Latest / Carbon Weekly News / Google's First Megaton Rock Weathering Deal | CWN EP06
Transcript
- speaker-0: Now it feels like every announcement is Google. speaker-1: This project with Google, it's our first megaton scale project, and We spread rock, we have to wait for it to weather. ⁓ So it's really just letting these two solutions kind of do what they do best. We want the project to be net zero warming from the time we deliver the first credit, and then forever. Right? What's brilliant about ERW, for four and a half billion years this process has cooled the Earth. We know it works. speaker-0: If on paper it looks the same, it's all about the... All right, here we are again with another exciting announcement. But first of all, it feels like 50 % of all our announcements so far were on Google. speaker-2: They have been a little bit active, I would say, lately. speaker-0: Exactly. Whereas like a year ago, if you would have started that show, everything would be Microsoft. Now it feels like every announcement is Google. Like last week we had the Mitty Labs, which I find quite interesting. There's also some connection here. But today we have Connor from Terra.io. Connor, ⁓ nice to have you. ⁓ Congrats. As I just said, congrats on the news. I think I found it, when I read it, I find it quite novel because like You know, there's enhanced rock weathering, but then also methane. And it feels like this is the Google narrative, right? It's like we love carbon removal, but we also love super pollutants. Is that how that deal also came together initially? speaker-1: Yeah, I mean, I think the and just to introduce myself, Connor Sandel, Chief Commercial Officer, part of the founding team at Teradot. ⁓ Teradot was founded out of Stanford Soil and Environmental Biogeochemistry Lab, and we're a large-scale enhanced rock weathering developer, primarily in Brazil and in the US. ⁓ so yeah, this project with Google, it's our first megaton scale project. And the kind of context for the deal was exactly as you said. We thought about how can we have the most impact as fast as possible and how can we spend as many dollars in the deal on climate impact as possible. ⁓ so we've been working on this with the Google team for gosh, like a year now. ⁓ started with a conversation in the back of a truck the last time that Google was with us in Brazil, whiteboarding session here in New York, and now like twelve months later, it's it's real. ⁓ so yeah, super consistent with Google's framework, but I think it's only enabled because there's been a a lot of work across the the industry on this concept, right? Frontiers published on this idea, Carbon Direct has published on this idea. I think it all fits in that framework of like third party thinking about this idea of can we have impact on temperature over time? And can we use that as our metric for climate? speaker-0: So was it basically that it still happened in like a collaborative way and it's not like we see some R &P sometimes where they're like, hey, we need a million credits ⁓ and also methane would be great. But it was more like a collaborative approach where Google was like, hey, look, this is really important for us. And you were like, I think we can do that. And then you figured out what is the best way to do that. speaker-1: Yeah, exactly. So this is our third deal with Google now. our first deal through the Frontier Coalition in twenty twenty four. We also did a large bilateral deal at the time, the largest enhanced rock weathering deal with Google. ⁓ I think this really came from knowing their team, those deals starting to deliver. ⁓ we have kind of thought about this as wanting to build the technical and operational platform for ERW. ⁓ so it's never just been about let's do one project together. We've always thought about okay, what's the next innovation? How can we work together to bring something that drives more impact sooner and lower cost to the world? ⁓ so I think that that collaborative effort has been really important here because the the groundwork is being laid not just for this deal, but to kind of do this approach with more customers, with more projects all over the world. ⁓ so we really want this to be more than just one one big project, one big deal. speaker-2: How do you think about this question of stacking and sort of solving some of the timing issues? You know, do you think pure play projects still have a place in the future, or is it all going to be driven by these opportunities to take kind of the unique circumstances of a a place where like in a rice system I can adjust one thing and get kind of two benefits from it and play one thing off the other? Like what how how do those how do those play? speaker-1: Yeah, I I think it's really like a yes and type of situation, right? So we're still big believers enhanced rock weathering, fantastic technology to bring large scale carbon removal to the world. I know you all are developing some enhanced rock weathering projects as well and probably feel similarly. I think we look at this project as a really unique opportunity to kind of do two things at once, which is ⁓ accelerate climate impact, super important, right? We look at the most recent UN report. Published just a few weeks ago, and they've emphasized: hey, we have both this near-term warming problem, it's too hot, we have to do something about it. But if we don't draw down the carbon as well, it's going to continue warming the climate for forever, right? ⁓ so how can we pull forward impact? And then in doing that, really from the specific ERW perspective, you're able to kind of solve some of the inherent challenges in ERW by Pretty simply creating a longer timeline for delivery. Right. So just like many durable CDR solutions, there's this natural delay to realizing the full climate impact. ⁓ we spread rock, we have to wait for it to weather by creating this kind of covered climate impact window with methane. And then we do some very careful math in this like framework that the Google team and Frontier published for exactly how much methane we need, how much climate impact coverage it buys us. We basically just extend this window to deliver the durable CDR impact. ⁓ that doesn't mean we deploy the rock later. We really want to make sure we make that intervention and get the rock on the ground. ⁓ and that that's the thing that that unlocks it in in ERW, right? ⁓ because we feel very confident that this rock is going to weather, we've been deploying in Brazil for three plus years. ⁓ By getting that rock deployed, we create this ability to cover that like time to impact with basically dollars spent on accelerated climate impact rather than dollars spent on extra MRV periods, extra project finance, things of those nature. ⁓ so it's really just letting these two solutions kind of do what they do best. speaker-2: How does that work operationally on the ground? Like you're applying rock, you're changing the practices of how they're managing water and in wetting and drying, and then you're measuring, presumably you're measuring kind of both things. There's some measurements that are being taken for the methane side, and then some measurements that are being taken for the carbon removal. What does a project life cycle look like then as a result of this stacked solution? speaker-1: Yeah, definitely. ⁓ so both both of the pathways that we're deploying, alternate wetting and drying and ERW will both be registered with existing protocols, existing methodologies. ⁓ both of them use direct measurement approaches. So we're actually quantifying in the case of AWD with gas flux, and in the case of enhanced rock weathering with solid-phase oil sampling, we're actually quantifying exactly what's happening across the project, just as we would today. ⁓ operationally on the ground, it's not too dissimilar from what we're doing in our existing ERW projects that are delivering in Brazil. ⁓ so we get in there when the farmers are applying ⁓ other agricultural inputs. Oftentimes in southern Brazil, they'll have a rotation of rice and other crops. So there's multiple times that we can enter in that system. And then the AWD side is pretty similar to any other AWD project in the world. We're generally partnering with On the ground organizations that farmers already trust, and making the small practice change to just dry down that field one additional time during the growing season. rice is a really efficient, effective system for enhanced rock weathering. We've seen this now replicated all over the world in rice systems. So we kind of get that efficient ERW when we deploy the rock, and then we'll do AWD every rice season on these fields. ⁓ the measurement for both. Both approaches is pretty much the same as it would be for a standalone project. speaker-2: Yeah, interesting. speaker-0: No, you both chief commercial officers. have a question for you. You both in Enhanced Rock Weathering. For me, like being like sometimes in between the corporate buy-in projects, especially on Enhanced Rock Weathering, the pricing for me feels like such a black box on like long-term because I mean, we're on some RFPs with big corporates and they wanted to have... already credits procured until 2014. And I asked a couple of EOW providers on their pricing and the pricing was completely different. Like completely. But the one had like one price from now until 2014 and it was, don't know, like 300. The other one is like, ⁓ we start now at 400, but it goes down to 150. And like there was everything and I'm trying to get across like, How should I think about pricing and enhance rock weather? speaker-2: That's a really good question. Well, I'll I'll have a perspective. ⁓ I'm sure you do too. You know, the the reality of enhanced rock weathering is quite different from reforestation projects. So for us, you know, we'd started in reforestation projects where you spend all of your money up front and then you're gonna have like 50 years of credits being generated from a forest that you've sunk all of your costs into in the first few years. And the only continuing costs are MRV and kind of maintenance of fire breaks and stuff like that. So you really spend the bulk of your money kind of right up front and you have to deal with that over the whole life of the project. And so it's interesting because when we when we've seen a lot of buyers in the market who are used to these like declining price curves, you you bring in an you're you know, you bring a re reforestation project and often you actually have an increasing price curve because you start with a base price and then you have to inflate to pay back your investors or whoever it might be. And so that already kind of throws people off. So I And then on the on the ERW side, I think one of the cool things that you see is that when you do like multi-year off takes, you actually do get the opportunity to have a declining curve because unlike reforestation where you might be spending all this money up front and then generating credits from that same site in an ERW project, you're gonna, you know, reapply or apply in a new site, but you're learning every time and you're probably scaling your operation. And so there is an opportunity to actually say, okay, I can take my scaling costs and my better you know. better understanding of MRV and everything else to bring the price down over time. So I think, you know, from our standpoint, there have though been a lot of people in the market who are just totally out of whack on pricing, don't really understand the economics and long term impact of what they're doing. You know, and then also you have people who could say, hey, let's price this like competitively so we can gain market share. And so you you never know like how all these things are playing out. Are they are they idiots and not doing a good job on pricing and don't understand the economics or are they being Smart to try to beat the market. Like, I don't know. There's a lot of different tactics that we see, and that results in just completely different pricing dynamics. I don't know. What's your perspective on it? speaker-1: Yeah, no, I mean I think ⁓ like you said, impossible to kind of know what others are doing and why they're doing it. I think at Teradot, we think a lot about hard costs and soft costs that are associated with the project. So, right, what's brilliant about ERW for four and a half billion years this process has cooled the earth. We know it works. ⁓ the question that we're basically faced with in ERW is how much could we speed that up? ⁓ so our job is to deploy. as much alkalinity as we can onto these fields as fast as we can and do it in places where it will happen really, really quickly. ⁓ and what that means from a hard cost perspective is to get like a potential ton of CDR deployed, it's really the cost of getting rock on field, ⁓ which comes down to basically project design and scale. Those are the two things that are impacting your cost of rock on field. Well rock are you using How close is it to the field and how big can you go to take advantage of like industrial economy scale? ⁓ soft cost, and the reason I talked about, you know, the how long does it take question? Right now we're adding substantial amounts of cost to projects that don't add climate impact in the format of project finance to carry that cost, frequent measurement periods to basically service that debt, pay back that project finance. ⁓ and that's just adding These incremental costs that can double or more the cost of deploying like a potential ton of CDR. ⁓ so we are really thinking about how we can get ERW projects as close to the hard costs as possible so that we can get down the cost curve and service, even compliance markets, kind of ETS pricing schemes, be at the very lowest end of delivered CDR means every dollar's going to CDR, right? So that traditional model. Project finance frequent MRV to service that debt. That's how we handle the time lag and kind of traditional ERW. This project with Google handles it very differently. We cover that lag with the methane elimination and create this idea that we can pay for climate impact rather than paying for just durable CDR. So if we've delivered that climate impact, deployed the CDR, that's good enough. And we're able to basically put more dollars on climate impact. ⁓ as a result and get closer to that kind of traditional ⁓ or rather updated approach where we're closer to those like hard costs that we incur to deploy a ton of CDR. speaker-2: Google has talked a lot about this near term warming problem and the long term, you know, carbon removal. we've also seen some of these groups like developing this concept of a permanence trust where I could take a credit that I know is going to be short lived because not because the carbon removal is inherently short lived, but because the farmer could reverse his practice or you could whatever. The tree could get cut down and I have to swap one credit for the next in order to get the long term climate impact. Do guys think about it like that as well? Or is this really just okay, there's a price for removing one ton of methane and there's a price for removing a ton of s of carbon and I I add those two up to finance my project? Or is it a s is it a swap in some kind of yeah. speaker-1: So we really think about this as one ton of durable CDR. ⁓ I think the difference from some of the permanent trust concepts, and I'm glad you brought this up because I think this is like an important distinction here. When we are issuing these credits or delivering this idea of a durable ton, the full intervention is complete. We can be very confident that the climate is going to get one ton of durable CDR, right? I think the idea of the permanence trusts, you run the risk of, hey, you're spending money today, you're funding something that you're expecting to do in the future, but there's no guarantee that that actually develops fast enough, costs come down the cost curve. So we really think that when you can create these complete climate interventions, you have the opportunity to do something like pay for climate impact. But the idea of just funding a permanence trust might not guarantee that same long-term durable impact, which is the claim the buyer's actually making. speaker-2: So to say it another way, like in a permanence trust, I've got to set some money aside in the hopes that in the future there's some direct air capture project or enhanced rock weathering project that's going to get cheap enough that my reforestation project and that little bit of money set aside is going to allow me to buy that credit. But here, because you're doing both at once, you have this kind of closed system that is already durable in its nature. Yeah. How long does that mean you need to? Given that time lag, how do you guys think about when that happens? Because obviously in a in a permanence trust approach, right, you could think about a hundred year reforestation credit and then a 10,000 year whatever credit. And how do so how do you think about the time lag and and climate impact? Like we know the half-life of methane is a certain thing. Is that how you guys are thinking about it? And is the financing of the project similar then because of that? speaker-1: Yeah, exactly. So we really lean on the climate science here. ⁓ so I think the our perspective is you want both interventions to be very well time and impact bounded before you put them together. ⁓ so methane and ERW are both uniquely time and impact bounded, especially when you take this temperature over time framework. So we really lean on the climate science that says one equivalent ton of methane, half life. basically delivers you like a 12 year window from the time you claim one ton until it will have kind of expired in its impact below one ton. And then that gives us our time bounding for delivering durable removal. And again, because we've been deploying in this region, we've selected sites very specifically characterized the efficiency of both the weathering curve and kind of the magnitude of removal we can deliver. We can do matching that gives us a lot of confidence. And we've designed extra time here, right? Like we'll have our first deliveries in 2028. We expect to deliver all the durable CDR well before 2040. But within that 12 year window, that's kind of the thing that gives us comfort that the project and the the term we've been using is net zero warming. We want the project to be net zero warming from the time we deliver the first credit and then forever. Right. So we'll always be delivering a warming impact that exceeds the claim that Google in this case is making for one million tons of garbage. speaker-2: Yeah, it's really interesting. How do you think about the opportunities internationally? I mean, you guys obviously made the acquisition of another company, Ion, that was doing projects in other geographies. Right. ⁓ you know, you've brought some folks into your team now from India who are working in rice systems there. You know, we often think about Brazil as this amazing play area for carbon removal. because of the unique characteristics of temperature and rainfall and land and so on. But obviously there are there are locations all over the world where these projects can can exist. What what how are you guys thinking about geographies and and reasons to go in one place or another for the commercials? Is it because of where your buyers are looking or or other characteristics that are driving you? speaker-1: Yeah, no, great, great question. I think ⁓ there's two big things we we think about. ⁓ where can we deliver low-cost CDR and where will markets pay for that? Right. ⁓ so we, I think like everyone else, believe that we'll need compliance markets to scale beyond the voluntary market. ⁓ certainly there's big opportunities in the voluntary market, but like you said, headlines have been Google before that, Microsoft. There's not that many more megaton scale off takes to be had. ⁓ So as you look at compliance markets, the imperative to deliver low cost removal becomes really clear, right? Like we know EU ETS prices are around 100 euros. We know Canadian ETS prices are below that and rising. Same thing in Asian markets. So we really look at how can we deliver low-cost CDR to the world? ⁓ and kind of let that guide our expansion. And then the other piece we look at is where will compliance markets be able to buy? ⁓ in the EU, there's geographic restrictions, at least in the initial rollout of CRCF, which put pushes us in like a certain direction. ⁓ but I think ultimately that that's what we want to do is deliver low-cost CDR to the world that someone will actually pay for at increasing scale. ⁓ and the good news is there's infrastructure to carry large-scale ERW all over the world because we manage a lot of farmland and we crush a lot of speaker-2: Yeah. Well we've got some great rainfall in the San Sebastian and Basque countryside. A lot of beautiful rock. There's actually a really amazing flish formation along the coastline where you have like a hundred million years of of geologic. So maybe maybe I'll see a ⁓ ERW project in my back. speaker-0: There was reason he moved there. He played a long game. Because I mean, I don't know if you've ever talked to a European buyer, they pay way less for the story. And if you ever been in the European procurement process, it's like if you offer a credit that is euro cheaper, they will work with you. It doesn't matter. If on paper it looks the same, it's all about the price. I think in the US we have a little bit of different. It's just... ⁓ I would say the buyers, you have less, but the ones that you have that pay a lot. And they also pay into the story and into this corporate, cooperation and collaborative approach whereas in Europe, we see it really different. Like there's the procurement structures in these European companies are again, it's already really different. Like most of the corporates we work with, like if they have to spend more than 10,000 euros, they have to run a proper procurement process where they have to have at least three competitive offers. Well, in the US, I mean, I talked to some buyers and is like, spend 5 million and they're like, ⁓ no, we actually only talked to this one. So it's really different. And I think you in the end, it all comes down to the price. So if you find the best location to do so outside of, let's say the compliance market, and you can run and at a point, can get a CDR credit for a hundred dollars. then you will win. And that's the reason I think 99 % of all the credits in Europe so far have been biochar credit. Because they're like, look, if the other thing is not like cheaper, I compared the moment biochar with enhanced rock weathering. It's just what I do. Let's not talk about that. They are different, but that's how they think. So in the end, speaker-1: And how how do you think ⁓ right, so we we have compliance markets coming online and they've set this very ambitious, from my perspective, target to trick your 250 megatons by 2040, right? This is the first megaton scale ERW project in the world, and we're sitting here just like 14 years from that that goal. ⁓ do you think that story changes is some of the scale constraints? come into play, right? Like I think right now there's a lot of focus on price, but certainly technologies like ERW and existing supply chains, much more ability to scale than like a huge direct air capture, Bex facility, billions of CapEx. Do you think there's like a tipping point where that speaker-0: Yeah, you at a certain point, we look at what is the potential per pathway. And if I look at biochar, it's really limited, right? So really limited. Of course you can still try for a little bit, but in the end, I think we need the mineralization and other approaches that just can scale on a different time scale. Because I, at this point at least, don't see how companies spend as much as on the data center expansion and build out the same amount into like direct air capture and back facilities and so on. So I see it and that's the reason I'm a big believer. still see that a lot of European buyers struggling little bit with the MRV side of things, where they're like, we're rather going to be a fast follower here on the buying side rather than a pioneer. And I think that's more the European side. But this is how I look at it at this point. speaker-2: We saw a a European buyer do kind of a a funny thing, which was they said, ⁓ yeah, we're no, we're ready to buy ERW. Let's get bids for ERW, send them in, we're gonna do tens of thousands of tons. And then at the last moment they were like, We're gonna go back to biochar. It's just a direct one I unbelievable to that you know. speaker-0: It's classic. You could have called me. ⁓ Thanks so much for coming over. This was fantastic and congrats again. And I wish you all the best for that Megaton project. Yeah. For more Megatons to come. speaker-2: Yeah, exactly. No huge congrats. speaker-1: Thank you. Thank you guys. speaker-0: Yeah. Thanks.