Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Missing 411: the rest of the information
Transcript
- 0:00From the unexplained to the mundane, come join us on a journey to the fringe.
- 0:14Hello and welcome to Journeys to the Fringe, where our research is generally better than
- 0:18the assholes we cover.
- 0:20And somehow they're the ones that make a career of this.
- 0:22Go fish here.
- 0:25We are your slightly salty podcast hosts, Taylor and Chelsea here continuing on with
- 0:30one of these said researchers, David Politis.
- 0:33If you didn't listen to part one, there's some stuff you should know, I think, before
- 0:38we continue on.
- 0:39So please go back and listen.
- 0:40Long story short, he technically was a cop.
- 0:43He says he retired.
- 0:44I shouldn't say technically a cop.
- 0:46He was a cop.
- 0:47He says he retired.
- 0:49Technically I guess you could say that, but more accurately he was definitely fired.
- 0:53Yeah, there's a difference.
- 0:54Before doing uncoply behaviors, I think is a good way to put it.
- 0:58And we'll just continue from here.
- 1:00Yeah, I just want to say that was a harsh reality that you started off with.
- 1:05We could be doing better.
- 1:09To me, I think our last episode on David Politis is probably the most important one
- 1:14because that's not what you're hearing talked about.
- 1:17All the other stuff that I'm going to talk about today about him being an excellent researcher,
- 1:22an excellent person, is going to be a really short episode.
- 1:24It's just going to be debunking of the Missing 411.
- 1:29What we talked about in the previous episode about his police brutality, in his, what was
- 1:34it referred to of, solicitation that he got actually fired for.
- 1:39To me is the bigger thing.
- 1:41But yeah, today we're just going to tackle Missing 411, so let's just jump right into
- 1:45it.
- 1:46According to Politis, his work on the subject began when he was doing research in the National
- 1:50Park and an off-duty Park Ranger found him an expressed concern about the questionable
- 1:55nature of some of the missing person cases that occurred in the parks.
- 2:00What was he doing that a Park Ranger is like, you know, I got to go to David Politis.
- 2:05He's the guy who could break this.
- 2:07I assume, so the Ranger, he says, knew Politis's background and asked him to research the issue.
- 2:12No, he did not know his background.
- 2:15I assume the background that he's talking about is Bigfoot.
- 2:20Not the police brutality, solicitation, and the one.
- 2:23Yeah, you hear those stories.
- 2:24You're like, oh, this guy needs to, you know what, maybe he's like, this guy needs something.
- 2:29I'm going to give him something.
- 2:31Yeah, he didn't even know who he was.
- 2:33He was just like that guy right there.
- 2:35Oh, that poor guy.
- 2:36That guy looks like he needs something to do.
- 2:38I assume it's Bigfoot.
- 2:40So just in specul- speculizing, speculat-ationing, making speculation.
- 2:47Speculatorying.
- 2:48I think it's speculating.
- 2:52Already someone who's into Bigfoot and would know David Politis about Bigfoot and the speculation
- 2:57is of course that it was about Bigfoot.
- 3:00But this guy, if that's what he's knowing him for, he's already a Bigfoot person.
- 3:05I'm a Bigfoot person.
- 3:07I'm into the paranormal things in life.
- 3:09That's already what this guy's going to him with, right?
- 3:12So he already is like of that mind going to Politis with this.
- 3:16And I feel like Bigfoot people, they don't want to know the outside bad stuff about other
- 3:22Bigfoot people.
- 3:23They just want to focus on the good stuff together.
- 3:25Yeah, the good stuff about Bigfoot.
- 3:28So Politis is like out of the goodness of my heart, of course I will, and asserts that
- 3:33he uncovered multiple lines of evidence suggesting negligence on the part of the park service
- 3:40in failing to locate the missing people suggesting that there is some sort of cover-up happening.
- 3:45This asserts that there are specific criteria in the missing person cases that must be met
- 3:50in order to be considered by him in the missing 411 cases.
- 3:54I started to develop some things that I call profile points.
- 3:58And those are things that come up time and time again on these cases.
- 4:02They are.
- 4:03They're rural disappearances.
- 4:05There's no suspects on the case.
- 4:07No history of mental illness.
- 4:09Can't be voluntarily disappeared.
- 4:11Can't be A.
- 4:12I wonder how often it comes up that he's like deep into researching a missing person and
- 4:18it's like, oh wait, they wanted to disappear.
- 4:21I just drop it.
- 4:22I'm going to go on a limb after doing all this research and say that doesn't happen.
- 4:29Not to spoil anything.
- 4:31They can't be voluntary disappearances.
- 4:34No evidence of animal attack.
- 4:37Back of ascent of canine puppies for a scent trail, missing clothing or shoes, older fields
- 4:43and berries are somehow related.
- 4:46Right.
- 4:47I forgot he did the berries stuff.
- 4:49Yeah, the berries.
- 4:50Bad weather found near creeks or bodies of water occur between 4 to 5 p.m. or slightly
- 4:56later.
- 4:57If found alive, they're found unconscious or semi-conscious.
- 5:00And when questioned, they can't remember details about the event.
- 5:03Low grade fevers are often involved and they're most often found in an area that had already
- 5:08been searched.
- 5:09So, he brought in his investigation to include missing people from across the world and this
- 5:15led to his belief that he hasn't covered a mysterious series of worldwide disappearances,
- 5:20which he said defied logical and conventional explanations.
- 5:25There are now 10 missing 411 books, 3 missing 411 documentaries, one of which is called
- 5:32Missing 411 the UFO Connection, which I find weird that has to be the closest he's ever
- 5:37come to saying it's something.
- 5:39So I was shocked to see that.
- 5:41So we've got Eastern United States, unexplained disappearances of North Americans that have
- 5:46never been solved, Western United States and Canada, unexplained disappearances of North
- 5:51Americans that have never been solved, North America and beyond.
- 5:55That's its own North American beyond.
- 5:57The Devils and the Details, a sober and coincidence, Hunters, Off the Grid, Law, Canada and Montana.
- 6:05Those are all the books.
- 6:06I probably said that really weird so it sounds like all one book, but they're all different
- 6:10books.
- 6:11They're all 10 of them I just named.
- 6:13You can't see the points that I have.
- 6:15You're probably thinking now like this sounds very mysterious.
- 6:19What way is this guy gonna take this?
- 6:21I don't know.
- 6:22I mean go listen to his interviews.
- 6:23You can see where he takes it yourself.
- 6:25This is not what this podcast is, that's just telling you what he's up to.
- 6:29He's already covered that.
- 6:30Yeah, he's covered it.
- 6:32I've covered what Nassaly is in the first one.
- 6:34Now let's just check out the critiques of his work.
- 6:37Probably one of the biggest ones is that people go missing for various reasons and just are
- 6:42plain never found.
- 6:44Everywhere.
- 6:45It doesn't have to be paranormal means.
- 6:48I want to think it is personally, but the odds are so minuscule that it's actually something
- 6:53paranormal.
- 6:54Yeah.
- 6:55I happily accept that it's aliens, reptilians, boulder rock people.
- 7:02The options are limitless and that's what is so appealing to these people because he's
- 7:07not to me and these people because he doesn't say.
- 7:12So your mind just wanders like crazy.
- 7:14It's like a horror movie where they never show the bad ghost, right?
- 7:18Like you can think of how scary it is, but the minute they show it, it's like, oh that
- 7:21sucks.
- 7:22But it is really where all more movies lose their rewatch value is what they actually
- 7:26are.
- 7:27Oh yeah, when you show them monster.
- 7:29Reasons for going missing in real life and probably most of his cases can include an individual
- 7:36deliberately wanting to disappear to find a new identity, falling or a sudden health
- 7:40crisis leading to a lone person becoming immobilized off trail, drowning, a bear or other animal
- 7:47attack, environmental exposure or even deliberate disappear.
- 7:52I just said that they make him up again.
- 7:54Sorry.
- 7:55In advance for anything that comes up more than once.
- 7:58I do what I can.
- 8:00These cases are not outside the frequency that one would expect or that there is anything
- 8:05unexplainable that I was able to identify.
- 8:07They're just regular missing persons cases, which I admit I am compelled by as well.
- 8:13Just like unsolved mysteries.
- 8:14You love it because there's no answer.
- 8:17And I'm sorry to say love it because these are people who have families who are actually
- 8:21it been impact dealing with this.
- 8:24So I hate to say it that way.
- 8:25I'm sorry.
- 8:26But there's a huge market for true crime and stuff like that.
- 8:31And it's it's very popular.
- 8:33There's something about not knowing the answer.
- 8:36Exactly.
- 8:37Not only that, there's a huge market for not having an answer.
- 8:41Oh yes.
- 8:42And presenting it as being mysterious.
- 8:44People want to know.
- 8:46They want to know what the end result is.
- 8:48They want closure when it comes to these things.
- 8:51So there's something that's very fascinating.
- 8:52I don't think with happened to this person.
- 8:54I think in the unsolved persons or missing persons entire podcast genre, they don't want
- 9:00to know the answer.
- 9:01They just want to be able to speculate or think about all the different possibilities.
- 9:05They don't want an actual.
- 9:07In the end, that's Eva Plato's job.
- 9:10Another big critique is the fact that people have independently looked into some of his
- 9:15account and found major flaws that polite us does not correct.
- 9:20Details like polite us claiming a person was never found.
- 9:23But there are newspaper reports that the person was found a short time later.
- 9:27Our polite is claiming no one knows why a person went missing when the missing person
- 9:32contacted the news family or police to state why they ran off.
- 9:36Some of the reasons people have given for going missing include avoiding abusive relationships.
- 9:41Tired of being around host guests that overstay their welcome.
- 9:47And so on.
- 9:49So the fact that David Pallatus constantly tries to play up the paranormal angle is a
- 9:55much lesser problem than the fact that you can't trust his version of events that are
- 9:59being put forth by him.
- 10:01Just a speculation on my part that this could be why he's self publishing because he's
- 10:07not actually publishing correct facts.
- 10:10And then just nobody wanted to publish it.
- 10:13Yeah, not that it was wrong that they didn't want to publish it.
- 10:17True.
- 10:18I mean, I mean, you're going to have to factor it.
- 10:20But yeah.
- 10:21Yeah.
- 10:22And also, yeah, there's no actual editor involved in his process.
- 10:24I don't think either.
- 10:25So nobody reviewing his research.
- 10:27If he doesn't want it, then he doesn't have to have it.
- 10:30A blog from one of the largest missing persons website on the internet.
- 10:34Yep.
- 10:35Are there non-internet blogs now?
- 10:38There are non-internet websites.
- 10:41Yes.
- 10:42Okay.
- 10:43I assume that's the newspaper.
- 10:46Largest missing persons website reviewed one of the books in 2012.
- 10:50They said some interesting things like the children being found impossibly far away.
- 10:55But they also point out that it's never mentioned by David that two cases are thought to be serial
- 11:00killer victims.
- 11:01That would be both Thomas Bowman and Bruce Kremen, two of the people profiled in the book
- 11:06and they are presumed victims of the serial killer, Mac Ray Edwards.
- 11:10A fact, Pallatus fails to mention or correct.
- 11:13Some of Pallatus's cases also go back a century or more, which would mean that some of those
- 11:18people are not listed with law enforcement or on missing persons databases anywhere,
- 11:24which is something he really gloms onto that there's no list or anything that he can find
- 11:29in.
- 11:30So he's independently doing all this research himself.
- 11:33If you go back that far, we're talking about Pinkerton was just coming up with his investigation
- 11:38skills from stumbling across those foragers.
- 11:40No, some of them are that far back.
- 11:43You would know that from listening to literally any interview.
- 11:46He brings up really old cases.
- 11:49Which I mean, if you have anything, you wouldn't be pulling anything from that long ago.
- 11:53Another case where he never discusses the evidence of drug use at the camp where they
- 11:57originated or positive drug screen, a case included in one of his books where a football
- 12:02player was acting weird while drug use was brought up.
- 12:06It's never been brought up.
- 12:07The autopsy showed the victim had CTE, which is a
- 12:12A concussion based brain issue.
- 12:14One of the cases of a missing ranger is showcased on a show called disappeared, showed the ranger
- 12:20to be depressed due to his divorce and life choices.
- 12:23This is someone telling the story.
- 12:24Sorry, I should have said that someone talking here.
- 12:27The person claims he told David this and he said all the reports he had on the case didn't
- 12:31show that the ranger was depressed due to divorce and life choices.
- 12:35So that's another thing.
- 12:36David won't contact survivors because before he wrote the book, he talked to search and
- 12:41rescue people and said, don't.
- 12:43So while he has talked to some relatives, it's not every case disappeared, had several
- 12:47people directly involved in the disappearance speak on camera and didn't just go by reports
- 12:52like David did for the case.
- 12:54Yeah.
- 12:55And when I've seen that he actually interviews family or people involved in the case, it's
- 12:59generally because they disagree with what the reports found.
- 13:03So he wants to use that.
- 13:04Yeah.
- 13:05I actually found a Reddit, good old Reddit that goes through case by case in great detail.
- 13:12There's a lot of them and just tears them apart in absolute detail.
- 13:18They find the original account, Plotus's research, there's charts, news articles, so and so on,
- 13:24lots of information that's just not accurate on David Plotus's part of his reporting.
- 13:29All in all, he misleads on cases, uses inaccurate information and makes bold claims on the case
- 13:35being mysterious based on inaccurate information.
- 13:38For example, going missing and traveling in total darkness during the night versus going
- 13:42missing in the morning, which he says is a criteria of his, which he just ignores.
- 13:48That's just one.
- 13:49So Kyle Pollock did an article looking into the missing 411 books titled, quote, an investigation
- 13:55of the missing 411 conspiracy.
- 13:57He took the book, missing 411, Western United States in Canada and a random number generator
- 14:02and selected several pages of the Hyman's categorical imperative, which is do not try
- 14:07to explain something until you are sure there is something to be explained to start.
- 14:11First off, he found Plotus did not make any disappearances up.
- 14:15Point one, Plotus.
- 14:16Good job.
- 14:17He didn't make anything up.
- 14:18I think that's the first good thing we've actually said.
- 14:21Yeah.
- 14:22It is.
- 14:23Yeah.
- 14:24That should go on his book, did not make anything up.
- 14:26That's a quote.
- 14:30Yet both cases are banal and devoid of any apparently unusual qualities, just random
- 14:36disappearances.
- 14:37But then the author finds these random duties, quote, the oldest victim in my audit involved
- 14:42a 69 year old hiker climbing Mount Shasta, moving alone in wind conditions estimated
- 14:47at 70 miles per hour.
- 14:49Once he split off from his companions, he was never seen again.
- 14:52I was finding these cases to be fairly mundane until I arrived at the hiker's disappearance.
- 14:57Following a deadpan factual reporting of the details, Plotus quotes a local person saying
- 15:02cryptically that according to local legend, beings called Lemurians lived underneath Mount
- 15:07Shasta.
- 15:08Maybe the Lemurians got Carl.
- 15:10The text is decorated sparsely with this and other head scratching non sequit- quitters?
- 15:16Non sequitur.
- 15:18Don sequitur.
- 15:19Just completely unrelated.
- 15:21For example, in the last case of my brief audit, a woman named Amy disappears while
- 15:25exercising.
- 15:26Her body was never recovered, but her wristwatch was found in a riverbed years later.
- 15:31Plotus points out that years after that, a woman named Anne disappeared from the same
- 15:35place.
- 15:36He felt the need to point out that both of their names start with A and their first names
- 15:40only had three letters.
- 15:42I can only presume Plotus is open to the possibility that some nefarious Batman villain is at work
- 15:48in this area.
- 15:49Beware of the three letter killers.
- 15:50I remember that too and he was talking about people going missing in cities and the German
- 15:54background.
- 15:55Yeah.
- 15:56Then you get things like the fact that Barry's and Barry Bush's play a common role in many
- 16:01disappearances is quite intriguing.
- 16:03End quote by Pollock.
- 16:04I'm gonna go more into what he has to say, but he's kinda...
- 16:09I don't know how he's coming to these conclusions of what these people have in common.
- 16:13It's almost like he's looking for anything.
- 16:16Anything that can tie one to another.
- 16:18A's.
- 16:19Literally A's.
- 16:20Literally Barry Bush's.
- 16:21Like, where are you gonna go into a bush and there's not Barry Bush's?
- 16:24Yeah, that's kind of wilderness needs to eat.
- 16:26Yeah.
- 16:27That's true.
- 16:28I'm frankly shocked that Lemuria came up in this episode.
- 16:32Yep.
- 16:33It did.
- 16:34We should end an episode on it if you want to go back.
- 16:37We sure have.
- 16:38We always need to tie another episode into an episode.
- 16:41Palatus describes the pattern of these cases.
- 16:44The pattern consists of some loose criteria such as victims found deceased with clothing
- 16:49removed, pants, shoes, or boots, typically.
- 16:51Easily explained by paradoxical undressing.
- 16:54Taylor brought it up in the last episode.
- 16:55That's the word.
- 16:57This is a condition found in people experiencing hypothermia who feel irrationally hot and
- 17:01remove clothing to cool themselves.
- 17:03Yeah, it's basically when you're about to die, your body releases the heat from the
- 17:07vital organs to the rest of the body, which makes you feel very warm and people get undressed
- 17:12when they're dying of hypothermia in the middle of winter.
- 17:15Very easy to even dive exposure in the middle of summer when you're in the middle of woods
- 17:20for a couple of days when it gets down.
- 17:23We're used to the comfort of our home and stuff like that.
- 17:26And when you don't know how to survive in the wilderness over a few days and you're
- 17:30losing that heat and have nothing to keep you warm, this is what's going to happen,
- 17:34even though it seems illogical for us to want to keep warm.
- 17:38And he's saying there's a big mystery to it.
- 17:40This also applies with the low grade fever that he has as a part of his criteria with
- 17:45the paradoxical undressing.
- 17:47Another is a deceased body recovered but found a distance or elevation away from the last
- 17:52known whereabouts that defies common sense.
- 17:55However, he doesn't talk about alive people that this has happened to.
- 18:00People can move and gain a lot of ground.
- 18:05Yeah.
- 18:06And in fact, they can go to places where people have looked for them.
- 18:10It's just, it's kind of like one of the rules that you're supposed to do when you're lost
- 18:14is not move, but people do it all over brick and time.
- 18:18And that's part of the problem is they end up in tracks and they work again.
- 18:21Yeah, we're going to bring that up as well.
- 18:22He loves to say whatever amount of distance is far.
- 18:26It's against all odds.
- 18:28I don't believe it.
- 18:29It's impossible.
- 18:31Which he uses especially with children.
- 18:33And to back this up, he uses a search and rescue manual to quote that 95% of missing
- 18:38seven year olds are found within a 4.5 mile radius.
- 18:42You still have 5% who are going to be found outside of that 4.5 mile radius.
- 18:47We're not found at all.
- 18:48This means rescuers expect to find some children outside of this radius.
- 18:54Finding a seven year old who traveled 10 to 15 miles is usually more difficult than finding
- 18:58a seven year old who only traveled two miles.
- 19:01Yeah.
- 19:02Well, just think of how much area you have to cover because they could have walked seven
- 19:05miles in any direction.
- 19:06So that just exponentially increases how far you have to go.
- 19:09Yeah.
- 19:10And if a child is not found, we do not know how far they traveled.
- 19:14This means the stats are incomplete regarding how far children walk.
- 19:17That's a fair point.
- 19:18A seven year old walking seven miles is not evidence that there is a missing 4.1.1 abductor
- 19:24in the first place and many children are capable of walking considerable distances.
- 19:29Despite live people doing this, most of these supposedly common self-defying distances
- 19:34polite is mentions are just a few miles.
- 19:37All it goes on to say granted, terrain and conditions have a huge impact on lost hikers.
- 19:42I don't want to dismiss anything outright due to low magnitude, but I don't find anything
- 19:47exceptional in the cases I reviewed.
- 19:50The strangest case I recall was a hiker who was found three days later, 14 miles from
- 19:54his last known location.
- 19:56To me, a hiker, this is not an implausible distance to cover in that time.
- 20:00I just want to say while I'm thinking of it, another one is bad weather around the
- 20:04disappearance, which could also explain why the person is missing in the first place because
- 20:10they get disoriented.
- 20:12There's some freak weather event that happens to
- 20:15Impact the path or the trail.
- 20:17Impact the path of the person who's on the trail.
- 20:20Yes, thank you.
- 20:21Another criterion is to not actually be missing.
- 20:24A minority of cases in the catalogue involved missing people who were recovered alive.
- 20:29Curiously, they all seem to be young children.
- 20:32I suppose an adult gone missing and found can self attest that their missing time was
- 20:36explained by ordinary circumstances.
- 20:39Children may not have the same developmental functions to coherently account for their
- 20:43whereabouts, thus leaving a gap to be filled with the possibility of something unusual.
- 20:47I do believe he talks about a child that says that they were taken by a bear.
- 20:52I was also just going to say that children also lie just all the time.
- 20:56Yes, you've come up before in this podcast.
- 21:00Strangely nuts.
- 21:02They sure do.
- 21:03They make shit up.
- 21:05With such imprecise criteria, it seems Flaity's considers himself the only person fully qualified
- 21:10to identify a missing person's case as belonging to the missing 411 or not.
- 21:15The proposed unusualness of these cases.
- 21:17Wait, Elsie, are missing 411 cases like your criteria for a Fringy Mini?
- 21:21It might be.
- 21:22You know what?
- 21:23It's a good cataloging system, okay?
- 21:26I would not be surprised if someone else is using it.
- 21:32I should trademark it.
- 21:33I should send them a cease and desist.
- 21:36And ask for an autograph too.
- 21:40The proposed unusualness of these cases seems hardly greater than one would find for a rare
- 21:45and unplanned occurrence such as a disappearance.
- 21:47Basically, he's just taking disappearances and putting them into a book.
- 21:52Flaity's relies heavily on look at all these cases, even if one or two explainable, it
- 21:57can all be explainable, which doesn't equal something mysterious happening, unfortunately.
- 22:02No, that also means that you're kind of lazy in how you're putting a book together if
- 22:06you're just throwing them all in and say sure, some of these can be explained.
- 22:10I mean, you see the same thing with UFOs, but surely you can apply the same logic to
- 22:15this.
- 22:16Another point Flaity's makes is that there are disproportionately large amounts of people
- 22:21disappearing from national parks.
- 22:23Turns out, if anything, you're less likely to disappear from a national park than from
- 22:27a major city.
- 22:29Hundreds of thousands and more visit the national parks each year, and in those people visiting,
- 22:34there are a whole lot of dummies.
- 22:35You see them in headlines.
- 22:37They want to pet bison, they want to feed the wildlife, and you know, people want to
- 22:41go on hikes.
- 22:43We really could just make Friggin Minis out of these ridiculous stories and we would
- 22:47never run out of them because people do not know how to act in nature.
- 22:50These are the people going into national parks and of course some of them are going to want
- 22:54to go hiking and they're not going, they're feeding wild animals.
- 22:57Yeah, they heard about it on TV once, they want to try it out.
- 23:00And they're not going to go into the wild, like think about like Grand Canyon National
- 23:04Park, someone's going to be like, I want to hike and they're not prepared for the environment
- 23:08that they're going into.
- 23:09Of course something's going to happen.
- 23:11Yeah, I mean, every time you read a headline that says Florida man and then it's continued
- 23:15from there, that person has the potential to go into a national park and want to go hiking.
- 23:19And go missing.
- 23:21As an aside from this article, I'm giving you this information from which is the Kiopolic
- 23:25one.
- 23:26I'd like to add that on an interview on Midnight in the Desert with Art Bell, great episode
- 23:31actually to listen to.
- 23:32Art Bell actually asked him some good questions.
- 23:34He doesn't know how to answer.
- 23:36Art questions him and says, is this outside of the expected norm?
- 23:40People going missing versus people visiting the park.
- 23:42Are there more disappearances in the parks based on our expectation of national averages?
- 23:48Let's hear the numbers.
- 23:49Take your number of mysterious disappearances, divide the amount of people that visit the
- 23:54parks and do it for North America.
- 23:55What do we get?
- 23:56Lightest says, no, thank you.
- 23:59Just kidding.
- 24:00What he actually says is I'd be playing into their hands by giving you a number.
- 24:06That's literally what he says.
- 24:07At this point, I'd be playing into their hands by giving you a number.
- 24:12There's people that are against him.
- 24:14It's the National Park Service, obviously.
- 24:16Oh, yes.
- 24:17Yeah, there's a conspiracy about them.
- 24:20You know, that's also a part of his misinformed one-munch deck.
- 24:23I thought the whole thing was just they were too lazy to put the list together.
- 24:26I don't know.
- 24:27He really gets it out there that there's a conspiracy with the National Park Service
- 24:32being in.
- 24:33There's a conspiracy about the National Parks because they're finding stairs in the middle
- 24:36of nowhere and not anything.
- 24:38But yeah, he definitely alludes to as well that the National Park Service is in on whatever
- 24:44is going on.
- 24:45So yeah, he won't give a number.
- 24:47So we don't even know if it's like that big of a problem or not.
- 24:51He says it's a huge problem.
- 24:53Back to Pollock, his article.
- 24:55In regards to Politis, claims about exorbitant amounts of money for the National Park Service
- 24:59to provide a list of missing peoples or they don't keep a list.
- 25:03So on and so on.
- 25:04Pollock spoke with a National Park Service Public Affairs representative about the handling
- 25:09of missing persons cases.
- 25:11Cases are entered into the National Law Enforcement Telecommunications System, N-L-E-T-S.
- 25:17This is a federated data sharing system used by law enforcement nationwide.
- 25:22I await proof that any cases failed to be entered.
- 25:25Obviously, the Park Service is going to go to law enforcement in the case that someone
- 25:29is missing or found deceased.
- 25:31Obviously, they have some means to go in and see what's going on.
- 25:34But it's not like they're not going to contact anybody.
- 25:38That actually is of the law and they're not like a governing body of law.
- 25:42So they obviously have people.
- 25:45For the most part, they're making sure that people are staying on trails and driving.
- 25:50Looking after the park.
- 25:51Yeah.
- 25:52Yeah.
- 25:53Like they got another job that isn't search and rescue.
- 25:54Search and rescue does search and rescue.
- 25:56And they're dealing with the idiots trying to feed wild life.
- 26:00They're not going to go searching.
- 26:02Like some of these people are a part of the search and rescue.
- 26:06Yeah, that's the secondary to their actual job there.
- 26:09Obviously, actual law enforcement is where the information is going to be tracked, not
- 26:13through like a list on a piece of paper kept by the Park Service.
- 26:17So I'm actually not sure what Pallatus is looking for here.
- 26:20Now that I think about it too, why would the different national parks need to share this
- 26:24information with each other?
- 26:25Because national parks are big enough that they just deal with people missing in their
- 26:28area.
- 26:29Exactly.
- 26:30And Pallatus is like, oh, well, they keep a list of movies filmed there.
- 26:34And he actually says like the Western National Park Service keeps a list of movies that are
- 26:39filmed there.
- 26:40And it's like Western National Park.
- 26:42So it's almost like they don't have to share that information as well, which would just
- 26:46be for fun.
- 26:47So it's almost like he's just kind of blowing hot air to find something that, you know,
- 26:52people are going to be like, they should be keeping a list.
- 26:55They absolutely should.
- 26:56But like when you look at it logically like that, like no, they shouldn't.
- 26:59It would just be someone like writing down, yeah, this person went missing in this park,
- 27:04in which case I too would charge him exorbitant amounts of money to put that list together.
- 27:10The list goes on with points, but those are the most interesting.
- 27:12The rest are kind of bull claims with nothing to back them up by Pallatus, not Pollak, or
- 27:17simply leaving out facts, whether he's aware of them or not.
- 27:20Pollak says, I won't take the books of gospel.
- 27:22And if any case interests you that Pallatus talks about, hit Google and dig deeper.
- 27:28Missing 411 research boils down.
- 27:30This is not Pollak anymore.
- 27:32It's me.
- 27:33So we're getting to the good stuff.
- 27:38Missing 411 research boils down to Pallatus believing or disbelieving things, not Pallatus
- 27:43collecting evidence and confirming things.
- 27:46He reaches conclusions without sufficient evidence.
- 27:49He beats around the bush saying he won't give an answer.
- 27:52However, it's obvious he's not pointing to anything mundane.
- 27:55He alludes to it being aliens or portals or paranormal of some sort.
- 28:00You think it's because he would also have to put work in like more work to actually
- 28:04give an answer?
- 28:05Or do you think it's the miscreasable support part?
- 28:08He knows the audience.
- 28:10He's on the specific circuit of paranormal.
- 28:14He knows who he's trying to sell these to.
- 28:16Pallatus gives no reason for these disappearances, but finds odd correlations for them, which
- 28:21we already talked about.
- 28:22For example, the Amy and Anne thing.
- 28:26In his analysis, he concludes with, I've exhausted my exploration for anything gen- oh no, this
- 28:31is someone researching.
- 28:32I've exhausted my exploration for anything genuinely unusual.
- 28:36After careful review, to me not a single case stands out, nor do the frequencies involved
- 28:41seen outside of expectations.
- 28:43Is a quote from someone.
- 28:45I'm sorry, you should be named, but you're not.
- 28:50Another belief you're going to like is how he argues against serial killers, which if
- 28:54you remember two of the cases he uses are actually thought to be victims of a serial
- 28:58killer.
- 28:59It's that he lives in Colorado and 80% of the people on trails are armed.
- 29:06This is why it can't be serial killers.
- 29:08That's the reason he gives.
- 29:11Okay.
- 29:12God, he's one of those people too.
- 29:14Oh man, that argument when there's like a school shooting, we need to just have more
- 29:17people with guns.
- 29:18Yeah.
- 29:19He's one of those people, isn't he?
- 29:20It has to be.
- 29:21Like what?
- 29:22Who's going hiking out in the wilderness armed?
- 29:24Can you imagine going on like an all day hike being armed?
- 29:28I mean, we live in Canada, so maybe I'm off on that perspective, but surely this can't
- 29:33be right.
- 29:34Yeah.
- 29:3580% of people on trails are armed.
- 29:38I mean, Americans who listen, you may know better than us, but this just feels wrong.
- 29:43It just feels wrong.
- 29:45If we're out of line here, like please let us know, it just feels so wrong.
- 29:51So this is.
- 29:52Hikers and gun advocates just seem like different groups in my mind.
- 29:56Yeah, that's his reason.
- 29:58A lot of his points he specifically looks at to narrow down his cases can be debunked
- 30:03as well.
- 30:04People found in an area that has already been searched.
- 30:07People do tend to walk in circles if they lost and even circle back.
- 30:10So this is why they're searching most areas more than once in the first place and also
- 30:15why they say stay put if you get lost so somebody can find you and you're not, you know, leaving
- 30:20an area they're about to search.
- 30:22And then you come up behind them.
- 30:24That people are found near bodies of water.
- 30:26Typically people will also seek out bodies of water like rivers to follow when they're
- 30:31lost.
- 30:32And not only that, lots can happen if you're already in water in the first place.
- 30:36You can have a heart attack in the water.
- 30:38You can get a poisonous bug bite.
- 30:40You can slip and fall and hit your head.
- 30:42So much stuff can happen and bam, you're how many miles downstream in water at a ridiculous
- 30:48distance away.
- 30:49And yeah, it's usually easy trail right beside water too.
- 30:53Yep.
- 30:54People like the water.
- 30:55They have to look at it and so on.
- 30:57Things about water.
- 30:58You could go on about water.
- 31:00Exactly.
- 31:03Missing without a trace.
- 31:04Obviously, this is part of the appeal of what he's talking about.
- 31:07However, this is obviously a selection bias when you're looking at national parks, which
- 31:11are huge.
- 31:12You're going to have more people who do actually go missing without a trace than in a city
- 31:17where there's cameras and stuff like that.
- 31:19And it even happens in cities.
- 31:21So you put that in a national park.
- 31:23Obviously it's going to be higher.
- 31:25Additionally, some have criticized the lack of peer reviewed research or scientific worker
- 31:29in his work.
- 31:30Again, he's self publishing.
- 31:32He doesn't have to as well as the absence of transparency regarding his investigative
- 31:37methods.
- 31:38I think we did narrow that down.
- 31:40We're on the same system as the my fringy minis.
- 31:42Great system by the way.
- 31:44Very reliable.
- 31:45If that's not a criticism, that's one of his problems.
- 31:48Yes.
- 31:49The guy loves to not speculate on what it is.
- 31:51I know I've said it before.
- 31:52I think it's for a few reasons, but he says if he does that, if he gives a reason and then
- 31:58he goes and interviews a family member, someone who's gone missing and they see him say it's
- 32:02Bigfoot, his credibility is out the window.
- 32:05Yeah, gone.
- 32:06He says Bigfoot gone.
- 32:07The person won't want to talk to him.
- 32:09I love that argument for him because I'm betting he thinks no one knows why he's actually
- 32:13not a credible person.
- 32:15If they knew about the police brutality, I keep saying it and it's slipping my mind
- 32:20now.
- 32:21Listen to the first episode.
- 32:22Go back if you forgot.
- 32:23I don't have time right now, but that's actually why he's not a credible person.
- 32:28So if I didn't already have you convinced that this guy's a shitty person, I have some
- 32:32stories shared by redditors that I just don't think I have enough time for, but let me share
- 32:36some of the highlights.
- 32:37They don't like that he masquerades as a former police officer doing excellent research
- 32:41when he's used his position to fraudulently obtain something out of it.
- 32:45He doesn't research his case as well, often getting information incorrect, then self-publishes
- 32:50incorrect information and does not correct it.
- 32:53When faced with any criticism say of incorrect information, he gets angry and is quick to
- 32:57fly off the handle.
- 32:59When faced with a question he doesn't want to answer, he tells people to go read the
- 33:03book.
- 33:04It sounds like you haven't read the book and just misses them.
- 33:06He says that a lot on like his interviews that he does.
- 33:09Well yeah, and it's because there's not enough time to actually get into each case.
- 33:13So it's a very easy way to avoid it.
- 33:15And in fact, generally when you see people trying to say in criticism, that's taken
- 33:19out of context.
- 33:20It's so easy to just say and never have to go back.
- 33:23Yeah, that's true.
- 33:24Which leads me to the difficult ego, which I could see him having coming from the positions
- 33:29he's held and situations he's been in.
- 33:32Lacks professionalism, it's a sales job, he's not a dumb guy.
- 33:36He was scamming celebrities, now he is using data presenting it as high strangeness and
- 33:40touring the conspiracy conferences.
- 33:42His books are vanity publishing, he has not been offered a book deal that has ever been
- 33:47mentioned.
- 33:48He's fascinated by the intrigue of 411.
- 33:51People love mysteries, people love true crime.
- 33:54I love Serpo, it doesn't make it true or like anything actually mysterious is going on.
- 34:00And that brings me to the end of David Pilatus.
- 34:05Wow.
- 34:06Yeah.
- 34:07While you were talking to, I looked up his Wikipedia page.
- 34:09Yeah.
- 34:10There's no section for criticism, which really surprised me.
- 34:13And it's a lot of the stuff that really stays under the radar.
- 34:17Wikipedia is one of the best for criticizing things.
- 34:20I know for people in this category.
- 34:23And I find it also funny that it has nothing about his police work on there and him being
- 34:29fired.
- 34:30Outside of like a brief statement.
- 34:32Because this can all easily be sourced to be put onto there and added onto that page.
- 34:39So I found that interesting because Wikipedia is usually on it to debunk something very
- 34:44quickly.
- 34:45Yeah.
- 34:46Right.
- 34:47Yeah.
- 34:48So yeah, Chelsea, thank you for that just because I do, I did like listening to David
- 34:52Pilatus just like he's a, he's a good talker.
- 34:55Even if the stuff he's saying is utter garbage.
- 34:57I know.
- 34:58They usually are to get that far.
- 34:59It makes me think we could probably do a similar thing if we wanted to sell some books because
- 35:05people obviously really like the missing people.
- 35:07All you got to say is we don't know what happened, but it's probably really mysterious.
- 35:11Yeah.
- 35:12Then we just make a book about it.
- 35:14We just got to find the time.
- 35:16Yeah.
- 35:17So we won't do it.
- 35:19Here we are spending our time on actual research into these horrible people.
- 35:23You're welcome.
- 35:25Yes.
- 35:26And with that, Chelsea, thank you very much for this episode.
- 35:29I have been Taylor here with Chelsea.
- 35:31We are Journey to the Fringe.
- 35:33Thank you all for listening and we'll see you next week.
- 35:34Bye.
- 35:35Okay.
- 35:36You were a cop for 20 years.
- 35:3820 years.
- 35:40Regular cop?
- 35:41I worked street crimes, detectives, SWAT team.
- 35:45Okay.
- 35:46Yeah.
- 35:47Three or four different detective units.
- 35:48Regular cop.
- 35:49All right.
- 35:50Thank you for listening to Journey to the Fringe.
- 35:53If you have liked what you have listened to, please like, share, subscribe, or follow
- 35:59depending on what venue you are listening to us through.
- 36:02Also please, if possible, leave a five-star review as that really helps us in the algorithms.
- 36:08If you wish to interact with us, please check us out on your social media of choice.
- 36:13I bet you we are there.
- 36:15And if you really want to communicate with us and give us ideas for new episodes or tell
- 36:19us that we're wrong and terrible, either way, please send us an email at journeytothefringe.com.
- 36:26For now, I'll see you in the next episode.