Latest / Together 4 Good: Making Sense of Life and Faith / Why Can’t We Stop Buying Things in December?
Transcript
- 0:00Coming up on the Together for Good podcast, I want to talk
- 0:03about consumerism because what else would we talk about this
- 0:06time of year? As Christmas is getting closer
- 0:10and closer by the day, you need to buy, buy, buy more, more,
- 0:14more. It's all coming up.
- 0:16Here we go. Welcome to the Together for Good
- 0:18Podcast, a podcast created by Bethany Lutheran Church in
- 0:22Cherry Hills Village, Co and hosted by me, Pastor Nate
- 0:26Pricinger and Together for Good. Our goal is to provide
- 0:29practical, engaging content that supports you without
- 0:33expectations. Whether you're feeling
- 0:35disconnected from traditional religion or simply exploring
- 0:38what faith means in your life, we are here to walk alongside
- 0:42you. No matter where you are on your
- 0:44journey of faith, we're glad you're here.
- 0:47Welcome to Together for Good. OK?
- 0:49Has this ever happened to you? It's late at night and you're
- 0:52bored, and So what do you do? You go online shopping, you open
- 0:56up that Amazon app and you just start adding things to your
- 1:00cart. Maybe you'll buy them, maybe
- 1:02you'll just save them for later, but there's something so
- 1:05enjoyable about that process of finding the item and adding it
- 1:10to your cart and maybe even clicking purchase there.
- 1:12There's a thrill, there's a rush, there's a dopamine hit in
- 1:16our brain that really appreciates this, and I wonder
- 1:21if there's a soul level phenomenon growing going on
- 1:24here. As we go through this process of
- 1:28continually trying to get more and more, it seems to really
- 1:33appeal to us on some sort of core level.
- 1:36We're not just buying items that we need, we're buying things
- 1:40that we want. We're buying things that give us
- 1:43the illusion that our life will somehow be more complete once
- 1:47that little widget is in our possession.
- 1:51And when you start to peel back these layers and think about it,
- 1:55there's something very strange going on here.
- 1:59And it's no mistake that Jesus offers a lot of words about the
- 2:04evils of greed and money and the ways that these types of
- 2:08consumeristic behaviors can really deeply affect us
- 2:13negatively. He saw it way back then in the
- 2:161st century. Imagine what Jesus might have to
- 2:19say when we are bombarded with advertisements and the
- 2:25consistent pressure to buy more. That's what we call consumerism,
- 2:33and it is what makes the world go round.
- 2:36The systems of our capitalist society are so complicated and
- 2:41so complex that it's nearly impossible to even dream or
- 2:45conceive of an alternative option at this point.
- 2:49And so it needs to keep going. We need to keep buying in order
- 2:55to feed the system. I listened to a podcast the
- 2:59other day by Todd McGowan, who's a philosophy professor at the
- 3:04University of Vermont, and he was talking about in this
- 3:07podcast about the ways that capitalism is specifically
- 3:12designed to only function when we are going after our wants.
- 3:18If all we ever purchased was the very basic needs, then the
- 3:22system could never continue to churn in the way it does.
- 3:25It is specifically built on the assumption that people will
- 3:31always purchase more than what they actually need or require.
- 3:37And you think about it and you look around, yes, there's so
- 3:39much. Now think of all of the items on
- 3:41your Christmas list or all of the items you've already
- 3:44purchased for family and friends.
- 3:46If only you were purchasing what was needed, would you have made
- 3:51any of those buys? Would you have added any of
- 3:56those things to your cart? And now I'm not trying to rain
- 4:00on our parade. Obviously for kids especially,
- 4:02this is such an exciting time of year to get presents and to give
- 4:07presents too. Hopefully there is something
- 4:10good about this sense of sharing with one another and thinking
- 4:15carefully about what an individual would really enjoy
- 4:19and appreciate and then making that purchase for them and
- 4:22seeing their joy on Christmas morning.
- 4:24I'm not trying to be a total Grinch about this, but I do
- 4:28think that there's something interesting for us to reflect on
- 4:32as people of faith living in the midst of this consumerist
- 4:36culture. I'm always amazed by how many
- 4:40advertisements are just out there and that we come across in
- 4:44a daily walk. I've heard it said that the
- 4:47average American will encounter 3000 advertisements a day just
- 4:54in walking and moving around. This can be advertisements on
- 4:58the podcasts that you listen to and have you bought your Casper
- 5:01mattress yet? This could be billboards that
- 5:04you drive by, commercials that you see or hear on the TV or
- 5:08radio advertisements that you scroll by on the Internet.
- 5:12They're always some pop up ads, etcetera. 3000 moments every
- 5:18single day where you are being asked to purchase something,
- 5:24where you are being pressured to consider this item that you
- 5:29weren't considering before, but now all of a sudden it's in
- 5:32front of you and there is this nudge to think more, to consider
- 5:39if that's something that you really want right now to then go
- 5:43and make that purchase. And it plays into so much of our
- 5:47brain chemistry because when we see these things and we're
- 5:51thinking to ourselves like, Oh my gosh, I do need that.
- 5:56There's a lot going on within us.
- 5:59We are being made to feel inadequate immediately, as if
- 6:02something is lacking in our current state of affairs.
- 6:06And then we're being pressured to give of our money, which is
- 6:10only accrued through time and hard work.
- 6:13We're being pressured to give that in order to obtain this
- 6:18item that we think will solve the ache within us.
- 6:23And it's that ache that I think really is the heart of our
- 6:28reflection as spiritual people. Why is it that we are constantly
- 6:33encouraged to feel incomplete, to feel like we're not enough?
- 6:38Why also are we constantly looking for ways to overcome
- 6:44that lack, overcome that ache by buying, by purchasing, by
- 6:50looking anywhere other then towards God, the one who always
- 6:55tells us that we are enough just as we are?
- 7:00Are you seeing all of the ways that these little parts play
- 7:04together and how there's an inherent, dare I say, sinfulness
- 7:10in the consumeristic mechanisms? Again, I'm not trying to rain on
- 7:15our parade and just say that we need to never buy anything
- 7:18again, but what I am saying is that we should stop and reflect
- 7:22on the ways that all of this plays out within our soul.
- 7:27You are enough as you are, and no purchase is going to make you
- 7:32feel more complete. Because I'm sure you've had that
- 7:35phenomenon, too, where you're so excited about the thing that
- 7:38you're going to buy, and then it finally arrives and your life
- 7:42goes back to normal and not everything has been solved, and
- 7:46your soul isn't finally at rest now that you have your new ice
- 7:50machine or whatever it may be. In the same sense, the joy of
- 7:55Christmas morning as the kids open the toys and they're so
- 7:58excited about it, and then two days later, it breaks.
- 8:02Yeah, their life isn't any more complete than it was before they
- 8:05got this thing they so desperately wanted.
- 8:10But these are the mechanisms of our society and culture.
- 8:15Today I want to introduce you to some philosophers who speak
- 8:21about these issues in some really poignant ways.
- 8:25And we're doing this during the season of Advent, not just
- 8:28because the consumeristic advertisements are at a fever
- 8:34pitch right now, but we're doing this also because I believe that
- 8:37the season of Advent inherently connects with what these
- 8:43philosophers have been telling us for hundreds of years.
- 8:46Some of them, you see, because Advent is this season of lack.
- 8:51It's a season of waiting and and preparation and emptiness.
- 8:56Advent is not when Jesus arrives.
- 8:59It's the time before when we're forced to encounter that part of
- 9:04our soul that's really uncomfortable with
- 9:07incompleteness. We're forced to sit and wait and
- 9:11maybe be a little bit bored or wondering if it's ever going to
- 9:14get solved. But there's something important
- 9:17about learning to just be with those emotions rather than
- 9:21constantly trying to satisfy them and cover them up.
- 9:25And Advent forces us to wait for four weeks, which I think is a
- 9:29beautiful, brilliant idea. Yeah.
- 9:33What? What?
- 9:33What if you waited 4 weeks before making those Amazon
- 9:36purchases? What if it wasn't as easy as
- 9:40just add to cart check out, but you had to wait and really
- 9:45consider if this is what your soul needs most right now?
- 9:52Advent invites those questions. And so let me introduce you to
- 9:57some philosophers. We're going to start with Hagel.
- 9:59I bring him up a lot, but I really like him.
- 10:01Andy was a Lutheran. Shout out to shout out to
- 10:04Lutheran philosophers everywhere.
- 10:06And so Hagel had this whole idea.
- 10:08And I, I also, I am not an expert on this dude.
- 10:12He is one of the most complicated, dense philosophical
- 10:15writers. And so I have other people
- 10:17explain it to me, Todd McGowan being one of them, who talks
- 10:21about Hagel a lot. And I just that that helps me
- 10:24understand a little better what he's getting at.
- 10:26But he's a paramount figure in philosophical thought.
- 10:30And his big thing is this idea of dialectics.
- 10:34And to be really overly simplistic, it's this sense that
- 10:38the spirit moves through tension and even disagreement.
- 10:44And so the dialectic process is sort of taking one idea and then
- 10:48critiquing it. But then you critique the
- 10:51critique. And it's this whole, I've talked
- 10:53about this before, spiral dynamics idea is that as we
- 10:58critique the critique of the critique of the critique, we
- 11:01start to get closer towards something more fulfilling and
- 11:06whole. The Spirit moves through
- 11:10tension. And so this is telling us that
- 11:13God works in contradiction. And don't we see that again and
- 11:18again in the scriptures or with our theologians?
- 11:22Martin Luther wrote so much about paradox and how we are
- 11:26Sinner and St., how God's promises are right now and not
- 11:31yet. And there's something powerful
- 11:33about recognizing that tension and disagreement and
- 11:38contradiction and paradox do not need to be dead ends, but maybe
- 11:44they are just the mysterious space where God is at work.
- 11:49And so in Advent, when you feel this need to want everything to
- 11:53be completed, but you're telling yourself to wait instead, that
- 11:57tension maybe is a space where the mysterious power of God is
- 12:02moving. Let's move on to our next
- 12:07philosopher, Jacques Lacan. And he talks about how desire is
- 12:12born from lack. Don't we see this in everything
- 12:17we've said thus far? When we are desiring something
- 12:22in the Amazon store, it is because we feel that we are
- 12:26lacking it. And he talks a ton about lack,
- 12:29but his idea is that the thing we want never actually satisfies
- 12:35us. Desire is born out of lack, and
- 12:38in our attempts to fulfill that desire, to cover up the lack,
- 12:43we're never actually satisfied. Our longing points us, though,
- 12:51towards the infinite. The lack is that mysterious
- 12:56space where God is working. Another clever way to talk about
- 13:01it is that it's not that we lack the secret.
- 13:06The secret is the lack itself. We can never actually fully
- 13:12satisfy what's incomplete within us, and that can feel really
- 13:16depressing and frustrating and it can force us into these loops
- 13:20where we're constantly purchasing and buying more,
- 13:23adding more and more to our carts because the lack is so
- 13:27uncomfortable. That's one way that we try to
- 13:31deal with this soul level phenomenon.
- 13:34But what Lacan is inviting us to think about is what if the lack
- 13:37is the secret itself? What if this inability to
- 13:43accomplish and fulfill our deepest desires?
- 13:48What if rather than doing the same thing again and again,
- 13:51purchasing again and again, what if rather than going down that
- 13:54road, we instead decided to just sit with this discomfort rather
- 14:01than trying to cover it up or fulfill the lack?
- 14:04We just realized that this infinite longing we have is
- 14:09actually a longing for God, the infinite, the Divine.
- 14:16To put this all together, let's talk about Peter Rollins, who is
- 14:21a present day philosopher. He's Irish.
- 14:24I really love his stuff. His his YouTube channel is
- 14:27great. I've watched maybe every video
- 14:30there and just think that he is a very, very good thinker in
- 14:37this day and age. And he kind of pulls a lot of
- 14:39Hegel and Lacan and some other philosophers into his work.
- 14:43And he talks about how Christianity doesn't fill in the
- 14:47lack. It helps us live truthfully with
- 14:52it. And so rather than, yes, trying
- 14:55to just satisfy our desire and those things that feel like
- 14:59they're empty within us, we sit with it, we consider it, we
- 15:04allow it to work on us, and we allow something creative and
- 15:08generative to rise out of that dissatisfied place.
- 15:14This is where love and generosity take root, is in our
- 15:20lacking. Rather than just trying to fill
- 15:24in that hole, we sit with it and we consider what it might look
- 15:28like to bring that to someone else in a meaningful,
- 15:33generative, generous, loving way.
- 15:37So that might not be making much sense.
- 15:39To put it into more simpler terms, when you're feeling that
- 15:45that boredom at night that causes you to scroll and add to
- 15:48cart and purchase, when you're feeling that discomfort, what
- 15:53would it look like if instead you you sat with it and you
- 15:58walked around it and you peeled back the layers.
- 16:02You said why? Why do I have this need right
- 16:06now to want more? Couldn't I just be grateful for
- 16:11what I have right now? Could I share with someone right
- 16:16now the gratitude I have for their presence in my life?
- 16:21We're just coming off Thanksgiving.
- 16:23Doesn't it feel good to spend that time just letting people
- 16:28know that you appreciate and love them you?
- 16:32You see, when we take this lack within us and we start to turn
- 16:38it and look at it from different angles, or we start to consider
- 16:43what's making us feel so uncomfortable, it starts to move
- 16:47us in entirely different directions.
- 16:51And what's really incredible about our story of faith is that
- 16:55is the story of Jesus entering into this very messy human
- 17:02reality. It is God coming down from
- 17:05heaven, from the infinite, vast divine spaces that we can't even
- 17:09begin to comprehend, and instead choosing to be a part of this
- 17:14moment. Of choosing to be a part of this
- 17:18way of living. A fragile, broken, lacking human
- 17:23being with complex emotions and an aversion to boredom.
- 17:28But Jesus enters into it in order to make it holy.
- 17:34In the Gospel of John it talks about how the Word became flesh
- 17:39and dwelt among us. But if you break down the Greek
- 17:42words, there dwelt among us. Another way to translate it, or
- 17:45it maybe even a better way to translate it, is the Word became
- 17:48flesh and tabernacled among us. The Tabernacle, of course, was
- 17:55the place where worship was held, and it's saying that the
- 18:00Word, this divine, eternal word of God that has been present
- 18:06since before creation began, it entered this temporal moment in
- 18:11time and made it holy, a place of worship and blessing and
- 18:20God's promises. The lack that is the color of
- 18:26our human existence, it seems, has been already declared holy
- 18:32by God. It is a place where we can
- 18:35encounter the very presence of God.
- 18:40This plays into my favorite spiritual practice that I've
- 18:45talked about before, Centering prayer, which forces me to
- 18:49encounter my boredom and not fix it or distract myself from it or
- 18:54cover it up. In centering prayer, you just
- 18:57sit in silence and you think of that space as holy.
- 19:02In fact, you're not even really supposed to think.
- 19:04You're just supposed to allow yourself to be and to ease into
- 19:08the presence of God. But notice how different that is
- 19:12from everything else and and notice how it plays off of
- 19:14everything we've been talking about here.
- 19:16When we feel like we lack, we want to cover it up.
- 19:19When we're feeling bored, it feels like something's lacking.
- 19:22So we turn to the Amazon app and we start shopping.
- 19:26All of this is playing out within us, in our conflicted
- 19:29human souls. And God has already tried to
- 19:32enter into this for our sake, to bless it, to make it holy, to
- 19:36remind us that we don't have to constantly be satisfying our
- 19:40human needs. That maybe if we just sit with
- 19:44it for a moment, we can talk to discover how God is already
- 19:47there and how God is already creating and leading us to paths
- 19:54of gratitude or love or creativity when we sit with our
- 20:02lack. I think that the season of
- 20:06Advent, as I said before, really ties in to these messages and
- 20:12ideas. And I think about the Manger
- 20:16where the Christ child will be laid, and I see that as the
- 20:22space that's ready and open and waiting for the one to come.
- 20:31I think about Mary and her song that she sings before Jesus is
- 20:36even born, and she sings it in the present tense because she
- 20:41assumes that it's already true, because it already is.
- 20:46She doesn't see anything is lacking in that moment because
- 20:49God's promises are as good as done.
- 20:53And so all of this is reminding us that the Word becomes flesh,
- 20:58not to erase our humanity, but to inhabit it and to declare it
- 21:03holy. And so as we struggle with the
- 21:07temptations of consumerism, as we, I'm sure, go out and make
- 21:11more purchases than we need to be making in order to keep all
- 21:15of this system churning And going forward, what if we also
- 21:21started to develop some patience during this season of waiting?
- 21:25What if we started to examine the desires within us that force
- 21:32us into buying and purchasing more?
- 21:35And instead of giving into that, what if we started to ask what
- 21:40God might be doing in that sense of incompleteness we feel?
- 21:46Can we start to discover that still small voice that calls us
- 21:50beloved child of God? Can we discover that we actually
- 21:54aren't lacking at all because of what God has already done?
- 22:00In those moments, I think we'll discover a far more abundant way
- 22:06of life, which of course is what Jesus says he came to bring to
- 22:11us into the world. That's a lot of thoughts about
- 22:16consumerism and Advent. I'm hoping you were able to
- 22:19follow and track this, but I'm always open for more
- 22:21conversation if you have additional questions.
- 22:23This was a little heavier and a little more dense than usual,
- 22:26but I had to bring in my philosopher friends.
- 22:28And I hope you are starting to understand just what our story
- 22:33of Advent and this promise of Christmas, what it's directing
- 22:37us toward, because it's so much deeper than just these simple
- 22:41ideas that we so often slap on to the Christmas story.
- 22:45No, no, no, there's something so level going on here that's so
- 22:48applicable for our world and society today.
- 22:52I had a ton of fun putting this together.
- 22:54I hope you enjoyed it, shared it with family and friends.
- 22:56And by the way, if you think of it, leave a like and a review of
- 23:00the podcast wherever you're listening to it, that does help
- 23:03more people discover it. We're trying to get this out
- 23:06there to even more and more folks and we appreciate all the
- 23:08ways that you have been supporting it all these years.
- 23:11As always friends, thanks for listening and stay in peace.
- 23:15Thank you for listening to the Together for Good podcast.
- 23:18If you'd like more resources for your walk of faith, please visit
- 23:21our website bethany-denver.org or download our mobile app by
- 23:26searching Bethany Connect in your phones App Store.