Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De'ah 292:1-3. Shiluach HaKen: Introduction; When the Mitzvah Applies, Kosher Bird, Location. By Rav David Genish

Transcript

Yoreh De'ah 292:1-3. Shiluach HaKen: Introduction; When the Mitzvah Applies, Kosher Bird, Location. By Rav David Genish · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:00
  OK, we're grace to hear from David Ganesh, the Rav of Mal
• 0:05
  Malaise and Arush Koval and finish Shmuel and OK.
• 0:12
  Miller's very, very good at. Figuring out when to put which
• 0:16
  subjects. When, because it works out very
• 0:18
  nice that we're doing, Simon. Race saadi bet, which is the
• 0:21
  mitzvah of shalat, the shalat, The famous myths of shaluk
• 0:24
  again, which we have especially here in ershala.
• 0:27
  Quite very often. And partials quit, they'd say.
• 0:29
  Now you have a lot what to say at your Shabba's table.
• 0:31
  It's our partial right now. Which discusses this mitzvah of.
• 0:34
  Shalat the shalaf minto Shalu again, like I said, over here in
• 0:37
  ershala, I get the shadows all the time.
• 0:39
  It comes up. Extremely and especially.
• 0:41
  During this time period. So it's very important to know a
• 0:43
  number of. The.
• 0:45
  It's a very small Simon, which means that we're not allowed.
• 0:48
  To spend too much time. Here to bring out.
• 0:51
  As the best I can the tamxis the.
• 0:53
  Main ideas that come up we know the pussy says like this is
• 0:56
  introduction. Yeah, Kia Cara can't, can't
• 0:58
  seaport la faneca videres, the whole eights O al ahrez
• 1:01
  efrochrim of 18. We're familiar.
• 1:08
  That there's an issue to take the mother while she's.
• 1:10
  Sitting on top of the. Eggs while she's in.
• 1:12
  On top of the egg, so it says. Which means there's a.
• 1:15
  Lot here we're talking about. One of the light.
• 1:17
  That said, and it also. Says, which is an assay.
• 1:23
  So here we have two out of the 613 mitzvahs come out of this.
• 1:27
  Mitzvah of. Shiluwa hakan and very important
• 1:29
  mitzvah le Mani tablok the. Arachta Yamim.
• 1:31
  Now most. Mitzvahs we know don't tell us
• 1:34
  the reason behind the mitzvah. You have to usually open.
• 1:36
  Up a Hiner or Mormon? Try to figure out reasons.
• 1:39
  Behind the Mitzus we. All know the real reasons behind
• 1:42
  the mitzvah. We can't know.
• 1:43
  Nobody really knows. Them, Ashlomo Malek told us.
• 1:45
  But the Karan over here is one of the only mitzvahs.
• 1:48
  Obviously with keyboard of M that tells us.
• 1:50
  The man Yita bloc that wraps the yumming that there's a special
• 1:53
  Sagula to give you a Rikus yumming.
• 1:55
  The main reason why people enjoy doing Shilu Hakka, we go for
• 1:58
  doing. Mitzvahs, we'll speak it out.
• 2:00
  Soon also, but mainly for this reason.
• 2:02
  First of all, it promises the puzzle prep the puzzle promise
• 2:05
  you. That Rikus Yumen.
• 2:06
  You know you're in good shape. Now we know the Kumar.
• 2:08
  And Kadusha really tells us Rita sham it.
• 2:09
  Could mean not only long life, which it also could mean that,
• 2:12
  but it could mean long life in the next World.
• 2:14
  Meaning he gives you. An extra you get extra.
• 2:16
  Bonus points upstairs. Also, that's first of all.
• 2:18
  But. The other reason why they.
• 2:20
  Do it is all. Peace out because the thesaurus
• 2:21
  says very strongly that when the mother comes back to the child
• 2:24
  and starts crying about her children that were taken away.
• 2:26
  So that is the. Shrina Kadasha.
• 2:28
  That's crying for us and it's a big schooler for the Gulu.
• 2:31
  That's why many people. Especially on facilitious.
• 2:33
  Circles and Friday circles and others who are always, you know,
• 2:36
  working on these kabbalistic ways of doing the ghoul and
• 2:39
  things like that. They they are very much trying
• 2:43
  to do this Mints. With Shalil, can everyone?
• 2:44
  Tries in all circles, I'm just saying.
• 2:46
  That there's a special idea of the Ghulam OK.
• 2:49
  One other reason which is brought amongst the play scheme
• 2:51
  is in order to have children. People don't have children, they
• 2:54
  look. For this mints of Shalu Hakim
• 2:55
  because. Obviously this has to do with
• 2:57
  the mother crying on her child and wanting her child back.
• 2:59
  Etcetera. So that idea.
• 3:01
  Also is a. Bekush Kabiol, It's a.
• 3:03
  Crying that the mothers begging begging for a child has shown if
• 3:07
  any woman is not. Able to have a.
• 3:08
  Child so many, many times. There's a gula that it works.
• 3:11
  They bring in orchestra even then call Khazanish that 5 of
• 3:15
  Reikim. Who did this mitzvah on one Ken?
• 3:19
  They use this as a Raya that you can use one Ken for many people.
• 3:22
  They did this mitzvah. For on five different of Reiken
• 3:26
  and all. Five of Rachel.
• 3:27
  During that year had. A Ben Zahar that a Ben Zahar
• 3:30
  that's a benzophist. So I meant, but that's the.
• 3:33
  To my, says one of those five of Rachel was.
• 3:35
  Rekhan Kanievsky, one of those five of Rachel was Rekhan guys,
• 3:38
  you see, You already see how old the Seaport is, how old the
• 3:40
  story is. But anyways we see that it has a
• 3:42
  special. Segul and that's why.
• 3:43
  People go after the reason. I have a whole here about the
• 3:46
  different reasons that people bring for this.
• 3:47
  Mitzvah. The Kinnock.
• 3:48
  And the Rash and the Rambam. But we don't have.
• 3:49
  Time for that, obviously. But you should.
• 3:51
  Know that it's one of these mitzvahs which has a lot of
• 3:53
  schoolas. And P I'll P the.
• 3:55
  Zoar and I'll PE different reasons so Asif all of.
• 3:58
  The Shahran already tells us shiluf again.
• 4:00
  Ain't. No noig Ella, the OIF.
• 4:01
  Tahor as we know the. Halakha, is that you?
• 4:04
  Can only do this on a kosher bird.
• 4:05
  It only works on a kosher bird because the idea is you.
• 4:07
  Want kosher eggs because you want.
• 4:09
  To take the eggs in order to eat them.
• 4:10
  So don't start sending away an owl.
• 4:12
  Who is sitting on top of his eggs?
• 4:13
  And he was going to eat you up, so you shouldn't do that.
• 4:15
  Anyways, but be Karan, it's fine.
• 4:17
  The kosher birds are the safe ones, are the ones that usually
• 4:19
  run away, and eagles and Falcons are not interested in you're.
• 4:22
  Doing this anyways, Ella Beef. Tahar, the Afili, my aim,
• 4:26
  traifa. And even if you.
• 4:27
  Find that if you know that the mother is not.
• 4:30
  Kosher 'cause she's a traifa. Meaning she's a kosher bird, but
• 4:33
  it's a traifa. Filu Angel.
• 4:38
  Even if you know that there's only one or one beta, you still
• 4:42
  have to send it. Away.
• 4:43
  Meaning behind it is that classically, you should know.
• 4:45
  In the world of the natural world, I'm sure most of us know
• 4:48
  that you can only every bird always has two eggs.
• 4:52
  Always. When it lays, it lays two eggs.
• 4:54
  1 is male and one is female. Incredible.
• 4:56
  Like a like clockwork, it always happens.
• 4:58
  There's one male and one. Female.
• 4:59
  So you might think that the den. Of shala shala because only when
• 5:01
  you have those two eggs and you want to come and take.
• 5:03
  Them. No, he says.
• 5:04
  Even if it. Happens to have one egg for
• 5:05
  whatever. Reason because someone else
• 5:07
  already snatched one of the. Eggs still the mitzvah is.
• 5:10
  To go ahead and send. Away the mother in order to have
• 5:12
  that in order to have that. Mitzvah.
• 5:16
  OK. As a chick, as a.
• 5:18
  Baby chick. Yeah, right.
• 5:20
  And the age. It means that when it's still.
• 5:22
  Tiny that it's not independent, it's still.
• 5:24
  Going and it's not on its own, it still doesn't have that, but
• 5:26
  as long as it. As long as the.
• 5:27
  Mother's basically sitting on top of it.
• 5:29
  That's when the. That's when the.
• 5:30
  Mitzvah is still there, OK. Fine.
• 5:33
  So that's the first din that tells us the importance of doing
• 5:37
  the mitzvah. It is important to mention
• 5:39
  because they say. This many times in Shiluwaka.
• 5:41
  Ken. With the beer que yosa.
• 5:43
  Brings a sense based on the Arizol.
• 5:44
  Just could I to know? That even though we say.
• 5:47
  Let me say like this, OK, there's a big hakure here, which
• 5:50
  is very important to say, which I know we don't have time to go
• 5:52
  expand on it, but this is this is a very important.
• 5:54
  Idea. OK.
• 5:55
  And. This is 2 parts to this idea.
• 5:58
  First of all, should I go and look?
• 6:00
  For this mitzvah, in other words, I go outside and trying
• 6:03
  to. Find a can going in.
• 6:05
  I think most of us know. That you're not going to usually
• 6:06
  bump into a nest. Anywhere here or form usually.
• 6:09
  It's not something that happens on.
• 6:11
  Should I be? Looking for the mitzvah?
• 6:12
  Searching for it in order to do it.
• 6:14
  So on that the gamar and Khulin on kuflamentes.
• 6:16
  By the way, the end of the gamar and Khulin is where this mitzvah
• 6:19
  comes up, where Sheila again comes up.
• 6:21
  It's the last parrot over there has about four or five.
• 6:23
  Daffim on this subject Ki karik on seaport the gamar.
• 6:26
  Says that where Medaiki Kare on seaport happened by accident, so
• 6:30
  then she'll have to show up. Yahoo yachts are garbage bars.
• 6:33
  You might think that you should walk around looking in the
• 6:35
  mountains of trees trying to. Find one.
• 6:36
  So where I says no. Do you carve it if you bump
• 6:38
  into? It go for it if you don't bump
• 6:40
  into it no. So we see from here you don't
• 6:42
  need it to look after it. However, like I said, the Berka,
• 6:45
  yes. If the orka.
• 6:46
  Shokan and others bring that It's a good mitzvah to try to
• 6:49
  do. You're not obligated to look for
• 6:51
  it, but it's good to do because as we know, the rule is that you
• 6:54
  want to, at least once in your life, try to do every single.
• 6:58
  Mitzvah, we are made. Up OF365248 and ramakh ivarim,
• 7:04
  and they are can they get all the mitzvahs?
• 7:05
  So therefore, we're always interested in trying our best to
• 7:07
  chase after the mischiefs, to try to do what we can.
• 7:09
  In order to make that equal. The result is always this very
• 7:12
  strong. Shyness, which is almost.
• 7:13
  Scary that if you don't do it, then you're going to come back
• 7:16
  as a Guild goal if you miss a mitzvah that you're supposed to
• 7:18
  do. I don't know.
• 7:19
  I'm not going there. Don't.
• 7:20
  Scares me just as much. Scares you, but I'm just saying
• 7:22
  that you. Know that by the spate of.
• 7:24
  Crime they were very much and they said how much that he was
• 7:27
  to go ahead and try to find every myth he went inside a guy
• 7:29
  with a. Donkey outside.
• 7:31
  And he helped him out. In order to pick him up.
• 7:32
  So whatever you see that it's something you try to do, and
• 7:35
  especially the mitzvah of Shiluwah.
• 7:37
  Hakan, which is not. Something that's so common for
• 7:39
  us, it's something that it's. Could die to find if you.
• 7:41
  Have a neighbor. He should call you.
• 7:42
  He should try. Everyone should try.
• 7:43
  Wants to do it. There's even a midriff that
• 7:45
  brings a. Double melted.
• 7:47
  He was living in the mid bar for 26 years.
• 7:48
  Poor guy right? He was thrown out.
• 7:49
  Of his house. So he was living in the desert.
• 7:51
  He did every myth except for Shiluwah.
• 7:53
  Hakan, for whatever reason, says that Sutton didn't.
• 7:55
  Let him do it. Whatever the major says over
• 7:57
  there and it says over there. That's why he wrote. 150
• 8:00
  tailums, can I get Ken? Kufnun, right?
• 8:02
  Can I get Ken in? Order to be in the.
• 8:04
  Fact that he. Wasn't able to.
• 8:05
  Do it. I'm just.
• 8:06
  Showing you. Serious business that it's a
• 8:08
  good thing to do. If you're able to go ahead, go
• 8:11
  ahead and do it. So that's a, that's the first
• 8:13
  part of this thing here. You don't have to look for it,
• 8:16
  but I do want to mention the next part because eventually on.
• 8:19
  TV on the Pistol. Two over here and that.
• 8:21
  Is I'll read it. To you in a second.
• 8:22
  And that is even though you don't have to look for it.
• 8:25
  If you bump into one you pass by, you have a window.
• 8:27
  Sill, that has it. We'll see if a window sill is
• 8:29
  good enough. Or you pass by your tree that
• 8:31
  has it. Or you see.
• 8:33
  Am I obligated now to do it? Is this something I need to go
• 8:36
  ahead and do or is it resusible? If I want to do it, I can do it.
• 8:39
  I can go ahead and. Pass by.
• 8:40
  Who says I'm obligated to go ahead and do it?
• 8:42
  OK, I'm walking. To do bump into a mess.
• 8:45
  I'm not interested in doing. I'm in a rush someone.
• 8:47
  'S waiting for me. I'm.
• 8:48
  Not interested. Or now that I bumped into it, am
• 8:50
  I obligated to do? Well, Marshall, we have a
• 8:52
  mitzvah. Of a Shava saveda returning the
• 8:55
  lost object. Coming soon I assume.
• 8:57
  Right. You have a mitzvah of a shava
• 8:58
  saveda. You don't have to.
• 8:59
  Look for lost objects. That would be a little bit nuts,
• 9:01
  right? But.
• 9:02
  When you find when you have 100% obligation of picking it up,
• 9:05
  you're. Not allowed to pass it by.
• 9:06
  It's an insert to pass by a lost object.
• 9:08
  You're obligated to to pick it up.
• 9:10
  So is it similar to that type of mitzvah and now that?
• 9:13
  I do it. I have a few but I say.
• 9:14
  Chalet for Charlotte to go ahead.
• 9:15
  And do the mitzvah. Or is it similar to the fact
• 9:18
  that I'm hungry so when I bump into every cow I don't?
• 9:20
  Have to go out and. Check it right hopefully.
• 9:22
  Not because I'm not going to do that.
• 9:23
  Right, you don't have to check every animal man too.
• 9:25
  But if I'm hungry, you better check.
• 9:26
  It you have to shut it. Meaning it's a means to get to
• 9:29
  an end. If you want to eat meat, so go.
• 9:30
  Ahead and check the animal. That you have an.
• 9:32
  Obligation to check the animals in order to eat the meat.
• 9:34
  You can't eat it alive, you can't kill it instead of you
• 9:36
  have to do it in this way. And you said there's two types
• 9:38
  of mitzvahs or when you bump. Into it I.
• 9:40
  Have to do it or when you want it.
• 9:43
  So this is the way the turret prescribed in order to do it.
• 9:46
  We're an ello. Am I obligated to Chuva?
• 9:49
  You're really not. Obligated to Chuva.
• 9:50
  Don't tell your rabbi you're. Not obligated.
• 9:52
  But if you want to do Chuva, the turret prescribed how to do it
• 9:55
  open. The round bum, he's going to
• 9:56
  tell you this is the way to do it.
• 9:57
  Karata, Ziva, etcetera. There are ways to do, there are
• 10:01
  ways to do tubas. So how is this mitzvah?
• 10:03
  This is a big equanium and a big market gear in that equanium.
• 10:06
  Which is quoted in the Quebeger and the Pistre Tuba.
• 10:09
  Says Tuba. That's a famous.
• 10:11
  Tuba here Heller did the Carican seaport.
• 10:13
  Muhuyebly, Zaki Club Li shloka. Emits and the pistre tuba.
• 10:18
  You are obligated to go ahead and send them away if you bump
• 10:22
  into him the. Aim rashido leche le darko
• 10:24
  massive British and he brings his.
• 10:26
  Feet said the same. Thing and there are other tubas
• 10:28
  that say the same thing that one is.
• 10:30
  Fully obligated to go ahead and. Do the mitzvahs you have to
• 10:32
  know? If you get in your windowsill
• 10:35
  again, we'll see if you're allowed to do in your
• 10:36
  windowsill. If you get in your.
• 10:38
  Windowsill a thing you are. Obligated, according to the fee,
• 10:41
  to go ahead and do this mitzvah, you have to go ahead.
• 10:43
  And do it majority of the price scheme are not like that.
• 10:46
  The custom cipher Mozamin. And if do you keep?
• 10:49
  In the run, the run is not much more.
• 10:51
  Like that other names. Which is not.
• 10:52
  I'm not going to name drop now, but be car.
• 10:55
  The Mahaga, The Mahalak is usually where Macabo.
• 10:58
  That's we are not fully obligated.
• 11:00
  The Khazanishan semiquifying hey brings many.
• 11:02
  Proofs to this that you're not obligated.
• 11:04
  It's rashous. And like I said, it's a
• 11:06
  beautiful thing to do, and the Zora says you should be.
• 11:08
  Doing it because you want to do a tikkun on the mitzvah.
• 11:11
  But you're not obligated to go ahead and do it.
• 11:15
  OK, you're still not obligated to do it, so a you don't have to
• 11:18
  look. For the mitzvah, everyone
• 11:19
  agrees. B.
• 11:20
  When you bump into the mitzvah, there are those that say you
• 11:23
  have to do it. We be.
• 11:24
  Quran, and there's those. That would be Makhmur.
• 11:26
  Yes you should do it, but be anchor then you don't have to do
• 11:30
  it. It's still blibes or issues.
• 11:32
  You don't have to necessarily do it in there.
• 11:35
  The Pista tuba throws in an extra.
• 11:37
  Curveball at us and he says it could be like a guy who snips as
• 11:40
  a four cornered beggin and he snips one of the corners.
• 11:43
  We say that it's considered. Eden Richter, That's a.
• 11:45
  Dangerous thing to do because you're.
• 11:47
  Pottering yourself from mitzvah that when the when it's a
• 11:49
  dangerous. Time that because Barkley.
• 11:51
  Gets upset at you. If you don't, if you're.
• 11:53
  Trying to circumvent. Mitzvahs.
• 11:55
  We're not always. Happy with that, so the
• 11:57
  pistolate Juba says if you. See a Ken.
• 11:59
  And you walk around it. Yes, you're not obligated, but
• 12:03
  Even so, it's not. Such a good segula to do that
• 12:05
  because. It shows the coach Barkley, I
• 12:07
  could care less about your mitzvahs.
• 12:08
  I'm not. Interested in doing it?
• 12:09
  So at least we see from here. This idea of the hue of the.
• 12:14
  Obligation. Now why am I?
• 12:15
  Mentioning this, it's enough, Kamina.
• 12:17
  And again, I'm giving you back. I know I'm starting.
• 12:18
  It's just right in the beginning of the seven, so I'm giving you
• 12:20
  back information. But the next time, we'll read a
• 12:22
  lot. Even next the next week was
• 12:24
  optional. We'll read a lot.
• 12:24
  We're till 10 right then if. Kamina between these two
• 12:27
  cheetahs are very important because everybody, everybody
• 12:30
  asks, am I obligated to take the children?
• 12:34
  Am I obligated to take the kids? The eggs that are underneath it
• 12:37
  do I have. To go ahead.
• 12:39
  And take the eggs underneath. It it's a very.
• 12:41
  Common question because most of us, I think, are not necessarily
• 12:45
  eating the eggs that are. Underneath these things that are
• 12:49
  on your these pigeons. That are on on your thing.
• 12:52
  I can't imagine that people want to spare themselves the shekel
• 12:55
  and buy the egg. And a tunuva instead.
• 12:57
  It'll take it underneath there. Right, 90% of people.
• 13:00
  Are not interested. In doing that.
• 13:02
  So the question is if I'm not? Interested in the egg?
• 13:04
  Should I still send away the mother?
• 13:06
  Or is there a mitzvah? The halal to send away the
• 13:09
  mother. And that depends on these two.
• 13:11
  Sides I just mentioned if. There's a mitzvah.
• 13:13
  Be fiance want to send away the mother the.
• 13:15
  Khavisiar, the Khansvi says. Yes, you are obligated send the
• 13:18
  mother away. You're obligated to go ahead and
• 13:20
  do it. So we see the mitzvahs.
• 13:21
  To send away the mother. So even if I pick.
• 13:23
  Up the eggs. And put it right back.
• 13:25
  Again, no big deal. We'll still let you.
• 13:26
  Get away with it. You don't have to do anything.
• 13:28
  You don't have to keep the eggs. You don't have to eat them.
• 13:29
  We're not going to make you close your nose and stick it in
• 13:31
  your in your mouth. Don't worry about it.
• 13:33
  You don't have to go ahead and do it.
• 13:34
  You can send away the mother. And you still have a queum of
• 13:37
  the mitzvah by sending away the mother.
• 13:40
  And and returning the things. Do you have to pick up the eggs
• 13:43
  that you're asking, and do you have to?
• 13:44
  Yeah, you still should make. A Canyon on the eggs, because
• 13:46
  that's what we're going to see. Also that you still have to pick
• 13:49
  up the the children, but you don't have.
• 13:51
  To keep them you. Can go ahead and put it right
• 13:52
  back and have nothing. To do with them.
• 13:54
  OK, right. That's a good question.
• 13:57
  However, if we go with the other side like the Iran and like I
• 14:00
  told you, many of the. Boys can say the cipher.
• 14:03
  If you don't want the. Eggs and yes, this is coming out
• 14:06
  a Homer, if you will, if you don't want the.
• 14:08
  Eggs and why you're sending away the mother.
• 14:10
  So some people say. Send it away and take the eggs
• 14:12
  and whatever and do. Do something with it or.
• 14:14
  Throw it away if you want, but if you don't want the eggs
• 14:17
  according to them, there's no necessary.
• 14:19
  Mitzvah of doing this mitzvah, which is a massive.
• 14:22
  Thing because if we don't. Want the eggs?
• 14:23
  So why am I saying mother now? He's the only one.
• 14:25
  Who says it? So I'm.
• 14:25
  Still going to quote it. Because some.
• 14:27
  Cipher says and if you don't want the.
• 14:28
  Eggs. I'm not saying we possibly like
• 14:30
  this, but. I want to tell you sometimes.
• 14:31
  If you don't want the eggs, it's start by the time to send away
• 14:33
  the mother. Why are you sending away the
• 14:34
  mother? You don't want the eggs but for
• 14:35
  not getting out of here. He says not to do that.
• 14:37
  Most places disagree because you still have.
• 14:39
  Bizarre that the mother's gonna come back and cry.
• 14:41
  And we still want the. Sagulas that come out of it.
• 14:44
  And when the mother's not gonna cry?
• 14:46
  What if the eggs put it right? Right.
• 14:48
  That's one of the times, they say, when you put the eggs back
• 14:50
  this time. It's just not 100.
• 14:51
  Percent true, by the way. Because when you pick.
• 14:53
  Up the egg though, and. Put it back.
• 14:54
  The mother usually doesn't come back.
• 14:56
  Some people pick it up with a glove in order.
• 14:57
  She'll come back, but if she. Can smell that your
• 14:59
  fingerprints. On top of it, right if she knows
• 15:01
  that she will not come back and since Mattheos.
• 15:03
  It happens very often. That you won't end up coming
• 15:05
  back. Afterwards to to do it.
• 15:07
  That's why she'll fight sometimes in the beginning.
• 15:09
  Before she sees. You taking it away because she
• 15:11
  knows she's not going to come back afterwards?
• 15:12
  Yeah, sometimes it comes away. Yeah, I've seen it both.
• 15:16
  Directions. I've seen it.
• 15:17
  Happen this way. Now, I know, I've seen, I know
• 15:18
  what you're saying. I've done many times and
• 15:21
  sometimes I've seen mothers not come back and sometimes come
• 15:23
  back, just so you know. OK, that's.
• 15:26
  That's that if it's not going to come.
• 15:28
  So the question is if you're not.
• 15:29
  Going to take the child according to the second.
• 15:31
  Cheetah. It could be it's.
• 15:32
  Not so. Therefore many people do take
• 15:33
  it. And even if you throw it away,
• 15:34
  at least you took it away both with Shlomo Zaman or Yoshif.
• 15:38
  Say it's called a need for the eggs.
• 15:40
  When you want the mitzvah, I'm doing for the mitzvah, say to
• 15:42
  her I'm not going to eat it for lunch.
• 15:45
  I understand I don't want to be felicicic, but still.
• 15:47
  Even though I'm not going to eat them.
• 15:49
  I still the mitzvah itself is called it's that's their hiddish
• 15:52
  a little bit. And we need that finished.
• 15:54
  For hour, day and age. We need that finish because I
• 15:56
  know nobody here is eating eggs. So that's one of the main
• 15:58
  reasons why we do this thing. And yes, there's a certain idea
• 16:02
  of taking it away if you can, if you want other people to do it.
• 16:04
  So then we go ahead and. Put it back.
• 16:07
  OK. Then we might go ahead and put
• 16:09
  it back, but you should know there.
• 16:10
  Is such an idea of. Of of taking it and actually
• 16:13
  retrieving it. And putting it away somewhere or
• 16:15
  doing it something they bring from a Don Sego that.
• 16:17
  He did the mitzvah, he took it and he put in a little glass
• 16:19
  box. To remind him all the.
• 16:20
  Time. Oh, I do the mitzvah.
• 16:22
  To keep himself as a. Reminder that I did the mitzvah.
• 16:24
  He kept it there in order to keep it around.
• 16:25
  Some people throw away the eggs and then the mother will come
• 16:28
  back. She won't see it.
• 16:28
  She'll cry. And that's how you were makai in
• 16:31
  the mitzvah, so. This is the mitzvah of.
• 16:34
  Doing it of taking it. And and bringing it back.
• 16:38
  I'll go on to see Beth if we have time.
• 16:39
  I'll, I'll, I'll continue about the idea of taking the, the
• 16:42
  children. We'll just see if I have time
• 16:43
  first. See bet See Bates.
• 16:46
  I'm assuming it's like you got your name.
• 16:47
  Shaddark Emly Godel. In Benet Adam.
• 16:49
  So this is based on the. Gemara in Kulin also that says
• 16:52
  if you have birds which are domesticated by you and they
• 16:55
  hang out by you and they're totally there, meaning you own
• 16:58
  them or they're part of your household, the bait, the.
• 17:00
  Batim of Azima. Torna go home should go.
• 17:02
  To the bite. Putter.
• 17:03
  So your putter from all their eggs.
• 17:04
  Any eggs that they have, you are definitely not obligated to take
• 17:08
  them. Because like we said.
• 17:09
  It has to be. He Carl Clark on.
• 17:12
  Seaport you came out to you you by accident, you bumped into it
• 17:16
  not the problem of zooming the aircraft they're.
• 17:19
  Already underneath you and and they're underneath your
• 17:21
  auspices. Or they're you own them.
• 17:24
  So then that is not a there's no Mitsuchi Luka can in such a case
• 17:28
  of Ayo Nisha Valley of. Azipor I'm Shakanu Between.
• 17:31
  However, if you have wild birds like we're familiar with, they
• 17:34
  come out and they go ahead and hang out and they have a nest.
• 17:39
  Uber Boris Velvez. Invitarna Golem should come in
• 17:42
  Uber partes. Kind of right they.
• 17:44
  Come you find in a ditch, or you find.
• 17:46
  A nest in a tree or they're in a partes.
• 17:48
  Some type of. Field, etcetera, etcetera.
• 17:50
  They're in a. Nest and they're just there so
• 17:51
  then definitely the mitzvah is over there because you.
• 17:54
  Don't own them, they're. Not part of your reservoir, EU
• 17:57
  Shaloy Hoogaboo. I am Alabatsima Klal Mishitilim.
• 18:01
  Abalim Hoogbu I am Mialeum even McCoy Miss Alalu Shaloy
• 18:07
  Zakhtaloy Khatzara Ghavalay Mazuman U.
• 18:10
  Potter now over here he mentions one of the hetarian.
• 18:13
  That we have these days, which is that the question?
• 18:16
  Is that if a bird? Comes on your in your.
• 18:19
  Let's go it easy in your Gina. OK, let's say you're in your
• 18:22
  backyard. In your Gina.
• 18:25
  You have a nest that comes. Over in the tree that's in your
• 18:29
  now. That is called a Hutzer Hamish.
• 18:31
  Tameris, that's called a hutzer. Hamish Tameris.
• 18:34
  A Hutzer. Hamish Tameris.
• 18:36
  Is is something that is protected by you, meaning it's
• 18:40
  in your shoes. Nobody's allowed to really walk
• 18:43
  in there, and therefore whatever goes in your hutzer, you're
• 18:47
  clean as he brings down here in. Steve Cotton, Evolve the Shark.
• 18:52
  Adam okay, a person say, even though I didn't mean to be coin
• 19:01
  and we know that it's kind of the Kumar and get in when the
• 19:03
  person throws a get into that you're coining the get whether
• 19:07
  you like not whether you like it or.
• 19:08
  Not, but that's how you are. You're claiming now a very
• 19:12
  important detail I just said is it has to be a.
• 19:15
  Clutter image tamaris meaning it's.
• 19:16
  Protected by you that someone else doesn't come.
• 19:19
  So that's one of the heterim we have.
• 19:21
  Usually birds are in window sills.
• 19:23
  There's window sills, A Hatsumish Tamaris.
• 19:25
  Many. Pies Kim say a window sill is
• 19:27
  not a Hatsumish Tamaris because any God of can go ahead and get
• 19:30
  it. Now if you live on the 36th
• 19:31
  floor, so it's probably. Called a Hatsumish tamaris.
• 19:34
  Because I don't know someone. Who's scaling the walls there's?
• 19:36
  A couple exceptions, but most people are not scaling the
• 19:38
  walls. To get to the 36th floor to be
• 19:40
  able to get. There so it could be a Hatsumish
• 19:41
  Tamaris. But if you have somewhat.
• 19:43
  Of a lower window sill with most people can get to and it's not
• 19:45
  so hard to get to. So then it is not considered.
• 19:50
  A Khatzer Mish Tamaris and and it.
• 19:54
  Would mean and then it would mean.
• 19:56
  That you are allowed to do Shilu.
• 19:58
  Hakken so again a you have to. Own the place and B.
• 20:01
  It has to be that it's something that's protected.
• 20:03
  By you owning it means. Or I bought it.
• 20:06
  Or if I'm a renter, renter also owns the territory and then.
• 20:10
  You don't have a Mr. Shila Hakken, but if.
• 20:11
  It's not Mish Tamaris, you live in a very.
• 20:13
  High window sill. Or it's in a shul, or it's on
• 20:18
  the roof, or it's in a place which is exposed to other people
• 20:22
  to be able to retrieve it. So then not a problem, you are
• 20:26
  allowed to go ahead and do Shiloh.
• 20:28
  Again, that's a. Now, B, what happens if it is in
• 20:32
  a hunter, Mr. Mayor? It's in a low window sill or
• 20:34
  it's in a tree in my cuts air. What do I do?
• 20:36
  What a caval I. Want to do this mitzvah?
• 20:38
  We all. Want to do this mitzvah?
• 20:40
  So basically there are two aces, there's three aces in order to
• 20:44
  get. Around this problem that we're.
• 20:45
  Going to finish basically the first.
• 20:46
  One the Chouhanora. Basically told us that he says
• 20:49
  that if the mother never took. Off off the eggs, meaning she
• 20:53
  laid the. Eggs and she's still there and
• 20:55
  she's resting there. She never actually flew up once
• 20:57
  and. Came back down.
• 20:58
  So you were never. Clinging to the eggs yet because
• 21:00
  you can't. Get the eggs.
• 21:01
  She's still sitting on them, the only way to get the eggs by.
• 21:03
  Sending away the mother. So you weren't actually kind of
• 21:06
  the the eggs and therefore it's OK, therefore the eggs you're
• 21:11
  allowed to still send her away and you were not.
• 21:12
  Cleaning the eggs yet? So that's the first one.
• 21:15
  Many times we don't know if it's she took.
• 21:17
  Off yet or not usually. Sometimes you could tell you
• 21:19
  should. I've had and some people said,
• 21:20
  oh, the mother just came there. I saw the nest.
• 21:22
  And it's still within, let's say the traverse 24 hours before she
• 21:25
  leaves. For just hatched.
• 21:28
  When they just hatched. And she's still Yeah.
• 21:30
  Before she laid them. Sorry, not like that before.
• 21:32
  Not hatch. Not hatch, not hatch.
• 21:34
  That's good. Right right after she laid them
• 21:36
  and she's still within the Hospice, he said.
• 21:38
  It's still underneath her and she hasn't.
• 21:39
  Done. Taranucci, she hasn't done.
• 21:41
  Switches with her husband yet, right?
• 21:43
  So she still just took off herself and therefore she's on
• 21:46
  top. Of the eggs, you can go ahead
• 21:48
  and do it. That's a B and this is the main.
• 21:51
  Header that we have is right now today because you're listening
• 21:55
  to this. Year you were going.
• 21:56
  To have this idea. One time a year or you could
• 21:59
  just say anything any and eggs that are laid in my cutser.
• 22:03
  I have nothing to do with them. I don't.
• 22:04
  Own them I don't care about. Them I could care less.
• 22:06
  About them? And I have no.
• 22:08
  Interest in prison is. Clean it makes an acquisition in
• 22:12
  his hutzer without his das, but not against his DAS.
• 22:15
  You can't force me to buy. Something I don't want to buy,
• 22:18
  right? Like some salesman's try to do
• 22:19
  for you, right? You can't make it you know it's
• 22:21
  your sorry page, right? You can't do that.
• 22:23
  I don't want these eggs leave me alone.
• 22:25
  And therefore 1 time a year that you know, you can go ahead and
• 22:28
  make a declaration. Anything that comes here is not
• 22:32
  mine. And therefore when the eggs come
• 22:34
  about and then when you see a nest or whatever, so then you're
• 22:37
  good to go. Let's say you see that the
• 22:39
  mother starting to make the nest, you see them starting to
• 22:41
  make a nest. So you go ahead.
• 22:42
  Immediately and you say no. Not interested.
• 22:44
  I don't want any of this. To do with this, I'm not
• 22:45
  cleaning my. Hutzer should not be cleaning
• 22:48
  for any. This AIDS is brought in the base
• 22:49
  of Levy. It's brought the Ebony Nazer.
• 22:51
  They're the awesome cipher, the Evan Ebony Srella's.
• 22:53
  Where I can be Srella, Ravoyosha, Vosner, all of the
• 22:57
  price. Scheme go with this aids.
• 22:59
  OK except for one surprisingly cuz he usually is like this.
• 23:02
  Type of direction somozamanzaman.
• 23:04
  Didn't like he actually held that.
• 23:06
  The fact that I could be cleaner right now just by thinking I
• 23:09
  want to be cleaner. He held that it's called.
• 23:11
  Mazuman. It has to be Mazuman, right?
• 23:13
  So this is Mazuman. Why?
• 23:14
  Cuz in a second I just say I want it so it's mine.
• 23:17
  I don't have to do anything. So he held that that is called.
• 23:20
  Mazuman. Everybody disagrees with that
• 23:21
  original Mazuman as. Good as he held that.
• 23:23
  Yes, if it's. If it.
• 23:24
  If it goes in your, it's not so simple.
• 23:26
  That you have a Mitzer. Of Shibuo Hakan, I told you, I
• 23:29
  think he's almost a duster. I don't think it's a.
• 23:31
  Someone else in that in that direction.
• 23:33
  OK, the last and important ETA which is what's been more meet
• 23:37
  Cabell in the past. I could say 20-30 years that
• 23:39
  when all this farm of coming out.
• 23:40
  And she'll ask the shalik. On this mitzvah.
• 23:42
  And they've been asking around with Climb can.
• 23:44
  He ask you who's asked this question and some and others.
• 23:47
  It's a very simple thing is that is we all know, especially those
• 23:50
  of us living in this thing stinks.
• 23:52
  I don't want this thing on my window sill.
• 23:53
  Who wants these? Pigeons over here off these
• 23:55
  eggs. And they're bringing fly or
• 23:57
  their. Maggots.
• 23:58
  So that's just. I wish it wouldn't be here.
• 24:00
  Nobody wants the same, so when you don't want something, you
• 24:03
  don't even have to say. Anything automatically, you're
• 24:04
  not going to. Automatically by by by by by
• 24:08
  that you're. Automatically not going to this
• 24:11
  this nest and. Therefore, that's the main hat
• 24:13
  that you so even if you never said anything or you didn't do.
• 24:16
  It the mimic is if you. Ask a rabbit, they'll say go
• 24:18
  ahead, you can do the Mr. Schluken, aye.
• 24:20
  It's in a tree in my thing. You want it.
• 24:22
  You love nests. That's like your thing.
• 24:24
  No, I really hate these things. So.
• 24:26
  And then you're not coined. A person can't be coined about
• 24:29
  cork. That's a.
• 24:29
  Clow that we have. In kosher Michigan.
• 24:31
  But the shock. Brings it over there and
• 24:32
  therefore more or less it's usually considered Mazuman.
• 24:35
  That's the main header. But like I said, most people are
• 24:37
  Mahmir. We try to say if I have a place
• 24:40
  where I could have a birth. So then right now we make a
• 24:43
  declaration that you should know for now, on any nest that comes
• 24:46
  around. I'm not interested.
• 24:50
  Yeah. So Mafia I'm actually.
• 24:51
  Going to speak about next. Tomorrow but.
• 24:53
  Yes, it's you. You're doing it by saying what I
• 24:57
  said. Until now is not being mafia,
• 24:58
  it's. Just saying I'm not owning it,
• 24:59
  I'm not mafia, I'm not giving it to someone else necessarily.
• 25:01
  I'm just it's not mine and I understand this.
• 25:03
  Let me just. Read it, Steve Gimmel.
• 25:05
  Just say because it's. Continuation, but call Malcolm.
• 25:06
  Sheet Santo Ben. Beilo, Ben.
• 25:07
  Bars Ben. Bars, Ben.
• 25:08
  Chiko no Mars anytime you find it, whether it's in a tree, in
• 25:11
  a, in a, in a cave, or wherever it is.
• 25:13
  Or Biyama. Borussia Shell.
• 25:15
  Adama, Borussia. Or either Rush Shar Balikheim,
• 25:18
  Beimer shoots around, and Beimer shoots the.
• 25:20
  No matter. Where you find it doesn't matter
• 25:22
  where it is as. Long as it's Mazuma, you have to
• 25:25
  go ahead and do it. And the MAR brings a very common
• 25:27
  case. That if.
• 25:28
  You know I hate when this happens if a bird makes a nest
• 25:30
  inside of your hair on top of your head so you're allowed to
• 25:33
  go. Ahead and send away.
• 25:33
  Go. You're allowed to send it.
• 25:35
  Away out of your head. Just try to watch out that he
• 25:37
  doesn't do that, but it's also called.
• 25:38
  That, you know, it's just. Mazuma Bialka.
• 25:40
  And therefore it's not OK.