Latest / The Morning Rundown / Trump's Ad Bill, Quebec's Separatist Win, and a Spy Chief Arrest
Transcript
- 0:14[Maya] Okay, I'm on my second coffee, a dark roast that tastes like
- 0:18[Maya] a campfire, and my brain is only half here.
- 0:22[Maya] Bear with me.
- 0:23[David] Half a brain.
- 0:24[David] So a normal Tuesday.
- 0:27[Maya] Rude.
- 0:28[Maya] Welcome to the Morning Rundown.
- 0:29[Maya] I'm Maya, and that's David, who is apparently here to roast me
- 0:32[Maya] instead of the coffee.
- 0:34[David] Someone has to.
- 0:35[Maya] I'll allow it, but only because the coffee is doing such a
- 0:38[Maya] poor job of defending itself this early in the morning.
- 0:41[David] Low bar.
- 0:42[David] It tastes like a campfire, and it's still winning.
- 0:44[Maya] Anyway, we've got three stories for you.
- 0:47[Maya] One is about a bill and presidential TV ads, one takes us
- 0:51[Maya] up to Quebec, and one ends with an arrest in Germany.
- 0:55[David] Wait, an arrest?
- 0:56[David] You buried that.
- 0:57[Maya] Saving it, David.
- 0:58[Maya] Hold your horses.
- 1:01[David] Fine.
- 1:01[David] I'll just sit here quietly.
- 1:03[Maya] You've never sat quietly in your life.
- 1:06[David] Yeah, true.
- 1:07[David] So where do we start?
- 1:09[Maya] Washington.
- 1:10[Maya] Where else?
- 1:11[Maya] First up, a story about who pays for the president's TV ads.
- 1:15[David] Oh, this one should be fun.
- 1:16[David] Follow the money.
- 1:18[Maya] Okay, so the president says the taxpayers are off the hook for
- 1:21[Maya] his TV ads.
- 1:22[Maya] That's the headline out of Monday.
- 1:24[David] Off the hook going forward, anyway.
- 1:26[David] The AP reported that Trump said he will stop using taxpayer money
- 1:29[David] for ads promoting himself, and his super PAC picks up the tab
- 1:32[David] from here.
- 1:33[Maya] Wait, so the government was paying for them up to now?
- 1:36[David] That's the complaint, and the backlash is why he's changing course.
- 1:39[Maya] Huh.
- 1:40[Maya] And what's his case?
- 1:42[David] The Hill quoted his Truth Social post.
- 1:44[David] He calls the ads positive promotion for the US.
- 1:47[David] He says the money will come from funds he raised for MAGA
- 1:49[David] Inc.
- 1:50[Maya] So his own donors cover it.
- 1:52[David] Right.
- 1:53[David] And he frames the critics as the radical left.
- 1:56[Maya] Of course he does.
- 1:57[Maya] I mean, come on.
- 1:57[Maya] That's a standard move.
- 1:58[David] Sure.
- 1:59[David] But in fairness to him, switching the bill to a super PAC
- 2:02[David] is a real concession.
- 2:03[David] Plenty of politicians dig in.
- 2:04[David] He didn't.
- 2:05[Maya] Fair.
- 2:06[Maya] Credit where it's due.
- 2:07[David] And it's worth saying plainly that The Hill piece gives his side
- 2:10[David] in his own words, so we're not paraphrasing him into something harsher.
- 2:13[Maya] Good.
- 2:14[Maya] A show like ours should let him make his case.
- 2:17[David] Now, the part the taxpayer should care about, the ads already ran.
- 2:20[David] The Guardian's live blog on this described him saying the spots were
- 2:23[David] positive promotion for what he called our great USA, but that he'll
- 2:27[David] cover the cost now.
- 2:29[Maya] Now, meaning not before.
- 2:31[David] Exactly.
- 2:32[David] So what about the money already spent?
- 2:34[Maya] Do we know how much that is?
- 2:36[David] Here's one number.
- 2:37[David] AdImpact estimated the spots cost at least one point four million
- 2:40[David] by the end of September.
- 2:41[Maya] That's not nothing.
- 2:43[David] And the AP says the real total could be higher.
- 2:45[David] That's just an estimate through the end of September.
- 2:47[Maya] Okay, but The Hill described the campaign as roughly twenty million dollars.
- 2:52[Maya] Why such a gap?
- 2:53[David] Different sources, different figures.
- 2:55[David] One is an ad tracking estimate through September.
- 2:57[David] The other is a description of the whole campaign.
- 2:59[David] I'm not gonna pretend I can line them up.
- 3:02[Maya] Honest answer.
- 3:03[Maya] So we've got a small number and a big number, and nobody's
- 3:06[Maya] reconciling them.
- 3:07[David] Right.
- 3:08[David] We just don't know how they fit together.
- 3:09[Maya] Keep it plain for me, David.
- 3:11[Maya] Why is this a legal issue and not just bad optics?
- 3:14[David] Because Congress controls the checkbook.
- 3:16[David] The AP says legal experts think the ads may violate federal law,
- 3:20[David] including the ban on using appropriated funds for publicity or propaganda.
- 3:24[Maya] Propaganda?
- 3:25[Maya] Strong word.
- 3:26[David] It's the statute's word, not mine.
- 3:28[David] Appropriated funds are money Congress set aside for specific government purposes.
- 3:33[David] Spending it to polish one man's image is the issue they're flagging.
- 3:37[Maya] And those experts said may.
- 3:39[David] May.
- 3:40[David] Nobody's ruled on anything, and Trump's side would say these were patriotic
- 3:44[David] ads for the country.
- 3:45[Maya] Which is why switching to the super PAC is convenient.
- 3:48[Maya] Fewer questions about whose money it is.
- 3:51[David] Maybe.
- 3:51[David] Though it doesn't answer what happened to the earlier spending.
- 3:54[David] Switching payers going forward doesn't erase the past.
- 3:57[Maya] Hmm.
- 3:58[Maya] Yeah.
- 3:59[David] Here's how I'd put it for anyone listening in the car.
- 4:01[David] There are two separate questions.
- 4:03[David] One is who pays from now on.
- 4:05[David] That's answered, at least on paper.
- 4:07[David] The other is whether the earlier spending was allowed in the first
- 4:10[David] place.
- 4:10[David] That one is still open.
- 4:12[Maya] And the second one is the one with the legal experts attached.
- 4:15[David] Right.
- 4:16[David] The first is a promise about the future.
- 4:18[David] The second is a question about money that's already gone out the
- 4:21[David] door.
- 4:21[Maya] Which is a pretty human distinction, like saying you'll stop borrowing the
- 4:25[Maya] car, but nobody's talked about the scratch on the bumper.
- 4:28[David] Ha.
- 4:28[David] Okay, that's better than mine.
- 4:29[David] And to be fair to his side, he'd say there's no scratch,
- 4:32[David] that these were positive promotion for the country.
- 4:34[David] Both of those positions are on the record.
- 4:37[Maya] So the argument isn't over facts so much as over what to
- 4:40[Maya] call the ads.
- 4:41[David] Mostly, as far as what we've got.
- 4:43[David] We have his description, and we have the experts' concern, and we
- 4:46[David] don't have a ruling.
- 4:48[Maya] Okay, that I can hold in my head.
- 4:50[David] And this was reported October fifth and sixth, so it could still
- 4:53[David] move.
- 4:54[Maya] Okay, so we watch whether anyone presses on the money already spent.
- 4:58[David] Right.
- 4:58[David] That's the open question.
- 5:00[Maya] All right.
- 5:01[Maya] Now to our northern neighbor, where an election result is giving Ottawa
- 5:04[Maya] something new to think about.
- 5:06[David] Quebec.
- 5:07[David] Ooh, this one's a big shift.
- 5:09[Maya] Okay, Quebec.
- 5:10[Maya] The Parti Québécois won the election, and the leader is Paul St-Pierre
- 5:15[Maya] Plamondon.
- 5:16[Maya] Politico says he takes power promising an independence referendum that most Québécois
- 5:20[Maya] don't want.
- 5:21[David] Wait, so he's promising something most voters don't want, and he still
- 5:25[David] won?
- 5:26[Maya] Politics, right?
- 5:27[Maya] Winning an election and winning a referendum are two different sports.
- 5:31[David] Totally.
- 5:32[David] And he didn't win big enough to just do whatever he likes.
- 5:35[Maya] Right.
- 5:36[Maya] Euronews reports the PQ is short of the sixty-four seats you need
- 5:40[Maya] for a majority in the one hundred and twenty-seven seat National Assembly.
- 5:43[David] How short?
- 5:44[Maya] Euronews had them on track for nearly sixty seats.
- 5:47[Maya] Fair warning, the count may have moved since.
- 5:50[David] So close, but no cigar.
- 5:52[David] I mean, come on, four seats or so is nothing in a
- 5:54[David] legislature, but it's still the difference between governing and begging.
- 5:58[Maya] Begging is a little strong, but Euronews says they need opposition support
- 6:02[Maya] to pass legislation and to survive confidence votes.
- 6:05[David] Hmm, and a confidence vote is the one where lose it, and
- 6:08[David] the government falls.
- 6:09[Maya] Yep.
- 6:10[Maya] Euronews also notes it's the PQ's first return to power in more
- 6:13[Maya] than a decade.
- 6:14[David] And that matters, right?
- 6:16[David] A party out of power that long has to relearn the job.
- 6:19[Maya] Be careful, because that's me guessing about their bench.
- 6:22[Maya] What the report says is the plain fact, first time back in
- 6:26[Maya] more than a decade.
- 6:27[David] Okay, so a long wait, then a narrow win.
- 6:30[David] What's he actually saying he'll do with it?
- 6:32[Maya] CBC reports that in his victory speech, he promised to be direct
- 6:36[Maya] with Prime Minister Carney and to work with other parties.
- 6:39[Maya] But he also said he still wants Quebec to become a country.
- 6:42[David] Both at once, handshake in one hand, flag in the other.
- 6:46[Maya] Basically.
- 6:47[Maya] And here's the timing wrinkle.
- 6:49[Maya] CBC notes that he says a referendum would wait until Trump is
- 6:53[Maya] out of office.
- 6:54[David] Huh.
- 6:54[David] So Trump's calendar is now part of Quebec's separation timeline?
- 6:58[Maya] Kind of wild, yeah.
- 6:59[Maya] I'd guess he figures a tense neighbor to the south isn't the
- 7:02[Maya] moment to ask voters to leave a country.
- 7:04[David] That's me reading his mind too, though.
- 7:06[David] He didn't spell that out in what you've got.
- 7:08[Maya] Fair.
- 7:09[Maya] All we know is the stated condition.
- 7:11[David] And that's the thing about stated conditions.
- 7:12[David] They're promises, and promises can change with the news cycle.
- 7:16[Maya] True.
- 7:16[Maya] Today's version is the wait until Trump leaves version.
- 7:19[Maya] Whether that holds is something we'll have to watch, and nothing we've
- 7:23[Maya] read says otherwise.
- 7:24[David] And for Ottawa, that's the part I care about.
- 7:27[Maya] CBC calls the result a major test for Carney, and it says
- 7:31[Maya] a Quebec referendum threat hasn't been on the federal radar for more
- 7:35[Maya] than a decade.
- 7:36[David] More than a decade.
- 7:37[David] So a whole generation of federal staffers never had to game this
- 7:40[David] out.
- 7:41[Maya] I'd soften that a little.
- 7:43[Maya] It's a fair guess that it's been a while, but the source
- 7:45[Maya] just says the threat hasn't been on the federal radar for more
- 7:48[Maya] than a decade.
- 7:50[David] Fair.
- 7:50[David] I keep adding color.
- 7:51[David] The fact is plain enough.
- 7:52[David] A question that sat quiet is now on the table with a
- 7:55[David] premier who says he still wants Quebec to become a country.
- 7:58[Maya] Right.
- 7:59[Maya] But let's keep the temperature down.
- 8:01[Maya] A minority government limits what the PQ can do.
- 8:04[David] Exactly.
- 8:05[David] No referendum gets called on vibes.
- 8:07[David] He needs other parties to go along with legislation, and any of
- 8:10[David] them can bring the government down.
- 8:11[Maya] Think of it like a roommate vote.
- 8:13[Maya] He can propose all he wants, but he needs enough people in
- 8:16[Maya] the house to say yes, and if they walk out, the lease
- 8:18[Maya] is up.
- 8:20[David] The lease being the government.
- 8:21[David] A confidence vote is basically that walkout.
- 8:24[Maya] And for Carney, it cuts both ways.
- 8:26[Maya] A PQ that has to bargain is easier to handle than one
- 8:29[Maya] that doesn't.
- 8:30[Maya] But he's still facing a leader who says out loud he wants
- 8:33[Maya] Quebec to become a country.
- 8:35[David] Right.
- 8:36[David] And CBC's point about the federal radar means Ottawa is out of
- 8:39[David] practice at this, which is my read, not CBC's.
- 8:41[David] Out of practice isn't the same as in trouble.
- 8:44[Maya] So this is a story to watch, not to panic about.
- 8:47[David] Agreed.
- 8:48[David] Slow burn.
- 8:49[Maya] Okay.
- 8:49[Maya] Last story.
- 8:50[Maya] A former German spy chief has been arrested, and the early reports
- 8:54[Maya] don't agree on which agency he led.
- 8:57[David] Wait, they can't agree on which agency?
- 8:59[David] That's a pretty basic detail.
- 9:01[Maya] Okay.
- 9:02[Maya] Germany.
- 9:02[Maya] A former intelligence chief has been arrested on spying allegations, and the
- 9:07[Maya] headlines from the AP, the Times, the BBC, The Guardian, and Reuters
- 9:11[Maya] all land in the same neighborhood: espionage, an alleged buying of classified
- 9:15[Maya] information.
- 9:16[David] Buying.
- 9:17[David] That word jumps out.
- 9:18[Maya] Right?
- 9:18[Maya] Not a leak over dinner.
- 9:20[Maya] Money allegedly changing hands.
- 9:22[Maya] And this is early.
- 9:23[Maya] It's all being reported today.
- 9:25[David] So who is he?
- 9:25[David] Because the AP headline says domestic intelligence chief.
- 9:28[Maya] Yeah, and that's where it gets tangled.
- 9:30[Maya] Euronews reports the man is August Hanning.
- 9:32[Maya] He's eighty, and he used to be president of the BND.
- 9:36[David] The BND is the foreign service.
- 9:38[Maya] Exactly.
- 9:38[Maya] Germany's foreign intelligence service.
- 9:41[Maya] So Euronews says the domestic label in that AP headline looks inaccurate.
- 9:45[David] Wait, really?
- 9:46[David] That's a pretty big difference.
- 9:47[David] Domestic versus foreign is basically a different building, different job.
- 9:50[Maya] Totally.
- 9:51[Maya] Though I'd hedge, that's one outlet's identification, and the headlines don't agree
- 9:55[Maya] with each other, so hold it loosely.
- 9:57[David] Okay, but give me the quick version of why it matters.
- 9:59[David] Why would a foreign service chief and a domestic one be treated
- 10:02[David] as different things?
- 10:04[Maya] Going only by what we have, the BND is the foreign intelligence
- 10:07[Maya] service.
- 10:08[Maya] Beyond that, I won't pretend to map out each agency's remit.
- 10:11[Maya] The point is that the label tells you what kind of job
- 10:14[Maya] he did, so getting it wrong changes the picture.
- 10:17[David] Fair.
- 10:18[David] What's he actually accused of?
- 10:19[Maya] Obtaining classified documents from a former aide.
- 10:22[Maya] That's the allegation.
- 10:23[David] From an aide, so an insider handing things over.
- 10:26[Maya] Allegedly.
- 10:27[Maya] And Euronews says investigators reportedly also want to know whether anything reached
- 10:32[Maya] foreign powers.
- 10:33[David] Hmm.
- 10:34[David] Which is the part that turns a document scandal into a national
- 10:36[David] security story.
- 10:38[Maya] Right.
- 10:38[Maya] But that's a question they're asking, not something anyone has shown.
- 10:42[David] That's a big gap between asking and showing.
- 10:44[Maya] Huge.
- 10:45[Maya] Investigators asking is just a step in an inquiry.
- 10:48[Maya] It's not a charge, and it's not a conclusion.
- 10:51[Maya] We'll hold that line all segment.
- 10:53[David] Got it.
- 10:53[David] Do we know what the documents are about?
- 10:55[Maya] Some of it.
- 10:56[Maya] Süddeutsche Zeitung reported the documents included intelligence reports meant for the Chancellery.
- 11:01[David] Oof.
- 11:01[David] Meant for the Chancellery, so the top of the government.
- 11:04[Maya] Yep.
- 11:04[Maya] And the allegations come from joint reporting by Süddeutsche Zeitung, WDR, and
- 11:09[Maya] NDR per Euronews.
- 11:11[David] So three German outlets working together.
- 11:13[David] That's not nothing.
- 11:14[Maya] It isn't, but still allegations, not findings.
- 11:18[Maya] Nobody's been convicted of anything, and the case is hours old.
- 11:21[David] And I'd say that's the right way to read it.
- 11:23[David] Joint reporting tells you several newsrooms stand behind the account, but it's
- 11:26[David] still reporting on allegations, and in what we've got, no court has
- 11:30[David] weighed in.
- 11:30[Maya] Right.
- 11:31[Maya] So we treat the Chancellery detail like any detail from one report:
- 11:34[Maya] interesting, attributed, and not something we've confirmed ourselves.
- 11:38[David] Which is why I keep staring at the headline thing.
- 11:40[David] Five big outlets and the very first detail, which agency, is already
- 11:44[David] in dispute.
- 11:45[Maya] Ha!
- 11:46[Maya] A spy story where we can't agree which spies.
- 11:48[David] Ha.
- 11:49[David] But it's a good reminder.
- 11:50[David] First reports get details wrong, and the correction rarely travels as far
- 11:54[David] as the headline.
- 11:55[Maya] Totally.
- 11:55[Maya] Wait for the second day of coverage before you repeat the first
- 11:58[Maya] day's version.
- 11:59[David] Especially with a name and a charge attached.
- 12:02[Maya] And it applies to us too.
- 12:03[Maya] We've said an eighty-year-old man's name today on one outlet's word, which
- 12:07[Maya] is exactly why we keep saying who reported it.
- 12:10[David] Which is the habit worth keeping.
- 12:12[David] Name the source, say what's alleged, and say what isn't known yet.
- 12:16[Maya] Right.
- 12:16[Maya] So we'll leave it there, and we'll keep an eye on it.
- 12:18[David] Sounds good.
- 12:19[David] That's the rundown, Maya.
- 12:20[David] Time to wrap it up.
- 12:21[Maya] Coffee's gone anyway.
- 12:22[Maya] Let's close this out.
- 12:24[Maya] Okay, so three stories, three different countries worth of fine print.
- 12:28[Maya] My brain is full.
- 12:29[David] Mine too, but there's a thread running through them.
- 12:32[Maya] Oh, go on.
- 12:33[David] Who pays, who holds power, and why the details matter.
- 12:37[David] A president moves ad bills from taxpayers to a super PAC, a
- 12:41[David] party wins Quebec without winning the thing it actually wants, and a
- 12:45[David] spy chief gets arrested, and the first headline got the agency wrong.
- 12:49[Maya] That's a lot of homework for one Tuesday.
- 12:51[David] Mm, it was a lot of asterisks too.
- 12:54[Maya] Okay, but if someone only remembers one thing from this morning, what
- 12:57[Maya] should it be?
- 12:58[David] That a number or a label can sound settled and still be
- 13:02[David] One outlet's version.
- 13:03[David] Check who's saying it, and check whether it's an allegation or a
- 13:06[David] finding.
- 13:07[Maya] Totally.
- 13:08[Maya] And every one of them could look different by tomorrow's coffee.
- 13:11[David] Which is why we keep showing up.
- 13:13[Maya] Thanks for spending the morning with us, everybody.
- 13:15[Maya] Go be nice to somebody who's still waiting on their first cup.
- 13:18[Maya] And that's the Rundown.