Latest / Forgotten Hollywood / Episode 239-"With Love, Mommie Dearest: The Making of An Unintentional Camp Classic."
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to You've Forgotten Hollywood with doug Hess here on Jiljmedia. Hello everyone,
- 0:22and welcome to Forgotten the Hollywood, your podcasts and memories of Yesterdyear.
- 0:25My name is doug Hess and if you're tuning and Forgotten Hollywood for the first
- 0:28time, what I do on this podcast is take you on a journey back
- 0:32in time and share with you pieces of Hollywood that you may or may not
- 0:35know about. And today we have a very special guest with us today,
- 0:40a Ashley Hoff and he is going to be here talking about his latest book,
- 0:45Go Behind with Love Mommy Dares, the making of an unintentional camp classic.
- 0:53Easy for me to get the tile right, A little bit of a
- 0:58tongue twister. That's fine, that happens to the best of us. Right.
- 1:02Well, welcome to Forgotten Hollywood and thank you for spending a few minutes
- 1:06with us today. Thank you well, thank you for having me. Gug
- 1:11I'm pleased to be here. As I just said, I had just learned
- 1:17about from one of your earlier podcasts about a new making of the Blues Brothers
- 1:23book and I'm definitely checking that out. So I appreciate the fact that you
- 1:27are promoting authors, promoting books and stimulating sales, and let's face it,
- 1:34helping to keep America literate absolutely and at the same time trying to keep some
- 1:40of these movies, films, actors, actresses, directors, composers, etc.
- 1:47Still relevant and still talked about after all these years. And one in
- 1:51particular, while I'm going to argue that Joan Crawford is not somebody that has
- 1:56forgotten per se, you do have a new book out about basically her wife
- 2:04with well Mommy Dearest, and I just wanted to least let you have the
- 2:07opportunity to start off by talking a little bit about what the book is about,
- 2:13well, the movie version, well, I guess I should start earlier.
- 2:20Joan Crawford, for those who are not really fully aware, was one
- 2:23of the great stars of the Golden Age of Hollywood. Started her career in
- 2:29the twenties, but really reached her peak throughout the thirties, the forties,
- 2:31the fifties onward, until she passed in nineteen seventy seven. The following year,
- 2:38nineteen seventy eight, her daughter eldest daughter, Christina Crawford, released a
- 2:45memoir called Mommy Dearest, which chronicled the somewhat tenuous relationship that the mother and
- 2:53daughter had, and even though it was not a full length biography on Joan,
- 2:59it's certainly, you know, touched upon both her and her career and
- 3:04in a lot of people's eyes, tarnished her image. When the book was
- 3:07published, actually just before produced, Frank Heiblonz purchased the film rights to Mommy
- 3:15DearS in order to do a big screen adaptation, which came out a few
- 3:19years later in nineteen eighty one, starring Fade Down in a Way, and
- 3:25the movie almost immediately became a while a critical failure, was a huge commercial
- 3:32hit, but not necessarily for all the reasons anyone intended. The producers and
- 3:39director had wanted to put together a lavish, big blockbuster studio biopic type of
- 3:47thing. It was a beautifully produced film. It had a top flight set
- 3:53and costume design, had an a list star, a list director studio backing,
- 4:00It had an a list budget, heavily promoted before its release by the
- 4:05studio, and when it was released, instead of a serious drama, it
- 4:11was seen as melodrama, mellow drama, and frankly an unintentional comedy, and
- 4:19there were people who were laughing saying that Fade Down her Way gave a very
- 4:24over the top scenery chewing performance, that she was overacting, and people were
- 4:30laughing in all the serious parts, and the movie has become kind of a
- 4:34notorious bomb. It was again, never a commercial failure, which is interesting.
- 4:44It was always hit from the very beginning, but it was never taken
- 4:46seriously as a serious movie. And so my book is a sympathetic look at
- 4:54why and how that happened. Basically, how to do movie that had all
- 4:57these advantages going for it and dealing with the very serious topic of child abuse
- 5:02and how to survive it? How did this turn into a laugh riot that
- 5:08people have been calling a camp classic And I guess four decades on it's graduated
- 5:14to bona fide classic status. It's also a movie that Faye Dunaway, highly
- 5:20accomplished, brilliantly talented actress, really does not like talking about. And I
- 5:29talk about why that is. She is a woman who has under her belt
- 5:34three of the twentieth centuries top one hundred films according to the Academy, the
- 5:43AFI, the BFI and pretty much every film critic who looks at films seriously,
- 5:50If you're lucky you get one, and she had her breakout role in
- 5:56nineteen sixty seven with Bonnie and Clyde, reached possibly her best performance and best
- 6:02film with Rowan Polanski's Chinatown in nineteen seventy four, and then two years later
- 6:09won the Oscar for Best Actors with Network, which is a movie that is
- 6:14more relevant today than it was even when it came out. And a lot
- 6:19of people say Mommy Dearest, which came out in nineteen eighty one, kind
- 6:24of finished her career. It didn't, but it nonetheless, despite her earlier
- 6:29successes and even her later ones, has kind of hung like an albatross around
- 6:33her neck as far as her reputation is concerned. So I talk about all
- 6:39that stuff in the book absolutely, you know. I remember my mother when
- 6:44the movie came out back in eighty one. I remember she wanted to go
- 6:47see it, and I think there was probably a lot of why it was
- 6:50a success with the box office, if you will, is because I think
- 6:55a lot of people are intrigued by an icon like Joan Crawford and wanted to
- 7:00get a sneak peek, if you will, into their lives and what it
- 7:04was like to be her, Oh yeah, oh yeah. Joan Crawford was
- 7:12fresh in everyone's mind. Everybody who had grown up launching her movies was still
- 7:17you know, alive and active and very interested in her at that point.
- 7:23I think the film would be viewed as less controversial had it been made today.
- 7:29You know, forty years later, people remember Crawford, but they are
- 7:32not quite so attached to her. You know. It's kind of like if
- 7:38we were to do a biopic today of oh, I don't know who's current
- 7:42Emma Stone, you know, Meryl Street, and learned that, you know,
- 7:49despite their reputations for being you know, not just accomplished actresses, but
- 7:57shall we say, benevolent figures or very nice people, we learned that maybe
- 8:01behind closed doors they were not always and that would cause quite the furor today.
- 8:05That's what happened in nineteen eighty one, when Mommy Darris was released.
- 8:11Faye Dunaway had initially thought she or I guess she tried to defend Crawford in
- 8:22starring in this movie. She felt that she might be able to soften the
- 8:26portrait of Joan that Christina's memoir had kind of painted of her. But ironically
- 8:33enough, I think Faye was fighting herself throughout the filming, and she really
- 8:39the character that she portrayed on screen was not a soft, a more impressionistic
- 8:46portrait of Joan Crawford. It was a very intense portrait of a woman who
- 8:54had a very difficult personal life, had a very difficult professional life, who
- 8:58was a golden age actress who was aging and therefore more tense without her career,
- 9:07and unfortunately, according to the screenplay and according to Christina's memoir, kind
- 9:13of took those frustrations out on her family and you know, so, Mommy
- 9:20dearest, both when the book was initially published as well as when the film
- 9:24itself was released, really kind of brought the topics of child abuse and how
- 9:30to survive it into the mainstream conversation. And that's a very good point.
- 9:37It was not really widely discussed in the seventies. There was really no distinction
- 9:41made between simply disciplining your child and then possibly bullying your child because you've had
- 9:48a lousy day at work. And that's kind of been addressed over the ensuing
- 9:56for decades. I think there are more laws put in place because of this
- 10:01movie and Christina's book and all that they kind of revealed about the American way
- 10:07of life and our work ethic and how sometimes work overshadows for personal life.
- 10:15But nonetheless, you know, so I recognized all the serious issues that the
- 10:20movie brought up, but at the same time it is considered a laugh riot,
- 10:26and I don't ignore that. I talk about particular scenes in the film,
- 10:30the memorable lines, the memorable moments that made audiences expecting a serious movie
- 10:37to be sitting there in the movie theater laughing, and because that was an
- 10:43unexpected response. Faye Dunaway, for one, was completely traumatized by the oh
- 10:48a whole end effort. She is a method trained actress. She's a very
- 10:54serious woman who takes her craft very seriously, and she did not see the
- 11:01film in the earlier press screenings or the earlier you know, studio screenings.
- 11:09She saw it with the general public after it was released. She went to
- 11:13Drums Chinese theater, sat in the back theater and was completely shell shocked by
- 11:18audiences laughing at the most inopportune moments. And she was completely devastated by it,
- 11:24which when you figure that she put several years or several months of her
- 11:30life into this role that she thought would actually be kind of a game changer
- 11:35for her. She had not had a hit for a couple of years.
- 11:41She needed a hit. She had just turned forward to at the top of
- 11:43filming, and that's a precarious position for any actress to be in. She
- 11:50wanted to do something that would be a tribute to Joan Crawford rather than something
- 11:54tarnishing her image or worse yet, making fun of her. And unfortunately,
- 12:01the whole thing she felt, blew up in her face. And it is
- 12:05one reason that even today she still feels very hurt by the movie director Frank
- 12:13Perry, who made a name for himself in independent movies and was very highly
- 12:18accomplished film film director in the sixties and early seventies. He by the time
- 12:24Mommy Dearest came on the scene, he because he had started in theater,
- 12:31he saw this story in very heightened theatrical terms. He kept directing Faye during
- 12:39the filming, be bigger, be bolder. He wanted her to be Medea,
- 12:45and he kept whispering to her, your media be Medea. And so
- 12:48she was. And so when the reviews came out and everybody was saying,
- 12:52Aidan Nuay is overacting and she's chewing the scenery and what a laugh riot,
- 12:56over the top performance she's giving. She took it personally because she was being
- 13:01blamed for the movie and what we're seen as its laws, and that's the
- 13:07way she was directed. She was simply doing her job and doing it really
- 13:11quite well. As everybody who whether they view the film seriously, whether it's
- 13:18a drag queen emulating her for an over the top stage parody performance. I
- 13:24mean, everybody agrees Fadeunaway gave a killer performance. She All you have to
- 13:33do is watch somebody else recite that dialogue and try to be even remotely convincing,
- 13:39and you will recognize the fact that Fade Dunaway is like a hurricane,
- 13:43a whirlwind. She's a force of nature, and nobody else could have given
- 13:46such a powerful performance that four decades on people still talk about. I wish
- 13:54that she could embrace the film and just recognize the film is what it is
- 13:58and it seemed by fans the way it's seen, because that's really not knocking
- 14:05her. I know that a lot of the initial criticisms were knocking her,
- 14:09but I don't think after four decades people are really knocking her. They actually
- 14:16worship and revere the movie and her performance in it. Absolutely. Now,
- 14:22with any book that gets made into a movie, Hollywood always takes its uh,
- 14:31what's what I'm looking for licensed to try to change things, you know
- 14:35in the movie. Any of that with this movie as well? Oh yes,
- 14:43Well and Christine, because so many people were still fans of Joan Crawford
- 14:50and found it horrific to believe, you know, that their Golden Age goddess
- 14:54was anything less than perfect. Christina over the years has been accused of mak
- 15:00stories in her book, and while I cannot speak to the veracity of you
- 15:07know, all the details of her memoir, the filmmakers definitely took dramatic license
- 15:13with the movie. There are a lot of inaccuracies in it, which happens
- 15:16with any quote. Iopic scenes are created for dramatic purpose in order to illustrate
- 15:26certain points that you know, you can explain on three pages of a book,
- 15:31but you have to be able to explain in two single lines of dialogue
- 15:37on screen. So there are a lot of There are a lot of inaccuracies,
- 15:43a lot of mistakes with the movie. Gets what it is you just
- 15:48simply recognize the fact that if you don't like the movie, go back to
- 15:54the original book. You'll get your clarity there. Things will be more deeply
- 15:58explained and for starters. In the movie, Fay as Joan has two children.
- 16:07In real life she had four. The two extra daughters were cut both
- 16:11for legal reasons because they disapproved of the whole endeavor, and also just because
- 16:18you know, the movie runs two hours nine minutes. You know, probably
- 16:22the other two girls would have taken up an additional fifteen minutes. So one
- 16:27of the problems with the movie is that the rough cut ended up being a
- 16:32three plus hour movie that had to then be cut down to appropriate feature running
- 16:40time length. So entire scenes and sequences were cut out of the finished edit
- 16:48of the movie, and that's why we see a lot of scenes like John
- 16:51Crawford winning the oscar for Mildred Pearce in one scene and then in the next
- 16:56scene going off on her daughter screaming because you know, there's a wire hanger
- 17:03in her closet instead of you know, the very you know, satin lined
- 17:10hangers that would otherwise keep her pretty frocks neat. So you know, it's
- 17:15a very jarring movie to watch. That's one of the reasons. The audiences
- 17:19responded to it as an over the top of comedy because you're being hit over
- 17:23the head every now and then assaulted the way young Christina in the film is,
- 17:30and a lot of actors and actresses maybe method actors, but audiences are
- 17:37not necessarily method audience members. They don't need to live everything that's being you
- 17:44know, held up on the screen. Absolutely, you made great a good
- 17:49point that back in you know, nineteen eighty eighty one, eighty two,
- 17:52when the film is being made and released, you know, if it was
- 17:56over two hours, people were probably shaking their head. You fast forward forty
- 18:02years later to today, and it seems like every movie's over three hours.
- 18:06And I'm exaggerating a little bit, But you know, it kind of goes
- 18:11back to your earlier point that maybe it was too fresh after Joan Crawford's death
- 18:15when the movie was made. You fast forward forty years, a lot of
- 18:18things could have changed and maybe would have been more accepted, and one of
- 18:22them could have been the link of the film. Yes, well, I
- 18:26had actually when I interviewed Tracy Hongner, who was one of the screenwriters,
- 18:33when I interviewed a couple other people, I asked them if they thought that
- 18:38maybe the movie being done as a made for television mini series would have been
- 18:42better because you would have had a couple of days to tell this really detailed,
- 18:48lugubrious story. And you know, basically, I was reminded that at
- 18:53that time, in nineteen eighty one, the made for television movie format was
- 18:59done very cheaply on a very tight budget. They had very tight deadlines.
- 19:03Frankie Blonde, who produced Mommy Dearest, was known for his very lavish movies.
- 19:11He had very handsome budgets to work with and as a result, had
- 19:17the time schedules to put the effort and the quality into the result. You
- 19:23know, today television, you know, there are TV shows that have multi
- 19:29million dollar budgets, but that was not the case in nineteen eighty one,
- 19:33so that would not have been able to be done back at that time.
- 19:41You know, it's kind of sad the way the movie turned out. It
- 19:45could have been. Christina Crawford herself felt a really groundbreaking movie that really kind
- 19:52of had a serious examination of this mother daughter relationship. You know, that's
- 20:00one reason she personally dislikes the film, but even she has recognized that it
- 20:06did its popularity at least did help bring the topic of child abuse into the
- 20:11mainstream. So it's the one major thing in her eyes that had come from
- 20:18the movie's release. But she's nonetheless not particularly fond of it. Neither is
- 20:22Fae. So I know we're getting close on time, but I do want
- 20:26to ask you one last question. The research during the writing of this book
- 20:32anything surprise you. Well, I was very lucky. First of all,
- 20:37I was able to track down people actors and actresses who had smaller roles,
- 20:42a lot of uncredited performers, as well as uncredited crew members, most of
- 20:48whom had never spoken about the movie publicly before, so I got a lot
- 20:52of great stories and a lot of corroboration about those stories. In this what
- 21:00I basically had discovered. I initially thought that I was going to be writing
- 21:03the making of a classic movie, even it was a camp classic, just
- 21:07simply the making of a movie. And what I realized was that Mommy Dearest
- 21:12in nineteen eighty one, when it was released, marks the end of two
- 21:18eras of Hollywood filmmaking. It was the end of the golden age of Hollywood,
- 21:22because of course this was the iconoclastic you know, retelling of a golden
- 21:29age star's life. But also it was the end of the American new wave
- 21:33of filmmaking that Faye Anaway had basically been poster child for, starting with Bonnie
- 21:37and Clyde and reaching its heights arguably with Chinatown and Network, and then really
- 21:45ending with Mommy Dearest, Because that same summer nineteen eighty one is when Spielberg's
- 21:52Raiders the Lost Arc was released. The following year Et was released, and
- 21:56the rest of the eighties was really dominating. Did either buy comedies or by
- 22:03the special effects Leyden cineplex blockbusters that we've got today, And that's not necessarily
- 22:08a bad thing, but it's just a very different type of film than,
- 22:12for instance, they Dunaway had been known for. And so I realized that
- 22:19what I was writing about was also the end of two eras of Hollywood filmmaking.
- 22:29Most of the filmmakers that came out in the eighties, like Spielberg,
- 22:33were young, and they were going in their own direction, and a lot
- 22:37of the old guard directors, old guard producers were either dying off or retiring
- 22:42at that point. So it was a changing of the guard, yeah,
- 22:48a shift that was definitely taking place at that time. Well, thank you,
- 22:56thank you again for coming on and spending some time with us today.
- 22:59Please please go out and get a copy of the book With Love Mommy Garris
- 23:03The Making of an Unintentional camp Classic by A. Ashley Hoff. Absolutely,
- 23:07I got my copy, actually has got his out there as well. Please
- 23:11go out and get a copy of this book. You're not going to be
- 23:14disappointed. I think you're going to enjoy it. If you enjoyed this interview,
- 23:18you're definitely going to enjoy the book. So please go out and get
- 23:21a copy. And I wouldn't be doing my job if I didn't say that.
- 23:26Your publisher at Chicago Review Press, I want to thank them for sending
- 23:30us a copy of the book as well, so we'll give a shout out
- 23:33to your publisher as well. Thank you, thank you. I appreciate it.
- 23:37Doug and I always tell people, if you're interested in buying books mine
- 23:44or anybody else's. While the obvious online platforms are always readily available, feel
- 23:51free to if you're able to support your local indie bookstores by going in there.
- 23:56Supporting mom and pop establishments because they really are the backbone of the publishing
- 24:00industry and keep America literate. Please. Oh, I couldn't agree with you
- 24:07more And I love going to bookstores, especially the smaller ones that they seem
- 24:15to be more intimate the staff is. I won't say the big corporations aren't
- 24:21as friendly because that's not true. They've been very friendly to me in the
- 24:25years. But you just get that good customer service at some of these independent
- 24:27bookstores. I couldn't agree with you more. So please just get a copy.
- 24:33If you can, go to your like actually said, go to your
- 24:36independent bookstore, but if not, there's other places that you can pick this
- 24:41book up as well. Again, thank you so much for coming on and
- 24:44spend some time with us today. Thank you and thank you for listening to
- 24:48this episode Forgotten in Hollywood. Just search for dek Hester forgott in Hollywood.
- 24:52You can also find me on Twitter, Instagram at hestog fourteen. If you
- 24:55listen to this podcast on iTunes and another podcast service, please subscribe to rate
- 24:59and read this episode. Tune in next week for the latest episode of Forgotten
- 25:03Hollywood. Thank you for listening and we will see you then.