Latest / Wisdom of the Ages Library / 07 - A Confession - Leo Tolstory
Transcript
- 0:00Chapter seven of a confession by Leo Tolstoy. Not finding an explanation in science,
- 0:05I began to seek forward in life, hoping to find it among the
- 0:08people around me. And I began to observe how the people around me,
- 0:12people like myself, lived, and what their attitude was to this question which
- 0:16had brought me to despair. And this is what I found among people who
- 0:19were in the same position as myself, as regards education and manner of life.
- 0:23I found that for people in my circle, there are four ways out
- 0:26of the terrible position in which we are all placed. The first was that
- 0:30of ignorance. It consists of not knowing, of not understanding that life is
- 0:34evil and an absurdity. People of this sort, chiefly women, or very
- 0:38young or very dull people, have not yet understood the question of life which
- 0:41presented itself to Schopenhauer, Solomon, and Buddha. They see neither the dragon
- 0:46that awaits them, nor the mice gnawing at the shrub by which they are
- 0:49hanging. And they licked the drops of honey. But they licked these drops
- 0:52of honey only for a while. Something will turn their attention to the dragon
- 0:55and the mice and there will be an end to their licking from them.
- 0:58I had nothing to learn. One cannot cease to know what one does know.
- 1:02The second way out is epicureanism. It consists while knowing of the hopelessness
- 1:06of life, in making use meanwhile of the advantages one has disregarding the dragon
- 1:11and the mice, and looking the honey in the best way, especially if
- 1:14there is much of it within reach. Solomon expresses this way. Thus,
- 1:18then I commanded mirth, because man hath no better thing under the sun than
- 1:22to eat, to drink, and to be merry, and that this should
- 1:25accompany him in his labor the days of his life, which God giveth him
- 1:27under the sun. Therefore, eat thy bread with joy, and drink thy
- 1:32wine with a merry heart, with joyfully with the wife whom thou lovest,
- 1:36all the days of the life of thy vanity. For this is thy portion
- 1:38in life and in thy labors, which thou takest under the sun. Whatsoever
- 1:44thy hand fitteth to do do with thy might, For there is not work,
- 1:48nor device, nor knowledge nor wisdom in the grave. Whither thou goest.
- 1:52That is the way in which the majority of people of our circle make
- 1:53life possible for themselves. Their circumstances furnish them with more welfare than of hardship,
- 2:00and their moral dulness makes it possible for them to forget that the advantage
- 2:02of their position is accidental, and that not everyone can have a thousand wives
- 2:07and palaces like Solomon, and that for everyone who has a thousand wives,
- 2:09there are a thousand without a wife, and that for every palace there are
- 2:14a thousand people who have to build it in the sweat of their brows.
- 2:16And that the accident that has to day made me a Solomon may tomorrow make
- 2:20me solomon slave. The dullness of these people's imagination enables them to forget the
- 2:24things that gave boodh no peace, the inevitability of sickness, old age,
- 2:28and death, which to day or tomorrow will destroy all these pleasures. So
- 2:32think and feel the majority of people of our day and our manner of life.
- 2:37The fact that some of these people declare the dullness of their thoughts and
- 2:39imaginations to be a philosophy which they call positive, does not remove them,
- 2:44in my opinion, from the ranks of those who, to avoid seeing the
- 2:46question lick the honey. I could not imitate these people, not having their
- 2:51dullness of imagination, I could not artificially produce it in myself. I could
- 2:55not tear my eyes away from the mice in the dragon, as no vital
- 2:59man can after he has once seen them. The third escape is that of
- 3:02strength and energy. It consists in destroying life when one has understood that it
- 3:07is an evil and an absurdity. A few exceptionally strong and consistent people act
- 3:12so, having understood the stupidity of the joke that has been played on them,
- 3:15and having understood that it is better to be dead than to be alive,
- 3:19and that is best of all not to exist, They act accordingly and
- 3:22promptly end this stupid joke, since there are means a rope round one's neck,
- 3:27water and a knife to stick in one's heart, or the trains on
- 3:29a railway. And the number of those in our circle who act this way
- 3:32becomes greater and greater. And for the most part they act though at the
- 3:36best time of their life, when the strength of their mind is in full
- 3:38bloom, and few habits degrading to the mind have as yet been acquired.
- 3:43I saw that this was the worthiest way of escape. And I wish to
- 3:46adopt it. The fourth way out is that of weakness. It consists in
- 3:51seeing the truth of the situation and yet clinging to life, knowing in advance
- 3:54that nothing can come of it. People of this kind know that death is
- 3:58better than life, but not having my strength to act rationally to end the
- 4:01deception quickly and kill themselves, they seemed to wait for something. This is
- 4:05the escape of weakness. For if I know what is best and it is
- 4:09within my power, why not yield to what is best? I found myself
- 4:13in that category. So people of my class evade the terrible contradiction in four
- 4:16ways. Strained my attention as I would, I saw no way except these
- 4:20four. One was not to understand that life is senseless, vanity, and
- 4:24and evil, and that it is better not to live. I could not
- 4:28help knowing this, and when I once knew that, I could not shut
- 4:30my eyes to it. The second way was to use life such as without
- 4:33thinking to the future, and I could not do that. I, like
- 4:36Sakimuni, could not ride out hunting when I knew that old age, suffering
- 4:41and death exist. My imagination was too vivid, Nor could I rejoice in
- 4:46the momentary accidents that for an instant threw pleasure to my lot. The third
- 4:49way, having understood that life is evil and stupid, was to end it
- 4:53by killing oneself. I understood that, but somehow still did not kill myself.
- 4:58The fourth way was to live, like Solomon in Schopenhauer, knowing that
- 5:00life was a stupid joke played upon us, and yet still go on living,
- 5:04washing oneself, dressing, dining, talking, and even writing books.
- 5:09This was to me repulsive and tormenting, but I remained in that position.
- 5:13I see now that if I did not kill myself, it was due to
- 5:15some dim consciousness of the invalidity of my thoughts. However, convincing an indubitable
- 5:20appeared to me the sequence of my thoughts and of those of the wise,
- 5:24that had brought us to the admission of the senselessness of life. There remained
- 5:28in me a vague doubt of the justice of my conclusion. It was like
- 5:30this, I, my reason, have acknowledged that life is senseless. If
- 5:34there is nothing higher than reason, and there is not nothing can prove that
- 5:38there is, then reason is the creator of life. For me. If
- 5:42reason did not exist, there would be for me no life. How could
- 5:45reason deny life when it is the creator of life? Or, to put
- 5:47it in another way, were there no life, my reason would not exist.
- 5:50And therefore reason is life's son. Life is all reason is the fruit,
- 5:56and yet reason rejects life itself. I felt that there was something wrong
- 5:59here. Life is a senseless evil, that is certain, said I to
- 6:02myself. Yet I have lived and am still living, and all mankind lived
- 6:06and lives. How is that? Why does it live when it is possible
- 6:11not to live? Is it that only I, in Schopenhauer are wise enough
- 6:15to understand the senselessness and evil of life? The reasoning showing the vanity of
- 6:18life is not difficult, and it has long been familiar to the very simplest
- 6:23of folk. And yet they have lived and still lived. How is it
- 6:27that they all live and never think of doubting the reasonableness of life? My
- 6:30knowledge, confirmed by the wisdom of the sages, has shown me that everything
- 6:33on Earth, organic and inorganic, is all the most cleverly arranged. Only
- 6:39my own position is stupid. And these fools, the enormous masks of people,
- 6:44know nothing about how everything organic and inorganic in the world is arranged.
- 6:47But they live and it seems to them that their life is very wisely arranged.
- 6:51And it struck me. But what if there is something I do not
- 6:54yet know? Ignorance behaves just in this way. Ignorance always says just what
- 6:59I am saying. When it does not know something, it says that what
- 7:02it does not know is stupid. Indeed, it appears that there is a
- 7:05whole humanity that lived and lives as if understanding the meaning of life. For
- 7:10without understanding it could not live. But I say that all life is senseless,
- 7:14and that I cannot live. Nothing prevents our denying life by suicide.
- 7:17Well, then kill yourself and you won't discuss. If life displeases you,
- 7:21kill yourself. You live and cannot understand the meaning of life, then finish
- 7:26it. Do not fool about in life saying and writing that you do not
- 7:29understand it. You have come into good company where people are contented and know
- 7:32what they are doing. If you find that dull and repulsive, go away.
- 7:36Indeed, what are we who are convinced of the necessity of suicide and
- 7:41yet do not commit it? But the weakest, most inconsistent, and to
- 7:44put it plainly, the stupidest of men fussing about with our own stupidity,
- 7:47as a fool fusses about with a painted hussy. For our wisdom, however
- 7:51indubitable it may be, has not given us the knowledge of the meaning of
- 7:56our life. But all mankind who sustain life, millions of them, do
- 8:00not doubt the meaning of life. Indeed, from the most distant time from
- 8:03which I knew anything, when life began, people have lived knowing the argument
- 8:07about the vanity of life, which has shown me its senselessness, and yet
- 8:11they have lived attributing some meaning to it. From the time when any life
- 8:15began among men, they had that meaning of life, and they led that
- 8:18life which descended to me. All that is in me and around me,
- 8:22all corporeal and incorporeal, is the fruit of their knowledge of life. Those
- 8:28very instruments of thought with which I consider this life and condemn it, were
- 8:31all devised not by me, but by them. I myself was born,
- 8:35taught, and brought up thanks to them. They dug out the iron,
- 8:37taught us to cut down the forest, tame the cows and the horses,
- 8:41taught us to sow corn and to live together, organized our life. Taught
- 8:45me to think and speak, and I their product, fed supplied with drink,
- 8:50taught by them, thinking with their thoughts and words, have argued that
- 8:52they are in absurdity. There is something wrong, said I to myself.
- 8:56I have blundered somewhere, but it was a long time before I could find
- 9:00out what that mistake was. End of chapter seven.