Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Navigate Insider Sales Without Tanking the Stock
Transcript
- Lucas: So if you've been following any post ipo stocks this year, you've probably noticed a pattern: a company reports a solid quarter, the stock jumps, and then — a few days later — an insider files to sell a chunk of shares, and suddenly everyone panics. Luna: Right, it feels like the selloff is almost baked in. But not all insider sales are created equal. Lucas: Exactly. And that's what we're digging into today — how post ipo companies navigate that moment when founders, early investors, or executives want to cash out some of their paper wealth without cratering the stock. Luna: Because it's a real tension. You want to reward early believers and give them liquidity, but retail investors see 'insider selling' and immediately think something's broken. Lucas: Right. And in mid-2026, this is especially relevant because a lot of companies that went public in the 2024-2025 wave are now seeing their lockup periods end — or they're approaching their second or third anniversary, when early employees really start to think about diversification. Luna: Plus some stocks are still below their IPO price, so insiders might be itching to lock in gains while they can. Lucas: Let's start with a specific case. Take a recent cloud security company that went public last year — strong revenue growth, but the stock has been volatile. A few weeks ago, one of its co-founders filed a plan to sell about 10% of his stake over the next six months. Luna: And the stock dropped 8% the next day, even though the company said it was a pre-arranged 10b5-1 plan. Lucas: Right. So the plan itself was set up months earlier — it's literally designed to avoid insider trading accusations by automating sales on a preset schedule. But the market still freaked out. Luna: So is the issue that the company didn't communicate it well enough? Or is it just that any insider sale spooks investors, period? Lucas: I think it's both. But some companies have gotten better at managing the narrative. For example, a food delivery platform that IPO'd in 2024 handled it differently. Before their first lockup expiration, they pre-announced that a group of early employees planned to sell a specific number of shares — and they also said the company itself would buy back an equivalent amount in the open market. Luna: That's smart — offsetting the seller with a buyer signal. It basically says 'we're not worried, we'll absorb it'. Lucas: Exactly. And the stock barely budged. So there's a playbook emerging: be transparent about the plan, put guardrails on volume, and sometimes put corporate money behind it. Luna: Are we seeing more companies adopting that playbook? Lucas: More are, but not all. The challenge is that for many post ipo companies, they don't have the cash flow to do a buyback while also funding growth. So they have to choose. Luna: And if you're a founder who holds 30% of the company, even a 5% sale can be millions of dollars. The incentive to sell is huge. Lucas: Absolutely. And let's not pretend these founders don't deserve some liquidity — they've been locked in for years. But the way they execute it matters. Luna: What about using secondary offerings instead of open-market sales? That seems cleaner. Lucas: It can be. A secondary offering where the company itself doesn't issue new shares, but existing shareholders sell a block all at once — that can actually be less disruptive because it's a single event, priced at a discount, and often marketed to institutional investors who are long-term holders. Luna: But then you've got the dilution perception issue — even if it's not dilutive, some retail investors hear 'offering' and think 'more shares coming'. Lucas: Right. So communication is everything. The best practice we've seen is to announce the secondary alongside a strong earnings report or a positive catalyst, so the narrative is 'we're doing well, here's a liquidity event for insiders, but the business is still on track'. Luna: Let's talk about timing more broadly. Are there seasonal patterns? Do insiders tend to sell more after lockup expirations, or after earnings? Lucas: Both. Lockup expirations are the big one — usually 180 days after the IPO. That's when early investors and employees can first sell. But we've also seen a rise in 'staggered lockups' where only a portion of shares unlock at a time, to smooth the impact. Luna: And after earnings, you get a window where insiders can trade without being accused of having material nonpublic information. So there's often a cluster of filings in the weeks after a quarterly report. Lucas: Yeah. And if the stock pops on earnings, that's when you see more sales — because the price is high and the window is open. Luna: But if the stock drops, insiders might hold off, which actually sends a positive signal: 'they're not selling into weakness'. Lucas: That's a great point. And some companies are now explicitly stating in their earnings press releases that no executives plan to sell in the coming quarter. It's a voluntary step, but it builds trust. Luna: Speaking of trust, what about the role of the board? Do boards have a say in when and how insiders sell? Lucas: They can — and increasingly, they do. Some boards have adopted insider trading policies that require pre-clearance for any sale over a certain size, or that limit sales to certain windows beyond the standard blackout periods. Luna: So there's a governance angle here too. Lucas: Absolutely. And it's becoming more important as ESG investors and activist shareholders start scrutinizing insider sales as a governance metric. Luna: Alright, before we wrap, I want to come back to something you mentioned earlier — about the buyback offset. It's interesting because we're seeing a few post ipo companies use buybacks specifically to counter insider selling, almost like a hedging strategy. Lucas: Yeah, and it's not just about volume. It's about psychology. When the company is buying alongside the insider selling, it signals alignment. The insider gets liquidity, the company shows confidence, and the market sees both sides. Luna: It's a delicate dance. But for investors, the takeaway is: not all insider selling is a red flag. You have to look at the context — is it a pre-arranged plan? Is it part of a broader liquidity event? Is the company offsetting it? Lucas: Exactly. And the data backs that up. Studies have shown that when insider sales are part of a 10b5-1 plan, the stock actually tends to perform in line with the market over the next six months. The panic selling is usually overdone. Luna: That's reassuring. But still, as an individual investor, it's hard not to feel a twinge when you see that filing. Lucas: For sure. That's why we do these episodes — to give you the context to make a smarter call. Luna: You know, Lucas, if today's conversation was useful for anyone building or running a business — or just investing in one — honestly, if it was worth a coffee to you, there's a link: buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's the smallest way to keep these conversations ad-free and on the record. Lucas: Yeah, it's totally optional, but it helps us keep the focus on what matters — no sponsors, no fluff. Just the real mechanics of how post ipo markets work. Luna: So back to that cloud security founder — do you think his 8% drop was an overreaction, or was the market right to be wary? Lucas: I think it was an overreaction, but only because the company didn't pair the news with any positive signal. If they'd announced a buyback or a strong guidance raise alongside it, the outcome would have been different. The lesson for companies: if you're going to have insiders sell, control the narrative. Luna: And for investors: look beyond the headline. Lucas: Right. It's easy to see 'insider selling' and hit sell. But the best investors dig into the details — the plan, the size, the context. That's where the real signal is. Luna: Alright, next episode we're going to look at how post ipo companies are handling stock-based compensation and dilution — another hot topic. Lucas: Looking forward to it. Thanks for listening.