a meeting, you can have some kind of icebreaker or
- 14:48activity to warm people up, as long as it's somehow connected to what comes.
- 14:52What drives me nuts is where you do some kind of icebreaker, and then
- 14:54the next task is totally unrelated.
- 14:56It's whiplash almost.
- 14:57It, it's, yeah, bad.
- 14:58The point of it is we need to activate the right parts of the brain or the
- 15:02right memories for the task at hand, and that's the point of a start.
- 15:06Yeah.
- 15:07And I liked, you know, I, I played with, uh, the three components of what a good
- 15:11portal does to, to make it alliterative.
- 15:12It's the triple A. It's anticipation.
- 15:15It's approach.
- 15:16And then I couldn't come up with anything besides altitude.
- 15:19It tells you what, what level we're coming.
- 15:22So, and you can do this not just at the beginning of, of your communication, but
- 15:27often in meetings you might need a portal to bring you into another topic or area.
- 15:31I challenge everybody listening to think about how can we look at this
- 15:36idea of portal, setting people up to be successful in a way that really helps.
- 15:42You know, at the beginning of this show, I try to do that, where I give
- 15:45a little bit of introductory idea to help people orient to what it is.
- 15:48I really appreciate that.
- 15:50And, and Troy, I've appreciated everything.
- 15:51We'll be right back to finish our conversation.
- 15:54But first, a quick word from one of our sponsors.
- 15:56Their support allows us to bring you this show free of charge.
- 16:00One of my favorite things about this show is hearing from
- 16:02listeners all over the world.
- 16:04Communication connects us, and the more people you can communicate
- 16:08with, the bigger your world becomes.
- 16:10So many of you are collaborating internationally, working across cultures,
- 16:15or simply trying to connect more deeply with people around the world.
- 16:18That's one reason I've been thinking more and more about language learning.
- 16:22Babbel focuses on helping you have real conversations with real people,
- 16:26not just memorized vocabulary.
- 16:28Their lessons are designed by more than 200 language experts and built
- 16:32around practical communication skills you can actually use in everyday life.
- 16:37And because the lessons are short and approachable, it's easy to
- 16:40fit them in a busy schedule.
- 16:42Just 10 minutes a day can help you make meaningful progress.
- 16:46If you've ever thought about learning a new language, this is
- 16:49the perfect opportunity to start.
- 16:51Right now, Babbel is offering up to 60% off your subscription at babbel.com/tfts.
- 16:59Before we get started, a quick reminder to make sure you're following our show
- 17:02in whatever app you're listening to.
- 17:05This is the best way to help our show grow and to make sure
- 17:07you never miss an episode.
- 17:09And now a word from our sponsors.
- 17:11Their support helps us bring you this show free of charge.
- 17:15Over the course of my career, I've had the privilege of working with
- 17:17some truly amazing coaches, and I've also spent years coaching others.
- 17:22And I can tell you firsthand, coaching makes a real difference.
- 17:26That's why I really appreciate what Strawberry.me is doing.
- 17:30Strawberry.me makes coaching more accessible, affordable, and global.
- 17:35Whether you wanna become a stronger communicator, a more confident leader,
- 17:38or simply more intentional in your career, having the right coach in your
- 17:41corner can make an enormous difference.
- 17:44Visit strawberry.me/smart and take 50% off of your first session, and make
- 17:50sure you let them know Matt sent you.
- 17:52And now, back to our conversation.
- 17:54As you well know, we always end by asking three questions.
- 17:57One I make up just for you, and the other two I've asked everybody, and I'll
- 18:00be curious to get your answers to that.
- 18:02Are you up for this?
- 18:02Let's do it.
- 18:03All right.
- 18:03So question number one, What's the best piece of communication
- 18:07advice you've ever received?
- 18:09Um, so the best piece of communication advice for me, it really was tailored
- 18:15well to me, uh, came from one of my advisors in graduate school, Dr.
- 18:19Peter Ubel, and let me set this up.
- 18:21So I gave my talk on my dissertation, and I went in and he sat me down and
- 18:26he said, "Troy, you're one of the most joyful people I've ever met. Your name
- 18:31even rhymes with joy. Uh, you sign your emails 'Enthusiastically, Troy,' every
- 18:38time, and your dissertation is literally about why people enjoy things." And for 20
- 18:46minutes I never saw you smile once, right?
- 18:50And telling somebody to smile is not always the best advice, but for me it was.
- 18:55Like, part of why people like engaging with me is that I
- 18:58really love these things.
- 19:00I'm the behavioral scientist who worked at Disney Imagineering.
- 19:03People want that energy and that joy.
- 19:06I'm literally delivering them on science.
- 19:08And so it's great advice for me, but it's also, like, who you are and
- 19:12what you are delivering, when you can match that, it works really well.
- 19:16Yeah, so striving for congruence between how you feel about something and how
- 19:20you deliver are really important.
- 19:22And, and I'm glad you got that advice because you do, uh,
- 19:25radiate joy and excitement.
- 19:27Um, question number two, who's a communicator that you admire and why?
- 19:31So one person who I really, really like in that space is Bong Joon Ho.
- 19:36He is the director of the Oscar-winning film Parasite, and also other films
- 19:40like The Host and Snowpiercer, and he is so good at using direction.
- 19:46So in the movie Parasite, uh, if you've seen it, the rich people live
- 19:50on the hill and the poor people live literally down the hill and in the
- 19:54basement, and he uses that up and down constantly for storytelling purposes.
- 19:59In Snowpiercer, it's a movie that takes entirely place on a train, and
- 20:04so one direction is always the back of the train, one direction of frame
- 20:08is always the front of the train.
- 20:09It's a metaphor, but it's also spatial and it's so wonderful.
- 20:14And after watching a video essay by Every Frame a Painting on the movie Snowpiercer,
- 20:19I was just like, "I should just be using space for everything I do." And so I
- 20:24used to be a person who walked around on stage, but just to bring energy.
- 20:27Now I walk, and when I move between parts of my story I now am in a new position.
- 20:33I'll assign different parts of the stage.
- 20:35Sometimes when I'm being more avant-garde, it's like this is, this
- 20:38is the scientific mind part, and this is the artistic heart part, and
- 20:41this is just me in the middle, Troy, telling you how I actually feel, right?
- 20:45And just the ability to use space to tell story is amazing, and it's
- 20:50just so wonderful to watch movies 'cause I get new ideas all the time.
- 20:54I like that idea of, of observing other forms of communication to teach you,
- 20:58uh, how to be better, but that use of space is really important because you're
- 21:02signaling and sending lots of information.
- 21:04Human beings are wired to pay attention to space, uh, and location, and doing
- 21:10that consciously I think adds a lot.
- 21:12And, and I really appreciate that you do a nice job of bringing
- 21:15science and art together.
- 21:17Final question, what are the first three ingredients that go into a
- 21:20successful communication recipe?
- 21:22Yeah, so, uh, since we've been talking about, a lot about storytelling,
- 21:26I'll do mine that's based on that.
- 21:27And it's cause, character, and change, right?
- 21:31And just those together is really simple.
- 21:33If you're like, "Oh, I need to make this data presentation more important,"
- 21:37okay, what are my characters?
- 21:38What's causing them to act?
- 21:39What can we do to then change?
- 21:40If you're stumbling on just, like, a story about your own past, it's
- 21:44like, okay, what caused me to change my mind about something, right?
- 21:50And all of a sudden you have a story.
- 21:53It's just three little tiny bits of things that can do so much.
- 21:57Cause, character, change.
- 21:58You know I'm gonna love it 'cause it's alliterative.
- 22:00Interestingly I don't know that the order of that matters if you're
- 22:04trying to get it, uh, to initiate a story or move a story forward.
- 22:07But you need the three ingredients together.
- 22:08Yeah.
- 22:09And our, so our brains can, our brains understand narrative causal structures,
- 22:15and they don't need to be told in order.
- 22:18And, uh, my friend James Antony does a lot of neuroscience research, and how
- 22:22he, he finds how people connect things and remember things and pair things in
- 22:27the brain based upon causal connections.
- 22:29So if you're watching something, you can watch, you know, a episode of Friends
- 22:34and they're, you put all your, "Okay, this character is in this plot, and I'm
- 22:39connecting it here, and I'm connecting these plots." Or you can watch an
- 22:42episode of, like, How I Met Your Mother that's often told out of order, but
- 22:46your brain can put that all together.
- 22:48Your brain is obsessed with understanding characters.
- 22:54It's a social, you're a social creature, and it processes things in logics.
- 23:00And so when you have characters in logical causations, you're just
- 23:04gonna reach the brain so well.
- 23:06So well put, as was everything that you shared.
- 23:09Troy, thank you for your time.
- 23:10Thank you for your insights, and thank you personally for
- 23:13impacting the way I communicate.
- 23:15Awesome.
- 23:15Well, it has been great to be on this, and, uh, I love what you do here.
- 23:20I love that you also create some of the best type of content that we
- 23:24can deliver to our students, right?
- 23:26You can start a class with a clip from your podcast and really get a ton
- 23:31of information and get the students excited to engage in something.
- 23:34Well, thank you.
- 23:34I appreciate that.
- 23:35Thank you for joining us for another episode of Think
- 23:37Fast, Talk Smart, the Podcast.
- 23:40To learn more about creative ways to communicate, please listen to
- 23:42episode 156 with Scott Doorley.
- 23:45This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 23:50Our music is from Floyd Wonder.
- 23:52With special thanks to the Podium Podcast Company.
- 23:55Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 23:58Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 24:00Also, follow us on LinkedIn, TikTok, and Instagram.
- 24:04And check out fastersmarter.io for deep dive videos, English language
- 24:08learning content, and our newsletter.
- 24:10Please consider joining our Think Fast, Talk Smart Learning Community
- 24:13at fastersmarter.io/learning.
- 24:16You'll find video lessons, learning quests, discussion boards, my AI
- 24:19coach, and book club opportunities.
- 24:22Again, that's fastersmarter.io/learning to become part of our Think
- 24:26Fast, Talk Smart Community.