Latest / MetroNews Talkline / Talkline LIVE From the WV Capitol Rotunda for Thursday, January 25, 2024
Transcript
- 0:10Good morning, Welcome to talk Line on the Metro News Radio Network all across
- 0:13the great state of West Virginia. Broadcasting live from the Encove Insurance studios that
- 0:18have been relocated to the A A r P broadcast location here at the Upper
- 0:21Rotunda of the West Virginia State Capitol, and we are underway. Turned from
- 0:36the studio so w v r C Media and the Metro News Radio Network,
- 0:40the voice of West Virginia, comes the most powerful radio show in West Virginia.
- 0:47This this is Metro News Talk Live with Hopy Kerchible up switch networking choles
- 0:54from Charles stand by you, Hoppy, You're On's A News talk Line with
- 1:00Hoppy Kerchival is brought to you by in COVID Insurance, encircling you with coverage
- 1:04to protect what you care about most. Visiting covid dot com to learn more.
- 1:11Good morning, Welcome to talk Line from the Upper Rotunda of the West
- 1:12Virginia State Capital as the legislative session continues. Happy Kurchible with you. Jeff
- 1:18Petty handling the video stream along with Austin Wright. Dave Wilson, our producer
- 1:22back in Morgantown. As always, when we're at the Capital a very full
- 1:25show today, so let's get right to it. Please welcome from Jefferson County,
- 1:29Eastern Panhandle, my neck of the woods, Republican Senator Patricia Rutgers,
- 1:33Senator, Good morning, good to see a person. Good morning, thanks
- 1:34for coming by. So you have a bill. The Senate, in fact,
- 1:38is advancing a bill that would mandate the viewing of a specific video in
- 1:42classrooms about conception. This is Senate Bill four six' eight that would require
- 1:49a course in public schools on human development. And the bill has been called
- 1:53the Baby Olivia Act because it would require public school viewings of Meet Baby Olivia,
- 2:00which is by Live Action, which is a nonprofit organization that's been involved
- 2:04with national abortion politics. I have watched the video, read portions of the
- 2:07bill. So what's the necessity of this? Okay, So this is actually
- 2:12a video not about conception, but about human development. And the idea is
- 2:17that we want our students to know about human development, beginning that conception and
- 2:23how that baby forms, grows, how every single week there's you know,
- 2:30this incredible change in transformation. And it's only around six or seven minutes long,
- 2:35and it's just amazing with the technology that we now have to basically look
- 2:39into the room we now know, like when eyelashes our first president, when
- 2:46the baby starts blinking, swallowing, moving its hands, Yes, exact.
- 2:52So it's a beautifully done video that just illustrates how that miraculous event happens in
- 2:59a min there's room, and it's not political. It doesn't mention any politics,
- 3:04it doesn't mention anything about abortion. All it is is human development,
- 3:07and that is the portion we would like students to be able to see,
- 3:10so that they have that understanding and can inform their decisions, and especially I
- 3:15think as they become adults. As you know, it's good that they have
- 3:22that understanding when as adults they make adult decisions. But I think that i've
- 3:28watched it and I've read about it, I think there are anti abortion overtones
- 3:32in it. I'm not suggesting anything wrong with that, but when I watch
- 3:37it and when I read about it, I think it is rooted in an
- 3:40anti abortion message that if you see this, if you see this, you
- 3:45might be less inclined to get an abortion. Is that a fair assessment?
- 3:49So the video doesn't say absolutely anything about that. It does not all,
- 3:53but of course those who have those thoughts in themselves. As you know,
- 3:59the anti abortion movement has basically predicated that it is not a human being and
- 4:04that it is just tissue cells. Clearly, if you present a different view,
- 4:10which is this is not just a bunch of tissues, This is actually
- 4:13a baby and you can recognize it starting at very very early stages as a
- 4:17baby with fingers and toes and everything else. It is not going to jive
- 4:21with their view that they like to present, but that's their view and it's
- 4:26not actually scientific. So what we're doing is presenting science. This is science.
- 4:30Everything in that video is reflected with actual pictures and information that we are
- 4:36now able to know because of the incredible technology that we have as to a
- 4:42child's development center. Patricia Rucker is with us on this Baby Olivia video that
- 4:46would be part of this instruction. Let me let me challenge you on this
- 4:48point because in the video it does say in it starts out with the sperm
- 4:54fertilizing the egg, and at that point in the video it says, this
- 4:59is the moment that life begins. That's what it says. I believe that's
- 5:02what it says in video, This is the moment that life begins. I
- 5:06would suggest to you that when life begins is a scientific and moral debate that
- 5:12goes on the National Library of Medicine says, until the fourteenth day after fertilization,
- 5:18all that happens is simply a preparation of the protective and nutritional systems required
- 5:24for the future needs of the embryo. Only when entity called embryotic disc is
- 5:29formed and can develop into a fetus, then you have a fetus form point
- 5:33being. And I'm not trying to argue science with you. I'm just saying
- 5:35that there are different I would like you to agree with me that I know
- 5:41what your view is, that there are different interpretations, different views scientifically and
- 5:46morally as to when life begins. Yes, there are, and I am
- 5:49it's really sad that unfortunately politics has unfortunately influenced a lot of those discussions and
- 5:57debates. But I will tell you that when folks talk about life, when
- 6:03they talk about creation, usually it is scientific that at fertilization you now have
- 6:12a distinct something and whether we're talking about a plant or a seat or an
- 6:16animal, oh yeah, there's there's something happening. I certainly don't disagree with
- 6:19that. It gets into this subjective view of life and what you define his
- 6:24life. I know what you would define his life at at that moment,
- 6:27as many do, like the Catholics do, that's life at that moment.
- 6:30There's something separate, There's something separate. But I'm just suggesting that there are
- 6:34alternative views that are not reflected in this. In this video, life begins.
- 6:40You can have discussions as to when life is viable, You can have
- 6:44discussions as to when life is independent. But I again, if we took
- 6:49the politics out of it and we were just dealing with science, I think
- 6:54again it would not be controversial. Unfortunately, though, we're human beings and
- 7:00we are going to insert opinions and beliefs and politics in the discussion. Patricia
- 7:06Rutgers with is a Republican Senator from Jefferson County, and this proposal to have
- 7:12this these lessons in our public schools, including the showing of this of this
- 7:16video. I'm going to ask you another provocative question. Okay, so when
- 7:20you watch it, and now I think that the way the bill is now,
- 7:24you could start watching, you could see it in the eighth eighth grade,
- 7:27correct, eighth and tent eighth and tent. Is that when you see
- 7:30this video, then you clearly understand how a baby. You probably know by
- 7:36then anyway, but that's how a that's where a baby comes from. The
- 7:41sperm reaches the egg, it grows, there's a baby. This is what
- 7:45the baby looks like. And I would argue again that that the intent here
- 7:49is to or part of the intent is to not have an abor, to
- 7:54not have an abortion, or not have an unplanned pregnancy, not have an
- 7:58unplanned pregnancy. Okay, so would you be willing to say, let's show
- 8:01this video as to how life begins, and then let's make available to these
- 8:09same students condoms and how they get how they get birth control pills. Would
- 8:18you be willing to say, let's also then make available to these students' forms
- 8:22of birth control so they don't have an unwanted pregnancy or pregnancy like is demonstrated
- 8:28in this video. So I will tell you that already we provide information and
- 8:33education about birth control. It is already part of the health classes that is
- 8:37existing now, there's no reason to add it's there. And in terms of
- 8:43us providing it, I mean, I will tell you I don't believe that
- 8:46that's the state's role. But there are of course nonprofit organizations that do provide
- 8:52that for you know, folks who are needed, especially low income who can't
- 8:56get their own. But it's the education as to how to not get pregnant
- 9:01is already that's that's what is that? And I don't know is that part
- 9:05of health classes now already part of health classes and is that part of this
- 9:07new instruction or you feel it's not necessarily because it's already there. Yeah,
- 9:11it's already there in these health classes now that students have h don't they already
- 9:16are about human development? Yes they do. There's nothing, nothing crazy about
- 9:22what we're doing except saying we want this video to be part of it.
- 9:26So instead of just talking about it, this is a visual way to present
- 9:31in Why do you feel so strongly about this particular video because it's beautiful.
- 9:33It's a beautiful video. I was just very impressed with what incredible job they
- 9:37did. And like I said, I mean, obviously the technology available now
- 9:43for us to understand, like wow, at this point, you know,
- 9:48it becomes separate fingers. At this point they start, you know, feeling
- 9:52pain. All of these things we've been learning a little at a time.
- 9:56But when I went to school. Obviously we didn't have this kind of Yeah,
- 9:58there's more technology, certainly that doctors know much more now. Everybody knows
- 10:03much more now about what the development looks like. And people can also decide
- 10:07for themselves. You can just google baby Olivia and watch this like I didn't
- 10:11watch the video yourself free access. Yeah, where is with the bill?
- 10:15Now? Out out of it's on first reading? I think on the centate
- 10:18floor. Okay, got it? Central Patricia Rutger, nice to see again.
- 10:20Thank you so much. All Right, we'll take a break and come
- 10:22back when we come back. Much more to talk about here at the Capitol.
- 10:26AARP's your ally for real possibilities in the Mountain state. Connect on social
- 10:31media at AARP West Virginia and learn more at AARP dot org. Slash WV
- 10:35Back to the Capitol or what after this? Thanks to all who have sent
- 10:39in some fantastic pictures of your hunting and fishing adventures to our Hoodoo Sports Trophy
- 10:43photo contest. Check out the gallery at the Outdoors page of wb metronews dot
- 10:46com. Also submit your pictures now and get in on the final monthly drawing
- 10:50plus the grand prize drawing a Hoodoo sports fishing kayak for which we'll draw during
- 10:56the month of February. Learn how to submit your pick by clicking the Hoodoo
- 10:58Sports icon at the Outdoors page off deltv metronews dot com. And remember,
- 11:03if it's a trophy to you, it's a trophy to us. Every house
- 11:07tells a story, and that's where I come in. My name is Aaron
- 11:09Weston, and my husband and I in calendar construction in Charleston. I'm also
- 11:13a West Virginia Promise Scholarship recipient. After I graduated from WU, I knew
- 11:18I wanted to carve a career in West Virginia, building a small business and
- 11:22helping people see the potential in their home. Now that's a great story.
- 11:24Proceeds from the West Virginia Lottery have helped generate nearly eight hundred and seventy six
- 11:30million dollars to Promise scholarships since two thousand and two for students like Aaron.
- 11:35West Virginia Lottery What if you play? It's good to have options when choosing
- 11:39health coverage for your family, your employees, and your company. You want
- 11:46to plan with people you know, like the Health Plan known for exceptional local
- 11:52customer service, and are headquartered right here in West Virginia. We are families,
- 12:00we are businesses, and we are all moving forward together. We are
- 12:05here for you the health Plan. We can all agree that hearing aids are
- 12:09expensive. No more. Fruit Pharmacy now offers hearing aids at affordable pricing.
- 12:15You can find the perfect over the counter nuvamed hearing aid and you'll have money
- 12:18left over to go to a concert and put that new aid to the test.
- 12:20Choose from the digiear Plus Max Pro or Life. Not only are you
- 12:24saving hundreds of dollars, but you also get a one year warranty and Nuvomed
- 12:30has a forty five day money back guarantee. Visit your local fruth today for
- 12:33your next hearing aid. Your hometown Family Pharmacy for over seventy years, we
- 12:41get almost here. Ontoon voting is a great way to spend time with your
- 12:46family and friends, and the off season is a great time to buy blue.
- 12:50Wendell just received a new shipment of boats, so get in while the
- 12:54selection is still good. Open Tuesday through Saturday, eight thirty to five four
- 12:56eighteen, First Avenue in Saint Albans. Come in and pick up your new
- 13:01Pontu boat. Today we gain almost blue Wendel Marine sales. We furnished family
- 13:07fun. This is talk Line on Metro News, the voice of West Virginia.
- 13:16Metro News this morning, the biggest stories from around the state of West
- 13:18Virginia when you want them, brought to you by Burdette Camping Center, home
- 13:22of the rb warranty Forever. Chris Lawrence at the anchor desk, we are
- 13:26ready to get to day who started in West Virginia with all of the information
- 13:30you negue. Harry hooda Sect, brings you the day's headlines at Charleston.
- 13:33Man is behind bars in charge with murdering his girlfriend. Twenty one year old
- 13:37Isaac Surface was arrested Sunday night in connection with the beating death of thirty six
- 13:41year old Laura Farley. Surface was named as a person of interest Friday and
- 13:43was later picked up on a previous battery warrant before he was charged with first
- 13:48degree murderer. Surfaces being held without bail. Kyle Wiggs at the sports desk,
- 13:52it was a huge victory for West Virginia over Kansas ninety one eighty five
- 13:58on Saturday. I'm a mountaineer, Get the road to the next two at
- 14:01Central Florida Tuesday, out at Oklahoma State on Saturday, and Hoppy Kirchible's daily
- 14:05commentary. Metro News This Morning brought to you by Burdette Camping Center Listen,
- 14:11where you get your favorite podcasts, and online at wv metronews dot com.
- 14:16Metro News is your source for high school sports coverage and the exclusive home of
- 14:20the High School Sports Line, presented by Parnlah, Kyle Wiggs and Joe Ricado.
- 14:26Bring you the latest scores and news, along with player and coach interviews
- 14:30and in depth stories. Get your high school sports fixed all winter long.
- 14:33The High School Sports Line, presented by Parmlah Wednesday nights at seven oh six
- 14:39here on the Metro News Radio Network and online at wv metronews dot com.
- 14:45Hey there, Dave Weekly, Here at your host from Metro News Hotline.
- 14:48Get ready for an epic journey. Every weekday from three to six pm,
- 14:52We've got all the excitement you need from sports to tech, music, pop
- 14:54culture, and everything in between. Join Coop and I as we bring you
- 14:58engaging discussions, cap debating interviews, fun games, and the latest sports and
- 15:01entertainment headlines that will keep you up Petro News Hotline is your go to source
- 15:05for sports, news, entertainment, and most importantly fun. Tune in weekdays
- 15:09from three to six on Metro News and wv Metronews dot com. Metro News
- 15:26Talkline with Hoppykerchible is brought to you by Encoca Insurance, encircling you with coverage
- 15:33to protect what do you care about most? Visit in Coca dot com to
- 15:35learn more. Talk line from the in Cova Insurance studios that have been moved
- 15:39to the ARP broadcast location here at the upper rotunda of the state Capitol.
- 15:43I'm reading from the news website West Virginia Watch. The West Virginia House of
- 15:48Delegates Education Committee has advanced to bill they did it yesterday that would prohibit transgender
- 15:54students from using the restroom that aligns with their gender identity. Again, transgender
- 16:00students would be prohibited from using the restroom that aligns with their gender identity.
- 16:06Houseboll forty eight h six would require schools to restrict bathroom use to students based
- 16:11on their gender listed on their birth certificate at or near the time of their
- 16:15birth. Story by Lori Cursey of West Virginia Watch Watch and Laurie good morning,
- 16:18Good to see it, Aria, Thanks for having me, Thanks for
- 16:21coming on. So what's this all about. Well, as you said,
- 16:25the band, the bill would ban will require schools to restrict bathroom use to
- 16:32the sex that you the students were on their birth certificate or at the time
- 16:37of their birth. And what do we do now in schools? You know?
- 16:44That's I mean, we don't. According to the reporting that I saw
- 16:48there, we are under the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals decision that ruled a
- 16:55few years ago that a similar ban in Virginia was unlawful. They struck down
- 17:02that ban. So the skate, according to the reporting, asshole, the
- 17:06state Board of Education right now goes by that that decision and there's no sort
- 17:11of transgender ban right now. Yah, So they're following they're following the Fourth
- 17:15Circuit because of Fourth Circuit. Well, then we are in the Fourth Circuit,
- 17:18right, So they're following that, meaning meaning that you that you cannot
- 17:22restrict the bathroom to sue your birth sex. Right. I think that's where
- 17:29it stands now. Okay, So tell me about the debate or the discussion
- 17:33and committee who said what what did you hear? Well? So the bill
- 17:37was sponsored by Delegate Dave Foggin. He's a teacher from Wood County, and
- 17:42what he said was that he had heard from the administrators of the school where
- 17:48he teaches that this had been an issue, and that was really the only
- 17:53comment that was in favor of the bill. There wasn't a lot of discussion.
- 18:00So it sounded like they heartily agreed with them because they all voted for
- 18:03it and passed it, But there wasn't a lot of discussion in favor of
- 18:06it. What about opposition? We heard from Delegate Mike Pushkin, who was
- 18:11a Democrat from Kanall County, who said that this was basically a red meat
- 18:17bill designed to appeal to the Republican's constituents in an election year and was the
- 18:23type of thing that would hurt harm students, so he did speak against it.
- 18:29We had a amendment fail from the delegate in Cable County, I believe
- 18:34Rick Griffith, who tried to amend it to the narrow exemption for students who
- 18:41maybe because right now we have a gender a firm and care band for minors,
- 18:47So his amendment would have allowed students who maybe they have an early birthday
- 18:52and they're still in school at age eighteen, but they are able to access
- 18:56a surgery and get a new birth certificate based on that or whatever. I'm
- 19:02not sure the requirements for a birth certificate, but if you were a student
- 19:04who is eighteen and had a new birth certificate yet. But they voted that
- 19:08down. Yeah, so what was do you remember? What? Was it?
- 19:12A voice vote? Probably a voice vote, vot vote. Yeah,
- 19:15so it passed out of House committee and now does it go to the floor.
- 19:18Does it have another stop? It has another stop in judiciary and we
- 19:22are hearing that the well heard from the civil rights organization Fairness West Virginia.
- 19:27They have asked for a public hearing about that, not there's not one scheduled
- 19:33yet, but they expect that to happen before or in line with the judiciary's
- 19:37consideration of this. Roy Kursy's with us from West Virginia. Watch did the
- 19:41boy? There are a lot of culture issues that are coming up this legislative
- 19:45session. Did you see the public hearing yesterday? I did? Yeah,
- 19:48I luckily did not have to cover that one. I watched that one.
- 19:52Yes, Yeah, we're going to talk about that more in just a little
- 19:56bit. That was on the library bill all right. So that bill had
- 20:00passed out of the House Education Committee, it now goes to judiciary, and
- 20:03it would, as it's crafted now, restrict in our public schools. It
- 20:07restrict bathroom use for students to the sex that they were assigned at birth as
- 20:15opposed to their gender identity. Correct, even though there are those who are
- 20:18challenging this that say, well, this would be in violation of what the
- 20:22Fourth Circuit is ruled in West Virginia's within the Fourth Circuit. Yeah, and
- 20:26what we heard about that was that, yes, the Fourth Circuit Court of
- 20:29Appeals has ruled a similar man from a challenged by a student in Virginia was
- 20:36unlawful. But there was a more recent decision by the Eleventh Circuit Court of
- 20:40Appeals. And what they said, council for the committee yesterday said that there's
- 20:45a possibility, since there is a difference of opinions in these federal courts,
- 20:48that maybe the Supreme Court might take it out and that could change things.
- 20:51Yeah. Rii Cursey with West Virginia Watch. It's a great read, a
- 20:53good media outlet, and she is covering the legislature for West Virginia Watch.
- 20:57Thanks word, thank you, good to see you. Let me do some
- 21:00text here, happy, let's see hoppy. I'm not certain that Patricia Rutger
- 21:06was completely truthful with you. You need to have someone on who teaches the
- 21:10health sex education portion. I don't believe they do talk much about preventing pregnancy.
- 21:15I don't I don't know. I don't know. I don't know what's
- 21:18taught in health classes. I do Look, I watched the video and you
- 21:26can watch it too. You can just google it, Baby Olivia, and
- 21:29you can watch it. Actually it's only like three or four minutes long.
- 21:33My impression is that it is. It is one of the better videos you'll
- 21:40watch, just objectively on human development. At the same time, I think
- 21:45there is a subtext there that is anti abortion, and that's that's okay,
- 21:55that's that's fine. But then you you know, then you have to question,
- 22:00you know, okay, is that what is that? The Is that
- 22:03a legitimate message that should be part of the curriculum of the public schools?
- 22:11You know, I don't know. I mean the And also that there is
- 22:18a line and I'm gonna double check this, but but according to our story,
- 22:21there is a line in there that says the sperm reaches the egg and
- 22:25that's when life begins. And I would what I would challenge on that is
- 22:30that there are different legal, moral, ethical, and religious views about when
- 22:37quote unquote life begins. That would be my point. Hobby providing birth control
- 22:42and courages teams to have sex. In some cases, it seems the video
- 22:47would do the opposite. I was just being provocative there, but I think
- 22:55if you're going to show teenagers how life begins, ends, and how a
- 23:03baby is formed, you might want to also give them corresponding information how to
- 23:07prevent that from happening. Until you're ready, Hoppy, legislators should be focused
- 23:15on issues that actually matter rather than subject matter and libraries and pregnancy videos say
- 23:19out of personal choice, and focus on policy that is actually impactful to constituents.
- 23:27Hopy. If you think science is trying to figure out the difference between
- 23:30a man and a woman, you're clearly going to struggle with the life question.
- 23:34I don't think I'm the only one who struggles with the existential question of
- 23:41when life begins. Just don't think I am. Take a break and come
- 23:45back. Brad macline joins us when talk line continues on Metro News. The
- 23:49Voice of West Virginia it's ten thirty. Let's get a news update. Checking
- 23:55with the Metro News radio network. Final It's happening statewide this hour, all
- 23:57across the great state of West Virginia. West Virginia Metro News designed Kelly Huda
- 24:06Sack. The House Judiciary Committee has yet to consider a bill that would lead
- 24:08to charges against librarians if children are exposed to obscene materials. American Federation of
- 24:14Teachers West Virginia President Fred Albert says this bill is unnecessary. Is this happening
- 24:19so frequently that it requires legislation? Is this really a problem in our schools,
- 24:26or our libraries or our museums, because I don't hear anything from our
- 24:30teachers and our service personnel who are there every day that this is a frequent
- 24:36issue. A public hearing was held in the House Chamber Wednesday. Meanwhile,
- 24:40the House is moving forward with a bill that would allow a resident to produce
- 24:42up to fifty gallons of moonshine for personal use. The bill passed forty nine
- 24:47to forty eight Wednesday. House Judiciary Committee Chair Tom Fast was a no vote.
- 24:51We've done enough to promote the cause of alcohol in this state over the
- 24:56last ten years. We've gone. I mean, one of our bills was
- 24:59over too one hundred pages long. The bill moves on to the Senate.
- 25:02Huntington police are searching for three suspects connected to an armed robbery. The robbery
- 25:06happened to Monday night in the eight hundred block of Virginia Avenue. Kamari Brown,
- 25:10Chase Jordan, and Dalton Daniels, who are all twenty one, are
- 25:12wanted on first degree armed robbery and conspiracy charges. And the National Weather Service
- 25:18is keeping a close eye on the possibility of high water caused by melting snow
- 25:22and rain that's in the forecast today. Currently, there's a floodwatch from Huntington
- 25:26to New Martinsville, generally the route two communities. You're listening to Metro News,
- 25:30the Voice of West Virginia. In school sports, it's easy to see
- 25:34the winds, the moments that make headlines, but there's so much work that
- 25:40goes unseen for any of it to happen. My name is Phil Risen,
- 25:44and I'm the executive director of the National Interscholastic Athletic Administrators Association. Throughout the
- 25:51country, athletic administrators dedicate countless hours to making life changing opportunities possible for student
- 25:59athletes sports. Their sacrifice is fueled by the belief that every student can grow
- 26:04and deserves their time to shine. On behalf of the ANI Triple A.
- 26:11We want to think every athletic administrator for your tireless dedication to providing seven point
- 26:17eight million students across the country a path to a better future. This message
- 26:23presented by the NI Triple A the National Interscholastic Athletic Administrators Association State DMP Commissioner
- 26:33of Ritt Fraser says there will be mobile driver's license and vehicle registration available this
- 26:37spring that you can store right on your smartphone. These advancements align with what
- 26:44you wanted and the Division of Motor Vehicles has wanted. It's just an ongoing
- 26:52commitment to modernization. Fraser joined Governor Jim Justice Wednesday to make the announcement about
- 26:57the free service from the Metro News anchoredesk Sky and Kerry Huda Suck. The
- 27:15Inkova Insurance studios have been moved to the AARP location. Here at the upper
- 27:18rotunda of the State Capitol is busy here. Today's Veterans Day, not Veterans
- 27:23Day, but it's Veterans day, small d here at the Capitol and more
- 27:26on that just a little bit. West Virginia high speed fiber internet is coming
- 27:30and city Net is helping lead the way to connection. City Net is West
- 27:33Virginia's local technology company. Their home office's phone number starts with three zero four.
- 27:38Long after the West Virginia fiber project is completed, city Net will still
- 27:41be your Internet connection. When it comes to technology. Citty Net connects,
- 27:45protects, and perfects. Joining us here spread my cliney mon, sir,
- 27:51How are you good morning? It's good to see the veterans around here very
- 27:53much. Oh my gosh, Yeah, place is packed. More on that
- 27:56just a little bit. How was the Marshall game last night? Heard it
- 27:59came away to win? You were? Yes? I heard fans. I
- 28:00did go to the Marshall game last night. They showed some pluck, they
- 28:04had grit. They were not playing well in the first half, but came
- 28:07from behind. So enjoyed by all on a rainy evening. Got it.
- 28:12A judge has rejected an argument that claims on a three hundred million dollar personally
- 28:19guaranteed liabilities should be set aside for Governor Jim Justice and his family's companies.
- 28:26A lot of legal talk in there, Brad, what's it all mean?
- 28:30It would make the normal person lose sleep? Hoppy. So the governor's longtime
- 28:37lender for his family network of companies has been Carter Bank and Trust of Martinsville,
- 28:41Virginia. That relationship has gone sour, to state it, to understate
- 28:47it. In recent years there has been a bubbling conflict over loans taken out
- 28:53by multiple offshoots of the Justice bus business empire. Carter would like it's money,
- 29:03and so in the how much money? Three hundred million dollars, which
- 29:08is why you would lose your sleep and maybe lose your lunch three hundred million
- 29:12dollars. In the most recent version of this dispute, Carter has taken to
- 29:18court signed documents by Governor Jim Justice, his wife Kathy the First Lady,
- 29:25and son Jay Justice to say that they are good for the debt. These
- 29:30are confessions of judgment, which is a sort of legal term, but there
- 29:34are liabilities that they have signed for personally liable they are on. They have
- 29:40personally guaranteed the loans, they've personally guaranteed the logos, and even if you
- 29:45are West Virginia's only billionaire, which has been a claim that's been endowed in
- 29:51recent years. The a three hundred million dollars hit to that claim is significant.
- 29:56It's being handled in local court Martinsville, Virginia because that's where that's where
- 30:03Carter Bank is, it's where the documents were signed. Essentially, normally,
- 30:07all that would have to happen would be the lendee would have to take those
- 30:12documents to court and say, look, they defaulted, which is what happened
- 30:17here back in April. They defaulted, they got to pay up. But
- 30:19those three hundred million dollars makes a difference. That's weighty. So the judge
- 30:23in this case, Judge Greer, Judge Carter Greer of Martinsville, Virginia,
- 30:29assessed the matter. He listened to Justice legal arguments that the Carter Bank has
- 30:36been unfair, that it's had highly restrictive lending arrangements with the justices that have
- 30:42not given them the flexibility to conduct their businesses in a way that would be
- 30:48fruitful for them. Can't make enough money because the lending restrictions are too great.
- 30:52Okay, that was the argument on the Justice side. The judge,
- 30:56I don't think necessarily, which is which is the Justice Company's way of saying,
- 31:00we shouldn't have to pay this right now. Not only we shouldn't have
- 31:03to pay it, but that the lending arrangements through Carter have been so restrictive
- 31:10that we have, for example, not been able to engage with other lenders
- 31:14or to buy the kind of equipment we need to make the kind of upgrades
- 31:18to make our businesses flourish. Then that's their argument. So what did the
- 31:22judge say? The judge said, well, you didn't provide any proof of
- 31:26that. And the Justice argument, he said several times in his filing,
- 31:33which is embedded in my story at metronews dot com, said over and over
- 31:37that the Justice argument was not factually based. So, I mean the phrase
- 31:42for that in the courtroom is when you don't have the facts, you hammer
- 31:45the table. The judge assessed it to be a hammer the table argument,
- 31:51and this week came out with a prelude. He came out with a memo
- 31:56to all the parties filed in court to say the Justice argument doesn't hold up.
- 32:01I reject it. What happens next, he is, and that's that's
- 32:06the There have been so many filings that's significant. Yeah, yeah, I
- 32:09mean he said that the justice argument doesn't hold water. Right, so now
- 32:13you go to the next thing. Your argument doesn't work. What's next,
- 32:16Well, so this has not been said, but the next thing would be
- 32:20to say, well, what happens with the three hundred million dollars that's hanging
- 32:22there this filing by the judge. Often what happens in court is the winner,
- 32:28the winner gets to write history, and in this case, the winner
- 32:30gets to write the order, which honestly, that's that's sort of standard procedure
- 32:36courtroom. This invites the Carter Banks lawyer to write an order that the judge
- 32:42will then submit, which will conceivably begin the process of of the justices and
- 32:47their businesses having to pay up. Now we know from history that that having
- 32:52to pay up is a very difficult procedure, but this would kick that off.
- 32:57And it's three hundred million dollars, it's take yeah, that that is
- 33:00significant. You have covered and we have covered so many stories about justice company
- 33:05liabilities and millions of dollars and millions of dollars and millions of dollars. And
- 33:07sometimes there's a court fight and they they settle and they're gonna pay a certain
- 33:12amount and there's another court fight. This strikes me as different because this is
- 33:17a bank. This is not another This is not a provider, This is
- 33:22not another entity, another business. It's a well, it's a business,
- 33:27but it's not like a supplier. Okay, it's a bank. They have
- 33:30an order or they're gonna get an order from a judge presumably that says you
- 33:36need to pay, and you need to pay, and Carter Bank's gonna right
- 33:39the order that's gonna say you gotta start paying right and then I don't know
- 33:45whether they want it all at once or you have a reasonable about on time,
- 33:49or you're gonna have to start selling. I mean, Jim Justice and
- 33:52Justice companies have wealth, but I suspect I think it's demonstrable that that wealth
- 33:59is tied up in businesses. They ain't got three hundred million dollars in the
- 34:01bank, so what happens they do? So the most notable business on the
- 34:07line here is there is a loan with a claim on it to the Greenbrier
- 34:10Hotel Corporation. You might have heard of that resort. It is one where
- 34:15Jim Justice first made his reputation as someone who was a notable person in West
- 34:22Virginia got great a claim when he bought it out of bank SA SA Save
- 34:27the Greenbrier made his reputation, and the Greenbrier is making money. The Greenbrier
- 34:30is making money and it is an entity that would be of value when you're
- 34:35looking to collect three hundred million dollars. As we know from from seeing many
- 34:39of these, even when companies can win in court on their claims against Justice,
- 34:45it is like pulling teeth to try to get the money. There's there's
- 34:50a case with the company five Mile, and it's been literally a decade.
- 34:54They are still in court trying to get their money. You might remember the
- 34:58helicopters helicopter copter gate. That is a claim that that has been adjudicated in
- 35:02international court. The company Caroling has been judged to need ten million dollars and
- 35:10for Justice to pay up. They've been going after the helicopter that's been in
- 35:14the news to try to make that claim. A few weeks ago. I
- 35:17don't know that we did an epilogue on this, but the judge and federal
- 35:21court in that helicopter case said yes, it does have to be sold and
- 35:25liquidated. But here's the thing, it wasn't paid off. So there is
- 35:30yet another lender that a helicopter has to be liquidated. It's got to be
- 35:34sold. I don't mean to have of that, but they say sell the
- 35:36helicopter. Okay, I can't because I owe money on the helicopter. Well,
- 35:39so what seems to be likely is the actual lender for the money that
- 35:45went to go to the helicopter may get the money when it's sold, and
- 35:49then the other company caroling that is trying to get money on its court judgment
- 35:53may be left to dry. So you know, I mean, I tell
- 35:58that story in part to pull the bow on the helicopter story, but it's
- 36:02an example of how difficult it is, even if you have won in court
- 36:07to try to get your money. I want my two dollars three million.
- 36:10Yeah, that is uh, that's incredible. That's incredible. All right,
- 36:15The story is post that's a really good explanation. I appreciate that story is
- 36:21posted at wv metronews dot com. Can you give a quick summary of the
- 36:23Moonshine bill. Yeah, I think people can maybe relate to that more than
- 36:28they can a three and a million dollar debt. So the Moonshine Bill passed
- 36:31yesterday. It would allow individuals or households to make I think fifty gallons of
- 36:37moonshine an amount meant to be sort of for personal consumption. That would be
- 36:43more than I would use. Right, But but what was interesting was the
- 36:50very narrow vote. It was a forty nine to forty eight vote that made
- 36:52it dramatic, but also the way the House of Delegates politics breaks down,
- 36:58because everybody's a Republican, right, even the Democrats, but they break down
- 37:02along sort of individual rights. Freedom lovers. On the one side, they
- 37:09want personal freedoms and lack of government, low government. But then on the
- 37:13other side there are cultural conservatives who you know, don't believe in making fifty
- 37:19gallons of moonshine for your annual consumption. So it broke down on a forty
- 37:24nine to forty eight vote, and so very very dramatic on the moonshine.
- 37:29Wow, okay, moonshine, Now we're interested. Yeah. So now goes
- 37:32to the Senate and you know, maybe it'll be a eighteen to sixteen vote
- 37:37if we get lucky. Brad Maquinny metro News dy corresponded. Read all about
- 37:39it at wv metrodnews dot com. Thank you, Brad, Thanks all right,
- 37:44it is Veterans Day small d here at the Legislature. More on that
- 37:46when we continue. AARP's your ally for real possibilities in the Mountain State.
- 37:52Connect on social media at AARP West Virginia. Learn more at AARP dot org.
- 37:55Slash WV talk line continues after this. Thanks to all who have sent
- 38:00in some fantastic pictures of your hunting and fishing adventures to our Hoodoo Sports Trophy
- 38:05photo contest. Check out the gallery at the Outdoors page of wv metronews dot
- 38:08com. Also, submit your pictures now and get in on the final monthly
- 38:13drawing plus the grand prize drawing a Hoodoo Sports Fishing kayak, for which we'll
- 38:16draw during the month of February. Learn how to submit your pick by clicking
- 38:20the Hoodoo Sports icon at the Outdoors page of WV metronews dot com. And
- 38:24remember, if it's a trophy to you, it's a trophy to us.
- 38:29Eye problems can become serious very quickly. The highly skilled retinas specialists at the
- 38:34WVUI Institute use state of the art technology to treat many eye diseases, including
- 38:38diabetic retinopathy, macular degeneration, and retinal detachments and our eye surgeons are the
- 38:45only ones in the state using three dviewing systems, providing high tech accuracy and
- 38:49safety for complex procedures. Trust your vision to the experts at the WVUI Institute.
- 38:54Visit Wvumedicine dot org slash I. It's good to have options when choosing
- 39:01health coverage for your family, your employees, and your company. You want
- 39:07to plan with people you know, like the Health Plan, known for exceptional
- 39:15local customer service and are headquartered right here in West Virginia. We are families,
- 39:22we are businesses, and we are all moving forward together. We are
- 39:27here for you the Health Plan. You're listening to talk Line on Metro News,
- 39:31The Voice of West Virginia. West Virginia Outdoors is the Mountain states only
- 39:38hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the more than quarter million hunters and anglers
- 39:43across the state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence has been tracking down hunting and
- 39:47fishing stories for more than twenty five years. No matter where we stalk the
- 39:52fish, they're ultimately going to look for the best suitable habitat. And as
- 39:55an angler, that's a secret of learning how to read the water and learning
- 40:00where the fish are most likely to be staged for feeding, whether it's hunting
- 40:04and fishing news or just compelling stories about the enjoyment of the great outdoors.
- 40:08And then right after the colds Vale, he started a pattern and I came
- 40:13in and it was the first time out hunted him in the morning, about
- 40:15eight point thirty he strolled in and I finally connected. With two days left
- 40:20in the season. Really, West Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday mornings at
- 40:24seven oh six am, and for your daily fix, Outdoors Today brings you
- 40:29two and a half minutes of news and notes from the woods and water every
- 40:31weekday morning on Metro News of Voice of West Virginia. Hey everybody, it's
- 40:37Tony Caridi, I'm Greg Hunter, and I'm Brad Howe, and we invite
- 40:39you to join us Sunday through Fridays right here on the Metro News radio network.
- 40:44It's the City Net Statewide sports line. We talk West Virginia University football,
- 40:50basketball, baseball, you name it. If it's got anything to do
- 40:52with the Golden Blue, we're on it. And don't forget the text line
- 40:55available every night. So we invite you to join us. The Senator coach
- 41:00Honor and me Tony Courritti. It's the city net statewide sports line on Metro
- 41:04News. News in the Mountain State happens quick and for decades you have depended
- 41:08on Metro News for accurate news delivered fast. Now here's your chance to help
- 41:14keep your fellow West Virginians informed. If you see news happening, become a
- 41:17Metro News Hawk by texting News to three five sixty five to one. If
- 41:22you take a picture or video of what you see, submit that as well.
- 41:25Text the word news to three five sixty five one to submit your tip
- 41:30or story. Standard texting rates apply. Please don't text and drive. Metro
- 41:47News Talk Line with Hoppy Kerchible is brought to you by Encovia Insurance, encircling
- 41:52you with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visiting Covia dot com
- 41:57to learn more. Welcome back to co Insurance Studios. Here at the Upper
- 42:01Rotunda, it is Veterans Day, Small d Here at the West Virginia Capital.
- 42:06Joining us are two members of the legislature themselves are veterans del Rick Hill
- 42:09and brand Republican from Hampshire County. Rick Good to see how are you sir,
- 42:13I'm doing well. Thank you. Welcome in and delicate. Charles Sheety,
- 42:15Republican from Marshall County, Charles, good to see you. How are
- 42:19you sad to see So this is a nice gathering, is huge. Yeah,
- 42:24West Virginia really turns out for the veterans. And you guys are part
- 42:30of the Veterans Caucus. So Rick, let me start with You don't go
- 42:32through everything, but you guys are What's what's at the top of the list
- 42:36of what this body wants to do for Veterans' Session. I think that the
- 42:38two overarching things that we're trying to do is take care of our veterans,
- 42:43and there are lots of different ways to do that. But the other thing
- 42:45is is to put in sufficient legislation that we're attracting veterans to come back to
- 42:52West Virginia. How do you do that? Well, educational benefits, we've
- 42:55done, tax benefits with regards to take things off your taxes or homestead exemptions,
- 43:01those types of things. But other types of things such as hunting and
- 43:06fishing, they're actually very popular. So those are issues that attract people to
- 43:12come back and in some cases relocate like myself. Yeah, you be located.
- 43:16How did you get here? You're absolutely right, as I tell people,
- 43:19you know, I had the choice. I chose to come to West
- 43:21Virginia. I was in the Pentagon when I retired, state in that area
- 43:25and in two thousand and nine, but properly in Hampshire County, So that's
- 43:29what brought me here. Yeah, Charles, you're a native, is that
- 43:31right? Well, I'm a transplant from Pennsylvania, very early transplant from Pennsylvania.
- 43:37I transplanted back in the eighties to West Virginia from southwestern Pennsylvania, so
- 43:40not too far away from home. But my family roots go back into Virginia,
- 43:45actually mand County, which is now in West Virginia. So and that
- 43:50goes back into eighteen oh eight. Wow, I have very deep roots in
- 43:53West Virginia. And you were in the army, yes, sir, Yes,
- 43:57career man Army, Army, National Guard Reserves, and then finish up
- 44:00with the West Virginia National Guard. How many years thirty seven and a half
- 44:04total, sir? What can you say about your experience in the military.
- 44:08It's something that you have to experience yourself. I would not if I had
- 44:13to do it all over again, as I was eighteen. I would do
- 44:15it again. Really, Yes, what drew you to it? Initially?
- 44:20My whole family has been connected in service, going back to even the French
- 44:22and Indian War, Revolutionary War, Civil War, World War One, World
- 44:27War II, Korea, Vietnam, and myself having served in the you know,
- 44:34the war's long. Terrorism, it was in the blood is in a
- 44:37blood? Rick? What about you? Now that's a great question, because
- 44:40I saw this as an opportunity to get in education. Really, I had
- 44:44the Navy paid through ROTC and got a few extra degrees after that, all
- 44:50through the Navy, and that's some of the benefits that we're looking for with
- 44:53regards to some of our legislation's education artists. So I think that's a huge
- 44:57attraction for people in the military. And like my friend Chuck here, I
- 45:04would tell you that it's something I would do again. I mean, certainly,
- 45:07every one of us has ever worn the uniform has had their bad days.
- 45:09But you know, you work your way through it and when you look
- 45:14back sometimes you realize it wasn't so bad. Chuck, you agree, Yeah,
- 45:17Well, when I retired, I said, it's been a hell of
- 45:21a roller coaster ride that I'd write it again. But you know what you
- 45:23guys have. You guys have something I'll never have, and that is you
- 45:27have the knowledge that you serve your country. Yes, and that has to
- 45:31mean something to you. It does. It's it's serviced your country, service
- 45:36to your state, service to your community. It's just service. It's it's
- 45:40I don't know, it's just something that gets in your blood and it's hard
- 45:45to get out exactly what I was thinking. And that's in part why I'm
- 45:50here, and I suspect, like many others, you know, it's a
- 45:52continuation of that service. Yeah. So yeah, so you already did the
- 45:57military had people telling you what to do, or you told people what to
- 45:59do. Now you you got you know, now you're coming down here,
- 46:00you're hitting your hitting yourself and head with a hammered out the legislature. What
- 46:04are you doing that for? That's a great question, because you know,
- 46:07I was actually retired for ten years and being a happy grandfather and all the
- 46:10rest of those things, but saw an awful lot of things that we're not
- 46:14going in the right direction in other parts of our country and thought, either
- 46:16you can sit on the sidelines and complain, or you can get involved and
- 46:20do what's best for our state. Yeah, Chuck way got you involved in
- 46:22politics about the same thing, you know. And it is odd because I'm
- 46:29a retired Master's argant, so enlisted my whole career and instead of saying yes
- 46:34general and no general, now they're come up to me and say, sir,
- 46:37could we h It's kind of a switcher, reversal of roles. But
- 46:40you know, even when you are enlisted, you realize what's going on in
- 46:45the political arena does affect you. Of course, is this a good place
- 46:49for veterans as West Virginia a good place for veterans to come and settle on
- 46:52the Chuck definitely, without a doubt. And we're working to try to make
- 46:57everything more more appropriate and more more approving for veterans to come here. There's
- 47:02so much legislation we have right now, all total. Rickover, he has
- 47:07a list of bills. There are probably close to forty bills that we would
- 47:10like to run. But you know, you have to pick and choose.
- 47:14Sure, you got to pick and choose veterans West Virginia. Oh. Absolutely.
- 47:17In fact, we're working on trying to attract more to come here,
- 47:21so you know, share the good news, do you do you share that
- 47:23with any of your brothers back in living in the crazy Washington, DC area.
- 47:30You know you gotta come to West Virginia. Absolutely, and many of
- 47:36them are envious. I think some of them don't just have that option.
- 47:38Yeah, absolutely understood. And listening to you guys who have a great turnout
- 47:44today, All these veterans organizations are represented. Anything on the floor today,
- 47:47you guys gonna do something on the floor today, do you know? For
- 47:51the veterans we had something in the chamber at ten o'clock where citation was read
- 47:54and the photo opportunity. We're also going to be available, especially if any
- 47:58of the folks that are here right now listening. We have a conference room
- 48:01off the chamber that the legislators will be available if they wanted to talk to
- 48:06them on specific issues. Okay, so that's like two fifty two. I
- 48:08think Rick has a higher rank thity Chuck, Yeah he did. But we're
- 48:12we're equals. We're friends and we're equals. Now. I would also like
- 48:16to say, on March first, we are going to have a ceremony of
- 48:20the decommissioning of the USS West Virginia in the Lower Rotunda, in which we
- 48:23will have the actual ship's bell on display down there, so and we're going
- 48:29to have a ceremony down there that the that the naval step are going to
- 48:34You know, we have the life Preserver now from the west for Jess.
- 48:37Yeah, we have that now exactly all right. W Chuck Shed from Marshall
- 48:40County, rick Hill and Brand from Hampshire County. Two veterans on this Veteran's
- 48:45day, Small d here at the Capitol. Thank you for coming by,
- 48:49Thank you for your service. Thank you very much, sir. Thank you
- 48:51all right, take a break of me back talk line continues. We'll be
- 48:52right back to stay with us. Met coal make steel. Did you know
- 48:57that metallurgical coal impacts our daily lives in many ways? Eight it's the coal
- 49:00used in the steel making process. Driving over a bridge or loading your family
- 49:04into an automobile, you experienced the value of metallurgical coal. Most met coal
- 49:07produced in the United States is found right here in our Appalachian basins. Infrastructure,
- 49:13comfort, and convenience all made possible my metallurgical coal. Learn more about
- 49:16met coal and the impact of the Metallurgical Coal Producers Association at Metcoalproducers dot com.
- 49:22And remember met coal make steel. Every house tells a story, and
- 49:27that's where I come in. My name is Aaron Weston, and my husband
- 49:29and I in calendar construction in Charleston. I'm also a West Virginia Promise Scholarship
- 49:32recipient. After I graduated from WVU, I knew I wanted to carve a
- 49:37career in West Virginia. Building a small business and helping people see the potential
- 49:40in their home. Now that's a great story. Proceeds from the West Virginia
- 49:45Lottery have helped generate nearly eight hundred and seventy six million dollars to Promise scholarships
- 49:50since two thousand and two for students like Aaron. West Virginia Lottery What if
- 49:54you play? It's good to have options when choosing health coverage for your family,
- 50:00your employees, and your company. You want to plan with people you
- 50:06know, like The Health Plan, known for exceptional local customer service and are
- 50:13headquartered right here in West Virginia. We are families, we are businesses,
- 50:20and we are all moving forward together. We are here for you the Health
- 50:24Plan. As West Virginians, we are proud of the natural beauty of the
- 50:29Mountain state and at ZMM architects and engineers. Our goal is to provide design
- 50:34solutions that give people the same pride in our built environments. That commitment to
- 50:38quality can be seen in recreational facilities throughout the state, from the Charleston Coliseum
- 50:43and Convention Center to the Valley Park Community Center, the Shawnee Sport Complex,
- 50:47and through the recent improvements to the lodges at Pipe Stem Resort State Park.
- 50:52ZMM Architects and Engineers, you see us in your community every day. This
- 50:57is talk Line on Metro News, the voice of West Virginia. WV metronews
- 51:04dot com, the only website you need to stay informed in the Mountain State.
- 51:07Get the latest news in sports, story information on the great outdoors,
- 51:12and never miss an episode of your favorite Metro News programs and podcast including Talkline,
- 51:17Hotline, sports Line, and Three Guys Before the Game. Make a
- 51:21bookmark now and visit do WV metronews dot com first thing every morning to find
- 51:25out what's happening all across the state. WV metronews dot com. West Virginia
- 51:31Outdoors is the Mountain states only hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the more
- 51:37than quarter million hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence
- 51:40has been tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five years.
- 51:45We used to always joke when we came up here, that's a smallmouth here
- 51:47born two pounds. It's it's rare. I mean it's it's more common to
- 51:53catch a four plus than it is one under twelve inches here. Whether it's
- 51:58hunting and fishing news or just come telling stories about the enjoyment of the great
- 52:01outdoors, it's got back up and must stay in. Around nine o'clock,
- 52:05he came cruising through kind of an open area that I could see on the
- 52:07staying as fortunate enough to bagging probably the biggest bred buck I've ever seen it.
- 52:13The money normally West Virginia here don't get that wide. West Virginia Outdoors
- 52:16covers it all Saturday mornings at seven oh six am and for your daily fix,
- 52:21Outdoors Today brings you two and a half minutes of news and notes from
- 52:24the woods and water every weekday morning on Metro News, the Voice of West
- 52:29Virginia. It's two hours of sports conversation to wrap up your weekend. It's
- 52:34the City that Sunday Night Sports Line Hey, this is Travis Jows joining myself
- 52:37and Greg Hunter every Sunday night from six oh six until eight o'clock as we
- 52:40wrap up the sports weekend. We talked Mountaineers High School, Mountain East Conference,
- 52:45and the latest in the national scene. The Sunday Sports Line is listener
- 52:49Interactive. You could call or text the show at three oh four Talk three
- 52:52oh four. It's a perfect weekend sports wrap up on your favorite Metro News
- 52:57affiliate, or watch the show at wv Metro News Talk Client from the AARP
- 53:17broadcast location. By the way, the Governor's budget does have a request to
- 53:22add money into the Assent program, which pays people to come to West Virginia,
- 53:27additional money for the Ascent program for veteran specific relocations. So that is
- 53:32in the Governor's budget which would be some additional money for the Ascent program just
- 53:37for trying to get veterans to come back to West Virginia. This is talk
- 53:39Line on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia. Welcome back, our
- 54:09number two talk line on the Metro News Radio Network, Broadcasting from the Encova
- 54:15Insurance studios that have been moved to the AARP broadcast location. You're at the
- 54:22West Virginia State Capital. Kind of going through my text here real quick.
- 54:35All right, I'll answer as many as I can here, but let me
- 54:38do this first. Brian Rates is director at the Parkersburg Wood County Library.
- 54:46And Yes, and there's what we're calling the Library Bill for lack of a
- 54:52better term, and this is a bill that specifically would remove the exemption that
- 54:59why raries and public libraries and school libraries and museums now have from the state
- 55:07law which protects them from being accused of providing obscene material. And there was
- 55:16an emotional public hearing yesterday on this and the intent by those who support this.
- 55:22They argue that, look, there are books that are in these libraries
- 55:28that are not age appropriate and children have access to it to them. And
- 55:34this bill, as it proposed, would permit criminal prosecution of librarians and museum
- 55:43curators if they violate the law and expose miners to material that is believed to
- 55:47be obscene. There is strong pushback from librarians. And joining us on talk
- 55:54line again is Brian Rates, who's director of the Parkersburg Wood County Library and
- 56:00next to this bill, Brian, good morning, thanks for joining us and
- 56:01Brian, your library has actually gotten more attention than most on this particular issue.
- 56:07So what has happened at your library? Tell us, Well, it
- 56:14actually started back in September of twenty twenty two when several people came to our
- 56:23board meeting and complaining about gender queer and they were very emotional about it.
- 56:29That's the book, that's the book, that's the book. And then yes,
- 56:34yeah, and I do, and Hobby, I want you to understand
- 56:40I do not question their emotional response to materials like this. I think there
- 56:49are I think it just about everybody in any community should be will be able
- 56:53to find something in their library that'll probably offend them. So I don't I
- 56:58don't fault people with the emotional responses to materials. That is their right and
- 57:04their ability to communicate that. But what happened was they they progressed to challenge
- 57:10us directly because our excess levee was on the ballot, and they tried to
- 57:15defund us. They went after city council, Board of Education, County Commission,
- 57:21they went to their meetings, reading the materials. They tried to get
- 57:23them to intimidate us and bully us. And in all this process they never
- 57:29while they were trying to challenge the levee, they never ever went through a
- 57:32challenge process. They bypassed that altogether. They just they went after us.
- 57:39So it was bully intimidy. They picketed outside of the library, they were
- 57:43doing email campaigns, they were putting t shirts out with offensive images and saying
- 57:49this is in the library and stuff like that. It was. It was
- 57:53pretty raucous. But what ended up being a response in the community was when
- 58:01we went to the levee that night, we ended up getting sixty seven percent
- 58:07of the vote and it was a huge increase from any the past levees that
- 58:13we had had tried to pass. The best we'd ever done was a low
- 58:16over sixty one percent, and it was a strong voter turnout, and we
- 58:22were getting comments left and right that people did not like their tactics. Let
- 58:28me go about Brian intimidation and bullying. I understand, Brian. Let me
- 58:31go back to some of the some of the logistics here, because my understanding
- 58:37is, and you referenced Brian Brian Raiches with his director of the Parkersburg Wood
- 58:39County Library, is that each library does have a reauthorization process. Correct,
- 58:46I mean could somebody, did anybody file a reauthorization, say I want you
- 58:51to review and take a second look at gender Queer or any other book and
- 58:55see if that could be taking out of the library. Did that happen to
- 59:00hobby? That is called a challenge process, reconsideration, reconsideration. So if
- 59:07we were something in the collection and you don't think it's in the appropriate place
- 59:09where it belongs in the collection, you can challenge it. It doesn't necessarily
- 59:14have to be removed, just maybe you don't believe where it belongs. That
- 59:19was never challenged by those individuals, but it Gender Queer was challenged by somebody
- 59:23else during that time period. We reviewed it and we decided that it did
- 59:28belong in the collection, it was in the adult biography collection, and that
- 59:31it was it was acceptable by standards, and it was not obscene. Yeah,
- 59:40okay, and now what is your opinion of this I'm not sure if
- 59:45you had a chance to listen or participate in the public hearing yesterday, what
- 59:49is your opinion of this bill? Yeah? I was there and I listened
- 59:53very closely to everybody's comments, and I respected everybody for in the against the
- 1:00:00bill. Again, I respect there there their response to it. I mean
- 1:00:07this is this is the difficulty when you come into freedom of read and freedom
- 1:00:12of speech, that you're going to run into things that really bother you.
- 1:00:17My response is that this bill is not something. The exemption that is there
- 1:00:24for libraries, teachers, and museums hobby is not for us to be hiding
- 1:00:30behind. It is not for us to protect ourselves from from so that we
- 1:00:37can provide obscene materials. I can clearly say to you without a doubt,
- 1:00:44we have no pornography. We have nothing obscene in our collection. Period.
- 1:00:51We get all of our materials the same place everybody else does. We get
- 1:00:54it available that's available to get it through Amazon or through a books or something
- 1:01:00like that without any age requirements. There is nothing in our collection that is
- 1:01:06limited in that way. We do not go to an adult store and get
- 1:01:09something. We don't do that, so we don't have obscene materials, So
- 1:01:15lifting this won't The protection isn't there to protect libraries and teachers from the law,
- 1:01:23so to speak, it's for frivolous lawsuits and bullying tactics. Well,
- 1:01:28let me so, if you, if you, if you Brian, if
- 1:01:30you, if you think that is the case when let's say this becomes law.
- 1:01:36Let me give you a hypothetical, but I think it's very real to
- 1:01:38talk about it that if this becomes law and there's a there's a book or
- 1:01:43books that come in and you're thinking about putting them on the shelves, are
- 1:01:49you going to pause and say, you know what, I could go to
- 1:01:52jail if I put this on the shelf. Would that occur to you,
- 1:01:58hobby? Let me let me change that a little bit there. I just
- 1:02:05did my book orders for the week. I do book orders every week.
- 1:02:07I have my staff give me their request cards, and I go through them
- 1:02:12and I order them. And I would say I consistently purchase materials for our
- 1:02:20collection that I do not morally or personally. That challenge me, okay,
- 1:02:30because this collection doesn't reflect me, it reflects everybody in the community. But
- 1:02:35when I look at those materials, I determine, yes, they have a
- 1:02:38representative in our community that would want this material in the collection. But it's
- 1:02:45sometimes hard. Sometimes you're like, well, do I really want to do
- 1:02:49this because it might upset this group or it might upset that group. And
- 1:02:52I'm like, so that's always in the back of your mind, and you
- 1:02:58can ask any librarian about that. So what happens when you take away this
- 1:03:02exemption and they're worried about even more? And then they worry about, you
- 1:03:07know, people coming in and threatening them and so forth. And that's what's
- 1:03:12going on across this country right now. It's becoming very it's a cultural war
- 1:03:19right now. There's a lot of people upset with where the where our media
- 1:03:23or whatever is going. And they're upset about it. And I don't have
- 1:03:28a problem with them being upset about it. But this is not the right
- 1:03:30way to handle it. Well, let me ask it. So finally,
- 1:03:34Bran, what is the right way? Because you sound like a guy who's
- 1:03:37seeking a balance. You're not dismissing, you're not denigrating those people who are
- 1:03:42raising concerns. At the same time, you say you want to serve all
- 1:03:45segments of your community. Where do you find a balance? And would this
- 1:03:50bill, if it becomes all upset that balance? In your opinion, it
- 1:03:55would upset the balance across the state. It would make people question whether they
- 1:04:00want to go into this profession. I'm worried more about other libraries. Am
- 1:04:04I going to change my methodology? How we do our things here? No,
- 1:04:11I'm not, but I have to. I'll have to do a better
- 1:04:15job of affirming my staff and making sure that they're supported because they'll, you
- 1:04:20know, they'll worry about that. But Poppy, the same thing that we've
- 1:04:27had policies for the and these types of materials are not new. They people
- 1:04:30will say, well, this is something to know. We've had materials in
- 1:04:33here that would offend people for decades and we've had this challenge policy for decades,
- 1:04:40and we've had this policy that we leave it to the parents for children
- 1:04:45and their children to decide what's best for them. So, yes, a
- 1:04:49child can get a library card here, but they have to get a parent
- 1:04:53to sign off on it, and that parent has to check off on that
- 1:04:58that they are aware that this card will give them access to everything in our
- 1:05:01collection. Now, how parents have choose to do this is their choice.
- 1:05:06And I've seen three different things that they do, Hoppy. One, they
- 1:05:12don't get a card for their kid, they just don't. They get one
- 1:05:15card for themselves and they check everything out on their card. In fact,
- 1:05:18most of our children's materials are checked out on adult cards. Two, they
- 1:05:23do get the child a card, but they keep a hold of it,
- 1:05:27and when they go into the library, they give the child a card.
- 1:05:29They work, they come in as a family, and then they check out
- 1:05:32together as a family, and then they take the card back. And then
- 1:05:35three is the final one is when the parent finds it is appropriate with this
- 1:05:43child. It may not even be the same age for every child that they
- 1:05:45have. This child is ready to take that responsibility and they trust them to
- 1:05:49make their own decisions. Then they give them the child, that child a
- 1:05:54card. That's my experience, and we also have a unattended child policy in
- 1:05:59our library. Children are under the age of ten are not allowed to be
- 1:06:01in the library by themselves. And then we also have in my experience,
- 1:06:09when you come into the libraries, parents and families come in together. They
- 1:06:13always do. And you know there are some kids that come into like after
- 1:06:16school or something like that. But it's what Poppy, this this is the
- 1:06:24thing that really real quick, real quick, go ahead, go ahead,
- 1:06:29Well no, I just I got to leave it there. But we're going
- 1:06:32to continue this discussion. I appreciate your insights today, okay, and I
- 1:06:38think we'll talk with you and others if this, if if this bill starts
- 1:06:43to move. Brian, thank you, very much, Brian Rates, director
- 1:06:45of the Parkersburg County Library, Can I share one thing with you very quickly?
- 1:06:50Please? Can I share one thing with you very quickly please? So
- 1:06:55what I hate about this is that go visit your library and see what's going
- 1:07:00on there, see what's going on with the children's programs and what good they're
- 1:07:04doing in the world, and don't let this one subject paint the entire picture
- 1:07:11of what you think that is going on in the library. If you're not
- 1:07:13already using us. Thank you. That's a good suggestion, Ron, Thank
- 1:07:16you very much. Appreciate it. When you need to see clearly, why
- 1:07:19not go to the best. At the WVUI Institute. You're treated by highly
- 1:07:23trained specialists who provide a variety of Conference of I care specialties and services for
- 1:07:27adults and children. From routine eye exams to specialty services including diabetic eye disease,
- 1:07:32laser vision correction, oculoplastical plastic surgical care, and more. The experts
- 1:07:39at WVUI Institute are committed to improving your vision. Called eight five to five,
- 1:07:42WVU care to schedule an appointment. We'll be right back. Hello.
- 1:07:45My name is Haley Bunn, and I'm running as an incumbent for the West
- 1:07:49Virginia Supreme Court. I'm a coal miner's daughter and a lifelong West Virginian who
- 1:07:54has the honor of being the youngest woman ever to serve on the Supreme Court.
- 1:07:58I was appointed by Governor Jim Jess after many years in private practice in
- 1:08:01seven years as a federal prosecutor fighting violent crime and the opioid epidemic. I'm
- 1:08:06a Christian, a mother, and a wife, and I'd be honored to
- 1:08:10have your vote. Vote Justice Hailey Bun for West Virginia Supreme Court. Paid
- 1:08:14for by Hailey Bunn for West Every house tells a story, and that's where
- 1:08:16I come in. My name is Aaron Weston, and my husband and I
- 1:08:19own Calendar Construction in Charleston. I'm also a West Virginia Promise Scholarship recipient.
- 1:08:25After I graduated from WU, I knew I wanted to carve a career in
- 1:08:28West Virginia. Building a small business and helping people see the potential in their
- 1:08:31home. Now that's a great story. Proceeds from the West Virginia Lottery have
- 1:08:35helped generate nearly eight hundred and seventy six million dollars to promise scholarships since two
- 1:08:41thousand and two for students like Aaron West Virginia Lottery what if you play?
- 1:08:46It's good to have options when choosing health coverage for your family, your employees,
- 1:08:53and your company. You want to plan with people you know, like
- 1:08:58the Health Plan, known for exceptional local customer service and are headquartered right here
- 1:09:04in West Virginia. We are families, we are businesses, and we are
- 1:09:11all moving forward together. We are here for you. The Health Plan West
- 1:09:16Virginia is home. It's where we work, live and raise our families.
- 1:09:21At the heart of our communities are West Virginia Hospitals and they're compassionate caregivers,
- 1:09:28from life saving treatments and emergency care to wellness support and screening services. We
- 1:09:33are improving your quality of life through extraordinary achievements and amazing results West Virginia Hospitals,
- 1:09:41Your health is the heartbeat of our communities. You're listening to talk Line
- 1:09:45on Metro News, the voice of West Virginia. Metro News this morning the
- 1:09:51biggest stories from around the state of West Virginia when you want them, Brought
- 1:09:57to you by Burdett Camping Center, home of the Rbar and forever. Chris
- 1:10:00Lawrence at the anchor desk, we are ready to get the day started in
- 1:10:03West Virginia with all of the information you need. Harry Houdas sec brings you
- 1:10:06the day's headlines at Charleston. Man is behind bars in charge with murdering his
- 1:10:11girlfriend. Twenty one year old Isaac Surface was arrested Sunday night in connection with
- 1:10:14the beating death of thirty six year old Laura Farley. Surface was named as
- 1:10:17a person of interest Friday and was later picked up on a previous battery warrant
- 1:10:21before he was charged with first degree murder. Surfaces being held without bail.
- 1:10:26Kyle Wiggs at the sports desk. It was a huge victory for West Virginia
- 1:10:30over Kansas ninety one eighty five on Saturday, and now the Mountaineers get the
- 1:10:34road to the next two at Central Florida Tuesday, out at Oklahoma State on
- 1:10:39Saturday. And Hobby Kirchible's daily commentary. Metro News This Morning brought to you
- 1:10:44by Burdette Camping Center. Listen where you get your favorite podcasts and online at
- 1:10:48wv metro news dot com. Metro News is your source for high school sports
- 1:10:54coverage and the exclusive home of the high School Sports Line, presented by Farmers
- 1:11:00and Joe Ricado, bring you the latest scores and news, along with player
- 1:11:03and coach interviews and in depth stories. Get your high school sports fixed all
- 1:11:08winter long. The High School Sports Line presented by Farmer Wednesday Night said seven
- 1:11:14oh six here on the Metro News Radio Network and online at wvmetronews dot com.
- 1:11:19Hey there, Dave Weekly, here your host from Metro News Hotline.
- 1:11:23Get ready for an epic journey. Every weekday from three to six pm,
- 1:11:27We've got all the excitement you need from sports to tech, music, pop
- 1:11:30culture, and everything in between. Join Coop and I as we bring you
- 1:11:32engaging discussions, captivating interviews, fun games, and the latest sports and entertainment
- 1:11:38headlines that will keep your books. Metro News Hotline is your go to source
- 1:11:41for sports, news, entertainment, and most importantly fun. Tune in weekdays
- 1:11:45from three to six on Metronews and wvmetronews dot com. Metro News talk Line
- 1:12:02with Hoppy Kerchible is brought to you by Encoca Insurance, encircling you with coverage
- 1:12:08to protect what do you care about most? Visiting Coca dot com to learn
- 1:12:12more talk on from me COVA Insurance studios here that have been moved to the
- 1:12:18AARP broadcast the location. Sorry, I got a lot of papers here footing
- 1:12:25around. UM. West Virginia high speed fiber internet is coming and city Net
- 1:12:33is helping lead the way to connection. City Net is West Virginia's local technology
- 1:12:38company. Their home office's phone number starts with three h four. Long after
- 1:12:42the West Virginia Fiber project is completed, city Net will still be your local
- 1:12:45internet connection. When it comes to technology, citty Net connects, protects,
- 1:12:48and perfects. Let me do some text real quick here, hoppy. I'm
- 1:12:53in favor of the students receiving accurate information about their health, including reproductive health.
- 1:12:58This particular video is not one of the best examples of how to do
- 1:13:00this, says the Texture. The idea that this has never before seen footage
- 1:13:05is not true. There's hundreds, if not thousands, of resources to provide
- 1:13:10the same information that are not politically motivated. This bill specifying one specific YouTube
- 1:13:16video is not the only way to accomplish the goal of educating our students,
- 1:13:23says the texture Techtopy. Does it not worry Republicans that justice has so many
- 1:13:30conflicts of interest and bad debts hanging over him. Well, according to the
- 1:13:35polls, apparently not Happy's second thought. You're right they should have used the
- 1:13:42term fetus instead of life. Keeps it straight biologically, and provides youth information
- 1:13:48to make their decision personally, says the texture Happy. The bill is certainly
- 1:13:57political, clearly anti abortion dog whistle, says the texture. This all this
- 1:14:00is all in reference to the Baby Olivia video, which, according to according
- 1:14:08to the bill, which would require additional instruction in the schools about all that,
- 1:14:19and it. Part of the requirement specifically says that you have to show
- 1:14:25this video this video, Hoppy, do we really want to send Big Jim
- 1:14:30to the Senate? On the other hand, on the other hand, he
- 1:14:35may be ideal. Borrow money was zero interest, zero intent of paying it
- 1:14:40back, says the texture Hoppy. I just got service so I could hear
- 1:14:47you. Have you heard anything about the new pay raise? No? Have
- 1:14:53not. All the there's a lot of Look, there are a lot of
- 1:14:57bills, just I mean hundreds of bills. Frankly, most of them are
- 1:15:01not of significant public interest or limited public interest. And I haven't heard squat
- 1:15:10about the pay raise since the governor's State of the State address, and since
- 1:15:15the House Education Committee passed out a bill that would raise the entry level salary
- 1:15:23for teachers to forty four thousand dollars and right now it's about thirty nine thirty
- 1:15:29eight somewhere around in there. That is a more expensive bill than the across
- 1:15:34the board for average five percent pay raise that the governor proposed, but that
- 1:15:40haven't heard much about it since then. That bill goes to the House Finance
- 1:15:44Committee and we'll see what happens from there. I would be shocked. Now.
- 1:15:47I wrote a piece where I said, I think it's a good idea
- 1:15:51to raise the base pay, the entry level pay for teachers to forty four
- 1:15:56thousand dollars a year. I mean, they're school teachers. The job is
- 1:15:59more difficult all the time. We have about fifteen hundred vacancies in our public
- 1:16:03school system. Fewer people are getting into public education. We had a serious
- 1:16:11shortfall of corrections officers in West Virginia to the point where the National Guard had
- 1:16:15to be called out hundreds of them and fill in those jobs. So what
- 1:16:19did corrections do? They ask for and receive substantial pay raises. Now a
- 1:16:23corrections officer begins at a minimum of forty thousand dollars and within six months goes
- 1:16:28to forty two to five, within a year is at forty five thousand.
- 1:16:31If you're in one of the facilities where there's an even dire need, more
- 1:16:34dire need, and there's about nine of those, you start at forty five
- 1:16:39and quickly get to fifty. Guess what, Guess what's happened is that those
- 1:16:43vacancies are being filled. So money is not the only issue, but it's
- 1:16:45a big issue. So if we want to fit now, when it comes
- 1:16:49to public ad, as I said, I think the teachers should make more.
- 1:16:54I also think that along with that, along with teaching is a profession,
- 1:17:01they should dress like professionals, they should conduct themselves professionally, they should
- 1:17:06get better results, and we should pay them as professionals. All of that
- 1:17:11rising tide, all of that tide needs to be raised. All of that
- 1:17:15tide needs to be raised in West Virginia. Take a break and come back.
- 1:17:19A massive, massive drug round up in the Eastern panandle that story when
- 1:17:24we return to the AARP broadcast location. This is talk Line on Metro News,
- 1:17:28the Voice of West Virginia. It's eleven thirty. Let's get a news
- 1:17:33update, checking with the Metro News radio network final What's happening statewide this hour,
- 1:17:38all across the great state of West Virginia. West Virginia Metro News.
- 1:17:44I'm Chris Lawrence. The Greenberg County Sheriff's Office reports a big drug bust in
- 1:17:46the community of charm Co from Wednesday. Authority say a search warrant executed in
- 1:17:49the community turned up large amounts of meth and fetamine, fentannel, and other
- 1:17:53controlled substances, and a significant amount of cash was seized as well. Authority's
- 1:17:58arrested forty seven year old James W. Walk Cup of charm Co on charges
- 1:18:00of delivering a controlled substance. He's in the Southern Regional Jail. Meanwhile,
- 1:18:04a similar hall of drugs found at a home in the Logan County community of
- 1:18:08Whitman back on Monday. Matt fentnel and suspected crack cocaine along with marijuana were
- 1:18:14seized in the raid of the home conducted by the state Police and the US
- 1:18:16one nineteen Drug Task Force along with federal agents arrested with fifty one year old
- 1:18:20Charles Pattison of Whitman and thirty three year old Thabat Bashir of Columbus, Ohio.
- 1:18:26They are charged with possession and conspiracy charges. Investigators say they had been
- 1:18:30looking into reports that Patterson was allowing individuals, including Bashir, to live at
- 1:18:33the home and sell drugs. Breeze Airways and West Virginia International Yeager Airport have
- 1:18:39announced plans to restart the seasonal flights from Charleston to Myrtle Beach. Yaeger Sheep
- 1:18:44marketing officer Page Withrow says, that's a big deal for the airport. This
- 1:18:46is one of the destinations that our customers are always asking us for, so
- 1:18:51we're excited to see this come back and to be a destination for our travelers
- 1:18:58and also can come and visit my Ninia. The first Phara start at forty
- 1:19:02nine dollars. The Myrtle Beach flights begin May tenth. You're listening to Metro
- 1:19:06and u's the voice of West Virginia. You guys just didn't want it bad
- 1:19:13enough. That should have been an easy win. What were you doing out
- 1:19:15there? You got a hostle. You could have made that play if you've
- 1:19:18been open on the car at home after the game. When you think you're
- 1:19:25helping by telling me what I did wrong and what I need to work on.
- 1:19:30Holly here is that I'm not good enough, that I'm supposed to be
- 1:19:35perfect, That it's not okay to lose on the car at home. All
- 1:19:42I need to hear is how much you love me and enjoy watching me play.
- 1:19:46That my worth isn't determined by my performance, that even on my worst
- 1:19:51day, I am worthy. That you see me learning, growing and doing
- 1:19:58my best, and that is enough. This message presented by the WVSSAC and
- 1:20:05the West Virginia Athletic Directors Association Official State Blasting works happening at the Morgantown Municipal
- 1:20:12Airport today and development of a new runway extension is happening. Airport Director Jonathan
- 1:20:15Brabele says, along with that as a companion project building a business park on
- 1:20:19I sixty eight. As we blast the rock and we move it over to
- 1:20:24the runway, it's slowly creating that industrial park. Total of four point four
- 1:20:29million kibit yards of material will come from the industrial park site to build that
- 1:20:32runway extension. From the Metro News anchored ESK, I'm Chris Lawrence. We're
- 1:20:54at the AARP broadcast location in Cova. Insurance Studio is located here at the
- 1:20:58upper rotunda of the West Virginia State Capital. Jackpots are in the millions here
- 1:21:02in West Virginia. Who doesn't want to be a millionaire? Get in the
- 1:21:04Powerball drawings Mondays, Wednesdays and Saturdays and the Mega Megion's drawings on Tuesdays and
- 1:21:09Fridays. Will you be the next big Winter play? Today? The Powerball
- 1:21:13jackpot is one hundred and sixty four million dollars. The Mega Meguons jackpot two
- 1:21:16hundred and eighty five million dollars. A massive drug round up in the eastern
- 1:21:23panhandle of West Virginia, a drug operation that came and originated in surrounding states.
- 1:21:30And we're talking about fentanyl, meth, cocaine, thousands and thousands of
- 1:21:35dollars, weapons, and more. Laura ums Bodiker is Assistant US Attorney for
- 1:21:42the Northern District of West Virginia, was on the front of this bush.
- 1:21:45She joined us on Metro News talk line. Laura, thanks for joining us.
- 1:21:48I gave a rough outline. Give us some specifics of this drug round
- 1:21:53up, give us some numbers. Yes, of course, thanks for having
- 1:21:56me on. So this drug investigation spanned over well into three years now at
- 1:22:02this point, beginning in twenty twenty one, and as you mentioned, eighty
- 1:22:06two individuals indicted. But as far as just the scale of this organization,
- 1:22:13the amount of drugs that were seized were far reaching. Ten kilograms of fentanyl,
- 1:22:18five hundred grams of cocaine, six hundred grams of crystal meths ounces of
- 1:22:25crack, and all of that just in the seas drug alone have a street
- 1:22:29value of over one point two million dollars. What about cash and weapons?
- 1:22:33With cash over with the assets and the cash over two hundred thousand dollars as
- 1:22:41well as at this point two weapons that were seized from the offenders. Well,
- 1:22:45give us some sense of how this operated. I mean, we're not
- 1:22:47talking about just a bunch of individuals, right. Was this a network?
- 1:22:51And if it was, how did it operate? Where did where did was
- 1:22:55it sourced? Then it got into the Eastern Panhandle, had distributors there?
- 1:22:59How did it work? So the investigation really began in the Eastern Panhandle of
- 1:23:03West Virginia and law enforcement officers from Jefferson in Berkeley County started seeing the flood
- 1:23:10of a unique fentanyl cap in the area. And these look like little vitamin
- 1:23:15capsules, but they're filled with a blue fentanyl powder and that's what gave it
- 1:23:19its distinct nature. So law enforcement began to put all this together as they're
- 1:23:24seizing drugs from different redistributors here in the area, and traced it back to
- 1:23:29one group in Baltimore, Maryland that was supplying this unique blue fentanyl powder.
- 1:23:34From there. It was a lot of thousands of hours of investigative work were
- 1:23:40put in by law enforcement to do surveillance, use other investigative methods to see
- 1:23:47redistributors from West Virginia traveling to Maryland to purchase drugs from this network. Did
- 1:23:56the fentanyl and any of the other drugs originated in Mexican code? Do you
- 1:24:00know the primary source? Any idea? Definitely international at this point. The
- 1:24:05capsules itself were the empty capsules were ordered from Amazon and they are linked to
- 1:24:12a Chinese company that's sending them in. And then the fennel itself. You
- 1:24:16know a lot is coming from either Mexico or China. But at this point
- 1:24:21those are just speculations of the ultimate source, and I know investigators are still
- 1:24:27working on that Laura Botiker is with us. She is assistant US Attorney for
- 1:24:31the Northern District and worked tirelessly for three years on this drug bust. After
- 1:24:38all this time, do you and those that work with you have a sense
- 1:24:42of accomplishment or is there any sense of resignation, because even after a bust
- 1:24:46of this size that it's hard to stem the flow when there is demand.
- 1:24:51What is your overall take on that, Well, we do feel a sense
- 1:24:56of accomplishment. Most of us who worked on this case are all from this
- 1:25:00community. We take great pride in keeping it safe and that our investigative efforts
- 1:25:05have paid off. But of course, as you mentioned, having a bust
- 1:25:11of this size is going to leave quite a void in the drug market,
- 1:25:15and unfortunately, there are still others out there who are going to continue to
- 1:25:18seek drugs. So the investigations for us will continue, and even on this
- 1:25:24investigation, you know, our goal is always to find the ultimate supplier of
- 1:25:28the fentanyl, So I would say that there's going to continue to be investigative
- 1:25:31efforts poured into this case as well. Do you believe that in this investigation
- 1:25:36and with the charges against the eighty two, that you got some of the
- 1:25:41top people and are they in custody. Yes, we do believe that as
- 1:25:45far as as our investigation and the top of the network we were looking at
- 1:25:49that we have arrested this point the individuals involved at the top, and there
- 1:25:56is one remaining defendant from that group, Charles Delvroy Singletary, who still remains
- 1:26:00a fugitive. All right. Laura Armsabotka is Assistant US Attorney the Northern District
- 1:26:06of West Virginia. Three year long investigation results in eighty two charges and arrests
- 1:26:14and busting up a major serious drug operation that stemmed from Baltimore in the Greater
- 1:26:18Metro Area into the eastern Panhandle of West Virginia. Laura, thank you.
- 1:26:23Good work on the part of you and your team. Thank you for coming
- 1:26:26on. All right, take good care. All right. This reminder jackpots
- 1:26:32in the millions here in West Virginia. Who doesn't want to be a migianair
- 1:26:34get in the Paraball drawings Mondays, Wednesdays and Saturdays and the Mega Minions drawings
- 1:26:39on Tuesdays and Fridays. Will you be the next big winner? Play today?
- 1:26:42The Paraball jackpot is one hundred and sixty four million dollars the Megamons jackpot
- 1:26:45two hundred and eighty five million dollars. When we come back, the latest,
- 1:26:50the latest on this big meeting of the Republican Executive Committee Saturday, where
- 1:26:58there will be a movement and potentially a vote and a decision on whether to
- 1:27:03close the Republican primary that is the primary of the dominant party in West Virginia
- 1:27:08two Republicans only and not allow Independence to vote in the primary. That story
- 1:27:15when we return. Talkline continues from the AARP broadcast location here at the Encove
- 1:27:19Insurance Studios at the upper rotunda of the State Capitol. The Wound Institute,
- 1:27:25the only wound center in the area with providers who are Board certified in wound
- 1:27:30and ostomy care. Doctor Kerry Fram and her dedicated team of skilled professionals are
- 1:27:33ready to provide you with the latest treatments and personalized care. Visit their new
- 1:27:39office location on Kenton Drive in Charleston for cutting edge wound care. Find more
- 1:27:43information and start your recovery today at the Wound Institute dot org. The Wound
- 1:27:47Institute healing complex wounds using advanced treatments. West Virginia is home. It's where
- 1:27:55we work, live, and raise our families. At the heart of our
- 1:27:59community are West Virginia Hospitals and they're compassionate caregivers, from life saving treatments and
- 1:28:05emergency care to wellness support and screening services. We are improving your quality of
- 1:28:11life through extraordinary achievements and amazing results West Virginia Hospitals. Your health is the
- 1:28:17heartbeat of our communities. West Virginia. High speed fiber internet is coming and
- 1:28:24citty Net is helping lead the way to connection. City Net is West Virginia's
- 1:28:28local technology company. Their home office's phone number starts with three zero four,
- 1:28:33and long after the West Virginia Fiber project is completed, citty net will still
- 1:28:38be your local internet connection no more one eight hundred. I can't talk to
- 1:28:43a human, reach out to your neighbors at city Net. When it comes
- 1:28:45to technology, citty Net connects, protects, and perfects. This is talk
- 1:28:51Line on Metro News, the voice of West Virginia. West Virginia Outdoors is
- 1:28:58the Mountain states only hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the more than quarter
- 1:29:02million hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence has been
- 1:29:06tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five years. No matter
- 1:29:11where we stalk the fish, they're ultimately going to look for the best suitable
- 1:29:15habitat. And as an angler, that's the secret, learning how to read
- 1:29:19the water and learning where the fish are most likely to be staged for feeding,
- 1:29:24whether it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories about the enjoyment of
- 1:29:29the great outdoors. And then right after the colds Vale he started a pattern
- 1:29:32and I came in and it was the first time I hunted him in the
- 1:29:35morning, about eight point thirty he strolled in and I finally connected. With
- 1:29:41two days left in the season. Really, West Virginia Outdoors covers it all
- 1:29:44Saturday mornings at seven oh six am and for your daily fix, Outdoors Today
- 1:29:48brings you two and a half minutes of news and notes from the woods and
- 1:29:51water every weekday morning on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia. Hey
- 1:29:57everybody, it's Tony Cariedy, I'm Greg Hunter, I'm a house and we
- 1:30:00invite you to join us Sunday through Fridays right here on the Metro News Radio
- 1:30:04network. It's the City Nets Statewide sports Line. We talk West Virginia University
- 1:30:10football, basketball, baseball, you name it. If it's got anything to
- 1:30:14do with the Golden Blue, We're on it. And don't forget the text
- 1:30:16line available every night. So we invite you to join us. The Senator
- 1:30:19Coach Hunter and me Tony Courritti. It's the City Nets statewide sports line on
- 1:30:25Metro News. News in the Mountain State happens quick and for decades you have
- 1:30:30depended on Metro News for accurate news delivered fast. Now here's your chance to
- 1:30:34help keep your fellow West Virginians informed. If you see news happening, become
- 1:30:39a Metro News Hawk by texting News to three five sixty five to one.
- 1:30:43If you take a picture or video of what you see, submit that as
- 1:30:45well. Text the word news to three five sixty five one to submit your
- 1:30:50tip or story. Standard texting rates applying. Please don't text and drive.
- 1:31:09Metro News talk Line with Hoppy Kirchible is brought to you by Incovia Insurance,
- 1:31:13encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visit in Covia
- 1:31:17dot com to learn more. Talkline from the AARP broadcast location with the in
- 1:31:23COD Insurance studios here at the West Virginia State Capitol Upper Rotunda. You know,
- 1:31:29the weekend's almost here, and it'd be great to relax on a pontoon
- 1:31:31boat from lou Wendell Marine this weekend. Check out all the inventory at Louwindelmarne
- 1:31:35Sales dot com. Joining is Tom Sussman t SG, consulting owner, operator
- 1:31:41of Metro News affiliate WMV, longtime political observer. He's probably got a pontoon
- 1:31:45boat somewhere. No one time it sunk, and then I figured the bats
- 1:31:50aren't for me. Well you know what they say when the ship runs aground.
- 1:31:55The sea has spoken absolutely yeah, I'm a land so uh Tom.
- 1:32:00A lot of attention now being focused on this upcoming meeting of the Republican Executive
- 1:32:05Committee Saturday in Charleston. You're not on that committee, but it was.
- 1:32:09It was schedule for last Saturday. Weather caused it to be delayed, and
- 1:32:12they're going to take up this proposal by the Resolutions Committee four to three vote
- 1:32:18that said the primary is starting with the upcoming primary should be restricted to Republicans
- 1:32:23only and that non affiliated and independence would not be able to vote in the
- 1:32:27primary, and they have been able to vote in the Republican primary for a
- 1:32:29couple of decades now, So give me your assessment. You don't. You
- 1:32:32can pick us out if you want, but give me your assessment of each
- 1:32:35side on that. So for my take on that, if you're a moderate
- 1:32:41Republican, a traditional Republican is the fire right likes to call them rhinos.
- 1:32:45They attract independent voters. And so for the far right candidates, you know
- 1:32:51Alex Mooney, he doesn't want Jim Justice getting independent voters. So what's the
- 1:32:57best way to do it. Let's just reshuffle the deck in the middle the
- 1:33:00game and say, all right, we're going to eliminate independence and that will
- 1:33:03take them out of the election. I mean, New Hampshire is a great
- 1:33:06example. Nikki Haley did better in New Hampshire than she'll probably do in other
- 1:33:12states. And mean, look at Iowa, not a lot of independence weren't
- 1:33:15allowed in those caucuses. So that's basically they're just trying to reset the playing
- 1:33:19field to try and catch up or to try and keep moderates like more Capito
- 1:33:25and others out of the governor's raes. In New Hampshire, in that GOP
- 1:33:29primary, Haley won Independence fifty eight percent to thirty nine percent. So that
- 1:33:34has caused Donald Trump to be critical of allowing those independents to vote. And
- 1:33:40that look, Donald Trump is so popular in West Virginia that I think would
- 1:33:44have impact in West Virginia, wouldn't it. I mean that could cut two
- 1:33:47ways. That could cut two ways. One is that you could have Republicans
- 1:33:53who say, well, Trump doesn't want independence to be able to vote in
- 1:33:56the primary, therefore we should not let independence vote in the primary. By
- 1:34:00the same token, there are probably a lot of independent independence in West Virginia
- 1:34:02who really are Republicans who want to vote for Trump, and they're Democrats who
- 1:34:06are independents who want to vote for Trump. I think he transcends party to
- 1:34:10a certain degree in West Virginia. Yeah. And I think what you're setting
- 1:34:13up is for MSNBC on election night to say, look at Donald Trump's gross
- 1:34:18votes in West Virginia. In twenty sixteen, he was here, twenty twenty,
- 1:34:23he was here, and now he's down one hundred and fifty thousand votes.
- 1:34:26The people in West Virginia don't like him because they won't understand or they
- 1:34:29won't talk about the fact that you know, guess what the independence aren't voting
- 1:34:33in the election, and our polls have always shown that the independence like Donald
- 1:34:36Trump in the state. Well, look, it's a conservative state. Yeah,
- 1:34:41okay, it's it's a conservative state. And you have a lot of
- 1:34:44people who there's two hundred and eighty thousand independents in West Virginia, two hundred
- 1:34:48and eighty two hundred and ninety thousand voters. And I, as I've said
- 1:34:53before, I do get both sides. I mean I get I understand it.
- 1:34:56Yeah, we'll do it in twenty twenty six when people have the opportunity.
- 1:35:00Here's who I'm concerned about. Not these candidates. I mean, they'll
- 1:35:02figure their way out, they always do. Their politicians. Nothing against politicians,
- 1:35:06but these little old women and men who work election day and people like
- 1:35:12me who are an independent are going to come in and say can I get
- 1:35:14my Republican ballot? And they're gonna say, I'm sorry, you're not allowed
- 1:35:16to have a Republican ballot. Well, they're not gonna blame Eugene mccartal or
- 1:35:20Alex Mooney. It's that poor little lady, the little grandma who's sitting there
- 1:35:26doing her civic duty, and she's gonna get abused on election night. I'm
- 1:35:30sorry. If you want to do it, and you've got great public policies
- 1:35:32to do it in twenty twenty six and let it, let it be where
- 1:35:35it is. You know, you got to think through how you're impacting people.
- 1:35:40And these people are gonna get nailed. Yeah, yeah, I think
- 1:35:43you're right. And there's also just a practical application I had on the County
- 1:35:45Court from Preston County and she says, we've been working on this for a
- 1:35:48year. Right now, you're gonna tell me now that I've got to change
- 1:35:51everything. You know, We've got to change computers, they gotta change this,
- 1:35:56got to change that, got to train all the polar you know,
- 1:35:58got to do everything and change all this. It is that it would be
- 1:36:00an unfair and it would be unfair to those to those folks too in the
- 1:36:03Cork's offices. Absolutely, and I think the legislature based on this should pass
- 1:36:09a law that says set your rules ninety days before filing period and that way
- 1:36:13people have plenty of notice. But now I mean the filing period people filed
- 1:36:17understanding the old rules of what the rules yeah gonna be. And I would
- 1:36:23suggest to you that if it's Saturday at noon or whenever they're meeting they make
- 1:36:27this decision, you're going to see some folks who are and if they decide
- 1:36:30to go through with this and eliminate the independence in some of these Senate races,
- 1:36:35I think you're going to see some people file who say, well,
- 1:36:39you know what, I can't get the independent vote, but I might get
- 1:36:42to far right vote. I'm gonna run. I mean, I think it
- 1:36:45shakes up the election, and I think you're really really I mean, I
- 1:36:47look at you know, there's an individual who's in the House who part of
- 1:36:51the reason he lost the Senate race four years ago was because of the independence
- 1:36:56voting for Senator Grady. Does Jim Butler back up and say, well,
- 1:37:00I'm gonna run for the Senate for Jim Butler, who's been on this program,
- 1:37:03the delegate he is among those. It might have been his resolution right
- 1:37:08that came out of the Resolutions Committee, the Republican part. I'm not putting.
- 1:37:11I don't know what Gim's gonna do, but it sets the cards the
- 1:37:14table better. You look at a Chris prep running against Eric Nelson and Charleston.
- 1:37:19You know Eric gets a lot of independent votes. For Chris who is
- 1:37:24extremely far right, this will be a This would be a real plus for
- 1:37:29him. You look at the secretary of State's race exactly where Doug scaff longtime
- 1:37:33Democrat, I mean, a high profile Democrat switches to Republicans running for secretary
- 1:37:38of State. Yeah, he has to get independent votes if he wants to
- 1:37:41win. And you know Ken Reid, he's a moderate Republican. Does that
- 1:37:45impact his ability? I mean, so you start going down the auditors are
- 1:37:47the attorney general's race. JB. McCaskey, he's a moderate Republican, Mike
- 1:37:53Stewart, conservative Republican, and so these folks and they're all I mean,
- 1:37:58they're they're trying to shuffle the deck so that it comes out the way it's
- 1:38:00better for them. Yeah, it's frustrating. And do again, I'm not
- 1:38:06part of the committee. I'm not part of the party. I'm an I'm
- 1:38:10an independence too. I mean, you're thinking of my valid away from it.
- 1:38:14You can do what you want to do, like the party can do
- 1:38:16what it wants to do. It really, don't, I think right?
- 1:38:18Better think this thing through, Yeah, because it doesn't happen in a vacuum.
- 1:38:23And here's what will happen. And this is my projection. So when
- 1:38:26they do this, either this time or next time, the Republican party in
- 1:38:30the legislature will move even further right. Really yeah, because I think you'll
- 1:38:33see some of the moderates can't get the independent vote, aren't going to survive
- 1:38:39primaries in future years. So that will force the business in a lot of
- 1:38:44ways, because the far right's not very business friendly at times, to maybe
- 1:38:46look for moderate republic moderate Democrats, or independence, and it will it'll change
- 1:38:51how this legislature long term. It don't have an impact long term. Anecdotally,
- 1:38:56I've gotten a lot of texts from people who say things like I'm an
- 1:39:00independent, I've been an independent, and if they do this, I'll never
- 1:39:02vote Republican again. Now maybe they will, I mean, who knows that.
- 1:39:05People say a lot of things, but but I do think that you
- 1:39:09run the risk. Republicans would run the risk of angering a lot of independence
- 1:39:13who've probably voted Republican ever since they had a chance to vote Republicans as an
- 1:39:16independent. That's why the Republicans allowed independence into the elections. People didn't want
- 1:39:20and so what happens people get frustrated with the process they stay home, and
- 1:39:27then in the general election in these if there are any purple districts in West
- 1:39:31Virginia there might be wondering there's a couple outside of the east. Then now
- 1:39:35there are a few where you'll see, you'll see Democrats win. I mean
- 1:39:39it just I don't if you want to do it, give people plenty of
- 1:39:43notice, and I think you're going to leave a real sour taste in people's
- 1:39:46mouth. Well, I have been told, and I have been told,
- 1:39:49but that was last week that there would be again. I'm not completely up
- 1:39:56to speed on all the rules of the Republican Party. But the Democrats were
- 1:40:01here for any three years. I don't think you ever saw this one.
- 1:40:04This is a good one. I haven't I have not studied them. But
- 1:40:06I do believe that the vote on the Resolution committee was four to three to
- 1:40:12propose that resolution. That if you were it's kind of like the legislator,
- 1:40:15I kind of like the legislature. If if you were in the minority,
- 1:40:18then you can propose an amendment to the resolution. Okay, okay, So
- 1:40:23there may well be a proposed amendment to the resolution to put it off until
- 1:40:28twenty twenty six. Maybe that was that was a number of days ago,
- 1:40:31so it's hard to tell. And I've talked to one side and they say,
- 1:40:34oh, we've got sixty sixty percent the people who are advocating. I've
- 1:40:39talked to the people who are against it, and I said they're fifty to
- 1:40:42fifty. I talked to somebody yesterday says, all we've got him killed.
- 1:40:45So I don't know. We'll just and I'm sure there's some polling being done.
- 1:40:48We're going to restate our poll and pull the independence out of the WMF.
- 1:40:51Yeah, yeah, yeah, And that'll give you a snapshot on why
- 1:40:55people are doing this, and I'll get that to you this afternoon. That's
- 1:40:58going to be very relevant. That's going to go to a lot of attention
- 1:41:00tomorrow, just one day ahead of that vote. Absolutely, all right,
- 1:41:02Tom Susman, Thanks Tom, Good to see it. Let get see sir.
- 1:41:04I would take a break. Talkline continues. We'll return just a moment.
- 1:41:11Despite the ill fated efforts of President Biden and his wealthy New York friends,
- 1:41:15West Virginia coal is thriving and being shipped to forty five countries worldwide given
- 1:41:21its high quality and clean burning properties. Countries across the globe are demanding and
- 1:41:26consuming it, and in state production continues to grow. With billions of dollars
- 1:41:30of recent investment in West Virginia mining operations, combined with the reliability of our
- 1:41:35coal fired electric manufacturing facilities, West Virginia coal is here to stay. No
- 1:41:41other fuel in the world matches West Virginia coal for baseload generation and steel making.
- 1:41:46Like a good friend, It's always been and always will be there,
- 1:41:50keeping the lights on and contributing greatly to our growing economy. In fact,
- 1:41:56coal continues to sustain fifty thousand plus West Virginia jobs, putting food on the
- 1:42:00table for Mountain State families. Visit Friends of Cold on org to learn more.
- 1:42:05A message from the Friends of Coals, West Virginia is home. It's
- 1:42:12where we work, live and raise our families. At the heart of our
- 1:42:15communities are West Virginia Hospitals and they're compassionate caregivers. From life saving treatments and
- 1:42:23emergency care to wellness support and screening services. We are improving your quality of
- 1:42:28life through extraordinary achievements and amazing results. West Virginia Hospitals, Your health is
- 1:42:34the heartbeat of our communities. Golf Week called Pete Die Golf Club one of
- 1:42:40America's best modern courses. Golf Digest recently called Pete Die one of America's one
- 1:42:45hundred greatest courses, and Pete Dye calls it eighteen of the most exciting and
- 1:42:48memorable holes I've ever built on one course. Pete Die Golf Club invites you
- 1:42:53to join the only course named after the legendary designer himself, National corporate and
- 1:42:58local memberships of now for a limited time. Visit Petdie dot com to learn
- 1:43:02more. Come play where the Mountaineers play at Petedie Golf Club. You're listening
- 1:43:08to Talkline on Metro News, the voice of West Virginia. Wvmetronews dot com,
- 1:43:15the only website you need to stay informed in the Mountain State. Get
- 1:43:18the latest news and sports story, information on the great outdoors, and never
- 1:43:24miss an episode of your favorite Metro News programs and podcast including Talkline, Hotline,
- 1:43:29sports Line, and Three Guys Before the Game. Make a bookmark now
- 1:43:32and visit wv metronews dot com first thing every morning to find out what's happening
- 1:43:38all across the state. Wvmetronews dot com. West Virginia Outdoors is the Mountain
- 1:43:44States only hook and Bullet radio show dedicated to the more than quarter million hunters
- 1:43:48and anglers across the state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence has been tracking down
- 1:43:53hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five years. We used always joke
- 1:43:57when we came up here, that's a smallmop here born to pounds. It's
- 1:44:01it's rare. I mean, it's it's more common to catch a four plus
- 1:44:05than it is one under twelve inches here, whether it's hunting and fishing news
- 1:44:10for just compelling stories about the enjoyment of the great outdoors. It's got back
- 1:44:14up in, must stay in. Around nine o'clock, he came cruising through
- 1:44:16kind of an open area that I could see on the stand as fortunate enough
- 1:44:20to bagging probably the biggest bread buck I've ever seen its own eyes normally West
- 1:44:25Virginia here don't get that wide. West Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday mornings
- 1:44:30at seven oh six am and for your daily fix, Outdoors Today brings you
- 1:44:33two and a half minutes of news and notes from the woods and water every
- 1:44:36weekday morning on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia. It's two hours
- 1:44:42of sports conversation to wrap up your weekend. It's the City that Sunday Night
- 1:44:45sports Line. Hey, this is Travis Jones joining myself and Greg Hunter every
- 1:44:49Sunday night from six oh six until eight o'clock as we wrap up the sports
- 1:44:53weekend. We talked Mountaineers, High School, Mountain East Conference, and the
- 1:44:57latest in the national scene. The Sunday Sports Line is listener interactive. You
- 1:45:00could call or text the show at three oh four Talk three oh four.
- 1:45:04It's a perfect weekend sports wrap up on your favorite Metro News affiliate, or
- 1:45:09watch the show at WV metronews dot com. Listening to talk Line on Metro
- 1:45:29News from the Upper Rotunda. AARPS your ally for real possibilities in the Mountain
- 1:45:33State. Connect on social media AARP West Virginia. Learn more at AARP dot
- 1:45:38org, slash, WV texts hoppy West Virginia legislators need to leave the virtue
- 1:45:44signaling to the Democratic Party. Republicans are not very good at it, says
- 1:45:48the Texture Hobby. I don't understand the big deal about the bill for obscene
- 1:45:56books. Kids today have probably already been exposed to everything you can imagine on
- 1:46:00the Internet, TV, Facebook, et cetera. You just can't think this
- 1:46:03will put a bubble around a child. And I say, if books get
- 1:46:08them reading, let them read, says the Texture. Three O four talk
- 1:46:15three oh four. Uh, Hopey, As a former CEO, only the
- 1:46:24most desperate loan seeker, and no reasonable business person would personally guarantee any loan,
- 1:46:30let alone three hundred million dollars. Why incorporate any business except to shield
- 1:46:34you personally, says the text. That's in reference to the story, and
- 1:46:40again kind of legally ted complicated, But it does not bode well for justice
- 1:46:45businesses because it is a step closer to a federal judge saying, look,
- 1:46:51Justice companies, you're going to have to pay Carter back three hundred million dollars.
- 1:46:55You better figure out how to do it. Text Hopy, I come
- 1:46:58in West Virginia. Conservative for getting back to real conservative ideals like protecting life,
- 1:47:02executing people, banning books. But what are the conservatives doing about witches
- 1:47:08in our community? And why have we stopped burning them? Asks? The
- 1:47:12Texture got a run. We'll see you tomorrow from Morgantown. This has been
- 1:47:15talk line on Metro News. Metro News is the voice of West Virginia.