Latest / Marketplace Businesses with Fexingo: Two-Sided Networks, Liquidity, and Take Rates / How Marketplaces Use Minimum Commitments to Fix Liquidity
Transcript
- Lucas: There is this moment every marketplace operator hits — you have supply, you have demand, but the two sides never quite sync up in real time. Drivers are online but not taking rides. Freelancers are available but ignoring invites. And the user who showed up ready to transact walks away empty-handed. Luna: That's the liquidity gap, right? The marketplace has the pieces, but they don't click together fast enough. Lucas: Exactly. And the standard playbook is to throw money at it — surge pricing, subsidies, bonuses. But a quieter, more structural fix has been gaining traction among the best marketplaces: minimum commitments. Luna: Minimum commitments — so requiring supply-side participants to agree to a baseline level of activity to stay on the platform? Lucas: Yes. And it sounds counterintuitive because marketplaces pride themselves on flexibility. Uber's whole pitch to drivers used to be 'be your own boss, work whenever you want.' But around 2022, Uber Eats started quietly requiring delivery partners in certain markets to accept at least one order per hour during peak blocks if they wanted to keep scheduling priority. The result? Average delivery time dropped by about four minutes per order in those zones. Luna: Four minutes is huge in food delivery. That's the difference between a warm meal and a refund request. Lucas: Right. And Upwork has been doing something similar on the freelancer side for years. If you want to keep your 'Top Rated' badge — which gets you better visibility and higher project invites — you need to maintain at least a 90 percent job success score, and that means completing a minimum number of contracts per quarter. The policy isn't about punishment; it's about signaling reliability to buyers. Luna: But isn't there a tension here? The more you push supply into commitments, the more you risk alienating the casual participants who make up the long tail. For every Uber Eats driver who likes the structure, there might be three who just want to log in when they feel like it. Lucas: That's the central trade-off. And the best marketplaces handle it by being surgical about which commitments they enforce. Instacart, for example, doesn't require shoppers to take a minimum number of batches overall. But it does require at least five batches per week to maintain 'Shopper Priority Access' — which means you see orders before everyone else. The commitment is tied to a premium feature, not to basic participation. Luna: So it's more of a carrot than a stick. You can still shop casually, but you lose some of the algorithmic advantages. Lucas: Exactly. And the data backs this up. A 2025 study from the Platform Economy Research Lab looked at 47 two-sided marketplaces and found that those with any form of minimum commitment policy — whether it's a minimum number of transactions per week, a minimum acceptance rate, or a minimum completion rate — saw 32 percent lower churn among their supply-side participants over a twelve-month period. The commitments actually improved retention, because the most reliable supply-side participants felt the platform was protecting their time. Luna: That's fascinating. The people who are already committed appreciate that the platform is filtering out the people who waste their time. Lucas: Exactly the mechanism. And the same study found that transaction times were 18 percent faster on average in marketplaces with minimum commitments. Because when supply knows it has to show up consistently, it's more likely to be ready to transact when a demand signal comes in. The marketplace effectively buys liquidity insurance by asking for a small sacrifice of flexibility. Luna: But I can think of examples where this backfired. Remember when DoorDash tried a minimum acceptance rate policy? Drivers in California pushed back hard, and DoorDash eventually walked it back. Lucas: That's a perfect cautionary tale. DoorDash in 2024 experimented with requiring Dashers to accept at least 70 percent of offered orders to keep their 'Top Dasher' status. The problem was that the algorithm was sending them low-paying, high-mileage orders, and the commitment felt exploitative. The policy didn't just reduce flexibility — it reduced earnings. So the backlash was justified. Luna: So the key is that the commitment has to be reasonable and aligned with what supply actually wants. Otherwise you're just driving away your best participants. Lucas: Right. And the marketplaces that do this well treat minimum commitments as a two-way street. They don't just demand activity — they also guarantee something in return. For instance, when a freelancer commits to a minimum number of hours on a platform like Toptal, Toptal guarantees a minimum number of project introductions per month. There's reciprocity. Luna: So it's more of a pact than a rule. You give us reliability, we give you opportunity. Lucas: Exactly. And this is where the concept of 'liquidity insurance' really comes into focus. If you're a marketplace operator and you're struggling with sporadic supply — people logging in but not accepting work — a minimum commitment can act as a circuit breaker. It forces a baseline of activity that makes the platform more predictable for demand-side users, which in turn increases their willingness to return. Luna: Do you have a favorite example of a marketplace that nailed the implementation? Lucas: I think Rover, the pet-sitting platform, does it well without calling it a minimum commitment. They have a 'response rate' metric — sitters who respond to at least 90 percent of booking inquiries within 24 hours get a visibility boost in search results. It's not mandatory, but the algorithmic incentive is so strong that most sitters opt in. The platform effectively achieves near-universal minimum commitment without a formal policy. Luna: So it's a minimum commitment by design, not by decree. That's clever. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the takeaway for anyone building a marketplace today: don't think of minimum commitments as a blunt instrument. Think of them as a design lever that shapes the behavior you want, while still preserving the flexibility that makes two-sided networks attractive in the first place. The goal isn't to control supply — it's to make demand confident. Luna: And if these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, listener support is what keeps this show ad-free. You can buy us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It genuinely helps us keep these episodes coming. Lucas: Appreciate that. So back to the design lever idea — what's interesting is that minimum commitments scale differently depending on the type of marketplace. In asset-light marketplaces like freelancing or gig work, the commitment is about time and effort. In asset-heavy marketplaces like vacation rentals or car sharing, the commitment is about inventory availability. Luna: Right, because if you're Turo and you have a host who only lists their car for two weekends a month, that's unpredictable for renters. You might want to ask for a minimum number of available days per month. Lucas: Turo actually does that. Hosts who keep their car available for at least 20 days per month get a 'All-Star Host' badge, which increases their booking rate by about 40 percent according to Turo's own data. And the platform benefits because more available inventory means higher conversion rates for renters. Luna: It's almost like the marketplace is creating a reliability score that both sides can see and trust. The commitment becomes a signal. Lucas: Exactly. And that signal is more powerful than any review system because it's forward-looking. A review tells you what happened in the past. A minimum commitment tells you what will happen in the future — that this supplier will be there when you need them. Luna: So for a marketplace operator listening right now, what's the first step? Should they just pick a number and start enforcing it? Lucas: No, absolutely not. The first step is to segment your supply base. Identify the top twenty percent of suppliers who already generate eighty percent of the transactions. Those are the ones who are most likely to embrace a commitment because they're already showing up. Then design a commitment that formalizes what they're already doing, and tie it to a benefit they actually value — better placement, more leads, faster payments. Luna: And leave the long tail alone. Let them stay casual, because they might become committed later. Lucas: Right. And then you measure. The metric to watch is not just transaction volume, but 'time-to-first-action' — how long does it take from a demand signal to a supply acceptance? If that number drops after you introduce a commitment, you know you've improved liquidity. If it stays flat, you've just annoyed people. Luna: What about the risk of supply shrinking because you've driven away the less committed? Is there a tipping point? Lucas: There is. And the research suggests that the optimal minimum commitment varies by marketplace maturity. Early stage marketplaces should avoid minimum commitments entirely — they need every bit of supply they can get. But once a marketplace reaches critical mass — say, a supply to demand ratio where there are at least three suppliers per demand signal — that's the sweet spot to introduce a lightweight commitment. The study I mentioned found that marketplaces that waited until they had a 3-to-1 ratio saw the best retention outcomes. Luna: So timing is everything. Introduce it too early and you choke growth. Introduce it too late and the liquidity problem might have already driven away your demand side. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the art of it. Minimum commitments are a tool for marketplaces that have demand but need to make supply more reliable. If you don't have demand yet, the commitment is meaningless — supply won't agree to show up for an empty room. Luna: It's like a guarantee that the party will have enough hosts to keep the guests happy. Lucas: That's a great way to put it. And that's really what liquidity is — not just having both sides present, but having them present at the same time, ready to transact. Minimum commitments are one of the few tools that directly addresses that timing mismatch. Luna: So next time I see a marketplace that feels fast and reliable, I'll wonder what commitments they've quietly put in place behind the scenes. Lucas: And nine times out of ten, there's something there. It might be a formal policy, or it might be an algorithmic nudge — but the best marketplaces are always engineering reliability under the hood.