Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / Steve Saretsky: Is it profitable to be a landlord in British Columbia?
Transcript
- 0:02Check Podcasts. Welcome back to this is Van Keller. Now, when we
- 0:10left off, I was giving the gears to landlords in this province and famous
- 0:14landlord Kevin Falcon. But maybe I'm wrong. Maybe landlords have it tough as
- 0:20they extract the household earnings from their renters to finance their purchase of a stable,
- 0:25appreciating asset like residential real estate. Here to give the other side is
- 0:29a real estate agent, analyst, commentator and advisor to policymakers and real estate
- 0:34developers alike. He's always making the rounds in local media as his business is
- 0:39among the top one percent of Greater Vancouver realtors and his weekly newsletter reaches several
- 0:45thousand readers. The founder of the Siretski Group, he is Steve Siretsky.
- 0:51Steve, so nice to see you. Thanks for having me on. It's
- 0:52always a pleasure. We let too much time pass for you to come back
- 0:56on, so I apologize, but it is nice to see you in person
- 0:59again. Likewise, looking good. Thank you you as well. Okay,
- 1:02I really gave landlords a hard time in the previous segment, but you were
- 1:07telling me that landlords actually have it pretty tough here in British Columbia. So
- 1:11I want you to make your case for why it's not attractive to be a
- 1:15landlord here. Yeah, I mean, I'll frame this up, which I
- 1:18think is no one's ever going to I don't think anyone's ever had sympathy for
- 1:21a landlord. I'm not expecting that to change anytime soon, obviously, especially
- 1:25in Vancouver. You look at the last ten twenty years of equity growth,
- 1:29you know, it's hard to again sympathize with the landlord. What I would
- 1:33sort of frame it up for is the other side of it. Looking at
- 1:37just strictly from like a number's perspective, you're saying, you know, the
- 1:38landlords say so. For example, I've had clients that have brought properties seven,
- 1:42eight, nine years ago, for example. Okay, And you know,
- 1:47these are like small mom pops, and it typically some of them for
- 1:51some of them, not all of them, but some of these ones in
- 1:53particular have been very cautious about raising rents. They say, you know,
- 1:57I've got a great tenet in there. I just want them to stay.
- 2:00They're always on time, they never call, they never complain. So I've
- 2:02just kind of just left my rents and you know, that that hasn't been
- 2:07an issue because you know, interest rates have stayed relatively the same for for
- 2:12really the last ten plus years. And so what we've see now in recent
- 2:17months is I didn't raise my rent for you know, five six years,
- 2:22all of a sudden, my variable rate mortgage is up five hundred basis points.
- 2:25My monthly mortgage payment. You know, I was when I was maybe
- 2:30three hundred dollars a month positive cashule in this investment unit. Now I'm losing
- 2:34one thousand dollars, right, And to be clear, it's not losing one
- 2:37thousand dollars, but it's one thousand dollars that they'd be paying out of pocket,
- 2:40right, correct. The rent isn't covering their mortgage anymore, exactly,
- 2:44So it's not like they're losing money in that sense, correct. So I
- 2:46mean you're basically, I mean, I don't look at that as a great
- 2:51investment personally. You know, you're out of pocket one thousand dollars a month
- 2:53especially, you know, so again, if you have let's say you have
- 2:54two of these properties, that's two thousand dollars a month potentially, So I
- 2:59think it's starts compounding. So now they're saying well, what do I do
- 3:01because I can only the government says I can only raise the rent. You
- 3:04know, now it's going to be three and a half percent. It's just
- 3:07not not So it's a lot of the times it's either like it's a forced
- 3:09sale, which now we're in a down markets that makes it always a little
- 3:13bit trickier. Or it's what we're starting to see is landlord is actually getting
- 3:16creative and starting to renegotiate leases and saying, listen, I have to I'm
- 3:21either going to legally move into this place because this is my financial situation,
- 3:25or I have to put it on the market and sell it. And if
- 3:28I sell it, there's probably a high probability the end user purchaser is going
- 3:31to want you to move out because they're going to move in. But when
- 3:34they're selling their property, especially if they bought five seven years ago, they're
- 3:38probably selling it at a nice profit, right exactly, And in many cases
- 3:42that is certainly the case. So again I'm saying it's hard to be empathetic
- 3:46for them, but I would say, like in this current environment right here,
- 3:50right now, I think there are a lot of landlords that are caught
- 3:52off side because again maybe maybe hypothetically they should have been raising the rent every
- 3:58year for the past five or six year and they didn't do that right and
- 4:00now, because again the tendency laws are what they are and BC, which
- 4:04I from my understanding and research, are some of the strictest in North America,
- 4:12the landlords are facing these situations. So that's interesting and I guess that's
- 4:15fair. But any business that starts or and a lot of businesses that exist
- 4:19right now are drawing from lines of credit or rotating lines of credit, and
- 4:24those costs of financing have to be taken into account. So again, a
- 4:30landlord is effectively running a business. So why is that burden being put onto
- 4:35the renter as it's their fault or you know, the government's being is being
- 4:42cruel or or not fair. Like, I don't understand the argument when they
- 4:46know they knew the rules going in and maybe they didn't fully understand those obligations,
- 4:49but ultimately, those are the obligations that the landlord signed and agreed to.
- 4:54Yeah, you know what, I actually look at it to two ways.
- 4:57It's interesting because again you just have conversations with people that are out there,
- 5:00Uh, you know, we have conversations with just momopod landlords and some
- 5:02of them. You know, I'm talking institutional level, and you know,
- 5:08I actually think that the the the way our tenancy laws are set up,
- 5:12they definitely in the near term they favor the tenant, right they're there.
- 5:15I think they're I think they are pro tenant. You know, we're like,
- 5:17okay, you can only raise the rent this much. It was obviously
- 5:20more into the liberal government now and you know, so it's changed in that
- 5:23regard. So it's more you know, I think if you talk to the
- 5:26landlord tenancy branch, the rules are set up to be more protenant than pro
- 5:30landlord. And there's a lot of bad landlords to get around those rules and
- 5:33whatnot. Yeah, there's bad landlords and there's bad tenants. So so when
- 5:36I'm saying that is I think ultimately I think it's also partially a natural throttle
- 5:42on supply, Okay, And so because if you think about it, right,
- 5:45if you're going if you're going to say, well, you know,
- 5:48the downside is almost unlimited, but we're going to cap your profits. Anytime
- 5:51you're capping profits, you're not necessarily incentivizing the free market to open up the
- 5:56spigotts on new supply. So when you actually talk I'm saying this like as
- 6:00as a legitimate conversation, is that when you talk to these sort of larger
- 6:03institutions and people that are deploying large pools of capital are buying apartment buildings at
- 6:09three caps three percent cap rates, the thesis is that there's a natural throttle
- 6:14and supply. It's just a hard market to oversupply, and so we feel
- 6:17that over the long run, rents are going to continue to go up.
- 6:23And yes, you know you have to wait for tenants to willingly leave to
- 6:27reset those rates higher because there isn't an incentive to build more supply. Is
- 6:30that exactly? So I'm just saying this So I think, like in the
- 6:33near term, I do think the tendency law is set up. They do.
- 6:36They are pro tenant. It's it's good for the tenant. But I
- 6:39think over a longer run period is I think this is why we continue to
- 6:42see despite all these rule changes, is that rents continue to push higher.
- 6:46But in an environment where there are more investor buyers of property, whether their
- 6:50institutions or mom and pop landlords, more than first time buyers. You know,
- 6:57wouldn't that market then be taken by for time buyers who have been priced
- 7:00out of the market. Yes. And I think what's interesting is on the
- 7:05investment side, there's a lot of people that upset what pre sale condos and
- 7:09stuff. That's actually I think a failure on the policy side as well.
- 7:14The way that we get new supply to market is through the pre sale channel,
- 7:16and so in the way that pre sales have been sold, especially in
- 7:19today's market, is that highly inflated costs and these investors are basically just out
- 7:25there speculating and thinking they're going to make a profit. And it's worked tremendously
- 7:30well over the last ten years. But you can hold me on record here.
- 7:31I think people of pre sales are going to do They're going to underperform
- 7:35over the next five to ten years. Interesting. I strongly, strongly believe
- 7:39that if you bought a pre sale condo in many circumstances, you will make
- 7:42little to no money over the next ten years. Wow. Okay, shifting
- 7:45gears here really quickly. We know that in BC we're changing the short term
- 7:48rental rules. Basically, you can't have an investment property as an Airbnb unit
- 7:56if you do have an airbbing unit. It has to be like in your
- 7:58own home, a spare bedroom or basement suite, something like that. Is
- 8:01this going to have any significant impact on the cost of rent? And I
- 8:05don't necessarily mean that it'll bring down the cost of rent in BC, but
- 8:09will it slow down what seems to be the escalating costs of rent? I
- 8:13think it can slow down the rate of growth in rents. I do believe
- 8:16that. I don't think it's going to make the market more affordable. I'm
- 8:18not convinced. This is my personal opinion. I could be wrong. My
- 8:22personal opinion is I'm not convinced that it's as large of a problem to drastically
- 8:28alter the rental market here. I do think it's certainly as impacting the market
- 8:31to some extent. I just don't I think it's I think it's being used
- 8:35as a little bit of a scapegoat in terms of what are some of the
- 8:39larger problems that we're facing. So what are some of the larger I think
- 8:43that Cannabi's population growth is growing at the fastest rate since nineteen fifty seven.
- 8:48You know, when you pull in one point one million people here over a
- 8:50twelve months period, you're exacerbating a housing crisis. So I think the immigration
- 8:56side, we've seen the federal government come out in recent weeks and saying,
- 9:00Okay, now we're gonna start to look at tweaking this. Obviously we've been
- 9:03fundamentally I think, underbuilding over the last ten fifteen years, and so I
- 9:07think those are some of the larger issues. And the Airbnb we're seeing obviously,
- 9:11cities across North America now grappling with this issue. I do think there
- 9:15needs to be some regulation, and it's hard to draw a line of what
- 9:20where do you draw? Where do you draw the line on Airbnb? Do
- 9:22you just outright ban it? I don't know. I don't really know necessarily
- 9:26the solution. I'm sure we can dig into that a bit. But so
- 9:30you're painting a very doom and gloom picture for the near future when it comes
- 9:33to BC's housing market and BC's housing crisis. What I'm hearing is it sounds
- 9:39like it's going to get worse. Is that your projection? My opinion is
- 9:43that I guess it depends on worse for who well, worse in terms of
- 9:46we're not going to be able to build the supply of effectively, we are
- 9:48going to see home prices go up. We're going to see the cost of
- 9:52rent go up from what that's what I'm gathering from what you're saying, is
- 9:54that is that a fair assessment? I would say so. So I think
- 9:58my personal view is in the near term, the very near turn over the
- 10:01next twelve to twenty four months is I think interest rates at six mortgage rates
- 10:05at six percent are going to slow the rate of growth in this housing market.
- 10:09We're probably gonna we are in a downturn. I think that's going to
- 10:13continue. I think that you might see some rents come off. So this
- 10:16is good stuff, right, I think I see rents come off those I
- 10:18think because the economy is weak, and when people start losing jobs, what
- 10:22happens is you, you know, you leave your one bedroom conte, you
- 10:26go back in, you move with mom and dad, and so you get
- 10:28this wholesold whosthold consolidation similar to the pandemic. Right. Why did rents drop
- 10:33downtown was because people started losing their jobs and everybody moved back home, right,
- 10:37And so people that were renting out studios they went back and lived in
- 10:41mom and dad's basement or what have you, and so they became a lot
- 10:43more available supply in the market. So I think in the near term,
- 10:46I think over the long run, though I'm talking like ten plus years,
- 10:50I think you and I will be sitting in this chair and still talking about
- 10:52the lack of affordability in this in this province. I hope that in ten
- 10:58years from now you and I are sitting and chatting about the housing market,
- 11:01but hopefully not with those circumstances. Nonetheless, I appreciate your time, and
- 11:05I appreciate the trajectory and the projection that you've just given us. So thanks
- 11:09so much, Steve. Thanks for having me on absolutely pleasure. Folks,
- 11:11if you're not following him on social media, you're missing out on a wealth
- 11:15of knowledge and analysis. He is, of course, real estate officionado Steve
- 11:20Serretzky. Now, after some business, let's pay tribute to the airbnb hosts
- 11:24throughout BC who are being hard hit by the province's new short term rental rules.
- 11:30Because Angela Valiant is ready to serenade you up next