Latest / CPG Insiders / The Future of CPG: AI, Innovation & Growth
Transcript
- Dr Mark Young (00:06) Welcome everyone to another edition of CPG Insiders. I'm your host, Mark Young, co-host Justin Girouard and we're going to introduce a new voice and we're going to talk about some new capabilities. So, a lot of times we we have guests on the show and we cover topics on the show, but we don't always spend a lot of time talking about what we do and what capabilities we do. So we're going to introduce you to a new voice on the podcast, which is Oddly enough, gentleman by the name of Dr. Mark Young. Good morning, Dr. Mark Young. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (00:40) Morning, Doctor Mark Young Dr Mark Young (00:42) Yeah. Justin (00:43) And for any of you that are listening, not watching on YouTube, this is not a bat of schizophrenia. This is literally another person. So just so you all know, it's true. There's two of Mark Young, DFM, PhD (00:57) Often confused, but Dr Mark Young (01:00) And you would think, in my defense, you would think a guy in the creative arts could maybe come up with a more creative name than his own name, but here we are. So anyways Mark Young, DFM, PhD (01:14) Imitation is the highest form of flattery. Dr Mark Young (01:16) And and here's what we're here's what we're going to be covering, folks. So first off, I want you to get used to hearing Mark because we're going to be rotating different different hosts through the show. And we're doing that because we want to give you more perspective. So what most of you don't understand is you're used to hearing CPG Insiders, you're used to hearing about Jekyll+Hyde Labs, but there are really four marketing companies. under this one umbrella that we're starting to call Young Impact Group. And they are Jekyll+Hyde Labs, the RYZE Agency, Pharmavision, and eConcierge. So what I'd like to do is I want to try to let everybody know what these different things do and how they interact with each other. So Justin, I'm gonna let you, if you would, you start by saying What do we do here in Detroit at Jekyll+Hyde? Mark Young, DFM, PhD (02:13) Did you just write his next line for him? Justin (02:16) Mm. Sure did. Yep. Hey, it makes it easy to follow, right? I mean Don't drop the ball. yeah, so for all of our seasoned listeners and any new listeners, Jeklin Hyde Labs. So our focus here is brick and mortar retail. That's our major focus. So our whole goal is to partner with great brands that are looking to break into the brick and mortar retail space. If you've been building a great direct consumer brand, but you have aspirations to go into brick and mortar, we have built the capabilities and the team to make that journey a reality, to really make that happen for you. And the other aspect of it is working with brands that are in brick and mortar currently and just aren't getting the results that they're looking for, that are really looking in trying to discover how to scale with that. So from a capabilities perspective and how we execute that is one, we have a big focus on leveraging mass media. Mass media is an amazing tool for for both direct consumer and brick and mortar brands, but we have really crafted over 30 years of business on how to develop the messaging, develop the creative, and also incredibly effective media buying in that mass media space. So that would be your radio, that is your television, also do some print. so engaging in that manner and also just helping build the the foundation for the business and for the brand. to again getting back around to making retail a successful platform for your business and for your brand. Dr Mark Young (03:49) And we do some of this through DRTV, we do some of this through you know distribution. And one of the reasons this is important, and if you're a regular listener, you know this, because a majority of CPG products, 80% of the CPG products still sold in the United States, are still sold through a brick and mortar store. Now that varies. Food items can be 90% plus brick and mortar, whereas supplements can be 60% brick and mortar. So it's not it's not a f it's not a straight line, but on an average it's eighty percent. And here at Jekyll+Hyde, not only do we have all the traditional media, but we have all the connections, we have all the brokers, we have the lawyers, we have all of those things that you need to make that happen. Now, Dr. Mark Two, we're gonna jump over to you and Let people understand what the RYZE agency does. And by the way, Jekyll+Hyde, we're in the suburbs of Detroit, RYZE is in Fort Lauderdale, and how the two interact with each other. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (04:49) Yeah, one of the things that I want to add there is that I I I often talk about you're familiar with the brand FUBU, the for us, buy us brand. And FUBU is one of those brands that is a a founder who's very relatable to his own customer base. And I I would say Jekyll+Hyde, RYZE, eConcierge, PharmaVision like all this family of businesses that we've been talking about that are, you know, owned jointly by this by the group. we're a FUBU brand. And and what I say to that is every time I'm dealing with one of our clients, it's typically a founder, it's an entrepreneur, it it is Justin (05:26) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (05:27) a it is a CEO who's an investor in the business who is choosing his own adventure or choosing her own adventure. and the reality is, is the the client whisperer in me is always looking at them going, look, I understand your struggle. I'm in it. I'm an entrepreneur too. And entrepreneurs, by their very nature, solve problems. They find gaps in an industry and then they they move in to solve it. I say all that to say that each of the brands that we're talking about, albeit Jekyll+Hyde, RYZE, eConcierge, each of these properties weren't Even necessarily developed intentionally so much as they were the offshoot of identifying a need, and that that need got filled, and that need got filled with with excellence. at RYZE Agency, we really focus on the digital footprint of a brand. And I always use the the the moniker seen, sold, serviced. To talk about Jekyll+Hyde. It's mass media. It is, it is awareness that you're putting on television, you're putting on this mass media, it's retail shelving. Sold is the digital footprint, it's what's going online that people understand how to build an ongoing relationship, a life cycle, a continued customer value, that lifetime proposition when acquiring a customer. And then serviced is this eConcierge side of the business, which eConcierge is our outsource. We call it a BPO, a business process outsource. And that is an entirely outsourced back office that can do everything from customer service, you know, questions, find locations, subscription management, and so on and so forth, and also drop shipping fulfillment for brands that are doing business in the e-commerce space. But each of these properties do something different, but they they fill a gap And and I think we sit in that unique space of being founder focused but also founder led. Dr Mark Young (07:23) Now let me jump into the fourth one, which is Pharmavision. PharmaVision's the fourth brand under this umbrella. And if you go to any of the websites, if you go to like Jekyll+Hyde Lab's website now, you'll kind of see all four brands are kind of down in the footer now. PharmaVision is our company that owns and operates all the television sets in every Kroger pharmacy in America, along with end caps, we have three-sided end caps where we have the ability to put product on the shelves. And then inside PharmaVision, we have Brick Tattoo, which is our print outdoor operation, where we have signage on the wall at the Kroger Drive-Thru Pharmacy, which is a big deal because Kroger are the busiest pharmacies in America. And 22% of the people who get their prescription of Kroger go through the drive-thru. So we have the opportunity to talk to them in the store and outside the store. And I think what's unique here is when we when we look at the whole picture, if we add up all the if we take the staff of all the companies, there's probably I'm gonna guess 60, somewhere between 60 and 70 employees there between all of them that are all here to help you. And when we look at these, you have your digital footprint done. Or in fact, let me back up. For a for a new brand, you have 3PL warehousing pick and pack and fulfillment. You now have the ability to be on Shopify and TikTok Shop and all of those things through RYZE. You have that ability to build that that Amazon and to build that Shopify business and now Let's move to retail. In retail, we have Walmart and Target and Costco, and now we have PharmaVision with its direct access into the Kroger system. We have Jekyll+Hyde, which, when you think about the sales funnel, think about Jekyll+Hyde at the top of that sales funnel, dumping in mass amounts of interested people. And then think of The other entities as being like RYZE, mid-funnel and down funnel, catching all of that that customer interest so that we don't lose any sales and we build that life cycle of continuing to have a relationship with that with that customer. So it's funny because I was talking to some some friends, and and you guys know who who I'm talking about. I was talking to some friends who consult two ad agencies. They're literally an ad agency for ad agencies. And their complete comment to me was, You guys are a complete unicorn. There is nothing like you anywhere out there. And I was having a conversation with another company in the CPG space yesterday, who is in the CPG funding space, which is another area that we cover. We don't in we don't have a company of our own to do it, but we have two different companies that we're tied to. Who can fund your business? So we have one who will loan you the money for your purchase orders. We have another one who will even loan you money for your Amazon and your Shopify business. So there's just not much th that we're missing. I mean, we have FDA, FTC lawyers, patent lawyers, accountants, brokers. We've built an ecosystem here. And as Mark T had said earlier, entrepreneurs make their money by solving other people's problems for a profit. That's what you do, that's what we do. And as Mark points out, everything that is developed here grew out of a hole. It grew out of Justin (11:21) Mm-hmm. Dr Mark Young (11:22) a need of here's a problem we need to go solve. Justin (11:28) Mm-hmm. Dr Mark Young (11:28) Mark, why don't you tell them how e concierge came to be? Mark Young, DFM, PhD (11:32) Yeah, I always say that's the business that started with a temper tantrum. it's the true story too. I don't know if you even know this story, Justin, but it I mean it's kind of funny. You'll remember back in the days we were dealing with a a medical device company, Justin (11:45) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (11:46) and I was personally overseeing their call center operations. and the volume that we were driving from national television media. was just more than a call center could handle. And it was because the way call centers are typically structured is that you train a certain number of people to do this particular product. So they all get product knowledge and they all sit by the telephone waiting for the phone to ring. The problem with national television is the phone may not ring for three hours. And then when it does ring, because you did a national TV spot, 65 lines ring at the same time. Well, you can't have sixty-five people sitting on the telephones waiting so you don't miss a phone call, because you'd be paying those sixty-five people for the other three hours also. so what what ended up happening was we ended up with such a that we went through three or four different call centers because every single one of them had the exact same issue, and that is, I don't need you until I need you. Justin (12:42) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (12:42) And then the problem became that we would miss telephone calls like they were like Like we were throwing them away and it was people trying to call and spend six hundred dollars a a phone call. And then the other issue was is that each of the agents who were on the telephone calls didn't even get sufficient training. Because if we ran two or three telephone calls a day, or two or three national spots per day, I may sit on the phones for eight hours and get three phone calls. Because by the time the swell of each of those those incoming telephone swells came in. By the time I got off my first call, all of them were gone. There was no second phone call to take because the swell was over. I sold my product, I moved on, which means training was a huge problem. I remember Yeah, Dr Mark Young (13:27) Yeah, we were we were getting people that were just reading a script. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (13:31) but well, and truthfully they were reading a script because they didn't have sufficient knowledge of the Justin (13:35) Yeah. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (13:35) product because they only talked about it two to three times a day. Justin (13:39) Right. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (13:39) It wasn't like they were talking about it for eight hours. So the reality is, is you know, it was it was a problem. It was a clear problem, and it was costing revenue for a client. I remember, I remember walking into Mark's office, and I'm pretty sure the conversation was nearly verbatim to this. And I said, I am so done dealing with these call centers. And he said, Yeah, they they can be rough. And I said, I'm just gonna go open my own damn call center. And he says, Okay. And I went, Dr Mark Young (14:06) Yeah. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (14:07) and I was like, You're not listening to me. And he's like, Sure I am. And I'm like, No, like these people are so frustrating. My gosh, I've run telephone sales centers for years. Like I could run a call center better than these people. And he said, Okay. I went and I said, I'm just gonna go open my own call center. I mean, I can do this. And he's like, Okay, then why are you still standing here? And I literally I just I got mad. I walked out of the office, I walked down the hallway, called a friend of mine who I knew had run. Sales centers in the past, and I said, This is what I want to do. You're not working right now. And he's like, No, I'm good. And I was All right, how do I deal with this? And he's just like, yeah, let's go, let's go do this. And I believe within about a month and a half, we had a full remote distributed network, we call it, of US based phone operators that were working from home. And at one point we had up to 165 seats. And again, it was we saw a problem. And we fixed the problem and we completely created the business model in such a way that redesigned the way it worked. And we called ourselves the Uber of telemarketing because our people were only on the telephones when there was demand. They were trained. They had to go through multiple gateways for training. But our sales model was such that we could have as many people as we wanted, but we were hiring people like stay-at-home moms and we were hiring Justin (15:36) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (15:37) military NVA. We were hiring seniors who people who were relatively homebound. So they weren't, you know, sitting at a call center all day long. They logged in when we needed them. So they logged in at those specific times. And again, it's necessity just being the mother of invention. Now, currently, that call center, fast forward 12 years, that call center is actually flipped to, I would say we call it AI forward and human-backed, and that is, we're using agentic AI to do all of that. And we're finding roughly a 70% containment. Because we Justin (16:13) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (16:13) again we saw an opportunity and pivoted to the opportunity. And the opportunity is we can actually move most customer service issues into a an LLM type environment where we train a robot and the robot does all of the customer service back end And if a person says, speech a representative, speech or representative, like it did not a problem. We have the humans who are still backing up the robots. But the humans are cross-trained on multiple accounts. The the point of that story though is you found an opportunity that was a problem for somebody and you solved somebody else's Justin (16:49) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (16:49) problem, as Mark said, for a profit. And we're Justin (16:52) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (16:52) solving that problem. But what we're able to do for a profit is still less expensive than what a company is able to do for itself. Because I can have a robot answer the telephone. You don't need to figure Justin (17:02) Right. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (17:03) out how to launch a robot. Dr Mark Young (17:05) And there's no limitation on how many inbound calls you can take with that, right? Mark Young, DFM, PhD (17:09) Zero. No no issue at all. Dr Mark Young (17:10) So if there's three hundred calls coming in, we can do three hundred calls. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (17:15) Correct. Dr Mark Young (17:17) And how does that impact the cost? 'Cause that's gotta really lower the cost of telemarketing from humans. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (17:22) Absolutely. We're finding that that rates on that are coming in, I would say roughly half the cost of a human, and we're always working to try to to try to lower that. The other thing that we find is not just that the per minute rate, because you mean there's still a lot of data and back and forth that's taking place through token usage, definitely cheaper than a human, hundred percent trained as opposed to a human. So if there's any human turnover at a call center, training and and Satisfaction ratings tend tend to go down. Even the best person doesn't know everything yet. so we end up finding that the the training is a bigger deal. We end up finding that the the satisfaction of the of the customer is a bigger deal, the accuracy is a is more accurate, the cost is obviously lower. But what we also find, and this is a deal because the way that we set up our call center was that they pay by the minute. That a person is actually on the telephone talking to a customer service agent. So it's scalable for a for a client. Justin (18:23) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (18:26) The scalable nature of it for a client, though, is that e concierge is able to I'd say using the agentic AI model, the calls don't last as long. Because Justin (18:39) Mm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (18:39) There's no agent on the telephone saying, you know what, I'm not sure about that. Hold on one second and let me look. And they're flipping through a frequently asked questions because this is an unfamiliar question or a question I don't get asked very often. Or they're Googling it to find an answer. The agent has all of the information available, which means the efficiency of the calls, even the while the per minute rate is obviously lower than a human. the efficiency of the phone calls are going from a three to four minute phone call down to about a minute and a half to two minutes. So you're cutting the Justin (19:11) Mm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (19:11) per minute fee in half, but you're also cutting the length of the calls in half because you're not chit-chatting. Dr Mark Young (19:18) You know, it's funny when when we look at AI and AI's really getting a lot of bad press right now. And and we'll talk about that in a minute. I'm thinking about telemarketing, and then what's running through my mind is now Tesla Cybercabs. The Tesla CyberCab is half the price of an Uber. Justin (19:40) Mm-hmm. Dr Mark Young (19:41) Just like what you're saying, half the price of a live take a live person, because labor's the biggest cost. Justin (19:48) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (19:49) Of every business. Justin (19:50) Mm-hmm. Dr Mark Young (19:50) Right. The biggest cost in an Uber isn't the car and the fuel, it's the driver. Justin (19:56) Right. Dr Mark Young (19:57) So we're seeing the same thing happen through Justin (20:00) Yeah. Dr Mark Young (20:00) technology, being able to reduce the cost. By the way, Tesla ran a test, and when a Tesla is driving versus a Tesla owner driving, the car is 54% safer Mark Young, DFM, PhD (20:14) Stay for a Dr Mark Young (20:15) than Tesla owners driving. And then there was another test comparing Waymo Waymo's are over ninety percent have ninety percent less accidents than Uber drivers. Which is phenomenal Justin (20:33) Mm-hmm. Dr Mark Young (20:33) when you think about that. Because I'm assuming there's it's funny 'cause the Uber drivers seem to be more dangerous than the Tesla drivers, and I'm assuming that's because they're in a hurry, probably a lot, trying to kind of drive like cab drivers. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (20:47) Well and the Waymo is not staring at its telephone the entire time it's on the road. Dr Mark Young (20:51) But I'm saying the the Uber drivers seem to not be as safe as a normal Tesla owner. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (20:55) Well, b 'cause the Uber drivers also started the cell Justin (20:58) Shit. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (20:58) phone the entire time each Dr Mark Young (20:59) True. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (21:00) driving. I mean you can change the brand. Dr Mark Young (21:02) Yeah, no, I get it. So sticking with the AI thing, how is AI, for both you guys, how is AI impacting your part of our practice and the industry in general? Mark Young, DFM, PhD (21:15) Give that to Justin first. Justin (21:18) what I will say about our practice, I'll kind of start there. So we're what we're really seeing when it comes to AI in use is one, like I think everyone else is seeing, it is increasing productivity. That's that's number one. And what I mean by that is at at every stage, your your speed to I'll call signal. Has just been amplified. And that comes into play everything from analyzing large data sets. And again, I'm sure we'll do a show on this, but when you think about the amount of data that's available now to us, whether it's in the advertising space or your business, right? The ability to be able to analyze data in a large quickly. is really speeding our ability to get to signal and make this and better and faster decisions. But even when it comes to the the creative side of the business, when we talk about the creative work that we do, having a creative partner available to you at all times has allowed for better creative work. If you think about the idea of collaboration, right? We used to be limited to the time that we had together. Someone would come up with ideas then desperately, right? Then you'd come in a room and try to figure it out. Well, now as creatives, we have the ability to have a partner there with us at all times. So we can throw ideas off of them and we can expand them and we can grow them. And and so our again, our ability to get to better decisions faster has just been amplified. And I think that that's kind of what I mean macro level I'm seeing across the the industry. and so as long as you have a a great operator alongside of it, your ability to make an impact has just been exponentially grown, in my opinion. Dr Mark Young (23:20) Now, Mark, what about on your side? 'Cause your side's really dependent on it. Probably even more than we are right now. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (23:25) Well, one of the things that yeah, I mean, from the digital side, I mean, I agree with Justin that the ability to analyze and the ability to find signal in convoluted data is huge because an AI model can pour through data in a way that a human couldn't if they you know, they were running a room full of supercomputers, right? Like the the ability for AI to find signal and data is amazing. The ability for AI to reference and make predictions about things is is just incomparable. But what I will say in our space, particularly in the digital space, I talked about AI dealing with customer service and whatnot, to the customer service side first, what AI is doing that that humans are bad at, and that is the biggest problem a client is having, is the phone call I just hung up. Justin (24:12) Mm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (24:13) So if you go and ask a customer service person, what are most of your calls? Like what are the problems you're seeing most? There's what we refer to as a recency effect. And that is the one that's the most memorable is the one that happened latest. Dr Mark Young (24:24) Right. So everybody's calling because the cap's hard to get off. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (24:28) And and the only reason is because the last two phone calls have been because the cap is hard to get off. But the eight before that were completely unrelated to that. But these two were the last two. So I reach for the most familiar, and familiarity Dr Mark Young (24:43) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (24:43) is often a bad data signal because it actually becomes an amplifier on data for zero logical reason. AI doesn't do that. So if I take 500 inbound telephone calls and I ask AI what are the most common problems we're having, AI is able to actually go through translation. transcripts of each of those calls, pick up signals because every customer phrases something different. Actually, break down the results that are taking place, categorize them by what the real problems are, and then measure them objectively. The objective measurement actually allows the business owner to make the corrections that need to be made because that data is something because a telephone call is not objective. A telephone call is very subjective. And I say that that data needs normalized. And by Justin (25:35) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (25:36) normalizing data, what I mean is that. I can take things, you know, one says one point zero, one says one point zero zero zero. Someone needs to say, okay, those are both one. even though they Justin (25:46) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (25:47) were phrased differently, those are the same thing. And by normalizing that data, we're then able to extrapolate actionable items out of it. So from a call center standpoint, that it's incomparable what it's able to do there. Because I'm old enough to remember when you used to keep a piece of paper next to the telephone and there was a bunch of categories and you put little hash scores next to each one every time one of these calls came in to try to figure out what happened, right? from a from a Digital marketing standpoint, I'm gonna tell you that it is a complete pivot away from everything that's ever been done. And it's not just strategy, it's not just ad creative, which every day I come to work, I unlock something and I've got another screen going right now because I just found an unlock over the weekend that is just gonna completely change the way we do business again. But what I will what I will say more than anything is everybody who is talking about a Nowadays has continued this conversation of what AI is going to do, and it's going to replace the people and it's going to increase unemployment. And you know, one of the things that I see very often in the news is this idea that there's a decoupling taking place right now in the economy. And the decoupling that takes place is typically you find that as GDP increases, unemployment rates decrease with it, that more people are employed when the market is high. So when you find that the market is expanding, you typically see that unemployment is going down in a correlative nature. The decoupling that's taking place right now, and it's what's freaking everybody out, is that the market is increasing while unemployment isn't moving. Justin (27:25) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (27:25) Because we're able to produce without the humans being involved, which means no longer is the cost of labor associated with the scale of the company or the greater economy as a nation. So that decoupling is actually causing people to go into a panic because no longer is the market a signal of employment rates. The permission behind that is what I think too many people are missing. So in a digital marketing business, I am forever talking to my people about stop talking about what the technology can do. Start talking about what the technology cannot do. Because the the security of my team, the security of any industry, to be honest with you, but I sit in the middle of this one every day, is that the humans need to be doing what only the humans can do. And there is an experiential nature, there is a life cycle management, there is a an authenticity in user-generated content. There is a relationship building of a founder's story that resonates. With customers in a way that AI cannot reproduce. It can media buy, it can make beautiful images, it can answer telephone calls, it can give me a strategic background, it can give me an entire market summary. It can't tell me how a human is going to feel when they read your website. Justin (28:59) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (29:00) And in that way, it's less about how do we become more AI dependent and how do we I I use the phrase that AI has given humans permission to be human again because people have spent entire careers selling their forty hours per week to do robotic tasks. Dr Mark Young (29:18) Yeah, just repetitive motions. It's it's put the Mark Young, DFM, PhD (29:21) Correct. Dr Mark Young (29:22) bolts in the bumper on the car. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (29:24) And and if I no longer have to do the robotic tasks of a forty hour week, too many people in our economy don't know what to do. Justin (29:33) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (29:34) And and if I don't don't Dr Mark Young (29:34) Well let me let me throw some history on this for you for a minute. And and I want to I'll get your input on this. Society has gone through these big technological changes. I mean, all the way back to the bronze era. But if we if we stay a little more modern, we can look at when trains it is, but but that Mark Young, DFM, PhD (29:49) It was a big throwback right there. Justin (29:50) Yeah. Dr Mark Young (29:53) was a technological change. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (29:55) Yes, the wheel. Dr Mark Young (29:56) And yep. But when we look at trains, trains was a big change, the telegraph was a big change. The automobile was a big change, the comp personal computer, the internet. But when we look over the history of these, the combine in the in agriculture, when we look over the history of these, there was typically about a 15 to 20 year transition. So when we look at the automobile, everybody was on horses. It took 15 to 20 years before the automobile became the dominant transportation. So it's funny because if you look back at pictures, and this is really weird for me because when I think about my own father, my own dad used to tell me about taking a horse and buggy to the store to get stuff. And he was born in 1924. So Justin (30:45) Mm-hmm. Dr Mark Young (30:46) I mean, we're not talking that much that far back anymore. But cars and horses and buggies shared the road. They were out there together. So there was a huge fear. Back then, that the automobile was going to wipe out the horse industry. Because no one was going to need to build a wagon and no one was going to make buggy whips and who was going to run the livery stables and horse feed and so on and so forth. But what has happened in every technology is over the 15 to 20 year rotation, people have relearned, retrained, and the new technology always made more jobs than it destroyed. So even when we look at the internet, which has wiped out some shopping malls and and and my own contention is shopping malls that were wiped out by by the internet were crappy shopping malls that that weren't built right and didn't run properly. Because good shopping malls are still highly successful today. So what the technologies really did was it gutted the weak players and it made the strong players have to be better. Justin (31:58) Mm-hmm. Dr Mark Young (31:58) And ultimately, more people today work because of the internet than what the internet gutted. More people work making cars than used to be in a horse and buggy. Where I'm going with this is AI is doubling in capacity every ten weeks right now. So the fifteen to twenty year window that society is used to to transition and retool, those years have turned into months. So my suspicion is that we will go through a period where we will see some increased unemployment because it's going to take people, it's going to take humans that 15 year window to figure out what am I going to do next and how am I going to retool and what am I going to do for a living? And the technology is moving way faster than in the past. Do you guys agree with that, disagree with that? Justin (32:55) completely agree. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (32:56) Yeah, I don't think it's fifteen years though. and it Dr Mark Young (32:59) No, I think it's what I'm saying it was fifteen Justin (33:00) Mm-mm. Dr Mark Young (33:01) years in the past is what society was used to having. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (33:03) Understood. No no no, understood. I'm saying that for this particular innovation between horses and cars, I can understand a fifteen year window because not everybody could afford a car, nor were the cars being produced fast enough to replace the horses. And the truth is nobody was going to decommission and just kill all the horses anyways. So th they're they're you know Dr Mark Young (33:22) But lots of people hated cars and wouldn't give up their horse. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (33:25) Understood, but fifteen years is a good life for a horse also. So so the old models expired when the new models came out. The the reality is is with AI, it's moving at such a pace, as you said, changes are going to be made. And you know, one of the things that concerns me is I I consider myself to be very much on the on the front end, I would not say cutting edge by any stretch of the imagination, but ser seriously, probably one of the more AI curious people I know. But as that has has leaned in, I have no idea how I would catch up if I just learned about it today. Justin (34:05) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (34:06) So a lot of people that are saying things like, yeah, I've been learning a little bit and I've been starting to use it I'm like, You're toast. Like Dr Mark Young (34:14) Yeah. I'm using ChatGPT in place of Google. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (34:18) Yeah, I I don't I don't know how those people catch up. And my what what excites me and also scares me simultaneously is the the excitement of it is coming from I believe that the next economic revolution of our country and perhaps civil war if I can be so predictive, is going to be based off of the people who have adapted to that technology versus the people who have not. Justin (34:43) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (34:43) And the reason I say that is because the invention of AI has leveled the playing field because anybody with a high IQ and an intellectual curiosity to learn can do anything they want to do in the world. Anybody who does not adapt or doesn't have the raw horsepower to do so is going to be left behind economically. And here's the deal: the family I was born into, the wealth that I had access to, the people I had access to, all of these precursors for success that have gotten me into Ivy League schools and so on and so forth in the past are irrelevant. Justin (35:24) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (35:25) None of those things matter the way they used to because a a a curious mind and a MacBook can give you access to any knowledge and any amount of horsepower you want in the world today. And what's going to happen is the haves and the have nots are going to turn into the smarts and the not smarts. And Justin (35:46) Mm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (35:47) it's going to be a complete shift in the way the economy functions. Could that be 15 years? Probably, but I think the chasm is already being being constructed. Dr Mark Young (35:58) One of the reasons I have a PhD after my name is just so I can with credibility tell people it's not important. Because if I didn't have one and I told people it's not important, then they would say, Well, it's because you don't have one. No, I actually have one. And I'm here to tell you it's irrelevant. It matters if I want to Mark Young, DFM, PhD (36:13) Well, I Dr Mark Young (36:15) be a doctor of medicine, it matters if I want to be a lawyer. But in the world of entrepreneurship, you can do anything. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (36:23) I I I laughed because as you know, I spent many, many years of my career in the university system and you know, and speaking from a bachelor's degree, four masters degrees and two doctorates. I can tell you, I don't know that I would recommend that a young person go to college today. And Justin (36:39) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (36:40) this is from a person who has Dr Mark Young (36:41) Agree. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (36:41) literally spent hundreds of thousands of dollars on school tuition. And I Dr Mark Young (36:44) And worked in colleges. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (36:46) And and literally have worked in the as a professor, I've worked in administration, I've been higher up at multiple institutions of higher education. Other than career focused training, where someone is going and getting the skills to be a plumber or getting the skills Justin (37:01) Right. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (37:01) to be a chef. Like I I don't know that institutions of higher learning are adapting at the rate that they need to. And the reality is is I mean a a very good friend of mine is a professor at the University of Miami. And I I mean the constant conversations I'm I'm having, it's like I don't I I'm well, let me give a better example. My director of AI, who actually is full time staff person here, is back in school doing his master's degree. And I'm I'm laughing because he's doing the master's degree. And I'm like, so how much of it are you just working and Claude is actually getting a master's degree? Like and it and it's kind of and he's like, no, no, I'm actually doing the work. And I'm like, I don't even believe you. Like because the truth of the matter is, is there's just anything you want can be gotten cheaply today, Justin (37:49) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (37:50) which Dr Mark Young (37:50) And Mark Young, DFM, PhD (37:50) means that the value is not in the credential. The value is in the output, and the output doesn't require the credential. Dr Mark Young (37:57) And even when we talk about trade schools, and I think the trades are just struggling for people right now. Not that this is about CPG, but they are. But the reality is, my dad, your grandfather, was a plumber, plumbing contractor. I learned plumbing as a kid. I never went to a trade school. I I worked Mark Young, DFM, PhD (38:17) It was an apprenticeship. Dr Mark Young (38:18) for a I worked for a plumber. It was the fastest way to learn the trade. Justin (38:23) Yeah. Dr Mark Young (38:25) I didn't need to go to plumbing school, although in the plumbing joke Justin (38:27) No, I Dr Mark Young (38:28) we used to always say, you know, the crap runs downhill and the payday was on Friday and that was everything we needed to know about plumbing. Justin (38:35) Sure. I I guess my only because I it's not that I I I agree with everything that's being said. I guess one of the questions that I have on this topic briefly is especially as it relates to higher education for young people, because at this point, if I'm trying to look for opportunity, right? The only op opportunity that might bubble up, but the institutions are not structured, I think, to cultivate this, is is the opportunity to be around a A group of different individuals that are having shared, you know, different thoughts that they can elevate, you know, through through the collective, if you will, right? As opposed to, I'm here to learn this information, to pass the test, to get this thing, right? Like if that's if that's the outcome to your point, Mark, like just go on Claude and you'll get all the answers and you'll be good to go. You're not learning as much. But if the institutions were structured in a way that We're bringing you all together to elevate your thinking through the collective and 'cause all of you have different experiences, so different perspectives. So even if you're leveraging this AI, even the output will could be slightly different because of your inputs would be slightly different. And so then all of a sudden there could be this elevation, but I it's not structured, I I believe. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (39:45) No, but if but if you think back to the to the days of Socrates and Plato and and the the days of teaching rhetoric, it was all done on the footsteps of the of the Acropolis, right? Like people Justin (39:57) Right. Right. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (39:59) stood around and they challenged each other because humans function in relationship with other humans. And as it relates to finding opportunity, the first step to finding the opportunity is to find your tribe. And it's Dr Mark Young (40:11) Right. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (40:12) And when sitting in my office and and I say this proudly because it it is it has been a work in progress for quite a while, but I probably have four, five, six people in my office that I mean it's hard ending a meeting. when we get together and just start collaborating about some of this stuff. And you'll never guess what I just found. And you'll never guess what I just found. And the enthusiasm and the high fives and the my gosh, I just went and built this thing. I can't wait to show all of you. And then it's, I'm gonna present my screen and my gosh, how did you even do this? Right. Like yesterday I said I'd found an unlock this weekend. And I was on a Zoom call with my creative director in the middle of a Saturday afternoon, just sharing my screen. Like, dude, you will never believe what I just did. And he's like, my God, you've got to be kidding me like like and it's but it's that kind of enthusiasm that goes along with it. But his excitement gets me more excited. My chief of staff's excitement gets me more excited. And that enthusiasm becomes, I don't need to sit and learn everything because I can walk down the hallway and say, Hey, Phil, I don't know how to do this. Have you done this yet? absolutely. And then we sit down and he's like, Hey, my gosh, I didn't even know you did that. And That type of tribal collaboration, that rising tide, lifts all the ships in the group. Because there is just more to learn right now than a single person can keep up with. Justin (41:37) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (41:37) And the bigger issue, I would say, and this is where what we do to bring it back to Young Impact or Jekyll+Hyde or CPG or whatever we want to talk about, what we do is that AI is an engine. What we're able to do is provide the suspension. And that is, we have the context, we have the industry knowledge, we have the relationships, we have the rule books on how just because you poured more fuel on the fire doesn't mean you've built a bigger fire. You could have just burnt down the forest. Like the reality is that when you're working with professionals who know how to harness this type of power, you get a higher output for your money. You're not paying me because of AI. You're paying me because I know how to use it and I know how it relates to getting you to where it is that you are trying to go. So raw power out of AI means nothing if unbridled. Justin (42:35) Mm-hmm. Dr Mark Young (42:36) I think what what our listeners need to think of, and I will credit Jeff Bezos for this, and that is don't put all your focus on what's changing. Put your focus on the things that will not change. And and what I mean by that Justin (42:51) Mm. Dr Mark Young (42:51) is people will still need to treat their toenail fungus. They will still need to solve a hemorrhoid problem. They will still want to look beautiful. They will still want to have shiny hair. So, what are the things that won't change? And human behavior is consistent. The things that will motivate them to want to have the shiny hair. The things that will motivate them to want to cure an ailment they have, the things that will attract them to a new food or a new profile or something that's better for them, those things stay constant. Would you guys agree with that? That those are those are the fixed things. Justin (43:32) Mm-hmm. Dr Mark Young (43:34) And this becomes a conversation. This actually is part of a conversation I had yesterday. I was with I'm on a board of a group called Unknown Nations, and we're a large ministry. And one of the things I was saying to the board was, it's the message that is sacred, not the method that we deliver the message. That we need to always focus on what the message is, but we need to embrace whatever is the greatest and best and fastest and biggest way that we can distribute it. Well, the same holds true for our listeners here. Focus on what won't change. And then surround yourself with the right who's who know how to stay up on top of the best way to deliver. So I'm gonna wrap up with you guys both giving your opinion. If you were to, if you were talking to a new client today on this call, let's say we had a new client on the show and they make a whatever, they make a personal care product. And they're an entrepreneur and they just invented a personal care product that works better than other stuff that's out there. And now I want to get it into the market, and I'm brand new. What are you going to tell me? What's what's my path for the next two, three years? Justin (44:52) I'll I'll try to give a short answer to that. if I can. it's Dr Mark Young (44:55) No, no, I understand because that's that's a lot of conversation, but just Justin (44:59) a lot of conversation. what I would say and and I will reference back to Dean Jackson. Okay. And then Dean Jackson has a formula that is vision plus capability times reach. And that's how you grow. And that and that's where I would start. I would say what we need to build a vision. need to build the vision of what is the experience of this product and this brand, how are you creating value for those individuals? Those those what is that connection you're trying to make and where are you trying to go? We have to figure that out, number one. Then number two is great, now let's go get the capabilities to do it. So let's build the team, let's get the funding, let's, let's make sure that we have the ability to make that vision a reality. And then once we've done that, then it's all about reach. Let's reach as many of those people that we've identified that we can create that value for as as as much as possible. And so along the way, there's so many things are gonna have to happen in there to build this. But that's the macro path forward. But first, let's start with the vision. Dr Mark Young (46:09) And Dean's model shows how old Dean is because he calls it VCR. And I'm assuming we have now we probably have some listeners who may not know what a VCR was. Justin (46:20) True. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (46:21) Well, I'm gonna I'm gonna throw some some context on there too. And I'm gonna say I I understand Justin's point and Love Dean. I'm gonna add something to that. I'm going to say that I believe too many brands are looking for Alex Hermozzi or Tony Robbins or whoever the guru du jour is to give them the outline, to to provide the acronym, to give the the the methodology and provide this this context. and I think the problem is, is too many Instagram influencers have tried to convince people that they have the exact method, and all you have to do is rub the lamp and make three wishes, and you're going to have success. My belief is that for a brand that's starting out, for a brand that's going to market, for a brand that's in market and not getting the results they want, I I actually believe that there's a bit of a snowflake thing going on here. And Justin (47:07) Mm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (47:07) that is while there are tested methodologies and there are definitely some secret sauces to amplifying business. Business success. The reality is that, and this is where I think companies like ours do an incredible job in the marketplace, and that is everything's different. And I can't put a templated cookie-cutter type result onto your business and tell you what three steps to take. Because for some businesses, if if it's an eight-step process, some businesses are one through eight. Some businesses are one, two, a little extra three, you can probably skip four. We're gonna go to five, you know, skip six, seven, go to eight, and then back to six three times. Like it it's not a uniformed path forward. And I believe that if if the the recipe exists, I agree, but the idea that we're just going to give you the recipe and you can run the playbook doesn't work because every play is different. I mean, watch sit and watch a college football game on a on a Saturday afternoon. They don't run the same play every single time. And if that's the play that's going to win the game, then why don't they do it every single time? Well, because because the defense changes, right? Because the players Dr Mark Young (48:15) But everybody wants to be a Red Bull or a Robin Hood. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (48:19) But it everybody wants to be those things. That the issue is is that I I don't think there's a recipe. I think that there's a lot of really good advice and I think we give a lot of it. But I think listening to what's going on in that brand and customizing a go forward is so Justin (48:35) Is it? Mark Young, DFM, PhD (48:35) much more important than trying to give an eight step action plan. Justin (48:39) Mm-hmm. Agreed. Dr Mark Young (48:40) You know, I d as as you guys both know, I I enjoy cars, I like cars, and I drive exotic cars. I drive every time I pull into a gas station to get gas, some twenty-something year old kid runs up to me and says, What do you do for a living? And how can I do that? Because I want to drive cars like this. And almost without exception, none of them want the answer. They just want the cheat coat. Justin (49:07) That's it. Dr Mark Young (49:08) How do I get to do that in the next six months or the next twelve months? Mark Young, DFM, PhD (49:13) And that makes me sad because Justin (49:14) Mm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (49:15) everybody wants the result and nobody wants the effort to get it. and I think there's a difference there with most entrepreneurs I encounter. Not all of them. There there's a few of them that would that would rather get the result without the without the work, but I Justin (49:29) Yeah. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (49:30) don't find many entrepreneurs or business owners or or C levels who are afraid of work. Justin (49:37) Is it? Dr Mark Young (49:37) I think I probably enjoyed getting to this place more than I enjoy the place. Justin (49:43) Well that's what I I agree. I mean that was the one thing I was gonna say is that if if you truly find joy in the process, then the results are going to happen because you're in love with the process. I mean you could still enjoy Mark Young, DFM, PhD (49:58) Yeah. Dr Mark Young (49:58) Right. I mean I I Justin (50:01) the process. I didn't s I didn't say you're gonna Mark Young, DFM, PhD (50:01) What's up big for those promises? Justin (50:05) like it all of the time. Like not everything is fun. Hard things are not always fun. That's not true. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (50:09) I mean success doesn't always follow. Dr Mark Young (50:13) But what I'm saying is I I enjoy having nice Justin (50:14) But it also determines how you how Dr Mark Young (50:16) cars, but I I more enjoyed the path to get to them. And and Justin (50:20) Yeah. Dr Mark Young (50:20) probably more appreciated and honestly more appreciate the car because of the history that Justin (50:27) Sure. Dr Mark Young (50:27) it took to get to it. Justin (50:29) Sure. Sure. Dr Mark Young (50:31) But that's not what a lot of people not a l lot of young people not here to beat on young people, but a lot of young people constantly come up to me and they just want the chica. Well, just just tell me what you do for a living, how can I do what you do? Mark Young, DFM, PhD (50:42) Yeah, but take a look at, you know, and I will say that a generational gap, and I I won't give a comparison that hits very, very close to home. But if you take a look at children that are raised in an environment where they understand hard work versus children that are raised in an environment that are given everything, that there's an entitlement that Justin (51:00) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (51:00) comes with the latter that doesn't come with the with the former. And I and I I believe that for most entrepreneurs. They didn't start with wild stories of of good fortune. You know, it's a lot Dr Mark Young (51:13) Yeah. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (51:14) of grit and a lot of sweat that goes into what they're doing. And and I will tell you, I'm eternally grateful for the struggle because I I didn't get to where I am because the road was easy. You know, to the contrary. Justin (51:27) Mm-mm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (51:28) Like it was off road. Dr Mark Young (51:30) When we look at the when we look Justin (51:30) Mm-hmm. Dr Mark Young (51:31) at the history of generational success, going all the way back to the days of the robber baron and what we see is the first generation created, the second generation expanded, the third generation destroyed. That's Justin (51:48) Mm-hmm. Dr Mark Young (51:48) actually the history of most family dynasties of generational wealth. Because the first generation, those were the entrepreneurs, those are the guys who and and women who grounded out. Their kids witnessed the grind. Justin (52:05) Mm-hmm. Dr Mark Young (52:06) So even if their kids had more stuff even, they witnessed the sacrifice, they witnessed the grind, they saw what it takes to do that, and they grew up with that level of expectation. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (52:16) Third generations are overgraded. Dr Mark Young (52:18) The third generation grows up and knew nothing of the grind. Literally, they never saw the grind. All they saw was the was Justin (52:24) Mm-hmm. Dr Mark Young (52:25) the outcome. Justin (52:26) Mm-hmm. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (52:26) Yeah. Well this has been fun. Dr Mark Young (52:29) This has been. So folks, I hope you, you know, I hope that show wasn't too boring for you. We just kind of wanted you to know where we're going. you're going to hear all three voices, not all at the same time on the podcast. So we're going to kind of shuffle the deck around. Mark Two will be coming in to talk to you more on future shows, more about digital and TikTok and customer lifetime cycles and things of that nature. And Justin and I will continue to be doing what we've been doing. As always, if you have any questions, reach out to us. You can get a hold of any of us at cpginsiders.com, jekyllhydelabs.com ryzeagency.com and RYZE is spelt R-Y-Z-E dot Justin (53:14) Mm-hmm. Dr Mark Young (53:15) com. But you can go anywhere in that ecosystem to get in touch with any of us. So don't worry, I've got to get the right website if I want to reach out to somebody. Go to any of them and and you're you're good to go. Also, don't forget if you enjoy the podcast, go to wherever you get your podcast and leave us a five-star review. We'd appreciate that. And also don't forget that we have numerous books on this topic. As some of you heard, my book, The 27 Unbreakable Rules. People are really, we're having such a great response to that. people that are reading it. And Mark, you have five books on digital marketing Mark Young, DFM, PhD (53:53) It's just a more complicated topic. Dr Mark Young (53:55) It is a more Justin (53:55) Mm-hmm. Dr Mark Young (53:55) complicated topic. where do people get your books also? Mark Young, DFM, PhD (54:00) available at themarkyoung.com or also obviously on Amazon. The audiobook is actually dropping next week, I believe. audiobooks on all five. Dr Mark Young (54:08) So there's five books there. Do they need to start with volume one? Mark Young, DFM, PhD (54:12) You know, that's it's it's been an internal question that we've been we've been having around here for quite a bit. And part of that is the it's certainly reading all five books is beneficial. But like for instance, book one is talking about branding and messaging and understanding your unique selling proposition and so on and so forth. For brands that already know that, it may be a little bit of repeat. if a brand really just wants to dial into paid media, there's an in there's a book just on paid media. if they really want to dial into just how to measure success, there's a book that's completely all about the KPIs of your industry. they're all great together. I'll be honest with you and tell you that it's an awful audiobook. I listened to it, and as I'm listening to it, and it's my voice, which is not the reason it's awful, that's just a contributing factor. The It's so much content that I'm saying, like you're you're listening to you need to measure the this and the measure the this and this is the way that you measure this. It's this divided by this times this. And I'm like, my gosh, in an audio book, I need to visualize this. So my recommendation and for people is to pick up a copy of the paperback, the paper book. There's a workbook that you can also get that's a compendium that you can actually write in everything for your own business so that you can take notes in a meaningful fashion and listen to the audiobook. So you're getting the the auditory learning as well as the visual learning and as well as the the tactile learning of writing along while you're doing it. And the stuff sinks in so much better. Justin (55:30) So what's the title of that book? Mark Young, DFM, PhD (55:31) called the Ecommerce Brand Guide To The Galaxy, Justin. Dr Mark Young (55:36) Justin just kind of put in a little fine point on that there. Thank you, Justin. Mark Young, DFM, PhD (55:40) Yeah, good. Dr Mark Young (55:42) All right, that's it for today, folks. Again, if you have any questions, come out and contact us. One last book I'm going to recommend everybody get is Dr. Ben Hardy's book, The Science of Scaling. And it's a great book, and you Justin (55:55) Right book. Dr Mark Young (55:56) can get it free at freescalingbook.com. And just go there and you can get the digital copy or you can get the free audio download, freescalingbook.com. That's it. Thanks, guys. We'll see everybody on their, or hear everybody, or they'll hear us on the next episode of CPG Insiders.