Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Credit Unions in Q3 2025: Stability Returns, Pressures Remain
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Trike with another
- 0:01episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03I'm here with my, my crew today.
- 0:05I've got Dennis Bauer, Steve Farr, Todd Miller all formerly of NCUA and or Credit
- 0:11Unions and or Credit Union Exam Solutions.
- 0:14How you guys doing today?
- 0:16Good.
- 0:16Doing
- 0:18Farrar: well.
- 0:18Merry.
- 0:18Merry Christmas.
- 0:19Treichel: Merry Christmas.
- 0:20That's right.
- 0:20And because it's Christmas near Christmas, we have a a quarterly episode that
- 0:26we've been doing and we're gonna be talking about the quarterly credit union
- 0:30data summary that comes out from NCUA.
- 0:33Of course this would be for quarter three as of September.
- 0:36But before we jump into that, just in case there's some New Watchers or
- 0:40some new listeners, why don't you guys give a little bit of your background,
- 0:43and I'm gonna, I'm gonna start with Dennis, and we're on my screen.
- 0:46I've got Dennis, Steve, and Todd in that, in going counterclockwise
- 0:50Dennis state, your your name, your background, et cetera, et cetera,
- 0:54et cetera, for those new listeners.
- 0:56I'll do that.
- 0:56I'll keep
- 0:57Bauer: it quick too.
- 0:58Yeah, I've I've been in the credit union industry for, or I was in the credit
- 1:01union industry for about 38 years.
- 1:03My first six years I spent with the NCOA I, I worked as a field examiner
- 1:08and then I my last couple years with N-C-O-A-I was a problem case officer.
- 1:12Then I switched sides, if you will.
- 1:14And I I spent the next 32 years at a credit union in St.
- 1:17Paul, Minnesota.
- 1:18I was postal credit union, and when I left, our name was Ideal Credit Union.
- 1:23I came on pretty much in the finance operations area.
- 1:26So I stayed with that credit union for 32 years.
- 1:29I, I re, or I retired in of September of 2024.
- 1:34So just over a year ago I retired.
- 1:36And I spent my time, as I said, in the finance and in the operations area.
- 1:40I finished up as the credit union's chief financial officer.
- 1:44So as I, I spent the 32 years there.
- 1:46We grew from a credit union of about a hundred million to just over a
- 1:49billion, and then Mark mark tapped me.
- 1:52I started out working with Mark, actually with NCUA.
- 1:55We started as examiners together and I stayed in touch with
- 1:58Mark throughout my career.
- 2:00And he asked me if I needed a little whiskey money.
- 2:02And I so I jumped on and I tried to bring a, I guess a an aspect a
- 2:06little bit of probably NCA, but that.
- 2:09That, that knowledge is long gone after 32 years, but more from a
- 2:13credit union operation perspective.
- 2:15So that's my story.
- 2:16That's
- 2:16Treichel: your story.
- 2:17I remember when I had a code four, a code five credit union in my district
- 2:21that will re remain nameless, who was trying to open a branch on the west
- 2:26coast and we were in the Midwest.
- 2:28And we, I think we even had a letter of understanding agreement
- 2:31that they agreed not to do it.
- 2:33And you said let's pick up the phone and see if they opened one.
- 2:36And you called information and Sure.
- 2:38As rain, they were in violation.
- 2:41They were iation.
- 2:43Bauer: I go here, mark, why don't you have a conversation
- 2:45Treichel: here, mark, why don't you talk to these guys?
- 2:47Yeah.
- 2:47I'm not sure.
- 2:48We ratcheted it up somehow, but they've since merged.
- 2:51But we won't mention who that was.
- 2:53No, we won't protect the guilty.
- 2:55All right.
- 2:55Steve Farr.
- 2:56Farrar: Hey, I'm Steve Farr.
- 2:58I break my career now down into the three parts.
- 3:01The first 15 years are in the field for the NCUA and mostly as a problem
- 3:07case officer, which was self-rewarding work, I'd have to say, because you
- 3:11loved working with the credit union.
- 3:14Management in, in fixing the problems and not having to necessarily merge
- 3:19them, although that happens sometimes.
- 3:21But that was, we had conservatorships and extremely bad cases.
- 3:24Spent a lot of time in Alaska at one point.
- 3:27Then after that, when Mark went to the central office, I followed
- 3:30him there and worked remotely for.
- 3:33Basically about the next 12 years or so in the division of risk
- 3:37management, and we all became deep.
- 3:39Todd and I and Mark were deeply involved in the corporate resolution.
- 3:43Towards the end of my career, I was vice president of the CLF.
- 3:47And spent the last couple years working on the risk-based capital rule.
- 3:51Since leaving NCUA, I enjoyed the consulting that we do.
- 3:55I got to do a stint as a chief financial officer at a conservatorship in Manhattan,
- 4:01which was, it's a great place to.
- 4:03To be when you're able to stay in the hotel and walk to work.
- 4:06That was a great experience.
- 4:07But yeah, I think we've enjoyed being able to keep our saws sharp
- 4:11with the consulting and keep up with what's going on in the industry.
- 4:16And now we're just sitting really observing, this influx of change
- 4:20that seems to be happening right now.
- 4:22So it's, we're gonna, we're gonna enjoy the ride.
- 4:26Treichel: Yeah, that's for sure.
- 4:27Enjoy the ride.
- 4:28I like that.
- 4:28I like that.
- 4:28If I remember right.
- 4:29Did.
- 4:30So I'm gonna get part of this story wrong.
- 4:33You came out and helped me when I was out on the East Coast and you had to
- 4:37do something for us in New York City, and somehow I'm picturing a David Cone
- 4:42no-hitter that you either were able to go to or weren't able to go to which
- 4:46Farrar: I bought tickets to go to the game when I was actually,
- 4:49I was doing the examination of one of your conservatorships.
- 4:52Treichel: Yep.
- 4:53Farrar: And, nobody really showed me how to ride the subway to Yankee
- 4:57Stadium, and I was like, eh, I don't think I'll take an adventure on my own.
- 5:02And so I was working out in the hotel gym and watching the no-hitter take place.
- 5:08Treichel: You could have kept those tickets and sold 'em now
- 5:10on eBay, got your money back.
- 5:12All right.
- 5:13Todd Miller.
- 5:14Last but not least.
- 5:16Miller: I spent 34 years with NCUA.
- 5:18I can break my career down into a couple, three big chunks.
- 5:22First decade, 10, 11 years, I was an examiner, problem case
- 5:26officer on the West coast.
- 5:28Then I spent roughly 11 years as a capital market specialist on the west coast.
- 5:32And then I spent about 12 years as a director of special actions
- 5:35on the West Coast supervising.
- 5:38Problem case officers, capital market specialist, regional lending specialist.
- 5:43Steve mentioned the corporate thing.
- 5:45I have what I call my lost year in there.
- 5:47After the agency conserved Westcorp Martin drugged me in there and attorney
- 5:51Bob Ner would send us a letter about every three months, the same letter.
- 5:55We're not allowed to talk to anyone about what we're doing, I just didn't talk
- 5:59to any of my fellow peers or anything for a year, so I call it my last year
- 6:03I just went to West Court every day.
- 6:06Treichel: Yeah, that was for the whole year.
- 6:09That was a, that was an interesting time.
- 6:12Miller: It was very much an interesting time, but I enjoyed my 34 years with NCUA.
- 6:17Like Steve said, there's times we did assistance packages.
- 6:21We gave credit unions capital to help them survive.
- 6:23A lot of them are still there.
- 6:25I don't know how many conservatorships I did, but I did return a couple
- 6:28conservatorships back to the members and those credit unions are still there today.
- 6:32Those are quite rewarding.
- 6:34You learn a lot on a conservatorship because you get to be the board of
- 6:38directors and the CEO and everyone else and got your hands tied and
- 6:43you got board members wanting this from you and that from you.
- 6:47And you tend to learn a lot of operational things that examiners don't when you
- 6:52have a credit union and conservatorship.
- 6:54And it's very rewarding to give those back to the members.
- 6:57Treichel: It is.
- 6:57Yeah.
- 6:57I had a couple that we were able to spin back too.
- 7:00That's we all enjoyed our time.
- 7:02Helping credit unions in that PCO role.
- 7:04We were all PCOS at one juncture and it's a lot more fun being on this side
- 7:08of at least at this stage of our life, a lot more fun being on this side
- 7:11of the table helping credit unions.
- 7:12But with that, let's pivot into the quarterly data for the September, 2025.
- 7:19Which trend do we wanna talk about first and who wants to jump in?
- 7:24Todd
- 7:24Miller: Fire.
- 7:25I'm never scared to talk first.
- 7:26And it's not so much a trend.
- 7:28It's somewhat interesting.
- 7:29If you look where credit unions went from like 2010 to
- 7:32COVID, we had really low rates.
- 7:35So things got distorted.
- 7:37Then COVID, we had this massive liquidity infusion and rapid growth
- 7:42and a lot of dumb investment decisions and long-term asset decisions made.
- 7:46Then we get inflation and rising rates.
- 7:49Caused some credit unions to struggle and where we're at here in the last year
- 7:53is it's almost a return to normalcy.
- 7:56People are getting their net interest margins back where they're at.
- 7:59Balance sheets are getting in much better shape.
- 8:02You're almost seeing a return to what credit unions look like in say 2007, 2009.
- 8:08Your share structure is returning to normal.
- 8:11So all in all, this year, it's like a really good year
- 8:14for the industry as a whole.
- 8:16Capital numbers have come up.
- 8:17Growth is slow.
- 8:19Okay.
- 8:19There's some delinquency things happening at the edges, but in
- 8:23general, it's return to normalcy here for credit unions, which is.
- 8:28A good thing.
- 8:29In other words it's not as exciting as it has been here the last few years.
- 8:34When you look at these trends, even the negative earners,
- 8:36there's only like 514 of them.
- 8:39There were 630 of 'em last year.
- 8:41So you know, that's way down.
- 8:44And interest margins are looking nice.
- 8:46So I would call the whole trend is, it's a return to some normalcy.
- 8:52Even though NCUA is in turmoil the credit unions are returning
- 8:55to a normal operating stance.
- 8:58Treichel: Yeah.
- 8:59There's a little bit of turmoil going on at NCUA.
- 9:01We may or may not dive into that.
- 9:02Somewhere along this along this call, Dennis, Steve, any thoughts
- 9:05on what Todd had to say there?
- 9:07Bauer: Yeah.
- 9:08On the margin?
- 9:08It was it was good to see that, I think margins compared to a year ago.
- 9:14There were up approximately 30 basis points from September of 24
- 9:21to September of this year and right in, and that it's predictable just
- 9:25because of what, to some degree, what's happening with the overall yield curve.
- 9:30Todd mentioned that things are getting back to normal.
- 9:32I think the yield curve is not quite.
- 9:34It's not quite, steep, the whole yield curve, but from the two
- 9:37year point on it's fairly steep.
- 9:39And then the the difference between the three month and 10
- 9:43year and two year has shrunk.
- 9:45And mainly because right short term rates have come down, which then has
- 9:49resulted in, cost of funds stabilizing.
- 9:52They haven't really increased.
- 9:53They're probably starting to actually maybe start to decline a bit just
- 9:56because of the way the, of the short-term nature of short-term
- 10:00CDs and non maturity deposits.
- 10:02So I, I would assume credit unions are starting to reprice those down,
- 10:05whereas then on the assets side it's geared more towards the longer end.
- 10:09And that part of the curve is not actually even, that's not coming down.
- 10:13That's I think the tenure is actually up higher than it was a year ago.
- 10:16So that's good for maintaining higher.
- 10:19Higher yield on assets, earning assets.
- 10:21So as a result, we got a 30 basis point pickup in interest
- 10:24spread compared to a year ago.
- 10:26We'll, and I, we'll probably get into that a little bit more, but
- 10:28some of that was eaten up, right?
- 10:29When you take a look at the ROA over overall was only up 11, 11 points.
- 10:33So we'll probably talk to as to reasons why that's going on, but
- 10:36that's what I would take onto the margin and things getting back
- 10:39to normal or for credit unions.
- 10:41Treichel: Got it.
- 10:42Got it.
- 10:42Steve, any thoughts to highlight add on to the, that theme?
- 10:46Farrar: Yeah, just, in big picture, one of the things I do e each quarter
- 10:50is I compare the credit union's performance against community banks.
- 10:55And like we Todd said, it's been a pretty good year in terms of performance and
- 10:59it's that way with the community bank.
- 11:01Also they come in with a significantly higher ROA they're a 1.11%
- 11:07so that, they're quite substantially higher there.
- 11:10And they have the other really astonishing numbers, they're much,
- 11:14much lower in terms of loan losses.
- 11:16They're at like 0.19
- 11:18in the credit union industry at 0.7177
- 11:22or eight one.
- 11:23So that's the biggest difference and that, and then there's the funding
- 11:26of those losses that, that the credit unions are having to fund more in,
- 11:30in loan losses than community banks.
- 11:32But generally the numbers moved in concerts where there net interest
- 11:36margins went up by so many basis points.
- 11:38It was really close to what, the credit union industry did.
- 11:41Like how Todd says it's, it looks like a good year.
- 11:44And then like Todd talked about, where we're at in terms of unprofitable
- 11:48credit unions have the number there.
- 11:50For the industry it's, 11.78%.
- 11:54But when you look at any the credit union's over a hundred
- 11:56million, it drops to 6%, which is pretty comparable to the community
- 12:00banks in that they run like 5.26%
- 12:04of their institutions were unprofitable.
- 12:06So we're, the performance of credit union industry against
- 12:09community bank, pretty consistent.
- 12:11Treichel: I gotta text a client back who wants to chat.
- 12:14Let them know that after I'm recording this podcast, I will give them a call.
- 12:19All right.
- 12:19Sorry about that.
- 12:20So the community bank's numbers are similar, but different.
- 12:24And Todd you said something about, delinquency around the edges.
- 12:29So capital's strong and getting a little bit better.
- 12:31But let's talk about the asset quality side of the game.
- 12:35What are you seeing statistically in the asset quality arena?
- 12:40Miller: First off, let's just talk about the effect that our
- 12:43ones credit unions have on this.
- 12:45So there are 25% of assets in the country, but they have 37% of the
- 12:52delinquency and 42% of the charge offs.
- 12:55Our 21 credit unions at one have a big impact on what the
- 13:00national numbers are showing.
- 13:03For charge offs.
- 13:05But when you look at things in aggregate, sometimes you break these
- 13:09delinquency and charge offs numbers down, and I sit there and wonder
- 13:13why credit unions have credit card portfolios anymore, or unsecured debt.
- 13:18Charge off ratios on credit card portfolios have been over 5% for
- 13:24two years now that's a big number.
- 13:27You're seeing.
- 13:30A deterioration in auto loans.
- 13:32And in fact auto loans have been shrinking a little bit.
- 13:35In terms of the portfolio that you see credit unions, and maybe this is in
- 13:39response to those loss rates, they're moving more and more towards more real
- 13:43estate loans again, and I think part of the lending and the auto lending
- 13:48shrinkage and slow down and you have almost a 1% charge off in auto loans.
- 13:53Not quite.
- 13:5588 basis points.
- 13:571.1
- 13:58for used cars, but part of that, I think it's just a matter of the economy is
- 14:02slowing and I just bought a new car and there's a little bit of sticker shock.
- 14:07You can hit a.
- 14:0950, $60,000 really fast on a not so fancy truck pickup anymore, or an SUV.
- 14:18And I think maybe you're seeing a slow down on that just because
- 14:21of economic uncertainty, but you're definitely, seeing.
- 14:25Increased losses in those auto loan portfolios.
- 14:29Real estate and stuff is still looking really good.
- 14:31And maybe that's why credit union are moving in that direction.
- 14:34And commercial lending losses are pretty low.
- 14:38And maybe that's why you're seeing some growth in commercial lending
- 14:40the last two, three years too.
- 14:43But I know NCUA is extremely worried about those commercial loan portfolios
- 14:48and how are they gonna hold up?
- 14:50And that's always a million dollar question.
- 14:53All four of us have been around for three, four different recessions,
- 14:58and those tend to be a little geographically isolated things.
- 15:01This recession is in these three states and this recession, the losses
- 15:06are in these four or five states.
- 15:07And this recession, that's these states, and that's probably the way
- 15:11it will play out again next time.
- 15:13But trying to predict where those states are gonna be, not so easy.
- 15:18Yeah.
- 15:18So N two A worries about everybody.
- 15:20Treichel: That's right.
- 15:21They worry about everybody and they send out their warnings about everybody
- 15:24on the delinquency and asset quality.
- 15:27Steve or Dennis any additional thoughts on that?
- 15:30Bauer: One thing I saw not so much in the data, but macroeconomic stuff
- 15:34unemployment's starting to tick up.
- 15:36I think unemployment came out even today.
- 15:38I think it ticked up to 4.6%,
- 15:41they were talking about maybe because of participation rate.
- 15:44So that might have an impact on that.
- 15:46But over over the last year, we were well below four, unemployment
- 15:50rate is up to about 4.6%
- 15:52right now.
- 15:53And then medium home sales, right?
- 15:55Those have declined over the last year or two two years ago.
- 15:58The medium house, I think sold for about 4 35.
- 16:02Four 35,000.
- 16:03That's down to four 10.
- 16:04So that's approximately not a big drop, about a 6% drop, but Right.
- 16:09As a, as I was leaving the credit union, we were getting all into Cecil.
- 16:13So those potentially could have a little bit of an impact on your
- 16:16overall Cecil calculation as you're looking, as you're looking forward
- 16:19and including macroeconomic things.
- 16:22So I, I noticed that.
- 16:24Then we did see that delinquencies increased.
- 16:27It hasn't really increased from a year ago, but from
- 16:29two years ago it's increased.
- 16:31Let's see, from 72 basis points up to 94 over the last two years, and charge offs
- 16:37have increased from 55 basis points to 77.
- 16:41Then I looked at, okay, ha, has the allowance changed?
- 16:44That's actually compared to loans that's improved from 1.2%
- 16:49up to 1.3%.
- 16:51So there's more dollars overall reserve.
- 16:53So looks like credit unions are taking that in into consideration.
- 16:56But then I looked at another ratio, coverage ratio, which you look at.
- 17:00You take a look at your your allowance compared to delinquency.
- 17:04Two years ago that was sitting at 167%.
- 17:07That's down to about 140%.
- 17:09So that hasn't kept up.
- 17:11And then I also look at net charge offs to the prior years delinquency.
- 17:16And that also has increased, so charging off more than we had in
- 17:21delinquency if you compare 2023 to 2025.
- 17:25So those, so right.
- 17:26So that may indicate if that trend continues, that there might
- 17:29be a little bit more pressure.
- 17:31For provision for loan loss to make sure to ensure that, we're
- 17:35maintaining we're maintaining proper reserves in the allowance.
- 17:38So those are some of the things that's interesting that I noted.
- 17:41Yeah.
- 17:42Miller: As you broke that down by loan type.
- 17:44'cause I looked at some of that similar type of stuff, Dennis, and, I looked at,
- 17:49okay, what are we provisioning versus what we're charging off and, at least.
- 17:55Through the last few years, there's still more provision than there has
- 18:00been charge offs through this year.
- 18:01It's only 108% of PLL versus charge offs.
- 18:06But if you go back to 20 22, 20 23, it was like 120, 130% of
- 18:12provision versus charge offs.
- 18:14It has to too, probably with loan growth too, I don't know, is, some of that.
- 18:19Numbers you're looking at changing just because the makeup of the
- 18:23loan portfolio is changing and leaning more towards real estate.
- 18:27Yeah, I didn't break it down.
- 18:28Bauer: And you're right.
- 18:28Yeah, there is a, there's a move, as you said, into more real estate types
- 18:33of products, and more commercial.
- 18:35And right now those aren't carrying maybe the same delinquency.
- 18:38So that could have a, could have an impact, obviously.
- 18:41Yeah.
- 18:42Yeah.
- 18:43Miller: Played with lots of numbers and couldn't reach any conclusions.
- 18:47Yeah, and one reason Dennis looks at it, one reason I look at it, amongst our
- 18:51clients, and this has been going on for, multiple years now, and the larger you
- 18:56get, the more emphasis NCUA puts on it.
- 18:59They want justification for their concentration levels
- 19:01in their loan portfolios.
- 19:03They want you to model it.
- 19:04They want sensitivity around it.
- 19:07And I think that will probably continue in the future too because
- 19:11we see it consistently amongst our various clients of all sizes.
- 19:16And it's been going on since we started in 2021.
- 19:18And it's still going on today in 2025.
- 19:21Treichel: Picking up a little momentum.
- 19:22Yep.
- 19:22Yep.
- 19:23Steve, any thoughts on asset quality, delinquency, the, anything
- 19:27to add to the commentary thus far?
- 19:29Farrar: Dennis covered it pretty good because my analysis came out
- 19:32with kinda the one thing as a.
- 19:33Little bit concerned about the level of the allowance when you look at
- 19:37it in terms of metrics compared to delinquency and charge off history.
- 19:41And Todd talked about that ratio of provision to net charge off used to
- 19:46be around the 130%, and that's what it runs in the community banking industry.
- 19:51And it hasn't changed over the last year and credit unions are running
- 19:55significantly lower than that.
- 19:57So there's.
- 19:58Right now, the higher delinquency and higher provision expense is a competitive
- 20:02disadvantage that the credit unions do have against community banks, and we
- 20:08just have, we don't want that to become more of a disadvantage going forward.
- 20:12Treichel: Great point.
- 20:13So on asset quality I was listening to a podcast, a FinTech podcast where this
- 20:19guy talks about different things, but he was talking to a guy who used to work
- 20:22at capital One, and they were talking about the different risks that they
- 20:27see in lending, and they talked about.
- 20:31Where we're at today, and is there gonna be a recession?
- 20:34Are there gonna be problems tied to the unemployment rate
- 20:39going up, et cetera, et cetera.
- 20:40But the guy had an interesting.
- 20:42Comment about 2008, 2009 and back then there was this concept that people were
- 20:50more willing to turn in their, that was, we're turning in the keys to our
- 20:54second home, or the delinquency was tied to a home situation, but people
- 20:58needed their cars to get to work so that the car loans at the time were viewed.
- 21:03Almost safer than home loans in some instances.
- 21:06And his takeaway was in oh eight and oh nine, we didn't have Uber,
- 21:10so you couldn't get anywhere as easily as you can with Uber.
- 21:14And we also didn't have work from home.
- 21:17And then he got into this discussion about the sub the challenges in subprime
- 21:21landing, subprime prime landing is higher than it was in oh 8, 0 9.
- 21:25But his thesis, and it was just that a thesis was there might be more repos and
- 21:30problems at the white collar, higher level jobs because they can Uber and they can
- 21:36stay at home and work in some instances, but they might, if they, if something's
- 21:41gonna give, it might be the car loan.
- 21:43And he was saying that even though subprime loans were a
- 21:47little bit more delinquent than normal, that it's the subprime.
- 21:52Borrowers who really need to have their vehicle to get to wherever they are going.
- 21:57'cause they tend to potentially be more in the service industry
- 22:01or the blue collar side of things.
- 22:03And any thoughts relative to that or do you wanna move on to the earnings arena?
- 22:08Bauer: That, that was interesting because my last couple years at
- 22:11the credit union we saw an a big.
- 22:14Fairly significant increase of people just turning in their keys for their car.
- 22:18And Todd mentioned that.
- 22:19I think part of it too is, and I think what the guy said may maybe makes sense in
- 22:23Minnesota here, I'm not sure, but Right.
- 22:25Car and truck prices just are just so exorbitant.
- 22:28People just, can't after that inflation hit and your bill.
- 22:33So we saw, we did see a more than usual number, and maybe that's continuing
- 22:37today, where people are just turning in their car or keys to their truck or car.
- 22:40More than I ever had ever seen in my career.
- 22:43Miller: It doesn't really break it down on the financial performance reports,
- 22:47but repossessed assets on credits, balance sheets are up quite a bit.
- 22:51Ah, interesting.
- 22:538% just in the last quarter.
- 22:56Treichel: Yeah,
- 22:56Miller: so it's over a billion dollars of repossessed assets setting on
- 23:00credit unions balance sheets right now.
- 23:03Treichel: And I wonder how many different ways they're being
- 23:05asked to account for that.
- 23:08Miller: There's more than what's on the balance sheet because examiners
- 23:11and CPAs, they'll let people, carry that as a delinquent loan rather than
- 23:16a repo if it's going to auction in a timely manner and things of that nature.
- 23:22So the accounting aren't exactly 100% consistent.
- 23:26Bauer: Our last exam, our examiner said you have to treat it as a.
- 23:31Repoed and you gotta change your whole process.
- 23:34So we went through that whole rigmarole and our auditor said it
- 23:37was immaterial, but we still did it.
- 23:40Our lending folks did not like that.
- 23:42But it was a pain.
- 23:44Hard to, it's hard to do it on a core.
- 23:46You got you.
- 23:47There's a process.
- 23:48You have to.
- 23:49You have to account for.
- 23:50So not a lot of credit unions do it that way, the right way.
- 23:54Treichel: I had on a related note I don't think I've mentioned this to any of you.
- 23:58I had a chat with the credit union that had been referred from someone
- 24:03who is familiar with the podcast and it related to some challenges in the 5,300
- 24:08and how things were being reported.
- 24:10And they were looking at.
- 24:13We talked through some of that and looking potentially for
- 24:18some training on how to do that.
- 24:19But in the middle of it all, I said something like I imagine that every time
- 24:23an examiner comes in, they might tell you that the way you're doing it now is
- 24:27wrong and you need to do it this way.
- 24:28And then the next one comes in.
- 24:29And I said, I've seen that, I've seen that a lot in my last five years.
- 24:33It happens a lot more.
- 24:35And the CEO who was on the call, more of as a, as an observer.
- 24:38At the beginning of the conversation came off mute and said, actually,
- 24:41that's exactly what happened to this.
- 24:43That's exact exactly why we're calling.
- 24:45How much can we push back on this?
- 24:47Can you provide us some training relative to this?
- 24:50And I basically said work with your current examiner NCOs.
- 24:54Instructions are the instructions, and they interpret
- 24:57them a little bit different.
- 24:58Push back on where it says you have to do it this way, but I said, you're they
- 25:02felt better just knowing they weren't alone, that this was happening to them.
- 25:05But I digress.
- 25:06I think
- 25:07Miller: Steve and I heard a lot of that from the Alaska Credit Unions back in
- 25:10the late eighties and early nineties.
- 25:12Tell us how you wanna do it and quit changing it
- 25:14Treichel: every quarter.
- 25:16Quit changing it based on the flight.
- 25:18And then they change the definition a little bit.
- 25:20But then they don't really explain, how it works.
- 25:22So then you get.
- 25:24Hundreds of examiners a applying it slightly different with
- 25:27no real guidance from nsu.
- 25:28And it's not ultimately the examiner's fault because there's no,
- 25:31they tweak it without telling 'em.
- 25:32They walk in and then they have to do their best to explain.
- 25:35All right.
- 25:36So earnings we touched on, Dennis.
- 25:38You talked about NIM being up a certain amount, but that the bottom line
- 25:41wasn't up That certain amount that the, that there's some difference.
- 25:44We've alluded to that, but
- 25:45Farrar: Yeah.
- 25:45Treichel: Let's tiptoe into the earnings equations.
- 25:48Yep.
- 25:49Bauer: So rates, so we compare ROA from a year ago.
- 25:52It's up 11 basis points, but 30 basis points was positive because of the
- 25:55nim that interest margin non-interest income was down four basis points.
- 26:00So that took away four.
- 26:01Provision for loan loss was about the same.
- 26:03I think it was up maybe a basis point.
- 26:05So you got total between those two of five.
- 26:07But the big one then is non-interest expense.
- 26:10That was up 12 basis points.
- 26:13Compared to Q3 of 2024, and then I went back to 2023 and it was up about the
- 26:21same percentage, so it was up about 7%.
- 26:24Expenses were up about 7% in 2023 to 2024, and then another 7% from 2024 to 2025.
- 26:33So right, so that, that is eating up, almost half of the net
- 26:37interest margin for the last year.
- 26:39Miller: So that's interesting because the expenses have been going up
- 26:43since COVID it actually started.
- 26:45Yep.
- 26:46Non-interest expense started increasing during COVID.
- 26:49And supposedly if you let people work from home, and a lot of credit
- 26:53unions do, we have a lot of clients who are almost half of their, back
- 26:56office staff are working from home.
- 26:58In theory you should get more productive, but that's not the direction the credit
- 27:03union industry has went during this period at a time when there's work from
- 27:08home and all of this, credit unions, operating expenses have gotten higher.
- 27:13Members per employee has stayed roughly the same.
- 27:17So you start asking yourself, why are their expenses growing?
- 27:20And maybe some of it's catch up in systems, implementation of cil,
- 27:25more credit unions hitting the ones category, and capital planning
- 27:29and models and things there.
- 27:31But some of it is just flat out we're paying people more.
- 27:352023, just two years ago, comp and benefits were 97,000 here in September.
- 27:42We're up to 107,000.
- 27:43So almost, a 10% increase in, 18 months roughly.
- 27:49Bauer: Yeah, I think wage and right inflation, I think inflation
- 27:52has a bit to, to do with it.
- 27:53We were up 20, I don't know how much inflation is up since 2022.
- 27:57It's probably 25, 20 6%, somewhere in there.
- 27:59So that's eventually gotta, that's gotta leak into employee comp and Ben.
- 28:04So I think that's a piece of it.
- 28:06But I looked, I broke down like where, the big categories.
- 28:09You got employee compensation benefits, that was up almost 8%
- 28:13over last year office operations.
- 28:16That was up almost 8%.
- 28:19And then professional services, which.
- 28:22That could be a myriad of things.
- 28:23That was up almost 10% from a year ago.
- 28:26So I think inflation, cybersecurity technology, all of that is contributing,
- 28:33trying to keep up is probably contributing to the overall expense structure growth.
- 28:38That makes a lot of sense.
- 28:40Farrar: Yeah.
- 28:41We've heard from some of our clients and that they've been investing.
- 28:45Over the past few, year, 18 months or so on their, in their technology
- 28:50to try and take advantages of ai.
- 28:53And they expect to see that start to show in their numbers
- 28:58starting really next year.
- 28:59We'll see how that goes because I was just listening to the guys talking about
- 29:03the implementation of AI and some of the businesses that have really taken it on.
- 29:09Found that, they had to go back and hire people back because they
- 29:13needed a little more human touch than they were getting off of ai.
- 29:17So it's gonna be interesting to see how that, that plays forward.
- 29:21And I think we're gonna start seeing some of those changes that pretty quickly
- 29:25because I tried to look and see if I could see the change in the numbers
- 29:27yet, and it couldn't see anything.
- 29:29It was an obvious reflection and kinda confirmed by, the
- 29:32analysis the other guys did.
- 29:35Miller: So community bank experts, Steve Farr, what's going on
- 29:38with their operating expenses?
- 29:40Are you seeing that increase there too?
- 29:42Or they more successful at keeping it
- 29:45Farrar: even?
- 29:46It, it holds pretty steady there and they do have a bit of a competitive advantage
- 29:51over the credit unions in that realm.
- 29:54It's like 40 basis points.
- 29:56That that they have an advantage over credit unions and operating expenses.
- 30:02Yeah.
- 30:02And I consider that, they have the loss of revenue on taxes that comes into play too.
- 30:08Treichel: Interesting.
- 30:10So the last I, if you haven't, couldn't tell, I went through the camel in order
- 30:16here as we were talking Todd, on the front end, you talked a little bit
- 30:19about the liquidity side of things.
- 30:21Any general thoughts on what you're seeing in the the liquidity type statistics?
- 30:28Miller: You have a fairly balanced level of growth going on right now.
- 30:33And what you're seeing with the deposit base, it's stabilizing
- 30:36back to historic numbers.
- 30:38When we got to COVID after those long years of flat interest rates, you had
- 30:44a mixture of, people that were rate sensitive, all that money was everywhere.
- 30:48It was in money Market that was in checking 'cause there was really no
- 30:50differentiation on dividends from basic, a savings account to a money market to a cd.
- 30:57Of course, as soon as rates started going up in 2023.
- 31:012022, you started seeing this rate sensitive money go
- 31:04to rate sensitive accounts.
- 31:06Right now, CDs and money markets are sitting at, let me look at this here.
- 31:12I have it somewhere.
- 31:14About 44% if you look back, 2007, 2008, when we had a normal yield curve is right.
- 31:2050%.
- 31:21So there's still a little bit of movement to go on, but basically our funding
- 31:25basis have gotten a lot more stable for our credit union than the last year.
- 31:29This whole money moving from, checking accounts into CDs or this dis air
- 31:36mediation, it's slowed way down.
- 31:38So it allows them to improve that net interest margin because that.
- 31:42Funding base has gotten very stable.
- 31:45Loan and share growth were really balanced in the last year.
- 31:48There's only a percentage or two difference, so realistically,
- 31:51funding sources in our credit unions have stayed exactly the same.
- 31:55Wholesale funding, borrowed money, non-member deposits.
- 31:58It was 5.9%
- 31:59of liabilities at the end of December.
- 32:01It's 5.2
- 32:02today.
- 32:03It was eight in 2023 borrowed money got paid down during 2024 and
- 32:09it's never gonna go back to zero.
- 32:11That 5% is probably mostly people borrowing long-term
- 32:15to hedge interest rate risk.
- 32:17So liquidity trends look really good.
- 32:20We have, clients are still getting beat up over their liquidity and NCUA has these
- 32:25expectations to support, how you operate with a limited amount of liquidity, but.
- 32:31As the industry as a whole, they look in really good shape liquidity wise.
- 32:35You've had balanced growth.
- 32:37That funding base has stayed really stable over the course of the year, so
- 32:44things have gotten a little bit easier for credit unions on that funding side.
- 32:48They still have to compete with all their other competitors that want
- 32:51that money but they don't have to.
- 32:54I don't have this volatility in funding sources that was there a couple years ago.
- 32:58So Todd, that's thing for the industry.
- 33:01Treichel: Todd, you and I were on a call with the credit union within the last week
- 33:04and they were getting asked to put some, what, some things that, that appeared to
- 33:09be odd relative to restrictions on how.
- 33:13Or parameters or guardrails on how much they would put into certain member
- 33:19types, whether it was money markets or CDs or share drafts or, and if I,
- 33:24Miller: they wanted to, the examiners in that credit, they wanted to
- 33:26limit on CDs and money markets to net worth and, my responses.
- 33:32I think that's bs.
- 33:33You have legal limits.
- 33:36And while it might be appropriate to put guardrails on non-member deposits and
- 33:40borrowed money, those secondary sources of income, I don't think it's reasonable to
- 33:45put guardrails on how you fund your share base between money market, CDs, regular
- 33:52shares, the marketplace and the yield curve is going to determine that for you.
- 33:58And competition is gonna determine that for you.
- 34:01And you can sort that out with your interest rate risk models.
- 34:05And how you measure interest rate, risk, and other liquidity metrics i'd,
- 34:10I basically said, I see no reason at all why a credit union would say We're gonna
- 34:16limit CDs to X percent of net worth.
- 34:18It made no sense to me where the examiners were coming from and they
- 34:23didn't really justify it anywhere in their exam report either.
- 34:26Dennis is making a weird face
- 34:28Bauer: yeah, no, I was gonna comment.
- 34:29I wish I was a CFO.
- 34:30I could do that.
- 34:31We're gonna have, this makeup of our certificates.
- 34:35In a and a good example of that, how the market.
- 34:38Market really determines that.
- 34:40Rates really determine it.
- 34:41And Todd alluded to this, but back in 2022, before interest rates started to go
- 34:47up quickly and interest rate environment was really low, there was only 13% of 14%
- 34:53of credit unions deposits were in CDs.
- 34:56Fast forward when interest rates started to.
- 34:59Increase and credit unions are trying to control cost of funds and they're
- 35:02offering up short term specials.
- 35:05That's now grown back up closer to 30%.
- 35:08So it's not all a matter of asset liability management and the market that's
- 35:13gonna dictate at a particular point where you're going to be, you try to, yeah.
- 35:17You, you gotta model it all and you gotta make compensation for that.
- 35:21But yeah.
- 35:23Putting a guardrail on CD portfolio.
- 35:26I wish
- 35:28Treichel: we could do that.
- 35:28Yep.
- 35:28Yeah so we advise them to push back gently and hopefully they'll they'll achieve
- 35:33some success in those negotiations.
- 35:35With that examiner, any o any other thoughts on the liquidity arena?
- 35:41Bauer: Oh, just one other thing.
- 35:42It was obviously with the decline in interest rates, the unrealized
- 35:45gains and losses on investments as is under 1% set 0.79%
- 35:51as of nine 30.
- 35:53So that also gives you a little bit more flexibility with maybe some
- 35:56liquidity issues he had before.
- 35:58So
- 35:59Miller: we will touch on this.
- 36:00I do have one more comment.
- 36:01So in 2022 when rates were low, a lot of credit unions
- 36:05went long term on investments.
- 36:07Because they had earnings pressure in the flat yield curve.
- 36:10It ended up hurting them a lot and they still haven't recovered from that.
- 36:14But what's interesting here this quarter is you can see the industry
- 36:18making bets on rates again, because they bumped up investments in that.
- 36:23Three to five and five to 10 year category.
- 36:26So there are some credit unions out there who are not making loans, but
- 36:31they are making bets on rates again, and hopefully it works out a little
- 36:35better for them than it did last time.
- 36:37Treichel: Interesting.
- 36:38Miller: Yeah.
- 36:39Bauer: I want, I wanna get when you do that one or credit unions
- 36:41are mo I mean we always did that.
- 36:43We modeled okay, we're we can hold it in cash or we're gonna, we could pick
- 36:47a longer term, investment model it and.
- 36:51The risk that you take on for the little bit of gain in a rising interest rate,
- 36:55this, you could clearly see that it wasn't worth, it's not worth the risk.
- 36:58So it's just a matter of, okay, I gotta make a decision what, how to
- 37:02deploy some of this capital, this cash.
- 37:04If you have a good AL model, it should pretty clearly show,
- 37:08you're not gonna pick up a ton in a 300 rate plus rate environment.
- 37:12Obviously it depends on the rest of your portfolio or your balance sheet.
- 37:15But generally speaking, not gonna work out.
- 37:18Miller: That's why it looks like it's a pure rate, that they're just betting
- 37:21that the fed's gonna lower rates again, and they went long term with excess cash.
- 37:24Bauer: Yeah, but then your gain, right?
- 37:25If you're you're not getting much of a gain, even if it works out.
- 37:28Your benefit's not gonna be that great.
- 37:30Might add a basis point or two to your bottom line, but not worth the risk.
- 37:33Man.
- 37:34Treichel: When I hear risk reward, I think about this example, this quote I heard in
- 37:38the, there was a hedge fund that failed.
- 37:41That was doing some risky things.
- 37:42They were called long-term capital management, but one of the, one of the
- 37:46people who ended up buying that one hedge fund, bought that hedge fund.
- 37:49And they said that their strategy was like picking up
- 37:52nickels in front of a bulldozer.
- 37:55And that obviously credit union should avoid strategies of going long.
- 37:59Hopefully if they're doing it, they've got people that are advising them
- 38:02on what makes sense and they're not not betting the house so to speak.
- 38:08Farrar: Yeah make a thoroughly researched good business decision
- 38:12Treichel: and MCA might ask for that documentation on that business decision.
- 38:16Who knows?
- 38:18So I have one slide in front of me from a lawyer a lawyer, and did a
- 38:23presentation for Callahan on the quarterly data that they'd have.
- 38:27And of course, Callahan gets their data out a little quicker
- 38:30and does a presentation on it.
- 38:33And one slide caught my eye, which the title of the slide is, members are
- 38:37Dipping Into More of their Available.
- 38:40Heloc, home equity line of credit balances and credit unions are issuing more lines.
- 38:45And the visual is this.
- 38:46So back in the end of 2020 through about the middle of 2021, credit
- 38:54unions had issued about 150 billion in lines, and those lines bottomed
- 39:01out on being tapped into at about 48% in the first quarter of 2022.
- 39:08So jump ahead to today from the first quarter of 2022 to the third quarter
- 39:12of 2025, there are, if I'm reading this right, about 325 billion outstanding.
- 39:22So more than doubled home equity lines approved line of credits.
- 39:27And not only did they double, instead of being tapped into at
- 39:3048%, they're tapped into at 56.4%.
- 39:36When I throw that out there what pops into your heads?
- 39:40Farrar: Yeah.
- 39:41My experience with the HELOCs is it was highly regionalized and that
- 39:46it's always in, those areas with the highest increase in property values.
- 39:51And so I think it would go beyond those numbers.
- 39:53I would be pretty sure that trend would continue.
- 39:57Miller: It really accelerated in 2022 and 2023, even 2024, but that
- 40:03has slowed way down here in 2025.
- 40:06Okay?
- 40:08It was double digit, so like I have it right in front of me.
- 40:12Just outstanding balances went up 39% in 2022.
- 40:1724% in 2023, 17% in 2024.
- 40:23It's only up 4% in 2025.
- 40:26So it's okay, have people tapped 'em out to the extent they're able, right?
- 40:31And then you get certain things with the high cost of automobiles and stuff.
- 40:36You know how many people are using home equity loans to buy what would
- 40:39traditionally been consumer goods?
- 40:42So yeah so the answer to that, but, so you got, when we started.
- 40:47Treichel: When we started, it was, what, 36 and 48 month loans and now
- 40:51we're into 60, 72, 84 or more loans.
- 40:55And then you could, because of the costs you could spread it out.
- 40:58You could just pay you get a home equity loan and just pay the interest.
- 41:01So that could be, or maybe you get the car loan and you put a
- 41:04little bit on the home equity line.
- 41:06That could.
- 41:07Create some pressure points.
- 41:09Miller: The other piece of it too is some of this could be just your remodeling
- 41:13and home improvement stuff as well.
- 41:15People, it's, 'cause the prices, it's harder to trade up and there's less
- 41:19trading up that makes going, makes sense.
- 41:21And there's less home sales available.
- 41:24There's probably ways to dig in and figure out what that money's being used for.
- 41:28Treichel: We'll just could be a
- 41:29Miller: lot of different reasons.
- 41:30We'll just, and maybe s are doing it just to reduce their credit risk because,
- 41:35home equity loans probably a little bit less on that Cecil model than a
- 41:38car loan is if people have that equity.
- 41:41Interesting.
- 41:44Bauer: Long as home values stay where they're at.
- 41:46That's so when you brought that up, it brought back memories
- 41:48of 28, 2008, nine, and 10.
- 41:51And that's where we.
- 41:53Experienced a lot of losses was were in, the home equity portion of the
- 41:57portfolio, so so we're increasing that and looking at that, hopefully
- 42:01good concentration risk limits in place and following that particularly.
- 42:05Values drop, making sure that you're,
- 42:07Treichel: you're covered, that you're on it and you've got reasonable limits.
- 42:10Makes sense.
- 42:11Yep.
- 42:12Miller: I'm a belief that every generation has to relearn
- 42:15their lessons all over again.
- 42:17Treichel: What does it, so I don't know who said this, history doesn't repeat
- 42:20itself, but it certainly does rhyme
- 42:23Miller: well.
- 42:24What else guys?
- 42:26I think another interesting thing, and see, they put out different pieces of
- 42:30information each quarter and you have to go to their analysis page and download
- 42:34a whole bunch of different things.
- 42:35On one of the things you can download, they have charts of camel ratings
- 42:40and while the number of code threes isn't necessarily going up, the number
- 42:46of code ones is plunging really.
- 42:51Especially on credit unions, 1 billion and over.
- 42:55The number of code ones is just dropping every single year.
- 43:00Treichel: That's interesting.
- 43:01Yeah.
- 43:01I always focus in on the three, four, and five data and I just ignore that
- 43:04one, but that, that that's interesting.
- 43:06Code
- 43:06Miller: threes went up in 2024.
- 43:08They haven't in, in 2025 but certainly the number of code ones
- 43:13is tumbling in the 1 billion in.
- 43:1710 billion categories, which is interesting when we know that,
- 43:22supervision wise, NCUA is gonna do less, they're extending exam cycles.
- 43:29And it will be interesting to see how that plays out.
- 43:33I see a not good ending to it personally, but just me,
- 43:38Treichel: I had, along the lines of, extending the exam cycle.
- 43:42And as we've discussed on other podcasts, and Todd, you discovered that on their
- 43:46NSPM they changed without publishing it, that they don't necessarily
- 43:50have to do a follow up and a code.
- 43:53Three every 180 days.
- 43:54And it used to be that they had to, and it had to be from finish date to finish date.
- 43:58And then they played with that a little bit.
- 44:00Now they're saying you don't necessarily have to have a follow up.
- 44:03And of course the CAMEL code in part is a resource tool.
- 44:06So if you code them a three, but you don't have to go back, are you
- 44:09really using it at the resource tool that it's supposed to be?
- 44:13And I made a.
- 44:14A, I was chatting with somebody from NCOA and I was saying, so
- 44:19what's the result of this gonna be?
- 44:20Are you, are examiners gonna go in and say, Hey, this is a borderline
- 44:25two, three, I'm not gonna have the resources to go in there, so you know
- 44:29what I'm gonna err on the side of not caution and give them an overall two.
- 44:34Or are they gonna, were they gonna put their thumb on the
- 44:36scale the other way and say.
- 44:38Hey, you know what?
- 44:39I'm not gonna have to go back and I don't want this to blow up on my
- 44:42watch, so I might as well code 'em a three anyway, because I'm not
- 44:45hamstrung by having to go back.
- 44:47Which one will it be or will it just normalize out?
- 44:50And you'll have some desu, some doing one and some doing another, but there will
- 44:54be some ramifications of this resource issue on Camel codes one way or another.
- 45:01Miller: The ones they put the thumb on the scale are the ones that are calling us.
- 45:04Treichel: Yes.
- 45:05Oh yes.
- 45:05Most definitely.
- 45:07Most definitely.
- 45:08And that conversation wa was around that is, is what is it that we're seeing
- 45:12And we see a little bit of that where.
- 45:14Where there seems to be an an overly aggressive situation
- 45:18in a particular credit union.
- 45:19Hey, if you're listening and that happens to you give us a call and we can help out.
- 45:23Miller: The other part of it, and maybe I'm just overthinking it.
- 45:27You're gonna have a change in administration in a couple years.
- 45:30They're going through all these massive cuts now and this kind of happened during
- 45:35the Reagan years with NCUA as well, by coding them lower, they setting a stage
- 45:41for, in 20 29, 20, 20 30, okay, we need to hire all these many people back.
- 45:48I don't know.
- 45:48Like I said, I might be overthinking it as a supervisor, I might.
- 45:52Actually a thought long term like that, how do we get out of the turmoil when
- 45:57there's a change in administration?
- 46:00Treichel: Sure.
- 46:00Change in administration and at some juncture, if they reduce costs in
- 46:04the budget, a hundred million dollars picking a number, and there's less of
- 46:08a imprint in credit union, short terms, individual credit unions like that.
- 46:12At some juncture, the economy moves.
- 46:18There is a loss or two, the IG does an audit report, brings that audit
- 46:23report to management and says, you need to, we have to come on
- 46:26an agreement on how to fix this.
- 46:27And you, at that point in time, you have an NCA board that has
- 46:30the appetite to expand staff.
- 46:32That's how I see it playing out in the pendulum going in the other direction.
- 46:36And it probably ties to a obviously a different administration at that juncture.
- 46:40Farrar: All right guys.
- 46:41Another thing that I usually update every quarter is I take a quick look at the
- 46:45N-C-U-S-I-F to carrying it to the deposit insurance fund, and they both have had
- 46:50a pretty good quarter, but equity ratios or the designated reserve ratios are up.
- 46:55The equity ratio, the NCSF is 1.28
- 46:58with the normal operating level 1.33,
- 47:01but the deposit insurance fund had a tremendous quarter.
- 47:05They finished a restoration plan when they got up above 1.36.
- 47:09Theirs is at 1.40
- 47:11now, so they're doing really well with their long-term goal of getting to 2%
- 47:16because of how massive their losses can be because of contagion risk and all that.
- 47:22One of the more interesting things is the yield on investments is
- 47:25so different between the two.
- 47:27For the N-C-S-A-F-S, it's 2.77%
- 47:30with a weighted average maturity of 2.7
- 47:33years.
- 47:34The deposit insurance fund does yield investments is 4.2%
- 47:38with a weighted average maturity of 0.57
- 47:41years.
- 47:42So they garner a lot more off of their investments but
- 47:46Bauer: They stay short.
- 47:48So is that, so their maturity is 0.57,
- 47:50you said?
- 47:51Miller: Yeah.
- 47:52Bauer: So they're shorter, but a higher yield.
- 47:55Then Okay.
- 47:57Miller: Benefiting from that inverted yield curve, it'll cost
- 48:00them rates go back to normal.
- 48:03Treichel: That sounds like a chip Filson email to the NCA board.
- 48:08Yeah.
- 48:10All right guys, so what else we got?
- 48:12Any final thoughts?
- 48:13Let's go around the around the horn here, as they say.
- 48:17Miller: I started with, hey, things are returning to normal, and that's where
- 48:20I'll end it too, is we're returning to a normalized level, which makes life a
- 48:26little bit easier for the credit union.
- 48:28They still have all these competitive factors and competition is never
- 48:32gonna go away, and their job is not gonna become easy, but it's a
- 48:36little bit easier for the moment,
- 48:39Treichel: a little bit easier.
- 48:39I like that Steve.
- 48:42Farrar: Yeah, competition is continues to change and you become more and more
- 48:46real with other entities in which they have to deal with and the demographics.
- 48:51So I think that's, something that might be affecting why, there's
- 48:55why there are less camel ones.
- 48:59Treichel: Makes sense.
- 48:59And as you mentioned, demographics two episodes back had a really good episode
- 49:04with Dan Preso of Olden Lane about the dynamics of of the the age, the
- 49:10different age groups, the Gen X, the Gen Z, the Gen Y, the Gen Q, whatever.
- 49:14Whatever name they put on all the generations and how that's
- 49:18impacting credit unions and having a game plan for that.
- 49:20If you're, if you've made it to the end of this episode, I, and you
- 49:24haven't listened to that episode, I highly recommend it, Dennis.
- 49:27All right.
- 49:27Last thoughts?
- 49:29Bauer: Yeah.
- 49:29I, basically what Todd Todd said, and credit as we're getting.
- 49:34To normal.
- 49:34The only thing I point out, again, credit unions continue to grow.
- 49:37They're strong.
- 49:38However, the number of credit unions continues to drop.
- 49:41I think since the last quarter we're down 168 and any credit unions
- 49:46under a hundred million, lost 179.
- 49:48Credit union.
- 49:49So obviously a shift and then mergers accounted for obviously that, that change.
- 49:55Treichel: And then there's the whole arena of the big merging with the big,
- 49:57which we won't get in here today, but some interesting big approvals across
- 50:01the industry, which will chan, which will impact the landscape as well.
- 50:06All right guys, and thank you as always for being on the show.
- 50:11And listeners, I want to thank you for listening and or watchers on YouTube.
- 50:15I want to thank you for watching.
- 50:16This is Mark TriCal signing off with flying Colors.