Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Protean Electric's In-Wheel Motors: Efficiency and Value
Transcript
- 0:09OK, close your eyes for justice a second.
- 0:11Imagine the car of tomorrow. Now what if the engine, you know
- 0:17the heart of the car, wasn't under the hood, right?
- 0:20What if it wasn't anywhere traditional, but actually inside
- 0:24the wheel itself? Yeah, it's pretty radical.
- 0:26Thoughts. Exactly what kind of fundamental
- 0:28shift could that mean for how cars are designed, how they
- 0:32drive, how they even feel? It changes almost everything.
- 0:35Well, today, that's exactly what we're diving deep into this
- 0:38groundbreaking world of in wheel motors and we're really going to
- 0:42focus on some truly transformative innovation from
- 0:46Protein Electric, specifically their latest development, the
- 0:49Gen. 5. And it's such an exciting area
- 0:52because, look, this isn't just some sci-fi concept stuck in a
- 0:55lab somewhere. Right, not just theory.
- 0:57No, not at all. In wheel motor technology is
- 0:59well, it's developing really fast.
- 1:02It's a solution that promises some really significant
- 1:04advantages. For who specifically?
- 1:06Well, obviously for the manufacturers building the cars,
- 1:08but also importantly for you, the person who might be driving
- 1:12one soon, it's about completely rethinking how you build a
- 1:16vehicle right from the basic architecture.
- 1:18So our mission for this deep dive today is basically to give
- 1:21you a shortcut, a way to get really well informed about this
- 1:25frankly pretty exciting automotive frontier.
- 1:28We'll unpack what in wheel Motors or IWMS actually are.
- 1:32We'll dig into their main technical advantages, and then
- 1:35we'll look at how Chrodian Electric is taking this really
- 1:38clever idea and turning it into a fully industrialized, ready to
- 1:42go product with their Gen. 5. And crucially, how it all
- 1:46connects back. Exactly what does this massive
- 1:49shift mean for the kinds of cars you might be driving, owning,
- 1:52maybe even experiencing in the next few years?
- 1:54OK, let's do. It.
- 1:55So let's start right at the beginning.
- 1:56What exactly is an in wheel motor, an IWM, right?
- 2:01Because when you think of a normal car, you picture like a
- 2:04central engine, right? And then all the complicated
- 2:06bits, Dr. shafts, differentials, sending power to the wheels.
- 2:10The traditional drive strain, Yeah, a lot of components.
- 2:13But with in IWM that whole setup is just gone.
- 2:16Poof. Vanished.
- 2:18Instead, you have an electric motor built right into the hub
- 2:20of the wheel. Integrated directly.
- 2:22Think about that. Each wheel basically becomes its
- 2:26own independent power source, its own little powertrain unit.
- 2:30It's a totally different way to think about making a car move.
- 2:33And here's where it gets really interesting.
- 2:35Like straight away Protein Electrics PD 18 Gen. 5 motor.
- 2:40It's not just neat packaging, it delivers some seriously
- 2:44impressive performance figures. OK, like what?
- 2:47We're talking about peak torque, the twisting force of 1500
- 2:50Newton meters. Industry leading stuff. 1500
- 2:54from inside a Weir. All achieved within an 18 inch
- 2:57wheel ram Now to give you a sense of that that kind of power
- 3:01from such a tiny space, it's truly remarkable more.
- 3:04Than you'd expect I guess. A way more there's actually more
- 3:07force than you'd get from some, you know, big traditional V12 by
- 3:10turbo engines and look, if you find these kinds of enriching
- 3:14details as genuinely exciting as I do well, you are definitely in
- 3:19for a treat today. OK, noted.
- 3:22So this compact motor packs a bigger punch than some massive V
- 3:25twelves, but what does all that power actually do for the car
- 3:29besides just making it go fast? Right, it's not just about zero
- 3:32to 60 times. Prodian talks about 3 main
- 3:35technical advantages with these IWMS. What are they?
- 3:39Yeah, they focus on three key areas.
- 3:41First, big gains and overall efficiency.
- 3:44Second, much smarter use of space inside the vehicle.
- 3:47And 3rd, a really enhanced driving experience.
- 3:51And these aren't just, you know, bullet points on a spec sheet.
- 3:53No, they have real consequences. They translate into a much
- 3:57bigger value proposition for the car makers, let's them build
- 4:00better, more innovative cars. And at the end of the day, that
- 4:02means a better, more capable, maybe even more affordable car
- 4:06for you, the customer. OK, let's really dig into those
- 4:09advantages then, because this is where it gets really interesting
- 4:12for everyday use. Let's start with space
- 4:15efficiency. Good place to start.
- 4:17When you stick the motor right in the wheel, what's the most
- 4:20obvious benefit for car designers?
- 4:23Is it just about cramming things in, or does it change how they
- 4:25approach the whole interior layout?
- 4:27Oh. It's a total paradigm shift for
- 4:29them. Instantly you delete what
- 4:31engineers call the drivetrain tunnel that.
- 4:33Hump in the middle of the car. Exactly.
- 4:34That bulky spine running down the car, usually housing the
- 4:38transmission, the Dr. shafts, all that mechanical stuff.
- 4:42Getting rid of it isn't just about removing parts.
- 4:44It fundamentally frees vehicle design from being dictated by
- 4:48that big central mechanical lump.
- 4:50OK, So what does that mean for, say, your next car if that
- 4:53tunnel's gone? Well, it frees up a massive
- 4:56amount of space. I mean, really try to visualize
- 4:59this. The outside size of the car, the
- 5:01footprint stays the same, right? But inside you suddenly have a
- 5:05way more usable area for people, for luggage, whatever.
- 5:08So you. Could have what?
- 5:09A completely flat floor. A completely flat floor, Yeah.
- 5:12Imagine how much more leg room that gives rear passengers.
- 5:16Or maybe you use that space for a huge cargo area.
- 5:18It makes the car way more versatile.
- 5:19The design possibilities must just explode like totally new
- 5:23cabin layouts become possible. Absolutely.
- 5:26Designers can really start thinking about making the inside
- 5:28of the car truly centered around the people using it, not around
- 5:33the mechanics. OK, space is 1 big class.
- 5:36How does this link to the second point, the enhanced driving
- 5:39experience? Well, that freedom flows right
- 5:42into it. Because each wheel has its own
- 5:44motor, you get incredibly precise individual control over
- 5:48how much power goes to each specific tire.
- 5:51Right, independent control. Exactly.
- 5:53Which raises the question, you know, how does controlling each
- 5:55wheels traction independently actually improve things like
- 5:58handling or dynamics or even safety?
- 6:01Yeah, how does? It it means you can have
- 6:03extremely nuanced power delivery.
- 6:05Think about cornering. You can use something called
- 6:07torque vectoring, where the car precisely adjust the power to
- 6:10each wheel to maximize grip and help pull you smoothly through
- 6:14the turn. So it actively helps you corner
- 6:16better. Precisely.
- 6:18Or imagine driving on a slippery Rd.
- 6:21Each wheel can instantly adjust its power completely
- 6:24independently to find the best possible traction and keep the
- 6:27car stable. It's way beyond what old school
- 6:30mechanical system can manage. It makes the car feel much more
- 6:33intelligent, much more responsive.
- 6:35OK. So better use of space, much
- 6:37finer control. What's the third big advantage
- 6:40you mentioned? Efficiency.
- 6:41Right efficiency, and this is a really compelling one for
- 6:44automakers, especially with EVs. How does moving the motor into
- 6:48the wheel actually save energy for the whole vehicle?
- 6:52Yeah, how does that work? Well, by putting the motor right
- 6:54at the wheel you eliminate a whole lot of mechanical losses
- 6:58you get in traditional drivetrains.
- 6:59Losses like what? Like friction in the gearbox, in
- 7:03the drive shafts and the differentials, all those
- 7:05spinning parts waste energy just turning each other.
- 7:08Ah OK Less plumbing, less waste. Pretty much protein solution by
- 7:13dramatically simplifying that whole drivetrain leads to a real
- 7:17measurable reduction in how much energy the vehicle uses overall.
- 7:21And for you, the driver that greater efficiency means what
- 7:24longer range? Potentially, yes.
- 7:27Longer range for your EV on a single charge, or if you're
- 7:31thinking about, say, delivery vans or trucks, it means lower
- 7:34running costs for the companies operating those fleets.
- 7:37Which eventually helps everyone, right?
- 7:39Lower energy use, maybe lower maintenance costs too.
- 7:42Exactly, it's just a smarter way to engineer the system leading
- 7:45to real world benefits. OK, so this technology sounds
- 7:48amazing on paper, but you said it's not just theory anymore.
- 7:52Protein Electric is actually building these things now.
- 7:54Oh yeah, absolutely. They are actively
- 7:56industrializing it. They've brought their protein
- 7:58drive generation 5, the Gen. 5PD18, to full production.
- 8:02This isn't a prototype anymore, it's a commercial product you
- 8:04can actually buy and use. Wow, and getting there must have
- 8:07been quite a journey. How do you even test something
- 8:10like this? Well, that's what's really
- 8:11fascinating here, the sheer amount of testing they did.
- 8:14They didn't just test one or two units, they took over 80 of
- 8:18these PD 18 Gen. 5 motors. 80. 80 and put them through 64
- 8:23distinct test programs 64. That sounds intense.
- 8:27It was brutal. Basically a gauntlet designed to
- 8:29simulate every horrible thing a car wheel might encounter over
- 8:33its entire life. Potholes, water, heat, cold,
- 8:36vibration. Everything.
- 8:38Why so much testing? To make absolutely sure it meets
- 8:42all the relevant laws, regulations and crucially, the
- 8:45incredibly strict standards set by the car manufacturers
- 8:48themselves, the OEM's. This product is built on, get
- 8:52this, over 15 years of engineering.
- 8:54Work 15 years. And a combined total of 700
- 8:57person years of development specifically focused on in wheel
- 9:01motors. That's a huge amount of
- 9:03knowledge and effort poured into this.
- 9:04What's tough? Extremely tough.
- 9:06The design itself is robust. It's engineered to meet a target
- 9:09of 15 years, or 300,000 kilometers of durability.
- 9:13300,000 kilometers. Yep, it can handle things like
- 9:15driving through deep water, hitting massive potholes, and
- 9:18dealing with really harsh environmental conditions from
- 9:21scorching heat to freezing cold. OK, but here's something
- 9:23interesting. You mentioned safety validation
- 9:25ISO 26262 iself LD. That sounds serious.
- 9:28It is serious and it's actually an industry first for in wheel
- 9:31motors. It's been validated to ISO 26262
- 9:35as something called A Safety Element out of context
- 9:38addressing ACL D level hazards. OK, translate that for me ACL D.
- 9:43ACL D is the highest level of automotive safety integrity.
- 9:47Think critical systems like airbags or braking systems.
- 9:50It means Prodian has engineered these motors to meet that
- 9:53absolute top tier of safety standards.
- 9:55Like aircraft level safety. Essentially yes.
- 9:58Ensuring the vehicle stays safe and controllable even if
- 10:00something unexpected happens and the safety element out of
- 10:03context part means a motor itself as a component is
- 10:06certified to this standard. So car makers can trust it more
- 10:10easily. Exactly, It makes it much easier
- 10:12for any manufacturer to integrate it into their vehicle
- 10:15safety systems confidently. As Stephen Lambert, Protein CTO,
- 10:19put it in, it's a great quote. He called IWMS A pivotal
- 10:22enabling technology for the next generation of EVs and stressed
- 10:25how vital that robust testing and validation framework is.
- 10:29They definitely seem to have covered the testing bases, but
- 10:32back to that durability number of 15 years, 300,000 kilometers
- 10:37for someone just driving their car day-to-day, What does that
- 10:40actually mean? Is my wheel motor going to
- 10:43suddenly die at 300,001 kilometers?
- 10:46No, definitely not. It's not like a timer runs out.
- 10:48Think of it more as the design for life under typical driving
- 10:51conditions. They've rigorously tested it to
- 10:54make sure it can endure years and years of normal driving,
- 10:57hitting potholes, temperature swings, constant use without
- 11:00failing. It means they validated the
- 11:02motor against severe shocks, vibrations, heat cycles, sand,
- 11:06dust, water, even chemical contaminants to ensure it's
- 11:09reliable and robust over that long period and high mileage.
- 11:13So it's really a statement about its built in long term
- 11:15dependability under realistic conditions, not some hard stop
- 11:19date. Got it.
- 11:20So designed for the long haul. And you said they're actually
- 11:22making these now, Yes. Production kicked off in the
- 11:24third quarter of 2023. They have a state-of-the-art
- 11:27factory in Tianjin, China. And is it like automotive grade?
- 11:31Oh yes, the facility has IETF 16949 certification.
- 11:37That's the global standard for automotive quality management.
- 11:41It's basically a stamp saying their factory produces parts
- 11:44with the same quality and consistency you'd expect from
- 11:46any major car brand. So this really is the start of
- 11:49large scale production. It marks the beginning of large
- 11:52scale industrialization for this tech.
- 11:54Absolutely, and they've designed it smartly too.
- 11:57It's modular. They have 400 Volt versions
- 11:59available now, and they're expecting 800 Volt versions to
- 12:02be ready by the end of 2024, which is important for newer EV
- 12:06architectures. Are we seeing these in actual
- 12:09vehicles yet or is it still mostly for future projects?
- 12:12No, they're already out there working, which is really
- 12:14exciting to see. For example, a company called
- 12:16BBEO is using them in their reborn electric retrofit
- 12:19solution. What's that?
- 12:21They basically take classic vehicles like old Land Rovers
- 12:24and convert them into modern EVs using these protein motors.
- 12:27Cool. Any other examples?
- 12:28Yeah, another one is Conmet. They're using a version for
- 12:31their preset Plus electric hub system.
- 12:33This is for 0 emission refrigerated trailers big
- 12:35trucks. Wow, so from classic cars to
- 12:38heavy duty trucking, that shows some versatility.
- 12:42Definitely. It really highlights how
- 12:44adaptable the technology is. Andrew Whitehead, Prodian CEO,
- 12:48really summed it up well. He calls IWMS a critical
- 12:52component to the future of the electric vehicle industry.
- 12:55Why critical? Because, he says it allows
- 12:57manufacturers to finally adopt in wheel motors at scale and at
- 13:01an affordable price, and crucially, use them to genuinely
- 13:06differentiate their vehicles and what's becoming a very crowded
- 13:09EV market. OK, so we've gone through the
- 13:11tech, the advantages, the fact that it's actually being built
- 13:14and used. Now let's bring it all together.
- 13:16What does this all mean for you listening now and for the wider
- 13:19car industry? What's the big So what here?
- 13:23Well, for the car manufacturers, it's potentially a huge win.
- 13:26This technology let's them achieve similar, maybe even
- 13:29slightly lower, production costs for their vehicles.
- 13:31Lower costs even with this advanced tech.
- 13:34Potentially, yeah, when you factor in removing all the
- 13:35traditional drivetrain parts. But here's the key.
- 13:38They get those costs while offering a much greater value
- 13:41proposition to the customer. Right.
- 13:43All those benefits we talked about space handling,
- 13:45efficiency. Exactly.
- 13:47More interior space, better handling, better safety, higher
- 13:50efficiency, all potentially for the same or even less
- 13:53manufacturing cost. So what does that let them do?
- 13:56Sell more cars, make more profit.
- 13:58Either or both. They can gain market share by
- 14:01offering a clearly superior product or they can improve
- 14:04their profit margins. It's why you're going to see
- 14:06more and more manufacturers looking seriously at large scale
- 14:09adoption as the tech matures and the cost keep coming down.
- 14:13It fundamentally changes the economics of building an EV and.
- 14:16Flip that around, what about for me, the person buying the car?
- 14:21For you, the driver, this directly translates into seeing
- 14:24potentially better quality electric vehicles hitting the
- 14:27market, maybe at more convenient, more accessible
- 14:29prices. Better and potentially cheaper.
- 14:31That's the promise in wheel motors contribute to EVs that
- 14:34are lighter, more agile, offering real economic
- 14:37advantages not just when you buy them but also in daily use
- 14:40because of that better efficiency, that longer range.
- 14:43So it's smarter tech that gets rid of complex heavy stuff.
- 14:47Precisely leading to better efficiency, better durability,
- 14:50and frankly just a more enjoyable driving experience
- 14:53overall. Imagine hopping into a car where
- 14:56the inside just feels way bigger than it should, we're taking a
- 15:00corner feels incredibly smooth and controlled, and where your
- 15:04battery charge just seems to last longer.
- 15:06That's really the tangible promise of in wheel motors
- 15:10becoming mainstream. So wrapping this up, it really
- 15:12feels like in wheel motors, especially with what protein
- 15:14Electric is doing with their Gen. 5, aren't just a small
- 15:17step, they're a significant leap.
- 15:19Oh. Absolutely.
- 15:20It's transformative. Yeah.
- 15:21Moving from a cool concept to actual industrial scale
- 15:24production. Yeah, the potential for vehicle
- 15:26design, performance, efficiency, it's huge.
- 15:31OK, so here's a final thought for you to chew on as we finish.
- 15:33If the drivetrain isn't this big central thing anymore, and each
- 15:37wheel is essentially its own independent unit, what totally
- 15:41new kinds of cars could this enable?
- 15:43Think beyond just extra legroom. Yeah, what weird shapes could
- 15:46cars take? Could we see vehicles that maybe
- 15:49change shape depending on what you need them for, or that can
- 15:52maneuver in ways we haven't even thought of yet?
- 15:56How could this fundamentally change how you drive, how you
- 15:59own a car in the years ahead? What possibilities open up when
- 16:03you free the wheels, so to speak?
- 16:06It's a fascinating question. And look, we absolutely love
- 16:09diving deep into these kinds of topics, uncovering these, well,
- 16:12surprising facts and trying to connect the dots for you.
- 16:15There's always more to learn, always more to discover,
- 16:17definitely. So to make sure you don't miss
- 16:19out on any of our future explorations and you stay ahead
- 16:22of the curve on cool stuff like this, please do be sure to
- 16:25follow our channel. We'll have more insights and
- 16:27yes, more surprising facts coming your way.