Latest / Portfolio Talks / Ep 15 : Reality Check For Retiring Doctors
Transcript
- Vishal Gill, CFP: Hey everyone, welcome to another episode of Portfolio Talks. What we want to talk about today is a story that may hold true for a lot of you that are out there. And we're gonna talk about the ideal retirement for doctors. For the most part, it's very much oversimplified. A lot of you out there will think, okay, cool, as I enter retirement, I'm gonna be mortgage-free, for the most part, debt-free. I'm gonna have enough investments that my dividends will cover my cost of living, and that's it. I'm good to go. The problem is that's an oversimplification. And just like any of your fields. You don't want to say, you know, an apple a day keeps the doctor away. That's too simple. You know, brush and flosh your teeth. You'll never need a dentist. Go for 8,000 steps a day. You'll never need a doctor. All those things aren't going to be true. Two cares a day, your eyes will be fine. Oversimplifying anything can result in tremendous impacts as your years go on and you get into the main deaccumulation years, which we'll talk about. So, what we're talking about today is prefer preferment for you doctors that are out there. So the date that you don't need to have a hard stop for retirement, but when you do want to retire, What does that look like? And how a lot of you are running into issues which become very expensive to fix when you're right at your finish line. So stay tuned. We're gonna talk about all that and more in this episode of Portfolio Talks, retiring for doctors. All right, everyone, we are back. Portfolio Talks, and we are right on the end of Thanksgiving long weekend. so I don't know how many of you out there actually have long weekends or not. we don't really have long weekends all that much, but happy Thanksgiving to everyone that is listening. Hope you spend time with your family and friends and just all the things that are, you know, there to be grateful for. It's very easy to get caught up in the busyness and investing, and I need to work and grow my money and all that kind of stuff, which is important, but It's more important sometimes just to take the time to be grateful, look at all the beautiful things around you, and we hope that you got a chance to do that this weekend. Tyson, how was your Thanksgiving dinner? Did you eat a lot? Tyson Nagasaka: No, we were we kinda we we cheated this year. We went out for lunch and did like Thanksgiving lunch with the family. And you know, I started saying that to some people and they also told me they cheated this year too. They some families went to Whistlers, some people went out to do something else. So there was a a a group of us that we didn't cook this year, we just went out and enjoyed and it's nice. no prep, no dishes, no nothing. Just eat and then leave. it was good. It's a good weekend. Vishal Gill, CFP: That's more and more what's happening now. It's like the old school days of just having like one grand house, one grand kitchen that you can fit like 30, 40 people in. that doesn't happen as much anymore, especially now that's we become a little bit fancier or older. I'm not sure which one it is, but I remember back in the day we used to sit on the floor or find a corner somewhere, and you just basically have your dinner there, and there's like all your cousins and and aunts and uncles all stacked up in one house. but we kind of cheated too. We did like a semi cheat. so we hosted, we usually host every year. We hosted the family, but this year we actually didn't cook, we just ordered out, and I didn't realize how many halls and and restaurants and stuff actually prepare all the dinner for you. So we thought this year we'll try it out and save ourselves some time. so we ordered the food, picked it up, and then just had a couple sides that we made. But for the most part, everything's all good to go, and it was phenomenal. So good. but I'm all just like turkey to stuff, you know. Like I I ate so much and just feeling it now. So hopefully we'll be good. Hopefully I can get to the gym in the next couple days and put all this these calories to work. But but I love food. So leftovers are great. I'm probably gonna eat some after this episode. Just rewarm some stuff and then and then I'm I'm good to go. Someone sent me a message on Instagram. They're like, hey, the trick is for a bunch of leftovers make a chili or like a soup with all the leftovers once you're running to the tail end. It's like a different way to eat it. It's like, wow. So that might be the year I tried out. Let's see. Dirky soup. Tyson Nagasaka: Turkey soup, yep, it's a thing. Vishal Gill, CFP: Way to go. awesome. Well, let's jump into it. So one of the things we want to be thankful for is gonna be thankful that we can retire at some points. but it is a very nuanced thing that we really want to deconstruct and talk about. And the the problem, the epidemic perhaps that we see is far too often it's oversimplified. Just put everything you have into low-cost ETFs, you're good to go. And You'll wake up one day, boom, you're at your retirement date. Just pick whatever day you want on the calendar, and then you you know, you're fine. As long as you pay off your mortgage, you're gonna be good to go. You're a doctor's, you're gonna have more than enough money and you're fine. Some of those things can be true. Like for the most part, you're in a recession, inflation-proof business, you earn a high income, which is great. but there's a lot of drags that are actually happening in your financial plan. And and tax drag is something that we'll talk about. but also there's an earning drag that most of you probably already passed. but some of you will be just starting your career there listening to this episode. I know we went to a new grab boot camp for doctors a couple of weeks back. And a lot of the listeners were at that event, which is great. So, you know, s you guys will know what the drag is for the income drag where haven't started earning yet because you've been going to school and building up all the student debt. And that is also dragging on your financial plan and your ability to invest your money. What we see for the most part when people come to engage with us closer to the retirement date is there is some thing that's happened. And we want to share a story to start with of a real story with a client of ours. And then we'll kind of finish off with what the solutions were. And then in between we'll we'll answer some some some nuances and talk about the problems in a more analytical way that and we'll kind of deconstruct the episode that way. But kind of wanted to start off and just let you guys know what happened. So this client, like many of the clients that are the winding down stage, I guess is the right way to say that. I don't know what the correct Polite way to say that instead of saying you're old, but as the the winding downstage in your career is they get referred to as from colleagues, their accountants or their association partners. this one that we'll talk about was from a colleague of theirs that worked at the same clinic. And it was an incorporated physician in her mid-40s. so she, just like many of you on the episode, was all you know, saw some posts early on on their Facebook groups. I was like, okay, cool, if I follow. This framework, I'll be good to go for retirement. debts, mortgage was paid off, no real debt. It was like a partial car, vehicle debt for a used car. So it wasn't really anything materially detrimental, and had some investments and was all good to go. She, like many of you, was like, Okay, the four percent rule is what I read about. So I have like a four percent of my net worth, I'll be fine. That's the money that I need and I'll I'll be off to the races. so that that that was it. It's and and I'll retire in my Mid-50s, 55 was the target date for her retirement. So that assumption carried for two decades and it and it was totally fine. over the last two decades, she paid herself for the most part all dividends. So not much salary, mostly dividends, and it was rinse and repeat, kind of going, going, going, because the advice from the accountant was tax deferral. So dividends is gonna cost you less in tax than your salary is, so do the dividends. And she did that for the most part for several, several years. The trigger That most people think of before actually sitting down and building retirement. Cause it's one thing to think about your retirement, it's another thing to model out your retirement. And we'll talk about the latter as this episode goes on. And many people think the trigger is once you hit a milestone birthday. you turn 60. Okay, cool, retirement's five years out, or you turn 50, retirement's five years out. And it's a milestone birthday. Cool, I got to this date, and now I have enough time to start preparing or massaging my finances to retire. For the most part, that isn't the case. there's a bunch of different trigger events that we see, but in this example, it was a health change. So she had an adverse health change in her mid 40s, and that's when she realized, you know, there's things that are out of my control. So I should start looking and actually modeling out my retirement. So in case I need to retire early, or what if I can't earn the same income as I was able to for the last two decades? You know, life isn't as controllable as I thought, which she jokes about it now, but she's like, I think that's a physician thing where You think that everything is controlled? You have a mind that works that way. So here's the controllables, and you do that. So that wasn't really the case. And when we actually sat down, when she sat down originally and looked, okay, so I got the four percent rule of a net worth. However, when she started looking at the real mechanics of where's the income actually coming from? Is it coming from my RSPs? I didn't pay myself enough for that. Is it coming from my PC? Is it coming from benefits? Wait, what's the tax look like when I sell my investments? How do I make sure that's still keeping up for inflation? am I gonna run out of money? And then it started causing a lot of stress. And you know, a lot of vulnerability to be honest, because what happened is her words were, I thought I was ahead. And what I realized is actually behind. And I think that is one thing that we hear very often or feel very often when we talk to these clients is you think you're ahead, but you're actually behind because you haven't actually modeled out your retirement. You just loosely thought about your retirement, saw some posts on Instagram or as Facebook groups, or some books, and you're okay, cool. I'm gonna apply these philosophies to my finances, low-cost ETS, 4% rule, and I'm good to go. And that's basically it. It doesn't work in your profession, it's not gonna work in your retirement. So, what we want to talk about is the six. main problems. and and we'll kind of jump right into that right now. So when we get referred to these clients, there's usually these six things. There's a lot more, but we Tyson and I kind of sat down over the last week and kind of went through some case files and went okay here the like focus on commonalities for the most part. So obviously there's nuance. Obviously if you're listening to this episode and you're like, you know, I have a different concern that's not part of these six doesn't mean you're wrong to think that way. It's okay to be concerned about that. These are just the main six that we're gonna talk about instead of a list of like 14 that'll take forever. Be like a four-part episode. So the main six, I'll kind of talk about first and then Tyson we'll kind of walk through and go through each one. But pain point number one or concern number one, longevity risk. So are you gonna outlive your money? We'll talk about that. Problem number two, not knowing where the money's actually coming from. So I know I need this on an annual or monthly basis. Where's it coming from? How am I getting it? No solid debt payment strategy or payoff strategy. So you actually need more retirement income. Than you think, or perhaps your plan was to pay it off or discharge this mortgage in retirement. What's the tax implications for that? Taxation problem with selling your investments to generate cash becomes an impending thing to do. So there's gonna be taxation problem for that. Sequence of withdrawals. So where do you get your money from? That kind of tails onto that. And but you know what parts you take the money out from at these different accounts. And then lastly, winding down your corporation. Do you sell it? Do you sell it? Are you able to even sell business? Are you in a profession that's unsellable? we'll talk about all of those. So before we jump into it, Tyson, anything you want to add before we jump into each one of these common problems? Tyson Nagasaka: not a lot, but I think that a lot of what you summed up is we see on a day-to-day basis, and it's the sound bytification of advice and nuance. Everyone wants to get to a one-sentence answer really quickly, whether that's low cost ETFs solve all my problems, or I'm gonna save ten percent of my income and it's gonna solve all my problems. i it it's it's almost like and I'm sure our clients in the each of their medical professions see this a lot too, is it's like they want their advice to fit inside a bumper sticker. And that is absolutely not the case, especially as we add more and more layers of complication, is there is nuances, there is order of operations, which we talk about a lot, but sometimes doing things in a different order creates efficiency for you or inefficiency. And doing the same thing can cost you more dollars, whether that's opportunity cost or tax or something else. And so one of the risks that we see is the sound bidification of everything. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, I the irony of that is that that sound bite that you just said is actually a really good soundbite. So that's the irony of that. but no, I agree. I I think it's really an oversimplification of everything. And our hope for a lot of you on this episode is we can take a of stress away from you in when it comes to thinking about your retirement. We can help you avoid the problems that your colleagues that are further ahead, you know, two decades ahead of you, a decade ahead of you perhaps. are running into because as you get closer to retirement, your problems have been deferred and they're getting more and more costly to fix. So hopefully this trigger something. And of course, if you guys have questions, you want to model out your retirement instead of just kind of thinking about your retirement, definitely reach out to to us or your financial planner, whomever, but just really start to model out your retirement as opposed to just thinking loosely about your retirement. Because for the most part, when we when we ask our clients when they engage us in this manner. Know what was your strategy before? They're like, well, I'm just gonna invest and then I'll I'll figure it out once I get to retirement. and then they kind of laugh and like I but I, you when I say it out loud, how foolish was that? So let's jump into that without further ado. So, you know, first one is longevity risk. What I would say for this is you know, there's not a definitive study that I've ever seen, but I think I guess my rationale and my thought on it is financial planners in general, we want to be conservative. So we look at average life expectancy. Fan FP Canada, Financial Planning Canada is like our our our main, you know, kind of data point for the most part. We're building plans. they have their own life expectancy numbers. Are you just modeling out retirement? If I'm gonna retire at 55 or 60 or 50, how long do you need your money to last? As a bunch of different inputs that can change that. But one thing I would always say to our clients to keep in mind is as a higher income earner, you are most likely indexing to a longer than normal life expectancy. Couple reasons why is you can afford better nutrition, better food. Whether you do or don't is up to you. you know, there's a I'm sure there's some doctors out there that are on a heavy McDonald's diet and they're just basically eat out a lot or eat out of vending machines. So obviously there's changes, but for the most part, you are able to afford meal prep. You're able to afford healthy food, nutritious food, you're able to afford preventative health. So you know, better gym memberships, personal trainers, all these things that will allow you to, you know, have hobbies and and all that kind of fun stuff. So because of that, we want to make sure that we kind of bump that buffer a little bit more to make sure that in your most vulnerable years, you're not running out of money and you know you can't just pop back into work in your mid 80s and be like, hey, guys, guess what, I'm back. Guess what, your job isn't here anymore. So, you know, longevity risk, that's my quick tidbit on it. But Tyson, I'll kick it to you. When it comes to longevity risk in retirement, you know, let's say a 30-year retirement, 35, 40 year retirement, you know, what are some concerns? What are some some planning things that can be done to mitigate that? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, I think it depends on the segment of clients that you're working in. Whereas with kind of my traditional legacy client base where they have different jobs, teachers, firefighters, police officers, whatever, they probably are l living more closely to the median age that we're predicting, which is I think right now it's what, like eighty five, eighty-six years old. and so saving And making their dollars last is more of a priority than with our clients that are medical professionals where they have a higher income earning trajectory, they save more money, and now we have different choices to be made. And like you said, different access to food, to nutrition. It seems to be a super healthy community. I see a lot of runners, cyclists, a lot of exercise. And and so I I think it's a really good community from that point of view. A lot of the retirement planning though that I was raised on in the industry, it's based on st studies that were being taught in the 80s and 90s. And that's those studies are super old. People used to retire at 65 and they would live to age 68 or 69. So retirement wasn't really a a thing. It was more like an afterthought that they did. Whereas now it's a third of your life. and so we really want to understand what are you gonna do? How are you going stay motivated? how are you gonna get out of bed in the morning? What do you have to look forward to? So a lot of our retirement conversations, it's a it revolves around like what is your lifestyle gonna be and and how do you really understand that? and there's not to go on too long of a rant, there's usually three phases of retirement. Right when you retire, it's called the go-go phase. You have lots of energy. You have lots of of available resources. So you're gonna travel. You're gonna do stuff. You're gonna join a pickleball league, you're gonna take dance lessons, you're gonna do all the things that you wanted to do. And you might have grandkids in the picture, so you're also going to their sporting events. And it's like your calendar is more full when you're retired than it was when you were working. And then there's the slogo years, which is usually about 10 years later. You've kind of done all your travel and now you might not do two or three trips a year, you might do one. You might not go to every event, you might select special events. And then after that season's done, it's kind of the no-go years where your circle of influence and your circle of travel gets a lot smaller, which also means you're spending money wildly different. And so to say that you're going to spend money the same every year, year in and year out for the next 35 years of your retirement is probably not realistic. And so that's all of that that it just means nuance to the retirement plan and really understanding kind of the lifestyle, what they want to do and how to how to set expectations correctly. Vishal Gill, CFP: Absolutely. And it and I think that just also talks about how important it is to keep your money invested for you on those longevity rare years. So if you're retiring for a third of your life, think about how important it is to still have your money working for you during those years when you're perhaps in your go go years, you're you're withdrawing a little bit more or you're just spending a little bit more. but when it goes to different times, okay, you're not pulling as much money, but what you can control is inflation. And we saw this during COVID, hyperinflation. you know, you also don't know what you're gonna be spending on medical bills as you get older and you need more meds, more expensive meds potentially. so it's just one of those things that you want to make sure that you're planning for a longer runway than you would expect because there's a lot of uncontrollables when it comes to your retirement years. Returns are unexpected, cost of medication is unexpected, and you don't really know what your health is going to be. so making sure that you plan for a longer runway than expected is all very important. Then you also just want make sure that you're investing based on that or keeping your money invested on that, which we'll talk about in little bit. All right, so moving on to the second concern, which is not knowing where the money is actually coming from. So you know, having assets isn't the same as having an income plan. the simple thought of just dividends will cover my cost of living, it is like a a soundbite as Tyson was talking about. It's not a fundamental plan or a good plan for you know where's your money actually actually coming from. so what can we talk about that when it comes to someone that is retired? they're a doctor that had a PC over for several years. And sorry, P C by PC I mean a professional corporation, your med co, your your dental corp, or your OD Corp. so they have all these things, but where's the money actually coming from in retirement? Tyson Nagasaka: Yep. And I think it has the the output has a lot to do with the input. So some of the things that we talk about pre-retiring. We might set up an IPP, an individual pension plan for our incorporated professional. What that allows you to do is take corporate dollars and fund a pension that's going to pay you on the personal side in the future years. it's going to act like a regular pension is if you worked for the government or you work for a big in institution. And that's going to be T4 income to you in retirement. And it gets money out of your corp. So that solves one problem that's pre-retirement. Somebody that sees us and they are retired, and we haven't done that. You might have assets at R RSPs, tax-free savings accounts, and inside your corporation. And with your planner, we should be working to decide how much do you need? How are we going to draw down these accounts? And every every decision has a pro and a con. So for somebody who's prior to age 65, we might. Do like an RRSP meltdown strategy to get the money out of the RRSP in stages and reinvest that as a non-registered or a cash investment style of account, it gets taxed differently as you go into retirement. What that also means is during your last few working years, when we melt down your RRSP, when you enter retirement years and you start to trigger things like CPP and OAS. Is you won't have as much income coming from these forced redemption type of vehicles, and you might max out your your benefits. So you might not experience OAS clawback and some of these other things. So RSP meltdown might be a strategy for you. if you have all of your money in your PC, which Vashal and I see all the time, is their accountant has set up a invest inside your corporation only strategy. Once you're over the age of 65, you can do income splitting with your spouse and not be subject to the TOSI rules, which is the tax on split income. So you and your spouse can each take a dividend out of your corporation, which would probably convert from an operating professional corp to a holding company. And then you can dividend split with your spouse into retirement that way. That is an option. And I think Through all of the optionality and things that Fashal and I would talk about is you want to weigh the pros and cons and just understand what they are because I think there's always pros and cons to every decision. and just knowing the order of which you want to withdraw, how is that gonna tax you, how is that not gonna tax you? Fashal alluded to triple taxation. And so if you want to liquefy all of your assets that are on the personal side first and then move on to the corporation if you wanted to do it in stages like that, but you pre-decease your full plan is your estate would have to cash out the portfolio inside your corporation and then wrap up the corporation, get the money out into your personal estate. And so you're paying tax at two spots, and then your estate would have to pay tax. on that income that it receives in that year. And that's triple taxation, which is, I don't know, what have we seen? Sixty five or sometimes seventy percent of the estate goes to various levels of tax without Vishal Gill, CFP: Crazy. Tyson Nagasaka: proper planning. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, not to mention the complexity that for your executor who can miss triggering events. Like if if some people like, okay, well, we'll set up a pipeline strategy, we won't talk that right now. But you know, a lot of these things have a time frame that need to be triggered. But when things are so complicated, these deadlines are are missed. And the only one that really capitalizes on that is the CRA. So not only your money fund is actually very, very important. And Tyson talked about the sequence of events, and it's different for each and every person. So like we said at the beginning of this episode, there's no quick slogan that's like follow this 4% rule or follow this redemption rule, and then you're good to go. It's different for each and every person. And you know, it's it's it's for the most part to answer not knowing where the money's coming from. What you should be able to do is if the difference of thinking about your retirement versus planning and modeling out your retirement is you should know which accounts you're tapping onto when it comes which one's coming first. If I need a hundred 180k a year, where what account am I withdrawing from first? And why? What's second and why? What's third and why? And then, you know, that is an actual good idea that you know that it's actually been modeled out. So you understand where the money's coming from and the purpose of what my sequence is. Is it to draw down? Am I taking money from my RSPs to melt down or draw down my rift minimum so that I stay under the OES clawback? Or so I keep under a lower marginal tax rate than I was in my income earning years? Am I taking money out from my corporations so that my unrealized tax bill isn't as big. Like am I am I doing this to defer CPP OAS? Like what is the rationale for it? all that stuff should be clarified for you. And then that way you know you actually have a modeled out retirement plan instead of just thinking loosely about it. Awesome. Moving on to number three, no solid debt payoff strategy. and kind of the resulting problem is you undercalculate your retirement needs, but what can we talk about that when it comes to no solid debt payoff strategy? Tyson Nagasaka: we see more and more retirees have a mortgage still. I think the risk in that is what we saw in 2022 when interest rates all of a sudden shot up. Now they were at historic lows. And so we went from almost no interest to having interest. And some people were paying six to eight percent for their mortgage because they were writing a variable mortgage. Not not having a contingency plan to cough up that extra cash for your debt can cost you. and and I think When we think of practice owners now, you might have practice debt. So maybe you financed a whole bunch of equipment or you bought your facility instead of leased it and you have a mortgage left that's on your practice. And so when you're thinking about wrapping up in stages, these are all buckets that we have to talk about and look at the pros and cons of how do we how do we unwind this? Do we sell this asset? Can we recover the cost? Has it depreciated? And like where's the cash gonna come from to pay off these debts? Now, if it's just a simple car debt or a mortgage that you have outstanding, you can l calculate the payments until the end of debt, and that's pretty pretty simple. But if it's a business debt and you're gonna wrap up the business, is that gonna be included in the sale? Is that gonna come out of the profits of your sale? is do you have a partner that's just gonna assume all of the debt? I mean, these are all considerations that you wanna take under advisement. and really understand again the pros and cons of of each one and how you're gonna get out. And a lot of the times what we see with people selling their businesses is we feel really good about the business that we've built and we think it's worth so much, but the market says it's worth this much. And that could be the difference between a great retirement and a good retirement. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, absolutely. And w you know what I see often is one of two things. either the clients are entering retirement, still carrying a a mortgage. And I know that seems strange for doctors that are listening to this, like, well, we have good income, so why would we carry a mortgage? And sometimes a refinance of a mortgage is a solution to a unforeseen problem, whether it be your child's cost of education was higher than expected, whether it be a amount of money that's needed to fund long-term care home for your for your aging parents, whether it's you know something in general that came up, an investment that you want to jump into your tap into your equity, or you consolidated debt, like you just had more debt. So all those things are reason why we see some clients enter retirement with this mortgage and they need higher than expected income. And if you take more income in the early years, what does that mean for your longevity risk? Does that increase it or or what's what's the trade off? That's one kind of segment that we see. Another segment that we see is they do enter mortgage free. So for example, the client that we had, this this mid forty physician, she did enter retirement mortgage free. But when we asked where did this money come from, she took it from her TFSA to pay off her mortgage to be mortgage free. And that's just something that she saw on a forum that she was reading. And she's like, that made sense. Like this money's sitting here, it's an investment. I get a guaranteed rate of return by paying off my I think it was like a 4.25% mortgage. So I get a guaranteed rate of return, no risk rate of return, perfect. 4.25%, I'm good to go. And my TFSA got me this. I didn't have to pay any tax on it. And that's not horrible, but it's not great. and that's just one of those things that again, you're now you're you're throwing into longevity risk. And also when it comes to your estate plan, one of the best tools out there is your TFSA for estate planning because your RSP will trigger tax, your corporal trigger tax. Investment properties, all that other stuff will trigger tax. But what could help a lot of that is your TFSA goes right to your beneficiary and they can use that to start to clear debts or move money around or whatever that may be. so discharging that to pay off a mortgage, you know, it's great. But at the same time, this client had CDA room or capital dividend account room inside the corporation where we could have just used that. And we'll we'll talk about how we fix that problem at the tail end of the episode. But there's there's usually a bunch of different options that are out there. So Now, having a solid debt debt payoff strategy is important because another thing that we see sometimes is people just have a really big tax bill because they'll take the money from the corp and just do a lump sum payout to themselves personally, get rid of the mortgage, and then you're good to go. and ends up being an absolutely massive tax bill, which they don't foresee. So making sure that you have a solid debt payoff strategy is very important. do you have opportunities available for you from a timing perspective that can help you? So if you're looking to retire around like 60. do you have any return of premiums coming for your insurance policies? Do you have capital dividend account room? Do you have you know RDTOH? There's there's things that could be available to you depending how you ran your finances over several years that will allow you the most efficient way to pay off that mortgage. Or do you want to be someone that is going to be downsizing and then that's going to be mortgage free? Like, is that something you want look at? or do you want to just re-amortize your mortgage if you're entering retirement with a mortgage? Do you want to just stretch that out? For another 25 years or 30 years and not even worry too much about paying it off, but just keep your cash flow needs as low as possible. That's another option Tyson Nagasaka: Yes. Vishal Gill, CFP: for you look at as well. So a bunch of different ways. And you know, I know it seems complicated, but that's the job as your planners, financial planners to kind of help look through the trade-offs. But what we want to make sure is that your debt payoff strategy is aligned with your longevity risk, like number three and number one are very much entangled because there's often trade-offs, direct trade-offs between the two of those. So again, make sure you have a solid model out plan of your retirement, not just a loose plan. Is your biggest objective is usually to pay off debt? You know, what is your strategy on that? All right, moving on to number four. How are we doing for time? Decent. All right. So how we do for four or number four, we'll talk about taxation problems with selling investments. So let's say these clients are entered retirement now. So they are fully retired, age 60, 65, fully retired, and they know that they need 100. $50,000 a year, no mortgage, $150,000 a year to pay for their travels, regular household bills, car payments, whatever that may be. And they're like, okay, well, I can get the hundred and fifty K from selling my investment portfolio, whether that be RSPs or corps, that is a taxation problem. And I know like one thing I'll say before I kick it to Tyson, but the one thing that we hear often is, okay, well, you know, if you s take the money from your corp, there's there's tax problems because you gotta pay yourself dividend or salary and Like that's complicated. Yeah, but you also gotta take your RSP as income as well. So it's not like your RSP is tax-free because it's a it's already on the personal side. That's not true. So any money you take from your RSP is gonna be added to your income, your taxable income, same as your corporation. The only difference to your corporation is you're deciding how you're showing that income, is a salary or dividends, and why. but they're both gonna be shown as income. So just one thing I want to let the audience know right away. but there's taxation problems when they need to sell their investments to generate cash to live off of to get into per on the personal side, Tyson. So let's talk about that. Tyson Nagasaka: Yep. I think having an idea of what you're investing my number one opening conversation when I have clients start investing is what is this money for? When do you need it back? because event eventually you want the money back. You're investing the capital to grow it, but you're gonna wanna spend it, enjoy it, eat it, drive it, live in it. You're gonna want the capital to be allocated to something eventually. and having a plan for deaccumulation is so important. Because I think people oversimplify where they're going to get cash from. I'm going to deplete all of my RSPs, then I'm going to move on, and then I'm going to deplete all of my corp, and then I'm going to do all my TFSA or in a different order, right? There's an order of operations to it. It's usually a blend. Like when we talk about what's better salary or dividends for how you take income, it's usually a blend because they do different things and there are benefits to them. And so you want to ensure that you're taking as much benefit. that you need for your specific plan. so if it's you and a spouse, you're both shareholders in your corporation, you can take out a dividend and you can do income splitting as dividends in retirement and you can take a certain amount. And then you have to take a certain amount from your RSPs and your RIF, but you really are only forced to take the minimum. So if you have, you know, a million dollars in there and the minimum's five percent, it If your portfolio is still growing at six, seven, eight percent, I mean you might be outgrowing your redemptions year over year over year. it's not a bad thing, it's just what could happen. And so having an idea of how you're gonna stage these things makes a lot of sense. Some advisors tell you to deplete your tax-free savings account early, which makes no sense to me because it's the one thing that is tax-free. So when you need extra money outside of a normal cash flow plan, tax-free savings account is a good place to take that extra money that you need because you won't pay tax on that bump up that you give yourself. so I think there's a lot of nuance. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, I I agree. Just quickly on that one, I always agree with that one. And I always find funny because like that is the thing that can protect you from bumping yourself up accidentally up to a higher marginal tax rate or the same marginal tax rate. Because to Tyson's point, if if you most people have anomalies in their cash flow, especially in the early go-go years in retirement, you end up spending a little bit more than you expected. And then if you end up being the same marginal tax rate as you were during your working years, then what was the point of deferring all that growth and and doing that? So I Also agree. The TFSA is fantastic to just have as a buffer. But sorry, continue on. Tyson Nagasaka: That's okay. people are gonna have a lot of optionality. And so to like the point where you're saying people just do a huge redemption from an investment account, whether it's registered, non-registered in the corporation, and they're gonna pay off their mortgage. The challenge with committing all that capital to your principal residence is if you come into a spot where you need money, you can't sell the kitchen cupboard doors, you can't sell the fixtures or like your house is not supposed to be an ATM. So if you pour all your capital into your house and it's a two million dollar house, now you're mortgage free, that's two million dollars that is locked up that you're not really supposed to draw on until you know, like you either downsize. Or you get into a situation where you might be doing a reverse mortgage or something, which we've talked about in previous episodes. It's probably not the first place that people want to go to, but you could. The other thing that we don't talk about that is probably not for everybody. It's a it's a small percentage, is if you have a really, really big portfolio, there are a lot of investment shops that will actually lend against your portfolio. So you can when you borrow money, it's not counted as income. And not not that we're plugging this company, but I saw it on Wealth Simple's app last week that they also are doing this now and they'll lend you thirty-five percent of your portfolio. It's major, major risk because if your portfolio goes down, now you've spent the money that you borrowed and your portfolio is down and so you're redeeming on a double down. But There are options available to people that have means and resources and I think it's really important to map out your cash flow expectation and the pros and cons of each choice. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. Really honestly, nothing to add. That was that was fantastic. So moving on to number five is your sequence of withdrawals. So we talked a little bit about the s one of the two parts of sequence of withdrawals, which is which account gets drawn down first. So we won't talk about that again. See prior points. but you know, one thing to talk about is sequence of withdrawals in the early years. So we've talked about the go-go years a few times, and this can have outsized damage because if you draw High amounts in your early years, higher than expected. And you know, all of a sudden you thought you need 150, but you're drawing out 190. and we actually we've seen this with some DIYs of like, well, 150 to live off of. I'm like, okay, was that net or gross? And they're like, yeah. So I actually need more than 150. I need like, you know, depending how then we start talking about how they're gonna pull it out and and what how they wanna take it, salary dividends. but you know, when it comes to sequence of withdrawals, the outsized withdrawals in the early years. What kind of trade-offs can happen and how can people plan for that? Because also to add another layer to that is what if you're doing higher than expected withdrawals in the early years, but it's also on a downsize because for most of our clients are investing in their corpse, especially when they get to higher portfolio size, they start holding like equity, individual stocks, blue chip stocks, blue chip equities. And they're not as diversified as just buying a simple index. They're holding actual investments. So I guess those two layers to that risk, pulling it higher than expected amounts, but then also potentially on a downsize. So, you know, what what can we add on that? Tyson Nagasaka: first I have an opinion. this is a scare tactic that a lot of advisors use, is they bring up sequence of return risk. You're entering retirement, you're 60, you're 65 years old, and we have a 2008 event. And then, my God, your advisor is gonna lose your money, and then you're gonna be re redrawing money before your portfolio recovers. but guess what? That advisor also has access to securities that can and will go down. And so it's not like they can predict the market better than any other advisor. it's really about how well built the plan is. And you should be doing something called a Monte Carlo analysis to look at over a thousand historical events. How does your plan and your portfolio stack up? How many times can you win even in bad conditions? And that's really part of like the battle planning of what goes on there. So sequence of return risk is real, it's something to talk about, but it is an advisor scare tactic. And you're gonna go to another advisor that says they're not gonna have those sequence of return risks. And what are they invested in? They're invested in some sort of security that also can go down. so understanding that going into your portfolio, it's really about mapping out cash flow. And I think the more detailed conversations you have up front, the more you de-risk your situation. Like for instance, you're gonna go into retirement. How many times or how many years apart do you change your car? Most people never think about this. But if you're gonna be buying a car every five years and you're gonna be retired for 35 years, how many cars are you gonna buy in retirement? Are you gonna buy four, five, six? Are you gonna stop driving? Are we gonna have self-driving cars at that point? Who knows? but these are conversations that you wanna have. do you want to I get this one a lot, especially because we're we're golf nerds. Vashal Tyson, I wanna buy a golf property and I wanna buy it in You know, name your spectacular golf course. it's two million dollars and I'm gonna go there twice a year and golf with my friends and do whatever. And I've had this conversation with some people, it's why don't you just invest the two million dollars? You can pull out $90,000 a year for the rest of your life just to spend on golf, and you can go to any golf course in the world. how's that sound for freedom rather than buying a one house at one course where you have to go to all the time, which does sound really cool. But it's control, it's flexibility, it's freedom. What happens if you get sick and you miss 18 months of golf? Now you've bought a house that you can't even use, you don't go to. And you know, in depending where it is, you might not be able to Airbnb it. So these are conversations that we want to have up front. And guess what we just did? We de-risk this guy's life. We've invested the money somewhere else. He can pull out an income from it. And there is actually a style of portfolio investing, like Vashal was saying, where you're buying blue chip. You're buying big company names that pay out really, really good dividends. And you can actually build what's called a paycheck portfolio that's going to spit out dividends, interest, return of capital so that you can have a tax efficient means of getting paid from your portfolio without having to severely deplete deplete the capital. So if you have a million or two million dollars in there and it's spitting out $90,000 a year and it always stays at $2 million or above, you can run that play. for a very, very long time and not have the risk of longevity and some of the other things that we talked about. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. And honestly, your point about the golf course is the same point I would say to our clients about vacation properties or cottages and things of that type. I'd say the exact same thing. They're like, yeah, but you know, it it'd be nice to have a memory or a place for our kids in our next generation and all of you know our cousins too to, you know, have this place in Soyuz or Hawaii or whatever that may be. And that is great. However, if you took that same amount of money, you go anywhere and just have the dividends kick out and then you can use that for a family retreat every single year. Even if you just end up renting that same place that like you really love Hawaii in this specific area in like Hawaii. Cool. Do that every single year. But now you don't need to worry about maintenance or if there's issues with the house or now you you are only ever gonna go up to this one place replication as opposed to having the flexibility to go wherever. we we had the same discussion and I was like honestly I would rather just rent wherever I want to go to and then I don't need to worry about I I don't have enough time as it is. I I don't want to have less time because I gotta go check out all this property. So I have the same point about vacation properties as you made about the golf places in in retirement. So flexibility is key and it just allows your capital to keep on growing, takes care of the longevity risk, still allows you to, you know, make those memories and it's just a more practical way to do so. All right, our sixth point is I'm just keeping an eye on time here, but our sixth point is winding down or selling the court. So this is two very different things for two very different types of clients. So I would say for the most part, our you know, optometrists and dental clients are private practice, whether they own their own practice that's independent, or they are a franchisee of an umbrella corporation, and then they're gonna do a share sale back to the parent company that will sell that partnership down to somebody else. or they're just selling directly to the next person, like an associate that's working for them. And that's very different than our locums of the same professions or our physicians who oftentimes don't have private revenue. And even the goodwill is very different than the goodwill in dentistry or autometry, even though the referral source is like, okay, well, goodwill is also the referral revenue for your specialist. So the referral referral revenue that comes from these other people. that is not looked at the same in our physician space because different agreements, different relationships, d you know, different way of practicing. So lots of nuance in it. But what I would say before I kick it to Tyson is selling or yeah, selling your corp isn't a should be looked at as a bailout. Like it's it's your if all else goes wrong, cool, I'll sell my practice and that's gonna get me to retirement, or I can underfund retirement because I can sell my practice and that'll you know help me solve that problem, fill that gap. You know, it could do that, but I would argue that you always want to look at it as a bonus. because you don't know what that market's gonna look like in the future. And you don't want your entire retirement plan dependent on that. The same as you don't want your entire retirement plan based on you downsizing your home or or moving further out into a rural community. Like you know, maybe you want to do that, but maybe the market isn't there for you to sell your house and something happened, or it's a down market, or you don't want to move anymore for XYZ reason, be closer to the hospital, and and not be in a rural community. There's so many things that could change. So you don't want to depend on the sale of the business. And then for physicians and people that are are don't have independent practice, it's that much more important for you to actually have your retirement modeled out. So all the guest work is out there because you don't have this windfall that can go there. and this is all assuming that the lifetime capital gains exemption will always be there. Who knows what's gonna happen in the future? so that's my thoughts on that. But Tyson, I'll kick it to you to add anything. Tyson Nagasaka: yeah, I don't have a ton to add on that, but I think it is shocking. Number one, when we started working in this space a couple of years ago, I was absolutely shocked at the difference between some of them pro professional models that we look at, and then like a family physician. Doctors of family physicians, especially during and around the COVID time, they were just closing up their practice. There was no handoff, they didn't sell their practice, there was not they just closed their doors, they were done, and there's no residual value. Whereas a community dentist clinic, an optometry clinic, some of these other ones that we work with that are like wellness centers where there's a bunch of practitioners under the umbrella, they have some inherent value, community value, and they can sell. but like I was saying earlier, I think a lot of the times when we have something that we can sell, we have a bias to think my clinic is worth X amount of dollars because a realtor told me or somebody told me I could sell my business for this much. Whereas it's really only worth what somebody else is willing to pay. And so building your business to sell it is very different than building it to maximize revenue, to get the most amount of clients in. There's a bunch of different factors of which ha you might want to build your practice, build your lifestyle on. so again, what to what Fashal was saying is yeah, I think building your whole life for that balloon payment exit, you could be left disappointed. And you could be left in a tax disadvantaged situation. We're exactly to what Vishal was saying is we've had clients that want to sell their clinic, they're dependent on the lifetime capital gains exemption, and then they're hit with AMT, right? Alter alternative minimum tax. Government just says, you made too much money, you can't use all of your lifetime capital gains exemption, you still owe X amount of money, and it's a lot. and it's just something that CRA can do and apply to your situation and then you could take them to court if you want to, but that's time and money that you thought you were gonna have in hand. Now you gotta go to court. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. And even the AMT, it's like it's it's built so that you have to keep on paying yourself because you have to have earned income to offset the AMT. So you'll you'll get that money back. However, it's it's not a a quick one for you to do. But that's that's a different topic we could talk about. so really what I would say is when it comes to running your business, for those of you that are incorporated that have a private practice, you want to run your practice as like a boring blue chip family type of business that's you know, profitable, it's run fundamentally strong. So you can use that, extract that money to start investing and grow your investment portfolio. You do not want to run it like a Silicon Valley VC where you're just scale, scale, scale, acquire, acquire, acquire, and then you get this massive loom payment. We are seeing time and time again in the news, you see those big home runs that get hit. and you know private equity buys this company and everything's all good. Everyone's like, wow, that'd be fantastic. I can do that as well. But for the most part, you don't see the flip side that's not public or or talked about very often, which is the ones that tried to do that model. And there is no one that wants to buy that. No appetite for it. So just be very careful and just make sure that you know your entire retirement is not modeled based on this balloon payment that you're gonna sell it to some random person they don't know about. So you're assuming that you're gonna find that person, you're assuming that person can afford it, you're assuming the CRA is gonna keep lifetime capital gains exemption, and you're assuming that you won't get hit with AMT. Tax, which you will. A lot of assumptions. We want to make sure that that's a bonus, not a fundamental part of your plan. Awesome. So just to wrap up here is going back to our client. So we talked about the six main problems or concerns that a lot of you have. So in an ideal world, you want to retire as you enter retirement. You well, at whatever age you decide, you're assuming that when some milestone event happens, you hit your 55th birthday. You're right, cool. Now I'm gonna start modeling it out and everything will work out well. You're gonna be Paying off all your debt before you retire. You're gonna have an investment portfolio that's kick out dividends that can cover your cost of living. And everything is simple because you invest in a low T ET, low-fee ETFs, and everything is all fine. The reality is it's a lot more complicated than that. And that's not happening for a lot of doctors that are out there. The six problems we talked about was make sure you discuss and think and plan at the longevity risk, make sure you plan for not knowing where the money's actually coming from. So Get rid of that unknown and know exactly where your money is coming from, what accounts, and what's the tax treatment on that? make sure you have a solid debt payoff strategy. Are you just amortizing, stretching it out? Are you downsizing? Or how are you discharging that mortgage and what's the tax treatment on that? And what's the trade-off of your longevity risk on that as well? Talks about taxation problem with selling your investments to generate cash. are you gonna sell your investments? Are you doing dividends from those investments? You know, what are you investing in? How you changing as you enter your retirement years? And what's the tax treatment on that? You can see a common theme. what's your sequence of withdrawals and how are you going to mitigate selling on a downsize, withdrawing too much money too early, and again running into longevity risk and again running into taxation risk? And if you have a corporation, how are you going to wind down that corporation? What's the plan? And then, you know, what's your plan to use the proceeds of a corp in your income earning years to fund your retirement plan to solve the other five points? Big problem, big solutions, but you're not alone. There is, you know, many people out there that are willing to help. don't just see a soundbite and see an Instagram reel, but cool, this is all I need, and I'm off to the races. There's a difference of looking and thinking about your retirement versus modeling out your retirement. And we want to make sure that you are modeling out your retirement. So a lot of you might be asking, what happened with our client that we talked about in in the early years? So for the most part, you always you can accomplish a lot of things, but you can't get everything that you want at the same time. There's Trade-offs that to happen. So for this client, everything ended up being fine. She just had to bump back her retirement by three years, which thought isn't ideal, but it's not horrible where it's like, you can't retire at all, or you gotta wait another decade. so we modeled it out. Three years will be okay. What we're able to do is look at triggering the CDA room that was sitting as a credit in our corporation. One thing to note is the CDA room isn't free to use. There's pretty significant accounting fees when it comes to activating your CDA. So That's accumulating year over year over year as you're selling your investments that are capital gains inside your corp. 50% of it will be taxable. 50% of it will just build up to your CDA account. And then you can use that later on. So for this client, we're able to use that CDA room and refill the money that she took from her TFSA to pay off her mortgage. We're able to replenish that by moving corp money that was sitting there into the personal side and then investing in that tax-free growth, which is really gonna help her out. With supplementing the income over the several years. We're going to be able to do a RRSP meltdown strategy to bump back. And the fact that she was hiring a bit later is going to increase her government benefits, OES and CPP, which will cover a pretty significant amount of the cash needs that's that's needed for her, which is great. And then just changing the way that the investment strategy was, because there was some tax strikes that were happening. So she was paying some money on an annual basis. Because it was kicking out T slips in her portfolio. So by reducing and removing that tax drag and just reinvesting that money into more capital gains investments, by using the CA room, by you know, building a plan of where is that money coming from, which was the RSP redemption, supplementing that with some TFSA, and then waiting until we could defer as long as possible for the CPP OAS, resulted in even with a longer than expected life expectancy, all good, and retirement is. Is well within reach. So there's tweaks that can be made. However, sometimes those can be a little bit more expensive than you expect. For this client, the biggest cost was the CDA and the accounting fees that came into that. And then some tax treatment on rebalance in the portfolio because the bigger number is a bigger tax bill. So lots of things that can be done. However, the earlier you solve these problems, the earlier you map out and actually model your retirement, the er the more money you'll really be able to save and the less stress you'll have when it comes to that eventual retirement date. What we want for all of you is to not have any stress and have true clarity when it comes to your retirement. You know, on an annual basis, you have an inflation proof, recession proof income. But when that income comes in, what are you doing with it? What accounts are you putting it into? What's the reason for it? What rates of returns do you need? These are all things that can be taken out of your assumptions and put into a plan. So with that being said, as always, we appreciate you guys by listening. for listening, I mean, and if you want to support the show further. Make sure you like and subscribe and share. I forgot to mention that early on, but all that stuff really helps me on whatever platform you are listening to. And then the last thing I wanted to finish off with is we did just wrap up the October 1st deadline for the disability changes for medical students and new residents. There were some big discount changes that happened. there were some comments from people that saw the episode a little bit later, and they did make that October 1st deadline. There's still discounts available. They aren't as advantageous as what RBC had prior to. but there are companies out there that still have some discounts that are a little bit less than what was available before. But I would assume it's gonna be a little bit more than what's probably gonna be happening in the next little bit. I I'm not I don't know anything. It's no insider information, I'm just guessing. But if I was one of the only players in town that offered a pretty good discount, and none of my competitors were com offering that discount, I would take some market cap for a little bit and then I would reduce my discount and just add more revenue to my top line. So I don't know. I'm just assuming based on things that we've seen before in the industry. So total guess, but I would say as soon as you want to get that looked at, feel free to reach out to your financial planners and discuss when you need to get your disability insurance and what that looks like. If you want to know how important it is, I think two episodes ago we talked about that, or maybe last episode, but just scroll up and just find the disability insurance one. We kind of map out why it's important to you and quantify it as well. and besides that. We will see you guys in the next episode of Portfolio Talks.