Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Alex Acosta And His Epstein Interview With OIG Inspectors (Part 11)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:02Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're going to pick up
- 0:06where we left off with alex Acosta's interview with the
- 0:10OIG Inspectors. Question, let me ask you this, having reached
- 0:15the decision that you approved that this was the offer
- 0:18and the term sheet or the terms. Having that decision made,
- 0:21would you have expected the line USA to frustrate that
- 0:25or to not abide by that since it was your decision.
- 0:29Answer no, with a caveat that, if at any point
- 0:32someone felt truly uncomfortable, I would expect them to come
- 0:35and talk to me about it. Question and can you
- 0:38recall any instance in which an ausa aligne ausa came
- 0:43and talked to you about a disposition that he or
- 0:46she was uncomfortable with. Answer? Yes, so I'll give you
- 0:50an example. I don't recall who before you asked me,
- 0:53but there was this ausa who was new to the
- 0:57office who impressed the hell out of me. I'm sorry
- 0:59that's not the appropriate language. Who impressed me significantly. He
- 1:03had inherited a case, and it was a fraud case,
- 1:06and the bigger players had been charged, and he was
- 1:08basically given a lesser player to basically just finish up
- 1:12on right. It was a done deal. The person was
- 1:15ready to plead to some minor account, no jail time,
- 1:18and he felt comfortable with it and went to a
- 1:20supervisor and then ultimately came up to me and I
- 1:23had a discussion with this person about it, and it
- 1:26ended up with my telling him to go back and
- 1:29call the defense counsel and tell them we were dropping
- 1:31the case, which for new AUSA in the office is
- 1:35pretty gutsy and unusual. But if this person really felt
- 1:39that this lesser player wasn't deserving, then that was the
- 1:42right thing to do. And so I don't think that
- 1:45the person was not punished for it. If anything, you know,
- 1:48I recounted that story to others. Question okay, A question
- 1:53shifting gears a little bit about US Code eighteen twenty
- 1:56two dot fifty five. Answer yes, okay. Question not to
- 2:01be confused with twenty eight US Code section twenty two
- 2:05to fifty five, which every prosecutor is familiar with. So
- 2:08whose idea was that it's a civil provision a civil
- 2:12it's not restitution, it's damages. It's damages recovery provision in
- 2:17the criminal Code? Answer right. Question who came up with that? Answer?
- 2:22I can't speak to who came up with that question? Okay?
- 2:26Answer I can speak to the reasoning behind it. Question
- 2:29your reasoning or the proponent's reasoning. Answer of my recollection
- 2:34of the reasoning as to why we thought it was important.
- 2:37Question and the importance was to provide a mechanism for
- 2:40recovery of damages? Answer yeah, I mean the victim's bad
- 2:45situation and we and here is will go on? Question
- 2:50all right? Answer I might circle back on something. Question
- 2:54so is it fair to say that a fairly had
- 2:57ever heard of it before? Had you come across it before? Answer?
- 3:01I don't know, but I don't think so. Question okay,
- 3:04so is it fair to say it was novel to
- 3:06the office, to you and to the team. Answer I
- 3:09don't think it's fair to say that it's novel to
- 3:11the office. Question well, do you recall whether anybody in
- 3:16the team had experience with US Code eighteen, Section twenty
- 3:20two to fifty five in a criminal case. Answer I
- 3:24don't have a recollection of any discussion as to whether
- 3:27people had experienced with this or not. Question did you
- 3:30believe that any legal research was needed or should be
- 3:34undertaken to ensure that the procedure was in fact legally
- 3:37sound when embedded, as it was in this case in
- 3:40a criminal plea. Answer, So, I would have expected to
- 3:44the extent that there were concerns. Again, we had an
- 3:48incredibly experienced between the various individuals on my management team,
- 3:53we probably had fifty years plus of criminal experience. I
- 3:57would have expected, to the extent of their concern for
- 3:59those concerns to be raised. Question did you raise any
- 4:04such concerns about it? Or did it seem to make
- 4:06sense to you? Answer? From my perspective, I don't know
- 4:10if it was at the time or subsequent to it
- 4:12reading it, and it seemed it seemed to make sense.
- 4:16Question Okay, after a dacted's letter went out on the
- 4:20third of August, you almost immediately, it appears you received
- 4:23a telephone call from Kirkland dan Ellis. Is that correct? Answer?
- 4:27I don't recall it independently, but that's what the record shows.
- 4:30Question all right, and that's reflected in Exhibit twelve. Do
- 4:35you remember who called you? Answer? I do not. Question
- 4:38do you recall it? Apparently was from the context of
- 4:41this Exhibit twelve and caption Epstein. Question it appears that
- 4:46the call is related to Epstein. Correct answer. Correct again,
- 4:50I don't remember the phone call, but from the email,
- 4:53I accept that it happened. Question so, what had been
- 4:56your knowledge and relationship with Ken Starr of kur Glen
- 5:00Ellis up to this point? Answer? So, I had been
- 5:03an associate at Kirkland. I think I indicated that it
- 5:07was from ninety four to ninety What was it? Was
- 5:10it ninety six or ninety seven? Question? Couple of years? Answer?
- 5:14For a couple of years. I worked on at least
- 5:17one case that I recall with them. I was the
- 5:19junior associate on merits brief that he argued. He at
- 5:23the time was also a special counsel, and so he
- 5:26wasn't in the office nearly as much because he was
- 5:28double hitting as special counsel and partner. Question all right,
- 5:33and what about redacted? Answer? So redacted was a partner
- 5:37at the time. I don't recall working with him on
- 5:39any particular case, although I think I work with him
- 5:42on at least a matter. He was on my hallway.
- 5:45He had an outside office. I had the typical inside office.
- 5:50Answer had you had any interaction, any contact with him
- 5:53in the intervening years socially or professionally? Answer off and
- 5:58on I was in Washington. You know, Ken Starr was
- 6:01in Washington. I think redacted had moved to New York
- 6:05but then came back to Washington to be in the administration,
- 6:08and he was in the policy office. And we may
- 6:10have not have, may have we likely interacted? Question and
- 6:15while you were here at the criminal at Civil Rights Division?
- 6:19Answer correct? Question? All right? Were you friends? Were you
- 6:22professional acquaintances? Were you what? How would you characterize that? Answer?
- 6:29We were professional acquaintance that had worked together several years
- 6:32ago that continued to interact. Question is that true as
- 6:36to the two of them? Answer? I mean, it's hard
- 6:39to characterize these things. I think it's fair to say. Question,
- 6:42did ken Starr know who you were? Answer? Yes? Question
- 6:46and obviously redacted as well? Answer yes. Question Okay, So
- 6:51what was your reaction to being contacted by them by
- 6:54their firm? Then presumably one of them? Perhaps? Answer so,
- 6:59I don't know who. Based on the email, I can
- 7:01infer that it was one of them. Question mm hmm. Answer,
- 7:05And you know, I think my reaction is captured by
- 7:08not the email, but by Jeff's comment. I don't have
- 7:12a clear recollection, but I'm going to speculate infer that
- 7:15I heard they were being brought onto the case, and
- 7:18I probably walked down to Jeff's office and said, Hey,
- 7:21Kirkland is coming onto the case. I bet they're going
- 7:24to come on to try and take this thing to DC.
- 7:27And then I get a phone call, and you know,
- 7:30I tell Matt, who tells Jeff, And you know, I
- 7:32didn't know. Maybe Kirkland made a call to You're right, unbelievable,
- 7:37And then I say they're likely to go to DC.
- 7:40We should strategize a bit. My concerns behind that are
- 7:43will DC look at this as sort of illegally troubled,
- 7:46going back to the earlier points that I made about
- 7:48the policy issues around the trafficking issues up here in DC,
- 7:53And I really do think he should go to jail,
- 7:55and so I want to strategize a bit. Question, So,
- 7:59did you have a concern about the fact that you
- 8:02that the defense team was sort of appealing you to
- 8:04the Big House? Answer? I think based on this, I
- 8:07almost predicted that it would happen. And Jeff is saying
- 8:11you were right, unbelievable, where I in some way, shape
- 8:15or form predicted that something would someone would be hired,
- 8:18or something would happen to take this all up to DC.
- 8:22Question and had you had experience with other cases, other
- 8:26instances in which defense team went to DC while you
- 8:29were at the US Attorney's office while you were the
- 8:32US attorney? Answer? Yes, question was that a concern to you? Answer?
- 8:37It wasn't a concern. It was how do we address
- 8:40this so that we can back our position and our office. Question?
- 8:44Did you have concerns about the disposition that was underway
- 8:48about Main Justice scrutiny of the NPA scheme? Answer? So,
- 8:52I had no concerns about Maine Justice scrutiny of the
- 8:55NPA scheme. In fact, I invited Drew to come down
- 8:59and he was part of the me where we discussed
- 9:01the NPA. And so I say that because if I
- 9:04had concerns, I wouldn't have invited them. If anything, my
- 9:07concern was is Main Justice on board or are we
- 9:10going to basically be told to drop this case when
- 9:13it goes up to main Justice? Question In your email
- 9:17to redacted when Sloman's on vacation, you say that you
- 9:20make reference to a process fel that the attorneys in
- 9:23the defense team want to go to DC on the
- 9:25case on the grounds of a process. Fel that I
- 9:29have not met with them, and you express concern that
- 9:31it would delay matters. Is that what led you to
- 9:34agree to meet with the defense team on the seventh
- 9:36of September? Answer? It is. My concern was if they
- 9:40came up to DC and the first talking about was
- 9:43the US attorney didn't even agree to meet with us,
- 9:47that's not the best foot to start with when you're
- 9:49having your case reviewed. Question So what was your understanding
- 9:54of what the purpose of the meeting on September seventh
- 9:56was supposed to be? Answer? They wanted to argue they,
- 10:00being defense counsel, wanted to argue why we should not
- 10:03pursue the case. Question and in this case it was
- 10:07Starr and Leftkowitz from kirk Lan Ellis and LILIANE. Sanchez.
- 10:11I believe who met with you? Answer Phair, I remember
- 10:14it was Starr and left Kowitz. I don't know if
- 10:16it was lilian Question all right, And our information is
- 10:20it was you, Drew Osterband Sloman redacted, and John McMillan.
- 10:25Do you know John McMillan Answer vaguely? Question all right?
- 10:30He was an Ausa as well. Answer right. Question correct
- 10:34in West Palm Beach. Answer right? And if I could
- 10:37just add again, I invited Drew, so Drew became fully
- 10:40aware of that, and my concern in getting Drew into
- 10:43the meeting was to not have them appeal us and
- 10:46then having Drew say not a good case. Question all right,
- 10:50So were you aware that Drew Osterband had, in preparation
- 10:54for this gone to West pomd Beach and actually gone
- 10:56through the evidence and met with the case agent and
- 10:59the line Au. Answer I was not. Drew is an
- 11:03independent actor and could do yeah, what he thought was appropriate.
- 11:06Question does that seem like an appropriate thing for him
- 11:09to have done in your eyes? Answer? Sure? Question okay,
- 11:14would you describe the meeting? Oh and to other people
- 11:17who were there again asak Val Parlav and Junior Ortiz
- 11:22the SSA. So the meeting I think was in West
- 11:26pom Beach. Answer yes. Question So what do you recall
- 11:29about the meeting the dynamics, who spoke? How did it
- 11:32go down? Answer? I recall there was a lot of people.
- 11:35I think mister Starr spoke most of the time. My
- 11:39recollection as best as I can, you know, with the
- 11:41caveat I thought redacted was there and clearly wasn't. So
- 11:45presented several arguments. I then either left the room with
- 11:49my team or I think I most likely asked them
- 11:51to leave the room. I then went around to gets interrupted,
- 11:55asked who to leave the room the defense. I then
- 11:58went around the table. I said does anyone have any
- 12:01concerns or something to that effect, and then, hearing none,
- 12:04I asked them to come back in and I reaffirmed
- 12:07the position of the office. Question. In other words, you
- 12:11sort of decided, you ruled from the bench as it were.
- 12:14Fair enough answer, fair enough question, Okay, you didn't take
- 12:20under advisement. You gave them what your position was right
- 12:22then and there. Answer, that's my recollection. I don't know
- 12:26if you have information contrary question, okay, answer that's my recollection.
- 12:33Question okay. So is it fair to say it was
- 12:35more of a presentation on the part of ken Starr
- 12:38and decide rather than a debate or a discussion. Answer.
- 12:42I think that's fair to say. I may have asked
- 12:44a question or two, but my recollection was not a negotiation.
- 12:49But oh, let's hear you out question and so we
- 12:52understand it was mainly a federalism presentation as opposed to evidence.
- 12:57Is this accurate answer? I believe that that's accurate. Yes. Question,
- 13:02And in your letter to ken start dated The letter
- 13:04is actually not dated, but we know that it was
- 13:07sent on the fourth of December of two thousand and seven,
- 13:10and it's in this package. You noted which exhibit. Mister
- 13:14Gonzalez asks thirty four. Question, thank you, exhibit thirty four.
- 13:19You note on page four, I'm sorry, page five you
- 13:22refer to a federalism argument, and you say that after
- 13:25considering the arguments and conferring with the FBI and Drew Osterband,
- 13:30you decided to proceed with the indictment, but that would
- 13:33delay presentation of the indictment to allow the defense to
- 13:36appeal to DC. Does that mean that you didn't find
- 13:39federalism arguments sufficiently persuasive to you to change your position. Answer? Yes,
- 13:46with the position defined as some concern but if we
- 13:49need to, if we don't come to a resolution based
- 13:52on the sheet, then we indict. All right, folks, We're
- 13:55gonna wrap up right here and in the next episode
- 13:57dealing with the topic, we're gonna pick up where we
- 13:59left off. All of the information that goes with this
- 14:02episode can be found in the description box.