Latest / The Film Hobbyist / Sunset Boulevard (1950): A Gothic Film Noir
Transcript
- 0:11Come on in and spend some time with the film
- 0:14hobbyist. My name is Lydia, and I love movies.
- 0:31We're sitting here in my attic room, in my nook,
- 0:35next to the window. Outside, the leaves on our
- 0:40two silver maples are beginning to turn, as are
- 0:43the white oak trees alongside my neighbor's fence.
- 0:47In a month, this yard will be an ocean of leaves,
- 0:51knee -deep, too many to mulch. But for now, we
- 0:56can enjoy the colors and the subtle drizzle of
- 0:59leaves as the wind blows. It's officially spooky
- 1:04season, and being a person who loves movies,
- 1:07This is the time of year when it's most appropriate
- 1:10to talk about horror. There is a distinct problem,
- 1:14though. I cannot watch most scary movies. I'm
- 1:20not against horror as a genre. I think it's incredibly
- 1:25fascinating. I've spent a lot of time reading
- 1:29and studying video essays about particular films
- 1:32and horror movies in general. There's so much
- 1:36rich thematic material in horror. It's rife with
- 1:41metaphor and symbolism, one idea representing
- 1:44a larger whole, a werewolf as untamed masculinity,
- 1:49an alien as a conquering other. There's also
- 1:53so much pure cinema, the use of an image or an
- 1:58edit or a sound effect to elicit a specific feeling.
- 2:03And that's where the trouble lies. My personal
- 2:07combination of vivid imagination and deep sense
- 2:10of feeling means that I get a little too invested
- 2:14in horror. And once the film is done, it follows
- 2:19me home. I once freaked myself out looking at
- 2:23the ghosts in the background of stills from Mike
- 2:28Flanagan's The Haunting of Hill House and continued
- 2:31to see faces in the dark for weeks after, so
- 2:35I have to be careful. But not all spooky stories
- 2:39are inaccessible to me. There are even whole
- 2:42realms that I particularly enjoy. I'm very drawn
- 2:46to gothic stories. And gothic isn't necessarily
- 2:51always horror. It's a genre concerned with the
- 2:55sins of the past coming to haunt the present.
- 2:58And its founder, Horace Walpole's 1764 novel
- 3:03The Castle of a Toronto, reads a lot like Brian
- 3:07Jakes' Redwall, with characters in a pastiche
- 3:10of medieval history exploring the secrets of
- 3:13an old castle to find hidden riddles and messages
- 3:17from the past. There are also otherworldly figures
- 3:21speaking truth to them in dreams, which is definitely
- 3:25Martin the Warrior's preferred method of communication.
- 3:29Gothic stories are filled with old buildings
- 3:33and hidden truths and so much atmosphere. We
- 3:38talked way back in March about the sublime. an
- 3:4118th century aesthetic principle that represents
- 3:45beauty's darker cousin, the awe of a thunderstorm,
- 3:49the shiver of a fox crying in the woods, the
- 3:53dark glory of a gust of wind skittering dried
- 3:56leaves over a sidewalk. Gothic stories are the
- 4:01sublime in -story, an atmosphere of pleasant
- 4:05thrill, that spine -tingling delight. And what's
- 4:10amazing about gothic tropes and imagery is how
- 4:14broad their reach can be, even as specific as
- 4:18they are. Which is why I'd like to talk today
- 4:22about Billy Wilder's 1950 film, Sunset Boulevard.
- 4:28I can see the confusion on your face. Sunset
- 4:33Boulevard is a film you might not have seen,
- 4:36but you've probably heard of. And if you haven't
- 4:39heard of it, I assure you, you actually have.
- 4:42If you've ever heard someone say, I'm ready for
- 4:46my close -up, Mr. DeMille, then you've heard
- 4:49of Sunset Boulevard. Norma Desmond, the film's
- 4:52villain, is a camp icon and is a frequent character
- 4:56of drag performers. Robin Williams, who was a
- 5:00kind of honorary member of that community, pulled
- 5:04out his own imitation on more than one occasion
- 5:06during an improv sequence in a film. It's his
- 5:10first persona when he starts trying out characters
- 5:13for what will be Mrs. Doubtfire. But if you know
- 5:18anything directly about Sunset Boulevard, what
- 5:21you will know, most distinctly, is that it's
- 5:25film noir. That's what I knew about it before
- 5:28I watched it for the first time, so I was quite
- 5:31surprised when I actually watched it and it wasn't
- 5:35at all what I was expecting. Film noir is a French
- 5:39term that means black film, and it really describes
- 5:42three different things. A cultural movement,
- 5:46a storytelling genre, and an aesthetic. Film
- 5:51Noir describes a kind of film that developed
- 5:54in Europe on the eve of World War II and thrived
- 5:58in post -war United States. As its name suggests,
- 6:02it's a storytelling with dark sensibilities,
- 6:05a violent, morally ambiguous, cynical kind of
- 6:09tone made by people who had watched incredibly
- 6:13oppressive regimes built on hate and lies sweep
- 6:17across the world. had lived through the horrors
- 6:20of war and been expected to go back to normal,
- 6:23and had watched the systems that were meant to
- 6:26bring peace continue to drag them into conflict.
- 6:30The Soviet Union went from an enemy to an ally,
- 6:34then straight back to an enemy again. Stories
- 6:38had no happy endings. Protagonists couldn't survive
- 6:42unscathed. And out of that cultural movement,
- 6:46Particular kinds of stories and particular kinds
- 6:50of tropes started to emerge. Film noir is closely
- 6:54associated with the hard -boiled detective genre.
- 6:58Some people use those terms interchangeably.
- 7:02Like if you're talking about a film as neo -noir,
- 7:06it's going to be a modern, twisty kind of mystery.
- 7:11First -person narration is very common. as is
- 7:15a MacGuffin, an object or figure of interest
- 7:18at the heart of a search or a mystery or an investigation.
- 7:23A femme fatale is most closely associated with
- 7:26this genre, a French term meaning deadly female,
- 7:30a beautiful, dangerous woman who charms our protagonist,
- 7:34earning his trust before turning on him, betraying
- 7:38him for her own selfish gains. Film noir is usually
- 7:43set in urban locations. There's a kind of architectural
- 7:47threat that represents society. The third man
- 7:51filmed in the actual ruins of post -war Vienna,
- 7:55the tangible physical decay of human depravity.
- 7:59And noir plots are very much about human depravity.
- 8:04They are about fallen men and fallen systems,
- 8:08corruption in business and politics and law enforcement.
- 8:12They often feature conspiracies, famously complicated
- 8:16and twisty. There's an old joke that nobody knows
- 8:21what the film The Big Sleep is actually about.
- 8:24Its machinations are so convoluted. But that
- 8:28journey, that complexity, that sense of being
- 8:32adrift in a dark and twisted world is such a
- 8:35big part of noir as a genre. But film noir is
- 8:41also an aesthetic descriptor. There's a heavy
- 8:45use of the interplay between light and dark,
- 8:48also known as chiaroscuro. Characters are often
- 8:52cast in shadow or thrown into sudden light or
- 8:56stand silhouetted in a fog. You might see the
- 9:00blinds cast jagged lighting on a face or watch
- 9:03a trail of cigarette smoke winding its way up
- 9:06a dark wall. This is an aesthetic with a great
- 9:10deal of very showy camera work, sudden zooms
- 9:14at a reveal or dramatic cranes over a set. It's
- 9:18not unusual to see a fair amount of experimentation.
- 9:22The third man is filled with a million Dutch
- 9:25angles, where the camera sits at a slant to make
- 9:29the world a little unsettled. A touch of evil
- 9:32opens with a long, unbroken shot following a
- 9:36car carrying a bomb as it meanders its way out
- 9:39through a city while we wait in agony for it
- 9:43to explode. None of these are the first thing
- 9:47I think of when watching Sunset Boulevard. Let
- 9:53me tell you a story. A man is traveling back
- 9:57home when the wheel of his vehicle breaks. Now
- 10:01stranded, he stumbles onto an old, disheveled
- 10:05castle. He thinks it abandoned until he sees
- 10:09a dark figure in a window. A lugubrious servant
- 10:13appears, telling him that he is late, that they've
- 10:17been waiting for him. The man protests, but comes
- 10:21in just explaining he was seeking shelter. He
- 10:26is called up by the dark figure, a woman in fabulous
- 10:30dress. She convinces him to stay the night, and
- 10:34he agrees, thinking he is striking a simple bargain.
- 10:38But when he awakes, he finds that all of his
- 10:41possessions have appeared, and he is expected
- 10:43to stay until his bargain is complete. All the
- 10:47while, the grand woman seeks to use him for her
- 10:51own nefarious plot, eventually leading to his
- 10:55sudden and tragic demise. That's, uh, that's
- 11:02a horror story. That's not just a horror story.
- 11:07That's a vampire story, or some other gothic
- 11:11monster tale. It's a knockoff of Dracula. Given
- 11:15a comedic twist, that's practically the plot
- 11:18of the Rocky Horror Picture Show. And that is
- 11:21the literal inciting incident of Sunset Boulevard.
- 11:27Joe Gillis is a struggling screenwriter with
- 11:30a couple of B -movies to his name and a long
- 11:33list of rejected story ideas. He's run out of
- 11:37money, and his car is about to be repossessed.
- 11:40After driving out to visit his agent for a last
- 11:43-ditch cash infusion, he runs into the repo men
- 11:47and flees. His tire blows out, and he makes his
- 11:51way to the nearest driveway on Sunset Boulevard,
- 11:53just planning on hiding the car in an abandoned
- 11:56mansion. Only it's not abandoned. It's occupied
- 12:01by Norma Desmond, a once shining star of silent
- 12:05cinema, now sitting in her castle, scrawling
- 12:09a hideous screenplay for her film return. Joe
- 12:14manipulates her into hiring him to fix up her
- 12:17screenplay by entertaining her delusions. It
- 12:21does not end well. As we see in the opening scene,
- 12:25Joe is narrating to us from beyond the grave.
- 12:30He will end up dead, floating in Norma's swimming
- 12:34pool. This film is often remembered for its Hollywood
- 12:38commentary, particularly the evergreen problem
- 12:41of how the industry abandons women once they
- 12:44leave their youth. Here, that distinction is
- 12:47most felt by the transition from silent film
- 12:50to talkies, a technological shift that dramatically
- 12:54altered the Hollywood landscape and left many
- 12:57figures behind in its wake. This film features
- 13:00cameos from some of the real victims of the change,
- 13:04Buster Keaton, Anna Q. Nielsen, H .B. Warner,
- 13:08as well as Cecil B. DeMille and Hedda Hopper,
- 13:11who adapted with the times in their own ways,
- 13:14DeMille by making talkies, and Hedda by leaving
- 13:18behind acting for journalism. Norma Desmond is
- 13:23played by Gloria Swanson, an actual silent movie
- 13:27star, and the film features footage from her
- 13:30actual performances, as well as promotional stills
- 13:34and portraits. One of the films featured was
- 13:37directed by Eric von Stroheim, who also appears
- 13:41in the film as Norma's butler Max, one of Norma's
- 13:45former directors. And yet... This film doesn't
- 13:50have the primary reputation as a Hollywood satire.
- 13:54It's seen as film noir. Is this film aesthetically
- 14:01a film noir? Yes and no. Norma's world might
- 14:09be described that way. There's extreme lighting
- 14:13in the scene where they watch one of her old
- 14:15films, the smoke from Joe's cigarette billowing
- 14:19out in the light of the film projector, and Norma
- 14:22herself, cast in the extreme lighting as she
- 14:25opines that we didn't need dialogue, we had faces.
- 14:31The camera is incredibly dramatic when she's
- 14:34around, because it has to be. How else do you
- 14:38match Gloria Swanson's energy? But outside of
- 14:43Norma's influence, this film is pretty practical
- 14:46and ordinary. It's shot in the California sunshine,
- 14:50where nighttime parties are a crowd of jolly
- 14:53people, and cafes and offices are places for
- 14:57ordinary meetings. There are no Dutch angles.
- 15:00The opening scene contains one of its most technically
- 15:04difficult shots, capturing footage of a dead
- 15:07Joe Gillis from under the water. But apart from
- 15:10the dead body, it isn't particularly noirish
- 15:13imagery. It's all ripples and light. Is this
- 15:19film a film noir by trope or genre? Well, it
- 15:24isn't a hard -boiled detective story. There might
- 15:27be a slight mystery, but... There's no real conspiracy
- 15:31to uncover or investigation. No MacGuffin. I
- 15:37wouldn't say this was a film where an urban environment
- 15:40is specially featured, though the architecture
- 15:43of Norma's mansion is heavily emphasized for
- 15:46dramatic effect. It is told in first person,
- 15:50and Joe Gillis is an incredible storyteller,
- 15:53especially for someone who's supposedly such
- 15:56a hack of a screenwriter. And there's the Norma
- 16:00Desmond of it all. She's a femme fatale, a literal
- 16:04deadly female. Well, no. I don't think so. Two
- 16:14key features of a femme fatale are seduction
- 16:17and betrayal. Sometimes the male protagonist
- 16:20is suspicious of her initially, but she always
- 16:23tricks him into trusting her. He falls for her
- 16:28only to be proven right or to be left high and
- 16:31dry. In this case, Joe never considers Norma
- 16:36as a real romantic possibility. He never falls
- 16:39in love with her. She does manipulate him and
- 16:43his circumstances until he's half -forced to
- 16:46become her kept man, but he resents her throughout
- 16:50that process. And in the end, She doesn't betray
- 16:54him as much as exert control over him as her
- 16:58possession. She's much closer to the femme fatale's
- 17:02predecessor, the vamp. The vamp was a character
- 17:07all over the silent film era. Sometimes she was
- 17:11just a bad girl, a temptress, the choice of fools.
- 17:15But more often, she had the power to subdue men
- 17:20to her will. Often this power was supernatural.
- 17:24Sometimes the power conveyed just by class or
- 17:28money or privilege, but she would entrap a helpless
- 17:32man. Her name comes from an 1897 poem and the
- 17:37painting that inspired it, both called The Vampire.
- 17:43Yes, the origins of the femme fatale are in horror.
- 17:51And here, Norma uses her perceived star power
- 17:55and her money and her privilege to ensnare Joe
- 17:58against his will. I suppose she would call it
- 18:03a seduction, and perhaps the against his will
- 18:07part could technically be called a betrayal,
- 18:10but not really. It's more a horrifying reality.
- 18:17So is this culturally a film noir. Yeah, I could
- 18:24see that. It's definitely cynical about the Hollywood
- 18:28system, the ways in which people are picked up
- 18:31and used and thrown out again. Joe is such a
- 18:36cynical, sarcastic character. His downfall is
- 18:41that he thinks he's wise to the world, only to
- 18:44discover all the ways he's actually vulnerable.
- 18:48Norma was always planning on trapping him. On
- 18:52a rewatch, you catch that when she's considering
- 18:55hiring him to fix her screenplay, she asks him
- 18:59if he's single. She was always planning on making
- 19:03him her boy toy before he could see it. And later,
- 19:07when he starts to work on a real screenplay idea
- 19:10with a bright, plucky girl he might be falling
- 19:14for, He doesn't realize that he's already doomed.
- 19:19But is this film gothic? Yes. Apart from the
- 19:27horror plot setup, we have the house. Joe compares
- 19:31it to Miss Havisham, a very gothic figure in
- 19:35Charles Dickens' Great Expectations, an old woman
- 19:39who has kept her house untouched. since she was
- 19:42jilted at the altar, and seeks to poison the
- 19:45next generation with her bitterness. Here, the
- 19:49house is untouched, which means it's in decay,
- 19:52a snapshot of a bygone era. Of the past. And
- 19:58Gothic stories are all about the past, the hidden
- 20:02sins of the past. Norma is the hidden shame of
- 20:08a Hollywood past, a representation of all the
- 20:12stars it made and then abandoned. She rises like
- 20:16some reawakened ghost or monster to conquer this
- 20:20world, but she's not capable of doing so. She
- 20:25can't. Ghosts cannot truly come back to life.
- 20:30And when Joe finally tells her the truth, that
- 20:33she isn't a star, that she can't live in the
- 20:36past, she can't accept it and lashes out, killing
- 20:40him. There's also the aesthetic of the house.
- 20:47Norma's mansion is a feast of gothic set decoration.
- 20:51The set decorators Sam Comer and Ray Moyer have
- 20:55an absolute field day making the gaudiest collection
- 20:59of furniture imaginable. Ornate plaster ceilings,
- 21:03bed frames with elaborately carved headboards,
- 21:07a black tile floor that shines like a dark mirror,
- 21:10and the pièce de résistance, Norma's gothic boat
- 21:14-shaped bed, a prop. literally taken from Lon
- 21:19Chaney's Phantom of the Opera. The truth is,
- 21:24gothic horror and film noir share DNA. Film noir
- 21:31isn't the first distinct aesthetic cultural cinematic
- 21:35movement to develop in Europe after a world war.
- 21:39That honor would belong to German Expressionism.
- 21:44A movement of film developed post -World War
- 21:47I, delineated by its extreme use of lighting
- 21:50and chiaroscuro, its elaborate, exaggerated sets,
- 21:55and its dark tone, as well as its connection
- 21:58to a dark spirituality. In the wake of World
- 22:02War I, the world was hungry for spiritualism.
- 22:06Not necessarily religion, but spirituality. Interest
- 22:12rose in occultism, in seances and psychics. On
- 22:17the one hand, people were looking for something
- 22:19to blame for what had happened, some external
- 22:22force they could give responsibility to. On the
- 22:26other, people were longing for some kind of control
- 22:30after the unthinkable happened. Maybe if we tried
- 22:34hard enough, we could keep evil at bay. German
- 22:39Expressionism confronted both ideas by exploring
- 22:43horror. This is where the original Nosferatu
- 22:47comes from, a poorly executed attempt at knocking
- 22:51off Dracula. Poorly as in they got sued. The
- 22:56Cabinet of Dr. Caligari comes from here as well.
- 23:00Metropolis. All of these are foundational works
- 23:03for cinematic horror and science fiction. But
- 23:08post -World War II, the world turned away from
- 23:12enchantment, from magic and spiritualism. The
- 23:17truth wasn't some malevolent will or dark spirit.
- 23:21It was just people following orders, passing
- 23:25on their moral obligations, the banality of evil,
- 23:29as philosopher Hannah Arendt put it. So German
- 23:34Expressionism loses the spirituality, becomes
- 23:37the cold, hard, twisted facts of film noir. And
- 23:44what is Norma Desmond, if not a vampire, in a
- 23:48disenchanted world? If magic doesn't exist, that
- 23:52doesn't mean monsters are gone. It's frankly
- 23:56more horrifying to know that people, plain old
- 23:59flesh -and -blood people, could be gothic creatures,
- 24:03that the hidden sins of the past don't need to
- 24:06be actual ghosts, just the ghost of a tennis
- 24:10court. So perhaps Sunset Boulevard is a film
- 24:16noir, just a gothic film noir. A horror movie
- 24:22where feeding the delusions of a forgotten woman
- 24:25must lead to the inevitable destruction of human
- 24:29life. And as Norma descends the stairs in this
- 24:33film's final iconic shot, reciting its most iconic
- 24:36line, I'm ready for my close -up, Mr. DeMille.
- 24:40We watch the world of reality fade into her delusion,
- 24:45and we are caught here, like Joe. trapped in
- 24:49Norma's bizarre gaze. And if you, like me, are
- 24:56drawn to the sublime, to the gothic, but find
- 25:01yourself unable to partake in most horror, why
- 25:05don't you mark this spooky season by watching
- 25:08a classic in a new light, or perhaps a new darkness?
- 25:18Thanks for coming.