Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Would Caleb Downs Or Kadyn Proctor Be The More Needed Portal Addition For Ohio State?
Transcript
- 0:01Hello, everybody, Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Gerdaman
- 0:05here as always with Tom or Tom. How's it going, Tony? I
- 0:11thought we were done with transfer portal season, and great news. We're not
- 0:16done with transfer portal season. Head coach, change season means transfer portal season
- 0:21back. It is the most exciting time of the year over transfer portal season.
- 0:29Oh, I'll never be over transfer portal season. Definitely not. And
- 0:35so there are certainly things to talk about, but we will talk about them
- 0:39through the avenue of some listener questions. And thankfully, one of the topics
- 0:44that we wanted to discuss is the first what was brought up in the very
- 0:48first question that we have here, Tom. So let's get started so that
- 0:52we can get going and so that we can get finished. All right From
- 0:55at WAGS fourteen fifteen. Okay, here you go. Mailbag question is a
- 1:00bigger gut for the Buckeyes out of the portal one? Caleb Downs of course
- 1:03Alabama safety to Caden Proctor, of course, Alabama tackle one meets an immediate
- 1:08need. One meets a luxury need. If I could get one, it
- 1:11would be Procter. I don't want to be greedy and ask for both.
- 1:15So I don't know that I view one of these as like a pure luxury,
- 1:22in one of these as a absolute need. I think I look at
- 1:26them as fairly similar situations where you're probably I mean, I know what he's
- 1:34saying, and I understand the argument that Caden Proctor is a tackle is a
- 1:38higher priority than Caleb Downs is a safety. But I think if you add
- 1:42either one of these, it raises the ceiling for that side of the ball
- 1:48for Ohio State by a significant amount. And I would say that Ohio State's
- 1:55not necessarily a favorite to land either one. Now that's sort of changed a
- 2:00little bit. But you know, if if you asked Ryan Day, okay,
- 2:04you can have either one of these guys, but you can only have
- 2:07one, which one is Ryan Day taking. I think Ryan Day is taking
- 2:13Cayden Proctor and running running home. But if you could add a player like
- 2:21Caleb Downs, now your defense is like your set. We don't even want
- 2:24anybody else. We've got everything. That the one missing piece, and I
- 2:28don't even know honestly that it's a missing piece, because you do have Molie
- 2:31Hartford there as well that could play that free safety who started two games as
- 2:35a true freshman, the first true freshman safety to start a game at Ohio
- 2:38State since Von Bell. Von Bell then responds as a second year guy,
- 2:43helping win a national championship, as a third year guy being a first team
- 2:46All American. But with Proctor, it is interesting to me that you both
- 2:55of these guys, whichever one you don't get in theory, whichever one you
- 3:00didn't get, the replacement is a talented Ohio State sophomore, likely like if
- 3:05you don't get Caden Proctor. Somehow, I think Luke Montgomery is involved,
- 3:09Like whether it's right guard or right tackle, if you don't get Caleb Downs,
- 3:14it's sophomore Molle Carford most likely at that safety spot instead of Caleb Downs.
- 3:20So they have people there. But if you can add a a guy
- 3:24who started at Alabama as a true freshman, whichever you know, then then
- 3:30you do it. But if it's me, it's it's really difficult not to
- 3:37just load up on the offensive line as much as you can, knowing how
- 3:39much you have back in the secondary. And no, you don't know who
- 3:46you necessarily your free safety is, and I think I think it is Mulli
- 3:49Carford and you don't know how good he is. But when you start that
- 3:53earlier, when you're when we've heard nothing but good things about Mollie Carford.
- 3:59The only bad thing we ever heard about him was what he got benched because
- 4:01he was you know, it was a second game in college and he got
- 4:05started, you know, he started because of injury, and then he made
- 4:09some bad reads and it's like, Okay, you're not ready yet. That's
- 4:12fine. You know, he's a true freshman. But yeah, at this
- 4:16point with this team, the way it's looking, I think Downs is the
- 4:21luxury Proctor. And I'm not even saying he is a need, but he
- 4:29would fill a bigger need. Yeah, and I can I can see that,
- 4:34and I think, I don't know. I view both of those guys
- 4:38as potential, significant opportunities. I don't know how realistic both of them are.
- 4:46Caden Proctor, the immediate smoke on Caden Proctor as soon as he went
- 4:48into the portal was that Iowa is a heavy favorite. He is an Iowa
- 4:51native. I think there were some anger when he left the state of Iowa
- 4:57to go to Alabama, and now he has a chance to the home state.
- 5:00Folks happy, So you know, I think Caleb Downs is the one.
- 5:04They're more likely to get either one of them, though I think that
- 5:09sort of materially impacts my view of what this next season could be because either,
- 5:15you know, moly Carford is, as you said, if you're even
- 5:18in this conversation where you're playing as a true freshman, that tells me an
- 5:23awful lot even if you're not ready. The fact that they're willing to put
- 5:26you out there, that tells me a lot about what they think you could
- 5:29be. But Caleb Downs was I don't know if he was actually an All
- 5:33American or like named an All American, or just played in a sort of
- 5:36All American kind of caliber on a very very very good Alabama defense last year.
- 5:42So either way, if Allhistate adds either one of those, I think
- 5:46that only makes them a stronger contender for the national championship this coming year.
- 5:49And if you can keep everyone you know, you bring in Caleb Downs and
- 5:55you keep Molie Hartford, and you shuffle your safeties. However you're shuffling your
- 5:58safeties, that only improves your your opportunities. Because with as we've talked about
- 6:04this before in other contexts, but with potentially having to play sixteen games if
- 6:10you win the Big Ten and you or you go win your twelve regular season
- 6:15games and then you go to the Big Ten championship game and you win that,
- 6:16and then you go to the College Football Playoff and you have you know,
- 6:21you have to win three games there to win the national championship. That's
- 6:24a lot of football and you're going to have to You're going to have to
- 6:28have established depth to be able to survive sixteen games. So either way,
- 6:34if they add either one of these, I think that is major, major
- 6:38celebration time in Columbus. We'll see if we'll see if it is, We'll
- 6:44see, you know, if they can land one or both of them,
- 6:46but it is either one would be a very very big deal. Well,
- 6:50and even the sixteen games, Leathan Ransom has battled injuries, if they'd had
- 6:57somebody as good as Lathan had some taking over for him when he got hurt,
- 7:01after he got hurt this past season, and they could have just kind
- 7:04of been more seamless in that. If you add somebody like Caleb Downes,
- 7:09that would do that. Georgia, if they get him, they already have
- 7:11an All American safety and Malachi Starks Now, now you add Caleb Downes to
- 7:15that, and you know wherever he's going to, wherever he goes, he
- 7:18is going to take some expectations individually and as a team with him. Yeah,
- 7:26and uh so let's go to the next one at Chris Underscore at SD's
- 7:30one. Where is all the dissatisfaction I've seen regarding Corey Dennis coming from He's
- 7:34had direct involvement with the quarterbacks being developed into three first round draft picks in
- 7:39the last few years. So this is I think a little bit of a
- 7:43complicated question because you've got a head coach who is not just an offensive side
- 7:48of the ball guy, but a specifically a quarterback guy. So when you
- 7:55have that and we have something he's known as a QB guru, and and
- 8:00he was the quarterbacks coach and then he was the offensive coordinator for Ohio State,
- 8:03it's like, Okay, how much credit exactly do you want to parse
- 8:09out to the different parties here in this conversation? And Corey Dennis, I
- 8:13think probably you know, as people are sort of doing that calculus, the
- 8:18fact that Cory Dennis was not a quarterback in college, has not served as
- 8:22a quarterback coach on any other staff, and the fact that Corey Dennis is
- 8:24the son in law of Urban Meyer. I think you have people sort of
- 8:28looking at that and going, so, walk me through exactly the process and
- 8:35the qualifications that got you this job. And that's true of anyone who's related
- 8:39to anyone who is a famous football coach. You see that a lot the
- 8:45sons or sons in law or grandsons of famous football coaches getting jobs. And
- 8:52you know, sometimes those guys turn into great coaches. And sometimes it's Jay
- 8:58Paterno or Jeff Bowder or Brian Farrence or you know, pick take your pick
- 9:03of other coaches. So I think you sort of come in with a little
- 9:09bit of a jaundiced I based on that. And then I think with a
- 9:15quarterback expert guru being the head coach, I think it's not that hard to
- 9:20look and go, well, it's Ryan Day's program. And even if Ryan
- 9:24Day is just telling you what to say and telling you what to do and
- 9:26telling you what to work on with these guys in practice, like how much
- 9:30credit do you get? I think I think that factors into this a lot.
- 9:35Well, in New A d ross Byorck talked about it a little bit
- 9:39on Wednesday when he called Ryan Day one of the best offensive minds in college
- 9:43football. And when you listen to recruits talk, they in terms of quarterbacks,
- 9:50it's like going and playing for Ryan Day. And there is a draw
- 9:54for playing a draw of playing for a head coach. Just look at all
- 9:56of the players leaving Alabama down decommitting from Alice Obama because the coach they went
- 10:01to play for is no longer there. And so Ryan Day gets a lot
- 10:05of that credit. And I don't know that anybody has said he shouldn't be
- 10:09getting that credit. And when they're saying when nobody's saying he shouldn't be,
- 10:11then clearly it doesn't mean nobody's saying, hey, why isn't Corey Dennis getting
- 10:16any of the credit? Because everybody knows this is Ryan Day's offense, and
- 10:22he's still calling plays, and he's still with the quarterbacks. An awful lot
- 10:24he moves around, but quarterback is always his home. I also think the
- 10:31lack of stellar play from the quarterback position at times this year, and then
- 10:35also in the Cotton Bowl, where we don't know what Devin Brown was going
- 10:41to do, but when the two and three quarterbacks don't look all that good,
- 10:46and during the season then that kind of falls on the quarterbacks coach as
- 10:52well. You can get one guy prepared, you can't get two guys prepared.
- 10:56And though as well as the starter was prepared, there are still some
- 10:58issue there as well. So I think, like you said, Tom,
- 11:03he can't get himself credit because of who he's coaching for. It's a lot
- 11:07like Eric b Enemy with the Chiefs had to leave so that people could see
- 11:13him as a future head coach as he's calling his own plays instead of Andy
- 11:16Reid is calling the plays, and everybody's like, well, you're just an
- 11:20offensive coordinator, but Andy Reid is calling the plays like Brian Hartlin, You're
- 11:24just an offensive coordinator, but Ryan Day is calling the plays. At some
- 11:28point, Corey Dennis for his own good. Like all coaches, you kind
- 11:33of have to eventually leave and prove yourself somewhere else. It's just really hard
- 11:39to leave a position coach at Ohio State because that is that's one where the
- 11:46next job is either a coordinator or a head coach or the same position in
- 11:52the NFL. And right now, when everybody gives all of the credit to
- 11:58Ryan Day, it's kind of hard to build up that cachet to get that
- 12:01next bump. Yeah, And I think another thing that maybe factors into this
- 12:07conversation a little bit is you go back to the COVID year and Ryan Day
- 12:11was working with j Justin Fields and Corey Dennis was working with the backups,
- 12:15and we've never really gotten a great answer on exactly how the division of laborer
- 12:22has worked in seasons since then. It's so you know, you kind of
- 12:24get the more general like, oh, everyone, you know, we're all,
- 12:28we're all coaches, drawn up ball plays, and you get you get
- 12:31the kind of like general answer that's not a real specific answer. But as
- 12:33you said, if the two and three guys don't look great, that's going
- 12:41to come back on the quarterback coach. And in a year when the QB
- 12:46one didn't look like a typical QB one, I think, you know,
- 12:52if you want to give him, if you want to give Corey Dennis credit
- 12:54for the previous three years to whatever degree you want to, that means you
- 12:58got to wear it in a year when QB one and QB two and QB
- 13:01three did not look like what the expectation is at Ohio State. So yeah,
- 13:07that's that's one of those things that kind of kind of swings both ways,
- 13:09and they're just there isn't a body of work of Corey Dennis working when
- 13:15he doesn't. He's not on Ryan Day's staff, so you just you don't
- 13:18have, like you said, that, that separate thing to point to that
- 13:20go you know, aha, look, he's you know, Jim Knowles.
- 13:24There's no question what Jim Knowles does on the Ohio State defense because Jim Knowles
- 13:28is the defensive coordinator and the head coach is on the offensive side of the
- 13:33ball, so it's Jim Noles defense. He's the head coach of the defense.
- 13:37It's very easy to figure out. Corey Dennis position coach with the head
- 13:43coach on that side of the ball specializing in that position, has never had
- 13:46to be that guy separate from Ryan Day. So I think I think there's
- 13:52you know, there's there's a lot of gray area there and he may get
- 13:54an opportunity to do something on his own in the future, and if so,
- 13:58then you know, then we'll all find out together. We'll see we'll
- 14:01see where he ends up. Where he ends up, if and when he
- 14:03leaves at some point, it may tell you a lot about the you know,
- 14:07the perception is, is he the quarterbacks coach or the you know,
- 14:11offensive coordinator at Oklahoma, or is he the quarterback coach at Bowling Green.
- 14:18You know, I have no idea where he you know, if and when
- 14:20he's headed somewhere and when you know where that might be. But that may
- 14:26give you a sense of, you know, sort of perception in the industry
- 14:30of where he is. Draftking sports Book, an official sports betting partner of
- 14:35the NFL Playoffs, is bringing you an offer that will help make the playoffs
- 14:37electrifying. New customers can bet five bucks on any game and get two hundred
- 14:41instantly in bonus bets. Download the Draftking sports Book app now and use code
- 14:46huddle up. New customers can bet just five bucks to get two hundred instantly
- 14:48in bonus bets only on Draftking sports Book with code huddle up. The Crown
- 14:54is yours. Gambling problem called one hundred gambler or visit www dot one hundred
- 14:58gabler dot net. In New York, call seven to seven hope and why,
- 15:01or text hope and why. In Connecticut, help is available for problem
- 15:03gambling called eight eight eight seven eight nine seven seven seven seven or visit CCPG
- 15:09dot org. Please play responsibly on behalf of Boothell Casino and Resort in Kansas.
- 15:13Twenty one plus age varies by jurisdiction void in Ontario. Bonus beets expire
- 15:16one hundred and sixty eight hours after issuance. See dkg dot com slash football
- 15:22for eligibility and deposit restrictions terms responsible gaming resources. Next one also from at
- 15:28Chris Underscore SDS one. Should special teams get more aggressive under the new coordinator?
- 15:31We've been extremely passive in both kickoff and punt returns. Tony. I
- 15:35feel like we've talked about this and at times in the past, and the
- 15:37answer is Yaha, Yeah, undoubtedly get more aggressive. Ryan Day likes to
- 15:43talk about we want to be aggressive on the offensive defense, and he also
- 15:48talks about special teams being a third of the game. So why don't you
- 15:52want to be aggressive and special teams And it doesn't have to be We're gonna
- 15:54come after every kick and if we end up running into a kicker or roughing
- 15:58a kicker, it is what it is is. Greg Ciana was really good
- 16:02at dialing up some specific Okay, we're going after the punt right now.
- 16:07I would love to see them be more aggressive in the return game, but
- 16:11it's just something that a lot of people do and it takes a certain mindset
- 16:15where that's what the coordinator does and whoever the special teams coordinator ends up being,
- 16:18whether they just give it to Keenan Bailey or somebody else on staff.
- 16:23Yes, there's no reason you should be passive in special teams at Ohio State
- 16:30right now. We've talked in the past about I understand them being passive when
- 16:33you have Dwayne Haskins justin field CJ. Stroud leading your offense because it's a
- 16:40lot easier to get those yards than it was last year, and you have
- 16:42no idea how easy it's going to be to get yards this year. Maybe
- 16:45you won't need to return a punt or you won't need to return a kickoff,
- 16:52but they needed to this year, and they just didn't even bother trying.
- 16:55They needed to gain an advantage. And then I think it becomes a
- 17:00fear where it's like, well, we don't want to try to return to
- 17:03a kickoff and then get tackled at thirteen is then we're really screwed. And
- 17:07so that's that's a terrible attitude to have, but it's also sometimes reality is
- 17:12what it is. But yeah, I would love to see Ohio State be
- 17:15more aggressive tom At some point they're going to need to return a kickoff for
- 17:21a touchdown just because, like it's just the sheer number of opportunities. And
- 17:29I do think if they would have actually returned every kickoff they've gotten been able
- 17:32to return over the last thirteen fourteen years since their last kickoff return, they
- 17:37probably would have returned something. But they're not even given themselves an opportunity.
- 17:41I'm just saying, give yourselves more opportunities to do something. Well, I
- 17:45just look at USC and who it's Zachariah Branch, right, who is a
- 17:52true freshman kick return of this year, one of the branches, one of
- 17:56the z branches that they have. Yeah, you have asked fleets like that,
- 18:00So let your athletes go be athletes and do athlete things like That's that's
- 18:06a real opportunity that you know, there are plenty of areas where our hig
- 18:10state has advantages over other teams. That's an opportunity to do. You know,
- 18:15you have people who can do things that people on the other team cannot
- 18:18do. So you know, as you said, they have sort of been
- 18:22able to lean on the offense in the past. In a year when you're
- 18:23not necessarily able to lean on the offense, it is a little maddening to
- 18:27see them just sort of handwave the opportunity to make something happen in the third
- 18:32phase of the game. We know Parker Fleming is not back. We do
- 18:34not know who is going to be in charge of the special teams in twenty
- 18:40twenty four, whether it's someone they bring in from the outside, or whether
- 18:44it's someone that they bring in, you know, on the current staff,
- 18:47and just who takes on a bigger role. That'll be very interesting to see
- 18:51how how that changes. Do you know, does the approach to bake punds
- 18:56on side kicks, any of that stuff. Does that change because it feels
- 18:59like that has just that has gone from an area where you had some creativity
- 19:02and you had you know, the crazy on side kick against Maryland that with
- 19:06Chris Olave and all that kind of stuff, and it just feels like the
- 19:10creativity has just dried up and blown away in the wind in that phase of
- 19:14the game in the last couple of years. So we'll see how that potentially
- 19:15changes in the coming year. Next time for Matt Buck Michigan Saban was twelve
- 19:22and five against Auburn, should have been eleven and six. Well that's you.
- 19:26You could say he was twelve and five in Aburn against Auburn. Should
- 19:30have lost to Auburn this year probably could have could very well have beaten Auburn
- 19:34if not for a kick six a few years ago. You know, the
- 19:38the what if game is a little tricky to play there. But would that
- 19:41big record be acceptable for an Ohio State coach against Michigan? Twelve and five
- 19:47Alabama against Auburn. Would twelve and five over the next seventeen years be acceptable
- 19:52for an Ohio State coach against Michigan. I feel like Tony, I need
- 19:56to know are we talking about twenty twenty one to twenty twenty three Michigan or
- 20:02are we talking about two thousand and eight to twenty ten Michigan, because those
- 20:07are very different answers, And right now I think you know. Right now,
- 20:11I think Ohiose Date fans would probably gleefully take twelve and five over against
- 20:15Michigan over the next seventeen years. Three years ago, I don't think any
- 20:19Ohiose Date fan would have taken anything less than maybe sixteen and one. How
- 20:25many opportunities? How many times are you are you allowed to lose to a
- 20:29Rich Rodriguez Michigan team twice? I think once might have been the you get
- 20:37one and then if you lose twice, then you're right, you can you
- 20:41can pack your bags. I yeah, Tarmac, Yeah, that's you know,
- 20:47if you're losing to a well, and part of this conversation now is
- 20:51changing because losing to Michigan is not necessarily the immediate death knell for the season
- 20:55that it would have been in previous years, you know, losing to me
- 21:00going eleven and zer into the Michigan game and then losing to Michigan and not
- 21:03going to Big ten championship game. That's the difference between Ohio State going to
- 21:08a Cotton Bowl game that had no meaning really for anything in terms of championships
- 21:14versus congratulations, Well, you have a home game in the playoffs and then
- 21:18you see where you go where you go from there. So the whole conversation
- 21:22around the Michigan game feels like it's changed. It's gonna be changing a little
- 21:25bit this fall. But you know, I wouldn't recommend any Ohio state coach
- 21:30do worse than twelve and five. But I think if you go twelve and
- 21:34five and you're you know, kind of handling the other stuff, and you're
- 21:37winning the Big Ten in your seventeen years, you're winning the Big Ten eight
- 21:41nine times, and you're maybe win a national championship, I think you're I
- 21:45don't think anyone's running out of town on a rail. Well, what if
- 21:49you start out twelve and zero and then he lost five in a row,
- 21:55like right now, if Rindy Day finishes twelve and five, people are gonna
- 21:57love him, you know, because that's what eleven and two over the next
- 22:03thirteen years or whatever. Assuming Michigan would choose to play every single year or
- 22:07shoot, those thirteen games may take nine years. You know, we don't
- 22:11know how many times they're going to play in a year. But twelve and
- 22:15five, I think is is perfectly acceptable because it is better than what he
- 22:19did. It's not better than Jim Tressel urban Meyer, and those two are
- 22:23held in very high esteem because of that, but what he Hayes is also
- 22:26held in very high esteem. So I think twelve and five is perfectly acceptable.
- 22:32But again, you need to know the circumstances of when what, like
- 22:37you said, the teams, the times, and also what else is going
- 22:41around the program, Because as I keep saying about John Cooper, he wasn't
- 22:47fired for losing the Michigan He was fired for everything else that was going on
- 22:49in nineteen ninety nine to two thousand. So don't don't give people a reason.
- 22:56Don't don't lose five times to Michigan just and give people a reason.
- 23:00But I think it'll be fine. But again, we need more information.
- 23:03Well, and the context around this is so different now than it was back
- 23:10in the nineties or even when Jim Tressel was hired, because when Jim Tressel
- 23:14was hired, the question was can you just beat Michigan every other year?
- 23:18Can you just sort of go five hundred against Michigan? And that was viewed
- 23:22as after a two to ten in one stretch, that was viewed as,
- 23:26certainly Ohio State should be able to go five hundred against Michigan. That is
- 23:30that too much to ask? I don't think that's too much to ask.
- 23:33And you win the Big ten every three years or something like that, and
- 23:37then Jim Tressell and Urban Meyer go through and it's like, well, you
- 23:41only beat Michigan nine out of ten years, and you only won the Big
- 23:44Ten eight out of the last ten years. Boy, I maybe we'll renew
- 23:48you. I don't know, it's the expectation just sort of changes with the
- 23:55times, and you know, broadly speaking, I think over the course of
- 24:00history, I think there are not very many times when going twelve and five
- 24:03against Michigan over a seventeen year span would have been you know, would have
- 24:07been enough to get you in real trouble. In Columbus. It's if you're
- 24:11if you're beating them two out of three years, basically, that's I think
- 24:15there's I think that's acceptable in just about any time period in Ohio state football
- 24:21history. Nobody has ever said Nick Saban didn't be Auburn enough either. You
- 24:25know, oh sure, I'm sure. I'm sure you have not listened to
- 24:30enough Paul Fine baalums to really be able to definitively say that. I I
- 24:34bet one of the early Harvey Updyke calls pre uh pre Tree Harvey Updyke calls
- 24:41involved not beating the Barners enough. Almost certainly from Zona Buck I'll have stat
- 24:48has five running backs now down to six tight ends after Sam Hart announced he'd
- 24:53be leaving in May. What is the right balance and what are the possible
- 24:56plans to get there? You know, what is what is the ideal?
- 25:03Five running backs seems like a perfectly acceptable number of running backs to have on
- 25:07Ohio States roster. We'll see what the roster looks like after the spring,
- 25:11because you can have guys coming in, you can have guys coming out.
- 25:15You don't really know, but five running backs seems like a pretty good number,
- 25:22especially if it's not the five running backs they had last year where it
- 25:25was all veteran guys and they're all sort of looking for carries. You got
- 25:27to you know, of those five running backs, two of them are true
- 25:30freshmen who are coming in and they probably want the ball some. But you're
- 25:33not coming in Sam Williams Sixon is not coming in expecting to get three hundred
- 25:37carries this fall. That's not that's not realistic. If he you know,
- 25:42you have your pair and a spare of veteran backs. You've got James People's,
- 25:47you've got Sam Williams Dixon. In terms of true freshmen tight ends,
- 25:52they just brought in the transfer tight end from Ohio University they've got g Scott
- 25:56there, you've got Johnnie Thurman, you've got you've got two true freshmen,
- 26:02and you've got Bennett Christian. So that's the six, don't I don't really
- 26:07know, Tony. Is six tight ends? Is that too few? They're
- 26:11they're sort of spaced throughout the years. It feels like, you know,
- 26:17they probably want to be taking Do you need to take more than three tight
- 26:22ends every two years? I don't know that you can take two tight ends
- 26:23every year. So six tight ends seems like that's a pretty reasonable number to
- 26:29me over a four year span. Yeah. I think they do one and
- 26:33then two, like one every other year or two every other year, and
- 26:37then you end up with six over a four year period. Sometimes they leave
- 26:42even so you have to go to a portal. I think six is I'm
- 26:45not sure, entirely sure that's the exactly where they will think it. I
- 26:51think it is. I know five running backs is what they shoot for.
- 26:53That's what they have allotted for their room. So they're I think they're fine.
- 26:59They're we'll see, like you said, if it stays at five after
- 27:03spring and at this point you can't assume anything, but with tight ends being
- 27:07such a developmental position. I don't see Demorion Witten playing this year in terms
- 27:14of a tight end, you know, don't. I don't see him ever
- 27:18lining up next to a tackle in a real, live game this year.
- 27:23I could see that from Maxell Blanc. I wish he had enrolled early.
- 27:26I really like him, and he's a He's more of a tight end than
- 27:30Tomorio and Witten is right now. Tomorrow Witten is a freak athlete who is
- 27:34incredible in high school at what he does. And what he does is play
- 27:38receiver, play quarterback, placekicker, you know, like he is the guy
- 27:45that Ted Ginn has always used in terms of your best athlete, Where's gonna
- 27:48put him a quarterback at times? Let him do stuff? Ted gin Jermale
- 27:52Hines. I think why Shaun Latimore was in the offense as well. I
- 27:56think maybe Christian Bryant as well. Like they just use the best athletes and
- 28:03just try to do as much as they can with them. And so Tomorrow
- 28:06witness played all over in his time at Glenville, and he's probably like six
- 28:11four two fifteen right now, So that tells you he's not ready for tight
- 28:15end. So I don't see him involved, but you've got the guys that
- 28:19you do. And Bennett Christian spending the entire season just waiting for building towards
- 28:26this coming season, I think he will obviously be hungry. We'll see if
- 28:30he can factor in. You know, when you lose Joe Royer, when
- 28:33you lose Sam Hart. I think part of that is because they see who's
- 28:36ahead of them, They see the situation that they are facing and playing time,
- 28:41wanting to be close from home. We'll see where Sam Heart ends up.
- 28:42He's from Colorado, so it wouldn't shock me at all if he ends
- 28:45up way out west somewhere. But they want to play, and they want
- 28:49to find a quicker way or an easier way, or a more sure way
- 28:52to the field. And I do also wonder how Jelani Thurman is going to
- 28:57develop this year because to me, I can see him being the third tight
- 29:02end, but I can also see him being the first tight end by the
- 29:04time the season rolls around. I think Max chas Merrick is going to have
- 29:11an impact on this team, and I like the top three that they have.
- 29:15We'll see if anybody else can factor in, And generally in any given
- 29:18season, they don't need more than three, especially if they have some sort
- 29:22of a guy who can do the fullback aspect of it. And it'll be
- 29:27interesting to ask who will be the fullback this year? Is it Kayden Curry
- 29:30again, is it Caden McDonald? Is there anybody on offense? But maybe
- 29:36you just do a lot of the two back sets with Henderson and Quinchahn Judkins.
- 29:41Well, I think whoever the fullback is this is going to be maybe
- 29:45the most interested in Ohiostate athletic director has ever been in who the fullback is,
- 29:51because that was something that ross Byorke mentioned specifically, he looked over Ryan
- 29:55Day and I think he was he a fullback when he played footballer plays full
- 30:00back at something like that. Yeah, and you know he he was sort
- 30:03of lobbying for Ryan Day to include a full back and you know, maybe
- 30:07work a little fullback trap into the end of the offense, which would undoubtedly
- 30:11please not only uh ross Byork but also our buddy Marcus Hartman of the Dayton
- 30:15Daily News, who's always always up for a good trap play. I was
- 30:18sitting right across the aisle from Ryan Day and he's, you know, sort
- 30:21of laughing and smiling and said we could probably make that happen, you know,
- 30:23something along those lines. So you know, I mean, if listen,
- 30:26if the boss wants a full back, Tony, I think you gotta
- 30:30you gotta get a full back otherwise, you know, next year's performance review.
- 30:33You know good, you know, beat Michigan won, whatever championship you
- 30:38won, must improve full back. You don't want that. You don't let
- 30:41that on your You don't want to just hand him a must improve. That's
- 30:45that's uh. You gotta you gotta work work someone in. And they have,
- 30:48they've been mining the defensive line room for a little while to try and
- 30:52find a full back. But you know, Bennett Christian is super interesting me
- 30:56because we just we didn't see him. He was suspended the whole twenty twenty
- 30:59three seasons. We have not seen him on the field in any meaningful way
- 31:03for a full calendar year. So what is he going to look like?
- 31:07Because he was someone who I think they thought was maybe going to be physically
- 31:10ready ish to be you know, that kind of all around blocker and all
- 31:15of that. So what is he going to look like when we get to
- 31:17see him out in the field this spring or whatever We're going to get see
- 31:19out of Jolani Thurman, who they are super super excited about, but you
- 31:22know, he's going to have another winter in the strength program and all that
- 31:26to sort of bulk up and get a little more ready to block and all
- 31:30that. And Kasmeric coming up from Ohio University. He's someone who I think
- 31:33they're looking at as someone who's going to be able to handle the blocking load.
- 31:36And so there's there's a lot of pieces there. There's a lot of
- 31:38pieces and parts, not a ton of real proven you know, I don't
- 31:44know there's anyone in that room that you look at and you go, this
- 31:45is a that's the guy who's going to have thirty five catches and four hundred
- 31:48yards like Cade Stover did, or that's the guy who's definitely going to be
- 31:52able to be the you know, grade A blocker that they need on the
- 31:56edge to make that run game work. There's a lot there's a lot of
- 32:00possible rules, there's a lot of maybees, but there's going to be a
- 32:04lot of stuff that we got to watch them sort out during the course of
- 32:07the spring in the summer. I think the one of the other interesting aspects
- 32:12you have all of these big, sizeable tight ends sixty six six five two
- 32:15fifty six seven, I think with Jolannie Thurman sixty five sixty six. And
- 32:20then you've got g Scott, who is completely different than all of them,
- 32:22but he may be the number one. But I'm interested to see what he
- 32:27can do as the number one receiving tight end target because he's never been there.
- 32:31Can he do what caged over did? Can he get downfield? Can
- 32:35he? You know, this whole plan of moving him to tight end to
- 32:39me, has been done to have him be a downfield thread and have him
- 32:45be used as a passing threat. So can he do that while the big
- 32:50bodies are doing maybe somemilar of the blocking. So it'll be interesting when the
- 32:53when Scott is finally this is finally his opportunity to be the number one tight
- 32:59end, and he's probably lined up in the slot more and in twelve personnel
- 33:02and then the bigger tight ends line up on the line. But I do
- 33:08wonder what he can do as that first option in the tight end room.
- 33:13But I think you can also say the same thing about Jilawnie Thurman and Kasmerk
- 33:17has been fantastic at Ohio and his time there, Tom, do we want
- 33:22to finish this up. Do you want to go and just runt through these
- 33:25these last two since it's about the same topic, he asked leadingly. That's
- 33:30fine, absolutely, Tony. You know, I'm always in favor of answering
- 33:32all of the listeners questions in one shot, So let's do it. From
- 33:36a big and chunky fifty. Returning players is great, but only if those
- 33:38players can have a positive impact. How do you feel about the returning players
- 33:42in the offensive line? Do you guys expect some of them to take a
- 33:44step forward or is just kind of a you know, quote he's the best
- 33:47we got quote scenario and also from at Chris underscore ST's one. How much
- 33:52more time does Ryan Day give Justin Fry to get the offensive line issues sorted
- 33:58out? I think, I mean, returning players is great. I don't
- 34:01know that there's anywhere on the field, outside of maybe quarterback, where returning
- 34:06players is better than on the offensive line. And to return, you know,
- 34:09potentially for starters on the offensive line. Matt Jones is the only one
- 34:14that we know that's not going to be there. They've obviously brought in a
- 34:17potential replacement at center. We'll see if Carson Hintzman holds onto the starting job
- 34:21or not. You know, right guard is going to be open? Is
- 34:23that Tager Shabola? Is that Josh Fryer? They kick him inside and they
- 34:28put Luke Montgomery at right tackle? Do they land Caden Proctor? Tony taking
- 34:31it full circle from the beginning of the show. Lots of possibilities there.
- 34:37But I think when you have a Donovan Jackson, I think it's going to
- 34:43be at least as good as it was last year, and he was solid
- 34:45but not spectacular, right and there's a possibility that it's much better. Josh
- 34:52Simmons, I think first year starter. You saw enough improvement from him just
- 34:54over the course of the season that's probably going to be better. He went
- 34:59from maybe one of their weaker offensive linemen to maybe their strongest offensive lineman by
- 35:02the end of the season. I think I'm expecting a much better offensive line.
- 35:09I'm not expecting Ryan Day to come out at the end of the spring
- 35:12and kind of give us the you know, the rock, like big exhale
- 35:17eye roll, like, oh fie, I don't know, boy, the
- 35:21offensive line, oh buddy, oh man, you know, I don't I'm
- 35:23not expecting that this year. I don't know if you're going from was okay
- 35:30to Joe Moore Award winning offensive line, but I think you also people need
- 35:37to keep in mind the Cotton Bowl offensive line was not the twelve game offensive
- 35:42line at Ohio State. So you know what you saw in the Cotton Bowl
- 35:45with enig Vermahi and Matt Jones at center, that's not gonna be You know
- 35:50that that's not the baseline for what this line is. The baseline for what
- 35:52this line is was the Michigan game. And you know the rest of the
- 35:57end of the season, and when you look at what Michigan's d did against
- 36:00a lot of other sort of top offensive lines, including the Ted Moore or
- 36:05the Joe Moore Award winning offensive line for Washington, I think once once you
- 36:10sort of see how the other teams graded out against that Michigan defense, the
- 36:15Ohio State offensive line performance, there is like, well, that wasn't so
- 36:17bad after all. Yeah. I'm looking back at my projected too deep for
- 36:24last year's offensive line. They started on January third, the version of four
- 36:30point one, which was when Luke Whipler went off to the NFL. Here
- 36:36here's the projected starting five that I had at that time to give you an
- 36:38idea of how things have changed and how much better Ohio State is right now
- 36:43in terms of the situation. So left tackle I was. I went with
- 36:47Donovan Jackson and Zen Maholski because Kevin Wilson had talked about Donovan Jackson and there
- 36:52was no left There was no ideal left tackle, so I put Donovan Jackson
- 36:57there. Left guard was a slew of or takership ball of Ben Christman,
- 37:01Carson Hinzman, Luke Montgomery, and Senator Matt Jones and Jacob James. Right
- 37:08guard Enoch form Ahi and then everybody else that was listened as a left guard,
- 37:14and then right tackle was Josh Fryar and George Fitzpatrick. And you look
- 37:17where they are now. They are so much better off right now than they
- 37:21ever were back then at the same timeframe. So I think they're They're okay,
- 37:27they'll be okay. I know the Missouri game was terrible, but I
- 37:30do expect them to be better than they were this year. They've added some
- 37:34people, so I think I don't think that's as doom and gloom as everybody
- 37:38is a lot of people are saying, especially when you add in the running
- 37:43threat of the quarterback. Two very good running backs. I think they're going
- 37:46to be okay. And then in terms of the how much time does Ryan
- 37:51Day give Justin Fry to get the offensive line issues sorted out? I think
- 37:55one more year unless the new offensive coordinator comes in is an like I want
- 38:00my guy. So I think if if it's underperforming again next year, then
- 38:07you've got to make a change. Well, and if it's underperforming this fall,
- 38:13what does that make this season for Ohio State? And you know,
- 38:16are you having bigger conversations about changes at Ohio State if it's an underperforming year
- 38:21again this year? So yeah, I think question number one is who is
- 38:24the new offensive coordinator? And Ryan Day on Wednesday was asked that, you
- 38:29know, I expected to have a new offensive coordinator, you know, he
- 38:31expected to introduce someone soon. And he said, I'm going to paraphrase this.
- 38:37It was sort of like, well, yeah, we're looking at a
- 38:37lot of stuff. Well we'll let you know, which was simultaneously an answer
- 38:43but not really an answer, if you know what I mean. So,
- 38:46you know, if and when there is a new offensive coordinator, and you
- 38:49get the sense that there probably will be that person. According to the sort
- 38:53of leaks and the rumors and reports on this. That person's gonna be the
- 38:57one who has to figure out personnel on that side of ball in terms of
- 39:01coaching staff and you know, are you making quarterback coach changes or changes at
- 39:07other positions. That's the person who's going to be making those decisions ultimately.
- 39:09So you know, the answer is, you know, consult the magic eight
- 39:14ball and then you know, picture Cloudy ask again later. Is sort of
- 39:17where we are on the future of pretty much anything on the offensive side of
- 39:22the ball until you start to get some of those those initial answers. There
- 39:27you go. So that will do it for this episode. We'll invite you
- 39:30all to go ahead and like this video if you're watching it on YouTube,
- 39:32and subscribe to our channel as well if you have not yet done so,
- 39:37at YouTube dot com slash Bucket Huddle. Also you can find us at Buckeye
- 39:39huddle dot com. Become a member, say hello to us there on the
- 39:43message board. There's all kinds of stuff going on right now. Recruiting,
- 39:46there will be some uh you know, there's always something going along with the
- 39:50portal. We're on that as well, so check it out. Take a
- 39:52look see what you think, and that will do it for us today.
- 39:55Want to thank you all for tuning in and we'll talk to you guys later